﻿

Science-Based Medicine: Vaccines & Vaccine Preventable Illnesses A Critical Guide for the Health Practitioner and Consumer. 2025 Edition.
by Executive Editor Steven Novella. Managing Editor David Gorski. Series Editor Mark Crislip.
Contributions by The writers of the Science Based Medicine blog.
Published by SBM
2025

   Table of Contents
Title Page
Introduction
Overview
About This Book
INFLUENZA
An Influenza Primer. Joseph Albietz 
Protect Yourself | M Crislip
Uneasy Lies the Head That Wears the Flu | M Crislip
Even in 2014, influenza kills | D Gorski
Scam Stud. The Food ‘Babe’ and Flu Vaccination | M Crislip
Why Get A Flu Shot? | M Crislip
Flu Vaccine Efficacy. Mark Crislip 
Does the Flu Vaccine Increase Hospitalizations? Steven Novella
Influnza Deaths. Mark Crislip
Short Attention Span SBM. Mark Crislip
Swine Flu Vaccine Fearmongering. Harriet Hall
Influenza Vaccine Mandate. Mark Crislip
Influenza Eye Roll | M Crislip
More About Flu Vaccine | H Hall
Drinking from the Fire Hose: Odds and Ends on the Gasping Oppression aka influenza | M Crislip
What are words for? On Vaccination. | M Crislip
No, the CDC did not just “admit” that this year’s flu vaccine doesn’t work | D Gorski
One Flu Into the Cuckoo’s Nest | M Crislip
When should I get the influenza vaccine? | M Crislip
Flu Shots: It’s That Time Again | H Hall
Flu Shots: Here We Go Again! | H Hall
Pandemrix and Narcolepsy | S Novella
Do two half-truths add up to a complete truth or a complete falsehood? Vaccinations truthiness. | M Crislip
A Defense of Childhood Influenza Vaccination and Squalene-Containing Adjuvants; Joseph Mercola’s “Dirty Little Secret” Joseph Albietz.
The influenza vaccine and miscarriages: Much ado about nothing | D Gorski
The Tamiflu Spin. Mark Crislip.
Yes, But. The Annotated Atlantic. Mark Crislip
New evidence, same conclusion: Tamiflu only modestly useful for influenza | S Gavura
Influenza Vaccine and Health Care Workers. More than one way to skin a literature | M Crislip
Does treating fever spread influenza? | S Gavura
Beyond the flu shot: A closer look at the “alternatives” | S Gavura
An Alternative “Truth” About Flu Shots | H Hall
Random Flu Thoughts | M Crislip
Ososillyococcinum and other Flu bits. Mark Crislip.
Flu Woo Hodge Podge. Mark Crislip
More Flu Woo For You, Boo Boo. Mark Crislip.
The Flu Vaccine and Narcolepsy. Steven Novella.
False “balance” on influenza with an appeal to nature | S Gavura
Joe Mercola: Falsely demonizing the flu vaccine by claiming it increases your risk of COVID-19 | G Gorski
Courage | M Crislip
Don’t Forget About the Flu | S Novella
Fun with Spanish Flu Myths | H Hall
The Madness of Crowding | M Crislip
Pump it up: osteopathic manipulation and influenza | M Crislip
Bird is the Word | M Crislip
Reality | M Crislip
VACCINE PREVENTABLE DISESASES
It’s the end of the world as I know it. And I feel fine. | M Crislip
Anti-Vaccine Hotspots are Getting Hotter | C Jones
Vaccines in the News: The Good, the Bad, and the Imminent Loss of Our Measles Elimination Status | C Jones
Childhood Vaccination Rates Move (Slowly) in the Right Direction | C Jones
Why Universal Hepatitis B Vaccination Isn’t Quite Universal. Joseph Albietz
I Used to Wonder How the Tuskegee Experiment Could Have Happened. No More. | J Howard
Quoth the anti-vaccine group SANE Vax: Beware HPV DNA in Gardasil! David Gorski
The Harm of Antivaccine Misinformation | S Novella
Vaccines Work. Here’s Why We Care About Your Unvaccinated Child. | J Howard
Thanks, Jenny McCarthy! Thanks for the measles! David Gorski
Measles. Mark Crislip.
Return of an old foe | P Lipson
Measles Spike in US | S Novella
Measles gets a helping hand | J Snyder
More Measles Myths | S Novella
Say it ain’t so, Mickey! A holiday measles outbreak makes the happiest place in the world sad | D Gorski
The Disneyland measles outbreak: “Dr. Bob” Sears says measles isn’t that bad, and an antivaccine activist invokes the Brady Bunch fallacy | D Gorski
The measles vaccine protects against more than just the measles | D Gorski
Measles More Deadly than Previously Thought | S Novella
SSPE: A Deadly and Not-That-Rare Complication of Measles | C Jones
Make measles great again: A case study of the politicization of school vaccine requirements in Michigan | D Gorski
Outbreaks among Somali immigrants in Minnesota: Thanks for the measles again, Andy | D Gorski
Minnesota Measles | S Novella
The benefits of the measles vaccine go beyond just protecting against measles, 2019 edition | D Gorski
Measles outbreaks, 2011. David Gorski.
Measles outbreaks and the antivaccine movement | D Gorski
Another Measles Outbreak – Blame Antivaxxers | S Novella
Rise of the Miscellany of Medical Malarkey…Again | C Jones
U.S. Measles Elimination Status in Jeopardy as the Number of Cases Reach 25 Year High | C Jones
More COVID More Measles? | C Jones
Measles Outbreaks on the Rise (2024) S. Novella 
Another Year, Another Measles Outbreak | C. Jones
Doctors on Measles: “NEVER Listen to the Anti-Vax Cult When They Say This ‘Natural’ Disease is Harmless”. Doctors on COVID| J Howard
Measles Deaths Surge Worldwide Thanks to Poverty and Anti-Vaccine Propaganda | C Jones
Measles 2024: ‘Merica, are you okay? | C Jones
Measles is back, and so are all the old antivax tropes about it | D Gorski
Vitamin A Does Not Treat or Prevent Measles | S Novella
Vitamin A, Infections and Measles | M Crislip
RFK Jr.: Vaccines Not Only Protect Individual Children From Measles, But Also Contribute To Community Immunity | J Howard
Beholden to Big Suppla, RFK Jr. Wants to Cover Up the Symptoms of Diseases With Untested, Toxic Chemicals & Drugs, Rather Than Prevent the Root Cause | J Howard
Measles, MAHA, and “soft eugenics” | D Gorski
Hello measles, my old friend: The return of previously vanquished vaccine-preventable diseases | D Gorski
Our Current Medical Establishment Would Have Botched COVID, The Same Way They Are Botching Measles | J Howard
Dr. Jay Bhattacharya on Measles: “I Think I’ve Done My Best.” | J Howard
MAHA Leaders Are Recycling COVID Myths to Minimize Measles | J Howard
Everything Old Is New Again, Again | J Howard
Measles Surging As Vaccine Rates Drop | S Novella
Making measles great again in Ohio | D Gorski
Miscellany of Medical Malarkey Part 6 | C Jones
Mumps. Mark Crislip.
The 2014 Ohio Mumps Outbreak | C Jones
England’s Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Year: Mumps and the “Wakefield Cohort” | C Jones
MMR is Safe and Effective | S Novella
The Revenge of Chicken Pox | S Novella
Pox parties taken to the next (illegal) level | D Gorski
Varicella Vaccination Program Success. Steven Novella
Should I Get the New Shingles Vaccine? | H Hall
A Recent Case Report Highlights Why Skipping the Chickenpox Vaccine is a Bad Idea | C Jones
Shingles Vaccine (Zostavax) Confirmed Safe. Harriet Hall.
Unintended Side Effects HPV and Shingles Vaccines—Reason for Concern |K Folta
Risk of Intussusception with Rotavirus Vaccines | H Hall
Rotavirus Vaccine May Reduce Risk of Type 1 Diabetes in Kids | C Jones
Some Good, But Preliminary Real World Data on Those Baby RSV Shots Clay Jones
More Evidence Supports Infant RSV Shot Safety and Effectiveness | C Jones
Pertussis Epidemic 2010. Steven Novella
Whooping Cough Epidemic | S Novella
The problem of waning pertussis immunity | D Gorski
The Pertussis Resurgence | S Novella
Pertussis Vaccine During Pregnancy Protects Vulnerable Newborns | C Jones
A Shot in the Dark Revisited. Steven Novella.
Smallpox and Pseudomedicine. Kimball Atwood.
Wrong About Polio: A Review of Suzanne Humphries, MD and Roman Bystrianyk’s “Dissolving Illusions” Part 1 (the short version) | J Harrison
Wrong About Polio: A Review of Suzanne Humphries, MD and Roman Bystrianyk’s “Dissolving Illusions” Part 1 (the long version) | J Harrison
Polio Outbreak in Papua New Guinea | S Novella
The Return of Polio | S Novella
Polio’s Resurgence | S Gavura
Holding the Polio Vaccine Hostage | S Novella
Polio Eliminated From Africa | S Novella
Eradication Isn’t Extinction. Too Bad. | M Crislip
Where’s the outrage? John Snyder 
Salk’s swansong: renaissance of the injected polio vaccine | E Parker
The evolving story of the harms of anti-inflammatory drugs | S Gavura
H. influenzae—it ain’t the flu, but it’s still pretty cool. Peter Lipso
Vaccines are a pain: What to do about it. Scott Gavura 
Another Child Suffers From the Effects of Anti-Vaccine Propaganda…and Tetanus | C Jones
What happened to the Lyme vaccine? | S Gavura
Cunnilingus, Michael Douglas’s Cancer, and the HPV Vaccine | H Hall
HPV Vaccine for Boys | H Hall
HPV vaccination misinformation and bias in Medscape. David Gorski
The HPV Vaccine (Gardasil) Safety Revisited. Joseph Albietz 
No, the HPV vaccine does not cause promiscuity | S Gavura
HPV Vaccine Compliance | S Novella
HPV Vaccine Safety and Acceptance | S Novella
The claim that Gardasil causes premature ovarian failure: Ideology, not science | D Gorski
Mercola, Gardasil, and Toyota? Joseph Albietz 
Death by Gardasil? Not so fast there… | D Gorski
In 2014, Dr. Kelly Brogan and Sayer Ji Told People Natural HPV Infections Were “Beneficial, Not Deadly.” What’s Happened Since? | J Howard
Preventing Malaria: A Glimmer of Hope? | H Hall
A Malaria Vaccine for Children: A Historic Achievement that will Save Countless Lives | S Novella
A New Malaria Vaccine | Science-Based Medicine
Cameroon Begins First Malaria Vaccine Program | S. Novella
Vaccine Post Updates: the Good, the Bad, and the Crooked? | C Jones
On the Orwellian language and bad science of the anti-vaccine movement: “SmartVax” versus “MaxVax”? David Gorski
Self-Amplifying RNA Vaccines | S Novella
Sleep and Vaccination Response | S Novella
Science Based Satire: Falling Vaccine Coverage Over The Years Is A Problem That Likely Increased Due To The Failed Covid-19 Policies That Jonathan Howard Championed. | J Howard
Science-Based Satire: My Patients are Refusing the MMR Because the CDC Added the COVID Vaccine to the Routine Vaccine Schedule | J Howard
Science-Based Satire: Children of Anti-Vaccine Parents More Likely to Refuse Cootie Shot | C Jones
Science Based Satire: The CDC’s Unyielding, Unscientific Push to Vaccinate Children Against COVID Caused a Measles Outbreak in Europe | J. Howard
Science-Based Medicine Reviews: Vaccines and Vaccine Preventable Illnesses 
A Critical Guide for the Health Practitioner and Consumer 
2025 Edition

Executive Editor Steven Novella MD
Managing Editor David Gorski MD PhD
Series Editor Mark Crislip MD

   Introduction 
Steven Novella
The world of health care is becoming an increasingly complex and challenging place. The internet is changing the way we generate and access information, and health information is one of the most popular uses of the internet. It represents an unprecedented democratization of information and opinion. 
While there are many advantages and benefits to such information access, there are also many challenges to health professionals, regulators, academics, and consumers. There is a proliferation of health related products and services, with many provocative health claims. Regulations are generally not keeping up, and often have been watered down, in the face of this onslaught of claims and products. 
The consumer is left with an overwhelming array of health claims, many of which challenge and even directly oppose the traditional experts and institutions. 
The mission of Science-Based Medicine (SBM) is to be a source of reliable information and analysis to help navigate the wild west of health information on the internet and elsewhere. The authors who contribute to this series of e-books are all physicians and other health care professionals who have a great deal of experience educating the public about complex medical issues. We especially take on controversial issues and try to expose pseudoscience and fraud wherever possible.
The Philosophy of Science-Based Medicine
The philosophy of SBM, at its core, is simple: Safe and effective health care is critical to everyone’s quality of life; so much so that it is generally considered a basic human right. Therefore, health care products and services that work and are safe are better than those that do not work or are unsafe. 
The best method for determining which interventions and health products are safe and effective is, without question, good science. Therefore it is in everyone’s best interest for health care to be systematically evaluated by the best science available.
Too often the nature of science itself is misunderstood or misrepresented to the public. Science is not an arcane and privileged discipline. By its very nature it is meant to be transparent and public. Science is nothing more than a systematic and careful use of evidence and logic to evaluate factual claims. And good science possesses certain virtues that are not unique to science but generic to all intellectual endeavors: fairly accounting for all available evidence, using valid and internally consistent logic, using unambiguous concepts and language, proper use of statistics, being quantitatively precise and accurate, and above all being honest.
And yet there are numerous and powerful influences in society that strongly appose the scientific basis of medicine. Driven by some combination of ideology or the desire for profit they wish to eliminate standards of science in health care, or (often under the guise of “health care freedom”) create a double standard in which unscientific methods and products can thrive unchecked. Others simply lack the training or knowledge to achieve minimal standards of quality for scientific medicine. And even the best traditions of scientific medicine can benefit from more critical analysis.
Recognition of the need for careful scientific analysis in medicine partly stems from a recognition that it is very difficult (almost impossible) to reliably assess treatments anecdotally. Human perception, memory, and cognition are prone to a host of flaws, weaknesses, and biases that will tend to mislead us, especially towards conclusions that we wish to be true. Placebo effects, confirmation bias, and simple statistics can make any intervention seem effective, even when they are worthless or harmful. 
Science-Based Medicine vs Evidence-Based Medicine
Within the practice of medicine there is already a recognition of the need to raise the standards of evidence and the availability of the best evidence to the practitioner and the consumer – formalized in the movement known as evidence-based medicine (EBM). 
EBM is a vital and positive influence on the practice of medicine, but it has its limitations. EBM tends to focus on clinical trial results to the exclusion of scientific plausibility. The focus on trial results (which, in the EBM lexicon, is what is meant by “evidence”) has its utility, but fails to properly deal with medical modalities that are highly implausible, or seem to defy well-established findings in science.
All of science describes the same reality, and therefore it must (if it is functioning properly) all be mutually compatible. Collectively, science builds one cumulative model of the natural world. This means we can make rational judgments about what is likely to be true based upon what is already well established. This does not necessarily equate to rejecting new ideas out-of-hand, but rather to adjusting the threshold of evidence required to establish a new claim based upon the prior scientific plausibility of the new claim. Failure to do so leads to conclusions and recommendations that are not reliable, and therefore medical practices that are probably not safe and effective.
The SBM Series
This is why the authors of this series strongly advocate for science based medicine – the use of the best scientific evidence available, in the light of our cumulative scientific knowledge from all relevant disciplines, in evaluating health claims, practices, and products. 
Some of the articles here will analyze individual studies, and explore the strengths and weaknesses of their methods, separating what the study really tells us from how it may be represented in the media. Other articles will summarize what many studies tell us about a specific medical question. 
We will also explore health information on the internet, separating out which information is reliable from that which is misleading, erroneous, or possibly even fraudulent. Likewise we will critique mainstream media coverage of health topics, giving the reader specific tools for to critically analyze health information for themselves.
Other articles will explore topics related to health regulation and academia. Regulations have struggled to keep up with the rapidly changing health care market place, with critical gaps that leave the health care consumer responsible for their own protection. Academic institutions themselves, long the defenders of high standards of scholarship in all fields, including medicine, have been infiltrated by promoters of pseudoscientific belief systems. The result is that there is no longer any single reliable guarantee of scientific integrity. 
The SBM series of e-books is organized by topic, such as acupuncture, chiropractic, homeopathy, and many others. The books are collections of essays, not intended to be a systematic reference, but rather to explore the various scientific issues related to each topic. The goal is to give the reader critical thinking skills and a deeper understanding of, not just the current findings of science, but the process of science, specifically how it relates to health care and the topic of each book. 
Science-based medicine can serve as your pocket guide through the wilderness of health information.

   Overview: Vaccines
Vaccines are generally considered to be the most successful public health intervention ever devised. And yet there have been opponents of vaccines ever since there have been vaccines. So-called antivaccinationists have claimed over the years that vaccines do not work, despite the overwhelming evidence that they do. They often spread misinformation about vaccine, such as the notion that vaccines weaken the immune system, when in fact they work by strengthening the immune response against the target infection.
In recent years the antivaccine movement has focused on the claim that vaccines are linked to neurological injury, and specifically to the neurological disorder autism, now referred to as autism spectrum disorder (ASD). However the scientific evidence overwhelmingly shows no correlation between vaccines in general, the MMR vaccine specifically, or thimerosal (a mercury-based preservative) in vaccines with ASD or other neurodevelopmental disorders.
The primary argument made for an association between thimerosal and ASD is that the rate of diagnosis of ASD has been steadily increasing since the early 1990s. At that time also the routine vaccine schedule was increasing, resulting in an increasing total dose of thimerosal. The antivaccinationists then assume causation from correlation to blame rising ASD rates on thimerosal.
However, by 2002 thimerosal was completely removed from the routine vaccine schedule, and now remains only in some flu vaccines. The total dose of thimerosal exposure is far below 1990 levels, before ASD diagnoses began to rise. Antivaccinationists predicted that ASD rates would fall dramatically in the years following the removal of thimerosal from most vaccines – but rates have continued to rise without even the slightest change in the rate of increase. This is a powerful refutation of the thimerosal-autism hypothesis, and has been replicated in other countries.
Further, the best epidemiological evidence suggests that the rise in the diagnosis rate of ASD is an artifact of broadening the definition of autism, diagnostic substitution, and increased surveillance. Therefore there isn’t really an autism “epidemic” just a change in the definition and efforts to make the diagnosis.
Undaunted, the antivaccinationists have changed their claims to blame any number of “toxins” in vaccines. However, their claims have no scientific validity.


As of 2025, there are over 5000 essays on the Science Based Medicine website. I do no know about you, but I find it difficult to find any post I wrote, much less one written by another contributor. 
So I have updated the books and include almost all the articles through 2025. The volumes are

CAM Concepts
Chiropractic
COVID 
Critical Thinking
Diet and Nutrition
Ethics and CAM
Herbs, Supplements, and Diet
Homeopathy
Infections and Immunity
Law and CAM
Media and Internet
Medicine, Public Health, Dentistry and Pediatrics
Miscellaneous CAM
Naturopathy
Neurology and Psychiatry
Placebo
Quackademic Medicine
Regulation. FDA and FTC
SBM or EBM
Stem Cells, Genetics, AI and Gender
Supplements, Vitamins and Herbs
Vaccine & Anivax
Vaccines and Autism
Vaccines and Preventable Infections

The articles are roughly organized by publication date and topic. Many articles will be in multiple volumes as an essay of, for example, chiropractic and law will be found in both the chiropractic volume and the law volume.
You may find the organization a bit odd. I do. But 5000 plus articles are difficult to organize and I have more to do in my retirement than work of these volumes.
Still, if you find I have missed a nentry or some glaring error, drop me a note and I will fix it for the next edition.

About the authors
Steven P. Novella, MD – Founder and Executive Editor Science Based Medicine.
Founder and currently Executive Editor of Science-Based Medicine Steven Novella, MD.
David H. Gorski, MD, PhD – Managing Editor. Science Based Medicine.
Mark A. Crislip, MD. Editor, Science Based Medicine Guides. 
He did he editing of all the volumes so is to blame for any mistakes.
As to all the other contributors, if you are interested click on the ‘Link’ at top of each essay to go the SBM site, where further information about each author can be found.
A Note On References

The chapters in this book were originally blog entries at ScienceBasedMedicine.org.
Blog and web pages lend themselves to hyperlinks to sources and references that are tedious to translate into footnotes for this ebook.
Under the title of each essay is a hyperlink, cleverly titled ‘Link’, to the original blog entry with all the hyperlinks and references, as well as the comments to the blogs, which often have interesting and thoughtful insights by our readers, as well as some curious comments by the not so thoughtful.
Graphs, tables and links to videos are not in included these essays due to issues of copyright and permission. However, thanks to the ‘Link’, the graphics are a click away.
Thanks for reading the site.
Mark Crislip 


   Influenza

   An Influenza Primer 
Joseph Albietz 
Link
The President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology recently submitted its report to the president in which they stated that this influenza season might kill 30-90,000 people in the US. This forecast of the upcoming season caught the media’s attention and appears to have stoked the public interest in influenza. We have had many requests for more information about influenza here at SBM, and so in this post I am going to discuss the basics of influenza and try to put the current pandemic and upcoming season in perspective.
I find it is best to start at the beginning.
What Is Influenza?
Within the public sphere, “The flu” has become shorthand for “I feel like crap.” I suspect that this is part of the reason why some people think the influenza vaccine doesn’t work. Medically speaking, however, influenza is a very specific family of viruses that cause a reasonably narrow set of problems for humans.
The influenza season in the Northern hemisphere usually runs from October through May, with a peak mid-February. Every season in the US between 5-20% of the US population is infected by influenza, and while the majority of people recover well from an influenza infection, not everyone will. Annually 200,000 people are hospitalized, and on average 36,000 will die either from influenza or its complications.
The classic influenza infection incubates for 1-4 days after exposure. Its onset is rapid, with most people experiencing high fever, headache, muscle aches, dry cough, sore throat, and nasal congestion. Gastro-intestinal symptoms like nausea, vomiting, and diarrhea are less common. Symptoms last from several days to almost two weeks, and a person is contagious from one day before symptoms begin to more than a week after symptom onset.
There are many strains of influenza. The current seasonal influenza is made up of three different influenza subtypes: A(H3N2), A(H1N1), and B. Don’t confuse the seasonal A(H1N1) strain with the current pandemic 2009 A(H1N1); they are distinct. I will refer to them as A(H1N1) for the seasonal strain, and 2009 (H1N1) for the pandemic “swine flu” strain. Influenza B is less common, less virulent, has a slower mutation rate, and is thus a lesser risk; the rest of this discussion is focused on Influenza A.
How Does Influenza Spread?
Influenza has two dominant modes of transmission: droplet and contact transmission. Droplet means that when someone coughs or sneezes, extremely fine (and sometimes not-so-fine) droplets are aerosolized into the air around them. If these droplets come in contact with your nose, mouth, throat, or lungs, it is possible for you to become infected by the viruses in those droplets.
The second way influenza can be spread is either through direct contact or through an intermediate like a doorknob, known as a “fomite.” The virus can survive for minutes to days depending on the surface, and if you touch that surface then your mouth or nose, again, it is possible that you can become infected. Influenza does not appear to be capable of spreading long distances through the air (across large rooms or through air vents).
How Does Influenza Change?
Influenza A is a versatile virus with many distinct serotypes. Most people are familiar with human, bird, and swine influenza, but influenza is in fact able to infect a large number of avian and mammalian species on the planet. It is important to realize that these viruses are not, despite their name, truly species specific. Random mutations and natural selection frequently create new strains of influenza capable of infecting other species; in its ability to mutate influenza is unparalleled.
Influenza is an RNA virus encoded by just 11 genes on 8 separate RNA segments. With only 11 genes, you can see that influenza is a relatively simple virus. But its simplicity is one of the most significant reasons for its success. Unlike our DNA, the RNA of influenza replicates without the benefit of enzymes that correct transcription errors. This means that it makes more transcription errors, a lot more. One in every 1000-10,000 nucleotides is mis-transcribed by influenza, giving it one of the highest mutation rates known. Some of these errors are neutral and have no effect on the virus. Some are detrimental and will result in a defective virus. But some of them are beneficial. Two genes encode influenza’s characteristic surface proteins hemagglutinin (HA) and neuraminidase (NA). There are 16 types of HA, 9 of NA, and respectively these two proteins serve to bind the virus to a target cell and to release new viral particles from a host cell, and they also happen to be the parts of influenza the immune system recognizes. Every so often a transcription error will change the conformation of either HA or NA just enough so that it cannot be recognized by the immune system. Voilà, we have a new strain of influenza, and your immune system has to start from scratch. This is the concept of “antigenic drift,” and it is responsible for the variation in influenza strains we see every year.
But that is only part of the story. Do you remember the 8 separate RNA segments? If a cell is infected with a single strain of influenza this is an inconsequential factoid. However, if two dissimilar strains of influenza co-infect the same cell, those 8 RNA segments become exceedingly important. Up to 256 unique combinations can result from that one pairing. Instead of a slow drift in the surface markers of the circulating influenza strains, suddenly we have a major re-assortment, and a brand-new strain is created. This is “antigenic shift,” and this is how the 2009 (H1N1) strain was born.
I hope it is clear at this point that influenza is not a single virus that changes over time, but is instead a family of viruses that to a greater or lesser extent co-exist and are constantly changing. Were it stable, your immune system would be able to establish meaningful immunity. Until we discover a way to make your immune system target a stable section of influenza, our best hope is to constantly redesign our vaccines against a moving target.
What Makes the Novel Influenza A 2009 (H1N1) So Special?
Other novel influenzas have been identified in the past without causing a pandemic. The 1976 swine flu is a prime example. Identified in Fort Dix, it infected at least 13 soldiers, killing one. It looked similar to the 1918 Spanish flu, which raised concerns of a potential pandemic and triggered a mass vaccination campaign. Yet it never spread beyond the base and has not been seen since.
Another example is the H5N1 “bird flu” that we’ve heard about since its emergence in 1997. It has had several outbreaks, caused over 167 deaths, and carries a ~60% mortality rate for those infected. Fortunately, though it can spread like wildfire through birds, and humans can catch it from birds, humans cannot reliably spread it to other humans. Thus it is a virus with the potential to be truly terrifying, but in its current state poses a limited infectious risk.
Why then are we so confident that the 2009 (H1N1) strain will behave differently and pose a real risk? Three reasons:
First, recall that the 2009 (H1N1) is distinct from the seasonal A (H1N1). It appears to be a “triple recombination,” with characteristics derived from human, bird, and swine influenzas. When our population was tested for antibodies against 2009 (H1N1) nearly no children, and less than 10% of those under the age of 65 had reactive antibodies, and of those over 65 only 33% showed any response. It seems no one has seen a similar influenza in half a century. This means that the vast majority of our population is susceptible to infection this season; you can see the potential for infection on a grand scale.
Second, unlike the 1976 strain, the 2009 (H1N1) has already proven itself to be highly contagious. From its first appearance in Mexico on March 18th, 2009, it took 4 weeks to spread outside the borders of Mexico, and within 2 more weeks it was in 5 states and 8 other nations. Only 6 weeks after being first identified, over 3000 cases were to be found in 43 states and 23 countries, and on June 11th, 2009, after only 3 months, it had achieved pandemic status. Furthermore, it was able to accomplish all this during the season least conducive to its normal spread.
Finally, the 2009 (H1N1) has proven itself to be far from benign. As of August 22nd, the US has hospitalized 8,843 people with 2009 (H1N1), and 556 have died, 101 of them under the age of 24. We have a hospitalization rate of 4.5/100,000 for ages 0-4, and 2.1/100,000 for ages 5-24. All of this, recall, has happened during influenza’s off-season.
In areas where 2009 (H1N1) emerged during the traditional influenza season, like Australia, they have reported more than a doubling in the number of people hospitalized from influenza, with around 1 in 5 requiring ICU-level care. Similar to what we have seen in the US, Australia has likewise demonstrated that 2009 (H1N1) has a higher attack rate in younger people, which is in stark contrast to the normal seasonal influenza pattern, and has shifted its mean age of death from influenza from 83 down to 54. Unlike what we have seen thus far, Australia has had a much higher hospitalization rate of 34.6/100,000 in ages 0-4, and an overall rate of 12/100,000 for the population. This likely reflects the differences between being on-season and off-season.
That is what makes 2009 (H1N1) so concerning. It is capable of causing serious infections even and perhaps especially in the young and the healthy. It is highly contagious, it has a worldwide population without immunity, and it now exists in low levels in most communities around the nation. And we are now entering into its prime season.
Conclusion
So is this the Zombie Apocalypse, or only slightly less concerning, is this going to be a repeat of the 1918 Spanish influenza pandemic? Almost certainly not. Nor, however, were the predictions made by the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology outlandish fear mongering. 30,000 dead is an average influenza season, and if we see a simple doubling in the number of cases we will rapidly approach the higher end of their estimate.
Influenza warrants our respect and attention. I hope these estimates are higher than what we will in reality see; it would make my winter in the ICU far more pleasant. The fact remains that only time will tell. In the meantime, we would be wise to be prepared.
So what can you do?
    • Get vaccinated against seasonal flu and 2009 (H1N1) – It’s cheap, safe, and effective. If you don’t get sick, you avoid all of the risks of infection while also avoiding the responsibility of infecting others.
    • Wash your hands – You should be doing this anyway.
    • Cover your cough and sneeze – It’s just polite not to spray your mucous in my face. Thank you.
    • If you are ill stay home until 24 hours after your fever abates – If you are infected, there is no reason to risk the health of everyone around you.
    • Don’t Panic – Most people will get through an influenza infection without medical attention. Rest, stay hydrated, and minimize your exposure to others.
The CDC recommendations for warning signs to seek medical care are as follows:
In children, emergency warning signs that need urgent medical attention include:
    • Fast breathing or trouble breathing
    • Bluish or gray skin color
    • Not drinking enough fluids
    • Severe or persistent vomiting
    • Not waking up or not interacting
    • Being so irritable that the child does not want to be held
    • Flu-like symptoms improve but then return with fever and worse cough
    • Any child under 12 weeks of age with fever over 100.4 F (38 C)
    • In adults, emergency warning signs that need urgent medical attention include:
    • Difficulty breathing or shortness of breath
    • Pain or pressure in the chest or abdomen
    • Sudden dizziness
    • Confusion
    • Severe or persistent vomiting
    • Flu-like symptoms improve but then return with fever and worse cough

Protect Yourself
Every year influenza makes the rounds, and every year people refuse to get vaccinated for very bad reasons. Don’t be a Dumb Ass – get vaccinated.
Mark Crislip on September 21, 2012
Link
Flu season is upon us. If there is such a thing as flu season. H1N1 started at the furthest point in time you could get from the traditional start of the flu season. It is an interesting question as to whether global warming will alter the flu season, as it has the RSV season. Classically influenza is a fall/winter disease and fall started today.
It is perhaps worthwhile to review what is known about influenza.
     1.  The disease influenza, the gasping oppression, is a disease that has been plaguing humans for about 500 years. It is a predominantly respiratory infection, causing a protracted cough with fever and myalgia. The term flu is used loosely to cover almost any febrile illness, and I remain uncertain as to what a stomach flu might be. I tend towards the picky side; flu is due to the influenza virus. There are many viri that can cause a flu like illness, but only the influenza virus causes the flu.
     2.  The flu is due to a virus, the influenza virus. There is influenza A and B and C. There are them what deny germs as a cause of disease, and I will admit that as an infectious disease doctor I have a vested interest in germs causing disease. After all, my job is me find bug, me kill bug, me go home.
     3.  Not every flu like illness is due to the influenza virus. In a given season the influenza virus may account for around 10-15% of flu like illness in the community, although during epidemics influenza can account for 60% of flu like illnesses.
     4.  Influenza kills. It kills directly, it kills by acute secondary infections, it kills by worsening underlying diseases like heart failure, it kills long term by increasing vascular events such as heart attacks and stroke. Influenza kills the young, the old, the obese and the pregnant. Deaths by influenza also depend on the virulence of the circulating strains. Some strains, such as H5N1 (the bird flu) or H3N2, are more likely to kill (60% for H5N1) than strains like H1N1 which was of moderate virulence. Influenza deaths, both direct and indirect, are difficult to measure and are at best an estimate. As an example somewhere between 151,700 to 575,400 people died worldwide from H1N1 the first year, with a mean of about 250,000.
     5.  When exposed to influenza, either as an infection or as a vaccine, the body responds in part by making antibody. Roughly, the better the antibody response to the influenza antigens, the better the protection to that strain of influenza. I say roughly as it depends on what part of the antigenic structure the body responds to: antibody to some antigenic sites offer better protection to influenza than others. If you are lucky enough to respond to some highly conserved sites on the virus you could conceivably be immune to all strains of influenza.
     6.  The influenza vaccine offers moderate protection against influenza. Unfortunately the antigens of the virus change year to year (antigenic drift) and decade to decade (antigenic shift), while the vaccine strains are fixed prior to a given season and may not optimally match the circulating strains. If there is a good match between vaccine and circulating strains in a healthy population, the protection from the vaccine can be high: for H1N1 it was 87%.
     7.  Unfortunately those who need to be protected from the influenza virus are those most likely not to respond to the virus vaccine: the obese, the pregnant, the elderly and those with chronic medical diseases.
     8.  The benefit of the vaccine extends beyond prevention of flu. Of course, if you don’t get influenza, you cannot spread it to others. If you do not get influenza, then, of course you can’t die of its complications, like pneumonia and heart attack. Influenza vaccination could potentially reduce the occurrence of sudden death, acute myocardial infarct, and stroke by 50%. Babies born to vaccinated mothers have fewer cases of influenza. Vaccinated mothers are less like to have stillborn or small babies. Not getting influenza or being vaccinated against flu has many short term and long term benefits.
     9.  Influenza spread can be decreased by mechanical/environmental interventions: hand washing and masks, although these interventions have variable efficacy depending on the population studied. They are not as effective as not getting the virus.
     10.  Health care workers are particularly problematic. For a variety of reasons they are likely to come to work ill, influenza can be potentially infectious before people are symptomatic, and spread in the hospital occurs, leading to true stories such as this:
Patient Story: Spreading the Flu 4-2012
As a reminder, we have added patient stories to meetings as a way of “bringing the patient into the room,” clarifying the context for our quality plan, and emphasizing the complexities and the importance of the work we are undertaking.
Today’s story is about a group of patients, a nurse, and influenza. It starts with Patient #1, a 57 year-old woman admitted through the emergency department (ED) to one of our hospitals in mid-March with fever and shortness of breath. She was transferred to an inpatient unit with a mask on, which triggered the staff on the receiving unit to implement droplet precautions. Initially thought to have pneumonia, testing confirmed her symptoms were the result of influenza type A, H1N1. After four nights in the hospital, she was discharged home after an uneventful hospital stay and a flu shot.
Patient #2, next door to Patient #1, is a 58 year-old man who was admitted in early March for a GI bleed with multiple co- morbidities. His progress was steady until nine days after admission, when he developed a new fever and respiratory symptoms. These symptoms developed on the same day of Patient #1’s admission. Influenza was suspected two days following the development of his fever, and staff implemented droplet precautions. Lab testing confirmed influenza type A. He remained hospitalized for two more days and received a flu shot before being transferred to a skilled nursing facility.
Down the hall, Patient #3, a 77 year-old man, was admitted two days after Patient #1 for acute stroke and urinary tract infection. On day 3 of his hospitalization, he developed a fever and cough. Lab testing confirmed influenza type A. Droplet precautions were ordered with the lab test for influenza. He remained hospitalized an additional four nights and received a flu shot before being discharged.
Patient #4, a 76 year old man, down the hall from the first two patients and around the corner from Patient #3, was admitted on the same day as Patient #1 following a fainting event at home. Due to his long-standing heart issues, he was kept overnight for observation and discharged the following morning. However, he returned to the ED three days later with continued symptoms. He was discharged from the ED only to return the next day with shortness of breath. Six hours after being readmitted, staff suspected influenza and ordered droplet precautions. His lab tests returned positive for influenza type A. After spending three nights in the hospital, he was discharged home after receiving a flu shot. The following day, he was admitted to the intensive care unit and continued receiving treatment as an inpatient for secondary pneumonia, a complication of his influenza type A infection.
The fifth person in our story is a nurse on the unit where these four patients were admitted. She works on a nursing unit whose hand hygiene performance is currently 67%, and where 85% of the unit staff were vaccinated for this year’s seasonal flu. The particular nurse in this case, however, was 1 of only 9 on the unit who chose not to be vaccinated. Her manager stated that the reason the nurse gave for not receiving the vaccine was that she “was not convinced of the evidence that the vaccine protects patients from transmission … she said she would get the vaccine if she truly believed it protected her patients, but that she didn’t.”
This nurse cared for Patient #1 on her first day of admission. She cared for Patient #2 on the eighth and ninth day (when he developed flu symptoms) of his stay. She also cared for Patient #3 on the first two days of his inpatient stay. There does not appear to be any direct contact with this nurse and Patient #4.
The nurse in our story developed symptoms consistent with influenza three days after working with Patient #1 and Patient #2 (which is the usual 1- to 4-day incubation period for influenza). Due to symptoms, she only worked a partial shift that day. Suspecting her symptoms may be influenza, she used a mask until relief staff was available. She returned home and was able to care for herself without medical intervention. She was not tested for influenza and remained off work for one week. She is still undecided about receiving the flu vaccine.
     11.  Because those in the hospital are particularly vulnerable to the ravages of infections, mortality from hospital acquired influenza is remarkably high: 25%.
     12.  Influenza vaccine is safe as well as effective. There have been some rare complications to the vaccine: Guillain-Barré syndrome in the 1970s and the recent reports that prior vaccination may have made disease from H1N1 worse. Biologic systems are complex, but I look at vaccines as much safer than seat belts and air bags, both of which can cause injury and death. I would still prefer to be in a car accident with seat belts and air bags and work during the flu season with vaccination.
     13.  Influenza vaccination for health care workers runs at best 70% in the US, which if it were my kids math grade would be cause for some ‘splanin. Doctors and nurses run a bit higher, with an 80% influenza vaccination rate in some institutions.
     14.  It would be nice to prevent the spread of influenza from health care workers to patients. There is no data for hospitals, although there are nursing home studies to suggest that when staff is vaccinated against flu there is a decrease in flu in the inmates, er, nursing home patients. One retrospective study suggested that units that had higher vaccination rates had fewer cases of flu, but the definitive study has yet to be done. There is buckets of biologic plausibility to suggest that vaccinating health care workers would be of benefit to patients under their care.
     15.  I have little (actually none) respect for HCWs who do not get vaccinated. We have a professional and moral obligation to place our patients first. I think those who do not get vaccinated, except for a minority with a valid allergy, are dumb asses. Here is a copy of my yearly screed over at Medscape:
This essay is, I would like to clarify, directed at healthcare providers, not patients. Healthcare providers have no excuse to avoid the flu vaccine: they have access to the world’s medical knowledge and should be able to rise above superstition and ignorance. Yes, I too am a Dumb Ass, but for different reasons.
I give you, slightly rewritten for 2012, a Budget of Dumb Asses.
I wonder if you are one of those Dumb Asses who do not get the flu shot each year? Yes. Dumb Ass. Big D, big A. You may be allergic to the vaccine (most are not when tested), you may have had Guillain-Barre (most can be vaccinated safely), in which case I will cut you some slack. But if you don’t have those conditions and you work in healthcare and you don’t get a vaccine for one of the following reasons, you are a Dumb Ass.
1. The vaccine gives me the flu.Dumb Ass. It is a killed vaccine. It cannot give you the influenza. It is impossible to get flu from the influenza vaccine.
2. I never get the flu, so I don’t need the vaccine.Irresponsible Dumb Ass. I have never had a head on collision, but I wear my seat belt. And you probably don’t use a condom either. So far you have been lucky, and you are a potential winner of a Darwin Award, although since you don’t use a condom, you are unfortunately still in the gene pool.
3. Only old people get the flu.Selfish Dumb Ass. Influenza can infect anyone, and the groups who are more likely to die of influenza are the very young, the pregnant, and the elderly. Often those most at risk for dying from influenza are those least able, due to age or underlying diseases, to respond to the vaccine. You can help prevent your old, sickly Grandmother or your newborn daughter from getting influenza by getting the vaccine, so you do not get flu and pass it one to her. Flu, by the way, is highly contagious, with 20% to 50% of contacts with an index case getting the flu. However, Granny may be sitting on a fortune that will come to you, and killing her off with the flu is a great way to get her out of the way and never be caught. That would make a good episode of CSI.
4. I can prevent influenza or treat it by taking echinacea, vitamin C, oscillococcinum or Airborne. Gullible Dumb Ass cubed then squared. None of these concoctions has any efficacy what so ever against influenza. And if you think oscillococcinum has any efficacy, I would like you to invest in a perpetual motion machine I have invented. None of the above either prevent or treat influenza. And you can’t “boost” your immune system either. Anyone who suggests otherwise wants you money, not to improve your health.
5. Flu isn’t all that bad of a disease. Underestimating Dumb Ass. Part of the problem with the term flu is that it is used both as a generic term for damn near any viral illness with a fever and is also used for a severe viral pneumonia. Medical people are just as inaccurate about using the term as the general public. The influenza virus directly and indirectly kills 20,000 people (depending on the circulating strain and year) and leads to the hospitalization of 200,000 in the US each year. Influenza is a nasty lung illness. And what is stomach ‘flu’? No such thing.
6. I am not at risk for flu. Denying Dumb Ass. If you breathe, you are risk for influenza. Here are the groups of people who should not get the flu vaccine (outside of people with severe adverse reactions to the vaccine): Former President Clinton, who evidently doesn’t inhale. Michele Bachmann. Wait, that’s the HPV vaccine. And people who are safe from zombies. If you don’t get the vaccine you do not have to worry about the zombie apocalypse, because zombies eat brains.
7. The vaccine is worse than the disease. Dumb Ass AND a wimp. What a combination. Your mother must be proud. Unless you think a sore deltoid for a day is too high a price to pay to prevent two weeks of high fevers, severe muscles aches, and intractable cough.
8. I had the vaccine last year, so I do not need it this year. Uneducated Dumb Ass. Each year new strains of influenza circulate across the world. Last year’s vaccine at best provides only partial protection. Every year you need a new shot.
9. The vaccine costs too much.Cheap Dumb Ass. The vaccine costs less than a funeral, less than Tamiflu, and less than a week in the hospital.
10. I received the vaccine and I got the flu anyway. Inexact Dumb Ass. The vaccine is not perfect and you may have indeed had the flu. More likely you called one of the many respiratory viruses (viri?) people get each year the flu. Remember there are dozens of potential causes of a respiratory infection circulating, the vaccine only covers influenza, the virus most likely to kill you and yours.
11. I don’t believe in the flu vaccine. Superstitious, premodern, magical thinking Dumb Ass. What is there to believe in? Belief is what you do when there is no data. Probably don’t believe in gravity or germ theory either. Everyone, I suppose, has to believe in something, and I believe I will have a beer.
12. I will wait until I have symptoms and stay home.Dangerous Dumb Ass. Despite often coming to work ill, especially second year residents, about 1 in 5 cases of influenza are subclinical, hospitalized patients are more susceptible to acquiring influenza from HCW’s than the general population, and 27% of nosocomial acquired H1N1 died. And you will never realize that you were the one responsible for killing that patient by passing on the flu.
13. The flu vaccine is not safe and has not been evaluated for safety. Computer illiterate Dumb Ass. There are 1342 references on the PubMeds on safety of the flu vaccine, and the vaccine usually causes only short term, mild reactions. All health care requires weighing the risks of an intervention against the benefits. For the flu vaccine all the data suggests huge benefit for negligible risk. And as a HCW, it could be argued that we have a moral responsibility to maximize the safety of our patients.
14. The government puts tracking nanobots in the vaccine as well as RFID chips as part of the mark of the beast, and the vaccine doesn’t work since it is part of a big government sponsored conspiracy to keep Americans ill, fill hospital beds, line the pockets of big pharma and inject the American sheeple with exotic new infections in an attempt to control population growth and help usher in a New World Order. Well, that excuse is at least reasonable.Paranoid Dumb Ass.
So get the vaccine. And pass this essay on to someone else instead of the flu. The life you may save may be your own. Or be a Dumb Ass.
     16.  And this leads to my final thought. There is a tremendous amount of medical literature pointing to the safety and wide ranging benefits of the influenza vaccine as well as the morbidity and mortality that influenza inflicts on humans every year. Despite that information, when you are admitted to the hospital you have a greater than one in three chance that the HCW taking care of you is ignoring that information and going unvaccinated.
I have long been of the opinion that you judge a person by the company they keep. If your health care worker is a big enough dumb ass to avoid the flu vaccine, what other areas of medicine are they equally incompetent in? Do you want to drive in a car with no seat belts or air bag, whose brakes are of uncertain maintenance? Do you want you or your loved ones to be cared for by someone who is dumb ass enough to not get the flu vaccine, putting you and yours at risk when most vulnerable? Can you expect that person to do the rest of their job correctly when they cannot understand and implement a core competency of medicine? Not me.
Here is my suggestion. When you and yours are in the clinic or the hospital, request care only from practitioners that have had the flu vaccine. Put a sign on your hospital room door: No entry unless you are influenza vaccinated or put a copy of this essay on the door. You do have the right to refuse care, especially from a dumb ass.
I know this idea is a non-starter. Sick, vulnerable people are in no condition to potentially antagonize their providers. No one is likely to want to piss off their HCW, especially if that person holds the key to the morphine.
There is a bankrupt idea that it is OK for patients to ask their provider if they washed their hands. It never worked. I took an informal poll of patients on one of my medical floors and asked if they would ever tell their doctor or nurse to wash their hands and not a one said they would. It would be like asking your pilot if he put the wheels down as they stated a landing. Patients need to trust that we are doing what is in their best interests. When it comes to influenza vaccination, you can’t.
I do not really expect anyone will actually ask to be cared for only by influenza vaccinated providers.
But I can dream.
References
Of sorts. I had the opportunity to play golf with my brother and son and the time I would normally spend linking to references was spent on the links. I hope to update it, but really, you can’t search the Pubmeds?
        ◦ Dolan GP, Harris RC, Clarkson M, Sokal R, Morgan G, Mukaigawara M, et al.Vaccination of health care workers to protect patients at risk for acute respiratory disease.Emerg Infect Dis [serial on the Internet]. 2012 Aug [date cited].
        ◦ Nosocomial H1N1 infection during 2010-2011 pandemic: a retrospective cohort study from a tertiary referral hospital.J Hosp Infect. 2012 Jul;81(3):202-5. Epub 2012 Jun 1.m

Uneasy Lies the Head That Wears the Flu
Mark Crislip on April 19, 2013
Link
Infectious diseases (ID), as those who read my not-so-secret other blog know, is without a doubt the most interesting speciality of medicine. Every interesting disease is infectious in etiology. What is cool about ID is that it has connections into almost every facet of human culture and history.
I note that at some point I have gone from being the young whippersnapper to the Grandpa Simpson at my hospitals and am one of the few who has been around long enough to be a repository of institutional memory. I remember what it was like 20 plus years ago, when no one consistently washed their hands, when all S. aureus (S. aureui?) were sensitive to beta-lactams and we wore an onion on our belt, as was the style of the day. Oh the changes I have seen.
Besides remembering the not so good old days of my professional career, ID keeps me reminded of how the world used to be in the past. Medicine used to be about the epidemics that would routinely sweep across the world. Polio, measles, mumps, scarlet fever, rheumatic fever, tuberculosis and on and on. I occasionally see TB but thanks to modern medicine many of these scourges have mostly faded from medical practice in the US. Not a one, I might add, has faded due to the efforts of alt med practitioners.
Influenza still gives me pause. It is, as infections go, quite the tricky virus and it remains a difficult beast to treat and prevent. Which is a drag as it remains one of the more consistent causes of infectious morbidity and mortality.
Epidemics and pandemics of influenza have been a reliable feature of the human condition since the gasping oppression first hit Europe 500 years ago. But it is never as simple as flu comes, people are sick, flu goes away.
There are three broad issues in how people respond to infections. There is the host and how able they are to deal with infections: genetic, nutritional, immunologic and other comorbidities that increase or decrease the chance that an individual patient may succumb to a given infection. This century has been fascinating in elucidating the increasing number of genetic variations that in part determine the outcome of an infection. There are those who scoff at personalized medicine, but I look forward to the day when I can smear my patient’s DNA out on a slide, point and say ‘look there’. There is the polymorphism that makes you susceptible or resistant to an infection. In part it is the terrain, but not in the manner the germ theory denialists would have us believe.
There is the effectiveness of the antibiotic, an issue of declining importance as increasing microbial resistance slowly pushes us into the post-antibiotic era. It is also the simplest factor in the interplay of forces that determine the outcome of an infection.
And then there is the intrinsic virulence of the infecting organism. Some organisms are relatively simple in their ability to infect and kill, and others, like S. aureus, are much more devious. I think of S. aureus as the Professor Moriarty of infections. Maybe influenza is the Ra’s al Ghul. I don’t know. Stretching for a metaphor. But looking over the history of influenza, you realize it has a nasty habit of coming back, new and improved, to wreak havoc.
On SCAM sites you can often find the opinion that influenza isn’t that bad, or that the medical-industrial complex overstates the morbidity and mortality of influenza to scare people into vaccination. Sometimes the flu season is mild and sometimes it is not. But I remember.
Those who do not remember the past are condemned to underestimate the morbidity and mortality of influenza.
~ George Santayana. Sort of.
Most in ID have the 1918-1919 pandemic in the back of our minds. In a world before jet travel, influenza went around the world three times, killing about 5% of the world. Some died directly from the flu, some from bacterial superinfections, and some, perhaps, from excessive aspirin consumption. The pandemic was also associated with a marked increase in lost pregnancies, perhaps as many as 1 in 10.
The virus in 1918 appears to have had the dreaded combination of both infectivity and virulence. They have reconstructed the influenza from specimens in the Alaskan permafrost and it was particularly virulent.
2013 is not 1919. We have better nutrition, better understanding of disease spread, antibiotics and better health care (no, not the ‘health care system’ in the US but the ability to treat the ill).
But there is always the worry that influenza will return in a form that is both very infectious and extremely virulent. And it is probably not ‘if’ but ‘when’ it will happen.
The last couple of years there have been some worrisome influenzas. First there is the bird flu, H5N1, that has been slowly making its way across the world. It has high mortality rates, with 60% of cases dying of the disease. It is not, however, particularly infectious as it has decreased affinity to human receptors to which it needs to bind to start disease:
The affinity of the influenza virus to different sialyl-sugar structures is an important determinant of range and pathogenicity in the viral host.14,15 Human influenza viruses preferentially bind to α2,6 sialyl glycan, whereas most avian viruses bind to α2,3 sialyl glycan. Q226L in the HA protein, which was first reported in H7 field viruses, as well as H5 subtypes, was expected to bind strongly to α-2,6 human-like receptors.
It is why those who have developed H5N1 have had to had close and prolonged contact with birds before getting the disease. They had to suck in a lot of influenza before it could cause disease.
However it would only take a couple of mutations or acquisition of a new chunk of DNA for the H5N1 strain to become far more infectious, although as a consequence it could lose some virulence. The two do not always go hand in hand, since it may not pay for the virus to be too virulent. There is, as an aside, some information to suggest that HIV, perhaps due to declining opportunity for spread due to safe sex etc, is becoming more infectious/virulent.
But for now H5N1 is a low grade uneasy worry in the back of the mind. Is it going to acquire new DNA? Mutate? Both? Neither? Fade away like an old soldier? Got me. If I could predict the future I would not be writing for this blog
Then there was H1N1.
Getting in the wayback machine I can see my first response to H1N1, published Tuesday, 28 Apr 2009 on my other blog:
I had five days off with my youngest for his spring break, and we spent the time at the Oregon Coast. Great time. No TV, only dial up internet, no newspaper, no contact with the real world. So I get back on Sunday and my wife tells me we are in a State of Emergency.
What?
We have closed the borders with Mexico
No way. Why?
Because of Swine Flu.
Huh? Flu season is over. Where in the hell did that come from?
Whether or not this is going to be a pandemic strain, and whether it is going to kill off 2% of the world like the 1919 pandemic, I can’t say. It may just dribble off the court and be a false alarm. I hope so.
However, people seem to be in panic mode real soon. As I write this there are 40 cases in the US, no deaths. People are wearing masks around town and asking for oseltamivir. Some people are keeping there kids home from school, even though no cases reported in Oregon.
We are just finishing the flu season. There were about 30,000 documented cases of flu, 55 deaths documented in kids, and thousands of extra deaths in adults. And it was a slow year.
There is a Cinco de Mayo party coming up (what day is that?) and concern was expressed about having the kids attend. Maybe 30,000 people die each year in car accidents. If you really want to protect you kids you would make sure they got a flu shot and not let them in a car. And don’t get me started on deaths from guns.
Swine flu? We will see. “Prediction is very hard, especially when it’s about the future” – Yogi Berra” Or perhaps it was “I predict the future to be full of pic-a-nic baskets, Boo-Boo.” Ask a psychic, not me.
I would prefer the government to over-react than under-react with infections. They (infections not government. Or did I get it backwards?) can spread to fast and kill too quickly. It is better safe than sorry. One of these days, be it avian flu, or this swine flu, or another strain, flu will come out of nowhere and kill a boatload of people. If it is going to kill lots of people, there is not much we can do for now except not inhale. Worked for President Clinton.
H1N1 turned out to be better than it could have been but worse than I would have wanted. An amazing thing about the H1N1 epidemic was that in Portland it was just severe enough to hit our peak capacity: every ICU bed full, all ventilators in use and if another patient came through the door needing advanced care we had nothing. They would die. Instead, the pandemic faded. There were also deaths I am not accustomed to seeing: the young, the pregnant, and we had two deaths from H1N1 encephalitis.
World wide H1N1
resulted in an estimated range of deaths from between 151,700 and 575,400 people who perished worldwide from 2009 H1N1 virus infection during the first year the virus circulated. A disproportionate number of deaths occurred in Southeast Asia and Africa, where access to prevention and treatment resources are more likely to be limited.
Mortality not as awful as prior pandemics at least in terms of numbers killed, unless you were the one who died. It was more remarkable as to who died and it was the worst flu season of my career.
It will be interesting to see what the epidemiology of this year’s flu season will be. It was a busy year with a lot of influenza in the outpatient setting but my sense is that there was little impact on my hospitals. There was not the surge of the critically ill in the ICU we saw with H1N1.
And now? There is H7N9 in China, a new bird flu.
Virulent? Seems to be. About 17 of 87 cases have died, about 20%, a number that is a moving target. Infectious? Best I can tell human to human transmission is perhaps possible, although most cases are from poultry. It apparently has low virulence in birds but kills humans, so it has the potential to spread widely by way of migratory birds, a worry with H5N1 as well. And the entire human population is at risk; with no prior H7N9 infections in humans no one is immune.
And it apparently has good potential:
The gene sequences also indicate that these viruses may be better adapted than other avian influenza viruses to infecting mammals. For example, the presence of Q226L in the HA protein has been associated with reduced binding to avian-like receptors bearing sialic acids linked to galactose by α-2,3 linkages found in the human lower respiratory tract,1 and potentially an enhanced ability to bind to mammalian-like receptors bearing sialic acids linked to galactose by α-2,6 linkages located in the human upper airway.
It would appear that H7N9 is not to be the next pandemic strain to repeat the disaster of 1918. Not quite there genetically. One of these days, though, it will happen. Infectious, virulent and a susceptible population and influenza will kill a lot of people.
Only the dead have seen the end of influenza.
~ George Santayana. Sort of.

Even in 2014, influenza kills
David Gorski on January 11, 2014
Link
I don’t think it can be repeated too many times during flu season: People can die of the flu.
The flu vaccine is one of the two vaccines most easily demonized by the antivaccine movement. The first, of course, is Gardasil (or Cervarix), the vaccine against HPV. The reason why Gardasil is so easily demonized is because it protects against an infection whose end result of cancer is many years in the future. Alt-med fans frequently castigate “conventional medicine” for not emphasizing prevention enough, but HPV vaccines put the lie to that. HPV vaccines protect against an infection that is usually fairly harmless in and of itself but has the long term effect of vastly increasing the risk of at least one potentially deadly cancer, and likely several others. Also, HPV infections are commonly sexually transmitted, allowing the moralistic wing of the antivaccine movement and misguided religious people in essence to “slut shame” the vaccine by arguing that it will encourage promiscuity by removing one of the consequences of sexual intercourse, one of the stupidest arguments against the HPV in existence. (Seriously, does anyone think teens and young adults, when their hormones are raging, worry about maybe the possibility of maybe getting cancer 20 years down the road when on the verge of a night of passion now? I don’t.)
The flu vaccine, of course, is the victim of the difficulty in targeting the vaccine to the strains of flu that circulate yearly, rendering the flu vaccine of variable effectiveness from year to year. When health officials guess right and target a year’s flu vaccine correctly against the strains of flu that circulate that year, the vaccine is quite effective. When they don’t guess right, not so much. Unfortunately, the design of a universal flu vaccine is very difficult and introducing one into the market is likely still at least a few years off. There’s also the widespread mistaken conflation of flu-like illnesses and colds with the actual flu. The actual flu is a bad actor. The last time I had it, which was, not so surprisingly, the last time I was too lazy to get the yearly flu vaccine, it knocked me on my posterior for over a week. I thought I was in danger of dying: high fever, generalized malaise and musculoskeletal aches, a bad cough, and in general just feeling awful. That is the flu. It can cause so much inflammation in your lungs that you can get a secondary pneumonia or your lungs can fail from the inflammation caused by the infection. If all you have is a few sniffles and a cough plus or minus a low grade fever, you probably do not have the flu, but people commonly think that it is. Based on this misconception, they downplay the seriousness of the flu, thinking they can deal with it if they get it. Most probably can, although they’ll be laid up for several days. Some, however, cannot, even if they’re young and healthy:
Alice Jones and her husband, Darrell, both in college and raising three children, got sick with the flu on a Thursday. By Monday, Alice, 29, an aspiring Dallas nurse, was dead.
Darrell Jones, a criminal justice student who served in the U.S. Army in Afghanistan for nearly a year, said he and his children are so devastated they can’t stay in their house and are temporarily living with relatives.
“I made it through Afghanistan and thought we would move on with our lives,” said Jones, who turned 27 the day his wife died. “I was thinking that was the most dangerous part of our marriage.”
Neither Jones nor his wife had gotten flu shots this year. At the time of her death at University General Hospital on Jan. 6, doctors insisted that the three children, ages 10, 7 and 3, be checked out and vaccinated.
One of the boys tested positive for flu.
It happened fast, too. Three days after she started showing symptoms, Alice started to experience shortness of breath. The next morning, she went to a clinic to seek care and this is what happened:
Monday morning, Jones said he took his wife to their local medical clinic, and when they found that her blood pressure was low, the clinic called 911 and she was rushed to University General Hospital, where she began to experience seizures.
“They were going to do a CT scan and got her into the ICU,” said Jones. “She started coding, and they couldn’t get her stable. I made it out there on time before her last breath. … It was a big shock. I still can’t really believe it.”
Here was a woman who was young and healthy, and in a mere four days or so after getting sick she was dead. She had her whole life to look forward to, to quote the common cliché used whenever anyone young dies unexpectedly, and there are now three children without a mother and a husband without a wife. Antivaccinationists frequently try to discount people who die from the flu, either by claiming that it wasn’t the flu that killed them or trying to argue that the flu only kills the very old and sick or the very young (as in babies). Of course, that latter observation is, at the very least, an excellent argument for vaccinating babies and children, but antivaccinationists do their best to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt (FUD) about flu vaccines (all vaccines, actually) among the parents who have to consent to allow their babies and children to be vaccinated. In the case of Alice Jones, none of these arguments apply. In the fantasy world of antivaccinationists who downplay the seriousness of the flu as a disease, Alice Jones should still be alive.
But she isn’t.
Alice Jones is the human face of the toll influenza takes every year. I first noticed that it could be a bad flu season this year in my neck of the woods when this article appeared in a local newspaper shortly after New Years: “3 more die of H1N1 flu in Michigan, with a dozen others on life support”.
Potentially deadly H1N1 — the influenza virus strain behind the 2009 pandemic — continues its resurgence in Michigan, with three more deaths reported by hospital officials.
About a dozen adults and children — patients who previously were healthy — have been on life support at the University of Michigan Health System’s hospitals because of the virus, according to the hospital system.
Three adults have died, according to a health system spokeswoman. An infant from central Michigan also has died from H1N1, according to the Michigan Department of Community Health.
“These deaths are among previously healthy individuals. This is not the group that the public usually thinks about as being susceptible to serious illness with influenza,” said Dr. Matt Davis, chief medical executive for the state health department and a U-M professor of pediatrics and communicable diseases and of internal medicine.
Some of these patients were referred to the University of Michigan Health System because their flu was so severe. Some had to be placed on extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO), in essence a heart lung bypass machine for “long term” use (days instead of the usual hours when it’s used in the OR during cardiac surgery) to oxygenate the blood when the lungs shut down. U. of M. was a pioneer in this technique. This is consistent with a report I’ve heard from a certain blogging infectious disease colleague of mine known for his strong opinions on the flu vaccine right here on this very blog, who also has been consulted on patients with the flu who had to be placed on ECMO. It’s also consistent with news reports from elsewhere in the country, such as “Six more Bay Area flu deaths reported“:
Six more deaths in relatively young Bay Area residents have been attributed to influenza, likely the subtype known as “swine flu,” public health officials reported Thursday.
So far, that makes eight flu-related deaths in the region as the annual flu season kicks into high gear.
In Marin County, a 63-year-old man with serious chronic conditions in addition to the flu died on Dec. 27, and a 48-year-old woman with no underlying conditions died Jan. 6, according to public health officials. In Santa Clara County, public health officials reported the death of a 61-year-old man, the second flu fatality there.
A 23-year-old resident died of flu in Sonoma County and a woman in her 40s died in San Mateo County. Thursday evening, San Francisco public health officials reported one death from the flu.
This story, as others have, reports that most, if not all, of the adults who have died of the flu thus far this flu season had not been vaccinated.
Perhaps the most famous flu vaccine “skeptic” (actually, pseudoskeptic/denialist) is Bill Maher, who has been known for spreading misinformation claiming that the flu vaccine can contribute to Alzheimer’s disease, that it doesn’t work, that it’s full of toxins, and that getting vaccinated is the “worst thing you can do,” all mixed with germ theory denialism (his denials notwithstanding) and an unjustified faith in the ability of “healthy living” to protect him from the flu. It’s the vaccine that Maher criticizes the most, although, ironically, he’s totally down with Gardasil. Maher’s not alone, though. There are antivaccinationists, contrarians like Tom Jefferson (who has even appeared on Gary Null’s radio show, and many others spreading FUD about the flu vaccine.
When you read the latest screed by the latest antivaccinationist telling you that you shouldn’t get the flu vaccine, consider this. It is true that the flu vaccine could be better. It’s true that it doesn’t provide you anywhere near 100% protection against the flu (although in years when the vaccine matches the flu strains well it is quite good). It’s even true that flu vaccines (for adults, anyway) may contain mercury in the form of the thimerosal preservative that is still in some flu vaccines. You should get it anyway. The risk is minuscule, and the flu can still kill. You might think, as Bill Maher does, that just because you’re perfectly healthy you can prevent the flu with healthy living and, if you’re unlucky and get it anyway, weather its effects with little difficulty. You’d be wrong, even if you’re in seemingly perfect health.
We can’t know whether Alice Jones thought something like that or not. She’s dead now from the flu. But it wouldn’t surprise me if she did. I’m not saying that she was antivaccine. Again, we have no way of knowing that; most likely she was not. Far more probable is that she was more like most people who fail to get the flu vaccine. They tend to be just people who, perhaps under the sway of mistaken confidence that leads them to think that the flu isn’t so bad and that they can handle it if they catch it, place getting vaccinated low on their list of priorities, sometimes so low that some years they don’t bother to do it at all. It’s an easy omission to make, particularly if you’re a young mother with three children to take care of and are thus very busy doing other things. I’ve even made that mistake—once. Never again. I was fortunate enough that, although I was very sick, I didn’t need to be hospitalized, and I didn’t die. Far too many are not that fortunate. Like Alice Jones.
Oh, and if you haven’t already, get your flu vaccine, people. It’s late, but still not too late.

Scam Stud. The Food ‘Babe’ and Flu Vaccination
Mark Crislip on October 18, 2013
Link
We have evolved in order to survive reality, not to understand it. And it is a good thing that understanding and survival are not tightly linked as many people are apparently totally disconnected from the reality I inhabit, the one described by the natural sciences. When I started writing and podcasting about the SCAMverse I was under the impression that people who used SCAMs were simply misinformed. If people were made aware of the facts of the matter, they would see the error of their ways and put away their SCAMs as the childish thoughts they are.
Silly me. Reality, as I understand it, is often if little interest to proponents of SCAM. This was brought home by the Food Babe with an essay Should I get the Flu Shot? Spoiler alert. Her answer is “No, I’m not taking the Flu Shot. Ever.”
It is how she reaches that conclusion that is amazing. There are nouns and adjectives and adverbs and verbs and article and prepositions. They are strung together to form sentences and paragraphs, but somehow, though an almost magical alchemy, all that writing transmutes into content that is completely divorced from reality as I understand it. It is a tour de farce that reaches the definition of the Pauli Principle, where “It is not only not right, it is not even wrong.”
Who is the Food Babe? A blogger and media personality who has been all over the print and electronic media. I am increasingly aware of how out of touch I am, for I was unaware of the Food Babe. I will confess to feeling a little sympathetic for Jenny McCarthy. Many articles about her wackaloon approach to autism and vaccines make mention of her appearing Playboy, as if being naked or attractive makes her message less valid. Her being wrong about vaccines has nothing to do with either her attractiveness or intelligence. The few times I have seen her interviewed on TV she was funny and articulate, although she was not discussing vaccines. I have yet to see a correlation between being attractive and being intelligent. Or being intelligent and being gullible. They are three independent variables. So whether or not Food Babe is, in fact, a babe, I will leave to others as it is not germane to the content of her post, which is butt ugly.
Food Babe is a blogger who focuses on food and says she is:
most knowledgeable about harmful ingredients in processed foods and how to avoid them. For this reason, I have made it my mission to spread as much information as I can about what is in food, how to make the right purchasing decisions at the grocery store and how to live an organic lifestyle in this over-processed world.
She is evidently self-taught, having her undergraduate degree in computer science, and her essay on the influenza vaccine suggests her institution of higher learning forgot the science part in her degree.
I freely admit I do not care that much about nutrition. I do not use food as medicine and as such food is mostly overrated. While I try to eat reasonably and nutritiously, during the day food is mostly fuel for the neurons. At home and on weekends I see food as one of the great pleasures of life. Pooh sums it up for me:
’When you wake up in the morning, Pooh,’ said Piglet at last, ‘what’s the first thing you say to yourself?’‘What’s for breakfast?’ said Pooh. ‘What do you say, Piglet?’‘I say, I wonder what’s going to happen exciting today?’ said Piglet.Pooh nodded thoughtfully. ‘It’s the same thing,’ he said.
As such I am not that interested in her blog entries on food, but I did notice that Food Babe has a curious approach to reality. Reading her website finds this thorazine-deficient paragraph as an argument to not use your microwave:
Last by not least, Dr. Masaru Emoto, who is famous for taking pictures of various types of waters and the crystals that they formed in the book called “Hidden Messages in Water,” found water that was microwaved did not form beautiful crystals – but instead formed crystals similar to those formed when exposed to negative thoughts or beliefs. If this is happening to just water – I can only imagine what a microwave is doing to the nutrients, energy of our food and to our bodies when we consume microwaved food. For the experiment pictured above, microwaved water produced a similar physical structure to when the words “satan” and “hitler” were repeatedly exposed to the water. This fact is probably too hokey for most people – but I wanted to include it because sometimes the things we can’t see with the naked eye or even fully comprehend could be the most powerful way to unlock spontaneous healing.
So that’s why my microwave-warmed coffee tastes off: the hitler and satan crystals. The problem is when I rewarm the coffee on the stovetop it makes boehner and bachmann crystals, which leave an exceptionally bad taste in the mouth and I do not like room temperature coffee.
And she dares, dares mind you, to cast aspersions on beer. Beer! Next up will be apple pie and mom. Evidently her article was not up to the standards reality and veracity that brewers would prefer:
Trawling through the bad grammar and typos (Not an issue for me, glass houses and all that -MC) was painful enough, but putting that aside, and dealing with the innuendo, misrepresentation, and blatant falsehoods made it doubly so.
Food Babe applies the same techniques to her analysis of the influenza vaccine and I suspect that there is not a single sentence relating to influenza and the vaccine that does not meet the above description. For the pedant in the audience, we will take it as given there is an inhaled influenza vaccine and refer to it no more. All that follows will concern the injectable vaccine.
She starts:
I want you to think about what you are directly injecting into your bloodstream.
I occasionally tell the house staff that precision of thought is reflected in precision of speech and precision of writing. God knows I have learned the hard way writing for this and other blogs what happens when I am not precise. I write for a tough crowd.
But really, that is just such cheesy innuendo. The vaccine is an intramuscular injection. The vaccine has to be absorbed into the bloodstream from the muscle. By the same argument, everything you eat is injected directly into the bloodstream. Sigh. This blog is not looking good for veracity.
She continues, jumping strait into the toxin gambit:
What’s exactly in the Flu Shot? To sum it up – A bunch of toxic chemicals and additives that lead to several types of Cancers and Alzheimer [sic] disease over time
See what I mean. All the components of a sentence but with zero true content, like a diet Coke. As we will see, Food Babe is, somewhat ironically, the aspartame of medical understanding. More the fool me, I thought the flu shot was predominantly proteins derived from the influenza virus grown in eggs or from recombinant technology selected for their ability to elicit protective antibody. And vaccines and their components cause neither cancer nor Alzheimer’s.
She then lists the components that ‘could’ be ‘lurking’ in the vaccine and mentions all the usual suspects save the most potentially fatal one:
Egg Products (including avian contaminant viruses), Aluminum, Thimersol [sic] (Mercury), Monosodium Glutamate (MSG), Chick Embryo Cells, Latex, Formaldehyde, Gelatin, Polysorbate 80, Triton X100 (strong detergent), Sucrose (table sugar), Resin, Gentamycin [sic].I won’t eat any of these ingredients or even put them on my body.
There goes peas, carrots and beets, good sources of sucrose and probably no pana cotta for the Food Babe, which means more for me and Pooh.
As the 2000 year old saying goes, it’s the dose that makes the poison. As an example, blood levels of formaldehyde, a product of normal metabolism, are 2.74 mg/L , about 15 mg total in a normal adult. A vaccine has about 1/50 the formaldehyde of a pear and given the concentration in the vaccine, the gradient would probably pull formaldehyde out of the body and into the injection site.
Only the multidose vials contain thimerisol and no flu vaccine, that’s no as in none, zero, zip, nil, nada, contains aluminum. So crediting those molecules as the reason vaccines increase the risk for Alzheimer’s (they don’t) is disingenuous at best. One would think a computer scientist could manage the Googles to find out the ingredients in the flu vaccine. It took me less than a minute.
However, Food Babe did say ‘could’ and could is not ‘is’, so if there were a freak transporter accident involving a shipment of influenza vaccine and soft drink cans, aluminum could be found in the influenza vaccine. The odds of that occurring are about the same as Food Babe doing proper research.
I am surprised she did not include dihydrogen oxide, found in every vaccine, which kills 4,000 people a year in the US. That is about the level of the Food Babes arguments. It is evident she does not put resin in her body, although I thought it was spelled r-e-a-s-o-n.
Then she says, after reading “a couple of studies” that the flu vaccine does not work. I have discussed at length (see links below) the issues around influenza vaccine efficacy. It you were to read the most of the 2087 studies on flu vaccination efficacy instead of a couple you might conclude, as I have, that the vaccine prevents influenza, its complications (secondary infections, stroke, heart attack, spontaneous abortion) and decreases the chance of spread to vulnerable populations.
No, the CDC even admits it doesn’t protect you because the virus mutates every year.
CDC says that? It does really? Here is what I find the CDC says:
How effective is the flu vaccine?How well the flu vaccine works (or its ability to prevent flu illness) can range widely from season to season. The vaccine’s effectiveness also can vary depending on who is being vaccinated. At least two factors play an important role in determining the likelihood that flu vaccine will protect a person from flu illness: 1) characteristics of the person being vaccinated (such as their age and health), and 2) the similarity or “match” between the flu viruses the flu vaccine is designed to protect against and the flu viruses spreading in the community. During years when the flu vaccine is not well matched to circulating viruses, it’s possible that no benefit from flu vaccination may be observed. During years when there is a good match between the flu vaccine and circulating viruses, it’s possible to measure substantial benefits from vaccination in terms of preventing flu illness. However, even during years when the vaccine match is very good, the benefits of vaccination will vary across the population, depending on characteristics of the person being vaccinated and even, potentially, which vaccine was used.Each season researchers try to determine how well flu vaccines work to regularly assess and confirm the value of flu vaccination as a public health intervention. Study results about how well a flu vaccine works can vary based on study design, outcome(s) measured, population studied and the season in which the flu vaccine was studied. These differences can make it difficult to compare one study’s results with another’s.While determining how well a flu vaccine works is challenging, in general, recent studies have supported the conclusion that flu vaccine.
I admire the way Food Babe can take a complex and nuanced topic and distill it down to an aliquot of pure error. It is a talent rarely seen outside of the Tea Party.
And she has a poor concept of vaccination and immunity and is under the false impression that vaccines are both lifelong and perfect:
Why do I have to get a Flu Shot every year? Aren’t vaccines suppose [sic] to immunize you for life? (Err, no – MC)…And this brings me back to my previous point – if the flu vaccine were truly a vaccine – it wouldn’t wear off. Think about it – Once you get chicken pox as a child, your body develops antibodies to strengthen your immune system from ever getting chicken pox again (Um, reinfections can occur and there is shingles – MC) This is how vaccines are suppose [sic] to work. But the flu shot doesn’t work this way.
Another perfect misunderstanding of reality with every assertion incorrect. Of course doctors do not suggest the flu vaccine because it prevents morbidity and mortality, but because big Pharma makes money from the flu.
Why are Flu Shots recommended for children, women who are pregnant and the elderly?
I thought it was because they are at increased risk of death from influenza.
Because that group of individuals typically have weaker immune systems and if they catch the flu and don’t treat it in time it can lead to other complications like pneumonia.However, why would you give a group with already weakened immune systems something that weakens their immune system systemically further?
Because the flu vaccine doesn’t weaken “immune system systemically further?” It makes it more effective against the influenza virus by generating antibody against influenza antigen. It is, dare I say it, a real vaccine.First she says that the vaccine doesn’t work because the virus mutates, then because it isn’t a real vaccine, but the real reason?
This is why the vaccine isn’t effective in the first place, because administering a drug that weakens the immune systems makes people even more susceptible to the flu!
Medicine by the Ministry of Truth:
The Ministry of Truth is involved with news media, entertainment, the fine arts and educational books. Its purpose is to rewrite reality to change the facts to fit doctrine for propaganda effect.
I hate to say Orwellian, but if the shoe fits. Finally she concludes the best way to get immune is to go out and get influenza:
You can build lifetime antibodies against the infection. Just Skip the vaccine, boost your vitamin D intake, and encounter the flu naturally. If you encounter the flu – rest, take care of yourself, understand that your body needs a break and focus on getting better – This type of immunizing yourself works amazingly better than relying on an artificial injection that has been proven ineffective. You’ll have these new antibodies for life that will ultimately protect you from similar strains of the virus better than any yearly shot could ever provide.
And perhaps die. Or get a secondary bacterial infection. Or a stroke. Or lose your pregnancy. Or pass it on to someone less able to handle the illness who will then die.
It is hard to find an example of a piece of writing where virtually every piece of information is wrong. And when there is a nugget of truth my first response is to question my knowledge. If Food Babe says it, it must be wrong.
An almost reality-free discussion of the influenza vaccine is, in a hideous kind of way, a thing of beauty. That people may make decisions based on this fictional account of the flu vaccine flabbers my gaster, any disclaimer notwithstanding. It is a good thing for Food Babe that understanding reality is not a part of being fit to survive, but I sure hope she is never exposed to influenza, especially if pregnant.
By the way, I have decided that henceforth I shall be referred to as the SCAM Stud. Sure, I am old, balding and slightly above my fighting weight, but I do not mean stud using the Urban Dictionary definition. No way will I ever meet that definition. No one can ever drink that much beer. I’m thinking more metaphorically, the 2×4 definition, the central support of a structure. Or maybe a boss… with a large head. I’ll let you decide on the preferred usage.
Finally, this was a hard entry to write. Thanks a lot, The Onion.
Further reading
My co-bloggers and I have written at length about vaccines in general, influenza and the influenza vaccine. For a further plug, there is an ebook, Science-Based Medicine: Guide to Vaccines, Vaccine Preventable Illnesses and Autism, that is a collection of the essays from the first 2.5 years of the blog, available on Kindle, iPad and Nook.
Here are links to some of my extensively-referenced essays on influenza and vaccines:
What are words for?
Toxic myths about vaccines
I refute it thus
Uneasy Lies the Head That Wears the Flu
One Flu Into the Cuckoo’s Nest*
Protect Yourself
Drinking from the Fire Hose: Odds and Ends on the Gasping Oppression
Random Flu Thoughts
Ososillyococcinum and other Flu bits.
Influenza Vaccine Mandates
Nine Questions, Nine Answers.
The Tamiflu Spin
Yes, But. The Annotated Atlantic.
Flu Vaccine Efficacy
More Flu Woo for You Boo Boo.
Herd Immunity
Flu Woo Hodge Podge

Why Get A Flu Shot?
Mark Crislip on November 14, 2014
Link

Actual discussion:
Parent “I want #Ebola vaccine for my child”
Doc “There isn’t one, but we have #flushot”
Parent “We don’t believe in that”
So much of what we are for at Science-Based Medicine is reflected in what we oppose: all the pseudo-medical interventions and SCAMs. It is not always a positive message, forever noting why you should not be participating in a given bit of fantasy-based medicine. We are often the nay-saying curmudgeons of the medical world. Even for medical topics about for which I am in strongly in favor, vaccines, much of my prose is devoted to countering myths and lies about influenza vaccines, from why the Cochrane review is messed up to why health care workers are dumb asses for not being vaccinated.
Well no Debbie Downer or Crotchety Crislip today. Nope. We are going to ride our Rainbow Unicorn to the land of Happiness and Immunity and discuss some of the reasons why you and yours should get the influenza vaccine.
There are many fine points about the flu vaccine that makes conclusions from the literature problematic: what are the circulating strains, what strains are in the vaccine, who is getting vaccinated and the quality of the studies. Influenza is a complex and complicated disease. If you are a preponderance-of-literature kind of person, as I am, you may find that the 23,600 plus articles on influenza vaccination mostly point to widespread moderate benefit of influenza vaccination, although, as always in medicine, for every study you can find an equal and opposite study and the quality of the studies are variable. At the conclusion you will find links to the other influenza related posts I have written.
The flu vaccine decreases your chance of getting the flu. Note decreases chances, not prevents. That remains the worst aspect of the flu vaccine: it is not as effective as other vaccines. But it does prevent the influenza. Even the biased, cherry picking, awful Cochrane review has to admit efficacy:
Parenterally administered influenza vaccines appear significantly better than their comparators and can reduce the risk of developing influenza symptoms by around 4%, if the WHO recommendations are adhered to and the match is right. However, whilst the vaccines do prevent influenza symptoms, this is only one part of the spectrum of “clinical effectiveness” as they reduce the risk of total “clinical” seasonal influenza (i.e. influenza-like illness) symptoms by around 1%.
and
While the parenteral vaccine efficacy against seasonal (i.e. non- pandemic) influenza is around 75% for the WHO recommended and matched strain, its impact on the global incidence of clinical cases of influenza (i.e. ILI) is limited (around 16% in best case scenario).
despite their disingenuous attempts to sabotage their results with anti-vaccine editorializing.
Sorry. Kinder and gentler. But when I re-read their meta-analysis, my Rainbow Unicorn began to sob.
The CDC estimates vaccine efficacy at around 60%, although it varies from year to year and from population to population.
Vaccination was significantly effective against laboratory confirmed influenza during sporadic activity (odds ratio [OR] 0•69, 95% CI 0•48—0•99) only when the vaccine matched. Additionally, vaccination was significantly effective during regional (match: OR 0•42, 95% CI 0•30—0•60; mismatch: OR 0•57, 95% CI 0•41—0•79) and widespread (match: 0•54, 0•46—0•62; mismatch: OR 0•72, 95% CI 0•60—0•85) outbreaks.
In the elderly the high-dose influenza vaccine drops the risk of influenza although the standard vaccination has efficacy as well. The vaccine has variable efficacy in other populations as well: dialysis patients, diabetics, and immunosuppressed adults with cancer to name a few. I could not find a population where influenza vaccination did not have some benefit, although it does not provide perfect protection.
In a highly-vaccinated, closed population (a Navy ship), there was an outbreak of influenza when almost 100% of the seamen were vaccinated. 24% came down with flu. Horrible efficacy, right? But in nonimmune populations the attack rate can be has high as 80%, so it is better to have a quarter of you population ill than four-fifths.
Even if you get the flu, the data is suggestive that you will have a milder illness. And a milder illness may mean fewer complications, less spread of disease and fewer hospitalizations.
I know there is a strong ‘screw you’ attitude in the US. I got mine, I don’t care about you. It used to be a rising tide lifted all boats, now it sometimes seems that many are not interested participating in activities that, while it may not be of personal benefit, it might benefit those around you. With infectious diseases, having the herd maximally immune is as important as having the individual immune. It protects those who cannot protect themselves.
One of my favorite examples of the population effects of flu vaccination was in Canada where one province, Ontario, had a much higher influenza vaccination rate than other provinces and the results were impressive: a decrease in influenza-associated mortality and health care use.
As they suggest:
The results of this large-scale natural experiment suggest that universal vaccination may be an effective public health measure for reducing the annual burden of influenza.
Even with only modest efficacy, when applied to large populations vaccination leads to significant decreases in morbidity and mortality:
We estimated that during our 6-year study period, the number of influenza illnesses averted by vaccination ranged from a low of approximately 1.1 million (95% confidence interval (CI) 0.6-1.7 million) during the 2006-2007 season to a high of 5 million (CI 2.9-8.6 million) during the 2010-2011 season while the number of averted hospitalizations ranged from a low of 7,700 (CI 3,700-14,100) in 2009-2010 to a high of 40,400 (CI 20,800-73,000) in 2010-2011.
There are those who dismiss the morbidity and mortality of influenza:
As healthy adults have a low risk of complications due to respiratory disease, the use of the vaccine may be only advised as an individual protection measure against symptoms in specific cases.
It is important to remember that with infectious diseases you are vaccinating not only individuals but populations. When you get a vaccine you may also be protecting others from disease, and the effects of herd immunity are evident when you look at the effects of vaccination on the health of populations.
While the Cochrane review mentions that vaccination did not prevent influenza transmission, that was only because they did not include the studies that demonstrate vaccination leads to decreased influenza transmission. Vaccination of children decreases disease in adults. The preponderance of data shows vaccinating against influenza prevents spread to those who are not vaccinated.
The Japanese schoolchildren program provided proof of concept of indirect effectiveness of influenza vaccine. The Central Texas field trial has demonstrated significant herd protection of adults utilizing the live, attenuated influenza vaccine (LAIV) to children. Immunization of <20% of children at the intervention site resulted in an 8-18% reduction of medically attended acute respiratory illness in adults compared to rates in the comparison sites.
When health care workers are vaccinated, patients have decreased mortality and the benefits spill over into the community:
for every 15 healthcare providers who get vaccinated, 1 fewer person in the community will contract an influenza-like illness.
Not bad for protecting yourself and others. I think of the flu vaccine like seat belts. No guarantee that you will not die or get injured in an accident, but just as I would prefer to use seat belts in a head-on collision, I prefer to enter the flu season with a vaccination.
And if you are pregnant?
Vaccination decreases influenza in pregnancy women and their newborns:
Influenza vaccine was immunogenic in HIV-uninfected and HIV-infected pregnant women and provided partial protection against confirmed influenza in both groups of women and in infants who were not exposed to HIV
Decreases the risk of small babies and decreases the spontaneous abortion rates:
Pandemic influenza virus infection in pregnancy was associated with an increased risk of fetal death. Vaccination during pregnancy reduced the risk of an influenza diagnosis. Vaccination itself was not associated with increased fetal mortality and may have reduced the risk of influenza-related fetal death during the pandemic.
Also, by getting the vaccine you can avoid some of the complications of influenza. Death of course, but as those who listen to my ID podcasts know I like to harp on the concept that infections lead to inflammation, inflammation is prothrombotic, and prothrombosis can lead to vascular events, strokes, heart attacks or pulmonary emboli.
Almost every infection that has been evaluated has been found to be associated with a vascular event of one type or another. The difference is that with influenza the vaccine may be protective:
Recent influenza infection was an unrecognised comorbidity in almost 10% of hospital patients. Influenza did not predict AMI, but vaccination was significantly protective but underused.
And:
Evidence from cohort studies and a randomized clinical trial indicates that annual vaccination against seasonal influenza prevents cardiovascular morbidity and all-cause mortality in patients with cardiovascular conditions.
As well as protect against stroke, although the data is variable.
Besides vascular events, influenza vaccination may prevent pneumonia as well.
So as vaccines go, the flu vaccine isn’t perfect but has many benefits at both the individual and population levels. Is it cost effective? Got me. The literature suggests so, and I will take their word for it. Cost effectiveness analyses make my head hurt.
If you like a number needed to treat:
…in well-matched years, if we divide 100 people who got the flu shot by the three people who benefitted, we get a Number Needed to Treat of 33. In well-matched years, for every 33 people who get immunized, one will benefit by not getting a bout of influenza she otherwise would have suffered.A NNT of 33 is, by the way, a fantastically good therapy. This is far better than the NNT to benefit of many, many other common therapies, like, for example, anti-depressants, anti-hypertensive drugs and prostate cancer screening.
And:
Even in not well-matched years, the flu vaccine is still effective, albeit not quite as well. In not well-matched years, the overall risk of getting the flu drops to 2 people out of 100. The flu vaccine cuts that number in half, for a 50% risk reduction. If you do the math, one person out of 100 benefits from the flu shot, making the NNT in not well-matched years 100.
So those are some of the reasons why you and yours should get the flu vaccine: less chance of flu, less chance of spreading flu, less chance of severe disease, less chance of complications from flu, less chance of death and it makes my Rainbow Unicorn happy.
Prior flu ramblings
    • https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/scam-stud — Scam Stud
    • https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/the-tamiflu-spin — The Tamiflu Spin
    • https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/yes-but-the-annotated-atlantic — Yes, But. The Annotated Atlantic.
    • https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/cochrane-reviews-the-food-babe-of-medicine — Cochrane Reviews: The Food Babe of Medicine?
    • https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/one-flu-into-the-cuckoos-nest — One Flu Into the Cuckoo’s Nest*
    • https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/uneasy-lies-the-head-that-wears-the-flu — Uneasy Lies the Head That Wears the Flu
    • https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/what-are-words-for — What are words for?
    • https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/i-refute-it-thus — I refute it thus
    • https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/uneasy-lies-the-head-that-wears-the-flu — Uneasy Lies the Head That Wears the Flu
    • https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/protect-yourself — Protect Yourself
    • https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/drinking-from-the-fire-hose-odds-and-ends-on-the-gasping-oppression — Drinking from the Fire Hose: Odds and Ends on the Gasping Oppression
    • https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/random-flu-thoughts — Random Flu Thoughts
    • https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/ososillyococcinum-and-other-flu-bits — Ososillyococcinum and other Flu bits.
    • https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/influenza-vaccine-mandates — Influenza Vaccine Mandates
    • https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/nine-questions-nine-answers — Nine Questions, Nine Answers
    • https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/flu-vaccine-efficacy — Flu Vaccine Efficacy
    • https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/more-flu-woo-for-you-boo-boo — More Flu Woo for You Boo Boo.
    • https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/herd-immunity — Herd Immunity
    • https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/flu-woo-hodgepodge — Flu Woo Hodge Podge

   Flu Vaccine Efficacy
Mark Crislip
Link
I guess I will be spending the rest the flu season writing about the nonsense that is promulgated about the flu vaccine and the disease. One of the more common laments about the flu vaccine is that it doesn’t work: I got the flu vaccine and still got the flu. Well maybe. Maybe not. It takes a few weeks to get protection, so the flu could have developed before the antibody response to the vaccine. The vaccine does not protect to the numerous other viral infections that circulate each winter, so perhaps you had an adenovirus but thought it was the flu. Then there is the evidence. Some readers of the blog are worried that the literature does not support the use of the vaccine.
“My research for good studies on the efficasy (sic) of seasonal flu vaccines so far has left me wondering if I’ve somehow missed the good research. Tom Jefferson of the Cochrane Institute says that Most studies are of poor methodological quality and the impact of confounders is high. I agree. Please would you refer me to some of the best studies on the efficasy (sic) of seasonal flu vaccines. After a critical appraisal of the best studies you know of I’d like to submit the same for publication in the interest of science.”
Why some readers think I am a research librarian, I do not know. It is not an uncommon request. As an aside, I have a full time job and a family to raise. Don’t be asking me to do your grunt work. It’s called Pubmed. Use it.
But the topic for this post concerns the efficacy of the flu vaccine. I am limiting myself to the use of the vaccine in adults.
The flu vaccine is not out best vaccine for at least three reasons.
First, every year they have to make an educated guess which influenza strains will be circulating 9 months in the future. The better the guess, the better the protection the vaccine should provide. Some years they choose better than others. But often the match between the vaccine and the disease is not optimal, so vaccine efficacy can be decreased. The vaccine works best when there is a good antigentic match between the vaccine and circulating strain of influenza.
Second, response to the vaccine is not 100%. The older and more immunoincompetent are the least likely to develop a good antibody response to the vaccine. In a bit of medical irony, the more likely a patient is to need protection from the vaccine, the less likely they are to get a protective antibody response from the vaccine.
Third, vaccination rates are often suboptimal to get benefit in populations, i.e. herd immunity. The elderly will more likely benefit if they are not exposed to influenza at all rather than relying of vaccine mediated protection. It may be more important if those around them, say their health care provider or family, receives the vaccine and as a result does not pass flu on to more vulnerable people. But we rarely (never, ever, never) get vaccination rates at levels for herd immunity to kick in.
So it’s a suboptimal vaccine. And that’s a problem. One, because it will make it more difficult to prove efficacy in clinical studies and two, there is a sub group of anti vaccine goofs who seem to require that vaccines either be perfect, with 100% efficacy and 100% safe, or they are not worth taking.
The influenza vaccine is not 100% efficacious in preventing disease, but it is as close to 100% safe, and much safer than the disease.
There are multiple kinds of studies one could do to prove efficacy, each with their own problems.
One kind of study would be direct inoculation of flu into volunteers who received either the vaccine or placebo. This is the simplest study to do (if you can find volunteers to get the flu) and lends biologic plausibility to the vaccine, but doesn’t reflect the real world.
Another study would be to to give vaccine or placebo to populations and see who develops influenza. These are not easy studies to do well. Do you diagnose flu as a flu like illness, i.e. on clinical grounds, or do you do cultures or PCR or both to prove the diagnosis? Outside of prison or the military, it is hard to capture people through an entire flu season to get the appropriate specimens.
Or do you use other endpoints? Death? Antibiotic use? Hospitalization? Perhaps the flu will not be prevented but attenuated, so it is less likely to spread, and overall the secondary complications of influenza will decrease in a population.
Influenza and pneumonia are both associated with acute myocardial infarction. “Many observational studies in different settings with a range of methods reported consistent associations between influenza and acute myocardial infarction (PubMed).” Influenza is a risk for developing acute bacterial pneumonia. Prevent influenza (PubMed) and you would prevent both primary and secondary myocardial infractions.
The best proof of concept of this effect, where vaccination of one population leads to a decrease in disease in another population, has been with the conjugated pneumococcal vaccine used in children, the Prevnar. This vaccine covers the 7 most common strains of invasive pneumococcus in children and uptake of this vaccine is high. Use of the vaccine has resulted in invasive disease plummeting in children, and as an side benefit, invasive disease with the same strains has also plummeted in the elderly (PubMed) .
Such an effect may be occurring when children are vaccinated against influenza. “Vaccination of approximately 20-25% of children, 1.5-18 years of age in the intervention communities resulted in an indirect protection of 8-18% against MAARI (medically attended acute respiratory illness in adults > or =35 years of age.” (PubMed)(PubMed).
In the end, almost all clinical studies have limitations. For a (mostly) good review of the problematic nature of the studies to date, read Influenza vaccination: policy versus evidence. I say mostly good as the conclusion from this paper is that the data is suboptimal and doesn’t support widespread use of the vaccine. I conclude, as shall be seen, that while the data may be suboptimal, it does support the use of the influenza vaccine. And, of course, I am the right one.
Sometimes you get unlucky doing clinical trials: plan a big placebo controlled trial with the influenza vaccine and that year you have both a vaccine mismatch and a mild flu season, and you end up with no good data (PubMed).
You have make due with the tools at your disposal. There are 1207 references on pubmed using ‘influenza’ ‘vaccine’ ‘efficacy’ as search criteria. That’s a lot of papers, that show varying effects. Like much of medicine, some studies are better and some are worse and they have variable outcomes.
Direct Inoculation
This type of study is the most compelling for proof of concept, but the least “real world”. Take a population of (one hopes) volunteers and give them either the vaccine or placebo, then squirt them in the nose with influenza. This has advantages and disadvantages, but at least you know exactly when there was an infection, with what strain, and you can measure antibody levels to see if the patients had what should be protective antibodies. Best of all, you can control the strain of influenza to get a best antigenic match between the vaccine and the pathogen. In the real world none of this is possible. Unless you are fool enough to walk into the room of a known influenza patient without a mask and inhale deeply.
There have been a variety direct infection studies with flu vaccine over the years.
“Protection rate against artificial challenge with influenza A was 96% when vaccine and challenge viruses were homotypic. When the vaccine strain and challenges virus were heterotypic, protection ranged from 70-100%. Protection rate from infection during a homotypic epidemic was, retrospectively, 95%; while 50-87% protection from influenza illness was achieved during a heterotypic epidemic. In all instances, vaccinees experienced mild, mostly afebrile upper respiratory symptoms, unlike controls who had moderate to severe symptoms, often with fever. Infecting virus was shed more often by unvaccinated controls (PubMed).”
Similar results are found for the live attenuated virus vaccine:
“The efficacy of live attenuated cold-adapted (ca) reassortant influenza A H3N2 and H1N1 virus vaccines against experimental challenge with homologous wild-type virus 7 months after vaccination was compared with that of licensed inactivated virus vaccine in 106 seronegative (hemagglutination-inhibiting antibody titer less than or equal to 1:8) college students. The live attenuated virus vaccines induced as much resistance against illness as did the inactivated vaccine. Vaccine efficacy, measured by reduction in febrile or systemic illness in vaccines, compared with that in controls was 100% for ca H3N2 vaccine, 84% for inactivated H3N2 vaccine, 79% for ca H1N1 vaccine, and 67% for inactivated H1N1 vaccine. Less protection was conferred against upper respiratory tract illness; there was 50 and 77% protection in ca and inactivated H3N2 vaccines, respectively, but there was no protection in ca or inactivated H1N1 vaccinees. The duration, but not the magnitude, of H1N1 wild-type virus shedding in both ca and inactivated vaccinees was significantly reduced compared with controls. In contrast, a significant reduction in the duration and magnitude of H3N2 virus shedding was observed in ca vaccinees but not in inactivated vaccines. After wild-type virus challenge, live ca virus vaccinees demonstrated resistance at least as great 7 months postvaccination as did inactivated virus vaccinees (PubMed).”
I find these types of studies compelling. They also make me optimistic for the H1N1 vaccine in that the match between the virus and the vaccine is excellent and we should get high levels of protection from the vaccine in those that can mount an antibody response.
These are not real world examples of course. In the real world the vaccine may not match perfectly, the vaccine may not be handled and administered correctly and the patient, for innumerable co-morbid conditions, may not be able to respond to the vaccine.
However, I am still, barely, young and no medical problems yet, and a health care worker who has daily contact with the old and infirm. The data above is enough for me to take the vaccine, if for no other reason that it may prevent me from passing it on to my patients.
Specific Groups
This is the most most difficult study to do for the reasons mentioned above.
What group of people are in the study? What are the endpoints and how are they defined? And, for the study period, how good a match is the vaccine for the circulated strains of flu? All these and more make the studies for flu efficacy at best difficult to do.
The NEJM this month had a nice study on the relative efficacy of killed vrs attenuated vaccine in a healthy adult population that was allowed to get seasonal flu naturally. The end point was culture or positive PCR.
“A total of 1952 subjects were enrolled and received study vaccines in the fall of 2007. Influenza activity occurred from January through April 2008, with the circulation of influenza types A (H3N2) (about 90%) and B (about 9%). Absolute efficacy against both types of influenza, as measured by isolating the virus in culture, identifying it on real-time polymerase-chain-reaction assay, or both, was 68% (95% confidence interval [CI], 46 to 81) for the inactivated vaccine and 36% (95% CI, 0 to 59) for the live attenuated vaccine. In terms of relative efficacy, there was a 50% (95% CI, 20 to 69) reduction in laboratory-confirmed influenza among subjects who received inactivated vaccine as compared with those given live attenuated vaccine. The absolute efficacy against the influenza A virus was 72% (95% CI, 49 to 84) for the inactivated vaccine and 29% (95% CI, -14 to 55) for the live attenuated vaccine, with a relative efficacy of 60% (95% CI, 33 to 77) for the inactivated vaccine.”
Perfect? No. 72% protection from the inactivated vaccine. Not bad. Other studies have demonstrated the the live attenuated vaccine efficacy rates of 50% or better. In the elderly, for example, a
“randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study investigated the efficacy, safety, and immunogenicity of LAIV in community-dwelling ambulatory adults >/=60 years of age in South Africa in 2001. Nose and throat swabs were obtained for influenza virus culture based on the symptoms of influenza-like illness. A total of 3242 subjects were enrolled, with a mean age of 69.5 years. The efficacy of LAIV against influenza viruses antigenically similar to the vaccine was 42.3% (95% CI, 21.6-57.8%). Efficacy against A/H3N2 viruses was 52.5% (95% CI, 32.1-67.2%); vaccine efficacy was not observed against antigenically similar B strains (PubMed).”
Of course, the weapon of choice in these debates are the meta analysis. In institutionalized elderly, the vaccine, when given to staff and patients, did not prevent influenza but did decrease pneumonia and all cause mortality (PubMed)(PubMed). “Staff vaccination had a significant effect on influenza-like illness (vaccine effectiveness [VE] 86%, 95% CI 40-97%) only when patients were vaccinated too.”
So, as a health care worker, you could conclude that a) vaccine doesn’t work it doesn’t prevent influenza. I don’t need it. Or b) the vaccine benefits my patients by preventing secondary complications and decreases their risk for death.
How about the general population? The most recent Cochrane meta analysis of the vaccine efficacy in 66,248 people (almost Cardiology levels of patient involvement) from 2004 (PubMed),
“Inactivated parenteral vaccines were 30% effective (95% CI 17% to 41%) against influenza-like illness, and 80% (95% CI 56% to 91%) efficacious against influenza when the vaccine matched the circulating strain and circulation was high, but decreased to 50% (95% CI 27% to 65%) when it did not. Excluding the studies of the 1968 to 1969 pandemic, effectiveness was 15% (95% CI 9% to 22%) and efficacy was 73% (95% CI 53% to 84%). Vaccination had a modest effect on time off work, but there was insufficient evidence to draw conclusions on hospital admissions or complication rates. Inactivated vaccines caused local tenderness and soreness and erythema. Spray vaccines had more modest performance. Monovalent whole-virion vaccines matching circulating viruses had high efficacy (VE 93%, 95% CI 69% to 98%) and effectiveness (VE 66%, 95% CI 51% to 77%) against the 1968 to 1969 pandemic.
AUTHORS’ CONCLUSIONS: Influenza vaccines are effective in reducing cases of influenza, especially when the content predicts accurately circulating types and circulation is high. However, they are less effective in reducing cases of influenza-like illness and have a modest impact on working days lost. There is insufficient evidence to assess their impact on complications.”
Again, those qualifiers. But the overall meta-analysis suggests the vaccine works for prevention of influenza, and the conclusion does bode well for vaccination against H1N1, which has matches the current strain and is in high circulation.
I will say as an aside that the earlier Cochrane review suggested that influenza cases were decreased by 6% from the vaccine. One commenter over at my Medscate blog, drdan23 suggested that a 6% decrease in disease was not worth it. 30,000 direct and indirect deaths from influenza in the US, maybe 500,000 worldwide. 6% of 30,000 is 1800. 6% of 500,000 is 30,000. Only 6% decrease in deaths? I was always wondering who would be sitting on those death panels that Palin was talking about. It’s the anti flu vaccine docs.
Since 2004, clinical trials testing the efficacy of the influenza vaccine have been drifting in:
“A total of 2058 persons were vaccinated in October and November 2005. Studywide influenza activity was prolonged but of low intensity; type A (H3N2) virus was circulating, which was antigenically similar to the vaccine strain. The absolute efficacy of the inactivated vaccine was 16% (95% confidence interval [CI], -171% to 70%) for the virus identification end point (virus isolation in cell culture or identification through polymerase chain reaction) and 54% (95% CI, 4%-77%) for the primary end point (virus isolation or increase in serum antibody titer). The absolute efficacies of the live attenuated vaccine for these end points were 8% (95% CI, -194% to 67%) and 43% (95% CI, -15% to 71%), respectively.
CONCLUSIONS: With serologic end points included, efficacy was demonstrated for the inactivated vaccine in a year with low influenza attack rates (PubMed).”
Or this:
“We carried out a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of inactivated and live attenuated influenza vaccines in healthy adults during the 2004-2005 influenza season and estimated both absolute and relative efficacies.
RESULTS: A total of 1247 persons were vaccinated between October and December 2004. Influenza activity in Michigan began in January 2005 with the circulation of an antigenically drifted type A (H3N2) virus, the A/California/07/2004-like strain, and of type B viruses from two lineages. The absolute efficacy of the inactivated vaccine against both types of virus was 77% (95% confidence interval [CI], 37 to 92) as measured by isolating the virus in cell culture, 75% (95% CI, 42 to 90) as measured by either isolating the virus in cell culture or identifying it through real-time polymerase chain reaction, and 67% (95% CI, 16 to 87) as measured by either isolating the virus or observing a rise in the serum antibody titer. The absolute efficacies of the live attenuated vaccine were 57% (95% CI, -3 to 82), 48% (95% CI, -7 to 74), and 30% (95% CI, -57 to 67), respectively. The difference in efficacy between the two vaccines appeared to be related mainly to reduced protection of the live attenuated vaccine against type B viruses.
CONCLUSIONS: In the 2004-2005 season, in which most circulating viruses were dissimilar to those included in the vaccine, the inactivated vaccine was efficacious in preventing laboratory-confirmed symptomatic illnesses from influenza in healthy adults. The live attenuated vaccine also prevented influenza illnesses but was less efficacious. (PubMed).”
Or this:
“INTRODUCTION: Influenza vaccine has been shown to be highly effective in temperate regions with well-defined seasonal influenza. Healthcare workers (HCWs) are advised to receive regular influenza vaccination to protect themselves and their patients. However, there are limited data on the efficacy of influenza vaccine in HCWs in the tropics.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: In this observational, investigator blinded cohort study, bi-monthly questionnaires recording influenza-like illness (ILI) episodes and medical leave were administered to 541 HCWs at the Singapore National University Hospital and KK Women’s and Children’s Hospital from 2004 to 2005. ILI was defined according to a standard symptom score.
RESULTS: Baseline characteristics were comparable in both the vaccinated and non-vaccinated groups. Overall, the relative risk of self-reported ILI in vaccinated HCWs was 1.13 [95% confidence interval (CI), 0.98-1.13; P=0.107]; medical leave taken was lower in the vaccinated group [mean 0.26+/-0.6 days per visit, compared with 0.30+/-0.5 days in the non-vaccinated group (P=0.40)]. Because of the reported Northern Hemisphere 2003/04 vaccine mismatch, we stratified the cohort and determined that the group which received a matched vaccine had a relative risk of ILI of 0.49 (95% CI, 0.37-0.66; P<0.001), achieving a vaccine efficacy of 51%. Mean medical leave decreased significantly in HCWs who received the matched vaccine, compared with those who did not receive vaccination (0.13+/-0.3 vs 0.30+/-0.5; P<0.001) and with HCWs vaccinated with mismatched strains (0.13+/-0.3 vs 0.39+/-0.9; P=0.01).
CONCLUSIONS: A well-matched influenza vaccine is effective in preventing ILI and reducing sickness absence in healthcare workers in tropical settings. Efforts need to be made to increase influenza vaccination rates and to improve the currently available vaccines (PubMed).”
Or this:
“BACKGROUND: We assessed the effects of an influenza season on patients with COPD. Data from 2,215 veterans in a multicenter, randomized, double-blind influenza vaccine efficacy study were analyzed for changes in spirometric and functional status, comparing patients with laboratory-documented influenza (LDI)-caused illness, non-LDI-caused respiratory illness, or no illness, and for association with influenza vaccination.
METHODS: Patients received either IM trivalent inactivated influenza virus vaccine (TIV) plus intranasal trivalent, live attenuated, cold-adapted influenza virus vaccine (TC) or TIV plus intranasal placebo (TP). We performed spirometry, measured the chronic lung disease severity index (CLDSI) score to assess functional status and well-being, and tested for influenza virus infection.
RESULTS: Worsening in FEV(1), percentage of predicted FEV(1), and CLDSI score (p < 0.001) was associated with acute respiratory illness in 585 illnesses including 94 LDI-caused illnesses. LDI-caused illness was more likely to be associated with worsening in FEV(1) and CLDSI score acutely than non-LDI-caused illness (p < 0.01). Logistic regression showed acute respiratory illness (odds ratio [OR], 1.78; 95% confidence limit [CL], 1.40 to 2.26) to be associated with worsening in CLDSI score, and receipt of TC (OR, 1.39; 95% CL, 1.10 to 1.74) and no illness (OR, 0.70; 95% CL, 0.53 to 0.91 for acute respiratory illness) to be associated with better CLDSI score at the end of the study. Hospitalization was more frequent in patients with acute respiratory illness (p < 0.0001).
CONCLUSIONS: Acute respiratory illness was associated with increased health-care utilization and obstruction to airflow, and worse functional status and well-being. At the end of the study, receipt of TC was associated with improvement and acute respiratory illness was associated with worsening in functional status and well-being (PubMed).”
But wait. There’s more. If you call now, not only will you get the above studies, we will add, at no additional cost:
“We identified six studies that assessed the incidence of influenza in vaccinated HIV-infected subjects. Four of these studies compared the incidence in vaccinated versus unvaccinated subjects. These involved a total of 646 HIV-infected subjects. In all the 4 studies, the incidence of influenza was lower in the vaccinated compared to unvaccinated subjects with RD ranging from -0.48 (95% CI: -0.63, -0.34) to -0.15 (95% CI: -0.25, 0.05); between 3 and 7 people would need to be vaccinated to prevent one case of influenza. Vaccine effectiveness ranged from 27% to 78%. A random effects model was used to obtain a summary RD of -0.27 (95%CI: -0.42, -0.11). There was no evidence of publication bias. CONCLUSION: Current evidence, though limited, suggests that influenza vaccines are moderately effective in reducing the incidence of influenza in HIV-infected individuals. With the threat of a global influenza pandemic, there is an urgent need to evaluate the effectiveness of influenza vaccines in trials with a larger number of representative HIV-infected persons (PubMed).”
Now it may be file drawer effect and negative studies are not being published. The studies show benefits from the vaccine, the benefit is variable depending on the circulating strain, the vaccine match and the population vaccinated. But a benefit none the less.
Population Studies
The most compelling population data comes from Ontario, Canada, where they have had a ongoing attempt to maximize the vaccination of the whole population against influenza (PubMed). The other Provinces did not see fit to try and vaccinate everyone, continuing with targeted influenza vaccination.
This represents an interesting natural experiment. If the effects of the influenza vaccine are less in preventing disease but more in decreasing secondary endpoints like death, hospitalizations, or antibiotic usage, it may show up in population studies. There are numerous issues with this kind of study, but are “appropriate for assessing the public health impact of a population-wide intervention.”
During the period in the reference, Ontario experienced greater uptake of vaccine than any other Province:
“Between the pre-UIIP 1996–1997 estimate to the mean post-UIIP vaccination rate, influenza vaccination rates for the household population aged ≥12 y increased 20 percentage points (18%–38%) for Ontario, compared to 11 percentage points (13%–24%) for other provinces (p < 0.001) (Table 2). For those <65 y, the vaccination rate increases were greater in Ontario than in other provinces, while for those ≥75 y, the increase was smaller in Ontario. For all age groups, Ontario always achieved higher vaccination rates than other provinces.”
And the results of all that vaccination:
“After UIIP introduction, influenza-associated mortality for the overall population decreased 74% in Ontario (RR = 0.26, 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.20–0.34) compared to 57% in other provinces (RR = 0.43, 95% CI, 0.37–0.50) (ratio of RRs = 0.61, p = 0.002) (Table 3). In age-specific analyses, larger mortality decreases in Ontario were found to be statistically significant only in those ≥85 y.”
Not Bad.
“Overall, influenza-associated health care use decreased more in Ontario than other provinces for hospitalizations (RR = 0.25 versus 0.44, ratio of RRs = 0.58, p < 0.001), ED use (RR = 0.31 versus 0.70, ratio of RRs = 0.45, p < 0.001), and doctors’ office visits (RR = 0.21 versus 0.53, ratio of RRs = 0.41, p < 0.001). In age-specific analyses, greater decreases were consistently observed in Ontario than other provinces for age groups <65 y. For seniors, greater decreases were observed in Ontario than other provinces for hospitalizations among those aged 65–84 y and for ED use among those 65–74 y.”
A subsequent paper (PubMed) demonstrated that “universal influenza immunization is associated with reduced influenza-associated antibiotic prescriptions.” So it may be the secondary effects of the vaccines that are more important than primarily preventing me from getting flu.
It’s the old rising tide lifts boats effect.
The study that needs to be done would be vaccinate everyone west of the Mississippi and no one to the east. Prevent travel between the two parts of the county. See who gets influenza. Now that would be an epidemiological study.
The study is in contrast to the Tom Jefferson paper that several, evidently anti vaccine folks, have sent me where is says,
“A meta analysis of inactivated vaccines in elderly people showed a gradient from no effect against influenza or influenza-like illness to a large effect (up to 60%) in preventing all-cause mortality. These findings are both counterintuitive and implausible, as other causes of death are far more prevalent in elderly people even in the winter months. It is impossible for a vaccine that does not prevent influenza to prevent its complications, including admission to hospital.”
Again with the binary approach to the vaccine. A milder case of flu due to the vaccine will lead to fewer complications and deaths. It is only impossible if you do not recognize that the influenza vaccine, unfortunately, is not like the tetanus vaccine, but its effects are more likely a continuum due to partial effects on the person getting the vaccine and the hard to measure benefits of being less likely to spread the disease.
In my mind that is the true benefit of the influenza vaccines: decreasing the morbidity and mortality of populations. The benefit for populations is derived through vaccinating individuals. That requires a bit of altruism on the part of those receiving the vaccine, as they may be getting vaccinated more for the benefit of others than for themselves. However, at least in the US, a premium is currently placed on being a self centered narcissist; indirectly helping others, even for MD’s and RN’s, is apparently not on the to do list.
Do flu vaccines work? It depends on what the meaning of is is. If you are simplistic and like binary answers, yes or no, then you can pick yes or pick no, and find studies to support your contention that the vaccine doesn’t work.
If you realize that medicine is subtle and nuanced, and often the answers are filled with qualifiers and uncertainty, that the practice of medicine is messy, I think the answer is that the flu vaccine is of benefit. And that the more people who get the vaccine, the greater the benefit for everyone. You do not know how much it pains me to quote Donald Rumsfeld , but he was partly right when he said “You go to war with the army you have, not the army you might want or wish to have at a later time.”
It is true in medicine as well. My army is the vaccine and the data used to support it. You can conclude that neither the vaccine nor the data is perfect, and decide the vaccine is not useful.
Or you can look at the preponderance of data, with all the flaws, nuance, subtleties and qualifiers, and conclude the flu vaccine is of benefit. The vaccine decreases the probability of morbidity and mortality. It is a good thing.

   Does the Flu Vaccine Increase Hospitalizations?
Steven Novella
Link
The Centers for Disease Control (CDC) currently recommends that children 6 month to 18 years old receive an annual flu vaccine. There are two types of flu vaccines used in the US: a live attenuated virus (LAIV) and a trivalent inactivated virus (TIV) vaccine. Both are safe and effective – while efficacy varies from year to year, they are 70-90% effective in healthy adults. Efficacy is young children appears to be slightly less, about 66%.
There remains, however, many sub-questions about the flu vaccines and by the time researchers have thoroughly explored them vaccine technology is likely to have progressed, and therefore any new vaccines will have to be tested all over again.
One of those sub-questions about vaccine safety and efficacy is the net effect of the flu vaccine in children with asthma. Some have raised concerns that the vaccine may exacerbate asthma, a 1-2% increased wheezing and 3% increased hospitalizations have been reported, although so far the bulk of the data suggests that both types of flu vaccines are safe in children with asthma. There is evidence to suggest that the LAIV may be superior to the TIV in children, particularly with asthma.
A new study, presented but not published, further explores the safety and efficacy of the TIV in children. Study author, Avni Joshi, M.D., of the Mayo Clinic, reports:
“The concerns that vaccination maybe associated with asthma exacerbations have been disproved with multiple studies in the past, but the vaccine’s effectiveness has not been well-established. This study was aimed at evaluating the effectiveness of the TIV in children overall, as well as the children with asthma, to prevent influenza-related hospitalization.”
The study is a retrospective study of 263 children who presented to the Mayo clinic with laboratory confirmed influenza. They found that children who had recieved the TIV vaccine had a 3 times greater risk of hospitalization than those who were not vaccinated. These results raise concerns about the safety and effectiveness of the TIV in children with asthma.
Dr. Joshi concludes:
“While these findings do raise questions about the efficacy of the vaccine, they do not in fact implicate it as a cause of hospitalizations. More studies are needed to assess not only the immunogenicity, but also the efficacy of different influenza vaccines in asthmatic subjects.”
That may seem like a curious conclusion given the results of this study, but it is accurate. The key to understanding the implications of this study is that it is retrospective. That means it looks at children who have the flu and then looks back to see who was vaccinated and who wasn’t. This in turn means that children were not randomized to either be vaccinated or not, and this opens the door to any number of variables that cannot be controlled for in the study.
The authors did look as obvious factors, such as severity of asthma and insurance status, and found that they did not correlate with risk of being hospitalized. But what other factors might there be? The flu vaccine is optional, which means that parents decide whether or not to vaccinate their children, perhaps with advice from their pediatrician. It is likely that sicker or more frail children are more likely to get vaccinated. It is also likely that children who had a bad reaction to the flu in the past are more likely to get vaccinated. The flu vaccine is recommended especially for those who are at high risk for complications if they get the flu.
Therefore while this study raises important questions, it is not designed to answer them definitively. A prospective trial is required for that, and that is what Joshi means by “more studies are needed.” In general, retrospective studies are useful to find correlations and generate hypothesis, but are not capable of determining causation – there are simply too many variables that are not controlled for.
As expected, the anti-vaccinationists have already jumped on this study and misinterpreted its significance. They did not recognize its retrospective nature nor put it into the context of existing research on the safety and efficacy of the flu vaccines.
Clinical trials are complex, and there are many types that each have their own strengths and weaknesses. Often, many independent lines of basic science and clinical evidence need to be brought together to form a reliable conclusion about a specific intervention. That is the essence of science-based medicine. Individual studies typically only provide a tiny slice of information, but are often presented to the public as if they are definitive. This creates a constant background noise of misinformation about medical questions.
It also provides a rich source of data from which to cherry pick, allowing proponents to support almost any notion by shopping from the vast store of often conflicting medical research. This reinforces the need to look thoroughly at the totality of scientific evidence on any claim or question.
When that is done on the question of the flu vaccines, it is clear that both types of vaccines are safe and effective. However, there is also much room for improvement in the vaccine technology itself, as well as evidence-based recommendations for who, exactly, should get which type of vaccine.
This current study adds incrementally to our knowledge on this question, and suggests questions for future research. It is not the kind of evidence, however, that should lead to changes in the current recommendations.

   Influenza Deaths
Mark Crislip
Link
“There are known knowns. These are things we know that we know. There are known unknowns. That is to say, there are things that we know we don’t know. But there are also unknown unknowns. There are things we don’t know we don’t know.”- Donald Rumsfeld
How do we know what we know? It is said by some anti-vaccine proponents that vaccines are not needed because the diseases they prevent are either gone or no longer as severe as they were in pre vaccine times. People may have suffered and died in the distant past, but no longer. The risk now is from the vaccines not the diseases they no longer prevent.
36,000 people, more or less, die every year from influenza. That is the number of deaths according to the CDC web site; the NEJM review uses the higher number of 56,000 (7). Which number is correct? Isn’t that why the flu vaccine is recommended: to prevent all those people from dying.
36,000 is a lot of people. That’s about 120 deaths per million people in the US. In Oregon, population about 3 million, that would be about 360 people a year, which is two deaths a day for the six month flu season.
“Death is caused by swallowing small amounts of saliva over a long period of time.”–George Carlin.
2,400,000 people die every year in the US, about 6600 a day. In Oregon, that is about 65 deaths a day. No one outside a epidemiologist is going to notice 2 extra deaths a day during flu season. I have seen a lot of people die of influenza, but I have a biased experience: I am an infectious disease doc, so I am likely to see people with influenza, especially patients with disease severe enough to kill them.
About the same number of people die from car accidents and die from handguns in the US each year as die from influenza. I have never known a person in my real, as opposed to my professional, life to die from influenza or handguns or a car accident. My personal experience suggests no one dies from these causes, but since I take care of patients at one of the Portland trauma hospitals, I know what cars and guns do to people. My professional life confirms that people do indeed die from being shot or car accidents. I would wager that most people reading this blog have not known anyone who has died from influenza, guns or car accidents. The fact that people do die of influenza seems contradicted by experience. Why get the vaccine? I don’t get the flu and and no one I know has ever died from it.
As an illustrative example, a relative of mine, a retired physician, mentioned that he thought the shingles vaccine was a waste of time and money as he had never known anyone to get shingles. Using personal experience to judge disease prevalence is unreliable. If I applied the same rationale to driving, I would not wear a seat belt as I have never been in a high speed crash.
36,000 people die of influenza each year. What is the source of that statistic? From “Mortality associated with influenza and respiratory syncytial virus in the United States”. JAMA 2003. Is that really how many deaths are there from influenza? It depends on what you mean by ‘death’ and what you mean by ‘influenza’ and what you mean by ‘from’.
“It depends on what the meaning of the words ‘is’ is.” – Bill Clinton
Influenza deaths are an estimate. A sample of a population is evaluated for a disease, like influenza, and the the results are extrapolated to the whole population. The bigger the sample, the more reliable the extrapolation. It is not a simple task to estimate disease prevalence. How do you define a case of influenza? Most people with influenza do not get cultures to confirm the diagnosis. What combination of cultures, rapid testing, serology and clinical syndrome do you use to define a case of influenza?
There is a lack of precision in determining if influenza was the cause of death since many people with influenza do not have the tests done to prove the diagnosis. Someone is admitted to the hospital with what starts as a febrile coughing illness and dies of heart failure and bacterial pneumonia. The initial illness could very well have been influenza that set them down the road to death. If you are interested in influenza deaths, you need to define what constitutes death from influenza. Did they die directly from influenza? Did they die from secondary infections? Did they die from underlying diseases such as heart or lung disease that are worsened by the physiologic stress of influenza?
To complicate matters, the US does not have a unified health care system and as a result deaths are not tracked uniformly. You might be surprised at how difficult it is to accurately fill out a death certificate since people often die from multiple diseases.
Lets peruse the JAMA article to get a sense how influenza deaths are estimated. How do they find that grain of sand that is influenza deaths from the mountain of routine mortality? Lets look at the reference in detail, because it gives insight as to how to determine influenza deaths in the US.
“The doctors killed Garfield; I just shot him.” – Charles Guiteau.
“Numbers of deaths attributable to influenza are difficult to estimate directly because influenza infections typically are not confirmed virologically or specified on hospital discharge forms or death certificates. In addition, many influenza-associated deaths occur from secondary complications when influenza viruses are no longer detectable. Nonetheless, wintertime influenza epidemics have been shown to be associated with increased hospitalizations and mortality for many diagnoses, including congestive heart failure, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, pneumonia, and bacterial superinfections.”
Here is how they arrive at an annual average of 36,000 influenza deaths.
First, they defined a time frame to evaluate: the respiratory season is July 1 to June 30.
Second, find influenza cultures. Positive cultures define a case of influenza. They looked at all the influenza isolates reported to the CDC. This is an underestimate of the amount of influenza as many cases of influenza are defined clinically and a a small fraction of suspected cases of influenza are confirmed with cultures.
Third, look at mortality from the National Center for Health Statistics. They included “the underlying cause-of-death because it represents the disease or injury that initiated the chain of morbid events that led directly to the death.”
Why did they die? The US lacks a national data base for cause of death, so they used diagnosis codes rather than death certificate reports, which also has issues. Every disease has an ICD-9 code associated with it. Fever is 780.6. HIV is 042. You know a doctor by the codes she has committed to memory from repeated use. Diagnosis codes exist for billing purposes and the rigorousness with which a diagnosis is made is often less than perfect, limited by time and potential morbidity. I could diagnosis every case of influenza if I could do an open lung biopsy on each patient, but that is not worth either the harm to the patient or the cost of the procedure. Often the diagnosis code represents a best, but honest, guess as to what diseases a patient had.
“The 3 death categories modeled were underlying pneumonia and influenza deaths (ICD-9 codes 480-487), underlying respiratory and circulatory deaths (ICD-9 codes 390-519 and ICD-10 codes (I00-I99, J00-J99), and all-cause deaths (all ICD codes).”
Diagnosis codes are not an optimal way to know what the ‘real’ diagnosis was, but the best we have. So we using a 2 megapixel camera to take a snapshot of influenza deaths, but the picture is going to be a reasonably accurate representation of the impact of the disease.
“While the individual man is an insoluble puzzle, in the aggregate he becomes a mathematical certainty. You can, for example, never foretell what any one man will be up to, but you can say with precision what an average number will be up to. Individuals vary, but percentages remain constant.” – Arthur Conan Doyle
Fourth, and final, part of the study is the application of magic. Or statistical analysis. Same thing to me. They used an “age-specific Poisson regression model that used weekly influenza circulation data.” Here is where I have to defer to people who have a deeper understanding of statistics as I thought a Poisson model would be fish counting in the Seine.
“Poisson regression has been mainly applied to compare exposed and unexposed cohorts and to evaluate the clinical course of ill subjects (2)”. Sounds perfect. That is what we want to do, so the statisticians appear to be using the right statistical analysis. Here is another factor that could lead to lack of trust in the death rates from influenza: the processes by which these numbers are generated are really understood by a tiny fraction of the population. It appears from reference (2) that the Poisson is a reasonable statistical analysis to apply to the question of the number of deaths from influenza, but I almost have to accept that proposition on the basis of faith given my bleak understanding of statistics.
So what did the analysis show?
For the period in question there was an yearly average (some years more, some years less) of
69,140 deaths from pneumonia and influenza,
1,135,724 deaths from underlying pulmonary or cardiac disease, and
2,126,740 deaths from all causes.
Applying the Poisson model to the data they looked at the deaths when influenza was circulating in the community and when influenza was not circulating in the community and compared the deaths. They determined that on average there were
5977 deaths from pneumonia and influenza,
25,420 deaths from underlying pulmonary or cardiac disease, and
34,470 deaths from all causes
could be attributed to influenza. These were the extra deaths, by type, that occurred when influenza was circulating in the US.
See copywrited material here: http://www.sciencecartoonsplus.com/pages/gallery.php. I feel the same way.
It is important to note that the flu does not kill most people directly, but indirectly through secondary infections or exacerbation of underlying chronic medical problems. There is year to year variation in the number of deaths depending on the virulence of influenza, the effectiveness of the flu vaccine and the number of people protected by past exposure to the strain.
The dogma, as an aside, has been that during the 1918 pandemic most people died from acute influenza infection, as occurs with the current strain of avian influenza. That may have not been the case, as an archeological epidemiologic study in Clinical Infections Diseases (8) suggests that deaths from secondary bacterial infections may have accounted for the majority of the deaths. I keep drumming my fingers nervously on the table, waiting for the perfect infectious disease storm to hit. If we have a bad influenza season combined with the new widespread MRSA strain, we could see a huge spike in deaths from secondary bacterial pneumonias from MRSA. The current USA 300 strain is impressively virulent when it gains access to virus damaged lungs, killing patients in less than 48 hours, and I can’t reliably kill MRSA.
The JAMA study also demonstrated that the older you are, the more likely you are to die of influenza, that if the patient is >85 years old, there is a 16 times higher chance of dying of flu than if they are less than 65.
Short of a universal health care, where everyone is in a database with precise diagnosis, this kind of epidemiologic study is as good as we can do to determine how many people die from influenza. The best way to determine death rates from influenza would be to take a defined population of people and routinely evaluate them by culture and serology through the flu season, see who developed the flu and determine who died as a result. Not an ethical prospective study, but accomplished retrospectively in Tennessee nursing homes, where they had patients for a total of 81,885 person years and evaluated them for influenza. In this population, most of which had multiple co-morbid conditions, when influenza was circulating there was associated increase in mortality of an extra 15 deaths/1000 (3). If the US population were all similarly old and debilitated, then we would have over 4 million extra deaths a year from influenza. Similarly, when influenza is circulating in the community, there is an associated extra 9% of deaths in those with lung disease (4).
There are other ways to determine deaths from influenza. Deaths have been reported and influenza tracked since 1900. The onset of the influenza season has always been associated with an increase in death of all kinds. Of course, until diagnostic tests were available, the diagnosis of influenza has to be taken with a grain of salt substitute. Using historical reporting data you can get a rough idea of how often influenza kills. This kind of data is an approximation (5), but probably close enough to the truth to understand the impact of influenza. The problem is knowing with reasonable assurance that the deaths were indeed due to influenza.
Given that limitation, over time deaths from influenza have fallen since 1900 from 10.2 deaths per 100,000 population in the 1940s to 0.56 per 100,000 by the 1990s. That would be about 16,800 deaths directly from influenza each year, not including the secondary deaths from heart and lung diseases, more than the JAMA article, but they used different case definitions.
Using a similar methodology, it is estimated that influenza results in 365,000 or more hospitalizations each year (6).
”An approximate answer to the right question is worth a good deal more than the exact answer to an approximate problem.”—John W. Tukey
All the studies demonstrate the same basic principal: when influenza arrives, so does the grim reaper. So how many people does influenza kill each year? 16,000? 36,000? 56,000? Even more? Or less? As you can see, it depends on how you do the counting. All the studies put the number of deaths in the same ballpark. One anti vaccine website says that influenza directly kills ‘only’ hundreds of people a year. I think hundreds is a lot of people, especially as the deaths were preventable. It is true that deaths directly from influenza are unusual. It was a mild flu season last year, but 76 children died directly of influenza, all unvaccinated, and the number of deaths is probably an underestimate given the current surveillance system. I could not find a number for adult deaths last year at the CDC site.
“A single death is a tragedy; a million deaths is a statistic.” —Joseph Stalin
By our best estimates, influenza, one way or another, kills 36,000 people in the US every year. 36,000 stacked corpses would make column 6 miles high. Many of those deaths were preventable with the flu vaccine. Every death was a tragedy.
For many people influenza is like being pushed off a cliff. Neither the push (the flu) nor the fall (underlying condition) kills you.
It is the sudden stop.
Next time: how effective is the influenza vaccine?
References
(1) Thompson WW, Shay DK, Weintraub E, et al. Mortality associated with influenza and respiratory syncytial virus in the United States. JAMA 2003;289:179–86.
(2) www.unipr.it/arpa/facvet/annali/2006/025_044.pdf
(3) J Am Geriatr Soc. 2003 Jun;51(6):761-7. Influenza- and respiratory syncytial virus-associated morbidity and mortality in the nursing home population.
(4) Arch Intern Med. 2002 Jun 10;162(11):1229-36. Winter viruses: influenza- and respiratory syncytial virus-related morbidity in chronic lung disease.
(5) Am J Public Health. 2008 May;98(5):939-45. Epub 2008 Apr 1. Trends in recorded influenza mortality: United States, 1900-2004.
(6) Influenza-Associated Hospitalizations in the United States. JAMA. 2004;292:1333-1340.
(7) Prevention and Treatment of Seasonal Influenza NEJM. 359;24 www.nejm.org december 11, 2008
(8) Predominant role of bacterial pneumonia as a cause of death in pandemic influenza: implications for pandemic influenza preparedness. J Infect Dis. 2008 Oct 1;198(7):962-70.

   Short Attention Span SBM
Mark Crislip
Link
The bar on this blog is set high. The entries are often complete, with no turn left unstoned. Yet, not every topic needs the full monty with every post. The blog has extensive evaluations on many topics, and new medical literature doesn’t require another complete analysis. Many new articles add incrementally to the literature and their conclusions need to be inserted into the conversation of this blog, like a car sliding into heavy traffic. My eldest son just received his driver’s license, and car metaphors are on my mind. As are crash metaphors and insurance metaphors.
So in response to this need, a need only recognized by me, I give you Short Attention Span SCAM. Occasionally I will summarize a few recent studies and their key points as they relate to prior posts at SBM.
Influenza
…any man’s death diminishes me, because I am involved in mankind, and therefore never send to know for whom the bells tolls; it tolls for thee. — John Donne
Influenza season will be starting soon. There are multiple misstatements made about influenza and its treatment in the SCAMosphere. The first concerns death. Flu does not kill, or so it is asserted, or it only kills a thousand people a year. During last year’s H1N1 season I took care of a pair of patients who died of acute influenza, not its complications. Direct deaths from influenza are always a fraction of the deaths from indirect causes: worsening of heart failure or lung disease or a secondary infections. I try to never use the word ‘only’ when discussing direct flu deaths; perhaps I take it too personally. Not patient of mine was ever an ‘only’ and it annoys me no end when the deaths of others are diminished.
How influenza deaths are calculated was discussed in the past, but the CDC released new information on influenza deaths from 1976 to 2007. Calculating flu deaths is not easy. The number lies somewhere between direct deaths from flu, and the deaths from other acute, but related causes:
Deaths from pneumonia and influenza causes are highly correlated with the circulation of influenza and can be considered a lower bound for deaths associated with influenza. However, a diagnosis of influenza virus infection often is not confirmed with sensitive and specific laboratory diagnostics, particularly among older persons, and even when identified is rarely recorded on death certificates (5). Many deaths associated with influenza infections occur from secondary infections such as bacterial pneumonia or complications of chronic conditions such as congestive heart failure and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Therefore, estimates using underlying respiratory and circulatory mortality data (which include pneumonia and influenza causes) can provide an upper bound for influenza- associated deaths.
The striking result is that, on average, there is no average flu season. Deaths vary from year to year and depends on the circulating strain of influenza.
Over 31 consecutive flu seasons, on average there were about 23,600 deaths a year linked to the flu varying from a low of 3,349 deaths in 1986-1987 to a high of 48,614 in 2003-2004.
When H3N2 predominated, deaths were 2.7 times higher than compared to other strains. As a comparison, 8,330 to 17,160 are estimated to have died from H1N1.
The ‘classic‘ number given is about 36,000 deaths a year, but the number is an average and, like so much in medicine, it depends. As the CDC says,
A single estimate should not be used to summarize influenza-associated deaths; a range of estimates should be described in the context of circulating virus strains and underlying causes of death among age groups.
Death is often a bad outcome and it is better to not die of the flu or its complications. A recent case controlled study compared flu vaccinated vs unvaccinated and found that the receipt of the flu vaccine decreased the risk of heart attack.
We included 78 706 patients, of whom 16 012 were cases and 62 694 were matched controls. Influenza vaccination had been received in the previous year by 8472 cases (52.9%) and 32 081 controls (51.2%) and was associated with a 19% reduction in the rate of acute myocardial infarction (adjusted odds ratio [OR] 0.81, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.77-0.85). Early seasonal influenza vaccination was associated with a lower rate of acute myocardial infarction (adjusted OR 0.79, 95% CI 0.75-0.83) than vaccination after mid-November (adjusted OR 0.88, 95% CI 0.79-0.97).
The authors do not speculate on the mechanism of the protection, but that will not stop me. Infections are pro-inflammatory and pro-thrombotic. Myocardial infarctions, strokes and pulmonary embolisms are increased during and after acute infections, perhaps in part due to increased stress on the heart, but also, perhaps due to the pro-thrombotic state. It is reasonable to suggest that flu leads to increased inflammation and thrombosis which leads to MI. No flu, no pro-thrombotic state, no MI. If one could “boost the immune system“, and you can’t, what you would get is a inflammatory/thrombotic state that should lead to more vascular events: strokes, MI and pulmonary embolism.
Vitamin D
Dont get the vaccine, many a site will say, all you need is vitamin D to prevent and treat flu. I am not going to deny the importance of having sufficient vitamin D to keep immune function optimal.
Having higher vitamin D serum levels does decrease the risk of a viral infection, although the effect is modest.
During 114 days of the fall and winter in a temperate zone a serum concentration of 25-hydroxyvitamin D of 38 ng/ml or higher was associated with a two-fold decrease (p<0.0001) in the risk of developing acute viral infections of the respiratory tract.
A modest decrease in risk, and enough to keep me drinking milk shakes all winter to keep my vitamin D levels elevated.
The question is, if you supplement vitamin D in patients, can you treat or prevent influenza? There is zero data for influenza. But there is data for viral upper respiratory tract infections. In Finland they they did a placebo-controlled double-blinded study in 164 young Finnish men (1828 years of age) who were randomly assigned to 400 IU (10 mg;) vitamin D3 daily or placebo.
The treatment and placebo group had the same initial levels of Vitamin D and a difference in levels at the end of the trial.
Intervention (78.7+- 14.9nmol/L) and placebo (74.4+- 20.8 nmol/L groups (P p .35)…after daily supplementation with 400 IU vitamin D or placebo for 6 months, the mean serum 25(OH)D concentrations were 71.6 +- 22.9 nmol/L in the intervention group and 51.3 +- 15.5 nmol/L in the placebo group.
Let’s see: moles to molecular weight to Avogadro’s number to … it’s late and I am tired and do not have there intellectual wherewithal to convert nmol/l to mg/ml. I must have a homeopaths understanding of concentrations. I will leave that as an exercise for the comments (yes, it is also fun to whitewash a fence) to see if they started at the 38 ng/ml that was effective to decreasing risk. Hey. I can’t be expected to do everything can I?
The results were, again, modest.
The main outcome variable, which was the number of days absent from duty due to respiratory tract infection, did not differ between groups. Mean number of days absent was 2.2 +-3.2 days in the intervention group and 3.0+-4.0 days in the placebo group . There was an effect during the first 6 weeks of the study, with a mean of 0.7+-2.1 days of absence in the intervention group and 1.4 +- 2.6 days absent in the placebo group. After the first 6 weeks, there tended to be no difference between groups. Nevertheless, the proportion of men remaining healthy throughout the 6-month study period was greater in the intervention group (41 [51.3%] of 80) than in the placebo group (30 [35.7%] of 80).
Not impressive, but something, and when it comes to avoiding illness, something is better than nothing. Better still, being replete in vitamin D will increase the response to the flu vaccine, so taking vitamin D, especially if you are deficient, may increase the antibody levels after the flu vaccine, still the best way to avoid the disease.
So would I suggest vitamin D? Yes, as part of a healthy breakfast and if you are deficient. It is one of a number of interventions you can use to prevent getting ill in the viral season. But is vitamin D the be-all and end-all of flu prevention and treatment. No. Not even close.
Acupuncture
Man is the only animal that blushes. Or needs to. — Mark Twain
Acupuncture is all placebo effect, what ever that is. This was re-confirmed in “A randomized controlled trial of acupuncture for osteoarthritis of the knee: Effects of patient-provider communication“.
In this trial, patients had real acupuncture or sham acupuncture (as if there is a difference) and they had neutral or enthusiastic acupuncturists. Those that had an enthusiastic acupuncturist had a better decrease in reported pain, whether the acupuncture was real or sham.
TCA was not superior to sham acupuncture. However, acupuncturists styles had significant effects on pain reduction and satisfaction, suggesting that the analgesic benefits of acupuncture can be partially mediated through placebo effects related to the acupuncturists behavior.
This result is of no surprise. Expectations will often color people’s perceptions. More expensive wine is rated higher than the same vintage labeled as cheaper. An expensive placebo is more effective than an cheap placebo.
But does perception of reality mean reality was altered?
I play golf with my kids almost every night in the summer and towards the end of the season I get right elbow tendinitis. As I make my downswing the pain fibers fire and can mess up my swing if I am not focused on hitting through the pain. If I take 400 milligrams of ibuprofen before I play, I have less pain and my swing is unchanged. Not enough to beat my son, but that is another matter.
Decreasing pain leads to improved function when pain limits function. If you have a musculoskeletal problem, you usually have a reproducible limit to your function due to the pain. If the pain is decreased, the function should improve.
As I have discussed at length, I do not think there is really a placebo effect. Certainly for objective endpoints, there is no placebo effect. Buried in the acupuncture paper were two objective end points: range of motion and the Timed Up and Go Test. For objective endpoints there were no changes in any of the groups. So it makes me wonder just what improvement these patients ‘really’ had. Subjectively better, objectively no change.
Is the placebo effect no more than a patient convincing themselves they are better when in fact nothing has changed? That is my interpretation. If function is not improved, if they are still limited by pain, is the pain really gone? Is this response a milder example of the same cognitive processes that can lead to hysterical blindness or not seeing tumors the size of a large mushroom? Man is the only animal with the ability to convince themselves that the tangible is unreal or that the unreal is tangible.
“Always keep your words soft & sweet in case you have to eat them!”
I have said numerous times that I was envious of SCAM practitioners as they live an essentially never-changing world. Once the ideas of homeopathy, reiki, acupuncture were codified, there is no change. Learn once … use forever.
Not so, it turns out, thanks to a report in Medscape (COI warning: I am a paid Medscape blogger).
New acupuncture points have been discovered! Acupuncture advances.
We generally modify acupoints to make them effective and more appropriate for cancer patients…For example, the acupoints which are predetermined places on the body where needles are inserted for therapeutic effect for hot flashes for normal menopause are “not necessarily the same ones for early menopause due to chemotherapy”.
Unfortunately, this breakthrough in acupuncture has yet to be published, although this pioneering work was done at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center. Evidently, the only way you can learn this incredible clinical breakthrough is by paying $495 dollars and taking the online acupuncture class offered by Sloan-Kettering. I guess there are some medical cures they really dont want you to know about unless you pay first. It worked for Kevin Trudeau, it works for Sloan-Kettering.
When this phenomenal pioneering work is finally published, I suppose in the NEJM, I will have a second helping of words.

   Swine Flu Vaccine Fearmongering
Harriet Hall
Link
Fear is a curious thing. It often bears no relation to the actual risk of what we fear. When swine flu first broke out in Mexico, people were understandably afraid. Travel was restricted, schools were closed, and so many people stayed home that the streets of Mexico City were empty. As the disease spread around the world, Egypt developed a paranoid fear of pigs and committed national pigicide. They ordered the slaughter of all 300,000 of their country’s innocent little porkers, ignoring the fact that the flu is spread person-to-person, not pig-to-person. Now that the disease has officially been labeled a pandemic, fears have switched from the real threat of the disease to an imagined danger from the vaccine. 
Some people just plain hate the idea of vaccines – to the point that they are willing to spread old falsehoods, make up new lies, distort the results of studies, misrepresent statistics, and endanger our public health. There are websites like “Operation Fax to Stop the Vax” and even anti-swine-flu-vaccine rap videos. Press releases, e-mail campaigns, talk shows, and blogs are being used to stir up irrational fears. These people are irresponsible fearmongers. They are wrong, and they are dangerous. 
Background
The 1918 flu. The flu epidemic of 1918 started as a mild disease in the spring, called the “3-day fever.” Most victims recovered in a few days; there were few deaths. Then in the fall, it turned into something far more severe. It was the same flu strain, but it had become more virulent. Some victims died within hours. Healthy young adults were as susceptible as children and the elderly. It affected remote villages as well as urban areas. It attacked 1/5 of the world’s population, ¼ of the US population, and killed 50 million people.
Wartime conditions may have favored the evolution of a more virulent strain. In peacetime, the sicker stay put and the mildly affected move around. In the trenches, the mildly affected stayed on duty and the sicker were sent on crowded trains to crowded field hospitals. Today, places with social upheaval might have similar effects favoring a virulent strain.
The 1976 swine flu. In February 1976 a strain of H1N1 influenza similar to the 1918 strain killed a soldier at Fort Dix. Officials feared a pandemic and over-reacted. In actuality, the H1N1 strain was limited to the Fort Dix area and quickly died out, and another related strain only persisted until March. Nevertheless, a swine flu vaccine was developed and was given to 48,000,000 Americans, 22% of the population. The vaccination program was stopped in December after 532 cases of paralysis from Guillain-Barré syndrome were linked to the vaccine and 25 people died. It had been a false alarm, and more people died of the vaccine than of the disease. The risk of getting Guillain-Barré from the vaccine was approximately 1 in 100,000.
The 2009 swine flu. Between April 15 and July 24, 2009, there were 43,771 confirmed and probable cases of H1N1 influenza (“swine flu”) in the US. There were 5011 hospitalizations and 302 deaths, 39% among those aged 25 to 49, in contrast to the usual flu where 90% of the deaths are in people over age 65. For comparison, the more common strains of flu have been killing around 36,000 people a year in the US. Swine flu has been declared a phase 6 pandemic by the World Health Organization: that is a measure of its spread, not of its severity.
What are the chances that the new swine flu will follow the course of the 1918 flu? We have no way of knowing. All we can do is hope for the best and prepare for the worst. In addition to the annual flu vaccine for the usual common strains, a specific vaccine for the H1N1 strain is being prepared and tested to see whether one or two shots will be needed to produce a satisfactory immune response. So we may be offered as many as 3 shots this year. Supplies will be limited, at least in the short run, so the CDC has announced these priorities:
    • Pregnant women
    • Household contacts and caregivers for children younger than 6 months of age
    • Healthcare and emergency medical services personnel
    • All people from 6 months through 24 years of age 
    • Persons aged 25 through 64 years who have health conditions associated with higher risk of medical complications from influenza. 
What if it fizzles out like the swine flu of 1976? That’s already ruled out: the 1976 flu had fizzled by March; the new swine flu hasn’t shown any signs of fizzling yet. We will be monitoring numbers of cases and vaccine complications very carefully, assessing the risk/benefit ratio, and we’re not likely to repeat the mistakes of 1976.
The Lies and Distortions vs. the Facts
I can’t hope to address all the misinformation that is circulating, and even if I could, more new lies would come out by the time I finished writing. Here are some of the ones I have heard.
A correspondent in the Netherlands forwarded me an alarmist e-mail that is circulating in Europe.
Claim: It alleges that only one person has died of swine flu in the UK, and it questions whether he really had flu. It tells us “you are slated for vaccination against a disease which poses no credible threat whatsoever.” 
Fact: As of August 27, the death toll in the UK was 66. As of Sept. 1, 2009, 2184 deaths had been reported worldwide. Most rational people would call that a credible threat.
Claim: Guillian-Barré Syndrome is a newly concocted name for a much more familiar condition: Polio. 
Fact: Ridiculous! Polio is a distinct disease and its symptoms are very different from those of Guillain-Barré syndrome. A diagnosis of polio can be confirmed by finding the actual poliovirus particles in body secretions or cerebrospinal fluid. The last case of “wild polio” in the US occurred in 1979. Polio has been eradicated in most countries; Guillain-Barré still occurs regularly in every country.
Claim: Guillain-Barré is still being caused by flu vaccines. A study based on the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) found 54 cases of GBS reported after vaccination in the United States in 2004. 57% of these followed flu vaccines and the rest followed other vaccines.
Fact: The VAERS is a voluntary reporting system that accepts all reports of symptoms or illnesses that occurred after vaccination. It even accepted a fraudulent report claiming that a man had been turned into The Hulk by his influenza vaccine. To find out whether the VAERS reports mean anything, it is necessary to compare the incidence of the condition in those vaccinated to the incidence in the unvaccinated. Guillain-Barré syndrome affects 1 to 4 of every 100,000 people around the world every year, and the increased risk from vaccines is currently estimated at no more than 1 in a million.
Claim: It usually takes several years to test a drug and show that it is safe, but the swine flu vaccine is going to be fast-tracked for quick approval.
Fact: A new flu vaccine has to be developed every year to respond to the new strains that are constantly evolving. Time does not allow for the same kind of testing we require for approval of a new pharmaceutical. Time is even shorter for the swine flu this year. We have a lot of experience in producing new flu vaccines every year, and there is no reason to suspect that this year’s batches will be any more dangerous than usual. Because of fast-tracking, we will be monitoring very closely for side effects. We have a choice between fast-tracking and being prepared for a serious outbreak, or being slow and cautious and totally unprepared.
Claim: 4000 people were afflicted with Guillain-Barré Syndrome in 1976. 
Fact: At least 1 in 100,000 people would have gotten Guillain-Barré syndrome anyway. The excess cases attributed to the vaccine were estimated at 532 (some sources say half of that number), and most of them recovered fully. 25 deaths were attributed to the vaccine.
——————-
There are several websites where writers with a bad track record for scientific credibility (like Joseph Mercola and Gary Null) advocate vaccine refusal. The Health Freedom movement wants the government to forget about trying to protect the public and give us the freedom to harm ourselves by using untested, disproven, useless, or even dangerous treatments.
Claim: Legislation allows for you to be isolated or quarantined or “incarcerated in relocation centers” if you refuse vaccination during a declared Pandemic Emergency. This is a violation of human rights and of the Constitution.
Fact: If you have active TB, the government has not only the power but the responsibility to require treatment or quarantine so you don’t sit next to me on the bus and cough in my face. If you contract Ebola virus, I sure hope you will be quarantined to reduce the death toll. Quarantine is legal, is mandated by legislation, and is accepted by international law. Sometimes the duty to protect most of the people in a society temporarily trumps a few individual human rights. The government is not going to require quarantine unless there is a serious threat that demands action.
Claim: People should be allowed to “self-shield.” For self-shielding you go home lock the doors and stay there. Then you can try to further protect yourself with nano-silver, homeopathic remedies, cold packs, vitamins, flavonoids, zinc, astaxanthin, magnesium, and other stuff.
Fact: A self-imposed quarantine is better than nothing, but I question whether it would be effective in practice. The suggested (untested) remedies might conceivably keep people entertained so they are more willing to stay home.
Claim: The CDC and the American Academy of Neurologists have asked neurologists to be vigilant in looking for cases of Guillain-Barré syndrome in people who have been vaccinated. This is an admission that they know the vaccine will be dangerous.
Fact: They clearly said “they do not expect the 2009 H1N1 vaccine to increase the risk for the autoimmune disease” but since this is a concern with any pandemic vaccine, they will be on the alert. This is a good thing. If the incidence starts rising, they will know it earlier and be able to react more quickly than they did in 1976. 
Claim: The threat of Guillain-Barré is a reason to reject vaccines. 
Fact: No one understands what causes Guillain-Barré syndrome, but it can develop after an infection, surgery or vaccination. It is possible that people who develop GBS after vaccination might also have developed GBS after natural exposure to the disease. “From both the societal and individual perspectives, the risk of GBS after a flu shot pales in comparison to the risk of serious adverse events if infected with the influenza virus: 60 to 70 cases of GBS vs. 20,000 deaths from influenza. Keeping things on the same scale, people over 65 years of age can choose from a risk of 1 case of GBS per million people or 10,000 cases of hospitalization and 1500 deaths due to influenza.” 
Claim: Joseph Mercola writes about “Squalene: The Swine Flu Vaccine’s Dirty Little Secret.” He has claimed that the vaccine adjuvant squalene is dangerous, that the Gulf War Syndrome was caused by the squalene in anthrax vaccines, that squalene is “good” or “bad depending on how it gets into your body: “Injection is an abnormal route of entry which incites your immune system to attack all the squalene in your body, not just the vaccine adjuvant.” And the only reason they put adjuvants in vaccines is to save money.
Fact: Squalene is found naturally in the human body. It is a precursor of cholesterol and other compounds necessary to human health. Squalene antibodies were found in Gulf War veterans; but the rate turned out to be no higher in those who had Gulf War Syndrome than in those who didn’t. Squalene antibodies were found at similar rates in people who had never been exposed to squalene in vaccines. The anthrax vaccine has been ruled out as a possible cause of Gulf War Syndrome. Anyway, it turns out there was no squalene in the anthrax vaccine!
American flu vaccines do not contain adjuvants, but maybe they should. Adjuvants enhance the body’s innate immune response to the antigens in vaccines, making vaccines more effective. And they allow for broader cross-reactivity against viral strains not included in the vaccine. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17931151?ordinalpos=33&itool=EntrezSystem2.PEntrez.Pubmed.Pubmed_ResultsPanel.Pubmed_DefaultReportPanel.Pubmed_RVDocSum Mercola says adjuvants are added just to increase profits, but the pharmaceutical and health industries could make far more money treating patients in an epidemic than they could ever make trying to prevent one.
There is a large body of data demonstrating the safety of squalene. Flu vaccines containing MF59, a squalene-based adjuvant, have been used in Europe for 10 years, with 22,000,000 doses given; and no serious adverse events have occurred, only mild local reactions. The vaccine does not raise the incidence or titers of anti-squalene antibodies. The World Health Organization (WHO) considers it safe. http://www.who.int/vaccine_safety/topics/adjuvants/squalene/questions_and_answers/en/index.html 
Claim: Flu vaccines are not very effective and don’t protect everyone. The effectiveness is particularly low in the elderly.
Fact: This claim is true, BUT… In recent years, flu vaccines have been 75% effective in preventing hospitalizations for flu. 75% is way better than nothing. No vaccine is 100% effective. Flu vaccine is particularly problematic because of the constantly mutating strains of the virus. Nevertheless, the benefits of vaccines are clear. It is true that the elderly are not as well protected by the vaccine (efficacy rates have been estimated at 50% or less): that’s why it’s so important for younger people to be vaccinated, reducing the prevalence of the disease in the population and thereby reducing the likelihood of the elderly being exposed. In other words, don’t just get the flu shot for yourself, get it for Grandma.
Claim: Mercola says “Injecting organisms into your body to provoke immunity is contrary to nature.”
Fact: Nature kills people. Doing something contrary to nature is what medicine is all about. It’s a good thing.
Claim: “The potential for a weaponized vaccine to be the vector for a weaponized flu cannot be discounted.”
Fact: Most far-fetched conspiracy theories are wrong: I have no trouble discounting this one. The potential may be there, but the likelihood is homeopathic.
Claim: People should make their own decisions about their health care.
Fact: One of the basic principles of medical ethics is autonomy: patients have the right to accept or reject any treatment. Modern doctors try to involve the patient in the decision-making process, but most people are ill-equipped to make health decisions on their own without getting information and guidance from a health care professional. In a recent survey, 30 percent of Americans believed that there had been a case of smallpox in the United States in the past five years, and 63 percent thought there had been a case somewhere in the world in the past five years. http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/full/348/5/426 They didn’t know that the last case in the US occurred in 1949 and the last case in the world occurred in 1977 in Somalia. Twenty-five percent thought it was likely that they would die if they got the smallpox vaccine (the actual risk of death from the vaccine is 1 per million). People who are uninformed and scientifically illiterate are not capable of making rational decisions about health matters.
Mercola’s advice for preventing flu: Eliminate sugar and processed foods from your diet, take a high quality source of animal-based omega 3 fats like Krill Oil, exercise, optimize your vitamin D levels, get plenty of sleep, deal with stress, and wash your hands.
Fact: Washing your hands is a good idea.
Mercola claims: “Vitamin D deficiency is the likely cause of seasonal flu viruses.”
Fact: Now really! Vitamin D deficiency in a human body can no more “cause a virus” than it could “cause a cat.” Perhaps he meant vitamin D deficiency could predispose to infection, and there is some research to suggest that it might. Some have claimed that taking vitamin D supplements will prevent the flu, but there is no evidence to support that.
—————————–
Mercola’s claims and arguments were decisively eviscerated on Science-Based Medicine by Dr. Joseph Albietz. http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=851 Not only are Mercola’s assertions demonstrably false, but they reveal a profound misunderstanding of immunology. Unfortunately, he reaches a large audience of scientifically naïve people who believe his every word.
In response to Dr. Albietz’s article, there were some interesting comments from readers that further demonstrate the anti-vaccine mindset and the ability to distort information to promote a cause.
Claim: The government is going to mandate that everyone get the swine flu vaccine.
Fact: No such proposal has been made. The government couldn’t do it even if it tried, because there won’t be enough doses to go around. That’s why they’ve issued recommendations prioritizing who should get the vaccine first.
Claim: George Bush signed an agreement that if a pandemic emergency arose and the President declared a national state of emergency, control of the government would be passed to the United Nations. Blue-helmeted UN soldiers would run our country and the Constitution would be suspended. 
Fact: It was simply an agreement to facilitate international cooperation, to share information and enhance collaboration in the event of an emergency. It says nothing about the UN at all, much less about relinquishing sovereignty to the UN or any other organization. The actual agreement can be read online: http://www.spp.gov/pdf/nap_flu07.pdf
The same person pointed out that shots hurt and that alone should tell you something. “Yet you are willing to trust these people with your lives to make a vaccine that the Creator never intended the human body should need, and let them inject it into your body? You people are scary or insane!”
No, it is the anti-vaccine zealots who are scary. They are not insane, just self-deluded and misguided. I hope the swine flu won’t develop into a reprise of 1918; but if it does, the false information these people are spreading could be responsible for a great deal of death and suffering. Freedom of speech is a good thing, but this kind of fearmongering is almost as bad as shouting “Fire!” in a crowded theater.

   Influenza Vaccine Mandates
Mark Crislip
Link
I have been involved in infection control and in what is now called quality for my career. Since infection control issues can occur in any department, my job involves being on numerous quality related committees (Medical Executive, Pharmacy and Therapeutics, etc) where I have witnessed or participated in what seems to be innumerable quality initiatives.
It always gripes my cookies when someone says “Get your own house in order,” because that is a person who evidently is arguing from ignorance. Since To Err is Human was published at the turn of the century, the hospital systems in Portland and across the country have invested significant time and money into quality improvement. Do a Pubmed on ‘Hand Hygiene Compliance’ in the last decade; there are over 400 references. Or ‘deep venous thrombosis prophylaxis’ — over 5,000 references. Or ‘ventilator associated pneumonia prevention’ — over 750 references. Pick a topic related to safety and quality and search the literature, and you will find a remarkable amount of research into the best ways to decrease morbidity and mortality in the hospital.
Hospitals, at least those in my city, take safety and quality very seriously, and by applying the results of these studies, there has been a marked decrease in mortality and morbidity in my institutions. Compared to historical controls, we estimate we have, in the last 2 years, prevented about 600 hospital acquired infections and over 200 deaths. Those numbers are not fudged, but real progress. I make, or made, a large chunk of mortgage payment from hospital acquired infections. Not any more.
Not a single intervention we have implemented has required the use of a SCAM. We did not need to introduce reiki or homeopathy or acupuncture into the hospitals to get these benefits. Nope. Not a one. Just the application of science-based medicine. It did require an immense amount of time and energy, because human behavior and hospital systems are complex and making changes that are effective and can be incorporated into in the busy work environment of the hospital is not as easy as one would think.
Not only has the implementation of all our quality initiatives not required the input of any SCAMs, it is difficult to find a reference where the SCAM community is making any efforts to improve their quality. Take hand hygiene, probably the most important intervention you can do to decrease the spread of infectious diseases.
In the chiropractic literature there is one study. Acupuncture and naturopathy? None. These are the three fields that are often associated with Institutions of <sarcasm> Higher Learning </sarcasm> and they are not publishing in areas of quality. Of course, evaluating quality interventions requires a firm understanding of the scientific method, not, given their curricula, one of their strong points.
There is one quality indicator where we still lag: influenza vaccine compliance. Locally and nationally, it is rare to get influenza vaccine rates above 50%. It is a condition of employment in health care, or at least in hospitals, that all the workers are vaccinated, or immune from prior illness, to a number of infections including chicken pox, mumps, hepatitis B, and measles. Most of the infections are those that can be transmitted from the health care providers (HCP) to their vulnerable patients. All the employees are immune to these diseases and, if at the time of employment they refuse the vaccines, they get the opportunity to find employment elsewhere. No exceptions.
The influenza vaccine is different; at most institutions it is not mandated and compliance is low. In recent years I have gone on the wards with the flu cart and given influenza vaccinations to the staff. It is fun and you get the opportunity to talk with your colleagues about the importance of vaccination and answer their questions. There are always one or two who will not make eye contact and avoid me so they do not need to get the shot or to engage in conversation with me. But most people, even those who may refuse the vaccine, will talk to me and, even if I do not convince them on the spot, I will give them something to think about. Some websites trumpet the low compliance of health care workers (HCW) as evidence that the HCW’s know something that the rest of us do not, and that is why they are not vaccinated. I have yet to hear a compelling reason outside of Guillian Barre and anaphylaxis. Instead I hear a variety of myths or misunderstandings. I address those arguments with a slightly more snarky tone over on my Medscape blog, A Budget of Dumb Asses. It is worth the every penny of the free registration for the opportunity to read it.
There is a movement to make flu vaccine mandatory, a condition of employment, for health care providers as well. The Society for Healthcare Epidemiology of America (SHEA) released a position paper, supported by the Infectious Disease Society of America, that recommends the influenza vaccine be mandatory for HCP’s. To the surprise, I am sure, of no one, I would support such a move.
There are three reasons to make the vaccine mandatory: two evidence-based, one philosophical.
There are careers where you are expected to place the needs of others ahead of your own. The most extreme example is the military or the secret service, where it is expected that you might die as a result of your job. Less extreme examples include policemen, firemen, and, yes, health care providers.
Medicine is more than a job. It is a calling, which is a weird thing for me to say, because it is a calling to what? Or whom? Got me. But it is. In medicine the expectation is that I will care for anyone who comes my way and that I will place the patients needs before my own.
I remember the old days, standing at the bedside of AIDS patients, with no idea what caused the disease or how it was spread, hoping that the (it turned out excessive) gowns and gloves would prevent transmission of the disease to me. But I, and my colleagues, did the work. And should plagues, known and unknown, strike again, as they will, I expect that most of my colleagues will be at my side, tending to the ill, regardless of the personal risk. Society expects that we will be there.
HCP’s have an moral obligation to minimize the chance that will harm will occur to patients, many of whom are particularly vulnerable. This duty is summed up in the three laws of health care:
     1.  A HCP may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.
     2.  A HCP must obey any orders given to it by SBM, except where such orders would conflict with the First Law.
     3.  A HCP must protect its own existence as long as such protection does not conflict with the First or Second Law.
SHEA summed it up:
Those in support of mandatory programs argue that influenza vaccination is an ethical responsibility of HCP, because HCP have a duty to act in the best interests of their patients (beneficence), to not place their patients at undue risk of harm (nonmaleficence), and to protect the vulnerable and those at high risk of infection. The duty to put patient interests first is outlined in nearly every professional code of ethics in medicine, nursing, and other healthcare fields.
The influenza vaccine is safe. Serious side effects are extremely rare and the risks from influenza are much greater. The vaccine is far safer than driving (30,000 deaths a year), taking a bath (450), or standing under a coconut tree (130). Of course people are not good at evaluating relative risks. I had a patient with a heart valve infection from heroin use who smoked 2 packs a day, drank a fifth a day, and rarely showered; but when he came in with new shortness of breath and I wanted to get a chest x-ray, he refused because he was worried about the radiation exposure. So it is with vaccine. Some people have a feeling, unsupported by the literature, that vaccines are unsafe, and if they were unsafe, I would not and could not recommend mandatory vaccination.
In adults
In placebo-controlled studies among adults, the most frequent side effect of vaccination was soreness at the vaccination site (affecting 10%–64% of patients) that lasted less than 2 days. These local reactions typically were mild and rarely interfered with the recipients’ ability to conduct usual daily activities. Placebo-controlled trials demonstrated that among older persons and healthy young adults, administration of TIV is not associated with higher rates for systemic symptoms (e.g., fever, malaise, myalgia, and headache) when compared with placebo injections. One prospective cohort study indicated that the rate of adverse events was similar among hospitalized persons who either were aged 65 years and older or were aged 18–64 years and had one or more chronic medical conditions compared with outpatients. Among adults vaccinated in consecutive years, reaction frequencies declined in the second year of vaccination. In clinical trials, serious adverse events were reported to occur after vaccination with TIV at a rate of less than 1%. Adverse events in adults aged 18 years and older reported to VAERS during 1990–2005 were analyzed. The most common adverse events reported to VAERS in adults included injection-site reactions, pain, fever, myalgia, and headache. The VAERS review identified no new safety concerns. Fourteen percent of the TIV VAERS reports in adults were classified as serious adverse events, similar to proportions seen overall in VAERS. The most common serious adverse event reported after receipt of TIV in VAERS in adults was GBS. The potential association between TIV and GBS has been an area of ongoing research (see Guillain-Barré Syndrome and TIV). No elevated risk for prespecified events after TIV was identified among 4,773,956 adults in a VSD analysis.
Then there is efficacy. I have discussed the efficacy of the flu vaccine before. In the hospital, there is no single intervention that will prevent the spread of infection. One of the hallmarks of anti-science/anti-vaxers is a binary approach: either the medical intervention is 100% effective or it is 100% useless. It is rare to see a nuanced discussion of the science behind the efficacy of the flu vaccine on the anti-vax web sites. Success in decreasing transmission of disease is always multifactorial: hand hygiene, cough etiquette, not coming to work when ill (an all-too-common problem), proper isolation for those who may have influenza, and more are part of a multifaceted approach to prevent the spread of infection in hospitals. Vaccines are like Captain Crunch: only part of a healthy breakfast.
The rationale for vaccinating HCW’s is also multifaceted.
We do not want health care providers to be disease vectors for our patients, most of whom are at high risk for bad outcomes from influenza.
Many of our patients may not be vaccinated or be unable to respond to the vaccine (the old and immunoincompetent) and are not protected from influenza.
There are 4 studies that demonstrate when HCW’s are vaccinated, mortality declines in residents of long term care facilities (the current phrase for nursing home). While similar studies have yet to be done in hospitals, there are multiple lines of data that converge on the same conclusion: the more people that are vaccinated against the flu, the fewer people who die.
The Cochrane review, as always with influenza, gets it wrong. While noting that “pooled data from three C-RCTs showed reduced all-cause mortality in individuals >/= 60.”, they go on to say “The key interest is preventing laboratory-proven influenza in individuals >/= 60, pneumonia and deaths from pneumonia, and we cannot draw such conclusions.” No, it is not the key interest. Most deaths from influenza are secondary deaths from exacerbation of underlying medical problems. All-cause mortality is an important endpoint, especially if you are the one dying.
The recent Skeptics Guide to the Universe podcast (#274) had an interview with Ben Goldacre, author of Bad Science and discussed big pharma malfeasance, of which there are endless examples. They noted that the makers of olsetamivir (Tamiflu) did not want to give the unpublished data from clinical trials to the Cochrane group for fear they would make a botch of the data. For once I am sympathetic to big pharma, given the bias and spin (i.e. they do not agree with me) of the Cochrane reviews on influenza treatment and prevention. I would not give my influenza data to the current crop of Cochran flu reviewers if I were a drug company, and I am no fan of the shenanigans that so often define the interactions of pharmaceutical companies and science.
I can, at some level, understand the opposition to mandatory vaccination as a philosophical position, although I see it on par with opposition to mandatory sterile technique in the OR. Many philosophical positions are at odds with reality. But you will excuse me if I neither let you operate in my hospital nor take care of my patients. I cannot see where your philosophy gets to triumph the material safety of patients.
Several institutions and health care systems have instituted mandatory vaccination with good results, achieving 96% and greater vaccination rates.
I get the sense that those who rail against the morbidity and mortality of modern medicine are the same who would decry mandatory vaccination, even though it would improve the safety in the hospital that they so fret about.
I completely support the SHEA/IDSA position. The vaccine is safe, effective, and HCP’s have a ethical and professional imperative to prevent the spread of infection to their patients.
SHEA views influenza vaccination of HCP as a core patient and HCP safety practice with which noncompliance should not be tolerated. It is the professional and ethical responsibility of HCP and the institutions within which they work to prevent the spread of infectious pathogens to their patients through evidence-based infection prevention practices, including influenza vaccination. Therefore, for the safety of both patients and HCP, SHEA endorses a policy in which annual influenza vaccination is a condition of both initial and continued HCP employment and/or professional privileges.
Sounds good to me.

Influenza Eye Roll
Mark Crislip on December 11, 2015
Link


I don’t know the best metaphor. What comes around goes around. The more things change, the more they say the same. Sisyphus. Whack-A-Mole.
So what to do when the same old same old rears its head yet again? There are 2,545 posts on this blog, and I suppose I could just point to prior posts. But a blog entry that consists of links to prior posts would make the managing editor irritable. And we don’t want him irritable. Although those links are at the end of the post.
And WordPress is not a good format for reference material. I have trouble finding my own articles even when I know they exist and search for them using what I think are relevant terms.
It being the start of the flu season the same ole same ole nonsense is back about flu vaccines and influenza treatment. Influenza seasons vary, the nonsense does not. On the assumption that most of the readers of the post have no prior knowledge of what I have written on the topic, I thought I would tackle influenza yet again.
The other problem with writing is the lack of the context we rely upon with spoken language. No tone, no facial expressions, no body language. Just words, and words do not always convey some forms of subtlety.
Sarcasm at least has punctuation although I have never seen it used. There is also a sarcastic font, a reverse italic. And I suppose you could always sure fake markup, <sarcasm>enclosing the comment in tags</sarcasm>. All the solutions are a poor substitute to a sneering tone and a curled lip. When you have to tell someone that a comment was sarcastic, or a joke, the sarcasm loses most of its power.
I don’t need sarcasm today. I need an eye roll. I know there is now an eye roll emoji available, but not on this version of Word Press, and the emoji would have the same killing effect of the sarcmark.
Look how expressive all these eye roll gifs are. For this entry, think of the Liz Lemon eye roll with every quote. Because the eye roll is there in my heart as I write this post, induced by:
Questioning Medicine: Why Is Tamiflu Still Around? Tamiflu doesn’t help, so why are docs still prescribing it?
Over at MedPage today. By a Family Practice Resident. Sorry Harriet, but I am channeling my internal medicine/ID specialist arrogance and I can now see out of the back of my head. I think I just tore both my superior obliques. I work in a hospital system with internal medicine residents. And they are Jon Snow when it comes to infectious disease. Which is expected. They do a residency to learn. But I would be surprised if anyone would want to demonstrate the depth of their Snow* with a blog entry on a major medical website. Not here. And I thought naturopaths had issues with understanding their limitations.
The article is a year old, but representative of the same old crap and the internet is eternal. I appreciate that it is fun to be edgy and contrarian, going against the conventional wisdom. I really do. But if you are going to be an edgy contrarian, do so after reading all the literature.
They start by mentioning the issues with Roche failing to report all the data from all the clinical trials and the brave crusade of Dr. Jefferson to get all the data.
Yep. Roche has behaved like dirtbags when it came to releasing information on the efficacy of oseltamivir. But, as has been discussed, the Cochrane reviewers are not angels either. Knowing the biases of the Cochrane reviewers and their awesome ability to evidently pull out of thin air explanations for the mechanism of oseltamivir’s effects, I do not trust their meta-analysis. They fall in the category of:
…a controversial tool, because even small violations of certain rules can lead to misleading conclusions. In fact, several decisions made when designing and performing a meta-analysis require personal judgment and expertise, thus creating personal biases or expectations that may influence the result.
Bibo: bias in, bias out. Cochrane stinks of bibo. Like this entry, n’est-ce pas?
And then the edgy contrarians proceed to cherry pick the results of the bibo Cochrane review that suit their narrative that oseltamivir is a useless drug. They say:
When the Cochrane reviewers were finally able to look at and sort through the body of information, and not just the abstract data, they came to similar conclusions, and reported that there were no differences for hospital admissions, reductions in confirmed pneumonia, or other complications.
What they do not mention from the bibo Cochrane review? What do they leave out of their edgy contrarian essay?
Oseltamivir and zanamivir have small, non-specific effects on reducing the time to alleviation of influenza symptoms in adults, but not in asthmatic children. Using either drug as prophylaxis reduces the risk of developing symptomatic influenza. Treatment trials with oseltamivir or zanamivir do not settle the question of whether the complications of influenza (such as pneumonia) are reduced, because of a lack of diagnostic definitions
What are the small, non-specific effects?
For the treatment of adults, oseltamivir reduced the time to first alleviation of symptoms by 16.8 hours (95% confidence interval (CI) 8.4 to 25.1 hours, P < 0.0001). This represents a reduction in the time to first alleviation of symptoms from 7 to 6.3 days.
So you are sick for about day less with oseltamivir. It figures that privileged physicians, with money and resources, would poo-poo a mere day of less illness. They are not single parents working minimum wage for whom getting back to work a day sooner may be critical to making the rent payment or putting food on the table. There are large numbers of people for whom an extra-day of illness could be catastrophic, not that a FAMILY PRACTICE resident would be aware of that. I certainly take care of those patients on a daily basis. Unfortunately, these are also the same patients who would be unable to afford oseltamivir.
And being able to prevent influenza in family members or in nursing homes is not a small, non-specific effect either.
The majority of these clinical trials are mostly in normal people. Could oseltamivir have other benefits than those mentioned by the very bibo Cochrane review? Again, it depends on what population you are treating and how promptly medication is given.
My favorite endpoint is death. A nice, binary endpoint with no issues about diagnostic definition. Death is easy to diagnose, just look for the sobbing family at the bedside as their 25 year old daughter goes into influenza-induced multi-organ system failure, the EKG slowing to flat line. Been there. Done that. Too many times. Not a fan.
What about oseltamivir and death? In Asia, prompt use of oseltamivir meant:
The incidences of hospitalization and the mortality were lower
If pregnant:
As compared with early antiviral treatment (administered < or = 2 days after symptom onset) in pregnant women, later treatment was associated with admission to an intensive care unit (ICU) or death (relative risk, 4.3).
If elderly:
oseltamivir therapy initiated after 48 hours (OR = 3.32, 95% CI = 1.02–10.8, P = .04) were identified as independent variables associated with mortality
If in Thailand:
Treatment with Oseltamivir is associated with survival in hospitalized human influenza pneumonia patients.
In AIDS patients:
Delayed administration of oseltamivir in hospitalized patients was significantly associated with mortality (P = 0.0022).
That is a fairly consistent finding. In at-risk populations (humans), prompt use of oseltamivir decreases the risk of death. And at $135 dollars, it is a lot less expensive than the $10,000 average cost of a funeral.
And if you are ill enough to be admitted to the hospital with influenza, early oseltamivir leads to less progression.
And at what cost? Nausea, vomiting, and headache. Those who let the bibo Cochrane reviews do their critical thinking for them are impressed with the number need to harm of 28 for nausea, 22 for vomiting, and 32 headaches. As if you can’t stop the medication or treat the symptoms if the potential benefit, depending on the patient population, is death. Let’s see. Death. Nausea. Death. Vomiting. Death. Headache. I’d tend towards avoiding my death and I would hope my doctor would as well.
Death sucks.
I remember 2009, the first year for H1N1. Every ICU bed in our system was occupied and every ventilator was in use. If a patient came in with flu needing a ventilator we had nothing to offer. They were dead. We were maxed out. It still amazed me that influenza peaked right at our surge capacity. It was also a year with 12 flu deaths in my system, mostly in the young and the pregnant. More flu deaths than I had ever seen before. Did putting all our flu patients on oseltamivir prevent a few deaths? Probably. I can’t say based on my own experience.
As an ID doc I am aware of the 1919 influenza pandemic. Flu killed maybe 5% of the world in 6 months. 650,000 deaths in the US, about to equal to all combat deaths in all of our wars. Influenza can be quite the killer and should flu ever return with a repeat of 1919, I’ll be glad to have some oseltamivir around to take the edge off the death rates. Oseltamivir isn’t anywhere as effective as penicillin for lues, but it is better than nothing.
There are 85,373 Pubmed references for influenza and 3,315 for oseltamivir. It looks like the authors read about a dozen papers. I wonder how many I have read in my 30 years of ID? Since starting the Puscast in 2006 I have reviewed about 3,200 articles related to influenza. At least that is how many pdfs I have on my hard drive tagged as influenza.
The influenza literature is, like most of medicine, complex, nuanced, and difficult, and it has to be applied thoughtfully to a patient population that it equally complex, nuanced, and difficult. Understanding influenza is more than writing a prescription for a patient. Understanding influenza is more than taking at face value a bibo Cochrane review. It is being a truly holistic doctor, factoring in the circulating strains of flu, the prior exposure/vaccination history, the co-morbidities of the patient and their close contacts and family, and their possible genetic resistance or susceptibility to influenza. Influenza is a disease of individuals, families, and populations.
So when I read a glib, superficial conclusion like:
Patients who have the flu feel bad, they want a drug to help them feel any amount of relief. Sadly, we have nothing for them. We can encourage hydration and rest, but that’s about it.
The easy path is to write a prescription for Tamiflu and move to the next patient. The hard path is to discuss why you are not going to write the script to someone who doesn’t want to hear it.
As with most things in medicine, we should do our best till we know better, and when we know better we should do better.
It’s safe to say with Tamiflu, as well as with the medical topics in previous posts, we know better!
I can’t even roll my eyes. JFC. I can only shake my head in sad disbelief and pity his future patients with influenza. I cannot find a GIF that is equal parts contempt and disgust. Because this is the kind of simplistic meme that will circulate among those who don’t recognize the how profoundly misleading it is.
In my practice I see the most patient harm occurs from those who honestly think they know what they are doing about infectious diseases but in fact do not know the difference between a burro and a burrow. Ignorance kills. It will be my colleagues, the ICU docs and nurses and RT’s, who deal with the results, at the bedside as the patient fades to black from influenza.
The good news? Now, when I discuss Dunning-Kruger I have an even better example than Jenny McCarthy.
More than you want to know about influenza
    • Scam Stud
    • The Tamiflu Spin
    • Yes, But. The Annotated Atlantic.
    • Cochrane Reviews: The Food Babe of Medicine?
    • One Flu Into the Cuckoo’s Nest*
    • Uneasy Lies the Head That Wears the Flu
    • What are words for?
    • I refute it thus
    • Protect Yourself
    • Drinking from the Fire Hose: Odds and Ends on the Gasping Oppression
    • Random Flu Thoughts
    • Ososillyococcinum and other Flu bits
    • Influenza Vaccine Mandates
    • Nine Questions, Nine Answers
    • Flu Vaccine Efficacy
    • More Flu Woo for You Boo Boo.
    • Herd Immunity
    • Flu Woo Hodge Podge
* I am particularly proud of that sentence. Just saying.

More About Flu Vaccine
More evidence that flu shots work, that they are safe during pregnancy, and that they don’t cause autism.
Harriet Hall on October 2, 2018
Link

Last week I wrote about influenza vaccines. I provided a link to a site summarizing the evidence that flu shots are effective and safe. Nevertheless, one reader commented “The flu vaccine does not work,” citing a Cochrane review. Elsewhere, a Twitter tweeter cited a study showing that flu vaccination in early pregnancy caused autism in babies. I thought it would be worthwhile to review those studies in case others are misled by them.
Does influenza vaccine in pregnancy cause autism in children?
The autism study didn’t say that at all. It was a large cohort study designed to investigate the association between influenza infection and vaccination during pregnancy and the risk of autism spectrum disorder (ASD). It looked at the records of 196,929 children born at Kaiser Permanente Northern California over a 10-year period. 23% of mothers (45,231 women) were vaccinated during pregnancy, and 1,400 mothers had clinical illnesses that were diagnosed as influenza infections by laboratory testing. 3,101 children were diagnosed with ASD. The study was published in 2017 in JAMA Pediatrics.
It concluded:
There was no association between maternal influenza infection anytime during pregnancy and increased ASD risk. There was a suggestion of increased ASD risk among children whose mothers received an influenza vaccination in their first trimester, but the association was not statistically significant after adjusting for multiple comparisons, indicating that the finding could be due to chance.
That single finding, which was not statistically significant, does nothing to tip the balance when weighed against this information from the CDC:
Flu is more likely to cause severe illness in pregnant women than in women of reproductive age who are not pregnant. Changes in the immune system, heart, and lungs during pregnancy make pregnant women (and women up to two weeks postpartum) more prone to severe illness from flu, including illness resulting in hospitalization. Flu also may be harmful for a pregnant woman’s developing baby. A common flu symptom is fever, which may be associated with neural tube defects and other adverse outcomes for a developing baby. Getting vaccinated can also help protect a baby after birth from flu. (Mom passes antibodies onto the developing baby during her pregnancy.)
Bottom line: flu shots are recommended for pregnant women.
The Cochrane review
The reader who asserted “the flu vaccine does not work” said, “Cochrane reviewed 90 flu vaccine studies, and less than 10 percent were considered good science.” He found this information here. That study didn’t say the flu vaccine didn’t work; it said it worked, with a number needed to treat (NNT) to prevent one case of influenza of 71.
The Cochrane review he cited was published in 2014 and has been superseded by a 2018 update. The 2018 review says:
Due to the uncertain quality of observational (i.e. non‐randomised) studies and their lack of influence on the review conclusions, we decided to update only randomised evidence. The searches for observational comparative studies are no longer updated.
They included 52 clinical trials of over 80,000 people. They said 15% of the studies they reviewed were well designed and conducted, but they found insufficient evidence to determine the likelihood of bias in about 70% of the studies they included in the review.
They found:
    • Moderate-certainty evidence that flu vaccines reduce the rate of influenza in healthy adults from 2.3% to 0.9%. (That’s percentages; think of how many individuals that corresponds to in our large population.)
    • 71 healthy adults need to be vaccinated to prevent one of them experiencing influenza. (This is actually not too shabby when compared to the NNTs for other widely accepted treatments, as reported here.)
    • Vaccination may lead to a small reduction in hospitalization, but the confidence interval is wide and doesn’t rule out a large benefit.
    • Low-certainty evidence that vaccines may lead to a small or no reduction in days off work.
    • A modest protective effect of vaccination in pregnant women and newborns.
    • A reduced risk of influenza-like illnesses.
Other relevant studies
A 2016 review in The Lancet found that the effectiveness rates for the specific strains of influenza virus covered in the vaccine ranged from 33 to 73%. For adults over 60, they found effectiveness rates of 24% to 63% depending on the strain.
The effectiveness varies with the accuracy of prediction of which strains will dominate in a given year. According to the CDC, the overall vaccine effectiveness for last year was 36%. The effectiveness for the H3N3 strain, the dominant strain circulating that season, was notoriously virulent and less receptive to vaccination than other types of influenza; its effectiveness was approximately 25%. The effectiveness for the less severe H1N1 was 67% and for influenza B viruses it was 42%.
As a TIME article pointed out:
36% effectiveness may not seem very impressive, but the CDC emphasizes in the report that even small increases in immunity can have a large impact on public health. CDC data has shown that even in 2014-2015, a year when vaccine effectiveness didn’t even hit 20%, immunizations prevented as many as 144,000 flu-related hospitalizations and 4,000 deaths. Plus, people who get the shot, but who still end up getting sick, tend to have less severe illnesses than unvaccinated people.
Lessons to be learned
    • Never rely on a single study.
    • Do your research carefully. Read what the study actually said rather than relying on a second-hand report from a possibly biased or ill-informed source.
    • Look for studies that refute the claim, not just ones that confirm it.
    • Make sure you have found the most recent information available.
    • When you find indications of a possible harm, weigh it against the known benefits.

Drinking from the Fire Hose: Odds and Ends on the Gasping Oppression aka influenza
Mark Crislip on April 6, 2012
Link
I spend most of my time taking care of hospitalized patients with acute infections and issues of public health are, outside of infection control, not a high priority. Vaccinations in training were always like clean water and fresh food: their benefit was a given and I never needed to consider the benefits and subtleties of vaccination. There is just so much time in a day and I was more concerned with AIDS, endocarditis and meningitis to worry about the ins and outs of vaccination.
One of the many benefits of writing for SBM, and being the Chair of Infection Control, is it is a stimulus to keep up on aspects of medicine that I might not otherwise pay close attention to, like vaccines. I have been far more interested in vaccines, especially influenza vaccines, since starting practice in 1990 than I ever was in the decade I spend in training.
Vaccination and the efficacy of vaccines is not as straightforward as I would have thought 30 years ago. It was give a vaccine, generate an antibody, and, viola, the patient is protected. The vagaries of the flu vaccine are even more pronounced, since response to the vaccine is variable and the population has never been vaccinated at levels, more than 90%, where herd immunity would likely kick in.
My ideal flu vaccine study, which would be both impossible and unethical, would be to vaccinate everyone West of the Mississippi and no one to the East (no coincidence that me and mine live in the West) and study the short and long term effects. Until that day, I am stuck with the hodgepodge of medical studies that look at the results of influenza vaccination and add insights into the disease.
I thought this week it would be fun to mention some interesting studies about influenza, the vaccine and flu immunity that have come out in the last 2 years. This is not meant to be anything more than a compilation of articles I thought were interesting, and the only purpose is to give a hint as to the complexities of influenza and vaccination. 
How did I choose these articles? Every two weeks I do an infectious disease update podcast (Puscast, on iTunes), and I went through my influenza related pdf’s from the Puscast from the last two years. Much to my surprise I had read over 250 influenza related articles. Is that alot or a little? There were 12,411 influenza articles on Pubmed in the same time frame, so I read about 2% of the influenza literature for my Puscast, but it represents about .6% of the 4000 articles I read in the same period. I am always impressed with the extent of what I have yet to learn compared to what I do know. So much knowledge, so little time to consume it. Dr Richard Bryant, my attending as a medical student and one of the big reasons I went into ID, said reading the medical literature is like drinking from a fire hose. Oh well, here is what I think is interesting, curious, or important about influenza in the last year. A sip from the deluge.
Believe is what you do when there is an absence of facts. One of the aggravating issues at the hospital is getting health care providers to get the flu vaccine. The best I can do is about 70% of employees to get vaccinated. Across the country those numbers are the same, although MD and RN vaccination rates hover around 80%. That is pathetic, since I have the old fashioned idea it is incumbent upon us to protect our patients, especially given that nosocomially acquired flu has a 27% mortality rate and people shed the flu before they are ill or likely to come to work when ill:
“…we estimated that 1%–8% of infectiousness occurs prior to illness onset. Only 14% of infections with detectable shedding at RT-PCR were asymptomatic, and viral shedding was low in these cases.”
Silent shedders may be unimportant as an outpatient, but if it were a nurse or respiratory therapist going from room to room, it could result in rapid spread of disease.
The antivaccine wackaloons see low vaccination rates in HCW’s as an indictment of the vaccine, that HCW’s know something that the rest of us do not. That is not the case. I have wandered the hospital giving flu shots, and there are the same lame reasons given by the HCW’s as the general population, although HCW’s should know better since they ostensibly have access to all the information and the best minds (mine) in the field. I publish an article on Medscape every October on why HCW’s are a dumbass for not getting the flu vaccine. Oddly, people take exception at being called a dumb ass.
What factors are important in HCWs getting the flu vaccine?
Knowing that the vaccine is effective (mhRR 2.22; 95% CI 1.93 to 2.54), being willing to prevent influenza transmission (mhRR 2.31; 95% CI 1.97 to 2.70), believing that influenza is highly contagious (RR 2.25; 95% CI 1.66 to 3.05), believing that influenza prevention is important (mhRR 3.63; 95% CI 2.87 to 4.59) and having a family that is usually vaccinated (RR 2.32; 95% CI 1.64 to 3.28) were statistically significantly associated with a twofold higher vaccine uptake.
And infected HCW’s markedly increase your risk of influenza like illness if you are exposed in the hospital.
For patients exposed to at least 1 contagious HCW compared with those with no documented exposure in the hospital, the RR of HA-ILI was 5.48 (95% confidence interval [CI], 2.09-14.37); for patients exposed to at least 1 contagious patient, the RR was 17.96 (95% CI, 10.07-32.03); and for patients exposed to at least 1 contagious patient and 1 contagious HCW, the RR was 34.75.
Part of the problem is there have been no studies to demonstrate that specifically vaccinating hospital workers will decrease influenza in patients. There is certainly buckets of biologic plausibility to suggest that if I do not get flu because of the vaccine, I will not pass it on to you as I make rounds in the ICU. There have been studies to suggest benefit in nursing homes, but of course nursing homes are not the same as acute care hospitals, were the length of stay is increasingly measured in hours rather than days, lessening the risk of exposure.
The literature now has an extremely suboptimal study that suggests vaccinating HCW’s decreases influenza in the hospital.
In summary, our observational study indicates a protective influence of vaccination of more than 35% of HCW on HAI in patients. Other experimentally-designed investigations are needed to demonstrate the effectiveness of HCW vaccination in the control of influenza outbreaks in healthcare settings, and to determine the threshold for vaccinated HCW proportion with more accuracy. Our findings must not be misinterpreted. To date, the HCW vaccination rate of 35% is not optimal to control HAI.
But I will take what I can get, since the more that are vaccinated, the fewer will get disease. What is curious to my mind is why people would think otherwise about the vaccine. My advice to you and yours during the flu season: If admitted to the hospital, you are probably in a population at risk for dying of influenza, and if your provider has not had the vaccine, they may not be convinced of the contagiousness of flu nor its seriousness. They are likely a dumb ass, and you do not want a dumb ass involved with your health care. You need to request another HCW and forbid them from entering your hospital room. If anyone from my family is admitted to the hospital, especially my mother, I will not allow anyone in her room who has not had the flu vaccine. I suggest you do the same.
Since the flu vaccine is not close to 100% effective, there are other measures to help decrease the spread. A career in infection control has consistently reinforced the idea that there is never one intervention that completly decreases the risk of infection, and no one, except the antivaccine wackaloons, think that the vaccine is an all or nothing phenomena. Simple mechanical issues often do not demonstrate benefit: good hand washing and masks are of variable help in outbreak situations, if started early.
During the 2009/10 and 2010/11 pandemic seasons, Dr. Buchholz and colleagues compared 84 households in which 1 member had influenza. The households were randomized into 3 groups: facemask use and intensified hand hygiene; facemask use only; and no intervention (control group). Among the 218 noninfected contacts in the 84 households, 35 (16%) developed flu. An intention-to-treat analysis found no benefit from facemasks and handwashing, nor from facemasks alone. However, when the intervention was started within 36 hours of symptom onset in the index case, pooled data from the 2 intervention groups showed an 84% reduction in secondary flu infection. In addition, when facemask alone was considered in a per protocol analysis, there was a 70% reduction in risk.
Other evaluations the effect of mask and hand washing was not as good for flu prevention.
Data from 788 households were collected from April 2008 to February 2011. The median age of the household member with flu was 5 years, and 724 (92%) slept in the same room with their parents. Among the household contacts, 31% became infected. Handwashing was found to have no significant benefit, and facemask use was associated with a modest increase in risk for influenza infection.
So that is why I would prohibit the unvaccinated health care worker from entering my room even if masked, although there are some hospitals in my area are having workers who are not vaccinated wear a mask. I should probably wear a mask for aesthetic reasons
There is a difference between using a mask and hand washing in the community to prevent acquisition, which is only of perhaps modest benefit, and is probably not the same as masking an infected person to prevent spread in the hospital. Given that hand hygiene is often not 100%, I would be further disinclined to allow the unvaccinated HCW in a mask to touch me and mine, never knowing for sure where those hands may have been. Actually I do know. And you should be ashamed.
It is doubly interesting since there was a proof of concept study to demonstrate the route of flu infection may be through the eyes. Volunteers were squirted with live flu vaccine while wearing various protective measures, and as long as there was no eye protection they became infected with the vaccine strain. I suppose if my unvaccinated HCW wore a spacesuit I would let them in my mothers room, but otherwise no way. See the addendum at the end for a recent real world, i.e. messy and incomplete, example.
The two groups who had inordinate mortality from the H1N1 pandemic were the obese and the pregnant, and both were targets for vaccination. It is harder to get a pregnant female (but not a pregnant male) to take anything for fear of affecting the fetus.
Flu is bad for the baby. Babies in utero during the 191p pandemic had
reduced educational attainment, increased rates of physical disability, lower income
and babies who were from vaccinated mothers were larger:
During this period, the proportion of infants who were small for gestational age was lower in the influenza vaccine group than in the control group (25.9% v. 44.8%; p = 0.03). The mean birth weight was higher among infants whose mothers received the influenza vaccine than among those who received the control vaccine during this period (3178 g v. 2978 g; p = 0.02).
Given that epidemiologic data suggests “pandemic influenza caused first trimester miscarriages in ∼1 in 10 pregnant women”, besides covering your own ass for dying from flu while pregnant, not getting the flu would be of great benefit for your unborn child. And the benefit continues after birth
Results. The mothers of 2 (2.2%) of 91 case subjects and 31 (19.9%) of 156 control subjects aged !6 months, and 1 (4.6%) of 22 case subjects and 2 (5.6%) of 36 control subjects aged > 6 months, had received influenza vaccine during pregnancy. The effectiveness of influenza vaccine given to mothers during pregnancy in preventing hospitalization among their infants, adjusted for potential confounders, was 91.5% (95% confidence interval [CI], 61.7%–98.1%; P p .001) for infants aged !6 months. The unadjusted effectiveness was 90.7% (95% CI, 59.9%– 97.8%; P p .001).
Conclusions. Influenza vaccine given to pregnant women is 91.5% effective in preventing hospitalization of their infants for influenza in the first 6 months of life.
I always assume that various biases result in overestimation of therapeutic benefit in studies. That is part of the decline effect in clinical medicine. As you weed out the bias the efficacy of treatments often declines. I had never considered that bias underestimates effectiveness, since there is an inherent urge in researchers to find positive results.
I have mentioned many times that statistical analysis make me feel like Mr. Gumby, and I dropped my statistics class every year for four years in college. One they got past the Bell shaped curve, they lost me to brain hurt. To this day I have to take the results of statistical analysis at face value. It turns out that, at least with the flu vaccine, bias may be underestimating the effectiveness by about 10%
By simulating a case-control study of influenza VE in children, we found that the sources of bias we included, when considered together, more often led to an underestimation rather than an overestimation of true vaccine benefit.
How widely the results are applicable to other interventions or studies that are not case control, I lack the intellectual wherewithal to say.
Association is not causation, but one of the effects of vaccination is prevention of complications of flu: bacterial infections and vascular events
There was strong evidence for a link between influenza and MI both in England and Wales, where 3.1%–3.4% of MI-associated deaths (P < .001) and 0.7%–1.2% of MI-associated hospitalizations (P < .001) were attributable to influenza, and in Hong Kong, where the corresponding figures were 3.9%–5.6% (P = .018) and 3.0%–3.3% (P = .002).
and
In a retrospective chart review of 119 individuals admitted to the hospital with H1N1 virus infection, 7 patients (5.9%) were found to have experienced thrombotic vascular events.
But those who listen to my Puscast know the bee in my bonnet of infection leading to inflammation which is prothrombotic which leads all manner of vascular events. Inflammation is bad, even when you are infected, but is the price we pay to survive infections.
Blood stream infections go up with flu season,
Regular influenza seasons were characterized by increased rates of S. pneumoniae BSI but with no increase in S. aureus and S. pyogenes BSI rates. The pH1N1/2009–2010 influenza outbreak was characterized by (1) higher rates of S. pneumoniae bacteremia among children but not among adults (IRRs for S. pneumoniae BSI among children aged 0–4 years during the summer and winter of 2009–2010 were 14.8 [95% confidence interval {CI}, 5–43.7] and 6.5 [95% CI, 3.6–11.8], compared with 2006–2009 summers and influenza-active winter weeks, respectively ]), higher rates of S. aureus BSI in all age groups (IRRs during the summer and winter of 2009–2010 were 1.6 [95% CI, 1.4–1.9] and 1.5 [95% CI, 1.2–1.7], compared with 2006–2009 summers and influenza-active weeks, respectively [P , .0001]), higher rates of S. pyogenes BSI during 2009–2010 influenza season (IRR 2.7 [95% CI, 1.6–4.6] and 3.3 [95% CI, 1.9–5.8] during the summer and winter of 2009–2010, compared with 2006–2009 summers and influenza-active weeks, respectively ).
and pneumonia
During ∼185 million person-years of surveillance, we observed 21,239 episodes of invasive pneumococcal pneumonia; 485,691 specimens were tested for influenza. Influenza circulation was associated with 11%– 14% of pneumococcal pneumonia during periods of influenza circulation and 5%–6% overall. In 2 of 3 regions, the association was strongest when influenza circulation data were lagged by 1 week.
A lot of badness is associated with the flu; at least the heart attacks may be prevented:
The incidence of AMI was significantly reduced in the 60 days following vaccination (compared with the baseline period), ranging from a reduction of 32% (IRR 0.68; 95% CI 0.60–0.78) at 1–14 days after vaccination, to 18% (IRR 0.82; 95% CI 0.75–0.90) at 29–59 days after vaccination.
The coolest article of the year suggests we may be on the path to a universal flu vaccine. Every year the structure of the flu proteins drifts and every 25 years or so there is a entirely new strain from genetic reassortment, or a shift. It is why we need a new vaccination every year. They have discovered a site on the influenza hemagglutinin protein, FI6, that has
broadly neutralizing antibody that recognizes all 16 HA subtypes, including emerging ones, such as H5N1.
If you are lucky, after the vaccine or the disease, you could develop an antibody against the FI6 site and be immune to all subsequent strains of flu. I say luck, as the researcher screened “104,000 peripheral-blood plasma cells from eight recently infected or vaccinated donors” to find one cell making that antibody.
Why the production of broadly neutralizing antibody occurs rarely is an unanswered question, although some are lucky enough to make such antibody. It might partially explain why seasonal influenza infection conferred cross-protection against pandemic influenza while vaccination does not.
It does make the whole issue of efficacy of vaccine that much more interesting. You get the vaccine, and depending on what parts of the vaccine you react to, you could have more or less chance of disease or disease severity. Hopefully they will be able to force the immune system to recognize the FI6 epitope more reliably and we will may be able to eradicate influenza. Or not. Not with the current vaccination rates. But I can dream. First smallpox, then rinderpest (good thing Wakefield was not a veterinarian), then influenza?
Complications of the vaccine are always a concern and the big one with H1N1 was Guillain-Barre syndrome (GBS), since after the 1979 1976 flu vaccine there was an uptick in cases of the disease, a complication never adequately explained and never repeated. Not only was the H1N1 vaccine not associated with GBS, but the flu itself had a higher association
Adjusted odds ratios for GBS occurrence within 6 weeks after seasonal and A/H1N1 vaccination were 1.3 (95% CI: 0.4, 4.1) and 0.9 (95% CI: 0.1, 7.6), respectively. Study results confirm that influenza virus is a likely risk factor for GBS. Conversely, no new concerns have arisen regarding influenza vaccination.
And you will be relieved to know that if you had GBS in the past, you can be vaccinated safely.
“Results. We identified 550 cases of GBS over 33 million person-years. Following their GBS diagnoses, 989 vaccines were given to 279 of these individuals, including 405 trivalent inactivated influenza vaccines (TIV) administered to 107 individuals with a prior diagnosis of GBS. Among the 550 total cases of GBS, 18 initially had onset within 6 weeks of TIV; of these, 2 were revaccinated with TIV without a recurrence of GBS. Only 6 individuals of 550 (1.1%) had a second (recurrent) diagnosis of GBS. Among these 6 individuals, none had any vaccine exposure at all in the 2 months prior to the second onset of GBS.
Conclusions. In our population of over 3 million members, during an 11-year period, risk of GBS recurrence was low. There were no cases of recurrent GBS after influenza vaccination and none within 6 weeks after any vaccine.
Right. I’m impressed with the power of Kaiser Permanente; I could never convince a GBS patient to receive a vaccine.
None of the studies quoted above are definitive, but if you are a fan of the concept of preponderance of data, it would seem that influenza is bad and the vaccine has benefits. There are numerous other interesting articles on antibiotic resistance, efficacy of vaccine, and the 500th anniversary of the gasping oppression I did not mention. There is always more to learn.
Addendum
A true story. When I first read it today, I thought it was made up to make a point. I did not write the text, but it occurred at a Portland hospital in mid March and I reproduce it with permission.
Patient Story: Spreading the Flu 4-2012
As a reminder, we have added patient stories to meetings as a way of “bringing the patient into the room”, clarifying the context for our quality plan, and emphasizing the complexities and the importance of the work we are undertaking.
Today’s story is about a group of patients, a nurse, and influenza. It starts with Patient #1, a 47 year-old woman admitted through the emergency department (ED) in mid-March with fever and shortness of breath. She was transferred to an inpatient unit with a mask on, which triggered the staff on the receiving unit to implement droplet precautions. Initially thought to have pneumonia, testing confirmed her symptoms were the result of influenza type A, H1N1. After four nights in the hospital, she was discharged home after an uneventful hospital stay and a flu shot.
Patient #2, next door to Patient #1, is a 61 year-old man who was admitted in early March for a GI bleed with multiple co-morbidities. His progress was steady until nine days after admission, when he developed a new fever and respiratory symptoms. These symptoms developed on the same day of Patient #1’s admission. Influenza was suspected two days following the development of his fever, and staff implemented droplet precautions. Lab testing confirmed influenza type A. He remained hospitalized for two more days and received a flu shot before being transferred to a skilled nursing facility.
Down the hall, Patient #3, a 71 year-old man, was admitted two days after Patient #1 for acute stroke and urinary tract infection. On day 3 of his hospitalization, he developed a fever and cough. Lab testing confirmed influenza type A. Droplet precautions were ordered with the lab test for influenza. He remained hospitalized an additional four nights and received a flu shot before being discharged.
Patient #4, a 73 year old man, down the hall from the first two patients and around the corner from Patient #3, was admitted on the same day as Patient #1 following a fainting event at home. Due to his long-standing heart issues, he was kept overnight for observation and discharged the following morning. However, he returned to the ED three days later with continued symptoms. He was discharged from the ED only to return the next day with shortness of breath. Six hours after being readmitted, staff suspected influenza and ordered droplet precautions. His lab tests returned positive for influenza type A. After spending three nights in the hospital, he was discharged home after receiving a flu shot. The following day, he was admitted to the intensive care unit and continued receiving treatment as an inpatient for secondary pneumonia, a complication of his influenza type A infection.
The fifth person in our story is a nurse on the unit where these four patients were admitted. She works on a nursing unit whose hand hygiene performance is currently 67%, and where 85% of the unit staff were vaccinated for this year’s seasonal flu. The particular nurse in this case, however, was 1 of only 9 on the unit who chose not to be vaccinated. Her manager stated that the reason the nurse gave for not receiving the vaccine was that she “was not convinced of the evidence that the vaccine protects patients from transmission … she said she would get the vaccine if she truly believed it protected her patients, but that she didn’t.”
This nurse cared for Patient #1 on her first day of admission. She cared for Patient #2 on the eighth and ninth day (when he developed flu symptoms) of his stay. She also cared for Patient #3 on the first two days of his inpatient stay. There does not appear to be any direct contact with this nurse and Patient #4.
The nurse in our story developed symptoms consistent with influenza three days after working with Patient #1 and Patient #2 (which is the usual 1- to 4-day incubation period for influenza). Due to symptoms, she only worked a partial shift that day. Suspecting her symptoms may be influenza, she used a mask until relief staff was available. She returned home and was able to care for herself without medical intervention. She was not tested for influenza and remained off work for one week. She is still undecided about receiving the flu vaccine.
Oregon is one of only two states in the US that prohibits employers from requiring vaccines as a condition of employment. Our organization is actively working with colleagues throughout the state to try to change this.

What are words for? On Vaccination.
Mark Crislip on September 20, 2013
Link
Do you hear me
Do you care
Do you hear me
Do you care
My lips are moving and the sound’s coming out
The words are audible but I have my doubts
That you realize what has been said
You look at me as if you’re in a daze
It’s like the feeling at the end of the page
When you realize you don’t know what you just read
What are words for when no one listens anymore
What are words for when no one listens
What are words for when no one listens it’s no use talking at all
I might as well go up and talk to a wall
‘Cause all the words are having no effect at all
Missing Persons on blogging. Or so I thought. I was surprised to learn the song was written by the brothers Gibb.
Words are important. I try and choose my words carefully when writing so that they accurately reflect not only my thoughts but reality. When I speak, not so much. My frontal lobe filters often fail if I think might I might get a laugh.
I tell housestaff, precision of writing reflects precision of thought. It is one of the reasons I write; the act of writing forces some coherence into what can be muddled and inchoate thoughts. Even though I have residents who write notes, I always write my own. Often I do not make a final decision as to a plan until I put pen to paper, or electrons to screen. Writing crystallizes thought.
Not, evidently, for everyone, as 10 Facts About the Flu Vaccine and the Flu nicely demonstrates.
Influenza is one the more difficult diseases and the vaccine one of the more problematic interventions. Influenza is tricky, mutating every year, acquiring new DNA, new virulence, reacquiring old genes to infect at risk populations.
Influenza is deadly, a consistent cause of morbidity and mortality since the gasping oppression arose in human populations. I have written extensively on influenza over the years on this blog as part of my goal of reaching a million words on vaccines. Influenza kills people directly, it kills with secondary infections, it kills those with underlying medical problems, it kills with heart attacks. It especially kills the old, the young, the pregnant and now the obese. It kills the unborn; influenza season is spontaneous abortion season. It leads to smaller, less intelligent children. Depending on the year and the circulating strains, influenza is a major cause of human suffering and death.
90% of my practice is in the hospital seeing people who are acutely ill. I see those who got the short end of the influenza stick, those who suffer from influenza, its complications and occasionally die.
Oddly, I take the responsibility to prevent morbidity and mortality very seriously. The pro suffering and death, er, I mean anti-vaccine contingent will often say those of us in the anti-suffering and death, er, I mean pro-vaccine contingent are big pharma shills only in it for the money. I wish.
Early this week I heard someone mention, in response to some unfair experience, that it was nothing personal, it’s business. I realized that for me it is always personal, never business. I take human suffering and unnecessary death personally, an affront that pisses me off. Sometime back someone mentioned my posts seemed angry. You bet I get angry. Preventable illness and death should make you angry.
Preventing disease is always multimodal. I have been the Chair of Infection Control for what seems forever and one clear lesson of infection prevention is there is no magic bullet. Stopping infections is the result of the sum of a multitude of interventions, all important, all critical. When you do everything right every time, hospital-acquired infections almost vanish, much to the disappointment of my bottom line.
Preventing influenza, and other infections, is both simple and difficult. Ameliorate risks by not smoking or being overweight. Wash hands. Don’t inhale around coughers or on airplanes. Be replete in vitamin D. And be vaccinated.
As vaccines go, the influenza vaccine is not our best and brightest. It has variable efficacy in different populations and because there are new strains every year re-vaccination is required. Those who need the protection the most are those who are least likely to respond. And we have never had enough of the population vaccinated at any one time to take advantage of herd immunity, even supposing an excellent antigenic match between the vaccine and circulating strains.
Overall it appears to be a modestly effective vaccine when used as part of a nutritious breakfast. It decreases the chances of getting flu, of having a flu-like illness, and of having complications of flu such as heart attacks and the need for hospitalization. It is not a great vaccine but it is better than no vaccine.
If you read the entire literature on the influenza vaccine I think you would be convinced and if you had a career watching people suffer and occasionally die from influenza, while you might wish for a better vaccine, you would be glad for any weapon you could bring to bear against influenza. “You go to war with the army you have—not the army you might want or wish to have at a later time.”
It is part of why cherry picking, half-truths and misleading essays on vaccines annoy me and warrant words. It is what words are for. Let’s see what SafeMinds has to offer with their facts:
According to the most extensive flu vaccine effectiveness review conducted to date, flu vaccines might be effective against influenza A and B, which represents about 10% of all circulating flu viruses each year.
No. I am picky here. Influenza A and B represent 100% of the flu viruses each year. The author points out in the introduction that there are 200 other viruses that can cause a flu-like illness, which is not necessarily the same as flu, the illness of influenza. Any illness with fevers, muscle aches and malaise is called the flu. But the flu is influenza. And I have zero idea what a stomach flu is.
The influenza vaccine prevents influenza. As it should. It does not have effects against rhinovirus, adenovirus, RSV or mimivirus. Nor should it. This is like noting the pneumococcal vaccine does not prevent the several hundred bacterial causes of pneumonia.
That is the type of sloppy writing that drives. Me. Nuts. I see it all the time in the newspaper when reading about topics of which I have extensive knowledge. They often get it wrong in ways that are misleading. Or just stupid. If I see the term “flesh eating virus” applied to Group A streptococcus one more time I will scream.
Under average conditions when the vaccine is a partial match for the circulating strains of flu, 100 people need to be vaccinated to avoid one set of influenza symptoms.
That is from the Cochrane reviews, whose leader has what I suspect is a strong bias against flu vaccine and looks at the effects of the vaccine as narrowly as possible.
Part of the issue with flu vaccine is the beneficial effects that also occur on populations and for diseases other than influenza. While the vaccine prevents infections from influenza, it also prevents other complication in those at risk: secondary pneumonias, heart attacks etc. Not getting influenza is a good way to avoid other illnesses.
And even when there is no match there can be effectiveness in the flu vaccine:
The TIV and LAIV vaccines can provide cross protection against non-matching circulating strains.
Determining overall benefit of vaccination is tricky depending on what goals you consider important. For example, with the H1N1 vaccine, using “societal perspective”:
Vaccination for pH1N1 for children and working-age adults is cost-effective compared to other preventive health interventions under a wide range of scenarios. The economic evidence was consistent with target recommendations that were in place for pH1N1 vaccination.
As the evil CDC notes:
Results of studies that assess how well a flu vaccine works can vary based on study design, outcome(s) measured, population studied and the season in which the vaccine was studied. These differences can make it difficult to compare one study’s results with another’s. As there is interest in how well flu vaccines may prevent illness, hospitalization, and even death with influenza, many outcomes need to be considered.
So when they say next:
Having received the flu vaccines has been found not to reduce hospitalizations or working days lost to flu like illnesses.
You can say it depends. On the study, on the vaccine, on the circulating strain, since others have shown:
Influenza vaccine is eﬀective in reducing hospital admissions for influenza, pneumonia, bronchitis and emphysema, and eﬀectiveness is comparable to that observed for influenza and pneumonia admissions in North America.
It is ignoring nuance of a complicated topic to grind your ax that annoys me. To continue:
In fact, the flu vaccine causes approximately one case of Guillian-Barré syndrome (GBS), a major neurological condition leading to paralysis, for every one million vaccinations administered.
Again, it depends:
After adjusting for antecedent infections, we found no evidence for an elevated GBS risk following 2009-10 MIV/2010-11 TIV influenza vaccines. However, the association between GBS and antecedent infection was strongly elevated.
So the infection is worse than the vaccine for association with GBS. I am not sure of their source, since it SafeMind is not completely referenced, but the Lancet confirms the risk is far higher from influenza infection when compared to the vaccine:
The attributable risks were 1•03 Guillain-Barré syndrome admissions per million vaccinations, compared with 17•2 Guillain-Barré syndrome admissions per million influenza-coded health-care encounters.
Partial words. Misleading words. Not what I would use words for.
Much of the published flu vaccines effectiveness data is funded by vaccine companies so the results may be overly optimistic estimate because company-sponsored influenza vaccines trials tend to produce results favorable to their products.
I do not deny the potential bias in pharmaceutical sponsored studies; it is why it is important to look at the study carefully for flaws that make the results suspect. Many of the epidemiologic studies are not funded by pharma.
According to flu vaccine package inserts, “Safety and effectiveness has not been established in pregnant women or nursing mothers and should only be given to a pregnant woman if clearly needed.”
Who dies from influenza? Pregnant females, although not in all studies (funded by the WHO, part of the New World Order, who get their funding from big pharma):
Some well accepted risk factors such as pregnancy and belonging to an ethnic minority group could not be identified as risk factors. In contrast, women who were less than four weeks post partum had a significantly increased risk of death from pandemic influenza.
Pregnant males are spared. And it kills the fetus as well.
Pandemic influenza virus infection in pregnancy was associated with an increased risk of fetal death. Vaccination during pregnancy reduced the risk of an influenza diagnosis. Vaccination itself was not associated with increased fetal mortality and may have reduced the risk of influenza-related fetal death during the pandemic.
Of course, that study was funded by Norwegian Institute of Public Health, notorious pharma shills (sarcasm, my Norwegian readers).
Not only does the vaccine protect mother and fetus (this time by those shills, the Argentinian Institute for Clinical Effectiveness and Health Policy. Bastards),
This large study using primary data collection found that MF59 adjuvanted A/H1N1 influenza vaccine did not result in an increased risk of adverse perinatal events and suggested a lower risk among vaccinated women.
And women give birth to healthier babies (this time it is Kaiser, man, do they have no shame?), one of many studies to show similar results:
Pregnant women who received H1N1 influenza vaccine were less likely to give birth preterm, and gave birth to heavier infants.
But mothers who are vaccinated pass protective antibody to their children resulting in less ill neonates:
Maternal influenza vaccination was significantly associated with reduced risk of influenza virus infection and hospitalization for an ILI up to 6 months of age and increased influenza antibody titers in infants through 2 to 3 months of age.
Again one of many representative studies, although who could ever trust the Center for American Indian Health? Those guys are known to be at the pharma trough.
SafeMinds continues:
A large-scale scientific study in approximately 50,000 pregnant women over five flu seasons found no difference in the risk for developing influenza illness among those who received the influenza vaccine during pregnancy and those who did not.
My Google-fu fails me. I can find two studies with 50,000 pregnant females and the flu vaccine and neither were efficacy studies. One was a safety study and the other a fetal safety study. Both demonstrated safety of the vaccine.
I know SafeMinds would not make up information, although if I were of conspiratorial bent (I am not), I would suspect that with “facts” such as these that they were in league with the New World Order to help depopulate the earth. Can someone help me out with the reference in question? It occurs to me as I do the final draft I should have just asked SafeMinds for the reference. Silly me.
Flu vaccines stimulate the immune system and product an inflammatory response. These same kind of inflammatory responses in pregnant women have been linked with the development of autism.
Nothing compared to the immune stimulation of infection which kills the fetus. At least autism is not due to mercury…oh wait:
Most flu vaccines contain mercury in the form of thimerosal. All forms of mercury have been found to be dangerous and should be avoided, especially by pregnant women. Simple methods such as good hand washing and avoiding contact with individuals who have the flu are also effective in preventing the flu for everyone.
Most? Try some. From the CDC:
Since seasonal influenza vaccine is produced in large quantities for annual immunization campaigns, some of the vaccine is produced in multi-dose vials, and contains thimerosal to safeguard against possible contamination of the vial once it is opened.The single-dose units are made without thimerosal as a preservative because they are intended to be opened and used only once. Additionally, the live-attenuated version of the vaccine (the nasal spray vaccine), is produced in single-dose units and does not contain thimerosal.
Of the 145 million doses made in 2012, 62 million were thimerosal-free.
I recognize that people have their biases. SafeMinds certainly does. But still. A little integrity when writing about complicated concepts. Please. SafeMinds are evidently neither HonestMinds nor FuntionalMinds.
What are my words for? My destination is known. Sorry. I so wanted to tie it up with another Missing Persons reference. A million words. In defense of vaccines, in defense of preventing illness. In defense of preventing death. Seem a good use of words to me.

No, the CDC did not just “admit” that this year’s flu vaccine doesn’t work
David Gorski on December 7, 2014
Link

Since the press release was originally issued on Thursday by now surely most of you have seen the news stories that popped up beginning yesterday morning with headlines like “CDC Warning: Flu Viruses Mutate and Evade Current Vaccine“, or “Flu vaccine protects against wrong strain, US health officials warn“, or “Flu shots may not be good match for 2014-15 virus, CDC says“, or “Health Officials Warn This Year’s Flu Vaccine Won’t Prevent New H3N2 Strain Of Influenza“. You get the idea. This year, apparently, the flu vaccine isn’t as effective as health officials and physicians would like. How could this have happened?
Those of you who are knowledgeable about the flu vaccine know that, as useful as it is, it’s not one of the greatest vaccines as far as effectiveness. Actually, that’s not true. Its effectiveness can and does vary considerably from year to year. The reason is simple. There are many strains of influenza, and the vaccine as currently formulated generally only covers a handful of strains. Basically, every year the World Health Organization, in collaboration with the CDC and other health organizations throughout the world, has to make an educated guess which strains of influenza will be circulating the following winter. Many months’ lead time is required because vaccine manufacturers require it to develop and test the new formulations and then to ramp up their manufacturing capabilities and distribute the vaccine. Generally, the WHO chooses the three strains it deems most likely to cause significant human suffering and death in the coming flu season. Specifically, the chosen strains are the H1N1, H3N2, and Type-B, although, starting with the 2012–2013 Northern Hemisphere influenza season, the WHO has also recommended a second B-strain for use in quadrivalent (four strain) vaccines. Basically, the WHO coordinates the contents of the vaccine each year to contain the most likely strains of the virus to attack the next year. Wikipedia has a helpful article that lists the formulations of all the flu vaccines recommended for the Northern and Southern Hemispheres dating back to 1998, to give you an idea what’s been recommended in the past. Also, there are exceptions. In the 2009-2010 season, for example, the H1N1 pandemic was occurring, and it was recommended that everyone be vaccinated against H1N1 in addition to the normal flu vaccine.
As you can imagine, predicting many months in advance which strains will be circulating in the following flu season is a dicey proposition under the best of circumstances. When the WHO gets it right, the flu vaccine is maximally effective. When it doesn’t, we have a situation in which the vaccine is not as effective as we would like. As this news story relates:
Much of the influenza virus circulating in the United States has mutated and this year’s vaccine doesn’t provide good protection against it, federal health officials are warning.
Flu season’s barely starting, but most cases are being caused by a strain called H3N2 this year, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said in a health warning issued to doctors Wednesday night.
The flu vaccine protects against three or four strains of flu — there’s always a mix of flu viruses going around — and H3N2 is one of them. But the strain of H3N2 infecting most people has mutated and only about half of cases match the vaccine, CDC said.
Basically, all the news stories to which I linked above report the issue in a similar way. One of the major strains in the vaccine is H3N2, a strain that normally circulates in pigs and can cause serious outbreaks. Unfortunately, based on its initial observations and data collection, the CDC has concluded that the H3N2 strain that’s causing most of the disease has undergone what is referred to as “genetic drift,” changes in the genetic makeup of the virus that make them different from the strain used many months ago to determine the recommended formulation. Personally, when I see stories like this, I like to go to the source. When the story is about a scientific study, that source is the original peer-reviewed scientific article. When it’s about something like this, the source is the CDC press release:
So far this year, seasonal influenza A H3N2 viruses have been most common. There often are more severe flu illnesses, hospitalizations, and deaths during seasons when these viruses predominate. For example, H3N2 viruses were predominant during the 2012-2013, 2007-2008, and 2003-2004 seasons, the three seasons with the highest mortality levels in the past decade. All were characterized as “moderately severe.”
Increasing the risk of a severe flu season is the finding that roughly half of the H3N2 viruses analyzed are drift variants: viruses with antigenic or genetic changes that make them different from that season’s vaccine virus. This means the vaccine’s ability to protect against those viruses may be reduced, although vaccinated people may have a milder illness if they do become infected. During the 2007-2008 flu season, the predominant H3N2 virus was a drift variant yet the vaccine had an overall efficacy of 37 percent and 42 percent against H3N2 viruses.
“It’s too early to say for sure that this will be a severe flu season, but Americans should be prepared,” said CDC director Tom Frieden, M.D., M.P.H. “We can save lives with a three-pronged effort to fight the flu: vaccination, prompt treatment for people at high risk of complications, and preventive health measures, such as staying home when you’re sick, to reduce flu spread.”
I can see what’s coming. In fact, I’m very surprised that, as I write this, it hasn’t come already. If there’s one vaccine that antivaccinationists love to hate, it’s the flu vaccine, because, compared to other vaccines, it’s the easiest target, given that it tends not to be as efficacious as many other vaccines. Heck, it’s the vaccine that Bill Maher likes to hate on (or at least show contempt for). Contrary to what antivaccinationists and cranks like Bill Maher would have you believe, the flu vaccine is not dangerous, and it does work. It might not work as well as some vaccines, and, until a universal flu vaccine is developed that targets antigens common to all strains of flu is developed, it never will be. But it’s still worth getting.
No, the flu vaccine is not worthless, but you know that hysterical antivaccine articles claiming that to be the case are coming.
For completeness’ sake, I’ll just mention that the quadrivalent flu vaccine for the 2014-2015 flu season is targeted to these strains:
    • A/California/7/2009 (H1N1)pdm09-like virus
    • A/Texas/50/2012 (H3N2)-like virus
    • B/Massachusetts/2/2012-like virus.
    • BBrisbane/60/2008-like virus (only included in some vaccines)
As this story on how this happened relates:
Since Oct. 1, 82% of the influenza virus samples subjected to laboratory testing have been H3N2 viruses, according to data from the CDC. And only 48% of these samples are closely related to the A/Texas/50/2012 strain that was picked for the flu vaccine distributed in North America.
Most of the rest of the H3N2 samples were similar to another strain called A/Switzerland/9715293. That strain was picked for the flu vaccine for the Southern Hemisphere, but not the one here.
Unfortunately, although the “drifted” (as in genetic drift) A/Switzerland/9715293-like strains were detected in late March 2014, which was after the World Health Organization (WHO) recommendations for the 2014-2015 Northern Hemisphere vaccine had been made in mid-February, their prevalence increased enormously by September, by which time it was far too late to revise this year’s flu vaccine formulation for the Northern hemisphere:
Health experts charged with monitoring flu viruses first detected strains of the A/Switzerland virus in the U.S. in March, Frieden said. By then, “it was already too late to include them in this season’s vaccine,” he said.
Besides, at that time, the A/Texas strains were still “by far the most common of the H3N2 viruses,” he said. The A/Switzerland strains didn’t appear in large numbers until September, he said.
Twice each year, the World Health Organization issues a recommendation for a flu vaccine — one for the Southern Hemisphere and one for the Northern Hemisphere. This approach gives health planners two opportunities to plan a vaccine.
Putting it all together, what this means is that the remaining 18% plus the remaining 48% of the H3N2 strains that are close matches to the vaccine H3N2 strain (0.48 x 0.82 = 0.39 or 39%), for a total of 57% constitute a good match for what’s out there. How did this happen this year? The same way it happens on any year when the flu vaccine isn’t as good a match as we would like to the strains circulating: Health officials made the best prediction they could at the time, but the virus changed in the six or seven months between when they had to commit to a formulation of the flu vaccine and the start of the flu season.
Another aspect of this is that it is likely that the H3N2 component of this year’s flu vaccine is still good enough to confer partial immunity to the A/Switzerland/9715293-like strains, so that, while it doesn’t protect against becoming sick by these strains it could make the illness less severe. This is important because the H3N2 strains tend to be associated with severe flu seasons.
Surprisingly, as I write this, the antivaccine crank blog Age of Autism has published only one brief mention of this news story in a link roundup and no characteristic screed about how this means that the flu vaccine is “worthless.” On the other hand, not surprisingly, everyone’s favorite quack, antivaccinationist (but I repeat myself), and all-purpose conspiracy theorist, Mike Adams, has weighted in under a rather restrained (for him) title, “CDC issues flu vaccine apology: this year’s vaccine doesn’t work!“, complete with a link to this video:
Contrary to what Gary Franchi of NextNewsNetwork claims, it should be emphasize that, no, the CDC did not just “apologize” and “admit” that the flu vaccine doesn’t work. It really didn’t. It just said that we can expect it to be less effective this year because it’s not as good a match as we would like. What’s with this concrete thinking among quacks? It’s the Nirvana fallacy in action: If a “Western” medical intervention isn’t 100% effective, to them it must obviously be pure, dangerous crap. Funny how they don’t apply that standard to the woo they normally like to pedal. On second thought, no it isn’t.
But back to Adams. Hilariously, after touting a “story” from a crank news source and criticizing the CDC for supposedly producing a defective vaccine and then using its ineffectiveness to sell help drug companies sell Tamiflu at a high cost, Adams pivots to promoting his own execrable science. Truly the man is without self-awareness:
Mercury tests conducted on vaccines at the Natural News Forensic Food Lab have revealed a shockingly high level of toxic mercury in an influenza vaccine (flu shot) made by GlaxoSmithKline (lot #9H2GX). Tests conducted via ICP-MS document mercury in the Flulaval vaccine at a shocking 51 parts per million, or over 25,000 times higher than the maximum contaminant level of inorganic mercury in drinking water set by the EPA.(1)
The tests were conducted via ICP-MS using a 4-point mercury calibration curve for accuracy. Even then, the extremely high level of mercury found in this flu shot was higher than anything we’ve ever tested, including tuna and ocean fish which are known for high mercury contamination.
In fact, the concentration of mercury found in this GSK flu shot was 100 times higher than the highest level of mercury we’ve ever tested in contaminated fish. And yet vaccines are injected directly into the body, making them many times more toxic than anything ingested orally. As my previous research into foods has already documented, mercury consumed orally is easily blocked by eating common foods like strawberries or peanut butter, both of which bind with and capture about 90% of dietary mercury.
This was, of course, one of the silliest things Adams ever did with his new toy (his mass spectrometer). If you don’t believe me, you should read why in detail here.
Adams then goes on to tick off a litany of antivaccine tropes, using a typical antivaccine technique known as “argument by package insert.” The central fallacy of such an argument is that package inserts are legal documents, not so much scientific documents, and are thus hyper-conservative in listing any reaction that’s ever been reported after a drug or vaccine, whether there is good scientific reason to believe that reaction is due to the vaccine or drug or not. He trots out the old claimed link with Guillain-Barre syndrome that is almost certainly not real. He even trots out the formaldehyde and toxin gambit!
It all builds up to a crescendo of Mike Adams’ spittle-flecked invective belied by the relatively tame (for him) title of his post:
Trusting a flu shot made by a corporation of felons is a lot like trusting the purity of heroin you buy from a street dealer. Both flu shots and street heroin have at least one thing in common, by the way: neither has ever been tested for safety.
We also know that flu shots contain neurotoxic chemicals and heavy metals in alarming concentrations. This is irrefutable scientific fact. We also know that there is no “safe” form of mercury just like there is no safe form of heroin — all forms of mercury are highly toxic when injected into the body (ethyl, methyl, organic, inorganic).
The only people who argue with this are those who are already mercury poisoned and thus incapable of rational thought. Mercury damages brain function, you see, which is exactly what causes some people to be tricked into thinking vaccines are safe and effective.
Technically, you’d have to be stupid to believe such a thing, as the vaccine insert directly tells you precisely the opposite.
At least Adams always entertains. No one can quite reach the level of ranting faux outrage with such hyperbole, with the possible exception of his mentor Alex Jones. But notice his not-so-subtle sucking up to his audience. Adams (and, by extension, those who believe him) are not “sheeple”! They’re not “brain-damaged” by mercury! Oh, no! Only they understand and avoid the evil pharma cabal. Everyone else is a mercury-damaged sheeple lining up placidly to receive more poison. (Look for some antivaccine activist to quote mine that last sentence.) Meanwhile, elsewhere, another antivaccine rant, “Flu Shot Fail: Vaccine Chiefs Forced to Admit it Won’t Work“, even tries to paint a blog post by a certain friend of this blog as “feverish attempts by pro-pharma internet gatekeepers to save the flu shot’s sinking reputation.”
It’s good to be recognized, isn’t it?
This year’s flu vaccine might well be suboptimal. Unfortunately, until there is a universal vaccine that targets the parts of the virus that don’t mutate so rapidly, the flu vaccine will always be suboptimal. Of course, companies and scientists are frantically working on just such a vaccine. If it weren’t so incredibly hard to do, they would have produced one already. In the meantime the flu vaccine, as imperfect as it is, is the best we have, and it is still very much worth receiving because the flu still can kill healthy individuals.

One Flu Into the Cuckoo’s Nest
Mark Crislip on January 25, 2013
Link
“I don’t seem able to get it straight in my mind….”― Ken Kesey, One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest
Influenza is going gangbusters at the moment. I like going to Google Flu trends as well as the CDC flu site to see what flu is doing. Using Google searches as a surrogate for infections is an interesting technique that public health officials have tried with less success in other illnesses but is not without utility. Behaviors of populations can presage a problem, my favorite example is the first hint of the 1993 massive Cryptosporidia diarrhea outbreak in Milwaukee was a sudden shortage of Kaopectate and Peptobismol. It appears there are more patients with flu like symptoms this year than at the height of the H1N1 epidemic of 2009. We have lots of flu like illness, and per the CDC there are buckets of confirmed influenzaflu, but so far the season, while probably having more cases than 2009, the outbreak is clinically not the same.
Compare and contrast, the two words that defined undergraduate liberal arts essay assignments. Get out your blue books and compare and contrast influenza outbreaks from 2009 and 2013. You have one hour.
The H1N1 epidemic was due to, well, influenza A H1N1. Only about 1% of the isolates are currently H1N1, so presumptively almost everyone is immune from prior infection or vaccination. That is what probably ends most epidemics: the herd has immunity and the virus can not longer spread in a population and the virus has to go into hiding in swine populations, biding its time until the population, and genetic shift, render the population susceptible again.
This season it is influenza A H3N2 and influenza B that are causing most of the disease. A lot of disease. Emergency rooms are seeing an increase influenza like illness and it is often caused by influenza. In my hospitals specimens positive for influenza jumped from 2% of submitted specimens to 26% positive and we are almost out of influenza PCR assay kits.
Despite the increase in cases, it is remarkable for what we are not seeing. While people are being admitted to the hospital with flu, and deaths are now increasing, unlike the H1N1 epidemic, the ICU is not filled with influenza patients on a ventilator.
The most remarkable aspect of the 2009 outbreak was how lucky we were. It still amazes me. We were maxed out in every ICU in my system. All ICU beds and ventilators were in use. If a patient came through the door needing a ventilator, we did not have one to offer. Someone was going to die we might have otherwise saved. And right as we reached our surge capacity, the epidemic peaked. No patients came in needing a ventilator for flu. Dodged that bullet.
This year we have had only a smattering of patients on a ventilator from influenza, no young people dying (20-30 year olds, there have been at least 20 pediatric deaths so far), no flu encephalitis (we had two deaths from CNS involvement in young people), no one on ECMO from influenza induced lung failure, no pregnant females with advanced influenza. Lots of morbidity, but different than 2009, milder than 2009. But it is still early in the season.
It is curious how the strains differ in their effects on populations. Maybe the H1N1 has modified the disease for H3N2, since infection and vaccination to H1N1 in some people can result in a more ‘universal’ antibody against flu. Immunity to influenza flu is not as simple as one antibody against one strain, since for the hemagglutinin and neuraminidase proteins there are multiple areas that can generate an antibody response. Some of these sites are variable and differ every year but some are conserved. If you are lucky enough to develop antibody against conserved regions you could potentially be immune to all influenza A. Or probably there are other factors with the H3N2 virus that result in different clinical manifestations. We will likely know is a year or two after the researchers have their opportunity to investigate the current flu season.
I would expect increased mortality this year from flu and I hope to be wrong:
The magnitude of the seasonal component was highly correlated with traditional measures of excess mortality and was significantly larger in seasons dominated by influenza A(H2N2) and A(H3N2) viruses than in seasons dominated by A(H1N1) or B viruses.
But not only from infection but from an increase in cardiac events:
These data suggest that influenza infections, particularly by A/H3N2 viruses, are directly associated with acute IHD-related events in older individuals.
At the moment it looks like we are having widespread flu and flu like illness but with less severe morbidity and less mortality. Of course, I speak from the perspective of a hospital based doctor in Portland Oregon, and as such have a narrow and probably not representative experience. Everything is always better in Portland. It will be interesting for someone with access to all the data to compare and contrast the two flu seasons in the years to come.
The one consistent question I get about the flu vaccine is “Does it work?”
Do not ask me that question if you don’t have at least 10 minutes to kill, because the answer is not yes or no. For some vaccines it is a binary answer and people like binary answers. Yes or no. Good or bad. I get the suspicion that those in the SCAM reality greatly prefer simple binary answers and do not deal will with uncertainty, spectrum and gradients of answers. Perhaps that is their defining characteristic. SCAM proponents seem to like black and white in a world of grey. Does the tetanus vaccine work? Yep. Everyone who gets the vaccine is protected from tetanus. Doe the influenza vaccine work? It depends on who is vaccinated, which vaccine, what the circulating strains are and how well the vaccine matches and what your end point for defining ‘works’ is.
Influenza is complex.
There is an interesting issue in medicine that is usually not explicitly discussed but comes up obliquely in the concept of number needed to treat. Sometimes, like pneumonia, we are treating an individual. Or the tetanus vaccine, where we are preventing an illness in an individual. Much of the time with prevention we are not only treating the individual but also populations. It is an interesting issue: applying population data to individuals. A given individual may gain no benefit from statins or the flu vaccine, whereas populations of often do.
That is one of the strengths and a public relations weakness of modern medicine. Ignoring the individual and treating populations in some circumstances can lead to marked improvement in every ones health, the ‘old rising tide lifts all boats’ approach to public health medicine. And people loathe not being considered a unique and special entity. Influenza vaccination is both a intervention for individual AND populations, since as the Googleflu trends graphs nicely demonstrate, influenza like illnesses affect populations and do so with remarkable rapidly. Look at the slope of those curves. They are almost vertical. I mean, whoa. That’s communicable.
Unlike other respiratory viruses, influenza can kill, directly and indirectly. So while there are 200 causes of flu like illnesses, influenza is unique in its ability to routinely cause severe morbidity and mortality. My ICUs do not fill up with rhinovirus and metapneumovirus infections and their complications.
So with influenza vaccination efficacy you can have a narrow perspective: does it prevent influenza in an individual (sometimes) or does it have more widespread population effects. The problem with the other benefits to vaccination it is like the dog that doesn’t bark.
Gregory (Scotland Yard detective): “Is there any other point to which you would wish to draw my attention?”Holmes: “To the curious incident of the dog in the night-time.”Gregory: “The dog did nothing in the night-time.”Holmes: “That was the curious incident.”
In part I do infection control for a living and we are successful when nothing happens, but people do not notice when nothing occurs, and I have to point out the benefits of events not happening. Potential benefits of flu vaccination include:
    • I don’t influenza.
    • I don’t get influenza and therefore don’t give it my Grandmother.
    • I don’t get the flu and do not pass it on to my hospitalized patient, who tend to die from nosocomial influenza.
    • I get influenza, but it is milder and I miss less work.
    • I get influenza and because it is milder and less infectious I don’t give it to my Grandmother.
    • Because my Grandmother doesn’t get influenza she does not have an exacerbation of her heart failure, diabetes, COPD etc.
    • My grandmother doesn’t get the flu and as a result doesn’t have a secondary myocardial infarction or bacterial pneumonia and is not hospitalized and doesn’t die as a result.
    • My pregnant wife doesn’t get the flu (from me or due to vaccination) and as such does not have miscarriage or is not admitted to the hospital with ARDS from influenza.
    • My obese Uncle doesn’t get the flu (from me or due to vaccination) and is not admitted with ARDS from influenza.
I have discussed flu vaccination multiple times in the blog. The question is not IF influenza vaccination works. It does. It is the magnitude of the effect and in what populations it is effective that is the question. The preponderance of information suggests the for most of the endpoints above, the influenza vaccine has beneficial effects. It’s not a great vaccine but better than nothing.
Then there is the political issue as to whether the bang is worth the buck, whether the benefits of pushing flu vaccines are worth the time and resources. That is a calculus that I am not capable of independently deriving, my sense is the answer is yes, and those with more expertise in these areas than I say influenza vaccination is cost effective.
One aspect of the flu season does not change from year to year is the anti-vaccine crowd, who continue to repeat the same half truths and misrepresentations. As I keep mentioning, they live in an alternative universe having quantum jumped into a part of the multiverse where my standards of reality need not apply.
Perhaps the highest profile critic of the influenza vaccine is Dr. Thomas Jefferson of the Cochrane Group. He generally takes the narrow perspective on the efficacy of the flu vaccine, that of preventing a case of influenza in an exposed individual and argues that the clinical trials that demonstrate efficacy are too flawed to make recommendations. I have begged to differ.
Dr. Jefferson was interviewed for Gary Null’s radio show, and I have taken the time to make a transcript of the interview. It makes for an interesting read, and I used the opportunity to add some annotations.
A couple of caveats. First, spoken language is most certainly not written language and I have omitted some the false starts and stumbles. The typo master (me) can hardly complain about others errors. The few times I have been interviewed I have greatly appreciated the editing that made me appear more fluent than I actually am. Speaking coherently about complex topics extemporaneously is difficult and an ability that neither Dr. Jefferson nor Mr. Null have apparently mastered.
I would wonder why Dr. Jefferson would choose appear to be on this podcast, since Mr. Null has been so against flu vaccination in the past he has sued to prevent the distribution of H1N1 vaccine. Mr. Null is a proponet of alternative medicines for cancer and HIV denialism. I suppose an Englishman living in Rome cannot be expected to know who Mr. Null is and what is approach to medical care might be, although a little Google searching quickly finds that Mr Null is the antithesis of everything science based medicine supports. And my Dad taught me early that you can judge a man by the company he keeps. Still, guilt by association is not the most reliable way to analyze an intellectual position. It is better to evaluate what they say in their own words (Or really close. I am no transcriptionist, but I think I got it right. Double question marks (??) were words I could not understand). [My annotations are in square brackets]:
Null: Lets Begin by saying hello to Dr. Thomas Jefferson. Nice to have to with us here today Dr. Jefferson.
Jefferson: Hello Gary.
Null: Hi. Dr. Jefferson is a former primary care physician from the UK who is now a leading investigator for the Infectious Disease research at the Cochrane Database Collaboration in Rome and he is the editor of their acute respiratory infection group and been the coordinator of the vaccine field which reviews existing peer reviews vaccine research which determines the accuracy and validity of scientific methodology used and the claims being made. And he was also an editorial board member of the Journal Vaccine and uh…Dr. Jefferson, our biggest concern today is that we have been led to believe that everyone beyond the age of 6 months should have a flu vaccination. We have been told that these vaccines are safe and effective for everyone. The we have an honest look at the literature. Here’s my question.
Can we say with certainly, based on good science, independent science, and a gold standard that it would include safety and efficacy for pregnant women, for women who might be taking chemotherapy,
[Patient with cancer and/or on chemotherapy can get a reasonable serologic response to the vaccine, although there are no studies of clinical efficacy. We do extrapolate from healthy populations to less healthy populations with vaccines. A reasonable approach, but not always reliable. Most of the time if you develop an immune response to a pathogen there will be some degree of resistance to that infection, but not always. As in all the clinical subsets mentioned by Mr. Null, the best approach is for their family caretakers to be immune and not pass on the virus to those at risk.]
or maybe on heart medication or statins,
[Probably a key population to get vaccinated, since influenza, especially the H3 strains, increase the risk for heart attack and vaccination can likely prevent influenza related myocardial infarctions.]
or impaired immune systems, or people on antipsychotic or antidepression medications, or the old, or people who are senior citizens in nursing homes, in hospices in hospitals, people who are suffering from diabetes and are on medications, can we say that all those people will be safe and actually find efficacy and prevent the flu vaccine.
[The biggest issue with those mentioned is the ongoing problem that those who need protection from influenza vaccination are those who will respond least to the vaccine. From a public health perspective, the best approach to preventing influenza would be to vaccinate the healthy population that serves as the vector for infection. As an example, use of the pneumococcal vaccine in children led to a marked decrease in invasive disease in adults and some modeling suggests that schools are the epicenter for spread of influenza epidemics. So an important question when discussing flu vaccination efficacy is individual goals or population goals. To paint with a broad brush, those in the anti-vaccine camp have little interest in the concept of helping others through the safe and modestly effective intervention of influenza vaccination.]
That’s what we’ve been told. And I want to know because you have taken the time to look for the truth.
Jefferson: Thank you very much for hosting me on your show Gary. You’ve asked me about 15 questions in one, so let me just start from the first one on pregnant women. When you are talking about pregnant women you are of course not just talking about pregnant women but you are talking about a pregnant woman and the fetus, the unborn baby. Now a pregnancy woman is a healthy adult despite desperate attempts at transforming pregnancy into a deadly disease.
[Pregnancy is a weird state. It is normal but it has the potential for complications and is somewhat immunosuppressive. While no one thinks pregnancy is a deadly disease, maternal death is common in the developing world. It is estimated to have killed 1 in 100 before the 20th century and worldwide currently kills about 24/100,000. Pregnancy is usually safe in the West, but not always. What you can say about influenza and pregnancy is that pregnant women are more likely to die if they get influenza and they are more likely to miscarry if they get the influenza. It it estimated that 1:10 first trimester pregnancies were lost during the 1919 pandemic. Babies born during flu epidemics are more like to be smaller and have lower lifetime earning potential. Smaller babies from influenza are perhaps stupider babies. Vaccination not only prevents influenza (and by extension death) in the mother but also prevents miscarriage. Vaccinated mothers are less likely to give influenza to their newborns. As to safety, no problems for mother or fetus have yet been discovered. The miniscule amount of antigen in the vaccine appear to have no adverse effects on either the mother or the baby and would be dwarfed by the massive amount of viral antigen exposure as well as exposure to the adverse effects of the inflammatory response from wild influenza. None of these studies probably meet the standards demanded by Dr. Jefferson, but it is difficult to ignore such a preponderance of data.]
Pregnancy is part of… is a physiological state. It is the reason why our race is still on the planet. So there is nothing wrong with pregnancy. That is, it is normal.
[And potentially filled with influenza related complications.]
Pregnancy women therefore are healthy adults and we do know what the performance of the inactivated influenza vaccine is in healthy adults because there are quite a number of trials, clinical trials, that’s experiments, we summarize them, and to give you some idea, we need to vaccinate about 33 to 99 people to avoid one set of influenza symptoms.
[Again, the narrow perspective: maternal death, spontaneous abortion, smaller birth babies, post partum influenza in the newborn are additional worries and the data strongly points to benefit from vaccination. If you fail to consider the preponderance of information and the multitudinous effects of both influenza and vaccination, you do the whole topic a major, and distorted, disservice. But that is Dr. Jeffersons modus operandi: frame the discussion narrowly, minimize the problems and ignore the numerous co-morbidities of influenza:
“Another consequence is the idea that influenza-line illness (“flu”) and its ravages can be prevented or minimised with influenza vaccines. Cochrane reviews show that vaccines could only affect at the most (i. e. if they had 100% efficacy) some 7-15% of the annual flu burden, since this is the proportion of people with the flu who truly have influenza. This “specificity” of approach (go for influenza, disregard all other causes of the flu) is probably based on what I call availability creep (let’s concentrate on influenza because that’s the one we have specifics for). But, if you think about it, it is a wonderful utopian policy against a syndrome as unspecific as this (just think of the role that other viruses play). In my opinion, the lack of logic in this thinking is stunning (7).”
So disingenuous. We use flu like illness as a surrogate since it is not practical to test everyone for influenza. Given that “worldwide, these annual epidemics result in about three to five million cases of severe illness, and about 250 000 to 500 000 deaths.” Whittling 10% off that number, in addition to the effects on pregnancy, cardiovascular disease and productivity lost, seems a reasonable goal. We go after influenza because of all the complications associated with the illness in addition to the almost unique morbidity and mortality the primary infection can cause. We fret as historically influenza epidemics have killed millions and we do not want a repeat of 1919. Influenza often is so much more than a flu like illness.]
The harm side, the safety side, is understudied.
[Although numerous studies in a huge number of patients with a wide variety of underlying medical issues fail to reveal any consistant important or unusual complications of the vaccine and the disease is always worse than the vaccine.]
It’s very difficult to actually give you an accurate breakdown of the potential risk of the vaccine.
[Because it you stick to the plausible risks of vaccination based on plausible physiology there are not many. If you include being hit by asteroids as a potential risk, then it is hard to give an accurate breakdown. After decades of giving the vaccine there are not any major risks, especially compared to the real and well documented risks of influenza. It is always about relative risks and benefits. The vaccine is safer by many orders of magnitude than the disease.]
There is the potential risk to the mother, there is the potential risk to the unborn baby, there is the potential risk… the certain risk to the taxpayer. And that is something else that should not be forgotten.
[One gets the feeling from his tone that this really fries his bacon, spending HIS money on other peoples health care.]
There are very very few studies on pregnancy women and none of them are high quality.
[But all show benefit and no risk.]
So I was taught at medical school the less you do to pregnant women the better it is.
[That is such a disingenuous use of the naturalistic fallacy it makes my teeth hurt. The reason we do not have maternal death rates of sub Saharan Africa (as high as 1100/100,000 live birth), where they really do the less is better approach, is the multiple interventions to and for the mother and baby.]
This of course goes contrary to modern medicine.
[Yeah, lets go deliver out children in the third world.]
if you like which is more and more interventional, and more and more preventive between inverted commas (ed: I believe he was making air quotes).
As far as effects on the fetus are concerned of the vaccine, the second person, which is involved in this equation, I would be very very cautious, about vaccinating unborn babies even with dead vaccines like these ones.
[Despite all the data to show benefit? Sure, the data isn’t perfect, but hard to kill a few babies and mothers for the sake of a perfect study.]
Of course live vaccines are out of the question for an unborn baby.
[That is the closest he gets to a declarative sentence. As I read the interview over and over, I realized he insinuates a lot, but maintains deniability. He never actually says don’t get the flu vaccine. I wonder in passing if he ever gets the vaccine. Although what little data there is suggests the live vaccine is safe for the fetus. <sarc>And wild influenza virus is so much better for mother and child</sarc>.]
Does that answer your question?
Null: Yes. Is it also the case when they are testing a vaccine should they also not have pregnant women and all the women with different diseases that would be required to take the vaccine included in the vaccine studies since when I read the literature I saw they were excluding the very people who would later be included in using it, to me that is a contradiction.
Jefferson: It’s not, it doesn’t necessarily have to be a contradiction because experiments, trials are quite artificial, in the way they are carried out, seldom are carried out in a perfect experiment, and there lies, in there lies some of the weakness of, of the design, of that particular design of a study, in as much as the more you select of the population, the less the results are application to the real population, so called reference population.
[That is always the difficulty in medicine: how does the results of a clinical trial apply to the patient you are treating. When I was a resident it seemed that all the studies for cardiovascular disease were done on old white smoking veterans. There are innumerable variables in influenza vaccination: the variability of the virus, the variability in the vaccine, the patient co-morbidities and (probably) the genetic ability of the patient to respond to both the vaccine and wild type infection. Seems daunting and will allow you to continuously quibble about the applicability of the results of a given vaccine trial. On the other hand, generally speaking, exposure to antigen often leads to protective immunity most of the time in most people for most infections. It is more a matter of trying to maximize those effects in a heterogeneous population and why flu vaccination is better approached as a population effect than an individual effect.]
So some public health bodies have turned to commissioning what they call real life studies or studies on real life data. These are almost certainly observational studies, the vast majority observational studies. The difference between a trial and an observational study is that in a trial the researcher decides who gets the vaccine and who doesn’t or who gets the vaccine and who gets the control. In an observational study that decision has already been made. There observation study therefor is probably closer to reality. The only problem with that is the design itself is the carrier of problems. It is very very difficult to have good well designed prospective observational studies, and we do know that studies carried out in the United States in the 90’s, huge database studies, which showed the influenza vaccines effect were so biased as to give the wrong answer, to give an answer which was completely implausible
[I am not certain what he is referring to here. The protection of the vaccine from mortality when there is no flu circulating? I am suspicious that may be due to the reduction in deaths that follow any infection. Patients who are hospitalized for infections have a higher post discharge mortality rate than those who are admitted without infections and all infections seem to lead to an increase in MI, PE or stroke that risk can persist for months after the infection. I wonder if that implausible effects of the flu vaccine are due to the lack of subsequent vascular events associated many infections.
Or he could be referring to the decrease in death from all causes but in that article, which he alludes to in other interviews, the definition of all cause mortality is not stated. Since the cause of death is not certain it is difficult to say of it was implausible or not. Interesting is a better term and given the widespread morbidities from influenza worthy of investigation.]
So we have to be very careful.
In general the answer is that we have to design better trials prospectively and enrolling significant populations, but these trials cost money and of course you have the problem that as the decisions have already been made, on evidence which is of very low quality, what bodies like CDC say is unethical to carry out trials now
[While placebo trials are not ethical in the US, it doesn’t prevent interesting comparisons of vaccinated and unvaccinated populations, while not randomized or placebo controlled, efficacy with huge populations vaccinated and unvaccinated have been compared with good results:
“From 245 schools, 25,037 students participated in the mass vaccination and 244,091 did not. During the period from October 9 through November 15, 2009, the incidence of confirmed cases of 2009 H1N1 virus infection per 100,000 students was 35.9 (9 of 25,037) among vaccinated students and 281.4 (687 of 244,091) among unvaccinated students. Thus, the estimated vaccine effectiveness was 87.3% (95% confidence interval, 75.4 to 93.4).”
By no means a perfect study, but it demonstrates good vaccine efficacy in a healthy population with a good vaccine-disease match. I might add with no GBS in the vaccine group and who were unlikely too pass the flu along to their 50,000 parents and 100,000 grandparents.]
Null: How do we actually know, unless we have two groups of people, lets say 5000 people who have not had the vaccine and 5000 cross matched who do have the vaccine and then do regular work up on them to see whether there is really efficacy because rarely to they use a non vaccinated group against a vaccinated group. More often than not they use one vaccine against another and they often say it’s a placebo and then we find out that the placebo was not a sugar pill, there was actually active ingredients in the placebo and yet you wouldn’t have known that from your physician or nurse or hospital or pharmacist or the CDC or the FDA. Its only when you take away all of the promotion and you look at the actual hard beginning data that there are these flaws and most people are not aware that these flaws exist, your thoughts?
Jefferson: Well, I entirely agree.
[Agree with what? I have reread the question multiple times: “More often than not they use one vaccine against another and they often say it’s a placebo and then we find out that the placebo was not a sugar pill, there was actually active ingredients in the placebo and yet you wouldn’t have known that from your physician or nurse or hospital or pharmacist or the CDC or the FDA.” What is he talking about? And how would one entirely agree?]
We published in 2009 we published a review of 270 of these studies and we found that only 5% of these studies were reliable, had reliable design and were reliably carried out.
[But that doesn’t mean they are all worthless. Dr. Jefferson and Mr. Null talk as if clinical studies are either perfect and valid or imperfect and worthless. All or nothing. The medical literature has a spectrum of quality and just because the study is note perfect does not mean it is worthless. Every study needs to be evaluated on its strengths and weaknesses and in the context of the entire literature.
And the unstated assumption, with which at one time I would have agreed, is that bias due to poor methodology in studies will overestimate efficacy of interventions. Maybe not. One interesting model of flu vaccine suggests bias results in an underestimation of flu vaccine efficacy:
“We found an average difference between observed and true vaccine effectiveness of 211.9%. Observed vaccine effectiveness underestimated the true effectiveness in 88% of model iterations. Diagnostic test specificity exhibited the strongest association with observed vaccine effectiveness, followed by the likelihood of receiving a diagnostic test based on vaccination status and the likelihood that a child hospitalized with acute respiratory infection had influenza. Our findings suggest that the potential biases in case-control studies that we examined tend to result in underestimates of true influenza vaccine effects.”
It is a complicated literature.]
We also found that studies which had been funded by industry were more likely to be published on prestigious journals. That, for you listeners, means, cited more, and more in the public eye, compared to other studies which had not been funded by pharmaceutical industry. But these studies funded by the pharmaceutical industry of influenza vaccines were not better quality nor were they larger. So there must have been another reason why medical journals found them irresistible which had nothing to do with the design, or the results, or the size of the study.
[I find this intimation of a sinister reason for the difference disingenuous. I presume he is referring to his study where “Two reviewers, independently unblinded to the authors and institutions of the article, extracted data from the studies in three phases.”
Seriously. Readers working for someone with a long standing and well known antipathy towards influenza vaccination are expected to read papers and come up with unbiased summaries for their boss? Snort. The reviewers had plenty of opportunity to be biased in their interpretation of the studies.
Dr. Jefferson makes it sound like there are a selection of studies from which the editors choose, like a fish at Pike Street Market. Oh, I’ll take that study, that you very much. The important question is whether the articles were submitted and rejected based on funding or were the government sponsored trials only submitted to lower impact journals and the editors of the high impact journals never even had the opportunity to be bribed, er, I mean, reject them. We don’t know and for a someone whose complains about the conclusions of influenza vaccine literature because of sloppy methodology and overstated conclusions making an insinuation based on a sloppy study with poor methodology and overstated conclusions does not add to his credibility. Relation of study quality, concordance, take home message, funding, and impact in studies of influenza vaccines: systematic review nicely demonstrates that when there is an ax to grind how easy it is to give it a sharp edge with a touch of spin.
Dr. Jefferson does like to position himself as the rare pure soul in a sea of venality and corruption:
“Much has been said about the role of experts in advising policy makers on both seasonal and pandemic influenza. We know that some of them have been parsimonious with declaring their interests and their role as members of lobbying organizations which are financed by industry and some did not think it important to disclose pretty hefty industry funding of their institutions. We know that transparency is proably not taken very seriously by WHO. However, few people realize that even experts with no ties to industry or government civil servants have career motivations, especially if they make policy and evaluate its effects.
I’ll leave the description of how this works to Professor Philip Alcabes in his modern classic Dread: “We are supposed to be prepared for a pandemic of some kind of influenza because the flu watchers, the people who make a living out of studying the virus and who need to attract continued grant funding to keep studying it, must persuade the funding agencies of the urgency of fighting a coming plague”(15).
Before you start wondering how I can myself escape this kind of criticisms I would like to inform readers that 2 months before the hearing I circulated a note of activities and interests in which I disclose all that I can think are relevant to this debate. The note was sent to the Secreteriat and can be viewed by any member of the Commission. In addition I would like to remind you of what I have written and stated to the media countless times since 2004: beware of catastrophic predictions, stick to the scientific evidence: all the evidence, not just what supports your theories (16).”
Dr. Jefferson tends to torpedo the conclusions of his own work, taking modest efficacy of the flu vaccine and treatment in the Cochrane and other meta-analysis and making sure we know the glass is half empty, not half full. Much of what he has published demonstrates modest flu vaccine efficacy, although he does his very best to muddy the water:
Influenza vaccines are efficacious in preventing cases of influenza in children older than two years of age, but little evidence is available for children younger than two years of age…The review showed that reliable evidence on influenza vaccines is thin but there is evidence of widespread manipulation of conclusions and spurious notoriety of the studies.
[Attention. Attention. This is the Pot speaking. The Kettle is black. Not me. Just the Kettle. That is all.] 
The content and conclusions of this review should be interpreted in the light of this finding.
We identified one RCT assessing efficacy and effectiveness. Although this seemed to show an effect against influenza symptoms it was underpowered to detect any effect on complications (1348 participants). The remainder of our evidence base included non-RCTs. Due to the general low quality of non-RCTs and the likely presence of biases, which make interpretation of these data difficult and any firm conclusions potentially misleading, we were unable to reach clear conclusions about the effects of the vaccines in the elderly.
Influenza vaccines have a modest effect in reducing influenza symptoms and working days lost. There is no evidence that they affect complications, such as pneumonia, or transmission. WARNING: This review includes 15 out of 36 trials funded by industry (four had no funding declaration). An earlier systematic review of 274 influenza vaccine studies published up to 2007 found industry funded studies were published in more prestigious journals and cited more than other studies independently from methodological quality and size. Studies funded from public sources were significantly less likely to report conclusions favorable to the vaccines. The review showed that reliable evidence on influenza vaccines is thin but there is evidence of widespread manipulation of conclusions and spurious notoriety of the studies. The content and conclusions of this review should be interpreted in light of this finding.
Influenza vaccines (especially two-dose live attenuated vaccines) are efficacious in children older than 2 years. Efficacy and effectiveness of the vaccines differed strikingly. Only two small studies assessed the effects of influenza vaccines on hospital admissions and no studies assessed reductions in mortality, serious complications, and community transmission of influenza. If influenza immunization in children is to be recommended as public-health policy, large-scale studies assessing such important outcomes and undertaking direct comparisons of vaccines are urgently needed.
Amantadine prevented 23% of clinical influenza cases (95% confidence interval 11% to 34%), and 63% of serologically confirmed clinical influenza A cases (95% confidence interval 42% to 76%). Amantadine reduced duration of fever by one day (95% confidence interval 0.7 to 1.3). Rimantadine demonstrated comparable effectiveness, but there were fewer trials and the results for prevention were not statistically significant. Both amantadine and rimantadine induced significant gastrointestinal adverse effects. Adverse effects of the central nervous system and study withdrawals were significantly more common with amantadine than rimantadine. REVIEWER’S CONCLUSIONS: Amantadine and rimantadine have comparable effectiveness in the prevention and treatment of influenza A in healthy adults, although rimantadine induces fewer adverse effects than amantadine.
No effect was shown for specific outcomes: laboratory-proven influenza, pneumonia and death from pneumonia. An effect was shown for the non-specific outcomes of ILI, GP consultations for ILI and all-cause mortality in individuals >/= 60. These non-specific outcomes are difficult to interpret because ILI includes many pathogens, and winter influenza contributes < 10% to all-cause mortality in individuals >/= 60. The key interest is preventing laboratory-proven influenza in individuals >/= 60, pneumonia and deaths from pneumonia, and we cannot draw such conclusions. The identified studies are at high risk of bias. Some HCWs remain unvaccinated because they do not perceive risk, doubt vaccine efficacy and are concerned about side effects. This review did not find information on co-interventions with HCW vaccination: hand washing, face masks, early detection of laboratory-proven influenza, quarantine, avoiding admissions, anti-virals, and asking HCWs with ILI not to work. We conclude there is no evidence that vaccinating HCWs prevents influenza in elderly residents in LTCFs. High quality RCTs are required to avoid risks of bias in methodology and conduct, and to test these interventions in combination.
But remember, I have given up on the Cochrane Group, which recently gave us:
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2012 Sep 12;9 Acupuncture for mumps in children. He J, Zheng M, Zhang M, Jiang H.
Abstract BACKGROUND: Mumps is an acute, viral illness transmitted by respiratory droplets and saliva. A number of studies published in China have suggested that acupuncture is beneficial for children with mumps but the literature reporting the benefits or harms of acupuncture for mumps has not been systematically reviewed. OBJECTIVES: To determine the efficacy and safety of acupuncture for children with mumps. SEARCH METHODS: We searched CENTRAL (2012, Issue 4), MEDLINE (1950 to April week 4, 2012), EMBASE (1974 to May 2012), CINAHL (1981 to May 2012), AMED (1985 to May 2012), the Chinese BioMedicine Database (CBM) (1979 to May 2012), China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI) (1979 to May 2012), Chinese Technology Periodical Database (CTPD) (1989 to May 2012) and WANFANG database (1982 to May 2012). We also handsearched a number of journals (from first issue to current issue). SELECTION CRITERIA: We included randomised controlled trials comparing acupuncture with placebo acupuncture, no management, Chinese medication, Western medication or other treatments for mumps. Acupuncture included either traditional acupuncture or contemporary acupuncture, regardless of the source of stimulation (body, electro, scalp, fire, hand, fine needle, moxibustion). DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS: Two review authors independently extracted data and assessed the quality of included studies. We calculated risk ratios (RR) with their 95% confidence intervals (CI) for the effective percentage and standardised mean differences (SMD) with 95% CIs for the time to cure. MAIN RESULTS: Only one study with 239 participants met our inclusion criteria. There were a total of 120 participants in the acupuncture group, of which 106 recovered, with their temperature returning back to normal and no swelling or pain of the parotid gland; the condition of 14 participants improved, with a drop in temperature and alleviation of swelling or pain of the parotid gland. There were 119 participants in the Western medicine group, of which 56 recovered and the condition of 63 improved. The acupuncture group had a higher recovery rate than the control group. The relative RR of recovery was 1.88 (95% CI 1.53 to 2.30). However, the acupuncture group had a longer time to cure than the control group. The mean was 4.20 days and the standard deviation (SD) was 0.46 in the acupuncture group, while in the control group the mean was 3.78 days and the SD was 0.46.There was a potential risk of bias in the study because of low methodological quality. AUTHORS’ CONCLUSIONS: We could not reach any confident conclusions about the efficacy and safety of acupuncture based on one study. More high-quality research is needed.”
A meta-analysis on one study on an intervention of magic. Pu-lease. I think they are running out of topics to meta-analyze. Next they will do a meta-analysis and systematic review of the written content on cereal boxes. And this is from Dr. Jefferson’s Group, the Cochrane Acute Respiratory Infections Group. I know, guilt by association again.]
Null: Also, if there are almost 200 different infectious organism that can cause flu like symptoms, and there is no standardized testing and proper diagnosis for people when they go to the doctor or clinic to be treated for a flu like illness, then what are we to make of all the warnings given about the seriousness of a particular flu season and also the world health Organizations record at predicting which strains of flu should be used in a given years flu vaccine is rather dismal and then there are studies such as Danish study that those receiving a seasonal flu vaccine in 2009 were more likely to get infected with swine flu and Canadian studies by ?? and ?? seem to confirm this same finding. So even the predictions of the flu strains are frequently inaccurate and what good is the flu vaccine against other flu strains not in the formulation.
[It depends on what part of the flu antigens you develop a response to; as H1N1 demonstrated, some people may develop universal antibody. I feel great sympathy for Public Health officials as they cannot win. Influenza is impossible to predict correctly. If the season is bad and they don’t call it in advance or of the season is bad and they predict a mild season, they are criticized. At least the CDC is not in Italy.]
Jefferson: The trademark of influenza and all acute respiratory infections, lets call it influenza like illness, is its unpredictably. That’s where the name comes from: it comes from the (??), which is Italian for influence of the planets.
[Ruh-Roh. The use of word origin is always a diagnostic clue. I am surprised he did not call flu a dis-ease.]
Because in the middle ages they could not understand why these local epidemics came and went. Mainly benign, they are self limiting, they last a few days, and they are unpredictable.
[My understanding is that influenza was particularly bad in the era of poor nutrition and hygiene; its English name was the “gasping oppression” with cough, fever, and a sensation of constriction of the heart and lungs began to rage, seemingly everywhere at once” and was not so mild:
To observers later in the 16th century, influenza came to be recognized as a distinct disease with consistent clinical features including acute onset of fever, headache, cough, and myalgia, with uncommon complications that included pneumonia and fatal outcomes in pregnant women and their fetuses, in infants and young children, and in the old and debilitated. Its epidemiologic featureswere understood to include explosive spread with high attack rates and directional movement along travel or trade routes, prevalence in a town or city for no more than 4–6 weeks, appearance at unpredictable intervals and at any time of year (influenza was frequent in the summer months until the 19th century 8]), and low-to-moderate population mortality.]
There is a very very long and complex literature reporting, for instance, what happened in the year of the French Revolution, which I believe was also the year of the inauguration of George Washington, in 1789. There were two outbreaks, one on the East coast and one on the West coast, which happened almost synchronously, like springing out mushrooms, and you can’t blame that on air travel.
[Almost only counts for horse shoes and hand grenades. Although I can find no specific information on the start of the 1789 epidemic in the US, it appears it started in the East Coast and then hit the West by way of the Caribbean and Central America. Flu does travel fast, the 1919 pandemic went around the world three time in one year, long before jet travel.]
It appears that (??) in 1789 there was no air travel.
[And there was air travel: birds. There is always the worry that avian flu will get here in a migratory bird, although an unlikely event.
“The genetic elements of influenza A viruses circulate globally in an extensive ecosystem comprised of many avian and mammalian species and a spectrum of environments. Unstable gene constellations found in avian species become stable viruses only upon switching to secondary hosts, but may then adapt and circulate independently. It may be desirable to think of influenza A viruses as existing and evolving in a large ecosystem involving multiple hosts and environments. Implications for understanding human influenza are discussed.” ]
It is an understudied, the real science behind this is understudied. It is covered in dogma, it is covered in public health marketing, and it is covered really in poor science as you pointed out. Very difficult to find good quality research in this area. It is not an easy area to research of course.
[I don’t really know what area he is talking about here. Flu spread? Vaccines? What does dogma have to do with 1789 flu outbreak? Public health marketing? It really gripes my cookies how he dismisses an enormous number of hard working professionals whose main goal is to prevent as many people as possible from dying from influenza and other diseases and an equally enormous supporting literature as dogma marketing. But Dr. Jefferson knows better.]
And the influenza vaccine mutates its coat, changes its coat very frequently, so it’s a, it’s a running target, the (??) influenza virus. It’s a running target, it changes. And you are quite right, clinically it is impossible to tell an influenza like illness, what you call the flu, caused by influenza virus from that caused by any of the other agents.
Bear in mind Gary that some studies show that almost 40% of these episodes have no recognizable cause.
[So? What does that have to do with flu vaccine efficacy.]
So that may mean they are caused by microorganisms which we cannot culture, which we cannot grow, or we cannot recognize, or are unknown, or they may not even be infectious, they may be stress related,
[Stress causing fevers to 104, severe myalgias, headache, intractable cough and shortness of breath?!?!?!?!? Glad he is not my GP.]
so it is a completely understudied area. The good science of it. The bad science part, well there’s tonnes of bad studies out there that show whatever they want to show.
[By that criteria all of medicine is understudied. Our knowledge of the causes of respiratory infections grows yearly and I suppose if we to devote the entire NIH budget to its investigation all would be clear. That last part “tonnes of bad studies out there that show whatever they want to show” is again disingenuous and dismissive of a preponderance of data that shows results that Dr. Jefferson doesn’t agree with, including the conclusions of his own work.]
Null: Well, I appreciate your coming on and sharing this insight with us today and we really support all your good efforts because you and your group over in Rome and Italy, you are not motivated by money you get from pharmaceutical industries. You just tell us the truth and what you are telling us gives us a reason for pause and to demand more independent, quality scientific research
[Such as the quality scientific research, free of financial incentive, that Mr. Null has demonstrated for his products, including the effects of vitamin D toxicity.]
before people in the public health sector tell us to take our flu vaccine, it’s safe and effective and will prevent the flu when they do not have the ?? of scientific integrity on their side to prove their point and so we need good science which is substantially lacking. Thank you Dr. Tom Jefferson for being with us today.
Jefferson: Thanks for having me.
When I read the Atlantic article about Dr. Jefferson, I was struck by the section that mentioned he was ostracized at meetings, eating alone:
Among his fellow flu researchers, Jefferson’s outspokenness has made him something of a pariah. At a 2007 meeting on pandemic preparedness at a hotel in Bethesda, Maryland, Jefferson, who’d been invited to speak at the conference, was not greeted by any of the colleagues milling about the lobby. He ate his meals in the hotel restaurant alone, surrounded by scientists chatting amiably at other tables.
and I thought, what a bunch of bastards. I spend lots of time with people with whom I disagree and we have fun arguing back and forth. Just because we disagree does not mean we can’t enjoy a good conversation and be civil.
Now I am not so certain. The interview suggests a conspiracy theorist who has a narrow viewpoint and ignores or misstates his own studies and the studies of others and prefers a simple message to the complexity of influenza and its many complications. What comes across in his interview, and in his written, and presumably carefully considered oeuvre, is buckets of anti-influenza vaccine bias; someone who has an opinion first which he defends with the narrowest of data second. He was interviewed in the appropriate venue after all.
PS
As I was writing this entry the Secret kicked into high gear in its spooky way yet again. Our editor received the folllowing letter:
I am the Social Media Marketing Manager here at Progressive Radio Network which is the #1 Progressive Internet Radio Station. We currently have a very popular Health and Nutrition Show on the network called “The Gary Null Show”. It is hosted by Gary Null who also owns his own Power Foods site (www.garynull.com). He also has numerous award winning documentaries and articles. We would like to get the show featured on your website if possible.
You ask, the Universe provides. Creepy.
*I have been trying to work influenza into the title of the Ken Kesey book for years.

When should I get the influenza vaccine?
Mark Crislip on October 14, 2016
Link


I was asked this question by one of my infection control practitioners. We started offering the flu vaccine the first week of October and some have delayed getting the shot for fear that immunity will not last the season. She pointed me to this NPR article, “Yes, It Is Possible To Get Your Flu Shot Too Soon,” as driving the fear of too little too soon.
So when should you get the flu shot?
Short answer – I don’t know.
There are multiple variables that make it a difficult question to answer. When does flu season start? When does it end? Influenza has immunologic variation from year to year and different strains circulate each year. How good is the match between the circulating strains of influenza and the vaccine? How good is the immunologic response of the host?
So many questions. By answering these question maybe we can come up with an estimated optimal time to receive the flu vaccine.
When is flu season?
When is the flu season? It usually starts in the mid-fall, rapidly rises in the winter, then just as rapidly declines.
Over a 34 year period:
flu activity most often peaked in February (14 seasons), followed by December (7 seasons), March (6 seasons), and January (5 seasons).
So you would want to have antibody from December to March for protection during the worst of the flu season.
Except for H1N1, which had the audacity to begin in the spring. And the great pandemic of 1918 that peaked in October.
It takes about two weeks to develop an antibody response after the vaccine, so if you go back six months from the latest historical peak of the flu season, that would be more or less October.
There are sporadic cases of flu during October and November as influenza stutters along but never really gets a hold. Why is that? Is it herd immunity? Waiting for declining vitamin D levels? Not enough indoor crowding? I don’t know, but I suspect a little bit of each.
Part of the problem with the flu vaccine is that it offers less than perfect protection combined with less than perfect uptake. With 60% of children and 40% of adults vaccinated last year, and a 60% effectiveness, the US did not have anywhere near the vaccination rates that would be expected to stop the spread of diseases.
I would wonder if maximizing vaccination early would have an effect on the spread of influenza later in the year, minimizing the effect on the population as opposed to the individual. I still want a year where the vaccine is only offered west of the Mississippi (I live in Oregon) and mandated for everyone under pain of having to move East.
Me versus the world
But I am writing in the US, societal benefits be damned, how will the timing of the vaccine help me? Me me me.
One answer may be to know how long neutralizing antibodies last. As always, it depends on the population studied.
Pregnant HIV positive patients have a lower antibody levels that falls faster than HIV negative patients:
HIV-infected women had lower seroconversion rates (ranging from 63%-92% vs 36%-40%), lower antibody titers through postpartum week 24, and overlapping antibody half-lives (ranging from 106-121 vs 87-153 days)
If you are elderly, the antibody response to the vaccine may last for a year, and is better if there was preexisting antibody:
These findings demonstrated that the elderly living in the community developed adequate antibody responses with sustainable titers throughout the 12-month study period after influenza vaccine immunization. Moreover, the presence of pre-existing antibody at a titer ≥40 prior to vaccination strongly affected the antibody response to influenza vaccination.
And the increased dose vaccine gives a higher antibody peak and a slower decline in antibody levels.
For H1N1? Protection lasts about 2 years, although there was some antibody from the 1976 Swine flu vaccine still active against H1N1.
And there are more of the same.
So how long do antibodies from the flu vaccine last? It depends on the strains in the vaccine and the host vaccinated and the type of vaccine, but most of the time for most of the strains in most of the hosts, the antibodies mostly last the season.
Mostly.
But it is well known that antibody levels do not necessarily correlate with protection against disease. How about more real world results? In the 2011 season in Spain,
The VE (vaccine effectiveness) was 61% (95% CI: 5 to 84) in the first 100 days after vaccination, 42% (95% CI: -39 to 75) between 100 and 119 days, and zero thereafter. This decline mainly affected people aged 65 or over. These results suggest a low preventive effect of the 2011/12 seasonal influenza vaccine, and a decline in VE with time since vaccination.
So good for three months. But that was for a year with a poor match between the circulating strains and the vaccine.
For the elderly against H2N2 in 2011 in a late season and with a limited match between the vaccine and circulating strains? Notice the qualifiers?
The estimated influenza VE was 52% (95% CI, -3 to 78), 40% (95% CI, -40 to 74) and 22% (95% CI, -135 to 74) at 3.5 months, 3.5-4 months, and >4 months, respectively, since vaccination. A decrease in VE with time since vaccination was only observed in individuals aged ≥ 65 years.
And this was before the high dose vaccine.
A subsequent study concluded:
We found an overall adjusted VE that provided significant and fairly consistent protection ranging from 54% to 67% during 0-180 days post vaccination.
So six months. But this was in a young population over four flu seasons (2010-2013).
But why does the efficacy of the vaccine decline in some populations and not others? It could be declining immunity, but it could also be due to drift of the virus during the season. The strains at the start of the season are immunologically different from the strains at the end of the season, so the vaccine would prevent disease at the start season would not prevent disease at the end of the season due to increase in mismatch, in which case delaying the vaccine would set you up for an early case and not help prevent a case later in the flu season. In other words, waiting could make you more vulnerable early in the season and still not protect you later.
Adjusted IVE was 38% (95%CI: -8 to 65) in the early influenza season (up to week 6 of 2012) and -1% (95% CI: -60 to 37) in the late phase. The results suggested a low adjusted IVE in 2011/12. The lower IVE in the late season could be due to virus changes through the season or waning immunity.
So, when should I you we get the vaccine?
So looking at the start of the season, the peak of the season, the type of vaccine (usual, adjuvanted, increased dose), the circulating strains, the host (young, old, transplant, HIV+ etc), antibody kinetics, and the clinical trials, when should you get the flu vaccine?
Got me.
But playing the odds, it looks to average out to about October to mid-November at the latest. That will provide protection at the usual start of season and during the usual peak. Which is when I am going to get mine. August and September could be too soon, December too late.
As the CDC suggests:
Optimally, vaccination should occur before onset of influenza activity in the community. Health care providers should offer vaccination by the end of October, if possible. Vaccination should continue to be offered as long as influenza viruses are circulating. While seasonal influenza outbreaks can happen as early as October, most of the time influenza activity peaks between December and March, although activity can last as late as May. Since it takes about two weeks after vaccination for antibodies to develop in the body that protect against influenza virus infection, it is best that people get vaccinated so they are protected before influenza begins spreading in their community.
I like it when the CDC agrees with me.

Addendum
After the final draft, this came across the web:“Modest Waning of Influenza Vaccine Efficacy and Antibody Titers During the 2007–2008 Influenza“:
Time-varying vaccine efficacy (VE[t]) was examined in healthy adult participants (age range, 18–49 years) in a placebo-controlled trial of inactivated influenza vaccine (IIV) and live-attenuated influenza vaccine (LAIV) performed during the 2007–2008 influenza season…Overall efficacy was 70% (95% confidence interval [CI], 50%–82%) for IIV and 38% (95% CI, 5%–59%) for LAIV. Statistically significant waning was detected for IIV (P = .03) but not LAIV (P = .37); however, IIV remained significantly efficacious until data became sparse at the end of the season. Similarly, antibody titers against influenza virus hemagglutinin and neuraminidase significantly decreased over the season among IIV recipients… Conclusions. Both vaccines were efficacious but LAIV less so. IIV efficacy decreased slowly over time, but the vaccine remained significantly efficacious for the majority of the season.

Flu Shots: It’s That Time Again
Flu shots are safe and effective. They not only protect the recipient but others in the community who are more vulnerable. Get your flu shot!
Harriet Hall on September 25, 2018
Link

It’s that time of the year again: time to get our flu shots. Flu shots are undeniably safe and effective, although they are not as effective as we might wish. Studies have shown that they reduce the risk of influenza infection by up to 60%, and that they reduce the risk of hospitalization and death. Even if the recipient does get the flu, it is a milder case without serious complications. Vaccination not only protects the recipient but others in the community who are more vulnerable, such as infants too young to be vaccinated, the elderly, the immunocompromised, and those with chronic diseases. The CDC recommends annual vaccination for everyone over the age of 6 months. The flu season in the Northern hemisphere starts in October. Recipients are protected after about two weeks. The CDC recommends vaccination by the end of October, but if that deadline is missed, administration at a later date is still beneficial.
Many people refuse to get flu shots, for all the wrong reasons.
Dumb Asses?
Our esteemed editor emeritus Mark Crislip is an infectious disease specialist. He is especially incensed by health care workers who refuse to get their flu shots and for years he published an annual tirade calling them Dumb Asses:
I wonder if you are one of those Dumb Asses who do not get the flu shot each year? Yes. Dumb Ass. Big D, big A. You may be allergic to the vaccine (most are not when tested), you may have had Guillain-Barre, in which case I will cut you some slack. But if you don’t have those conditions and you work in healthcare and you don’t get a vaccine for one of the following reasons, you are a Dumb Ass.
He listed 14 bogus reasons and named 14 types of anti-flu shot Dumb Asses, from the plain Dumb Ass who thinks the vaccine can give them the flu to the Paranoid Dumb Ass who thinks the government puts tracking nanobots in the vaccine.
Not dumb, just misinformed
While I share Dr. Crislip’s rancor towards unvaccinated health care workers who represent a real danger to patients, I am more charitable about their level of intelligence. I don’t think vaccine refusers are dumb. I think they are (1) misinformed and (2) reasoning poorly.
There are a lot of flu vaccine myths circulating. I needn’t list them here. The journalist Tara Haelle has provided a handy compilation listing 25 of those myths and debunking them. I have written previously about those myths in SBM articles here and here, and I wrote a “SkepDoc” column for Skeptic magazine on Flu Shot Facts and Fallacies.
Accurate information about flu vaccines is readily available. The CDC website consolidates the information in a “Key Facts” page.
Flu infection is no laughing matter
Some people think of the flu as a minor illness that, at worst, might keep them home from work for a few days. People tend to be more impressed by stories than by studies, and vaccine refusers would be well advised to check out the many personal stories showing that influenza can be a devastating and even fatal illness. The website Families Fighting Flu collects the stories of children who died or suffered serious consequences from influenza infections. On the New Zealand Ministry of Health website there is a video series of “flu stories“. In one video, a man tells how he watched his 49-year-old wife die in the intensive care unit; he says he and his wife hadn’t been vaccinated because they hadn’t known that people who are healthy can die of the flu. The website emedicinehealth.com has many patient accounts of the suffering adults endure when they get the flu. The symptoms are so severe that first you’re afraid you’re going to die and then you’re afraid you’re not going to die.
What’s new this year?
Several trivalent and quadrivalent vaccines are available. A live attenuated quadrivalent nasal spray (FluMist) was dropped from CDC recommendations for two years because studies showed low rates of protection; but after reviewing new evidence, the CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices voted 12-to-2 to reinstate it this year. It is only authorized for healthy, non-pregnant individuals between the ages of 2 and 49, and there are a few contraindications and caveats listed here. A high-dose vaccine is available that provides better protection for those over 65 who don’t have as good an immune response. Scientists are working to find a better flu vaccine that would not need to be repeated yearly in response to changes in circulating virus strains.
Conclusion: get your flu shot!
The only valid reasons not to get the flu shot are age under 6 months or severe, life-threatening allergies to flu vaccine. Every other reason has been thoroughly debunked. The flu vaccine is not perfect, but it’s good insurance. If you are healthy and don’t feel a need to insure yourself, be public-spirited and get the vaccine to help protect others in your community who are more vulnerable. If you refuse the vaccine and catch the flu, you might inadvertently expose grandma or your neighbor’s new baby before you even realize you are sick.
My own testimonial, for what it’s worth
I practice what I preach. I have gotten the flu vaccine every year for as long as I can remember, and my husband and I both got the high dose vaccine again last week (as a joke, he asked for thimerosal in his!). During my 20 years in the Air Force, vaccination was required even back when the package insert said, “Not intended for children or healthy adults”. None of my vaccinated family members has ever had the flu. I have never had the flu, despite caring for a whole ward full of flu patients during an outbreak in Spain in the 1970s. I can’t be sure it was the vaccine that protected me. I may have just been lucky. But I believe it is worthwhile to buy insurance for my home and my automobile, and I believe insurance for my health is even more worthwhile.
P.S. Since someone will inevitably accuse me of being a shill for Big Pharma, I suppose I must clarify that I was not paid to write this. I have no connections with Big Pharma and I have no conflicts of interest.

Flu Shots: Here We Go Again!
The many myths about flu shots continue to circulate and persuade some people not to get a flu shot. Flu shots are excellent insurance, safe and reasonably effective. Immunization protects not only the recipient but also vulnerable groups in the community.
Harriet Hall on September 19, 2017
Link

It’s that time again. The flu season starts in October. You will be protected about two weeks after you get the flu shot. Flu vaccination is recommended every year for everyone over 6 months of age. This year there is a quadrivalent option in addition to the usual trivalent option (covering four circulating strains of virus vs. three). The live attenuated nasal spray vaccine is no longer recommended due to concerns about its effectiveness. High-dose vaccines are available for the elderly, who may not mount a satisfactory antibody response with the standard dose. Egg allergy is not a contraindication. It is now considered safe for people with egg allergy to get any standard vaccine; but if the allergy involves any symptoms other than hives, the vaccine should be given in a medical setting and supervised by a professional trained to handle emergencies. And if you’re still worried, there are egg-free vaccine options.
The CDC has a useful information page.
Flu shot myths
Every year people refuse to get their flu shots because they believe false information they have encountered. Every year we have to repeat our efforts to debunk that false information and provide accurate information. We feel like Sisyphus: we roll that rock up the hill every year, and every year it rolls right back down.
Science journalist Tara Haelle has compiled the most comprehensive list of flu shot myths I’ve come across. On her website, she provides answers to the myths and links to her sources. I encourage you to go there. As a preview, here is her list:
    • Myth #1: The flu vaccine gives you the flu or makes you sick.
    • Myth #2: Flu vaccines contains dangerous ingredients, such as mercury, formaldehyde and antifreeze.
    • Myth #3: Pregnant women should not get the flu shot. / The flu shot can cause miscarriages. / Pregnant women should only get the preservative-free flu shot.
    • Myth #4: Flu vaccines can cause Alzheimer’s disease.
    • Myth #5: Flu vaccines provide billions of dollars in profits for pharmaceutical companies.
    • Myth #6: Flu vaccines don’t work.
    • Myth #7: Flu vaccines don’t work for children.
    • Myth #8: Flu vaccines make it easier for people to catch pneumonia or other infectious diseases.
    • Myth #9: Flu vaccines cause vascular or cardiovascular disorders.
    • Myth #10: Flu vaccines can break the “blood brain barrier” of young children and hurt their development.
    • Myth #11: Flu vaccines cause narcolepsy.
    • Myth #12: The flu vaccine weakens your body’s immune response.
    • Myth #13: The flu vaccine causes nerve disorders such as Guillain-Barré syndrome.
    • Myth #14: The flu vaccine can cause neurological disorders.
    • Myth #15: Influenza isn’t that bad. Or, people recover quickly from it.
    • Myth #16: People don’t die from the flu unless they have another underlying condition already.
    • Myth #17: People with egg allergies cannot get the flu shot. It will kill them!
    • Myth #18: If I get the flu, antibiotics will take care of me.
    • Myth #19: The flu shot doesn’t work for me, personally, because last time I got it, I got the flu anyway.
    • Myth #20: I never get the flu, so I don’t need the shot.
    • Myth #21: I can protect myself from the flu by eating right and washing my hands regularly.
    • Myth #22: It’s okay if I get the flu because it will make my immune system stronger.
    • Myth #23: Making a new vaccine each year only makes influenza strains stronger.
    • Myth #24: The side effects of the flu shot are worse than the flu.
    • Myth #25: The flu vaccine causes Bell’s palsy.
Some further points
She covered it pretty well. I can only think of a few things to add. Some of the people who think they got influenza after the shot did get influenza, but from another strain of the virus that was not covered by the vaccine. Others had a “flu-like” illness from another virus that was not influenza. You can hardly expect the flu shot to protect against strains it was not formulated to work on! Although actually it might provide partial protection against related strains.
The protection from the vaccine is not perfect, but if you are infected with one of the strains of virus that were covered by the vaccine, you will likely have a milder illness.
Cost should not be a concern. It may cost more than some people think they can afford, but catching the disease would be much more expensive (count not just treatment costs but time off work, pain and inconvenience, and the risk of transmitting it to others). If you don’t have health insurance, there are ways to get a free flu shot, or to get one for a reduced cost (as low as $14.99 at Costco). There is a convenient website that tells you where to look.
Some people have objected that the yearly-changing new flu vaccines have not been properly tested. They don’t need to be, because they are the same vaccine as in previous years, just with slightly different strains of the virus. And if we were to do controlled studies on each year’s vaccine, by the time the studies were completed it would be too late to use that vaccine, because it would be another year with a new group of strains circulating.
Babies under the age of 6 months can’t get the flu shot; they are unprotected. The elderly, the chronically ill, and the immunocompromised are more vulnerable than the average healthy adult. The more people in a community who get the flu shot, the smaller the chance that flu will spread through the community and reach these vulnerable groups. One way to put this is “If you won’t get the flu shot for yourself, get it for Grandma!”
Flu shots make sense
No immunization is 100% effective, and flu shots are less effective than immunizations for many other diseases, like measles. By one estimate, 33 to 100 healthy adults have to be vaccinated to prevent one case of influenza symptoms. But that one case might be you. It’s like insurance. How many houses have to be insured against fire for one house to burn and get a payout? Does anyone say, “I don’t need insurance because I’ve never had a fire”?
Flu shots have been given to millions of people; they are remarkably safe, and far safer than catching the disease. The disease can kill; the shots are not known to have ever killed anyone (deaths after vaccination have been reported, but no causal link to the vaccine has been found).
So, we have a safe, low-cost (or even free) insurance that will reduce your risk of having to suffer through a bad case of influenza and might even save your life, and that might help save the lives of vulnerable people in your community. It’s a no-brainer.
Get your flu shot!

Pandemrix and Narcolepsy
Pandemrix has been implicated in inducing narcolepsy in a small number of patients in Scandinavian countries. The mechanism by which this could occur very well may have been found.
Steven Novella on January 23, 2013
Link
In 2010, following the H1N1 pandemic and the vaccination campaign to reduce its impact, researchers noted a significant increase in a rare neurological disorder, narcolepsy, in Sweden and Finland. Since then researchers have been studying a possible association between a specific H1N1 flu vaccine, Pandemrix by Glaxo-Smith-Kline (GSK) and a sudden onset of the sleep disorder narcolepsy. In those two countries the association seems strong, but the full story is still complicated with many unknowns.
Narcolepsy is a neurological disorder marked by excessive sleepiness, cataplexy (sudden loss of muscle tone, usually triggered by emotions) and disordered sleep. Almost all cases are associated with low levels of hypocretin in the hypothalamus – this is a hormone involved in sleep regulation. Further there is a strong HLA (human leukocyte antigen) association – specifically DQB1*0602. HLA is a group of proteins involved in regulating immune activity. An HLA association strongly suggests that narcolepsy may be an auto-immune disease.
The current synthesis of this information is that narcolepsy occurs in genetically susceptible individuals after some environmental trigger, such as in infection, that causes the immune system to attack and destroy hypocretin cells in the brain.
It is currently not known what the precise mechanism is for the increase in narcolepsy in the two “signal countries,” Sweden and Finland. Possibilities include immune stimulation from the vaccine itself, increased immune activity from the adjuvant ASO3, immune activation from H1N1 infection, or a combination of these factors, perhaps with some other infection present at the time.
Epidemiologically, at this time it seems that the increase in narcolepsy in Finland and Sweden among children <20 (but not in adults) is a fairly strong signal and has been reasonably confirmed. This does not establish by itself a specific cause and effect, but other factors such as timing and the relative risk of vaccinated vs unvaccinated children make a causal link to the Pandemrix vaccine plausible. The increased risk from the Swedish data is about 1 case of narcolepsy per 27,800 vaccinations.
The Pandemrix vaccine was used throughout Europe and Scandinavia, and in a few South American countries, but not in the US (which used a vaccine without adjuvant). A related vaccine was used in Canada during the H1N1 outbreak. It is still uncertain whether other European countries also had an increase in narcolepsy. Data from France is conflicting. A 2011 study found no reports of narcolepsy following the vaccine through June 2010. A later report found a possible increase, but the pattern does not match the patterns seen in Sweden and Finland, with more adults affected in France.
There is still a debate as to whether there is a signal of increased narcolepsy in other countries that received the Pandemrix vaccine, but as yet this has not been confirmed. A recent review of the evidence concluded:
According to the strictest primary analysis, the kind of assessment designed to avoid most biases like media and diagnostic awareness biases, no significant risk was found in children and adolescents in other countries included in the study – Denmark, Italy, France, the Netherlands, Norway and the United Kingdom (non-signalling countries).
But there may be a signal when only data from prior to media attention are considered. This likely means that if there were an effect, it is much smaller than what was seen in Finland and Sweden. This leads to the question of why such a dramatic difference in different countries receiving the same vaccine. This cannot be explained by genetics alone, although this is a likely factor. This suggests that other environmental factors may be important, and even necessary, for narcolepsy risk to occur. There also may be confounding factors that have not yet been identified.
Conclusion
It now seems likely that some combination of factors, including but not limited to the Pandemrix vaccine, led to a spike in narcolepsy cases among children but not adults in Finland and Sweden. The same effect has not been confirmed in other countries, but a smaller effect has not been ruled out.
Use of Pandemrix has been suspended because of this concern, which is appropriate. It must be emphasized, however, that this effect, if confirmed, has no relevance to the flu vaccine in general. It has led to increased surveillance for narcolepsy following vaccination, to be cautious, but at present there is no reason to be concerned about this risk with the seasonal flu vaccine, even those targeting H1N1.
Depending on the results of further investigation, this episode might lead to genetic typing for the DQB1*0602 variant and vaccine recommendations based upon this genetic type. It must be recognized, however, that infection can also trigger narcolepsy in susceptible individuals, and therefore all factors will be considered in making recommendations. At present there are still too many unknown variable to say what the implications of the Finland and Sweden experience are.

Do two half-truths add up to a complete truth or a complete falsehood? Vaccinations truthiness.
Mark Crislip on February 6, 2015
Link

I swear that the evidence that I shall give, shall be the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth
The interwebs are not a court of law, that is for sure. The whole truth. Interesting idea. I have no idea how applicable Godel’s theorems are outside of mathematics, but from a practical point knowledge is always incomplete. There is too much to know and too little time and brain power to acquire perfect knowledge of a topic.
It is why medicine is a challenge. You have to synthesize all the available data, which is often incomplete. You have to decide what is quality information, what is not, and why, and how a given study or fact fits into the overall picture, on the continuous asymptotic journey towards unobtainable total knowledge. But you try for the whole truth, the good, the bad and the ugly.
Half-truths, partial stories, can be hard to challenge. In part because, well, they are half-true. They have an air of truthiness. It is perhaps much easier to counter an out-and-out lie. Well, maybe not. I’m thinking Wakefield here. I suspect that in having to admit that half-truths have some validity, it renders them more believable.
The world of pseudo-medicine, and pseudo-science, is filled with half-truths. I wonder when I read these half-truths whether the author is deliberately avoiding all the information, especially since the rest of the story often results in the weakening the impact of the half-truth. Paul Harvey could have had a field day with the anti-vaccine literature.
One of the greatest challenge facing young people today, is the large scale availability of half truth’s and manipulated facts– Oche Otorkpa, The Unseen Terrorist
Influenza
Beware of the half-truth. You may have gotten hold of the wrong half.– Author unknown
Take “Do Not Believe Everything You Read About Flu Deaths” from the October, 2014 Journal of Advanced Practice Nursing. As best I can tell this is a peer reviewed journal. You know, “peer“, as in “to appear partially or dimly.”
I imagine someone squinting over the top of their glasses at the manuscript, muttering, “that ‘peers to be a paper about influenza deaths. Let’s publish it.”
They start with:
Flu results in “about 250,000 to 500,000 yearly deaths” worldwide, Wikipedia tells us. “The typical estimate is 36,000 [deaths] a year in the United States…adding that “Those numbers are controversial because they are estimates.”
One would think that ‘advanced practice’ would include checking the facts from the original source with, oh, a google search.
That 36,000 number is an estimate and, an outdated estimate, from 1999. They seem not to have paid attention to more recent estimates from 2010 that used better models to estimate flu deaths. Why get all upset about the evil CDC using old, out dated statistics? The more recent estimates have influenza deaths varying from year to year:
During the past three decades, the estimated number of annual influenza-associated deaths from respiratory and circulatory causes ranged from a low of 3,349 to a high of 48,614 deaths.
So the 36,000 deaths is one of those half-truths, once the best, if flawed, estimate of influenza deaths but no longer.
Trying to determine how many deaths are due to influenza is tricky: there are direct deaths and indirect deaths from ‘flu, such as secondary bacterial pneumonia.
They ask:
But why are flu and pneumonia bundled together? Is the relationship so strong or unique to warrant characterizing them as a single cause of death?
Implying they are not. Again it depends. For H1N1 co-infections and deaths:
the incidence of influenza A H1N1 infection in CAP during the pandemic period was 19% (n, 667). We studied 128 patients; 42(33%) had bacterial co-infection. The most frequently isolated bacterial pathogens were Streptococcus pneumonia (26, 62%) and Pseudomonas aeruginosa (6, 14%). Predictors for bacterial co-infection were chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and increase of platelets count. The hospital mortality was 9%.
Although in this study having a bacterial superinfection was not associated with increased death. In prior pandemics bacterial superinfections were perhaps a more important cause of death in influenza patients.
The majority of deaths in the 1918–1919 influenza pandemic likely resulted directly from secondary bacterial pneumonia caused by common upper respiratory-tract bacteria. Less substantial data from the subsequent 1957 and 1968 pandemics are consistent with these findings.
The authors of the JAPN conclude:
The article’s answer is no. Most pneumonia deaths are unrelated to influenza.
But that is backwards. The question is, “how many influenza deaths are a result of a secondary bacterial pneumonia?” Sometimes it is, sometime it isn’t.
And there are the vascular events (heart attacks and strokes) and exacerbation of other cardio-pulmonary diseases , set off by influenza, that kills people.
Influenza kills those people as well. Arguing that they are not ‘flu deaths, as suggested, is akin to arguing that the only gun deaths you should count are in those pistol whipped to death. Otherwise they died of bullets, bleeding or major organ trauma, but not guns.
The final point of the essay is that the CDC played up the flu deaths to get people to take a vaccine they do not need. That is where the summation of multiple half-truths equals one complete falsehood, the intimation that the CDC is manipulating data for nefarious reasons.
That is one of the curiosities about the vaccine opponents and pseudo-medical providers. Somehow they just cannot wrap their heads around the fact that most time most people in reality-based medicine really, truly, are making recommendations because the preponderance of data suggests it is the right thing for people to do.
Then, as I finish this part of the essay, I discover it is actually a Huffington Post article published by the Journal of Advanced Practice Nursing with no attribution that I could find, as are other articles on the site. Go figure. I was always under the impression it was tacky to publish the copyrighted material of others without attribution, although I cannot log on to the site to see if permission etc. are behind the paywall as I am not a member.
I suppose the take home is Do Not Believe Everything You Read in Advanced Practice Nursing.
Measles
A half-truth is a whole lie.
– Yiddish proverb
There is no shortage of measles articles for some odd reason of late. Some contain TNTC examples of half-truths. For example, Roman Bystrianyk’s “Measles and measles vaccines: fourteen things to consider.”
He starts:
     1.  Measles death rate had declined by almost 100% before the use of a measles vaccine.
That is wonderful. And half the story. How about measles cases? Cases of measles didn’t fall precipitously until after the vaccine became widespread. They never show that graph. Instead, they show a section of the graph, using a different scale on the y axis and a different time interval on the x axis to minimize the effects. Please. I know what website he visits. Look carefully at the graph. Cases went from about 450/100,000 to 300/100,000 from 1934 to 1962. After the vaccine? Locally acquired measles went to 0/100,000. And yes measles was declining before the vaccine. We went from 500,000 cases a year to 50 only after the vaccine was introduced. A 99.9% reduction in cases after the vaccines; sadly, the estimated decrease in mortality was 39%. Measles can still be fatal. Controlling infections is always multifactorial, from understanding the epidemiology to nutrition to quarantine.
For the rest of the world measles is still a scourge:
Worldwide, an estimated 20 million people get measles and 146,000 people die from the disease each year—that equals about 440 deaths every day or about 17 deaths every hour.
And about 1/1,000 cases died in the US until 1963, the year the vaccine was introduced:
During this year, the whole of New England (Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, and Connecticut) had only 5 deaths attributed to measles.
Note the ‘only’. Only five deaths. Only 10 heartbroken parents, 20 heartbroken grandparents, plus brothers, sisters, aunts and uncles sobbing at the gravesite.
How many measles deaths in the last decade in the US when our vaccination rates were maximal? Zero. None. Zip. Zilch. Nil. Nada. No mother needed to hold their ‘only’ lifeless child in their arms because of measles. Roald Dahl’s daughter need not have died in 1962, a year before the vaccine:
Olivia, my eldest daughter, caught measles when she was seven years old. As the illness took its usual course I can remember reading to her often in bed and not feeling particularly alarmed about it. Then one morning, when she was well on the road to recovery, I was sitting on her bed showing her how to fashion little animals out of colored pipe-cleaners, and when it came to her turn to make one herself, I noticed that her fingers and her mind were not working together and she couldn’t do anything.
“Are you feeling all right?” I asked her.
“I feel all sleepy,” she said.
In an hour, she was unconscious. In twelve hours she was dead.
From his diary:
Got to hospital. Walked in. Two doctors advanced on me from waiting room. How is she? I’m afraid it’s too late. I went into her room. Sheet was over her. Doctor said to nurse go out. Leave him alone. I kissed her. She was warm. I went out. ‘She is warm.’ I said to doctors in hall, ‘Why is she so warm?’ ‘Of course,’ he said. I left.
That’s the whole truth of measles and what the vaccine prevents.
The rest of the article contains some historical curiosities (The 1963 measles vaccine caused a severe disease called atypical measles) and a recounting of some of the over exuberance of the measles vaccine programs that do not apply to the vaccine today.
Measles was supposed to be eradicated in 1967 and A single shot was said to provide lifelong immunity.
Somehow I get the impression that the measles vaccine should have emerged with perfect understanding. That, unfortunately, is not how the world works. They did the best they did with the tools they had and with those tools saved the lives of millions. Our understanding of measles and immunity has evolved and with it the safety and efficacy of the vaccine improved.
Bystrianyk notes:
Measles is not serious in well-nourished people.
But forgetting to mention that in the current outbreak about 15% of cases have been hospitalized.
But the author has issues with a consistent argument, first saying measles is no big deal, then he also argues that there is no such thing as measles: that doctors are misidentifying other illnesses with a fever and rash as measles. He seems surprised that in a communities with no measles (because of vaccinations) that illnesses that look like measles are due to other infections, then implies that doctors were misdiagnosing measles in the past as well.
Bystrianyk also suggests that:
Now, whereas natural measles exposure generally left the person with reliable lifelong immunity, measles vaccines leave the individual with waning immunity.
Probably not so. It is more likely that when disease runs rampant in a community adults are getting reinfected and immunity is boosted with each epidemic rather than a single natural infection giving perfect life time immunity:
However, when one examines the neutralizing-antibody levels before and after an epidemic of measles, one finds that the reinfection rate is high in those with low antibody levels. In one study, for instance, 50 per cent of the subjects with initial neutralizing-antibody levels of 1:2 to 1:8 become reinfected whereas those with levels of 1:16 or higher escaped.63 Almost all cases of reinfection are clinically inapparent. After live-virus vaccination, the antibody levels also tend to fall in persons living in isolated islands where measles has not been observed, suggesting the possibility that the persistence of antibody level after measles vaccination depends on reinfection and the “booster effect” produced by exposure to wild virus. Subacute sclerosing panencephalitis of Dawson represents another remarkable example of endogenous reinfection by measles virus…
Whether from disease or vaccine, often the only way to maintain high antibody levels and protection against an organism is to be re-exposed, either from natural disease or revaccination. I would rather get a booster vaccine as an adult than be boosted by recurrent disease epidemics. But that’s just me.
Measles is, technically, eradicable. Rinderpest probably jumped from cattle to humans to become measles. A couple of years ago rinderpest was eradicated from the planet, although I half expect us to return the favor and eventually have measles jump back into cattle.
To eradicate measles we will need more than half truths.
It’s not enough to be able to lie with a straight face; anybody with enough gall to raise on a busted flush can do that. The first way to lie artistically is to tell the truth — but not all of it.― Robert A. Heinlein, Time Enough for Love


   A Defense of Childhood Influenza Vaccination and Squalene-Containing Adjuvants; Joseph Mercola’s “Dirty Little Secret”
Joseph Albietz
Link
Fall is around the corner, and with it comes the influenza season. Each year an average of 200,000 people in the US are hospitalized with influenza, and 36,000 die.1,2 With the addition of the novel H1N1 strain (swine flu), this season promises to be more interesting, and even less predictable, than most. There can be no doubt, however, that this one set of viruses will exact a heavy toll for thousands of families this season.
Too often in medicine we find ourselves confronted with problems we cannot fix. Some traumas are too severe, some infections have too much of a head start. Some diseases are poorly understood, while others have no known treatment. One of the darker adages of medicine still holds true: In spite of all our advances, the world mortality rate seems to be holding quite steady at 100%.
Thankfully, influenza is not a disease against which we are helpless. We have ways to limit its spread, and medicines with a modest effect in assuaging symptoms and shortening the length of illness. Most importantly, we have vaccines that can safely prevent the disease altogether.
There are myriad misconceptions and fears surrounding the influenza and its vaccines, most are not new and have been addressed elsewhere, including the concern that the influenza vaccines cause the flu (they don’t), that the thimerosal they contain causes autism (it doesn’t), and that it can trigger Guillan Barre Syndrome (it can3, at a rate of 1/1,000,000, similar to the background rate of Guillan Barre in the population4). The confusion has been compounded by the emergence of the novel H1N1 pandemic. With so much at stake, it is exceedingly important to have clear, accurate information available to physicians and the public alike.
Dr. Joseph Mercola’s recent screed foisted upon the public is no such source. “Squalene: The Swine Flu Vaccine’s Dirty Little Secret” reveals his exceptionally poor grasp of the immune system, asserts that influenza is not worth preventing (36,000 deaths, 200,000 hospitalizations from seasonal flu, I suppose one could see his point), and perpetuates the thoroughly refuted toxin gambit. Nevertheless, at the time of this writing his article has misinformed nearly 250,000 readers.
If Thousands of Children Aren’t Dying It Can’t Be That Bad
His article begins with his confession that he doesn’t understand why children should be vaccinated against influenza. After all, in his own words:
Less than 100 children in the US die each year from seasonal flu viruses… If children are the first target group in the U.S. per Sebelius, that means we’re about to inject around 75 million children with a fast tracked vaccine containing novel adjuvants, including dangerous squalene, to prevent perhaps 100 deaths.
First off, the groups given the highest priority by the CDC and HHS as outlined by Kathleen Sebelius for H1N1 vaccination are:
    • Pregnant women
    • Health care and emergency workers
    • Caregivers and close contacts of children under 6 months of age
    • Anyone between the ages of 6 months and 24 years old
    • Adults with a subset of chronic medical conditions
These groups differ from the seasonal influenza recommendations due to the behavior of H1N1 since its emergence. Thus far, more than 70% of US H1N1 cases have been in people under the age of 24, and children less than 4 years of age have had the highest rate of hospitalization. The recommendations are designed to protect those at the highest risk of complications and death, and given that the groups targeted encompass more than half the US population (approx. 159 million people), children are hardly being singled out for experimentation as he implies.
Second, in discussing only the children who die, Dr. Mercola implies that the only benefit of vaccination is the prevention of death in the person vaccinated. People aren’t either healthy or dead. Those who survive an infection are still subject to its inherent suffering and complications. Furthermore, survivors run a high risk of spreading it to others who then share in the risk and misery. Dr. Mercola doesn’t seem to appreciate that children suffer the greatest rate of infection from seasonal flu each season (10-40% of all children are infected each year, ~1% of all infected children are hospitalized), and are therefore the primary source from which influenza spreads (that’s the “infectious” part of an infectious disease, I know, it’s subtle) to the rest of the population. By immunizing children against influenza we not only save their lives, we also reduce the burden of disease on the elderly who make up the bulk of the 36,000 seasonal influenza deaths each year. We do not vaccinate “to prevent perhaps 100 deaths,” we vaccinate to prevent a disease altogether, and to help the entire population avoid all of these risks.
Preventing children from contracting influenza, either seasonal or H1N1, is a very rational, humane goal, and hardly the “ridiculous assumption” Dr. Mercola claims it to be.
Fear Factor: Squalene Edition
After his incredibly callous argument to allow children to contract influenza (I’m paraphrasing for brevity), Dr. Mercola then employs the toxin gambit to assert that the H1N1 vaccine is unsafe. Here I have to give him credit for promoting yet another molecule to the anti-vaccination list of Chemicals of Omnipotent Toxicity™: Squalene.
The U.S. government has contracts with several drug companies to develop and produce swine flu vaccines. At least two of those companies, Novartis and GlaxoSmithKline, are using an adjuvant in their H1N1 vaccine.
Half-truths are the most dangerous ones aren’t they? Novartis and GSK are indeed developing H1N1 flu vaccines with adjuvants containing squalene. In fact, they’ve been doing it for more than a decade – but I don’t want to give away the punch line. Let’s examine the rest of Dr. Mercola’s claims first.
Adjuvants cause your immune system to overreact to the introduction of the organism you’re being vaccinated against.
No. Adjuvants are used to get your immune system to recognize and react to antigens that do not trigger a sufficient response on their own. Sometimes this is because the antigens are poorly reactive without being attached to a virus or bacteria like they usually are. Other times it is because we use such a minuscule amount of antigen compared to what occurs during an infection that it’s invisible to the immune system. For example, vaccination against Hepatitis B exposes you to a total 30 mcg of antigen compared to 1100 mcg/hour produced during an infection6. Regardless, adjuvants take your immune response from next to nothing to just enough to induce immunity.
Less vaccine required per person means more individual doses available for mass vaccination campaigns. Coincidentally, this is exactly the goal of government and the pharmaceutical companies who stand to make millions from their vaccines.
Dr. Mercola’s on to us! Maybe he saw the latest batch of H1N1 vaccine delivered in one of our unmarked black helicopters. We should really be more careful.
It is no coincidence that we are trying to make hundreds of millions of vaccines at a limited cost. It is fully intentional. The world is faced with the need to produce hundreds of millions of doses of influenza vaccine with a limited amount of antigen and a limited amount of time. Failure to meet the demand will result in rationing of vaccine supplies and will leave people vulnerable who desire and deserve to be protected. Again, we would have needless suffering and lives lost. If the use of an adjuvant can help meet this demand, reduce costs, and save lives, then yes, it should be strongly considered.
Before I leave this comment, I’ll take the opportunity to point out that pharmaceutical companies, doctors, and hospitals stand to make a lot more money from an uncontrolled pandemic than from its prevention. The money spent on antivirals, antibiotics, sedation and pain medications, physician and hospital billing for the 200,000 people hospitalized in the US during a normal flu season would compensate them far better than profits from vaccine sales. It’s almost as though, against our financial interest, all of our efforts are designed to keep people from getting sick…
Your immune system recognizes squalene as an oil molecule native to your body. It is found throughout your nervous system and brain. In fact, you can consume squalene in olive oil and not only will your immune system recognize it, you will also reap the benefits of its antioxidant properties.
The difference between “good” and “bad” squalene is the route by which it enters your body. Injection is an abnormal route of entry which incites your immune system to attack all the squalene in your body, not just the vaccine adjuvant.
Your immune system will attempt to destroy the molecule wherever it finds it, including in places where it occurs naturally, and where it is vital to the health of your nervous system.
Gulf War veterans with Gulf War Syndrome (GWS) received anthrax vaccines which contained squalene. MF59 (the Novartis squalene adjuvant) was an unapproved ingredient in experimental anthrax vaccines and has since been linked to the devastating autoimmune diseases suffered by countless Gulf War vets.
There are several points that could be addressed in this section, including anti-oxidant abuse, the childish (and incorrect) description of “good” and “bad” squalene, and the evidence refuting the claim anthrax vaccine given to Gulf War vets contained squalene, much less that it is the cause of Gulf War Syndrome (GWS). However, the main claim Dr. Mercola makes here is that squalene, when injected, will trigger an immunologic response and that these squalene-specific antibodies will then cause untold havoc in your body. That’s a testable hypothesis, and don’t you know scientists just love to test hypotheses?
To support his assertion he cites a small cohort study from 2000 that reported anti-squalene antibodies in veterans afflicted by GWS. Case closed, right? Not so much. A larger and better-designed study found no correlation between the presence of squalene antibodies and symptoms of Gulf War Syndrome. More important regarding vaccine safety, a subsequent study using more sensitive and accurate methods than those used in the study by Asa established that anti-squalene antibodies are present in a large percentage of adults regardless of exposure to squalene from vaccines, and are unchanged by subsequent exposure to squalene containing adjuvants.
In other words, adjuvants containing squalene don’t induce an immune response to squalene. No antibodies are created to cause whatever autoimmune phenomena Dr. Mercola cares to postulate, including GWS. His hypothesis fails.
There is virtually no science to support the safety of vaccine injections on your long-term health or the health of your children. Follow-up studies last on average about two weeks, and look only for glaring injuries and illnesses.
This is simply untrue. Post-licensure surveillance for vaccine safety is among the most extensive in medicine. Squalene-containing vaccines are no exception. As of 2009, over 40 million people have been given squalene containing influenza vaccines in Europe. The incidence of serious adverse events so far reported, 1.4/100,000 doses administered, is at the baseline of the general population with no exposure to the vaccine.
As far as long-term follow-up, squalene has been studied as part of influenza vaccines in over 30 phase 1-4 trials, 13 of which had 4-6 month follow-up, and included over 14,000 people, and the current influenza vaccines in development are subject to clinical trials with a 6-12 month follow up schedule.
THE PUNCH LINE
With his article Dr. Mercola sought to scare people away from vaccinating against influenza in general, and H1N1 in particular. Contrary to Dr. Mercola’s poorly informed assertions, cherry picked and outdated studies, and outright misinformation, influenza is a real threat and vaccines against it are both effective and safe.
Ah, but earlier I promised you a punch line. Remember this quote?
The U.S. government has contracts with several drug companies to develop and produce swine flu vaccines. At least two of those companies, Novartis and GlaxoSmithKline, are using an adjuvant in their H1N1 vaccine.
Novartis and GSK are indeed developing influenza vaccines containing adjuvants – for use in Europe, where squalene containing adjuvants have been safely used for over a decade. The US is indeed conducting H1N1 vaccine safety and efficacy studies that include the use of adjuvants. Given the unpredictable nature of the upcoming season and the very real potential that vaccine demand will outstrip its supply, it would be irresponsible for the US not to be prepared with a well studied contingency plan that includes possible adjuvant use.
However, it must be clearly stated that there are no adjuvants, nor have there ever been, in the US influenza vaccines. Furthermore, barring the highly unlikely failure of the standard unadjuvanted vaccines currently in trial, the H1N1 vaccines available in the US will also be adjuvant free.7
Even if Dr. Mercola’s entire article made a single valid point regarding the use of adjuvants in the H1N1 vaccine, it is irrelevant to the US population. Based on poor science, packed with misinformation, and designed to promote unwarranted fear, his article is not a source of information, it is dangerous, irresponsible fear mongering.
Citations:
Thompson WW, Shay DK, Weintraub E, et al. Mortality associated with influenza and respiratory syncytial virus in the United States. JAMA 2003;289:179–86.
Thompson WW, Shay DK, Weintraub E, et al. Influenza-associated hospitalizations in the United States. JAMA 2004;292:1333–40.
Guarino M, Casmiro M, D’Alessandro R. Campylobacter jejuni infection and Guillain-Barre syndrome: a case-control study. Emilia-Romagna Study Group on Clinical and Epidemiological problems in neurology. Neuroepidemiology 1998;17:296–302.
Haber P, DeStefano F, Angulo FJ, et al. Guillain-Barre syndrome following influenza vaccination. JAMA 2004;292:2478–81.
Thompson WW, Shay DK, Weintraub E, et al. Influenza-associated hospitalizations in the United States. JAMA 2004 Sep 15;292(11):1333-40.
Courtesy of Quackcast, Episode 30, 2/22/2009, by Mark Crislip. http://www.quackcast.com/spodcasts/files/48f9db861d8a83f764792aa4b77990f8-29.html
This decision drew heat from the international medical community, as it runs counter to the World Health Organization’s recommendations, will mean fewer vaccine doses produced overall, and may compromise our ability to control the spread of H1N1 worldwide if supplies fall short.

The influenza vaccine and miscarriages: Much ado about nothing
A study published on Wednesday claims to have found a link between influenza vaccination and miscarriage, and antivaxers are gloating. The study itself suffers mightily from post hoc subgroup analyses on small numbers, so much so that even its authors don’t really believe its results. None of that stopped them from publishing the study, thus justifying “more research” that will almost certainly reinforce the scientific consensus that the flu vaccine is safe during pregnancy.
David Gorski on September 15, 2017
Link

[Ed. Note: We happen to have a hole in the schedule today; so I’m repurposing a relevant post from elsewhere for SBM, because it’s a study that was in the news a lot and is now making the rounds on antivax social media. It’s been spiffed up a bit for SBM.
Also: If you’ve come here from the NYT article citing this one, please read my whole post. I think that the NYT somewhat misrepresented my actual position here.]
Earlier this week, a CDC-funded study of the flu vaccine hit the news, and the antivaccine movement went wild. The reason was due to headlines like this, including in some major news outlets:
    • “Study Linking Early Miscarriage to Flu Vaccine Puzzles Doctors“
    • “Study shows miscarriage risk may have increased after flu shots, puzzling researchers“
    • “What to know about a study of flu vaccine and miscarriage“
    • “Study signals association between flu vaccine, miscarriage“
In the antivaccine world, the blog post titles were practically giddy in their fear mongering, such as “Devastating flu vaccine-miscarriage study sparks ridiculous spin” (J.B. Handley).
The crankiest of these cranks, of course, is Mike Adams, a grifter deep in the thrall of any form of pseudoscience that he can sell to burnish his brand and keep the rubes buying and who knows how to whip his minions into a fine frothy head of anti-pharma conspiracy mongerings:
A CDC-funded medical study being published by the medical journal Vaccine has confirmed a shocking link between flu shots and spontaneous abortions in pregnant women. The study was rejected by two previous medical journals before Vaccine agreed to publish it, further underscoring the tendency for medical journals to censor any science that doesn’t agree with their pro-vaccine narratives.
“A study published today in Vaccine suggests a strong association between receiving repeated doses of the seasonal influenza vaccine and miscarriage,” writes CIDRAP, the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy.
“A puzzling study of U.S. pregnancies found that women who had miscarriages between 2010 and 2012 were more likely to have had back-to-back annual flu shots that included protection against swine flu,” reports Medical Xpress, a pro-vaccine news site that promotes vaccine industry interests. Notice that the opening paragraph of their study assumed the study couldn’t possibly be true. It’s “puzzling” that mercury in flu shots could cause spontaneous abortions, you see, because these people have no understanding of biochemistry and the laws of cause and effect.
Actually, as has been documented so many times before, it is Mike Adams who has no understanding of biochemistry—or any other science—other than what it takes for him to portray himself to his gullible followers as a “real scientist.” As for the “laws of cause and effect,” whenever someone says something like that in reference to an epidemiological study, I know he’s really, really clueless, because if there’s anything that’s very difficult to do in an epidemiological study with reliability it’s determining cause-and-effect. That’s why the cardinal rule of epidemiology is that correlation does not equal causation. It might, but usually it doesn’t, and it usually takes a whole lot more than just one study with a correlation to start to suggest causation. This is particularly true when a study like the one Adams is gloating about is such an outlier, which this study most definitely is, as you will see. It’s also an exercise in data dredging that illustrates the danger of doing subgroup analyses in which each subgroup has small numbers.
Let’s go to the study itself. I can’t help but note that Frank DeStefano of the CDC is a co-author. DeStefano, as you might recall, is one of those CDC investigators that antivax conspiracy theorists like those who made the propaganda film VAXXED portray as one of the main villains in the “CDC whistleblower” conspiracy theory. Also, several of the authors receive pharma money for research support. Nicola Klein, for instance, receives research support from GlaxoSmithKline, Sanofi Pasteur, Pfizer, Merck, MedImmune, Novartis, and Protein Science, while Allison Naleway receives funding from GlaxoSmithKline, MedImmune, and Pfizer. Others receive support from MedImmune and Novavax. So basically, this was a study funded by the CDC and carried out by CDC scientists and scientists receiving significant pharma funding. I just couldn’t resist pointing that out. I know, I know, antivaxers will claim that the findings were so compelling that not even the CDC and pharma shills could hide them, but it would amuse me to point these things out to antivaxers.
Yet, here we see Del Bigtree, producer of VAXXED, gleefully citing J.B. Handley gloating over this study:
Tough breaking news for @ChelseaClinton @DrPanMD @doritmi FLU SHOT linked to MISCARRIAGE! #endvaxinjury https://t.co/6JwjnsAviY
— Del Bigtree (@delbigtree) September 13, 2017
I wonder if Bigtree knows that DeStefano is a co-author. He probably doesn’t care, because DeStefano, like any scientist, can be a hero or a villain depending solely upon whether he produces information or studies that agrees with the antivaccine narrative that the flu vaccine is not just useless but dangerous. Be that as it may, the article above is a typical bit of Handley’s Dunning-Krugger arrogance of ignorance, even more full of hyperbole and nonsense than the usual Mike Adams’ endeavors in that area. Indeed, Handley even uses the argumentum ad package insert gambit. (Whenever I see that gambit used by an antivaxer, my estimation of his cluelessness goes up several notches, which for Handley is really saying something.) In any case, you can get a feel for how much the authors of this study are stretching to find a correlation—any correlation—between influenza vaccines and miscarriages that they’re looking at combinations of vaccines by their brief justification for the study:
Since 2004, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) and other organizations have recommended routine influenza vaccination for pregnant women regardless of gestational age [1,2]. Influenza in pregnancy can cause serious, life-threatening illness in both the mother and fetus, as demonstrated during the 2009 pandemic [3,4]. Numerous studies of influenza vaccine during pregnancy have not identified serious safety concerns [5–12], but relatively few investigations have evaluated vaccination in the first trimester, a period when the embryo is highly vulnerable to teratogens and other factors [5,13]. A case-control study conducted by the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD) demonstrated that influenza vaccination during early pregnancy in the 2005–06 and 2006–07 influenza seasons was not associated with spontaneous abortion (SAB) [14].
The emergence of a pandemic influenza virus, A/California/ 7/2009 (H1N1)pdm09 (pH1N1), led to rapid development and widespread use of vaccines containing pH1N1 antigens. Several studies have evaluated the safety of vaccines containing pH1N1 in pregnancy, but few have focused on outcomes in early pregnancy [15–19]. Using a design and protocol similar to the previous study [14], we conducted a case-control study to determine if receipt of influenza vaccine containing pH1N1 was associated with SAB.
Notice the eight studies cited (references 5-12) that failed to find significant safety issues with the vaccine in pregnancy, and a study (reference 14) using VSD data failed to find an association between flu vaccination with spontaneous abortion. That’s actually a lot of data for the safety of the flu vaccine during pregnancy, which makes me wonder what the justification for yet another study looking for an association between influenza vaccination and miscarriages. If I were a funding agency and received a grant application to do a study like this with text above in the “Background and Significance” or the “Impact” section, my first reaction would be: Why on earth would we fund this? It’s all been done before, many, many times. Yet the CDC funded this study. So much for antivax claims about the CDC not being concerned about vaccine safety and not being willing to look for adverse reactions due to vaccines.
I also find it rather odd that the authors would say that few studies have been done looking for a correlation between vaccination against influenza, even in early pregnancy, when in fact there have been a lot, many well-designed, and they’ve pretty much all been negative. Whenever you see a study that finds something a lot different from the bulk of the studies that have been done before, the first question to be asked is: Are the results of the current study so robust that they indicate a hole in the existing data addressing the question asked that we should begin to question the cumulative results of all the studies that have gone before? Keep that question in mind as I continue.
Also consider the bias that exists in journals to publish novel findings. As this news report points out, this is the “first study to identify a potential link between miscarriage and the flu vaccine.” That’s almost certainly the reason that it was published. Adams, in his haste to portray as a conspiracy to silence, inadvertently tells me something. That this paper was rejected by two previous journals is not surprising to me. What is surprising is that Vaccine ultimately accepted it, which was reported in the AP version of this story. I’m not sure why Gregory Poland, the editor of Vaccine, felt obligated to point that out to a reporter. One would think that a journal editor wouldn’t want to advertise that he accepted a manuscript that had been rejected elsewhere. My guess is that the authors submitted it to epidemiology journals, where reviewers dinged it for its obvious flaws, but I have no way of knowing.
So what about the study itself? First, it’s a case-control study. Basically, that means that the authors studied a cohort of women who had miscarriages (the cases) and compared them to a cohort of women who didn’t have miscarriages but instead delivered full term infants or had stillbirths during the study period (the controls). The authors chose two flu seasons (2010 to 2012) and asked if women who had miscarriages were more likely to have been vaccinated for influenza within 28 days prior to miscarriage, as well as for different time periods before miscarriage. That’s how case control studies work. You compare patients who have a medical condition (the cases, in this case, miscarriages) to those who do not (the controls), matching them as closely as possible in other relevant traits, and then ask whether there is a difference in the exposure under study between the groups.
The most critical aspect of any case control study if, of course, the matching of cases to controls. The idea is to match them as closely as possible on all relevant factors other than the condition under investigation (in this case, miscarriage). Not uncommonly, investigators will do a 2:1 match, controls to cases, in order to make the comparison more robust. It’s not mandatory, and Donohue et al chose not to do this. In this study, cases had SAB and controls had live births or stillbirths and were matched on site, date of last menstrual period, and age. I also note that the database they used was the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD). As I like to say, the VSD is an excellent rebuke to antivaxers who claim that doctors don’t care about vaccine safety. It’s a database designed to document adverse events associated with vaccination, and it’s a huge database.
So what did the study find? Here’s a summary of the cases analyzed:
I can’t help but note that the matching leaves something to be desired. Cases and controls were matched to last menstrual period, which is appropriate to assure nearly identical gestational ages. Other matching included VSD site, maternal age (30 years was the cutoff). That’s some rather loose matching, in my book, given that there are a lot of other potential factors that can increase the risk of spontaneous abortion (miscarriage). More on this later.
If you look at the tables in the paper, the first thing you will notice is that the adjusted odds ratios (aORs) for miscarriage as a function of having received the flu vaccine are nearly all around 1.0 or not statistically different from 1.0. Obviously, there are exceptions. Basically, the study found that, if a woman had consecutively received a flu vaccine containing the 2009 H1N1 virus the season before and had the flu vaccine in one of the two seasons studied, the aOR in the 1–28 days was 7.7 (95% CI 2.2–27.3). Otherwise, the aOR was 1.3 (95% CI 0.7–2.7) among women not vaccinated in the previous season; i.e., not statistically significant from 1.0, meaning no detectable difference in miscarriage rates compared to women who had not been vaccinated. This effect was noted in both seasons.
Now here’s where you should be skeptical.
This study has several important limitations. First, the most striking findings relate to the association between SAB and IIV [inactivated influenza vaccine] in women who previously received pH1N1-containing vaccine. This interaction effect was not an a priori hypothesis; the results were generated in a post hoc analysis with small numbers of women in the various subgroups. Although the interaction was observed in each of the two seasons studied, the point estimates were substantially larger (though not statistically different) in the first season for reasons that are unclear. Second, although most cases had an ultrasound, assignment of a precise date of SAB was challenging. With guidance from an obstetrician we integrated different types of information from the medical record (e.g., ultrasound results, clinical and laboratory findings, provider notes) to estimate the timing of the SAB. Estimation of SAB dates was independent of vaccination status so any error should bias the results toward the null (i.e., non-differential misclassification). Third, we studied only women who had clinically confirmed SAB; the proportion of women with clinically unrecognized pregnancy loss is uncertain but may be substantial [50,51]. Our results could be biased if women who sought care for SAB were more likely to be vaccinated in the 28-day exposure window.
So what we’re looking at is an association, nothing more. It’s an association with a lot of caveats, too. Basically, having found nothing more than one association with an aOR of 2.0 for the 1-28 day window of exposure to the influenza vaccine before miscarriage that was barely statistically significant (95% confidence interval: 1.1-3.6), the authors did a post hoc analysis looking for other associations. (Never mind that the “association” they found was eminently unimpressive given the size of the confidence intervals.) “Post hoc” means that they did additional analyses not originally specified. Basically investigators don’t usually do post hoc analyses if there is a robust association in their data. They do it when they fail to find an association or only find an unimpressive association that is not robust. Also, post hoc analyses are prone to type 1 errors, which means finding a statistically significant “association” where there is none; i.e., finding a false positive. When the numbers in the subgroup are so small and the study is observational (i.e., retrospective), that tendency is even stronger. Then there was the issue that the cases and controls were not as comparable as one would like in a case control study. For example, cases were significantly older than controls and more likely to be African-American, to have a history of 2 spontaneous abortions, and to have smoked during pregnancy. The authors did some correcting for age and history of spontaneous abortions, but it’s questionable to me whether it was adequate.
Basically, the authors did what we refer to as a subgroup analysis, in this case the subgroup being women who had received H1N1 vaccination the season before they received the flu vaccination in the seasons examined? That clearly wasn’t a primary hypothesis being tested. Rather, it was a hypothesis the authors clearly came up with while doing the study. One wonders if this analysis was prespecified or whether the protocol was changed midway through. I only ask that because antivaxers went wild over claims by the “CDC whistleblower” that the Atlanta MMR study changed its protocol part way through the study, but, here, where the analysis seems to suggest such an “adjustment” during the study (although it is certainly possible that the H1N1 analysis was prespecified in the original protocol, given the choice of the 2010-11 and 2011-12 flu seasons), we hear…silence. Whatever the case, there clearly was post hoc analysis going on, so much so that I smell= p-hacking.
Speculations about the protocol aside, the investigators found what they found, namely an aOR of 7.7 for cases versus controls for exposure to the H1N1 vaccine the year before plus the flu vaccine within 1-28 days before their miscarriages. This was based on some very small numbers, though, namely 14 miscarriages and 4 controls. In other words, this is almost certainly a statistical fluke, given that it was only found for women who had received H1N1 the season before and had received the flu vaccine within 28 days of their miscarriage, and that the association was not observed for pretty much any other time window or combination. When considering such a result, one also has to consider biological mechanism and plausibility, and it is just not very plausible from a biological or immunological standpoint that this combination of flu vaccines—and only this combination—given only during a specific time window will cause miscarriages. Like Dr. Gregory Poland, the editor of Vaccine, I don’t believe these findings, either. Unlike Dr. Poland, I wouldn’t have published these findings, given how very likely it is that they are a statistical fluke.
I particularly don’t believe them in light of what we already know, based on studies Tara Haelle summarized the data with respect to flu vaccines and miscarriages, stillbirths, and birth defects in 2014, using mainly studies published during the prior two years, and the results were very consistent and overwhelming: There was no association between vaccination for influenza and adverse fetal outcomes. Just for yucks, I did some PubMed searches myself for more recent studies, and found basically the same thing, but instead of listing those studies, I’ll just refer you to a recent large meta-analysis that found that the risk of stillbirth was actually lower in women vaccinated against influenza and no difference in the risk of spontaneous abortion. In other words, this new study is an outlier. It’s such an outlier, that scientists are correct to be very skeptical of its results. Heck, even the authors are skeptical of its results. Unfortunately, they’re not so skeptical that they don’t resist making the call for “more research.” They’ll probably get the funding for that “more research,” and then when the inevitable negative study is finally published, no one will remember it. They’ll all remember this study, and, of course, the antivaccine movement will be flogging it for years to come, beginning now.

   The Tamiflu Spin
Mark Crislip
Link
I will start, for those of you who are new to the blog, with two disclaimers.
First, I am an infectious disease doctor. It is a simple job: Me find bug. Me kill bug. Me go home. I spend all day taking care of patients with infections. My income comes from treating and preventing infections. So I must have some sort of bias, the main one being I like to do everything I can to cure my patients.
Second, in 25 years I have, to my knowledge, accepted one thing from a drug company. The Unisin (that’s how I spell it) rep, upon transfer from my hospital, sent me a Fleet enema with a Unisin sticker on it. I show it proudly to all who enter my office. I do not even eat the drug company pizza at conference, and I cannot begin to tell you painful that is.
As we leave (I hope) the H1N1 season and enter seasonal flu season, there has been a flurry of articles, originating in the British Medical Journal , questioning whether oseltamivir is effective in treating influenza. The specific complaint at issue is whether or not oseltamivir prevents secondary complications of influenza like hospitalization and pneumonia. Although you wouldn’t guess that was at issue from the reporting. As always, there is what the data says, what the abstract says, what the conclusion says, and what other people say it says. Reading the medical literature is all about blind men and elephants.
There is, evidently, going to be an investigation by the European Union Council of Europe into whether or not the H1N1 pandemic was faked to sell more oseltamivir. Sigh.
Is oseltamivir effective against flu? Lets start with background. What do I want to know about an antiviral to help determine its efficacy?
I would like a mechanism of action that would prevent replication of the virus. I can’t kill a virus, as I can a bacteria, but at least I can stop if from reproducing.
I would like the antiviral to be effective in the test tube at physiologically achievable concentrations.
I would like the antiviral to be effective in an animal model.
I would like the antiviral to be effective clinically: on challenge studies if ethical and in the real world.
There is the virulence of the organism, and there can be strain to stain variation in the virulence. Some influenza strains are better at spreading or killing than other strains. Everyone seems to have forgotten that when H1N1 started in Mexico it apparently had a horrific mortality rate in hospitalized patients.
” By 60 days, 24 patients had died (41.4%; 95% confidence interval, 28.9%-55.0%).”
The worry was that there was going to be a repeat of the 1919 influenza pandemic. Fortunately the subsequent mortality rate was much less as it swept the world. H1N1 turned out to be a highly infectious, low virulence strain of flu. This time. But I would still fret that one-day there will be another repeat of the 1919 pandemic. The current bird flu has a 66% mortality rate, but is not spread human to human. Maybe someday it will gain that ability. But at the beginning no one knew what mortality of H1N1 or bird flu was going to be and they prepared accordingly. Of course public health officials are always in a no-win situation. They are either going to over-prepare or under-prepare, and as a result at best look a fool and at worst look evil. Next time they may err on the side of under-preparing so they are not accused of faking a pandemic.
There is the hosts ability to respond to the infection. Just as there is variability in the virulence of the pathogen, there is variability in the hosts ability to control the infection. It is often the case that whether you live or die from an infection may be due to the immune system with which you are born. Pubmed ‘toll like receptor’ ‘polymorphism’ and ‘infection’ for further information that is beyond the scope of this entry. There may be an inherited predisposition to dying from influenza.
In the H1N1 pandemic, mild as it was overall, caused disproportionately relatively high mortality in children
“Between May and July 2009, a total of 251 children were hospitalized with 2009 H1N1 influenza. Rates of hospitalization were double those for seasonal influenza in 2008. Of the children who were hospitalized, 47 (19%) were admitted to an intensive care unit, 42 (17%) required mechanical ventilation, and 13 (5%) died. The overall rate of death was 1.1 per 100,000 children, as compared with 0.1 per 100,000 children for seasonal influenza in 2007. (No pediatric deaths associated with seasonal influenza were reported in 2008.) “
and pregnant women
“Data were reported for 94 pregnant women, 8 postpartum women, and 137 nonpregnant women of reproductive age who were hospitalized with 2009 H1N1 influenza… In all, 18 pregnant women and 4 postpartum women (total, 22 of 102 [22%]) required intensive care, and 8 (8%) died.”
Who gets the disease may be, depending on the organism, more important than the strain of infection.
There is how strong or powerful (meaningless terms to an ID doc, but part of the popular language of medicine) the antibiotic is. Antivirals are not that effective because they do not kill viruses, they only halt their replication. Given the prodigious replicative capacity of viruses, it is going to be impossible to shut down every virus from replicating with an antiviral. With HIV it took the combination of three different anti-retrovirals to (almost?) completely shut down viral replication. As those without immune systems prove with depressing regularity, no antibiotic will work for long if the host’s immune system cannot help control the infection.
Finally, there is promptness of therapy. For serious infections even a day in the delay of appropriate antibiotics can dramatically increase mortality. So the later you begin therapy, the less effect one should expect. This is one of the issues with a disease with a very rapid onset like influenza and why the challenge studies, where you give the medication right after exposing the subject to influenza, show better effect. Viral replication will often rapidly outstrip the available antiviral.
What would I expect from an influenza medication?
Prevent disease after exposure?
Decrease the severity of the infection?
Prevent death in all cases? Prevent death in the more severe cases? Decrease the odds of dying?
Decrease complications of the disease?
Some combination of the above?
All good endpoints. As a rule, I expect antivirals for to lessen the severity of disease if given early in the disease.
So what can we say for oseltamivir?
Does it have a mechanism of action that would interfere with viral replication? Yes. Oseltamivir blocks the activity of the viral neuraminidase enzyme, preventing new viral particles from being released by infected cells. Not a thrilling mechanism of action. The virus can multiply all it wants if it infects a cell, and since no drug is 100% effective, one would expect it would slow down the disease, not stop it.
Sometimes, as we shall see, that may be enough to make the difference between life and death.
Does oseltamivir work in the test tube? Yes. In animal models? Yeah. In human clinical trials? Yes.
It is in human clinical trials and the choice of efficacy endpoints where the current brouhaha starts.
LA times headline reads
“British medical journal questions efficacy of Tamiflu for swine flu — or any flu.”
The Atlantic , which has now supplanted the Natural News for the worst medical coverage, has a headline that reads
“The Truth About Tamiflu”
followed by the opening paragraphs.
“Two months ago, we pointed out in our story on flu in The Atlantic that the antiviral drug Tamiflu might not be as effective or safe as many patients, doctors, and governments think. The drug has been widely prescribed since the first cases of H1N1 flu surfaced last spring, and the U.S. government has spent more than $1.5 billion stockpiling it since 2005 as part of the nation’s pandemic preparedness plan.
Now it looks as if our concerns were correct, and the nation may have put more than a billion dollars into the medical equivalent of a mirage. This week, the British medical journal BMJ published a multi-part investigation that confirms that the scientific evidence just isn’t there to show that Tamiflu prevents serious complications, hospitalization, or death in people that have the flu. The BMJ goes further to suggest that Roche, the Swiss company that manufactures and markets Tamiflu, may have misled governments and physicians. In its defense, Roche stated that the company “has never concealed (or had the intention to conceal) any pertinent data.”
The medical equivalent of a mirage. Hmmm. And death? The Cochrane review, upon which the whole controversy revolves, does not comment of prevention of death nor does the BMJ feature or editorial on the topic. Into the second paragraph and already they are apparently making things up. I remember when I trusted the Atlantic. Interestingly, the Atlantic never quotes the results of the Cochran review. They suggest that the review demonstrates that oseltamivir is worthless.
Does it? Start with the methods section.
They looked for randomized, placebo controlled trials. Cochran gold.
“We excluded experimental influenza challenge studies as their generalizability and comparability with field studies is uncertain.”
Which is a shame, as the challenge studies always show efficacy. But they are not representative of the real world as they have the best case for treating with an antiviral: you can start the medication right when the disease may start.
They screened 1416 articles and ended up with 29 studies, 10 for effectiveness, the cream of the crop. 1416 articles is a lot of articles. I know they are not the crème de la crème, and is why I am not a fan on just relying on meta-analysis alone. That is a lot of ignored information. And their results?
Here is the conclusion in the abstract:
“Neuraminidase inhibitors have modest effectiveness against the symptoms of influenza in otherwise healthy adults. The drugs are effective postexposure against laboratory confirmed influenza, but this is a small component of influenza-like illness, so for this outcome neuraminidase inhibitors are not effective. Neuraminidase inhibitors might be regarded as optional for reducing the symptoms of seasonal influenza. Paucity of good data has undermined previous findings for oseltamivir’s prevention of complications from influenza. Independent randomized trials to resolve these uncertainties are needed.”
I am already confused.
“The drugs are effective postexposure against laboratory confirmed influenza, but this is a small component of influenza-like illness, so for this outcome neuraminidase inhibitors are not effective.”
They are effective but they are not. But the abstract suggests in normal people, oseltamivir has modest efficacy.
Later, there is the Take Home message box, which says
“WHAT IS ALREADY KNOWN ON THIS TOPIC
Neuraminidase inhibitors (especially oseltamivir) have become global public health drugs for influenza
They prevent symptoms and shorten the duration of illness by about one day if taken within 48 hours of the onset of symptoms
Toxicity and the effects on complications have been debated
WHAT THIS STUDY ADDS
Neuraminidase inhibitors reduce the symptoms of influenza modestly
Neuraminidase inhibitors reduce the chance of people exposed to influenza developing laboratory confirmed influenza but not influenza-like illness
Evidence for or against their benefit for preventing complications of influenza is insufficient
Evidence for or against serious adverse events is lacking, although oseltamivir causes nausea”
To me the take home message suggests some efficacy. Lets move on to the results and the discussion. Perhaps it will clarify the situation.
“The data suggest that neuraminidase inhibitors are effective at reducing the symptoms of influenza. The evidence is of modest benefit—reduction of illness by about one day. “
Which is what I would expect in a population of healthy, mostly young people with seasonal flu of low virulence.
Note the caveats. Young, healtyh people and influenza of low virulence.
Every season we have new strains of influenza and the ability of influenza to kill people varies from year to year.
“This benefit has been generalized to assume benefits for very ill people in hospital. This seems reasonable, although it is worth remembering that we have no data to support this, and it is unlikely that ethics committees would allow a trial of no treatment for people with influenza who have life threatening disease.”
Yeah. We will probably not have randomized controlled trials in the seriously ill. While we do not have randomized, controlled, clinical trials, we do have data to support the use of oseltamivir in ill patients. Not no data.
In the Mexican experience with H1N1 mentioned above,
“After adjusting for a reduced opportunity of patients dying early to receive neuraminidase inhibitors, neuraminidase inhibitor treatment (vs no treatment) was associated with improved survival (odds ratio, 8.5; 95% confidence interval, 1.2-62.8).”
And in pregnant women with H1N1 mentioned above
“As compared with early antiviral treatment (administered 2 days after symptom onset) in pregnant women, later treatment was associated with admission to an intensive care unit (ICU) or death (relative risk, 4.3).”
Or this experience with H1N1
“Of the 268 patients for whom data were available regarding the use of antiviral drugs, such therapy was initiated in 200 patients (75%) at a median of 3 days after the onset of illness. Data suggest that the use of antiviral drugs was beneficial in hospitalized patients, especially when such therapy was initiated early.”
And what about seasonal flu?
“No randomized trials of neuraminidase-inhibitor treatment of hospitalized influenza patients have been conducted. However, three observational studies suggest that oseltamivir treatment of hospitalized patients with seasonal influenza may reduce mortality. In one prospective Canadian study among hospitalized patients with seasonal influenza, (N=327; mean age, 77 years), in which 71% began oseltamivir treatment >48 hours after illness onset, oseltamivir treatment was significantly associated with a reduced risk of death (OR, 0.21; P=0.03) within 15 days after hospitalization as compared with untreated patients.7 In a subanalysis, in a Hong Kong study of hospitalized seasonal influenza patients (N=356; mean age, 70.2 years), oseltamivir treatment initiated within <96 hours after illness onset was independently associated with decreased mortality as compared with untreated patients (OR, 0.26; P=0.001).8 A retrospective chart review of hospitalized seasonal influenza patients in Thailand (N=445; mean age, 22 years), including 35% with radiographically confirmed pneumonia, reported that any oseltamivir treatment was significantly associated with survival (OR, 0.11; 95% CI, 0.04 – 0.30) as compared with untreated patients.”
In the seriously ill, people who are going to die from influenza, taking oseltamivir appears to decrease the odds of dying. Remember that the authors of the Atlantic article said olsetamivir didn’t prevent death. Maybe their firewall blocks access to Pubmed and Google. Or maybe they are no good at evaluating elephants.
So what would you do if you were in charge of public health policy and confronted with a new strain of influenza, be it H1N1 or bird flu, with a potentially catastrophic mortality rate? Ignore it? Or get as much oseltamivir and vaccine as you could lay your hands on?
Maybe not the highest quality studies, but we have a biologic mechanism, we have test tube and animal studies, we have challenge studies, we retrospective studies that show efficacy. We have a lot of data to support efficacy of antivirals in some patient populations.
The question is not whether oseltamivir is effective, but in what population the medication will be effective and for what strains of influenza. Certainly I am not going to withhold oseltamivir from a hospitalized pregnant female with presumptive H1N1 given an 8% mortality rate. Does a 45 yo with H1N1 or seasonal flu need oseltamivir? No. An 85 year old with multiple medical problems? Probably. Nuance. Subtlety. Understanding the breadth and depth of a topic no longer seems to be part of the Atlantic medical reporting. I originally typed the last sentence as the Atlantis medical reporting. Pity I have to change it; it seemed much more accurate the first time.
The Cochran review states, “Because of the moderate effectiveness of neuraminidase inhibitors, we believe they should not be used in routine control of seasonal influenza.” The first half of statement is a fact, the second half is opinion. The ‘we’ evidently being “Tom Jefferson, researcher, Mark Jones, statistician, Peter Doshi, doctoral student, Chris Del Mar, dean; coordinating editor of Cochrane Acute Respiratory Infections Group.” It is not a ‘we’ that I would use for deciding medical treatment. It is one thing to say that in healthy people from age 14 to 65 treatment is modestly effective, quite another to extrapolate that information to everyone, young and old, healthy and ill, pregnant or not.
If large populations are ill one less day during widespread disease, the positive effects of people returning to school and work can be enormous. Whether olsetamivir is worth the cost and the breeding of resistance requires a complicated cost-effective analysis that I will never understand.
In the Atlantic article they confuse the treatment of seasonal flu in studies in young(er) patients when there is some vaccine immunity and relatively low virulence with preparing for a new pandemic strain with no vaccine, and what appeared at first to be an fearsome mortality rate. In hindsight, now that we know the virulence of H1N1, we did not need to stockpile the oseltamivir for H1N1. If it had continued with the high mortality rate and, based on the studies mentioned above, we would be glad they stockpliled. And if avian flu becomes infectious while maintaining virulence, well, lets just say I am practicing not inhaling for a year.
Does oseltamivir prevent complications? Maybe. But that is not a primary endpoint in treating infections. You want to cure the patient, shorten the illness and prevent death. Oseltamivir does this. If it prevents complications, so much the better, but if it doesn’t I, and my patients, can live with that.
The Atlantic article partly concludes:
“There are a couple of take-home messages here. One is pretty obvious: Tamiflu may not be doing much good for patients with the flu who take it, and it might be causing harm.”
So disingenuous since this is not the conclusion of the Cochrane review. It depends on who you are treating and what strain. It seems that understanding nuance is not part of the Atlantic’s oeuvre. Or even reading the primary sources.
The other part of the Tamiflu kerfuffle is more difficult to discuss because it concerns information we do not have.
As the Cochran review alluded to the fact that they wanted to get original data about the ability of olsetamavir to prevent secondary complications of influenza but the company would not release the information. Note. Secondary complications. Pneumonia increases the risk of heart attack. Treating the pneumonia with penicillin does not prevent the heart attack, but that does not make the treatment of pneumonia less beneficial. Only living people can get a heart attack anyway.
“Attempts to deal with these shortcomings were unsuccessful: although three of five first authors of studies on oseltamivir treatment responded to our contact, none had original data and referred us to the manufacturer (Roche), which was not able to unconditionally provide the information as quickly as we needed it to update this review.”
But the Atlantic was more, well, descriptive
“The dog ate my homework
But when the Cochrane team, led by Chris Del Mar, from Bond University in Australia, re-examined the studies they had previously used in 2006, they found some discrepancies. It turned out that only two of the ten studies had ever been published in medical journals, and those two showed the drug had very little effect on complications compared to a dummy pill, or placebo. So the Cochrane reviewers decided to look at the data for themselves.
First they went to the lead authors of the published studies—the researchers who were supposed to have access to all of the data. One author said he had lost track of the data when he moved offices and the files appeared to have been discarded. The other said he’d never actually seen the data himself, and directed the Cochrane team to go directly to the company.
Four months and multiple requests later, the Cochrane researchers had a hodgepodge of data from the company, including two studies that showed the drug was ineffective, but which the company had never published. Roche also provided data from a third study, which involved 1,447 adults and adolescents aged 13-80, the largest study of the drug ever conducted. Yet the company never published that one either. (A summary of this and other studies is available at www.roche-trials.com). But with only partial data, the Cochrane team couldn’t even figure out what the study had been intended to measure.”
That is a problem.
One of things I have learned in blogging and podcasting is how limited and unimpressive meta-analysis and structured reviews are. They do pool the best studies. But often it seems that the process of choosing the studies, much important and relevant information is not considered. Most of infectious diseases is not based on randomized, placebo controlled trials and does not need to be. After reading the influenza Cochrane reviews I am starting to understand the point behind another BMJ meta-analysis. One would have to be a wackaloon at the most bizarre fringes of medicine to demand that I treat endocarditis or meningitis on the basis of such a trial. Other diseases? Not so much.
There is a bit of irony in the whole process. The first Cochrane review of oseltamivir that suggested benefit from oseltamivir was published in 2005.
One would have thought they knew what they were doing since the lead author is touted by the Atlantic as the master of the influenza literature.
Subsequently, a Japanese physician wanted to know more about the details of effect of oseltamivir on complications. Part of the data to demonstrate that oseltamivir is effective is from an article entitled “Impact of oseltamivir treatment on influenza-related lower respiratory tract complications and hospitalizations.” which was a summary of 10 unpublished trials done by the makers of olsetamivir. The review suggested that oseltamivir halved hospitalization.
The Cochrane review, which had used the published data in an earlier meta analysis, decided that they needed to be more rigorous this time. Why they didn’t bother, with their alleged mastery of the literature, to be this rigorous the first time I am uncertain, and it casts a sliver of doubt in my mind as to the rigorousness of the influenza vaccine meta-analysis, so touted in another Atlantic article discussed on this blog.
Turns out Roche tried their best to not release all the data. First they asked for the Cochrane reviewers to sign a non-disclosure contract, then said they were giving the information to another group instead. Why the majority of the studies were unpublished were explained by lame excuses.
“It begged the question: why were so many of the trials still unpublished and not easily accessible?
When the BMJ expressed concern to Roche that eight of 10 treatment trials were unpublished and therefore unverifiable by the general medical community, Roche said that the additional studies “provided little new information and would therefore be unlikely to be accepted for publication by most reputable journals.”
They also added that now it is standard practice for Roche to publish all its clinical trial data, but this was not standard policy within Roche or elsewhere within the industry seven to 10 years ago. “At the time, it was considered that the studies that were published (2 abstracts and 2 full manuscripts) reflected accurately the benefits of the drug,” they said.”
Good questions. Given the history of pharmaceutical companies hiding and obfuscating important data about their drugs, it would be nice if they released the data. Most drug studies are funded by pharmaceutical companies. Does that invalidate the study? No. A drug company study can be just as well done as one funded by an NIH grant. That outcomes will be slightly tilted in favor of the drug if it is funded by the company as compared to non drug company funded studies is recognized. Some studies are well done, some studies are little better than infomercials. In the end you have to read the literature, not the reviews. So I can’t comment on the validity of olsetamivir to prevent complications. Neither can the Cochrane review. Just the Atlantic, who concludes that it is all a mirage. So much sound and fury, signifying nothing.
Then, for each study, there is what the results of the study are, there is the spin put in the discussion, and finally the spin that the drug company reps put on the study when they show it to a doctor.
Kind of like a Cochrane review, huh?
The review says Tamiflu is modestly effective.
Yep.
The conclusion says “Because of the moderate effectiveness of neuraminidase inhibitors, we believe they should not be used in routine control of seasonal influenza.”
Fact, then Spin.
And the drug rep, er, I mean Atlantic says it is nearly worthless.
Lots of unjustified spin.
Remember the conclusion of the review, “Evidence for or against their benefit for preventing complications of influenza is insufficient.”
Pretty mild. The BMJ has an nice discussion on the information, as such as can be determined, from the studies on prevention. By themselves they showed no efficacy but did (may be) when combined. But with no access to the data, there remains uncertainty.
Do drug companies hide and spin important information? Do drug companies inflict bias into studies? Do drug companies influence doctors prescribing habits? Is homeopathy nothing but water?
Yes. It is why you need to consider the entire medical literature.
But to quote the ever helpful Dr. Hill
“All scientific work is incomplete, whether it be observational or experimental. All scientific work is liable to be upset or modified by advancing knowledge. That does not confer upon us a freedom to ignore the knowledge we already have, or to postpone the action that it appears to demand at a given time.”
Like evolution, there are multiple lines of evidence to demonstrate oseltamivir efficacy against influenza. When it should be used to get the most bang for the buck depends on the strain of influenza and the patient being treated. And when (not if) we get a pandemic influenza that is both highly infections and highly virulent, I hope we will have a drug like olsetamivir. It will not be a panacea, like penicillin for syphilis. But it will keep some people alive who would otherwise die. The Atlantic concludes
“The more important issue, however, involves the need for trust in science and medicine. Governments, public health agencies, and international bodies such as the World Health Organization, have all based their decisions to recommend and stockpile Tamiflu on studies that had seemed independent, but had in fact been funded by the company and were authored almost entirely by Roche employees or paid academic consultants. So did the Cochrane Collaboration, at least in its earlier assessments of Tamiflu. Millions of flu patients have taken the drug as a result.”
We also need the 4th estate to write and publish quality articles on science and medicine and not go for the easy story of good and bad and obscure importance detail in inflammatory prose. It would be nice if the 4th estate took the time to, oh, maybe actually understand the nuances involved in influenza prevention and treatment. The Atlantic is 0 for 2 with their reporting on influenza. At least I get a topic to write about, and, like their spiritual colleagues Dr. Mercola and The Natural News, the worse the reporting, the better the blog.

   Yes, But. The Annotated Atlantic.
Mark Crislip
Link
The Atlantic recently published an article called “Does the Vaccine Matter?.” The quick answer is “yes”. If you want to know more, keep reading. They concluded, based on a narrow interpretation of a small subset of the data, that vaccines probably do not matter. The tone suggests that the vaccine is a vast boondoggle perpetuated on the American people by frightened doctors and greedy pharmaceutical companies. At least that is my take on the article, your mileage may vary. Lets look at that article, and its review of the influenza vaccine, and see whatthe authors say, how they say it, and, perhaps more importantly, what they don’t say.
Unfortunately, I do not have a good story to tell with protagonists and antagonists and lone voices protesting the evil medical industrial complex. I don’t have a morality tale to tell, with good guys and bad guys. I have the medical literature, with its numbers and uncertainties and nuance. I also have patients I have to treat and have to apply the medical literature to as best I can.
This entry may be a bit of a repetition for those who read my previous entry on vaccine efficacy, but my entry hit the blogosphere a few days before the Atlantic article, so I did not get a chance to incorporate it into my entry.
Let us go through the article paragraph at a time, with commentary as needed. The bold is from the Atlantic. There is a logical fallacy called Argue By Demanding Impossible Perfection. I wonder why I mention that (bold text from the Atlantic) …
Drive too fast along Red Lion Road, beside Philadelphia’s Northeast Airport, and you will miss the low-rise cement building where the biotech company MedImmune has been quietly pumping out swine flu vaccine at about a million doses a week. Through the summer and fall, workers wearing protective gear that covered them from head to toe brewed up batches of live, genetically modified flu virus. Robots then injected tiny doses of virus-laden fluid into glass vials, which were mounted into nasal spritzers, labeled, and readied for shipment at the direction of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, in Atlanta, which is helping to coordinate the nation’s pandemic-preparedness plan. In the most ambitious vaccination program the nation has mounted since the anti-polio campaign in the 1950s, the federal government has commissioned MedImmune and four other companies to produce enough vaccine to cover the entire U.S. population.
Vaccination is central to the government’s plan for preventing deaths from swine flu. The CDC has recommended that some 159 million adults and children receive either a swine flu shot or a dose of MedImmune’s nasal vaccine this year. Shots are offered in doctors’ offices, hospitals, airports, pharmacies, schools, polling places, shopping malls, and big-box stores like Wal-Mart. In August, New York state required all health-care workers to get both seasonal and swine flu shots. To further protect the populace, the federal government has spent upwards of $3 billion stockpiling millions of doses of antiviral drugs like Tamiflu–which are being used both to prevent swine flu and to treat those who fall ill.
Paragraphs one and two set the scene. Vaccines are important. Already I am uncertain as to the content. Yes, the US wants to dispense 159 million
H1N1 vaccines to decrease the morbidity and mortality from swine flu. But swine flu shots are not yet available at the time this was published, just seasonal flu. Watch as you read the article as the authors bounce from swine flu to seasonal flu to treatment to death to prevention and often fail to be precise as to what they are referring to. And, as I tell the residents, precision of thought manifests as precision of speech and writing, he says setting himself up for a huge fall in the comments. I now wait for that shoe to drop. At least I am not going to make a grammar complaint. That would lead to certain sarcasm in the comments.
But what if everything we think we know about fighting influenza is wrong? What if flu vaccines do not protect people from dying–particularly the elderly, who account for 90 percent of deaths from seasonal flu?
What if the 14,400 plus influenza vaccine articles on Pubmed are wrong, all the biology and virology and pharmacology and clinical trials about influenza are wrong? What if every brick in the wall was an illusion and the edifice of flu treatment is wrong. What if a few brave souls can see the real truth. I look forward to a review of the 50 years of influenza research in all its complexity. It’s a huge literature, with multiple lines of evidence all converging on the conclusion that vaccines and antivirals are effective against influenza. Because I would hate to make decisions based on the opinions of a few people reading a narrow sampling of the literature.
And which is it? Is EVERYTHING wrong? Everything? Or the narrow issue of mortality prevention. The articles starts with everything, but focuses on vaccine preventable mortality and, to a lessor extent, the efficacy of Tamiflu. Does the vaccine prevent death in the elderly? That is not as simple a question to answer as you would think. Here is where the nuance comes in.
Here are possible outcomes of receiving the flu vaccine:
Patient A doesn’t get flu. Life continues.
Patient A gets the flu, but has a milder case and doesn’t die directly of flu.
Patient A gets the flu, but has a milder case and doesn’t go on to die of complications of flu, like a secondary infection or worsening heart failure.
But perhaps of equal importance, under all three possibilities, patient A is less likely to pass on the disease to the next person who may not have immunity and then could die of flu or its secondary complications.
Key point: with highly contagious diseases, you try and prevent or ameliorate disease in individuals, but one of the effects is the prevention or amelioration of disease in populations. You try for herd immunity, which, because you need a vaccination every year, we are not even close to achieving. So, for example, you have a large population that does not get a reliable response to the vaccine. Like the elderly. And the elderly are constantly exposed to a population that has the flu because of lack of vaccination: the community, for them (the elderly) the effect of flu vaccination will be less than one might like. And it is an important issue in evaluating flu vaccine efficacy in the elderly and makes the epidemiologic data always less robust than we would like.
“And what if the expensive antiviral drugs that the government has stockpiled over the past few years also have little, if any, power to reduce the number of people who die or are hospitalized.”
What if? Well,
“Two data sets were presented at the second European Influenza Conference in Malta (www.eswi.org) in September. A large retrospective cohort study of patients with influenza-like illness (n = 176001) taken from a US health database showed that oseltamivir (75 mg twice daily, n = 39 202) significantly reduced the risks of pneumonia by 32% (P <0.001) and of death by 91% (P < 0.05) (Nordstrom et al).
In Canadian patients with laboratory-confirmed influenza (A or B) requiring hospital admission (< 15- > 64 years; n = 359), oseltamivir reduced the risk of death by 68% (McGeer et al). Treatment with oseltamivir therefore statistically and meaningfully reduces the risk of death in patients of all ages and from all walks of life, infected with influenza A or B. (16293852).”
Whew. At least we do not have to worry about oseltamivir efficacy. It is important to remember that antivirals are nowhere near as good as antibacterials and efficacy is always less than 100%. But decreasing risk of death by 68%? When I have a patient being admitted with severe influenza, 68% is a lot better than nothing. Of course, one of the thrusts of the article, as we will see, is that the only trial upon which we can make decisions is the randomized, placebo controlled trial. It is the best data, but not the only data.
The U.S. government–with the support of leaders in the public-health and medical communities–has put its faith in the power of vaccines and antiviral drugs to limit the spread and lethality of swine flu.
It is not faith, it is a reliance on the data, with all its problems and uncertainties. But as we go through the paper, remember in complex diseases and their treatment, it is the preponderance of data that guides what we do. Medical knowledge is cumulative and changing and rarely has a simple binary, yes/no, black/white, answer. Almost always the answer starts with a “it depends on.”
Other plans to contain the pandemic seem anemic by comparison.
Plans like let people get the flu and suffer and die? Shut down society for three months? For pandemic H1N1, short of telling the population to stay home and don’t go out for the next three months, or not inhaling for the next three months, there are not a lot of other good options. One of the issues we worry about in pandemic flu is how the hospital is going to function if there is no one to make and deliver all the supplies it takes to keep our doors open. Your household probably has the same issues. When a third of everyone stays home, just who is going to get the food to the store, much less to your larder? What happens to essential services? Police, fire, ambulance drivers, bartenders and brewers? We need these people.
“Yet some top flu researchers are deeply skeptical of both flu vaccines and antivirals. Like the engineers who warned for years about the levees of New Orleans, these experts caution that our defenses may be flawed, and quite possibly useless against a truly lethal flu.”
I am already confused. Is this about seasonal flu? H1N1 pandemic flu? Or a repeat of the highly virulent H1N1 flu of 1918 that killed maybe 5% of the world, which we appear to have avoided this time around? Remember the “it depends on” mentioned a few paragraphs ago? Already the “it depends on” is being obscured. The response needed for seasonal flu is not the same as needed for a highly lethal pandemic, and, as H1N1 progresses, we are learning the differences between it and seasonal flu. There is a difference in the response to a flu that kills 36,000 elderly each year, a flu that kills 30,000 (maybe) children and pregnant women, and a flu that kills 5% of everyone.
And that unless we are willing to ask fundamental questions about the science behind flu vaccines and antiviral drugs, we could find ourselves, in a bad epidemic, as helpless as the citizens of New Orleans during Hurricane Katrina.
I am getting increasingly pumped. A good review of the entire flu literature appears to be in the offing. Because if you cherry pick and focus on one or two papers, no matter how well done, you can make any argument you choose. And that would be a disservice to everyone.
Then as now, flu seemed to appear out of nowhere each winter, debilitating or killing large numbers of people, only to vanish in the spring. Today, seasonal flu is estimated to kill about 36,000 people in the United States each year, and half a million worldwide.
Yet the flu, in many important respects, remains mysterious. Determining how many deaths it really causes, or even who has it, is no simple matter.
No simple matter. Watch for the later, 
“Demonstrating the efficacy (or lack thereof) of vaccine and antivirals during flu season would not be hard to do, given the proper resources. Take a group of people who are at risk of getting the flu, and randomly assign half to get vaccine and the other half a dummy shot. Then count the people in each group who come down with flu, suffer serious illness, or die.”
Rather than not being ‘simple’, such a determination ‘would not be hard to do’, which is, I guess, different than simple. It is not simple, I agree, which is why I discuss it on this site.
We think we have the flu anytime we fall ill with an ailment that brings on headache, malaise, fever, coughing, sneezing, and that achy feeling as if we’ve been sleeping on a bed of rocks,
I do like the phrase sleeping on a bed of rocks and I fully intend to steal it for talks. I usually say you feel like you have been pummeled all over by a small hammer, but I prefer their description.
but researchers have found that at most half, and perhaps as few as 7 or 8 percent, of such cases are actually caused by an influenza virus in any given year. More than 200 known viruses and other pathogens can cause the suite of symptoms known as “influenza-like illness”; respiratory syncytial virus, bocavirus, coronavirus, and rhinovirus are just a few of the bugs that can make a person feel rotten. And depending on the season, in up to two-thirds of the cases of flu-like illness, no cause at all can be found.
No problems with this. It is the frustrating problem for those of us in the medical trenches: we can rarely diagnose quickly and inexpensively, those self-limited infections that are life-inconveniencing, but not-life threatening. Is the flu? Which can kill and infected others? Or a less potentially fatal disease?
Nobody knows precisely why we are much more likely to catch the flu in the winter months than at other times of the year. Perhaps it’s because flu viruses flourish in cool temperatures and are killed by exposure to sunlight. Or maybe it’s because in winter, people spend more time indoors, where a sneeze or a cough can more easily spread a virus to others. What is certain is that influenza viruses mutate with amazing speed, so each flu season sees slightly different genetic versions of the viruses that infected people the year before. Every year, the World Health Organization and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention collect data from 94 nations on the flu viruses that circulated the previous year, and then make an educated guess about which viruses are likely to circulate in the coming fall. Based on that information, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration issues orders to manufacturers in February for a vaccine that includes the three most likely strains.
This, of course, is one of the three problems with the influenza vaccine that make determining efficacy difficult. The match between the circulating strain and what is in the vaccine is often less than perfect. The better the match between the vaccine and strain, the better the vaccine protection. And, as the virus mutates further and further away from the vaccine strain as the flu season progresses, it becomes more likely that the effect of the vaccine will be to cause a milder disease in the vaccinee but still, hopefully, lead to less likely spread of the disease.
Another problem with the vaccine is that those who need it most are least likely to not respond to the vaccine. More on that later.
The third problem is that the flu vaccine is, in part, a vaccine that gets more bang for the buck as the vaccination rates increase in populations. Unfortunately, we never get a large percentage of the population vaccinated. The best results, as the Ontario experience demonstrates, show that as vaccination rates increase for everyone, morbidity and mortality declines in the population. A rising tide, as they used to say, lifts all boats.
Every once in a while, however, a very different bug pops up and infects far more people than the normal seasonal flu variants do. It is these novel viruses that are responsible for pandemics, defined by the World Health Organization as events that occur when “a new influenza virus appears against which the human population has no immunity” and which can sweep around the world in a very short time. The worst flu pandemic in recorded history was the “Spanish flu” of 1918-19, at the end of World War I. A third of the world’s population was infected, with at least 40 million and perhaps as many as 100 million people dying–more than were killed in World Wars I and II combined. (Some scholars suggest that one reason World War I ended was that so many soldiers were sick or dying from flu.) Since then, two other flu pandemics have occurred, in 1957 and 1968, neither of which was particularly lethal.
Public Health and infectious disease specialists have been worrying a repeat of the 1918 influenza pandemic. It is why the concern with the bird flu, which, while lethal in humans (66% mortality), is not easily spread human to human. When H1N1 hit in Mexico last spring, it wan not known if the flu would be mild or fatal, although the preliminary Mexican mortality rates looked worrisome, those rates have not been repeated in the industrialized world.
Those in charge of preparing for pandemics or outbreaks always have two choices: over prepare and look like a fool if the pandemic does not occur or under prepare and look incompetent if the pandemic does occur. And make no mistake, if there is a fatal pandemic the repeats the 1918 experience, there will be no way to prepare, and those in charge, no matter what they do, will look like incompetent fools.
In August, the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology projected that this fall and winter, the swine flu, H1N1, could infect anywhere between one-third and one-half of the U.S. population and could kill as many as 90,000 Americans, two and a half times the number killed in a typical flu season. But precisely how deadly, or even how infectious, this year’s H1N1 pandemic will turn out to be won’t be known until it’s over.
So what should they do? Prepare for worst case? Prepare for best case and hope that H1N1 isn’t all that bad? Something in between? I always have sympathy for those in charge of pandemic planning. No matter what decision is made, it will probably be the wrong one.
Most reports coming from the Southern Hemisphere in late August (the end of winter there) suggested that the swine flu is highly infectious, but not particularly lethal. For example, Australian officials estimated they would finish winter with under 1,000 swine flu deaths–fewer than the usual 1,500 to 3,000 from seasonal flu. Among those who have died in the U.S., about 70 percent were already suffering from congenital conditions like cerebral palsy or underlying illnesses such as cancer, asthma, or AIDS, which make people more vulnerable.
For example, the US has 13x the population of Australia, so that would be, hmmmmm, maybe 13,000 deaths in the US. As I write this it is healthy children and pregnant woman who have the greatest odds of dying of H1N1.
There is always that implication that those who died, well, were not worth saving. They were due to die. Culling the herd, they were sick and their time was up. Cancer, cerebral palsy, AIDS, well, they were supposed to dance with the reaper. They had a reason to die. I know the authors did not mean it that way, but it still rankles. I hear the same reasoning when we review hospital acquired infections and deaths: the patient often has numerous comorbid conditions that made the infection or death more likely. That does not stop us from asking what could we have done differently to have prevented the death. That the patient had an increased risk of death is not an excuse for a preventable illness or death.
It’s the same when people say flu kills ‘only’ x number of people. I had a flu-related death in a young person with no underlying medical problems this week. That patient was not an “only”. But as someone who is often partially responsible for the critically ill, I always have a habit of personalizing deaths.
“The moral test of a government (and a health care system I will add) is how it treats those who are at the dawn of life, the children; those who are in the twilight of life, the aged; and those who are in the shadow of life, the sick and the needy, and the handicapped.” – Hubert Humphrey.
If this was a multiple choice test, I would say we might have pulled a D.
Public-health officials consider vaccine their most formidable defense against the pandemic–indeed, against any flu–and on the surface, their faith seems justified.
That’s right. Over 14,000 references on the flu vaccine covering the all aspects of the disease and forming multiple lines of evidence all converging on the efficacy of the vaccine is a superficial, surface reality. But underneath the surface we have to look for the truth THEY don’t want us to know. Sorry. That’s Kevin Trudeau’s line.
Back to pandemic, i.e. swine, flu, although we are going to jump to seasonal flu in a moment. What is different about H1N1 is that no one has immunity. There is a huge population of susceptible people, maybe 60% of the population, that can get this disease, and influenza often has a 20-30% attack rate for susceptible people. So it should go through the country like grass through a goose. From a disease causing/biologic/immunologic point of view, it’s the same old same old. It is just another strain of flu, we just have an enormous number of people who can get this strain. There is no reason to suspect that if we can induce a good response to the viral hemagglutinin (the H) and the neuraminidase (the N) with the vaccine that people should not be protected from H1N1. Historically, when we have a good match with the flu and vaccine we get great protection from acquiring the flu.
Vaccines developed over the course of the 20th century slashed the death rates of nearly a dozen infectious diseases, such as smallpox and polio, and vaccination became one of medicine’s most potent weapons. Influenza virus was first identified in the 1930s, and by the mid-1940s, researchers had produced a vaccine that was given to soldiers in World War II. The U.S. government got serious about promoting flu vaccine after the 1957 flu pandemic brought home influenza’s continuing potential to cause widespread illness and death. Today, flu vaccine is a staple of public-health policy; in a normal year, some 100 million Americans get vaccinated.
Yep. Less than a third. Not enough. That is part of the problem. Herd immunity depends on the vaccine and the organism, but as a rule of thumb when vaccination rates fall below 90% herd immunity fails.
But while vaccines for, say, whooping cough and polio clearly and dramatically reduced death rates from those diseases, the impact of flu vaccine has been harder to determine.
No, it hasn’t. As we will see, the impact of flu vaccine has been demonstrated in numerous studies. If the end point is death, and that is the only end point you are interested in, then the data is not as clear cut as one would like. But the beneficial impact of flu vaccination is there, in the literature (the scientific literature, not a novel, which is a different kind of literature, not usually used as evidence).
If you only looked at deaths that air bags prevented, it would also not be as impressive than if you included the injuries and expense benefits of air bags. Vaccines have multitudinous benefits. Most of all the vaccine prevents people from getting the flu. There are numerous placebo controlled trials in various populations to demonstrate decreased acquisition of flu by those who receive the vaccine. I reviewed this in detail in the vaccine efficacy post, complete with references.
Flu comes and goes with the seasons, and often it does not kill people directly, but rather contributes to death by making the body more susceptible to secondary infections like pneumonia or bronchitis. For this reason, researchers studying the impact of flu vaccination typically look at deaths from all causes during flu season, and compare the vaccinated and unvaccinated populations.
Such comparisons have shown a dramatic difference in mortality between these two groups: study after study has found that people who get a flu shot in the fall are about half as likely to die that winter–from any cause–as people who do not. Get your flu shot each year, the literature suggests, and you will dramatically reduce your chance of dying during flu season.
Yet in the view of several vaccine skeptics, this claim is suspicious on its face. Influenza causes only a small minority of all deaths in the U.S., even among senior citizens, and even after adding in the deaths to which flu might have contributed indirectly. When researchers from the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases included all deaths from illnesses that flu aggravates, like lung disease or chronic heart failure, they found that flu accounts for, at most, 10 percent of winter deaths among the elderly. So how could flu vaccine possibly reduce total deaths by half?
Welcome to the difficulties of clinical medicine. Conflicting studies. Different methodologies in different populations studied at different times have, what the?, different results. You mean there is variability in clinical trials? Water is wet? Fire is hot? What next? Crap. I guess I will have to read all the studies, compare and contrast them, and come to some conclusion. Or I could ask, say, Tom Jefferson.
Tom Jefferson, a physician based in Rome and the head of the Vaccines Field at the Cochrane Collaboration, a highly respected international network of researchers who appraise medical evidence, says: “For a vaccine to reduce mortality by 50 percent and up to 90 percent in some studies means it has to prevent deaths not just from influenza, but also from falls, fires, heart disease, strokes, and car accidents. That’s not a vaccine, that’s a miracle.”
Well, I doubt fires were a major cause of death in the elderly, but stroke and heart attacks are a well described long term complication of infections, perhaps due to inducing a long term pro-thrombotic effect, as I discussed in the Boost your Immune system post. If people get the flu vaccine they will be healthier and less likely to fall, break a hip, and die. They will be less likely, since they are healthy, to fall asleep with a lit cigarette and die in a house fire. If people get the flu vaccine and they have less complications and exacerbations of underlying diseases, and as a result they will be driving to their doctors less often, so yes, he continues only a little sarcastically, they would be less likely to die in car accidents. Aspirin is the wonder drug that works wonders, perhaps the vaccine is the miracle drug that works miracles. The point, of course, is there are a lot of indirect benefits to being healthy. There are always numerous confounders that are hard to control for.
The estimate of 50 percent mortality reduction is based on “cohort studies,” which compare death rates in large groups, or cohorts, of people who choose to be vaccinated, against death rates in groups who don’t. But people who choose to be vaccinated may differ in many important respects from people who go unvaccinated–and those differences can influence the chance of death during flu season. Education, lifestyle, income, and many other “confounding” factors can come into play, and as a result, cohort studies are notoriously prone to bias. When researchers crunch the numbers, they typically try to factor out variables that could bias the results, but, as Jefferson remarks, “you can adjust for the confounders you know about, not for the ones you don’t,” and researchers can’t always anticipate what factors are likely to be important to whether a patient dies from flu. There is always the chance that they might miss some critical confounder that renders their results entirely wrong.
And there is always the chance that you DID NOT miss an unknown confounder that renders the results entirely wrong. There is the chance that “study after study” is wrong. Which is why you need to rely on multiple lines of evidence for vaccine efficacy.
What is the source of the figure of 50% mortality reduction? As written it sounds impressive. I am sure I am about to get my ass handed to me as I discuss statistics, but I read Atlantic quote as an absolute decrease in mortality. But the numbers, when you look at the NEJM article, are a relative risk reduction to get the 50% decrease in mortality.
Of those who died, there were fewer vaccinated than unvaccinated who died. That is a flu of a different color.
From the NEJM, the most reliable source of medical dogma,
“There were 713,872 person-seasons of observation. Vaccinated subjects were slightly older and had higher prevalence rates of all the baseline medical conditions except dementia or stroke ”
“During the 10 influenza seasons, there were 4599 hospitalizations for pneumonia or influenza and 8796 deaths. The observed hospitalization rates for unvaccinated and for vaccinated participants were, on average, 0.7% and 0.6% per season, respectively, with corresponding death rates of 1.6% and 1.0% per season.”
“Influenza vaccination was associated on average with substantial reductions in hospitalizations for pneumonia and for influenza (vaccine effectiveness, 27%; adjusted odds ratio, 0.73; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.68 to 0.77) and in death (vaccine effectiveness, 48%; adjusted odds ratio, 0.52; 95% CI, 0.50 to 0.55). Estimates varied from season to season and across the 18 cohorts (Fig. 2). In the two seasons with a poor match between the vaccine and the virus strain, vaccine effectiveness was lower for reducing death (in seasons with a poor match, vaccine effectiveness was 37% [ad- justed odds ratio, 0.63; 95% CI, 0.57 to 0.69]; in seasons with a good match, vaccine effectiveness was 52% [adjusted odds ratio, 0.48; 95% CI, 0.46 to 0.51]) but not for reducing hospitalization.”
The study points out vaccine efficacy is variable and that
“Our inclusion criteria were designed to minimize the possibility of survivor bias, and we did not find evidence for a healthy-vaccinee effect in our analyses. Nevertheless, residual confounding may have influenced our results, and our sensitivity analyses indicate how our estimates of vaccine effectiveness would be lower, though still significant, after adjustment for the effect of a strong hypothetical unmeasured confounder.”
So anyone who reads this literature reads it with a grain of salt substitute. Part of the problem, I would suspect, is 50% is just such a nice number. I would speculate that it became part of the medical culture, like 98.6 being normal temperature, easy to remember, but not absolutely true. You know, “it depends”.
I will confess that until I read the Atlantic, I had never heard of 50% as an absolute number. I recognize, as do my colleagues, that all flu vaccine efficacy statistics depends on “it depends” and are therefore not clear cut.
The most recent edition of the standard ID text, Mandell, Douglas and Bennett, has this to say about the flu vaccine in the elderly:
“Relatively few prospective trials of protective efficacy have been conducted in high-risk populations. In one placebo-controlled prospective trial in an older adult population, inactivated vaccine was approximately 58% effective in preventing laboratory-documented influenza. In addition, numerous retrospective case-control studies are available that have documented the effectiveness of inactivated influenza vaccines in older adults. Vaccine is protective against influenza- and pneumonia-related hospitalization in older adults, and it is accompanied by a decrease in all-cause mortality… Vaccine has also been shown to be protective in limited studies in other high-risk groups, including those with HIV infection.
It has recently been shown that inactivated vaccine administered to older adults and persons with coronary artery disease can reduce the rates of coronary events or stroke during the influenza season.”
No 50% there.
I also went to the CDC site, and no 50% there either.
At IDSA national meeting last week I went to a talk on communicating vaccine safety and one of the panel members mentioned the importance of not qualifying the issue of vaccine safety with phrases like the ‘data show no association between vaccine and autism’ which is a different message than ‘vaccines do not cause autism’. Give, we were told, clear cut, declarative statements without ambiguity or qualifiers. Which I find hard to do. Medicine is all about ambiguity and qualifiers.
I am struck by the ‘damned if you do damned if you don’t’ disadvantage that we SBM-oriented folks have. The anti-science goofs can simply repeat lies over and over. Vaccines cause autism. If I use the qualifiers and look at the nuance, I seem like an equivocating weasel. If I decide to use a simple message, like flu vaccines prevent death by 50%, I look like a lying shill for the medical industrial complex. But I doubt that the authors would resort to the ‘doctors are evil shills of the medical industrial complex’ gambit; that kind of characterization would be so cheesy in a reputable periodical.
But if you have a story tell, it is best to avoid the known qualifiers, nuance, and subtleties and set up a straw man you can beat like a mule. So, I suppose, it would be a straw mule argument.
When Lisa Jackson, a physician and senior investigator with the Group Health Research Center, in Seattle, began wondering aloud to colleagues if maybe something was amiss with the estimate of 50 percent mortality reduction for people who get flu vaccine, the response she got sounded more like doctrine than science. “People told me, ‘No good can come of [asking] this,’” she says. “‘Potentially a lot of bad could happen’ for me professionally by raising any criticism that might dissuade people from getting vaccinated, because of course, ‘We know that vaccine works.’ This was the prevailing wisdom.”
Nonetheless, in 2004, Jackson and three colleagues set out to determine whether the mortality difference between the vaccinated and the unvaccinated might be caused by a phenomenon known as the “healthy user effect.” They hypothesized that on average, people who get vaccinated are simply healthier than those who don’t, and thus less liable to die over the short term. People who don’t get vaccinated may be bedridden or otherwise too sick to go get a shot. They may also be more likely to succumb to flu or any other illness, because they are generally older and sicker. To test their thesis, Jackson and her colleagues combed through eight years of medical data on more than 72,000 people 65 and older. They looked at who got flu shots and who didn’t. Then they examined which group’s members were more likely to die of any cause when it was not flu season.
Jackson’s findings showed that outside of flu season, the baseline risk of death among people who did not get vaccinated was approximately 60 percent higher than among those who did, lending support to the hypothesis that on average, healthy people chose to get the vaccine, while the “frail elderly” didn’t or couldn’t.
Or it could be that the pleomorphic benefits of flu vaccination last longer than we suppose and extend beyond the flu season.
In fact, the healthy-user effect explained the entire benefit that other researchers were attributing to flu vaccine, suggesting that the vaccine itself might not reduce mortality at all. Jackson’s papers “are beautiful,” says Lone Simonsen, who is a professor of global health at George Washington University, in Washington, D.C., and an internationally recognized expert in influenza and vaccine epidemiology. “They are classic studies in epidemiology, they are so carefully done.”
The results were also so unexpected that many experts simply refused to believe them. Jackson’s papers were turned down for publication in the top-ranked medical journals. One flu expert who reviewed her studies for the Journal of the American Medical Association wrote, “To accept these results would be to say that the earth is flat!” When the papers were finally published in 2006, in the less prominent International Journal of Epidemiology, they were largely ignored by doctors and public-health officials. “The answer I got,” says Jackson, “was not the right answer.”
The Jackson article is a good and interesting paper. If the JAMA reviewer rejected it solely said the reason iof the statement quoted above, that would indeed be appalling. I hope that the editors of JAMA not use her services again to review a paper. If it was rejected on that basis, then JAMA has some serious editorial issues. It would be of interest to see the entire text from all the reviewers. As a rule, reviewers are a wee bit more detailed in the reasons behind their rejection. Of course, if it were rejected by JAMA based on a detailed critique that concluded with the flat world statement, that would not make for a story of good and bad. But I am old school. I like to see the full text from which quotes are taken. I doubt a reputable periodical like the Atlantic would take quotes out of context to mislead readers. That would not be responsible.
There are problems with the Jackson study but it is not the results.
One, it is an outlier, and outliers need confirmation. The preponderance of all the literature suggests that influenza vaccine prevents disease and death. If you do not get flu, you can’t die from flu or flu related illnesses. When outliers are published, people read them, think “huh, that’s interesting”, but there is going to have to be more than one contradictory study to change my practice. But if “study after study” shows mortality benefit, and one study does not, it is food for thought, but not necessarily the basis of changing practice. The results, above all, needs to be repeated by others on a different population with the same methods. In medicine we tend to be conservative about changing practice unless there is a preponderance of data to suggest a change is reasonable. Except, of course, if our big pharma overlords take us to a good streak house.
As a fellow, I read the reports of H. pylorii causing gastritis and ulcer that were starting to trickle in and, contrary to popular myth, I can remember discussing these article with my attending, a diarrhea expert. The attitude was, interesting, lets see if future data supports it. The myth that it was rejected and scorned has been discussed elsewhere.
The other annoying aspect is the division of mortality effect into a red state/blue state divide. Again with the binary. Medical results, especially epidemiological data, is always moving as data collection and analysis are refined. At 25 I was told that half of everything I learned in medical school would be proven wrong, the problem is that I would not know which half.
When I read the Jackson article and the NEJM article back to back, I am left with the question not of yes/no as to mortality, but instead wondering what the magnitude of the effect is. Given all the other data on influenza vaccine efficacy, I have trouble abandoning vaccination of the elderly based on one epidemiologic study. Some day it may come to that, but not yet. Not enough data.
As Jackson said in the discussion, “We found the greatest reductions in the risk of death and of pneumonia hospitalization in the period before influenza season, when there should be no true vaccine effect.”
I am also not so sure that is true. The pro-thrombotic effects of infections can last for a year, as I discussed in the boost your immune system post, with a resultant increase in stroke, heart attack and pulmonary embolism, the first two accounting for significant mortality in the elderly. The effects of not getting the flu because you were vaccinated could persist a year, so I am not so sanguine the mortality effects of the vaccine would not be demonstrable longer than anticipated. That is one alternative explanation for the results and there may be others. Which means, of course, we need more studies. And it means the answer is not as clear as one would like.
The history of flu vaccination suggests other reasons to doubt claims that it dramatically reduces mortality. In 2004, for example, vaccine production fell behind, causing a 40 percent drop in immunization rates. Yet mortality did not rise. In addition, vaccine “mismatches” occurred in 1968 and 1997: in both years, the vaccine that had been produced in the summer protected against one set of viruses, but come winter, a different set was circulating. In effect, nobody was vaccinated. Yet death rates from all causes, including flu and the various illnesses it can exacerbate, did not budge. Sumit Majumdar, a physician and researcher at the University of Alberta, in Canada, offers another historical observation: rising rates of vaccination of the elderly over the past two decades have not coincided with a lower overall mortality rate. In 1989, only 15 percent of people over age 65 in the U.S. and Canada were vaccinated against flu. Today, more than 65 percent are immunized. Yet death rates among the elderly during flu season have increased rather than decreased.
This does not surprise me, as people get older and more frail they are less likely to respond to the vaccine. Unfortunately, depending on the host and the vaccine match, getting the vaccine does not mean the patient will be protected from disease. The vaccine mediated mortality effects on the elderly may not be as robust as we would like, depending on the subset of elderly vaccinated.
One issue not addressed is whether the deaths are shifted. Everyone dies eventually, and I have always wondered if the the vaccine just shifted when everyone dies. But the rates stay the same, they mortality wave has moved downstream. I am sure I will get smacked for that statement.
Vaccine proponents call Majumdar’s last observation an “ecological fallacy,” because he fails, in their view, to consider changes in the larger environment that could have boosted death rates over the years–even as rising vaccination rates were doing their part to keep mortality in check. The proponents suggest, for instance, that influenza viruses may have become more contagious over time, and thus are infecting greater numbers of elderly people, including some who have been vaccinated. Or maybe the viruses are becoming more lethal. Or maybe the elderly have less immunity to flu than they once did because, say, their diets have changed.
Or maybe vaccine just doesn’t prevent deaths in the elderly. Of course, that’s the one possibility that vaccine adherents won’t consider. Nancy Cox, the CDC’s influenza division chief, says flatly, “The flu vaccine is the best way to protect against flu.” Anthony Fauci, a physician and the director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases at the NIH, where much of the basic science of flu vaccine has been worked out, says, “I have no doubt that it is effective in conferring some degree of protection. To say otherwise is a minority view.”
The flu vaccine IS the best way of protecting yourself against the flu. Except for living in a bubble with no human contact. And it is effective in conferring SOME degree of protection. Both statements are as true as a scientist can make them. I think it is something we all consider: what is the degree of effectiveness and in what subgroups. Any thoughtful physician, when taking care of a patient, asks how best to apply population data to the individual sitting in the office. Note, by the way, none of the vaccine adherents are saying a 50% decrease in mortality.
Majumdar says, “We keep coming up against the belief that we’ve reduced mortality by 50 percent,” and when researchers poke holes in the evidence, “people pound the pulpit.”
I can just see the preacher up there extorting the congregation: “I have no doubt that it is effective in conferring some degree of protection. To say otherwise is a minority view.” Ooohhhhhhh. That’s what I call fire and brimstone preaching. I have admit that in 25 years of infectious disease, I have not seen any pulpit pounding over the flu vaccine. Perhaps I have attended the wrong talks, and I suspect that PowerPoint, the preferred method of education, prevents pulpit pounding.
The most vocal–and undoubtedly most vexing–critic of the gospel of flu vaccine is the Cochrane Collaboration’s Jefferson, who’s also an epidemiologist trained at the famed London School of Tropical Hygiene, and who, in Lisa Jackson’s view, makes other skeptics seem “moderate by comparison.” Among his fellow flu researchers, Jefferson’s outspokenness has made him something of a pariah. At a 2007 meeting on pandemic preparedness at a hotel in Bethesda, Maryland, Jefferson, who’d been invited to speak at the conference, was not greeted by any of the colleagues milling about the lobby. He ate his meals in the hotel restaurant alone, surrounded by scientists chatting amiably at other tables. He shrugs off such treatment. As a medical officer working for the United Nations in 1992, during the siege of Sarajevo, he and other peacekeepers were captured and held for more than a month by militiamen brandishing AK-47s and reeking of alcohol. Professional shunning seems trivial by comparison, he says.
Yep. People are jerks. However, this is a story of a few lone, brave voices in the wilderness, their voices unheard by the Man. It really is not about the literature, so I suppose the Man is going to overreact.
“Tom Jefferson has taken a lot of heat just for saying, ‘Here’s the evidence: it’s not very good,’” says Majumdar. “The reaction has been so dogmatic and even hysterical that you’d think he was advocating stealing babies.” Yet while other flu researchers may not like what Jefferson has to say, they cannot ignore the fact that he knows the flu-vaccine literature better than anyone else on the planet.
It is not a matter of like, as if it were personal preference, like choosing a style of beer. I disagree with Dr. Jefferson’s conclusions from reading the literature. I appreciate his analysis, agree with his criticisms, but I, and many others, think his conclusions are wrong. The Atlantic makes it sound as if people agree with his conclusions yet ignore them. If I disagree with someones conclusions, I am hardly going to act on them.
He leads an international team of researchers who have combed through hundreds of flu-vaccine studies. The vast majority of the studies were deeply flawed, says Jefferson. “Rubbish is not a scientific term, but I think it’s the term that applies.”
Rubbish? No. Not perfect? Yep. Welcome to the real world. Again this binary approach: either the data is perfect or its rubbish. I am just a clinician who spends most of my time taking care of people with infections. Trying to decide how much morbidity and cost you want to inflict on a patient before you have enough data to make a diagnostic and therapeutic decision is not easy. I could, as an example, probably diagnose every pneumonia by sending every patient off for an open lung biopsy and combining it with 1000′s of dollars of diagnostic testing. But to what end? In the real world one has to be satisfied with diagnostic uncertainty, especially if you feel that you are not missing a diagnosis that could hurt or kill someone if left untreated.
Only four studies were properly designed to pin down the effectiveness of flu vaccine, he says, and two of those showed that it might be effective in certain groups of patients, such as school-age children with no underlying health issues like asthma. The other two showed equivocal results or no benefit.
All that time and money spent on trials and every almost every study was incompetent and flawed. If only they had asked Dr. Jefferson first as only he knows how to do a proper clinical study. Must be hard to be as knowledgeable as Dr. Jefferson, with all that knowledge and expertise, and to have to be ignored. I mention this with the sarcasm as in the Atlantic Dr. Jeffersonis represented as the be all and end all of designing studies, yet, as best I can tell from Pubmed, he has never participated in a clinical trial. He usually does reviews of studies done by others. Of course, theoretical expertise in an area does not necessarily invalidate criticisms; the Pope’s opinions on contraception may be valid despite practical experience.
What is the topic? Preventing flu or preventing death? My entry on flu efficacy discusses the data and difficulty with deciding exactly what are the benefits of the flu vaccine. The problem with popular articles is the lack of references, so it is hard to comment. Effective how? Endpoints? What population were studied? There is so little real substance in the last paragraph that I cannot tell if it is rubbish or not. But it sure sounds like someone does not know what they are doing.
Flu researchers have been fooled into thinking vaccine is more effective than the data suggest, in part, says Jefferson, by the imprecision of the statistics.
Huh? Jackson uses statistics to show the vaccine doesn’t work. I wish they would explain why one set of statistics is good and those of others are not. It would be nice to know which statistics are statistically appropriate. Perhaps they have been ‘fooled’ by multiple lines of convergent evidence that consistently demonstrates efficacy of the influenza vaccine on multiple endpoints. Damn, maybe all 14,000 references on the influenza vaccine have fooled me.
The only way to know if someone has the flu–as opposed to influenza-like illness–is by putting a Q-tip into the patient’s throat or nose and running a test, which simply isn’t done that often.
That is simply not true, although the recent NEJM reference that looked at vaccine efficacy was probably not published before the Atlantic was written. However, the direct inoculation studies did stick a swab in the patient for culture after giving a nose full of flu after placebo or vaccine. So in the best of all possible worlds, we know that vaccine can prevent flu. Problem is, of course, translating the perfect world to the real world.
Likewise, nobody really has a handle on how many of the deaths that are blamed on flu were actually caused by a flu virus, because few are confirmed by a laboratory. “I used to be a family physician,” says Jefferson. “I’ve never seen a patient come to my office with H1N1 written on his forehead.When an old person dies of respiratory failure after an influenza-like illness, they nearly always get coded as influenza.”
Again, no argument with this. I wonder if the coding issue is true, it is a reference free statement, but coding data, which by the way both the NEJM and Jackson used to calculate their results, are known to be unreliable. So the data from Jacksons codes are good and the NEJM are not? Again, the problem of how deaths from flu are calculated is discussed on a blog entry. Real world = messy.
There’s one other way flu researchers may be fooled into thinking flu vaccine is effective, Jefferson says. All vaccines work by delivering a dose of killed or weakened virus or bacteria, which provokes the immune system into producing antibodies. When the person is subsequently exposed to the real thing, the body is already prepared to repel the bug completely or to get rid of it after a mild illness. Flu researchers often use antibody response as a way of gauging the effectiveness of vaccine, on the assumption that levels of antibodies in the blood of people who have been vaccinated are a good predictor–although an imperfect one–of how well they can ward off the infection.
Antibodies are a surrogate for efficacy and, as a rule, antibodies levels are predictive for vaccine efficacy. Fooled by statistics, fooled by antibodies, we docs sure are a gullible bunch of rubes who just fell off the turnip truck. It fools no one. I fail to follow how an antibody response fools people into thinking the flu vaccine is effective. As the Cochrane review points out, the best effect of the flu vaccine occurs when there is a good match between the vaccine and flu, and the only way that is going to happen that I can think of is that the vaccine generated a good antibody response.
A meta analysis of the vaccine efficacy in 66,248 people (almost Cardiology level of patients involvement) from 2004:
“Inactivated parenteral vaccines were 30% effective (95% CI 17% to 41%) against influenza-like illness, and 80% (95% CI 56% to 91%) efficacious against influenza when the vaccine matched the circulating strain and circulation was high, but decreased to 50% (95% CI 27% to 65%) when it did not. Excluding the studies of the 1968 to 1969 pandemic, effectiveness was 15% (95% CI 9% to 22%) and efficacy was 73% (95% CI 53% to 84%). Vaccination had a modest effect on time off work, but there was insufficient evidence to draw conclusions on hospital admissions or complication rates. Inactivated vaccines caused local tenderness and soreness and erythema. Spray vaccines had more modest performance. Monovalent whole-virion vaccines matching circulating viruses had high efficacy (VE 93%, 95% CI 69% to 98%) and effectiveness (VE 66%, 95% CI 51% to 77%) against the 1968 to 1969 pandemic.
AUTHORS’ CONCLUSIONS: Influenza vaccines are effective in reducing cases of influenza, especially when the content predicts accurately circulating types and circulation is high. However, they are less effective in reducing cases of influenza-like illness and have a modest impact on working days lost. There is insufficient evidence to assess their impact on complications.”
There’s some merit to this reasoning. Unfortunately, the very people who most need protection from the flu also have immune systems that are least likely to respond to vaccine. Studies show that young, healthy people mount a glorious immune response to seasonal flu vaccine, and their response reduces their chances of getting the flu and may lessen the severity of symptoms if they do get it. But they aren’t the people who die from seasonal flu. By contrast, the elderly, particularly those over age 70, don’t have a good immune response to vaccine–and they’re the ones who account for most flu deaths. (Infants with severe disabilities, such as leukemia and congenital lung disease, and people who are immune-compromised–from AIDS, or diabetes, or cancer treatment–make up the rest. As of August8, only 36 deaths from swine flu had been confirmed among children in the U.S., and the overwhelming majority of those children had multiple, severe health disorders.)
Again, I have issues with that ‘only’. Tell 36 mothers that their child was an ‘only’. I know. Little things like compassion should not be part of the equation, but I am a clinician, not a scientist. We shouldn’t make policy on the basis of a few children dying. Now its ‘only’ about 100, mostly healthy, dead children as of this posting. That is a question that I will not even try an answer. At what point do the number of deaths go from ‘only’ to ‘worrisome’? What is the acceptable death rate in a population? Got me. In the 80′s, if it were AIDS in gay men, any death rate was acceptable, but no death in a Legionnaire was acceptable. Me bitter much?
In Jefferson’s view, this raises a troubling conundrum: Is vaccine necessary for those in whom it is effective, namely the young and healthy? Conversely, is it effective in those for whom it seems to be necessary, namely the old, the very young, and the infirm? These questions have led to the most controversial aspect of Jefferson’s work: his call for placebo-controlled trials, studies that would randomly give half the test subjects vaccine and the other half a dummy shot, or placebo. Only such large, well-constructed, randomized trials can show with any precision how effective vaccine really is, and for whom.
It is not radical but unethical to do these studies. Some basic principals of human research include:
“Research should be based on a thorough knowledge of the scientific background (Article 11), a careful assessment of risks and benefits (Articles 16, 17), have a reasonable likelihood of benefit to the population studied (Article 19)”
We have so much data that show beneficial effects of influenza vaccine and it would be difficult to find a physician to participate. As I have mentioned before, not unless you really want to have a death panel for the elderly. It would also make for interesting informed consent.
There is a third option discussed later, universal vaccination.
In the flu-vaccine world, Jefferson’s call for placebo-controlled studies is considered so radical that even some of his fellow skeptics oppose it. Majumdar, the Ottawa researcher, says he believes that evidence of a benefit among children is established and that public-health officials should try to protect seniors by immunizing children, health-care workers, and other people around them, and thus reduce the spread of the flu. Lone Simonsen explains the prevailing view: “It is considered unethical to do trials in populations that are recommended to have vaccine,” a stance that is shared by everybody from the CDC’s Nancy Cox to Anthony Fauci at the NIH. They feel strongly that vaccine has been shown to be effective and that a sham vaccine would put test subjects at unnecessary risk of getting a serious case of the flu. In a phone interview, Fauci at first voiced the opinion that a placebo trial in the elderly might be acceptable, but he called back later to retract his comment, saying that such a trial “would be unethical.” Jefferson finds this view almost exactly backward: “What do you do when you have uncertainty? You test,” he says. “We have built huge, population-based policies on the flimsiest of scientific evidence. The most unethical thing to do is to carry on business as usual.”
Flimsiest of scientific evidence? Rubbish? The man is good with hyperbole. There are now 5 studies that demonstrate that vaccinating those around the elderly for influenza decreases death or heart attacks in the elderly.
The Ontario experience, which I am sure is deeply flawed to Dr. Jefferson, is still compelling: the greater the number of people vaccinated, the greater the decrease in mortality in the community. Most studies show benefit from the vaccine.
When you have uncertainty, which is always the case in medicine, you try and decrease the uncertainty with tests. But not by potentially killing people. And that potential is not trivial.
It would be an interesting informed consent: a large number of studies suggests that the vaccine is protective for morbidity and mortality but we want to prove it with a placebo controlled trial. Are you going to sign up? And you have to ask: if the test proposed by Dr. Jefferson, a large trial of vaccine in the elderly with death as an endpoint is accomplished and it shows that the elderly do have increased mortality if they are not vaccinated, which is strongly suggested by the preponderance of data we already have, what are you going to tell the next of kin of the dead? We were right, thanks for the sacrifice.
Such a trial would have been doable 30 years ago, but not now.
All epidemiologic studies have issues:
“Recent studies questioning the plausibility of reported mortality benefits among vaccinated elderly persons may themselves be based on assumptions that are susceptible to important limitations and multiple biases. Future studies that incorporate prospectively collected information on functional status, life expectancy, and other types of data may provide additional insights into these concerns. At present, even after taking into account the potential for residual bias and confounding, most studies confirm the benefits of vaccination among the elderly for reducing hospitalization and death (19840665).”
Of course, to discuss that one would have to abandon the good/bad dichotomy that makes for a good story. But that is a reasoned review, with qualifiers and nuance. Doesn’t make for a good story.
Just after 6 p.m. on a warm Friday evening in July, Dr. David Newman is only minutes into a 10-hour shift in the emergency room of New York City’s St. Luke’s Hospital, and already he has assumed responsibility for 11 patients. The young Italian tourist sitting on the bed in front of the doctor has meningitis, and through an interpreter, Newman tells him he almost certainly has the viral form of the disease, which will do nothing more than make him feel ill for a few days. There is a tiny chance, says Newman, that the illness is caused by a bacterium, which can be deadly, but he is almost positive that’s not what the tourist has. He says to his patient, “I can’t tell you with 100 percent certainty that you don’t have it, but if you do, you’ll begin to feel worse and you’ll need to come back.” The tourist, on learning that he might be infected with a potentially lethal disease, looks down at his feet and confesses that he is much more worried about another illness: swine flu. Newman smiles patiently. “It would be nice if you had swine flu,” he says. “Compared to bacterial meningitis, swine flu is safe.”
Late last spring, as headlines and airwaves warned of a possible pandemic, patients like Newman’s began clogging emergency rooms across the country, a sneezing, coughing, infectious tide of humanity more worried than truly sick, but whose mere presence in the emergency room has endangered the lives of others.
“Studies show that when there is ER crowding, mortality goes up, because patients who need immediate attention don’t get it,” says Newman, the director of clinical research in the Department of Emergency Medicine at the hospital, which is affiliated with Columbia University. In an average year the ER at St. Luke’s, a sprawling 1,076-bed hospital on 113th Street, takes in 110,000 patients, some 300 a day. At the height of the summer swine flu outbreak, that number doubled. The vast majority of panicky patients who came in the door at St. Luke’s and other emergency departments didn’t actually have the virus, and of those who did, most were not sick enough to need hospitalization. Even so, says Newman, when patients with even mild flu symptoms show up in the hospital, they vastly increase the spread of the virus, simply because they inevitably sneeze and cough in rooms that are jammed with other people.
Hmmmm. Maybe, the tide of humanity could benefit from, hmmmm, a vaccine. To prevent H1N1 and decrease spread. Given the good match from the vaccine and the current strain, one would expect an excellent immune response in the young and if enough people get vaccinated then herd immunity may kick in, protecting those who can’t respond to the vaccine. It would keep the ER from being a cesspool of contagion.
Many of the worried sick come to St. Luke’s and other hospitals in search of antiviral drugs. The CDC recommends the use of two drugs against H1N1: oseltamivir and zanamivir, better known by their brand names, Tamiflu and Relenza, which together form the second pillar of the government’s anti-pandemic-flu strategy. Public-health officials at the state and local levels are also recommending the drugs. Guidelines issued by the New York City Department of Health, says Newman, “encourage us to give a prescription to just about every patient with the sniffles,” a practice that some experts worry will quickly lead to resistant strains of the virus.
We do not have the resources to test everyone for H1N1, so currently we are testing those who are admitted to the hospital. And we were never “treating anyone with the sniffles”. Dr. Newman exaggerates.
The first New York State Public Health communication says “Antiviral treatment for confirmed or suspected ill cases of swine influenza virus infection may include either oseltamivir or zanamivir, with no preference given at this time. Initiate treatment as soon as possible after the onset of symptoms.” Most of the CDC guidelines have said pretty much the same thing since the onset of the pandemic. What we have learned is that the lethality of H1N1 has been less than feared and as a result recommendations as to when to start antivirals has changed over time. But sniffles? Puh leze.
Remember that when H1N1 started in Mexico it had an high mortality rate (maybe 4%, we didn’t know with certainty, but 4% is 1918 level mortality) that was subsequently not replicated in the US. Under those circumstances, early treatment was reasonable when there was no vaccine to prevent the disease. Current recommendations are to treat those at risk of dying of flu. As the pandemic has progressed we have learned and adapted to the situation.
Indeed, that’s already happening. Daniel Janies, an associate professor of biomedical informatics at Ohio State University, tracks the genetic mutations that allow flu virus to develop resistance to drugs. Flu can become resistant to Tamiflu in a matter of days, he says. Handing out the drug early in the pandemic, when H1N1 poses only a minimal threat to the vast majority of patients, strikes him as “shortsighted.”
That is the question and problem with all antibiotics and antivirals: the trade off for the short term use and benefit is long term resistance and loss of drug efficacy. It just happens faster with influenza. Certainly now that we know it is a mild illness in most people the drug should be reserved for those at risk of death and the very ill. Hindsight is always 20:20 and people forgets the uncertainty associated with the beginning of the outbreak.
Indeed, samples of resistant H1N1 were cropping up by midsummer, increasing the likelihood that come late fall, many people will be infected with a resistant strain of swine flu. Alarmed at that prospect, the World Health Organization issued an alert on August 21, recommending that Tamiflu and Relenza be used only in severe cases and in patients who are at high risk of serious complications. By mid-August, two U.S. swine flu patients had developed Tamiflu-resistant strains.
The Borg did have it partially right. Resistance is inevitable and we try to be judicious with the use of antivirals. As is often the case with novel infections, at first the response is to play it safe and be aggressive with treatment and isolation until you have more data and know it is reasonable to be less aggressive. Those of us in the trenches, who get to watch people suffer and die from these diseases and are responsible for their lives, cannot take that responsibility lightly. I have to bet your life that I make the right decision, and at the beginning of the H1N1 pandemic, the feeling was to play it safe.
The U.S. first began stockpiling Tamiflu and Relenza back in 2005, in the wake of concern that an outbreak in Southeast Asia of bird flu, a far more deadly form of the disease, might go global. On November 1, 2005, President George W.Bush pronounced pandemic flu a “danger to our homeland,” and he asked Congress to approve legislation that included $1billion for the production and stockpiling of antivirals. This was after Congress had already approved $1.8billion to stockpile Tamiflu for the military, a decision that was made during the tenure of Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld. (Before joining the Bush Cabinet, Rumsfeld was chairman for four years of Gilead Sciences, the company that holds the patent on Tamiflu, and he held millions of dollars’ worth of stock in the company. According to Roll Call, an online newspaper covering events on Capitol Hill, Rumsfeld says he recused himself from all government decisions involving Tamiflu. Gilead’s stock price rose more than 50 percent in 2005, when the government’s plan was announced.)
The perfidious influence of big pharma. Even if the right decision is made, trying to prepare for a repeat of the 1918 pandemic, it is tainted by Rumsfeld.
As with vaccines, the scientific evidence for Tamiflu and Relenza is thin at best.
The evidence isn’t thin, but the effects of the drug in healthy people are modest. But that is not why Tamiflu was being stockpiled. Bird flu, H1N5, has a 66% death rate. But for a variety of reasons is not very infectious. What would happen if there was another re-assortment in a pig somewhere with the current H1N1 and the current bird flu and the new strain became both contagious and fatal and there was no vaccine? The best you could do was decrease morbidity and mortality with early treatment with Tamiflu. Early on it appeared that H1N1 was going to be lethal.
In its general-information section, the CDC’s Web site tells readers that antiviral drugs can “make you feel better faster.” True, but not by much. On average, Tamiflu (which accounts for 85 to 90 percent of the flu antiviral-drug market) cuts the duration of flu symptoms by 24hours in otherwise healthy people. In exchange for a slightly shorter bout of illness, as many as one in five people taking Tamiflu will experience nausea and vomiting. About one in five children will have neuropsychiatric side effects, possibly including anxiety and suicidal behavior. In Japan, where Tamiflu is liberally prescribed, the drug may have been responsible for 50 deaths from cardiopulmonary arrest, from 2001 to 2007, according to Rokuro Hama, the chair of the Japan Institute of Pharmacovigilance.
Such side effects might be worth risking if the antivirals prevented serious complications of flu, such as pneumonia, hospitalization, and death. Roche Laboratories, the company licensed to manufacture and mark et Tamiflu, says its drug does just that. In two September 2006 press releases, the company announced, “Tamiflu significantly reduces the risk of death from influenza: New data shows treatment was associated with more than a two third reduction in deaths,” and “Children with influenza [are] 53 percent less likely to contract pneumonia when treated with Tamiflu.”
I addressed this at the top of the post. Again with the binary approach. Antivirals have always had modest effects in treating infections. But during a pandemic, having 30% of the work force potentially out sick with flu, is also going to have adverse effects. It would be nice when I am in a major car accident and I am rushed to the trauma center that the staff is actually working and not out ill with influenza.
Once again cohort studies (the same kind of potentially biased research that led to the conclusion that flu vaccine cuts mortality by 50 percent) are behind these claims. Tamiflu costs $10 a pill. It is possible that people who take it are more likely to be insured and affluent, or at least middle-class, than those who do not, and a large body of evidence shows that the well-off nearly always fare better than the poor when stricken with an infectious disease, including flu. In both 2003 and 2009, reviews of randomized placebo-controlled studies found that the study populations simply weren’t large enough to answer the question: Does Tamiflu prevent pneumonia?
What I want Tamiflu to do, and it does, is decrease the chance that my patient will die of severe flu. Decrease the chance. That’s the best one can for with an antiviral, and if there is not an effective vaccine, the best I will be able to offer my patients.
But prevent pneumonia? Huh? Is this a reference to prophylactic studies? And does the author mean influenza or bacteria pneumonia? This kind of obscure sentence drives. Me. Nuts. It casts doubt with obscurity.
Again with be binary, does it prevent pneumonia? What one learns early in medicine is that the effects of our interventions, are incremental and additive. No single intervention is a magic bullet to treat or prevent disease. Flu treatment and prevention will be most efficacious when we do many interventions.
As late as this August, the company’s own Web site contained the following statement, which was written under the direction of the FDA: “Tamiflu has not been proven to have a positive impact on the potential consequences (such as hospitalizations, mortality, or economic impact) of seasonal, avian, or pandemic influenza.” An FDA spokesperson said recently that the agency is unaware of any data submitted by Roche that would support the claims in the company’s September 2006 news release about the drug’s reducing flu deaths.
Why, then, has the federal government stockpiled millions of doses of antivirals, at a cost of several billion dollars?
Because there is some effectiveness of the medication against the disease and should there be a Tamiflu sensitive flu pandemic and we do not have an effective vaccine, we may be able to save a few people who might have otherwise died. Again, welcome to the messy world of the practice of medicine.
And why are physicians being encouraged to hand out prescriptions to large numbers of people, without sound evidence that the drugs will help?
They are not. Here in the Northwest, most patients are not being treated with Tamiflu now that we know who may and who may not die of the illness. In medicine if you wait for perfect studies to give irrefutable answers, good luck. If that is the standard, then we will do nothing. But I disagree with the author. I think the preponderance of data is good enough to make decisions: treat the really ill and those at high risk of death and vaccinate as many as you can to prevent the disease.
The short answer may be that public-health officials feel they must offer something, and these drugs are the only possible remedies at hand. “I have to agree with the critics the antiviral question is not cut-and-dried,” says Fauci. “But [these drugs are] the best we have.” The CDC’s Nancy Cox also acknowledges that the science is not as sound as she might like, but the government still recommends their use. And as with vaccines, she considers additional randomized placebo-controlled trials of the antiviral drugs to be “unethical” and thus out of the question.
This is the curious state of debate about the government’s two main weapons in the fight against pandemic flu.
It is not curious. It is the real world, with limited time and resources. We have to fight the war, as that evil bastard said, with the Army we have. Sometimes even the irreducibly corrupt will make the right decision.
At first, government officials declare that both vaccines and drugs are effective. When faced with contrary evidence, the adherents acknowledge that the science is not as crisp as they might wish. Then, in response to calls for placebo-controlled trials, which would provide clear results one way or the other, the proponents say such studies would deprive patients of vaccines and drugs that have already been deemed effective. “We can’t just let people die,” says Cox.
We can’t let people die. Maybe it is me, but the tone of the article is that “unethical” and “not letting people die” are used in a manner to suggest these are not valid reasons for the current policy. They are very valid reasons to making decisions.
Students of U.S. medical history will find this circular logic familiar: it is a long-recurring theme in American medicine, and one that has, on occasion, had deadly consequences. In 1925, Sinclair Lewis caricatured a medical culture that allowed belief–and profits–to distort science in his Pulitzer Prize-winning book, Arrowsmith. Based on the lives of the real-life microbiologists Paul de Kruif and Jacques Loeb, Lewis tells the story of Martin Arrowsmith, a physician who invents a new vaccine during a deadly outbreak of bubonic plague. But his efforts to test the vaccine’s efficacy are frustrated by an angry community that desperately wants to believe the vaccine works, and a profit-hungry institute that rushes the vaccine into use prematurely–forever preempting the proper studies that are needed.
So a work of fiction is now considered part of medical history? Great. In that case I think we should use Marcus Welby MD as example of the history of the profession. He was a nice, caring, MD who did what ever he could to help his patients. I love the profession being reduced to an evil caricature. Well, as long as we are using a work of fiction as a characterization of how medicine works, might as well go to the Onion to see how journalism works. If me and mine are going to be reduced to an evil cliched stereotype, lets do the same with journalists.
I have to admit this kind of characterizaion irritates me. I just came back from the national infectious disease meetings, and, while there are docs who are just as greedy and ignoble as any journalist, what drives people in public health and the CDC is to do good. I know no one believes that. It sure isn’t the money.
The annals of medicine are littered with treatments and tests that became medical doctrine on the slimmest of evidence, and were then declared sacrosanct and beyond scientific investigation. In the 1980s and ’90s, for example, cancer specialists were convinced that high-dose chemotherapy followed by a bone-marrow transplant was the best hope for women with advanced breast cancer, and many refused to enroll their patients in randomized clinical trials that were designed to test transplants against the standard–and far less toxic–therapy. The trials, they said, were unethical, because they knew transplants worked.
False analogy. With the treatment of breast cancer with bone marrow transplant, there was not 50 years of convergent data to suggest bone marrow transplants worked for breast cancer. Nothing. Again, we have a rich data set to show that flu vaccine decreases flu morbidity and mortality.
When the studies were concluded, in 1999 and 2000, it turned out that bone-marrow transplants were killing patients. Another recent example involves drugs related to the analgesic lidocaine. In the 1970s, doctors noticed that the drugs seemed to make the heart beat rhythmically, and they began prescribing them to patients suffering from irregular heartbeats, assuming that restoring a proper rhythm would reduce the patient’s risk of dying. Prominent cardiologists for years opposed clinical trials of the drugs, saying it would be medical malpractice to withhold them from patients in a control group. The drugs were widely used for two decades, until a government-sponsored study showed in 1989 that patients who were prescribed the medicine were three and a half times as likely to die as those given a placebo.
Again false analogy. I remember the day when we gave everyone lidocaine and other antiarrhythmics, back when I was an intern. Antiarrhythmics are toxic drugs. We knew it in the day, we thought they were less toxic than the diseases they treated Antivirals and the vaccines have a long track record of safety and significant toxicities are rare.
Demonstrating the efficacy (or lack thereof) of vaccine and antivirals during flu season would not be hard to do, given the proper resources.
Remember I told you that was coming. Now its not hard to do with the proper resources. Getting to Mars would not be hard to do with the proper resources. A quarter of our population is uninsured and as a result has double the mortality rate when compared to the insured. Wait. That’s not based on a double blind study either. So it probably isn’t true. The best thing to do is take away everyone’s insurance, since it is the well-to-do who are healthy and can afford health care and it is not access to health care that makes the difference.
The best solution would be to take all the money used to fund the NCCAM, as they have never demonstrated efficacy of alternative therapies, and spend the money on influenza research. That would be a win-win.
Take a group of people who are at risk of getting the flu, and randomly assign half to get vaccine and the other half a dummy shot. Then count the people in each group who come down with flu, suffer serious illness, or die. (A similarly designed trial would suffice for the antivirals.) It might sound coldhearted, but it is the only way to know for certain whether, and for whom, current remedies actually work.
I love that cold hearted. Evidently the authors haven’t watched someone die of influenza or its complications, a clinical problem I am getting reacquainted with thanks to H1N1. I think there is enough data with flu vaccine efficacy to have a high expectation that the vaccine will prevent flu and, as a result, its complications. I don’t think we need to kill a cohort of the elderly to prove it, but I also doubt such a trial is feasible in that it would be difficult on enroll people given our current knowledge.
It would also be useful to know whether vaccinating healthy people–who can mount an immune response on their own–protects the more vulnerable people around them. For example, immunizing nursing-home staff and healthy children is thought to reduce the spread of flu to the elderly and the immune-compromised. Pinning down the effectiveness of this strategy would be a bit more complex, but not impossible.
We have four studies that show just this effect: vaccinating health care workers decreases mortality in their patients, although the effect is nuanced and variable. Again. As Dr. Jeffersons review said,
“Staff vaccination had a significant effect on influenza-like illness (vaccine effectiveness [VE] 86%, 95% CI 40-97%) only when patients were vaccinated too. If patients were not vaccinated, staff immunization had no effect. Vaccinating health-care workers did not appear efficacious against influenza (RR 0.87, 95% CI 0.46-1.63). There was no significant effect of vaccination on lower respiratory tract infections: (RR 0.70, 95% CI 0.41-1.20). Deaths from pneumonia were significantly reduced (VE 39%, 95% CI 2-62%), as were deaths from all causes (VE 40%, 95% CI 27-50%) (16631547).”
In the absence of such evidence, we are left with two possibilities. One is that flu vaccine is in fact highly beneficial, or at least helpful.
Again with the binary. The effect of the flu vaccine and other interventions is a continuum. It depends on who gets it, their ability to respond with antibody and whether they get secondary complications. The data is clear that it is helpful. It is if you read ALL the literature.
Solid evidence to that effect would encourage more citizens–and particularly more health professionals–to get their shots and prevent the flu’s spread. As it stands, more than 50 percent of health-care workers say they do not intend to get vaccinated for swine flu and don’t routinely get their shots for seasonal flu, in part because many of them doubt the vaccines’ efficacy.
I spend each flu season talking to my colleagues about the vaccine and the reasons they do not get the vaccine rarely have anything to do with the data, see for a smart ass rant on the topic.
The other possibility, of course, is that we’re relying heavily on vaccines and antivirals that simply don’t work, or don’t work as well as we believe. And as a result, we may be neglecting other, proven measures that could minimize the death rate during pandemics.
What is the difference between ‘do not work as well as we believe’ and ‘at least helpful’? Again, I keep harping on the issue that the response to the flu vaccine is nuanced, not black and white. And what are these other issues to minimize the death rates?
“Vaccines give us a false sense of security,” says Sumit Majumdar. “When you have a strategy that [everybody thinks] reduces death by 50 percent, it’s pretty hard to invest resources to come up with better remedies.” For instance, health departments in every state are responsible for submitting plans to the CDC for educating the public, in the event of a serious pandemic, about hand-washing and “social distancing” (voluntary quarantines, school closings, and even enforcement of mandatory quarantines to keep infected people in their homes). Putting these plans into action will require considerable coordination among government officials, the media, and health-care workers–and widespread buy-in from the public. Yet little discussion has appeared in the press to help people understand the measures they can take to best protect themselves during a flu outbreak–other than vaccination and antivirals.
Social distancing is suggested. And based on what randomized controlled trial? The data to support social distancing are limited and in a recent Annals article was not optimistic:
“Sixty (8%) contacts in the 259 households had RT-PCR– confirmed influenza virus infection in the 7 days after intervention. Hand hygiene with or without facemasks seemed to reduce influenza transmission, but the differences compared with the control group were not significant. In 154 households in which interventions were implemented within 36 hours of symptom onset in the index patient, transmission of RT-PCR–confirmed infection seemed reduced, an effect attributable to fewer infections among participants using facemasks plus hand hygiene (adjusted odds ratio, 0.33 [95% CI, 0.13 to 0.87]). Adherence to interventions varied.”
All of us in health care know the difficulty in getting patients to adhere with recommended interventions. Not mentioned is Dr. Jefferson’s review of this issue where he notices that the quality of the data to support other means to prevent influenza is not very good:
”The quality of the studies was poor for all four randomized controlled trials and most cluster randomized controlled trials; the observational studies were of mixed quality” and “The quality of the methods varied in these studies but may reflect the difficult and real life circumstances in which they were carried out (19773323).”
What a surprise. More less-than-perfect studies. You know, if we just had the resources…
“Launched early enough and continued long enough, social distancing can blunt the impact of a pandemic,” says Howard Markel, a pediatrician and historian of medicine at the University of Michigan. Washing hands diligently, avoiding public places during an outbreak, and having a supply of canned goods and water on hand are sound defenses, he says.
Shut down society. It would work. But if 30% are infected over three months, as worst case scenarios show, who will be around to care for the ill?
Such steps could be highly effective in helping to slow the spread of the virus. In Mexico, for instance, where the first swine flu cases were identified in March, the government launched an aggressive program to get people to wash their hands and exhorted those who were sick to stay home and effectively quarantine themselves. In the United Kingdom, the national health department is promoting a “buddy” program, encouraging citizens to find a friend or neighbor willing to deliver food and medicine so people who fall ill can stay home.
I also have a career devoted to trying to get dedicated health care workers to consistently wash their hands. The reasons for the prior failures to increase compliance are multitudinous and the reason for our current excellent success are complex, but expecting the public to wash their hands reliably is probably not realistic. As the Annals article said:
“Only half of the index patients in the face mask plus hand hygiene group reported regular use of a surgical mask during follow-up. Face mask adherence among household contacts was lower. Adherence to the hand hygiene intervention seemed low compared with rates recommended in health care settings but was similar to rates in previous community studies. In addition, effects in our study may tend toward a lower bound on the effects that might be observed in a pandemic with heightened public awareness.”
Everything seems so simple: do a quick study on Tamiflu and vaccine efficacy, have people wash their hands. Why didn’t the CDC think of that? Bumbling, incompetent bureaucrats one and all. And while we are at it, lets have everyone lose weight and exercise regularly.
And once you have influenza and are ill enough to be in the hospital, heading for a ventilator and the perpetual night, what are you doing to do instead of Tamiflu? Social distancing? Got me. I am open for ideas.
In the U.S., by contrast, our reliance on vaccination may have the opposite effect: breeding feelings of invulnerability, and leading some people to ignore simple measures like better-than-normal hygiene, staying away from those who are sick, and staying home when they feel ill. Likewise, our encouragement of early treatment with antiviral drugs will likely lead many people to show up at the hospital at first sniffle. “There’s no worse place to go than the hospital during flu season,” says Majumdar. Those who don’t have the flu are more likely to catch it there, and those who do will spread it around, he says. “But we don’t tell people this.”
And relying on hand hygiene and social distancing may have the opposite effect: it will lead people to a sense that they can’t get the flu and so not get a protective vaccine and then acquire the disease and die. Again, its this all or nothing approach. As if we are not doing and recommending the simple measures. My hospitals are full of signs and pamphlets: wash your hands, wear a mask, stay home if ill. And the patients and visitors routinely ignore them. We want children to not be in the family birth center since they can be ill and not inform people of their symptoms. One visitor smuggled her child into the unit in a paper sack. Good luck with simple measures.
There is a rule in health care: no good deed goes unpunished. No matter what we do there will be unintended adverse consequences. Sometimes, and in medicine it is often, it is not what is the best answer, but the least bad answer.
All of which leaves open the question of what people should do when faced with a decision about whether to get themselves and their families vaccinated. There is little immediate danger from getting a seasonal flu shot, aside from a sore arm and mild flu-like symptoms. The safety of the swine flu vaccine remains to be seen. In the absence of better evidence, vaccines and antivirals must be viewed as only partial and uncertain defenses against the flu. And they may be mere talismans. By being afraid to do the proper studies now, we may be condemning ourselves to using treatments based on illusion and faith rather than sound science.
Always end with vaccine safety fear mongering. Trying to be an ethical researcher who is concerned about the health and well being of the people for whom we are responsible is being afraid. I have noticed one thing in 25 years of practicing medicine: death lasts along time.
So what are the options?
You could read the entire literature on flu vaccine. I have, over the last 25 years, read most of it. It is compelling. Or rely on two researchers.
We could stop vaccinations. I think that would be wrong. We can do more studies and make better vaccines. Always a good idea. Eventually, if we can get the resources, perhaps definitive studies will be done as to the effect on mortality in elderly.
We could vaccinate everyone west of the Missisippi and no one to the east (I live in the west and have no loved ones in the east) and look at death rates.
What I think is needed is universal vaccination. We need to get everyone vaccinated to protect those that can’t get vaccinated or can’t respond to the vaccine. Of course, that’s impossible. It is a yearly shot and we lack the resources to accomplish this. What we will end up with is a refinement of the current approach. More emphasis on vaccinating the caregivers and family of the vulnerable, more emphasis on hygiene. Medical knowledge is always imperfect and always changing, one hopes for the better
And a year from now we will have some interesting data on morbidity and mortality from the current pandemic. It will be another brick in the wall of information, and it may be a good fit, or it may be an outlier. But we will not have any randomized placebo controlled trial since the mortality of this strain is greatest in children and pregnant women, who wants to volunteer their children or pregnant spouse to participate? Dr. Jefferson? The authors of the paper want to offer up their children? I think based on the data of prior influenza vaccines, and the fact that this is just another flu, I would be unwilling to risk sacrificing my children to appear cold hearted and unafraid.
Maybe those that read this will have a better understanding that medical knowledge and its application is imperfect and incremental.
I grew up knowing that the universe is big. “Space is big. You just won’t believe how vastly, hugely, mind-bogglingly big it is. I mean, you may think it’s a long way down the road to the chemist’s, but that’s just peanuts to space.”
Yet there was a time, just a century ago, where the universe was thought to consist of our galaxy. That was it. And erroneous conclusions followed from that narrow perspective. Even Einstein modified his equations with a cosmologic constant to account for the small universe. Bigger universe, bigger data sets, lead to different conclusions.
Vaccine efficacy is a huge universe. The Atlantic article, “Does the Vaccine Matter?“, is an island universe. True as far is it goes, but limited. I’m sticking with the whole universe.

New evidence, same conclusion: Tamiflu only modestly useful for influenza
Scott Gavura on April 10, 2014
Link

Does Tamiflu have any meaningful effects on the prevention or treatment of influenza? Considering the drug’s been on the market for almost 15 years, and is widely used, you should expect this question has been answered after 15 flu seasons. Answering this question from a science-based perspective requires three steps: Consider prior probability, be systematic in the approach, and get all the data. It’s the third step that’s been (until now) impossible with Tamiflu: Some data was unpublished. In general, there’s good evidence to show that negative studies are less likely to be published than positive studies. Unless unpublished studies are included, systematic reviews are more likely to miss negative data, which means there’s the risk of bias in favor of an intervention.
The absence of a full data set on Tamiflu (oseltamivir) and the other neuraminidase inhibitor Relenza (zanamivir) became a rallying point for BMJ and the AllTrials campaign, which seeks to enhance the transparency and accessibility of clinical trials data by challenging trial investigators to make all evidence freely available. (Reforming and enhancing access to trial data was one of the most essential changes recommended by Ben Goldacre in his book, Bad Pharma.) In 2009, Tamiflu’s manufacturer, Hoffman-La Roche committed to making the Tamiflu data set available to investigators. Now after four years of back-and-forth between BMJ, investigators, and Roche, the full clinical trials data set has been made freely available. An updated systematic review was published today in BMJ (formerly The British Medical Journal), entitled “Oseltamivir for influenza in adults and children: systematic review of clinical study reports and summary of regulatory comments.” This will be a short post covering the highlights. As the entire study and accompanying data are freely available, I’ll await continued discussion in the comments.
What do we already know about influenza and the antiviral drugs?
Influenza is a significant cause of illness and death. While deaths directly attributed to the virus tend to be uncommon, influenza kills through its effects on other diseases, like lung and heart disease, and by causing secondary infections. It doesn’t always discriminate, either – every influenza season we see stories of otherwise healthy adults, pregnant women, and children who died due to influenza. Influenza is an unpredictable killer – seasonal variation and genetic variation make each year’s influenza season slightly different.
It’s been widely acknowledged that we have limited tools to prevent and treat influenza. Beyond the basic infection control processes (e.g., handwashing), there’s the vaccine, and then there’s antiviral drugs. The influenza vaccine can be effective (depending on the antigenic match) but even a well-matched vaccine still has only modest efficacy – especially compared to other vaccines, like smallpox (now eradicated), polio (on its way to being eradicated), and measles (potentially eradicable, but we’re not close yet). For decades, the main drug was amantadine, a drug with little persuasive evidence of efficacy. In the late 1990’s two new antiviral drugs were launched: oseltamivir, an oral capsule marketed as Tamiflu, and zanamivir, an inhaled powder, sold as Relenza. While these drugs were widely marketed when launched, there was very little good evidence to demonstrate that they had meaningful effects in the ambulatory (generally healthy) population that contracted influenza. Evidence suggested that it seemed to only shorten the duration of influenza slightly, though it seemed more useful at preventing its spread. There was also some observational data suggesting a possible mortality benefit. Meta-analysis by groups other than Cochrane suggested some benefit. Guidelines in the 2000’s reinforced the primary role of vaccination and tended to recommend the restriction and use of antiviral products to populations considered more “at-risk”: The hospitalized, those that could not be vaccinated, and those exposed to the virus, particularly in locations like nursing homes, where the risks and consequences of infection were much higher. Despite guidance that was, in some cases, quite limiting, the drugs developed a perception of efficacy, no doubt reinforced by effective marketing, extensive prescribing, and undoubtedly, patient demand.
Despite the modest efficacy of the new antivirals, most governments developed stockpiles of the medications. All public health agencies fear that we may someday see another influenza pandemic like 1919 (which killed millions worldwide), so it’s not surprising that there’s a supply maintained, even when the overall efficacy looked poor. There is evidence for the prevention of spread, and given the unknown virulence of the next virus to circulate, stockpiling is like an insurance policy of unknown value – it might help, and it might not, but if you don’t have any stockpiled, you won’t have anything at all in a pandemic situation. It’s important to reiterate (as we’ll come back to this point) that stockpiles are not for seasonal influenza, they are reserved for pandemics, where infectiousness and virulence may be much greater. Given most of the drug probably expires before it’s ever used, the value-for-money of this strategy isn’t clear and can really only be assessed in retrospect – and in the face of a new pandemic, it will be difficult to assess.
What new information does this analysis provide?
This new paper is written by Tom Jefferson, Mark Jones, Peter Doshi, Elizabeth A Spencer, Igho Onakpoya, and Carl J. Heneghan, several of whom contributed to the previous version of the same review. Some of these names may be familiar to regular readers of this blog. Tom Jefferson is a vocal critic of the influenza vaccine and his strict approach to data been criticized as “methodolatry” by some epidemiologists. Mark Crislip, this blog’s resident infectious disease specialist, agrees with many of Jefferson’s criticisms of the existing evidence but comes to a different conclusion regarding the vaccine’s effectiveness based on a different interpretation of the data, one that’s pretty consistent with the perspective of David Gorski. The other author who holds strong opinions about influenza is Peter Doshi, who is so stridently anti-vaccine he makes Tom Jefferson look pro-vaccine. Doshi believes that influenza itself is an example of “selling sickness”, and questions the morbidity and mortality estimates of the disease. It is perhaps not surprising, then, to see the authors describe influenza as “benign” in the text of this review. It all depends on the population you study. Lest you think I’m poisoning the well before getting into the data, it’s important to keep the authors’ perspectives on the disease itself in mind, when we discuss what the study results are telling us about the “real world” outside the randomized controlled trial.
The data set the authors used is described as complete, and they suggest that every trial of oseltamivir, both unpublished and published, has been included (83 trials). They included randomized controlled trials of oseltamivir that examined prevention, treatment, and post-exposure prophylaxis (another type of prevention). Patients had to be healthy, or have a chronic illness. Trials that studied the immune-compromised were excluded. The authors also excluded all trials for which they could not access unabridged clinical study reports, creating the strictest inclusion criteria I’ve ever seen in a systematic review. Clinical trial reports can run into the thousands of pages and are the medical equivalent of visiting a sausage factory – the final product looks nothing like the raw ingredients. They admit this was a challenge:
The main limitation of our study is our relative inexperience in dealing with large quantities of information and our lack of familiarity with certain trial documents such as blank case report forms. A further limitation of our review is that the methods we have developed to assess and summarise information from clinical study reports may not apply to non-industry trials (which may not be reported in clinical study reports).
Which is a pretty significant limitation, as non-industry-sponsored trials may have been excluded based on this strict criterion. With the new criteria and dataset, new findings and conclusions were drawn:
Treatment
    • Tamiflu reduces symptoms in adults by about 2/3 of one day, from 7 days to 6.3 days (P<0.001)
    • Tamiflu reduces symptoms in children by over one full day (P=0.001) but not in asthmatic children
    • Tamiflu has no effects on rates of admission to hospital when used for treatment or prophylaxis (prevention)
    • Tamiflu significantly reduced the risk of “investigator mediated” unverified pneumonia (risk ratio 0.55) (NNT=100)
    • There was no reported difference for trials that reported pneumonia differently
    • Tamiflu did not appear to influence the likelihood of pneumonia in pediatric patients
Prevention
    • Tamiflu reduces the risk of symptomatic influenza in individuals by 55% (NNT=33)
    • Tamiflu reduces the risk of symptomatic influenza in households by 80% (NNT=8)
    • Tamiflu has no effects on rates of admission to hospital when used for prophylaxis (prevention)
    • There was no effect on asymptomatic influenza transmission
Post-exposure prophylaxis
    • There was only a single post-exposure trial included in the analysis. The manufacturer concluded the drug was effective; the authors disagree with the trial’s design. No statistics are provided.
Overall, these new findings provide convincing evidence that Tamiflu has a beneficial effect for treating influenza, but the net benefit is small. Moreover, the drug does not seem to prevent complications like hospitalizations. However the drug provides a meaningful benefit in the prevention of influenza, especially in households.
Harms
Like the efficacy data, the harms data are consistent with what’s already known about Tamiflu. When used for treatment of infection, the drug is generally well tolerated with the exception of nausea and vomiting, which are not uncommon (NNH 28 and 22, respectively). However, it reduces the risk of diarrhea (NNT 43) and “cardiac body system events” (NNT 148). There is no evidence to suggest that Tamiflu increase psychiatric side effects while on treatment.
When used for prevention of infection, Tamiflu can cause headache (NNH 32), nausea (NNH 25) and neuropsychiatric adverse effects (NNH 94).
There were insufficient deaths in the dataset to draw conclusions about effects.
What about real-world data?
Accompanying the Jefferson paper is a paper by Freemantle and colleagues, entitled “Oseltamivir: the real world data”, that goes beyond the dataset used in the Jefferson analysis, which was restricted to randomized controlled trials only. The authors note:
    • RCTs tend to include healthier patients that may not reflect the population that receives a drug in the real world.
    • While observational trials don’t randomize (and can be more easily prone to bias) they allow study in populations where RCTs may be ethically impossible (e.g., pregnancy). Some biases can be addressed in part by statistical techniques.
The authors updated a systematic review that was last completed in 2012 examining oseltamivir’s impact on mortality. The search strategy is well described and 18 studies were included:
    • Prevention of death: Three observational studies evaluated the effectiveness of oseltamivir to prevent death. The authors noted design, analysis and reporting issues with the three studies. However all three studies found that oseltamivir reduces mortality, a finding the authors describe as “reasonably consistent evidence which points towards a benefit of oseltamivir in this setting.”
    • Effects in pregnancy: Three observational studies have looked at maternal infant outcomes. No harms have been noted.
    • Neuropsychiatric effects: Three observational studies examine psychiatric and neurological events. The effects are mixed to positive, with one study finding reduced psychiatric effects with treatment.
The authors conclude that Tamiflu has some overall positive effects but also argue that they’re inconclusive, given the quality issues in the data. They argue, justifiably, for more trials, both prospective and observational, in higher-risk populations, where there continues to be a lack of good-quality evidence. This conclusion is largely consistent with another, older, systematic review of observational studies completed in 2012 by Hsu, which cautiously suggested a net benefit in high-risk patients.
Conclusion
The headlines today may suggest Tamiflu is a scam, and there’s no doubt that the beneficial effects have been overstated, particularly in the general population where the risk of serious complications tend to be low. However, the data are more nuanced than the investigators themselves believe. Jefferson and associates argue their findings provide evidence that stockpiling of this drug should end. One question is how generalizable the current evidence base is to a pandemic situation, and how much we’re prepared to invest (to stockpile) given the limited beneficial effects shown as a treatment. The second question is the role of Tamiflu in the seriously ill, and in those at greater risk of flu-related complications and death. What the news coverage and the authors seem to be ignoring is that Tamiflu is demonstrably and meaningfully effective at preventing the spread of the infection. At the same time, there’s some real world evidence (albeit with limitations) that suggests that oseltamivir may provide a slight survival advantage in the very ill. Tamiflu is also well tolerated and has a generally good side effect profile. Overall, this new study reinforces what’s been argued by science-based medicine for years: Antivirals like Tamiflu don’t replace vaccination. It offers little benefit in the routine treatment of influenza in the otherwise-well individual, but may have a role in those with other medical conditions, or when used to prevent influenza’s spread.

Influenza Vaccine and Health Care Workers. More than one way to skin a literature
There are many ways to apply the medical literature. For me it starts with the premise that health care workers may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.
Mark Crislip on March 3, 2017
Link

I work in a teaching hospital. That means there are often residents and medical students involved in the care of patients. So when I have a consult, not only do I have to give my assessment and plan, I try and justify that assessment and plan with the literature.
But the literature is often less than clear cut.
There are those consults where my conclusion has the force and authority of the 10 commandments. Perhaps a bad metaphor. Some consults, like the treatment of MSSA endocarditis, result in an assessment and plan that is big ‘T’ Truth.
Others? Like how to treat MRSA endocarditis? Lots of depends (no incontinence jokes please) and requires an interpretation of a less than straightforward literature. These are times that I have to offer my best synthesis of the data. But my opinion is likely better than most.
Sometimes I have little to guide me. I have a weird bug in a weird place and no literature to guide me outside of a few case reports. All I have is the bacterial antibiotic sensitivity pattern and hope.
And sometimes I got nothing. I get asked a question that has no real answer, such as is the fever from infection? I don’t really know and I let the house staff know that my opinion is just that, an opinion informed by experience and bias, not evidence. And oddly, others often defer to my advice. Kind of scary. One of the few advantages of being old and grey, it gives the illusion of wisdom. I often say being a sub-specialist is being ignorant with style and authoritah.
But I need to be explicit when my opinion is just my opinion.
Sometimes papers are opinion wrapped in data, which is nice, as that is just what this blog is, but the medical literature, I think, tends to be read with the assumption that the journal articles are written are without bias, the opposite of a blog. Not always.
Take “Influenza Vaccination of Healthcare Workers: Critical Analysis of the Evidence for Patient Benefit Underpinning Policies of Enforcement.”
They reviewed the studies to date on the benefits of health care worker influenza vaccination and conclude:
The four cRCTs underpinning policies of enforced HCW influenza vaccination attribute implausibly large reductions in patient risk to HCW vaccination, casting serious doubts on their validity. The impression that unvaccinated HCWs place their patients at great influenza peril is exaggerated. Instead, the HCW-attributable risk and vaccine-preventable fraction both remain unknown and the NNV to achieve patient benefit still requires better understanding. Although current scientific data are inadequate to support the ethical implementation of enforced HCW influenza vaccination, they do not refute approaches to support voluntary vaccination or other more broadly protective practices, such as staying home or masking when acutely ill.
The studies, all done in long term care facilities (aka nursing homes) are admittedly relatively weak tea when taken in isolation from the rest of the vaccination literature. But it is the data we have.
They did not include “Influenza vaccination of healthcare workers in acute-care hospitals: a case-control study of its effect on hospital-acquired influenza among patients” from 2012, probably as it wasn’t an RCT. The only study in hospitals, it demonstrated benefit from HCW flu vaccination:
The median proportion of vaccinated HCW in these units was 11.5% for cases vs. 36.1% for the controls (P = 0.11); 2 (20%) cases and 21 (48%) controls were vaccinated against influenza in the current season (P = 0.16). The proportion of ≥ 35% vaccinated HCW in short-stay units appeared to protect against HAI among patients (odds ratio = 0.07; 95% confidence interval 0.005-0.98), independently of patient age, influenza season and potential influenza source in the units.CONCLUSIONS: Our observational study indicates a shielding effect of more than 35% of vaccinated HCW on HAI among patients in acute-care units.
The authors of the review do declare their bias behind the review up front:
The ethical premise for mandatory HCW influenza vaccination critically hinges upon the valid demonstration of patient benefit substantial enough to justify infringement of the personal rights of HCWs who would otherwise choose not to receive influenza vaccine each year.
What, I wonder is substantial enough?
So I start with an entirely different premise/bias for my take on the literature. I approach the problem from a patient safety perspective and start with the issue of patient harm. What is the result of hospital acquired influenza?
Answer?
Death.
“Characteristics of patients with hospital-acquired influenza A (H1N1)pdm09 virus admitted to the intensive care unit“:
influenza A (H1N1)pdm09 infection (odds ratio: 1.63; 95% confidence interval: 1.37-1.99)…CONCLUSION: Influenza A (H1N1)pdm09 infection acquired in the hospital is an independent factor for death in critically ill patients admitted to the ICU.
And:
in children with severe viral respiratory infection, hospital acquisition of infection is associated with increased mortality even after adjusting for chronic medical conditions that predispose to an increased risk of complications from viral illness.
And:
Influenza virus pneumonia (3 patients) and attributable mortality (2 patients) during active infection was observed in patients with lymphocytopenia at onset.
Although others have demonstrated less mortality in retrospective studies but all have the patient morbidity of a week or two of influenza.
But killing patients by giving them influenza is, to my mind, a bad thing. What is an insubstantial number of deaths from flu acquired from HCW’s such that no vaccination is required? For me? Zero.
Hospital acquired influenza does happen, although rarely:
The overall incidence of hospital-acquired respiratory viral infection was 3.9 (95% confidence interval, 3.7-4.1) cases per 1,000 admitted patients. Rhinovirus was the most common virus (30.3%), followed by influenza virus (17.6%) and parainfluenza virus (15.6%).
Of course, knowing the influenza is acquired in the hospital is one thing, knowing if the patient acquired influenza from a health care worker is quite another. Often, we do not know just where the patient acquires her influenza:
Unobservable transmission was the main cause of HA-ILI transmission suggesting that symptom-based control measures alone might not prevent hospital outbreaks.
And more exposure is worse the less:
Hospitalization in double-occupancy rooms and the risk of hospital-acquired influenza were assessed prospectively. The incidence was 2.0 for 100 patient-days in double- vs. 0.7 in single-occupancy rooms (p 0.028).
So hospital acquired influenza is rare, difficult to determine the source, can be fatal, results in morbidity and is hard to control.
And I will note there is often an odd disconnect between morbidity and mortality from hospital acquired infections and taking responsibility for that morbidity and mortality. I suspect is part of why infection control and prevention guidelines are sometimes forgotten or ignored. There is an institutional responsibility (in my institutions we ‘deep dive’ into every infection) but not a personal responsibility, as would occur if a patient had a fatal overdose or a doctor put a chest tube trochar through the heart. If we could only know who passed on the organism that caused infection and when it occurred, guilt would be so much simpler. So who gave the patient the influenza that killed her? We never know and it takes the edge off of the responsibility for some.
In my own experience, and I am not immune to the dangers of anecdotes, in my 27 years we have had one influenza outbreak that we could credit to a HCW, unvaccinated, who came down with symptoms in the middle of his 12 hour shift. No one died although there was significant morbidity. And to the best of my memory we have never had a death from nosocomial influenza in my hospitals.
And:
Nearly half of HCWs with influenza were afebrile prior to their diagnosis. HCWs with respiratory symptoms but no fever may pose a risk of influenza transmission to patients and coworkers.
Making waiting for symptoms to intervene problematic.
As a health care provider the dominant ethical imperative is to protect my patients. It is the first law: A robot, er, I mean, health care worker may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm.
I wonder. Is there a relatively effective way to prevent the spread of influenza? I would suggest the flu vaccine. I have written buckets on the flu vaccine on this blog, so my summary. All the data points the same direction: the flu vaccine decreases the chance of acquiring the flu and if a HCW does not get the flu they are not going to pass it to their patients. And kill them. Plus, a vaccinated HCW is potentially one less vector in the community, adding to herd immunity, such as it is with flu.
Is the bang worth the buck? That is a question I cannot answer. What is one life worth? We do a lot of things in the hospital to prevent complications that have a low probability from occurring but have a high morbidity and mortality. And if I have learned one thing in 30 plus years of infection control, there is no one intervention that will prevent infections, it is the summation of many interventions.
I do think our primary moral imperative is to not kill our patients with vaccine-preventable illnesses and that is the more important ethical imperative, not HCW autonomy.
But that is me.
It would be interesting to come up with a series of vignettes, like the Trolley Problem, to see where most people stand with the ethics of HCW vaccination. In the meantime I’ll let you hash it out in the comments.
Prior flu ramblings
    • Scam Stud
    • The Tamiflu Spin
    • Yes, But. The Annotated Atlantic.
    • Cochrane Reviews: The Food Babe of Medicine?
    • One Flu Into the Cuckoo’s Nest*
    • Uneasy Lies the Head That Wears the Flu
    • What are words for?
    • I refute it thus
    • Protect Yourself
    • Drinking from the Fire Hose: Odds and Ends on the Gasping Oppression
    • Random Flu Thoughts
    • Ososillyococcinum and other Flu bits.
    • Influenza Vaccine Mandates
    • Nine Questions, Nine Answers
    • Flu Vaccine Efficacy
    • More Flu Woo for You Boo Boo.
    • Herd Immunity
    • Flu Woo Hodge Podge

Does treating fever spread influenza?
Scott Gavura on January 30, 2014
Link

Treating a fever with medication like Advil or Tylenol is reflex action when we come down with colds and influenza. But could treating fevers actually worsen an illness and contribute to its spread in the population? That’s the impression you may have gained from the headlines and press last week, where antipyretics (fever-reducing medications) were described as some type of “anti-vaccine”:
Fever-reducing meds encourage spread of flu: McMaster report
Taking over-the-counter flu medication to cut your fever might help you feel better, but it might not be so good for the people you come into contact with.
When it comes to fever, your mother really did know what’s best
Who would have thought that the simple giving of a fever reducing agent, to either one of our family members or ourselves before we go off to school or work, may inadvertently lead to the death of someone that we see that day?
Use of fever-reducing drugs may lead to tens of thousands more influenza cases
The bottom line is that fever suppression increases the number of annual cases by approximately five per cent, corresponding to more than 1,000 additional deaths from influenza in a typical year across North America.
The paper, published in Proceedings of the Royal Society B, entitled “Population-level effects of suppressing fever“, got a lot of press: Google says 116+ news articles. And it’s not surprising. Who can resist an “Everything you know is wrong” story? It’s a great hook and it seems to call into question one of the most frequent reasons we take medication. Treating fever, especially in children, has been the norm for decades. I can still recall some of my childhood cold- and flu-related feverish nights, 30+ years on. The vivid dreams that felt like hallucinations, the sweating and shivering, and tossing and turning for hours. I’d lie awake waiting for the next dose of Tylenol so I could sleep. Influenza infections can be miserable and exhausting, and have the potential to do serious harm, killing thousands each year. Analgesics that reduce fever, aches and pains may help people get to sleep and to stay asleep – something you covet when you’re bedridden and ill, or caring for your sick child who’s radiating heat.
David Earn, the lead author of the paper, is a professor of mathematics at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario. The analysis considers the impact of treating the fever of influenza infections and the population-level consequences. (It’s not available free online, unfortunately.) There is no new medical data in this paper. It is, in the authors’ own words, a “theoretical argument” – a mathematical model based on a series of assumptions:
    • Fever is beneficial, not harmful
    • Suppressing fever with antipyretics may increase the extent and duration to which the virus is shed
    • Treating fever with antipyretics (drugs that reduce fever) increases the probability that the sick will interact with the well
    • Sick people using antipyretics will therefore shed more viruses to more people, causing larger epidemics, and more deaths from influenza
Let’s look at these assertions sequentially to assess their validity.
Fever – is it beneficial?
While reaching for analgesics to treat a fever is a reflex action for many, there is some evidence to suggest that fever is a beneficial adaptive response in the infected. Clay Jones discussed fever phobia in 2012 and while he argues that it’s often unnecessarily over-treated, he’s not convinced there’s a sound medical basis for leaving it untreated.
There is merit to the idea that fever has a beneficial purpose but it remains somewhat controversial. Elevating our core body temperature in response to infection is a primitive and almost universal response, seen even in cold-blooded species. Lizards have been observed staying in the sun longer and fish seeking out warmer water when ill for example. This implies at least that there is some degree of survival advantage in being able to develop a fever. Some bacteria and viruses do grow poorly when exposed to higher temperatures. Iron is required for growth by many pathogenic bacteria, and it appears that fever decreases availability of it in the blood. Test tube studies have shown that elevated temperatures may increase the activity of various components of the immune system. There are a few non-primate experiments, particularly in rats and rabbits, that have shown improved outcomes with fever and even some human studies showing prolonged symptoms when fever is treated aggressively. But everything seems to increase the activity of various components of the immune system in test tubes, and those studies were small and difficult to extrapolate to all humans or to all specific fever causing infections. Plus there is also data showing that the immune system may actually become impaired during high fevers above 104-105 degrees. And there is also evidence in animals and human patients that raises concerns of poorer outcomes from some illnesses, particularly in critically ill patients, with very high fever. It is a mixed picture essentially and the jury is still out. Regardless, any benefit of fever is likely so minimal that it would not preclude treatment of a miserable toddler with a temperature of 102.
Mark Crislip has written about the merits of fever as well:
There are numerous beneficial physiologic effects that occur as part of the febrile response. Virtually all aspects of the physiologic response to infection are, dare I say it, boosted, and many wings of the immune system function better at higher temperatures. I feel the naturalistic fallacy creeping over me: fever is an almost universal response to infection that evolved millions of years ago and helps enhance the response to infection. So suppressing a fever during infection should be bad. Right? This becomes a little less clear cut. There are issues as to how the fever is suppressed: mechanical, such as ice or alcohol baths. Pharmacologic: acetaminophen, steroids, aspirin or nonsteroidal anti-inflammatories, all of which have effects that go beyond suppressing fevers. What infection is occurring? A response that has evolved as a response to the infections found on the plains of East Africa could be counter productive against diseases of modernity like Pseudomonas sepsis in the ICU or MRSA endocarditis in a heroin user.
With respect to data on influenza and fevers, Crislip points to this review which notes the following:
In animal models, treatment with antipyretics for influenza infection increases the risk of mortality. There are no randomized placebo-controlled trials of antipyretic use in influenza infection in humans that reported data on mortality and a paucity of clinical data by which to assess their efficacy. We suggest that randomized placebo-controlled trials of antipyretic use in human influenza infection are urgently required, and that these are sufficiently powered to investigate a potential effect on mortality.
The bottom line in the medical literature, nicely summarized by these two SBM authors, is that fevers may offer beneficial effects, but there is no clear evidence of harm from treating them. So it seems premature to conclude that fevers in influenza confer meaningful beneficial effects.
Does suppressing a fever lead to more virus shedding?
The authors make the following statement to support their claim that treating fevers lead to more virus shedding:
To our knowledge, the only published experiment concerning the effects of antipyretic treatment on influenza viral shedding was conducted in ferrets (considered the best animal model for human influenza).
And they’re absolutely correct. There is no published evidence in humans to demonstrate that treating the fevers of influenza leads to more virus shedding. The authors cite what they believe to be supporting evidence in colds and chicken pox infections, but their relevance to influenza is unclear. The only other indirect evidence that seems relevant is a paper that they state shows a correlation between antipyretics and influenza A, but the abstract notes this was due to a second, bacterial infection, so it’s not relevant to this argument. I’m not a fan of relying on animal models to make conclusions about human outcomes, especially when I can easily find contradictory information, such as mice models that find acetaminophen reduces the morbidity associated with influenza without compromising immune responses. On balance it seems reasonable to conclude that there’s no convincing evidence to suggest that treating fevers will lead to more virus shedding.
Does treating a fever increase the likelihood that the sick will interact with the well?
The authors argue that a proportion of infected individuals will treat their fever. This proportion (“p”) will therefore increase their probability of infecting others to some extent (“fp“). The reproduction number (“R”) is the number of secondary infections caused by a primary infection. (In short, how many people does each sick person infect?) R is therefore proposed to increase by a factor of fp because of antipyretic use. The net effect is that treating fevers will increase that reproduction number, and therefore the overall size of the influenza pandemic (“Z”). These calculations are described in detail in a free supplement to the paper.
Are those with influenza infections more likely to interact with the well? The authors offer no justification for this assumption, perhaps believing it to be self-evident. They simply state:
An individual whose fever has been reduced is likely to feel better and is therefore more likely to interact with others.
But there’s no evidence provided to support this statement. It’s a hypothesis that’s completely unsubstantiated. It’s possible, yes. But it’s also speculation. It could be that those with treated infections don’t change their habits enough to increase their contact with others. There is no evidence to answer the question.
Will more viral shedding lead to larger epidemics, and deaths from influenza?
The authors try to establish a relationship between the illness, viral shedding, and transmission of the influenza virus. Their approach is as follows:
In order to infer the overall transmission implications, we need an estimate of the natural infectivity of influenza, i.e. the probability that a susceptible contacted by an (nonantipyretic-using) infectious individual will become infected. We are not aware of direct measurements of this probability, so we use published estimates [42] of the household secondary attack rate (SAR) as a proxy.
Yet another estimate in the absence of direct evidence. It’s not clear that infections within a household are a relevant comparator to the broader population. So this another assumption based on indirect data of questionable relevance. There is some research in this area which is somewhat supportive of the idea that virus shedding is generally correlated with the severity of the infection. However, it’s been established that virus shedding starts before symptoms like fever appear, and children start shedding earlier than adults. In addition, shedding can continue for days or even weeks after the symptoms have disappeared. It’s also important to note that 30-50% of influenza infection may not cause illness. And if they don’t cause illness, there’s no need to treat a fever. On balance, there’s no substantive or persuasive evidence to demonstrate that the antipyretics will have any meaningful influence on the degree to which influenza is spread in a population.
The remainder of the paper is the description of a population-based model estimating the negative consequences of treating the fevers of influenza. The authors estimate that most influenza fevers are treated with antipyretics (and again, don’t provide any direct evidence), ultimately concluding that treating fevers with antipyretics increases the spread of influenza by “at least 1%”, and suggesting that “at least 700 deaths per year” could be prevented in the United States alone by avoiding antipyretic medication when treating influenza. To the authors’ credit, they use a range of probabilities for each of their estimates. But in the absence of establishing cause-and-effect to any meaningful degree, this reminded me more of tooth fairy science than of a serious discussion of epidemiology. The authors paint a correlation between the harms of antipyretic use with the indiscriminate use of antibiotics, a comparison that falls flat given the good evidence of harms with antibiotic use, and the speculation throughout this analysis.
Conclusion
The idea that treating the fever of influenza with medication leads to more deaths in a population is a hypothesis. Critically, the authors fail to provide adequate scientific justification for their approach, nor do they substantiate any of their key assumptions with real world data. While successful in gaining media impressions and potentially frightening people away from treating the fevers associated with influenza, the paper fails to offer any credible evidence to support their claim that antipyretics have serious, negative population-level consequences. While it’s perfectly fine not to treat a fever, there is no convincing evidence to suggest that you’re putting others in the population at risk if you choose to do so.
Reference
Earn D.J.D., Andrews P.W. & Bolker B.M. (2014). Population-level effects of suppressing fever, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 281 (1778) 20132570-20132570. DOI: 10.1098/rspb.2013.2570

Beyond the flu shot: A closer look at the “alternatives”
Scott Gavura on December 5, 2013
Link
Once again, it’s influenza season. The vaccine clinics are open, and the hysterical posts about the vaccine’s danger are appearing in social media. There’s familiarity to all of this, but also a big new change – at least in Canada, where I am. Pharmacists can now administer the vaccine. And it’s completely free to anyone in Ontario (where I am), so the barriers to obtaining the vaccine are pretty much eliminated. There’s no longer a need to drag your kids to their family doctor or line up at a public health clinic. Anyone can walk into a pharmacy, show their health card, and walk out minutes later, vaccinated. It’s another enabling change that may help improve immunization rates, as uptake rates in the population remain modest.
This year’s flu season is (as of week 47) fairly quiet. Google Flu trends suggests a fairly typical picture, nothing like what we saw in 2009/10, the year of H1N1. My city’s influenza tracker reports only a dozen cases so far this season. Many of us will get our flu shot, continue with our lives, and not think about the flu until next season’s announcements. That’s the hope, anyway. Influenza can kill, and in its more virulent forms, is devastatingly deadly. The worst case scenario (so far) is almost unimaginable today. In 1918/19 an influenza pandemic killed 50 million people worldwide (5% of the population). So among public health professionals, that worry about the next wave is always present. Much has been written at this blog <plug>nicely compiled in the SBM ebook,</plug> on the efficacy and safety of the flu vaccine. In short, the vaccine is effective for both individual and population-level protection, but only modestly so, and its effectiveness varies based on its match with circulating strains. And despite widespread use for decades, there are frustrating limitations with the current vaccine beyond efficacy, including the need to repeat the shot annually. Someone said something about “going to battle with the army you have”. (I thought it was Crislip but he was quoting Rumsfeld.) The quote is apt. It’s not a perfect vaccine, but it does offer protection – if not directly to you, then indirectly to those at greater risk of infection. Hospitals and health facilities have been criticized for demanding health professionals either get the vaccine or wear a mask – and the arguments against vaccination are losing. But even the strongest advocates of influenza vaccine will acknowledge its limitations, which perhaps contributes to the understandable perception that there is more that could be done- beyond reasonable and effective precautions like handwashing and hygiene.
Whether it’s the confusion of colds with the flu, the known limitations of the vaccine, or the ubiquity of upper respiratory infections, there is no end to the products, therapies, and nostrums touted as influenza preventatives or treatments. And half of the population may be using them. In this realm, where evidence is mostly absent, pretty much anything goes. I was reminded of this by physician Yoni Freedhoff who noted that he was handed a coupon for “Flu Shield” after he and his family received the vaccine at his local pharmacy. These products are marketed like an extended warranty offer: Why stop at the vaccine? Buy the supplement for extra protection. At least extended warranties can occasionally be useful, unlike Flu Shield. Locally, the alternative-to-medicine purveyors are competing with public health endeavors by touting a monthly “homeopathic flu injection” while subtly discouraging the vaccine that actually provide immunization. Many of these products have been examined in detail in this blog, so I’ve compiled a list of the most actively promoted. I’ve categorized them loosely based on their plausibility and known efficacy data:
Possibly effective
Oseltamivir (Tamiflu): This is a drug, not a supplement, but worth mentioning as one of the few products that might work. There is published data to suggest oseltamivir is modestly effective for the prevention and treatment of influenza. However, given the lack of complete transparency with the oseltamivir clinical trials, it’s not possible to make any definitive conclusions about its effectiveness. Given any positive data would likely have been published already, my sense is that oseltamivir’s modest efficacy may be still overstated.
Unlikely to be effective
Vitamin D: While there’s evidence that some may be deficient in vitamin D, especially in the winter, supplementation doesn’t appear to have any effect at preventing infection.
Elderberry: There’s some promising data with elderberry suggesting it can reduce flu-like symptoms, but these findings it needs to be confirmed in larger trials. We’ve seen this pattern with just about every herbal remedy: Promising preliminary data, followed by less impressive data when better trials are done. It would be nice to see further studies to evaluate its effectiveness.
Zinc: Sold as lozenges for the treatment of colds, the effects are inconsistent. There’s no evidence showing efficacy for treating influenza. Zinc nasal sprays, such as Zicam, have been associated with permanent loss of the ability to smell.
Garlic: There is some preliminary data examining garlic’s effectiveness for preventing colds, but it’s inconsistent and the positive effects may not be real. There’s no evidence demonstrating any effectiveness of garlic for preventing or treating influenza. As preventatives go however, I’m supportive of any that also enhance my meals.
Ginseng: There are a number of forms of ginseng that have been studied for their immunostimulant effects. One of the more popular brands is Cold-fX. To the manufacturer’s credit, there have been some trials on Cold-fX examining its ability to help prevent colds and influenza. The data don’t suggest the effects, if any exist, are that meaningful. Whether it has any meaningful effects at influenza protection hasn’t been specifically studied.
Probably useless
Echinacea: Despite the hype and the marketing there is no persuasive evidence that Echinacea does anything to prevent or treat influenza. It’s one of the better-studied herbs for respiratory infections and is demonstrably ineffective. As Steven Novella noted, “The market for Echinacea endures, largely on a sea of anecdotes and marketing spin that is incongruous with the evidence.” If you think it works, you might feel better, but there’s no meaningful or measurable actual effects.
Wheatgrass: True modern-day snake oil, this is touted as an “immune booster” but isn’t any better than any other food.
Megavitamins: Sometimes called “orthomolecular” treatments, this is based on the idea that if vitamins in our diet are good, then massive doses of vitamin supplements must be better. The most commonly touted is vitamin c, but there’s no shortage of others. It’s the same idea behind the belief that vitamin infusions are a good idea. In the absence of a deficiency, there’s no convincing evidence that megavitamins have any beneficial effects for prevention or treatment.
Oil of Oregano: This is the herbal cure-all without demonstrable evidence of efficacy.
Definitively useless
Vicks Vaporub: Commonly used for symptom relief (it was around for the big pandemic of 1918/19), there’s no evidence it is effective for prevention or treatment. Even data showing it has any meaningful effects is poor. The active ingredient is camphor, a tissue irritant. There’s an urban myth that putting it on your feet will treat a cough, but that’s all it is – a myth.
Onion: Cutting up an onion and putting it beside your bed or around your house. Because onions suck up viruses, apparently.
Engystol, Pascoleucyn, and Gripp-Heel: These are homeopathic products. Like all other homeopathic preparations, there are no medicinal ingredients and are quite literally placebos, without demonstrable evidence of efficacy to prevent or treat influenza. Quite frighteningly, some that are approved as oral supplements (in Canada, at least) are marketed by the manufacturers (PDF) and administered by naturopaths as injections. Yes, they’re injecting oral products. Hopefully that water is sterile.
Oscillococcinum (Oscillio): The heart and liver of a Muscovy duck, fermented, then diluted to nothingness so the final product is 100% pure homeopathic placebo. Useless for both prevention and treatment.
Wet socks: This naturopathic strategy involves putting on a pair of cold, wet socks, covering them with dry socks, and then going to sleep. Apparently it will “‘rev up’ the immune system”, demonstrating the limits of the naturopathic understanding of immunity.
Pouring oil in your ear: Despite the claims, trying to heat a lymph node in your neck won’t have any impact your illness.
Despite all the limitations of the current flu vaccine, it still represents the most effective means of protecting yourself and the community from influenza. Despite the myriad of complementary and alternative remedies touted to prevent or treat influenza, there’s no convincing evidence for most treatments. This list isn’t exhaustive – if I’ve missed any popular ones, please let me know in the comments.

An Alternative “Truth” About Flu Shots
Harriet Hall on December 25, 2012
Link
Vaccines, and flu shots in particular, have been covered ad nauseum on this blog; but the anti-vaccine propaganda never stops, so forgive me for bringing it up again. A correspondent inquired about a podcast by Steve Wright on Revolution Health Radio entitled “The Truth About Flu Shots (and What to do Instead).” You can either listen or read the transcript. It’s just too funny to pass up. That is, it would be funny if it weren’t endangering our public health by spreading misinformation. 
Wright found an “expert” to interview: Chris Kresser, L.Ac. That’s Licensed Acupuncturist. Kresser says the dogma about flu shots is not evidence-based and they are over-promoted and over-hyped. He cites studies that cast doubt on their efficacy. He says a low percentage of health care professionals get them, which suggests to him that they know something that the general public doesn’t know. He says everyone should decide for themselves; but he doesn’t get flu shots himself, doesn’t think the risks justify the benefits, and interprets the evidence as showing that flu shots don’t work. He dismisses positive studies that were funded by industry. He dismisses studies about efficacy in the elderly because they rely on unreliable epidemiologic evidence. He says the risk of dying from flu is less than the risk from “other things, like car accidents and flying in a plane and stuff.” He says the studies on Tamiflu are biased. Based on a comment a former FDA employee supposedly left on his blog or on Facebook (he can’t even remember which), he claims the FDA approval process for vaccines is a joke, that they don’t put them through any of the same protocols that they would for normal drug development. (This is demonstrably false.)
Instead of Vaccines
He refers listeners to an article he wrote on his own blog about how to prevent (and treat) colds and flu naturally. His recommendations include:
    • A nutrient-dense, low-toxin diet with no sugar or refined flour but with lots of organ meats (!)
    • Fermented cod liver oil
    • Bone broth
    • Fermented foods
    • Probiotics
    • Neti pots
    • Vitamin C
    • Vitamin D
    • Handwashing
    • Zinc
    • Staying away from children
    • Getting adequate sleep
    • The Chinese herbal formula Yu Ping Feng San, or Jade Windscreen
    • Lactoferrin
    • Lauricidin
    • Raw garlic
He says he recognizes the need for scientific studies but he seems to rely on trying things for himself and listening to the anecdotal accounts of others.
Laughable References
His research abilities and the references he found to cite do not inspire confidence. He provides links to:
    • The writings of a prominent anti-vaccine spokesperson
    • An article in Scientific American that actually undermines his thesis (it reports the evidence fairly and questions the vaccine’s efficacy in the very young and very old but clearly says it works for older children and adults)
    • The article he wrote himself about natural flu remedies
    • Some of the systematic reviews mentioned in the Scientific American article
    • 4 links to Amazon.com pages offering various natural products for sale. (I don’t recall ever seeing Amazon pages proffered as references before.)
The studies he cites only demonstrate what we all know: the flu vaccine is far from ideal. Strains change every year, protection is far from 100%, and older adults don’t benefit as much as younger ones. People over 65 don’t develop as robust an immune response to the vaccine, so a new high-dose formula has been developed with four times as many antigens; studies have shown that it generates more antibodies but studies to determine its effectiveness in actually preventing cases of the flu are still in progress. We tell people if they don’t want to get the vaccine for themselves they should “get it for grandma” because the more vulnerable older and younger groups will be at less risk if more people are vaccinated so the disease can’t spread as well through the community.
He cherry picks the evidence and interprets it from a biased perspective. Experts in various fields put their heads together and reviewed ALL the published evidence and all the current scientific knowledge before they issued the official recommendations. They have seen and carefully considered all the studies he mentions. It is arrant hubris for him to think he knows more than all of them or has better judgment or has access to privileged information that the rest of us don’t.
Contradicting Himself
He says:
flu vaccines are not effective for adults. You have to treat between 33 people when the vaccine and infecting strain are well matched, which is rare, and 100 people when they’re not well matched, which is much more common, to prevent a single case of flu.
He says they are not effective but in the very next sentence gives statistics showing that they are effective! He’s talking about the NNT, the number of people needed to treat for one to benefit, and the numbers he provides are in line with a lot of other treatments we accept as effective. Who is he to decide that preventing one case of flu for every 33 to 100 people vaccinated is not worthwhile? I probably have less than a 1 in 100 chance of my house burning down, but I consider it worthwhile to have fire insurance. Remember that the goal of flu shots is not just to prevent deaths, but also to prevent suffering from flu symptoms and to reduce complications, time lost from work, and spread of disease in the community.
Not Enough Evidence, So Try Something with Less Evidence
Perhaps the funniest thing about his spiel is that after criticizing current flu shot recommendations for inadequate evidence, he proceeds to recommend a series of methods to prevent and treat flu naturally, methods that are supported by far less evidence and usually no evidence at all.
Conclusion
Why would anyone go to Kresser for advice about vaccines? He’s an acupuncturist, for Pete’s sake! His whole livelihood is based on a prescientific system of mythological qi and meridians. His website offers inaccurate information and questionable advice on diet, diabetes, heart disease, thyroid disorders, skin health, heartburn, and depression. He even offers a paleo detox program.
This podcast is an ignorant, biased distortion of the facts; and despite his protestations he is clearly trying to dissuade listeners from getting flu shots. It’s unfortunate that he is spreading this rubbish. He wants to talk people out of needles that might actually do some good, while deceiving them with useless acupuncture needles. Let the listener beware!
I didn’t take Latin; would that be caveat auditor?

Random Flu Thoughts
Influenza is a serious disease (not an upset tummy). The vaccine is an imperfect, yet still valuable tool in preventing deaths due to influenza. Get your ‘flu shot!
Mark Crislip on November 4, 2011
Link
I normally write the first draft of this blog the weekend before it is due, and this is no exception. However, I am ill this weekend. Headache, myalgia, painful cough, but only mildly ill. The worst part is the interferon induced brain fog; my thoughts flow with all the speed of pudding and I was not appreciably better as the week progressed, although no cracks about how you can’t tell any difference in my writing over baseline.
I doubt the cause of my symptoms is influenza. According to the CDC site and Google flu trends there is little influenza activity in the US at the moment, so it is probably one of the innumerable viruses that can cause a flu-like illness. I am also not ill enough to think I have influenza, but I could be having a modified course as I was vaccinated a month ago. Of course, the doctor who treats herself has a fool for a patient and an idiot for a doctor. Flu season approaches, so from my interferon-addled brains, flu thoughts.
Flu vaccine efficacy
The flu vaccine has a bad reputation in part because it is not the best of our vaccines for preventing illness and those who need vaccination the most are the least likely to respond. Still, I was happy to see the Lancet meta-analysis this month on the efficacy of the influenza vaccine, although it breaks no new ground. It was a nice paper in that they only included studies where influenza confirmed by culture or real-time polymerase chain reaction, not the clinical diagnosis of influenza:
We screened 5707 articles and identified 31 eligible studies (17 randomised controlled trials and 14 observational studies). Efficacy of TIV was shown in eight (67%) of the 12 seasons analyzed in ten randomised controlled trials (pooled efficacy 59% [95% CI 51—67] in adults aged 18—65 years). No such trials met inclusion criteria for children aged 2—17 years or adults aged 65 years or older. Efficacy of LAIV was shown in nine (75%) of the 12 seasons analysed in ten randomised controlled trials (pooled efficacy 83% [69—91]) in children aged 6 months to 7 years. No such trials met inclusion criteria for children aged 8—17 years. Vaccine effectiveness was variable for seasonal influenza: six (35%) of 17 analyses in nine studies showed significant protection against medically attended influenza in the outpatient or inpatient setting. Median monovalent pandemic H1N1 vaccine effectiveness in five observational studies was 69% (range 60—93).InterpretationInfluenza vaccines can provide moderate protection against virologically confirmed influenza, but such protection is greatly reduced or absent in some seasons. Evidence for protection in adults aged 65 years or older is lacking. LAIVs consistently show highest efficacy in young children (aged 6 months to 7 years). New vaccines with improved clinical efficacy and effectiveness are needed to further reduce influenza-related morbidity and mortality.”
Seems on an order of efficacy with seat belts, which decrease death by 70% and injuries by 40%. Neither the seat belt nor the flu vaccine is perfect, but both are better than no intervention at all. The largest problem with the vaccine is the difficulty in choosing the correct strains every year to be in the vaccine. If the JREF ever has a million dollar winner, I hope the new millionaire would use their powers for good and predict the upcoming years influenza strains.
A universal flu vaccine
There is ongoing work to improve the flu vaccine, which is what we really need. The problem with influenza is that it mutates. In the argot of the field it has antigenic drift, so that the organism at the end of the flu season does not antigenically resemble the strain at the beginning of the season and antigenic shift, where there is a whole new strain unknown to world, as happened with H1N1.
There are sections of protein of the virus that do not mutate, regions that are highly conserved, and if those proteins could be isolated perhaps there would be a universal vaccine against all influenza strains. And someone is on track to do just that:
To answer that question, Corti et al. screened 104,000 peripheral-blood plasma cells from eight recently infected or vaccinated donors for antibodies that recognize each of three diverse influenza strains: H1N1 (swine-origin influenza) and H5N1 and H7N7 (highly pathogenic avian influenzas). From one donor, they isolated four plasma cells that produced an identical antibody, which they called FI6. This antibody binds all 16 HA subtypes, neutralizes infection, and protects mice and ferrets from lethal infection. The most broadly reactive antibodies that had previously been discovered recognized either one group of HA subtypes or the other, highlighting how remarkable FI6 is in its ability to target the gamut of influenza subtypes.
That was a lot of work, but now that they have discovered the key to neutralizing all influenza, the challenge is to develop a vaccine that promote a reaction to that antigenic site and, viola, a universal flu vaccine. I hope we see it in my lifetime. It explains why if there is poor match between the vaccine and circulating influenza there is still efficacy, although decreased, from the vaccine. The lucky few will make antibody to the conserved areas common to all viruses and develop protective antibody in a mismatch year. Vaccine response is always more subtle than one antigen/one antibody.
It really surprises me that this advance is coming from basic science work on the immunology of influenza, I would have anticipated this kind of breakthrough would have come from NCAAM, which has been on the cutting edge of improving patient care and quality initiatives. Like, um, er, well, the brain fog is preventing me from recalling the advances.
Flu stats
Humans always have difficulties comprehending large numbers. Politics, and life, is small and local. If an event did not happen to you and yours then often it wasn’t important. I am used to thinking about large numbers and influenza, but they do not have the same impact compared to what happened in my own ICU with the initial H1N1 outbreak: all beds filled, all ventilators in use and no place to put the next case which, by some random luck, never occurred. The pandemic affected millions; I remember my 30 cases.
The CDC released estimates (and they are estimates, based to best data and models; if the CDC develops a better technique and changes the numbers, they are not “backing away” from the prior estimates, a phrase that always identifies someone who is both against vaccines and does not understand the tentative nature of all data) on both the effect of the H1N1 pandemic on the US:
43 million to 89 million cases, 195,000 to 403,000 hospitalizations, and 8,900 to 18,300 deaths, including 910 to 1,880 deaths among children aged <18 years, during April 2009–April 2010.
As well as the estimates for what the vaccine accomplished:
713,000 to 1.5 million cases, 3,900 to 10,400 hospitalizations, and 200 to 520 deaths were averted as a result of the vaccination campaign.
Not bad prevention considering 61 million Americans received the vaccine, a paltry 1 in 5.
Flu and pregnancy
There are people who have a marked increased risk of dying from influenza, including the obese and pregnant women (not pregnant men, I hasten to add living in Oregon). 1% of the population is pregnant, but in 2009 pregnancy accounted for 5% of H1N1 deaths.
It is difficult to convince pregnant women to get the vaccine, since people have an understandable fear of anything that could adversely affect the pregnancy. The data available suggests that not only is the vaccine safe in pregnancy but maternal vaccination protects the child against influenza. There is no data to suggest that the flu vaccine increases the risk of miscarriage and some reports suggest that influenza is associated with premature delivery. The effect of influenza infections on pregnancy outcomes has had little evaluation.
There was an interesting epidemiological study this month in JID on the 1919 pandemic that suggested that about 1 in 10 pregnant women had a first trimester miscarriage from influenza:
…documented an unusual 5%–15% decline in natality with a trough 6.1–6.8 months after the peak of the severe autumn 1918 pandemic wave in several Scandinavian countries and the United States. On average, 2.2 births per 1000 persons were missing during spring 1919, corresponding to an excess of ~1 in 10 pregnant women infected with influenza during their first trimester having miscarried in autumn 1918. We argue that the most parsimonious explanation for this unusual and temporal birth depression is substantial pregnancy losses following influenza infection in autumn 1918 among women who were then in their first trimester of pregnancy.
Whether vaccination would prevent miscarriage is unknown, but there is strong biologic plausibility to suggest it could. Vaccination benefits often extend beyond the simple concept of one vaccine preventing or ameliorating one infection. There is also all the positive consequences of not having an infection, from potentially avoiding a miscarriage to not having a heart attack.
Moral imperative
I am an Infectious Disease blogger over at Medscape and every October I publish a deliberately obnoxious essay on the flu vaccine. The essay is addressed to fellow Health Care Workers (HCW), and does somewhat come from the heart.
Here is my opinion.
Patients in the hospital are particularly vulnerable. They are a population at risk from their care providers. About 1 in 5 cases of influenza are subclinical, hospitalized patients are more susceptible to acquiring influenza from HCWs than the general population, and 27% of nosocomial-acquired H1N1 die.
As HCWs, it is our responsibility to our patients to maximize their safety when under our care. While not perfect, the influenza vaccine is a reasonable intervention to prevent the spread of flu from HCW to patient. Since HCWs have ready access to the worlds literature and the best minds in medicine, if HCWs use any of the standard excuses to avoid the flu vaccine and increase the risk of their patients they are, well, a Dumb Ass. We owe it to our patients to keep them safe.
There was a program a few years back to try an increase the hand hygiene rates in the hospital by enlisting the patients help. It is “OK to ask” if your HCW had washed their hands. I thought from the beginning the idea was bankrupt, and would anyone fly on an airline where it was “OK to ask” if the wheels are down when landing? I took an informal poll of patients on a medical unit and it was unanimous. Everyone understood what “It’s OK to ask” referred to, and not a one would ever ask their doctor or nurse if they washed their hands for fear of making them angry. And really, who wants to piss off the person responsible for their morphine?
Be that as it may, I would suggest that, during flu season, if you or someone you love is in the hospital, ask if their providers are vaccinated against the flu. Remember that being in the hospital probably means you are one of the groups unlikely to benefit from the flu vaccine and that your best protection is to not acquire influenza from others. If your HCW has not received the vaccine, ask for a new provider or, at a minimum, request they wear a mask while involved with your care. I know it will never happen, but there is a lot to be said for public pressure to alter behavior. I have been half thinking about starting a web site to promote the idea, but I haven’t the time.
Dumb associations
While a blog aimed at medical providers, Medscape apparently has a fair number of Dunning-Kruger amateurs who have taken offense at my suggestion that the vaccine is a good thing for health care providers and their excuses for avoiding vaccination are not grounded in reality. Again, the blog was not directed towards patients, but HCWs, and since the comments are anonymous, there is no way of really knowing who is commenting.
There are two broad themes as to why people refuse the vaccine. One is straight from Bizarro World: there is a cabal of government, pharma, and doctors whose sole purpose in giving the vaccine is to line the pockets of big pharma and keep people ill. This is a delusional state so at odds with the reality to which I am accustomed, and evidently so common, I am surprised there is no DSM entry for the disorder and there are no clinical descriptions of the phenomena. Most articles that address vaccine refusal have similar reasons:
Predictors of vaccine noncompliance were fear of needles (P ≤ 0.042), fear of getting sick from the vaccine (P ≤ 0.000), disbelief that the vaccine is effective (P ≤ 0.000), ignoring vaccination as a healthy behavior (P ≤ 0.000), and younger age (P ≤ 0.026).
And do not mention the paranoid medical-industrial conspiracy delusion that seems to be at the heart of a vocal subset of vaccine refusers. I make no money from giving the flu vaccine or from promoting the flu vaccine. Promoting the flu vaccine, like much of my professional life, is counter-productive to making money. I make money, and can prescribe with abandon to line the pockets of my corporate masters, only when people are admitted with the flu. At least, in the other Bizarro world where people have health insurance. Not always my world. The last thing I would want to do financially is prevent influenza.
Association is not causation
The other theme is that they, or someone they knew, had the vaccine and shortly thereafter had some adverse reaction attributed to the vaccine. Like the paranoid conspirators, the idea that the vaccine caused the subsequent disease is not amenable to logical refutation. It is a motto in the skeptical world that association is not causation, but it is a concept that is paid little attention.
Humans underestimate the role of randomness in their life and I recommend the Drunkards Walk as an excellent book on the topic. You have to know the background rate of events to know if there is an increased rate associated with a vaccine as a hint that the vaccine is potentially causative. For example:
On the basis of the reviewed data, if a cohort of 10 million individuals was vaccinated in the UK, 21·5 cases of Guillain-Barré syndrome and 5·75 cases of sudden death would be expected to occur within 6 weeks of vaccination as coincident background cases. In female vaccinees in the USA, 86·3 cases of optic neuritis per 10 million population would be expected within 6 weeks of vaccination. 397 per 1 million vaccinated pregnant women would be predicted to have a spontaneous abortion within 1 day of vaccination.
Random badness happens and it takes an immense, and for some impossible, effort of will to ignore what appears to be an association. Take, as example, death. People die. People get the vaccine. A hefty segment of those who get the vaccine are at risk of dying from underlying diseases. So you would predict that there would be a cluster of people who will die shortly after receiving the vaccine, but not due to the vaccine, as if anyone would be convinced otherwise:
In October 2006, four deaths occurred in Israel shortly after influenza immunization, resulting in a temporary halt to the vaccination campaign. After an epidemiologic investigation, the Ministry of Health concluded that these deaths were not related to the vaccine itself and the campaign resumed; however, vaccine uptake was markedly reduced. Estimates of true background mortality in this high-risk population would aid in public education and quell unnecessary concerns regarding vaccine safety. We used data from a large HMO to estimate mortality in influenza vaccine recipients aged 55 and over during four consecutive winters (2003, 2004, 2005 and 2006). Date of immunization was ascertained from patient treatment files, vital status through Israeli National Insurance Institute data. We calculated crude death rates within 7, 14 and 30 days of influenza immunization, and used a Cox Proportional Hazards Model to estimate the risk of death within 14 days of vaccination, adjusting for age and comorbid conditions (age over 75, history of diabetes or cardiovascular disease, status as homebound patient) in 2006. The death rate among influenza vaccine recipients ranged from 0.01 to 0.02% within 7 days and 0.09-0.10% at 30 days. Influenza immunization was associated with a decreased risk of death within 14 days after adjustment for comorbidities (Hazard ratio, 0.33, 95% CI, 0.18-0.61). Our findings support the assumption that influenza vaccination is not associated with increased risk of death in the short term.”
Yet I know, and you know, that any event after a vaccine will be credited to the vaccine, even, as with death, the preponderance of data points to the influenza vaccine decreasing mortality.
It was better back in the day
As a grumpy old fart who thinks that medical training was better back in my day, I have one piece of data in support of that assertion. An abstract at IDSA, and reported in Medscape suggests:
…that more recent graduates were 15% less likely than older graduates to believe that vaccines are effective. The younger graduates were also less likely to believe that inactivated or oral polio, measles, mumps, rubella, and varicella vaccines are safe.
Great. I suppose that my initial hypothesis was wrong. Having access to the world’s literature and the best minds in medicine is not so conducive to understanding the benefits of vaccines. Given the other nonsense taught in medical schools that is given the patina of respectability, what should I expect?

   Ososillyococcinum and other Flu bits.
Mark Crislip
Link
Osillococcinum
I keep half an eye on the medicine displays in stores when I shop, and this year is the first time I have seen Oscillococcinum being sold. Airborne as been a standard for years, but Airborne has been joined by Oscillococcinum on the shelves. Dumb and dumber. It may be a bad case of confirmation bias, but it seems I am seeing more iocane powder, I mean oscillococcinum, at the stores.
On a recent podcast I was listening to one of the hosts suggested a homeopathic remedy for flu symptoms, and then specifically suggested osillococcinum. This is a technology podcast, the 404, and the hosts are certainly bright, educated people. Why would he suggest osillococcinum? Probably because he unaware of how oh so silly the product is.
Look at the box. Seems impressive.
It is non sedating, no drug interactions, no side effects. It also has no cholesterol and no radon. It is, I have heard, the biggest emitter of N-rays ever discovered. It is “officially included in the Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia of the United States”, and we know from yesterdays post how worthless that designation is.
The active ingredient is listed as anas barbarae hepatis et cordis extractum 200C.
Whoa. The power of Latin, like a Harry Potter curse. I bet the product has been imbued with the Confundus charm, which may explain why it is “used by millions of people and is recommended by doctors around the world.”
What is the active ingredient, this anas barbarae hepatis et cordis extractum?
In the 1919 flu epidemic a physician who did not understand that artifacts on the slide, probably bubbles, move randomly due to Brownian motion. Looking at the tissues of flu patients with a microscope, he found what he thought was not only the cause of influenza, but the cause of all diseases: small cocci (round balls) that oscillated under the microscope. He found these wiggling bubbles in all the tissues of all the ill people he examined and thought he discovered the true cause of all disease. Sigh. Yet another cause of all illness. He is the only person, before or since, to see these oscillating cocci. Hence the name.
Subsequently, for obscure reasons, he became of the opinion that the heart and liver of the Muscovy Duck were the most concentrated source of these oscillating cocci. I have found the suggestion that it was because duck liver and heart is a source of influenza, but the product predates the discovery of the influenza, so that would be an oh so silly explanation.
So how best to to treat disease? Turn the oscilliococinum into a homeopathic nostrum:
Into a one litre bottle, a mixture of pancreatic juice and glucose is poured. Next a Canard de Barbarie is decapitated and 35 grams of its liver and 15 grams of its heart are put into the bottle. Why liver? Doctor Roy writes: “The Ancients considered the liver as the seat of suffering, even more important than the heart, which is a very profound insight, because it is on the level of the liver that the pathological modifications of the blood happen, and also there the quality of the energy of our heart muscle changes in a durable manner.”
After 40 days in the sterile bottle, liver and heart autolyse (disintegrate) into a kind of goo, which is then “potentized” with the Korsakov method where the glass containing the remedy is shaken and then just emptied and refilled, and the dilution factor is assumed to be 1:100.
Go to Starbucks tomorrow and get your Americano at 200C made with the same method as oscilliococinum. They will make your drink. Pour it out and fill the cup with water and shake it. Then pour it out, fill it up with water and shake it again. Pour it out etc.. And so on 200 times, the ultimate rinse, lather, repeat. And that should potentize the drink such that you will never sleep again.
By the time they are done, the duck goo can be found at one part duck goo in 102000 water molecules, which is damn impressive since there are only about 1080 (+/- 3) total atoms in the entire observable universe. Then one drop is placed on a bunch of tiny pills and sold for about a dollar a vial in the US. I bitch that linezolid is 50 dollars a pill, but at least there is something useful, 600 mg in fact, in the pill.
And that is the active ingredient. Active. I do not think it means what you think it means. Is here anyone of sound mind who reads the above who thinks oscilliococinum has any potential to treat flu? Really? I have a bridge in Brooklyn I would like to sell you. How this nostrum is supposed to alter the course of influenza is a delusion understood only by homeopaths. Anyone who understands the life cycle of influenza, the immune response to infection would find this concoction mystifying as a treatment for flu or its symptoms.
Oscilliococinum is popular over the world, and many of the testimonials on the interwebs suggest it is effective as both a preventative and a therapy, a stark example of why anecdotes are considered a suboptimal form of evidence.
There is no better example of the disconnect between EBM and SBM than oscilliococinum used for the treatment of flu, since the Cochran reviews have evaluated oscilliococinum and suggests that while it is useless for a prevention, it shortens symptoms by 0.28 days. For reasons I cannot discover, the Cochrane review on homeopathy was withdrawn. Embarrassment would be my guess. Other reviews have found no effect of oscilliococinum on flu symptoms.
Think about it. .28 days is about 6 hours. Have you ever had the flu or other viral illness and could say yes, now, at 3 pm, I am symptom free and no longer ill? Viral illnesses don’t die, they fade away. Given the nature of oscilliococinum, it is far more likely that the 6 hours from the studies was the random variation seen in clinical trials. There is zero reason, based on the known pathophysiology of influenza and the known origin of oscilliococinum, that the latter would have any effects on the former. And yet, while subsequently withdrawn, the folks at the Cochrane reviews felt it was a reasonable to perform a meta-analysis on nonsense.
Cochrane Reviews and the Flu Vaccine
Fortunately no one needs to go one on one with Death with oscilliococinum as your wingman. It has been a very quiet flu season. Much better than last year, when, thanks to H1N1 we were maxed out in the ICU.
There is a better way to prevent the flu than dilute, liquified duck innards. The flu vaccine. The Cochrane folks put out an update of their systematic review for the effectiveness of influenza. And their conclusions? It is not the greatest vaccine but effective.
In the relatively uncommon circumstance of vaccine matching the viral circulating strain and high circulation, 4% of unvaccinated people versus 1% of vaccinated people developed influenza symptoms (risk difference (RD) 3%, 95% confidence interval (CI) 2% to 5%). The corresponding figures for poor vaccine matching were 2% and 1% (RD 1, 95% CI 0% to 3%). These differences were not likely to be due to chance. Vaccination had a modest effect on time off work and had no effect on hospital admissions or complication rates. Inactivated vaccines caused local harms and an estimated 1.6 additional cases of Guillain-Barré Syndrome per million vaccinations. The harms evidence base is limited.
AUTHORS’ CONCLUSIONS: Influenza vaccines have a modest effect in reducing influenza symptoms and working days lost.
You get the feeling it pains them to admit the flu vaccine has efficacy, what with the caveat “In the relatively uncommon circumstance of vaccine matching the viral circulating strain and high circulation” in the conclusion.
And then, the weirdness in the abstract:
WARNING: This review includes 15 out of 36 trials funded by industry (four had no funding declaration). An earlier systematic review of 274 influenza vaccine studies published up to 2007 found industry funded studies were published in more prestigious journals and cited more than other studies independently from methodological quality and size. Studies funded from public sources were significantly less likely to report conclusions favorable to the vaccines. The review showed that reliable evidence on influenza vaccines is thin but there is evidence of widespread manipulation of conclusions and spurious notoriety of the studies. The content and conclusions of this review should be interpreted in light of this finding.
Fine. Who pays for the study can subtly bias the outcomes. I have written about that before. It does not necessarily discredit a study, but you do have to read and interpret the studies carefully and take the conclusions with a bit of salt substitute.
That is where, I thought, a meta-analysis comes in. Someone like Cochrane reviews the data with no concern about the quality of the journal or notoriety of the references. The Ccochrane reviews, I thought, looked at the numbers unbiased by the spin in the conclusions or where it was published.
So I can only think of two reasons why this warning was published.
1) The authors do not like the conclusions from the data, and are undermining the result, spinning the abstract to try and sway the message casual readers will take away from the review.
or
2) The authors are saying they are biased by the conclusions in the papers and the notoriety of some studies and as a result their analysis of the numbers is not to be trusted. In other words, they are incredulous rubes who just fell off the turnip truck and were sold a bill of goods by those city slickers with their manipulated conclusions and spurious notoriety. Sad either way.
The discussion is odd, with the authors saying that everyone misuses their meta-analysis and ignores the data.
Both generalizations are not supported by any evidence and seem to originate from the desire to use our review to support decisions already taken. The misquotes appear to be based on both the abstract and Plain language summary (which is what you would expect from a superficial reading of the review by people with a specific agenda).
They also use significant column inches to demonstrate just how the ACIP misquoted them.
and
The CDC authors clearly do not weight interpretation by quality of the evidence, but quote anything that supports their theory.
What a weird, petulant little potshot at the CDC. I could see a statement like that maybe in an editorial, definitely in a blog entry, but in the text of a major review? It makes me wonder if the Cochrane reviews have any editorial oversight for their content. If they do, then their editors have some splainin’ to do as to how a major evidence based review could revert to ‘Mommy, mommy, I don’t like the way the CDC is playing with my ball and they are calling me names. Make them stoooopppp.’
It is like reading a review of gold mining efficacy and the purity of the mined gold, and the author noting that some of the mines are near Las Vegas, a den of sin and that gold miners discuss mining at the roulette tables and sometimes the gold in made into baubles that decorate painted women, so the content and conclusions of the mining review should be interpreted in light of these findings. So weird.
It is probably projection on my part, but I find the Cochran reviews on influenza vaccination to be biased against the flu vaccine in a subtle way that I do not see in the other reviews. The oscillococcinum review, while fundamentally stupid given the nature of the intervention, brainlessly followed the data, even though there was no plausibility for the intervention.
The choice of adjectives used by the authors seem designed to cast doubt on vaccine efficacy. Now I am a vaccine proponent, and I could very well be reading into the text something that is not there. For an example, the plain language summary says
Inactivated influenza vaccines decrease the risk of symptoms of influenza and time off work, but their effects are minimal, especially if the vaccines and the circulating viruses are mismatched.
Minimal: of a minimum amount, quantity, or degree;
The data says
In the relatively uncommon circumstance of vaccine matching the viral circulating strain and high circulation, 4% of unvaccinated people versus 1% of vaccinated people developed influenza symptoms.
In a country the size of the US, that is the difference between 12 million and 3 million getting flu if everyone were vaccinated (yes, I know, all 300,000,000 Americans are not healthy adults). Worst case, it would be 6 million vrs 3 million. Still, across the whole population of the country, that would not be a minimal effect.
Or the number needed to treat:
The combined results of these trials showed that under ideal conditions (vaccine completely matching circulating viral configuration) 33 healthy adults need to be vaccinated to avoid one set of influenza symptoms.
In comparison, there are 250,000 new cases of Hepatitis B each year in the US and maybe 4000 HPV related cancer deaths a year in the US. Are the effects of the flu vaccine minimal in preventing these diseases? Maybe. But that is a judgement call, not a medical call.
Flu vaccine seems good intervention, a reasonable bang for the buck. I would say it is a moderately effective vaccine with widespread health benefits beyond the prevention of acute influenza (see below). The cost effectiveness of flu vaccination is debatable and is ultimately a value judgment. In medicine they try an calculate the quality-adjusted life-year of an intervention to see if it is worth it to society.
It is form of evaluation that makes my brain hurt and I lack the knowledge to do much except to take them at face value. The outcome of cost-effectiveness evaluations depends on the assumptions made. For the elderly, you get conclusions like this:
Vaccination was cost saving, i.e., it both reduced medical expenses and improved health, for all age groups and geographic areas analyzed in the base case. For people aged 65 years and older, vaccination saved $8.27 and gained 1.21 quality-adjusted days of life per person vaccinated. Vaccination of the 23 million elderly people unvaccinated in 1993 would have gained about 78 000 years of healthy life and saved $194 million. In univariate sensitivity analysis, the results remained cost saving except for doubling vaccination costs, including future medical costs of survivors, and lowering vaccination effectiveness. With assumptions most unfavorable to vaccination, cost per quality-adjusted life-year ranged from $35,822 for ages 65 to 74 years to $598,487 for ages 85 years and older.
In the US a cost per quality-adjusted life-year of around $50000 is considered acceptable for an intervention.
It appears to me that the authors of the Cochrane reviewers think flu vaccination is not a worthwhile public health intervention, which is fine, but quit being a weasel and hiding behind words like minimal and complaining that people misuse your reviews for their own ends. The get close to admitting this in the discussion:
Given the limited availability of resources for mass immunization, the use of influenza vaccines should be primarily directed where there is clear evidence of benefit.
If I waited for clear evidence in medicine I would treat no one. However, the preponderance of data from basic principals to epidemiology to clinical trials leads me to conclude that the flu vaccine is moderately effective and cost effective. Someday, I hope, they will develop the universal flu vaccine and then, with universal vaccination, we will get rid of flu morbidity and mortality. But, to quote Rumsfeldt, I have to fight the wars with the weapons I have.
The Cochrane reviewers appear to be whiny, little babies. BTW. It is not an ad hominem since I do not think the review is wrong or flawed because they are crybabies. The substance is fine, the style is whiny crybaby. Boo frigity who. Got an issue? Here’s a tissue.
Either way, the confidence I have in the Cochrane reviews, at least as far as influenza vaccine goes, is now at an all time low.
A Cherry Picked Study.
There are multiple potential benefits from the flu vaccine:
1) You do not get the flu this year.
1a) You have a milder case of flu.
b) You do not pass the flu to others.
iii) You do not die of flu.
IV) You do not die of short term complications of flu.
FIve) You do not die of long term complications of flu.
6) You may not get the flu in the future with other strains. It would appear that those who had the 1976 swine flu vaccine has some protection against the 2009 strain and since strains of flu keep returning, if there is a mismatch in the flu and the vaccine this year, it may give you benefit in the future.
One of the arguments against the efficacy of the flu vaccine as a preventative against death is the fact that those who get the vaccine have decreased mortality when there is no circulating flu. It is suggested that the decreased mortality is not due to the flu vaccine, but that those who get the vaccine are healthier.
Could there be an alternative explanation?
There are two ongoing themes in the ID literature that have yet to overlap. One is people who get severe infections that require hospitalization not only have increased short term mortality, but long term mortality as well. Why they die is not as well worked out, but in those who die after pneumonia have increased inflammatory markers at discharge.
The other theme is that inflammation is a prothombotic state and patients with acute infections are more likely to have strokes, heart attacks and pulmonary embolisms and that risk of vascular events can be elevated for up to a year. Even an aggressive tooth cleaning increases the risk for a vascular event.
The rate of vascular events significantly increased in the first 4 weeks after invasive dental treatment (incidence ratio, 1.50 [95% CI, 1.09 to 2.06]) and gradually returned to the baseline rate within 6 months.
I have said before that if probiotics could really boost your immune function, they should also increase vascular events like stroke and heart attack.
Infection leads to inflammation leads to clot leads to vascular events. If you could stop that cascade, say with a vaccine, you could conceivably decrease the number of deaths. And so it does with a combination of the flu and pneumococcal vaccine.
Of the 36,636 subjects recruited, 7292 received both PPV and TIV, 2076 received TIV vaccine alone, 1875 received PPV alone, and 25,393 were unvaccinated, with a duration of follow‐up of 45,834 person‐years. Baseline characteristics were well matched between the groups, except that there were fewer male patients in the PPV and TIV group and fewer cases of comorbid chronic obstructive pulmonary disease among unvaccinated persons. At week 64 from commencement of the study, dual‐vaccinees experienced fewer deaths (hazard ratio [HR], 0.65; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.55–0.77]; P<.001) and fewer cases of pneumonia (HR, 0.57; 95% CI, 0.51–0.64; P<.001), ischemic stroke (HR, 0.67; 95% CI, 0.54–0.83; P<.001), and acute myocardial infarction (HR, 0.52; 95% CI, 0.38–0.71; P<.001), compared with unvaccinated subjects. Dual vaccination resulted in fewer coronary (HR, 0.59; 95% CI, 0.44–0.79; P<.001) and intensive care admissions (HR, 0.45; 95% CI, 0.22–0.94; P=.03), compared with among unvaccinated subjects.
Note: the beneficial effects occurred up to 64 weeks after receiving the vaccines; influenza vaccine could conceivably protect from death outside of flu season because vaccination prevents the sustained detrimental inflammatory effect of infections.
This result does not hold true in every study, but the data suggests that the beneficial effects of preventing influenza are wide-ranging and not limited to avoiding an acute viral pneumonia. The effects of both influenza and the vaccine are more complicated than a simple flu vaccination prevents flu.
Two Statements
There are two statements that pretty much insure that the writer is an influenza goof.
One is that the H1N1 pandemic last year was no big deal. I do not know what planet they were on, but H1N1 brought my hospitals right to the edge of the volume of severe illness we could handle. In my system we also had around 10 deaths, several in pregnant females and all in young people. In 25 years I had never had a young person die of acute influenza until last year, and I do not want to repeat the experience.
One of our hospitals is a Trauma Center and we able to save a few patients who would have otherwise died because we offer ECMO. While the epidemic was not particularly virulent compared to historical disasters like the 1919 pandemic, it was the worst flu season I have experienced.
The other statement is that the CDC is “backing off” the claim that influenza kills 36,000 people a year, as if the prior estimates were a lie.
The problem with medicine is we develop better methodologies and techniques to try to answer difficult questions. How many people die of influenza? For years the answer has been around 36,000 and I have discussed the paper that resulted in that number. It was, like all epidemiologic studies, imperfect, but was the best at the time. Now they have a better study.
For H1N1 in 2010, the estimates for total direct and indirect deaths is ~12,470, with a range from ~8,870 to ~18,300. Certainly less than 36,000. How about other years? Turns out that, like much of medicine, the answer is complicated and depends on the year and the circulating strain of flu. Some years are better than others. Estimated number of annual influenza-associated deaths with underlying pneumonia and influenza by age group — United States, 1976–77 through 2006–07 influenza seasons cause was 6,309 deaths a year, with a minimum of 961 and a maximum of almost 15,000 deaths, plus or minus the usual margin of error.
The estimated number of annual influenza-associated deaths with underlying respiratory and circulatory causes, by age group — United States, 1976–77 through 2006–07 influenza seasons was an average of 23,000 deaths with a minimum of 3000 and a maximum of 48,000.
Like so much in medicine the answer hinges on the phase ‘it depends.’ The CDC used more sophisticated techniques and came up more nuanced numbers. When someone asserts that the CDC is backing away from prior numbers, you know they have no understanding of medicine or epidemiology and the constant urge to improve. Unlike most SCAM’s, which have made almost no substantive improvements since their founding. Of course you cannot improve on perfection. Or increase by multiplying something by zero.
So get the vaccine and avoid the o-so-silly-o-coccinum.

   Flu Woo Hodge Podge
Mark Crislip
Link
Perhaps you have discovered for yourself that I am always the last to write a post on a ‘hot’ topic. I am definitely the slowest writer (and thinker?) on this blog, starting each post at least a week before it is up. So the faster writers weigh in first and I am left with clean up.
As I finish writing on Thursday, there have been 892 cases of H1N1 aka Swine flu and 2 deaths in the US. Looks like the world has avoided a disastrous pandemic like the 1919 flu that killed off 2 to 5% of the world. For now. Maybe. I hope.
However, the flood of nonsense about the flu far exceeds the infection rates from H1N1. This entry will be the limited by necessity. The quantity of quackery (9) far exceeds my ability to type. I thought that influenza virus replicated and spread fast. It pales next to the flu woo.
First off
The conspiracy loons are out again. Sorry. I can’t say theorists, as a theory does not, to the best of my understanding, apply to fantasy.
One form of conspiracy suggests that the new strain of influenza could not have happened naturally; that it has been manufactured by the government.
“The latest bioterrorism attack by the New World Order is likely a beta test. Yes, it is a bioterrorism attack. It was a hybrid strain created from human, swine, and bird flu from North America, Europe, and Asia. It was created in a laboratory. This doesn’t happen in nature.(1)”
But it does happen in nature. All the time. Making a new flu is the modus operandi of the influenza virus.
There are lots of flu’s. Human, swine, bird, cat, dog, and horse influenza. And the flu is different from most viruses in that it can jump species. So a bird flu can infected a pig. And a human flu can infect a pig. And pig flu can infect, well, a pig. I am glad I am not a pig.
The other difference between influenza and most other viruses is that influenza DNA is in segments. Usually a virus has one long piece of DNA or RNA. Influenza has seven or eight segments of RNA.
So if a pig is simultaneously infected with pig, bird, and human strains of influenza, as it reassembles itself, it takes a few segments of pig RNA, a few segments of human RNA and a few segments of bird influenza RNA, and, much like what occurred in Frankenstein, you have a new strain of flu constructed from the parts of other flu’s. Like Frankensteins monster, it can go berserk, killing and maiming. It happened in 1919, infecting half the world and killing 2 to 5%. Or, soothed by music (can I stretch a metaphor?), it can be calmed and hurt no one, as happened in 1976 and, maybe, 2009.
When you get those new strains (what we call in the biz the genetic shift), there is no prior immunity in the population so the disease can spread rapidly and, if an aggressive strain, kill. This genetic shift has occurred regularly in history and we are somewhat overdue for a pandemic strain of influenza. You cannot predict in advance when the genetic shift will occur and, when it shifts, if the new strain has the right combination of virulence (the ability to kill) and infectivity (the ability to spread) to cause a catastrophic pandemic. Avian flu, H5N1, is virulent, but currently not infectious in humans. The H1N1 seems infectious but not virulent. Let us hope these two strains do not meet in a pig somewhere and re-assort their genes to give us the Hannah Montana flu with the best of both worlds, virulence and infectivity.
That “this doesn’t happen in nature” is completely, totally 100% wrong. The production of new strains of influenza goes back forever, or at least 1890, which is the same thing.
Why would they the evil government release such a virus into the world? Evidently some think the world is run by Ra’s al Ghul , and the purpose of releasing the flu is to decrease over population. Yes, the world is over populated, so the our secret overlords have made a new strain of flu and released it on an unsuspecting world to thin the herd. Now if it were my goal to decrease world population, influenza flu would be the last virus I would choose as a bio weapon. It ‘only’ kills, at most, 5% of those infected. Rather than starting the infection in a Mexican pig farm, I would release it in the naked mole rat warrens of Chicago O’Hare airport to insure maximal spread. And lastly, I would be competent enough to make a strain of flu that was, oh, I don’t know, lethal.
The combination of a lack of knowledge of history and biology is astounding in these web sites. As I mentioned above, flu changes. Constantly. One of these years, maybe this one, may in 25 years, there will be a perfect storm of a new strain of flu with both high infectivity and high virulence to which the world lacks immunity and a lot of people will die. It did not pan out in 1976 and it may not pan out in 2009, but, like earthquakes and volcanic eruptions, a pandemic will happen again.
The another reason this strain of influenza is alleged to have been released into the wild was by Big Pharma to sell more drugs and vaccines.
This has two variations. The first is that the swine flu is a natural phenomena that Big Pharma is taking advantage of to sell more drug. Well, duh. But Big Pharma are pikers compared to the woo sites for pushing their antiflu nostrums, often while complaining about the avarice of the makers of Tamiflu.
The other is that the virus was deliberately released by the government to allow Big Pharma to take advantage of the pandemic to sell more Tamiflu. One web site calls Swine Flu the Big Pharma Bailout.
I can’t even begin to wrap my head around the idea that H1N1 is a joint effort of the Mexican drug cartels and al Qaeda to accomplish some nefarious scheme or other. All conspiracy ideas are, at their core, incomprehensible when tested against reality.
So many conspiracies that the government is evolved in: bigfoot, UFO’s, Kennedy assassination cover up, suppressing the truth about alternative medicine, faked moon landings and on and on. How do they find the time to be involved in so many secret projects and still get the mail delivered, I will never understand.
You do not need a conspiracy theory to understand why one frets when a new influenza starts. Reality is far more distressing.
The other oddness in many of the flu woo sites is saying that the swine flu of 1976 is the same swine flu as 2009. The argument is since swine flu in 1976 didn’t spread or kill and the 1976 vaccine was more dangerous than the disease, we should not worry about the swine flu of 2009 and we should avoid vaccines as the current flu will behave the same.
They are not the same. They are different strains, altered over time, and already are manifesting different pathogenicities. The flu strain from 1976 never became infectious and did not spread beyond Fort Dix New Jersey. The 2009 Swine seems to be spreading quickly around the world and has, maybe, an infectivity rate in families of about 25%. It is also apparently causing a mild to moderate disease in most people.
And it appears that rather than being a new strain, this is a direct descendent of the H1N1 from 1919. It is thought that in 1919 the influenza entered the pig population at the same time it infected humans, although pigs had a much less severe disease in 1919, and it has been circulating in the pig population ever since, evidently attenuating its virulence. Saying that this strain is the same as 1976 and we need do nothing is not rational. Equally irrational would be to say it is the equivalent to the 1919 strain and reacting accordingly. I do feel pity for those that have to make the decision as to how to react to the potential of a pandemic. If it doesn’t pan out, they look like over-reacting fools, and if it recapitulates 1919, everyone will call for their heads.
Today on the morning news program Wake Up and Panic America, or some such show my wife had on as we prepared for work, I heard the newscaster solemnly assure the American people that the flu ‘had not mutated yet” and was not yet able to kill people.
One wonders why Americans are less than knowledgeable about science when such a phrase, incorrect in general and in the specifics, appears to be the stock phase on the TV.
Of course influenza is mutating. Viruses are sloppy at reproduction. Millions of viruses are being made and there is the slow, inevitable genetic drift that ensures that the strain at the beginning of the flu season is slightly different than the stain at the beginning of the season. That happens every year in every strain of flu. What the flu does not usually do is mutate towards any goal, like increased virulence. If, as mentioned above, the Hannah Montana strain is produced in some pig somewhere, that will not be a mutation any more than the my children are a mutation of me.
An exception to this may be avian flu. The current bird flu prefers to bind to α-2,3–linked sialic acids, which are only found deep in the lung and whereas human influenza viruses bind preferentially to α-2,6–linked sialic acids, which are in the upper airway. It is a worry with the bird flu that simple mutations (or meeting a swine flu) could change its preference from lower airway sialic acids to upper airway sialic acids with a marked increase in potential infectivity. There is not an issue for the current swine flu.
The ones to really suffer are the pigs. The disease is spread human to human. It is not spread by eating pork. Pigs are only a potential source for the disease if you are a pig farmer. Egypt killed 300,000 pigs and in the Iraq zoo (they have a functioning zoo!) they killed the Boars out of fear of influenza transmission. Bad mistake should the flu lead to a fatal pandemic a-pork-alypse (5): they have removed an important source for food.
Some web sites have blamed are the factory farms for the outbreak (6).
“To understand how this happens, you have to compare two farms. My grandparents had a pig farm in the Swiss mountains, with around twenty swine at any one time. What happened there if, in the bowels of one of their pigs, a virus mutated and took on a deadlier form? At every stage, the virus would meet stiff resistance from the pigs’ immune systems. They were living in fresh air, on the diet they evolved with, and without stress – so they had a robust ability to fight back. If the virus did take hold, it would travel only as far as the sick hog could walk. So if the virus would then have around twenty other pigs to spread and mutate in – before it would hit the end of its own evolutionary path, and die off.
If it was a really lucky, plucky virus, it might make it to market – where it would come up against more healthy pigs living in small herds. It has little opportunity to fan out across a large population of pigs or evolve a strain that could be transmitted to humans.
Now compare this to what happens when a virus evolves in a modern factory farm. In most swine farms today, six thousand pigs are crammed snout-to-snout in tiny cages where they can barely move, and are fed for life on an artificial pulp, while living on top of cess-pools of their own stale faeces.
Instead of having just twenty pigs to experiment and evolve in, the virus now has a pool of thousands, constantly infecting and re infecting each other. The virus can combine and recombine again and again. The ammonium from the waste they live above burns the pigs’ respiratory tracts, making it easier yet for viruses to enter them. Better still, the pigs’ immune systems are in free-fall. They are stressed, depressed, and permanently in panic, making them far easier to infect. There is no fresh air or sunlight to bolster their natural powers of resistance. They live in air thick with viral loads, and they are exposed every time they breathe in. “
It’s a nice story, but ignores influenza biology. Factory farms are probably the reason new strains of flu do not originate in the US. You get new strains not when influenza mutates (the aforementioned genetic drift) but when it gets new DNA from re-assortment (the shift). The shift occurs when humans, birds and pigs live in close proximity, like in small farms found in SE Asia.
Besides, the 1919 pandemic preceded the rise of factory farming and the record of pandemics stretches far into our agrarian past, when the world was full of eco-friendly, stout gentleman-farmers. We are overdue for a good pandemic. If factory farming were to blame, I suppose we should have seen more rather than fewer pandemics last century. It could also be argued that dense pig populations lead to less infectious, less virulent organisms as the crowding helps facilitate spread of virus. If the next pig is a cough away, the virus need not be particularly infectious or virulent. Highly virulent infections often become less so as they spread through a population, becoming attenuated. Rapidly killing your host is not an efficient way to spread.
Factory farms have many infectious disease issues, but helping evolve new hyper virulent flu may not be one of them.
Then there is prevention and treatment flu woo.
Prevention
Wash your hands often and well. Easy enough. Infected secretions are on the phone (think Golgafrincham). You touch the phone and, by the magic of the finger, it is transferred to your mouth or nose and you get the flu. No one seems to object to hand washing.
Masks? Interesting question. Do masks prevent flu?
Well, the counterfeit masks no not. Our pharmacist informs me that counterfeit N95 masks are coming into the country. But lets say you have a real n95 mask. Will it work? Interestingly, the data to support n95 masks to prevent viral infections is not good. Most of the data is from surrogates or other, similarly sized virus. Are there clinical data to suggest that n95′s will prevent flu? Not that I can find. It should work, but should is not will.
A surgical mask, which is used to prevent the surgeon from dribbling on the wound, lets about 20% of viral particles through. The n95 lets in 5% if used correctly. If I were being exposed to an infection that was spread in part by breathing it in, I would prefer to inhale 5% of the potential infection rather than 100%. Whether that would be enough to prevent the acquisition of swine flu will depend on how infective this strain is.
There is, in the flu woo writings, perhaps a double standard. In medicine we recognize that benefits are incremental. No single prevention is 100% effective and prevention of infection is due to the summation of multiple interventions: sanitation, nutrition, vaccination, and medication. Are masks 100% effective? Nope. Are they 100% worthless? Nope. The truth lies somewhere in between. Masks are not a panacea, but then no single intervention in medicine is.
This is contrasted with woo therapies, which are often touted as the one true therapy.
Currently, every known nostrum possible is offered to combat the flu instead of the antiviral Tamiflu. As the Natural News (10) says:
“since swine flu is only a few weeks old, it is impossible for any substance to yet have “scientific evidence” of efficacy, including government-recommended anti-virals like Tamiflu. Technically speaking, there is zero credible scientific evidence that Tamiflu works to treat swine flu infections, either. Where are the studies? The scientific papers? There are none, precisely because swine flu is too new to have been carefully studied by anyone.”
That is true. Technically. At a technical level, on some days my whole practice is unproven. There is zero credible evidence, at least by Natureal News standards, that antibiotics work for a particular infection. I know the organism (say H1N1), I know what organ is infected (say the lung). I know whether in the lab the infection is susceptible to a given antibiotic (say Tamiflu), and I know if similar organisms are susceptible in that space, then I can alter the course of infection with antibiotics (like occurred with prior influenza strains). Based on biologic plausibility and the Infectious Disease Law of Similars, Tamiflu should be effective. This line of reasoning is not limited to Tamiflu. For example, I have a patient with an MRSA hip infection who is allergic to Vancomycin. There are no series of MRSA in hips, with the patients similar co-morbidies, treated with any of the alternative agents for MRSA. Yet oddly enough, I expect her to respond to the antibiotic because we have a long track history of knowing that if it is sensitive in the test tube, and has been effective in other infections, it will often work in the patient.
The natural news continues:
“I’m not against Tamiflu. It’s a very effective anti-viral drug, thanks to the fact that it’s derived from a natural anti-viral herb. If I were infected with swine flu and offered some Tamiflu, I’d take it, too.”
The naturalistic fallacy in full display. Tamilfu’s origin has nothing to do with its efficacy. It is effective because chemists have modified shikimic acid, from Chinese Star Anise, to a molecule that specifically interferes with the influenza viral neuraminidase (11):
Being the end result of 13 steps that massively alters the structure of the molecule, it is a wonder that the Natural News approves of its naturalness.
Chinese Star Anise being in short supply, chemists have developed at least three ways of bypassing the need for shikimic acid completely. Will the resultant Tamiflu be rendered ineffective because it is not longer derived from the natural product?
As an aside, as best as I can determine, there are no intrinsic antiviral effects from shikimic acid on the influenza virus.
The argument from Natural News appears to be that since plants are infected with viruses and therefore have anti-viral defenses, by consuming plants, you get the benefit of the plant anti-viral molecules.
This would be a good reason to smoke, it humans could be infected with the tobacco mosaic virus. But we aren’t. A plant has no biologic reason to have a specific anti-influenza molecule like a neuraminidase inhibitor, because plants are not infected with influenza, something about not having a lung.
Some flu woo is interesting, he writes sarcastically, like homeopathy or enemas and detox. If you are getting a respiratory virus in your colon, you have greater issues to worry about than the need for a colonic detox. There’s blood electrification, and colloidal silver and a huge list of herbal products.
What does the medical literature say about sCAMs and the treatment of influenza? There are a smattering of studies that have evaluated these products for the prevention and treatment of influenza.
Homeopathy
Perhaps the oldest and most popular nostrum specifically suggested for influenza is oscillococcinum. Oscillococcinum (12) is a homeopathic preparation of duck liver and heart liver that has been allowed to autolyse for 40 days. Really. This preparation has an odd history, even for homeopathic remedies. Joseph Roy, a French physician during the Spanish flu of 1917, examined the blood of influenza patients under a microscopeand saw “a bacterium that consisted of two unequal balls that performed a quick vibratory motion. Roy called them oscillococci.” Sounds like he was seeing brownian motion artifact.
There are no oscillococci. They are the N-Rays of homeopathy. He found these oscillococci in every disease he examined and concluded there were the cause of everything from flu to eczema. Since oscillococci were found in every disease, a homeopathic preparation of oscillococci would be a universal cure for all disease.
Here is how it is made (12):
“Since 1925, Oscillococcinum has been prepared as follows. Into a one litre bottle, a mixture of pancreatic juice and glucose is poured. Next a Canard de Barbarie (duck) is decapitated and 35 grams of its liver and 15 grams of its heart are put into the bottle. Why liver? Doctor Roy writes: “The Ancients considered the liver as the seat of suffering, even more important than the heart, which is a very profound insight, because it is on the level of the liver that the pathological modifications of the blood happen, and also there the quality of the energy of our heart muscle changes in a durable manner.” … After 40 days in the sterile bottle, liver and heart autolyse (disintegrate) into a kind of goo, which”
then undergoes homeopathic dilution. And is it diluted to 200 C. That’s 1 part in 1000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000.
The known universe is not large enough to dilute one atom to that degree.
Now I thought that homeopathic treatments were individualized. Except when they are not, as in the case of Oscillococcinum. One wonders, since the oscillococci are non-existent, how duck liver/heart adheres to the “like cures like” manifesto, since neither the duck heart nor the duck liver, although delicious, causes flu symptoms?
Does it work? Should it? As a remedy, it violates the principals of both real medicine and magical homeopathy.
There have been clinical trials with Oscillococcinum, and, for the sake of brevity, I quote the Cochrane review (13):
“Seven studies were included in the review, three prevention trials (number of participants (n) = 2265) and four treatment trials (n = 1194). Only two studies reported sufficient information to complete data extraction fully. There was no evidence that homeopathic treatment can prevent influenza-like syndrome (relative risk (RR) 0.64, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.28 to 1.43). Oscillococcinum treatment reduced the length of influenza illness by 0.28 days (95% CI 0.50 to 0.06).”
The Cochrane reviews are always punctilious about language. Patients who received Oscillococcinum were better 6 hours faster. There is no good reason to suggest causality, and while doubtful it is a real effect, rather than artifact of clinical trials, it is also a duration that is clinically irrelevant.
Oscillococcinum is worse than Tamiflu, which has barely clinically relevant results, decreasing the duration of illness a little over a day. Its why prevention of influenza (vaccine), if available, is always better than treatment.
Other CAM
The same lack of efficacy was found for P. quinquefolium, Sambucus nigra, Kan Jang, which failed to show benefit in the treatment of influenza (6):
“In conclusion, the effectiveness of any complementary and alternative therapy for treating or preventing seasonal influenza is not established beyond reasonable doubt. Current evidence from randomized controlled trials is sparse and limited by small sample sizes, low methodological quality, or clinically irrelevant effect sizes. For avian influenza, no data are currently available. These results strengthen conventional approaches for seasonal influenza. (6)”
Chinese herbs have also fared badly when evaluated critically:
“The present evidence is too weak to support or reject the use of Chinese medicinal herbs for preventing and treating influenza (13).
Otherwise trying to find references specific to influenza and various combinations of alternative and complementary medicine clinical trials yields so little research that I am sure those at the Natural News would never suggest them as therapeutic options for H1N1 since there is ”zero credible scientific evidence that (natural preparations) works to treat swine flu infections.”
I did find
” Treatment of fever due to exopathic wind-cold by rapid acupuncture, from J Tradit Chin Med. 1992 Dec;12(4):267-71.
57 cases of common cold, influenza, acute tonsillitis and acute bronchitis were treated by rapid needling with filiform needles at Dazhui (Du 14), Fengchi (GB 13), and Quchi (LI 11). The indices for observation were first determined, and the 19 cases that manifested an axilla temperature drop of over 1 degree C after treatment and a ratio of < 0.3 of the main symptom scores after treatment were regarded as markedly effective; the 27 cases that manifested an axilla temperature drop of 0.5-1.0 degree C and a symptom score ratio of 0.3-0.6 were regarded as effective, and the 11 cases that manifested an axilla temperature drop of < 0.5 degrees C and a symptom score ratio of > 0.7 were regarded as failures. The total effective rate was 80.7%. Analysis of the individual patients indicated that the peripheral blood leucocyte and lymphocyte counts differed insignificantly after needling, while the body temperature, rate of respiration, pulse, blood pressure and acupoint temperature all dropped, with a simultaneous increase in the percentage of T-lymphocytes. The immediate effects were especially marked in fevers due to exogenous wind and cold.”
Which did make me giggle. All fevers break making the patient feel better. I am surprised acupuncture was not 100% effective, since it is the natural history of the disease.
There is no end of nonsense touted for the prevention and treatment of the flu; there is a very short list of those that have been clinically evaluated and all have been found wanting. I will mention the one piece of advice that may indeed be reasonable, with caveats.
Vitamin D
More than important for bone and calcium metabolism, vitamin D is an important hormone for immune function.
It has been noted that influenza occurs in the winter when the least amount of vitamin D is made from sun exposure. Several studies have demonstrated that people who are low in vitamin D are at increased risk for viral respiratory infections (7). Unfortunately, the one study that looked at vitamin D supplementation for the prevention of upper respiratory infections in normal people (vitamin D levels of 63) had no benefit despite increasing the vitamin D serum levels (8). Equally unfortunately, as an ‘immune booster’, vitamin D does not improve the response to the influenza vaccine (18).
Vitamin D deficiency is not uncommon and increasing (18). So if you are vitamin D deficient, there may be benefit in taking supplemental vitamin D. But like all vitamins, taking extra does nothing. When the gas tank is full, there is no benefit in adding more gas. Vitamin D is not a panacea and of no utility as a therapy if you are replete.
Best bet for swine flu? Wash your hands, don’t inhale, stay away from coughers. Get the vaccine if available (given the experience of 1976, that will be a hard sell). And hope H1N1 doesn’t meet H5N1 in some lonely pig.
And finally, don’t try a ‘pox party.’ Some parents take their kids to get chickenpox when there is an outbreak in the neighborhood so they have some control over when their child is infected (I will admit to some sympathy with this position in the pre vaccine era). There is a suggestion that similar parties should be held with swine flu patients (19). I would advise against it. One, you may end up passing flu on to someone less able to contain the disease and die. And, although the current strain does not appear to be that virulent, some people may, due to the wrong gene set, be predisposed to die from the flu (19). Unless your DNA has been. decoded, why take the risk?
====
(1) http://www.dvorak.org/blog/2009/05/01/is-the-swine-flu-a-beta-test-attack-by-the-new-world-order/
(2) Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2007 Oct 17;(4):CD006207. Interventions for the interruption or reduction of the spread of respiratory viruses.
(3) Am J Infect Control. 2006 Mar;34(2):51-7. Do N95 respirators provide 95% protection level against airborne viruses, and how adequate are surgical masks?
(4) http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/EID/vol12no01/05-0965.htm
(5) Thanks to Rebecca Watson of SGU for this hideous pun.
(6) Complementary medicine for treating or preventing influenza or influenza-like illness. Am J Med. 2007 Nov;120(11):923-929.e3. Review.
(7) Association between serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D level and upper respiratory tract infection in the Third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey.
Arch Intern Med. 2009 Feb 23;169(4):384-90.
(8) A randomized controlled trial of vitamin D3 supplementation for the prevention of symptomatic upper respiratory tract infections. Epidemiol Infect. 2009 Mar 19:1-9.
(9) The next James Bond movie.
(10) http://www.naturalnews.com/026215.html
(11) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oseltamivir_total_synthesis
(12) http://www.homeowatch.org/history/oscillo.html\
(13) Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2006 Jul 19;3:CD001957 Homoeopathic Oscillococcinum for preventing and treating influenza and influenza-like syndromes.
(14) Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2007 Oct 17;(4):CD004559. Chinese medicinal herbs for influenza.
(15) Calcitriol (1,25-dihydroxy-vitamin D3) coadministered with influenza vaccine does not enhance humoral immunity in human volunteers. 1999 Apr 9;17(15-16):1883-8.
(17) Epidemiol Infect. 2006 Dec;134(6):1129-40. Epub 2006 Sep 7. Epidemic influenza and vitamin D
(18) Arch Intern Med. 2009 Mar 23;169(6):626-32.Demographic differences and trends of vitamin D insufficiency in the US population, 1988-2004.
(19) J Infect Dis. 2008 Jan 1;197(1):18-24. Evidence for a heritable predisposition to death due to influenza.

   More Flu Woo For You, Boo Boo
Mark Crislip
Link
In which we try to be smarter than the average bear.
Flu season is upon us (it kind of never left us this year), and there is a new strain of flu, the H1N1, aka Swine flu that adds a wrinkle or two to the usual potential for influenza related morbidity and mortality. And with the new flu is the new woo. I know that others have addressed flu in this forum and some of this may be redundant. Still, we each have our different styles and interests, so I hope the various posts are additive rather than redundant. I am going to wander through some odds and ends about flu in general and H1N1 specifically and compare some of the woo with the reality. At least my reality.
Influenza and Vitamin D
Influenza can be prevented or treated with Vitamin D. Don’t tell that to Dr. Marshall. The Natural News, the source for all things over hyped and under understood (Ick. That parallel form didn’t work.), is a nice example of the hype of Vitamin D as a preventative an treatment of influenza.
Vitamin D is an interesting molecule. Besides its long known effects on bone metabolism, Vitamin D has many immunomodulatory effects and is an important vitamin for immune function. Vitamin D even has effects on nitric oxide regulation. Its effects on infection risks are just beginning to be elucidated but deficiency states (note deficiency states) are associated with an increased risk of viral respiratory infections and worsening of pulmonary tuberculosis.
Again, deficiency states. If you are replete in your Vitamin D, there is apparently no immunologic advantage in taking extra, as seems to be the case with all vitamins. Metaphorically, if the tank is full of gas, you can’t go further by pumping more gas into the tank.
Vitamin D deficiency is not uncommon in the Northern Latitudes especially in the winter and in populations who have little sun exposure (nursing home patients). So like all deficiency states, it is reasonable to fill the tank, with extra Vitamin D. It will probably decrease the chance of getting a viral respiratory infection. In general, supporting data is limited and the effect small, as a review points out (2).
How about Vitamin D specifically for influenza?
There, the data is limited and mostly epidemiologic, but interesting none the less. The natural news, which states “In the realm of peer-reviewed medical literature, searching Google Scholar for “influenza” and “vitamin D” returns tens of thousands of results (http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q…).”
Interestingly, using influenza and dental floss for search terms on Google scholar results in over 1500 articles; it is hardly the source for the peer reviewed literature. If you use Pubmed, the source for peer reviewed literature, there are 30 references, not tens of thousands, and less than a half dozen specifically concerning vitamin D and influenza.
The reasoning goes like this: flu increases in the winter. In the winter people get less sunshine and their vitamin d levels drop. Therefore it is the vitamin d deficiency in the winter that predisposes to influenza. Of course, people crowd together inside in the winter, increasing ease of transmission and flu occurs in the tropics where it is always sunny, so it is probably not the only reason flu increases in the winter. But it may well be a small component,
It is biologically plausible that vitamin deficiency increases your risk for infection, there is reasonable epidemiologic data to support the association, and it is not unreasonable to be replete in you vitamins.
What is neither reasonable nor supported is to take supratherapeutic amounts of vitamin D as a replacement for either the vaccine or, if you should get flu, oseltamivir.
Vitamin D is not ” is perhaps the single most powerful nutrient in the known universe for preventing influenza, ” despite the Natural News hysterics. Yet another alternative mountain made from a scientific molehill.
SURVIVAL OF THE FITTEST
Use of the vaccine is counterproductive. Use of the vaccine will lead to a superbug.
I have found this on the webs and from a letter to SBM, and I can only speculate where this idea originates.
Antibiotics can breed resistant bacteria and resistant organisms are often referred to a superbugs. The resistant organisms may not necessarily be more virulent. Just because the bacteria may be harder to kill with antibiotics doesn’t necessarily mean it is more invasive. Sometimes, like current strain of methicillin resistant staphylococcus, may also has a high incidence of carrying genes that increase its virulence. However, as best I can tell, the increased virulence genes of the USA 300 strain are independent of its antibiotic resistance.
There was an interesting report in Clinical Infectious Diseases that suggests that as a result of anti retrovirals, perhaps HIV is becoming more virulent. It can happen as a result of antibiotics, but it is unpredictable.
Certainly if you markedly decrease a pathogen in the community, those who would have died in the past are more likely to survive and pass on their susceptibility to their offspring, increasing the vulnerability of the population to the severe disease. Put’ toll’, ‘infection’ and ‘polymorphism’ into Pubmed to find a growing literature on the genetic susceptibility for getting and dying from various infections. Historical epidemiology out of Utah suggests that the risk of death from influenza is inheritable.
So what you might expect is after long term vaccine use allows for the accumulation of susceptible hosts in a population and if there is a decline in vaccine use that there will be an increase in morbidity and mortality when the disease returns to a more susceptible population. So it may not be due to a superbug, but a susceptible population; increase in death due less to the organism and more to the host.
So can vaccine induced immunity lead to a superbug? It has not yet happened, but it does have some plausibility and it depends on the virus. Widespread use of smallpox vaccine did not lead to a super-small pox, it lead to the eradication of small pox. But, some viruses, due to sloppy reproduction, as occurs in influenza, can alter their surface proteins (where antibodies bind) to escape the immune system. So widespread use of the vaccine could (and should?) lead to new strains of influenza that avoid the antibody. But, and here is the key thing, that happens with normal infection.
As the flu season progresses the organism slowly changes its surface proteins (aka genetic shift) so that the strain at the end of the season is different than the strain at the beginning of the season, part of why we need a new vaccine every year. However, these mutations as a rule do not make the organism more virulent. That usually requires both a genetic shift (new genes) and bad luck (the organism getting the ‘right’ new genes) and this process is not affected by immunity. So it seems unlikely that widespread use of the vaccine would lead to a superbug. So you can potentially put immunologic pressure on influenza to change two ways: my getting the vaccine or by getting the flu. Both will lead to antibody against the organism, but only one will make you sick and potentially pass the infection on to others. But the end result will be the same.
A NEW WORLD ORDER
There is this weird paranoid thread running through the internet that the government simultaneously wants widespread use of the vaccine to line the pockets of doctors and big pharma, and to control health care costs by releasing a laboratory derived influenza culling the ill who cost society the most, and to cause widespread panic so that the UN can take over the US and install a new world order.
H1N1 is not going to be a very good way to either decrease costs or to cull the most susceptible.
First, H1N1 is highly infectious but not particularly virulent. While the 1919 H1N1 killed maybe 5% of the population, the current H1N1 has a mortality rate of 0.6%. Since this is based on hospitalized cases, the true death rate is probably much less. The groups most at risk of dying from H1N1 are those less than 60 and healthy. So if you were trying control costs by killing the most at risk, this is wrong strain of flu. Not only is it relatively non fatal, it kills off those who have little impact on health costs and causes widespread morbidity, only increasing costs. Of course, the government is incompetent, so leave it to them to do it all wrong.
As the Chair of our Infection Control committee, the hospital bylaws give me, in case of emergency, the powers to do anything I damn well please to control infection, including isolating patients, shutting down hospital wings, and sending people home. And I have had the opportunity to do all the above, but never by myself. At least in the hospital we work with consensus. You don’t close a hospital wing lightly.
States have also long had the power to compel people in infectious disease emergencies. I remember, and I am sure some of you will be appalled, as a resident we had a person with cavitary (read very infectious) tuberculosis who refused medications and was homeless (and crazy). As a public health risk she was basically incarcerated in the hospital and forced to take Tb medications. It was not fun.
It is an interesting question to what extent the state will compel patients in the case of widespread contagion. Hopefully they will not respond like the Italians to bubonic plague and brick people up in their houses, presumably with a cask of amontillado. It is also the case that our legislators, generally being ignorant of things medical and scientific, will pass stupid laws. Don’t get me started in mandatory MRSA screening.
I do see the need for these laws as the history of plagues demonstrates that people do not necessarily exhibit their best behavior nor act rationally in an epidemic. Fortunately, as this strain of flu is not usually fatal, calmness will probably prevail and we will not be turning our government over to the UN, although just how this is supposed to occur logistically is never stated.
FLU WILL MELT MY IMMUNE SYSTEM
The reason I do not want to call it the swine flu, besides the fact it is not really from swine, is that it hearkens back to 1976 when we last had a ‘swine’ flu. (I want to call it the rotting genitals flu, it may make the vaccine more desirable). With that vaccine was a bump in the incidence of Guillain- Barre syndrome (GBS), as disease where the insulation of your nerves falls off, leading to paralysis.
Not a good disease. Now as I write this on 9/8/9 there have been 598 deaths from H1N1. How many cases of Guillain- Barre syndrome were there in 1978 ? 532 cases that occurred within 5 to 10 weeks of the vaccine in over 40 million vaccinations. Why? No one knows.
“As of 1976, >50 “antecedent events” had been identified in temporal relationship to GBS, events that were considered as possible factors in its cause. The list included viral infections, injections, and “being struck by lightning.” Whether or not any of the antecedents had a causal relationship to GBS was, and remains, unclear. When cases of GBS were identified among recipients of the swine flu vaccines, they were, of course, well covered by the press. Because GBS cases are always present in the population, the necessary public health questions concerning the cases among vaccine recipients were “Is the number of cases of GBS among vaccine recipients higher than would be expected? And if so, are the increased cases the result of increased surveillance or a true increase?” Leading epidemiologists debated these points, but the consensus, based on the intensified surveillance for GBS (and other conditions) in recipients of the vaccines, was that the number of cases of GBS appeared to be an excess. (ref)”
Was it the strain of flu? Was it the preparation? Subsequent flu seasons have not seen an increase in GBS. The current H1N1 is genetically distinct from the 1976 strain (ref) and there is no cross protection from the 1976 vaccine. Given the strain difference and the improved production of vaccines, there is probably no reason to worry about increased risk of GBS with this vaccine. Unfortunately we will know for sure until we have given 40 million doses.
Don’t you love the uncertainty. That’s the problem. I have to deal with uncertainties and probabilities of complex systems. I know the estimates are that for every 1000 people who get H1N1, 40 may end up in the hospital and 1 may die. With 300,000,000 Americans, that’s 30,000 deaths (standard for flu) and 120,000 in the hospital. Compare to 598 cases of GBS and 25 deaths in 1976. About as many as are trampled by cattle each year, but no one is getting rid of steak.
That’s always a problem. Maybe 800 lives are saved by airbags a year; they kill maybe 20 people a year. Numbers vary. So the greater risk is not having air bags, and like many aspects of life, it is not all or nothing. People expect vaccines to be all or nothing. 100% effective, zero risk. Humans are not good at trying to decide what relative risk is. Odds are far greater that you will get and die from H1N1 than the odds you will die from vaccine related GBS, assuming that the vaccine has the same risk as 1976, about the same risk as being killed by your airbags. But we will not know with certainty until this time 2010. People do not deal well with this kind of uncertainty. As Ed said, “Doctors say that Nordberg has a 50/50 chance of getting the flu, though there’s only a 10 percent chance of that.”
Public health and influenza vaccines target populations by treating individuals, trying to do the most good for the most number of people. But real effects of influenza vaccination are on populations, and the more of a population is vaccinated, the better the population does. People miss part of the point when they look at sub groups and say, well, the vaccine only helps the elderly or pregnancy women. It’s the old adage of the rising tide lifting all boats. But my sense is that people are more selfish now than they were back in the last century, being unwilling to have 2 days of a sore arm to potentially prevent spread of a disease that may kill a stranger. Besides, they were old and going to die anyway.
A NEW AND UNTESTED VACCINE IS BEING TESTED ON THE AMERICAN PUBLIC
It is new, and it is untested. As the flu vaccine is every year. Or, more appropriately, it’s the same old flu with the same old vaccine. Keeping with the car metaphor used above, we are not seeing a new form of transportation, just a new model of the same old car.
It takes about 9 month to make a flu vaccine. The first three months or so are spent deciding on what strains are to be included and if there are representative strains that grow well for vaccine production.
After the strains are chosen, it takes about 6 months to grow up large quantities of vaccine in chicken eggs. Each dose of vaccine comes from one egg. And there is only one chicken that can make all those eggs and she gets tired. Then the vaccine is purified to just the neuraminidase and hemagglutinin proteins that are in the vaccine.
The fast track we have now is due to a lucky confluence of factors. First, industry had just finished making this years seasonal flu vaccine so they had the unexpected capacity to churn out vaccine. But more importantly they had a jump on picking the strain. They did not have to guess which strains to include, they knew it was H1N1, so that gave them a three month head start. That is the main reason we have the H1N1 vaccine in record time. The process of growing the influenza and purifying it is preceding at the usual pace. We we just lucky that we were able to know the exact strain and it occurred when we had the capacity to make extra vaccine.
So while it is being produced at a faster rate, it is not because they are skimping on the steps in the production, it is because we got lucky. As an aside, I am told that the strain they are using for the vaccine is not the best at growing in chicken eggs and is a reason the vaccine will not be ready until mid October. Evidently it does not grow as robustly in chicken eggs as they would like.
As far as anyone can tell, they is nothing special about the H1N1 strain (and they have looked at it closely) to suggest there is anything unique about it except that it is immunologically new (at least since 1950′s, when the H1N1 progenitors were last seen in humans). This H1N1 in part can be traced back to the 1918 strain and explains why those over 60 have a decreased death rate rather than the usual increased mortality from influenza: old people have cross reacting antibodies to the strain that is protective.
This strain is only new to people born since about 1950, which is billions of people at risk with no immunity. But as far as virulence and antigenicity, it is the same old influenza, re-assorting its RNA to come up with new strains as it has always done and will continue to do as long as there are people pigs and birds around to get influenza.
H1N1 is fundamentally the same as any other flu that we have been making vaccine against for as long was he have been making vaccine. It is undergoing the same testing we have used every year and there is no reason to suspect that we should be doing otherwise.
I am nervous. Fall is coming. If H1N1 comes again (and pandemics have swept through the world several times in one year, the 1919 flu may have had three peaks) before the vaccine, we could be in a world of hurt. Not a lot of deaths by US standards (we lose that 30,000 or so to guns or car accidents every year, just like flu). I have spent a career watching people suffer and occasionally die of potentially preventable illnesses. I am not a fan of death by infection. I hope the vaccine is widely available and widely used so that people live to die at a later date by “a parachute not opening… that’s a way to die. Getting caught in the gears of a combine… having your nuts bit off by a Laplander, that’s the way I wanna go!” But I digress.

   The Flu Vaccine and Narcolepsy
Steven Novella 
Link
Last year it was reported that there was a possible increase in narcolepsy, a sleep disorder characterized by excessive sleepiness, in children who had received the Pandemrix brand of H1N1 flu vaccine in Sweden, Finland, and Iceland. However a review of the data did not find a convincing connection, although concluded there was insufficient data at present and recommended further surveillance. A narcolepsy task force was formed in Finland, and now we have their preliminary report.
They conclude that the evidence suggests there is a connection:
Based on the preliminary analyses, the risk of falling ill with narcolepsy among those vaccinated in the 4-19 years age group was 9-fold in comparison to those unvaccinated in the same age group. This increase was most pronounced among those 5–15 years of age. No cases were observed among those under 4 years of age. Also, no increase in cases of narcolepsy or signs of vaccination impacting risk of falling ill with narcolepsy was observed among those above 19 years of age.
The World Health Organization (WHO) has reviewed these results and concluded:
WHO’s Global Advisory Committee on Vaccine Safety (GACVS) reviewed this data by telephone conference on 4 February 2011. GACVS agrees that further investigation is warranted concerning narcolepsy and vaccination against influenza (H1N1) 2009 with Pandemrix and other pandemic H1N1 vaccines. An increased risk of narcolepsy has not been observed in association with the use of any vaccines whether against influenza or other diseases in the past. Even at this stage, it does not appear that narcolepsy following vaccination against pandemic influenza is a general worldwide phenomenon and this complicates interpretation of the findings in Finland.
I agree with the WHO, who is basically saying that these results are intriguing, but are problematic and should be considered preliminary. They then follow with – more research is needed. Epidemiology is a complex endeavor, and there are lots of wrinkles to this data. The increased risk of narcolepsy was only seen within a certain age range. In Iceland (but not Sweden or Finland) the increase in narcolepsy was also seen in those who were not vaccinated. And further, other countries (47 in total) that also used the Pandemrix vaccine have seen no increase in narcolepsy, including Norway, the UK, Germany, and Canada.
Overall we have a very inconsistent pattern. The vaccine does not appear to be a consistent or unique risk factor for narcolepsy in these populations. The task force concludes from this that there must be another factor or factors that is combining with the vaccine to increase the risk. This is logically possible, but until this factor X is identified it remains speculation.
Narcolepsy is a neurological disorder characterized by excessive daytime sleepiness (narcoleptics sleep all night and all day), cataplexy (a tendency to lose muscle tone and collapse in response to stress), hypnagogia (hallucinations associated with a fusion of the dream state and the waking state, so-called waking dreams), and sleep paralysis (being paralyzed upon awaking from sleep). There is a strong genetic predisposition for narcolepsy. In fact it is only seen with a certain genetic type known as the (HLA) DQB1*0602 genotype.
All of the individuals who developed narcolepsy following the Pandemrix vaccine have the narcolepsy HLA type. Therefore there is the possibility that the vaccine only increases risk within this genetic populations, perhaps combined with other gene variants. Perhaps something else is also triggering the increase in Iceland, but not Finland and Sweden, to explain the rise in narcolepsy there in the unvaccinated.
Another possibility is that there is one or more confounding factors leading to the increase in narcolepsy, and the vaccines are a correlating but not causative factor.
Such is the nature of epidemiology, or observational studies. Variables are not controlled for and confounding factors are always a possibility. That does not mean that observational data is not useful or cannot be definitive – but it requires careful, thoughtful, and thorough collection and analysis of data from multiple different angles. The data we have so far from Finland is very preliminary, and generates more questions than answers. There is certainly sufficient cause for caution and further analysis. But at this point I would not be surprised by any particular outcome, since the data can be interpreted in many ways.
Conclusion
While there is an intriguing correlation between the Pandemrix vaccine and narcolepsy, this correlation is inconsistent – it is isolated to a few countries and to one age group and there is a rise in narcolepsy in Iceland not correlated to the vaccine. Further the cases identified so far are restricted to those with a known genetic predisposition to narcolepsy. This could mean that this population is susceptible to some factor in the vaccine, but it could also mean that they are susceptible to some other trigger, or perhaps were destined to get narcolepsy and the apparent increase in entirely an artifact of observation and reporting.
I agree with the WHO that this data should be considered preliminary – which means it is worthy of further monitoring and research, but we are not able to make any firm conclusions at this time. I would not be surprised if it turns out to be a real effect of the Pandemrix vaccine. Vaccines are not without risk, although over the decades the risks have proven to be very small and vastly outweighed by the benefits. Obviously it would be hugely useful to identify which ingredient was the culprit and exactly how it triggered narcolepsy in this population. But I would also not be surprised if this turns out to be entirely a red herring. Such is the nature of observational data.

False “balance” on influenza with an appeal to nature
Scott Gavura on February 13, 2014
Link

One of the encouraging shifts I’ve seen in health journalism over the past few years is the growing recognition that antivaccine sentiment is antiscientific at its core, and doesn’t justify false “balance” in the media. There’s no reason to give credibility to the antivaccine argument when their positions are built on a selection of discredited and debunked tropes. This move away from false balance and towards a more accurate reflection of the evidence seems to have started with the decline and disgrace of Andrew Wakefield and his MMR fraud. And there is now no question that antivaccine sentiment has a body count: Simply look at the resurgence of preventable communicable disease. Today, antivaccinationists are increasingly recognized for what they are – threats to public health. It seems less common today (versus just 5 years ago) that strident antivaccine voices are given either air time or credibility in the media.
But false balance on topics like influenza can occur without giving a voice to groups like antivaccinationists. A more subtle technique to shift perceptions is both widespread and hard to detect, unless you’re aware of it: the naturalistic fallacy, known more accurately as the appeal to nature. In short, it means “It’s natural so it’s good” with the converse being “unnatural is bad.” In general, the term “natural” has a positive perception, so calling a product (or a health intervention) “natural” is implying goodness. The appeal to nature is so common that you may not even recognize it as a logical fallacy. Unnatural can be good, and natural can be bad: Eyeglasses are unnatural. And cyanide is natural. Natural doesn’t mean safe or effective. But the appeal to nature is powerful, and it’s even persuasive to governments. If we believe that health interventions and treatments should be evaluated on their merits, rather than whether or not they’re “natural”, then decisions to regulate “natural” products differently than the “unnatural” ones (like drugs) makes little sense. Yet the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act was a legislative appeal to nature, introducing a different regulatory and safety standard for a group of products while drawing a fallacious distinction with “unnatural” products like drugs. Canada fell for the appeal to nature too: It has the Natural Health Products Regulations which entrenched a lowered bar for efficacy and safety for anything a manufacturer can demonstrate is somehow “natural”.
The combination of false balance and the appeal to nature has a subtle but insidious effect on how we view health care. Promoters of CAM (complementary and alternative medicine) know and use this strategy very effectively. If we’re willing to mentally distinguish between “conventional” and “natural” health approaches, then we may be more willing to overlook issues with respect to evidence – the Achilles’ heel of CAM. It’s a simple strategy for advocates to wrap their products with the “natural” banner, and our own perceptions give it a mental pass. As consumers, we’re the ones with the fallacious reasoning. The promoter is just priming us to accept the fallacy.
While I take some comfort in the fact that I’m told this blog is both widely read and well-respected, its reach is still miniscule compared to those that promote CAM. (The SBM logo should be Sisyphus, because that’s how it can feel when you’re providing science-based information against a torrent of pseudoscience.) I don’t envy Dr. Oz, but I do envy his reach and his platform, and only wish he used his prominence to promote credible health strategies, instead of what is often rank quackery. As a pharmacist I can literally see the effectiveness of the mainstream media on shaping perceptions of heath, and driving consumers to act on those demands. When I used to work in a retail pharmacy, it was immediately obvious which new miracle supplement had been hyped on Oprah, as demand would explode following an episode.
No matter how effective we are as promoters of science-based medicine, we’ll be fighting a losing battle against pseudoscience and CAM unless we have health journalists as partners. The very best health journalists are not just superb communicators; they share SBM’s goals of advocating for the best health care. My hypothesis is that the decline of major media organizations (particularly print) over the past decade may be making the task of public health and science communication more difficult. Not only do the number of dedicated health and science journalists seem to be declining, but those journalists that are tasked with covering health issues may lack the experience, background and context to communicate in the most responsible and effective way. Today it’s a hunt for eyeballs and clicks.
A series of columns in The Globe and Mail summarizes the continued challenge to communicating science-based medicine. If you’re not familiar with The Globe, it’s Canada’s largest national newspaper, and while it’s no New York Times, it’s generally considered Canada’s paper of record. The Globe has some excellent health journalists like André Picard and Carly Weeks who consistently provide some of the best health content in the country. But recently The Globe launched a new online feature, the Health Advisor, which appears to be a series of contributed posts from writers that are external to the paper:
Welcome to Health Advisor, where contributors share their knowledge in fields ranging from fitness to psychology, pediatrics to aging. Follow us @Globe_Health.
Most of the columns I’ve seen seemed to have reasonable content, and some have medically qualified authors. The series seems to be an effort to gain web traffic, as there’s no coherent theme other than the intent for posts to be clickbait, with titles such as “Former Olympian Jennifer Heil’s five tips for eating healthy on the road” or “How to tell when your memory loss is normal – and when it’s dementia.” But a recent column made me look more closely at the series: “Eight easy, natural ways to keep the flu at bay (without leaving home).” It’s written by Bryce Wylde, a homeopath who is a regular on shows like Dr. Oz. It would be a straightforward matter to look at Wylde’s recommendations and the science evidence supporting them. But the story is far more interesting than that. It starts with what Wylde suggests. He leads off with:
There are some highly effective natural solutions you can try to help prevent contracting the flu, or mitigate the symptoms once you have it. Still, recent news about the effectiveness of some supplements and home remedies has left many confused with what remedies are best to take both proactively and reactively.
Cue the appeal to nature and the false balance. His most conventional recommendation is getting more sleep. No argument there. But he goes on to suggest the following:
Apply petroleum jelly to the insides of your nostrils: How this would block influenza isn’t clear. Given there’s a published case report of lipid pneumonia from nasal application of petroleum jelly, and no evidence of efficacy, this seems like an irresponsible recommendation.
Thinly cut and plate two onions. Sprinkle sugar over the sliced onions. Cover with plastic wrap and refrigerate for two hours. With the liquid that results, dose out one tablespoon every three to four hours. Again, zero information to suggest that sliced onions have any effectiveness against influenza.
Like onions, honey-based homeopathics may provide a safe and effective solution. Honey may have some effectiveness to treat cough, but it does nothing to affect the risk of infection or the severity of an infection. Honey-based homeopathics are simply honey, as the homeopathic nostrums in these products are ineffective and then diluted to the point that any of the original substance is gone.
Garlic: What’s good for the heart blows infections apart. Yet another folk remedy with no evidence to suggest it has any effect on influenza or its complications. A systematic review of garlic for colds (not the flu) noted that claims of effectiveness are based on poor-quality data.
Get proactive with probiotics. Wylde gives the standard alt-med trope that “80% of your immunity is in your gut” which always makes me wonder how immunity is being quantified. He touts Bio-K brand of probiotics. Indeed, the Bio-K website claims it is helpful for influenza and points to this study as evidence. However that study used a different formulation of probiotics and looked at symptoms only, finding a modest improvement. There’s no information to demonstrate it has any effect in influenza, as the study didn’t determine the cause of each illness.
Shower your nose. Wylde recommends a neti-pot, which may help with the symptoms of a cold but is would have no effect on preventing or treating an influenza infection.
Whip up an immune-boosting soup. Yet another trope, the scientifically ignorant idea that immunity is a singular thing that can be “boosted”. Wylde recommends astragalus root with ginger and garlic. A good soup makes anyone feel better, but there’s nothing to astragalus or the other ingredients for the prevention of influenza.
By any responsible health journalism standard, this has serious problems. I was not alone in noticing Wylde didn’t actually recommend strategies that do have some evidence to support them, such as vaccination, handwashing and social isolation. When I put the question to The Globe on Twitter, Wylde responded and claimed that the mention of vaccines had been removed at The Globe’s request, which I found pretty concerning. And then The Globe responded:
And then it doubled down on the column, promoting it all day:
Spot the fallacies? A lot of people did, and commented online and via Twitter. The Globe’s response was more problematic than Wylde’s – it ought to know better. To The Globe’s credit, they subsequently took the feedback seriously enough for the paper’s “public editor” to address it a few days later, in a column entitled Homeopath’s advice needs to be balanced:
Last Friday, a blog on natural ways to keep the flu at bay written by an alternative-medicine specialist garnered criticism on social media and in the story comments. The blog suggested a variety of solutions that the writer, who has a diploma in homeopathic medicine, felt could either help to prevent contracting the flu or mitigate the symptoms. The blog was criticized by medical professionals on a number of points and most said it missed the key advice that what really works is the flu vaccine.
One public health physician-in-training wrote to me to say the article “makes a number of health claims regarding ways to prevent or treat the flu, but which lack any evidence to support them. Indeed, [the] … recommendations (such as the use of probiotics) …demonstrate a basic misunderstanding of what the flu is (a virus, not a bacteria). “As a member of the medical community, it concerns me when unfounded claims from Complementary & Alternative Medicine (CAM) providers are presented as fact and given legitimacy via publication. Incomplete or incorrect health information can produce very real harm, as it often prevents people from seeking out appropriate, evidence-based care (e.g. flu vaccine, antiviral medications).”
The physician’s question was about The Globe and Mail’s obligation in presenting health information. It is an excellent question. Medicine is a science based on studies and factual observations, unlike, for example, politics, where it is important for media coverage to balance the different sides of a debate.
The Globe has published many articles on the importance of getting a flu vaccination. But if the paper chooses to run an article by a homeopath in addition to the articles by medical professionals, such as a doctor, nurse or pharmacist, the article needs to be seen in the context of who the writer is and what his credentials are.
The article properly sets Health Advisor in context, saying this is a blog where contributors share their knowledge. At the bottom in italics is an explanation of the credentials of the writer so that readers will see this person is not a medical doctor but rather an alternative-medicine expert.
However, in my view, the label Special to The Globe and Mail is not clear, as it is commonly used to indicate articles by freelance journalists. It also would have been preferable to have the related links to the story balance the homeopath’s advice with a medical professional’s advice. The top three links were about learning to dream, outdoor fun and good germs. In my view, the top link should have been this article: “As a doctor, I’ve seen why vaccination is a ‘no brainer.’ ”
I think there should be a bias toward medical professionals writing about medicine and, while there is room for some coverage on alternative or homeopathic treatments, care should be taken to always balance such coverage with a doctor’s or other medical professional’s experience and expertise.
Regrettably, this response seemed to miss the point of the criticism, suggesting that all the Globe needs to do is to “balance” columns like this with a bit more science. I see the issue of “freelance journalist” as a bit of a red herring – this is the Globe and Mail, and the paper shouldn’t be lending its credibility to contributors touting unscientific health information. The proper way to deal with pseudoscience isn’t to “balance” it with links to credible health information, it’s to present the facts accurately the first time, and not give a platform to quackery. And when it comes to CAM, the science is very clear: if a “natural” approach or remedy has medicinal effects, it’s simply medicine. (All the rest is a nice bowl of soup and some potpourri, argues Dara O’Briain). There is no need to present two different perspectives. Just describe what’s effective.
Conclusion
The appeal to nature is one of the most insidious logical fallacies, and it can contribute to misguided attempts to “balance” science-based information against treatments and strategies that lack good evidence of effect. While The Globe and Mail is to be commended for publicly acknowledging and responding to online criticism, a stronger response would have acknowledged the paper’s responsibility to ensure that contributed health content is reviewed and vetted by the appropriate subject-matter experts. Logical fallacies are critical thinking “blind spots”, and it’s only when we know they exist that we can spot them.

Joe Mercola: Falsely demonizing the flu vaccine by claiming it increases your risk of COVID-19
September is the time of the year when the CDC, state public health authorities, and doctors urge everyone to be vaccinated against the flu. In the year of the COVID-19 pandemic, that means antivaxxers like Joe Mercola have a new angle to demonize the flu vaccine: Falsely claiming it increases your risk of catching COVID-19.
David Gorski on September 21, 2020
Link

[Editor’s note: I’m sorry to do this twice in one month, but real life has intervened again and I have an urgent grant deadline tomorrow. As a result, I’m repurposing a post that some of you might have seen before in the last month. As always, if you don’t read my not-so-secret other blog, it’ll be new to you. If you do read that blog, I will reassure you that I did make some changes/updates so it’s not entirely a repost. It’s partially new to you. There will be all-new material next week, but I will warn you that I have two grants due, one on October 5 and one on October 6, which means that this might happen again for my October 5 post, although it’s not that likely, given that I have to upload my grant at least a business day—preferably two days—before the deadline. Also, I’ll try to arrange a guest post if I can’t get something together that week.]
The COVID-19 pandemic has now been going on for nine months, and it’s been six months since the first lockdowns were imposed in the US to slow the spread of SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus responsible for the pandemic. Now we’re approaching the 2020-21 flu season, which threatens to make a bad situation even worse by adding another potentially lethal respiratory virus to the mix with SARS-CoV-2 and to confuse the care of severely ill patients with symptoms of respiratory infection, as doctors now have to consider the diagnostic possibility of seasonal influenza. Of course, antivaxxers have long targeted the flu vaccine because, compared to most other vaccines, it is an easier target. Different strains of flu predominate every year, forcing public health officials to make a “best guess” in the spring as to which influenza strains will dominate in the fall and winter, so that vaccines can be developed and manufactured in time. A consequence of this necessity is that the efficacy of the flu vaccine can vary widely from year to year. Mismatches between circulating flu strains and the vaccine can lead to poor efficacy some years, while during years that there is a good match to the circulating strains the efficacy is much better. Also, the response to the vaccine tends to be less robust in one group who most needs its protection, the elderly, although higher dose shots can partially solve that problem. Then there’s the issue that flu vaccine uptake is basically never sufficient to achieve community immunity in any given year. Even Mark Crislip used to concede that the flu vaccine is “suboptimal” but nonetheless argued that the evidence is sufficiently robust for its benefit to recommend it every year. Unfortunately, flu vaccines are only moderately effective, but it is clear that they are safe, and it should be remembered that influenza still kills, contrary to the claims of antivaxxers that the flu is not a serious illness.
With the arrival of the COVID-19 pandemic, it was not long before antivaxxers, being the conspiracy theorists that they are, latched onto a new conspiracy theory linking the flu vaccine to increased susceptibility to COVID-19. Indeed, the first I heard about this was in January, before the coronavirus and the disease it causes had even received their final, formal name. (That happened in March.) Back then, antivaxxers were blaming the flu vaccine for having sparked the COVID-19 outbreak in Wuhan, China that later spread to become a pandemic based on China’s having allegedly purchased more doses of flu vaccine than a usual year and a tenuous link to some science about viral interference that I’ll explain in a bit more depth in this post. I bring this up because a couple of weeks ago I came across an article on the website of Dr. Joe Mercola, the über-quack who’s built an online empire that’s made him worth over $100 million, asking “Might Flu Shots Increase COVID-19 Pandemic Risk?” The short answer is no. The long answer follows, and I consider it important to amplify my original rebuttal to this nonsense on a platform with several times more regular readers because antivaccine activists all across the quackosphere (like Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.) are parrotting the same claim as Mercola.
So the claim that the flu vaccine increases your risk of getting a life-threatening form of COVID-19, by 36% or by however much, is something I’ve written about at least twice already, once in January for my not-so-secret other blog and once in March for SBM. (Oh, wait, there was one other time.) So why revisit it? Simple. Flu season is upon us, which means that, pandemic or no pandemic, public health officials are rolling out the seasonal flu vaccine, as they do every year around this time. Indeed, I just got mine last week, and I had a really bad reaction to it. (Just kidding. I did have an adverse reaction, but it was nothing more than a sore shoulder for a couple of days, more sore than most years. It’s also here that I have to express the disappointment that I express nearly every year that my cancer center chose to use Fluarix Quadrivalent, which does not contain thimerosal. I almost asked the nurse administering the vaccine if she could add some extra thimerosal to it. OK, I’ll stop with the thimerosal jokes. At least the lack of thimerosal in Fluarix saved you from my older—and, I now realize, sometimes offensive to some—jokes when I did receive thimerosal containing vaccines about how the vaccine didn’t make me autistic.)
Of course, I don’t mind the yearly hassle. I get a flu vaccine every year and still remember the one time I didn’t twelve years ago and ended up knocked on my posterior for a week, sick as a dog with the flu. In any event, with the flu vaccine making its way to doctors’ offices, hospitals, and pharmacies near you, with public health messaging urging everyone to get vaccinated, it’s predictable that the antivaccine movement would do what the antivaccine movement always does at this time of year and try to convince people that the vaccine is dangerous. This year, more than even 2009-2010 (the year of the H1N1 influenza pandemic), this antivaccine pushback has the potential to be really dangerous. After all, with fall coming, there is a very real possibility of a resurgence of COVID-19 cases and deaths at the very same time that influenza cases will be increasing in the same way they do every year. We don’t have a vaccine against COVID-19 yet, but we do have one against influenza.
That’s why I decided to call out Mercola’s disinformation, which begins:
Could a “perfect storm” be brewing, ready to be unleashed this fall? If the regular influenza season ends up converging with a resurgence of SARS-CoV-2 outbreaks, or even a new SARS-CoV-3, the results are anyone’s guess at this point. Confounding matters is the possibility that influenza vaccination may increase people’s risk of other viral infections.
Mercola quotes Michael Osterholm, virologist and director of the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy at the University of Minnesota in Minneapolis, and Edward Belongia, director of the Center for Clinical Epidemiology and Population Health at the Marshfield Clinic Research Institute in Marshfield, who warned in an editorial in Science in June about the possibility of such a “perfect storm” of influenza and COVID-19 and urged an aggressive influenza vaccination campaign:
We do not yet have a COVID-19 vaccine, but safe and moderately effective influenza vaccines are available. Their widespread use is more important now than ever, and we encourage health care providers, employers, and community leaders to promote vaccination. Vaccine effectiveness varies by season and subtype, but vaccination offers similar protection against laboratory-confirmed influenza hospitalization and outpatient illness. Widespread misinformation on social media includes the false claim that influenza vaccination increases the risk of SARS-CoV-2 infection. Scientists, health care providers, and public health leaders must counter these claims with clear, evidence-based information on the importance of influenza vaccination during the COVID-19 pandemic.
It’s at this point that Mercola pulls a gambit that made me literally laugh out loud:
But this so-called “false claim” is not a rumor pulled out of thin air. As is so often the case, Osterholm and Belongia are actually insulting fellow virologists and researchers when slapping a hoax label on such claims, seeing how there is published research showing that, yes, influenza vaccination appears to worsen outcomes during viral pandemics.
If Osterholm and Belongia wanted to be factual and clear, they should dissect the actual studies using scientific methods and reasoning, and not just dismiss them as made-up internet hoaxes.
The fact that peer-reviewed studies have come to the conclusion that previous flu vaccination seems to increase patients’ risk of contracting more severe pandemic illness at least worthy of consideration and review.
You got that? By strongly refuting the unproven claim that influenza vaccination can increase the risk of COVID-19 and subsequent severe illness and death and characterizing it as “false”, Osterholm is insulting his fellow virologists and not listening to the science! Indeed, Mercola, amusingly, takes it one step further:
I’m not surprised though, seeing how Osterholm appears to routinely ignore the reality of published science. In a March 10, 2020, interview with Joe Rogan,2 in which the question of SARS-CoV-2’s origin came up, Osterholm stated that “we could not have crafted a virus like this to do what it’s doing; I mean we don’t have the creative imagination or the skill set.”
This simply does not line up with reality. Again, published research shows we clearly have the technology, know-how and “creative imagination” to create SARS-CoV-2.
Actually, Osterholm is correct. Although we have considerable expertise in genetic engineering and splicing genes in and out of viruses, it takes a lot more than that. In order to engineer something like SARS-CoV-2, you have to know enough about how coronaviruses cause disease and how they are transmitted and then about what structural features are required in the virus’ proteins to achieve the desired virulence and contagiousness, and we just don’t. Moreover, as I’ve pointed out many times before, once the complete nucleotide sequence of SARS-CoV-2 was elucidated, it became very clear that the virus was of natural origin. It had no tell-tale signs of having been engineered, as documented in a study in Nature in March. There’s just a lot of evidence that the virus was not engineered, but that doesn’t stop this conspiracy theory from popping up again and again, such as in Plandemic, the film featuring disgraced scientist Judy Mikovits and its sequel Plandemic: Indoctornation, or, as I like to call it, Plandemic 2: Electric Boogaloo.
Mercola bases his claim that the flu vaccine increases your risk of COVID-19 on five pieces of information. The last I’ll deal with first because it’s easy. I’ve already dealt with it before. Contrary to what Mercola claims, a 2020 study did not find that people were 36% more likely to get some form of coronavirus infection if they had been vaccinated against influenza. That claim is based on a gross misinterpretation of the study in question, plus a bit of misdirection. The study examined Department of Defense personnel from 2017-2018, long before SARS-CoV-2 emerged to cause the COVID-19 pandemic, meaning that the coronaviruses that the influenza virus allegedly interfered with in a phenomenon known as “viral interference”, the “interference” blocked by vaccination against the flu, were not SARS-CoV-2. Moreover, as I pointed out at the time, the study used to justify the “36%” claim was actually a negative study, with the coronavirus number cherry picked from a single table.
The rest of the studies that Mercola cites are, unsurprisingly, cherry picked and shoehorned into his narrative. First, there’s this:
So, what is the basis for these claims? Research raising serious questions about flu vaccinations and their impact on pandemic viral illnesses include a 2010 review3,4 in PLOS Medicine, led by Dr. Danuta Skowronski, a Canadian influenza expert with the Centre for Disease Control in British Columbia, which found the seasonal flu vaccine increased people’s risk of getting sick with pandemic H1N1 swine flu and resulted in more serious bouts of illness.
People who received the trivalent influenza vaccine during the 2008-2009 flu season were between 1.4 and 2.5 times more likely to get infected with pandemic H1N1 in the spring and summer of 2009 than those who did not get the seasonal flu vaccine.
The second study cited by Mercola is a study in ferrets that was presented at the 2012 Interscience Conference on Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy. All Mercola could provide was a reference to a MedPage Today article. I wonder why, given that the actual study is easily locatable on PubMed, and I did locate it, where the authors conclude:
Although ferrets are considered the ideal animal model for human influenza infection, there are anticipated differences in immunologic and clinical aspects of immunization, infection and illness responses (timing, dosing and intensity) across species. Overall patterns may be compared but ferret studies do not support precise quantification of actual risk in humans. The greater likelihood of more severe disease based on several clinical indicators (weight loss, lung virus titers) among vaccinated compared to unvaccinated ferrets may not replicate the greater likelihood of medically-attended A(H1N1)pdm09 illness we previously reported in vaccinated humans.
Unsurprisingly, Mercola neglects to provide the appropriate level of uncertainty about this review article, as mentioned in this commentary by Marry McKenna:
But the authors warn that, since all four studies were observational, even careful design cannot rule out the possibility that some undetected methodologic bias affected the results. That caution is echoed in a companion editorial, written by US researchers unconnected to the Canadian study, who cite the contradictory results of six other studies conducted in Mexico, Australia, and the United States at the same time as the Canadian ones. Four of those studies found no association between seasonal flu vaccination and pandemic flu illness, while the two done in Mexico paradoxically found that seasonal flu shots may have had a protective effect.
And:
“We have looked at our data at the CDC nationally,” Dr. Thomas Frieden, director of the CDC, said on Sept. 25, 2009. “I have looked carefully at the data from New York City where we had a very large outbreak and lots of information about what vaccine was received. The Australians have looked at it and published their information. And in none of those data is there any suggestion that the seasonal flu vaccine has any impact on your likelihood of getting H1N1. If data is published in the scientific literature, by all means, we would love to see it. If there’s preliminary data, we would love to see it. But nothing that we’ve seen suggests that that is likely to be a problem.”
Funny how Mercola neglected to mention this. What I was seeing at this point after the H1N1 pandemic was consistent with statistical noise. I was also amused to note that Danuta Skowronski also recently published a paper that found no increased risk of coronavirus or other non-influenza respiratory infection attributable to the influenza vaccine, thus refuting the “36%” claim Mercola parrots later in the article. (I also can’t resist mentioning this article that makes the case that selection bias is the reason for the apparent relationship between coronavirus diagnosis and the odds of prior influenza vaccination.)
Next up, Mercola picks more cherries:
Another study,7 published in the Journal of Virology in 2011, found the seasonal flu vaccine weakens children’s immune systems and increases their chances of getting sick from influenza viruses not included in the vaccine.
Further, when blood samples from 27 healthy, unvaccinated children and 14 children who had received an annual flu shot were compared, the former unvaccinated group was found to have naturally built up more antibodies across a wider variety of influenza strains compared to the latter vaccinated group, which is the type of situation Collignon referred to in the quote above.
Then there’s a 2012 study in the journal Clinical Infectious Diseases, which found that children receiving inactivated influenza vaccines had a 4.4 times higher relative risk of contracting noninfluenza respiratory virus infections in the nine months following their inoculation.
The authors proposed the theory that “Being protected against influenza, trivalent inactivated influenza vaccine recipients may lack temporary nonspecific immunity that protected against other respiratory viruses.”
First off, the first study did not find that the seasonal flu vaccine “weakens the immune system.” Immunologists don’t use terminology like “weaken” or “strengthen” the immune system. Second, this is a small study. Third, the study compared T-cell responses of normal children unvaccinated against the flu with children with cystic fibrosis who underwent yearly vaccination. That’s different from the way Mercola described it. It’s not clear if CF affected the results. The authors tried to argue that it did not, and maybe it didn’t, but we don’t know for sure because there was not the ideal control group, as the authors themselves acknowledged. Moreover, the finding reported is much more subtle than Mercola portrayed it. Basically, the finding was that a certain subset of T-cell response was less in the children vaccinated every year, but the authors noted that a live virus vaccine didn’t have that problem.
As for the second study cited, that’s a cherry picked study. As the CDC notes:
After that study was published, many experts looked into this issue further and conducted additional studies to see if the findings could be replicated. No other studies have found this effect. It’s not clear why this finding was detected in the one study, but the majority of evidence suggests that this is not a common or regular occurrence and that flu vaccination does not, in fact, make people more susceptible to other respiratory infections.
Maria Sundaram et al. (2013). Influenza Vaccination Is Not Associated With Detection of Noninfluenza Respiratory Viruses in Seasonal Studies of Influenza Vaccine Effectiveness.
Then Mercola throws a red herring in there to distract:
So, on the one hand, studies have shown that when you get the flu vaccine, you may become more prone to flu caused by influenza viruses that are not contained in the vaccine, or other noninfluenza viral respiratory illnesses, including coronavirus infections (more on that below).
Conversely, researchers recently found that common colds caused by the betacoronaviruses OC43 and HKU1 might actually make you more resistant to SARS-CoV-2 infection, and that the resulting immunity might last as long as 17 years.
The authors suggest that if you’ve beat a common cold caused by a OC43 or HKU1 betacoronavirus in the past, you may have a 50/50 chance of having defensive T-cells that can recognize and help defend against SARS-CoV-2.
This is, of course, good news if it’s true. If the finding is replicated, it would imply that many of us who get the common cold could also as a result have some immunity to COVID-19 without ever having had it. Of course, what Mercola is up to here is not reassurance. He’s using this example to suggest plausibility of his previous Gish galloping with cherry picked studies claiming that the flu vaccine increases your susceptibility to COVID-19, even though coronaviruses are very different from influenza viruses, meaning that having cross immunity between two coronaviruses does not necessarily imply the same relationship between flu viruses and coronaviruses like SARS-CoV-2.
Finally, Mercola pulls out a claim by someone named Dr. Michael Murry on Facebook dated March 30 that the flu vaccine resulted in a higher mortality among the elderly who contracted COVID-19:
Could a new flu vaccine be partly responsible for the COVID-19 mortality rate in Italy?In case you are not aware, the…
Posted by Dr. Michael Murray on Monday, March 30, 2020
Naturally, there is no scientific evidence presented to support this wild speculation. In addition, Dr. Vasquez runs a website called Inflammation Mastery and is, in addition to being a DO, a chiropractor and a naturopath. His website screams, “Quack!” It touts something called the “Functional Inflammation Protocol”, claiming brain inflammation is a cause of pain and fibromyalgia, and a book blaming autism on the “gut-brain axis”.
In the end, what we have here from “Dr.” Mercola is nothing more than a Gish gallop of cherry picked studies and observations without context designed to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt about the flu vaccine. We also know that, despite extensive refutation online and in the mainstream media, the claim that influenza vaccines increase your risk of contracting COVID-19 by 36% (or by whatever) and increase your risk of dying from COVID-19 is yet another antivax slasher claim. What I mean by that is that this claim is like Jason Voorhees in the Friday the 13th movies or Michael Myers in the Halloween movies. No matter how many times you think he’s been killed at the end of one movie, he always returns for yet another sequel, and, when the sequels finally run out, there’ll always be a reboot of the series. Yes, conspiracy theories are the iconic hockey or William Shatner mask of the COVID-19/antivaxxer unholy alliance.
Mercola concludes with a warning about fast-tracked COVID-19 vaccines, which is a concern many of us on the provaccine side have brought up ourselves, thus providing the one bit of semi-reasonable concern sprinkled into the fear mongering, in order to provide a touch of plausibility. Also, there’s the grift. There’s always the grift, complete with a plug for an antivaccine conference in October by the National Vaccine Information Center, Barbara Loe Fisher’s antivaccine organization that Mercola has been generously supporting for over a decade.
Because of course there is.
Joe Mercola: Falsely demonizing the flu vaccine by claiming it increases your risk of COVID-19
September is the time of the year when the CDC, state public health authorities, and doctors urge everyone to be vaccinated against the flu. In the year of the COVID-19 pandemic, that means antivaxxers like Joe Mercola have a new angle to demonize the flu vaccine: Falsely claiming it increases your risk of catching COVID-19.
David Gorski on September 21, 2020
Link

[Editor’s note: I’m sorry to do this twice in one month, but real life has intervened again and I have an urgent grant deadline tomorrow. As a result, I’m repurposing a post that some of you might have seen before in the last month. As always, if you don’t read my not-so-secret other blog, it’ll be new to you. If you do read that blog, I will reassure you that I did make some changes/updates so it’s not entirely a repost. It’s partially new to you. There will be all-new material next week, but I will warn you that I have two grants due, one on October 5 and one on October 6, which means that this might happen again for my October 5 post, although it’s not that likely, given that I have to upload my grant at least a business day—preferably two days—before the deadline. Also, I’ll try to arrange a guest post if I can’t get something together that week.]
The COVID-19 pandemic has now been going on for nine months, and it’s been six months since the first lockdowns were imposed in the US to slow the spread of SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus responsible for the pandemic. Now we’re approaching the 2020-21 flu season, which threatens to make a bad situation even worse by adding another potentially lethal respiratory virus to the mix with SARS-CoV-2 and to confuse the care of severely ill patients with symptoms of respiratory infection, as doctors now have to consider the diagnostic possibility of seasonal influenza. Of course, antivaxxers have long targeted the flu vaccine because, compared to most other vaccines, it is an easier target. Different strains of flu predominate every year, forcing public health officials to make a “best guess” in the spring as to which influenza strains will dominate in the fall and winter, so that vaccines can be developed and manufactured in time. A consequence of this necessity is that the efficacy of the flu vaccine can vary widely from year to year. Mismatches between circulating flu strains and the vaccine can lead to poor efficacy some years, while during years that there is a good match to the circulating strains the efficacy is much better. Also, the response to the vaccine tends to be less robust in one group who most needs its protection, the elderly, although higher dose shots can partially solve that problem. Then there’s the issue that flu vaccine uptake is basically never sufficient to achieve community immunity in any given year. Even Mark Crislip used to concede that the flu vaccine is “suboptimal” but nonetheless argued that the evidence is sufficiently robust for its benefit to recommend it every year. Unfortunately, flu vaccines are only moderately effective, but it is clear that they are safe, and it should be remembered that influenza still kills, contrary to the claims of antivaxxers that the flu is not a serious illness.
With the arrival of the COVID-19 pandemic, it was not long before antivaxxers, being the conspiracy theorists that they are, latched onto a new conspiracy theory linking the flu vaccine to increased susceptibility to COVID-19. Indeed, the first I heard about this was in January, before the coronavirus and the disease it causes had even received their final, formal name. (That happened in March.) Back then, antivaxxers were blaming the flu vaccine for having sparked the COVID-19 outbreak in Wuhan, China that later spread to become a pandemic based on China’s having allegedly purchased more doses of flu vaccine than a usual year and a tenuous link to some science about viral interference that I’ll explain in a bit more depth in this post. I bring this up because a couple of weeks ago I came across an article on the website of Dr. Joe Mercola, the über-quack who’s built an online empire that’s made him worth over $100 million, asking “Might Flu Shots Increase COVID-19 Pandemic Risk?” The short answer is no. The long answer follows, and I consider it important to amplify my original rebuttal to this nonsense on a platform with several times more regular readers because antivaccine activists all across the quackosphere (like Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.) are parrotting the same claim as Mercola.
So the claim that the flu vaccine increases your risk of getting a life-threatening form of COVID-19, by 36% or by however much, is something I’ve written about at least twice already, once in January for my not-so-secret other blog and once in March for SBM. (Oh, wait, there was one other time.) So why revisit it? Simple. Flu season is upon us, which means that, pandemic or no pandemic, public health officials are rolling out the seasonal flu vaccine, as they do every year around this time. Indeed, I just got mine last week, and I had a really bad reaction to it. (Just kidding. I did have an adverse reaction, but it was nothing more than a sore shoulder for a couple of days, more sore than most years. It’s also here that I have to express the disappointment that I express nearly every year that my cancer center chose to use Fluarix Quadrivalent, which does not contain thimerosal. I almost asked the nurse administering the vaccine if she could add some extra thimerosal to it. OK, I’ll stop with the thimerosal jokes. At least the lack of thimerosal in Fluarix saved you from my older—and, I now realize, sometimes offensive to some—jokes when I did receive thimerosal containing vaccines about how the vaccine didn’t make me autistic.)
Of course, I don’t mind the yearly hassle. I get a flu vaccine every year and still remember the one time I didn’t twelve years ago and ended up knocked on my posterior for a week, sick as a dog with the flu. In any event, with the flu vaccine making its way to doctors’ offices, hospitals, and pharmacies near you, with public health messaging urging everyone to get vaccinated, it’s predictable that the antivaccine movement would do what the antivaccine movement always does at this time of year and try to convince people that the vaccine is dangerous. This year, more than even 2009-2010 (the year of the H1N1 influenza pandemic), this antivaccine pushback has the potential to be really dangerous. After all, with fall coming, there is a very real possibility of a resurgence of COVID-19 cases and deaths at the very same time that influenza cases will be increasing in the same way they do every year. We don’t have a vaccine against COVID-19 yet, but we do have one against influenza.
That’s why I decided to call out Mercola’s disinformation, which begins:
Could a “perfect storm” be brewing, ready to be unleashed this fall? If the regular influenza season ends up converging with a resurgence of SARS-CoV-2 outbreaks, or even a new SARS-CoV-3, the results are anyone’s guess at this point. Confounding matters is the possibility that influenza vaccination may increase people’s risk of other viral infections.
Mercola quotes Michael Osterholm, virologist and director of the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy at the University of Minnesota in Minneapolis, and Edward Belongia, director of the Center for Clinical Epidemiology and Population Health at the Marshfield Clinic Research Institute in Marshfield, who warned in an editorial in Science in June about the possibility of such a “perfect storm” of influenza and COVID-19 and urged an aggressive influenza vaccination campaign:
We do not yet have a COVID-19 vaccine, but safe and moderately effective influenza vaccines are available. Their widespread use is more important now than ever, and we encourage health care providers, employers, and community leaders to promote vaccination. Vaccine effectiveness varies by season and subtype, but vaccination offers similar protection against laboratory-confirmed influenza hospitalization and outpatient illness. Widespread misinformation on social media includes the false claim that influenza vaccination increases the risk of SARS-CoV-2 infection. Scientists, health care providers, and public health leaders must counter these claims with clear, evidence-based information on the importance of influenza vaccination during the COVID-19 pandemic.
It’s at this point that Mercola pulls a gambit that made me literally laugh out loud:
But this so-called “false claim” is not a rumor pulled out of thin air. As is so often the case, Osterholm and Belongia are actually insulting fellow virologists and researchers when slapping a hoax label on such claims, seeing how there is published research showing that, yes, influenza vaccination appears to worsen outcomes during viral pandemics.
If Osterholm and Belongia wanted to be factual and clear, they should dissect the actual studies using scientific methods and reasoning, and not just dismiss them as made-up internet hoaxes.
The fact that peer-reviewed studies have come to the conclusion that previous flu vaccination seems to increase patients’ risk of contracting more severe pandemic illness at least worthy of consideration and review.
You got that? By strongly refuting the unproven claim that influenza vaccination can increase the risk of COVID-19 and subsequent severe illness and death and characterizing it as “false”, Osterholm is insulting his fellow virologists and not listening to the science! Indeed, Mercola, amusingly, takes it one step further:
I’m not surprised though, seeing how Osterholm appears to routinely ignore the reality of published science. In a March 10, 2020, interview with Joe Rogan,2 in which the question of SARS-CoV-2’s origin came up, Osterholm stated that “we could not have crafted a virus like this to do what it’s doing; I mean we don’t have the creative imagination or the skill set.”
This simply does not line up with reality. Again, published research shows we clearly have the technology, know-how and “creative imagination” to create SARS-CoV-2.
Actually, Osterholm is correct. Although we have considerable expertise in genetic engineering and splicing genes in and out of viruses, it takes a lot more than that. In order to engineer something like SARS-CoV-2, you have to know enough about how coronaviruses cause disease and how they are transmitted and then about what structural features are required in the virus’ proteins to achieve the desired virulence and contagiousness, and we just don’t. Moreover, as I’ve pointed out many times before, once the complete nucleotide sequence of SARS-CoV-2 was elucidated, it became very clear that the virus was of natural origin. It had no tell-tale signs of having been engineered, as documented in a study in Nature in March. There’s just a lot of evidence that the virus was not engineered, but that doesn’t stop this conspiracy theory from popping up again and again, such as in Plandemic, the film featuring disgraced scientist Judy Mikovits and its sequel Plandemic: Indoctornation, or, as I like to call it, Plandemic 2: Electric Boogaloo.
Mercola bases his claim that the flu vaccine increases your risk of COVID-19 on five pieces of information. The last I’ll deal with first because it’s easy. I’ve already dealt with it before. Contrary to what Mercola claims, a 2020 study did not find that people were 36% more likely to get some form of coronavirus infection if they had been vaccinated against influenza. That claim is based on a gross misinterpretation of the study in question, plus a bit of misdirection. The study examined Department of Defense personnel from 2017-2018, long before SARS-CoV-2 emerged to cause the COVID-19 pandemic, meaning that the coronaviruses that the influenza virus allegedly interfered with in a phenomenon known as “viral interference”, the “interference” blocked by vaccination against the flu, were not SARS-CoV-2. Moreover, as I pointed out at the time, the study used to justify the “36%” claim was actually a negative study, with the coronavirus number cherry picked from a single table.
The rest of the studies that Mercola cites are, unsurprisingly, cherry picked and shoehorned into his narrative. First, there’s this:
So, what is the basis for these claims? Research raising serious questions about flu vaccinations and their impact on pandemic viral illnesses include a 2010 review3,4 in PLOS Medicine, led by Dr. Danuta Skowronski, a Canadian influenza expert with the Centre for Disease Control in British Columbia, which found the seasonal flu vaccine increased people’s risk of getting sick with pandemic H1N1 swine flu and resulted in more serious bouts of illness.
People who received the trivalent influenza vaccine during the 2008-2009 flu season were between 1.4 and 2.5 times more likely to get infected with pandemic H1N1 in the spring and summer of 2009 than those who did not get the seasonal flu vaccine.
The second study cited by Mercola is a study in ferrets that was presented at the 2012 Interscience Conference on Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy. All Mercola could provide was a reference to a MedPage Today article. I wonder why, given that the actual study is easily locatable on PubMed, and I did locate it, where the authors conclude:
Although ferrets are considered the ideal animal model for human influenza infection, there are anticipated differences in immunologic and clinical aspects of immunization, infection and illness responses (timing, dosing and intensity) across species. Overall patterns may be compared but ferret studies do not support precise quantification of actual risk in humans. The greater likelihood of more severe disease based on several clinical indicators (weight loss, lung virus titers) among vaccinated compared to unvaccinated ferrets may not replicate the greater likelihood of medically-attended A(H1N1)pdm09 illness we previously reported in vaccinated humans.
Unsurprisingly, Mercola neglects to provide the appropriate level of uncertainty about this review article, as mentioned in this commentary by Marry McKenna:
But the authors warn that, since all four studies were observational, even careful design cannot rule out the possibility that some undetected methodologic bias affected the results. That caution is echoed in a companion editorial, written by US researchers unconnected to the Canadian study, who cite the contradictory results of six other studies conducted in Mexico, Australia, and the United States at the same time as the Canadian ones. Four of those studies found no association between seasonal flu vaccination and pandemic flu illness, while the two done in Mexico paradoxically found that seasonal flu shots may have had a protective effect.
And:
“We have looked at our data at the CDC nationally,” Dr. Thomas Frieden, director of the CDC, said on Sept. 25, 2009. “I have looked carefully at the data from New York City where we had a very large outbreak and lots of information about what vaccine was received. The Australians have looked at it and published their information. And in none of those data is there any suggestion that the seasonal flu vaccine has any impact on your likelihood of getting H1N1. If data is published in the scientific literature, by all means, we would love to see it. If there’s preliminary data, we would love to see it. But nothing that we’ve seen suggests that that is likely to be a problem.”
Funny how Mercola neglected to mention this. What I was seeing at this point after the H1N1 pandemic was consistent with statistical noise. I was also amused to note that Danuta Skowronski also recently published a paper that found no increased risk of coronavirus or other non-influenza respiratory infection attributable to the influenza vaccine, thus refuting the “36%” claim Mercola parrots later in the article. (I also can’t resist mentioning this article that makes the case that selection bias is the reason for the apparent relationship between coronavirus diagnosis and the odds of prior influenza vaccination.)
Next up, Mercola picks more cherries:
Another study,7 published in the Journal of Virology in 2011, found the seasonal flu vaccine weakens children’s immune systems and increases their chances of getting sick from influenza viruses not included in the vaccine.
Further, when blood samples from 27 healthy, unvaccinated children and 14 children who had received an annual flu shot were compared, the former unvaccinated group was found to have naturally built up more antibodies across a wider variety of influenza strains compared to the latter vaccinated group, which is the type of situation Collignon referred to in the quote above.
Then there’s a 2012 study in the journal Clinical Infectious Diseases, which found that children receiving inactivated influenza vaccines had a 4.4 times higher relative risk of contracting noninfluenza respiratory virus infections in the nine months following their inoculation.
The authors proposed the theory that “Being protected against influenza, trivalent inactivated influenza vaccine recipients may lack temporary nonspecific immunity that protected against other respiratory viruses.”
First off, the first study did not find that the seasonal flu vaccine “weakens the immune system.” Immunologists don’t use terminology like “weaken” or “strengthen” the immune system. Second, this is a small study. Third, the study compared T-cell responses of normal children unvaccinated against the flu with children with cystic fibrosis who underwent yearly vaccination. That’s different from the way Mercola described it. It’s not clear if CF affected the results. The authors tried to argue that it did not, and maybe it didn’t, but we don’t know for sure because there was not the ideal control group, as the authors themselves acknowledged. Moreover, the finding reported is much more subtle than Mercola portrayed it. Basically, the finding was that a certain subset of T-cell response was less in the children vaccinated every year, but the authors noted that a live virus vaccine didn’t have that problem.
As for the second study cited, that’s a cherry picked study. As the CDC notes:
After that study was published, many experts looked into this issue further and conducted additional studies to see if the findings could be replicated. No other studies have found this effect. It’s not clear why this finding was detected in the one study, but the majority of evidence suggests that this is not a common or regular occurrence and that flu vaccination does not, in fact, make people more susceptible to other respiratory infections.
Maria Sundaram et al. (2013). Influenza Vaccination Is Not Associated With Detection of Noninfluenza Respiratory Viruses in Seasonal Studies of Influenza Vaccine Effectiveness.
Then Mercola throws a red herring in there to distract:
So, on the one hand, studies have shown that when you get the flu vaccine, you may become more prone to flu caused by influenza viruses that are not contained in the vaccine, or other noninfluenza viral respiratory illnesses, including coronavirus infections (more on that below).
Conversely, researchers recently found that common colds caused by the betacoronaviruses OC43 and HKU1 might actually make you more resistant to SARS-CoV-2 infection, and that the resulting immunity might last as long as 17 years.
The authors suggest that if you’ve beat a common cold caused by a OC43 or HKU1 betacoronavirus in the past, you may have a 50/50 chance of having defensive T-cells that can recognize and help defend against SARS-CoV-2.
This is, of course, good news if it’s true. If the finding is replicated, it would imply that many of us who get the common cold could also as a result have some immunity to COVID-19 without ever having had it. Of course, what Mercola is up to here is not reassurance. He’s using this example to suggest plausibility of his previous Gish galloping with cherry picked studies claiming that the flu vaccine increases your susceptibility to COVID-19, even though coronaviruses are very different from influenza viruses, meaning that having cross immunity between two coronaviruses does not necessarily imply the same relationship between flu viruses and coronaviruses like SARS-CoV-2.
Finally, Mercola pulls out a claim by someone named Dr. Michael Murry on Facebook dated March 30 that the flu vaccine resulted in a higher mortality among the elderly who contracted COVID-19:
Could a new flu vaccine be partly responsible for the COVID-19 mortality rate in Italy?In case you are not aware, the…
Posted by Dr. Michael Murray on Monday, March 30, 2020
Naturally, there is no scientific evidence presented to support this wild speculation. In addition, Dr. Vasquez runs a website called Inflammation Mastery and is, in addition to being a DO, a chiropractor and a naturopath. His website screams, “Quack!” It touts something called the “Functional Inflammation Protocol”, claiming brain inflammation is a cause of pain and fibromyalgia, and a book blaming autism on the “gut-brain axis”.
In the end, what we have here from “Dr.” Mercola is nothing more than a Gish gallop of cherry picked studies and observations without context designed to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt about the flu vaccine. We also know that, despite extensive refutation online and in the mainstream media, the claim that influenza vaccines increase your risk of contracting COVID-19 by 36% (or by whatever) and increase your risk of dying from COVID-19 is yet another antivax slasher claim. What I mean by that is that this claim is like Jason Voorhees in the Friday the 13th movies or Michael Myers in the Halloween movies. No matter how many times you think he’s been killed at the end of one movie, he always returns for yet another sequel, and, when the sequels finally run out, there’ll always be a reboot of the series. Yes, conspiracy theories are the iconic hockey or William Shatner mask of the COVID-19/antivaxxer unholy alliance.
Mercola concludes with a warning about fast-tracked COVID-19 vaccines, which is a concern many of us on the provaccine side have brought up ourselves, thus providing the one bit of semi-reasonable concern sprinkled into the fear mongering, in order to provide a touch of plausibility. Also, there’s the grift. There’s always the grift, complete with a plug for an antivaccine conference in October by the National Vaccine Information Center, Barbara Loe Fisher’s antivaccine organization that Mercola has been generously supporting for over a decade.
Because of course there is.

Courage
If I were King of the Vaccines. Some thoughts on influenza vaccine, hospitalization, death and courage.
Mark Crislip on June 20, 2023
Link

Cowardly Lion: Courage. What makes a King out of a slave? Courage.What makes the flag on the mast to wave? Courage.What makes the elephant charge his tusk in the misty mist or the dusky dusk?What makes the muskrat guard his musk? Courage.What makes the Sphinx the 7th Wonder? Courage.reWhat makes the dawn come up like THUNDER?! Courage.What puts the “ape” in ape-ricot?Whatta they got that I ain’t got?Dorothy & Friends: Courage!Cowardly Lion: You can say that again.
The Wizard of Oz, Movie Version, slightly edited for modern sensibilities.
The medical literature can, I suppose, can be divided into three categories. There are the slam dunk studies, where the outcomes are clear-cut. Penicillin treatment of syphilis and HAART for the treatment of HIV come to mind for positive studies. Anti-endotoxin monoclonal antibodies for negative studies pop to mind. Being a retired ID doctor, I tend towards infections as examples.
There are the stupid. Those studies that are unhinged from reality, like acupuncture or homeopathy, where you know any positive result is going all bias, all the time. But occasionally stupid studies get published in the literature. My favorite is Computed Tomographic Study of the Common Cold where 31 people got their heads irradiated to show that people with the cold had stuffy noses. And it made the New England Journal of Medicine!
But much of the medical literature is so often not as clear-cut as one would like. It is messy and often manifests Newton’s third law of the medical literature: for every study there is an equal an opposite study. Well, opposite in results, rarely equal in methodology.

The first law? Interpretations of the literature tend not to change with disconfirmatory studies aka the Law of Inertia.
The second law? Why F = ma, of course. Fatuous = (medical literature)(acerebral). I did learn something from that physics degree all those years ago.
Large swaths of the medical literature are filled with ambiguity and in reading and understanding it, requires lots of qualifiers. As an example, the best treatment for methicillin resistant S. aureus? I don’t know. As the Magic 8 Ball notes, Reply hazy, try again. Which antibiotic to use depends on many factors, but my bias is the answer is never vancomycin. I have long said that if your physician refers to vancomycin, or any antibiotic, as strong, powerful, or big gun, she is an idiot who knows nothing about the treatment of infectious diseases. I digress. ID stands for so many things with me.
The flu vaccine is one of those interventions whose effects are messy. Its effects depend on the vaccine, the host, the circulating strains of flu, prior vaccinations and disease. Synthesizing the literature either makes my brain hurt or identifies me as a first-rate intelligence. Probably the former.
An ideal vaccine would prevent all illness. Influenza vaccine is not ideal, so what would you like from the flu vaccine? Prevent illness, lessen the severity of illness, decrease spread of disease, decrease complications (stroke, heart attack, bacterial pneumonia, spontaneous abortion etc), decrease hospitalization and if hospitalized decrease transfer to the ICU and death. And, perhaps, lead to smarter, richer children.
Plow through all of that literature (as I write there are 41,622 results for influenza vaccine on the PubMeds. Reading one an hour would take 1734.25 days), which no one has, and you get the sense that, however imperfectly, the flu vaccine does all of the above. Just not every time in every person. I like to compare the flu vaccine to seat belts. Not perfect, but better to have them when needed than to go without.
Which brings us to Influenza Vaccine Fails to Stop Hospitalization and Death. Large Japanese Study Shows No Benefit on Hard Outcomes
You will probably be surprised to know that I am a fan of sarcasm and snark, although it is difficult sometimes to make either recognizable in writing. For example, my website is edgydoc.com. When I was doing my ID podcasts I would ask my kids to clarify some point regarding popular culture (from which, at 66, I am far removed) and my son would sarcastically say, “Being edgy again, Dad”? I would not consider myself to be edgy, but I thought it would be funny as a website name. I really should have gone with Slacker ID. Slacker Astronomy being my favorite podcast when I started all those years ago.
Anyway, the above headline is from Courageous Discourse, and since there is nothing whatsoever resembling courage in what follows, I assume the title is tongue in cheek. Like Standing Up For What’s Right.
The author quotes from the results:
The multivariable analysis showed a lower incidence of influenza in vaccinated individuals (hazard ratio [HR], 0.47; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.43-0.51; P < 0.001), however the incidence of hospitalization for influenza did not differ significantly by vaccination status (HR, 0.79; 95% CI, 0.53-1.18; P = 0.249). Protective effectiveness against incidence waned quickly after 4 or 5 months.
and then concludes:
These data suggest the massive effort on vaccination in the general population is a waste of time and effort. If the frail and elderly get no overall direct reduction in hospitalization and death, influenza vaccination should be individualized based on pulmonary and systemic risks.
Oddly, he fails to courageously quote from the conclusion, which says:
Our study identified moderate vaccine effectiveness in preventing the incidence of influenza in the Japanese elderly. Vaccine effectiveness showed a trend of gradual attenuation. Clinicians should suspect influenza infection even in those vaccinated, especially in elderly individuals who had received vaccination more than 4 or 5 months previously.
The paper notes:
Multivariable analysis based on the time-dependent Cox regression model showed that vaccinated individuals had a lower incidence of influenza (HR, 0.47; 95% CI, 0.43–0.51; P < 0.001), while hospitalization for influenza did not differ significantly between the vaccinated and non-vaccinated groups (HR, 0.79; 95% CI, 0.53–1.18;P = 0.249).
Then those pesky qualifiers. The paper notes the vaccinated group were older and sicker, so the two groups were not really comparable. And we do not know what vaccination was used, regular or high dose. In Japan, as best I can tell they have the high-dose vaccine for the elderly; I can’t tell if its use is standard.
Then the primary outcome was getting the flu.
Hospitalization and death were secondary end points and so one never really knows what to make of results one way or the other. There is a long history of secondary endpoints being unreliable. The authors note:
Second, confounding factors adjusted in the multivariable analyses were limited, especially for the secondary outcome of hospitalization. Those vaccinated may have been biased toward individuals who were more likely to be hospitalized according to the unadjusted vaccine effectiveness of hospitalization (HR, 1.21). On the other hand, the point estimate of the adjusted hazard ratio for hospitalization was less than 1, which suggested the effectiveness. However, the confidence interval was wide (0.53–1.18), and the results were not statistically significant due to lack of power. This is because the number of events for hospitalization was less than one-tenth of the number of events for incidence of influenza, regardless of age group. The results should be revalidated in the future with a larger number of event.
As the original authors suggest, it would be suspect to use the results of the paper to make decisions about vaccine effectiveness for hospitalization. I wonder why that was not courageously mentioned.
As to death, the older sicker vaccinated group had more deaths, the study makes no mention on the relationship between death, influenza, or the vaccine and no suggestion as to causality. The deaths are just listed on a table, not remarked on one way or the other.
I suspect the courageous author read the paper but in a cursory way, much in the way the proverbial drunk uses a streetlight.
Overall, this is par for the course for influenza vaccine papers that look at large populations and try and draw conclusions: modest efficacy that wanes with time.
But how does it fit in with the literature as a hole, er, I mean whole?
If you PubMed influenza vaccine and hospitalization, you get 9761 hits. Way too many to go through.
There was a meta-analysis of the high-dose vaccine in the elderly. The results were good as in fewer hospitalizations and deaths:
15 publications were meta-analyzed after screening 1,293 studies, providing data on 10 consecutive influenza seasons and over 22 million individuals receiving HD-IIV3 in randomized and observational settings. Across all influenza seasons, HD-IIV3 demonstrated improved protection against ILI compared to SD-IIV (rVE = 15.9%, 95% CI: 4.1-26.3%). HD-IIV3 was also more effective at preventing hospital admissions from all-causes (rVE = 8.4%, 95% CI: 5.7-11.0%), as well as influenza (rVE = 11.7%, 95% CI: 7.0-16.1%), pneumonia (rVE = 27.3%, 95% CI: 15.3-37.6%), combined pneumonia/influenza (rVE = 13.4%, 95% CI: 7.3-19.2%) and cardiorespiratory events (rVE = 17.9%, 95% CI: 15.0-20.8%). Reductions in mortality due to pneumonia/influenza (rVE = 39.9%, 95% CI: 18.6-55.6%) and cardiorespiratory causes (rVE = 27.7%, 95% CI: 13.2-32.0%) were also observed.
In diabetics?
influenza vaccination was associated with a lower mortality rate (Mantel Haenszel Odds Ratio (MH-OR), 95% CI: 0.54 (0.40; 0.74), p < 0.001). Patients who received influenza vaccination showed a lower risk of hospitalization for pneumonia (MH-OR, 95% CI: 0.89; (0.80; 0.98), p = 0.18). A sensitivity analysis using fixed effect model confirmed the results (MH-OR, 95% CI: 0.91; (0.87; 0.96); p = 0.001).
Community living elderly?
A meta-analysis of studies selected using predetermined criteria without language restriction. Conclusion: Influenza vaccine was effective in reducing influenza-like illness by 35% (95% confidence interval (CI) 19–47%), hospitalization for pneumonia and influenza by 33% (CI 27–38%), mortality following hospitalization for pneumonia and influenza by 47% (CI 25–62%); and mortality from all causes by 50% (CI 45–56%).
And the trivalent inactivated vaccine adjuvanted with MF59?
Our results suggest that MF59-TIV is effective in reducing several influenza-related outcomes among the elderly, especially hospitalizations due to influenza-related complications.
Again, in a recent meta-analysis, the flu does more than prevent flu hospitalization and death
receipt of influenza vaccination was associated with a 34% lower risk of major adverse cardiovascular events, and individuals with recent ACS had a 45% lower risk
So there is a large literature that shows efficacy of flu vaccination in preventing hospitalization and death as well as a variety of other complications.
My first thought would not be to courageously question the need for the vaccine, but wonder why this study was an outlier, besides low power. Is there something about the Japanese? There can be racial/regional differences in susceptibility to infections; I cannot find anything specifically related to the Japanese.
Prior studies have found benefit if vaccinations in elder Japanese:
The adjusted VE, determined using a case-control study, for preventing hospitalization for influenza A infection was 72.6% (95%!CI: 30.7–89.1%). In addition, the VE for preventing hospitalization of influenza patients with comorbidities was 78.2% (95%! CI: 41.1–92%).
Although there is not a robust number of studies, what is out there suggests the elderly Japanese may respond particularly poorly to influenza vaccine, with emphasis on may. And I cannot find a robust literature specifically looking at the effects of the influenza vaccine specifically on the hospitalization and death in elderly Japanese.
I would conclude that when taken as a whole, the influenza vaccine does indeed decrease the odds of hospitalization and death in not just the elderly but all groups, as well has having multiple beneficial downstream effects for both individuals and populations.
My response from a single outlier would not be to courageously conclude that:
These data suggest the massive effort on vaccination in the general population is a waste of time and effort. If the frail and elderly get no overall direct reduction in hospitalization and death, influenza vaccination should be individualized based on pulmonary and systemic risks.
But instead wonder, huh? Why the outlier? Why was this study different? The methodology? The vaccine? The population?
Courage, well, more likely just good sense, is realizing that a single study in a messy literature is hardly the basis for firm conclusions. Or any conclusion. Perhaps the solution lies in the needs of the Scarecrow rather than the Cowardly Lion.

Don’t Forget About the Flu
We are heading into a bad flu season. Get vaccinated.
Steven Novella on November 16, 2022
Link

The COVID pandemic appears to be causing a flu-season double-whammy – increased risk and decreased attention. It starts with the fact that during the last two years the severity of flu seasons have been dramatically diminished:
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) recently reported that it had logged 1,316 positive flu cases in its surveillance network between September 2020 and the end of January 2021. During that same period last year, the CDC had recorded nearly 130,000 cases.
Flu cases partially rebounded last year, but were still historically low. Almost certainly the reason for this decrease in flu cases is because of the implementation of masking and social distancing – because these methods work to prevent the spread of respiratory infections. And now the flu, and other respiratory infections, are rebounding with a vengeance.
The reason for this is what experts call immunity debt. Our immune systems respond to challenge with a virus or other infectious agent by not only responding with an immediate immune response, but with long-term immunity. Among other mechanisms, for example, memory B-cells that produce antibodies with fine-tuned affinity for the infecting agent can have a robust immediate response on later exposure.
But immunity generally wanes over time (at varying rates depending on the type of organism and degree of initial immune reaction). Some vaccines, such as those for measles, rubella, and diphtheria, provide good life-long immunity. But the flu has particularly short-lived immunity from infection or vaccine, waning after only a few months. This is because some of the immune cells involved in that immunity are short-lived. Immunity is complex, however, and other aspects of immunity may last for years. In addition, there is evidence that repeated annual flu vaccines provide some cumulative benefit, reducing mortality from the flu especially in older adults. The flu strains also drift every season, evading prior immunity to some extent.
It is likely that exposure to the flu every year, even if one doesn’t develop a clinical infection, may provide a little boost to immunity. If, however, the general population has essentially gone two years with little or no exposure to flu viruses, we are missing this boost – and that’s the immunity debt. Plus, we also now have a crop of young children who have never been exposed to the flu.
For these reasons experts are expecting a worse than normal flu season. In fact, early cases are already worse than average. In fact, some are warning of a “tripledemic” with a spike in COVID cases, a bad flu season, and a bad season for RSV and other respiratory viruses.
The best thing you can do to protect yourself and others is to get vaccinated. If you have not yet had your annual flu vaccine, get it as soon as possible. The flu season is already underway – but it’s not too late, as the season is likely to last for months. Get fully boosted against COVID, and get your flu vaccine. You can get them at the same time, but spreading them out over a few days to limit side effects is reasonable.
This brings us to the second part of the double whammy – despite the fact that we are facing a worse than average flu season, vaccine uptake is down. According to the CDC we are at about 5 million fewer doses given than at the same time last year. It’s always hard to know exactly why aggregate behavior shifts. There are lots of factors to consider, so we don’t really know why fewer flu vaccines are being given this year.
It is possible, however, that we are partly seeing the effect of pandemic fatigue. People are simultaneously tired of having their life disrupted by the COVID-19 pandemic, and yet COVID still is occupying their attention when it comes to public health concerns. The regular-old flu seems to be forgotten. Perhaps this effect is exacerbated by two recent flu seasons that were minimal.
Basically the message is – don’t forget about the flu. This is still a serious illness. The flu causes between 12,000-52,000 deaths each year in the US alone, and between 294,000 and 518,000 deaths each year globally. It causes more than 10 times that many hospitalizations. This is another very real concern – the total hospital burden of a tripledemic.
Get your flu vaccine. This is part of basic preventive care and health maintenance. COVID is also likely slipping into an endemic illness, and so we will likely need to get at least an annual COVID booster as well. This is now just part of routine care.

Fun with Spanish Flu Myths
There are many myths about the Spanish flu pandemic of 1918. Some of them are pretty funny.
Harriet Hall on June 20, 2017
Link
In the SBM comments section, someone recently posted this gem:
That “Spanish flu” pandemic was actually caused by a typhus vaccine. They called it Spanish flu so the vaccine didn’t get blamed.
Other commenters quickly pointed out that time travel is not possible. The Spanish flu pandemic started in 1918 and the typhus vaccine wasn’t developed until 1933.
After I stopped laughing, I began to wonder where that bizarre idea had come from.
I quickly determined that the commenter had confused typhus with typhoid, but typhoid didn’t make sense either. As I kept looking, I came across a number of myths surrounding the Spanish flu, some of them very amusing. But first, let’s review the facts.
The facts about the 1918 flu pandemic
Note: an epidemic is when a disease spreads rapidly through a community or a geographic area; a pandemic is a global outbreak where the disease spreads around the entire world.
First some background. The Spanish flu began during WWI and lasted from 1918 to 1919. It was the deadliest pandemic in modern history. It first affected people in Europe, the US, and parts of Asia and quickly spread worldwide, reaching even to remote Alaskan villages and to the most remote islands of the Pacific. 500 million people were infected (one-third of the world’s population), and 20-50 million died. Whole families were wiped out. A first wave of the disease occurred in the spring of 1918 and was relatively mild, but a more severe wave began later in the year. Troop movements and other war-related disruptions played a role in its rapid transmission. The more virulent disease appeared almost simultaneously in Sierra Leone, France, and Boston. It hit hardest in young, healthy adults, invading the lungs and causing suffocation. Sometimes it killed within a matter of hours. Doctors didn’t know what caused it, and there was no treatment other than supportive care. The pandemic fizzled out in the summer of 1919, as the infected either died or developed immunity.
It wasn’t until 1928 that the cause of influenza was determined to be a virus. Eventually it was pinned down to an H1N1 virus, the so-called “swine flu” virus that also affects pigs. The 1918 strain was the most virulent in recorded history. Scientists have studied tissue samples from 1918 victims, including the frozen corpse of an Inuit woman buried in Alaskan permafrost, and have managed to sequence its entire genome. Their findings suggested it may have originated in birds and a mutation may have allowed it to spread to humans.
There was a second swine flu pandemic in 2009 caused by a new H1N1 strain that originated in pigs in Mexico. As with the 1918 strain, it disproportionally affected healthy young adults. A vaccine was available, and millions of doses were administered; but a study published in The Lancet estimated that the swine flu may have killed as many as 575,400 people that year.
Not Spanish
The very name Spanish flu is based on a myth. The first cases may have come from France, Belgium, Kansas, or China; experts disagree. But they all agree it did NOT originate in Spain. Spain got the blame because it was a neutral country in WWI and had no wartime press censorship. The countries involved in the war censored news about flu cases in their own countries. When Spain reported its cases, that news was reprinted and everyone got the idea that that’s where the epidemic started.
Myths on the Exopolitics website
Along with promoting flu vaccine myths, this website has some very questionable claims about Ebola, calling it “a man-made bioweapons owned and patented by the US government and the CDC.” It claims vitamin C is the ideal treatment for Ebola, calls Ebola “a gift from Jesuit murderers,” and claims that Bush’s “pandemic laws” and Obama threaten the American public with martial law and genocide by vaccine.
It also claims the World Health Organization (WHO) has admitted that its smallpox vaccine caused AIDS.
Some of its claims about influenza (errors in the original):
    • “There was no Spanish flu”
There was no 1918 Spanish flu – 50-100 million people were exterminated by vaccines and aspirin. Mandated vaccines at the end of the war, forced on soldiers triggered lots of horrible symptoms of all kinds and lots of deaths and it was all blamed on a mysterious flu… Vaccines set off symptoms and death, everyone was told there was a flu pandemic, doctors and people used aspirin…aspirin is immune suppressant and led to pneumonias and death or to overdosing with aspirin and death.
    • Patients died of pneumonia, not influenza. Well, yes; the flu virus damaged the lungs and allowed for bacterial superinfections. But the flu was clearly responsible.
    • Blame it on aspirin. It says the Journal of the American Medical Association recommended “toxic” doses of aspirin: 1,000 mg every three hours, or 8,000 mg/day. That is not a toxic dose. Mild toxicity begins at a dose of 150mg/kg and serious toxicity begins at dose of 300 mg/kg. A toxic dose for an adult male would be more like 24,000 mg/day. A study by Karen Starko suggested that overdoses of aspirin might have contributed to a small number of deaths, but she acknowledged that she did not have autopsy reports or other documents to support her conjecture.
    • Homeopathy saves lives. Homeopaths allegedly saved the lives of almost every patient who came to them, supposedly because they didn’t use aspirin. Homeopaths did report astounding success rates, but their results were self-reported and anecdotal: no controlled studies were done to evaluate their claims. If a patient died who had gone against the homeopath’s advice in any way (for instance taking aspirin) they might not have felt obligated to count that case as a failure of homeopathy.
    • There was a conspiracy. Bayer and other manufacturers were involved in a conspiracy to criminalize homeopathy and natural cures in order to sell more aspirin.
    • Godwin’s law strikes again. According to Godwin’s law, “As an online discussion grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving Hitler approaches 1.” Sure enough:
Twenty years after Bayer contributed to the largest number of deaths by disease (20 to 50 million) in human history, Bayer was a primary funder of Hitler, helped run the basic operations of the war, including the concentration camps, and in causing WWII and slaughtering and experimenting on people during the Holocaust, was responsible for the deaths of 50-70 million people. Was Bayer a financial backer of the German military during WWI as well?
Really? Bayer caused WWII? I don’t think so! And anyway, whatever sins they may have committed in WWII, that doesn’t mean they were responsible for the 1918 flu epidemic.
    • Hallucinogenic nonsense? They quote Shiv Chopra, microbiologist, vaccine expert:
“The bird and mammalian species took hold on the earth approximately 65 million years ago, i.e. the same time as the dinosaurs went extinct. So did the flu and other viruses of all the surviving species. Since then, all those viruses have been mating [viruses don’t mate!] and mutating among themselves without the sky caving in due to any infection. Therefore, any talk of a bird or swine flu pandemic with the probability to kill millions of people is either a purposeful or hallucinogenic nonsense to make profit on the backs of the innocent following.”
Myths on Whale.to
John Scudamore’s Whale.to may be the worst site on the web, full of misinformation and conspiracy theories. Orac has explained “the nuttiness that is Whale.to” and how it led to the formulation of Scopie’s law: “In any discussion involving science or medicine, citing Whale.to as a credible source loses you the argument immediately…and gets you laughed out of the room.” Some of the myths Scudamore promotes:
    • In Whale.to’s “Swine Flu Expose” he says:
”Their scare-head campaign cry is that the swine flu is like the 1918 flu which killed 20,000,000 people. They don’t have any usable and provable blood samples from the 1918 flu epidemic to prove it. That was 58 years ago, and the doctors were just as confused and inefficient then as now. However, one thing is certain — the 1918 Spanish Influenza was a vaccine-induced disease caused by extreme body poisoning from the conglomeration of many different vaccines. The soldiers at Fort Dix who were said to have had Swine Flu had been injected with a large variety of vaccines like the vaccines which caused the 1918 flu epidemic. The flu epidemic at Fort Dix was in no way related to swine. There were no swine at camp (unless we want to sarcastically call the vaccine promoters who caused the diseases -“swine.”)”
    • “Vaccines are designed to cause a mild case of the diseases they are supposed to prevent.” [No, they are designed to train the immune system to recognize antigens and prevent the disease. They contain either a small, noninfectious portion of the organism or a weakened form of the whole organism. Vaccines can’t cause even a mild case of the original disease.]
    • “Smallpox vaccine often causes syphilis, paralysis, leprosy, and cancer.”
    • “I heard that seven men dropped dead in a doctor’s office after being vaccinated.”
    • “Many [soldiers] were insane from postvaccinal encephalitis, but the doctors called it shell shock.”
    • “The diphtheria vaccine caused lung congestion, chills and fever, swollen, sore throat clogged with the false membrane, and the choking suffocation because of difficulty in breathing followed by gasping and death, after which the body turned black from stagnant blood that had been deprived of oxygen in the suffocation stages. In early days they called it Black Death.” [The diphtheria vaccine doesn’t do that, and the Black Death was an entirely different disease.]
    • “When doctors had tried to suppress the symptoms of the typhoid with a stronger vaccine, it caused a worse form of typhoid which they namedparatyphoid. [Paratyphoid is not form of typhoid: it is a separate disease caused by a different organism.] But when they concocted a stronger and more dangerous vaccine to suppress that one, they created an even worse disease which they didn’t have a name for. What should they call it? They didn’t want to tell the people what it really was — their own Frankenstein monster which they had created with their vaccines and suppressive medicines. They wanted to direct the blame away from themselves, so they called it Spanish Influenza.”
    • He says “The flu hit only the vaccinated,” but later on the same page he contradicts himself, saying “There was seven times more disease among the vaccinated soldiers than among the unvaccinated civilians.”
    • He claims that drugless doctors at non-medical hospitals like Battle Creek were able to cure nearly 100% of their patients with water cure, baths, enemas, fasting, and diets of natural foods.
    • “One soldier who had returned from overseas in 1912 told me that the army hospitals were filled with cases of infantile paralysis and he wondered why grown men should have an infant disease. Now, we know that paralysis is a common after-effect of vaccine poisoning. Those at home didn’t get the paralysis until after the world-wide vaccination campaign in 1918.” [Simply not true. People were being paralyzed by polio as far back as ancient Egypt, long before vaccines.]
Myths on Natural News
Mike Adams, “The Health Ranger” runs the infamous website Natural News. He does his part to spread myths about the 1918 flu (errors in original):
    • It began in multiple cities, simultaneously!There is no single point of origin with the 1918 flu. It appears to have “spontaneously” sprung up across multiple cities all at once, including a military base in Kansas. (Kansas? Yep. So how did it get to Kansas in an era when air traffic was virtually non-existent? Vaccines, of course!) All those cities and servicemen have one thing in common: Flu shot vaccinations given to them by the military.”
    • “If you put the pieces together on this, it’s not too difficult to suspect that influenza could potentially be used as a tool of control by governments or drug companies to catalyze outrageous profit-taking or power grabbing agendas. A desperate, infected population will gladly give up anything or pay anything for the promise of being cured.”
    • “Allen Tyler, a medical doctor and naturopathic physician, reports that fibromyalgia was not seen before the1918 flu pandemic. In his research, he found that 90 percent of fibromyalgia patients tested positive for influenza A antibodies.”
    • “This [homeopathic] tablet is made from the combined strains ofinfluenza virus from the major flu epidemics since 1918. The combined strains are then homeopathically prepared and potentized. No ill effects have ever been reported from the “cold and flu” tablet, and the rate of protection has been high.”
Myths on Mercola.com
Natural health proponent Joseph Mercola says that historical evidence points to too much aspirin as a contributor to high death tolls in the pandemic. And he suggests that Tamiflu, used to treat influenza, may be similarly causing deaths today. He also says many of the deaths blamed on flu were due to strep infections.
Myths on the Vaccine Liberation website
This website makes many questionable claims based on a single story in an Irish newspaper:
    • The Germans might have been responsible for the bug as part of their war effort, spreading it in theaters or where large numbers of people assembled.
    • All non-combat deaths of American soldiers may have been from the flu.
    • After vaccination became compulsory in the US Army in 1911, typhoid and all other vaccinal diseases increased at an alarming rate.
    • In 1917, 19,608 soldiers were hospitalized due to anti-typhoid inoculation and vaccinia.
    • “When Army doctors tried to suppress the symptoms of typhoid with a stronger vaccine, it caused a worse form of typhoid paratyphoid. But when they concocted an even stronger vaccine to suppress that one, they created an even worse disease Spanish flu.”
    • Patients didn’t die of the flu: doctors killed them with their crude and deadly treatments.
Osteopathic myths
DOs used osteopathic manipulation along with other measures to treat victims of the pandemic. A report in the Journal of Osteopathy in 1919 explained:
To treat the Flu osteopathically is to inhibit mechanically, by relaxing the muscles along the spine, gently but persistently, with deep pressure over its entire length, preferably with the palms of the hands, with special inhibition in the suboccipital fossa, the area of the fourth, eighth, tenth … and eleventh dorsal inclusive. When there is edema of the lungs the muscles employed in respiration should receive special attention.
DOs criticized medical doctors for using aspirin, saying it suppressed the fever but lowered blood pressure, “counteracting nature’s efforts to correct the secretory disturbance and leaving the patient to drown in his own secretions.”
DOs reported a death rate of only one-fourth of one percent, 40 times less than allopaths, but those statistics were from self-reports and are not credible. Nevertheless, they claimed:
The greatly higher success rate of flu treatment by osteopathic physicians (D.O.s) over allopathic physicians (M.D.s) suggests having osteopathic manipulative treatment as a line of defense in preparing for another flu pandemic.
Chiropractic myths
Chiropractors also reported an impressive success rate.
A YouTube video by Dan Murphy, DC, points out that chiropractic was new, barely 20 years old in 1918. He claims that back then, patients mainly consulted chiropractors for infectious diseases rather than for back pain. He claims that patients’ immune systems work better when their spines are adjusted. He says that up until the 1950s chiropractors were mainly treating patients with polio. He claims that the success rate in the 1918 pandemic was so great it directly led to the licensing of chiropractors.
Conclusion: Influenza myths are false but fun
One of our commenters defended these mythmongering sources by saying “Whale /to and Vaccine Liberation are very well received on Facebook. Thank you.” Wow! Just wow! There ought to be another law like Scopie’s Law for people who think a favorable reception on Facebook has anything to do with truth or reality.
There’s no reason we can’t appreciate mythology for its own sake. After all, we enjoy a lot of things that are fictional: movies, TV shows, novels, science fiction. I had a lot of fun reading these myths. I laughed, I was entertained, and I marveled at the creative thinking and human ingenuity (and gullibility) that went into some of them. I was reminded of a quotation from Albert Einstein’s letter to a colleague: “Your chain of reasoning is so wonderfully self-contained. Except for agreeing with reality, it is certainly a grand intellectual achievement.”

The Madness of Crowding
Crowding and Influenza.
Mark Crislip on July 21, 2026
Link

I am always amused by people who think that by living right, whatever right might be, they can avoid infections. Nope. Living right is not going to do much to prevent infections.
It is good to be nutritionally replete, but more is not better for preventing infection. Can’t put more gas in the tank once it is full. And moderate exercise is good for you as well, with the emphasis on moderate.
You may credit diet or supplements for never getting the flu. More likely you were born with the right immune system that allows you to avoid getting an infection. No two immune systems are the same, and we are chockablock full of variations, polymorphisms (two or more variant forms of a specific DNA sequence) and mutations that increase or decrease susceptibility to infection. Sometimes both. Lack the chemokine receptor, be resistant to HIV but have an increased risk for West Nile encephalitis. Evolution has an odd sense of humor. Pick an infection and Google it with polymorphism, and like as not you will find interesting associations.
I was always fascinated by polymorphisms and often wished I had Dr. McCoy’s tricorder so I could scan patients and answer the question as to why they had a particular infection. Although I am not sure saying the reason for the severe influenza A infection is an IL6 rs1818879 (GA) heterozygous genotype is an improvement over crediting blind, stupid, simple, doodah, clueless LUCK!
The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars,
But in ourselves
And there ain’t much you can do about it.
You can avoid behaviors that put you at risk for infections. Most infections are acquired one of three ways: sex, eating, and breathing. You can avoid the first by getting married, but it is hard to stop the other two without adverse consequences. It is better to have unprotected sex in Provo than Detroit or avoid lettuce, the latter always a good idea. Salads are my dinner’s dinner.
I was always aware that the first word to describe my subspecialty was infectious (in the old days it was communicable). The raison d’ etre of most infections is to use us to reproduce. We are an irresistible dinner, flowers and water bed for viri. And nothing outside of preexisting immunity/vaccination is going to prevent them from using us as their love hotel. I wonder, am I oversharing? Nah.
Respiratory viri love crowds. Indoor crowds. Outdoor crowds. Filled with susceptible people. No better way to spread rapidly.
Schools are one example. There is an extensive literature trying to evaluate the effects of schools and the spread of influenza. The results are variable. Mostly they look at flu during school times and during breaks, and find there is a modest decrease in influenza in children during holidays but little to no impact on the spread in the community. Which seems about right, given the infectivity of flu.
It took COVID, with everyone stuck at home, to really decrease flu transmission, going so far as to drive one strain of B into extinction.
The military has long been plagued by outbreaks, especially in boot camps. In the 1918-1919 flu epidemic
The war fostered influenza in the crowded conditions of military camps in the United States and in the trenches of the Western Front in Europe. The virus traveled with military personnel from camp to camp and across the Atlantic, and at the height of the American military involvement in the war, September through November 1918, influenza and pneumonia sickened 20% to 40% of U.S. Army and Navy personnel. These high morbidity rates interfered with induction and training schedules in the United States and rendered hundreds of thousands of military personnel non-effective. During the American Expeditionary Forces’ campaign at Meuse-Argonne, the epidemic diverted urgently needed resources from combat support to transporting and caring for the sick and the dead. Influenza and pneumonia killed more American soldiers and sailors during the war than did enemy weapons.
Read that last sentence again. Wow.
Influenza was not the only problem at the time.
A US army-wide measles outbreak in 1917–18 resulted in more than 95 000 cases and more than 3000 deaths.
And there were other infections as well. Menigococcus and acute rheumatic fever were being spread.
The situation during World War I was similar. There were 24,770 admissions for acute articular rheumatism reported, but the significance of this disease was apparently overlooked even though it was occurring at the rate of 6.00 per 1,000 per annum.
And while spread was not due to crowding and crowds (I would hope), I would be remiss not to mention venereal diseases:
U.S. Army Medical Department statistics relating to venereal disease in the War are extensive and interesting. Thus, in 3,500,000 outpatient and hospital encounters 383,706 included a venereal disease, thus, 11%. The rate for officers as compared to enlisted soldiers was less than one-fourth. The rate of younger soldiers was higher than those older. Interestingly, the venereal disease incidence rate was about 50% higher for soldiers serving in the United States and even much higher yet for soldiers serving in the Philippines. French prostitutes, much maligned in 1918, appear to have been much less a danger than their American and Filipino sisters-in-sex. As might be imagined, the diagnosis of syphilis was much less common than that of gonorrhea.
I picked WW1, as it was the first war where influenza was a major cause of mortality and morbidity. But through time, infections routinely killed or disabled more soldiers than combat and have had a major impact on readiness and fighting capabilities. Different wars had different infectious worries. For the Civil War, it was dysentery.
Diarrhea and dysentery were the number one killers. (Dysentery is considered diarrhea with blood in the stool.) 57,000 deaths were directly recorded to these most disabling maladies. The total recorded Union cases was 1,528,098. Thousands of the afflicted went into battle fatigued with abdominal pain, malaise and dehydration. If wounded, they often died due to their poor constitutional state,
In Vietnam, it was malaria
Although severe malaria resulted in 78 known deaths in the US Army (and 46 in the US Marines), the real military issue was lost days due to illness, averaging more than 1 month per malaria case and at least 200,000 lost man-days per year.
I do not doubt that future wars will have their own unique as well as traditional infection risks. Whether those infections will be prevented by testosterone replacement is uncertain. What little that is out there suggests testosterone replacement therapy (TRT) increases the risk of a variety of post-operative infections, so soldiers on TRT should avoid being wounded.
But at least we have vaccines. Right? Right.
Those who are too incompetent to understand history are going to repeat it.
No one is more crowded together than military trainees
Recruits live in tightly packed bays, shower communally and spend much of the day within arm’s reach of one another.
Hog heaven for flu and other infectious diseases.
Just two months after our wise Secretary of War scrapped the influenza vaccine mandates (calling the flu vaccine requirement an “absurd, overreaching” mandate that had served to “weaken our warfighting capabilities”), vaccination rates fell to 40%, and guess what happened? Outbreak. Duh.
Lackland Air Force Base had 275 cases of flu with four hospitalizations and one death.
One death too many. When you volunteer to serve, there is the implicit recognition that you could die for your country. I respect those who make that choice. But I doubt they would sign up if that death was due to influenza because absurd, overreaching vaccine requirements were abandoned.
So they brought the vaccine requirement back.
And this policy change occurred knowing that
Military trainees have historically been vulnerable to acute respiratory disease due to relative immune compromise from physical, environmental, and psychological stress. Multiple studies have reported that recruits have a higher incidence of influenza-like illnesses compared to non-recruits.
You may not remember this, but the one death from the 1976 Fort Dix swine-flu outbreak was in a recruit who had just undergone a forced march. High-intensity exercise, which defines boot camp, increases risk for influenza.
I keep wondering if those in the Trump administration have invested in casket production. Probably not. More likely just betting on the prediction market. It would explain a lot of their public health policies. That or rank stupidity.
Oh. BTW.
Scientists have found that men with relatively high amounts of circulating testosterone benefit less from vaccination against influenza than do men with lower testosterone levels.
Crowding. Influenza. A more dangerous mix than cheeseburgers and loneliness. Unless vaccinated.

Pump it up: osteopathic manipulation and influenza
Mark Crislip on October 4, 2013
Link

First, my bias. I work in Portland and we have medical students, residents, and faculty who are DOs (Doctor of Osteopathy). Before he moved on to be a hospitalist my primary physician was a DO. From my experience there is no difference between an MD and a DO. In my world they are interchangeable. There are many more qualified applicants for medical education than positions in MD programs and some opt for a DO education. Osteopathy has a dark side.As best I can determine from my colleagues, learning osteopathic manipulation (OM) is the price they pay to obtain an otherwise standard medical education. I have yet to see OM offered by any of my DO colleagues. It may be they know better than to offer such a modality around me given my ranty propensity for all things SCAM.
The literature would suggest that OM is left behind by most DOs upon graduation. DOs are not proud of their OM, and rarely invite them ‘round to dinner. It will be interesting to see if OM fades over time in DO school as the old time true believers die off and are supplanted by a generation of DOs trained with more traditional medical education.
OM, the small pseudoscientific aspect of DO medical school education, is a form of massage and manipulation invented in the 19th century with no basis in reality. OM postulates
the existence of a myofascial continuity – a tissue layer that interlinks all parts of the body. By manipulating the bones and muscles of a patient a practitioner is supposed to be able to diagnose and treat and variety of systemic human ailments.
Studies into the efficacy of OM find it to be ineffective for any process aside from low back pain (is there anything that does not help low back pain?), not surprising for a therapeutic intervention detached from reality. My purpose with this entry is not to review OM per se, which may be a good topic someday, but to focus on a specific application of OM.
Despite OM fading in the US, that does not mean there are not true believers; all nonsense has its die-hard proponents and OM is no exception, yielding peculiar publications. An example I ran across: The 2012–2013 influenza epidemic and the role of osteopathic manipulative medicine.
It caught my interest. How could a ritualistic massage and muscle manipulation have any effect of a virus that is multiplying in and destroying respiratory epithelial cells? Can they do OM on the lining of the lung? And if so, how do they get into the airway to do it? Inquiring minds want to know the rationale behind such a goofy intervention for a viral infection of the lung. Routine readers of the blog know I am very much a Bayesian/prior plausibility kind of guy. It is inconceivable to me that OM could have any effect on of influenza.
There remains a great need for a “something more” to be done to deal with this highly contagious viral infection—and that “something” is embodied by what osteopathic medicine has offered in the past: a distinctive care that helped the world manage the Spanish influenza pandemic of 1918-1919, nearly 100 years ago. Then as now, osteopathic physicians were in a unique position, armed with osteopathic manipulative treatment (OMT). Modern osteopathic physicians use OMT in conjunction with vaccination, antiviral treatment, and chemoprophylaxis to turn the tide against this devastating, highly contagious pathogen.
Weird, huh? Give a list of reality based interventions to decrease infection risk and therapy (hygiene, vaccination, medications) then toss in some useless pseudoscience. Interesting how a mind can hold two contradictory ideas at the same time: simultaneously suggesting reality- and fantasy-based medicine.
One of the themes of this blog and one of the topics that I have an evolving interest in is how we know what is true and the standards we use to determine reality. My time in the SBM world has greatly heighten my awareness as to how horrendous we are at interpreting the effectiveness of medical interventions and how iffy much of the medical literature is.
What is the basis of using OM for the treatment of influenza? For that you have to go back to a time when all medical treatments were little better than using stone knives and bearskins, the turn of the century. It was a time when most of medicine was, by the standards of today, worthless, dangerous or both. Most of the focus of this entry will be on the original papers, which had better be pretty damn impressive to suggest OM is a reasonable adjunct to standard influenza care. Spoiler. It isn’t.
The source was the 1918–1919 influenza pandemic where:
osteopaths had a substantial impact on patient care: according to Smith, patients who received conventional (i.e., allopathic) medical treatment had a death rate 40 times higher than those who received osteopathic care.
Standard care at the time had a case fatality rate of about 2.5%, although they give more impressive mortality rates in the paper.
Whoa. Really? It did? That would be amazing if true. Let’s go to the video tape. Or the scanned pdfs.
The original reference from 1919 is a fun read, the transcription of a talk full of the pomp and verbosity common in the time. I am writing the final draft of this essay during breaks at the national ID meeting, where I have spent the last few days mostly having Powerpoint slides read to me. We could use some 19th century pomp and verbosity to enliven the sessions.
The reproduction is poor with a lot of bleed-through. I think it says, and this is the methods part of the presentation:
As you know, a letter containing a blank questionnaire on Influenza and Pneumonias was sent last November to all practicing osteopathic physicians in the United States and Canada. Strict and emphasized instructions were given to report only definitive and well developed cases and to report all such, together with all fatalities.
That’s it. I cannot locate what the strict and emphasized instructions were. Very little real data is given. Nowhere do they mention what specific osteopathic treatment was used, there was more of a focus on what was not done: no aspirin, no narcotics.
The data was equally minimalistic. In the original paper it was reported that 2,445 osteopaths answered the questionnaire and reported treating 110,220 cases of influenza with 257 deaths, 1/4 of one percent. They also reported 6,248 cases of pneumonia with 655 deaths.
The paper was presented in July 1919, only about 7 months after the end of the epidemic. A damn impressive turnaround time to send out almost 2,500 letters, have them filled out, returned, read and analyzed. I would so love to see those letters. It seems a wee bit suspicious to me. Anyone have the originals?
A further illuminating feature of these reports revealed that fact that few persons contracted influenza who, just preceding and at the time of the epidemic, had been having more or less regulate osteopathic manipulative treatment.
The actual data to support the preventative effects of OM? Nothing. His assertion. Color me unimpressed (mauve-y shade of pinky russet is the color of unimpressed, if you must know).
Most of the report goes on to castigate the powers that be for not including DOs as part of the medical response to the pandemic despite their superior medical treatments and noting that DOs did not make any of their patients drug addicts. It is quite an indignant screed, worthy of the blogosphere but short on supporting data.
The paper, while interesting, is of no value what so ever for supporting the use of OM for influenza: no microbiologic diagnosis, no case definition, no case control, and huge opportunity for reporting bias that renders the information totally unreliable. But a fun rant does not a reliable intervention make. I would love to see the original questionnaires and look at the data. We have to take the word of the author who, from the tone of the paper, has a real ax to grind in the promotion of DO/OM treatment.
Although anti-medication in tone, it is of interest that they were of the opinion that:
In 1918-1919, aspirin…played the same harmful role as was played by antipyrin and ?? a generation earlier.
How much of the death in the US from influenza was due to inadvertent aspirin overdose is an interesting question:
In 1918, the US Surgeon General, the US Navy, and the Journal of the American Medical Association recommended use of aspirin just before the October death spike. It has been suggested that aspirin overdose lead to significant pulmonary edema and death in the US. If these recommendations were followed, and if pulmonary edema occurred in 3% of persons, [a significant proportion of the deaths may be attributable to aspirin.]
A curious hypothesis, although the virus was quite capable of killing without the benefit of medical care and aspirin.
It is an interesting question as to whether it was DO care or the avoidance of MD care and aspirin, if it occurred, that resulted in an improved survival rate. The fact that most SCAMs do nothing would be a benefit in a time when medicine inflicted aggressive nonsense upon the ill. More likely is biased reporting by an author railing against “medical bigotry and medical politics.”
Even if OM care was responsible for a decreased death rate, and I would be skeptical based on the methods and data reporting, it is more likely a result of what DO did not do (standard care) than what they did (OM).
The author of the 1937 paper referring to the 1919 report credits:
the lymphatic pump technique, which has become popular in the last few years is a procedure of definite value in the treatment of influenza.
What proportion of patients actually received the ‘lymphatic pump technique’ cannot be discovered, as it is not mentioned in the original 1919 paper what exactly the DO interventions consisted of.
As best as can be determined, there is no information in the original reports to suggest that any conclusions can be made about any specific osteopathic intervention for influenza as no specific intervention is mentioned (must less the use of any lymphatic pump).
The fact that there is no mention of a lymphatic pump as the intervention that led to such a dramatic decline in mortality doesn’t stop the technique as being touted for the treatment of influenza:
Should we face additional waves of new influenza infections in the coming year, the use of the gentle lymphatic treatment techniques and medications such as oseltamivir will likely help pre- vent many persons from getting the influenza-related complications that took so many lives during the Spanish influenza pandemic of 1918-1919.
and
Retrospective data gathered by the American Osteopathic Association shortly after the 1918–1919 influenza pandemic have suggested that osteopathic physicians (DOs), using their distinctive osteopathic manipulative treatment (OMT) methods, observed significantly lower morbidity and mortality among their patients as compared to those treated by allopathic physicians (MDs) with standard medical care available at the time. In light of the limited prevention and treatment options available, it seems logical that a preparedness plan for the treatment of avian influenza should include these OMT procedures, provided by DOs and other healthcare workers capable of being trained to perform these therapeutic interventions.
I love their understatement about the validity of the original data:
These were not controlled studies. The data is retrospective and some conclusions cannot be well drawn from such information.
How about no conclusions can be drawn? I grow even more of a mauv-y shade of pinkish russet by the paragraph. It doesn’t prevent the author from declaring
OMT proved to be a critical factor in the success of osteopathic physicians treating influenza patients during the pandemic of 1918
They suggest a variety of pumps that are supposed to boost the immune system (zero prior plausibility for that concept) and increase lymph flow (maybe, but I can’t see that lymph flow would be of any value in and of itself and the short term increase in lymph flow, if it does occur with OM, would be brief and of an inconsequential amount given the duration of the intervention relative to the 24–7 illness like influenza. A pump would be like adding a lit match to increase the burn rate of a forest fire).
The various pumps are described look to me like a series of massages, some of which look like they are designed to give influenza to the practitioner. I wonder how a patient with flu, intractable cough, high fevers and severe myalgia would lie still to let this be done.
It is often interesting to go back to the original literature and see if the paper actually says what people say it does. I learned as a fellow that papers are often ink blots and people see in them what they think should be there rather than what actually is there. Confirmation bias can show up in the damnedest places.
A reading of the primary literature for OM and influenza does not lead to great confidence in the intervention for influenza nor do the papers actually say what the proponents suggest they do. I become Shaltanac’s joopleberry shrub.
As we head into the influenza season, stick with realty-based interventions. Wash your hands, avoid the spew of coughers, harder than you might think, get the vaccine and be replete in your vitamin D. I think it is safe to say you can pass on osteopathic manipulation.

Bird is the Word
Something H5N1 this way comes. Perhaps.
Mark Crislip on May 21, 2024
Link

A well a everybody’s heard about the bird
B-b-b bird, bird, bird, b-bird’s the word
A well a bird, bird, bird, the bird is the word
A well a bird, bird, bird, well the bird is the word
A well a bird, bird, bird, b-bird’s the word
A well a bird, bird, bird, well the bird is the word
A well a bird, bird, b-bird’s the word
A well a bird, bird, bird, b-bird’s the word
A well a bird, bird, bird, well the bird is the word
A well a bird, bird, b-bird’s the word
The Trashmen. Surfin Bird.
Bird is the Word. Indeed. Finest tribute to Charlie Parker ever, at least as I understand the lyrics. But then, didn’t Frank Zappa say something to the effect it is foolish to look for meaning in rock lyrics? I think so. Can’t quickly find the quote and don’t want to go down that rat hole. Wouldn’t be prudent.
I am a bit punk this month. My gallstones, after years of lying quietly, decided to try and kill me. Nothing like a gangrenous gallbladder to slow you down. I found it interesting in that for years I said the gallbladder was the second most difficult to understand organ, and it could go south with remarkably little lab and physical findings pointing to the gallbladder. Then you open the patient up based on CT findings and it is dead, Jim. Although green, rather than the usual red shirt. Like mine. I am getting better, but do not have my usual focus.
My long and storied career saw three pandemics. AIDS started when I was in medical school (remember, association is not causation), then H1N1 influenza, and finally COVID 45. At 67 I wonder if I will live long enough to see a fourth, or ironically, to die in one? Could be.
I never saw coronaviruses as a pandemic worry. It wasn’t discussed much in the journals or meetings that I remember, although there were the smart ones who were worrying about coronaviruses and there were a few coronaviruses that tried, and failed, to go full pandemic.
It was always influenza that kept that ball of anxiety alive, because we (by we I mean ID docs) remember the 1918 influenza that killed, in less than a year, more Americans than died of enemy action in all our wars combined. 600,000 or so. 5% of the population. Dead. Damn impressive. COVID killed around 0.3% in comparison, but in 3-ish times the population.
By the way, the descriptor ‘only’ never belongs in front of morbidity or mortality statistics, and is the marker of an uncaring asshole, an anti-John Donne. One death is not an only to the person dying or their friends and family. And please, if you find I did just such a faux pas in the past, I do not want to know about it. We all do foolish things in our youth, youth being defined as age less than current age.
Influenza has always been one of the more interesting infectious diseases, in part due to its history, in part due to its impact on society, and in part due to it pathophysiology. Which is like most of the ‘fun’ infectious diseases. Syphilis, TB, Malaria, and influenza are some of the pathogens that share those characteristics.
While it looked early in the outbreak that H1N1 was going to be the next Spanish flu, the reported initial high mortality rates out of Mexico were a reporting artifact. H1N1 probably killed 284,000 (range from 150,000 to 575,000) people, so not a particularly virulent by 1918 standards. Or COVID 45.
Of course, with H1N1 we had residual immunity from prior outbreaks, vaccines, medications to treat flu and its secondary infections, ICUs, and a better understanding of how to dose aspirin. So I would be surprised even if there was a new influenza outbreak it would kill at 1918 rates. But given the huge world population now, a death rate of 0.5% would kill a lot of people.
During most of my career, avian influenza has been wandering through the world, and I get the impression it is probing the barriers between birds and humans, looking for a way in. Of course, it is not really doing that, but a rule of infectious diseases, if it is possible to get infected by some weird, unusual route, someone will get infected by that route. And if there is an environmental niche that an infection can move into, it will. Evolution is a bastard. The question is whether it will be a one-off event (likely) or the start of something worse.
But first, let’s talk influenza A. As you know, flu is brought to you by the letters H and N. The H stands for the hemagglutinin and N the neuraminidase. H1, H2, and H3 are found in human strains. H4, H5, H6 etc (18 have been isolated so far) are strains found in other animals, like bird influenzas. Similarly, there are human and non-human neuraminidases (11 total). They are important virulence factors where
HA initiates viral fusion by binding to sialic acid-containing receptors on the host cell and NA facilitates viral release by hydrolyzing the ketosidic bond of sialic acid. The balance of HA and NA activities is thought to be critical for influenza virus infectivity and transmissibility.
Generally, these enzymes are mostly species-specific, although humans, and pigs are remarkably alike as far as influenza, and my wife, are concerned. She always wished she realized at a younger age that most men are pigs. The pig-human similarities are why outbreaks of human influenza often originate in pig farms.
In ID, it is traditional to mention if a given virus is DNA or RNA or single-stranded or double-stranded or circular or whatever. Much of the time it is information that does not help understand the virus. For some, like HIV, that information can be helpful. The key thing about influenza is that it is a segmented genome. Eight segments, in fact.
So what can happen, often in a pig, is the poor swine is infected with say, a human and a bird flu, and in forming a new virus it takes a segment from a pig flu and a segment from a human flu and, viola, you have a new strain of flu. The dreaded antigenic shift that usually happens every 30 to 50 years. That is different than the antigenic drift, where there is the gradual accumulation of mutations in the viral genome. For, like humans, influenza is a sloppy reproducer.
So right now the worry is H5N1. Where did it come from? Chinese poultry farms around 1996. As is typical of influenza. Farms the world over have a mix of humans, pigs, birds and other animals in high density, perfect for breeding a new strain of influenza. Since that time, by way of wild birds, it has spread across the world, killing uncountable birds, 900 or so humans with a 50%, yes 50%, death rate.
And, to my surprise given that viri are usually relatively species-specific, killing other animals. Lots of other animals. It has killed huge numbers of elephant seals and
Avian flu viruses tend to be picky about their hosts, typically sticking to one kind of wild bird. But this one has rapidly infiltrated an astonishingly wide array of birds and animals, from squirrels and skunks to bottlenose dolphins, polar bears and, most recently, dairy cows.
And that is odd. Cows? Cows have their own influenza D. But A? A Pubmed search suggests reports for influenza A in cows only started in the last decade. Cows do not die off like sea lions but get a mild illness. But the influenza is now widespread and spreading in dairy cows and, when tested (many farmers are evidently refusing not only to have the milk tested, but will not let their cows wear masks. Free the cow.) H5N1 is found in milk. And if raw milk from infected cows is fed to cats, the cats sicken and die from H5N1.
Feels like we would cure the music from Jaws.
But despite being widespread, there has been a paucity of human cases with one case in a dairy worker, suggesting that cows and cow milk are not that efficient at spreading H5N1. Yet. Why? Besides pasteurization? We lack the receptors in the upper airway for H5N1 to bind to. And the first, necessary, step in an infection is the pathogen binding to a very specific receptor on a cell:
Epithelial cells in the intestinal tract of birds (the major target organ of influenza viruses in avian species) express primarily sialic acid linked to the penultimate galactose residue by an α2,3-linkage, and avian influenza viruses have evolved to preferentially bind to this type of sialic acids. In contrast, epithelial cells in the respiratory tract of humans (the major target organ of influenza viruses in humans) express primarily α2,6-linked sialic acids. After they infect humans, influenza viruses therefore need to acquire mutations in HA that confer efficient binding to α2,6-linked sialic acids to enable efficient transmission among humans. The HA proteins of highly pathogenic avian H5N1 influenza viruses preferentially interact with α2,3-linked sialic acids (reviewed in [22]); human infections with these viruses may, in part, be explained by the finding of α2,3-linked sialic acids on type II pneumocytes lining the alveolar wall, and on nonciliated bronchiolar cells [23–26]. The lack of α2,3-linked sialic acids on epithelial cells of the upper respiratory tract of mammals may explain why highly pathogenic avian H5N1 influenza viruses do not transmit efficiently among mammals.
2-3 linked sialic acids are found in human intestines, so raw milk could be a potential source for H5N1. But who in their right mind would drink raw milk in the year 2024? Plenty, I would suspect.
Pasteurization, however, should take care of it. The lone case report of disease in the dairy worker suggests a respiratory route, and as is usual of H5N1 infections, it occurs in those with potentially massive exposures that allow the virus to reach the lower airway to start infection.
And as best I can tell, the alpha 2,3 linked sialic acids are plentiful in cat gut and the cow trachea. It turns out that cow udders have human and bird sialic acid and
human eyes contain the same H5N1 receptor found in ducks and cow udders.
Explaining why the one reported case of a human had conjunctivitis as a predominant symptom. Could have been a splash injury, they were certainly common enough in hospitals before widespread goggle use.
As an aside, I once had a question about HIV prophylaxis. The stripper was lactating and while spinning about the stage, her milk splashed in the eye of a patron. He wasn’t wearing goggles or glasses. But perhaps one should be cautious of lactating animals of all species infected with H5N1. As to my recommendation, I think I laughed too hard to give one.
Cool, huh? Know the receptor that the pathogen needs to get started and a lot of the disease manifestations are explained, be it flu, COVID 45, HIV, or Gonorrhea. That link has the best review of the distribution of sialic acid receptors you could possibly want. Or not want.
But humans seem to be protected. For now. Influenza is unstable, shifting and drifting, changing its genome. It will not take much for it to become transmissible by the air, maybe 3-5 mutations, a number that does deserve an only. Of course, becoming more transmissible doesn’t necessarily mean it will continue to have a 50% mortality rate. It might be more transmissible but less virulent. Or not. And note the N1 in H5N1. As in H1N1. A common human N. So we may have some immunity from H1N1 depending on how much antigenic drift has occurred:
Our results support experimental evidence that prior infection with H1N1 confers partial cross-immunity to H5N1.
It is likely that some preexisting immunity, vaccinations, medications, and bankrupting modern medical care (at least in the West) will attenuate the mortality of H5N1 when and if it becomes more transmissible. Hopefully, mortality will decrease a lot, as a 50% death rate would be a bit much.
I fully expect H5N1 to get those mutations, one way or the other. What can happen, will happen. As I said, H5N1 is very unusually pushing and prodding its way into many other animal species. And if it gets into our closest influenza and spiritual relative, the pig? Can’t see why humans would not be next, so invest in coffins. Something wicked this way comes, but with more or less 1918 levels of morbidity and mortality, got me.
        ◦ All I know for sure is that since COVID 45, a tremendous number of people will do the wrong thing and die as a result. As the wise man noted, no one ever learns from past mistakes and so repeat the same damned thing over and over.

Reality
Reality. Doesn’t care what you think.
Mark Crislip on December 17, 2024
Link
Been thinking about reality of late. I have always been a big fan of the concept. Of course, comprehending reality is not so easy. Some concepts, like gravity, are relatively straightforward. Others, like quantum mechanics, are not. Yes, deliberate joke. And medicine is, more often than not, not so clear cut.
Because a lot of medicine is statistical. For example, say you grow Candida in a blood culture from a central venous catheter. As an intern it was not treated as the therapy was toxic and the risk of a complication from the fungemia was considered negligible. Now we have less toxic therapies and a better understanding of the risks. But not everyone has a complication from the fungemia and some have issues with the treatment. But you play the odds and treat. For me that was always the most problematic part of practice: applying group results to an individual. Cure rates mght be 98%, but for the individual it was all or nothing. As was wisely noted, doctors suggested that Nordberg had a 50 – 50 chance of living, though there was only a 10 percent chance of that.
We use the methods of science as our tools for understanding medicine and reality. I was always drawn to the idea of reality-based medicine rather than science-based medicine. So much of what we discuss on this blog is, at the end of the day, a fiction divorced from reality. But they had a good lawyer and took reality for all she was worth. Reality needed a good prenup, but the result is the SCAMers use science (of a sort) to justify their fiction.
It annoys me no end when talking heads say there are two realities in the US. Nope. There is one reality, often hazy, but there are 335 million interpretations of that reality. Those responses parallel the categories of Kübler-Ross’s 5 stages of dying: denial, anger, bargaining, depression, and acceptance. I know there are issues with that classification, and I am glad that she moved on to helping elves make cookies. And people do not move though these stages when confronting reality; they glom on to one and hold it tight. Denial has always been the most popular.
Which is quite amazing. I know that we have evolved to survive reality, not to understand it, but my flabber has long been gasted by people’s ability to deny the evidence of their lying eyes.

I have told this story before, but I got interested in SCAMs my first year in practice when I was consulted on a case of gangrene. It turned out to be a young female who had a cancer (sarcoma as I remember it) of her leg. Rather than get a probably curative amputation, she sought the care of a naturopath, who treated her. Very unsuccessfully. Her leg was a mass of rotting cancer (quite the smell, let me tell you) but she saw it, as did her ND, as the cancer being successfully treated. She refused any treatment (she was admitted to the hospital as she had passed out and could not refuse) and died that night when the cancer eroded into an artery and she bled out.
Forty years later I shake my head in disbelief at that particular reality denial. Not the last, unfortunately.
That is not the only advanced cancer that I saw in my long and storied career where the patient denied a very obvious problem. Melanoma the size of a large mushroom, cancers that ate away normal flesh to the size of a dinner plate, and massive fungating breast cancers. No, nothing wrong, nothing to see here. The ability of people, and, on occasion, their SCAM providers, to deny reality is amazing. I suppose it is but a more advanced manifestation of a common human characteristic. It is, as an example, manifestly obvious that walnuts are an abomination made by Satan for the sole purpose of turning brownies and chocolate chip cookies inedible. But huge numbers of people deny that reality. Go figure.
Denial comes at three levels.
Individual denial. It harms the patient and their immediate friends and family and sometimes enriches a SCAM practitioner. This is the one I saw most often.
There is group denial. These are groups that deny, not people who deny groups. The most egregious are the homeopaths, but most SCAM practitioners have tenuous relationship with the real world. Perhaps they don’t have cable? The group denial can be religious, like Christian Scientists, whose reliance on prayer to combat illness, often ends badly. The denial groups can be colored, like the increase in COVID morbidity and mortality in Red folks compared to Blue group. I suppose Blue Man Group did well during COVID. The old saying better dead than red doesn’t work so well any more. There are stories of people on their death beds dying of COVID refusing to the last to recognize they had COVID. I took care of buckets of COVID patients but never saw that particular manifestation, although it is part and parcel with how people can react to other diseases.
The worst is when reality denial becomes part of government policy, where ideology determines the science, if you can call it science, and reality is ignored. This approach was popular in the last century; its apotheosis was probably Trofim Denisovich Lysenko, Stalins chief agronomist, who denied all the precepts and modern biology and preferred a Marxist approach to farming. At least 7 million people died in the famines that followed. It is good that sort of reality denial can’t happen in the US. Nope. Everything is fine here as he whistles in the dark. Which only attracts the clickers, so I best keep it down.
That’s the thing about reality: it is one honey badger. It doesn’t care. It doesn’t give a shit what you think. Reality is going to do what it does regardless of ideology or your personal response to it. Which is kind of reassuring if the response to reality is acceptance, problematic if it is depression, and catastrophic if denial.
For most of my career, I was in charge of Infection Control in my hospital system. I think of the environment as filled with Ophiocordyceps unilateralis infected humans, constantly testing our barriers to infect us. Anyone care to guess what game I just finished?
My take home from a lifetime of infection control? If you want to prevent infections, you have to do all the interventions every time and perfectly. Reality needs to be fastidiously adhered to. Any breakdown in technique and the pathogen will use the opportunity to infect. Which makes it a pain when taking care of patients, but it tends to work. Forty years of taking care of infectious disease patients. HIV. Tb. COVID. Influenza. Stickittothemaneosis. I was always fastidious with infection control policies and proceedures and never caught an infection from a patient. I paid close attention to the reality of these infections. Infectious is the first word in my specialty, not kind-of-infectious diseases or sort-of-infectious diseases.
Now we have bird flu at the door. It was found in a pig in Oregon and that cues the music from Jaws. Pigs are the creepy castle on the hill in which Baron Frankenstein can construct his monster, perhaps to run amuck and kill the villagers. Or not. If we are lucky, the evolution to an increase human infectivity will come with a decrease in virulence. So far in humans bird flu is mostly causing a mildish upper respiratory tract disease. Perhaps it will stay that way. And perhaps not. Perhaps we will get some amelioration from partial immunity to the prior infections and vaccines that were N1. Again. Or not.
Like most ID (infectious disease, not intelligent design) doctors, I have been nervously drumming my fingers on the table waiting for an influenza pandemic like 1918-19. And we may be perhaps one mutation away from an infection that has a 30% death rate. Or not.
But it will be… interesting, yeah interesting, that’s the word, to see the federal response in the next 4 years to the reality of a bird flu, or any new influenza, going full pandemic. The flu vaccine is not the best of breed, but, like airbags and seat-belts in a high-speed collision, better than not. It is also a vaccine whose benefits are better noticed in populations than in individuals. I have written extensively about flu here, so to sum up, the vaccine decreases the odds of getting flu, getting sick with flu, being hospitalized with flu, and dying of flu. Note the key words, decreases the odds. And it decreases odds of pregnancy loss and, perhaps in some, stupid(er) children. You can’t make a silk purse out of a sows ear.
It was also interesting what COVID restrictions did to flu and an other respiratory illnesses. Shut them down. One influenza, B/Yamagata, looks like it went extinct. Amazing.
So we know the benefits of vaccinations and, from COVID, the benefits of restrictions, as well as the downsides. We have a fairly good understanding of reality.
So when and if bird flu hits, which stage of dying will the federal government embrace? Me? I’m investing in crypto-coffins. The best of both worlds.
    • 

   Vaccine Preventable Diseases

It’s the end of the world as I know it. And I feel fine.
Pondering the future of a few infections. As to the image, consider it a metaphor of before and after where Jesus is a stand in for science or public health or whatever you want him to be. Except a promoter of peace and helping the poor. Not in 2025 anyway. See https://www.bu.edu/sequitur/2016/04/29/handler-ecce/ for more.
Mark Crislip on February 18, 2025
Link
Six o’clock, TV hour, don’t get caught in foreign tower
Slash and burn, return, listen to yourself churn
Lock him in uniform, book burning, bloodletting
Every motive escalate, automotive incinerate
Light a candle, light a motive, step down, step down
Watch your heel crush, crush, uh oh
This means no fear, cavalier, renegade and steering clear
A tournament, a tournament, a tournament of lies
Offer me solutions, offer me alternatives and I decline
It’s the end of the world as we know it (time I had some time alone)
REM.
Note: I wrote the first draft of this about two weeks ago. It looked bad then. Since? Holy cannoli.
Sigh. Not with a bang but a whimper. This is my whimper for the month. I had other ideas for the blog. There is an acupuncture post I thought about doing. Two on chiropractic, but I suppose the one on chiropractic and the Senate is a non-starter on basic principles. I will eventually get around to them but given the rapid planned disassembly of the government, the topics seemed so trivial. Don’t get me wrong. I enjoy writing on the usual SCAM topics. So eventually.
Sports metaphors are always popular, so here is mine. Right now, if the medically oriented federal organizations such as the NIH or CDC were an NBA team, they are filling their roster and coaching staff with, well, people like me. Short, weak, uncoordinated, slow and with only a trivial understanding of the details of the games. Put that team on the court and it will not go well. Although, such a team could perhaps beat the Wizards. But I do not think the current appointments are going to be able to handle a resurgence of long controlled and mostly forgotten infectious diseases. But not forgotten by me. It was my job for 40 years to think about infections, a mindset that made me popular at parties. “Hey, did you know you could get Listeria from eating that?” and “Oh, that could be a sign of syphilis.”
My wife likes to say the best way to predict the future is to understand the past. George Santayana had it wrong. People usually remember the past, incorrectly, preferring to ignore it or figure it doesn’t apply to them. So I thought it might be fun to try and guess what is going to happen in the next decade.

I saw a few of the vaccine-preventable diseases in my long and storied career. One case of tetanus in an elderly unvaccinated SE Asian immigrant. Ever had a muscle cramp? Hurt like hell, didn’t it? Now imagine every muscle cramping at once and not stopping. Awful.
I saw one case of paralytic polio 40 years ago, again an immigrant who never received the vaccine. Lots of chickenpox over the years. A couple fatal cases in pregnancy, an awful complication, and the occasional necrotizing fasciitis complicating chickenpox, again in the unvaccinated. One case of mumps in a middle-aged unvaccinated truck driver.
I never saw a case of whooping cough, diphtheria or measles, in part because I was an adult infectious disease doctor and all the children were cared for at the pediatric hospital, and in part due to the rarity of the diseases.
Couple cases of H. influenzae b meningitis in young adults. They died. Bad disease.
I saw lots of pneumococcal disease early on in my practice and all the odd manifestations of that organism: meningitis, heart valve infections and even a couple rare cases of hemolytic uremic syndrome and Hemophagocytic lymphohistiocytosis syndrome. They died as well. But thanks to childhood vaccination, adult pneumococcal disease, along with antibiotic resistance (temporarily), went away. The importance of immunizing the vector/source of infection,
Meningococcal disease also disappeared in the second half of my practice. There is a disease that can kill and kill fast from sepsis and meningitis. Fine at breakfast, dead by dinner. Glad it was mostly gone.
Awful diseases and rare complications are, if you are a clinician and temporarily turn off the empathetic/sympathetic parts of the brain, intellectually really cool. I have said that infectious disease is kind of like birding, only interesting in that you have a life list of all the odd infections you have seen. Unlike birders, I don’t want to complete the list. I don’t want to see a case of measles or whooping cough or smallpox. I am quite satisfied with the historical descriptions. Unfortunately, the best cases with the most interesting physiology and the deepest understanding of disease are the worst for the patients. You never want to be an interesting or great case for your doctor.
What to expect? Clinicians are going to have the opportunity to see a lot of interesting, great cases. And mores the pity.
Vaccine preventable diseases will return. Measles, pertussis aka whooping cough and chickenpox will lead the charge given how communicable they are. I always remembered my specialty was infectious diseases, with emphasis on infectious. The other vaccine preventable diseases, perhaps less so. But the number of infections will be small potatoes relative to the entire US population. Vast swathes of the country will still be immune and continue to get their vaccinations. The outbreaks will be confined to communities whose vaccination rates will run in the 80%. Like Texas. More cases in red counties if COVID is any example, although anti-vaccination knows no color. There will be dozens of children who will sicken, but, fortunately, rarely die. And it will be very expensive. In 2019, across the Columbia from Portland:
The overall societal cost of the 2019 Clark County measles outbreak was approximately $3.4 million ($47,479 per case or $814 per contact). The majority of the costs (≈$2.3 million) were incurred by the public health response to the outbreak, followed by productivity losses (≈$1.0 million), and direct medical costs (≈$76,000).
But I suppose they are getting what they voted for.
I expect there will be the reports from parents whose unvaccinated children died or had horrible complications imploring people to get vaccinated. That, like COVID testimonials, will do nothing.
So I would bet against huge outbreaks of childhood diseases that will sweep the US. There will likely always be enough immunity that those diseases will fester along, causing morbidity and mortality in a relatively small population.
Huge outbreaks infecting millions will require a new pathogen where there is no preexisting immunity in the population or that has the bad combination of being both virulent and infectious, Hmm. Like bird flu could become. Look how we did with COVID when we had the best and brightest at the CDC. Moving forward?
Yeah, there were issues with CDCs response to COVID. Armchair quarterbacking is easy. I was in charge of infection control for 6 hospitals for much of my career and knowing what to do with known diseases and a small outbreak was difficult. I cannot imagine trying to control a new/unknown infection for 350,000,000 plus people. It ain’t easy and the CDC has my sympathy.
But the best and the brightest are being replaced by oh man, I don’t even have the adjectives. Starting at center, Chandra Bahadur Dangi.
And when and if there is a new pandemic, if bird flu mutates or who knows what is lurking out there decides it’s dinner time and humans are now on the menu? Man, we are so toast.
And then there is AIDS. My career started with AIDS, remembering the association is not causation. I still remember my first patient, a twenty something male, dying of disseminated M. avium, wasting away with fevers and intractable diarrhea. We did not know the cause of his disease, which made care a little anxiety provoking. I remember he told me he could spit in my mouth and not give me AIDS. Besides ick, how did he know? At autopsy he was more M. avium, than human cells. It was an awful death, the first of many I saw in the following years. Everyone in medicine probably has the diseases they don’t want to die of. AIDS, ALS, and pancreatic cancer may be my top three.
AIDS was the death no one wants. Slow, debilitating and often painful. And they could the bullet coming, Not the quick demise of a cardiac arrest we all hope for. And I saw lots of AIDS deaths before the amazing results of HAART now called ART. Much better than the Fairly Active Anti-Retroviral Therapy that preceded it. Yes, I went there. You may be young once, but you can be immature all your life. Since around 2005 I had not had a single patient die of an AIDS-related infection. Amazing.
It was nice not to give people a fatal diagnosis. One of the least fun parts of the job is telling someone they have an illness that will likely kill them in the next year or so, there is nothing to be done about it, and you have seen the effects of the disease in many of your friends. The despair and anguish of patients and their loved ones are awful. And, in the US, mostly in the past.
In Africa? About 21 million people are alive because of AIDS medications, much of it supplied and managed by US dollars gleefully being cut off.
Twenty-one million people showing up in clinics being given a death sentence. 21 million people lying in bed, staring at the ceiling, with the anguish and despair of knowing they are going to die soon and unpleasantly. Mothers and fathers and brothers and sisters and children are going to lose their loved ones. Babies will be infected in the womb and die young.
The amount of totally preventable suffering and death may be staggering.
It’s going to take time and it probably (I hope) will not happen at quite the scale of 21 million. Stop HAART and it takes a month for the HIV to rebound, 6-ish years to progress (all the while the patient is now infectious so spread increases) and kill. So some time to mitigate. But the deaths and suffering could be catastrophically huge. This one hit me hard, a pit of the stomach feeling of despair. Americans? For good or bad—well, mostly bad—we are getting what the majority voted for. Millions of those outside the US whose lives depend on us? Not so much.
As I recently heard, the willingness to inflict suffering and death is a feature, not a bug. It is a shame humans have never developed a philosophy of love your neighbor, peace and love (besides Ringo), and help the helpless. It would be nice for such a thing to exist. I dream.
The good news in all this? The death and suffering in the next century from unopposed climate change will make even this look like a walk in the cemetery. At least I will be dead.
For Whom the Bell Tolls 2025 Edition
I am an island,
Entire of myself.
You are a piece of the continent,
A part of them.
A clod to be washed away by the sea, I couldn’t care less.
I will not vaccinate.
Or wear a mask outside of a manor of thine own
Or fret of thine friend’s HAART needs.
Each man’s death? Doesn’t bother me,
For I don’t care for mankind.
Therefore, send not to know
For whom the bell tolls,
No concern of mine.
John Donne
    • 

Anti-Vaccine Hotspots are Getting Hotter
More parents are seeking to avoid childhood vaccinations in states that allow nonmedical exemptions. These “hotspots” of decreasing vaccination rates, some of which include large urban cities, are likely locations for future outbreaks of preventable disease.
Clay Jones on June 15, 2018
Link


I recently cared for a child with a bloodstream infection caused by a nontypable Haemophilus influenza, one of the more common causes of childhood upper and lower respiratory tract infections such as sinusitis and pneumonia. It isn’t a common cause of disseminated infection, but it isn’t unheard of and it tends to have a good outcome. The child received appropriate medical care and left the hospital smiling in anticipation of seeing her friends at school the next day.
What made this case particularly interesting to me wasn’t what bacteria caused her illness but what bacteria didn’t. I couldn’t help but consider how the course of this child’s life would have almost certainly been changed for the worse, if she even survived, had she suffered from disease caused by a very closely related and much more dangerous bug: Haemophilus influenza type b, also known as Hib. Hib, an adversary of humanity that still strikes fear in the hearts of many a pediatric medical professional, is a bacterial pathogen that I have never seen and probably never will.
Since 1990, at least in the United States and most of the developed world, infants have received an extremely effective vaccine that protects them from Hib. As expected, the incidence of infection with this dreaded bacterium has plummeted dramatically. So very few children in regions where the vaccine is in widespread use will ever experience the meningitis, epiglottitis, or cellulitis that in the past killed thousands of children every year.
And now the bad news…
Unfortunately, a paper published in PLOS Medicine earlier this week detailed a worrisome trend in several states. More parents are seeking out nonmedical exemptions (NMEs) in several states despite all the efforts of the medical community and other proponents of vaccines, the overwhelming success of vaccines such as the one that has prevented immeasurable suffering from Hib infections over the years, and the increasing outbreaks of vaccine preventable infections across the country.
Currently 18 states allow so-called “philosophical-belief” exemptions from childhood vaccination, while all but three (CA, MS, WV) allow exemptions based on religion. According to data compiled since 2009, rates of these non-religious NMEs have increased in 12 of the 18 states. The states with these higher rates of NMEs are Arkansas, Arizona, Idaho, Maine, Minnesota, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Texas, and Utah.
Vaccine exemption “hotspots” are putting more kids at risk
Rates of vaccination against the most serious infections, such as measles and Hib, are still very high, although only 72% of toddlers had received all recommended vaccines in 2015. And there is growing concern that unprotected children are forming clusters is certain areas. The researchers looked at exemption rates in individual counties and located several “hotspots”, defined as having more than 400 kindergarten-aged children with NMEs, some of which were found in major cities with international airports such as Seattle, Phoenix, and Houston. So there are a lot of kids who are not going to benefit from herd immunity. This is scary stuff.
There were a few other interesting and concerning findings that shouldn’t really surprise anyone. In states with more NMEs, there was a corresponding decrease in rates of vaccination against measles, mumps, and rubella. You probably are familiar with measles and mumps, but rubella, which I haven’t covered in a prior post, is just as scary because it likes to cause severe disease in babies still in the womb. It has been eliminated from the Americas but, as you know, everything is only a quick flight away.
Curious which states have the highest MMR vaccination rates? It’s the three states that have banned all nonmedical exemptions of course. That’s Mississippi, California, and West Virginia if you are keeping score. The authors point out the increased vaccination rates in California after their 2016 legislation doing away with NMEs and call for other states to enact similar policies.
Conclusion: Some doom and gloom for your Friday
As we’ve pointed out countless times here on SBM, childhood vaccinations stand out as one of the most successful public health interventions of all time. They have saved millions of lives and prevented untold suffering. They are safe and they are effective.
Despite this, we are seeing a rise in parents seeking to exempt their children from the recommended vaccine schedule and this new paper further reveals that many of these children are clustered and perfectly positioned to serve as epidemiological kindling. The reasons that these parents seek exemptions are many, and have largely been covered in previous posts. My fear is that we are past the point of reversing this trend and that only a series of large and deadly outbreaks will get through. That may not even be enough for some.
Sorry for the pessimistic conclusion.

Vaccines in the News: The Good, the Bad, and the Imminent Loss of Our Measles Elimination Status
A quick recap of vaccine-related news from over the past several weeks.
Clay Jones on October 4, 2019
Link

Vaccines are always in the news it seems, but there was a bit of a spike in activity over the past several weeks. Unfortunately, not all of it is good news. In this brief post, I’ll run through a few of the more interesting updates.
Fewer rotavirus infections, less type 1 diabetes in kids
Back in February, I wrote a post about a study showing that the infant rotavirus vaccine might protect young children against more than just a bad case of diarrhea:
Late last month, a study out of Australia published in JAMA Pediatrics found a 14% reduction in the diagnosis of type 1 diabetes in rotavirus vaccinated children through age 4 years. They compared the rate of this diagnosis during the 8 years before and after introduction of the vaccine in May of 2007. Unfortunately, they did not see a decrease in older children.
I pointed out at the time that the data was preliminary but exciting. Well, I’ve got some good news. A cohort study published in June and involving nearly 1.5 million American infants has replicated these results. In fact, the new study found an even more impressive apparent reduction in the risk of type 1 diabetes, clocking in at more than 30%, when children are fully protected against rotavirus infection:
We found a significant reduction in the incidence of type 1 diabetes in children who received the entire rotavirus vaccination series compared to both a contemporary cohort and a historical cohort who were not vaccinated. There was no reduction in incidence in children who received only part of the recommended vaccination series. The pentavalent vaccine, in particular, was associated with lower risk. These results support the findings from Australia and the decrease in type 1 diabetes incidence in children <5 years observed in the SEARCH for diabetes in youth registry. The rotavirus vaccine appeared safe with fewer hospitalizations among those vaccinated.
Obviously we can’t say with certainty that there is a proven causal relationship between the vaccine a lower risk of diabetes. After all, it would be unethical at this point to do a prospective controlled study because of the proven benefit from reducing the incidence of rotavirus infection. But taking into account two large studies in two different countries, plus the established plausibility that rotavirus infection might result in an autoimmune process that leads to type 1 diabetes, I’m comfortable adding this to the list of vaccine benefits.
Childhood chickenpox vaccine reduces the risk of childhood shingles
Chickenpox and shingles are two conditions caused by the same pathogen: the varicella-zoster virus or VZV. After an initial infection with VZV in childhood, such as when I came down with those infamous itchy blisters back in the 2nd grade, the virus isn’t eradicated. We don’t have a full understanding of the pathophysiology, but after a case of chickenpox the virus appears to remain dormant in certain nerves near the brain and spinal cord only to reappear as painful shingles lesions. This most commonly occurs after age 50 but can happen at any point.
A vaccine against VZV rolled out in 1996, and subsequently the incidence of chickenpox has plummeted. I haven’t personally seen a case in years. And when they do occur in a vaccinated child, they tend to be fairly mild with only a few lesions instead of potentially hundreds.
Naturally one of the biggest questions regarding the vaccine, which is made using live but weakened virus, has been the potential effect on the incidence of shingles. Smaller studies have had somewhat murky results, but a study involving over 6 millions patients was published in July that helped clear things up. It showed that routine VZV immunization lowered the rate of shingles in children under 18 years from 170 to 38 per 100,000, with the exception that vaccinated children in the 2nd year of life were found to be at higher risk of developing shingles.
Because widespread availability of the vaccine was only a little over twenty years ago, we don’t know what will happen with the incidence of shingles in older adult populations. Most experts believe that it will decrease, likely dramatically. But long term studies need to be done to know for sure. In the meantime, there is an effective vaccine against shingles that is recommended for adults over the age of 60.
Influenza vaccine is still safe during pregnancy
A recent Canadian study of over 100,000 children adds to the data showing that it is safe for pregnant women to receive the flu shot. The study looked at rates of “immune related (infectious diseases, asthma), non-immune related (neoplasms, sensory disorders), and non-specific morbidity outcomes (urgent or inpatient health services use, pediatric complex chronic conditions)” from birth to 5 years of age:
Overall, our findings indicate that 2009 pH1N1 influenza vaccination in pregnancy was not associated with negative five year health outcomes in children, which is reassuring and consistent with a similar recent study from Denmark.
Speaking of the flu shot. It’s time for you to get yours. Now.
Many adults aren’t aware of the HPV vaccine
This July survey was small, with only about 1,500 respondents aged 18 to 59 years, but still frustrating. Only 290 of the 1,500 adults were familiar with HPV vaccine. But it gets worse. Of the 290 people who were at least aware that the HPV vaccine is a thing, only about 60% supported a policy to require pediatricians to offer it. And only 40% supported making the vaccine a requirement for attending public schools. Adding insult to injury, only 44% and 15% of the female and male respondents respectively were immunized against this cancer causing virus.
Measles elimination status at risk
In 2000, the United States was declared free of endemic measles infections. Things have changed as of late. When I wrote about the 2019 measles outbreaks in May, we had already broken a record more than 2 decades old. We topped 1,000 cases within a couple weeks of that post and are currently at 1,243 with 12 new cases last week. It does appear to be slowing down at least.
According to an August announcement by the WHO, four countries have lost their measles elimination status because of recent outbreaks. These include Albania, the Czech Republic, Greece, and most recently the United Kingdom. Up next appears to be the United States. In order to achieve this dubious distinction, there only needs to be one additional case in October that is linked to the ongoing outbreaks in New York City and Rockland County. Just one case.
Now back to the unraveling of the American government.

Childhood Vaccination Rates Move (Slowly) in the Right Direction
Childhood vaccination rates worldwide tanked during the first two years of the pandemic. A recently released report from the UN revealed that 2022 was better, but the improvements weren’t seen everywhere. And we still have a long way to go.
Clay Jones on July 21, 2023
Link

Back in December of last year, I mentioned in a post that one of the complications of the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic was a decline in childhood vaccine rates:
During the peak of the pandemic, when people were trying to stay home and avoid COVID-19, millions of children got behind on their routine immunizations. This was, and is, a worldwide phenomenon. The WHO recently estimated that 40 million children missed a dose of the measles vaccine in 2021 alone, putting them and potentially millions more around them at risk of developing this potentially deadly disease.
At the time, an outbreak of measles was occurring in Central Ohio that ultimately ended in February after 85 children were diagnosed. 36 of these children required hospitalization and all cases occurred in kids who were not fully vaccinated, either because they were too young or because of their parent’s decision to refuse the lifesaving intervention. Thankfully nobody died, although measles carries with it an unfortunate possibility of death even years after the initial infection has resolved.
Measles infection is associated with suppression of the immune system that can last for years, which increases the risk of subsequent infection with other potentially deadly pathogens. This is an excellent example of a vaccine having benefits far beyond simply preventing acute complications of infection by the targeted virus or bacteria, others being the reduction in cases of diabetes linked to the rotavirus vaccine and the prevention of cancer by the HPV and Hepatitis B vaccines.
Measles infection, particularly during infancy, is also a cause of subacute sclerosing panencephalitis, a thankfully uncommon disease that is as nasty as it sounds:
Acute encephalitis occurs when the immune system reacts to measles virus that has found its way into the central nervous system. But the immune system doesn’t always respond aggressively. In some cases, a mutation occurs in the virus which renders it unable to produce certain proteins that would have served as a signal flare. In addition, particularly in children less than 2 years of age, an immature immune system simply fails to respond.
Regardless of the specific reason, measles virus is allowed to remain in neural tissue relatively unchecked and it slowly proliferates under the radar as the years go by. Eventually, usually in the ballpark of 6 to 8 years later, the progressive inflammatory process becomes clinically apparent. Death is almost certain and occurs within 1 to 3 years of diagnosis in most cases, although there are case reports of more rapid progression as well as the occasional patient who survives.
In January, I followed up with a bit more discussion of the unfortunate decline in vaccination rates among kindergarten children in the United States. Data from 2021-2022 revealed a further decline from the previous year, which was already moving in the wrong direction:
The specific vaccines included in the CDC data were the MMR vaccine (93.5%), DTaP (diptheria, tetanus, pertussis, 93.1%), polio vaccine (93.5%), and varicella (chickenpox) vaccine (92.8%). I imagine for many folks 93% seems like a pretty good number, and it would be for Mrs. Peebles’ Biology II class. Unfortunately, for highly infectious diseases like measles we really need to be a bit closer to 100% in order to maintain herd immunity and protect vulnerable people, particularly those who are at high risk of severe disease.
When it comes to vaccine rates, there is significant variation between and within states, largely because of because of the three Ps of healthcare disparity: politics, poverty, and prejudice. Sticking with measles, for example, New York was a clear winner with an MMR vaccination rate of 98%. Great job, you coastal liberal elites. Rhode Island came in second with just over 97%. Let’s all raise a coffee milk toast to all those anti-virus Ocean Staters.
On the other end of the data are states like Alaska (78%), Wisconsin (82.6%), and Georgia (83%). Overall, only 13 of the 49 (what’s your deal, Montana?) states included in the data met the CDC goal of 95% of eligible kindergartners having received both doses of the MMR vaccine. So is most states, and almost certainly even in parts of the others, there are communities that are fully primed for a major outbreak of this horrible disease.
Now a bit of good news (but don’t get too excited)
There appears to have been a bit of a post-pandemic rebound in worldwide childhood vaccinations in 2022, though not in every country and we still have a ways to go overall. Historically the UN has focused on diphtheria, tetanus, and pertussis (DTP) vaccines as a marker of general uptake in communities. With this in mind, the UN recently announced that 20.5 million children missed at least one dose in 2022, which is an improvement of 4 million children compared to the year before. In 2019, roughly 18 million children missed a DTP dose, making it clear that the pandemic only exacerbated an already worrisome reality.
I picked out a few interesting numbers reported by the UN this month to share, but there is a lot more. Please check out this detailed discussion of the report.
     1.  The number of children who received zero vaccine doses in 2022 improved from 18.1 million to 14.3 million. It was 12.9 million in 2019.
     2.  Children getting their first dose of measles vaccine increased from 81% to 83% in 2022, but even the pre-pandemic level of 86% is terrible and we need to do better.
     3.  21% of eligible girls got their first HPV vaccine in 2022, up from 16%. Also terrible.
     4.  Less than half (48%) of eligible at risk children got a yellow fever vaccine. We are shooting for 80%, so not great.
     5.  Global coverage with 3 Hib vaccine doses was 76%, with significant variation between regions. 93% of kids in the WHO European Region were fully vaccinated compared to 32% in the Western Pacific Region. Hib meningitis is a nightmare (1 in 20 die, 1 in 5 suffer permanent brain damage/deafness despite proper treatment) and, again, we need to do much better.
If you are concerned that this improvement in vaccine rates was mostly only seen in certain countries, perhaps those with more available resources, you are intelligent, compassionate, and probably pretty good-looking to boot. The above linked article from UN News points out how numbers in aggregate can be misleading:
The early stages of recovery in immunisation rates have not occurred equally. Progress in well-resourced countries with large infant populations such as India and Indonesia, masks slower recovery rates, or even continued declines, in middle and low-income countries.
The UN adds that 34 of the 73 countries that had significant decreases in childhood immunization numbers during the first two years of the pandemic were worse off or saw no improvement in 2022. Of the countries that did improve, only 15 got back to pre-pandemic rates. And truly unfortunately, because it is such an infectious and dangerous disease, measles vaccination continues to lag behind even in some countries that are otherwise doing better overall. More than 33 million children missed a measles dose last year, leaving many communities at risk of outbreaks.
An international effort is currently underway to remedy these gaps in vaccine coverage. Calling this push “The Big Catch-Up“, the WHO, UNICEF, Gavi, The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, and others are working with governments to get missed doses to kids all over the world. It’s going to take a lot of money, of course, to make this happen, as well as widespread policy changes that improve access in low resource regions. Just as important is the need to combat anti-vaccine propaganda and reduce vaccine-hesitancy.

   Why Universal Hepatitis B Vaccination Isn’t Quite Universal
Joseph Albietz
Link
I am just a parent with some questions about vaccine safety and was happy to find your website. I have noticed that the Scandinavian countries do not routinely recommend HepB vaccination unless the mother is a known carrier. I did not see this addressed anywhere on your website and I hope you or one of your colleagues might consider discussing the reasons that some advanced countries are not routinely giving this particular vaccine. Thank you.”
Vaccination is a complicated and at times confusing topic that generates a large number of quite reasonable questions by parents like the one above. At the same time, the ever-wandering aim of the anti-vaccinationist movement appears once again to be falling on the vaccine against Hepatitis B, and I’ve heard them pose this very question with the intent of sowing doubt in the current vaccination schedule. Regardless of the source, this question is clearly on the mind of some parents, and I am happy to answer it.
As usual, this question has quite a bit to parse out. I think it may be most helpful to examine why we vaccinate against Hepatitis B the way we do in the US, how most countries in the world approach the problem, and finally examine the reason why eight European countries do not universally vaccinate against HBV. First things first though: what is Hepatitis B?
HEPATITIS B
Hepatitis B (HBV) is a double stranded DNA virus found in the bodily fluids of infected people including their blood, semen, and saliva, and can be transmitted through sexual contact, exposure of infected fluid to mucous membranes, or through injection.
As the name suggests, infection causes damage primarily to the liver, though the spectrum of disease experienced by any one person can be quite broad. In adults, 50-70% of infections are asymptomatic or mild enough to not come to medical attention. The remaining adults experience a range of hepatitis lasting weeks to months, with ~1% of these being a fulminant, life-threatening infection. Adults are relatively efficient in their ability to clear the virus after the initial infection, and only ~10% become chronicly infected carriers.
Children, on the other hand, present a very different pattern of disease. Though ~90% of infected children are initially asymptomatic, they are rarely able to clear the virus. 90% of infants and 25-50% of those 1-5 years old will become lifelong carriers.
Chronic Hepatitis B infection is a serious problem. Beyond the ability of most chronic carriers to spread the virus throughout their lives, ~ 20% of people with chronic Hepatitis B develop cirrhosis, a condition where the liver cells are lost and the liver becomes progressively more fibrotic and dysfunctional.
Cirrhosis isn’t the only life-limiting problem to result directly from chronic Hepatitis B infection. Hepatocellular carcinoma, a primary cancer of the liver, is in the top 10 cancers in both sexes in the US, and 60-80% of all cases are cause by Hepatitis B. All told, around 25 % of people who become chronically infected with Hepatitis B will die from its complications.
Hepatitis B is a major cause of worldwide morbidity and mortality. More than 1/3 of the world’s population has been infected with Hepatitis B and 5% are chronic carriers. That totals up to around 350,000,000 people chronically infected, and around 620,000 deaths from HBV yearly.
As in many health care related issues, the worldwide epidemiology of HBV infection does not necessarily reflect that of the United States. Even so, the picture isn’t particularly pretty. Around 5% of the US population has been infected with Hepatitis B, and 0.3 are chronic carriers. Most HBV infections occur in those aged 25-44 (4/100,000), with the lowest rates of infection in those under 15 (0.1/100,000). In 2007 4,519 new cases in the US were reported to the CDC, though this represents a fraction of the total number of infections.
These numbers are significant. To put this in perspective, the mortality from HBV in the US was 5 times higher than Haemophilus influenza type B and 10 times greater than measles before vaccination was introduced.
The Hepatitis B Vaccine
HBV is a relatively stable virus posing a serious public health threat with humans as the only known reservoir, and as such is a prime target for prevention, and theoretically eradication, through vaccination. The first vaccine against HBV became available in 1981, and the current recombinant vaccine has been in use since 1986. As a recombinant vaccine it contains proteins normally made by HBV, but does not have the virus itself, and therefore carries no risk of HBV infection.
As far as efficacy is concerned, the HBV vaccine has a very high response rate, inducing an appropriate antibody response in more than 95% of people from birth to 30 years of age, and decreasing but still significant response rates in older age groups. Immunity from the vaccine lasts at least 20 years in healthy individuals.
The HBV vaccine has an excellent safety record. The most common side effects are pain and swelling at the injection site in ~3% of people, and fever in ~1%. The only serious confirmed reaction is anaphylaxis that occurs in 1/600,000 injections with no deaths reported in over 20 years of use. Concerns regarding the HBV vaccine’s association with demyelinating diseases, the use of thimerosal in its formulation in the past or aluminum at the present have all been investigated and found to be without support; I will give such allegations no further time in this post.
Strategies of Hepatitis B Vaccine Use
There are a number of viable strategies available to countries seeking to address the spread of HBV in their populations, and variants on each. When deciding which strategy is best for any given country, there are multiple factors to consider, including disease severity, the availability and efficacy of treatments, the risk and cost of infection, the risk, efficacy and cost of vaccination, etc.
The first option is to vaccinate people at high risk of infection. In situations where the risk of infection is very low this makes good sense. For instance, in the US the risk of contracting Yellow Fever is essentially zero at baseline without vaccination. No risk or cost of vaccination, no matter how small, is small enough to offset zero risk of disease, therefore we do not routinely vaccinate against it. However, if you were to travel to an area where Yellow Fever is endemic, your personal risk can suddenly become significant, and easily justify the minimal cost and risk of vaccinating you as a person at high risk.
Since the majority of people infected with HBV have identifiable risk factors, this approach makes some sense. However, it has several major drawbacks. It requires all individuals in a high-risk group to have health care, be identified, and to acquire the vaccine before they are infected. This is labor and cost intensive, and extremely unlikely to capture the entire target population. Well executed, this approach can protect a majority of people at high risk, but in the case of HBV it will not immunize a large enough population to generate a herd immunity effect. The greatest flaw of this approach lies in the 1/3 of HBV infections that occur in people with zero known risk factors who, by definition, are unable to further reduce their risk, and are left unprotected by a vaccine. These shortcomings guarantee this strategy will fail to fully control the spread of HBV in the community.
The second approach is to vaccinate the entire population as they enter into the age of greatest incidence of infection, adolescence and early adulthood. This addresses one of the shortcomings of the first strategy, namely the need to identify people at high risk. It also takes advantage of the fact that children more reliably have health-maintenance office visits than do adults, and are more likely to be given vaccinations as part of a universal schedule.
Though this captures a large majority of the total number of infections, it too has a flaw; it fails to address the people infected in early childhood. Though this is a relatively small number of people (4% of HBV infections), remember that children are far more likely to become lifelong carriers, and thus make up a disproportionate number of the infected at any one point in time (24% of chronic carriers). While more effective at reducing the prevalence of HBV in the population than only vaccinating high-risk groups, this strategy too has little hope of eliminating HBV.
The third possible strategy is to vaccinate people at the time of birth. This strategy addresses the problem of perinatal infection, prevents the acquisition of HBV by people during early childhood when the risk of chronic infection is highest, and since the immunity it induces lasts for decades it covers the entire population during the highest risk times of their lives. Universal vaccination with HepB vaccine at birth, even in regions with a low prevalence of chronic carriers like the US, could reduce mortality by an additional 10-20% compared to early childhood vaccination.
Even this strategy has a drawback, however, and that is time. Beginning an immunization program with only infants would take a few decades to generate a maximum reduction in HBV in the population.
The US Vaccination Strategy
Though the burden of disease from HBV in the US is relatively low compared to say, heart disease, it remains a significant public health threat only partially addressed through screening, education, and preventative measures, and with limited treatment options. This makes it an ideal target for vaccination.
From 1981 through 1991 the US vaccinated only people with identified risk factors. Predictably, this campaign had an underwhelming effect on HBV infections seen during this time period.
In 1991, the strategy was reworked to better address the various methods of HBV transmission in an attempt to eliminate HBV spread in the US. The new strategy is an amalgam of all three strategies described earlier. In addition to vaccination of high risk groups, we began universal vaccination of all infants at birth, vaccination of adolescents, and prenatal screening of pregnant women to identify children who would require not only vaccination at birth but also Hep B immunoglobulin (HBIG).
Since its launch in 1991, we have seen a steady decrease in Hepatitis B infections. Hep B incidence in the US fell from 10.7/100,000 in 1983 to 2.1 per 100,000 in 2004. (25,916 total cases down to 6212 cases). Though it’s true other factors have been contributing to HBV’s decline, most notably the public education campaign aimed at curbing the spread of HIV, this doesn’t account for the pattern of HBV decline across age groups. There has been a 95% drop in HBV in people under 15 years of age, 87% in ages 15-24, 71% from 25-44, and 51% decrease in people over 45 years old. This is precisely what you would expect from a pediatric vaccination campaign.
Using a cost effective and exceptionally low-risk intervention of universal Hep B vaccination the US is well on its way to control, if not elimination, of HBV.
The Northern European Vaccination Strategy
The strategy taken by the US is typical of most developed nations, even those with a relatively low incidence of HBV. In 1992 the WHO recommended the inclusion of HBV vaccination in nearly all national vaccination programs. Since that time, the vast majority of countries (177/193 countries) have adopted infant HBV vaccination into their childhood schedules as can be seen here. This graphic also illustrates the few countries that have instead opted to vaccinate only high-risk individuals, primarily those in Northern Europe, including Scandinavia.
The reason these countries have not adopted universal vaccination against HBV is the exceptionally low level of HBV in their population and the associated costs of prevention. Sweden, for instance, has one of the lowest prevalences of HBV in the world at 0.05%. This is 6 times lower than what we have in the US, with the majority of cases occurring in those engaged in high-risk activities or in immigrant populations that tend to have minimal contact with the indigenous population. The public health organizations of these Northern European countries consider HBV to be a minor public health problem best addressed by targeted vaccination. The cost of instituting universal vaccination would not offset the benefit of further reduction in HBV prevalence in their countries.
It is interesting to note that though these countries have low baseline rates of HBV infection, they have not generated the same relative decrease in rates that countries, like the US, have been able to produce with universal HBV vaccination. This fact, in combination with high immigration rates to these countries from areas of heavy HBV, makes it likely that the cost/benefit ratios of the Northern European countries will sway even more strongly in favor of universal HBV vaccination over the next several years.
It is also worth noting that of the many factors being weighed by the medical community and public health officials of these Northern European nations, serious concerns of the Hepatitis B vaccine’s efficacy or safety are not among them.
Conclusion
We will continue to make progress in medicine by never being satisfied the care we provide is good enough; the ongoing debate about how best to apply the Hepatitis B vaccine is an excellent example of this concept. The inconsistency between these nations’ vaccination policies is little more than physicians and health care officials seeking the most efficient and effective use of the vaccine within the unique conditions inside their borders.

I Used to Wonder How the Tuskegee Experiment Could Have Happened. No More.
The cowards and sycophants who enabled, promoted, and normalized MAHA in any way are collectively to blame for its attempt to do Tuskegee 2.0.
Jonathan Howard on October 15, 2026
Link

“The men were not informed of the nature of the study, proper treatment was withheld, and more than 100 died as a result.”
According to Wikipedia:
The Tuskegee Study of Untreated Syphilis in the Negro Male (informally referred to as the Tuskegee Experiment or Tuskegee Syphilis Study) was a study conducted between 1932 and 1972 by the United States Public Health Service (PHS) and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) on a group of nearly 400 African American men with syphilis as well as a control group without. The purpose of the study was to observe the effects of the disease when untreated, to the point of death and autopsy. Although there had been effective treatments to reduce the severity of the disease since the 1920s, the use of penicillin for the treatment of syphilis was widespread as of 1945. The men were not informed of the nature of the study, proper treatment was withheld, and more than 100 died as a result…
None of the infected men were treated with penicillin despite the fact that, by 1947, the antibiotic was widely available and had become the standard treatment for syphilis. The study continued, under numerous Public Health Service supervisors, until 1972, when a leak to the press resulted in its termination on November 16 of that year. By then, 28 patients had died directly from syphilis, 100 died from complications related to syphilis, 40 of the patients’ wives were infected with syphilis, and 19 children were born with congenital syphilis.
“Since the introduction of universal newborn hepatitis B vaccine in the United States, vertical transmission rates have declined by 94%-98%.”
The core sin of the Tuskegee Experiment was withholding a proven treatment for a devastating infection for “research” purposes and, like penicillin, the hepatitis B vaccine is tried, true, and tested. According to the article The History of Hepatitis B Vaccines and the Importance of Universal Vaccination in Infancy:
The first hepatitis B vaccine, Heptavax, was plasma-derived and was approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in 1981. It was used in targeted populations of high-risk individuals, including infants born to infected mothers. In 1986, the FDA approved the first recombinant vaccine, Recombivax HB. This vaccine was derived from yeast and was used for the same high-risk populations.
In 1989, a second recombinant vaccine was approved, Engerix-B. Unfortunately, the targeted vaccination strategy did not have an impact on reducing the overall incidence of the disease. Efforts to identify high-risk individuals were further complicated by data that showed 35%-65% of hepatitis B surface antigen (HBsAg) positive mothers had no identifiable high-risk factors. Vertical (mother-to-child) transmission was the most common route of infection. Approximately 90% of babies born to mothers with hepatitis B become infected, and an estimated 25%-40% die prematurely in adulthood due to complications such as cirrhosis or hepatocellular carcinoma. This led the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) to recommend the vaccine for all newborns, starting in 1991.
Since the introduction of universal newborn hepatitis B vaccine in the United States, vertical transmission rates have declined by 94%-98%.
Not bad.
The article further explained the rationale for giving the dose at birth:
While hepatitis B screening is recommended for all pregnant individuals by the CDC and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), only 82%-86% have the screening performed, and just 35% of those who test positive receive all recommended follow-up care. This leaves a gap for 2.9-3.1 million infants per year who are born to mothers not screened for hepatitis B. The universal hepatitis B vaccine dose serves as a critical safety net, providing protection to infants born to hepatitis B infected mothers who were not identified at the time of delivery.
In addition to being effective, the vaccine is safe. A recent review titled Hepatitis B Vaccination at Birth: Safety, Effectiveness, and Public Health Benefit found:
A comprehensive review of safety data from randomized and nonrandomized clinical trials, cohort studies, national vaccine safety monitoring programs, and systematic GRADE analyses demonstrated that the hepatitis B vaccine is safe and well-tolerated in all age groups.
“You are now enrolling newborns in a lottery to test a hypothesis.”
Despite this decades-long track record of proven success, MAHA/MAGA disinformation agents want us to pretend none of that evidence exists. They claim we need to start over with a new randomized-controlled trial (RCT) of the vaccine using children in Guinea-Bissau, a country with an extremely high prevalence of hepatitis B. They argue that “many physicians don’t understand clinical trial ethics” and this new trial is “ethical, feasible, practical and would be quite useful“.
Jonathan Jarry called this deliberate ignorance the square one fallacy, and Dr. David Gorski discussed this proposed trial last year in his article MAHA’s New Tuskegee Experiment. Its fate has gone back and forth, even this week alone, and the latest update is that health authorities in Guinea-Bissau are refusing to let their children be used for unnecessary research. Let’s hope that’s the end of it.
However, even if this trial never gets off the ground, it is worth discussing how it was even considered in the first place and to recognize that once again, White scientists are seeking to exploit Black bodies for unethical medical experiments.
According to a recent article by Melody Schreiber titled Controversial Vaccine Trial Touted by RFK Jr Gets Go-Ahead in Guinea-Bissau:
A controversial research trial that will withhold hepatitis B vaccines from some African newborns was given approval to move forward this week… It is a central part of the vaccine vision for Robert F Kennedy Jr, the secretary of the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) and a longtime vaccine opponent.
At an anti-vaccine conference last month, Kennedy praised the Danish researchers behind the trial and touted US-supported research on hepatitis B in newborns as exemplifying the Trump administration’s agenda for vaccines, which has included slashing vaccine recommendations and casting doubt on the safety and effectiveness of shots.
She further described the proposed experiment.
Danish researchers plan to enroll 14,000 infants in Guinea-Bissau in the trial, giving the hepatitis B vaccine to half of the babies at birth and withholding it from the others for the first six weeks of life…

The researchers will now test mothers for hepatitis B before they give birth. The babies of mothers who test positive will be given the vaccine and will not be included in the trial. But the babies of mothers whose tests are negative may be enrolled. The new protocol has not been shared publicly.
In previous research, half of children who contracted hepatitis B did so after birth, through community exposures. “This virus can be transmitted casually,” Offit said. It can live on surfaces for up to seven days, and it can be acquired by sharing washcloths, toothbrushes and fingernail clippers. In addition, the hepatitis B test has a 5% false negative rate, which could provide false assurance that a birthing parent does not have the virus.
She quoted vaccine experts who were rightly appalled by this trial:
Kennedy “wants to make it so we don’t use a birth dose here in this country,” said Paul Offit, an infectious disease physician at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia. “That’s the goal.”
Kennedy would never be able to do the trial in the US because of its significant ethical concerns, Offit added. “He’s taking advantage of a developing country … Is it because children in Africa are more expendable than children here?”
“Experts have decried the African experiment as ‘horribly unethical and cruel‘, ‘neo-colonialist‘ and ‘damaging‘,” she reported.
She further revealed:
An ethics committee at the researchers’ home institution of the University of Southern Denmark voted this week to proceed with the trial, and officials in Guinea-Bissau have also greenlit the project, which the health minister, Quinhin Nantote, initially said was suspended after international uproar earlier this year.
Stig Børsen Hansen, a founding member who was one of two reviewers who presented the study to the Danish committee, resigned from the group in protest on Friday, citing major ethical issues with the study.
“You are now enrolling newborns in a lottery to test a hypothesis,” Hansen said. The children who are randomly selected not to receive the birth dose of the vaccine, those who “lost the lottery”, face in their earliest days the risk of contracting hepatitis B, which can cause irreversible lifelong damage. “They contract hepatitis B in the context of being part of a research project,” Hansen said, which made their infection happen, in effect, “by design”.
Three other members of the committee have also resigned in protest.
Ms. Schreiber also reported that while the CDC planned to spend $1.6 million on this study:
It would cost approximately $13,200 to buy enough vaccines through Unicef and Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance, to immunize all newborns in Guinea-Bissau each year, Delawalla (a researcher and founder and CEO of the non-profit Stand Up for Science) pointed out.
Everyone involved should work together to ensure that every baby in Guinea-Bissau receives the birth dose of the hepatitis B vaccination, she added. “This is not muddy water: we can use Black babies to further pseudoscience or we can save children’s lives with a 20-cent shot.”
“It is a red flag when people don’t report the primary result of a randomized trial.”
While this study would be abhorrent even if it were carried out by credible researchers, that is not the case here. According to one article on the lead researchers, Christine Stabell Benn and Peter Aaby:
Stabell Benn and Aaby are currently under investigation by Danish authorities over allegations of “falsification” and “scientific misconduct” related to previous vaccine research.
According to an article titled Controversial Danish Vaccine Research Group Faces New Allegations:
A new paper levels fresh allegations of questionable scientific practices by the Bandim Health Project (BHP), an embattled group led by researchers in Denmark that has long studied vaccines in West Africa and has recently become influential in U.S. health policy…
Benn’s group has been criticized in the past for what other researchers say are poor reporting practices—accusations her team denies. In a paper published today in Vaccine, researchers allege problems at BHP go deeper. The authors say they were unable to find comprehensive data on primary outcomes—the effects a trial was designed to investigate—for 10 of the group’s studies carried out over 2 decades. Together, the studies included tens of thousands of Bissau-Guinean children.
The article continued:
“It is a red flag when people don’t report the primary result of a randomized trial,” says Evan Mayo-Wilson, an epidemiologist at the University of North Carolina’s Gillings School of Global Public Health who was not involved in the new study. “We have an ethical obligation to participants in randomized trials to report the results for the research questions that those trials were designed to answer.”
Benn, who is affiliated with the University of Southern Denmark, told Science the new paper is “substantially flawed in both content and interpretation,” but that she did not have time to respond in detail today.
Another article titled Randomized Trials Show no Evidence of Non-Specific Vaccine Effects said:
For more than three decades, researchers Christine Stabell Benn and Peter Aaby from the Bandim Health Project have conducted randomized trials involving thousands of children in Guinea-Bissau and Denmark to demonstrate so-called non-specific vaccine effects – that is, whether vaccines also protect against diseases other than the one they are designed to prevent.
A new comprehensive Danish review now shows that the trials have been unable to demonstrate non-specific effects for the widely used vaccinations against measles, tuberculosis, diphtheria, tetanus, and whooping cough.
“It is concerning that such a prominent research group has conducted so many randomized trials over such a long period without finding real results. Randomized trials are normally considered the gold standard in medical research, so if they do not show anything, one should be very cautious about presenting it as convincing evidence,” says Henrik Støvring from Steno Diabetes Center Aarhus and Aarhus University, who led the new review.
Given this inglorious track record, it’s no surprise that:
Kennedy has repeatedly praised their work, which he says shows that after vaccination, “you can have mass injuries, and catastrophic injuries, and they’re hiding in plain sight.”
“I didn’t want to believe it.”
The Tuskegee Experiment ended only after it was exposed by a 28-year-old whistleblower, Peter Buxton, who said:
I didn’t want to believe it. This was the Public Health Service. We didn’t do things like that.
I had a similar reaction when I learned about the Tuskegee Experiment as a naïve youth, and Buxton’s bravery only raises the question of why no one spoke up sooner. How could such an atrocity be allowed to happen?
Today at least, I no longer have to wonder about such things. I just have to read the news and recognize that the cowards and sycophants who enabled, promoted, and normalized MAHA in any way are collectively to blame for its attempt to do Tuskegee 2.0.


   Quoth the anti-vaccine group SANE Vax: Beware HPV DNA in Gardasil!
David Gorski 
Link
Every so often, there’s a bit of misinformation that starts spreading around the Internet that shows up in enough places that our readers take notice and e-mail us about it. What happens is that these in essence become “requests.” We at SBM are, of course, happy to consider all requests and sometimes will actually take them on, particularly when doing so will be educational about the mission of this blog, namely discussing science-based medicine and providing much needed critical analysis to the pseudoscience that is, alas, becoming more and more common in medicine. A frequent topic of this blog is, not surprisingly, the anti-vaccine movement, which is arguably the most dangerous (to public health, at least) pseudoscience movement currently in existence. The misinformation about vaccines that anti-vaccine activists spread through websites, podcasts, radio, TV, and other media is protean, and it’s difficult to keep up with it all.
Which is probably why I hadn’t heard this bit of misinformation about the HPV vaccine from an anti-vaccine group I hadn’t heard of before (or at least didn’t remember) called SANE Vax. (I include the “Inc.” because SAFE Vax, Inc. itself insists on using it frequently in all its press releases.) If you’ve been in the biz a while, as I have, you can tell right away from the very name of this website exactly where its creators are coming from. Here’s a hint. It’s not the mission that the website claims that it is, which is stated thusly:
The Sane Vax Mission is to promote Safe, Affordable, Necessary & Effective vaccines and vaccination practices through education and information. We believe in science-based medicine. Our primary goal is to provide the information necessary for you to make informed decisions regarding your health and well-being. We also provide referrals to helpful resources for those unfortunate enough to have experienced vaccine-related injuries.
Oh, no. SANE Vax didn’t go and claim that its members believe in science-based medicine, did it? Science-based medicine. You keep using that term. I do not think it means what you think it means. (I know, I know, I use that quip far too often, but I like it.) In any case, SANE Vax appears to be anti-vaccine to the core, which should be obvious from its name. Clearly, if its creators think they’re promoting “sane vaccination,” by implication they very likely think that by comparison the current vaccination schedule is not sane. Further supporting the rather mind-numbingly obvious conclusion that SANE Vax is indeed anti-vaccine are videos featuring Andrew Wakefield, Barbara Loe Fisher, and other luminaries of the anti-vaccine movement, as well as a Vaccine Victims Memorial, the latter of which is a page taken right out of the playbook of the National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC), one of the oldest anti-vaccine groups still in existence. Meanwhile, it’s list of “vaccine groups” contains all the usual anti-vaccine suspects, like the Australian Vaccination Network, Age of Autism, ThinkTwice, Generation Rescue, and Impfschaden.
I also don’t believe for a minute that SANE Vax is, as it bills itself, a “vaccine safety” group. For one thing, in the comments of two of the SANE Vax posts I’m about to discuss, Australian skeptic Peter Bowditch shows up to ask, “Which vaccines are “necessary” and “effective” to match the ‘N’ and ‘E’ in SANE?” He has yet to receive an answer. This fulfills one of my key criteria of an anti-vaccine activist in that when, after hearing her piously pontificate that she is “not anti-vaccine,” you ask her which specific vaccines she supports and get either no answer or dancing around the question with no real answer.
So what’s got SANE Vax in an uproar? DNA. But not just any DNA. Recombinant DNA. But not just any recombinant DNA. HPV recombinant DNA. Take a look at some posts that appeared on the SANE Vax blog over the weekend and on Tuesday:
SANE Vax to FDA: Recombinant HPV DNA found in multiple samples of Gardasil
SANE Vax Inc. Discovers Potential Bio-hazard Contaminant in Merck’s Gardasil™ HPV 4 Vaccine (NOTE ADDED:
SANE Vax Inc. Announces the Discovery of Viral HPV DNA Contaminant in Gardasil.
SANE Vax, Inc. Reports Human Papillomavirus (HPV) DNA Contamination in Gardasil™ To FDA: Requests Public Safety Investigation.
Oh, no! DNA! The horror…the horror.
Does this sound familiar? It should. It’s almost exactly the same fear mongering nonsense that Helen Ratajczak used to try to claim that homologous recombination of fetal DNA in vaccines with the DNA in babies’ brains resulted in autoimmune inflammation that led to autism. In this case, the vaccine is the HPV vaccine, but the arguments are merely a variation on the same scientifically ignorant theme. Here’s what SANE Vax is :
SANE Vax Inc. contracted with an independent lab to test for contamination and found HPV recombinant DNA (rDNA) in 13 vaccine vials. The Gardasil vials with different lot numbers were from New Zealand, Australia, Spain, Poland, France and three states in the U.S. 100% of the samples tested positive for the presence of the genetically modified HPV DNA.
Dr. Sin Hang Lee, a pathologist at the Milford Hospital pathology laboratory well-known for using cutting-edge DNA sequencing for molecular diagnoses, was initially contracted to examine a single sample of Gardasil for possible contamination. This sample tested positive for recombinant HPV-11 and HPV-18 residues, both of which were firmly attached to the aluminum adjuvant.
Wow. Sounds pretty scary, doesn’t it? Actual HPV DNA! But not just any HPV DNA. Oh, no. We’re talking recombinant HPV-11 and HPV-18 residues, which–horror of horrors!–were attached to the dreaded aluminum adjuvant! Stop the factories! Stop injecting our little girls with that evil vaccine whose only purpose is to encourage them to go out and have unprotected sex, knowing that they won’t get HPV!
Now hold on just a minute. I got a little carried away.
Let’s take a look first. First of all, one notes that there is not a single scientific paper–or even scientific report–describing the methodology used and the specific tests used. True, in SaneVax’s letter to the FDA, Norma Erickson provides an actual picture of an actual graph from an actual DNA sequencing run in order to look all science-y, but then she also says:
The SANE Vax Inc. data, including the electropherograms of short target sequencing used to validate the HPV DNA detected in the thirteen (13) Gardasil samples, each with a different lot number, are available for your review, provided appropriate safeguards are in place to protect the proprietary processes and information utilized by our laboratory to test the samples.
Protect the “proprietary” processes used to test the samples? Why on earth does the Milford Hospital Pathology Laboratory need to use “proprietary” processes to test for recombinant DNA in the vaccine? Whenever I see a result like this attributed to proprietary, non-transparent methodology, it sends up huge red flags, particularly when it comes to doing something like detecting DNA contamination. I could do it in my own laboratory using simple polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and then sequencing the DNA sequences (if any) that I managed to amplify up! There’s no need for anything proprietary, other than choosing the PCR primers properly! I could use PCR kits right off the shelf and any of a number of PCR machines, either the old warhorse in my lab or the spiffier, newer machines that some other investigators in nearby labs have. Again, the key is choosing the right primers and working out the right conditions, but none of that is anything particularly difficult, although testing different conditions can be time consuming and require a fair amount of trial-and-error drudgery.
Before I get to the significance (or, far more likely, lack of significance) of this finding. Let’s take a look at the methodology. As is my wont when I see someone making a claim I haven’t seen before, I did a bit of Googling for Dr. Sin Hang Lee, and it turns out that he is rather well known in the Lyme disease community for having apparently invented a new test for Lyme disease. That may or may not be dubious. What is definitely dubious is that he’s also teamed up with SANE Vax—excuse me, SANE Vax, Inc.—to offer an HPV genotyping test announced on the quackery-promoting NaturalNews.com. This latter link actually suggested to me what Dr. Lee’s “proprietary” methodology might be, as it’s described as “nested PCR with short target DNA sequencing for HPV genotyping.” Going back to look at his Lyme disease DNA test, I find this paper, which also used nested PCR to detect sequences from the Lyme disease spirochete Borrelia burgdorferi.
So what is nested PCR? As readers might recall, PCR is a method to amplify nucleic acid sequences, like those of DNA or RNA. Believe it or not, the Wikipedia entry for PCR contains a pretty good description. Having a great deal of experience with PCR, I know, as does anyone who works with PCR, that the greatest power of PCR also leads to its greatest difficulties in its usage, namely its extreme sensitivity. PCR is so sensitive that it’s very, very easy to amplify a contaminant or for the primers to bind to (and thereby amplify) DNA sequences other than the one of interest. This problem goes double (or even quadruple) for nested PCR. The reason is that nested PCR involves using one set of primers to amplify a DNA sequence, and then taking some of the resultant reaction mixture and using a second set of primers that amplifies a smaller sequence within the sequence amplified in the first PCR run. The process is illustrated below. First, here’s routine PCR: see website
And here’s nested PCR: see website
The usefulness of nested PCR is two-fold: First, because two different sets of primers are used, specificity is increased and the amplification of contaminants decreased because, although there might be contaminants amplified in the first PCR run, it’s very unlikely that any of the unwanted PCR products so amplified contain binding sites for both of the new primers used in the second PCR run. Second, nested PCR can be very, very sensitive, even more sensitive than “simple” PCR, depending upon the number of amplification cycles used in each PCR step. It’s that sensitivity that allows nested PCR to amplify very tiny amounts of target sequence.
Which brings me to the lack of any detail in this report.
Let’s say, for the moment, that Dr. Lee did everything right and actually did detect a bit of recombinant DNA from the HPV DNA used to make the vaccine still remaining in the 13 vials of vaccine he tested. It’s possible. He’s apparently made a name for himself in developing PCR-based diagnostic tests and has published in the peer-reviewed literature. Would it matter? One factor to consider is how much DNA was present, which was almost certainly very, very tiny, given that it took nested PCR to detect it. However, we don’t know how much was detected, because nothing on the SANE Vax posts tells us enough to let us know approximately how much was detected. Did Dr. Lee amplify his template with 40 cycles, followed by another 40 cycles? That would imply an incredibly tiny amount of DNA, indeed, and would actually be very difficult to do without a lost of false positives. Given that, and given the probably minuscule amount of DNA detected, even assuming these aren’t false positives, there is no justification for statements like this:
In an effort to help her now very sick daughter the mother went to an MD practicing naturopath who conducted a toxicity test that eventually found HPV DNA in the girl’s blood. The significance of this finding is that it is highly unusual to find HPV DNA in the blood. HPV, if present in the body, exists in the epithelial (skin and mucosa) membranes. HPV or its DNA, by itself does not survive for any great length of time in the bloodstream. Why was the HPV DNA in her bloodstream two years post-vaccination?
My answer would be: Probably because the naturopath, like most naturopaths, didn’t have a clue what he was doing or how when he “detected” HPV DNA in the blood. If Dr. Lee had clue one, that’s what he would have said. But he didn’t. He said this instead:
According to Dr. Lee, “‘Natural HPV DNA does not remain in the bloodstream for very long. However, the HPV DNA in Gardasil™ is not ‘natural’ DNA. It is a recombinant HPV DNA (rDNA) – genetically engineered – to be inserted into yeast cells for VLP (virus-like-particle) protein production. rDNA is known to behave differently from natural DNA. It may enter a human cell, especially in an inflammatory lesion caused by the effects of the aluminum adjuvant, via poorly understood mechanisms.
“Once a segment of recombinant DNA is inserted into a human cell, the consequences are hard to predict. It may be in the cell temporarily or stay there forever, with or without causing a mutation. Now the host cell contains human DNA as well as genetically engineered viral DNA.”
This is utter nonsense. First off, as I described before, it’s not a trivial matter to get recombinant DNA into human cells and expressing the protein that its sequence codes for. It’s worth repeating what I described when I first encountered this sort of claim in a different context. For rDNA to do what Dr. Lee worries about, the minute amount of rDNA in the HPV vaccine would have to:
    • Find its way into human cells in significant quantities, which is highly unlikely given the tiny amount that, even in the worst case, is there.
    • Express the protein that it codes for, which would require that the DNA be intact, complete with its promoter and regulatory regions. Again, this is incredibly unlikely, given the amount of DNA we’re talking about unlikely.
I actually have some experience with direct intramuscular injection of DNA to try to get gene expression, at least in the distant past. Indeed, some of the earliest experiments studying gene regulation in rat muscle by direct injection of plasmid DNA were performed in the laboratory where I did my PhD work. I knew the graduate student who was doing it, and even now I know investigators who are working on DNA vaccines. In humans, it takes microgram quantities of intact plasmid DNA, and even then expression levels are usually low without special help, such as the “gene gun” or other techniques. Indeed, this is arguably the single biggest problem that needs to be overcome in developing effective DNA-based vaccines. Also remember that the HPV vaccine is made of non-infectious HPV-like particles, which are basically formed from the L1 surface protein of the HPV virus, which makes the outer coat of the virus particle. Even in the highly unlikely situation that the tiny amount of recombinant DNA alleged to be left behind in Gardasil could get into human cells and actually make detectable amounts of VLP, the only place it’s likely to be able to do that is in the muscle in the immediate vicinity of the injection site.
None of this prevents SANE Vax from extrapolating beyond science and reason:
SANE Vax Inc. wants to know how many adolescents who have suffered adverse reactions post Gardasil vaccination have HPV DNA in their blood. What are the medical ramifications should HPV DNA remain in the bloodstream for an extended period of time?
Does the aluminum adjuvant become the carrier for HPV DNA causing said DNA to remain in the blood and/or organs for an extended length of time?
Since viral DNA cannot replicate by itself (it needs a host cell) what happens if genetically engineered viral DNA enters a human host cell?
In a followup post, SANE Vax demands:
    • What autoimmune-related disorders could result from this contamination?
    • Is it possible for this contamination to initiate gene mutations which may lead to cancer?
    • What genetic changes (mutagenesis) could occur should the residual HPV DNA enter and begin reproducing in a human cell?
All of this is putting the proverbial cart before the horse. First things first. Before anyone takes the claim that there is HPV DNA left in HPV vaccines and, more importantly, before anyone does anything (if, indeed, anything even needs to be done, which it probably doesn’t), an external laboratory needs to replicate Dr. Lee’s results. Interestingly, SANE Vax now appears to be backpedaling a bit:
The HPV DNA testing was performed by Dr. Sin Hang Lee, a pathologist at the Milford Hospital pathology laboratory known in using cutting-edge DNA sequencing for molecular diagnoses. This methodology was first reported to the FDA in 2006 and has been published in various peer-reviewed scientific journals, stated Erickson.
If Dr. Lee’s methodology was reported to the FDA in 2006 and has been published in peer-reviewed scientific journals, then what’s “proprietary” about it, and why is he so reluctant just to publish his results regarding the HPV vaccine? I challenge Dr. Lee and SANE Vax to publish in full the complete methodology used to make this finding, along with the results, and, no, this claim in the comments of one of the press releases doesn’t fly:
Question #3 – The results are already included as an attachment in the SANE Vax press release.
I tried to figure out what she meant, because if the results are included anywhere on the SANE Vax website, I couldn’t find them. Then I looked again at the original press release. The “attachment” there is simply a snippet of the graph from a DNA sequencing reaction. That’s not “results.” That could have come from anywhere, including just directly sequencing a plasmid containing HPV sequences. At the very least, any full report should include a description of the methodology, including sequences of the PCR primers, the temperatures and times of the PCR cycles, and gels of the PCR results, complete with positive and negative controls at each step of the nested PCR, plus sequencing of the PCR products. What SANE Vax has provided as “results” is meaningless and does not allow scientists to determine whether Dr. Lee detected what he claims to have detected. Sorry, Charlie. This won’t fly.
I find it most ironic that SANE Vax repeatedly calls on the FDA and Merck to be “transparent,” but nothing about the way SANE Vax has publicized its “results” is in the least bit transparent, nor has Dr. Lee’s methodology to obtain these results been peer-reviewed. Worse, in the SANE Vax letter to the FDA, SANE Vax demands assurances that the FDA will protect Dr. Lee’s proprietary methodology before it will provide the FDA with its results. The hypocrisy and intellectual dishonesty are staggering. More importantly, without SANE Vax’s alleged results being available to the FDA and independent scientists to examine, all we have to support the claim that there is recombinant DNA in the HPV vaccine is the word of an anti-vaccine group.
Color me not particularly worried. Until there is independent verification, it’s utterly pointless even to worry about these other questions because the source, being rabidly anti-HPV vaccine, is suspect, and there is no way to determine if the methodology used is valid and not likely to produce false positives. After all, the HPV vaccine is tested for the presence of recombinant DNA, and it’s below the limit of detection of standard techniques; otherwise, Merck, the FDA, and other scientists would have detected it before. Only a scientist affiliated with an anti-vaccine group can seemingly detect it. Moreover, even if Dr. Lee did detect what previously couldn’t be detected before, clearly he’s detecting rDNA at such a low quantity that it’s doubtful that it would be harmful in the least. Certainly, given such a tiny amount of rDNA, it’s downright silly to talk about whether the aluminum adjuvant could somehow become a “carrier” for HPV DNA that allows it to be present in the blood for an extended period of time. Given that the HPV rDNA couldn’t replicate, the law of conservation of mass is enough to dismiss this concern as ridiculous, because it would take far more DNA than could possibly be in the adjuvant to produce detectable levels in the blood for long periods of time, particularly given that the way the L1 protein is made is to use expression plasmids designed to work in yeast, most of which will not work (or will work very poorly) in human cells. Finally, even in the incredibly unlikely event that a tiny amount of L1 rDNA could be expressed by surrounding muscle cells, what would it do? It would make more L1, arguably slightly increasing the efficacy of the vaccine.
Maybe Dr. Lee should be come a homeopath. He seems to think that the more the HPV DNA is diluted, the stronger it becomes.

The Harm of Antivaccine Misinformation
Anti-vaccine misinformation has a body count.
Steven Novella on January 8, 2020
Link

When considering how to balance freedom of speech with attempts to manage the effects of misinformation, it’s reasonable to consider the fact that some types of misinformation cause direct demonstrable harm. Vaccine-preventable diseases, such as measles, are on the rise recently due partly to active campaigns of clear misinformation about vaccines (poverty and lack of access still remain a huge challenge as well).
A recent study out of Denmark quantifies the potential harm, this time regarding the HPV vaccine. The HPV vaccine provided protection from multiple strains of the Human Papilloma Virus, which is responsible for many cases of cervical cancer. As I noted when I discussed HPV vaccine previously, Dr. Heidi Larson points out that:
Every year brings 528,000 new cases of cervical cancer and 266,000 deaths, linked to human papillomavirus (HPV). We have a highly effective HPV vaccine, but suspicion stands in the way of its adoption in many countries.
The vaccine is safe and effective (actually there are several vaccines with different coverage of various strains – the latest is nonavalent, covering nine strains). It prevents cancer and saves lives. If we consider risk vs benefit, there is clear benefit to the vaccine with minimal risk. But of course these facts don’t get in the way of antivaccine propaganda.
The primary obstacle to uptake of the HPV vaccine around the world has been unsubstantiated fearmongering. For example, there are commonly rumors about deaths associated with the vaccine. As David Gorski has discussed, however, none of these rumors are credible and the evidence does not support them. But people are easier to scare with stories than they are to reassure with dry facts. The recent Denmark study shows the effects:
In the period with some negative media coverage, HPV vaccine uptake fell to 83.6% (95% CI:78.0%–89.7%) of baseline uptake. In the period with extensive negative media coverage, uptake fell even further to 49.6% (95% CI:44.5%–55.2%) of baseline uptake. After the information campaign, HPV vaccine uptake recovered to its baseline level (109.2%, 95% CI:90.1%–132.4%) due in part to catch-up doses. Despite the recovery, an estimated 26,000 fewer girls initiated the vaccine than if uptake had not declined.
The campaign to counter the misinformation cost Danish taxpayer about $1 million. That represents resources not used on other public health initiatives. There is also significant morbidity and mortality associated with the misinformation. Public health measures have statistical effects, and that includes misinformation campaigns.
The experience in Japan was even more stark. Uptake of the HPV vaccine fell from 70% to single digits (reports range from 1-7%) after a vaccine panic hit the media. This went beyond misinformation to an actual panic. The episode was triggered by a preliminary study involving mice and reporting to show brain damage from the vaccine. The episode was a perfect storm of incompetence and malfeasance. The research itself was preliminary, not replicated, and frankly dubious. Despite this the media ran with it, spreading unnecessary fear. Further, the government’s response was worse than inadequate. They actually made the situation worse by suspending their recommendation for the vaccine.
One researcher stood up to the misinformation, Riko Muranaka. She looked into the study and found:
When Muranka [sic] finally tracked down the source of the slide, the researcher involved told her the experiment had involved only one mouse being injected with each vaccine, and that the mouse brain showed by Ikeda was not even the one injected with HPV vaccine.
Muranaka also discovered that the mice vaccinated in the experiment had been genetically modified and produced an auto-antibody naturally during aging. Serum full of the antibody was taken from these mice, sprayed on brain sections of normal mice and photographed to show “brain damage” supposedly caused by HPV vaccine.
But the PR damage was done. Further, when Muranaka published her findings, Ikeda sued her for defamation. This had the effect of causing a media blackout for Muranaka, including canceling her book that was about to be published. The Ikeda study was also followed quickly by a class action lawsuit against the HPV vaccine manufacturers, and has put a pause on further government support for the vaccine. This could take a decade or more to resolve. (There are many scary parallels between this story and the effects of Andrew Wakefield’s fraudulent study on the MMR vaccine in the UK.)
The end result of all this is likely to be 100,000 women or more suffering from HPV-related cervical cancer.
The more difficult question is – what can be done about it? There is no easy solution. However, at the very least the media needs to be more responsible. They should take their lead on science stories, especially medical stories, from objective and recognized experts. Governments should also be more proactive in fighting misinformation, stemming panics, and disseminating reliable information. Whistle-blowers like Muranaka also need to be protected better with libel reform.
There is also a great deal of debate about the role of giant social media companies. Many argue that they have some responsibility for the information that spreads on their platforms. They are certainly under no obligation to promote harmful misinformation, even if inadvertently through blind algorithms. But perhaps they should also take an active role in minimizing the spread of clearly harmful medical misinformation.
One way to look at it is this – a small minority now has the ability to hijack public health policy by waging their own shadow campaign on social media. They are accountable to no one. They can force the expenditure of limited public health dollars just to minimize the effect of their own campaigns. This is also an asymmetric campaign, because it is much easier to spread fear than proper information. At the very least it is reasonable to filter out their harmful misinformation from private platforms. Panels of experts can be used to provide the filter, and fair processes can be made available for appeals. At the very least these options need to be explored.

Vaccines Work. Here’s Why We Care About Your Unvaccinated Child.
While normal people don’t want any child to suffer or die because their parents were tricked by disinformation, the leaders of the anti-vaccine movement, who profit by lying about vaccines, don’t care at all.
Jonathan Howard on March 20, 2026
Link

Previously, I discussed one of the oldest and most noxious anti-vaccine talking points, “Why should you worry about my unvaccinated child if vaccines work so well?” and linked to an article from 2011 titled Why Worry About the Unvaccinated? that supplied the obvious answer:
When a very high percentage of people are vaccinated there’s very little chance that the vaccine-preventable disease will spread through the community. But if not enough people are vaccinated, then the disease can pass from person to person, increasing the risk for everyone, but especially for those who aren’t (or can’t be) vaccinated.
The article correctly noted that some children are “too young to get vaccinated” while others have “a compromised immune system.”  It appropriately noted that these weren’t mere theoretical talking points. Real children had been hurt. It said:
There are children like Maggie, diagnosed with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (blood cancer), who can’t be vaccinated against diseases like measles. After finishing her last round of chemotherapy, she was discharged from the hospital and went that same afternoon to a clinic for lab work. At the clinic, she was exposed to a patient with measles. After the exposure Maggie was given shots of measles antibodies. She thankfully survived, but it was a scary time for her and her family.
Or take baby Brie. Unlike Maggie, Brie didn’t survive the vaccine-preventable disease she was exposed to. Brie caught pertussis (whooping cough) when she was less than a month old. Her family said goodbye to her on her 52nd day of life, just seven days shy of being eligible for the pertussis vaccine.
Maggie was immunocompromised and Brie was not yet eligible for the pertussis vaccine, but anyone can become seriously sick from disease as well. 
Two recent new stories show that these still aren’t theoretical talking points.
The first article was titled Boy, 7, Dies of Brain Condition Caused by Measles — Years Later. It said:
He had contracted measles as a baby of just 7 months old — but fast-forward years later to when he was 6 and experiencing cognitive deterioration and seizures.
Doctors eventually diagnosed him with subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE), a neurological disease that can develop years after a measles infection.
This brain disorder usually starts with subtle personality changes, like memory loss, irritability or mood swings. Over time, it can progress to involuntary muscle spasms, loss of coordination, severe brain damage, coma — and almost always death.
The second article was titled A Teen Girl’s Harrowing Journey With Measles Highlights How Serious the Virus Can be for the Immunocompromised. It said:
When 14-year-old Makayla Skjerva came home from school last month complaining that the side of her neck was hurting, her parents didn’t think she had much more than a mild illness.
However, that symptom soon progressed to body aches, a fever and a noticeable rash. Then came notifications from the health department and Makayla’s school that a measles exposure may have occurred at the school gym.
Soon after, Makayla, from Cavalier, North Dakota, tested positive for measles and her health rapidly declined. She was quickly hospitalized and had to be transferred to another state by air ambulance to receive care…
Her stepmother, Ashley Skjerva, told ABC News that Makayla was vaccinated against measles but, because she is immunocompromised, it left her at high risk for infection and serious complications.
“Makayla is a fighter but the fight’s not over,” Ashley said. “We’re all trying to hold ourselves together and it’s been very difficult. I’m just glad she’s here still. That’s all I keep saying to myself.”
Herd immunity could have prevented this. In both cases, strangers made selfish, uninformed decisions that devastated these children and their families.
However, a third article reveals yet another reason why we should care about the needless suffering of unvaccinated children. The article was titled Mom of 7-Year-Old Hospitalized with Brain Swelling from Measles: ‘I Still Wouldn’t Have Given my Son the Vaccine’. It said:
Six weeks ago, Ethan was like most 7-year-olds — spending the weekend riding his new bike or playing Minecraft on his iPad on a rainy day.
“He just learned how to ride, he got the hang of it right away,” Ethan’s dad, Luis, said proudly. “He wanted to go outside because he wanted to jump on his bike…it was an amazing thing for him.”
Instead, since late January, the schoolboy has been confined to a hospital bed with measles encephalitis, a complication that causes swelling and inflammation in the brain. “He’s pretty much as if he was paralyzed,” his devastated father, 41, told The Independent in a phone interview from his son’s hospital bedside.
Ethan’s parents decided not to immunize him against measles as they did with his three brothers. Three out of four of them contracted measles. Still, despite Ethan’s ordeal, his mom stands by their decision. “We’re not blaming God for this,” said 35-year-old Kristina. “Yes, it hurts, of course, it hurts. But God has chosen Ethan for a reason. God is doing something, and we’re gonna glorify his name regardless.
“And we wouldn’t change it any other way,” the mom continued. “If I knew this could be the outcome, I still wouldn’t have given my son the vaccine.”
“Our biggest reason why we didn’t do it is just with all the unnecessary stuff they add into it,” Kristina added, referring to her beliefs about the vaccine. “With my own eyes, I have seen the damage it does to kids who are perfectly normal, and then once they get it, they’re not the same anymore,” she claimed.
Ethan’s mom is wrong. Her son and other children like him didn’t have to suffer this way. A simple vaccine could have prevented all this, and normal people don’t want any child- even a stranger’s child- to suffer or die because their parents were tricked by anti-vaccine disinformation.
In contrast, the leaders of the movement, those who profit by lying to Ethan’s mom about “unnecessary stuff” in vaccines, don’t care at all.


   Thanks, Jenny McCarthy! Thanks for the measles!
David Gorski
Links
I would like to take this opportunity to echo my co-blogger Steve’s sentiment and thank Jenny McCarthy.
What? You say. Has Gorski completely lost his mind? (Or maybe you used another word besides “mind,” a perhaps not so savory word.) Not really. I just agree with Steve that accomplishment should be recognized, and there’s no doubt that in her year as the new celebrity spokesperson for the antivaccination movement, Jenny McCarthy has pulled off a major coup.
She’s helped reignite a movement that was until her entrance (and especially the entrance of her far more famous boyfriend Jim Carrey, who’s said some things just as breathtakingly dumb as Jenny has) more or less moribund, to the point where it’s now become so effective that measles is coming back far faster than I had thought possible. Between her tireless prosletyzing on Oprah Winfrey’s show that vaccines caused her son’s autism and that “biomedical” quackery can “cure it”; her organizing of a march on Washington, D.C. this summer to push an explicitly antivaccine agenda disguised under the deceptive and disingenuous (but brilliantly Orwellian) slogan “Green Our Vaccines“; her holding celebrity fundraisers (complete with Britney Spears, Hugh Hefner, and Charlie Sheen, yet!); and her fronting WWE events to raise money for Generation Rescue, she’s done it all in a little more than a year. And she’s not resting on her “laurels” (such as they are), either. This September, she will be publishing the followup to her previous book on “healing autism” (with quackery), Mother Warriors: A Nation of Parents Healing Autism Against All Odds. No doubt she will again appear with Oprah to fawning acclaim to make the unfounded assertion that vaccines injured her son to make him autistic and that her favored forms of quackery have successfully “healed him.”
In light of these “accomplishments,” it’s only right that we all give Jenny (and Jim) the “thanks” they deserves for their role in bringing the measles back to the U.S.
As further evidence that this is the case, last week, the CDC released an update to its Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR) that demonstrates very clearly that the antivaccination movement is having an effect. Let’s put it this way. A mere eight years ago, measles was considered, in effect, eradicated from the U.S., thanks to a vigorous vaccination program and a very high vaccine uptake. All that remained were a handful, usually less than 100, cases of measles from outside the U.S. That’s all changing now:
The number of measles cases in the U.S. is at its highest level since 1997, and nearly half of those involve children whose parents rejected vaccination, government health officials reported Thursday.
The number of cases is still small, just 131, but that’s just for the first seven months of the year and doctors are troubled by the trend. There were only 42 cases for all of last year.
“We’re seeing a lot more spread. That is concerning to us,” said Dr. Jane Seward, of the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
Pediatricians are frustrated, saying they are having to spend more time convincing parents the shot is safe.
“This year, we certainly have had parents asking more questions,” said Dr. Ari Brown, an Austin, Texas, physician who is a spokeswoman for the American Academy of Pediatrics.
The CDC’s review found that a number of cases involved home-schooled children not required to have the vaccines.
[...]
It is no longer endemic to the United States, but every year some Americans pick it up while traveling abroad and bring it home. Measles epidemics have exploded in Israel, Switzerland and some other countries. But high U.S. childhood vaccination rates have prevented major outbreaks here.
In a typical year, only one outbreak occurs in the United States, infecting perhaps 10 to 20 people. So far this year through July 30 the country has seen seven outbreaks, including one in Illinois with 30 cases, said Seward, deputy director of the CDC’s Division of Viral Diseases.
None of the 131 patients died, but 15 were hospitalized.
It’s not all bad news. The article and the MMWR report note that vaccination rates in the U.S. are still over 90%, still high enough for herd immunity to hold sway, but that outbreak pockets, where lower vaccination rates are the rule and herd immunity has become shaky, are forming. That’s what’s allowing these outbreaks to occur. Here’s the kicker:
Of this year’s total, 122 were unvaccinated or had unknown vaccination status. Some were unvaccinated because the children were under age 1, making them too young to get their first measles shot.
In 63 of those cases _ almost all of them 19 or younger _ the patient or their parents refused vaccination, the CDC reported.
In Washington state, an outbreak was traced to a religious conference, including 16 school-aged children who were not vaccinated because of parents’ beliefs. Eleven of those kids were home schooled and not subject to vaccination rules in public schools.
The Illinois outbreak _ triggered by a teenager who had traveled to Italy _ included 25 home-schooled children, according to the CDC report.
So, rejoice, Jenny McCarthy, J.B. Handley, David Kirby, Kim Stagliano, Dan Olmsted, Barbara Loe Fisher, and all the other antivaccine activists (or their enablers, such as pediatrician to the stars’ children, including Jenny McCarthy’s son Evan, Dr. Jay Gordon, who oh-so-piously claim they are really and truly “not antivaccine” but then repeat antivaccination pseudoscience word-for-word) spreading misinformation, pseudoscience, and fear about vaccines! You’re winning. You’re succeeding in casting doubt on the safety of vaccines to the point that it’s causing real problems for our public health system:
The nation once routinely saw hundreds of thousands of measles cases each year, and hundreds of deaths. But immunization campaigns were credited with dramatically reducing the numbers. The last time health officials saw this many cases was 1997, when 138 were reported. Last year, there were only 42 U.S. cases.
The American Academy of Pediatrics has made educating parents about the safety of vaccines one of its top priorities this year, in part because busy doctors have grown frustrated at the amount of time they’ve been spending answering parents’ questions about things they read on the Internet or heard from TV talk shows.
In June, the CDC interviewed 33 physicians in Austin, suburban Seattle and Hollywood, Fla., about childhood vaccinations. Several complained about patient backlogs caused by parents stirred up by information of dubious scientific merit, according to the CDC report.
Yes, Jenny, this resurgence in measles is at least in part the result of your tireless labor in scaring parents with lies and pseudoscience to the point where they fear and refuse vaccination. Now, thanks to you and your allies, your efforts are really beginning to bear fruit, and we’re catching up with the U.K., which has a decade-long head start. Measles is coming back, Who knows? If you keep it up, you could reach the golden age of pre-MMR, as described in the CDC report:
In the United States, measles caused 450 reported deaths and 4,000 cases of encephalitis annually before measles vaccine became available in the mid-1960s (1). Through a successful measles vaccination program, the United States eliminated endemic measles transmission (1). Sustaining elimination requires maintaining high MMR vaccine coverage rates, particularly among preschool (>90% 1-dose coverage) and school-aged children (>95% 2-dose coverage) (7). High coverage levels provide herd immunity, decreasing everyone’s risk for measles exposure and affording protection to persons who cannot be vaccinated. However, herd immunity does not provide 100% protection, especially in communities with large numbers of unvaccinated persons. For the foreseeable future, measles importations into the United States will continue to occur because measles is still common in Europe and other regions of the world. Within the United States, the current national MMR vaccine coverage rate is adequate to prevent the sustained spread of measles. However, importations of measles likely will continue to cause outbreaks in communities that have sizeable clusters of unvaccinated persons.
But, hey, if Jenny succeeds, it’ll be far more than just isolated communities of unvaccinated persons being victimized by measles outbreaks. If Jenny succeeds, the measles can really go to town in a manner not seen since the pre-vaccine era of early 1960s! After all:
Measles is one of the first diseases to reappear when vaccination coverage rates fall. Ongoing outbreaks are occurring in European countries where rates of vaccination coverage are lower than those in the United States, including Austria, Italy, and Switzerland (3,4). In June 2008, the United Kingdom’s Health Protection Agency declared that, because of a drop in vaccination coverage levels (to 80%–85% among children aged 2 years), measles was again endemic in the United Kingdom (3,8), 14 years after it had been eliminated. Since April 2008, two measles-related deaths have been reported in Europe, both in children ineligible to receive MMR vaccine because of congenital immunologic compromise (4,8). Such children depend on herd immunity for protection from the disease, as do children aged <12 months, who normally are too young to receive the vaccine. Otherwise healthy children with measles also are at risk for severe complications, including encephalitis and pneumonia, which can lead to permanent disability or death.
Let’s not forget that that was just the measles. Keep it up, Jenny and other antivaccine activists, and you can probably drive vaccination rates low enough that polio, Haemophilus influenza b, the mumps, pertussis and a whole lot of other vaccine-preventable diseases currently under good control make a similar comeback. Heck, if you work hard enough, maybe they’ll all become endemic again. It’ll be just like the old days! That’ll be the reward for your success, just as the manner in which Andrew Wakefield’s incompetent, litigation-driven, and unethical “research” led measles, which had been similarly declared as conquered in the U.K. 14 years ago to become endemic again less than ten years after Wakefield first published his results. (Indeed, we should thank Andrew Wakefiedl as well for his role in paving the way for Jenny McCarthy and friends here in the U.S.!) That’s the world to which Jenny McCarthy and her merry band of antivaccine activists are leading us in name of a false dichotomy that parents face a choice between either vaccine-preventable infectious diseases or autism. It’s a false dichotomy because the best scientific evidence says that mercury in the thimerosal that used to be in vaccines does not cause autism, nor do vaccines themselves. Indeed, Jenny’s claims that her son Evan has “recovered” from his “vaccine injury”-induced autism have recently been revealed to be highly doubtful, and more recently even her fellow travelers can’t seem to keep their stories straight.
I’m sure all the suffering, hospitalized, and dead children in the future will Jenny for her tireless efforts to “save them from autism” now at the cost of suffering and dying from vaccine-preventable diseases in the future. Steve Novella put it well when he said:
The idiocy of antivaccinationists partly rests upon the modern luxury of never having had to live through the horrible epidemics of the past. I wonder how much the current generation will have to suffer through before they get it.
And I will say it again – if Jenny McCarthy is going to put her own “mommy instinct” before the consensus of scientific opinion, and exploit her dubious celebrity to champion anti-science, then she is going to have to take responsibility for her actions. The way I figure it, so far there are at least 68 measles cases on her tally sheet, and the number is growing.
I fear how large that number will grow before there is a backlash against the antivaccine activists who had a large role in causing this incipient public health disaster.
ADDENDUM:
By the way, my blog bud PalMD also thanks Jenny for the opportunity to fill in a gap in his medical education by providing him with the future opportunity to see cases of diseases that had previously been driven to being very rare, thanks to vaccines.

   Measles
Mark Crislip
Link
It looks like the H1N1 pandemic is fading fast. I am amazed at how lucky we were, at least in the hospitals where I work. A month ago all the ICU beds were full, most of the ventilators were in use and we were wondering how we were going to triage the next batch of patients who needed advanced life support and we had none to offer. Then, right as we reached maximum capacity and had no more wiggle room, the rates plummeted. We skated right up to the edge of the precipice, looked down, and did not have to jump.
The pandemic has not been as bad as expected, but it was still no walk in the park. Nationwide H1N1 killed maybe 10,000, with 1,100 in children and 7,500 among young adults (ref). Oregon has had 1200 hospitalizations and 68 deaths. We had about 8 deaths from H1N1 in my hospital system. We would have had twice that number, but one of our hospitals is a trauma center and offers ECMO (Extra Corporeal Membrane Oxygenation) and we managed to save a number of people who would have died if they had been in a lesser hospital. The national statistics mirror our experience. None of the deaths were in the elderly. Pity the vaccine was slow to be produced as it could have prevented the majority of those deaths.
Are we done with H1N1? Will it become part of seasonal flu? Will it have a third comeback, fueled by holiday travel? Will it mutate and increase virulence? Will it recombine with avian flu to generate a new strain? Is this THE pandemic that comes every 30 years or so, and we will not see another until after I am long dead?
How am I supposed to know? I can’t see the future. Or can I? Mr. Randi, listen up: I am thinking I will be eligible for that million dollar prize. I am receiving future information from the Large Hadron Collider, curiously delivered inside a baguette. I think I can predict the next infection to sweep the US.
Measles.
Easy call, huh?
I have seen a grand total of one case of measles in my career. It was in an unimmunized young male who picked up measles traveling to Africa. I had not expected to see another case thanks to immunization. I am no longer certain that will be the case.
Measles, due to the rubeola virus, is a typical virus, with the usual fever, cough, runny nose, red eyes and a generalized, maculopapular, erythematous rash. One of many childhood infections that have plagued mankind. Measles is very infectious, with 90% of household contacts exposed developing the disease. It is one of those infections that is easy to acquire in the waiting area of a doctors office.
Case fatality rates in the West are low, about 0.3%, while in the third world it kills up to a third of infected children. About one in a thousand get encephalitis.
In the old days, everyone developed measles with about 3 million cases a year, with relatively little, but devastating, morbidity and mortality.
“Before measles vaccine, nearly all children got measles by the time they were 15 years of age. Each year in the United States about 450 people died because of measles, 48,000 were hospitalized, 7,000 had seizures, and about 1,000 suffered permanent brain damage or deafness.”
Much of this is preventable by the vaccine. No vaccine is perfect, and the measles vaccine is no different. Measles vaccine is about 90-97% effective in preventing infection, depending on the population studied. Or to think of it another way, 3 to 10% of the population would remain susceptible to the disease even if we had 100% of the population vaccinated.
Thanks to Dr. Andrew Wakefield, fear of MMR induced autism is highest in Great Britain and as a result measles vaccination rates have fallen. Perhaps it should now be Mediocre Britain, at least where vaccines are concerned.
Vaccination rates have fallen in England, and at one point 20% of children were susceptible to measles, mumps and rubella. Since the English refer to vaccination as ‘the jab’ I am surprised they get anyone to take the vaccine. It’s like referring to colonoscopy as riding the python. Who would want that?
“A particularly significant decline was observed between 2000 and 2004, which can arguably be attributed to deterioration in public confidence about the safety of the MMR (Reference).”
As a result, measles boomed.
All due to Dr. Wakefield’s report in the Lancet, which evidently should have been published as work of dark humor in Punch.
“More importantly, the controversy appeared to affect parental decision-making. Uptake rates for MMR in England fell from 87.4% in 2000-01 to 79.9% in 2003-04, the lowest figure at any time since the widespread introduction of the triple vaccine in 1990-91. The decrease was especially significant given that the single vaccines alternative was only available from private medical clinics, at a cost of around £200.
The Wakefield study has been widely discredited, and MMR uptake has recovered to an extent: in 2007 vaccination rates stood at 84.6%. Meanwhile, measles notifications in 2006 and 2007 were the highest for almost a decade. (Reference)”
I wonder, as an aside, about responsibility. One of the refrains of the antivax crowd is that big pharma is protected from any liability from vaccine injury. Big pharma cannot be held responsible. I wonder, when the causes of autism are finally elucidated and vaccines are definitely exonerated as we have the answers to the etiology of autism, if Dr. Wakefield, AoA and Ms. McCarthy will assume the responsibility and liability for all the morbidity and mortality their actions caused. I am sure they will happy to step up to the plate and offer restitution to the affected families.
There was, of course, another paper out of Poland, “Lack of Association Between Measles-Mumps-Rubella Vaccination and Autism in Children,” this month exonerating the MMR as a cause of autism. Poland has an interesting history with regards the measles vaccine:
“The MMR vaccine was introduced in Poland later than in most other European countries. For the past 10 years, the MMR vaccine has been gradually replacing the single-antigen measles variety. When it was first introduced, MMR was not covered by the national health service of Poland. Parents who wished to vaccinate their children with MMR, as opposed to the single mandatory measles vaccine, had to pay extra. For this reason, few children were immunized with MMR. The Polish mandatory vaccinations schedule did not include MMR for all children until 2004.”
As a result,
“Poland’s heterogeneous population (ie, vaccinated with MMR, vaccinated against measles only, nonvaccinated) serves as a unique sample group for studying the debated association of these vaccines with autism in children.”
In comparing the three groups they found no association between MMR and autism. None. In fact, they found “a lower risk of developing autism for children vaccinated against measles, with the lowest risk being found for children vaccinated with MMR.”
This finding is dismissed by the authors as perhaps
“the decreased risk of autism among vaccinated children may be due to some other confounding factors in their health status. For example, health care workers or parents may have noticed signs of developmental delay or disease before the actual autism diagnosis and for this reason have avoided vaccination.”
Dr. Gorski also thought the finding was a fluke. Part of the argument against MMR being protective being that having one child in the family with autism would make it unlikely for other children in the family to get the vaccine out of fear of the vaccine causing autism when, in fact, it is due to perhaps inherited causes. The lack of vaccination actually being a marker for families with other predispositions to developing autism.
I am not certain that is true. As the authors report:
“This serves as evidence that, despite extensive media coverage of the debated association between MMR and autism, public acceptance of this vaccine remains very high. The situation in Poland is different to that of many European countries, where MMR vaccinations by age 2 years fell more than 10% and were followed by measles outbreaks. In this time, Poland’s already high rate of measles immunization even slightly increased.”
Seems that the Poles were immune to the anti-MMR hysteria, although I cannot say with certainty. If so, then the finding of the protective effect of vaccination, given the study population, may be valid.
Me? I think everything is due to an infectious disease. Infections are the One True Cause of All Disease. While this is the first study to demonstrate the protective effect of the MMR, remember that measles, mumps and rubella are neurotropic viruses with encephalitis a known complication. There has long been a suspicion of viral infections altering the brain to unmask schizophrenia and there is an association between borna virus and OCD. Could a subtle neurologic infection exacerbate a predilection towards autism? I do not think it is out of the question. But that is my delusion.
Vaccination rates have fallen in some segments of the US population as well. In the US, low vaccination rates are found primarily in the children of the well-to-do and often are clustered in alternative schools. There are dozens of schools with vaccination rates under 80%, with some schools having vaccination rates of 5% (reference).
Well, fine, you may say to yourself: they can get the measles or other vaccine preventable diseases. At least it will stay in the those enclaves of unvaccinated children. My kids are vaccinated and in schools where vaccine rates are high. My kids are safe. I would have thought the same thing.
Herd immunity and the models that try and predict what levels of immunity are needed to protect a population are based on the assumption that unimmunized people are randomly distributed in a population, not clustered in alternative schools.
In the Journal of Infectious Diseases this month is a description of a measles outbreak in Canada where clusters of unvaccinated populations helped perpetuate a measles outbreak even though overall community vaccination rates were high (“Long-Lasting Measles Outbreak Affecting Several Unrelated Networks of Unvaccinated Persons”):
“Despite a population immunity level estimated at ∼95%, an outbreak of measles responsible for 94 cases occurred in Quebec, Canada. Unlike previous outbreaks in which most unvaccinated children belonged to a single community, this outbreak had cases coming from several unrelated networks of unvaccinated persons dispersed in the population. No epidemiological link was found for about one-third of laboratory-confirmed cases. This outbreak demonstrated that minimal changes in the level of aggregation of unvaccinated individuals can lead to sustained transmission in highly vaccinated populations. Mathematical work is needed regarding the level of aggregation of unvaccinated individuals that would jeopardize elimination.”
The graphic shows how schools acted to magnify the epidemic:
The isolated measles virus was genotyped and almost all isolates were identical, demonstrating how infectious measles can be with what was presumptively minimal contact.
As the discussion said:
“An important assumption of mathematical models predicting elimination, however, is the random distribution of susceptible persons in the population. In reality, unvaccinated individuals are not distributed at random. Religious groups opposed to vaccination are often tightly knit communities. Our outbreak involving 2 unrelated alternative schools attended by children whose parents were resistant to vaccination on philosophical ground demonstrated that these persons also aggregate. The spontaneous interruption of this outbreak, despite the current level of aggregation in unvaccinated children, suggests that endemicity was not likely to be reestablished in this population. The continued propagation throughout many generations of cases, however, raised the possibility that a minimal change in the overall vaccine coverage in the population or in the level of aggregation of unvaccinated individuals can lead to sustained but protracted transmission despite an immunity level near 95%.”
Lest you think this outbreak epidemiology is limited to measles, the US northeast experienced a similar outbreak with mumps, where clusters of unvaccinated populations help magnify the spread of disease.
A child with mumps came to the US from, hey, I’ll be damned, England, thank you Dr. Wakefield, where, thanks to low uptake of the MMR (the second M standing for mumps) there is a mumps epidemic. The index case went to a religious camp and gave it to the other campers, who in turn went to other collections of unvaccinated people to start their own epidemic and so on. In this case there was little spread into the wider community that “might be attributable to generally high vaccination levels and little interaction between members of the affected religious community and persons in surrounding communities.”
It appears that collections of unvaccinated people may serve to magnify the ability of diseases to spread in a community. Those unvaccinated children in the alternative schools may be unlikely to keep their infections to themselves.
My million-dollar prediction? Measles will be imported into the US in a student from Mediocre Britain. That student will visit an alternative school and start an epidemic in the school. Measles will be spread from school to school and into the community and will be difficult to control.
It will occur in 2012. The Mayans, along with the other indigenous peoples in North and South America, were killed by the millions by vaccine preventable illnesses like measles, pertussis, mumps and smallpox. The real reason the Mayan calendar ends in 2012 is the end of the world will be due to the return of vaccine-preventable diseases.

Return of an old foe
Peter Lipson on November 1, 2011
Link
In 2000, a panel of experts was brought together by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). They came to discuss whether measles was still endemic in the United States, that is whether it still existed in the general background of US infectious diseases. They concluded that measles had been eradicated in the US, and that the occasional cases imported from abroad were stopped by a wall of vaccinated Americans.
Welcome to the future. The US is in the middle of its largest measles outbreak since 1996. Most of the cases originated abroad, brought back by unvaccinated travelers, either American residents or foreign visitors. This has so far led to 12 outbreaks (that is, a cluster of three or more connected cases) mostly among the unvaccinated. Of the 139 cases who were US residents rather than foreign visitors, twelve had documentation of adequate immunization.
The surprise isn’t that a few cases should slip through the wall of vaccination, but that the wall has so many chinks in it. The number of measles cases being imported, and the falling vaccination rates of Americans may reach the point soon where we no longer need to import our measles as it will once again become endemic.
Measles isn’t just a curious disease that we learned about in medical school (“cough, coryza, conjunctivits”); it’s a serious disease that leads to pneumonia in 1 in 20 children, and brain inflammation in 1 in 1000. Outside the US, it causes hundreds of thousands of deaths yearly.
We must increase our efforts to vaccinate all US residents properly (including undocumented residents). If measles does take hold once again in the U.S., the blame will fall squarely on our health care system’s failure to deliver vaccine, and on those who for whatever reason delay or avoid vaccination altogether.
It used to be that Americans viewed public health battles with excitement, a battle against fear itself, against the fear of children choking to death from whooping cough, or becoming paralyzed by polio. Now, as we sit behind our crumbling shield of vaccination, we have become complacent. If we fail to act, our complacency will be replaced by very real fears, especially for our children.

Measles Spike in US
Steven Novella on December 10, 2013
Link
The Centers for Disease Control (CDC) announced in a recent press release the data for 2013 so far shows 175 confirmed cases of measles in the US. This is about three times the usual rate of 60 per year since endemic measles was eradicated in the US, and is the most in the last decade other than 2011, which saw 222 cases.
Measles is a highly contagious virus that primarily causes a respiratory infection. It is not benign. According to the CDC:
About one out of 10 children with measles also gets an ear infection, and up to one out of 20 gets pneumonia. About one out of 1,000 gets encephalitis, and one or two out of 1,000 die.
About 500 Americans died each year of measles prior to the introduction of the vaccine. Measles is still endemic in Europe and many other parts of the world, causing about 20 million infections and 164,000 deaths each year.
The US has high overall vaccine rates and due to the measles vaccine, endemic measles was officially eradicated by 2000. A recent study finds that measles is still eradicated – officially this means there are less than one case per 1 million people. Being endemic means that the virus is being passed around within the population. High vaccine rates keep this from happening through so-called herd immunity – the virus has no place to go and the infection dies out.
Most new cases of measles in the US, 88%, are imported from outside the country by travelers. When such imported measles hits a community with low vaccination rates, however, and outbreak can occur. While overall vaccinations rates remain high there are pockets of low vaccination in communities with philosophical objections to vaccines.
In fact the largest recent outbreak of measles, 58 affected individuals, occurred in an orthodox Jewish community in New York. Such outbreaks are increasingly common. It is no mystery why this is – 65% of cases of measles occur in those who are unvaccinated (with 20% having unknown vaccination status).
You are more than 22 times more likely to get measles if you are not vaccinated than if you are vaccinated. Further, if you are vaccinated but still get measles you likely caught it from someone who was not vaccinated. Communities with high vaccine refusal rates are more likely to have outbreaks than communities with high vaccination rates.
The evidence is clear. The MMR vaccine works against measles. It is responsible for eradicating measles from the US, with only sporadic imported cases. However, since eradication in 2000 pockets of vaccine refusal have cause outbreaks to occur. So far measles is still not endemic in the US, but it might once again gain a foothold if vaccine refusal rates increase.
This is all a legacy of anti-vaccine fearmongering and misinformation.

Measles gets a helping hand
John Snyder on February 28, 2014
Link

In a recent post I shared a bit of my personal, near-death experience with measles during the US epidemic of 1989-1991. As I describe in that post, I contracted a very serious measles infection at the end of medical school, and was highly infectious when I interviewed for a residency position at Seattle Children’s Hospital. Like others my age who received an ineffective, killed measles vaccine between 1963 and 1967, I had not been adequately protected. The MMR vaccine was not yet available, and no boosters were recommended at the time. Unfortunately, though my measles titers (a test of immunity to measles) were checked when I entered medical school, the school’s student health department failed to notice or respond to the results – I was not immune and did not receive a booster dose at that time, as I should have. That mistake was huge, and could have cost me my life. It also caused me to potentially sicken many vulnerable children during my tour of the hospital, as well as others I may have inadvertently exposed during the window of communicability as I walked the streets of Seattle. The Department of Health had to be called to trace all of my steps and attempt to track down and protect any potential contacts.
Measles (or rubeolla) is a serious infectious disease caused by an RNA-containing paramyxovirus. The virus is primarily spread by respiratory droplet from a cough. Within two days of replicating in the nose and throat, it disseminates rapidly throughout the body. The incubation period is 10-12 days, after which the clinical manifestations of the disease begin. These early signs typically include escalating fevers, runny nose, cough, and watery, red eyes. Within a few days, the typical pink, blotchy measles rash begins at the hairline and spreads down the body, usually lasting for 5-6 days. While the initial signs of measles (the prodrome) resemble a bad cold, the illness quickly becomes much more severe. As a resident, we were taught that there is no such thing as a mild case of measles. Victims invariably look and feel horribly ill. Additionally, 30% of cases are associated with complications such as diarrhea, ear infections, pneumonia (5%), encephalitis (0.1%), seizures, permanent neurological impairment, and death (0.2%). The highest morbidity and mortality is seen in children under 5 and adults over 20 years of age. The mortality rate is approximately 0.2%, with death usually a result of pneumonia or encephalitis. Subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE) is a rare, degenerative brain disease that occurs several years following an episode of measles in approximately 5-10 cases per million reported cases.
Prior to introduction of the measles vaccine in 1963, there were approximately 500,000 cases of measles reported annually in the United States, though it is estimated that the true annual incidence was more like 3-4 million. The disease reared its head in 2-3 year cycles, infecting nearly everyone at some point during childhood. Shortly after the vaccine was introduced, the incidence of measles plummeted by more than 98%, and the epidemic cycles ceased.
The combined MMR vaccine, covering measles, mumps, and rubella, was introduced in 1971, though still as a single dose. A booster dose at 4-6 years of age was recommended in 1989 when it was determined that over half of all school-aged cases of measles occurred in children who had already been vaccinated. The addition of this second dose for school-aged children raised the vaccine efficacy rate from 90-95% to 99.7%, and in 1983 there were fewer than 1,500 reported cases of measles in the United States. The epidemic that occurred in this country between 1989 and 1991 (my own illness included) resulted in over 55,000 cases and 123 deaths, and was largely a result of poor vaccination rates among black and Hispanic preschool-aged children living in high-poverty, urban areas. Ninety percent of deaths during that epidemic occurred in people who were entirely unvaccinated. A major campaign to vaccinate all preschool-aged children brought this crisis under control, and disease rates have declined since then. In 2000 measles was officially eradicated as an endemic disease in the United States. In 2004, a record low 37 cases of measles were reported, presumably all a result of importation from endemic countries.
Though this is a tremendous accomplishment, the successes achieved throughout the rest of the world are equally if not more encouraging. Within two years of successfully eliminating the transmission of measles in the United States, a relentless vaccination program conducted by the Pan-American Health Organization (PAHO) is close to achieving similar success throughout Latin America and the Caribbean. In 2011, the PAHO asked each member country to submit a progress report to verify the eradication of measles, rubella, and congenital rubella syndrome from the Americas. The CDC has just published this report for the United States, and has confirmed the sustained elimination of these entities. Once the other reports are in, the Western hemisphere will have verified an amazing, widespread public health accomplishment.
Similar successes are being demonstrated around the world. Globally, the coverage rate for the first dose of a measles-containing vaccine increased from 72% to 84% between 2000 and 2011. The number of countries providing a routine second dose increased from 97 (50%) in 2000 to 141 (73%) in 2011. During this period of time, the annual reported measles incidence decreased 65%, from 146 to 52 cases per million population, and the estimated number of measles deaths decreased 71%, from 548,000 to 158,000. All World Health Organization (WHO) regions of the world reported substantial reductions in mortality, ranging from 36% (India) to 90% (Western Pacific). Between 2000 and 2012, an estimated 13.8 million people worldwide were spared a measles-related death due to the Measles and Rubella Initiative, a global collaboration between the WHO and national infectious disease and control agencies. Still, hot regions of low vaccination coverage continue to challenge these efforts. According to the CDC’s report on the Global Control and Regional Elimination of Measles, 2000–2011:
Field investigations of recent measles outbreaks found most cases were among unvaccinated persons, suggesting the main underlying cause was persistent gaps in immunization coverage, despite overall increased measles vaccine coverage…All five countries with the largest number of infants who did not receive MCV1 [a single dose of measles-containing vaccine] through routine immunization services in 2011 had large outbreaks of measles during 2011, highlighting the importance of a strong immunization system.
Here’s where our success story takes a sick and ironic turn. Despite our triumph over these seemingly monumental challenges – dramatic drops in morbidity and mortality in the far corners of India and Africa, and the near heroic success of eliminating measles from places like Mexico City’s Neza-Chalco-Itza, considered the world’s largest slum – our hope of truly eradicating measles from the planet faces an additional but much more banal obstacle: educated, privileged, Google-empowered parents who fall for the pseudoscientific mythology of vaccine risk. Enlarging pockets of underimmunization due to vaccine hesitancy are threatening to derail our massive, worldwide efforts at controlling this and other horrendous diseases.
Vaccine hesitancy and refusal was largely responsible for the 189 confirmed cases of measles that occurred in the United States in 2013, the highest measles rate in 17 years. According to the CDC, most cases were in persons who were unvaccinated.
The trend shows no sign of breaking. Some of the more recent cases and outbreaks in the US highlight this problem:
    • March 13, 2013: Brooklyn, NY – an intentionally unvaccinated 17 year old who became infected with measles while on a trip to London, initiated the largest outbreak of measles in the United States since 1996. A total of 58 cases were identified, all in an orthodox Jewish community of Brooklyn, NY. All cases occurred in intentionally unvaccinated individuals or in infants too young to be vaccinated.
    • April-May, 2013, North Carolina – An unvaccinated traveler to India sparked an outbreak of 23 cases of measles. Most cases were among residents of a largely unvaccinated religious community in rural North Carolina. Most were unvaccinated.
    • August, 2013: 20 cases spread through a Texas Mega-church, the leader of which preached about the dangers of vaccines. All cases occurred in families that chose not to vaccinate, and all of the infected children to had been home schooled.
    • Feb 4, 2014: Measles confirmed in a graduate student at MIT who acquired the disease on a trip to South America.
    • Feb, 2014: Five Counties in New York each reported one confirmed case of measles. Four of the five cases were unvaccinated:
        ◦ Feb 1, 2014: Rennselaer County, NY – A case of measles confirmed in a student at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute (RPI). Multiple exposures may have occurred in a number of different settings beyond the college campus due to the student’s recent cross-country travel.
        ◦ February 4, 2014, Albany County, NY – An unvaccinated one-year-old child contracted measles on a trip to the Philippines. He was treated and potentially exposed people at a private medical practice and at the Albany Medical Center.
        ◦ February 7, 2014, Rockland County, NY – Another one-year-old unvaccinated child developed measles while visiting the Philippines and potentially exposed patients at a local medical office and a large shopping mall.
        ◦ February 7, 2014, Monroe County, NY – A University of Rochester student who contracted measles during a trip to the Republic of Georgia was treated at Strong Memorial Hospital.
        ◦ Feb 24, 2014: Orange County, NY – DOH issues Health advisory concerning a confirmed case of measles in Goshen, NY.
    • Feb 24, 2014, Framingham, MA: two confirmed cases of measles potentially exposing many people at a Trader Joe’s, a local restaurant, a Bose Corporation office building, and a Harvard Vanguard medical clinic.
    • Jan-Feb, 2014: California – 15 cases of measles have already been documented in California this year, mostly associated with travel to the Philippines and India. Most of the cases occurred in intentionally unvaccinated individuals or in infants too young to be vaccinated. Four of the 15 cases occurred in the Bay Area. This includes an unvaccinated man with measles who rode the San Francisco BART train between Feb. 4 and 7, potentially infecting many people in a particularly underimmunized region.
The human tragedy aside, outbreaks like these require extensive resources from state and local public health agencies, including thousands of hours of investigative labor.
As bad as it is in the United States, the creeping menace of vaccine denialism has taken root even more destructively in the United Kingdom. The UK reported 2,000 cases of measles in 2013, the highest level in 19 years. In the Swansea region of Wales alone, over 1,200 cases of measles were reported between November, 2012 and July 2013, and the numbers continue to rise.
It is clear that, while we have succeeded in eliminating endemic measles in the US, imported cases from other countries are creating outbreaks in areas where parents are altering vaccine schedules and outright refusing to vaccinate in increasing numbers. As discussed previously, the school vaccine exemption rate demonstrates wide geographic variability, from 0.1% in Mississippi to 6.2% in Washington State. But even this hides more extreme regional differences. There are some schools and school districts with much higher exemption rates and dismally poor vaccine coverage. Washington State publishes its school vaccination and vaccine exemption rates. A quick search of their DOH website reveals countywide exemption rates as high as 19%. California also publishes vaccination and personal belief exemption rates on its DPH website. Perusing this data is truly eye-opening and frightening. In Marin County, 7.8% of kindergarten students have been registered as vaccine-exempt by their parents. Some schools in the state have staggeringly high vaccine exemption rates. There is one in which the entire student body is vaccine-exempt. While vaccine exemption rates can tell us much about the trends in parental vaccine hesitancy, it underrepresents the problem. For example, it tells us little if anything about parents who alter the schedule without claiming a formal exemption. An altered schedule may technically meet school vaccine requirements, while still damaging herd immunity and increasing the population risk of disease.
Although the problem of parental vaccine hesitancy in the United States is of critical public health importance, it’s an issue that has been largely ignored. Parents who are concerned may be hesitant to bring it up, as it tends to polarize individuals within communities. While much emphasis is placed on the safety of our children’s environment, from the air they breathe and the water they drink, to the types of foods they eat and the way their fruits and vegetables are grown, few parents give any thought to whether their children are surrounded by the protective shield of community immunization. While this information should be an important consideration when deciding where to send one’s child to school, it isn’t on the minds of most parents, nor is this information typically made available. My state of Massachusetts does not currently publish this data. None of the parents I know have ever thought about the degree to which their children are protected by herd immunity in their school or community. If that data were made available, and the importance of community immunity discussed and pushed more aggressively by providers, public officials, and society in general, perhaps the dangerous trend of vaccine hesitancy would begin to shift. It would be a tragic shame if all of our efforts and dramatic successes were thwarted by the backward antiscience of parental vaccine denialism.
We have also arranged things so that almost no one understands science and technology. This is a prescription for disaster. We might get away with it for a while, but sooner or later this combustible mixture of ignorance and power is going to blow up in our faces.
– Carl Sagan (from The Demon Haunted World)

More Measles Myths
Steven Novella on March 26, 2014
Link
Antivaxxers spread misinformation. This does not have to be the case – I can envision those who wish to function as watchdogs on the vaccine industry or prioritize personal freedom over government programs (even good ones), but who strive to be logical and evidence-based. The culture within the anti-vaccine movement, however, is not logical and evidence-based. Rather, they spread whatever misinformation supports their rather extreme ideology – that vaccines do not work and are dangerous.
Countering anti-vaccine misinformation can be almost a full time job. It is the proverbial game of whack-a-mole, especially in the social media age where old debunked anti-vaccine memes can resurface over and over again on Facebook or Twitter. The game is also rigged in that it is easier to spread fear with misinformation than to reassure with accurate information. Even if we address every anti-vaccine trope, parts of the public can be left with the vague sense that there is something dangerous about vaccines, or that the government is not playing entirely straight with us.
In any case, here is this week’s edition of whack the anti-vaccine mole. The particular varmint that popped its head up recently is the claim that 2-5% of children who receive the MMR vaccine (mumps-measles-rubella trivalent vaccine) contract measles from the vaccine. This specific claim was made on the realfoodeater blog (another thing you should know about the anti-vaccine community is the broad overlap with the natural, alternative medicine, and conspiracy subcultures). The blogger gave as a reference a conversation she had with an unnamed doctor at DeVos Children’s Hospital. 
This, of course, is a huge problem with medical information on social media – much of it is second-hand information passed through non-experts, often through thick ideological filters. Can there be any truth to this particular claim?
The measles component of the MMR vaccine is a live attenuated virus. Some vaccines use only parts of organisms, some used whole killed organisms, and some use live attenuated viruses. A live virus vaccine does cause an actual infection, just a weakened one that the immune system should have no problem fighting off, resulting in lasting immunity without having to suffer from the full-blown illness.
Viruses are attenuated for such vaccines by culturing them in a non-human medium, in this case, chicken embryos. The virus essentially adapts to the non-human host and over time loses its adaptations to humans and so becomes less virulent. In the case of the attenuated measles virus, it replicates much more slowly in human hosts, giving the immune system time to gear up and wipe it out before it can cause any serious problems.
Where the 2-5% figure likely comes from is that this percentage of children who receive the MMR vaccine will get a mild measles-like rash. This is not full-blow measles, however. It is easy to see how the blogger could have misunderstood this kind of information.
In order for the vaccine to cause an actual measles infection the attenuated virus would need to mutate back to its wild type, regaining some of its lost virulence. This can theoretically happen, but is extremely rare.
The meme that kids get measles from the vaccine goes beyond this one blogger. An anti-vaccine chiropractor, Tim O’Shea, makes this claim overtly. He has two references to support his claim – neither of which have anything to do with contracting measles from the vaccine. They report measles outbreaks among high school and secondary school children.
The reports, in fact, demonstrate that the MMR vaccine is mostly effective. These particular outbreaks spread through children who did not have antibodies to the measles virus. In the second report, for example, 99% of the students had been vaccinated, but 4.1% did not seroconvert (in line with other published data on antibody rates in those vaccinated). The outbreak spread only to those without antibodies.
Without the high vaccination rate of this population, the small outbreak could have become a major epidemic. It is entirely unclear how O’Shea concludes from these studies that either vaccines cause measles or that the vaccine does not work. He writes:
Before 1978, measles was a minor, self-limiting, immune-building disease of childhood. You wanted your child to get it because they would have lifetime immunity. Then in 1978, the MMR shot suddenly became part of the vaccine package for all kids. 3 doses. Even though the incidence was down by 90% by then.After a decade or so, many incidents like the 2 cited above began occurring all over the country – groups of kids who obviously got measles from the shot itself. They got the exact disease the shot was pretending to prevent. Such examples continue to the present.
He does not explain how children contracted measles from a vaccine they received over a decade earlier. Here we also see other anti-vaccine memes – that the diseases vaccines prevent are not so bad, and that they were on their way out anyway, and the vaccines just made things worse. This is abject science denial.
This meme is epitomized in the book Melanie’s Marvelous Measles, claiming that it is good for children to contract these diseases as it builds “natural” immunity. I’m still waiting for the sequels – Peter’s Powerful Polio, and Tina’s Terrific Tetanus.
The World Health Organization, however, spells out the real toll of measles:
    • Measles is one of the leading causes of death among young children even though a safe and cost-effective vaccine is available.
    • In 2012, there were 122 000 measles deaths globally – about 330 deaths every day or 14 deaths every hour.
    • Measles vaccination resulted in a 78% drop in measles deaths between 2000 and 2012 worldwide.
Measles is also a significant cause of blindness in developing countries. This is not a benign disease.
The notion that measles builds the immune system is also misleading. The immune system develops perfectly well without this particular infection. Infection results in immunity to measles alone. Of course, vaccination results in immunity to measles with far less risk.
Conclusion
Anti-vaccine sources make demonstrably incorrect claims about diseases and vaccines. This is not a matter of opinion – they are doing it wrong.
The examples above are just the tip of the iceberg. They get the science wrong by making factual errors and misinterpreting the evidence. Further, when their mistakes are pointed out to them, they rarely make corrections. They continue to use the discredited arguments.
This is the pattern of behavior of an ideological group engaging in motivated reasoning. Some of them, however, have computers and spread their misinformation like a virus.
I guess that makes SBM a vaccine in that analogy. Now we just have to figure out how to increase compliance.
Addendum: I had asked the CDC if there were any reported cases of full measles (not just mild symptoms) from the MMR vaccine and this is their response:
We are aware of 3 reported potential cases of measles contracted from the MMR vaccine. These 3 cases are from published reports in persons with immune deficiencies which described measles inclusion body encephalitis after measles vaccination, documented by intranuclear inclusions corresponding to measles virus or the isolation of measles virus from the brain among vaccinated persons. The time from vaccination to development of measles inclusion body encephalitis for these cases was 4–9 months, consistent with development of measles inclusion body encephalitis after infection with wild measles virus. In one case, the measles vaccine strain was identified.
Three total cases, and only one in which the measles vaccine strain was identified. This is out of millions of doses given. This is rare indeed.

Say it ain’t so, Mickey! A holiday measles outbreak makes the happiest place in the world sad
A measles outbreak at the Magic Kingdom? And it’s due to unvaccinated children? Say it ain’t so, Mickey!
David Gorski on January 12, 2015
Link

Last week, the self-proclaimed “happiest place on earth” wasn’t so happy.
One of the disadvantages of posting once a week is that, unless I muscle in on someone else’s day I can’t respond rapidly to stories that appear early. Of course the flip side of that is that if a story appears over the weekend it’s all mine, and, besides, I have my not-so-super-secret other blog to respond to issues that occur earlier in the week. Another advantage is that, if I do decide to write about something from earlier in the week, I have the advantage of time to think.
You’ve probably figured out that what I’m referring to is the latest measles outbreak. Not surprisingly, it happened in the Los Angeles area. Surprisingly (or perhaps not so much), it happened at Disneyland. I say “not surprisingly” because it’s been well-publicized over the last few years that there are pockets of low vaccine uptake and high personal belief exemptions in California, complete with measles and pertussis outbreaks. This is thanks to pockets of affluent, entitled parents full of the Dunning-Kruger effect who think that they can learn as much about vaccines and autism via Google University as pediatricians and researchers who have devoted their entire professional careers to studying them. Of course, these parents are also facilitated by pediatricians who cater to their fears, the most famous of whom is Dr. Bob Sears, whose The Vaccine Book is a very popular, reasonable-sounding (to parents not aware of the antivaccine tropes within) bit of antivax lite, but there is also our old buddy Dr. Jay Gordon and a host of others.
So what happened at Disneyland? On January 7, the California Department of Public Health confirmed seven measles cases:
California Department of Public Health (CDPH) has been notified of seven confirmed cases of measles in patients from five different locations within California it was reported today by Dr. Ron Chapman, CDPH director and state health officer. Two Utah resident cases have also been confirmed and three additional California residents are also suspected to have measles and are under investigation. All confirmed and suspect cases reported visiting Disneyland or Disney California Adventure Park in Orange County, California sometime between December 15 and December 20, 2014.
Based on information from current cases, it is likely that a person infectious with measles was at one of the theme parks on these dates. People can be infectious with measles for nine days. Measles typically begins with fever, cough, runny nose and red eyes and within a few days a red rash appears, usually first on the face and then spreads downward to the rest of the body. Measles is a highly infectious, airborne disease.
By week’s end, health officials were reporting a dozen cases and expecting more to appear. Of the total cases thus far, six of the original seven cases were in unvaccinated children. Late Thursday the health department reported:
Orange County health officials confirmed late Thursday that a total of five more people contracted the disease, bringing the countywide total to six cases.
Of those diagnosed, three were unvaccinated children — who were all old enough to be vaccinated — that contracted measles between Dec. 15 and Dec. 20 at the amusement park, said Orange County Health Care Agency spokeswoman Nicole Stanfield.
Three others are adults; one was unvaccinated, one was partly vaccinated, and one was fully vaccinated. None of the adults were hospitalized, Stanfield said.
On Wednesday, California’s Department of Health reported nine confirmed cases of measles, of which seven cases are in California and two in Utah.
Other sources were reporting that the total had reached 17. It wouldn’t surprise me if, by the time this post goes live, the figures I’m reporting here are outdated and the number of cases goes even higher still. Among these are at least two infants too young to be vaccinated. From what I’ve been able to ascertain, most of the victims were not vaccinated. This is in contrast to other outbreaks, where the majority of those getting the measles were actually vaccinated. Antivaccinationists point to this, crying “Most of the measles cases were vaccinated!” This is a common antivaccine trope that sounds reasonable on the surface. Unfortunately, the measles vaccine is not 100% effective. No vaccine is. It is, however, highly effective, and, if one actually corrects for the percentage of the population that is vaccinated, one invariably finds in such outbreaks that the risk of acquiring measles is much higher in the unvaccinated. In the Disneyland outbreak, antivaccine activists can’t even make that claim, as it appears that the majority of those who caught the measles were either unvaccinated or incompletely vaccinated.
I had never really thought of it before, but a theme park is an excellent incubator for an outbreak of a disease as highly infectious as the measles, particularly a theme park like Disneyland. While many theme parks tend to attract mainly from their region, theme parks like Disneyland, Disneyworld, Universal Studios Orlando, and the like, attract visitors not just from their region but from all over the world. That includes countries where there are ongoing measles outbreaks and high percentages of unvaccinated children. Add to that a location in a state where there are populations of children with low MMR uptake who visit Disneyland too, and the recipe for an outbreak is there. Over the Christmas holidays, it finally happened.
Antivaccine pediatricians run
I’ve mentioned antivaccine and antivaccine-sympathetic physicians in southern California before. It’s not surprising that the most prominent are running like the wind from news of the Disneyland outbreaks.
For example, given that he’s the foremost seemingly “reasonable” promoter of antivaccine pseudoscience, it’s not surprising that Dr. Bob Sears is once again feeling the heat, as well he should. You might recall that, in response to previous outbreaks in southern California, Dr. Bob let loose with a rather despicable couple of posts to his Facebook page, in which he expressed vexation with parents who, rightly concerned about the measles outbreak, were apparently deluging his office with calls of concern and asking if they should get their children vaccinated. His first response to them was basically a highly unprofessional rant entitled “Measles Epidemic…Not!” and boiled down to, in essence, “get the vaccine if you’re worried, but there’s no real reason to worry,” a complete abdication of his professional responsibility as a pediatrician. He also downplayed the significance of the measles outbreak in a fashion completely unbecoming a pediatrician (or physician of any kind). Basically, Dr. Bob’s message was: Don’t worry, be happy, and, if you’re worrying and not happy, get the vaccine. Just don’t bother me about it anymore. Oh, and you nasty pro-science vaccine supporters (whom he described as “mandatory vaccine militants”) out there are big meanies for pointing out that I’m irresponsible and antivaccine.
So great was the heat Sears felt, even from his own “vaccine-averse patients,” that he felt obligated to post a follow-up. And so he did in a Facebook post entitled “Orange County Measles Epidemic . . . Not (yet, anyway)!” This time, the message, also highly unprofessional, boiled down to, “Don’t worry, be happy, and if you’re worrying and not happy get the vaccine. Just don’t bother me about it anymore.” Oh, and “I’m giving informed consent.” The problem, as we’ve documented many times here, is that Dr. Bob and his fellow antivaccine activists don’t give informed consent. They provide “misinformed consent” that vastly inflates the risks of vaccines, attributes nonexistent risks to them (such as autism; more on that later), and minimizes the benefits of vaccines.
This time around, Dr. Bob appears to have learned a lesson from his previous crybaby outbursts. He’s managed to control his petulance a little better. On Thursday, he wrote a post entitled “Measles Makes a Stop at Disneyland“. His tone is much more measured, but underneath lies the same old attitude, in particular his downplaying the seriousness of the measles. Indeed, after acknowledging that the measles can be “miserable,” well, here’s how Dr. Bob put it:
The bad news – although I make light of people’s tendency to panic unnecessarily, measles is no laughing matter for those who are exposed to one of these nine cases. Although most cases pass harmlessly in the long run, it is a miserable week. Severe complications are very rare, thankfully. But moderate complications, like pneumonia, can occur. It can also be more severe for infants and for pregnant moms and for immunocompromised people. Our hearts go out to any of these high-risk people who are exposed. But most complications are manageable. So, it is a worry for exposed people, I know. But for the public at large, we should just go about life as usual. For anyone exposed to those nine, you are being managed by your doctor and the health department.
As with all previous measles outbreaks, there’s no reason to panic. Here is some info to know:
If vaccinated with one dose of MMR, you have a 95% chance of being immune. If two doses of MMR, 99% chance. But this isn’t perfect. As you will read in the link, one of the cases was fully vaccinated.
Make light of people’s tendency to panic? A more accurate way of saying it would be that Dr. Bob heaped scorn on people’s concerns, not just once but twice. Still, at least he acknowledges the potential complications, but even then he can’t resist downplaying their seriousness. Pneumonia a “moderate complication”? No, it’s a serious complication that very frequently requires hospitalization. I suppose it’s a minor victory, though, that he acknowledges that the MMR is highly effective, particularly when multiple doses have been received, but one still can’t help but note that Dr. Bob had to harp on the fact based on information available at the time that one of the cases was fully vaccinated.
Meanwhile, I had an exchange with our old buddy Dr. Jay Gordon on Twitter, based on this Tweet:
Yes, there have been cases of Disney spread from Measlesland. I will give MMRs to kids 3 yrs+ if parents are worried.
— Jay Gordon, MD, FAAP (@JayGordonMDFAAP) January 8, 2015
Of course, the CDC recommends that children receive their first dose of the MMR vaccine between age 12 and 18 months. So what’s this with Dr. Jay’s obfuscating? I and others asked him on Twitter:
.@JayGordonMDFAAP You should be giving MMR to kids according to the @CDCgov recommendation, not "because parents are worried.
— David Gorski (@gorskon) January 10, 2015
Dr. Jay responded to me and others:
@scottmyers20 @gorskon @cdcgov The MMR vaccine may not be inherently unsafe but it appears safer to give it after age three years.
— Jay Gordon, MD, FAAP (@JayGordonMDFAAP) January 10, 2015
To which I responded:
.@JayGordonMDFAAP @ScottMyers20 @CDCgov That's nonsense, but assume for 1 min. it's true. Do you recommend MMR for all your patients over 3?
— David Gorski (@gorskon) January 10, 2015
Dr. Jay responded:
@gorskon @scottmyers20 @cdcgov Great question, David. My thoughts have changed because of colleges requiring MMR and travel while pregnant.
— Jay Gordon, MD, FAAP (@JayGordonMDFAAP) January 10, 2015
Which wasn’t an answer. So I and others pestered him. Finally, he said:
@doritmi and if the parent, worried about this outbreak, wants MMR for their one year old?___I give them the MMR. My reluctance is secondary
— Jay Gordon, MD, FAAP (@JayGordonMDFAAP) January 10, 2015
And:
@doritmi But I don't fee; great about the timing. I think the MMR risk is minimized by waiting until age three. But parents decide, not me.
— Jay Gordon, MD, FAAP (@JayGordonMDFAAP) January 10, 2015
So, as I’ve observed before, Dr. Jay won’t give the MMR (or, it would seem, any vaccine) unless the parent badgers him to do it. Basically, like Dr. Bob, he washes his hands of the decision (and therefore responsibility) to vaccinate, justifying it by saying he’s just letting the parents choose. The problem is that he’s “letting them choose” based on misinformed consent, in which his copious statements expressing “concern” about vaccines, invoking the “toxins” gambit, and likening vaccine manufacturers to tobacco companies, as he states unequivocally that vaccine cause autism.
Not coincidentally, after Dr. Jay was cornered on Twitter, he had a couple of new posts on his blog to justify his “concern” for vaccinating children under three. First, he referenced the conspiracy-laden “#CDCWhistleblower” manufactured scandal and referred to the original paper by DeStefano et al. to justify his concern about vaccinating children under three. As I explained in three lengthy posts, neither that study, Brian Hooker’s now-retracted paper, nor William Thompson’s conscience tortured over fairy dust, show that the MMR vaccine causes autism when given before age 3. Dr. Jay clearly misunderstands the science.
Dr. Jay’s second post is entitled “The MMR is not controversial because of Wakefield“, a title that almost destroyed my keyboard, as I was foolishly taking a sip of my Sunday morning coffee when I first read it. Key gems:
The vaccine is best given later because it can cause large side effects in a small percentage of kids when given at 12-15 months. Parents’ testimony, the above CDC publication and much more supports this conclusion.
Dr. Jay provides no evidence to support this and no citations, but this is of a piece with what Dr. Jay contributed to the response to the earlier measles outbreaks in southern California. His letter to his patients basically echoed Dr. Bob, saying, “If you would like the MMR vaccine, feel free to get it.”
He then concludes:
When we coerce parents into vaccinating their children younger than they feel comfortable doing, we diminish their confidence in their doctors and compromise our ability to continue the dialogue about vaccines and all aspects of their children’s care. If one really cares about herd immunity–and I do–respecting parents’ decisions is crucial.
Of course, a huge part of “respecting parents’ decisions” is to give the parents accurate scientific and medical information, rather than antivaccine fear mongering. If parents’ pediatricians say or imply that vaccinating (or vaccinating before a certain age) is dangerous when it’s not, the parents will likely believe it, particularly if they are predisposed to believe bad things about vaccines. Dr. Jay, whether knowingly or unknowingly, presents a slanted case to his patients’ parents, thus making it highly unlikely that they will agree to the MMR before age 3. Of course, if Dr. Jay doesn’t even offer it before age 3 and has to be pummeled by pro-vaccine parents into giving the vaccine earlier, then very few of his patients will get it before age 3. Parents who have to badger their child’s pediatrician to vaccinate will pretty quickly realize that this is not the pediatrician for them and find another who vaccinates according to the CDC schedule. Dr. Jay’s patients are thus self-selected to be vaccine-averse, and he caters to that. After all, he is well known as Evan’s pediatrician (Jenny McCarthy’s son) and has even written the foreword of one of her books.
Unfortunately, the problem of pediatricians who are either antivaccine, antivaccine-sympathetic, or have come to cater to vaccine-averse parents is a huge problem in California. There are, not surprisingly, pediatricians who aren’t as famous as Dr. Bob Sears or Dr. Jay Gordon contributing to this problem. They are misleading parents and catering to the scientifically-unfounded fears of others.
Meanwhile, VaxTruth.org posted a highly misinformation- and fallacy-laden response to the Disneyland measles outbreak, complete with one of the most intellectually-dishonest antivaccine tropes out there, the infamous “vaccines didn’t save us” trope. It was coupled, of course, with a “What, me worry?” trope in which the writer did everything she could to downplay the seriousness of the measles. It might be worth a separate post.
No, vaccines do not cause autism
Ironically, just before news of the Disneyland measles outbreak hit the press, a mere couple of days into 2015 there was published a study that reinforced the already copious scientific evidence that neither the MMR nor thimerosal preservative in childhood vaccines is associated with autism. The study was entitled “Early exposure to the combined measles–mumps–rubella vaccine and thimerosal-containing vaccines and risk of autism spectrum disorder” and comes to us courtesy of Nagoya University, the Yokohama Psycho-Developmental Clinic, Fukushima University, and Juntendo University.
I realize that I’ve already given away the punchline, namely that this is yet another in a long line of studies that failed to find a link between vaccines (in particular the MMR) and autism or between thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism, but the journey to refuting antivaccine quackery with pseudoscience is more than half the pleasure. So let’s take a look.
The authors started out discussing the studies that didn’t find a link between either MMR vaccination and autism, or between thimerosal-containing vaccines and autism. So why did they bother to do a new study? Their rationale is actually kind of interesting:
However, most studies have not considered vaccinations’ timing and the subject’s racial heterogeneity even though genetic factors are known to be strongly involved in ASD onset. As an investigation that specified the race of the study participants, we conducted a case–control study from the Japanese population [19]. Japanese people were proven to be highly genetically homogenous according to the genotyping results of 140,387 single nucleotide polymorphisms [20]. In our previous study, there was not any convincing evidence that MMR vaccination was associated with an increased risk of ASD in Japanese people. However, the effects due to the differences in vaccinations timing and the amount of exposure to thimerosal were not accounted for in this study.
OK, fair enough. The Japanese are a pretty genetically homogeneous people compared to most other areas where the question of whether vaccines cause autism has been studied, but, given the multiple resoundingly negative studies done before, it’s highly unlikely that doing it again in the Japanese would provide a different result, and it didn’t. Don’t get me wrong. This is a good study and is an important addition to the existing body of evidence supporting vaccine safety. It’s just irksome how the antivaccine movement forces scientists to reinvent the wheel again and again.
What about the study itself? It’s a case-control study, which means looking at vaccine history in autism cases versus controls after controlling for known confounders and determining if there are differences in MMR vaccination or thimerosal exposure. Basically, vaccination histories at 1, 3, 6, 12, 18, 24, and 36 months from birth were investigated in ASD cases (189 samples) and controls (224 samples) matching age and sex in each case. Crude odds ratios (ORs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were calculated. Then dosages of MMR vaccine and thimerosal were examined and investigated using a conditional multiple-regression model in order to determine if there were is any relationship between autism and overall exposure. The population providing case data came from the Yokohama Psycho-Developmental Clinic (YPDC), a clinic that only accepts patients with suspected neurodevelopmental disorders. Eligible case subjects were evaluated by the YPDC between April 1997 and March 2011 and were (1) diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder and (2) had been born between April 1, 1986 and April 30, 1992.
There’s also a quirk in how the cases were chosen based on the unique situation in Japan with respect to the MMR vaccine:
MMR vaccination in Japan was conducted under specific circumstances and for only a short period of time. A combined MMR vaccination program commenced from April 1989, and only one vaccination using MMR was included in the immunization schedule. The monovalent mumps, measles, and rubella vaccines remained the optimal choice of vaccine for those who did not participate in the MMR program. However, soon after the immunization program had started, there were several cases of aseptic meningitis, which may have been caused by the mumps vaccine [31]. As a result, in April 1993, the Government ceased extensive inoculation with MMR. Therefore, children who were born from April 1984 to April 1992 could receive MMR vaccination. However, children who were born between April 1984 and March 1986 were able to receive it after the age of three. Therefore, they were excluded from the samples, because autism features always appear before the age of three. As a result, children who were born from April 1986 to April 1992 were included in the present study.
These days, Japan still vaccinates against measles, but, because it was the mumps component of the MMR vaccine used in Japan that caused problems over 20 years ago, the Japanese now require a combined measles-rubella (MR) vaccine instead, which is mandatory. The mumps component is voluntary but recommended. Of course, it’s hard not to note that autism rates continued to rise in Japan even after the discontinuation of the use of MMR-combined vaccine and substitution with two separate vaccines that, together, cover the same diseases. Same as it ever was. As far as science has been able to ascertain after much trying, vaccines don’t cause autism; so it should not be surprising that discontinuing a vaccine demonized as the cause of autism does not result in a decline in autism prevalence.
In any case, the control group consisted of age- and sex-matched subjects recruited as volunteers from general schools in the Kanto area, which is the same area where YPDC patients live. Students who had previously been diagnosed with developmental disorders or problems were excluded.
So what were the results? I already told you, but it’s worth quoting the study:
There were no significant differences in MMR vaccination and thimerosal dosage between cases and controls at any age. Furthermore, the ORs (95% CIs) of MMR vaccination and thimerosal dosage associated with ASD in the conditional multiple regression model were, respectively, 0.875 (0.345–2.222) and 1.205 (0.862–1.683) at age 18 months, 0.724 (0.421–1.243) and 1.343 (0.997–1.808) at 24 months, and 1.040 (0.648–1.668) and 0.844 (0.632–1.128) at 36 months. Thus, there were no significant differences.
The authors thus quite properly concluded that there was no convincing evidence that MMR vaccination or increasing thimerosal dose are associated with an increased risk of ASD onset. Once again, there was not a whiff of a whisper of a hint of elevated MMR or thimerosal exposure in the case group compared to controls. A key strength of this study is that parents of children receive a document referred to as the Maternal and Child Health (MCH) handbook, which is described by the authors as a “highly reliable data record of early development, health, and immunization, and the data are recorded by health professionals (e.g., public health nurses, obstetricians, and pediatricians).” This allowed the investigators to access detailed, accurate immunization records for cases and controls, and they excluded subjects in which entries regarding vaccines in the MCH handbook were missing or illegible. This allowed not only accurate assessment of the number of MMR vaccines each subject received, but also the total dose of thimerosal received by each subject.
So once again, a year starts out with researchers asking the questions:
    • Is MMR vaccination associated with an increased risk of autism?
    • Is thimerosal exposure in vaccines associated with an increased risk of autism?
Again, the answers to these questions are no and no. Vaccines do not cause autism. Again.
In fact, so common is this finding now that, contrary to the Disneyland measles outbreak, I didn’t see a single news story about this study. That’s rather unfortunate, because I believe that it helps to publicize such studies as yet another example of the depth and breadth of the evidence that has failed to find a link between vaccines and autism and to counter the misinformation spread by the antivaccine movement and, even worse, by pediatricians who should know better.
It’s not at all surprising that the first measles outbreak of 2015 (or the last measles outbreak of 2014, depending upon how you want to look at it) occurred in southern California. It’s one of the best places in the country for it. Unfortunately, the same sort of attitudes have infested my state, as evidenced by recent measles and pertussis outbreaks here. The attitudes are the same, and the results are the same. We’re just fortunate enough not to have an international destination that packs children of all ages from all over the world together as a place to facilitate outbreaks.

The Disneyland measles outbreak: “Dr. Bob” Sears says measles isn’t that bad, and an antivaccine activist invokes the Brady Bunch fallacy
One argument antivaxers frequently make about the measles is that it’s not dangerous. As “evidence” of this contention, they will often cite examples of sitcoms and cartoons from a half a century ago or more when measles was played for laughs. This is a fallacious argument, and there was a profound disconnect between the popular perception of measles and its reality.
David Gorski on January 19, 2015
Link

Editor’s note: There is an extra special bonus guest post today in addition to my regular post. It’s by Paul Knoepfler, a stem cell biologist, and it’s about unregulated stem cell clinics. Be sure to check it out!

Last week, I wrote about a rather impressive measles outbreak at the “happiest place on earth,” a.k.a. Disneyland. At the time I wrote that post, the outbreak, which had reached several states, had spread to 17 people. As I sat down to write this, I wasn’t actually sure that this topic needed another post, but then I saw this:
As the number of measles cases continues to rise in Southern California following an outbreak at Disneyland last month, about two dozen unvaccinated students at one Orange County high school have been forced to stay home after a classmate contracted the disease.
In a message to students and parents at Huntington Beach High School on Thursday, Pamela Kahn, health and wellness coordinator at the Orange County Department of Education, said that students “who do not have any documented [measles, mumps and rubella] immunizations will be excluded from attending school until January 29.”
Also, the number of confirmed measles cases has climbed to 52, 46 of them in southern California. In Orange County itself, there were 16 cases as of Friday, ten of them linked to Disneyland, the rest not, a finding that’s led health officials to conclude that “measles has become more widespread throughout the county.” Not surprisingly, health officials in Californian are warning that the number is likely to go higher still. In fact, it’s already happening as “satellite” outbreaks are being reported as children infected at Disneyland come home and infect others.
Meanwhile:
A South Pasadena woman’s younger sister came down with the measles. Now, federal health officials want her locked down under quarantine, but she is resisting.
Ylsa Tellez is a 26-year-old grad student whose younger sister, 24-year-old Maura Tellez, was one of the confirmed cases of measles caught recently at Disneyland.
And:
“(They were) saying I need to get vaccinated and I need to be quarantined, otherwise I’m going to go to jail or something, or I’m going to get a misdemeanor,” said Ylsa.
Ylsa says she refuses to be a prisoner in her own home despite the possible quarantine order. Ylsa’s mother is also defending her daughter.
“It’s not nice when my daughter is threatened like this because she’s not even sick,” said Myrna Tellez.
No, but she’s been exposed. The reason to quarantine someone who has been exposed is because that person can be infectious before symptoms appear. That’s very reason for quarantines, and always has been, to keep people who have been exposed isolated until health officials can be sure that they aren’t contagious. One comment I saw about this issue (several comments, actually) questioned why we quarantine someone like Tellez but not Ebola patients. When I see a question like this, I want to respond: How is this thing not like the other? Measles is incredibly contagious through respiratory contact. In contrast, Ebola is not. It requires close personal contact with infected bodily fluids. Quarantine can stop the spread of a disease like measles; for Ebola it’s a lot more dicey.
As I discussed last week, the majority of the measles cases thus far have occurred in the unvaccinated. More importantly, the association of this outbreak with Disneyland gives this story legs. It’s drawn international attention of a very negative kind on how the antivaccine movement has spread misinformation and frightened parents, thus contributing to declines in vaccine uptake, which in turn have led to pockets of vaccine uptake sufficiently low as to permit, facilitate even, outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases. The heat has come down particularly hard on certain antivaccine-friendly pediatricians in the area, such as our old friend Dr. Jay Gordon in Santa Monica and, of course, Dr. Bob Sears in Capistrano Beach, right in Orange County itself. I took Sears to task last time for having downplayed previous measles outbreaks, treating the parents of his patients condescendingly by basically waving them away and telling them to get the damned shot if they’re worried but stop bugging him.
I exaggerate, but not by much.
What really make up my mind to follow up on this outbreak is that, over the last week, I’ve noticed that the antivaccine movement is pushing back. Stung by the publicity and criticism, they’re pulling out all the stops—or should I say tropes?—to deflect attention. Even “Dr. Bob” has gotten into the act, dropping all pretense of not being antivaccine, as he pulls out an old chestnut, much beloved of antivaccinationists since time immemorial (or at least for the last couple of decades). I like to call it the argumentum ad Brady Bunchium. Sometimes I call it the “appeal to the Brady Bunch” or, more generally, the “appeal to classic television” vaccine fallacy. What do I mean by that?
This antivaccine trope is a claim that the measles just isn’t that serious a disease, followed by the question or implication: Why are we worrying about it so much? Examples of this fallacy include this video, Measles, Back In The Days Before The Marketing Of The Vaccine:
The video above includes clips from The Donna Reed Show (specifically this episode), The Flintstones, and The Brady Bunch about the measles. It’s a theme repeated by, for example, the antivaccine crank blog Age of Autism (AoA) in posts like this one entitled “Before Fear Sold Vaccines, Children Got Sick… On TV Even” and “Measles and Chicken Pox: Entertainment or Epidemic?” [NOTE ADDED 1/26/2015: And AoA has brought up the “appeal to Brady Bunch” again with A Very Brady Measles.] You get the idea. Back in the days before vaccines for measles and various other childhood diseases, almost everybody got these diseases as a child. For most children, they were usually self-limited diseases and no big whoop, right? Just another childhood disease that most children had to endure, right? After all, Hollywood included bits about measles in sitcoms and cartoons, such that Donna Reed and the Brady Bunch didn’t think it was a big deal. In fact, all the kids were happy not to have to go to school and sat around smiling and playing Monopoly! About the only thing that the writers get right is that the measles is contagious as hell, but that only provided more grist for the comedy mill to make jokes about all the kids coming down with measles, and then Mike and Alice too. Only Carol escaped because, as we learn in the last scene, she had had the measles “years ago.” In fact, for completion’s sake, here’s the entire episode, in case you’re interested:
Of course, I can’t help but see that episode of The Brady Bunch and wonder why Mike and Carol hadn’t gotten at least some of their kids vaccinated. After all, the vaccine was licensed in 1963, and that show first aired in 1969. Not surprisingly, given how effective the measles vaccine has been, by 1969 the incidence of measles had already plummeted dramatically:
Not that one would expect comedy writers to be familiar with vaccine recommendations at the time, but based on past recommended vaccination schedules, it might have been unsurprising that the older kids were unvaccinated, but one would think that the younger children would have been. Also, by 1969, measles incidence had become so much less common, particularly in children under 10, that one can’t help but think some fuzzy-headed and nostalgic writers were a bit behind the times. After all, The Brady Bunch wasn’t exactly a font of scientific knowledge. For instance, I remember an infamous three-part “very special episode” of the show (parts 1, 2, 3) where the family vacationed in Hawaii and Bobby found a tiki statue claimed to cause bad luck. Once the tiki statue was in Bobby’s possession, all sorts of bad things started happening to the family, including a surfing accident and Peter nearly being bitten by a tarantula. In the story, there was a curse that couldn’t be lifted until the tiki was returned to an ancient burial ground. I suppose antivaccinationists would use that The Brady Bunch story as an example of how people understood back in 1972 that there actually do exist tiki statues in Hawaii that confer extreme bad luck on the ones who possess them. That’s the quality of argument here: Silly, vacuous, and a non sequitur.
In any case, the essence of the argumentum ad Brady Bunchium fallacy with respect to vaccines is that measles was no big deal before the vaccine and that pharmaceutical companies and health officials are stoking unneeded fear of measles in order to sell the vaccine, through a combination of desire for profits and ideology. In fact, if you peruse the more stinky cesspits of antivaccine nonsense (such as the comments in AoA), you’ll see commenters, particularly older ones who were children before the measles vaccine was available in the early 1960s and/or who had had the measles themselves sometime during the 1940s-1960s frequently referencing the above YouTube video to argue that measles is nothing, that it’s something “we” all had and did just fine. It’s very much of a piece with curmudgeons of a certain age (which, unfortunately, includes my age) complaining about today’s youth and pointing out how they used to walk to school in the snow and uphill both ways or the occasional equally cranky rants by surgeons trained before work hour limitations (like me) about how they loved being on call every second or third night and spending 100+ hours a week in the hospital, the only problem with every other night call being that you miss half the cases. It’s basically an assertion of superiority and toughness by the older generation over the younger, the sort of thing that’s been going on hundreds of years.
Indeed, if you really want to see this sort of approach taken to an extreme, just check out VaxTruth.org the website of Marcella Piper-Terry, a woman who is known for her extreme antivaccine views to the point where she has likened vaccination to rape and has recently been ranting about the “civil rights violations” of quarantine for measles. In a series of posts, Piper-Terry has argued, echoing the argumentum ad Brady Bunchium, that measles is not harmful and that measles is even good for you, citing a rather interesting experiment in which massive doses of the measles vaccine has been used experimentally to treat cancer based on case reports of spontaneous regression of Hodgkin’s lymphoma in children after measles infection.
Piper-Terry even cites an abstract from a fundamentalist Catholic scientist named Theresa Deisher, who through her Sound Choice Pharmaceutical Institute (SCPI), has been trying to prove that DNA from “aborted fetuses” in vaccines is responsible for autism through its ability to recombine with the infant’s DNA. It’s very much of a piece with the same sort of nonsense peddled by Helen Ratajczak in a truly awful “review” article published four years ago that keeps being resurrected, Michael Myers-like, every so often. The sad thing is, Dr. Deisher is a real molecular biologist and really should know better, but apparently does not, at least not any more since she became an “adamant right-to-lifer.” Like the case of Peter Duesberg and his HIV/AIDS denialism, Dr. Deisher has become full-on antivaccine based on the use of cell lines derived from a fetus decades ago to manufacture some vaccines. In some of her posts, she even invokes the intellectually-dishonest gambit beloved of antivaccinationists I dubbed “vaccines didn’t save us.”
Particularly despicable in Piper-Terry’s post is how she zeroes in on 450 people dying each year of the measles in the US in the years before the vaccine was licensed dividing by the entire US population of 189 million at the time, and concluding that only 0.000237% of the US population died of the measles each year. In fact, in the post referenced by Piper-Terry entitled “Putting Measles Into Perspective“, her friend Dawn Babcock Papple even asks rhetorically about the number of people dying of the measles world-wide, “When over 150,000 people die each day total, is 540 people dying of measles each day really that outrageous?”
The entire attitude is that the 450 deaths from measles each year in the US before the licensing of the vaccine and the 197,000 people dying worldwide of measles now are inconsequential. I kid you not. See why I call this attitude so despicable? I suppose according to these two antivaccine warriors, the last major measles outbreak in the US before the current one, in which 55,000 cases and more than 120 measles-related deaths were reported, also wasn’t a big deal. What’s a few hundred dead children, after all, compared to freedom from the evils of vaccines? This is what Dr. Paul Offit spoke about in his talk at TAM last year, and his description of watching children die of the measles was incredibly depressing.
Sadly, “Dr. Bob” has traveled far down the same sort of path as Piper-Terry, at least in terms of echoing her sentiment, and that of many antivaccine activists, that measles is “no big deal.” True, he isn’t as crass or callous about it, expressing sympathy for people outside the US who die of measles, but his arguments, at their core, are very much the same as those of Piper-Terry and Papple, although he at least is not foolish enough to use the “vaccines didn’t save us” gambit. Last week, Dr. Bob posted this update on the Disneyland measles outbreak on his Facebook page entitled “JUST HOW DEADLY IS MEASLES?” In it, Dr. Bob strives mightily to convince his readers that the measles is no big whoop. I’m reprinting the complete text, in case Dr. Bob has second thoughts and sends his Facebook post below down the old memory hole, not to mention for the benefit of those of you who don’t have Facebook accounts:
Post by Dr. Bob Sears.
The full text of Dr. Bob’s little rant follows:
What makes measles so scary? What is it about measles that spreads fear and dread through our population? Three things, in my opinion, set it apart from most infectious diseases that make us afraid: 1. It’s untreatable, and it has a high rate of complications, so we are at it’s [sic] mercy, 2. It’s been virtually eliminated from the U.S., so we aren’t used to it anymore, and 3. It’s potentially fatal.
Now, let’s play two truths and a lie. Two of these statements are true, and one is not. Well, the one that is not is technically true, but it’s not true in all practical terms.
1. Untreatable? Correct. There is no anti-viral medication that will help, so we just have to stand by as the disease runs its course. We are powerless, and that creates fear. We don’t want to take a risk with something which we have no way to mitigate or control. The only thing that may make measles less severe is high dose Vitamin A therapy (which is approved by the WHO). But that’s not an anti-viral med; it just helps us fight it off a little better.
Complications? Ear infection is the most likely complication – treatable. Pneumonia is next – also treatable. Ya, you don’t want those things to happen, but they are treatable. Encephalitis? That’s much worse. Fortunately it’s extremely rare in well-nourished people (see below).
So, the lie is that measles has a high rate of serious complications. It doesn’t. It CAN, but it rarely does.
2. Eliminated? Virtually. Over the past 20 years we’ve sometimes only had 50 cases a year. Sometimes 150. Nobody knows measles anymore, and when we are ignorant of something unfamiliar, we fear it until we understand it.
Ask any Grandma or Grandpa (well, older ones anyway), and they’ll say “Measles? So what? We all had it. It’s like Chicken pox.” Ask a twenty-five-year-old mom with two young kids, and she’ll scoop up her kids and run away from you for even mentioning the M word.
If you understand measles, you wouldn’t fear it. Respect it.
I do acknowledge that it’s a public health nightmare in that it takes a lot of effort and money to contain these outbreaks. And it causes a lot of people to get tested, quarantined, or treated with preventive immune globulin shots. It’s no joke. But, those efforts are largely because we are trying to contain it, not because it’s going to kill everybody. So, not fear – respect.
3. Potentially fatal? Technically true, but herein lies the lie. It’s been publicized as “the deadliest of all childhood fever/rash illness with a high rate of complications.” Deadly? Not in the U.S., or any other developed country with a well-nourished population. The risk of fatality here isn’t zero, but it’s as close to zero as you can get without actually being zero. It’s 1 in many thousands. Will someone pass away in the U.S. from measles one of these years? Tragically yes. That will likely happen to one person. It hasn’t happened here in at least ten years (or more – I don’t even know how many years we have to go back to find one). When that happens, it will be extremely tragic.
But will it spread through the U.S. and kill people left and right? No. Does measles do that in underdeveloped countries? Sadly, yes. It kills countless people worldwide every year. So, that’s how health officials can accurately say it’s so deadly. They don’t have to tell you the whole truth, just the part of the truth that they want you to believe.
Measles can also be serious for young infants, just as many diseases can. It can also be serious for immunocompromised people, just as all illnesses. It can also cause pregnancy complications, just like many infections can. Measles isn’t unique in these risks. But they are risks nonetheless.
So, fear measles? No. Not in the U.S.. Respect measles? Yes. Take appropriate precautions with it. But don’t let anyone tell you you should live in fear of it. Let’s handle it calmly and without fear or blame.
“Without blame”? As in, “Don’t blame me for the consequences of what I’ve been saying and doing for all these years”? Nice try, Dr. Bob. You’re not getting off that easily, nor will you be so easily allowed to shift the blame to the parents who listened to you rather than your own words and behavior. In fact, Dr. Bob’s reminded me of so much of an antivaccine meme originated at The Vaccine Machine, a virulently and unfortunately popular Facebook page run by the equally virulent and antivaccine Robert Schecter (known on my not-so-super-secret other blog as Sid Offit) that’s dedicated to trashing vaccines and spreading antivaccine pseudoscience that I just had to post it here:
Yes, notice how Dr. Bob even invokes a variant of the “argumentum ad Brady Bunchium” fallacy when he mentions how “grandma and grandpa” poo-poo the measles as being “just like the chicken pox” and dismiss it with, “We all had it,” an attitude that he compares to that of a 25-year-old mother who’s never seen the measles before and therefore fears it because she doesn’t know it. It’s a rather clever inversion of the argument frequently used by pro-vaccine bloggers that points out that the reason parents don’t fear vaccine-preventable diseases anymore—the usual example used being polio—is because they’ve never personally witnessed the death and complications these diseases used to cause. In retrospect, I’m actually a bit surprised Dr. Bob didn’t mention the infamous “measles” episode of The Brady Bunch, actually. Come on, Dr. Bob. Let it out! You know you want to!
On that note, after having read Dr. Bob’s treatise above, I’d like you to go and read Marcella Piper-Terry’s initial response to the Disneyland measles outbreak from January 8 entitled “Measles at Disneyland!” Can you tell the difference? Other than Piper-Terry’s longer post, with calculations designed to make you think that measles was never a big deal, Dr. Bob is using exactly the same arguments without adding the calculations, in particular the key argument being that measles in developed countries is not a threat, only in those “other” people in Third World countries who aren’t as developed as we are because, you know, we’re superior. Measles doesn’t kill very many of us compared to those poor, blighted savages! (I exaggerate, but, I contend, only a little.) He dismisses complications of measles as being “treatable” and therefore of little consequence. In fact, he makes it sound as though a measles-associated ear infection is equivalent to measles-associated pneumonia, dismissing them both as “treatable” with a jaunty, “Ya, you don’t want those things to happen, but they are treatable.” Never mind that many, if not most, cases of measles-associated pneumonia require hospitalization, many also requiring an ICU stay. As Dr. Roy Benaroch sarcastically puts it in his post entitled “Dr. Sears continues to salute our children with his middle finger“, many parents would indeed consider an ICU stay “somewhat of an inconvenience.” (I like Dr. Benaroch’s style.)
Think of it this way. According to the CDC, before the vaccine, 48,000 people a year were hospitalized for the measles; 4,000 developed measles-associated encephalitis; and 400 to 500 people died. By any stretch of the imagination that was a significant public health problem, and the introduction of the measles vaccine in 1963, followed by the MMR in 1971, made it much less so. As Dr. John Snyder reminded us five years ago responding to Dr. Sears making the same arguments in his book, measles is not a benign disease, regardless of what popular culture thought of it 50 or 60 years ago.
Of course, even Dr. Bob has to concede that measles-associated encephalitis is a Very Bad Thing, but he dismisses the risk with an equally jaunty rejoinder that encephalitis is “extremely rare in well-nourished people” (i.e., his well-off patients at whom his Facebook post is aimed). As for death, Dr. Bob’s message is, “Don’t worry, be happy.” After all, according to him, the risk of fatality is “as close to zero as you can get without actually being zero,” or one in many thousands. Funny how Dr. Bob (and the antivaccine activists to whom he panders) dismiss a possibility of death of this magnitude as being of no consequence; yet, a one in a million chance of Guillan-Barre disease after the meningococcal vaccine (or a one in several hundred thousand risk of severe reactions to vaccines in general) is completely unacceptable. Indeed, if you accept at face value Dr. Bob’s grossly-exaggerated estimate for a severe vaccine reaction of one in 100,000, by Dr. Bob’s own definition, the risk of severe reactions to any given vaccine is even lower than “as close to zero as you can get without actually being zero.” Even if you accept Dr. Bob’s even more ridiculously inflated estimate that the risk that “any one child will suffer a severe reaction over the entire, twelve-year vaccine schedule is about 1 in 2600,” I can’t help but note that we’re now in the range of the likelihood of a child with measles dying due to this disease in the United states. To Bob, the risk of these vaccine injuries is unacceptable, but a similar or much higher risk of death if a child catches the measles is just the cost of doing antivaccine business. According to Dr. Bob, yes, sooner or later a child is going to die of the measles—and won’t that be so tragic?—but it’ll likely only be one.
Hypocrisy, thy name is Bob Sears.
If Bob Sears weren’t such a worthless excuse for a pediatrician when it comes to promoting misinformation about vaccines, I’d almost feel sorry for him. Almost. He is, however, a perfect example of what the phrase “hoist with his own petard” means. Dr. Bob has for years made a profitable career for himself as the “reasonable” face of the vaccine-averse, painting himself as not like all those other loony antivaccinationists out there but rather as a reasonable pediatrician taking a “middle way” and “listening to parents.” Now the consequences of the ideas Dr. Bob has promoted are starting to become apparent, with measles outbreaks becoming increasingly common right on his home turf, leading the parents of his patients to ask him what to do now that the low vaccine uptake encouraged by him are facilitating measles outbreaks like the most recent one in Disneyland. They are asking him for guidance, and he’s fobbing off the responsibility on them, telling them just to “get the vaccine” and if you “don’t want the vaccine, accept the risk.” Nice.
I’ve been fearing for a long time that the US was only several years behind the United Kingdom and Europe when it comes to suffering a major resurgence of the measles and that such a resurgence was coming. I hope I’m wrong, but I fear that 2015 might finally be the tipping point when measles really comes roaring back to levels not seen in a quarter century or even more. If that happens, Dr. Bob Sears will have to take his share of the blame for cashing in on fear and driving vaccination rates down. He’s not alone.

The measles vaccine protects against more than just the measles
David Gorski on May 11, 2015
Link

One of the disadvantages of writing for this blog is that sometimes I feel as though I spend so much time deconstructing bad science and pseudoscience in medicine that I’m rarely left with the time or the opportunity to discuss some interesting science. Of course, even when I do that, usually it’s in the context of that very same bad science or pseudoscience, and this post won’t be different. Still, there was some interesting science with respect to vaccines published last week in Science, and I think it’s worth looking over. The only thing that surprises me is that the antivaccine movement hasn’t jumped all over it yet. On the other hand, its press coverage was relatively minimal, and I didn’t really notice it until an article appeared on (sadly, yes) The Huffington Post entitled “The Measles Vaccine Can Protect Against Much More Than Measles, According To New Study“:
A new study suggests the measles shot comes with a bonus: By preventing that disease, the vaccine may also help your body fight off other illnesses for years.
It’s long been known that contracting measles weakens the immune system for weeks or months, putting people, especially children, at increased risk for potentially fatal infection by a host of germs.
Now, scientists find that this vulnerable period goes on much longer than thought, up to three years. So the benefit of avoiding measles also extends longer than was appreciated. Researchers also found that measles vaccination campaigns were followed by a drop in deaths for other infectious diseases.
Experts said the work is a wake-up call to parents who don’t vaccinate their children out of unfounded fears about a link between vaccines and autism.
Or, as is reported in more detail in this NPR story, this is what happened after the introduction of measles vaccination campaigns:
Childhood deaths from all infectious diseases plummeted. Even deaths from diseases like pneumonia and diarrhea were cut by half.
Scientists saw the same phenomenon when the vaccine came to England and parts of Europe. And they see it today when developing countries introduce the vaccine.
“In some developing countries, where infectious diseases are very high, the reduction in mortality has been up to 80 percent,” says Michael Mina, a postdoc in biology at Princeton University and a medical student at Emory University.
“So it’s really been a mystery — why do children stop dying at such high rates from all these different infections following introduction of the measles vaccine,” he says.
Of course, as I’ve discussed on many occasions, before the introduction of the measles vaccine in the early 1960s, there were routinely a half a million cases of measles per year in the US, an incidence that dropped dramatically, as shown on this graph, which I’ve used periodically whenever I want to make this point:
Also each year, out of those roughly a half million cases, an estimated 400 to 500 people died, and there were around 48,000 hospitalizations, with 4,000 ending up suffering encephalitis (swelling of the brain) from measles. Contrary to antivaccine activists invoking what I like to refer to as the “Brady Bunch” fallacy, a name I chose based on how antivaccinationists like to invoke a 1969 episode of the Brady Bunch in which all six children, the father, and the maid Alice came down with the measles, a situation that was played for laughs. In the episode, the measles was portrayed as no big deal, a normal childhood disease that almost everyone gets, and the kids were shown happily playing board games and rejoicing that they got a few days off from school. The message? Obviously that the measles shouldn’t be feared. But it should. As Clay Jones reminded us not too long ago, the most feared and deadly complication of measles, subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE) is not as rare as it is portrayed, and after a measles infection it can appear after a latent period lasting 6-8 years to cause an encephalitis that kills most children it affects within three years. Actually, SSPE is rare now, but that’s because its incidence plummeted after widespread measles immunization efforts caused the incidence of measles to plummet. As Clay put it, where there is more measles, there is more SSPE.
All of the above observations are more than adequate reasons to immunize against measles. However, if the recent study in Science is correct, measles vaccination is even more important than the reasons above make it because it prevents more than just measles. Let’s take a look at the study by Mina et al. out of the laboratory of Bryan T. Grenfell, “Long-term measles-induced immunomodulation increases overall childhood infectious disease mortality“, the study that spawned the stories I cited above. It’s a study funded by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation that comes out of the Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, Princeton University; Emory University; the Fogarty International Center at the National Institutes of Health; and the Department of Viroscience, Erasmus University Medical Center, Rotterdam, Netherlands. Not only does it provide a possible answer to one of the great mysteries of measles and the measles vaccine, but it suggests that measles vaccination is even more important than it is already known to be. The reason is as described in the stories above, introduction of mass vaccination programs against measles routinely produces a greater drop in mortality than can be attributed just to the decline in measles incidence.
The authors begin by pointing out how successful measles vaccination programs have been; that is, where they have been able to achieve high levels of vaccination. It’s a success that, contrary to what most people realize, goes beyond just preventing measles and causing its incidence to plummet to very low levels in developed countries:
Measles vaccines were introduced 50 years ago and were followed by striking reductions in child morbidity and mortality (1, 2). Measles control is now recognized as one of the most successful public health interventions ever undertaken (3). Despite this, in many countries vaccination targets remain unmet, and measles continues to take hundreds of thousands of lives each year (3). Even where control has been successful, vaccine hesitancy threatens the gains that have been made (1, 4). The introduction of mass measles vaccination has reduced childhood mortality by 30 to 50% in resource-poor countries (5–8) and by up to 90% in the most impoverished populations (9, 10). The observed benefits cannot be explained by the prevention of primary measles virus (MV) infections alone (11, 12), and they remain a central mystery (13).
MV infection is typified by a profound, but generally assumed to be transient, immunosuppression that renders hosts more susceptible to other pathogens (14–17). Thus, contemporaneous reductions in nonmeasles mortality after vaccination are expected. However, reductions in infectious disease mortality after measles vaccination can last throughout the first 5 years of life (5–10), which is much longer than anticipated by transient immunosuppression, which is generally considered to last for weeks to months (16, 17).
They cite a recent report by the World Health Organization (WHO) that examined the nonspecific effect of various vaccines on all-cause mortality (i.e., the effect of the vaccine on causes of mortality other than the disease that it is designed to prevent), which concluded that measles vaccination is associated with large reductions in all-cause childhood mortality, an effect more marked in girls than in boys, but that there is no firm evidence to explain an immunological mechanism for the nonspecific vaccine benefits. To illustrate this, here is a graph from the report summarizing the results:

As you can see, most of the studies show a significant decrease in all-cause mortality, an effect that is more marked in girls than in boys. The authors separated studies deemed to be at high risk of bias from those judged to be higher quality, and the effect is still there. Mina et al. note that proposed mechanisms for a nonspecific beneficial effect of measles vaccination include suggestions that the live vaccine might directly stimulate cross-reactive T cell responses or that they might train innate immunity to take on a phenotype like that of immune memory. However, they question whether such effects can explain the long term benefits of measles vaccination and the pre-measles vaccine associations between measles and mortality from other infectious disease. At this point, I can’t help but emphasize that what Mina et al. found is not a new finding that measles vaccination has a robust effect on all-cause mortality, including infectious diseases other than measles. This is a finding that has been observed enough times that it is generally agreed upon. Rather, what Mina et al. did was to test a hypothesis using population-level data that the reason for this effect has to do with modulation of the immune system by the measles virus such that it is less effective in warding off other infectious diseases for a significant period of time after.
So what might explain this effect? The authors invoke a different hypothesis, proposed by Rory D. de Vries at the Department of Viroscience, Erasmus MC, Rotterdam, that a loss of immune memory cells after measles virus infection “resets previously acquired immunity, and vaccination prevents this effect.” The idea is this. Measles often causes depletion of lymphocytes, which rapidly rebound after the disease clears. However, de Vries et al. hypothesize that “massive expansion of MV-specific and bystander lymphocytes masks the fact that pre-existing memory lymphocytes have been depleted” and conclude that “measles virus infection wipes out immunological memory, leaving individuals susceptible to opportunistic infectious agents that would normally be controlled by the immune system.” In a commentary, de Vries argues:
Experimental MV [measles virus] infections in animal models have demonstrated that percentages of infected lymphocyte subsets are higher than previously thought, especially in secondary and tertiary lymphoid tissues [11], [13]. We believe that measles immune suppression mainly results from depletion of immune cell subsets, which is masked by the rapid proliferation of MV-specific and bystander lymphocytes (Fig. 1D). This model is fully compatible with the measles paradox. Clinical studies are required to test our hypothesis that measles immune suppression is mainly a numbers game.
Consider Mina et al. a first attempt at testing this hypothesis at a population level using mathematical modeling of measles cases and mortality from other infections before and after the introduction of widespread measles vaccination campaigns in the US, England and Wales, and Denmark. In fact, the raw data (in Figure 1, if you have access to Science) suggest a very strong correlation between measles infection and death rates from other infections. To provide supportive evidence for the hypothesis, the following had to be true
     1.  Nonmeasles mortality should be correlated with measles incidence data, especially because the onset of vaccination reduces the latter.
     2.  An immune memory loss should present as a strengthening of this association when measles incidence data are transformed to reflect an accumulation of previous measles cases.
     3.  The strength of the association should be greatest when the mean duration over which the cases are accumulated matches the mean duration required to restore immunological memory after measles infection.
     4.  The estimated duration should be consistent both with the available evidence of increased risk of mortality after measles infection compared with uninfected children, and with the time required to build a protective immune repertoire later in life.
Finally, as the authors stated, “To explicitly address whether the observed nonspecific benefits of vaccination can be attributed to the prevention of MV immunomodulation, evidence for the four hypotheses must be present separately within the pre-vaccine eras.” Let’s just say that they were.
For example, when the authors transformed the data as described in #2 and #3, for England and Wales, the best fit occurred centered at a 28 to 28.3-month duration of measles-induced immunomodulation in the pre-vaccine era. In the pre-vaccination era, they obtained an estimated 29.2 month duration for measles-induced immunomodulation in the post-vaccine era. These results were robust and held up to a number of manipulations, including examining various age groups and different disease classes. Looking at the different countries, the authors found strong evidence to support “a generalized prolonged (roughly 2- to 3-year) impact of measles infection on subsequent mortality from other infectious diseases.”
Additional controls only strengthened the authors’ observations. For example, because previous evidence suggests that the immunomodulatory effect of measles virus is stronger in girls, thus leading to a greater nonspecific benefit of measles vaccination, the authors tested whether their model showed this same effect by comparing genders. Using their model, they found “consistently stronger associations among females,” in agreement with existing data, an agreement that held over multiple tests using either the full data set or the pre-vaccine data set. Finally, as an additional control, the authors repeated their analysis, only this time for pertussis, because pertussis is also vaccine-preventable and is not known to be immunosuppressive, like measles. They found no correlation between pertussis incidence and mortality from infectious diseases other than pertussis, and no correlation was observed even when the authors transformed their data in the same way they did the measles data to reflect the sum of previous pertussis cases.
Of course, this study is not perfect. One can always criticize choices made in mathematical models, and the authors do point out a caveat of their study and its strong agreement with previous observations in that other studies have failed to detect long-term immunological sequelae from measles. However, they point out that these cohort studies focused on low-income countries, where high rates of death from opportunistic infections during the acute measles infection tend to drive mortality; in other words, in these countries, so many children die of opportunistic infections and other acute sequelae of measles that effects from long term immunological sequelae are probably masked, given that approximately 50% of all childhood deaths recorded after five years of followup occurred within two months of infection.
The authors end up concluding:
MV infection and vaccination produce strong and durable herd immunity against subsequent epidemics (40). Our results thus suggest an extra dynamical twist: MV infections could also reduce population immunity against other infections in which MV immunomodulation could be envisioned as a measles-induced immune amnesia (17); hence, measles vaccination might also be preserving herd protection against nonmeasles infections.
Measles vaccination is one of the most cost-effective interventions for global health, and our results imply further immunological dividends: mortality (and probably morbidity) reductions linked to measles vaccination might be much greater than previously considered. This is of particular importance today where, especially in wealthy nations, reduced opportunistic infections during acute measles immunosuppression, added to the comparative rarity of infection, has led to a public view of measles as a benign childhood disease. Our findings help dispel the mystery surrounding the disproportionately large reductions in mortality seen after the introduction of measles vaccinations and reinforce the importance of measles vaccination in a global context.
Indeed, it has been noted that, after the introduction of the measles vaccine, not only did measles cases decline in the US, but deaths from infections such as respiratory and diarrheal diseases also fell from 18 per 100,000 before vaccination to 6 per 100,000 after vaccination, or, as the authors state earlier in their study:
Our results show that when measles was common, MV infections could have been implicated in as many as half of all childhood deaths from infectious disease, thus accounting for nearly all of the interannual fluctuations in childhood infectious disease deaths. The reduction of MV infections was the main factor in reducing overall childhood infectious disease mortality after the introduction of vaccination.
Of course, this is just one study and will require replication and studies to expand upon its results, assuming they hold up, but it fits in with other, earlier studies, suggesting that the benefits of vaccinating against measles go beyond preventing just measles. It is also yet another piece of data that puts the lie to claims by the antivaccine movement that measles is not dangerous and that we should believe a silly old sitcom’s view of the measles over the view of pediatricians and scientists, who knew that the measles is not a benign disease but had little to offer with respect to prevention or treatment of the disease other than supportive care. Think of it this way: if measles were such a benign disease and no big deal to worry about, why was such a major effort made to develop a vaccine in the late 1950s and early 1960s? Why was it the next big vaccine after the polio vaccine? This story in the New York Times from 1963 tells the tale:
In terms of frequency, measles is the number one disease of childhood, and it is far from harmless. It renders its victims highly susceptible to other infections. The most dreaded complication is encephalitis, an inflammation of the brain and spinal cord that may lead to permanent damage. In 1958 there were 522 deaths in the United States compared with 255 deaths from polio. In 1960 there were 410 deaths from measles, compared with 260 deaths from polio.
Fifty-two years later, we are now beginning to understand that measles doesn’t just render its victims susceptible to other infections during its acute phase, but that its immunomodulatory effects last as long as three years. Antivaccinationists frequently claim that vaccines “damage” the immune system, despite all the evidence that they do not. Rather, if anything “damages” the immune system, it’s the measles virus, and the protection against that damage is a vaccine.

Measles More Deadly than Previously Thought
Steven Novella on November 2, 2016
Link

One of the common tropes of the anti-vaccine movement is that vaccine-preventable diseases are not all that bad. Perhaps the most direct manifestation of this is the self-published children’s book, Melanie’s Marvelous Measles, by Australian author and anti-vaccine activist Stephanie Messenger. Throughout the book Messenger claims that measles is nothing to be frightened of and in fact makes the body stronger.
This is an absurd and counterfactual claim, resulting, it seems, from a desire for a simple, clean narrative. People are born lawyers – we pick a side and defend it jealously. So, if you believe vaccines are dangerous you must also believe they are useless and the diseases they prevent benign. All the facts have to align in one direction.
The evidence strongly supports the conclusion that vaccines are safe (although not risk free), that they work (although are not 100% effective), and the diseases they prevent can sometimes cause serious complications. 
Measles is Not Marvelous
Worldwide, measles is a leading cause of death in young children, and is the most preventable cause of death. The World Health Organization Statistics tell a very clear story:
In 2014, there were 114 900 measles deaths globally – about 314 deaths every day or 13 deaths every hour.
Measles vaccination resulted in a 79% drop in measles deaths between 2000 and 2014 worldwide.
In 2014, about 85% of the world’s children received one dose of measles vaccine by their first birthday through routine health services – up from 73% in 2000.
During 2000-2014, measles vaccination prevented an estimated 17.1 million deaths making measles vaccine one of the best buys in public health.
The MMR vaccine is also clearly effective, as the graph indicates. Deniers will likely point out that correlation does not prove causation, but it is certainly evidence for causation, and in this case very strong evidence. Around the world, MMR vaccination rates highly correlate with a decrease in measles cases and deaths.
We should not, however, focus only on deaths, because even children that survive may have serious complications. The two most common serious complications of measles are pneumonia and encephalitis, which is inflammation of the brain. About one in 20 children with measles develop pneumonia, which is the leading cause of death from measles.
Encephalitis is less common, affecting about one in 1,000 children with measles. This may also be fatal, but children who survive are likely to have epilepsy or intellectual impairment. Cases of measles encephalitis may be underestimated as there are reported cases of measles encephalitis without the characteristic rash, which means it will only be properly diagnosed if the virus is specifically looked for.
And these outcomes don’t even include possible indirect harms caused by the broader impact of measles on the immune system.
Subacute sclerosing panencephalitis
A serious late complication of measles infection is subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE). In some people with measles the virus is not eliminated, but rather travels to the brain where it sits dormant. Dormant viruses can reactivate in the future, often for reasons that are unclear. In the case of the measles virus, the virus can reactivate on average 7-10 years following the measles infection, causing SSPE, or severe brain inflammation. SSPE causes widespread damage to the brain. It usually starts subtly with changes in behavior, problems at school, difficulty walking, and muscle twitching. As the disease progresses it causes seizures of increasing frequency and severity and progressive dementia. Eventually the disease leads to coma and death, on average 1-2 years from onset of symptoms. The disease is universally fatal and without any cure.
In the developed world SSPE is a vanishing disease, specifically because of vaccinations against measles. World-wide the rate of SSPE is decreasing along with decreasing measles and increasing vaccination.
The risk of developing SSPE following measles has been estimated at about 1 in 100,000 children. However, this may be a huge underestimation.
A recent study, not yet published but presented at the infectious disease conference, IDWeek 2016, examines this. As reported in Scientific American:
But the new analysis suggests that kids who get the measles before age 5 have a one in 1,387 chance of developing SSPE, and kids who get the measles before age 1 have a one in 609 chance.
The authors looked for all cases of SSPE in California between 1998 and 2015, identifying 17 cases, resulting in the odds detailed above.
The data also reinforce the need for herd immunity. The risk of SSPE is greatest for children who contract measles prior to age one. However, the first dose of the MMR vaccine is not given until 12 months, which means that children less than one need to be protected from measles by herd immunity.
None of this, by the way, is marvelous.
Conclusion: The reality is, measles is extremely dangerous
While this study is just one piece of epidemiological data, it is a good opportunity to review the scientific reality of measles and the importance of vaccination.
In the case of measles we have a highly contagious virus that is a leading cause of death and disability in young children. Fortunately, it is also completely preventable with a simple and effective vaccine. As the WHO points out – this is one of the most cost effective and highest benefit-to-risk ratio health interventions that humans have devised. The world-wide vaccine campaign has saved an estimated 17.1 million children deaths from measles in the last 14 years.
Denial of these facts, and fear-mongering about vaccines, directly results in the death of children.

SSPE: A Deadly and Not-That-Rare Complication of Measles
Clay Jones on February 27, 2015
Link


[Editor’s note: We have two posts today, this post by our regular contributor Dr. Clay Jones, and an excellent guest post by William London about a chiropractor’s dubious neuropathy treatment protocol. Enjoy today or over the weekend!]
As a pediatrician, even one who has spent the majority of his career caring only for hospitalized children, the death of a patient has been a rare occurrence. There are certainly some pediatric specialties, such as intensive care and oncology, that because of the nature of their patient population must develop a more intimate relationship with the end of life. But compared to the adult world, even their exposure pales in comparison. The most common form of pediatric cancer, acute lymphoblastic leukemia, has a cure rate that is over 90% for example – making the unnecessary death of Makayla Sault after some worthless “treatment” at the Hippocrates Health Institute all the more tragic.
A bit more common in pediatrics are the patients that require significant intervention, and who may come close to death, but recover thanks to advances in modern medicine. These patients, however, are dwarfed by the number of children who receive routine hospital care and recover fairly uneventfully. And most children emerge into adulthood having never had more than a few self-limited viral illnesses and maybe a cavity or two. This wasn’t always the case. In 1900, 10% of 1-year-old children would not make it to adulthood.
I remember every patient that has died while I took part in their care, the bulk of which occurred during my residency training over a decade ago. Their names are lost to time but not their faces, and certainly not the lasting emotional impression they made on me. My experiences with patients who did not survive have changed the way I think about and practice medicine, and significantly influenced the way I approach life in general.
During my first rotation as a resident in the pediatric intensive care unit, seven children died. This was a bad month even for a large academic facility. One young girl suffered a catastrophic injury to her brain because of a rare complication of infection caused by eating improperly cooked hamburger at a church picnic. And a newborn infant just a few days home from the hospital was accidentally smothered by her parents while sleeping between them in bed. I won’t list them all, but I would hope that it is clear why this month stands out in my mind as the worst of my career so far, and why to this day I have a deep and unwavering hatred for all-terrain vehicles.
Lately I have been thinking a lot about one of the children that died that month. I only knew him and his family for a short time but the course of his illness had been long and exceptionally tragic, and he had been brought to the hospital to die. Over the roughly two years prior to his death, this previously healthy and thriving teenager had slowly but steadily deteriorated, beginning with his parents noticing that his temperament had changed and that his grades were dropping. They thought that maybe he had started experimenting with drugs.
As the months passed, his condition worsened. His ability to think became more and more impaired and he began to have odd muscle spasms, eventually losing the ability to even walk or care for himself. He lost the ability to speak and then to swallow, becoming dependent on nutrition administered through a tube surgically inserted directly into his stomach. By the time of his last admission to a hospital, he was in a persistent vegetative state. His brain began to shut down, his drive to breathe became erratic.
The cause of his deterioration had been diagnosed by the time I knew him. It wasn’t related to a traumatic injury or stroke, and it wasn’t because of an infection in his brain, at least not a new one. It was actually the result of what some would consider a mild illness of childhood – no big deal even.
In reality this infection is one of the most common causes of death in children around the world and has only recently re-entered general public awareness in the United States thanks to widespread media coverage of a large cluster of cases centered at Disneyland. I’m of course talking about measles. The complication that ended my patient’s life in such a tortuous way is called subacute sclerosing panencephalitis or SSPE.
What is SSPE?
Measles can make children very sick, primarily when one or both of two organs are involved: the lungs and the brain. Pneumonia associated with measles, which can occur in as many as 1 out of every 20 young children who acquire the infection, is the most common culprit in fatal cases. But inflammation of the brain, called encephalitis, can kill during the initial illness or leave a child with permanent cognitive impairment or hearing loss. SSPE occurs when infection of the brain becomes clinically apparent years later, often after an otherwise mild and uncomplicated case.
Acute encephalitis occurs when the immune system reacts to measles virus that has found its way into the central nervous system. But the immune system doesn’t always respond aggressively. In some cases, a mutation occurs in the virus which renders it unable to produce certain proteins that would have served as a signal flare. In addition, particularly in children less than 2 years of age, an immature immune system simply fails to respond.
Regardless of the specific reason, measles virus is allowed to remain in neural tissue relatively unchecked and it slowly proliferates under the radar as the years go by. Eventually, usually in the ballpark of 6 to 8 years later, the progressive inflammatory process becomes clinically apparent. Death is almost certain and occurs within 1 to 3 years of diagnosis in most cases, although there are case reports of more rapid progression as well as the occasional patient who survives.
How does SSPE present?
The early stages of SSPE are subtle and often confused with other issues. As with my patient, it often begins with behavioral changes, such as irritability, and mild memory problems that mimic psychiatric conditions or drug use. As the condition progresses, central nervous system control of the muscles is affected. This leads to involuntary muscular activity in the form of spasms or rapid jerking movements. Seizures and impairment of vision are also common.
Eventually in most cases the ability to walk becomes impaired. Loss of motor control also tends to affect the ability to speak and swallow, which increases the risk of aspirating. Continued decline in cognitive capabilities occurs. Dementia, coma and a persistent vegetative state represent the final stages of the illness, with death resulting when the brain loses control of vital functions like breathing and cardiovascular regulation.
How is SSPE diagnosed and treated?
The diagnosis of SSPE requires clinical suspicion, especially in an area where measles rates are low. This currently still includes the United States but that may change if the ongoing increase in cases we are seeing continues. When a patient has signs and symptoms consistent with SSPE, the next step is usually imaging of the brain and obtaining an EEG. Results of these studies are often non-specific, although there are some EEG findings considered to be fairly consistent with the diagnosis. Testing the patient’s blood and spinal fluid for evidence of an immune response in the form of anti-measles antibodies (IgG) plays a role, as does PCR testing, which can reveal the presence of actual virus.
A variety of antiviral drugs have been tried over the years, as well as potent immune-suppressing medications, without significant success. If started very early in the course, preferably before there is significant cognitive impairment, there is a chance that treatment might slow the progression of symptoms. These therapies, when helpful, must be taken for the duration of the patient’s life. Unfortunately, there is no cure for SSPE.
Who gets SSPE and how common is it?

Where there is more measles, there is more SSPE. In regions where vaccine uptake is high, such as the United States, the incidence is extremely low with roughly ten cases diagnosed per year total. In developing regions where measles remains endemic and common, SSPE is diagnosed at a rate of 20 per million people. But this data likely doesn’t reflect the true risk considering that many cases will go undiagnosed.
The last large outbreak of measles in the United States occurred from 1989 to 1991 with over 55,000 cases reported. Most of the cases involved unimmunized preschool children. 11,000 patients were hospitalized and 123 died, which was consistent with the expected 1-2 deaths per 1,000 cases. Worse actually.
In 2005, CDC researchers combed through medical records and tested available brain tissue samples from patients diagnosed with SSPE. They wanted, using modern PCR technology, to determine the rate of SSPE specifically in patients who were infected with measles during the outbreak from 1989 to 1991. Their results revealed a risk of 1-2 per 10,000 cases, which was 10-fold higher than prior estimates.
Conclusion
Even considering the recent increase in measles cases in the United States, it is still a very rare condition. And SSPE is an uncommon sequelae, although perhaps not as uncommon as historical estimates would have us believe. But measles is not rare in many regions of the world, and our attempts at eliminating it have stalled. Worldwide measles deaths actually increased from 2012 to 2013 and the number of cases in some developed nations is increasing.
SSPE is a horrific potential complication of infection with measles that can arise years after even an uneventful case. No child should have to suffer through it and no parent should have to worry about their child developing it. And although there is no effective cure for the condition, there is a highly safe and effective vaccine which can prevent it.

Make measles great again: A case study of the politicization of school vaccine requirements in Michigan
Protecting our children through school vaccine requirements has long had strong bipartisan support. Unfortunately, the antivaccine movement has had success linking “vaccine choice” with “freedom” and “parental rights”, leading to a surge of right wing antivaccine activism that has undermined that bipartisan consensus. Two bills under consideration by the Michigan legislature represent a microcosm of what is going on in much of the US.
David Gorski on May 1, 2017
Link

Last week, I wrote about how antivaccine activists have been targeting the Somali immigrant community in Minnesota, with disastrous results in terms of public health, with Andrew Wakefield himself having made at least a couple of visits to proselytize his religion in which vaccines are Satan. Basically, MMR uptake among the Minnesota Somali community’s children has plunged over the last decade, from 92% to 42%. Completely predictably, that very same community is in the midst of a measles outbreak, whose toll has risen to 32 since last week (and is continuing to rise), making it bigger than the last outbreak among the Somalis in 2011. Meanwhile, yesterday a coalition of antivaccine groups targeted the same community with the message that the “epidemic is autism, not measles,” featuring antivaccine activist Mark Blaxill. I can’t help but wonder how many children will be sickened before this particular outbreak is contained and whether it will spread far beyond the Twin Cities area where it is concentrated now. That doesn’t even consider my concern about the politicization of what used to be a bipartisan consensus on school vaccine mandates.
Such thoughts were on my mind as I received a letter from my State Representative Jeff Noble on Saturday. My wife received an identical letter the same day. The reason was that we had both reached out to his office to express alarm and opposition to two bills related to school vaccine requirements and policy being considered in the Michigan House right now, HB 4425 and HB 4426. Rep. Noble told us, in essence, thanks for contacting his office, but bugger off. Here’s the letter:
Neither my wife nor I reacted very well to this letter, as you might imagine. After all, unlike me my wife is a pediatric nurse practitioner in primary care. She administers vaccines every day.

So, what, you may ask, are HB 4425 and HB 4426? What did Rep. Noble mean by his comment about how the “intent of the legislation is to reign [sic] in the department who [sic] has overstepped the boundaries that were implemented by past legislatures”? I also can’t help but note that there’s another, darker provision in these bills that Rep. Noble conveniently left out of his letter, as you will see. Unfortunately, both my State Senator Patrick Colbeck (who has antivaccine-sympathetic proclivities) and now my State Representative Jeff Noble, have shown a—shall we say?—openness to antivaccine advocacy. Indeed, Sen. Colbeck is the main sponsor of the Senate versions of these bills, SB 299 and SB 300. I also should have checked more closely, as I subsequently learned that Rep. Noble strongly supports HB 4425 and HB 4426 to the point of co-sponsoring them. To understand what is happening in Michigan, it’s necessary to go back a couple of years, when the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services (MDHHS) instituted a new rule making the process to obtain personal belief exemptions (PBEs) to school vaccine requirements more difficult. HB 4425 and HB 4426 are explicitly designed to reverse that rule and forbid MDHHS from making new rules like it in the future.
A solution to low vaccine uptake that is working
In response to increasing nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine mandates and falling vaccination rates, as well as pertussis outbreaks, particularly a big pertussis outbreak in 2012, the MDHHS decided to do something about it. In brief, the state emulated California’s first attempt to combat the rising tide of PBEs. Basically, starting January 1, 2015, the MDHHS altered the rules regarding requirements for parents to claim personal belief exemptions to vaccine mandates, patterning its policy change on California Bill AB 2109, a bill from a few years ago that sought to tighten up requirements for PBEs in California. AB 2109 required parents seeking PBEs to meet with a physician or other enumerated health care practitioner to receive counseling on the risks of opting their children out of school vaccine requirements. The physician would then have to sign the PBE form to verify that he had counseled the parents. Of course, in the wake of the Disneyland measles outbreak a year ago, California passed a far stronger measure, SB 277, which, beginning with the 2016-2017 school year, eliminated PBEs in California. SB 277 has already shown results in decreasing the rates of PBEs and increasing vaccine uptake.

The rule change took effect on January 1, 2015. Since then, parents seeking PBEs to school vaccine requirements must visit their local county health department office to:
    • Be educated by a local health worker about the benefits of vaccination and the risks of disease.
    • Sign the universal state form that includes a statement of acknowledgement that parents understand they may be putting their own children and others at risk by refusing the shots. Only the state form is allowed. No substitute forms are allowed any more, as they were in the past.
Why did the MDHHS make this rule change? Simple:
Michigan has one of the highest immunization waiver rates in the country, with some counties reporting waiver rates up to 12.5% (that is, more than 12% of school-age students in these places have not received all vaccinations). In addition, individual school buildings have reported even higher waiver rates. High nonmedical waiver rates can leave communities susceptible to the entry of diseases such as measles, chickenpox, and pertussis (whooping cough) by undermining community or “herd” immunity that protects vulnerable children (for example, children who cannot be vaccinated for medical reasons and children with compromised immune systems). Herd immunity can also slow the spread of disease if a high proportion of individuals are immune to the disease in a community. Immunization is one of the most effective ways to protect children from harmful diseases and even death.
The result of Michigan’s abysmal vaccine uptake rates have been outbreaks, particularly a large pertussis outbreak in 2012, out of which was born a campaign by a mother whose baby died of pertussis to increase vaccine uptake. There have also been measles outbreaks.
Short of an SB 277-like law banning nonmedical exemptions, this is the best that the MDHHS could do, and it’s working too. Early data indicate that PBE rates are declining and vaccine uptake is starting to increase in Michigan.
Not surprisingly, the antivaccine movement really, really, really doesn’t like this rule. As soon as the rule was publicly announced, it was attacked, with the most common claim being that the MDHHS broke the law because it didn’t have the power to institute such a rule. This is a fallacious argument, as the rule was approved, as such rules must be, by the Joint Committee on Administrative Rules, a bipartisan legislative committee charged with the legislative oversight of administrative rules proposed by state agencies. Basically, JCAR reviews state agency regulations and, if it takes no action, allows them to go into effect after 15 legislative days. The committee is composed of lawmakers, giving it a legislative imprimatur, but it is not the Legislature itself, thus avoiding the political rancor that can accompany debate on controversial issues. Antivaccinationists have described this as a “stealth move,” but it was entirely legal, and the rule change is having its intended effect.
Antivaccine parents were outraged and immediately started targeting the offices of a few sympathetic legislators, such as Rep. Thomas Hooker:
Concerned parents came in droves to the state capital Wednesday morning to protest a new vaccine waiver policy which opponents say bullies parents.
But supporters say the new policy, which requires parents to make an appointment with the county health department to officially obtain a waiver, is working. Although some counties had already been doing this, it’s a big change for parents who had previously been able to waive their child’s vaccinations with a quick signature in a school’s office.
Reps. Mike Callton, R-Nashville, and Thomas Hooker, R-Byron Center, held a joint hearing of their respective Health Policy and Families, Children and Seniors committees Wednesday morning to discuss the change.
“A lot of parents got upset right there because they felt it’s their right, why should they have to drive all the way to the health department? And for some of them it’s not that easy and some of the health departments aren’t real nice,” Callton said.
Parents testified Wednesday about the extra trouble of making health department appointments, which serve primarily to educate them about vaccines before opting out with a waiver.
My reaction at the time was basically: Oh, poor parents! They’re being “bullied” because they can’t just sign a piece of paper and let their children degrade herd immunity and endanger other children with infectious diseases any more. They actually have to go to the health department and listen to science-based information before signing a state-mandated waiver form that acknowledges that the risks to their child and their community of not vaccinating have been explained to them and that they understand. This complaint is of a piece with other things that antivaccine parents characterize as “bullying,” such as simply questioning their beliefs in the slightest.
Unfortunately, these parents have enough clout to have resulted in HB 4425 and HB 4426 plus their Senate counterparts SB 299 and SB 300, which, if passed, would strike down this rule and bar MDHHS from writing new rules like it in the future. That’s not all it will do if passed, though, nor are the current bills the first attempt to reverse the MDHHS administrative rule.
Pro-disease legislation being considered in Michigan
Fresh off the first case of measles in Michigan this year, having another go at reversing the MDHHS rule:
Michigan Republicans have decided to throw established science and concerns for public health out the window by introducing bills that are clearly catered to the anti-vaccine crowd — and will ultimately put the public’s health at risk.
According to MLive, “parents seeking an exemption to vaccinations must be educated by a local health worker about vaccines and sign a universal state form, which includes a statement of acknowledgement that parents understand they could be putting children at risk by refusing the shots.”
Under the proposed bills, the rule would be eliminated.
According to health officials, this rule helped drive down vaccine waivers, which led to more kids getting immunized. Data from 2015 showed that Michigan ranked 43rd lowest in the nation for immunizations covering kids from 19 to 35 months. So clearly, we still have some work to do.
Not surprisingly, there was a statement from my very own state senator, Sen. Patrick Colbeck:
“The rules enacted by DHHS pertaining to parents who wish to opt out of vaccinations for their children go beyond the intent of the current law, which was to inform parents of potential consequences of their choices, but now seems to have a punitive intent,” Sen. Colbeck said. “Whenever a department promulgates rules that go beyond the intent of the legislation, it is then the role of the Legislature to make sure those rules are reined back in. It was never the intention of the Legislature to see a vaccination opt-out procedure put into place that essentially mandates that parents have to take time off of work to meet with specific people, view videos, or sign inflammatory forms to exert a right they should be able to exercise more simply.
“State legislators are increasingly concerned about departments implementing rules that go beyond legislative intent. There is a strong desire to reform the administrative rule-making process across the board, thereby limiting the need for retroactive correction.”
Notice how much he sounds like Rep. Noble? Not surprisingly, Sen. Colbeck is the sponsor of SB 299 and SB 300. In any event, given that the rule passed the Joint Committee on Administrative Rules, it’s hard to argue that it went beyond the intent of existing legislation; otherwise, JCAR would likely have nixed the proposed rule when it considered it. This is the “wedge” that antivaxers in Michigan are using, though. They’re appealing to conservative legislators using the antivaccine dog whistles of “freedom” and “parental rights,” bolstered with an appeal to conservatives’ distrust of regulation. Indeed, on the website of the antivaccine group Michigan for Vaccine Choice you can find exactly those arguments, plus the claim that the MDHHS “overreached.”
The bills I’ve been discussing are not the first time that some Michigan legislators have tried to reverse the rule change on PBEs requiring a trip to the county health office and the use of only the state form to claim an exemption. Before HB 4425/6 and SB 299/300, there were HB 5126 and HB 5127, whose primary sponsor was Rep. Hooker and which were introduced during the 2015-2016 legislative session. Fortunately, they failed to pass; in fact, they didn’t even make it out of the Committee on Health Policy. HB 4425/6 and SB 299/300, introduced this year, are basically identical to the previous bills and are now under consideration by a different committee, the Committee on Education Reform. Vaccine advocates tell me that there will likely be at least a hearing on these bills sometime during the next several weeks, which, if it happens, will be further than they got last time.
First, let’s take a look at the relevant part of HB 4425:
(2) A child is exempt from this part if a parent, guardian, or person in loco parentis of the child presents a written statement to the administrator of the child’s school or operator of the group program to the effect that the requirements of this part cannot be met because of religious convictions or other objection to immunization.
(3) THE DEPARTMENT’S AUTHORITY TO PROMULGATE RULES UNDER SECTION 9227 DOES NOT INCLUDE THE AUTHORITY TO PROMULGATE OR ENFORCE A RULE THAT IMPOSES A DIFFERENT OR ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENT FOR A CHILD TO BE EXEMPT FROM THIS PART THAN THOSE DESCRIBED IN THIS SECTION OR THAT REQUIRES THE EXEMPTIONS DESCRIBED IN THIS SECTION TO BE ON A FORM PRESCRIBED BY THE DEPARTMENT.
(4) IF THE DEPARTMENT PROVIDES INFORMATION TO THE PUBLIC ON THE EXEMPTIONS DESCRIBED IN THIS SECTION, THEN WITH THAT INFORMATION THE DEPARTMENT SHALL INCLUDE INFORMATION ABOUT THE EFFECTIVENESS AND POTENTIAL RISKS OF IMMUNIZATION FOR DISEASES FOR WHICH THE DEPARTMENT REQUIRES IMMUNIZATION UNDER SECTION 9227.
Basically, this law, if passed, would handcuff MDHHS by explicitly forbidding it from making it any harder for parents to claim a PBE than to present a signed written statement to the school administrator saying, in essence, “I don’t wanna.” You can also spot the influence antivaxers had in drafting this bill by the rather obviously antivaccine-inspired language about the “potential risks of immunization.” Finally, you can see that Rep. Noble is a co-sponsor of HB 4425, something I should have noticed before I contacted his office. He’s also the primary sponsor of HB 4426.
If handcuffing the MDHHS regarding the education and forms requirement to obtain a PBE were all that these bills do, it would be bad enough. However, HB 4425 goes beyond that and seeks to make it difficult for local health officers to contain small outbreaks and prevent them from becoming large outbreaks.
Make measles great again! Or: How to make small outbreaks bigly
By far the worst part of these bills is found in this language in HB 4425, which is basically custom-made to make it easier for single cases of vaccine-preventable disease to become outbreaks, for small outbreaks to become large outbreaks, and large outbreaks to become epidemics:
(2) THE DEPARTMENT’S AUTHORITY TO PROMULGATE RULES UNDER SECTION 5111 DOES NOT INCLUDE THE AUTHORITY TO PROMULGATE OR ENFORCE A RULE ALLOWING A LOCAL HEALTH OFFICER WHO CONFIRMS OR REASONABLY SUSPECTS THAT AN INDIVIDUAL ATTENDING A SCHOOL OR GROUP PROGRAM HAS A COMMUNICABLE DISEASE TO, AS A DISEASE CONTROL MEASURE THAT IS NOT IN THE CASE OF AN EPIDEMIC, EXCLUDE FROM ATTENDANCE AN INDIVIDUAL WHO LACKS DOCUMENTATION OF IMMUNITY OR IS OTHERWISE CONSIDERED SUSCEPTIBLE TO THE COMMUNICABLE DISEASE. AS USED IN THIS SUBSECTION, “GROUP PROGRAM” MEANS THAT TERM AS DESCRIBED IN SECTION 9211.
What this provision would do is to prevent the MDHHS from empowering local health officers to bar unvaccinated children from school if they suspect or confirm a case (or cases) of a vaccine-preventable disease in that school. Presumably, that would mean that only MDHHS could take such an action. So much for local autonomy that conservatives claim to champion!
I looked at this provision, looked at it, and then looked at it again. For the life of me I can’t figure out any reasonable rationale for such a law, other than to strip the MDHHS of a power that would make its ability to contain outbreaks easier. Basically, the only purpose this provision will serve, if passed, is to endanger children who are not vaccinated thanks to PBEs, while at the same time inserting additional susceptible children into an environment where a contagious disease resides, thus making outbreaks more likely. This provision is, at its core, a near-perfect strategy to make it much more likely that a single case of disease becomes a small outbreak and that a small outbreak grows into a large one—or even becomes an epidemic. Here’s a hint for Rep. Hooker, Sen. Colbeck, and the rest of the sponsors of these ill-advised bills: By the time you have a large outbreak or an epidemic, it’s too late. Keeping unvaccinated children out of school is a strategy that works best if it’s done early in the course of an evolving outbreak, and empowering local health officers to do just that would provide the flexibility needed to act early. This law, if passed, could easily result in a public health disaster.
The politicization of vaccine policy
There has been a long history of bipartisan consensus on vaccine policy and school vaccine mandates in this country. Unfortunately, this consensus is being undermined, and bills like HB 4425/6 and SB 299/300 are the result. My personal suspicion is that, energized by the fight against California SB 277, antivaccine activists stumbled upon a successful strategy based linking “vaccine choice” with “freedom” in general, “parental rights,” and the distrust of the government baked into conservative politics. Thus, over the last five years or so, the loudest voices in the antivaccine movement have increasingly tended to come from the right, not the left, such that vaccine policy even featured prominently in the second Republican debate, largely thanks to Donald Trump’s long history of antivaccine rhetoric and the increasing alignment with antivaccine groups with Tea Party and right wing political groups. To me, this alignment in rhetoric and viewpoint was epitomized by an interview with Sen. Rand Paul (who really is antivaccine) two years ago in which he said, “The state doesn’t own the children. Parents own the children, and it is an issue of freedom.” Antivaccine-sympathetic physicians like “Dr. Bob” Sears, in particular, traffic in these “parental rights” and “freedom” antivaccine dog whistles. Antivaxers were further energized when it was revealed that Donald Trump had met with disgraced British antivaccine gastroenterologist Andrew Wakefield in August and then again when he met with antivaccine activist Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. in January, allegedly about a vaccine safety commission.
There have always been politicians who are antivaccine. (Think, for example, Rep. Dan Burton, who held endless hearings on the “risks” of vaccines and the “autism epidemic” in the late 1990s and early 2000s.) However, they have generally been the fringe, to whom few paid much attention and whose antivaccine views fewer still supported. Unfortunately, antivaccine activists have become very good at conflating the “freedom” to refuse vaccines with “freedom.” Worse, they are fringe no longer, and vaccine policy is being politicized in a way that it has never been before. Indeed, a couple of months ago, The Washington Post published an article, “Trump energizes the anti-vaccine movement in Texas“, and it’s not just in Texas where they’re being energized. (It doesn’t seem to matter that Trump appointed an honest-to-goodness pharma shill who is very pro-vaccine as FDA Commissioner.) Indeed, the article explicitly makes my point:
One particularly strong strain of anti-vaccine rhetoric in Texas is libertarian and anti-government. Texans for Vaccine Choice receives help and expertise from “friendly” lawmakers and groups such as Empower Texans, said Jonathan Stickland, a tea party Republican representative from Tarrant County and a key supporter. Political experts consider Empower Texans the state’s most sophisticated and influential conservative organization.
“Our message resonates with people,” said Schlegel, 37, in a brief interview after a day of meetings at the Capitol. “Texans value parental rights,” she said. “We have a message of liberty. We have a message of choice.”
It is a powerful message that is difficult to counter. As I’ve said more times than I can remember, antivaccine pseudoscience is an irrationality that appeals to both the right and the left, but for different reasons. On the left, it’s often due to a belief that “natural” is somehow better, coupled with distrust of big business, especially big pharma. On the right it’s “freedom” and anti-government rhetoric. Think of it this way. Political operatives know that people tend to be more passionate when they are against something rather than for something. It’s easier to get them to donate and volunteer to oppose a policy rather than to promote a policy. That was how the Tea Party got started, and we’re seeing what might be the start of a similar passion on the left in response to Donald Trump.
Sadly, here in Michigan we really do have a large number of legislators who conflate “freedom” with the freedom to endanger public health and fetishize “parental rights” without even considering the rights of the child. It’s almost as though they’re trying to turn Michigan into Romania, with its massive ongoing measles outbreak. Evidence of the susceptibility of our legislators to antivaccine dog whistles comes from a recent trip to Michigan by Del Bigtree, producer of the antivaccine propaganda film VAXXED, to meet with legislators. For instance, here is Bigtree interviewing Rep. Hooker:
Note how Rep. Hooker is spouting off about “parental rights” and “parental choice” in the usual way that antivaccine activists do, such that the child is basically viewed as the parents’ property instead of an autonomous being with rights of his or her own, such as the right to good medical care. Good medical care, I note, includes standard of care preventative medicines such as the CDC-recommended vaccine schedule. Hooker also blathers on about “big pharma” in a typical conspiratorial manner. He even invokes one of the most brain dead antivaccine arguments there are, an argument that fundamentalist Christians make about the HPV vaccine:
Obviously, as a parent and a grandparent myself, it’s important to me that parents have their rights protected and, you know, their choice of what’s best for their kids. I think of the immunization Gardasil. If my children are raised in a godly Christian home, they don’t need Gardasil, because they’re going to make the wise choices, and again, the advertisements they’re putting out on television to the parent (“You could have protected me and let me have an immunization as a child”) takes the responsibility away from the kid, who should be making the responsibility for having sex outside of marriage.
No, vaccination with Gardasil does not lead to promiscuity.
When, near the end of the interview, Hooker brought up the “aborted fetal tissue in vaccines” distortion, I had to stop and thank my lucky stars that Rep. Hooker was term-limited. I’m thankful now that he’s no longer in the House. Unfortunately, there are many to take his place.
Bigtree also managed to meet with a number of other legislators, including Sen. Phil Pavlov, Rep. Hank Vaupel, and Rep. Mike Callton. Pavlov represents the 25th District, which encompasses much of the Thumb area of the state, while Representative Vaupel represents a district that includes several exurbs northwest of Detroit and Rep. Caldon represents a rural district west of Lansing. Sadly, there was at least one Democrat on the list, specifically Sen. Vincent Gregory, whose district covers several of the northern suburbs, including Farmington Hills, Southfield, Farmington, Ferndale, and more. This swath of northern suburbs encompasses an area where I’d guess that much of Detroit’s antivaccine contingent resides; no wonder Sen. Gregory is a co-sponsor of SB 299 and SB 300. Bigtree exults that his meeting with Gregory was one of the best meetings he’s ever had with a Democrat and how Gregory promised he’d get Bigtree’s antivaccine concerns heard by the Congressional Black Caucus in Detroit. Meanwhile, through it all, Bigtree was driven around by a representative from Michigan for Vaccine Choice, one of our state antivaccine groups, the same one that’s promoting HB 4425/6 and SB 299/300.
Bigtree wrapped up his visit to my state with a fundraiser for the Michigan Vaccine Freedom PAC, which is exactly what you think it is and lists Rep. Noble as supporting “vaccine choice” and “legislative oversight,” and opposing “vaccine discrimination”:
In his talk, Bigtree spends a lot of time arguing for “health freedom,” portraying “vaccine choice” as an integral part of health freedom, where the parents have the right to refuse vaccination for their children. Of course, as I’ve mentioned in this very post and more posts than I can remember, the problem with this argument is that it completely ignores the autonomy of children. Children are not the property of their parents. They are not extensions of their parents. They are autonomous beings who have an existence outside of their parents and who have the right to medical care, including the right be protected against vaccine-preventable diseases, regardless of the misguided beliefs of their parents who refuse to vaccinate. Not surprisingly, Del Bigtree traces his antivaccine activism (I know, I know, he doesn’t think that he’s antivaccine) to the introduction of SB 277, the California bill that is now law that has eliminated nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine mandates.
He concludes:
If we do not fight now, then there will be nothing left to fight for. And I think that is where everyone in this room, I pray you realize how important you are in this historic moment. We will never be stronger than we are right now. We will never be healthier than we are right now. Our children are looking like this, a generation of children, as we’ve said on The Doctors television show this is the first generation of children that will not live to be as old as their parents. Are we going to stand…are we going to sit down and take it? Or are we going to stand up and say: This is a historic moment, that my forefathers, those from Jefferson all the way to Martin Luther King, the moments where people stood up and something inside of them said I’m going to stand for freedom and I’m going to stand for it now. That is in our DNA. It is pumping through me, and I pray that you feel it pumping through you, because we must look back. Our grandchildren will look back and thank us for having stood up one more time and been the generation that said, “We the People of the United States of America stood for freedom, stand for freedom. We will die for freedom today.”
Histrionic? Yes. Overwrought? Definitely. Grandiose? Well, it is Del Bigtree. Even so, it’s not hard to see how this can be a very effective message among libertarian and government-distrusting conservatives.
What can science and public health advocates do?
Sadly, now that we’ve gone down this road, I don’t see a clear path to preventing the further politicization of school vaccine mandates and state vaccine policy. I fear that it might require much bigger outbreaks than we’ve seen thus far before we as a nation come to our senses about vaccines, at least. Vaccine advocates have science on our side, but the antivaccine movement has emotional stories and passion. If we can’t match that passion and couple it with science we will lose.
Medical societies should be leading the way in this fight, particularly those representing specialties that care for children. Fortunately, one such group is leading the way:
State physicians groups are also opposed. For example, the Michigan Academy of Family Physicians, which issued an action alert to urge state legislators to vote no on HB 4425 and HB 4426, as did the Michigan State Medical Society. Then, of course, there is the Alliance for Immunization in Michigan, an organization of health care professionals who advocate for vaccines.
Although Michigan medical groups have started to stir themselves to oppose the bill, so far I’ve seen little other than the action alerts above. What will be more important, however, is for parents in affected states to become active. For example, Michigan’s first pro-vaccine parent advocacy group is now up and running, The Cooperative for Safe Kids (Facebook). Not surprisingly, the group opposes HB 4425 and HB 4426, as well it should. Then there’s the Franny Strong Foundation and its I Vaccinate campaign, which was born out of the tragic death of its founder’s baby to pertussis during the 2012 outbreak.
The same is true in every state where antivaccine groups are influencing the legislature to weaken school vaccine requirements. Pro-vaccine advocates need to be active at the local level, working to elect pro-vaccine legislators, to defeat antivaccine-sympathetic legislators, and to defeat bad legislation like HB 4425 and HB 4426. Unfortunately, the situation around the country is like that in Texas, where the antivaccine groups outgun pro-vaccine groups in terms of funding and activism. Unless we can reverse this situation, the antivaccine movement will succeed in making measles great again, not to mention several other vaccine-preventable diseases.

Outbreaks among Somali immigrants in Minnesota: Thanks for the measles again, Andy
Andrew Wakefield’s antivaccine propaganda film VAXXED claims that MMR vaccination causes autism in African American boys. Unfortunately, this is not the first time Wakefield has targeted people of color with antivaccine misinformation. Before there was VAXXED, Wakefield and antivaxers targeted Somali immigrants in Minnesota. Measles outbreaks have been the result.
David Gorski on April 24, 2017
Link
Th ere are many harms attributable to the antivaccine movement and its promotion of antivaccine beliefs. Certainly, the harm those of us who have been combatting antivaccine misinformation fear is the return of vaccine-preventable diseases, which is something we’ve seen in the form of outbreaks, such as the Disneyland measles outbreak two years ago and, in my own state, pertussis outbreaks. The Disneyland outbreak was a wake-up call to California legislators, who in its wake passed SB 277, a law that eliminated personal belief exemptions (PBEs) to school vaccine requirements. Now, only medical exemptions are permitted, and so far the law has worked well. In Michigan, we’re still struggling. The Michigan Department of Health and Human Services issued a new rule that requires parents seeking a PBE to attend an education and counseling session at a local county health office before the PBE is issued. Not surprisingly, local antivaxers are not happy and have managed, by painting this rule as a horrific affront to “freedom” and “parental rights,” to persuade legislators to try to pass a law that would not only revoke the rule and explicitly bar MDHHS from issuing similar rules in the future, but it would prevent local health officers from barring unvaccinated children from school during an outbreak. The law failed to pass the first time it was introduced, but Michigan legislators are nothing if not extremely persistent in pursuing harmful policies, and a new version of the same old bill is again under consideration. It matters not one whit to our stupid legislators that the rule change is starting to work to increase vaccine uptake. Unfortunately, we have a fair number of antivaccine and antivaccine-sympathetic legislators.
Although the antivaccine movement in the US has classically been associated with upper middle class and affluent white people, they are not the ones who are likely to suffer the most when herd immunity breaks down. I’ve written extensively here about how the newest (and perhaps most pernicious) antivaccine conspiracy theory, the so-called “CDC whistleblower” conspiracy theory promoted by Del Bigtree and Andrew Wakefield’s propaganda film disguised as a documentary VAXXED, explicitly targets the African-American community, complete with promotional visits featuring the Nation of Islam going to speak in Compton and being involved in protests outside the CDC. Wakefield, as you recall, is the British gastroenterologist who in 1998 published a case series in The Lancet linking MMR to autism. It has since been retracted and shown to have been fraudulent, and Wakefield has had his UK medical license stripped from him. Unfortunately, that only makes him more of a hero to the antivaccine movement, and he’s spent the last 19 years playing that role to the hilt.
The “CDC whistleblower” conspiracy theory is based on the story of CDC scientist William Thompson, who in 2013 apparently contacted biochemical engineer turned incompetent antivaccine epidemiologist Brian Hooker to vent about a study he co-authored in 2004 that examined whether there was a correlation between vaccination with MMR and subsequent risk of autism. Not surprisingly, the study failed to find a correlation. However, there was one subgroup, African-American boys, in which the unadjusted data showed a 3.4-fold increased risk of autism. (I’m simplifying for space considerations in providing background, obviously; if you want the gory details, read here and here for a contemporaneous account of the origin of a new conspiracy theory, as well as my review of the book Vaccine Whistleblower and Andrew Wakefield’s fraudumentary VAXXED.) Thompson had had disagreements with how the data were presented and how he thought the CDC has “suppressed” the unadjusted data. Unfortunately for him, Thompson didn’t realize that Hooker was recording their conversations, and Andrew Wakefield found out about it. Thus, he became the “CDC whistleblower” who seemingly validated what I like to call the central conspiracy theory of the antivaccine movement, specifically that the CDC “knows” that vaccines cause autism but covered it up. It didn’t matter one whit that the correlation was found only in a small subgroup (African-American boys), but it did matter because African-Americans already have reason to distrust the medical community based on history. The “CDC whistleblower” myth feeds into that sad history, which is why Wakefield loves to invoke the Tuskegee syphilis experiment.
This is also not the first time Andrew Wakefield has targeted people of color with his pseudoscience. By any objective measure, for the most part the CDC whistleblower conspiracy theory and VAXXED have not had much resonance in the African-American community other than in the Nation of Islam and among a handful of parents like Sheila Ealey who really believe vaccines caused their children’s autism. The first time around, unfortunately, Wakefield was much more successful. Now, nearly a decade after he first started targeting the community, they are continuing to suffer measles outbreaks. I will begin with the story as it stands now and then go back and look at how it got to this point. The story takes place among a seemingly unlikely group of people in an unexpected location. It’s also a story that I can’t believe I’ve never blogged about before, given how long it’s been going on.
Measles outbreaks among Somali immigrants in Minnesota
Before I first encountered this story several years ago, I had no idea that there was a large community of Somali immigrants in Hennepin County in Minnesota, but there is. In fact, it’s the largest community of Somali immigrants in the US that began forming over a quarter of a century ago and now numbers in the several tens of thousands. Right now, the community is the center of a new measles outbreak, which is just the latest. From the Friday StarTribune:
As a registered nurse and a consultant to the Minnesota Department of Health, Asli Ashkir has spent nearly a decade talking with Somali parents about autism, vaccines and the importance of getting their children immunized.
Last week she redoubled her efforts. A measles outbreak in Hennepin County has sickened 12 children — all of them unvaccinated and all of them from Somali families, according to the department — throwing a spotlight on low immunization rates among Somali children.
Now state and county public health workers are doing their best to contact Somali parents and underscore the value of immunization. “I know when parents have facts, they do the best they can to make the right decision,” Ashkir said.
The story shows why the Somali community in the Twin Cities area is so susceptible to measles outbreak. All you have to do is to look at this graph of MMR vaccine uptake by year:

The graph above shows what can only be described as a catastrophic plunge over the course of just one decade in MMR uptake among American-born children of Somali descent, from 92% to 42%. There is, for all intents and purposes, no herd immunity in this community. The interesting thing here, though, is that this plunge is very specific. It’s noted in the story that there is not a fear of vaccination in general among the Somali immigrant population. Rather, it’s fear of just one shot: the MMR. It is a fear that antivaxers stoked, beginning sometime around 2008, and they have unfortunately been wildly successful in inculcating fear of the MMR in Somalis in Minnesota. Indeed, a 2014 study examined attitudes towards the MMR vaccine in Somali and non-Somali children in Minnesota and found:
Somali parents were more likely than non-Somali parents to have refused the MMR vaccine for their child (odds ratio, 4.6; 95% confidence interval, 1.2–18.0). Most of them refused vaccines because they had heard of adverse effects associated with the vaccine or personally knew someone who suffered an adverse effect. Somali parents were significantly more likely to believe that autism is caused by vaccines (35% vs. 8% of non-Somali parents). Somalis were also more likely to be uncomfortable with administering multiple vaccines at one visit (odds ratio, 4.0; 95% confidence interval, 1.4–11.9) and more likely to believe that children receive too many vaccines.
It was a small survey, but it was the only one I found in the peer-reviewed medical literature thus far. Its results are not surprising, however, to anyone directly involved with the Somali community, particularly public health officials. There haven’t (yet) been studies published about this latest measles outbreak, but there was a study about the 2011 measles outbreak in Minnesota, which, to that point, was the largest such outbreak in 20 years, with 21 cases identified. Its conclusions were also unsurprising. The source was found to be a 30-month-old US-born child of Somali descent infected while visiting Kenya and then spread to the Somali and non-Somali population primarily through the unvaccinated:
Three case-patients had unknown vaccination status, 1 was vaccinated before the recommended age (11 months), and 1 was a health care worker who was thought to be immune (IgG-positive documented >10 years previously). Sixteen of 21 (76%) were unvaccinated; 7 of 16 (44%) were too young for routine vaccination. Nine (56%) children were age-eligible for routine vaccination but unvaccinated, 7 because of safety concerns owing to the misinformation that MMR vaccine causes autism; 6 of these children were of Somali descent. Two other children did not refuse but were behind on immunizations.
This is how the outbreak spread:
This outbreak began with an unvaccinated US-born child who was exposed to measles in an endemic region of Africa and developed disease on return to the United States. Low vaccination rates in the local Somali community, and subsequent exposures among susceptible homeless shelter residents, fueled ongoing transmission of measles. Delay of the source case-patient’s measles diagnosis also may have contributed to transmission before public health interventions. Although post-exposure prophylaxis, vaccination, and voluntary isolation and quarantine were implemented after the first known case, there was ongoing transmission in 1 of the 2 affected shelters. This transmission was attributable to several factors, including exposures that occurred before the first identified case, an exposure of an infant too young for MMR vaccine according to the routine schedule, as well as exposure of an infant who was too young for the early MMR vaccine outbreak recommendation. Other contributing factors were caused by the challenges of quickly assessing and documenting immune status in a large group of individuals living in a temporary, communal setting. These challenges allowed transmission to individuals who initially were assumed to be immune, but who lacked documentation. After ongoing transmission was seen, immune status testing was implemented for those who lacked documentation.
Notably, two-thirds of the cases in this outbreak were hospitalized, and many of these were hospitalized for respiratory complications in addition to dehydration, highlighting that measles is a severe infection even in well-resourced countries.
If measles is as harmless as antivaxers claim that it is, then why were two-thirds of the people stricken with measles in this outbreak hospitalized for complications? That’s a rhetorical question for antivaxers, obviously.
The first question that faces Minnesota public health officials is, of course: How did we get here? The second is: What can be done to combat MMR fear-mongering? I can’t help but note that the fear of the MMR that is so prevalent among Somali immigrants in Minnesota, while primarily about the MMR, is bleeding over to other vaccines. Some Somali immigrants are starting to show susceptibility to the “too many too soon” myth and, as a result, spacing out the remaining vaccines other than the MMR that they are willing to administer to their children, believing that early vaccination can “damage an infant’s language skills.” Basically, if you live in Minnesota, combatting antivaccine and anti-MMR views in the Somali immigrant community is imperative. Even if you don’t live there, given that the Twin Cities area is a hub of national and international transportation, measles could be as short as a quick plane flight to where you live.
So let’s look at how we got here. Andrew Wakefield has his fingerprints all over this, but it didn’t start with him. As is his usual MO, he opportunistically took advantage of a situation, as he did when he discovered that Brian Hooker had been recording telephone conversations with a disgruntled CDC scientist.
2008: Autism in the Somali immigrant community
The story of how the myth that MMR causes autism became so firmly entrenched among Somalis living in Minnesota began sometime around 2008, with a cluster of autism cases among the community and a news story, as described by Bahta et al. in Minnesota Medicine:
Parents in Minnesota’s Somali community have voiced concern that their children are disproportionately affected by autism spectrum disorder (ASD) compared with children of other ethnicities. Many in the community blame the MMR vaccine. In an August 2008 news story on WCCO-TV, one parent was quoted as saying, “It’s the vaccines.”
Shortly after the story aired, the Minnesota Department of Health reached out to members of the Somali community to gather more information. Health department staff attended meetings with Somali parents, many of whom were unfamiliar with ASD. Repeatedly, they stated that they don’t even have a word for autism in their language. In telling her story, one mother reported that in their attempt to understand ASD, she and others discovered groups that supported the claim that vaccines, particularly MMR, cause autism. Misinformation can spread rapidly in the Somali community, which has a rich oral tradition of passing information to one another. It is now widely accepted among Somali Minnesotans that MMR is to blame for autism.
The antivaccine movement was all over this story in 2008. For example, David Kirby, author of the book Evidence of Harm: Mercury in Vaccines and the Autism Epidemic: A Medical Controversy, which was one of the early works using pseudoscience to link thimerosal in vaccines to autism was writing articles like ‘Autism May Be Caused By “Chemical Exposures”‘ specifically about the Somali community in Minnesota, with a “wink, wink, nudge, nudge” that the “idea that ‘chemical exposures’ (vaccine related or otherwise) might cause autism still brings virtual apoplexia to certain scientific circles.” He had previously hammered the same theme on the antivaccine blog Age of Autism, noting from the data presented that “rate of autism among Somali children in the public schools had been reported at 1 in 28 kids” and that the “80 or so Somali parents who attended were disappointed, by all accounts, that Dr. Punyko had no way to tell them if autism among their children was, as they strongly suspect, more common than among non-Somalis the same age.”
But was autism more than twice as common among the American-born children of Somali immigrants, as the data linked to above suggest? In early 2009, the Minnesota Department of Health released a study of autism among Somali immigrants. It is a substantial read. Here are a couple of key findings, which, as is often the case in studies of autism compared to parental perception of autism prevalence, are not as clear as the prevalent belief among the Somali community in Minnesota or as the antivaccine movement latched onto:
    • The administrative prevalence for three and four year old Somali children was significantly higher than for non-Somali children. This is consistent with the perceptions of the community that a larger number of Somali children were participating in ASD programs. Because of the study’s limitations, it is not proof that more Somali children have autism than other children; however, it does raise an important question about why Somali children are participating in this program more than other children.
    • The relative difference between Somali and non-Somali administrative prevalence decreased markedly over the three years covered by the study. It is unclear if this is an identification issue, a change in parental awareness for the need for developmental screening or some other issue.
    • Administrative prevalence rates for the Asian and Native American groups were found to be “strikingly low.” The reasons for these low rates are unknown, but they could be important to understanding whether the rate of ASD is higher among Somali children or underestimated among other children. In other words, the seemingly low prevalence rate among Asian and Native American children may artificially boost the comparative rate among Somali children, distorting a true understanding of all groups involved.
So, yes, administrative prevalence of autism was higher among Somali-Americans in Minnesota, but there were a lot of issues that made it difficult to use these data to determine for sure whether actual autism prevalence was higher, not the least of which was that as was noted in Left Brain, Right Brain, Department of Education data are not reliable for tracking autism. Jim Laidler made the same point in a publication in Pediatrics in 2005. Indeed, the most recent study of autism in the Somali-American community in Minneapolis was published in 2016 and found that Somali children were as likely to be identified with an autism spectrum disorder (ASD) as white children but that Somali children with ASD were significantly more likely to have an intellectual disability than children with ASD in all other racial and ethnic groups. Meanwhile, Steve Novella examined the cluster and proposed other potential causes for it, if even there was a cluster, such as vitamin D deficiency or a founder effect. Of course, as I pointed out above, it appears that children born to Somali immigrants are no more likely to be diagnosed with autism than white children; so there wasn’t even a cluster there. Unfortunately, it took eight years to figure that out.
By long before then, the damage had been done and the seed of distrust in the MMR and other vaccines had been planted by antivaxers. Over the next several years, as you will see, antivaxers nurtured that seed until it blossomed in the form of measles outbreaks.
Enter Andrew Wakefield
It’s not clear exactly when Andrew Wakefield first made contact with the Minnesota Somali community, but I do know that Age of Autism was on the case as early as August 2008 and that the founder of the antivaccine group Generation Rescue J.B. Handley published “An Open Letter to the Somali Parents of Minnesota” in which he told them it was the vaccines and that they can’t trust the local health authorities. He even went so far as to urge them to declare a “state of emergency within your community and create a new vaccine schedule for your kids.” Meanwhile, also as early as August 2008, David Kirby had been writing stories like ‘Is Autism an “American Disease?” Somali Immigrants Reportedly Have High Rates.’
I do know for sure from media accounts and triumphant blog posts in Age of Autism that he met multiple times with the community and its leaders between 2010 and 2011 and that he appears to be still intermittently in contact. For instance, here is one contemporaneous account in local media from 2010. It was a time when he proposed as “study” of autism in Somali immigrants and promised to raise funds for it, something he appears never to have done. At the same time he sold the study this way:
Minnesota Somalis worried about autism rates among their children recently invited controversial British researcher Andrew Wakefield to Minneapolis to talk to their community.
At a Somali community meeting in Minneapolis, Wakefield asked his audience to participate in a study. He told about a hundred people gathered at a Somali-owned restaurant that they could help find the cause of autism.
“It is solvable, it has a cause, it had a beginning and it must have an end,” Wakefield said. “We cannot accept the damage that is being done to all of these children. It is completely unacceptable and the suffering you’re going through.”
At the same talk, Wakefield claimed that there were no known cases of autism in Somalia, characterized in the story as an “anecdotal observation many Somalis confirm.” It staggers the mind that Wakefield would make such a claim (OK, actually, it doesn’t, given how big a liar Wakefield is), but it does not stagger the mind that Minnesota Somalis would find such a claim credible. Somalia is a poor country, and it does not stretch the imagination to speculate that most people living there are unfamiliar with autism. Nor does it bend credibility too much to observe that a Third World country is unlikely to have the same sort of screening and support programs for autism that we have in the US and other developed countries and that in such countries most cases of autism other than the most severe would go undiagnosed. Indeed, even the severe cases might well be diagnosed as mental retardation rather than autism.
Be that as it may, the cluster of autism in 2008 led to perceptions like this one:
She recalled a Somali mother who spoke at a public health meeting at the Brian Coyle Community Center some years ago. She had given birth to several healthy children in Africa, but her first child in the United States showed autism symptoms at an early age.
Wakefield visited Minneapolis again right in the middle of the 2011 measles outbreak to give a talk at a Somali restaurant. It was noted at the time that there were “a number of vocal pediatricians and doctors of Somali descent trying to speak out about this” but that distrust of health authorities was very high and local antivaccine groups like the Vaccine Safety Council of Minnesota were actively influencing Somalis. They still are. In 2016, for instance, the VSCM board member Patti Carroll published a warning to Somali parents that the Minnesota Department of Health “schools professionals to persuade Somali parents to give their children the MMR vaccine, despite clear opposition.”
Gee, you say that as though it were a bad thing.
That’s the problem, of course. Antivaxers are opportunistic in the extreme. If they see a population who are vulnerable to their disease-promoting message, they will pounce, and it’s always about the vaccines. They saw a story of a possible autism cluster among the children of Somali immigrants in Minnesota. Where scientists see such a story and ask “Is the cluster real and not spurious?” and “If it’s real, what might be causing it?” antivaxers see such a story and assume it absolutely, positively must be the vaccines. In this particular case, they took advantage of a newly arrived immigrant community’s lack of knowledge about autism and vaccines, its tradition in which information is primarily transmitted orally, and the distrust some of its members had for the local health authorities. The results are still playing out in catastrophically low MMR uptake and measles outbreaks.
What can be done?
As every source I’ve read over the years about the Minnesota Somali community and vaccines has stated, suspicion and fear of the MMR vaccine are now very much entrenched and will be very difficult to reverse. Indeed, it’s been pointed out:
Minnesota Department of Health staff found that fear of autism was often the reason for parents’ refusal to have their children vaccinated. Highly educated Somali Minnesotans are not exempt from this fear. As one Somali educator admitted, “My children did not get the MMR; my evidence is the Somali children I see who have autism.”
Parents who cited fear of autism as the reason for their vaccine hesitancy told health department staff that they received their information mostly from other Somali Minnesotans. Being told that MMR does not cause autism was not satisfactory for many parents because no one could tell them what does cause autism. Yet, when asked whom they would trust for health information, nearly all said they trusted their health care provider. And a significant number who refused vaccinations said they would reconsider their decision if they were given more information.
Parents of children diagnosed with ASD were articulate about their belief in an association between MMR and autism and sometimes also implicated receipt of multiple vaccines as the cause of their child’s autism. Some Somali parents have come to realize that autism and vaccines are unrelated, but they are in the minority.
Vaccine hesitant Somali parents thus resemble our own native-grown antivaxers and vaccine hesitant parents in many ways. Many are highly intelligent and educated. They get their misinformation about vaccines and autism from their peers more than from medical authorities. Also, it is the parents who have children diagnosed with ASD who are the most passionate and persuasive in arguing that vaccines are linked with autism, and, because of the low rate of measles (thanks to the MMR) many Somali parents view autism as a greater threat to their children than the measles and base their decisions about vaccines on that misperception. One difference is that, unlike many of our native antivaxers, Somali immigrants generally hold the medical profession in high esteem and are thus more open to being influenced by physicians and other clinicians. Actually, I should be a bit more clear. American antivaxers generally distrust the medical profession, while American parents who are vaccine-hesitant tend to hold the medical profession in higher esteem.
Be that as it may the Minnesota Department of Health has been trying to meet the challenge of reaching Somali parents through outreach programs in the schools and day care centers aimed at increasing awareness of Somali children’s growing vulnerability to vaccine-preventable diseases. Bahta et al note:
Finding ways to leverage the respect Somalis have for doctors and other health care professionals is challenging. In studies examining how clinicians can provide effective care to Somali patients, building trust has been identified as important. Two things that contribute to trust that are repeatedly cited in the literature are the availability of a competent interpreter and not feeling rushed by the clinician. Clinic policies such as ensuring that a professional interpreter is available, adding time to appointments when interpreters are needed, and consistently scheduling families with the same clinician can support efforts to build trusting relationships with Somali patients.
At their heart, strategies like these are no different than techniques used with the vaccine-hesitant of any race or nationality, adapted to Somali parents by including an interpreter. There’s one area where the Minnesota Somali community might be a bit different, though:
They also want clear direction from their physicians. Providing parents with options may confuse them. A statement such as, “We can give your child the vaccine today, or if you want, we can wait,” may be perceived by the parent as meaning that the clinician also has reservations about vaccines or thinks that either choice is acceptable. One Somali interpreter described an interaction this way: “When the mother told the doctor that she did not want her child to get the triple-letter vaccine, the doctor said, ‘OK.’” The interpreter was worried that the parent thought the doctor agreed that the MMR vaccine wasn’t needed or that he, too, was worried about its effects.
This is different from American parents, who tend to resent being told too firmly what to do and want to make their own decisions. Again, what this shows is the importance of flexibility in dealing with vaccine hesitant parents and how strategies and messaging, although generally sharing the same broad themes, have to be adapted to the specific population being targeted. It’s also important to remember that Minnesota Somalis are not monolithic. Although anti-MMR views predominate and antivaccine views have become common, there have been (and still are) members of the community who are joining forces with Minnesota health officials to push back.
Unfortunately, progress is likely to be slow, as changing entrenched beliefs is difficult and requires a sustained, targeted effort. In the meantime, the children of the Minnesota Somali community will remain vulnerable to measles and potentially other vaccine-preventable diseases and are likely to serve as the nidus for further outbreaks until the MMR uptake rate can be raised back to what it was in 2004. Remember, it took the UK many years to lift its MMR uptake level back to somewhere near where it was before Wakefield, aided and abetted by the tabloid press, caused the MMR panic. There’s no reason to expect that a similar recovery will take any less time in Minnesota.
Sadly, measles is the gift that keeps on giving, and nobody is better than giving it than Andrew Wakefield. The Somali immigrant community in Minnesota is now finding that out.

Minnesota Measles
There is currently an outbreak of measles in the Somali population of Minnesota – an outbreak that can be directly linked to antivaccine propaganda.
Steven Novella on June 7, 2017
Link


There is currently a measles outbreak in Minnesota. This was, unfortunately, entirely predictable – not, of course, that an outbreak would occur specifically in Minnesota, but that we would start to see outbreaks in communities with low vaccination rates.
So far Minnesota has seen 73 cases of measles. This is more than any year in the last 20 years (or more, that is how far back the tables go). In fact, that is more than all Minnesota cases combined in the last 20 years (56).
Nationwide we hit our low point for measles in 2004 with only 37 cases, all imported from other countries. This means that measles was eliminated from the US, with no native reservoir and no endemic cases. Measles, of course, has not been eradicated from the world and so we can still have imported cases. Thirty seven cases is down from the millions that would occur each year prior to the introduction of vaccines. The graph shows reported cases, which were as high as 800,000, but the CDC estimates that the real number was much higher as most cases went unreported.
There is no mystery what is going on – the modern anti-vaccine movement has been effective in spreading false fears about vaccines. Since 2004 the number of measles cases has been climbing. The recent peak was in 2014 with 667 cases, due largely to the Disney outbreak.
A vulnerable community
Something else happened in 2004 – Andrew Wakefield visited Minnesota. There is a Somali community there and they had been experiencing a relatively high number of cases of autism. They did not understand why there was a cluster of cases, and the cultural barrier complicated efforts to provide answers. I first wrote about this apparent cluster in 2008. In 2013 a long term study confirmed that there is a cluster in Minneapolis in general, but in greater numbers among Somali children.
There is also a cluster among Somali immigrants in Sweden, but not in other locations. The cause of these clusters is not currently known. Preliminary evidence suggests that low vitamin D levels may be playing a role, which makes sense for a dark-skinned population migrating to higher latitudes. It is also possible that the population simply has a higher genetic predisposition to autism which is just being recognized when they move to countries with better access to health care and services.
In 2004 the Minnesota Somali community had high vaccination rates, >90%. Then, after Wakefield’s visit, fear started spreading through the community that vaccines were the cause of autism. Vaccine compliance plummeted, and today less than half of Somali children in Minnesota are vaccinated.
This represents the predatory targeting of a vulnerable community by an ideological group for propaganda purposes. There is a direct correlation between anti-vaxxers targeting the Somali community and dropping vaccine rates, followed predictably by disease outbreaks.
The only thing we can do now is reach out to this community with efforts to educate them about the safety of vaccines in the hopes that vaccination rates will increase. However, once a fear is instilled it is difficult to eradicate. That is the more pernicious virus at work here.
This episode and the entire anti-vaccine movement also represent the hidden risk of the alternative medicine/appeal to nature narrative which is currently on the upswing. Ideas have a lot of cultural inertia, especially once they become embedded to the point that many people just take them for granted, and incorporate them into their world view and self-identity.
The notion that medical authorities are compromised and cannot be trusted, but that purveyors of natural cures are trustworthy, is nothing but marketing propaganda for snake oil. And yet this propaganda has been remarkably successful, because it is selling an emotionally compelling narrative. That narrative is not aligned with reality and has tremendous potential to cause harm.
The Somali measles outbreak is just one tiny example.

The benefits of the measles vaccine go beyond just protecting against measles, 2019 edition
It’s indisputable that vaccines protect against specific infectious diseases. What’s less well known is how a vaccine like the measles vaccine protects against more than just measles.
David Gorski on February 11, 2019
Link 

Editor’s note: By mistake, an unfinished version with a huge cut and paste error was originally published. That is entirely my fault. It has been fixed, and this is the correct version. Sorry about that.
It’s getting depressing. It’s as though nothing ever changes, and maybe nothing ever does. Regular readers probably remember the Disneyland measles outbreak four years ago. As bad as that outbreak was, however, it was an outbreak that made the impossible possible; in its aftermath, spearheaded by Sens. Richard Pan and Ben Allen, California passed SB 277, a law that eliminated nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine mandates. SB 277 was approved by the California legislature in June 2015 and signed into law by Governor Jerry Brown on June 30, 2015. The new law took full effect in the 2016-2017 school year, and it has worked. Nonmedical exemptions have plummeted. That’s not to say that the law is perfect. Unfortunately, there’s a huge loophole in that any physician can write a letter in support for a medical exemption. Not surprisingly antivaxers have taken advantage of that weakness in the law, namely that there is no overriding governmental body that reviews and approves requests for medical exemptions, as there is in, for example, West Virginia, where requests for medical exemptions are reviewed by an Immunization Officer, who determines if they are appropriate “based upon the most recent guidance from the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP), the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), and the American Academy of Family Physicians (AAFP) with respect to medical contraindications or precautions for each vaccine”.
As a result, medical exemption rates have increased, thanks to an increase in medical exemption requests, some likely organic from parents who found it easier to claim nonmedical exemptions than going to the trouble of claiming a medical exemption, but also due to bogus medical exemptions on sale from a cottage industry of antivaccine quacks like Dr. Bob Sears, who blazed the trail.
Unfortunately, we’re in the midst of multiple new measles outbreaks, the largest occurring in Washington, across the Columbia River from Portland, Oregon. As a result, the same battles from 2015 are taking place in 2019, this time with antivaxers rallying in a state with a major measles outbreak to oppose a bill that would eliminate personal or philosophical exemptions to requirements families immunize their children against measles, mumps, and rubella (MMR), led by—who else?—Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. and the usual cast of characters. This bill isn’t even as comprehensive as SB 277 in that it wouldn’t eliminate religious exemptions, but antivaxers are still fighting it with all they have. Of course, you can predict what will happen if this bill passes; antivaxers will all get religion.
As history repeats itself—whether this time as farce or not, I’ll leave the reader to decide, although arguably everything antivaxers do is infused with farce—there are other elements that keep repeating, in particular, the claim that measles is “not that big a deal” or “just a childhood disease.” You might remember the brain dead argument that because there was an episode of The Brady Bunch that made a joke about the kids getting measles, it must mean that doctors didn’t think measles was dangerous back then. It is, as I like to call it, the Brady Bunch fallacy. But is this true? The answer, obviously, is no.
The dangers of measles, take one: SSPE
Of course, we’ve discussed the dangers of measles before here on SBM many times. For instance, the complications of pneumonia, encephalitis, and perhaps the most feared complication of measles, subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE), a universally fatal complication in which the measles virus lies dormant in the brain, only to reactivate on average 7-10 years following the measles infection. As Steve Novella described it, SSPE leads to “severe brain inflammation. SSPE causes widespread damage to the brain. It usually starts subtly with changes in behavior, problems at school, difficulty walking, and muscle twitching. As the disease progresses it causes seizures of increasing frequency and severity, and progressive dementia. Eventually the disease leads to coma and death, on average 1-2 years from onset of symptoms. The disease is universally fatal and without any cure.” The risk of SSPE after measles had been estimated at one in 100,000, but it turns out that children who get the measles before age 5 could have as high as a one in 1,387 chance of developing SSPE, and kids who get the measles before age 1 could have a one in 609 chance.
It turns out that a “rare” complication of measles is not as rare as had previously been believed.
The dangers of measles, take two: a new study
Basically everyone, even the antivaccine movement, concedes that the measles vaccine is highly effective at preventing the measles. Actually, there are a few who don’t, but most simply try to argue that measles isn’t deadly and that therefore the fantastical “risks” ascribed to the vaccine by antivaxers (autism, neurodevelopmental disorders, diabetes, sudden infant death syndrome, etc.) outweigh the benefits of presenting measles. Be that as it may, the point is that the main benefit of vaccinating for measles has generally been believed to be the not-insignificant benefit of preventing the measles and its attendant complications, including the most dreaded SSPE. However, a new body of evidence is developing that the benefits of preventing measles go beyond just preventing measles and its known complications. In fact, it turns out that vaccinating against measles lowers all-cause mortality among children.
A new study adds to the growing evidence that measles is even more harmful than traditionally thought, making measles vaccination even more important than believed. From Science Daily:
In the largest study to date on children in a low/middle income country, new research in Ghana finds that the timing of a measles vaccine in an overall vaccination schedule can have a profound impact on child survival rates beyond protecting against measles infection. The findings, published today in open access journal Frontiers in Public Health, suggest that measles vaccination in the recommended sequence may have made an important contribution towards achieving the Millennium Development Goal 4 of reducing child mortality.
Here’s the study. Basically, it followed yearly cohorts of children aged 9-23 months from 1996 to 2012. The study area was the Kassena-Nankana East and West Districts in the Upper East region of northern Ghana, which have an estimated population is 160,000 of whom about 8% of the current population is aged 9–23 months. The area is quite large, covering a land area of 1,675 km2. Its major health care facilities include a hospital that serves as a referral hospital to seven health centers, a private clinic, and over 40 Community Health Compounds located in rural communities and manned by trained nurses who provide basic health care as well as routine vaccinations. The area is mostly rural (80%) with the primary occupation being agriculture.
Before we get to the results, here’s some background on the current vaccination schedule in Ghana and its history that will help put those results into context. The current schedule in Ghana includes one dose of Bacille Calmette–Guerin (BCG) at birth, four doses of oral polio vaccine (OPV) (at birth, 6, 10, and 14 weeks), three doses of pentavalent (Penta) vaccine (at 6, 10, and 14 weeks), two doses of rotavirus at (6 and 10 weeks), three doses of pneumococcal vaccines (at 6, 10, and 14 weeks), two doses of measles (at 9 and 18 months), and one dose of yellow fever (at 9 months). Note that Penta vaccine (diphtheria, tetanus, pertussis, Haemophilus influenza type b, and hepatitis B) was introduced in January 2002 to replace diphtheria–tetanus–pertussis (DTP), and in May 2012, three additional vaccines, pneumococcal, rotavirus, and second dose measles vaccine (MV), were added to the vaccination schedule for 18-month-olds.
For this study, a total of 38,333 children were assessed for survival in relation to the measles vaccination status within the first 12 months from interview date and until 5 years of age, using Cox proportional hazards models. The findings were quite striking. In essence, measles vaccine (MV), after the third dose of diphtheria-tetanus-pertussis (DTP, or DTP3), is associated with a significant decrease in all-cause mortality in the children in this cohort.
With that background, here are the details:
Children not vaccinated with MV at enrollment had 38% higher risk of dying than those vaccinated with MV-after-DTP3 during 12 months of follow-up [HR = 1.38 (1.15–1.66)] (Table 2). When mortality was assessed from interview date until 5 years of age, measles-unvaccinated children had 22% higher risk of dying than children vaccinated with MV-after-DTP3 [HR = 1.22 (1.05–1.41)]. The size of the beneficial effect of MV did not change when we censored for measles deaths (Table S1 in Supplementary Material).
Stratifying the analysis by periods in which DTP and Penta were used, children without MV in the DTP period (1996–2001) had 30% higher risk of dying in the first 12 months of follow-up [HR = 1.30 (1.04–1.62)] than those who received MV-after-DTP3. In the Penta period (2002–2012), children without MV had 52% higher risk of dying during 12 months of follow-up than those who received MV after Penta3 [HR = 1.52 (1.12–2.05)] (Table 2). The risk associated with not receiving MV did not change when we censored for measles deaths (Table S1 in Supplementary Material). When the children were followed from the assessment date until they were 5 years old, children without MV during the DTP period had 10% higher risk of dying than those with MV after DTP3 [HR = 1.10 (0.92–1.32)]. In the Penta period, children without MV had 44% higher risk of dying than those who received MV after Penta3 [HR = 1.44 (1.13–1.84)] when they were followed from the assessment date until they were 5 years old. The risk of dying for MV-unvaccinated children was higher during the Penta period compared to the DTP period in the first 12 months after assessment of vaccination status (52 vs 30%) (P = 0.021), and with follow-up to 5 years of age (44 vs 10%) (P = 0.005).
The most important qualifier in the results discussed above is this: “The risk associated with not receiving MV did not change when we censored for measles deaths.” In other words, even though the measles vaccine protects against measles, it protects against more than just the measles. Those who didn’t die of the measles were still protected by the measles vaccine from other causes of death:
We, further, classified the MV-unvaccinated children into two groups; children who received other vaccines but not MV, and those who did not receive any vaccine (unvaccinated). The adjusted HR for those who received other vaccines except MV compared with MV-after-DTP3 vaccinated children was 1.42 (1.18–1.72) in the first 12 months after assessment of vaccination status and 1.24 (1.06–1.44) with follow-up to 5 years of age.
So basically, the measles vaccine was the key, with decreased mortality associated with its receipt after DPT3. The authors looked for potential confounding factors, such as “general improvement in the health-care delivery system, health literacy as well as infrastructure, which could have affected the mortality rates and also increased MV coverage.” They also conceded that the comparison group of no measles vaccine “may represent the population with no access or difficult access to vaccines or health care, hence have higher mortality in general.” However, they pointed out that they still observed much higher mortality among MV-unvaccinated children compared with MV-after-DTP3 in “both communities with nurses and control communities without nurses” and that the “difference between the two groups disappeared making it unlikely that the difference in mortality is primarily due to inherent weaknesses or frailty.”
Overall, the results of this study clearly demonstrate a nonspecific benefit to measles vaccination, but the mechanism is unclear, particularly given the inconsistencies noted with previous studies, which the authors freely discuss:
Our results point to a beneficial effect of MV on child survival. The 38% higher mortality for MV-unvaccinated children would correspond to 28% lower mortality for MV-vaccinated children. Considering that this estimate is probably conservative, this is consistent with other studies from developing countries which have reported mortality reductions in the range of 30–86% (3, 6). Other studies comparing mortality rates before and after the introduction of MV reported major reductions in mortality after the introduction of MV (3, 28–31). The data from the present study also supported that MV may have non-specific beneficial effects which go beyond protecting children from dying from measles infection.
Measles vaccination was associated with beneficial effect for both boys and girls before receiving any campaign vaccine (Table 4). However, after the campaigns, we found a significantly stronger beneficial effect of measles vaccination for boys, but not for girls. It is unclear why the beneficial effect is stronger for boys as many other studies reported stronger beneficial effects of measles vaccination for girls than boys. For example the SAGE review suggested that MV had a 40% (22–53%) stronger effect for girls than boys (6). However, some studies have suggested that OPV is associated with stronger beneficial effects for boys than for girls (32, 33). Hence, we recommend that future studies examine the sex-differential effect of measles vaccination on all-cause mortality before and after OPV or measles campaigns.
I noticed this sex-associated difference as well, because I remembered a study from 2015 that I discussed, which observed the same thing (a decreased mortality in children vaccinated against the measles that couldn’t be explained by just its effect on measles incidence) but with a more marked effect among girls. The hypothesis supported by the study was that measles infection causes an immunomodulation/immunosuppression that lasts around three years after the infection and that can lead to increased mortality from other infectious diseases. Other studies are less clear-cut in terms of a mechanism, but several studies show an association between vaccination against measles (and a few other diseases) with decreased all-cause mortality.
Vaccines: More powerful than believed?
If “all” that vaccination did was to decrease deaths from infectious disease, they would still be the most effective preventative medicine ever conceived by the human mind, but it turns out that they might do even more than just prevent the diseases they are designed to prevent. Michael J. Mina hypothesized a mechanism in 2017:
A lot of this is speculative in that we don’t really know for sure how the measles vaccine contributes to decreased non-measles-related mortality. We just know that, even after eliminating confounders, a beneficial effect remains. We also know that this these beneficial nonspecific effects (NSEs) might occur with other vaccines, as the authors of the current study note:
Previous studies have suggested that OPV might have beneficial NSEs (32, 35, 36). Findings from a randomized trial suggested that OPV might have beneficial non-specific effects that reduced all-cause mortality by 17% (30). Though the underlying biological mechanisms have not been fully studied, some studies suggest that OPV, just like BCG, is capable of inducing strong immune training (36). In this study, the NID campaigns with OPV or MV might have reduced the effect of being MV-after-DTP3 vaccinated vs MV-unvaccinated.
As has been shown for BCG, beneficial NSEs may be due to epigenetic changes reprogramming innate immunity. This may change once the child gets a new vaccination (19, 20). The specific immunological mechanisms behind the non-specific effects of vaccine are still being investigated, and it might be a mixture of heterologous immunity, trained innate immunity, and other types of changes in the immune system (16, 19).
The irony, of course, is that antivaxers frequently (and loudly) claim that vaccines harm the immune system when, if these hypotheses hold up, it would appear that exactly the opposite could well be the case. Vaccines actually do “stimulate the immune system” in beneficial ways, and those benefits could well go beyond just preventing the diseases intended to be prevented. They might even prevent type I diabetes, too.

   Measles outbreaks, 2011
David Gorski 
Link
We frequently write about the consequences and costs of not vaccinating and how the anti-vaccine movement is causing real harm to real people through its assaults on public health. For example, through his fear mongering in the U.K., Andrew Wakefield, aided and abetted by a credulous and sensationalistic British media, managed to reverse decades of progress that had resulted in measles having come under control; as a result of plummeting vaccination rates in the wake of his 1998 Lancet case series, measles came roaring back in the U.K. Now it appears to be roaring back in Europe as well.
It’s bitterly ironic that news of measles outbreaks in the U.S. and Europe have come to the fore even as, over the long Memorial Day weekend, promoters of the scientifically discredited notion that vaccines cause autism gathered in a suburb of Chicago to sell “biomedical” treatments for autism and promote an anti-vaccine world view as part and parcel of the yearly autism quackfest known as Autism One. Adding to the grim irony is that last Thursday Nature published an issue with a special section devoted specifically to vaccines. The timing seemed just too deliciously appropriate to ignore. Think of it. In the Chicago area, there was a collection of anti-vaccine crackpots meeting to present fallacious “science” claiming that vaccines cause autism and all manner of chronic health problems. In contrast, one of the oldest and most distinguished scientific journals in existence publishes several articles in a single issue about vaccines. The karma was even stronger, given that the week before the CDC published a new Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report (MMWR) last week discussing the status of measles in the U.S.
The Nature vaccine issue has a number of articles on the topic of vaccines, ranging from an editorial, to news items, to scientific articles. For my purposes, three articles caught my attention:
    • The case of measles
    • The real issues in vaccines safety
    • Target the fence-sitters
The article discussing the case of measles is particularly relevant today, as we are in the middle of a resurgence of measles cases, both here in the U.S. and a much worse outbreak in Europe. In the U.S. we have had thus far this year 118 cases of confirmed measles, the most cases since 1996. Of these cases, 47 resulted in hospitalization and 9 in pneumonia. Fortunately, none had encephalitis, and none died, but that’s only because the risk of encephalitis is between 1:1,000 and 1:5,000. In an outbreak of 118, there’s only around a 10% chance (at the most) of having a case of measles encephalitis among the children. However, the more children there are who are infected, the greater the chance of complications such as encephalitis, and let’s not forget that we already have an 8% pneumonia rate.
Fortunately, MMR vaccine uptake in the U.S. remains generally high, although there are increasingly pockets of low uptake susceptible to outbreaks. Indeed, that’s what appears to be happening. As reported in Nature and the MMWR report cited above, measles was in essence eliminated from the U.S. in 2000. This was not easy to do; measles is one of the most contagious viruses that exist. Indeed, it’s the contagiousness of the measles virus that has allowed it to find its way back into the U.S. from other countries, as described in the MMWR report:
Among the 118 cases, 105 (89%) were import-associated, of which 46 (44%) were importations from at least 15 countries (Table), 49 (47%) were import-linked, and 10 (10%) were imported virus cases. The source of 13 cases not import-associated could not be determined. Among the 46 imported cases, most were among persons who acquired the disease in the WHO European Region (20) or South-East Asia Region (20), and 34 (74%) occurred in U.S. residents traveling abroad.
More worrisome, of the 47 hospitalized patients, all but one were unvaccinated, and the statistics were:
Unvaccinated persons accounted for 105 (89%) of the 118 cases. Among the 45 U.S. residents aged 12 months−19 years who acquired measles, 39 (87%) were unvaccinated, including 24 whose parents claimed a religious or personal exemption and eight who missed opportunities for vaccination. Among the 42 U.S. residents aged ≥20 years who acquired measles, 35 (83%) were unvaccinated, including six who declined vaccination because of philosophical objections to vaccination. Of the 33 U.S. residents who were vaccine-eligible and had traveled abroad, 30 were unvaccinated and one had received only 1 of the 2 recommended doses.
Do you see the pattern here?
Leaving a child unvaccinated leaves that child at a greatly increased susceptibility to measles and therefore a highly elevated risk of catching the virus when exposed. This is particularly true when enough people refuse vaccines to compromise herd immunity, so that the unvaccinated can no longer rely on the herd, which they’ve gotten away with doing in the past. Nowhere is this more evident than in Europe, where more than 6,500 cases were reported in 2010, and we have Andrew Wakefield to thank for decreased vaccination rates that are only now starting to recover, as this story in–of all places–The Huffington Post describes:
To prevent measles outbreaks, officials need to vaccinate about 90 percent of the population. But vaccination rates across Europe have been patchy in recent years and have never fully recovered from a discredited 1998 British study linking the vaccine for measles, mumps and rubella to autism. Parents abandoned the vaccine in droves and vaccination rates for parts of the U.K. dropped to about 50 percent.
The disease has become so widespread in Europe in recent years that travelers have occasionally exported the disease to the U.S. and Africa.
Although overall vaccine uptake rates are high, thanks to Andrew Wakefield, there are pockets of children whose parents fear the vaccine more than measles and have therefore not vaccinated. These pockets have been enough to allow measles not just to come roaring back in Europe, but to allow Europe to export its measles to the U.S.
Perhaps the most interesting perspective this week on the issue of vaccine rejectionism is the second article I cited above, Vaccines: The real issues in vaccine safety by Roberta Kwok, who notes in the beginning of her article that “hysteria about false vaccine risks often overshadows the challenges of detecting the real ones.” She begins by citing the case of John Salamone. We’ve met him before in the context of my review of Paul Offit’s most recent book, Deadly Choices: How the Anti-vaccine Movement Threatens Us All. Salamone’s son is an example of a real adverse reaction to a vaccine. Basically, his son got polio from the live oral polio vaccine, a known complication. His son got that vaccine, even though an inactivated polio virus vaccine known to be safer was available at the time, because the oral polio vaccine was cheaper and more easily administered. As a result, Salamone became a real vaccine safety activist, in contrast to the anti-vaccine activists at Generation Rescue masquerading as “vaccine safety” activists. He and other parents worked together to effect change, and the U.S. shifted to the safer vaccine in the late 1990s.
Kwok’s overall point is that these fake vaccine safety scares, such as the widespread belief that vaccines cause autism, have made it more difficult to identify real vaccine safety issues:
Vaccines face a tougher safety standard than most pharmaceutical products because they are given to healthy people, often children. What they stave off is unseen, and many of the diseases are now rare, with their effects forgotten. So only the risks of vaccines, low as they may be, loom in the public imagination. A backlash against vaccination, spurred by the likes of Andrew Wakefield — a UK surgeon who was struck off the medical register after making unfounded claims about the safety of the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine — and a litany of celebrities and activists, has sometimes overshadowed scientific work to uncover real vaccine side effects. Many false links have been dispelled, including theories that the MMR vaccine and the vaccine preservative thimerosal cause autism. But vaccines do carry risks, ranging from rashes or tenderness at the site of injection to fever-associated seizures called febrile convulsions and dangerous infections in those with compromised immune systems.
Serious problems are rare, so it is hard to prove that a vaccine causes them. Studies to confirm or debunk vaccine-associated risks can take a long time and, in the meantime, public-health officials must make difficult decisions on what to do and how to communicate with the public.
It’s true, too. So much time and effort of legitimate researchers, not to mention scarce research funds, have been wasted demonstrating again and again that there is no detectable link between vaccines and autism suggestive of a causative relationship. None of it is enough to convince the believers. Whenever yet another in a long line of studies is published that fail to find any detectable link between vaccines and autism or vaccines and other chronic conditions or diseases, the anti-vaccine believers brush it away and demand “more research.” Either that, or they demonize the researchers and those who point to those studies as being “pharma shills” or somehow possessing of nefarious motives of some sort or another. And so it goes.
The article then goes on to describe how public health officials have become increasingly vigilant about vaccine side effects, setting up intensive surveillance systems, most recently and famously for the 2009 H1N1 pandemic. Specifically, scientists were looking above all for evidence of a link between the H1N1 vaccine and Guillain-Barré syndrome, based on studies that suggested a link between the 1976 swine flu vaccine and this debilitating neurological syndrome. Studies thus far have not shown a link between the latest H1N1 vaccine and Guillain-Barré, which is good, but vigilance continues, not just for H1N1 vaccines but for every vaccine. The result of this surveillance has been to find a link between a rotavirus vaccine and intestinal intussusception, as well as a link between the measles, mumps, rubella and varicella (MMRV) vaccine and febrile convulsions. As a result, the MMRV was no longer recommended as a preferred choice.
Unfortunately, links are often not clear, and during the period of uncertainty between the first report of a possible vaccine complication and studies that either confirm or refute the link, public health officials are forced to make decisions on incomplete evidence. One current example is the possible link between the H1N1 vaccine Pandemrix and narcolepsy in young people. It is not yet clear whether this association is spurious or likely to indicate causation. Another aspect of this issue is whether there are genetic susceptibilities to adverse reactions due to vaccines. Contrary to what the anti-vaccine movement claims, scientists have never denied that there might be genetic factors resulting in increased susceptibility to vaccine injury. However, in science actual evidence is required, rather than speculation, and what we have now on this issue is, for the most part, speculation. It’s also not at all a straightforward issue to determine genetic determinants of increased risk for adverse reactions. Just as finding a genetic cause of autism has been difficult and full of dead ends, despite clear evidence of a strong heritable component, finding evidence of a genetic predisposition to vaccine injury is anything but a trivial task. Moreover, even in children who might have such a hypothetical predisoposition to vaccine injury, when the risk-benefit calculation is done it may well end up that the benefits of vaccines still outweigh the risks. Such would seem to be the case for children with mitochondrial disorders.
So how do we convince parents that the fear mongering by the anti-vaccine movement about vaccines and autism (or vaccines and all the other the movement tries to link with them, for that matter) is without basis in evidence and science and that it is safe to vaccinate? I agree with Julie Leask is at the National Centre for Immunisation Research and Surveillance, Discipline of Paediatrics and Child Health, School of Public Health, University of Sydney, New South Wales 2006, Australia, who wrote the last article that caught my interest, Target the fence-sitters. This is the way to go; the hard core anti-vaccine believers are not going to change their minds, no matter how much evidence you throw at them. We’ve seen this time and time again right here on this very blog, right here in the comments, stretching back over six years.
That’s why it’s a waste of time and effort to try to change the mind of the likes of J.B. Handley, Jenny McCarthy, Barbara Loe Fisher, Ginger Taylor, and others. There was a time when I thought that I could, but six and a half years of beating my head against the wall has taught me that I’m about as likely to succeed in changing their minds as I am to convince the Pope to become an atheist. It’s just not going to happen. What does happen is that I (and others) are attacked for our efforts. The bottom line is that I no longer care about changing, for example, J.B. Handley’s mind; I only care about countering his influence whenever possible. The fence-sitters can still be reached. They haven’t (yet) fallen down the rabbit hole of pseudoscience, autism “biomed,” and conspiracy mongering. There’s still hope to reach them, and reach them I try to do, using a variety of techniques ranging from pure sarcasm and full frontal assault to humor to dispassionate discussions of scientific papers. What works the best? I really don’t know, because I have no way of measuring. I do, however, keep trying. So do several other members of the SBM blog, who all have different styles, different levels of—shall we say?—aggressiveness in attacking pseudoscientific and unscientific claims about vaccines.
In the meantime, as the MMWR report on the 2011 measles outbreak in the U.S. and the articles in Nature demonstrate, the anti-vaccine movement is doing real damage as it reverses hard-won gains made against measles over the last four decades

Measles outbreaks and the antivaccine movement
Dr. Gorski returns from medical leave and finds that a lot has been going on with respect to vaccines, antivaxers, and measles outbreaks. Measles outbreaks are changing the narrative, emboldening legislators to tighten vaccine mandates, and also making antivaxers more radical. However, the narrative is, as is usually the case, more complex than what we usually hear.
David Gorski on April 15, 2019
Link

I’m ba-ack.
As I announced three weeks ago at the end of my last blog post before going on medical leave, I underwent surgery. In the nearly three weeks that I’ve been away, I thought about just how much to reveal and how much not to. Basically, I developed a pretty nasty cervical radiculopathy, complete with pain and some weakness. Conservative management, including steroids followed by two steroid injections, helped some, but I hit a plateau where I wasn’t improving any more. The pain was still quite bad, to the point where it was still interfering with my work; so I decided not to bother with a third steroid injection and went for surgery. Fortunately, I was a good candidate for a foraminotomy (enlarging the foramen, or hole, through which the affected nerve passes) and didn’t need removal of the disc and fusion of the two involved vertebrae. Thus far, the results have been good, although I do remain surprised at how much such a small incision can still hurt after nearly three weeks, but such is life. Now it’s on to physical therapy.
So what to write about for my return? This post might be a little disjointed and shorter than my usual logorrhea, because I’ll probably need a bit of time to get back up to speed. However, it’s pretty hard not to take note of all the vaccine-related stories that have been going on in my absence. For instance, thanks largely to the antivaccine movement, there are multiple measles outbreaks around the country. According to the CDC, as of April 4 there were 465 cases documented in 19 states, more than the total number of cases recorded in the last three years, and we’re only one quarter of the way through 2019. At this pace, we’re unfortunately currently on track to surpass 2014 nationwide total of 667 cases—and by a huge margin.
By far the largest of these outbreaks is centered in Brooklyn and Queens, with 285 cases since October (229 so far in 2019), most of which involved members of the Orthodox Jewish communities in those boroughs. Further up the Hudson River, in Rockland County, NY, there’s another outbreak ongoing, whose 2018-2019 total is up to 184 cases, which the Rockland County Department of Health breaks down this way:
Vaccination rates for confirmed measles cases in Rockland County as of April 12, 2019:
    • 81.0% have had 0 MMRs
    • 4.3% have had 1 MMR
    • 3.3% have had 2 MMRs
    • 11.4% unknown status
It is, of course, not at all surprising, as most of the cases have been associated with failure to vaccinate. Elsewhere another large outbreak is in progress centered in Clark County, WA just across the Columbia River from Portland, OR. There, they’re up to 74 cases. Not surprisingly, a prominent antivaxer, Dr. Paul Thomas, whom I’ve called a “rising star” of the antivaccine movement, practices in Portland and is making claims that he has almost no autism among his unvaccinated patients.
Unfortunately, we in southeast Michigan are not immune to this problem. We have a measles outbreak that’s currently up to around 40 cases, again associated with lack of vaccine uptake and international travel. (Indeed, I called it when I said that the first outbreaks in Michigan would occur in Oakland County, which is densely populated and antivaccine-central for the Detroit metropolitan area.) Considering all these measles outbreaks, I wanted to discuss two things: first, how these outbreaks have been shaping our conversation about vaccines, and, second, how they are interrelated. To discuss the second point, I will look at a news story that appeared yesterday in my local newspaper, The Detroit Free Press, entitled “How Oakland Co.’s Orthodox Jewish enclave became the epicenter for Michigan measles outbreak“. (I like to discuss local issues that are related to broader concerns, because, hey, how many skeptics and bloggers with a special interest in the antivaccine movement are based in the Detroit area?)
Antivaxers react to the backlash
If there’s one thing that’s been happening as a result of the ongoing and growing measles outbreaks throughout the US, it’s been a backlash against antivaccine viewpoints. It’s the same phenomenon that we observed after the Disneyland measles outbreak four years ago. It was that very backlash that provided the political will in California to pass SB 277, the law that eliminated nonmedical personal belief exemptions to school vaccine mandates. It’s a law that’s worked so far, with significant increases in vaccine uptake observed. Unfortunately, it became clear that SB 277 has a significant flaw. It’s a flaw that I pointed out soon after its passage, namely that any physician can write a medical exemption for basically any reason, regardless of whether that reason has a basis in science and clinical evidence. As a result, soon after SB 277 passed, a cottage industry of selling medical exemptions popped up, pioneered by antivaccine-friendly pediatrician Dr. Bob Sears, who was observed selling them online.
Unfortunately, after the measles outbreak abated, so too did the political will to pass further legislation making exemptions to school vaccine mandates more difficult to obtain. Here in Michigan, the Department of Health and Human Services did it administratively by requiring parents seeking personal belief exemptions to go to their county health department to undergo an educational course by a public health official before being granted an exemption. Even that small measure, although successful, resulted in a backlash among antivaxers, who successfully conflated the ability of parents to refuse vaccines for their children with issues of personal freedom and parental rights to persuade conservative legislators to try to pass legislation to make measles great again in Michigan. The bill, if passed, would have stripped from the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services the power to require parents to attend an educational program before being granted a nonmedical exemption for school vaccine mandates, but it’s even worse than that. The law, if passed, would have made it much more difficult to exclude unvaccinated children from school during an outbreak of vaccine-preventable disease. Meanwhile, in 2018 several Republicans actively campaigned on antivaccine-friendly promises in my state.
If there’s a good thing about this measles outbreak, it’s that the backlash against the antivaxers who contributed to it has once again forged the political will in several states to propose measures to tighten up the requirements for medical and non-medical exemptions. For instance, in California Senator Richard Pan, who co-authored SB 277 and lobbied to get it passed, has recently introduced a bill (SB 276) that would address the loophole allowing physicians to use any reason in justifying a request for a medical exemption by requiring the state health department to vet each medical exemption form written by physicians. The department would also maintain a database of exemptions that would allow officials to monitor which doctors are granting the exemptions, and the state would rely on federal guidelines to determine which reasons are valid for vaccine exemptions. This is the same approach that West Virginia uses.
Meanwhile, other states, including Washington and Maine, are considering bills that would end nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine mandates, while New York Mayor Bill DeBlasio issued a mandatory MMR vaccination order for the affected areas of the city. In Rockland County, a measles emergency was declared that barred children and teenagers who are not vaccinated against measles from public places. It was halted through a preliminary injunction soon after, but the fact that public health officials and politicians are now willing to go that far to control measles outbreaks is a sea change in attitude from even a year ago.
In response to the backlash, antivaxers have, predictably, dug in their heels and become even more intransigent. Perhaps the best example of this occurred a couple of weeks ago in Texas, when antivaxer Del Bigtree, who produced the antivaccine propaganda film disguised as a documentary (or, if you prefer, the antivaccine quackumentary), VAXXED, held up a handmade Yellow Jewish Star of David in “solidarity” with the Orthodox Jews of Brooklyn where a large outbreak of measles is currently centered.
The anti-vaccine crowd has evidently decided their persecution can only be expressed in Holocaust metaphors. At a rally in Texas yesterday anti-vax media personality Del Bigtree pinned a yellow star on himself mid-speech. pic.twitter.com/m672NNiEzY
— Anna Merlan (@annamerlan) March 29, 2019
Condemnation was swift:
This time, he had a prop: Near the end of his speech, he affixed a yellow Star of David to his coat with the words “No Vax” across the center. It was a symbol, he said, of solidarity with New York’s Orthodox Jewish community, which is in the throes of a measles outbreak.
Condemnation of the stunt—from the Auschwitz Memorial Museum and the Anti-Defamation League, among others— was swift. But Bigtree said he wasn’t worried about the criticism.
“Honestly, I was doing what I thought I was raised to do, which was stand up for minorities,” he told The Daily Beast in a recent interview. “A Jewish community was going to be quarantined and not allowed to go into their own synagogues during Passover. To me it seems so obvious that smacks of the issues in Germany.”
Bigtree’s explanation for why he used the Yellow Star of David is transparent, disingenuous nonsense. He’s never shown evidence of standing for minorities that I’m aware of other than in the context of the antivaccine movement. Indeed, he arguably exploited the distrust for the medial system held by African Americans in his use of Brian Hooker’s bogus “reanalysis” of a study that purportedly showed that the MMR vaccine was associated with an increased risk of autism in African-Americans. He’s gone to Compton to preach the evils of vaccination, not unlike the way that Andrew Wakefield went to Minnesota to fuel the measles outbreak among the Somali immigrant community there.
I’ve written about the penchant of prominent antivaxers to liken school vaccine mandates to the persecution of Jews by the Nazis. Indeed, RFK Jr. himself once likened vaccination to the Holocaust. (But don’t call him antivaccine!) This isn’t even the first time that antivaxers have misappropriated the symbol of the Nazi persecution of the Jews, the Yellow Star of David that the Nazis forced Jews to wear in order to be instantly identifiable. During the political battle in 2015 over SB 277, an antivaxer named Heather Barajas made a badge with a syringe on it. True, it wasn’t yellow, and it wasn’t a Star of David, but her intent was explicit in the Facebook post in which she showed off her new badge with her child in a photo with photos of Jews during the Holocaust wearing Yellow Stars of David. She deleted it, but I preserved it (unfortunately I did not preserve the text):
That was 2015. In 2019, everything’s been amped up, leading to Del Bigtree’s appropriation of the idea of a yellow star badge. Bigtree’s not the only one, either. Here’s a version that’s been popping up on social media all over the place:
As the measles outbreaks continue to grow and the backlash against antivaxers grows with it, I fear even worse reactions from antivaxers. After all, Del Bigtree has been known to say that “now’s the time for guns“, and during a trip to Michigan in 2016 said this in a speech to antivaxers:
If we do not fight now, then there will be nothing left to fight for. And I think that is where everyone in this room, I pray you realize how important you are in this historic moment. We will never be stronger than we are right now. We will never be healthier than we are right now. Our children are looking like this, a generation of children, as we’ve said on The Doctors television show this is the first generation of children that will not live to be as old as their parents. Are we going to stand…are we going to sit down and take it? Or are we going to stand up and say: This is a historic moment, that my forefathers, those from Jefferson all the way to Martin Luther King, the moments where people stood up and something inside of them said I’m going to stand for freedom and I’m going to stand for it now. That is in our DNA. It is pumping through me, and I pray that you feel it pumping through you, because we must look back. Our grandchildren will look back and thank us for having stood up one more time and been the generation that said, “We the People of the United States of America stood for freedom, stand for freedom. We will die for freedom today.
Yes, I know that Del Bigtree is a blowhard. I know that he is likely just playing to his audience with hyperbole. Even so, I’m not exaggerating when I say that I fear violence is not an impossibility. Antivaxers are already busy harassing physicians who speak out against antivaxers and for vaccines in order to intimidate them into silence. Online, they are arguably winning, because pro-science, pro-vaccine groups are only recently organizing more effective countermeasures against the threat, and Hollywood is starting to feature storylines illustrating the threat of the antivaccine movement. Even Saturday Night Live featured a sketch making fun of Jenny McCarthy and antivaxers the other night.
We’re all in this together, or: The narrative is more complicated than you think
The US is not the only place where there are ongoing measles outbreaks. Indeed, the outbreaks here pale in comparison to outbreaks elsewhere, particularly Europe, where there have been massive outbreaks including deaths, Israel, and the Philippines. In our local Sunday Free Press, there was an interesting story illustrating how vaccine hesitancy and antivaccine views must be combatted around the world. It’s by Kristen Jordan Shamus and it’s entitled “How Oakland Co.’s Orthodox Jewish enclave became the epicenter for Michigan measles outbreak“:
It was a traveler from Israel, state health officials say, who unknowingly brought the measles to Oakland County in early March, and sparked what has become the largest measles outbreak in Michigan in 28 years.
Before he came to visit an Orthodox Jewish enclave in Southfield and Oak Park, the man spent some time in New York, where an unrelated and fast-spreading measles outbreak among mostly unvaccinated children led the mayor last week to declare a state of emergency.
Once he got to Michigan, the man spent his time at Jewish synagogues and institutions to pray and study every day from March 6-13, unaware that he was spreading the virus along the way.
And:
Eliav Shoshana, a father of six from Southfield, didn’t know that the traveler had exposed him to the measles at Congregation Yagdil Torah in Southfield on March 9, said his wife, Henny Shoshana.
“My husband was sitting in a synagogue and studying Torah and praying” that day, Henny Shoshana said. “He realized in retrospect there had been a person there who seemed sick and was coughing a lot. He was covering his mouth. … I am sure he was horrified when he realized what had occurred. He probably had no idea that he had measles and that it is so highly contagious, even covering your mouth can allow some droplets to escape.”
What’s particularly interesting about this story are a couple of things. First, what got the measles outbreak going was a “perfect storm”:
“There was this perfect storm that led to the outbreak in the Michigan Orthodox community,” Henny Shoshana said. “In the run-up to this holiday, which as you can imagine takes a lot of preparation … people were contagious but not aware yet they were sick — either entirely asymptomatic or maybe feeling a little under the weather.
“Because it happened over Purim, the breadth of the exposure was enormous, obviously. That’s really the story of what happened over here.”
She recalls celebrating Purim at parties on the evening of March 20 and continuing until March 21.
“We went to this big party that had at least 150 people there, including infants and pregnant women,” she said. “And again, we went not knowing he was sick at all, and certainly not with the measles. Then, that night, he came home, and it was very clear he had a fever. So he stayed in bed.”
More importantly, it shows that it’s not just antivaxers that fuel outbreaks. Contrary to the Orthodox Jewish community in Brooklyn, where there is an even larger outbreak of measles, the Orthodox Jewish community in Michigan is pro-vaccine. What facilitated the spread of measles within the community was that there was a larger number of susceptible people than known. There were many adults who thought they were immune who turned out not to be:
“The quick spread of the virus,” said Lynn Sutfin, a spokeswoman for the state DHHS, “had more to do with how many places he visited, the number of people exposed initially (the couple weeks before Purim), and subsequent exposure of close/household contacts to confirmed cases.
“The other thing that played a role in this is the number of individuals who were susceptible to measles. Unfortunately, there were many adults who thought they were immune to measles but ultimately were susceptible.”
The result? The Council of Orthodox Rabbis of Greater Detroit issued a statement:
The response was immediate and striking. Members of the Orthodox Jewish Community turned out in droves to be vaccinated. In just three days, the health division administered 970 MMR vaccinations, and in one week the health department gave over 2,000 doses of MMR, not counting the hundreds of vaccine doses administered in private doctors’ offices to babies, children, and adults for whom documentation of measles vaccination could not be found.
Which brings me to another point. The narrative is not as simple as saying that antivaxers are solely responsible for measles outbreaks. They are, without a doubt, a major factor, but other factors contribute as well. Antivaxers are an easy scapegoat, the more so because they most definitely do contribute to outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases. However, they could not be so effective if there were not other factors that leave people unvaccinated and other situations. Combatting antivaccine misinformation is still critical, but it is not enough.

Another Measles Outbreak – Blame Antivaxxers
We are in the midst of record-breaking measles outbreaks. This is the time to push for stronger regulations and to get rid of non-medical exemptions.
Steven Novella on April 10, 2019
Link

We are in the midst of yet another measles outbreak, and this one is on track to be record breaking. The CDC reports:
From January 1 to April 4, 2019, 465 individual cases of measles have been confirmed in 19 states. This is the second-greatest number of cases reported in the U.S. since measles was eliminated in 2000.
The states that have reported cases to CDC are Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Massachusetts, Michigan, Missouri, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, Oregon, Texas, and Washington.
In 2014 there were a total of 667 cases, making 2019 already the second worst year in a decade, and on track to be the worst since measles was eliminated in the US. The 2014 cases were part of the Disney outbreak that continued into 2015. However the majority were from an unvaccinated Amish community in Ohio.
This year the outbreaks are all in communities where unvaccinated children are clustered. Make no mistake – the evidence is clear that these outbreaks are due to vaccine refusal, to the misinformation campaign of antivaxxers. The rate of vaccine refusal remains low overall in the US, but they do tend to cluster. These are pockets of susceptibility where this highly infectious disease can spread; you can’t hide in the herd.
From 2001-2015 about 70% of the total measles cases in the US were in those who were not vaccinated or had unclear vaccination status. The percentage of cases imported from outside the US decreased from 46.6% in 2001 to 14.7% in 2015, representing the rise of cases originating in the US.
The antivaccine movement kicked into high gear around the turn of the century with the publication of the paper by Wakefield suggesting a link between autism and the MMR vaccine (which covers measles). Even though Wakefield was thoroughly discredited, and the scientific evidence shows no such link, the antivaccine movement has spread. Some credit social media for the ease with which they were able to spread their misinformation.
We predicted that it would take a return of previously eliminated diseases before there would be public pushback against the antivaccine movement, and that is what happened in 2015 after the Disney outbreak. In 2016 California even passed a law banning non-medical exemptions. This worked, sort of, but since then the number of medical exemptions has tripled.
The law just created an industry of unscrupulous doctors giving away medical exemptions. In San Diego one doctor is responsible for one third of the medical exemptions given. They are sometimes just sold to patients, or given with little justification.
Clearly the response to 2014-2015 outbreaks was not sufficient. The antivaxxers just redoubled their efforts and found ways around the new restrictions. We are feeling the result now, with another record-breaking year of measles. And now we are in another political fight between those trying to protect the public health, and a small minority of parents who feel they know better than the consensus of scientific and expert medical opinion.
In Rockland County NY, center of a large outbreak, official have tried to ban unvaccinated students from attending school in an attempt to stem the spread of measles. However, a judge just put a hold on that ban while a lawsuit works its way through the courts. As The Washington Post reports:
But in the days that followed, parents from a private Waldorf school filed a lawsuit that called the ban “arbitrary” and “capricious.” The parents argued that county officials had exceeded their legal authority and that the ban “effectively prohibited their movement and denied them the right to congregate and assemble in public places.”
Yeah – that is the point, to restrict your right to congregate and assemble in public and spread measles. This is a feature, not a bug, of the proposed ban.
At least the recent outbreaks are forcing a public conversation about this issue. While the ethics seems fairly clear, we do want to strike a reasonable balance. It is well accepted, for example, that competent adults have the right to refuse any medical intervention. Parents also have the right to make medical decisions for their children, but the state has a right and a duty to also look after children and may intervene if the parent’s decisions amount to abuse or neglect. This is a reasonable big-picture balance, and the details will be endlessly tweaked and debated in court.
But with vaccines there is a new element to consider – because they affect the entire community, not just the individual. We rely on community immunity, which requires a critical threshold of people to be vaccinated to prevent the spread of an infectious disease. Adequate immunization effectively prevents isolated cases from turning into outbreaks, and outbreaks turning into endemic (self-sustaining) disease.
As we are seeing, even small numbers of vaccine refusers, if the congregate together, can form pockets in which outbreaks occur. Those outbreaks then spread to those who are vaccinated but did not form adequate antibody protection, or have legitimate medical exemptions from vaccines. When your personal decision can affect others in your community, the community has a legitimate stake and can use the legal system to protect itself. You can’t, for example, burn toxic substances on your property because the fumes will affect your neighbors.
As a reaction to the recent measles outbreaks, many states are tightening their laws. Most are simply getting rid of non-medical exemptions for vaccines, a move which we heartily endorse. You can’t simply say that you disagree with the science and choose to make a bad medical decision for the community. Again – there are many analogies to this. We have scientific and legal institutions so that we can make collective decisions for the public good, and we do try to carefully balance personal liberty with the needs of society.
This logic is partly what has lead to the many smoking bans. Your right to smoke is limited by the spread of that smoke into the air that someone else breathes, especially if that smoke causes harm. Similarly, your right to gather together into groups of unvaccinated people can legitimately be limited by the harm this does to the community by increasing the risk of disease outbreaks.
Further, states considering getting rid of non-medical exemptions should learn the lesson from California. You can’t simply leave it up to the discretion of individual practicing physicians, because even one outlier can veto the law by indiscriminately giving out exemptions. There also needs to be a standard in place that is enforced – what counts as a medical exemption? Doctors found to be giving out excessive exemptions should be investigated in the same way that doctors who are found to be writing disproportionate opiate prescriptions are investigated. We already have an enforced standard of care – it just needs to be applied to vaccine exemptions.
We also need to continue public education efforts to stem the flow of misinformation from the antivaccine movement, but I doubt we will ever be able to win that battle sufficiently. Even a small number of people can break the system of protection unless the restrictions are tightened significantly.
We can also look at it this way – antivaxers have been preaching for years that vaccines don’t actually work, that vaccine refusal is not the cause of outbreaks, and that these illnesses are benign anyway. Well – they caused a natural experiment of those claims, and they all failed completely. Vaccine refusal leads directly to outbreaks, because the vaccines work. The evidence is overwhelming, far more than sufficient to use as a basis for public policy.
Politicians now just need to do their jobs, to protect the public health (one of the fundamental missions of government), and not to cave to small special interest groups. These outbreaks do give us a window of opportunity to marshal the political will to craft proper regulations. The antivaxxers have left us no other choice.

Rise of the Miscellany of Medical Malarkey…Again
More deaths in the European measles outbreak. Experts call for a national registry of sleep-related deaths in infants. Raw milk puts several Tennessee children in the intensive care unit. Oh, and medicinal dog urine. It must be time for another miscellany of medical malarkey.
Clay Jones on June 29, 2018
Link

Some weeks I have time to dedicate my blogging efforts to a thorough discussion of one specific topic, and some weeks I just don’t. Fortunately, I came across a few newsworthy items that I think readers will be interested in, and only one of which involves drinking dog urine for its medicinal benefits. Welcome, once again, to yet another Miscellany of Medical Malarkey.
Measles continues to spread across Europe and people are dying
Thanks to a growing anti-vaccine movement and decreasing immunization rates, cases of measles have been on the rise throughout Europe. And despite the frequent claims from some anti-vaccine propagandists that it is a mild infection in healthy individuals with good nutritional status who are replete with vitamin A, implying that it’s fine for poor people in developing regions to suffer and die, in reality it is an infection with serious potential for morbidity and mortality. But don’t take my word for it.
In February, The New York Times reported that measles cases throughout Europe quadrupled in 2017 with over 21,000 recorded cases. I’m sure it goes without saying that this is almost certainly a significant underestimate of the actual numbers, and I’ll tell you why that really matters shortly. The largest outbreak took place in Romania, which had more cases in 2017 than in all of Europe the previous year.
Italy was a very close second with around 5,000 cases, Ukraine just a few hundred less than that, and several other countries had large outbreaks of up to 1,000 cases, including Belgium, Britain, France, Germany, Greece, Russia, and Tajikistan. Just under half of the reported cases were in children under the age of 15 years, but the single most effected demographic were children under a year of age. As expected, virtually all reported cases involved individuals who were not vaccinated or who had not received the full series. So the fact that these countries tend to have the highest levels of “vaccine skepticism” isn’t a coincidence.
But how many died from this “mild infection” that according to vaccine science deniers should run its course uneventfully in patients living in developed countries? I found a couple different answers, but most of the reporting and WHO data was somewhere in the 30-50 range. Most of these were in children, as would be expected.
In addition to the people of all ages that succumbed to the initial infection, we can also expect the eventual death of many of the young children that recovered in the years to come. This will include kids who had milder infections and weren’t officially diagnosed. This second round of deaths will come in the form of subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE), a horrific, slow-yet-steady cognitive decline that ultimately results in death. I’ve written about SSPE before. To be clear, there will be children and young adults years from now who begin having mild cognitive impairment that will, over several months, slowly progress to death.
The 2017 measles outbreaks across Europe have continued into 2018. In France, to give just one example, there have been roughly 2,500 cases since November. 88% of these patients were not fully immunized and about 1 out of 4 have required hospitalization.
This is France, which has better healthcare than the United States and a generally healthier population. Unfortunately, French health authorities announced that there is no region in the country that can boast levels of vaccine uptake that would provide proper herd immunity so they are primed for a major outbreak. Just this week, they announced two more deaths.
And while I realize that Papua New Guinea isn’t in Europe, and that Steve covered this in a post earlier in the week, I’ll still shoehorn in the announcement of polio cases popping up 18 years after the country was declared free of it. This is very scary stuff.
As many babies die unexpectedly during sleep in the United States every year as all pediatric motor vehicle fatalities combined
As a parent of young but rapidly aging* children, one of my greatest anticipated worries is the day that they are able to get behind the wheel of a car. I won’t be the first parent to lose sleep over this concern and I certainly won’t be the last because cars are terrifying death machines that kill thousands of people every year. We are constantly bombarded with reports of these accidents by our local news outlets, and many people can relate to this concern through personal experience.
But as a pediatrician, particularly one who primarily cares for newborns, the specter of sleep-related death haunts me as well. I spend a significant amount of time with each family discussing safe sleep practices that have been proven to reduce the risk of death during sleep, the most commonly known presentation being SIDS. SIDS deaths, however, are just one component of the total number of sudden unexpected infant deaths (SUID) that occur every year.
Unfortunately, the literature is confusing because historically different terms have been used in a haphazard manner to catalogue these deaths. In order to improve our ability to draw conclusions from the data, there has been a move to try to stick with SUID as a global category and then break it down from there. Only recently has there been the creation of a CDC registry to keep track of SUID cases, but only 16 states are currently contributing.
In a recent JAMA Pediatrics Viewpoint, three experts in the Rush University Department of Pediatrics call for more support for efforts to create a comprehensive SUID registry. They believe such a database can better guide research and help fine-tune public health efforts, and they use the dramatic drop in pediatric motor vehicle fatalities over the years as an example of how successful this approach can be. They point out that this is necessary because, after initial reductions in sleep-related deaths when the AAP and NIH endorsed Back to Sleep program was rolled out in 1992, there has been a plateau at around 3,700 yearly cases since 1999. This is equivalent to the current number of yearly pediatric deaths from car accidents.
One of their concerns, and I absolutely agree, is that many parents just don’t seem to take the risk as seriously as they should, and they may not be strictly following recommended safe sleep practices because of it. This may in part be because these deaths are not reported publicly in the same way that pediatric traffic fatalities are, giving a false sense that they are very rare. I’ll add that there is also a worrisome amount of science denial and misinformation available online regarding the risk factor of sharing a bed with young infants.
Consuming raw milk is dangerous, especially for kids
Earlier in the month, news of several children in Knox County, Tennessee being hospitalized with severe E. coli infections made the rounds. Many of the cases, and in particular the two toddlers featured in the news reports, were linked to the consumption of raw milk from a local farm. They were extremely ill and required ICU admission for management of a very dangerous potential complication, seen when children are infected with certain toxin-producing strains of the bacteria, known as hemolytic uremic syndrome.
HUS is serious stuff. I’ve been involved in the care of three children with HUS in my career. One died, one survived with permanent cortical blindness, and one had a full recovery. The two children in this story both developed kidney failure requiring dialysis, and needed multiple blood transfusions. One had a staph infection of his central line that complicated his course. Both are now home and continue to have residual kidney injury as of the latest report I could find.
The father of the two children admitted to being completely unaware that raw milk could result in such severe illness. This is unfortunate because that information is readily available through the CDC and numerous other trustworthy sources of medical information, not the least of which should have been the children’s pediatrician or family doctor. More unfortunate is the fact that the family had signed up for a “cow-share” program, which is perfectly legal while selling raw milk at a store is decidedly not, because they had read about health benefits of avoiding pasteurization.
This is dangerous misinformation. There is absolutely no health benefit experienced by consuming raw milk over pasteurized, only risk. It makes no sense to me that these cow-share distribution systems are legal. Thankfully the family is now speaking out about the risks of raw milk consumption, a refreshing outcome considering the response of Ezekiel Stephan’s parents to their child’s death by worldview.
Finally, medicinal dog urine?
Yes, it’s a thing. Not that there are medical benefits, just that apparently some people believe that there are. The woman in question collects a clean catch specimen of her clearly well-trained pooch’s urine every morning, topped off by the neighbor’s dog if supplies are limited, and down it. She claims that it has given her perfect skin, cured her depression, and prevented cancer since she began this routine two years ago. I feel compelled to point out that she has also not been attacked by a bear in the past two years.
She began drinking dog urine after reading a decades-old study that discussed antibodies being found in human urine, although I doubt she just stumbled on it. The interest was probably already there. She also says something about a Big Pharma conspiracy but it doesn’t really matter why though, does it? Urine therapy, even using animal urine, isn’t new but it certainly isn’t mainstream. It’s pretty ridiculous actually.
There obviously isn’t any good evidence that it is beneficial in any way to drink urine. There is, however, good reason to consider not drinking it, especially canine urine. Leptospirosis, a serious infection that can cause meningitis and organ failure, can be spread through exposure to dog urine. Wait, the neighbor’s dog? How do you start that conversation I wonder?
See you next time.

*To be clear, my children are aging at the normal human rate. They aren’t Benjamin Buttoning. It is my false perception of the passage of time that gives me the impression that they are gaining at least two years to my one.

U.S. Measles Elimination Status in Jeopardy as the Number of Cases Reach 25 Year High
Thanks in large part to anti-vaccine propaganda and decreasing vaccination rates, 2019 is shaping up to be a bad year when it comes to measles outbreaks, the worst in over 2 decades to be exact. And we are now at risk of losing our hard-fought elimination status.
Clay Jones on May 31, 2019
Link

Remember 1999? Of course you do. That was the year the euro was established, Clinton was acquitted, and Bill Gates became the richest man on Earth. But wait, there’s more.
1999 was the year that Napster debuted. Remember Napster? 1999 also brought us The Phantom Menace, The Matrix, and The Sixth Sense. He was a ghost the whole time!
Any music fans out there? In 1999, a sassy teenager from Kentwood, LA named Britney Spears arrived on the scene. Lauryn Hill won all the Grammys and Cher made a huge comeback with “Believe”, becoming the oldest woman to top the Billboard Top 100. And Gary Glitter was arrested for downloading child pornography.
A lot of things happened in 1999, ranging from the very bad (Columbine) to the very good (Bran the Broken was born. Too soon?). In regards to science-based medicine, however, 1999 is particularly important to me, not only because it was the year that I entered medical school but because it marked the last year that measles was considered to be endemic to the United States. And in early 2000, the CDC made it official: measles was eliminated.
This didn’t mean that there wouldn’t be the occasional case, or even small outbreak, involving foreign travel. But with vaccination rates at record high levels, we were confident that measles was no longer something we would need to worry about here in the United States. Soon after, the entirety of the Americas were declared free of continuously circulating measles virus. Elimination of measles from the world was within our sights, similar to the way we rid ourselves of smallpox.
Sadly, the tide began to turn as the anti-vaccine propaganda that has been well documented on the pages of SBM took its toll on vaccination rates. Over the past several years we have seen significant increases in European measles cases, and more recently huge outbreaks in places like Madagascar and the Philippines. After years of steadily declining worldwide deaths caused by the infection, we have begun to see an increase. We haven’t been spared here in the United States as more and more children are not being vaccinated.
In medical school, I learned about the clinical manifestations of measles, but it was taught largely as a historical disease. My education on measles primarily involved discussion of the safety and incredible effectiveness of the vaccine. Wherever the measles vaccine is made available, and uptake is high, measles cases decrease dramatically. Millions of lives have been saved.
So I learned about the way patients ill with measles present, but I never thought it was particularly important information to keep readily available as I progressed through my general medical and then pediatric training. I figured that the likelihood of encountering a patient with measles was essentially zero. I’ve had to adjust my expectations.
The United States is currently experiencing multiple outbreaks, largely occurring in predicted hot spots. In just the first 5 months of 2019, a mere two decades after the declaration of its eradication here, we have had more measles cases than in any year since 1993, officially eclipsing the number of cases in 1994 as of May 30th. We now sit at 971 total cases.
According to the CDC, we are close to a huge lurch backwards in our fight against ending this deadly disease:
If these outbreaks continue through summer and fall, the United States may lose its measles elimination status. That loss would be a huge blow for the nation and erase the hard work done by all levels of public health. The measles elimination goal, first announced in 1963 and accomplished in 2000, was a monumental task. Before widespread use of the measles vaccine, an estimated 3 to 4 million people got measles each year in the United States, along with an estimated 400 to 500 deaths and 48,000 hospitalizations.
A few weeks ago I found myself in our pediatric emergency department admitting a child with fever and a rash to the hospital. For the first time in my medical career, I felt the need to seriously consider the possibility that I was seeing my first case of measles. After a thorough history and physical exam I was able to rule it out, but I did take the opportunity to teach a group of students about the condition. I shouldn’t have had to do that. The experience made me angry. Okay…angrier.
There have been two recent cases of measles in the Boston area so far this year. I’m worried that there will be more. Despite what is often spouted by anti-vaccine propagandists, measles is not a benign disease. It is a big deal. It has killed millions of children worldwide, sometimes in horrific ways.
I’ve been reading a lot about measles over the past few weeks, and learning more about its history, epidemiology, and the myriad ways it effects the human body than I ever wanted to. It’s fascinating, and more than a bit scary. And again, it makes me angry. More to come in two weeks.

More COVID More Measles?
There are a number of potential problems children are facing that are related to the ongoing SARS-CoV-2 pandemic, not the least of which is a rise in vaccine hesitancy and even anti-vaccine belief.
Clay Jones on December 23, 2022
Link

A quick Christmas Eve Eve post on a very serious topic.
The list of problems caused by the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic is long and, in some cases, more than a bit surprising. Clearly the death and suffering of millions of people around the world tops that list. You’ll get no argument from me or, I think, anyone else here about that. Then there is the unfortunate economic upheaval that most, if not all, countries have been dealing with.
But I’m a pediatrician, so what about the kids? Won’t anyone think about them? Yes! Unsurprisingly, children have also suffered greatly over the past nearly three years. In the United States alone, there have been roughly 15 million documented pediatric COVID-19 cases, which is undoubtedly a massive underestimate of the true incidence. And in addition to the direct repercussions of infection, with a not-insignificant number of deaths and many more hospitalizations for severe disease, children have also had to deal with a variety of other problems, not all of which could have been predicted. Nobody was expecting MIS-C in early 2020, for example.
Adding to the possibility of that severe and even life-threatening inflammatory condition, even children with only mild COVID-19 are at increased risk of developing diabetes, to give just one of several more examples. There have also been significant increases in ED visits and hospitalizations for mental health crises in our teen and young adult populations. This really is just the tip of the iceberg as there are a number of post-COVID-19 conditions that have been seen in children, with as many as 25% still having symptoms a month after diagnosis. Between 2% and 10% of children diagnosed with COVID-19 will ultimately develop the more disruptive syndrome of post-acute sequelae of COVID (PASC), also known as “long COVID”.
But today I want to discuss a different issue related to the pandemic that is indirectly harming children and has the potential to do so for a very long time. During the peak of the pandemic, when people were trying to stay home and avoid COVID-19, millions of children got behind on their routine immunizations. This was, and is, a worldwide phenomenon. The WHO recently estimated that 40 million children missed a dose of the measles vaccine in 2021 alone, putting them and potentially millions more around them at risk of developing this potentially deadly disease.
In addition to lack of access, the pandemic has also appeared to fuel a wave of anti-vaccine sentiment in the United States. Being against routine childhood immunization, something that has saved countless lives and prevented suffering in so many innocent children, is becoming a plank in the GOP platform. This growing number of people that are wary of vaccines is adding to the number of children who will not be protected from vaccine-preventable illnesses.
I’ll finish up by letting you know what’s going on in central Ohio, where a measles outbreak among children is currently underway. Since late October, more than 70 children have been diagnosed with measles and 26 of them have been sick enough to require hospitalizations. Remember, despite it’s often bland portrayal in sitcoms and cartoons of the past, something that has been wielded as an anti-vaccine talking point, measles is a terrible illness that historically put 25% of infected kids in the hospital and killed 1-2 per 1000.
37% of the infected children in the current Ohio outbreak have been hospitalized so far, which underscores the fact that we don’t have effective treatments. There is no modern medical anti-viral triumph that cures this disease. There is supportive care and correcting vitamin A deficiency, which has been linked to increased risk of death. The modern medical triumph was the vaccine.
All of the 73 children infected with measles in Ohio, at least through last week, were not fully vaccinated against the disease, with 67 of them having not received any doses. 17 of the infected children were too young to have received their first dose. So for most of these kids, their caregivers made a choice to avoid the vaccine.
On that unfortunate note, I hope that everyone out there reading this is happy, healthy, and enjoying the holiday season. Stay warm, stay safe, and see you next year!

   Measles Outbreaks on the Rise
Steven Novella on March 20, 2024
Link

The WHO reported over 30,000 cases of measles in the European Region in 2023, up from less than a thousand in 2022 – a 30 fold increase. This year is already looking to have an increase in measles in many regions, with outbreaks noted in Chicago, Sacremento, and the UK.
There have been 41 cases so far in the US this year, while there were 58 cases for all of 2023. In 2000 measles was declared eliminated from the US. That means it is no longer endemic, with all new cases being imported from outside the US and immediate spread from those cases (causing outbreaks) but no continuous spread. However, if we have continuous outbreaks for a year or more the US will lose its “eliminated” status, and we have been on the brink of this happening in recent years.
This story, of course, is all about the measles vaccine – MMR. This is a safe vaccine that effectively prevents infection with measles, which is otherwise a highly contagious disease. Measles is a serious infection, that also weakens the immune system, making those infected more susceptible to other infections.
The good news is, we have an effective MMR vaccine program in the US (part of the overall childhood vaccine program) – by 24 months of age 90% of children are vaccinated against measles, and by teenage years the number is 92%. That’s good for any public health program. However, because measles spreads so easily, it is estimated that we need 95% coverage in order to achieve herd immunity, the level at which the disease can no longer spread through a population.
Also, total percentages may be misleading, because local communities may have lower vaccination rates. In Chicago, for example, where the CDC just sent people to help contain an outbreak, they warn that vaccination rates have dipped from 95% to 93%. This is just enough to go below herd immunity. In other locations experiencing outbreaks the numbers are worse – the UK has about an 85% vaccination rate against measles, far below herd immunity levels.
In some parts of the world vaccination is about resources, but even in poor countries there are international programs to fund vaccination. The real challenge is in getting >95% of people to do something. We can lower the barriers by making it free and easy, we can do public education and outreach. Such measures get you to the UK level of about 85%.
The evidence is pretty clear and overwhelming – in order to get >95% of people to do something, even something that is in their own personal best interests, is to mandate it. That is the difference between the US and the UK numbers – childhood vaccines are mandated in the US in order to attend public school, and they are not in the UK. This is also why the UK lost their measles elimination status while the US (so far) has not.
In the US, while we have mandatory vaccines for school entry, the various states also have different rules for exemptions. This creates 50 natural experiments – and the result clearly show that looser rules for exemptions result in decreased vaccine uptake and increased risk of outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases. hj
And of course there is another factor at play here – this is not just about getting people to be responsible about their preventive health care, there is also an active anti-vaccine movement spreading fear and misinformation. This misinformation spreads easily across social media, which also fuels general conspiracy theories and distrust of authorities, experts and institutions. The primary cause of vaccine hesitancy is viral misinformation.
This causes a genuine dilemma for free societies. The Supreme Court recently heard a significant case in which the 5th circuit appellate court ruled the government violated the first amendment when it “significantly pressured or coerced” social media companies to remove misinformation about COVID-19 from their platforms. This is a complicated case I can’t do justice here – but the issues involve the right of citizens to say things in the public square that are objectively wrong, even harmful, the governments duty to protect the public vs their power to suppress speech, and the degree to which social media companies are private entities with their own free speech (manifest through editorial policies). Further, if the government pressures a social media company to take down a post, does the social media company become an agent of the government, triggering the first amendment? If so, then how does the government protect its citizens from harmful misinformation?
Recent measles outbreaks and the MMR vaccine uptake are on the front lines of this issue. That 2-3% variance which can take us above or below herd immunity is likely a result of misinformation on social media. Also, there were likely thousands of deaths from COVID directly due to misinformation on social media.
At the same time, we see (with China, for example) that a totalitarian government can effectively use social media and digital technology to tighten their grip on society and create an overwhelming surveillance state. In short, sometimes giving the government the power to do good, also gives them the power to do bad.
There is therefore no simple solution, but that does not mean we should stop searching for one. At the very least this means finding the proper balance of the current factors at play – social media companies, the government, and free speech. But we likely will have to search for methods that allow for the identification and removal of demonstrably false and harmful information that represents a direct risk to public health, without violating free speech or giving any entity too much power to act unilaterally. This will likely mean that we need a process that has total transparency, and significant checks and balances.
The other factor here is the degree to which we can collectively mandate certain behavior. This already exists – see the entire legal system. We have speed limits, seatbelt laws, public health regulations, environmental protection regulations, and countless other laws and regulations that prohibit or mandate certain behaviors. The general legal rule is that the government has the burden of demonstrating a compelling interest in fulfilling its duties to the public to justify any restriction of personal liberty, and that the government is taking the least restrictive option to achieve its goal.
Personally I think that mandating vaccines that have been proven safe and effective, and limiting exemptions to medical reasons, fulfills these criteria. Without such mandates we can expect to be increasingly plagued by measles and other vaccine-preventable infectious diseases.

Another Year, Another Measles Outbreak
Another year is here, and that means more measles outbreaks here and around the world as far too many children (and some parents) lack protection from the safe and effective vaccine.
Clay Jones on January 19, 2024
Link

A little over a year ago, I wrote about a measles outbreak in Ohio in the context of increasing concerns of the pandemic’s effect on vaccination rates around the world:
During the peak of the pandemic, when people were trying to stay home and avoid COVID-19, millions of children got behind on their routine immunizations. This was, and is, a worldwide phenomenon. The WHO recently estimated that 40 million children missed a dose of the measles vaccine in 2021 alone, putting them and potentially millions more around them at risk of developing this potentially deadly disease.
In addition to lack of access, the pandemic has also appeared to fuel a wave of anti-vaccine sentiment in the United States. Being against routine childhood immunization, something that has saved countless lives and prevented suffering in so many innocent children, is becoming a plank in the GOP platform. This growing number of people that are wary of vaccines is adding to the number of children who will not be protected from vaccine-preventable illnesses.
The 2022-2023 Ohio outbreak ended up putting 36 children in the hospital with 85 total measles infections. Every single infected child was not fully vaccinated, which makes sense given how amazingly effective (and safe) the vaccine is. There were no deaths during that outbreak, though it is only a matter of time. And because of the nature of measles infections, which can lie dormant and cause death years later in a small but very real percentage of cases, we can’t say with certainty that all of these children are safe.
Though some improvements in vaccination rates around the world were seen in 2022, the issues with vaccine availability, hesitancy and refusal, in many cases fueled by blatant anti-vaccine propaganda, is still a big problem. 2023 data likely won’t be available for a few months, but it is safe to say that millions of children were left at risk of this potentially debilitating and even life-threatening disease and many thousands will end up dying because of it. Certainly there will be some regions with lower rates of vaccine uptake, but every region, and every community, will continue to have problems.
A perfect example of this is currently impacting Philadelphia, which has an overall measles vaccination rate of 93%. That may sound good, but 95% is necessary in order to achieve herd immunity against measles in a community. With such a contagious virus, having 7% of children unprotected means that there are enough for outbreaks to occur, particularly if social factors result in clumping of unprotected children in specific schools, churches, or other groups. It is important to remember that even with higher vaccination rates, any unlucky at-risk individual could still be at the wrong place at the wrong time.
As of yesterday, 9 cases of measles have been reported in Philadelphia in the past month. The index case was a young child who had recently visited a high risk country and was subsequently hospitalized. It wasn’t until 2 days after their admission that he was diagnosed with measles, however, and two others were infected before appropriate containment was initiated. One of these was an infant too young to have received the MMR vaccine and the other, an older child, was unvaccinated. That child’s unvaccinated parent also became ill.
The additional cases occurred because one of the infected children was sent to daycare in violation of quarantine recommendations. The most recent reported case is the fifth originating at the daycare. So far, 6 of the 9 cases have required hospitalization but they have all been discharged home. But it’s early. An outbreak can’t be considered over until two incubation periods have passed since the last case, so about 40 days.
The measles virus can remain airborne and infectious for 2 hours, so close contact isn’t required. Simply getting into the wrong elevator is enough. Fairly nonspecific flu-like symptoms in a non-immune individual can take up to 2 weeks to appear, but the classic rash can take another 3-5 days. This means that it is very easy to be out and about in a community without realizing that you have measles, and you are able to spread the disease for a few days prior to, and a few after, the rash appears. Most people recover uneventfully, but severe lung disease and inflammation of the brain can occur (and is more common in young children), with the overall mortality rate for measles being about 1-2 per 1000.
Things are much worse in across the pond. Europe reported more than 30,000 cases of measles last year, a massive 30-fold increase from 2022. Currently England, specifically the West Midlands area, is the epicenter of measles in the region with an ongoing outbreak of at least a couple hundred cases, 50 of which required admission to a hospital for care. Numbers are higher in other regions, particularly the Middle East and Africa. Overall, 136,000 deaths were caused by measles in 2022, an increase of 43%. And again, there is a general expert agreement that this is all the result of significant decreases in vaccine rates during the early years of the pandemic.

Doctors on Measles: “NEVER Listen to the Anti-Vax Cult When They Say This ‘Natural’ Disease is Harmless”. Doctors on COVID: 😂
Measles and COVID are different, of course, but they are not categorically different. With both viruses, unvaccinated children suffer the most. Yet, doctors who rightly said “measles can be a devastating childhood illness” also said it was “breathless fear-mongering” to acknowledge that COVID can also be a devastating childhood illness.
Jonathan Howardon September 22, 2023
Link

Measles: The New Red Scare
In 2019, an article titled “Measles: The New Red Scare” revealed several key anti-vaccine techniques. It ridiculed parents who wanted to protect their children against measles, saying they fell into an “emotional fear-based primal mental algorithm”. It asked its readers to “to step back from the hysteria”, and minimized measles deaths in children by arguing that hardly any died prior to the vaccine. It said:
In fact, if we look at all the causes of death from the United States Vital Statistics in 1962, we see that measles accounted for 0.02% of deaths that year…In 1962, measles was sixth from the bottom for causes of death. You can look through the list of causes of death and find almost everything from “Birth Injuries” at 28,199 to “Ulcers” at 12,228 to “Asthma” at 4,896 were far higher than the 408 deaths attributed to “Measles” that year.
These are standard an anti-vaccine sleight of hand tricks. Through mockery and irrelevant comparisons, anti-vaxxers have one revolting goal: to make you yawn at dead children.
Of course, it’s appropriate for parents to fear measles, and the only numbers that matters are these:
Before the measles vaccination program started in 1963, an estimated 3 to 4 million people got measles each year in the United States, of which 500,000 were reported. Among reported cases, 400 to 500 died, 48,000 were hospitalized, and 1,000 developed encephalitis.
That is a huge number of dead and suffering children, not hardly any. Happily, the measles vaccine wiped that all way. Though the future may be grim, at least for now, American children aren’t dying of measles. That’s a good thing. As vaccine-advocate Noah Louis-Ferdinand said:
One of the great achievements of US public health is that almost all kids reach adultment. Thats like a whole generation of heartbreak made very rare. So when we have the opportuntiy to reduce it *even further* with a vaccine, you take it.
You don’t say, “eh that’s not that many.”
Doctors and measles
When it comes to measles, every reasonable doctor agrees with Mr. Louis-Ferdinand. Dr. Vinay Prasad recently wrote, “Measles can be a devastating childhood illness”, and he is absolutely right. Indeed, before the pandemic, normal doctors were rightly bothered when children suffered needlessly from measles, or any other vaccine-preventable illness for that matter. Measles outbreaks got international attention, because they were easily preventable, and they revealed a broader truth about the potential of misinformation to cause real suffering.
In 2019, for example, anti-vaccine activists fueled a measles outbreak in Samoa causing 83 deaths, mostly in young children. In December that year, Dr. Zubin Damania (ZDoggMD) recorded a podcast titled Deadly Samoan Measles Outbreak, What Can We Learn? In it, he rightfully pushed back again the idea that we should accept children dying from measles simply because hardly any died. He said:
The tragedy of measles deaths in Samoa is a stark warning: NEVER listen to the anti-vax cult when they say this “natural” disease is harmless.
He pitched the episode on Twitter by saying:
Measles outbreak in Samoa, 60 dead (mostly children under 4), and the antivaxxers will say measles is a safe and natural childhood rite of passage.
Like Dr. Prasad, Dr. Damania was absolutely correct about all this. Measles is not harmless just because it is natural and the preventable deaths of children should not be brushed off just because hardly any died. No reasonable doctor argued with Drs. Prasad or Damania or accused them of “breathless fear mongering” for telling the truth about measles. It used to be normal for doctors to be upset when several hundred unvaccinated kids contracted measles, even though none died, thankfully. In fact, prior to the pandemic, normal doctors agreed that even a single child dying of a vaccine-preventable disease was a big deal. Only quacks shamed parents for “fearing” measles or argued that we should let it kill and maim children today, because more died of asthma in 1962.
Doctors and COVID
Things are very different with SARS-CoV-2.
In April 2021, two months after recording The End of the Pandemic with Dr. Monica Gandhi, Dr. Damania recorded Focused Protected for COVID with Dr. Jay Bhattacharya. Dr. Bhattacharya is an anti-vaccine misinformation doctor who never treated COVID patients, but claimed herd immunity would arrive in 3-6 months if only 250 million unvaccinated, “not vulnerable” Americans contracted COVID simultaneously in October 2020. In this podcast, Dr. Damania heaped praise on Dr. Bhattacharya for his plan of mass infection of unvaccinated youth saying, “You’re fearless, you’re compassionate, you’re rational.” He also said:
Even though this thing (COVID) has killed less than you know, or, or about as many as flu would kill in a normal year in kids, I say hardly any.
By this point in the pandemic, the American Academy of Pediatrics reported 297 pediatric deaths – hardly any according to Dr. Damania. Millions more children had yet to be infected, and around 2,000 children have now died of COVID. As with measles, COVID can injure children without killing them. Nearly 200,000 children have been hospitalized with COVID, and some were very sick, needing mechanical ventilation in the ICU. Rarely, children have strokes, or required amputations or lung transplants. Nearly 10,000 children suffered from MIS-C, and most of these children go to the ICU. 79 children died from MIS-C. Other children are gravely impacted by Long COVID. All of this would have been much worse had we allowed 73 million unvaccinated children to simultaneously contract COVID as many doctors proposed.
Measles once exacted a nearly identical toll on children, and COVID’s pediatric impact greatly exceeded that of many other diseases for which we vaccinate children. Of course, it doesn’t matter exactly where COVID ranks on the list of deadliest viruses. Multiple pathogens can hurt children, and it’s entirely appropriate to protect children against all diseases that pose a risk to them. Before the pandemic, it wasn’t controversial to use vaccines to save the lives of hardly any children.
COVID’s pediatric death toll, compared to other vaccine-preventable diseases
How things have changed
And let’s review how much things have changed. During the pandemic, many doctors underwent a dramatic transformation, where justified anger about suffering children was replaced by a casual indifference and mockery, only because a different virus was injuring and killing children. In 2019, Dr. Damania was rightly enraged by children dying of measles, even though hardly any died, just a few dozen. In 2021, however, he said hundreds of dead children was hardly any, only because COVID was the cause.
Dr. Prasad, who said “Measles can be a devastating childhood illness”, routinely minimizes COVID using the same mockery and rhetorical chicanery as the author of “Measles: The New Red Scare“. He’s argued that unvaccinated children should contract COVID because more die of suicide, for example, and routinely belittles those who disagree, accusing them of “breathless fear mongering”. He implied that children killed by COVID aren’t “real lives” and that we should accept their deaths “as a matter of course“. He’s mocked Andrew Wakefield, while mocking those who exposed anti-vaccine data fraudster, Dr. Joseph Ladapo.
Other doctors wrote articles titled The Triumph of Natural Immunity and Tweeted “natural immunity wins again“. They said young people should not fear literal death from COVID, because only 4,560 young people died in the pandemic’s first 5 months – hardly any. These same doctors said rare vaccine side-effects, which are milder than, say, literal death, demanded “respect“. They advocated the mass infection of unvaccinated youth, and some treated the consequences as a joke.
Before the pandemic, a doctor who called vaccine-advocates “idiots” or used a laughing emoji to discuss children sickened by measles would have rightfully been a pariah in the medical community. Today, they get promotions.
Today, a virus that sickens and kills children is 😂
Most children with COVID do well. Most children with measles do well, as anti-vaxxers point out frequently. The COVID vaccine is not perfect. The measles vaccine is not perfect, as anti-vaxxers point out frequently. Measles and COVID are different, of course, but they are not categorically different. With both viruses, unvaccinated children suffer the most. The COVID vaccine is not as effective as the measles vaccine, sadly, but this is not a reason to not use it. These vaccines are not in competition with each other, and the COVID vaccine has already spared a meaningful number of children from rare, but grave harms. A recent study of children under 5-years, those with the highest risk by far, found:
That children who received two or three doses of the updated COVID-19 vaccine were 70% less likely to wind up in the ER or urgent care due to COVID and 60% less likely to see their doctor compared to unvaccinated kids.
Dozens of other studies show similar results. There’s no clear difference I can see between a doctor who spreads misinformation about measles and one who spreads misinformation about COVID.
Unfortunately, many doctors made it a core mission to discourage pediatric vaccination – for COVID, not measles. We all agree, only a quack would encourage parents to leave their children vulnerable to a dangerous disease like measles. However, these doctors acted as if there were a core, fundamental difference between a child killed by measles and one killed by COVID. One would be a grave tragedy, while the other “breathless fear-mongering”.
In reality, the only difference between a child killed by measles and one killed by COVID, is that children killed measles don’t exist in the US. Blessedly, measles has not killed an American child in over 30 years. That’s not true for COVID. Tragically, there are children who would still be alive had they been vaccinated against COVID. Am I “off my rocker” because I think that’s sad and want to prevent similar tragedies in the future? Or is it strange that doctors feign concern about viruses that killed zero children for the express purpose of leaving them vulnerable to a virus that killed 2,000 children?
Viruses that killed 0 children are “truly dangerous” compared to the one that killed 2,000 children.
Why I care
I write about this topic so often, because I fondly remember the days – not long ago! – when all reasonable doctors told parents, “NEVER listen to the anti-vax cult when they say this ‘natural’ disease is harmless”. I remember when it was normal for doctors to be upset by any unvaccinated child suffering from any vaccine-preventable disease. I haven’t changed a bit. I still feel this way, even though this belief now makes me the object of scorn and contempt from some of my fellow doctors. On a personal level, it’s dizzying to be called a “book-selling schmuck” and similar juvenile japes simply because I still believe what all reasonable doctors once believed: we should use vaccines to save children from grave harms, even if it’s hardly any children.
I write about doctors who now plagiarize anti-vaccine talking points to infect children with SARS-CoV-2, not just because I disagree with them, but because I admired many of them a great deal. I didn’t expect better from quacks. However, I expected better from them. I suspect their pre-pandemic selves would agree. During his 2021 podcast, the 2019 version of Dr. Damania made a momentary return and asked about his own “hardly any” comment:
I mean, again, it’s not, that’s not that’s not compassionate to the people who’ve lost children. Right?
Right.
Doctors would have cared, had she died of measles

Measles Deaths Surge Worldwide Thanks to Poverty and Anti-Vaccine Propaganda
According to recently released WHO/CDC data on worldwide measles mortality, 2018 marks the second year in a row with a significant increase since the historical low in 2016. And 2019 is shaping up to be even worse. The main reason for this is poverty and lack of access is resource poor regions.
Clay Jones on December 13, 2019
Link

As the year limps to the finish line, new data from the World Health Organization and the CDC is shedding light on just how much we are losing ground in the fight against suffering and death caused by measles, a vaccine-preventable viral infection. According to the new estimates released last week, more than 140,000 people lost their lives in 2018. Most of these deaths occurred in young children:
Most deaths were among children under 5 years of age. Babies and very young children are at greatest risk from measles infections, with potential complications including pneumonia and encephalitis (a swelling of the brain), as well as lifelong disability – permanent brain damage, blindness or hearing loss.
Prior to the development of a safe and effective vaccine, which was introduced in 1963, there were millions of measles cases around the world and about 2.6 million deaths each year. The success of the vaccine, largely thanks to donor-driven efforts to reach the poorest regions of the world where the risk of death is higher, has been incredible. Though there have been serious concerns over lower than desired vaccine coverage in many areas, both resource poor and rich, worldwide measles deaths plummeted to an all-time low of 90,000 in 2016.
Since 2016, cases of measles have increased steadily, so it should come as no surprise that there have been more deaths. In 2017, 110,000 people died as a result of the virus. The 2018 data, as described above, confirms two consecutive years with a significant increase in mortality. 2019 is likely going to give us a third.
I’ve written about our 2019 year of measles here in the United States, which at nearly 1,300 cases is the worst since 1992. Things haven’t been any better worldwide, with the most cases since 2006 being reported though the first half of the year. When the 2019 mortality data is eventually made available, I’ll almost certainly cover it on SBM. Prepare yourself for the possibility that somewhere in the ballpark of a quarter of a million children will have died this year.
Of course, the number of reported deaths caused by measles each year is almost certainly an underestimate of how many ultimately will die from the infection. In October, the concept of immune amnesia in the aftermath of measles infection was a hot topic because of new and confirmatory data. Children who survive a bout of measles, in addition to the possibility of death years later from SSPE, are also at increased risk of serious infections because of an impairment of the immune system that can last for years.
Why are measles cases increasing? Unfortunately, the success of the worldwide vaccine program peaked about a decade ago. Currently only 86% of children around the world receive the first of two recommended doses of the measles vaccine, and only 70% get the second. This is well below the percentage required to prevent outbreaks, which because of the extreme communicability of the virus is 95%. That gap in coverage allows for outbreaks, and currently every WHO region is experiencing at least one that is large and extended.
These numbers reflect average coverage percentages, which means that there are large numbers of children who live in so-called hotspots where coverage rates are sometimes considerably lower. As I discuss in the post I’ve just linked to, this can represent bastions of anti-vaccine ideology in wealthy nations such as the United States. Or, as discussed in the WHO/CDC news release on the 2018 death toll, an insufficient access to appropriate care in resource poor regions plays the largest role:
In 2018, the most affected countries – the countries with the highest incidence rate of the disease – were Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC), Liberia, Madagascar, Somalia and Ukraine. These five countries accounted for almost half of all measles cases worldwide.
What are we doing about it? Although we often focus on anti-vaccine propaganda and the effect of it on immunizations rates, that’s not the issue that is causing the most harm worldwide. That distinction unequivocally belongs to poverty, which results in both lower immunization rates and increased risk of morbidity and mortality when measles infections occur.
In 2001, the American Red Cross, the CDC, the United Nations Foundation, UNICEF and the WHO founded the Measles & Rubella Initiative:
The M&RI aims to reach the measles and rubella elimination goals of the Global Vaccine Action Plan by supporting countries to raise coverage of measles, rubella and other vaccines; fund, plan, implement and monitor quality supplementary campaigns; investigate outbreaks and provide technical and financial support for effective outbreak response, propose and participate in solutions to strengthen immunization delivery; and support a global laboratory network for measles and rubella.
This program has been astoundingly successful, having provided vaccines for just shy of 3 billion children around the world and saved millions of lives. One of the stated goals of the M&RI though has been to eliminate measles in five of the six WHO regions by 2020. Sadly, we don’t appear to be on target to do that. Measles is almost completely preventable, and it really could be eliminated from the Earth just as smallpox was decades ago. All that is needed is money and the political will to make it happen. (Insert joke about politics here)

Measles 2024: ‘Merica, are you okay?
Measles cases are increasing. Kids and even many adults are at risk of injury and death from this vaccine-preventable illness that should be a historical footnote.
Clay Jones on August 2, 2024
Tweat

In January, I discussed the first measles outbreak of 2024 here in the United States, specifically in Philadelphia. That outbreak was officially over in late February and ended up involving six children and two adults living in the city with one additional case diagnosed in someone who was visiting. Six of the cases resulted in hospitalization but there were no deaths…yet.
Nine cases of measles in a city with a population of more than 1.5 million might sound unimpressive. I get it. It’s a tiny percentage. Measles, to risk anthropomorphizing a deadly virus, doesn’t care what your or I think. Because of the S-tier contagiousness of the measles virus, even a city with an overall immunization rate of 93% is not protected against the possibility of significant outbreaks. This could have been much worse, as I explained in my earlier post:
That may sound good, but 95% is necessary in order to achieve herd immunity against measles in a community. With such a contagious virus, having 7% of children unprotected means that there are enough for outbreaks to occur, particularly if social factors result in clumping of unprotected children in specific schools, churches, or other groups. It is important to remember that even with higher vaccination rates, any unlucky at-risk individual could still be at the wrong place at the wrong time.
We are now over the halfway point for 2024 and measles has continued to be an issue, which should come as no surprise. Childhood immunization rates have yet to return to prepandemic levels, a problem that is not isolated to the United States. This means that there are still millions of children around the world who are at risk of catching measles and who could serve as an index case for a severe outbreak that results in large numbers of children being injured or killed pretty much anywhere they might travel.
So how are things going so far here in the United States?
As of last week, 188 measles cases have been reported to the CDC from 27 different jurisdictions, which is a 3-fold increase compared to the total for all of 2023. Even states with high immunization rates, like Massachusetts, have reported cases this year. There have been 13 clusters of 3 or more related cases, which is how the CDC defines an outbreak, which have accounted for two thirds of the total number so far.
Breaking the numbers down a bit more, and none of this is unexpected, most cases have occurred in the young (43% under age 5 years) and underimmunized (85% unvaccinated/unknown, 10% with one MMR dose). 5% of cases involved fully immunized (2 doses of MMR) individuals because no vaccine is 100% effective. This is why herd immunity is such an important concept, particularly with measles.
In order to achieve herd immunity, and to provide a meaningful barrier of protection for those who are too young to be fully immunized, or for those who have a legitimate contraindication, 94% of eligible people would need to be immune. Taking into account the small chance that two doses of MMR do not result in immunity, which is generally considered to be 4%, you need a higher percentage of eligible people to get the shot. But because people who intentionally avoid the MMR, whether because of vaccine hesitancy or firmly held anti-vaccine beliefs, often cluster together, it is exceedingly difficult to protect them fully via herd immunity because it only takes one mission trip to Uganda, for example, to bring measles back to a highly vulnerable community in, say, Tallahassee.
Of the 188 cases reported so far this year, half were hospitalized with 61% of patients under age 5 years spending some time as an inpatient. What is not clear is how ill these patients have been. Some were probably admitted out of an abundance of caution with the intention to quarantine them rather than because they had severe disease. No deaths have been reported so far, but again we need to give it a decade or two to say with certainty that none of these cases resulted in death because of the late-onset terror that is SSPE.
Measles is a dangerous infection. It can cause serious morbidity and result in death from acute injury to the lungs and brain, and a small but scary number of deaths from brain injury years after a seemingly uneventful recovery. Historically this amounted to about 1-3 deaths per 1,000 cases in the United States. That number was probably a significant underestimation, however, as we have only recently recognized the increased risk of bacterial infections in the months after measles as a result of immune amnesia.
Fatality rates would very likely be lower in the United States in the event of major outbreaks involving thousands of people, but there would be deaths. 188 cases and counting is the highest since we saw more than a thousand in 2019, a total that we are unlikely to see this year. Still, as immunization rates continue to decline or remain stagnant, it truly is only a matter of time before we see another major outbreak or three. We clearly need to do better, but frankly I don’t see the tide turning in the current climate. Fingers crossed.

Measles is back, and so are all the old antivax tropes about it
Measles is back, and so are all the old antivax tropes about the disease and the vaccine. Unfortunately, there’s an antivaxxer in charge.
David Gorski on March 3, 2025
Link
I frequently quip that, with respect to the antivaccine movement, there is never anything new under the sun and everything old is new again. Rarely have I seen a better example than the antivax response to the ongoing measles outbreak in Texas in an undervaccinated population, which, according to the Texas Department of State Health Services, has as of Friday sickened 146 *and counting), hospitalized 20, and claimed the life of one unvaccinated child. It’s been a long time since I’ve felt the need to write about measles, the antivax movement, and the MMR vaccine, but this outbreak, which continues to grow and is being joined by cases and (thus far) smaller outbreaks in a total of ten states (and, likely, counting). Unfortunately, this time around, the person in charge of all nonmilitary health agencies, including the most important one whenever there is any outbreak of infectious disease, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), is a longtime antivax activist and conspiracy theorist, Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. It is accurate to say that, never before in living memory (or even in the history of the US) have we had someone so detached from science and reality at the helm of our federal health agencies. (Not even during the first Trump administration was this the case, and look at how incompetent the initial response was to the COVID-19 pandemic.) That’s why I thought it a good time to write about the measles outbreak and how, unfortunately, this time around a lot of antivax tropes about measles are going to be official government policy.
Buckle up, it’s going to be a painful ride into measles misinformation that I haven’t written about in a while, in the context of an outbreak. I did, however, write about how RFK Jr.’s apologists tried to gaslight the nation about his activities promoting antivax beliefs during the deadly measles outbreak in Samoa in 2019. I’ll get back to that in a moment. First, however, let’s look at the first major trope, namely that measles outbreaks are common and no big deal, the corollary being, “So why are we getting so worked up over measles?”
Quoth RFK Jr. (at first): Measles outbreaks are “not unusual”
Faced with the first outbreak of a vaccine-preventable disease on his watch, you might wonder how RFK Jr. would respond. In fairness, the outbreak had started late January, which was before he was sworn in as Secretary of Health and Human Services, although I wouldn’t entirely absolve him given how he has been a key figure in promoting fear, uncertainty, and doubt (FUD) about vaccines going back 20 years. Moreover, the the outbreak is still raging and growing; so it’s his responsibility now. One might wonder if, faced with actual responsibility for dealing with a potential public health disaster, RFK Jr. might be chastened. His initial response was not encouraging, given that he said, more or less, that, even after the death of a child—the first measles death in the US in a decade and the first child to die of measles in 22 years—was the outbreak was. As Rex Hippie at USA TODAY noted, when asked about the measles outbreak by a reporter at Trump’s first cabinet meeting last week, RFK Jr. basically shrugged his shoulders:
Kennedy showed his deep empathy and concern for the Texas outbreak, which has now claimed the life of an unvaccinated child, by giving the verbal form of a shoulder shrug during President Donald Trump’s first Cabinet meeting this week.
“There are two people who have died, but we’re watching it,” Kennedy said, with the deep human compassion one expects from a dead-eyed conspiracy theoristwith a taste for roadkill bear-cub meat.
Apparently he’s not watching it too closely. Texas health officials say only one person has died, a child in Lubbock, the first child to die from measles in 22 years. But hey, one death … two deaths … who’s really counting?
It is rather shocking that any HHS Secretary would get such a basic fact wrong, although it is not at all shocking at all that RFK Jr. would. It is even more shocking that any HHS Secretary or federal public health official would respond to a large outbreak that has killed a child with a shoulder shrug and saying, in essence, “Hey, shit happens.”
But, wait, I hear RFK Jr. apologists saying. What about what he posted to X, the hellsite formerly known as Twitter, on Friday, a couple of days after that cabinet meeting? On the surface, it looks as though RFK Jr. has backtracked on his longstanding antipathy towards the MMR vaccine:
On the surface, this sounds…OK, at least not bad. Did the weight of having actual responsibility affect his beliefs? I doubt it. Also note that bit about vitamin A, which I’ll get to in a minute. It’s a favorite old antivax trope that is now official CDC guidance.
You might wonder why RFK Jr. mentioned providing communications materials in Low German. That’s because the focus of the current measles outbreak is in a Mennonite community in western Texas. Many Mennonites speak Plautdietsch, a Low German dialect, for which there appears to be no one accepted written form of the language. In fairness, it should be emphasized that, as was the case many years ago when it was claimed that Amish communities don’t vaccinated, there is nothing inherent in Mennonite beliefs that prohibits vaccination; although some conservative sects do not vaccinate. Indeed, according to one pastor in the area:
In an interview Wednesday, Jake Fehr, the pastor at Seminole’s Mennonite Evangelical Church in Gaines County, said there’s a “misconception” that all Mennonites aren’t vaccinated. The 40-year-old pastor said his entire family has been vaccinated, including himself. All of his children who attend public school are vaccinated, and he estimated that about half of the church’s 800 members who live in the area are also vaccinated.
Since he began working at the church in 2017, Fehr claimed he’s never preached about vaccinations from the pulpit and that Mennonite religious doctrine doesn’t oppose vaccinations of any kind. “We have not been out there teaching against vaccinations or for people not to obey the government,” Fehr told Chron, adding that his “church family hasn’t been affected largely” by the measles outbreak; he was aware of only two cases in his congregation.
Of course, that’s not entirely true, as the story goes on to describe, as it describes just his congregation, which appears to have been lucky thus far (luck that could easily soon run out) given that only half of his congregation’s children have been vaccinated, a percentage far below the 90-95% vaccine uptake threshold needed to achieve herd immunity against measles, which is one of the most highly contagious viruses known to humans:
However, Fehr acknowledged that the church-affiliated private school, where children aren’t required to vaccinate, was one of several Mennonite schools in the area to shut down for several days after an increase in measles cases. He also noted that there’s “some validity to the fact” that a conservative faction of Mennonites, known as Old Colony Mennonites, and conservative non-Mennonites in the majority Republican county haven’t been vaccinated.
“It’s not necessarily that there’s this specific script for reference that they would take as to why they wouldn’t. However, they’re sort of reluctant to adopt a lot of governmental ways,” Fehr said of the unvaccinated individuals. “So, they’ve just made what I would consider to be personal health choices for their families.”
The outbreak has since spread to nine Texas counties and across the border to New Mexico. Whatever the reasons—and, in fairness, it is also noted in this story that this is a rural area where “some people there live a far distance from healthcare options while others choose not to vaccinate due to various reasons and enroll their children in private schools or homeschool.” Likely, a combination of religious beliefs, political ideology, and isolation and distance from easy access to healthcare have contributed to low vaccine uptake in the affected Texas counties.
Regardless of why vaccine uptake had been low in these western Texas counties, the outbreak started there and is growing larger. A child has died. As for providing vaccines to the counties, good. I hope that the CDC is doing that; it’s the bare minimum that the CDC should be doing, although one wonders how RFK Jr.’s fans, who have imbibed deeply of his antivaccine messaging, one of which being that the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine causes autism and is more dangerous than the disease and portraying all vaccines as unsafe. Indeed, two weeks previously, he had been on Laura Ingraham’s show, where he proclaimed:
Vaccines are the one medical product that is exempt from pre-licensing safety studies.
So I sued HHS a few years ago, in 2018, and I said, show us one study, one pre-licensing study of any of the vaccines that are—72 vaccines that are now mandated for children on the childhood schedule.
After a year of sandbagging, HHS came to the courthouse and handed us a letter saying, yeah, there are no studies.
The only vaccine that is on the childhood study that had a placebo-controlled, double blind trial was the COVID vaccine. None of the other ones have.
That doesn’t mean you have to do that kind of trial now, but you need to know what the risk profile is for these products.
Regular readers will recognize the lies here, namely the misleading half-truth that vaccines in the childhood vaccination schedule have never been tested in a “proper” randomized controlled clinical trial (RCT) versus saline placebo and that safety monitoring is inadequate, both of which have been discussed here multiple times, most recently here and here. Moreover, just because RFK Jr. thinks that vaccines should be held to standards impossible to meet in the real world does not mean that they are “exempt” from pre-licensure safety studies. However, these are not antivax narratives specific to measles. Antivaxxers make these claims for all vaccines. That means it’s time to move on. First, however, let’s take a look at measles cases in the US over the last 25 years:
.
As you can see, since 2000, the year when measles was declared to be under control in the US, cases generally remain under 50-100 per year for the entire country. Notable exceptions occurred in 2015, the year of the Disneyland measles outbreak, and in 2018-2019, when waning vaccine uptake combined with waning vaccine-mediate immunity in adults over 50 led to large outbreaks in orthodox Jewish communities in Brooklyn and Rockland County, New York. So far this year, the trajectory does not look good, with vaccine expert Dr. Peter Hotez predicting that the outbreaks are nowhere near over.
“…you shouldn’t be afraid of the measles”
The claim that measles outbreaks are not unusual is closely related to another favorite measles myth, namely that the measles is not dangerous. This narrative presents the measles as being a harmless childhood disease that just needs to be endured, after which the child will have lifelong immunity to measles. For instance, a week ago antivaxxer Megan Redshaw wrote a post—on Substack, naturally!—entitled Why You Shouldn’t Be Scared of Measles, with the tagline, Measles is not “back” in the U.S. It never left. The mainstream media was ready to go with its same old measles hysteria as soon as RFK Jr. took over HHS. Sound familiar, other than the twist about RFK Jr. heading up HHS? It’s a useful article to point to because Redshaw regurgitates nearly every common antivax talking point about measles in one convenient Substack article, for example, that measles is a harmless childhood disease:
Even before the vaccine hit the scene, measles was considered a routine childhood illness—one that came, went, and left behind lifelong immunity. What the fear-mongers won’t tell you is that measles deaths had already plummeted by over 98% before the vaccine was even introduced, thanks to improved sanitation, nutrition, and access to medical care.
Naturally, to Redshaw it’s all a conspiracy:
The ink had barely dried on Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s appointment as Secretary of Health and Human Services when the mainstream media—which we now know has been heavily funded by the government through USAID to peddle propaganda—launched a full-scale campaign to preserve the vaccination program and, by extension, the pharmaceutical industry’s lucrative bottom line.
In a synchronized media blitz, headlines screamed of measles outbreaks, with reports of approximately 93 confirmed cases across various states. Of these, 28 cases affected kids under 4 years old, 48 affected kids aged 5 to 17, and 15 cases occurred in adults. The ages of the other cases are unknown.
And, of course:
The media’s narrative, however, is unmistakable: Blame the unvaccinated and, by extension, the new HHS Secretary known for his critical stance on vaccine safety. Then incite public fear, perpetuate misconceptions, and manipulate public opinion. Use this fear to rally against those fighting for medical freedom, religious and philosophical exemptions, and the “vaccine-choice activists.”
As Mrs. Potts, the enchanted teapot in Beauty and the Beast, once said, this is a “tale as old as time.”
Actually, the only “tale as old as time” is how antivaxxers like Redshaw spin every measles outbreak that ever occurs. In any event, Redshaw wrote this post over a week ago. As I pointed out, it’s 146 cases as of Friday (164 nationwide) and the case count will no doubt be higher at the end of this week, when new statistics are reported. Basically, Redshaw’s narrative is no different than the narrative from a particularly bonkers “natural health” grifter, Mike Adams, who proclaimed the measles outbreak a “hoax” and a “pharma psyop.” Same as it ever was, regarding every single measles outbreak I’ve written about for the last 20 years, the sole difference being that the reasons for the hype now also include trying to “tear down” the sainted RFK Jr., who is now in charge of HHS.
I do want to discuss Redshaw’s claim that the vaccine didn’t matter with respect to decreasing mortality from measles. That is an antivax trope that in 2010 I dubbed “vaccines didn’t save us,” a highly intellectually dishonest argument, as explained in the link. The short version is that, while it is true that mortality from measles had plummeted in the decades before the vaccine due to better medical care and nutrition, every year there were still 400-500 people dying of measles, a number that antivaxxers appear to consider unimportant and want to see again (more, actually, given the increase in the US population since the early 1960s), and considerable misery from from the huge numbers of new cases every year (most people caught measles before they turned 15), which resulted in roughly 48,000 hospitalizations per year and 1,000 cases of encephalitis. Redshaw does a common statistical slight-of-hand by pointing to a CDC publication of vital statistics to claim that measles deaths were “almost non-existent before the introduction of the first measles vaccine,” but I note that the graph (Figure 19) shows a death rate per 100,000 population. In 1960, the population of the US was 179,323,175. Less than 1 per 100,000 dying in the early 1960s easily translates into hundreds of deaths. It’s the same statistical trick antivaxxers did with COVID-19, implying that just because “only 0.1-0.2% die” of the disease, then the disease is no big deal, even though that translates to hundreds of thousands of deaths.
But what about measles still being around? While, technically it is true that measles never entirely left the US, it was declared eliminated from the US in 2000, meaning that there had been an entire year without continuous transmission of the virus. Since then, aside from the years of the Disneyland measles outbreak and the 2018-2019 outbreaks, the number of measles cases recorded each year has been so small relative to the total pop ulation as to be negligible—and thankfully so! Indeed it is uncommon for yearly case counts to climb into the triple digits. However, Redshaw’s claim represents an obviously deceptive narrative if you know a little history, as portrayed on this famous graph:
As I said, technically it is true that measles has never quite “gone away,” I’m sure you can see that the roughly 1,200 cases seen in the US in the worst year for measles this century is approximately 500-fold smaller than the average number of cases that were registered every year before the measles vaccine. Also note that this graph is an extreme underestimate of the number of measles cases, which was estimated to be in the millions per year. For example, it is estimated that in 1963, there were >100 million measles cases resulting in 6 million deaths worldwide, with 4 million cases and 450 deaths in the US annually.
One particularly vile variant of this attempt to portray measles as harmless is something I call the Brady Bunch gambit, which I first wrote about in 2015 during the Disneyland measles outbreak. You can read about it in detail here and see a YouTube video by antivaxxers making the claim here:
You might even have seen this meme:
The CliffsNotes version is that in 1969 an episode of The Brady Bunch played measles for laughs. In the episode, all six of the kids caught it. None of them got very sick, and they all enjoyed having a few days off from school. Ultimately the Mike (the father) and Alice (the maid) caught it too, but Carol (the mother) did not because she had had measles as children and thus had post-infection immunity. Antivaxxers pointed to this episode, an episode of The Flintstones from the early 1960s, and a 1950s episode of The Donna Reed Show in which measles was played for laughs on a sitcom as supposed evidence that measles was viewed as no big deal before the vaccine. (I note that the vaccine had existed for six years prior to The Brady Bunch episode cited.)
The facts are that before the vaccine measles was viewed by the medical profession with great concern, hence the effort put into developing a safe and effective vaccine for it. Roughly 1 in 1,000 with measles died; another 1 in 1,000 developed encephalitis; and 20% developed pneumonia. A particularly dreaded consequence of measles is subacute pan-sclerosing encephalitis (SSPE), a devastating fatal late complication affecting 4 to 11 per 100,000 cases of measles, a number that goes up to 18 per 100,000 cases if the child was less than five years old when primarily infected with measles. Moreover, measles causes temporary (but fairly long-lasting) immune amnesia that leads the immune system to “forget” pathogens that it had previously encountered and thus to higher mortality from other infectious disease for up to three years after a case of measles. All this disease, suffering, and death are too high a price to pay for “natural immunity” when a safe and effective vaccine that can prevent them exists.
The vaccine didn’t protect…
It didn’t take long after news of the initial cases of the current outbreak broke for antivaxxers to start promoting a couple of other old tropes. I’m lumping them together here because they are related. One of the first ones is to claim that the vaccine doesn’t protect because there are cases of measles among vaccinated people, sometimes a lot more, which is what I’ll start with. It’s a very obvious statistical trick if you know basic mathematics and think about it more than superficially, but unfortunately most people don’t. To them it sounds convincing. The idea is to look at raw case counts rather than cases per unit of population.
When over 90% of the population is vaccinated, for instance, equal numbers of cases do not imply that the vaccine doesn’t work. Let’s say, for instance, that there are 100 cases of measles, 50 cases in vaccinated people and 50 in unvaccinated people, out of a population of 1,000. (I chose fifty on purpose, because the vaccine is 95% effective, although in reality its efficacy is higher, all to make the numbers easy.) Let’s say now that the vaccine uptake rate is 90% That would mean that 50 people out of 900 people caught the measles, or 5.6%. (OK, I should have chosen a slightly lower number.) However, it would mean that 50 out of 100 unvaccinated people caught the measles, or 50%. It’s the attack rate that matters, not the raw numbers of cases in the vaccinated and unvaccinated populations. Antivaxxers pull this trick every time there is a measles outbreak, and not just for measles. Pertussis is a favorite as well for this tactic.
This time around, though, there is a variant to this approach that I’ve been seeing a lot on social media. Redshaw, of course, parrots it:
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), 95% of measles cases occurred in individuals classified as either unvaccinated or having an “unknown” vaccination status—a vague category that conveniently includes people who may be fully vaccinated but lack official confirmation. This “unknown” group consistently makes up the majority of measles cases and is routinely lumped in with the unvaccinated to inflate numbers and reinforce the false narrative that outbreaks are driven solely by the unvaccinated.
No, “unknown” means unknown, although I do find it amusing that antivaxxers are attacking the CDC for its reporting now that it’s under RFK Jr.’s control as HHS Secretary. Note the trick here, though. First, the statistics are known and easily found. Let’s look at the actual statistics on the Texas Department of State Health website for the measles cases thus far:
    • Not vaccinated: 79
    • Vaccination status unknown: 62
    • Vaccinated with at least one dose: 5
The website further notes:
    • Vaccination status is classified as unknown when the case investigation is still ongoing or when the person does not know if they were ever vaccinated.
    • The investigations into the cases who are currently classified as vaccinated are ongoing. A dose of MMR is given to unvaccinated people within 72 hours of their exposure to the measles to lessen the severity of the illness if they get sick from their exposure to the virus. We are looking into if any of these cases received their MMR dose after exposure.
Also, this bit of misdirection on the part of Redshaw and antivax messaging does not change the fact that unvaccinated people are far more likely to contract measles than vaccinated people. Indeed, even if every single case with “unknown” vaccination status were demonstrated to have been vaccinated at least 72 hours before symptoms (highly unlikely), the total number of vaccinated people contracting measles would then be 67. Remember my math above? That would still work out to an attack rate among the vaccinated being very much lower than among the unvaccinated. Most likely, most, but certainly not all, of those with unknown vaccination status are unvaccinated.
Redshaw also uses this sort of tactic of focusing on raw numbers of hospitalizations and complications from measles:
The data also show that 23 patients were hospitalized. Of these, 16 patients are in Texas and nearly half were fully vaccinated. The CDC reports that these 23 hospitalizations were for “isolation” or “management of measles complications,” a broad classification that raises more questions than it answers. Health officials have not provided any details about their underlying health conditions—a key piece of information when it comes to measles severity.
Even accounting for the publication date of the post (more than a week ago) and the higher number of cases reported now on the various government websites, I have to note that nowhere could I find in the link provided by Redshaw evidence that “nearly half” of those hospitalized were fully vaccinated, as that link goes to the Texas Department of State Health statistics that I’ve been citing. If I missed something, I’ll be happy to add an addendum or addition to this post to look at the statistics claimed. According to the CDC there are currently 32 people of 164 who’ve contracted the measles in the entire US who have been hospitalized for measles in 2025 thus far, I’m not seeing how the numbers add up. I would, however, be happy to tack an addendum to this post if anyone finds the source of these figures.
The natural endpoint of this narrative is that the child who died wasn’t killed by measles, because, obviously, if the measles kills someone, then it can’t be a harmless childhood disease. Redshaw’s post was written before there were any deaths due to measles reported. I have no doubt that, if she had written this after reports of the death of an unvaccinated child with measles, she would have included this trope. So we have to look elsewhere.
Unfortunately we don’t have far to look, because RFK Jr.’s old antivax group Children’s Health Defense published in The Defender an article entitled Texas Reports Death of Child Who Tested Positive for Measles, But Releases Few Details. Note the careful wording. They don’t say “child with measles,” but rather “child who tested positive for measles,” the implication being that measles didn’t kill the child. It’s a common tactic used by antivaxxers when people die of complications of vaccine-preventable diseases, like the measles, influenza, and COVID-19 to deny that it was the vaccine-preventable disease that killed them. You might remember this as a favorite tactic during COVID-19, to claim that people died “with” but not “of” COVID-19, particularly when it comes to bacterial pneumonia, which is a frequent complication of viral respiratory diseases.
Indeed, leave it to an chemical engineer turned incompetent biologist to trot out that very claim:
But Brian Hooker, Ph.D., Children’s Health Defense (CHD) chief scientific officer, said it’s too early to assume that the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine, which targets measles, would have prevented the child’s death.
“It is very easy and almost by design that we would jump to the conclusion that the vaccine would have saved this child. But we have no real information at this point.”
For instance, a medical doctor in the Lubbock, Texas area told The Defender he received a text message that suggested the child may have died from pneumonia, which can be a complication from measles.
“Health Ranger Danger” Mike Adams is also pushing this narrative:
The recent media frenzy over a supposed measles outbreak has been met with skepticism by health freedom advocates. Mike Adams, founder of Brighteon and host of Brighteon Broadcast News, has called the panic a “total hoax.” He highlights a recent case in Texas where a child reportedly died “with measles,” not “from measles.”
“The child died in a hospital, and the cause of death was likely something else entirely,” Adams explains. “They probably used a PCR test to claim the child had measles, but that doesn’t mean measles was the cause of death. This is fearmongering at its worst.”
Adams also points to the hypocrisy of the media, which ignores the hundreds of thousands of children injured or killed by vaccines while amplifying rare cases of measles. “The corporate media doesn’t care about the 1.5 million Americans killed by the COVID vaccine,” he says. “But one child dying with measles? Suddenly, it’s a national emergency.”
Same as it ever was, be it measles or COVID-19. Adams even goes further and takes it in a truly deranged direction, as you can see if you like by listening to the video linked in the quote starting around the 12:00 mark by claiming that the child was dying of something else and that they “faked” the PCR test.
Here’s a hint: If the unvaccinated child had measles and died of a superimposed pneumonia, measles killed the child; the pneumonia was a complication of measles. It’s no different than if you have a heart attack and then go into congestive heart failure, which kills you. The heart attack killed you; the congestive heart failure was how it killed you. Another way of looking at it: If a child gets viral encephalitis due to a measles infection, it was still the measles that killed the child; the encephalitis was how the measles killed the child.
If blaming complications doesn’t work, then blame the victim’s health:
The last measles death reported in the U.S., in 2015, was a young woman with underlying health issues that required her to take immunosuppressive drugs, according to the Seattle Times.
Because if the person killed by measles had other conditions, such as a suppressed immune system, then measles is still a perfectly “harmless” disease. Indeed, here comes the vitamin A, citing antivax physician Liz Mumper:
“I eagerly await details about age, prior state of health and circumstances of the reported death before jumping to conclusions. My condolences to the family who must be devastated,” she said.
In an earlier interview with The Defender, Mumper explained that effective treatments for measles include vitamin A in high doses and attention to hydration status.
“Many natural methods to help the body fight viruses, like extra vitamin D and vitamin C are effective but not widely recommended by mainstream medicine,” she added.
Elsewhere, Dr. Vincent Iannelli describes how antivaxxers are coming up with all sorts of nonsense claims regarding this unfortunate child:
Dr. Iannelli describes why this is nonsense:
Measles has a 7 to 21 day incubation period!
If the child was hospitalized just last week for RSV, there would not have been enough time for them to be exposed, get sick, and then die with measles.
See what I mean? If a child dies of measles, to antivaxxers it must have been either because something else other than measles killed them, because they were sick to begin with, or because they didn’t avail themselves of any of the “natural” preventatives and remedies, like vitamin A. Of course, while it is true that in populations living in underdeveloped countries, low vitamin A levels are associated with increased severity and mortality from measles infections. However, there is no evidence that administering vitamin A to people with adequate vitamin A levels can prevent measles or lessen its severity:
Vitamin A is less commonly used for measles cases in the U.S., according to the National Foundation for Infectious Diseases. Doctors say one reason may be that most Americans have enough vitamin A in their diet.
“I think the big caveat of all of this is that there’s a significantly higher rate of vitamin A deficiency in developing countries,” said Dr. Alexandra Yonts, infectious disease specialist at Children’s National Hospital in Washington, D.C. “So it is less clear whether there is any benefit in populations like in the U.S. and other developed countries.”
While recommending vitamin A is probably not dangerous, it probably won’t help US children with measles. I look at it as the narrow part of the wedge at the CDC that will be used to open the door to more antivax narratives and even to some outright quackery becoming CDC-recommended guidelines. Start with a fairly unobjectionable recommendation with little evidence that is probably harmless, and then add to it. That’s what I see happening.
Finally, if all of the above antivax tactics fail, blame the vaccine for measles and deaths!
…the vaccine kills!
CHD isn’t satisfied just claiming that the vaccine didn’t protect and that the unvaccinated child who died didn’t die of measles but rather “with” measles. Oh, no. They have to insinuate that it might have been the MMR vaccine that killed the child:
An additional text message received by the same medical doctor revealed the medical staff in the child’s area were instructed to give the MMR vaccine to children who were already infected with measles — even though Merck, maker of the most common MMR vaccine, states the vaccine should not be given to anyone experiencing a moderate to high fever, one of the most common symptoms of measles.
It has yet to be confirmed that the child who was reported unvaccinated against measles was not given an MMR vaccine as an acute treatment for the child’s measles infection.
As I quoted from the Texas Department of State Health website above, MMR can decrease the severity of measles if administered within 72 hours of a measles exposure. How much do you want to make a bet that the above is a misinterpretation of this standard recommendation to administer a dose of MMR to those exposed to measles? I’m sure that The Defender will be happy to provide the text of the actual message or messages sent out to doctors and medical staff in West Texas. Somehow I doubt that doctors were being instructed to give MMR to children to treat children with active measles; far more likely it was being suggested that they vaccinate children with a known exposure within the last 72 hours. Naturally, The Defender goes on to harp on how it is now rare to die from measles. Of course it is! That’s because of the success of the vaccination program!
A more common variant of “the vaccines done it” is the claim that it is actually the vaccine, not the virus, that is responsible for outbreaks. I happened upon a rather extreme case of the post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy with respect to this common antivax talking point. It’s by someone named John Fleetwood. It’s on—of course!—Substack and entitled Free Measles Vaccine Campaign Followed by Measles Outbreak in Texas County, with the tagline Measles vaccine contains live virus that can shed onto unvaccinated. Yes, it’s the old “shedding” claim, this time after a free vaccine clinic held in Texas:
Immediately following the vaccine handouts, the Texas Department of State Health Services announced the Gaines County measles outbreak had increased to 48 cases, a 242% increase.
Most cases were in children 5 to 17 years old.
However, health officials suspect as many as 200 to 300 people are now infected in Gaines County.
The timing of the outbreak’s surge—immediately following a mass vaccination campaign using a live-virus vaccine—raises serious questions about whether the shots themselves played a role in fueling the spread of measles in West Texas.
Of course, this is a very silly argument indeed. Why was Texas offering free MMR vaccine? Because cases of measles had been reported in an undervaccinated population and the health department t was trying to get ahead of the breakout. Here’s the thing. Measles is so transmissible that in an outbreak in an undervaccinated population cases will start with a few cases and then rise exponentially, which is exactly what was observed. It’s not at all surprising that case counts rose as quickly as what was observed. The vaccine had nothing to do with it, and the vaccination program might even have slowed the rate of increase, although we likely will never know for sure.
Recall that the MMR vaccine is a live attenuated virus vaccine. Such vaccines use a weakened version of the pathogenic virus that doesn’t cause full disease but does stimulate immunity to the “wild type” virus; i.e., the naturally occurring virus that causes disease. If there’s one thing you can count on antivaxxers to do, it’s to claim that live attenuated virus vaccines cause the disease that they are designed to prevent and that those vaccinated with such vaccines “shed” virus that can infect others, and, really, shedding is mainly an issue with the oral polio vaccine, not MMR. It’s true that some pediatric cancer centers in the past used to caution the parents of immunosuppressed patients to keep their children separated from recently vaccinated children, but that was more out of an abundance of caution than anything else. None of this stops antivaxxers from JAQing off (“just asking questions”) about the strains of measles virus that caused the measles cases. Cue Megan Redshaw again:
Health officials have not disclosed whether the measles strain responsible for recent outbreaks is vaccine-derived or wild-type, nor have they released details regarding the virus’s genetic sequencing.
Multiple strains of the measles virus can cause measles outbreaks, and the MMR vaccine contains a live attenuated virus that can replicate within the body and infect other people. But let’s not talk about that inconvenient little detail, shall we? Let’s not talk about the fact that live vaccines have and do cause outbreaks.
No, the measles vaccine cannot cause an outbreak due to shedding. It can, however, cause a fever and a rash, which is not measles, but that doesn’t stop Redshaw from going on:
The CDC even admitted this was occurring until it quietly scrubbed its website. The agency previously stated that 5-10% of people vaccinated with MMR develop a fever and rash post-vaccine. Given the number of vaccine doses given to infants, that means there could be 650,000–1,300,000 cases of vaccine-induced measles in the U.S. each year.
No, getting a rash and fever after measles vaccination is not the same thing as getting the measles. Note the conflation of the two, though. Whether it’s intentional or due to ignorant cluelessness, you can decide for yourself. At least in the case of measles, it is an actual virus being used in the vaccine. The super clueless version of the “shedding” myth claimed that mRNA from COVID-19 vaccines could be “shed” and cause disease, when that is actually physically impossible based on the design of the vaccine and the lack of viable virus. In any event, I the claim that it was the vaccine strain that caused an outbreak is a longstanding antivax trope. They used it during the Disneyland measles outbreak, and it wasn’t the vaccine strain that caused the outbreak. RFK Jr. himself trotted out this old antivax chestnut in his letter to the Samoan Prime Minister in 2019 during the middle of a a very deadly measles outbreak, and, again, it was not the vaccine strain causing the outbreak.
As Dr. Iannelli explains:
As Dr. Iannelli explains:
In this measles outbreak, as in all others, we find that:
    • cases are caused by a wild-type strain (the D8 strain has been found in the Texas outbreak, not the vaccine strain)
    • nearly all cases are in the unvaccinated
    • most outbreaks start when someone travels out of the country and returns with measles
    • measles is rarely mild, with typical symptoms including a high fever, irritability, cough, and a risk of death
Lastly, if it wasn’t the vaccine strain that caused the measles outbreak, it was still the vaccine, especially any deaths. How? The claim is that the vaccine supposedly selects for more virulent strains of measles. Indeed, RFK Jr. trotted out this antivax gem in the same letter to the Samoan Prime Minister, which I discussed (and deconstructed) recently. Basically, it’s a variant of a claim made by the godfather of the 21st century antivaccine movement, Andrew Wakefield himself, who made a highly fallacious argument that measles vaccinations select for such virulent strains of measles that they could cause a mass extinction of humans. I kid you not. If you really want to know the details of why this claim is unsupportable, feel free to read this. Part of the basis of the claim is that leaky vaccines (vaccines that do not fully suppress transmission) can in some cases observed in animals lead to selection for more virulent strains. It’s a claim that RFK Jr. made not just in Samoa but was making a year ago. Spoiler alert: MMR is not a leaky vaccine.
Everything old is new again…sort of
I realize that I sometimes repeat things enough to irritate some readers. One of these is that there is nothing new under the sun when it comes to antivax narratives, which is definitely true, although there are sometimes new variants of the same basic narratives. With the re-emergence of measles, starting in west Texas, with additional outbreaks in a number of states, it is important to be familiar with these old antivax narratives about measles, as well as their variants. You will see them a lot more. While there might be nothing new under the sun in terms of these narratives, there is one disturbingly new twist in 2025, which is that some, if not all, of these variants could easily become official CDC policy and advice, given that they have all been promoted in the past by our new HHS Secretary, who is likely going to try to downplay or eliminate the role of vaccines in public health, while stoking fears that vaccines are not safe and do not work. Depressingly, he now has unprecedented power and influence to do just that. What a scary time to be alive.


Vitamin A Does Not Treat or Prevent Measles
Steven Novella on March 12, 2025
Link
It didn’t take long for concerns about RFKs unscientific ideological approach to healthcare to manifest. We are in the middle of a measles outbreak – the exact kind of situation for which we need a strong federal response. The person in charge of that response, RFK Jr., is a notorious anti-vaccine crank who is not a scientist or healthcare expert, even though he acts as if he is.
His response to the outbreak has not been as bad as feared, in that he does support the use of vaccines and does say that vaccines work to prevent disease and provide community immunity. But he pairs that with the anti-vaccine dog whistle of saying that vaccines are a personal choice. He then immediately pivots to touting vitamin A and cod liver oil as treatments for measles, saying that, “Studies have found that vitamin A can dramatically reduce measles mortality.” He links to this 2010 study.
This is a great example of how easy it is to mislead by presenting scientific evidence, through cherry picking and misrepresentation. Kennedy also cites that the CDC now recommends vitamin A for the treatment of measles. But this is what the CDC has to say:
“Supportive care, including vitamin A administration under the direction of a physician, may be appropriate.”
That is a pretty luke warm recommendation. Doctors also understand what “supportive care” means – it is not a preventative or a therapeutic. It “may” help the patient weather the stress of the illness. Let’s take a look at the data to see what it actually shows.
Here is the most recent systematic review I could find, from 2017, which concludes:
“At longest follow-up, there was a 12% observed reduction in the risk of all-cause mortality for vitamin A compared with control using a fixed-effect model (risk ratio (RR) 0.88, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.83 to 0.93; high-quality evidence).”
That is a 12% reduction in mortality, not the 65% cited by RFK’s study. But also we have to dig a bit deeper into the data. The review also found no preventive benefit from vitamin A – something that would be worth pointing out to the public, who may not distinguish between a supportive treatment and a preventive strategy.
There is concern that some people are using vitamin A routine supplementation, sometimes in high doses, to prevent measles, prompting responsible healthcare experts to specifically point out that this does not work and vitamin A is not a substitute for vaccination. Also, vitamin A is likely the most toxic vitamin in high doses, which is also important to warn the public about.
Still, you might be thinking, a 12% reduction in mortality is significant and the public should be made aware of this. But the data showing a reduction in mortality from measles using vitamin A is limited to countries where vitamin A deficiency is rampant. Measles can cause a further depletion of vitamin A, and both measles and vitamin A deficiency weaken the immune system. So yes, in parts of the world where vitamin A deficiency is common, targeting those with measles for vitamin A supplementation is beneficial. The data shows is works for children less than two years old, and with two high dose administrations of vitamin A.
Does this data apply to a measles outbreak in the US? No, not at all. In fact, the one study specifically looking at vitamin A for the treatment of measles in a high income country found no benefit.
It is therefore more accurate to say that young children at high risk for vitamin A deficiency should be specifically targeted for supplementation if they contract measles or during a measles outbreak. But vitamin A is not a specific treatment for measles, it has no benefit in children who are not at high risk of vitamin A deficiency, and it has no role in prevention.
Just saying that “studies have found” vitamin A to “dramatically reduce measles mortality” in the context of an outbreak in Texas is more than misleading. It is dangerous. It will likely have an impact on public behavior which is counter productive (classic RFK jr).
What the public should be told, if they are told anything, is what all the data, put into a proper medical context, actually is telling us – while vitamin A may be helpful for supportive care of some patients, vitamin A is unlikely to be of any benefit in a measles outbreak in the US. It is not a treatment for measles itself, and it is not effective for prevention. Only vaccines (along with isolation and avoidance of contact) can effectively prevent the contraction of measles, which is a highly contagious illness. Do not take high doses of vitamin A, and do not use vitamin A to self-treat measles or as a substitute for the vaccine.

Vitamin A, Infections and Measles
Mark Crislip on March 18, 2025
Link
I have always had a bias towards the Appeal to Nature Fallacy:
An Appeal to Nature Fallacy happens when someone argues that something is good, better, or more authentic simply because it’s natural, while brushing aside anything man-made as inferior or harmful.
Or last my version of it.
I have always thought of the human body as more or less tuned by evolution to run optimally. More or less. I know there are those who marvel at the human body, but after 40 years as a doctor, I am more amazed that this kludge of half-assed systems, mutations, and polymorphisms that is a human can survive at all. The only organ that functions adequately in my meat sack is my liver, and that is because I exercise it regularly. Or am I over-sharing?
Be it sodium or temperature or hematocrit or whatever, physiology keeps the value in a tight range. I assume the value is an optimal trade-off between benefits and complications. If we had a core temperature of 103, humans would likely have fewer infections, but the caloric requirements to maintain that temperature would be prohibitive.
Among the many physiologic half assitudes of being human is we have lost the ability to synthesize some vitamins (vitamins A and C) or we have moved to parts of the world that make that synthesis more difficult. Long periods of gray skies here in the great Pacific NW make vitamin D synthesis problematic.
So for these, and other vitamins, we have to rely on diet to stay replete, and evolution has determined what those optimal vitamin levels should be. Much of the world can’t run over to Safeway and get a varied diet to prevent vitamin deficiency. Not that always helps to live in the US. Many people in the US live in food deserts or have food peccadilloes that get in the way of good nutrition. Years ago I saw a patient who for years ate only white rice and had high-output heart failure from thiamine deficiency. That takes real commitment to achieve.

I have always had an interest in vitamins, specifically as they relate to infectious diseases. For those stumbling upon this blog for the first time, I was an infectious disease doctor for 36 years, hence the interest.
There are two issues concerning vitamins and infections: The consequences of deficiency and whether the vitamins can be used pharmacologically to help treat infections.
It is an interesting literature. For vitamins C and D I will sum up, as they are not the focus of this entry: Deficiency in either increases risks for a variety of infections in a variety of populations. In deficient populations, treatment does not always have a clear-cut benefit. In replete populations, supplementation likely does little and supratherapeutic doses do less. It’s like oil in your car. You want the oil at the optimal level on the dipstick and there is no point in adding 7 quarts when the capacity of the crankcase is 6. Many a crank fails to make a case for supratherapeutic doses of vitamins. Although I made sure my TB patients took vitamin D, even if the literature is messy.
But the vitamin treatment du jour is vitamin A and measles. So what’s the deal?
First, vitamin A and the immune system. Does it boost? Of course not. But vitamin A is important for the function of many physiologic functions. Should you be low on Ambien, a nice review notes:
Vitamin A (VitA) is a micronutrient that is crucial for maintaining vision, promoting growth and development, and protecting epithelium and mucus integrity in the body. VitA is known as an anti-inflammation vitamin because of its critical role in enhancing immune function. VitA is involved in the development of the immune system and plays regulatory roles in cellular immune responses and humoral immune processes.
In vitamin A deficiency,
impaired antibody responses to challenge with protein antigens, changes in lymphocyte subpopulations, and altered T- and B-cell function.
All bad if infected with measles, or any pathogen, so like all vitamins, it is good to be replete.
And more is not better, as there is vitamin A toxicity, an issue with all fat-soluble vitamins. And Americans do have a lot of fat to store vitamins.
So being deficient impairs the immune response to measles, and measles is an infection that whacks the immune system, a bad combination. As an example
measles infection can greatly diminish previously acquired immune memory, potentially leaving individuals at risk for infection by other pathogens. These adverse effects on the immune system were not seen in vaccinated children.
Measles
wipes out 11 percent to 73 percent of the different antibodies that protect against viral and bacterial strains a person was previously immune to — anything from influenza to herpesvirus to bacteria that cause pneumonia and skin infections.
And during acute infections is a cause of neutropenia, aka low white cell counts.
As a result of that gruesome twosome, vitamin A deficiency leads to worser outcomes in measles with more death and more blindness. Given that vitamin A deficiency is common in much of the world, I was curious about Samoa, where 83 of 5,707 with measles died (1.4%), more than the usual 1 in 1000. People think a 1 in a 1000 chance of death is low. As a thought experiment, I do not think I would hold a gun to my head and pull the trigger if there was a 1:1000 chance of blowing my brains out. But that’s me.
The Wikipedia says
Clinicians reported that Vitamin A deficiency or immunodeficiency did not appear to be a substantial contributing factor to the outbreak.
But the reference is useless:
“We’re not really seeing evidence of acute malnutrition,” says the British paediatrician Dr. Owens, who arrived from the UK on the same flight as me. “As I understand it, there is very little evidence of clinical vitamin A deficiency. And I’ve not met a patient yet with a defined immune deficiency.”
“As I understand it” is not the deepest of understanding or a robust reference. I usually use that phrase when I have only a superficial understanding of a topic.
The Samoan government noted
The amount of vitamin A available for consumption in Samoa is, on average, about 310 mcg per capita per day, which is slightly higher than the average requirements of 282 mcg per day. Huge disparities within the population can be observed, as the level of vitamin. A available for consumption among the poor population is almost half the requirement, while richer households have access, on average, to an amount of vitamin A twice the requirement. The average quantity of vitamin A available for consumption is also well below requirements for large households with many members compared to small households.
And the UN noted
Samoan households generally have a lower intake of vitamin A than is recommended.
Vitamin A deficiency could have been a factor for the deaths in Samoa. Of course the US is not Samoa. It might be worse.
Texas, where measles is running rampant, is not noted for either healthy diet or food security. One summary of vitamin A in the US says:
Dietary surveys indicate that many US adults are not meeting dietary requirements for vitamin A: Even when accounting for vitamin A from fortified food, which is significant, 51% of adults fall short of the EAR. In contrast, more than 94% of children and adolescents (ages 2-18 years) have vitamin A intakes equivalent to the requirement or higher. Fortified, ready-to-eat cereal and fortified milk are important sources of vitamin A for children and adolescents. NHANES has also reported serum retinol concentrations: less than 1% of the US population is deficient in vitamin A. Serum retinol concentrations can be used to assess deficiency in a population but this assay cannot assess vitamin A inadequacy because retinol concentrations decline only once liver reserves are depleted.
The raw data is there on vitamin A, but not by state. Vitamin A deficiency is fairly rare in the US. In Texas, who knows? In poor Texans with a bad diet? Who knows?
It is unlikely that vitamin A deficiency is going to be important in measles outcomes in the US, except perhaps for the poor, and in the US the poor don’t matter. And I would suppose that those most in need of supplementation, the poor and those with food insecurity, are also those least able to purchase vitamins or find vitamin A rich foods.
So how about vitamin A as a treatment?
A summary of placebo-controlled trials.
Main results
Eight trials met the inclusion criteria (2574 participants). There was no significant reduction in the risk of mortality in the vitamin A group when all the studies were pooled (RR 0.70; 95% CI 0.42 to 1.15). The evidence suggests that vitamin A in a single dose was not associated with a reduced risk of mortality. However, two doses of vitamin A (200,000 international units (IUs) on consecutive days) reduced the mortality in children aged less than two years (RR 0.21; 95% CI 0.07 to 0.66) and pneumonia‐specific mortality (RR 0.57; 95% CI 0.24 to 1.37). Two doses of vitamin A reduced the incidence of croup (RR 0.53; 95% CI 0.29 to 0.89) but not pneumonia morbidity (RR 0.92; 95% CI 0.69 to 1.22), nor diarrhea morbidity (RR 0.80; 95% CI 0.27 to 2.34). None of the studies included in this review reported any adverse effects.
Authors’ conclusions
No overall significant reduction in mortality with vitamin A therapy for children with measles was found. However two doses reduced overall and pneumonia‐specific mortality in children aged less than two years. No trials directly compared a single dose with two doses.
And studies out of Africa, where vitamin A deficiency is common and vaccination is not
A systematic review, including the use of meta-analysis was done of randomized controlled trials comparing vitamin A with placebo obtained from a systematic search of the medical literature to determine whether vitamin A prevents mortality and pneumonia-specific mortality in children with measles. We identified five trials conducted in Africa, four in hospitals and one in a community that met the inclusion criteria. There were 445 children aged 6 months to 13 years supplemented with vitamin A and 478 with placebo. There was a 39 per cent reduction in overall mortality when vitamin A was used for the treatment of measles but this was not statistically significant (relative risk 0.61; 95 per cent confidence interval 0.32-1.12). When stratified by dose, 200 000 IU of vitamin A given for 2 days was associated with a reduction in overall mortality (0.36, 0.14-0.82) and pneumonia-specific mortality (0.33, 0.08-0.92) in hospitalized children in areas with high case fatality. Greater reduction in mortality was observed in children under the age of 2 years (0.17, 0.03-0.61). On the other hand, a single dose of 200 000 IU of vitamin A was not associated with reduced mortality (1.25, 0.48-3.1). There were no trials comparing a single dose with two doses of vitamin A. There were not enough studies to separate out the individual effects of age, dose, formulation, hospitalization and case fatality in the study area. We conclude that 200 000 IU of vitamin A repeated on 2 days should be used for the treatment of measles as recommended by WHO in children admitted to hospitals in areas where the case fatality is high.
Like most viral infections, interventions are probably too late in the course of the disease to do much. Viri multiply at an amazing rate and by the time people get to the doctor, most viral infections are too advanced to alter the course with antibiotics. But if there is a reasonable chance of vitamin A deficiency, it is probably good to give the kids a couple doses of A, and other vitamins, on general principles.
And in Italy, where vitamin A deficiency is unlikely? One tomato has 17% the RDA and the average Italian eats 35 kg a year. An Italian diet looks pretty good for vitamin A.
Vitamin A does not change the clinical course of measles infection or the rate of complications in children hospitalized in a high-income country.
And vitamin A or not, I also suspect that many who die of infections have mutations that increase their chance of dying, like influenza. The human genome is chockablock full of variations, polymorphisms, that increase or decrease the risk from infections. The fault, dear RFK, is not in our vitamin A, But in ourselves, that we need vaccinations.
And vitamin A doesn’t prevent measles. Remember my appeal to nature fallacy. Measles whole purpose in life is to infect humans. Infecting you is what it has evolved to do. You think the urge to reproduce was annoying as a teenager? Try being a virus.
Measles has likely only been infecting humans for 900 years or so, jumping from rinderpest, the measles of cows and goats. Eradicated by vaccination, BTW. Or perhaps rinderpest began after a leak from an 11th century Chinese virology lab. Hard to say. But I would wager measles has not had the impact on the human genome and immunity of, say, malaria.
Take home for vitamin A and measles?
Be vitamin A replete. If you are in a Third World medical and nutritional area and could be vitamin A deficient, perhaps like worst-of-breed Texas, there may be some marginal benefit from vitamin A to treat measles. If not vaccinated, try to be replete. When a child hits the ER with measles, you don’t know their nutritional status and while some vitamin A probably will not help in the short term, but might in the long run.
It would be silly to rely on vitamin A for either prevention or treatment when we have a very effective and safe vaccine.
Remember, vaccinated people do not die of measles, do not get immune reset, and do not get sicker than shit. Unvaccinated do. Vitamin A at best, in the vitamin A deficient, decreases mortality by 39%, not the 100% decrease from vaccination.
An ounce of perversion is better than a pound of pure. No. Wait. That should be an ounce of prevention is better than a pound of cure.
Get vaccinated.


RFK Jr.: Vaccines Not Only Protect Individual Children From Measles, But Also Contribute To Community Immunity
“RFK Jr. switching sides on vaccines now is like an arsonist urging people to put out the fire he started.”
Jonathan Howard on March 4, 2025
Link
Vaccines not only protect individual children from measles, but also contribute to community immunity, protecting those who are unable to be vaccinated due to medical reasons.
Much of my writing has centered around the idea that having real-world responsibility matters. It’s easy to say what one would do in a difficult situation, but reality often forces one’s hand, and RFK Jr., a man who has never had any real-world responsibility for anything, is now in charge of the health of 73 million American children. He promised that he would make them healthy, and it’s not good optics when they get sick and die of measles, as is happening in Texas. Now that it’s his job to stop children from dying, RFK Jr. can’t blame vaccines or claim the outbreak is fabricated, as he did with in far-away Samoa. As Ayn Rand said, “You can avoid reality, but you cannot avoid the consequences of avoiding reality.
So after facing backlash for minimizing the outbreak during a cabinet meeting, leading to the resignation of his top spokesman, RFK Jr. was forced to backtrack and acknowledge reality about vaccines for the first time in his life. He recently published an an opinion piece in Fox News, Measles Outbreak is Call to Action for All of Us MMR: Vaccine is Crucial to Avoiding Potentially Deadly Disease. I am sure it was painful for him to say the following:
As the Secretary of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, I am deeply concerned about the recent measles outbreak. This situation has escalated rapidly, with the Texas Department of State Health Services (DSHS) reporting 146 confirmed cases since late January 2025, primarily in the South Plains region. Tragically, this outbreak has claimed the life of a school-aged child, the first measles-related fatality in the United States in over a decade.
Measles is a highly contagious respiratory illness with certain health risks, especially to unvaccinated individuals. The virus spreads through direct contact with infectious droplets when an infected person breathes, coughs, or sneezes. Early symptoms include high fever, cough, runny nose, and red, watery eyes, followed by a characteristic body rash. Most cases are mild, but rare complications can be severe, including pneumonia, blindness, and encephalitis. Prior to the introduction of the vaccine in the 1960s, virtually every child in the United States contracted measles. For example, in the United States, from 1953 to 1962, on average there were 530,217 confirmed cases and 440 deaths, a case fatality rate of 1 in 1,205 cases.
The current Texas outbreak has predominantly affected children, with 116 of the 146 cases occurring in individuals under 18 years of age. The DSHS reports that 79 of the confirmed cases involved individuals who had not received the measles, mumps, and rubella (MMR) vaccine, while 62 cases had unknown vaccine status. At least five had received an MMR vaccine.
Vaccines not only protect individual children from measles, but also contribute to community immunity, protecting those who are unable to be vaccinated due to medical reasons.
I can’t believe I’m saying this, but that’s pretty good. Hell has apparently frozen over.
Yet, RFK Jr. couldn’t completely escape his anti-vaccine roots. 79 cases were in unvaccinated people, but just 5 were in vaccinated people. This shows the MMR is as good as promised, taking into account the base rate. Two doses are about 97% effective at preventing measles, though most people won’t figure that statistic out the way RFK presented the data. It’s also possible the 5 people had received just one MMR dose. Older people, who received a single dose decades ago might be more vulnerable to measles than they think. They’ve been protected by herd immunity thus far.
RFK Jr. also repeated the “vaccines didn’t save us” trope, debunked here by Dr. David Gorksi 15 years ago, by saying:
By 1960 — before the vaccine’s introduction — improvements in sanitation and nutrition had eliminated 98% of measles deaths. Good nutrition remains a best defense against most chronic and infectious illnesses. Vitamins A, C, and D, and foods rich in vitamins B12, C, and E should be part of a balanced diet.
He also recommended vitamin A, discussed Monday by Dr. Gorski, and winked to anti-vaxxers with language such as “The decision to vaccinate is a personal one,” which contradicted his earlier, factual statement about community immunity. He never suggested that parents vaccinate their children and said:
We must engage with communities to understand their concerns, provide culturally competent education, and make vaccines readily accessible for all those who want them.
RFK Jr. also wrote:
HHS’ efforts include offering technical assistance, laboratory support, vaccines, and therapeutic medications as needed ensuring that accurate information about vaccine safety and efficacy is disseminated.
Is RFK Jr. really providing significant on-the-ground assistance, or is he shipping vitamin A? Is he really ensuring that accurate information about vaccine safety and efficacy is disseminated? It doesn’t seem that way. According to an article by Melody Schrieber titled RFK Jr.’s Policies Could Spread Measles Far Beyond Texas:
In the first few months of the year, measles spread like wildfire among a largely unvaccinated population, the number of cases quickly outpacing the total for the entire previous year. Then, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) sent a strike team, spending long days assisting local efforts to vaccinate, help patients isolate, and trace their contacts. The community in question wasn’t opposed to vaccines; they simply hadn’t had steady access to health care, and they gladly rolled up their sleeves. The outbreak was controlled and the worst was avoided.
That was last year, in Chicago. Now, a similar situation is unfolding in West Texas. The population is different—now, it’s spreading largely among rural Mennonite communities; then, it was clustered around an urban immigrant shelter—but the same underlying issues of access persist.
And this year, the CDC isn’t sending a team.
The CDC isn’t sending a team because RFK Jr. hasn’t ordered it.
RFK Jr. switching sides on vaccines now is like an arsonist urging people to put out the fire he started.
So what to make of all this? That RFK Jr. felt obligated to share accurate information shows that public pressure still has some sway and at least for now, there’s broad agreement that it’s bad when children suffer and die from measles. I never imagined that I’d agree with large passages of an essay by RFK Jr., and though I doubt he typed those words himself, it’s good that he signed his name to them. I encourage him to keep his new attitude and will praise him if he does so.
RFK Jr. also said he had talked to the parents of the deceased child. I sincerely applaud him for that too. I am sure that was a horrible conversation that he’ll never forget, especially if he influenced these parents not to vaccinate their child. However, it was the right move, and it should set a precedent. RFK Jr. should call the grieving parents anytime a child dies of a vaccine-preventable disease, including COVID and the flu, which has taken a severe toll on children this winter. These parents are suffering just much as the parents who lost their child to measles, and RFK Jr. should want to call as few parents as possible. Of course, many parents might not want to talk to him and that’s understandable given his potential role in their child’s death.
However, a couple of solid paragraphs in a single article doesn’t suddenly erase RFK Jr.’s 20 years of anti-vaccine disinformation. That’s how we got here in the first place. As one person said:
RFK Jr. switching sides on vaccines now is like an arsonist urging people to put out the fire he started.
Another person added:
I just read Kennedy’s op-ed, and is like a guy yelling “fire” while holding a lit match. He talks a big game about stopping measles, but then downplays vaccines, pushes vitamins like a snake oil salesman, and barely acknowledges his own role in fueling vaccine hesitancy. First off, measles didn’t disappear because people ate more vegetables. The vaccine wiped it out. The second we stopped vaccinating enough kids? Boom, outbreak. But instead of saying “Get the damn shot,” he dances around it, calling it a “personal decision.” Personal decision? Tell that to the kid who just died…
Kennedy wants credit for taking measles seriously, but this isn’t leadership, it’s damage control. You want to fix the problem? Stop feeding the nonsense fear that created it.
That’s exactly right. RFK Jr.’s harm is baked in already. Countless children are currently unvaccinated because of his efforts, and they’ll be the ones getting measles in the future. RFK Jr. encouraged loathing and distrust of anyone who provided accurate information on viruses and vaccines, and that will now boomerang back on him, now that it’s his job to contain a deadly outbreak. It will take more than one article to reverse worrisome trends on vaccines. The anti-vaccine movement is powerful and attitudes are fixed. According to the article Amid West Texas Measles Outbreak, Vaccine Resistance Hardens:
When the local hospital warned of a brewing measles outbreak, Kaleigh Brantner urged fellow residents of this rural West Texas community to beware of vaccinating their children.
Two weeks later, her unvaccinated 7-year-old son came home from school with a fever. The telltale rash across his body followed. But his mild symptoms and swift recovery only hardened Brantner’s anti-vaccination convictions, even after an unvaccinated child died of measles at a hospital 80 miles away.
“We’re not going to harm our children or [risk] the potential to harm our children,” she said, “so that we can save yours.”
She and many others learned that antisocial attitude from RFK Jr. and his ilk. The anti-vaxx genie is out of the bottle, and every time a child is infected with measles, we need to ask, “What role did RFK Jr. play in that?”
Predictably his base is turning on him, as described in the article RFK’s Flip-Flop on the Measles Shot Is Ripping the Anti-Vax World Apart. RFK Jr taught people that everything is a conspiracy, and how he’s part of the conspiracy. RFK Jr. is in a tough spot. He spent his life railing against the “medical establishment.” He got what he wished for, and he is now the medical establishment. He knows it’s not good for him or Trump when kids in rural West Texas start dying of measles. Yet, because vaccines are needed to stop measles, he can only avoid horrible headlines if be betrays everything and everyone he has dedicated his life to thus far. The more RFK Jr. succeeds is in stopping measles, the more nasty accusations he’ll face from his former allies. Presently, all he has done is fail to stop measles, while earning the complete distrust of pro and anti-vaxxers alike. That’s hard to do.
I am sure that RFK Jr. didn’t have a sudden and genuine change of heart about vaccines. I am sure he was forced to write that article by someone. It goes against everything he has said for 20 years. I suspect it will primarily serve as a tool to give him and his supporters plausible deniability as measles spreads. After all, he wrote the words, “Vaccines not only protect individual children from measles, but also contribute to community immunity.” What more could anyone want?
Here’s the answer.
A few solid paragraphs in one article will not convince skeptical parents to vaccinate their children. To change the mind of at least some anti-vaxxers, RFK Jr. has to repeat this pro-vaccine message in a sincere, consistent manner. He and his staff need to get on camera and encourage the MMR at every opportunity. He needs to go to Texas and urge parents to vaccinate their children. He needs to use every tool at his disposal, such as CDC “strike teams,” to limit outbreaks. He should have done all of this already.
Moreover, if RFK Jr. wants parents to have “accurate information about vaccine safety and efficacy” he needs to disavow his entire life’s work on the topic. He needs to explicitly warn parents against his writing and everything his website has ever published. He needs to unequivocally say that the MMR does not cause autism. He needs to denounce Andrew Wakefield and Del Bigtree and tell parents to listen to experts like Drs. Peter Hotez and Paul Offit. He needs to do this not just for the MMR, but for every vaccine on the CDC schedule. They all protect against dangerous pathogens.
If RFK Jr. does this on a repeated basis and actually uses his power to contain outbreaks, I will welcome him to the resistance. If he can admit he was wrong about vaccines, I will gladly admit I was wrong about his ability to change his mind.
Until then, I’m afraid reality will continue to find tragic ways of making itself known. No matter what he does moving forward, RFK Jr. and everyone who enabled him will be responsible for that.


Beholden to Big Suppla, RFK Jr. Wants to Cover Up the Symptoms of Diseases With Untested, Toxic Chemicals & Drugs, Rather Than Prevent the Root Cause
Fortunately, there is a better way. Millions of parents have embraced a holistic approach, one that boosts the immune system by harnessing children’s innate, natural ability to prevent illness.
Jonathan Howard on March 21, 2025
Link
Safety and effectiveness in pediatric patients have not been established.
The head of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services department, RFK Jr. recently said doctors were seeing “almost miraculous and instantaneous” results from treating measles with a cod liver oil, vitamins, a steroid called budesonide, and an antibiotic called clarithromycin.
Though this is false, people are listing unfortunately. An article titled Keeping With Kennedy’s Advice, Measles Patients Turn to Unproven Treatments In West Texas quoted Katherine Wells, the director of public health in Lubbock, Texas, as saying:
I’m worried we have kids and parents that are taking all of these other medications and then delaying care. Some seriously ill children had been given alternative remedies like cod liver oil. If they’re so, so sick and have low oxygen levels, they should have been in the hospital a day or two earlier.
Beyond harming innocent children, RFK Jr. illustrates another core feature of the anti-vaxx movement- their eagerness to use chemicals and drugs to cover up the symptoms of diseases, rather than prevent them in the first place.
Unsurprisingly, these chemicals and drugs have names that are impossible to pronounce. Can you say (2E,4E,6E,8E)-3,7-dimethyl-9-(2,6,6-trimethylcyclohex-1-en-1-yl)nona-2,4,6,8-tetraen-1-ol or 11β,21-dihydroxy-16α,17α-(butylidenebis(oxy))pregna-1,4-diene-3,20-dione? Me neither. Even 6-O-methylerythromycin doesn’t exactly roll of the tongue, and cod liver oil contains two acids, eicosapentaenoic acid and docosahexaenoic acid. Yet, despite telling us that such unpronounceable drugs and chemicals are dangerous, RFK Jr. wants to give them to our sickest, most vulnerable children.
Obviously, they have toxic side effects and most have not been tested for measles. Don’t take my word for it. It’s all there in the package insert. The insert for budesonide even says:
Safety and effectiveness in pediatric patients have not been established.
That’s not encouraging.
The package insert for budensonide. Would you give a drug that can do all this to your sick child?
Measles Cases Linked to Texas Outbreak Grows to 259, With Just 2 Among Fully Vaccinated People
Fortunately, there is a better way. Millions of parents have embraced a holistic approach, one that boosts the immune system by harnessing children’s innate, natural ability to prevent illness. As the article Measles Cases Linked to Texas Outbreak Grows to 259, With Just 2 Among Fully Vaccinated People shows, just two vaccine doses are incredibly effective at preventing measles for life. The MMR’s safety and efficacy has been established in children for over 60 years, via billions of doses, though its roots can be traced back to traditional Chinese healers.
Of course, they won’t tell you this. RFK Jr., who is now the epitome of the Medical Establishment, has close ties with big names in the supplement business, a powerful industry that was valued at $177.5 billion in 2023. Big Suppla knows that a patient cured is a customer lost, and they are perfectly willing to suppress preventative treatments to expand their market share.
Indeed, RFK Jr. recently claimed that measles protects against cancer and heart disease, and an article titled RFK Jr.: It Would Be Better If ‘Everybody Got Measles quoted him as saying:
It used to be that everybody got measles. And the measles gave you lifetime protection against measles infection. The vaccine doesn’t do that. The vaccine is effective for some people for life, but for many people it wanes.
He also said:
There are adverse events from the vaccine. It does cause deaths every year. It causes all the illnesses that measles itself cause.
RFK Jr. spreads such lies because he wants to cover up the symptoms of diseases with untested, unsafe, unpronounceable chemicals and drugs, all to help his partners sell more supplements and assorted chicanery. In contrast, we here at SBM strongly believe it’s best to prevent the root cause of diseases, and we don’t get paid a dime to say so.


Measles, MAHA, and “soft eugenics”
I’ve long said that the antivax movement is borderline eugenicist (or at least social Darwinist) in nature. Now that a second child has died of measles, it’s time for me to take a look at the “soft eugenics” of the antivax movement.
David Gorski on April 7, 2025
Link
Saturday, a second child died of measles this year, a little more than a month after the first death of a child of measles in two decades had been reported. This brings the total number of measles fatalities so far this year to three, and it’s only early April. Details are thus far scarce, but according to the New York Times:
The measles crisis in West Texas has claimed the life of another child, the second death in an outbreak that has burned through the region and infected dozens of residents in bordering states.
The 8-year-old girl died early Thursday morning of “measles pulmonary failure” at a hospital in Lubbock, Texas, according to records obtained by The New York Times. It is the second confirmed measles death in a decade in the United States.
The first was an unvaccinated child who died in West Texas in February. Another unvaccinated person died in New Mexico after testing positive for measles, though officials have not yet confirmed that measles was the cause of death.
A Trump administration official said on Saturday night that the girl’s cause of death is “still being looked at.”
This measles outbreak, which is the largest, and other outbreaks in other states are clearly associated with low vaccine uptake. I hate to have to repeat this again, but measles is one of the most transmissible respiratory viruses, and maintaining herd immunity/community immunity requires a high level of vaccine uptake in a population, at least 90-95%. As for this case, from what we know thus far, it sure sounds a lot like the first tragic measles death, in which the child developed a superimposed bacterial pneumonia to which she succumbed. As you might know, one of the ways that people die from viral respiratory diseases is that the virus weakens the lungs’ defenses sufficiently that a bacterial pneumonia can gain hold. This is true for influenza, it’s true for COVID-19, and it’s true for measles. Meanwhile, it’s being reported that, as of now (early April), the US has seen twice as many measles cases as it did in all of 2024:
Texas’ outbreak began more than two months ago. State health officials said Friday there were 59 new cases of measles since Tuesday, bringing the total to 481 across 19 counties — most of them in West Texas. The state also logged 14 new hospitalizations, for a total of 56 throughout the outbreak.
More than 65% of Texas’ cases are in Gaines County, population 22,892, where the virus stated spreading in a close-knit, undervaccinated Mennonite community. The county now has logged 315 cases since late January — just over 1% of the county’s residents.
New Mexico announced six new cases Friday, bringing the state’s total to 54. New Mexico health officials say the cases are linked to Texas’ outbreak based on genetic testing. Most are in Lea County, where two people have been hospitalized, and two are in Eddy County.
Elsewhere, there have been smaller outbreaks in New Mexico, Kansas, Oklahoma, Ohio, and New Jersey, and the numbers cited above are likely significant underestimates of the true number of cases, given that many parents are not getting their children tested.
A few weeks ago, I wrote what to me was a frightening and difficult-to-contemplate post in which I made some predictions about how our new Secretary of Health and Human Services, longtime antivax activist Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., might go about dismantling federal vaccination and public health programs. It turns out that my imagination wasn’t expansive enough, as he’s come up with ways that I hadn’t thought of, such as eliminating grant funding for studies of vaccine hesitancy, COVID-19 vaccines, and COVID-19 itself. While this current outbreak cannot be attributed to RFK Jr.’s policies given that he hadn’t been confirmed as HHS Secretary yet when it began, I agree with Dr. Paul Offit that, thus far, RFK Jr.’s response has been abysmal. On the other hand, the declining uptake of the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine and other vaccines driven by the distrust of vaccines stoked by the antivaccine movement, of which RFK Jr. has been the most prominent American voice since 2005, can be laid right at RFK Jr.’s doorstep. Before he became HHS Secretary, he was a major influential figure in the antivax movement and worked tirelessly to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt (FUD) about vaccines.
This time around, RFK Jr. planned to attend the funeral of the child who died which was scheduled as of this writing for Sunday, perhaps in response to the widespread criticism that he received for his reaction to the first pediatric measles death and frustration from the Trump Administration that he has not been more proactive in messaging around the outbreaks. When I heard about this, I was immediately with Dr. Offit when he wrote:
When RFK Jr. attends the funeral of yet another child who has died from measles unnecessarily, he should apologize to the family. Apologize for his inaction. Apologize for his continual spread of misinformation about the disease and the vaccine. Apologize for his failure to strongly support the importance of vaccinating children during an epidemic. And apologize for cutting funds for immunization clinics in areas with low vaccination rates. The frankly dismissive mantra of “thoughts and prayers” doesn’t cut it here.
Did RFK Jr. do any of this? Spoiler alert: No, he did not. What he did was similar to what he did the last time a child died. Actually, what he did is more defined by what he didn’t do rather than what he did, as you will see.
“Make America Healthy Again”: “Soft eugenics” and social Darwinism
RFK Jr.’s history of antivaccine activism is well known and has been well documented, both here on this blog and over at my not-so-super-secret other blog. I mentioned “soft eugenics” in the title of this post. Before I proceed to explain, I have to give a hat tip to Derek Beres and Matt Remski at the Conspirituality Podcast, specifically the March 8 episode, MAHA’s Soft Eugenics. The reason that I feel obligated to mention them is because, although I’ve long called, for example, the Great Barrington Declaration a “eugenicist” document and referred to the eugenics-adjacent tendencies of the antivaccine movement, I had been a bit troubled, a bit concerned that perhaps I was overstating my case. Eugenics, after all, implies the active removal of those thought to be inferior, either through sterilization or outright killing, and, say what you will about RFK Jr. and the antivaccine movement, it’s difficult to accuse them of actively doing that. What the antivaccine movement does—and has always done—is basically “let nature take its course”; i.e., let nature do the culling. The child who survives was “fit,” and the child who doesn’t wasn’t. That’s why I like the term “soft eugenics,” which was defined in the episode thusly:
To be very clear, I don’t think Kennedy or any of the wellness influencers I’ve criticized are eugenicists in terms of advocating for the death of a group of people or even suggesting fetuses with genetic problems should be killed. That’s not what we’re discussing here. That type of language predominantly remains over on the fringes of ethno-nationalism.
But it very much fits the bill of soft eugenics, which is more of a shrug and sigh than a battle cry. We’ve been hearing this type of rhetoric from anti-vaxxers and anti-maskers since COVID. But to be honest, it pervaded wellness speak for generations.
When you hear an influencer claim that someone died with COVID, which is a thoroughly debunked idea, instead of saying they died from COVID, you’re hearing soft eugenics. When you hear someone, as I pointed out on Thursday’s episode, talk about only malnourished children dying of measles and healthy children have nothing to worry about. I mean, it’s an immunological rite of passage.
Of course, when the first child died of measles a month ago, I noted that all the old measles tropes had come back (they had never really ever gone away, in fact), in particular the claim that measles is a benign childhood illness that rarely causes significant injury, disability, or death.
With that passage, it all crystallized in my head. I had heard a term that accurately describes the antivaccine movement. Instead of an active removal of the “unfit” from the gene pool, “soft eugenics” is more of a shrug, followed by an attitude of “let nature take its course.” The idea, of course, is that the “fit” will easily survive the challenge—in this case, measles—and it’s only if you’re “unfit” somehow that you have anything to worry about. What also caused the lightbulb to go on in my head was the realization that there is a real point here. It wasn’t just the antivaccine movement. It is huge swaths of MAHA, which is derived from older, more general quackery. Thinking about “soft eugenics” in the context of MAHA and the antivax movement led me to realize, however, that MAHA is not just soft eugenics. After all, eugenics implies removing from the gene pool, which fits the antivaccine movement and many of the ideas promoted by “wellness” influencers if you’re talking about children who have not yet reached reproductive age, but what about adults or the elderly?
It turns out that very similar ideas were behind the Great Barrington Declaration, a document published by Martin Kulldorff, Sunetra Gupta, and our new NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya that basically advocated a “let ‘er rip” approach to COVID-19 in order to achieve “natural herd immunity.” But what about those at high risk for hospitalization, complications, and death from COVID-19? The authors of the GBD advocated for them “focused protection.” Unfortunately, this was never really well defined; it was basically an afterthought. The overall document was at the very least social Darwinist, its central idea being that the “young and healthy” will be fine if they get COVID-19 and therefore shouldn’t be expected to alter their lifestyle and participate in “lockdowns” in order to protect the vulnerable.
See where the social Darwinism comes in? Admittedly, I’m not a historian (although I do know a hell of a lot about World War II and Nazi Germany, given an interest in WWII that dates back to junior high) nor am I an expert in these topics, but I know enough to know that eugenics is related to social Darwinism, and vice-versa. Eugenics tends to be more about actively trying to “improve the gene pool” by decreasing the fertility of people who are considered “inferior” and/or promoting childbearing among people considered “superior.” Social Darwinism can encourage such negative and positive eugenics, but doesn’t have to. It is more like the “soft eugenics” in that it posits a worldview in which the “strong” or the “fit” should have higher social status and the “weak” or the “unfit” should be subservient or allowed to die. In a more individualistic, laissez-faire societies (e.g., the US), the individual tends to be the unit of selection, while in more nationalist movements it is the race or ethnic groups (e.g., Nazi Germany). Social Darwinism tends to justify socioeconomic differences as being a product of the “strong” rising and the “weak” being left behind, considering this to be “nature.” You can see how an attitude of “let nature take its course” and “if he dies, he dies” can be compatible with this worldview.
In any event, call it what you want, “soft eugenics” or social Darwinism, what the antivaccine movement basically promotes is a deceptive appeal to nature, in which immunity from “natural infection” is always superior to “artificial” immunity from vaccines (never mind that the same immunologic mechanisms are at work) and infectious disease is nothing to worry about if you are “fit” and have a “healthy immune system.” In that latter case, you will suffer briefly, but come out fine on the other side, with all-powerful superior “natural immunity” to the disease. When last I wrote about measles tropes, I pointed out how desperately antivaxxers work to portray measles as a “harmless” disease, to the point where they like to refer to an old episode of The Brady Bunch in which the kids all caught measles or episodes of The Flintstones or The Donna Reed Show in which measles is played for laughs as evidence that, before the measles vaccine arrived six decades ago, people didn’t view measles as much of a threat or big deal, contrary to today of course.
After the first measles death, RFK Jr. himself, under the guise of supposedly recommending that parents get their children vaccinated with MMR, promoted such tropes, as I detailed. Read the post for the details, but examples included emphasizing vaccination as a personal choice, saying that children died “with measles” instead of “of measles,” doing his best to downplay the risk of measles, and recommending vitamin A to treat measles, when the only evidence that it helps comes from children in underdeveloped countries, where the prevalence of nutritional deficiencies, including. Vitamin A, is high. (Unsurprisingly, there have been cases of Vitamin A toxicity among the children of antivax parents seeking to prevent or treat measles with it.)
As Beres put it:
And if someone dies from natural infection, I’m gonna find a reason why they couldn’t possibly be healthy in the first place, instead of recognizing that measles is a vicious disease that can cause a lot of chronic disease, blindness, and at the extreme, kill people, mostly young children. Like I said, a sigh, but a rather pernicious one.
Indeed. Let’s take a look at an example, namely the first child to die. I expect that it won’t be long before the second child and her parents are subject to the same treatment.
How antivaxxers and MAHA react to deaths from measles
It represents a challenge for antivax messaging whenever a child dies of a vaccine-preventable disease like measles, and antivaxxers know it. As a result, as soon as the news was announced, a number of the usual antivax suspects started promoting familiar narratives. For example, some said that the child died “with measles,” not “of measles,” because she had apparently died of a superimposed bacterial pneumonia. A variant of that was that the child never had measles at all, as Mike Adams tried to claim:
The recent media frenzy over a supposed measles outbreak has been met with skepticism by health freedom advocates. Mike Adams, founder of Brighteon and host of Brighteon Broadcast News, has called the panic a “total hoax.” He highlights a recent case in Texas where a child reportedly died “with measles,” not “from measles.”
“The child died in a hospital, and the cause of death was likely something else entirely,” Adams explains. “They probably used a PCR test to claim the child had measles, but that doesn’t mean measles was the cause of death. This is fearmongering at its worst.”
Sound familiar? Brian Hooker, a chemical engineer turned incompetent antivax “epidemiologist” (and the chief scientific officer of RFK Jr.’s old antivax group Children’s Health Defense) opined:
Hooker said the lack of useful information about the current measles outbreak in Gaines County, Texas, has been “extremely frustrating.” The West Texas county has been home to a Mennonite community since 1977, according to the Seminole Chamber of Commerce.
“People typically don’t just die from measles,” Hooker said. “We know it was a child in the Lubbock, Texas, hospital — that’s it. No idea of comorbidities, complications, course of disease, nothing.”
Notice the obvious underlying assumption that children don’t die of measles unless they are somehow unfit less than healthy to begin with. Of course, if a child actually does have a medical condition that predisposes them to severe complications or death from measles, that’s actually all the more reason to get that child vaccinated!
Unsurprisingly, Del Bigtree also jumped on the bandwagon, interviewing mothers of unvaccinated children who had contracted the measles and recovered, all of them standing by their decision not to vaccinate using similar sorts of assumptions, such as “natural immunity” being better, the vaccine being “unnatural” or otherwise somehow inferior, and the disease itself not being that serious. Of course, he featured a quack who claims to be able to treat measles with budesonide, an inhaled steroid that COVID-19 contrarians had touted as a highly effective treatment for severe COVID-19, just showing how not only is everything old new again but lots of new things are being repurposed for the old, as in unproven COVID-19 treatments being applied to the new measles outbreak.
CHD, for its part, decided to exploit the grieving parents of the girl who died, neither of whom regretted not vaccinating, despite holding back sobs as they described how their girl had gotten sick from measles, developed pneumonia, and then ended up on a ventilator in a hospital, where she eventually died. From a local news report:
The couple, members of a Mennonite community in Gaines County with traditionally low vaccination rates, spoke on camera in both English and Low German to CHD Executive Director Polly Tommey and CHD Chief Scientific Officer Brian Hooker.
“It was her time on Earth,” the translator said the parents told her. “They believe she’s better off where she is now.”
“We would absolutely not take the MMR,” the mother said in English, referring to the measles-mumps-rubella vaccination children typically receive before attending school. She said her stance on vaccination has not changed after her daughter’s death.
“The measles wasn’t that bad. They got over it pretty quickly,” the mother said of her other four surviving children who were treated with castor oil and inhaled steroids and recovered.
The couple told CHD that their daughter had measles for days when she became tired and the girl’s labored breathing prompted the couple to take her to Covenant Children’s Hospital in Lubbock. There, the girl was intubated and died a few days later. The other children came down with measles after their sister died.
The parents also noted about their other children, “The measles wasn’t that bad. They got over it pretty quickly.”
I watched as much of the actual video as I could stand, given the ghoulishness of Brian Hooker and Andrew Wakefield’s old antivax friend Polly Tommey. Even though Tommey oozes sympathy for the parents, her questions indicate that she was looking for a reason to dismiss measles as the cause of this poor girl’s death. More disturbing, the parents are still antivaccine and attribute their daughter’s death to the will of God:
The couple, who are Mennonites, believe their daughter’s death was the will of God. When Children’s Health Defense’s director of programming, Polly Tommey, asked specifically about parents who heard their story and might be “rushing out, panicking,” to get the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine, the parents rebuked the intervention that offered the best chance of preventing their daughter’s death.
“Don’t do the shots,” the girl’s mother said. Measles, she added, is “not as bad as they’re making it out to be.” She noted that her four other children all recovered after having received alternative treatments from an anti-vaccine doctor, including cod liver oil, a source of vitamin A, and budesonide, an inhaled steroid usually used for asthma.
Again, everything old is new again and new is old again, including RFK Jr.’s response. This time around, he did go to Texas to attend the funeral of the girl who died:
U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. visited the epicenter of Texas’ still-growing measles outbreak on Sunday, the same day a funeral was held for a second young child who was not vaccinated and died from a measles-related illness. 

Kennedy said in a social media post that he was working to “control the outbreak” and went to Gaines County to comfort the families who have buried two young children. He was seen late Sunday afternoon outside of a Mennonite church where the funeral services were held, but he did not attend a nearby news conference held by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention about the outbreak.
Seminole is the epicenter of the outbreak, which started in late January and continues to swell — with nearly 500 cases in Texas alone, plus cases from the outbreak believed to have spread to New Mexico, Oklahoma, Kansas and Mexico.
The optimist in me likes to hope that encountering people who suffered unimaginable loss due to a vaccine-preventable disease might change RFK Jr. Did it? Judging from his response, probably not. Characteristically, he posted his response to X, the hellsite formerly known as Twitter:
Notice how RFK Jr. buried that statement about the “most effective way to prevent the spread of measles is the MMR vaccine” almost as an afterthought, after having touted how supposedly the growth rates for new cases and hospitalizations have “flattened.” The overall message comes across to me as grudgingly admitting that the MMR vaccine works but implying that it’s probably not that necessary anymore because things are getting better. (Hint: If an another child dies, things aren’t getting better. Actually, just objectively, the outbreak is not yet waning.)
While it might be a good thing that RFK Jr. sees the actual fruits of his two decades of antivaccine fear mongering about vaccines, including the MMR, somehow I doubt that it will change him, but his post did have its intended effect, resulting in a number of news reports that took his statement at face value and ignored context, resulting in headlines like:
    • ‘Most effective way’ to prevent measles is vaccination, RFK Jr. says, in most direct remarks yet (STAT News)
    • RFK: MMR vaccine is the “most effective way” to prevent measles spread (Axios)
    • RFK Jr. consoles Texas family: MMR vaccine ‘most effective’ way to stop measles spread (The Hill)
Notice what RFK Jr. didn’t do? He didn’t do what past HHS Secretaries and CDC Directors did in the face of measles outbreaks or outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases. He didn’t urge families to vaccinate their children. He didn’t mobilize mass vaccination efforts and public messaging campaigns about the vaccine. He just said that the MMR is the “most effective” way to prevent measles spread without actively encouraging vaccination. It’s because he can’t. Even if he could bring himself to say explicitly that the MMR vaccine is safe and effective and doesn’t cause autism (or all the other things he’s claimed that it causes), MAHA has framed vaccination solely as an individual choice without regard to society at large.
Meanwhile, Sen. Bill Cassidy posted:
Not publicly known if the child was vaccinated, but almost certainly not. Everyone should be vaccinated! There is no treatment for measles. No benefit to getting measles. Top health officials should say so unequivocally b/4 another child dies. https://t.co/iUbcspUlNn
— U.S. Senator Bill Cassidy, M.D. (@SenBillCassidy) April 6, 2025
We actually do now know that the child was, unsurprisingly, not vaccinated.
Too bad that Sen. Cassidy could have stopped RFK Jr.’s nomination in its tracks but was too cowardly to do so. He can try to assuage his conscience now by playing at being the voice of science, but it’s too late.
Enter The Secret
The interesting thing about the soft eugenics of MAHA and the antivax movement is that it isn’t just about “survival of the fittest” (or health of the fittest); that is, unless you consider fitness to include will, as in triumph of the will. Beres said it one way:
You’re hearing the language of soft eugenics. And when you hear the blaming of chronic disease on fat people who don’t know how to control their urges, which is something I’ve seen for years in the wellness landscape, yeah, you’re hearing soft eugenics. It’s this moralizing of wellness, this idea that your health is only dependent on you.
And if you can’t achieve it, you’ve failed. Because there’s a level of unacknowledged privilege that’s infected wellness for a long time. It might be genetic privilege.
It’s often financial privilege. But what you’re really hearing is someone say, you, you’re not me. And when you unpack that sentiment, it actually translates to, I’ve had a set of opportunities and access that I’m blind to, because I just assume everyone has the same opportunities and access.
That’s an excellent way of saying it. For example, I love to refer to Bill Maher’s long-ago claim that his lifestyle was so healthy that he couldn’t catch the flu. The example that he used was that, were he to fly in an airplane in which a lot of the passengers were coughing, he would not catch the flu. This claim led to one of my favorite retorts, a retort so brilliant that, even 16 years after writing about it, I still remember it and still refer to it. It came from, of all people, Bob Costas, who gave Maher serious side-eye and said sarcastically, “Oh, come on, Superman!”
Perhaps the most blatant example of this attitude comes from an episode of The Highwire with Del Bigtree posted in June 2020, when he dismissed the idea that he is obligated to do anything for those susceptible to death or severe complications from COVID-19, the frequency of whom he rates at 0.26%, completely blaming the victim:
But here’s the problem. When you were my age, you were most likely eating food and fast food and Doritos and drinking Coca-Cola, which you’ll never find in my home. You were eating that all the time. You probably were drinking a lot of alcoholic beverages and really liked to party and enjoyed your cigarettes and said to yourself, “You know what? It’s more about the quality of my life right now. I don’t care if I live to be 100 years old. I want to enjoy my life right now. I like the finer things in life. I like good rich food. I like smoking a cigarette once in a while. I like to drink my drinks.” And you know what? Good on you! That’s the United States of America. No problem, that, some of my best friends think like that. It’s great, and they’re fun to hang out with. That’s perfectly OK.
But here’s what’s not OK. When you reach that point in your life where now your arteries are starting to clog up, your body is shutting down, and the alcohol is eating up your liver, and you have diabetes, or you have COPD, you have asthma, you can’t breathe, all the cigarette smoking has finally caught up with you, you have heart disease because of the way you decided to live your life in the moment, here’s what you are now. You are pharmaceutical-dependent. You did that to yourself, not me. You decided that the moment mattered, and now you find yourself pharmaceutical-dependent, which is really what that 0.26% is, and that’s OK too. Thank God there’s drugs out there! There’s drugs that allow you to eat the Philly cheesesteak even though your body knows it hates it, but, go ahead, take the Prilosec. What difference does it make? Drug yourself! Drug yourself! Get through the day! Don’t exercise! Maybe just attach an electrode and see if a little electricity to the stomach will give you the abs you want.
What follows is Bigtree moralizing about those who had not been sufficiently “virtuous” and now have chronic disease with respect to vaccine mandates, which he views as being forced to become “pharmaceutical-dependent”:
Or could we live and let live? Eat all the Twinkies you want! Drink all the bourbon you want, and smoke as many cigarettes as you want, and when you find yourself pharmaceutical-dependent I will go ahead and say thank God the drug companies are there for you, but you do not get to make me pharmaceutical-dependent. You do not get to put me in the way of Heidi Larson, who wants to eradicate natural health and natural immunity and make us all pharmaceutical dependent.
See what I mean?
I look at it slightly differently though. While it is true that MAHA seems to view health as a result of virtue, as evidenced by virtuous behavior (as defined by MAHA, of course), I hear echoes of The Secret in MAHA that I wrote about a couple of months ago, inspired by—of course!—RFK Jr.’s answers at his confirmation hearing, specifically:
SANDERS: Do you agree healthcare is a human right?

RFK Jr: I can't give you a yes or no answer pic.twitter.com/z10JyGeM16
— Aaron Rupar (@atrupar) January 29, 2025
Specifically, the key part of the exchange that caught my ear was this part of RFK Jr.’s answer to the question, which occurred after he had dodged and weaved in order not to give a definite yes/no answer:
Free speech doesn’t cost anybody anything, but in health care, if you smoke cigarettes for 20 years and you get cancer you are now taking from the pool. Are you guaranteed the same right?
Does this sound familiar? It’s a recurring theme that we hear from believers in alternative and “natural” medicine, namely the victim-blaming idea of lifestyle über alles in medicine, the judgmental mindset that if you are ill it is your fault. This is, of course, very much like what Beres was saying. If I were to sum up the idea succinctly, it is the concept that virtue equals health and that, if you are not healthy, you must not be virtuous. In this context, “virtue” means leading a “virtuous” lifestyle with respect to health; i.e., eating a healthy diet, exercising, not indulging in habits that contribute to chronic disease, etc. Consequently, if you develop lung cancer or heart disease as a result of your having smoked cigarettes for 20 or 30 years, somehow you are less deserving of healthcare. It’s a concept that suffuses the antivax movement too, with claims that diet and healthy living can prevent disease better than any vaccine.
I’ve written more than once over the years about the central idea that undergirds alternative medicine (which MAHA includes as a major part of what it is), an idea that I once called the central dogma of alternative health, namely a variant of “The Secret,” or, as I like to call it, “wishing makes it so.” Recall that The Secret posits the universe will provide what you need and want if only you want it badly enough. While it is true that if you want something badly enough, you are far more likely to strive to get it, The Secret makes it seem as though it is an ironclad law that if you want something badly enough, the universe will provide. In the case of MAHA, it manifests—if you’ll excuse my use of the word—as the idea that a virtuous lifestyle with respect to health will ward off all disease, the flip side being that, if you’re sick, then you must not have been living a virtuous enough lifestyle or wanted health badly enough.
Bringing it all together, “fitness” in MAHA (and the antivax movement) thus involves not just genetic fitness, but it also involves moral fitness, with “moral” being whatever MAHA decides is virtuous with respect to health. It’s an attitude that underlies a lot of the unproven treatments and “biohacking” promoted by MAHA, as Beres notes:
It’s often financial privilege. But what you’re really hearing is someone say, you, you’re not me. And when you unpack that sentiment, it actually translates to, I’ve had a set of opportunities and access that I’m blind to, because I just assume everyone has the same opportunities and access.
And this is the mentality that often leads to assuming biohacking protocols and untested supplements are the keys to optimal health, not money or geography or social status. And that blindness leads to a set of assumptions about health that doesn’t reflect the biological, social, historical, or geographical factors that all play into individual health. And if you’re that far off the mark with individual health, well, public health is definitely going to elude you.
That’s also what allows you to look at one of the greatest health interventions in human history and say, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. I’m not gonna believe centuries of scientific rigor testing and yes, failures, to where we’ve come to today. Instead, I’m going to stand firm in my conviction that cod liver oil is a better therapeutic than a vaccine.
Yes, I realize that I forgot to mention that RFK Jr. did indeed suggest that cod liver oil could treat measles. At its core, MAHA, of which RFK Jr.’s antivaccine activists is but a part (albeit a huge part), makes health an individual responsibility, denying any sort of public or collective responsibility and defining health as the result of individual willpower, actions, and virtue with respect to health. It ignores social determinants of health, how infectious diseases like measles cannot be controlled with a focus on the individual alone and requires a public health effort, opting instead to make all health and public health a matter of will and good ol’ American “do it yourself” doggedness and ingenuity.
It will be interesting—and likely in many cases tragic—to see what happens when the fantasy of MAHA meets the reality of dealing with healthcare policy on a national level. In the case of measles, so far it hasn’t been a pretty sight, as Dr. Offit and the recently ousted Dr. Peter Marks, the FDA’s recently ousted Director of the Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research (CBER), head of both note, but it won’t just be measles where reality will collide with fantasy, particularly given the massive cuts to HHS that would hamstring RFK Jr. from accomplishing much, even if he were competent and reality-based.


Hello measles, my old friend: The return of previously vanquished vaccine-preventable diseases
A study published last week suggests that, if vaccine uptake continues to decline, measles will soon be endemic again in the US. It’s just part of how RFK Jr. is making America sicker again.
David Gorski on April 28, 2025
Link

“Hello measles, my old friend. Let Bobby bring
you back again…” (Paul Simon would probably
hate me for repurposing his lyrics like this, even
in jest.)
When a country puts an antivaxxer and supporter of quackery whose worldview with respect to medicine and biomedical science is as utterly divorced from science and reality as that of longtime antivax activist Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. in charge of the nation’s medicine and public health, there are certain predictable outcomes that we can expect to observe over the next few years. The most obvious of these outcomes is the likely return of once-vanquished vaccine-preventable diseases. I was reminded of—and alarmed by!—this likelihood when I came across a modeling study hot off the presses from JAMA last Thursday. The study basically models what might happen as vaccine uptake declines, concluding first that if vaccine uptake declines sufficiently, measles could well become endemic again. (Make measles endemic again? I prefer what I’ve been sarcastically saying about antivaxxers since 2017, namely “Make measles great again.” Because everyone loved the pre-1964, pre-vaccine situation, with millions of cases every year, right?)
Even more alarmingly, though, it’s not just about measles. Measles, being among the most transmissible viruses in existence, is just the canary in the coal mine. It’s come back first, but it won’t be long before other pathogens join it. (Indeed, as I predicted, cases of pertussis—whooping cough—are starting to surge, too.) This study is also about rubella, diphtheria, and even polio. I’ll provide a spoiler alert before I discuss the study in more depth: The model predicts tens of millions of measles cases and millions of polio cases over the next 25 years if vaccine coverage declines sufficiently. (Make polio great again?) It also illustrates how it’s not at all implausible that uptake of various critical vaccines could decline sufficiently to result in this outcome.
Make America Sick
Before I discuss the JAMA study, here’s some obligatory background, with a hint of “I told you so.” (It’s actually more than a hint.) I had started sounding the alarm soon after RFK Jr. bent the knee to Donald Trump last year, suspending his quixotic independent Presidential campaign in return for a prominent role in health policy, which, alarmingly, turned out to be Secretary of Health and Human Services. He’s now in charge of the massive sprawling bureaucracy responsible for overseeing basically all non-military federal public health and health care policy, including such critical infrastructure as the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the Food and Drug Administration, and the National Institutes of Health. Unsurprisingly, he’s appointed a number of antivax grifters and quacks to head up these agencies. I’m talking “America’s Quack” Dr. Mehmet Oz, who is now in charge of CMS and overseeing Medicare, Medicaid, and the insurance exchanges under the Affordable Care Act. I’m talking Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, co-author of that “let ‘er rip” COVID-19 manifesto (with “focused protection” of the vulnerable as an afterthought) the Great Barrington Declaration, in charge of the NIH. I’m talking COVID-19 contrarian and popularizer of the quack myth that medical errors are the third leading cause of death in the US, Dr. Marty Makary, in charge of the FDA. True, President Trump tried to appoint longtime antivax doctor and politician Dr. Dave Weldon to run the CDC, but that appeared to be a quack too far. (How RFK Jr. himself as HHS Secretary was not a quack too far, I leave as an exercise for our readers.) Unsurprisingly, RFK Jr. set about undermining vaccine programs and, instead of “make America healthy again” (MAHA), we’re seeing him make America sick again.
Of course, RFK Jr. proclaims his MAHA movement as being all about fighting chronic disease and “making America healthy again” by safeguarding the food supply and encouraging healthy eating and lifestyles, thus (if you believe him) leading to a decline in obesity and chronic diseases that he attributes to big agriculture, big pharma, vaccines, and “chemicals.” Indeed, RFK Jr. has made a big show out of a policy to phase out certain food dyes, a move that will almost certainly do little or nothing to “make America healthy again” but sounds good on the surface. I don’t have really have a dog in this particular hunt and am happy to go where the evidence shows with respect to food dyes, but even the most negative interpretation of the existing data tells me that, even if RFK Jr. is correct about the purported health dangers of these food dyes, eliminating them will have at best marginal effects on public health.
It’s also pretty easy to illustrate just how delusional RFK Jr. is in light of what has happened under RFK Jr.’s watch during the two months he’s been in charge. I will cite some examples. First, you would think that if RFK Jr. were for making America’s children healthy again, he’d be beefing up the CDC’s capacity to deal with known, science-based toxic exposures, like lead, especially given his longstanding fear mongering about mercury in childhood vaccines. Nope. Recently, the health department in Milwaukee asked the CDC for assistance because of a lead contamination problem in its public schools. The CDC declined, because the personnel responsible for such activities had been fired, leading Mike Totoraitis, commissioner of the Milwaukee Health Department, to lament, “April 1 is a really stark moment for public health here across the country, and specifically here in Milwaukee, where now we don’t know who to call. We don’t know how to respond to some of the challenges that we’re dealing with right now because we don’t know if I’m reaching out to someone today, if they’re going to be there tomorrow.” Second, if RFK Jr. were really about protecting the food supply, you’d think that he would have said something about the USDA reversing a Biden-era policy that would have set final standards to determine whether raw poultry products are contaminated with Salmonella, thus moving from a reactive posture to a preventative posture. And don’t even get me started on HHS shutting down the CDC’s Office of Smoking and Health. Apparently he wants to make smoking great again or make lung cancer great again.
Yes, I know that HHS doesn’t control USDA, which is in the Department of Agriculture, but, according to Politico:
Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is fast becoming the most prominent face of the Trump administration’s domestic agenda, taking on a portfolio well beyond the role of a traditional Health secretary. And the White House is thrilled.
And:
Guided largely by his own longstanding fixations on food, wellness and environmental “toxins,” Kennedy is leading a campaign to ban soda and other unhealthy items from the food stamp program, at one point vowing to approve restriction requests sent to “my agency” even though it falls under the USDA’s jurisdiction. A skeptic of fluoridated water, he’s touted the EPA’s reexamination of national fluoride standards.
See what I mean?
Finally, I hearken back to RFK Jr.’s confirmation hearings, when he refused to give a direct answer to a question from Sen. Bernie Sanders asking whether access to healthcare is a human right and countered with a comparison to the right to free speech and an example of the smoker who develops lung cancer:
Free speech doesn’t cost anybody anything, but in health care, if you smoke cigarettes for 20 years and you get cancer you are now taking from the pool. Are you guaranteed the same right?
Yes, you fool. The answer is yes. It’s not just good morality, but it’s good science-based public health, as it’s long been known that one of the key reasons why the US lags behind other wealthy industrialized nations in health outcomes is our lack of universal health insurance, even after the Affordable Care Act. As I said, this was basically “soft eugenics,” “borrowing” a term I heard from the Conspirituality Podcast. However, RFK Jr. is on board with believing that healthcare is not a right, but a privilege. Given that, the proposed elimination of the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA), which operates the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline, and the elimination of the Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA), which is responsible for ensuring access to health care for uninsured, isolated, and vulnerable people (e.g., HIV/AIDS patients, mothers and children, and families in isolated rural communities) start to make sense, even though these are exactly the sort of functions of HHS that work to make America—at least the most vulnerable among us—healthy again. As I have said repeatedly, MAHA is a lot like The Secret combined with the delusion that you have total control over your health, meaning that if you aren’t healthy it’s your fault. Also, let’s not forget the pure neo-Lysenkoism.
If the Politico report is to be believed, RFK Jr. is the most popular cabinet secretary in the Trump administration. Personally, citing the great Charles Pierce’s characterization of Politico as “Tiger Beat on the Potomac,” I’m hoping this is an exaggeration. Still, it is quite concerning. RFK Jr.’s purview appears to be expanding well beyond that of a traditional HHS Secretary, and HHS Secretaries have long had a lot of power. One also wonders how RFK Jr. plans to make the FDA and CDC more effective, given the leaked administration draft of its FY2026 budget proposal that includes massive budget cuts for the FDA and CDC:
At many of the health department’s existing agencies, the proposed cuts would deliver a devastating blow. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s budget would be almost halved, from $9.2 billion to $5.2 billion, while the National Institutes of Health would have its funding drop from its current level of almost $48 billion to $27.3 billion.
At the Food and Drug Administration, the budget would also be reduced, from $7.2 billion to $6.5 billion. The memo also proposes that routine inspections of food facilities be contracted out entirely to states, while the Trump administration would take various unspecified actions “so chemicals and other additives in food and food packaging can be expeditiously removed from our food supply.”
I note that the budget cuts to the CDC and NIH would basically destroy the organizations, leaving them shells of themselves, unable to do anywhere near what they do now, and that a massive proposed reorganization included in the budget that would consolidate multiple centers would not save it. If scientists think it’s difficult to get an NIH grant now, if these cuts go through, it will become well-nigh impossible for most scientists. Paylines have long already been so low that less than 10% of grant applications are funded now; look for that payline to plunge into the low single digits. As I have warned before, say goodbye to the greatest engine of biomedical research ever created. As an aside, I did read the proposal and noticed that it actually proposes to eliminate that bastion of quapkademic medicine known as the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH). That would normally be a good thing, but, given the quackery that infuses MAHA, I strongly suspect that NCCIH would just dissolve into the rest of the NIH, contaminating everything there with its quackery.
As for vaccines, one must concede that the current measles outbreaks didn’t start because of Trump or RFK Jr. Indeed, they can be accounted for easily by declining vaccine uptake during the pandemic, stoked by the antivaccine movement that took the suspicion of COVID-19 vaccines based on their speed of development and novel technology and quickly turned suspicion to fear and generalized that suspicion and fear to other vaccines, regurgitating the oldest antivax tropes in the process and making them mainstream. By the time RFK Jr. was confirmed by the Senate, the west Texas measles outbreak was in full swing and smaller measles outbreaks had popped up in a number of other states. We can, however, blame RFK Jr. for his response since, which has been to downplay the MMR vaccine, grudgingly saying it’s the “most effective” way to stop the spread of measles while promoting all manner of dubious measles treatments, claiming that measles is basically harmless to healthy children without chronic diseases, and seemingly reinforcing the antivax stance of the parents of the two girls who have thus far died of measles during this outbreak. Meanwhile, the NIH is defunding grants supporting the study of mRNA vaccines and studies on vaccine hesitancy, while the FDA is making Novavax jump through the unnecessary hoop of doing another large RCT of its Novavax COVID-19 vaccine before changing its emergency use authorization (EUA) to a full FDA licensure, invoking methodolatry at its most base.
Now, let’s see what could happen if RFK Jr.’s HHS continues to make it harder to approve new vaccines and works to stoke mistrust in the vaccines already approved.
Hello measles, my old friend (and rubella and diphtheria and polio)
So let’s get to the numbers. The study is entitled Modeling Reemergence of Vaccine-Eliminated Infectious Diseases Under Declining Vaccination in the US and coauthored by a multi-institution team lead by corresponding author Nathan C. Lo, MD, PhD at the Division of Infectious Diseases and Geographic Medicine, Stanford University. Given that our current antivax-curious NIH Director Dr. Jay Bhattacharya hailed from Stanford before his elevation, I find this ironic. In the interests of the “radical transparency” that RFK Jr. claims to espouse even as he shut down FOIA offices of many HHS agencies and gutted the public records office at the CDC, I also note that friend of the blog, pediatrician and vaccine researcher Dr. Peter Hotez, is a coauthor.
The purpose of the study as stated was to “estimate the number of cases and complications in the US under scenarios of declining childhood vaccination for measles, rubella, poliomyelitis, and diphtheria,” and a “simulation model was used to assess the importation and dynamic spread of vaccine-preventable infectious diseases across 50 US states and the District of Columbia.” The idea was to model what the expected results of various vaccination rates would be over a 25 year period using data on area-specific estimates for demography, population immunity, and infectious disease importation risk, one of its inputs being childhood vaccination rates based on 2004-2023 data. The primary outcomes that were modeled included estimated cases of measles, rubella, poliomyelitis, and diphtheria in the US, and the secondary outcomes included estimated rates of infection-related complications (postmeasles neurological sequelae, congenital rubella syndrome, paralytic poliomyelitis, hospitalization, and death) and the probability and timing for an infection to reestablish endemicity.
Endemicity means nothing more than that the disease is continually being transmitted and circulating within a population, unlike the current situation with vaccine-preventable diseases. Because I’m a bit of a geek I’m going to quote a bit about the modeling and the assumptions used:
We simulated the population for each state by using demography and unique population immunity profiles for each infectious disease. For demography, we included 2019 state-specific estimates from the US Census Bureau for birth rate, population size, and age distribution and used state- and age-specific death rates from the National Center for Health Statistics.46 For generation of the age-specific profiles of population immunity, we used a combination of data from the National Immunization Surveys and data reported in published literature (additional information appears in the eAppendix in Supplement 1 and in the Table).25–33 We used state-specific estimates for population immunity (based on available vaccine coverage data from the National Immunization Surveys) for individuals 24 years of age or younger. For individuals older than 25 years of age, we assumed a general US-wide adult population immunity profile for each infectious disease informed by published literature.25–33 These data included seroprevalence estimates or vaccine data for the measles-mumps-rubella vaccine; the diphtheria, tetanus, and pertussis vaccine; and the inactivated poliovirus vaccine.
Each infection had unique pathogen characteristics, including a basic reproduction number, latent period, duration of infectiousness, and risk of complications (Table). Risks of infection-related complications were computed using literature-based risk estimates (ie, fraction of cases with the complication).
To evaluate model validity, we ran the model under current vaccination coverage levels over a 5-year period for each infectious disease. We then compared the estimated case numbers with publicly available observed case numbers reported by the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to assess how accurately the model reflects current transmission dynamics (eAppendix in Supplement 1).47
Here’s one of the key “money graphs.” Let me briefly explain. For each disease, the number of cases during the next 25 years was modeled under certain vaccine uptake rates. 0% means no change over vaccine uptake in 2023, while 100% means a 100% decline from 2023 rates; i.e., no children are being vaccinated against that disease. Now, if you look at the graphs, you’ll see a very interesting and disturbing phenomenon:
The model estimated the number of cumulative cases for each infectious disease under different routine childhood vaccination scenarios (x-axis), including vaccine decline (5%-50%) and vaccine increase (5%-10%). Each vaccination scenario is a relative percentage of the current state-specific level of childhood vaccination (shaded area). The ranges for the current state-specific vaccination levels appear under the x-axes. The point estimates represent mean cumulative cases over the 25-year simulation period and the bars represent the 95th percentile of the stochastic uncertainty interval (UI) around the estimate. The y-axis is on a log scale. The median vaccination rate was 91.6% for measles and rubella, 93.0% for poliomyelitis, and 84.2% for diphtheria.
And here is an estimate of complications from these four diseases:
The model estimated the cumulative cases of infection-related complications (y-axis) over 25 years under each scenario of change in childhood vaccination (see Table for model inputs) relative to the current state-specific levels of childhood vaccination (shaded area). The ranges for the current state-specific levels appear under the x-axes. The point estimates represent mean cumulative cases over the 25-year simulation period and the bars represent the 95th percentile of the stochastic uncertainty interval (UI) around the estimate. The y-axis is on a log scale. The median vaccination rate was 91.6% for measles and rubella, 93.0% for poliomyelitis, and 84.2% for diphtheria.
Note, first, that the Y-axes use a logarithmic scale. That means that a 10% decline from current vaccine uptake results in nearly a 10-fold increase in the number of cases of, for example, measles, whereas it takes more like a 25% decline in rubella vaccine uptake to see a ten-fold increase in the number of rubella cases. Alarmingly, a 25% decline in polio vaccine uptake will get us to roughly 100,000 cases of polio. On the other hand, note how increasing measles vaccine uptake by just 10% would result in a dramatic decline of nearly three orders of magnitude.
But what does this mean in raw numbers? The authors estimate first what would happen if current state-level vaccination rates were maintained or improved upon slightly:
Over a 25-year period and under a scenario with current state-level vaccination rates, the simulation model predicted there would be 851 300 cases (95% UI, 381 300-1.3 million cases) of measles, 190 cases (95% UI, 154-230 cases) of rubella, 18 cases (95% UI, 3-61 cases) of poliomyelitis, and 8 cases (95% UI, 1-22 cases) of diphtheria. Under this scenario, we projected 851 cases (95% UI, 372-1270 cases) with postmeasles neurological sequelae, 170 200 hospitalizations (95% UI, 76 200-250 000 hospitalizations), and 2550 deaths (95% UI, 1130-3760 deaths) (Figure 1 and eTable 8 in Supplement 1). Under a scenario with state-level measles-mumps-rubella vaccination rates that were 5% higher over 25 years, there would be 5800 cases (95% UI, 3100-19 400 cases) of measles. With a vaccination rate that was 10% higher, there would be 2700 cases (95% UI, 2200-3400 cases) of measles.
The first thing I noted here is that we are, arguably, already screwed. If nothing changes, we can expect a lot of bad things to happen in the US, at least with respect to measles, a scenario that could be massively improved upon just by a slight increase in vaccination rates, by 5-10%. Of course, this part can’t be blamed on Trump or RFK Jr., at least not directly. I do blame RFK Jr. for his 20 year campaign of promoting fear mongering about mercury in vaccines, MMR vaccines supposedly causing autism, and vaccines (and chemicals) creating what he called the “sickest generation.” Unfortunately, he had a lot of help, particularly during the pandemic. Now that he is HHS Secretary, however, we can see how his promotion of pseudoscientific claims of vaccine harm and his conspiracy theories about vaccines could lead a bad situation to become massively worse. for example:
In contrast, under a scenario with a 10% decline in measles-mumps-rubella vaccination, the model estimates 11.1 million (95% UI, 10.1-12.1 million) cases of measles.
I’d say that, if RFK Jr. is left in charge of HHS for the full four years of the second Trump administration, a 10% decline in vaccine uptake would arguably be a conservative estimate of what is likely to happen. More likely would be a larger decline, such as 25%, which the authors modeled:
If routine childhood vaccination declined by 25%, we estimated 26.9 million (95% UI, 25.5 million-28.1 million) cases of measles would occur within the 25-year period, 790 cases (95% UI, 429-1700 cases) of rubella, 87 600 cases (95% UI, 3 cases to 1.7 million cases) of poliomyelitis, and 11 cases (95% UI, 1-52 cases) of diphtheria. Under this scenario, we projected there would be 26 900 cases (95% UI, 25 500-28 100 cases) of postmeasles neurological sequelae, 100 cases (95% UI, 0-1300 cases) of paralytic poliomyelitis, 1 case (95% UI, 0-3 cases) of congenital rubella syndrome, 5.4 million hospitalizations (95% UI, 5.1-5.6 million hospitalizations) due to all infections, and 80 600 deaths (95% UI, 76 500-84 300 deaths) due to all infections.
Did I read that right? An estimate of nearly 88,000 cases of polio over 25 years? Polio was nearly eradicated worldwide, and RFK Jr.’s policies could well lead to its massive resurgence here in the US. And nearly 81,000 deaths from what are now vaccine-preventable diseases? Is that how RFK Jr. would “make America healthy again”? Apparently so. Maybe he yearns for the days of FDR. And, no, I don’t believe RFK Jr. for a minute when he says he doesn’t want to discourage vaccination or “take away people’s vaccines.” The very best we can expect from him is a not-so-benign neglect, coupled with a failure to promote vaccination. Under such a scenario, I can easily envision vaccine uptake falling by 10-25%, possibly more.
For example, by 50%, which, unless RFK Jr. actually does start delicensing childhood vaccines (which he might, based on his false belief that they cause autism), is unlikely, but worth looking at:
If routine childhood vaccination declined by 50%, the simulation model predicted there would be 51.2 million cases (95% UI, 49.7-52.5 million cases) of measles over a 25-year period, 9.9 million cases (95% UI, 6.4-13.0 million cases) of rubella, 4.3 million cases (95% UI, 4 cases to 21.5 million cases) of poliomyelitis, and 197 cases (95% UI, 1-1000 cases) of diphtheria. Under this scenario, we projected there would be 51 200 cases (95% UI, 49 600-52 600 cases) of postmeasles neurological sequelae, 5400 cases (95% UI, 0-26 500 cases) of paralytic poliomyelitis, 10 700 cases (95% UI, 6700-14 600 cases) of congenital rubella syndrome, 10.3 million hospitalizations (95% UI, 9.9-10.5 million hospitalizations) due to all infections, and 159 200 deaths (95% UI, 151 200-164 700 deaths) due to all infections (Figure 1, Figure 2, and eTables 8-9 in Supplement 1).
In the Supplements, there is a graph that basically shows how many cumulative cases we can expect under various scenarios, including 100% decline, the complete cessation of vaccination:
eFigure 2. Predicted cumulative cases of measles, rubella, diphtheria, and poliomyelitis over 25 years under different scenarios of childhood vaccination.
The model estimated mean number of cumulative cases of each disease (rows) under different routine childhood vaccination scenarios (colors), including current state-specific levels of vaccination. Each vaccination scenario is a relative reduced percentage of the current state- specific level of vaccination. The line represents the mean over 2,000 simulations and the shaded region represents the 95th percentile of stochastic uncertainty around the estimate.
And here are the estimated likelihoods of each disease returning to endemicity:
The model estimated the probability of reestablishing endemicity for a given scenario over 2000 simulations; the location of the point estimate (in respect to the x-axis) represents the mean time to reestablish endemicity for the proportion of simulations that achieved endemicity over the 25-year simulation period (ie, this estimate for timing does not include scenarios when endemicity was not reestablished). Endemicity was defined as when the national approximated effective reproduction number reached 1 or greater over a 12-month period, suggesting sustained local transmission, which is a conservative definition. Alternative definitions for endemicity were also evaluated (eAppendix and eFigure 13 in Supplement 1). The size of the point estimate represents the probability of reestablishing endemicity for a given scenario over 2000 simulations. The horizontal bars represent the 95th percentile of the uncertainty interval around this estimate on time to endemicity (for the proportion of simulations that achieved elimination). Endemicity was reestablished for measles in a very high proportion of simulations, including under current levels of vaccination. Diphtheria was the least likely to reestablish endemicity. In the high vaccination scenario (≥5% change in coverage from current levels of vaccination), no disease reestablished endemicity. The median vaccination rate was 91.6% for measles and rubella, 93.0% for poliomyelitis, and 84.2% for diphtheria.
Unsurprisingly, measles, being by far the most transmissible disease, would be expected to have the highest likelihood of becoming endemic again and doing it the fastest. Also, as the authors note, measles is the disease that is most commonly imported from other countries or regions with low vaccine uptake, with polio and diphtheria being the least common.
Like all modeling studies, this one has weaknesses largely based on its dataset and assumptions. For example, some of the assumptions were simplified, although the authors take pains to point out that they tended to use conservative estimates for “model inputs, meaning the risk of outbreaks and speed of reemergence under declining vaccination may be greater than predicted.” Similarly, they modeled outbreaks in states as though the states were independent, when clearly they are not. As we have seen with the west Texas outbreak, measles quickly popped up across the border in New Mexico. As the authors note again, this weakness, if anything, would imply that “the base-case model is an underestimation of total cases given the lack of spillover from state to state.”
Among other weaknesses, this one caught my eye:
Eighth, we did not account for outbreak-related reactive vaccination from public health departments or behavior change on vaccine uptake during outbreaks. Ninth, we did account for age-specific social mixing patterns, but there was homogenous mixing within those groups. However, there may be assortative mixing by vaccine status, which could lead to earlier outbreaks and return to endemicity. We generated mean risk estimates for complications related to each disease, but did not account for age-specific differences in outcomes.
“Assortative mixing by vaccine status.” What they mean is antivaxxers tending to cluster together. In any case, the vast majority of the weaknesses cited by the authors in their model would tend to underestimate, not overestimate, the number of cases expected, with the possible exception of effective reactive vaccination programs from public health departments. Even there, though, I remain pessimistic, because I know that RFK Jr. will not seriously support local public health departments in terms of strong promotion of vaccination campaigns. The states and localities will likely be left on their own.
What can we do?
I hate to be the constant Voice of Doom, but things are bad—and likely to get much worse over the next few years—with respect to public health, medicine, and biomedical research. Because RFK Jr. is gutting the CDC, even if President Trump is replaced by a pro-public health President in the 2028 election, who then appoints a pro-public health HHS Secretary in 2029, it will likely take years, possibly decades, to rebuild the public health infrastructure in the US, and, given the mistrust of public health and vaccines stoked by RFK Jr. (among others) before he was appointed and now being stoked by him as HHS Secretary, who know if there will be the political will to do what it takes to return to a science-based public health and vaccination policy?
It’s not all gloom and doom, even if it mostly is, however:
Vaccine scientists and medical leaders have announced they are launching an unprecedented initiative to react to vaccine misinformation and scientifically unfounded vaccine decisions by the U.S. government. https://t.co/WqjiipCjBm
— News from Science (@NewsfromScience) April 25, 2025
From the article:
Vaccine scientists and medical leaders announced today they are launching an unprecedented initiative to react to vaccine misinformation and scientifically unfounded vaccine decisions by the U.S. government.
The nascent Vaccine Integrity Project (VIP) is being spearheaded by the Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy (CIDRAP) at the University of Minnesota and funded by philanthropist Christy Walton, widow of an heir to the Walmart fortune. Led by former chiefs of the National Academy of Medicine (NAM) and the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), next month it will begin to convene leaders across public health and medicine to sound out their views on how to set up such a reaction team, Michael Osterholm, an epidemiologist and director of CIDRAP, told journalists at an embargoed press conference yesterday.
“This project acknowledges the unfortunate reality that the system that we’ve relied on to make vaccine recommendations and to review safety and effectiveness data faces threats,” Osterholm said in a release. At the press conference, Osterholm also referred to August 2024 comments by Jayanta “Jay” Bhattacharya, now director of the National Institutes of Health (NIH), about the technology behind leading COVID-19 vaccines. “Somebody has to be prepared to stand up if the director of the National Institutes of Health declares that mRNA [messenger RNA] vaccine technology is potentially dangerous,” he said.
It’s good that vaccine and public health scientists are pushing back. I wish them luck, even as a nagging voice in the back of my mind asks at the risk of offending or angering allies and colleagues, “Is it too little too late?” After all, the time to push back against misinformation in an organized, effective manner was 20 years ago, when RFK Jr. emerged and first came out as an antivaccine conspiracy theorist and quack. Indeed, I’ll be relieved if the only outright misinformation coming from Dr. Bhattacharya is just that mRNA vaccines are unsafe. After all, he’s already apparently signed on to RFK Jr.’s eugenicist characterization of the “autism tsunami” and endorsed RFK Jr.’s plan to fund dubious research, proposing an autism registry that would mine private medical records, a plan that so alarmed people that HHS backed off on Friday and said there were no plans for such a registry.
Nor do I mean to be too negative. Something needs to be done, and this initiative could conceivably be the spark that gets scientists motivated to push back. As Jason Schwartz says:
Some vaccine advocates not associated with VIP applaud its creation. “It’s important to get such a group up and running and be ready to respond to whatever may come down the line with vaccines,” says Jason Schwartz, a vaccine policy specialist at Yale University. “Because I think we would be kidding ourselves to think there will not continue to be more changes, more threats, more weakening of the federal government’s stewardship of our national vaccination efforts in the months and years to come.”
However the VIP evolves, I’m happy to support it and become involved if there’s anything I can do or if they’ll even have me in spite of my skepticism. More will clearly be needed, however. It’s incredibly difficult for small (thus far) private efforts to counter the tsunami of misinformation and disinformation that is out there now when much of it is now coming from the actual federal government. Contrary to scientists and physicians who sucked up to RFK Jr. because they liked parts of MAHA enough that they thought they could control him, science when it is applied to public policy can’t help but be political. After all, what could be more political than the Trump administration and its MAHA lackey mass canceling NIH grants based not on scientific considerations but on ideological considerations and bullying and punishing universities that do not sufficiently align with its political agenda?
In the meantime, I fear that it’ll be for the foreseeable future, “Hello measles, my old friend.”


Our Current Medical Establishment Would Have Botched COVID, The Same Way They Are Botching Measles
Those of us who paid attention to their COVID wishcasting are not the least bit surprised that measles is killing and injuring children under their watch.
Jonathan Howard on April 25, 2025
Link
What would you have done?
Recently, an interviewer sympathetic to the Great Barrington Declaration (GBD) listened to my criticisms of it and asked me: What would you have done? That question has me bothered me ever since.
Unlike the doctors I critique, I never claimed to be a pandemic guru with all the answers, and what I actually did is exactly what I would have done. There is no alternate version of me where I was the was mayor of NYC or the dictator of some country. What I actually did is much more interesting than fantasies about what I would have done. I worked in a hospital. I was in a vaccine trial. I corrected doctors’ misinformation. Moreover, just because someone says they would have done something doesn’t mean they actually would have done it. It’s trivially easy to write the words “I would have kept schools open” or “I would have protected the vulnerable.” Anyone can do it.
While obviously anyone can voice their opinion on how we could have better handled the pandemic, and it’s vital that we do that. However, the question “what would you have done?” conjures a parallel universe where words become reality, and both the virus and the public can be bent to one’s will.
Nonetheless, imagination time is fun, so here’s my answer:
I never would have let SAR-CoV-2 into the country. The moment the virus emerged in China, I would have sealed the border. If any COVID cases snuck in, I would isolate them before the virus could spread. I’d launch a massively successful vaccination campaign and ventilate indoor spaces. I’d create a culture where people stayed home when they were sick and where mask-wearing was not unusual. By keeping the virus out of the country, society could function normally, and people would remain healthy.
A reasonable person would not be impressed by this. They’d expect to see a detailed plan to keep COVID out of the country, and even then they would spot its many flaws.
Yet, many people did not demand such a plan from the GBD, although their proposal was as absurd as mine. They wanted 2/3 of the country live in a world of pure COVID and 1/3 of the country live in a world of zero COVID. They said this would end the pandemic in 3-6 months. Although though the virus shuttered schools and killed a record number of people when they ran the show in Florida, they claim that if only we had listened to them, everything would have been just fine.
Measles Surge in Southwest Is Now the Largest Single Outbreak Since 2000
While my plan of keeping the U.S. COVID-free is obviously superior to the GBD’s, I will receive zero credit for it. In contrast, the authors of the GBD and like-minded doctors received many accolades for merely saying what they would have done. However, recent events reveal just how absurd this adoration was.
Doctors who became celebrities for saying what they would have done, parlayed that game of make-believe into high positions in the Trump administration. They are the Medical Establishment now, and they no longer get to say what they would have done on Twitter and Fox News. They have real-world responsibility, and it’s a mess all around.
I don’t need to repeat all of the headlines of censorship and purges they are generating, but one thing they are doing is letting children suffer and die from vaccine-preventable diseases. Under our current Medical Establishment, the headlines read Measles Surge in Southwest Is Now the Largest Single Outbreak Since 2000, Texas Announces Second Measles Death in Unvaccinated Child, Texas Measles Outbreak Surpasses 600 Cases With Most Among Children, Teens, Two Infants Die of Whooping Cough in Louisiana as Cases Climb Nationally, and ‘Fighting to Breathe’: Whooping Cough Surges as Vaccination Rate Falters. We are just getting started. Another recent headline declared Millions of U.S. Measles Cases Forecast Over 25 Years if Shots Decline.
Despite these suffering children and the potential for many more to come, the Medical Establishment is focused on other topics. The article Robert F. Kennedy Jr. to Launch Autism Registry Using Private Health Records provides a preview of their creepy intentions, and in this unhinged screed, RFK Jr. says we need healthy kids for the military. What could go wrong?
Our Medical Establishment is trying to pull the COVID vaccine for children- FDA Commissioner Says Pulling COVID Vaccine For Children Will be ‘Welcomed’ Dr. Jay Bhattacharya wants to get rid of mRNA technology all together. They are also focused on fertility and testosterone levels in teenage boys. At this moment, these are their priorities.
Yes, measles is still the most contagious virus there is, but it should be easy to handle compared to COVID. We have a near-perfect vaccine, and most parents want it. Anti-vaxx disinformation is the only reason we are having measles outbreaks today, and explained by the article Measles Misinformation Is on the Rise — and Americans Are Hearing It, things are heading in the wrong direction. Allaying the fears of vaccine-hesitant parents should be a top priority for our Medical Establishment. That’s not happening.
The doctors who claimed they would have solved COVID are flailing with measles- amongst other things. Not only are the failing to correct anti-vaccine disinformation, they are making things worse. In one recent interview, Dr. Marty Makary, flanked by the Food Babe(!), twice refused to answer “YES!” when asked if parents should vaccinate their children against measles. In the video below, he said the bare minimum about the MMR. However, while saying “we have to be honest,” he minimized children dying of measles with the same noxious myths he used with COVID.
He said only vulnerable children are at risk of measles, he ignored its non-fatal outcomes, and absurdly implied parents are not given any choice regarding vaccines. He said that measles outbreaks are not unusual. He spread misinformation about the hepatitis B vaccine for no reason. He said that RFK Jr. had no responsibility for the current outbreak. He instead blamed “migrant communities” and unspecified “government misinformation” about COVID, even though the people who died of measles should have been vaccinated before the pandemic. This is yet another example of our FDA director endorsing time travel.
It’s also an example of deflection. The current Medical Establishment doesn’t want to take responsibility for what is happening under their leadership. Dr. Makary doesn’t want to acknowledge the obvious truth about his boss, a crank who lied about vaccines for 20-years and predictably botched this measles outbreak. While the current Medical Establishment got famous by blasting the previous Medical Establishment for their supposed dishonesty, they now seek to protect themselves above all else and distract from their ineptitude with odd ramblings on teenage hormones.
Stanford Doctor Jay Bhattacharya Calls Dr. Fauci ‘Number One Anti Vaxxer’
Despite their grand pronouncements, our current Medical Establishment wouldn’t have opened schools or protected the vulnerable when COVID was raging. Those were empty boasts. Right now, they are demonstrating their complete inability to keep people safe from a dangerous pathogens.
Yet, the problem isn’t just their incompetence, it’s their apathy. Our current Medical Establishment does not care about keeping people safe from dangerous viruses, though this is hardly breaking news. However, the strategy that catapulted them to their current positions, downplaying COVID on Fox News, isn’t going to work now that they are in charge. The media is paying attention to these interviews now and will scrutinize their false claims- FDA Head Falsely Claims no Scientists Laid Off, as Agency Shutters Food Safety Labs– something they were generally spared previously. They can’t just wish measles away. Even Megyn Kelly is asking about it. They will continue to be blamed for bad headlines about is meals, which is appropriate. It’s their job now to stop it, and the only way to do that is with vaccines.
Those of us on the outside have every right to treat our current Medical Establishment as harshly as they treated public health officials regarding COVID. Drs. Bhattacharya and Makary mocked them and depicted them as dishonest imbeciles for not saying that COVID vaccines were a perfect panacea or that natural immunity was this wonderful, powerful thing. We also have every right to hold them the highest standards. After all, they set high expectations by telling us all the amazing, incredible, wonderful things they would have done with COVID.
Obviously, our Medical Establishment does not deserve credit for these imagined “accomplishments”. Rather, they deserve to be judged for the real-world consequences of pandemic misinformation and everything that’s actually happening right now. Those of us who paid attention to their COVID fantasies are not the least bit surprised that they shrug as measles kills and injures children under their watch.
In contrast, I deserve praise and glory. Unlike our inept, bumbling Medical Establishment, I would have prevented this.
    • 

Dr. Jay Bhattacharya on Measles: “I Think I’ve Done My Best.”
As football coach Bill Parcells famously said, “you are what your record says you are”.
Jonathan Howard on August 27, 2026
Link

“Florida Leads Nation in Number of COVID-19 Deaths of Nursing Home Residents and Staff.”
Football coach Bill Parcells famously said, “you are what your record says you are”. Though SBM readers know about it already, Dr. Jay Bhattacharya had a horrific record advising Gov. Ron DeSantis during Florida’s brutal Delta wave in the summer of 2021. Although he claimed the state had “protected the vulnerable,” here’s what he actually accomplished when he had the chance to put his ideas into practice:
    • He failed to protect “vulnerable” people: “Florida Leads Nation in Number of COVID-19 Deaths of Nursing Home Residents and Staff,” August 2021.
    • He failed to protect “not vulnerable” people: “Child Covid Deaths More Than Doubled in Florida as Kids Returned to the Classroom,” September 2021.
    • He failed to keep schools open: “School Closures Reported In Five Florida Counties; Districts ‘Drowning’ In COVID,” August 2021.
    • He failed to protect educators: “15 Miami-Dade Public School Staff Members Die of COVID In Just 10 Days,” September 2021.
    • He failed to achieve herd immunity: “Florida’s COVID Deaths Reach Nearly 6,000 in 2024,” January 2025.
    • He failed to protect education: “Florida Ranks Last In Reading, Warns Nationwide Education Report“, May 2026
“We called for focused protection of vulnerable elderly and called for many policies.”
Florida turned out to be a preview of coming attractions, and more people should have paid attention it at the time. Unfortunately, instead of caring about reality, many influential pundits ignored Florida’s warning and glorified Dr. Bhattacharya simply because he called for things. Members of sheltered Opinion Class felt this was a big deal.
Indeed, in August 2021, during the worst of it all in Florida, Dr. Bhattacharya wasn’t in the hospital to witness what his precious “natural immunity” was doing to citizens, both young and old. Rather, he was busy giving promoting both himself and “natural immunity” in the media.
He gave an interview to the misinformation publication Unherd that month, boasting of his 1-page online petition. The interview was titled Prof. Jay Bhattacharya: I stand by the Great Barrington Declaration, and it opened by saying:
Professor Jay Bhattacharya is one of the famous voices to have emerged out of the pandemic. A vocal critic of lockdowns, his name became synonymous with the controversial Great Barrington Declaration, which called for an “alternative approach to the pandemic” that would entail no lockdowns. Along with co-signatories Sunetra Gupta and Martin Kulldforff (who featured on UnHerd last year), the trio argued that public health strategies should instead centre on the ‘focused protection’ of at-risk groups while keeping society as open as possible so the healthy parts of the population could build herd immunity.
This was 100% true, and everyone should be in complete agreement about it. Dr. Bhattacharya wanted society to open as open as possible so the healthy parts of the population could build herd immunity. Even during the middle of Florida’s Delta wave, he wanted them infected.
He also became a famous voice because he called for things and argued that other people should do them. Here’s a smattering things Dr. Bhattacharya called for on social media alone:
    • Focused protection of vulnerable elderly and many policies
    • We had twenty suggestions for how to accomplish focused protection in the gbd, and we called for public health to join in thinking creatively to think of more
    • A study to get a better estimate so we could make better decisions
    • Keeping schools open in Oct. 2020
We should also be clear that not only did Dr. Bhattacharya call for many things, this is all he did. He wasn’t in schools, hospitals, or nursing homes putting his plan into practice. As COVID raged, he was busy calling for things in podcasts, YouTube videos, editorials, and Tweets.
He further claimed that that he was were in charge, he would be able to do them. He would simply flip the “on” switch and everything would turn out just fine. How nice! Conversely, he blasted public health leaders for not doing all the things he called for. Why didn’t those fools just flip the “on” switch?
Fundamentally, Dr. Bhattacharya was a content creator who portrayed him as a pandemic superhero- COVID MAN, More Powerful Than a Deadly Virus. In the Fantasy of the Optional Pandemic, the virus was magically erased from the equation, and there was no difference between calling for something and actually doing it.
“Infant in Pennsylvania is one of the two measles deaths reported this week”
Things are very different today. Based on all the wonderful, amazing things he called for and would have done, Dr. Bhattacharya was elevated to a position of great authority and responsibility.
Dr. Bhattacharya’s days of calling for things are over. Now, it is our turn to call for things and to say we would do them. It’s his job to do everything we call for and to deliver concrete results. We have the right to excoriate him when he fails to do everything we call for, just like he did with his predecessors.
Feel free to share in the comments what you would call for Dr. Bhattacharya to do. One of you may call for him to stop censoring scientists. That’s a good idea. Someone else might call for him to stop appointing unqualified people with dangerous beliefs to lead the NIH. That’s important too. Anyone can call for Dr. Bhattacharya to do whatever they want, and there’s no shortage of complaints regarding his dismal performance in office.
For my part, I am calling for Dr. Bhattacharya to control measles. Things are going very poorly right now. Measles seems to be everywhere. Children are suffering. A few of them have died, most recently an infant in Pennsylvania. Measles is straining local budgets and impacting education, as reported by the article A Study Shows Just How Much School Absences Soar in a Measles Outbreak.
It’s not the only virus spreading now. Though he previously claimed he would have perfectly contained COVID, today the headlines read CDC: COVID Infections Likely Rising in 50 States and South Texas School District Cancels Classes Amid COVID-19 Spread. It’s Florida’s Delta wave all over again, but now for the entire country and with multiple viruses, as well as bacteria and parasites.
Once again you are what your record says you are. Here’s Dr. Bhattacharya’s record.
“I think I’ve done my best.”
Dr. Bhattacharya was recently confronted about his failure with measles by Margaret Brennan. In addition to blaming Biden, he boasted about a video he posted to X six months ago where he encouraged the MMR.
There is no reason to think this lone social media post changed the mind of a single parent, however, Dr. Bhattacharya was extraordinarily proud of it. “I think I’ve done my best,” he said, and I believe him. He is not capable of doing better than this. Posting a single social media video is the best he can do to control dangerous viruses, and while he absolutely deserves a participation trophy for it, his “best” obviously isn’t good enough
Unfortunately, we are probably just getting started. Only the MMR can contain measles, and with anti-vaxx disinformation flying from the Oval Office, it’s no surprise that the headlines read Kindergarten Routine Vaccination Rates Continue to Decline.
So while Dr. Bhattacharya may be doing his best, he obviously needs a lot of him help. Since I am calling for him to contain measles, I will also tell him what I would do.
I would blanket the media with the facts. I would tell parents measles is dangerous while the MMR is safe and effective at every opportunity. This is exactly what Ms. Brennan suggested. She and I hit on the same idea, not because it is brilliant, but because it is obvious.
I would further travel and encourage vaccination during public meetings. I would send a diverse group of HHS employees to spread this message to different communities. I would call out anti-vaccine disinformation spread by Stephen Miller, Kennedy, and Trump, even this honesty cost me my job.I would not debase myself and the entire medical profession by nodding along as they lied about vaccines.
But that’s what Dr. Bhattacharya chose to do.
And until he gets measles under control, we should all point out his gross incompetence and call for him to get his act together in podcasts, YouTube videos, editorials, and Tweets. He’s the medical establishment now, and this is what he signed up for.


MAHA Leaders Are Recycling COVID Myths to Minimize Measles
Once again, everything old is new again. The circle of disinformation is complete.
Jonathan Howard on February 8, 2026
Link

Dr. David Gorski previously coined the phrase “everything old is new again” to describe how disinformation agents plagiarized “old school” anti-vaccine balderdash to minimize COVID. These techniques were dishonest, but effective. As a result, people died of COVID, and MAHA doctors were catapulted to power.
However, with the geniuses who “would have” perfectly controlled COVID in charge, the headlines read:
    • 4 Times As Many Measles Cases In A Few Weeks Than Us Typically Averages In A Whole Year
    • Measles Hits ICE Family Detention Center in Texas
    • Measles Is Causing Brain Swelling in Children in South Carolina
Competent leaders would use their authority and soapbox to promote the MMR at every opportunity. MAHA leaders are not doing that, and we are allowed to judge them on their silence now. Instead, they have been recycling COVID myths, which were themselves recycled from pre-pandemic anti-vaxx myths, to minimize measles and fear monger about the vaccine. Here are 6 examples.
1. People Die With COVID/Measles, Not of COVID/Measles
To minimize COVID then and measles today, disinformation agents spread the myth that people died with the virus, not from the virus.
2. Only Sick Kids Die
To minimize COVID then and measles today, disinformation agents spread the toxic myth that only unhealthy children died from them, though death is not the only bad outcome from either virus.
3. It’s All Going Away
To minimize COVID then and measles today, disinformation agents prematurely claimed the worst was over, and it was all going away.
4. The Vaccine is Dangerous
To minimize COVID then and measles today, disinformation agents treated vaccine side effects, both real and imagined, as a fate worse than death from a virus.
5. Doctors Are to Blame
To minimize COVID then and measles today, disinformation agents claimed that incompetent doctors were to blame for the death of their patients.
6. Infections Are Beneficial
To minimize COVID then and measles today, disinformation agents claimed that these viruses have potential health benefits. In his essay and video, I Am Going To Mask Because I Want To Get Fewer Colds & Other Flawed Ideas Dr. Vinay Prasad said:
It is natural to be infected repeatedly with respiratory viruses— if we got fewer infections what would that mean for auto-immunity for cancer? We have no clue. We have no idea if we would actually live longer or healthier lives trying to dodge seasonal runny noses and coughs.
Once again, everything old is new again, again. The circle of disinformation is complete, and we are still just getting started. Though I can’t help but wonder if maybe we could have avoided everything that’s happening with measles today had more people cared about COVID disinformation back then.


Everything Old Is New Again, Again
Myths spread by contrarian doctors to minimize COVID are being recycled to minimize measles. The anti-vaccine circle is complete.
Jonathan Howard on March 7, 2025
Link

Several years ago, Dr. David Gorski coined the phrase “everything old is new again” to describe how contrarian doctors perfectly parroted what “old school” anti-vaxxers said about measles and the MMR. None of their arguments against the COVID vaccine were new or original, at least to those of us who cared about the anti-vaccine movement before the pandemic, and tried to warn of its threat. It was obvious to us that myths spread by anti-vaxxers to minimize measles were being recycled by contrarian doctors to minimize COVID.
Now, measles is back. Thanks in part to the efforts of contrarian doctors, RFK Jr. is trying to stop it with vitamin A and cod liver oil. He’s not getting on camera urging vaccinations. As measles spreads, the anti-vaccine movement is prepared, emboldened, and empowered. Respected doctors from respected universities amplified their ideas and made them mainstream. Today myths spread by contrarian doctors to minimize COVID are being recycled by anti-vaxxers to minimize measles.
The anti-vaccine circle is complete.
Child that died in Texas apparently had pneumonia and RSV and word is they vaccinated while sick for measles.
In August 2021, as the Delta variant ripped through the country, Dr. Tracy Beth Høeg looked a random data fluctuations and decided to “just ask questions” about whether SARS-CoV-2 was really hurting children. To minimize COVID, she suggested that RSV was filling up pediatric hospitals and that incompetent pediatricians were misdiagnosing their patients. I debunked that myth here.
Today, anti-vaxxers are claiming that the child who died of measles in Texas, actually died of RSV.
Unless children have underlying conditions or are malnourished, measles in not a problem.
With COVID, Dr. Marty Makary spread the myth that there was a “mortality rate of zero among children without a pre-existing medical condition such as leukemia.” I debunked that myth here.
Today, anti-vaxxers are claiming that measles is harmless for healthy children. Although anti-vaxxers don’t seem to recognize this, children with underlying medical conditions also are loved and have value.
The 6yr old did not die from measles. She died because the hospital refused to give her breathing treatments.
Because he could not utter the words “I underestimated COVID”, Dr. John Ioannidis decided to throw frontline doctors under the bus. He said lives were lost in 2020 because doctors were “just going crazy, and intubating people who did not have to be intubated”. They, not COVID, were to blame for the demise of their patients. I debunked that myth here.
Though they now blame the lack of “breathing treatments,” anti-vaxxers are again blaming doctors, not measles, for the death of the child in Texas. In this universe, doctors are deadlier than measles and COVID.
Did the child die with measles or from measles?
Another technique Dr. Ioannidis used to minimize COVID was to claim that people were dying with COVID not from COVID. In one typical interview he said:
It’s very difficult to differentiate between deaths by SARS-CoV-2 and deaths with SARS-CoV-2. Since we had close to 99% of people dying have other causes that may have contributed to their demise, it’s very difficult to dissociate and say that these people specifically died because they were infected.
Only someone who never worked in a hospital would say anything that absurd, and I debunked that myth here.
Now, anti-vaxxers are again claiming that children die with measles, not from measles.
I don’t remember measles cases (which happen every year) being breathless national news in previous years. Does the media know children are dying from chronic diseases (not measles.)
Even though COVID hospitalized 234,000 children, Dr. Vinay Prasad tried to minimize it by claiming it was “breathless, fear-mongering” created by the news. He portrayed anyone who wasn’t apathetic to sick children as both hysterical and indifferent to other risks. I discussed this misleading technique here.
Now anti-vaxxers are claiming measles is a creation of “breathless” of the news and that anyone who disagrees doesn’t care about “chronic diseases.”
Source for this quote
For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life.
Along with Allison Krug, Dr. Prasad also argued that COVID was “natural and healthy” for children to contract COVID and that it was “reckless” to prevent infections. Their article Should We Let Children Catch Omicron? was written during the deadliest wave of the pandemic for children, and it said:
When it comes to infectious disease, normality means a world where they are routinely exposed to, and overcome, viral illness. For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life…
Parents must consider that exposures are how we best protect our children against the variants of the future. In fact, it is reckless to let children age into a more serious encounter with a disease best dealt with while younger.
I debunked the myth that COVID is healthy for children here.
Today, authorities are asking parents not to hold “measles parties”. These parents have been told that for children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life
Indeed, everything old is new again, again. However, beyond using identical language and techniques to mislead their audience, there is no fundamental difference between someone who minimizes COVID and someone who minimizes measles. Grieving parents aren’t focused on which particular virus killed or injured their child. It’s a tragedy any time a child suffers because their parents were tricked by anti-vaxxers.
This didn’t used to be controversial in medicine.

Measles Surging As Vaccine Rates Drop
Steven Novella on May 6, 2026
Link

As easily predicted, declining measles vaccine rates in the US is leading directly to surging measles cases. In 2025 we saw the highest measles cases, 2288, since 1991, and in 2026 we are on track to exceed this number with 1814 confirmed cases so far (these are confirmed cases).
The US is also not getting the worst of it, that would be Bangladesh. The WHO reports: “A total of 19,161 suspected measles cases and 2,897 laboratory-confirmed measles cases have been reported between 15 March and 14 April 2026, including 166 measles related deaths (CFR 0.9%). The majority (79%) of the reported cases are children aged under 5 years.” This includes 166 deaths, mostly of children under 2.
There is no mystery as to why this is happening. In Bangladesh 74% of the case are in individual who are unvaccinated, with another 14% in those who received only one of the two recommended MMR doses. The other 14% were in the fully vaccinated. In the US the numbers are even more stark – with 92% of cases in the unvaccinated and only 4% of cases in the fully vaccinated. These numbers are even more significant when you consider that the fully vaccinated outnumber the unvaccinated by 23 to 1, which translates to the unvaccinated being 264 times more likely to get infected. The difference between the US and Bangladesh is likely due to increased susceptibility in the population due largely to poor nutrition.
We can also look at the numbers over time. Bangladesh actually was approaching elimination of measles up until 2016. Elimination means that a disease is no longer self-sustaining in a population. Eradication means that an infection is removed from the world. Before Bangladesh achieved elimination status, however, vaccine rates declined due to a number of reasons. As vaccine rates drops, measles cases increased, leading to the recent outbreak.
In the US we had achieved elimination status in 2000 (which requires 12 months of no domestic transmission). This correlated directly with introduction of the measles vaccine in 1963, followed by the combined MMR in 1971, and the recommended second dose of MMR in 1989. In every country, there is a direct correlation to measles vaccine uptake and reduction in cases. In the US, through the early 2000s, we saw fewer than 70 cases per year, all introduced by foreign travel.
The anti-vaccine movement, however, was on the rise at this time leading to a softening of MMR uptake. It is estimated that 95% average vaccine uptake is required to achieve herd immunity (or community immunity), a condition in which the virus cannot find enough susceptible hosts to spread, and so any outbreaks burn out. Dipping below 95% coverage, even in some regions, leads to increased risk of outbreaks and larger outbreaks. This too we see over and over with undervaccinated populations being the centers for outbreaks.
The recent problems with measles began in 2019 with the COVID pandemic. Without relitigating the ultimate causes, it’s pretty clear that COVID lead to increased vaccine hesitancy and resistance to public health measures, leading to further drop in MMR uptake. As you can easily see in the graph above, as vaccine uptake declined, measles cases increased. The US almost lost its elimination status (which requires 12 months of continued internal spread) last year, and very likely might lose it this year. This completes the circle of evidence – as vaccine rates increase measles drops, and as vaccine rates decline measles surges – in every country, over and over. Evidence for the effectiveness and necessity of the MMR vaccine is overwhelming.
The reasons for declining uptake in the US are complex. I am not going to pretend this is all due directly to RFK Jr. The backlash to public health due to COVID clearly seems to be a major trigger. But RFK Jr. is exacerbating the problem. He has a career spreading anti-vaccine misinformation and conspiracy theories. He has decimated the CDC, purged the vaccine council of legitimate scientists and packed it with anti-vaccine cranks, and has done everything possible to undermine vaccine science and confidence in health institutions.
The Trump administration in general has been hostile to science and science-based policy. Most recently he has fired all 22 members of the National Science Board, the group that oversees the National Science Foundation. There does not appear to be any legitimate cause for this mass firing, and we can only speculate how they may have displeased the president. Regardless – the bigger picture is that this represent a continued attack on the independence of experts who are supposed to inform federal policy. Purging independent recognized experts and replacing them with ideologues and toadies is a clear authoritarian move, and it antithetical to science and good governance. This is not normal – these are not political positions we expect to change with every administration.
A surge in measles cases in only the most immediate and obvious result this anti-science and anti-expertise agenda. Long term generational damage is guaranteed at this point, and we will likely never know its full extent.

Making measles great again in Ohio
Dr. Jonathan Howard was right. They really do want you—and your kids—infected, preferably with measles. One way they’ll accomplish this is by preventing schools from excluding unvaccinated children during outbreaks.
David Gorski on September 14, 2026
Link

I’ve written about the central conspiracy theory of the vaccine movement, but there is also an idea held by many antivaxxers that I now like to call their central delusion. (Well, one of several delusions, but this is arguably the most prominent.) Specifically, it is the idea that immunity after surviving an infection (often referred to as “natural immunity”) is somehow inherently superior to immunity acquired through vaccination. While it is true that for some vaccines postinfection immunity is longer lasting than vaccine-induced immunity, the price of postinfection immunity is suffering through the infection and being at risk for the serious complications that the infection can cause. The main conclusion that flows from this assumption is that “natural herd immunity” is inherently superior to herd immunity acquired through mass vaccination. Although antivaxxers have long made this claim for measles, the most recent and famous statement of this principle was the Great Barrington Declaration, the pre-vaccine October 2020 “declaration” claiming that if governments would just let COVID-19 rip through their “low risk” population, “natural herd immunity” could be achieved in six months. True, the GBD did also call for “focused protection” of those at high risk for hospitalization and death due to COVID but proposed no actual concrete suggestions for policy initiatives that would accomplish this end. As we’ve written multiple times before, the GBD was a eugenicist (or at least social Darwinist) document that was a disaster as policy (it never would have worked) and was a major force decimating public health during the pandemic, given how many governments were seduced by its claims.
Hello measles, my old friend…
Our very own Dr. Jonathan Howard even wrote a book that documented this fervent belief in “natural immunity,” We Want Them Infected: How the Failed Quest for Herd Immunity Led Doctors to Embrace the Anti-Vaccine Movement and Blinded Americans to the Threat of COVID. Unfortunately, as we came to know for certain after suspecting it, “natural herd immunity” was never going to be on the table for COVID-19, given that postinfection immunity is relatively short-lived and SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus that causes COVID-19, easily mutated under selection pressure to produce successive variants that could evade the “natural” immunity caused by infection with previous variants, leading to the Delta and Omicron waves, for instance. However, the idea that “natural herd immunity” is superior is not new, and it is manifesting itself in other ways during the current ongoing measles outbreak that is on track to cause the US to lose its measles elimination status later this year. Just an hour’s drive south of me, in Ohio, antivaxxers are kicking up a fuss about a surprisingly rational policy (given the state and its politics) designed to help control school outbreaks of measles and other vaccine-preventable diseases. Over at Children’s Health Defense, the antivax org founded by our current Secretary of Health and Human Services and longtime antivax activist, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., Michael Nevradakis is in fine fettle complaining that Ohio Schools Can Send Unvaccinated Kids Home for 25 Days — Even If They’re Not Sick.
First, he describes the policy:
Ohio’s new policy forcing healthy, unvaccinated children out of school for 21 to 25 days after a confirmed case of measles or rubella is drawing fire from parents, lawyers and scientists.
Critics say the policy isn’t needed to protect public health, it could harm children and it may be illegal.
The policy, part of a public health order signed in February by Ohio Department of Public Health (ODH) Director Bruce Vanderhoff, is enforceable even if the unvaccinated student shows no signs of illness or infection.
The policy also applies whenever a mumps or chickenpox outbreak occurs — and it extends to sports and extracurricular activities, not just classroom attendance.
The 21-to-25-day quarantine resets every time a new case or outbreak is reported at the student’s school.
“Critics say”? You really mean, “Antivax activists say.” “Scientists”? Say instead the antivax cranks and quacks aligned with the vaccine movement, which is what you really mean. In any case, kudos to the Ohio Director of Health, Dr. Bruce Vanderhoff, for having the testicular fortitude to use his power to protect unvaccinated children. Given the political landscape in Ohio, he must have known he would face a lot of blowback and even possibly personal danger.
This is, of course, Epidemiology 101. In order to slow an outbreak of an infectious disease like measles, keep as many individuals most susceptible to the disease (e.g., the unvaccinated) away from places where they are likely to come into contact with the disease (e.g., schools in which a case of measles has been observed). In addition, such a policy protects the individuals most vulnerable to the disease, namely the unvaccinated. (I’ll explain more about why this policy is science-based a little later.) In public health, this sort of policy is science-based and unobjectionable, so much so that it’s difficult to believe that anyone would argue otherwise, but Nevradakis is an antivax activist with an antivax organization; so he continues:
Naturally, CHD frames this policy as an assault on liberty, because of course they do:
Jeffrey Tucker, president and founder of the Brownstone Institute, called the policy “cruel and discriminatory” and a violation of the rights of children and their parents or guardians.
“If the policy is to protect the unvaccinated children, the parents should be the ones to decide,” Tucker said.
Karl Jablonowski, Ph.D., senior research scientist for Children’s Health Defense (CHD), said the “contrast between medical freedom and medical tyranny is blatant” in the policy, which he said “discriminates against people based on medical choice … with zero evidence that they pose a risk.”
Citing the neo-Confederate hack conspiracy theorist Jeffrey Tucker, who arguably is the one most responsible for the GBD, given that he brought together the three malleable libertarian-leaning scientists who wrote and signed the Declaration, one of whom, far from being “persecuted” is now the Director of the National Institutes of Health, is certainly a… choice. It’s not a good choice, but it’s definitely a choice. Before I discuss this more, though, I want to push back on the idea that there is “zero evidence” that they pose a risk.
The scientific rationale for excluding unvaccinated children from school during an outbreak
Let’s recap what the Ohio policy states. I do want to mention one thing about it that antivaxxers should like, specifically this:
A child who had measles disease and presents a signed statement from their parent, guardian, or physician to that effect, is not required to be vaccinated against measles. However, in an outbreak situation, a written statement of previous measles disease is acceptable in lieu of vaccination only if it is signed by a physician and gives the month and year of infection.
Surprise! It turns out that, contrary to claims otherwise by antivaxxers, those nasty public health officials do recognize postinfection immunity as being important, although, understandably, in an outbreak situation the health department wants more evidence than just the parents’ say-so.
But why do public health officials recommend excluding unvaccinated students from school when a measles case is reported at their school? It all boils down to a science-based knowledge of the measles virus and the behavior of measles as a disease.
First, we know that measles is highly transmissible. Indeed, it has one of the highest reproductive numbers (R0) of any known virus that infects humans, generally estimated to be around 12–18 in susceptible populations; i.e., one case can infect 12–18 others in a fully susceptible group. (This estimate comes from decades of outbreak-investigation studies and is summarized in systematic reviews of measles transmission dynamics, such as this highly cited one from 2017. This very high R0 is why the herd immunity threshold for vaccine coverage is so high for measles (~95%).
Second, measles is spread by respiratory droplets and aerosols and can persist in a room for up to two hours after the infected person leaves, meaning that face-to-face contact is not necessary to transmit measles. Add to that the fact that infected people are contagious up to four days before the characteristic measles rash appears, although respiratory symptoms tend to appear slightly earlier. It turns out that the incubation period for measles is generally around 10 days from exposure to onset of illness and 14 days to appearance of the rash. This lag is why exclusion policies tend to emphasize the date of exposure rather than the date of symptom onset. A susceptible child can shed virus for over a week with no visible signs.
Third, among people with no pre-existing immunity, the infection rate is estimated to be approximately 90%, which means that 90% of people who are not immune will develop disease after exposure. This is one of the highest attack rates documented for any vaccine-preventable disease.
All of this leads to the generally accepted guidance from public health institutions (e.g., the CDC and most state health departments) that unvaccinated or otherwise nonimmune children be excluded from school for 21 days after the date of possible exposure or until they show evidence of immunity. The 21-day window to be excluded is not at all arbitrary; rather, it covers the outer bound of the incubation period so that an infected but asymptomatic child does not return to school and start a new chain of transmission. Similar estimates for incubation periods used to guide school exclusion policies can be found in this systematic review of several vaccine-preventable diseases from 2018. These sorts of considerations are behind the CDC’s recommendations for a 21-day exclusion period for unvaccinated children when a case of measles is detected at a school or day care facility. (I’m surprised RFK Jr.’s antivax goons haven’t gotten around to deleting that webpage yet.) The science-based rationale behind such policies can be summed up simply: Measles spreads too efficiently and too early (before symptoms) to rely on anything other than excluding the non-immune during the incubation window.
I would also point out that this policy has the primary purpose of protecting the unvaccinated child from measles, in addition to its purpose of preventing the creation of a secondary chain of transmission from the unvaccinated child who’s been exposed and shedding virus but is not yet symptomatic. Not that this consideration seems to enter into antivaxxers’ consideration. After all, to them, measles is a “harmless” childhood disease. Never mind that it is not, and that a significant proportion of children who get the measles develop secondary pneumonia, that there is roughly a 1 in 1,000 risk of serious neurological sequelae, and a 1:1,000 risk of death. I also like to point out that antivaxxers not infrequently advocate quarantine to control outbreaks of infectious disease. Exclusion from school is a step considerably less drastic than quarantine, and here they are, losing their minds over it.
Vaccine injury?
After laying down the appeal to “personal freedom” to spread disease and let their children catch measles, Nevradakis immediately pivots to fear-mongering about “vaccine injury” from the MMR vaccine:
Earlier this month, Ohio school districts sent letters to parents warning that children who haven’t received two doses of the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine will be “excluded from school” for 21 days whenever the school confirms a measles case.
According to the policy, any vaccine doses children received five or more days before the minimum interval or age are “invalid” — so those students are classified as unvaccinated and required to be re-vaccinated.
That could put those children “at serious risk of vaccine injury,” according to Ohio Advocates for Medical Freedom, which called for the “immediate repeal” of the policy.
In a letter to leaders and members of the Ohio Senate and House of Representatives, the group said Ohio’s policy amounts to a “coercion tactic to bully parents into submitting to vaccination against their conscience out of desperation.”
Most families will be unable to find solutions to keep their unvaccinated children at home for several weeks or months, the letter noted.
Leslie Manookian, president of the Health Freedom Defense Fund, agreed that the policy appears deliberately designed to “coerce busy parents into vaccinating their children so they won’t be excluded from attending school and any school-related activities.”
Does anyone remember Leslie Manookian? I do. I first encountered her in 2011 when I reviewed her movie The Greater Good, one of the first antivax propaganda films masquerading as a documentary that I ever deconstructed. I encountered her again a year later, this time in person, when while attending that year’s The Amazing Meeting, I was invited to witness a debate about vaccines at FreedomFest in Las Vegas between our fearless leader Dr. Steven Novella and antivax “wellness” crank Dr. Julian Whitaker. (Dr. Novella wiped the floor with Dr. Whitaker, leading to a hilariously pathetic response from him.)
As for Ohio AMF, they really turn up the hysteria to 11 in their objection:
Also included in Vanderhoff’s “Approved Means of Immunization” 2/4/26 document, he has set a dangerous requirement for parents to RE-VACCINATE their child if ANY DOSE they received did not occur within 4 DAYS before the “minimum age requirement” and labels 5-day-late doses “INVALID.” This requirement puts children at serious risk of vaccine injury due to over-vaccination and places extreme time-constraint burdens on parents. This tyrannical, unfounded requirement is another grave abuse of power on behalf of the Health Director and it demands immediate attention, reprimand, and REPEAL of the order by the legislature.
Hysterical much. Let’s look at what the order actually says:
Vaccine doses administered four (4) days or less before the minimum interval or age are considered valid. Doses of any vaccine administered five (5) or more days earlier than the minimum interval or minimum age should not be counted as valid doses and should be repeated as age appropriate. The repeat dose should be spaced after the invalid dose by the recommended minimum interval. Any live virus vaccines (measles, mumps, rubella, and varicella vaccines) not administered on the same day must be separated by at least four (4) weeks (28 days).
This is a whole lot less “draconian” than Ohio AMF tries to make you believe. Note that the order says “repeated as age-appropriate” and not mentioned by Ohio AMF is this part of the order:
A student who presents laboratory evidence of immunity shall be exempt from the second dose requirement.
If measles antibody titers are drawn and shown to be sufficiently high to indicate immunity to measles, then extra doses are not required in this policy. As for “risk of vaccine injury,” that is standard antivax nonsense. I realize that antivaxxers don’t believe it, but there are mountains of evidence that vaccines are effective and incredibly safe. Are they absolutely, perfectly safe? No. Nothing in medicine (or life, for that matter) is. Compared to remaining susceptible to the diseases they prevent, however, vaccines are far safer.
Meanwhile, as antivaxxers are wont to do, Ohio AMF is portraying the unvaccinated as victims, this time of… segregation:
Ohio Advocates for Medical Freedom is asking House and Senate members to call for the immediate repeal of ORC Section 3701.13 Department of Health – Powers (B)(4). This section, which is supposed to “encourage vaccination,” is instead being abused by the Department of Health to implement state-sanctioned segregation of healthy Ohio children and the coercion and punishment of parents who lawfully exercise their right to vaccine exemptions for school attendance.
I always find it gross when antivaxxers don the mantle of victimhood for their choices, but it’s even grosser when they co-opt the language of civil rights to liken themselves to historically disadvantaged and oppressed minorities by invoking terms like “segregation.” They love to do this all the time too, even going so far as to declare themselves the “new civil rights movement.” I guess that their likening themselves to victims of segregation is marginally less offensive than past examples of this sort of rhetoric: for example, when they liken themselves to victims of “othering” of the sort that led to the Holocaust, the Rwandan genocide, and the like or when they liken vaccines and vaccine mandates to slavery (even likening pre-pandemic laws on vaccine mandates to the Fugitive Slave Act), rape, segregation and Jim Crow, human trafficking and sex slavery, and child grooming. At least this time, they haven’t tried to co-opt holidays commemorating the end of oppression (e.g., Juneteenth, which commemorates the end of slavery) or symbols of oppression (e.g., the Yellow Star of David used by Nazis to identify Jews in Germany and their conquered territories) and declared themselves to be like abolitionists.
They do love their language of victimhood, though, and this time it’s no different. Consistent with longstanding antivax rhetoric, they are also, apparently, the victims of “bullying”:
Health Director Vanderhoff is setting school EXCLUSION policy for timeframes and infections that are NOT listed in ORC to exclude totally healthy unvaccinated children from school and activities, as a COERCION tactic to BULLY parents into submitting to vaccination against their conscience out of desperation.
And:
Vanderhoff knows exactly what he is doing. The average Ohio parent can NOT manage having their child doing school from home remotely for WEEKS to MONTHS. How many students will lose out on sports or other college scholarships because they were obstructed from sports and in-person learning? Did we not learn our lesson during COVID as to the level of damage this caused our children in the name of “public health”?
Actions. Consequences. Learn the relationship, antivaxxers. Your “choice” for your child has consequences.
But, but, but… the measles vaccine doesn’t work?
A bit later in the CHD post, Nevradakis lays down a masterclass in spreading fear, uncertainty, and doubt (FUD) about the measles vaccine by trying to claim that the MMR vaccine doesn’t work. Of course, it is more than 90% effective when children receive the two recommended doses, but it isn’t 100% effective, which means—to antivaxxers at least—that it’s crap. Key to Nevradakis’ Gish gallop of deception is the claim that the vaccinated can still catch and transmit measles:
According to a systematic review published last month in the peer-reviewed Expert Review of Vaccines, people who were vaccinated against measles can still contract and transmit the virus to others, and in some instances initiate substantial chains of transmission, which can “contribute to outbreaks.”
In 2011, a fully vaccinated person in New York also infected others. In measles outbreaks in Italy between 2017 and 2021, many vaccinated people became infected. The same was true for a 2025 outbreak in Colorado.
“Even if every single child in a school, community or state were vaccinated, that would not stop cases of measles, because the measles vaccine suffers from both primary and secondary vaccine failure,” Manookian said.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimates that the primary failure rate of the MMR vaccine is as high as 7%.
Tell me you don’t understand herd immunity without telling me you don’t understand herd immunity.
Yes, some people vaccinated with MMR can still catch measles. However, the above quote is a misreading of all the studies cited. For example, the article in Expert Review of Vaccines cited concludes:
Measles transmissions from vaccinated cases, although relatively uncommon, must be considered in public health investigations, as such transmissions can contribute to outbreaks.
That’s the point that Nevradakis fails to mention. Yes, vaccinated people can catch and transmit measles. They just have a far lower chance of catching and transmitting measles than unvaccinated people do. That’s the function of vaccines: to decrease the risk as much as possible; vaccines can’t eliminate it entirely. Again, this is a typical antivax fallacy of black-and-white thinking—if a vaccine doesn’t prevent disease and transmission 100% of the time, it’s useless. Let’s put it this way: According to this review, 7.9% of vaccinated people who got measles transmitted it to other people. In the unvaccinated, that number would be closer to 100%. The article also estimates an R0 for these people of around 4. Remember, the R0 for unvaccinated people in a susceptible population is 12-16. Seriously, Nevradakis’ argument is so stupid that it insults my intelligence to read it.
As for that 2011 case, the article concluded:
This is the first report of measles transmission from a twice-vaccinated individual with documented secondary vaccine failure. The clinical presentation and laboratory data of the index patient were typical of measles in a naive individual. Secondary patients had robust anamnestic antibody responses. No tertiary cases occurred despite numerous contacts. This outbreak underscores the need for thorough epidemiologic and laboratory investigation of suspected cases of measles regardless of vaccination status.
The first report. Again, what Nevradakis is fear mongering about, vaccinated individuals catching and transmitting measles, is very uncommon. Again, the issue is not that some vaccinated people become infected with measles and transmitting during an outbreak. The issue is the risk of becoming infected with measles and transmitting it during an outbreak, and that risk is a lot lower if you’ve been vaccinated and have never had measles before than it is if you’re immunologically naive; i.e., unvaccinated and have never had measles before.
It’s the same game antivaxxers play every time there’s a measles outbreak. They point to a number of cases of measles in vaccinated children as evidence that the “vaccine doesn’t work,” neglecting to divide by the denominator to determine the percentage risk (or attack rate) of measles in the vaccinated and unvaccinated populations. When that is done, inevitably it is found that the risk of getting measles is much lower if you’ve been vaccinated. I’ve seen them play this game every time there is a measles outbreak, dating back to my earliest days as a blogger.
Nevradakis’ final ploy involves—you guessed it!—waning immunity:
A 2007 CDC study concluded that the immunity provided by the MMR vaccine wanes over time. The study found that 35% of vaccinated 7-year-olds, 60% of vaccinated 15-year-olds and approximately 66% of vaccinated adults can carry measles and infect others even if they don’t have symptoms.
Ohio Advocates for Medical Freedom addressed the MMR vaccine’s waning protection in its letter, stating that it’s “absurd to discriminate against healthy unvaccinated children when more than 60% of the teachers are able to carry and spread measles to students.”
The study cited above showed nothing of the sort. (Read it for yourself if you don’t believe me. I wondered if someone had inserted the wrong link when I read the study.) It was strictly a seroprevalence study that looked at waning antibody levels over time after vaccination, using a cohort of children who received the second measles vaccine dose at kindergarten (aged 4-6 years) or middle school (aged 10-12 years) in 1994 or 1995. Serum samples were collected periodically during a 10-year period for the kindergarten group and a 5-year period for the middle school group. The authors did note that low measles antibody titers (<120 mIU/mL) did represent that a “threshold of potential susceptibility used in our study has been used in previous studies modeling projections of vaccine-induced immunity in the absence of wild-type measles boosting.” However, they did not look at whether these levels indicated that vaccinees could have asymptomatic cases that infect others. The “waning immunity” examined during the study was no more than waning antibody levels, and the investigators noted:
A rise in the proportion of persons with low antibody levels suggests an increase in potential susceptibility, but low titers are unlikely to represent the same risk of illness or viral transmission as absent antibodies.28,37–39 In our study, none of the children with low titers had positive or even indeterminate IgM responses to MMR2, in contrast to the majority of those with negative titers, suggesting that those with low titers may generate an anamnestic response to wild-type virus, consistent with previous studies.37–39 If ongoing viral transmission requires that a substantial portion of the population be antibody-negative, our data suggest that such a situation may be several decades away. Furthermore, as demonstrated by Ward et al37 and Gans et al,40,41 cell-mediated immunity plays an important role in resistance to measles infection, an issue we did not address. This is an area in which large-scale prospective studies are needed to provide reliable and quantifiable population-based indicators of cell-mediated protection from measles disease. Such studies would assist clinicians and public health policymakers to determine the relative importance of measles-specific T cells to protection as they encounter an expanding number of persons with low, indeterminate, or undetectable measles antibody levels.
In other words, low antibody titers alone might not indicate susceptibility, due to cell-mediated “memory” immune responses. It is known that antibody titer decline doesn’t map cleanly onto loss of clinical protection against measles infection, because immunity to measles involves memory B- and T-cells that can still mount a rapid anamnestic response even after circulating antibody levels fall, possibly even to below levels that are considered protective. Not that that stops CHD and Ohio AMF from citing this study as slam-dunk evidence that 60% of teachers are susceptible to asymptomatic cases of measles. Of course, if that were the case, one would expect a lot of teachers to become infected and even clinically ill during outbreaks, and we just don’t see that happening.
But won’t you think of the children?
Thus far, the antivax complaints about the Ohio policy boil down to false claims that the vaccine doesn’t work, that it causes vaccine “injury,” and that excluding unvaccinated children from school during outbreaks is tyrannical and fascistic. As if that weren’t bad enough, won’t someone think of the children excluded from school for a whopping three weeks?
Enter Nevradakis again:
According to CHD Advocacy Director Michael Kane, evidence shows that excluding children from school can lead to their being “branded and scarred as being different and being removed.”
School districts and state health boards haven’t conducted studies on the potential harms of their exclusion policies. However, statistics suggest such policies may be connected to an increased rate of youth suicides in the U.S. in recent years.
Data from the Washington State Department of Children, Youth & Families show a sharp increase in youth suicides during the COVID-19 pandemic.
In Nevada, the Clark County School District, which includes Las Vegas and is the fifth largest district in the U.S., reopened schools to in-person learning in January 2021, after 18 students had committed suicide since the beginning of the pandemic. That was double the number recorded in the district for all of 2019.
Can you say “apples and oranges”? Sure, I knew you could. There’s a difference between a short term exclusion from school and switch to remote learning and what happened during the pandemic, when schools were closed for months on end before finally reopening. I have relatives who had school-age children at the time who experienced this firsthand, and it was not easy. It was also very different from what CHD and Ohio AMF are ranting about in that it applied to all children and nothing the parents did could change that. In contrast, in this case, parents who decide not to vaccinate their children should be aware that there are potential consequences if there are outbreaks of vaccine-preventable disease.
Everything old is new again… or is it?
Those who haven’t followed the vagaries of antivax rhetoric and politics might be shocked to have encountered an example of antivaxxers opposing a rather common-sense, science-based policy to help to control outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases by excluding unvaccinated children from school after a case of measles is identified at their school. I thought I’d conclude by pointing out that there is nothing new here. Unfortunately, Michigan antivaxxers tried to pave the way, starting over a decade ago. For example, in 2015, antivaxxers in Michigan tried to pass HB 5126 and 5127, bills that would have stripped local health departments of their power to exclude unvaccinated children from school during outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases. Hell, it would also have stripped local health authorities of the power to exclude children with vaccine-preventable diseases from attending school and rescinded the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services rule that requires parents seeking nonmedical exemptions to school vaccine mandates to attend an educational session at their county health department. I kid you not. Fortunately, it did not pass. Not that Michigan antivaxxers aren’t persistent. After the election of Donald Trump, in 2017 they tried once more to make measles great again.
Before I conclude, I can’t resist revisiting an experience I had in 2018 during the primary election season when I attended a “vaccine choice roundtable” hosted by the local district Republican Party. I went incognito, of course, because I was fairly well known—by name, at least—among the local antivax community. Fortunately, not many of them knew what I looked like, which allowed me to observe the proceedings as the proverbial “fly on the wall.” There were, of course, many lamentations and complaints about vaccines expressed by the panelists, but one of the complaints by antivaxxers that riled the crowd up the most was the complaint about the power of state and county public health departments to exclude unvaccinated children from school during the outbreak of vaccine-preventable disease. Multiple times, antivaxxers expressed outrage that unvaccinated children are excluded from school if there’s even a single case of measles there, while children with hepatitis B and HIV are not. There was a real sense of misunderstanding of the rationale for why unvaccinated children are excluded from school, namely because they are susceptible to the disease, while children with HIV and hepatitis B generally do not pose a danger to other children. There was also a serious sense of entitlement and a view that the health of other people’s children is none of their concern.
Unfortunately, these attitudes are nothing new. I’ve been dealing with them for many years now. Consequently, nothing that is being done in Ohio or other states to eliminate the power of public health officials to exclude susceptible children from school during an outbreak of vaccine-preventable disease is new. It’s just that the antivaxxers are emboldened to push for policies that, in Michigan at least, were always rejected, even by Republican administrations. It’s also, unfortunately, a time when politics are such that antivaxxers might succeed in a number of states.

Miscellany of Medical Malarkey Part 6
The Ohio measles outbreak is (hopefully) winding down. Vaccine rates among American Kindergartners are dropping. A new cure for sickle cell disease might not reach everyone who needs it. All that, and acupuncture for deadly infections? It appears that the miscellany of medical malarkey has returned again once more!
Clay Jones on January 20, 2023
Link

The last one came out years ago and he moved on, you think to yourself as a chill runs down your spine. You know there is no way he would dust that old concept off after all this time. Then why the sudden and overwhelming sense of dread? Why the cold sweat?
Trust your instincts.
Through a combination of dark magic and poor time management skills, it has been resurrected. In fact, it’s shambling towards you at this very moment. It’s right around the corner, just out of frame. Can you hear it now? Can you smell the rot?
Screaming won’t help. There is no escape. Just accept your fate and keep reading.
That’s right. Here we are today with another collection of odds and ends from both within and beyond the world of science-based medicine, where despite our best efforts there exist alternative realities in the darkness of shadows yet to be illuminated by science and reason. Behold…a miscellany of medical malarkey is upon you!
The Ohio Measles Outbreaks 
Last month, I discussed a measles outbreak in central Ohio:
Since late October, more than 70 children have been diagnosed with measles and 26 of them have been sick enough to require hospitalizations. Remember, despite it’s often bland portrayal in sitcoms and cartoons of the past, something that has been wielded as an anti-vaccine talking point, measles is a terrible illness that historically put 25% of infected kids in the hospital and killed 1-2 per 1000.
37% of the infected children in the current Ohio outbreak have been hospitalized so far, which underscores the fact that we don’t have effective treatments. There is no modern medical anti-viral triumph that cures this disease. There is supportive care and correcting vitamin A deficiency, which has been linked to increased risk of death. The modern medical triumph was the vaccine.
As of a week ago, this total has risen to 85 children with 8 additional hospitalizations. 40% of the involved children were sick enough to be put in the hospital, which continues to outpace historical percentages. There hasn’t been a death associated with this outbreak, but as I’ve discussed in the past that doesn’t mean that these kids aren’t at risk of serious or even deadly complications in the future.
While this outbreak has largely involved the unvaccinated, 24 of the cases were in children who were too young to have gotten their first dose. This is important to point out because one (of many) garbage talking point spouted by those proselytizing anti-vaccine beliefs is that the vaccinated shouldn’t care about people who refuse immunizations if they believe they work. This is obviously wrong because it ignores the need for herd immunity to protect those who cannot receive immunizations or who remain unprotected despite their immunizations, since no vaccine is 100% effective.
The last case of measles diagnosed in Ohio was on December 24th, which is promising. If they remain measles free through the first week of February, the outbreak will be officially over per CDC guidelines. Hopefully there will be a silver lining of increased vaccine rates among the hesitant in response. Of course, I would rather people respond to education and guidance from trusted medical professionals in the future rather than the acute fear of an impending infection.
Vaccine Rates Continue to Drop in U.S. Kindergartners
As reported last week, the official vaccine uptake numbers from 2021-2022 are in and the decrease seen in 2020-2021 continued:
Overall, those receiving state-required vaccinations declined to about 93% last year, down from 94% in the previous school year and 95% in the 2019-2020 school year, according to the CDC report.
The specific vaccines included in the CDC data were the MMR vaccine (93.5%), DTaP (diptheria, tetanus, pertussis, 93.1%), polio vaccine (93.5%), and varicella (chickenpox) vaccine (92.8%). I imagine for many folks 93% seems like a pretty good number, and it would be for Mrs. Peebles’ Biology II class. Unfortunately, for highly infectious diseases like measles we really need to be a bit closer to 100% in order to maintain herd immunity and protect vulnerable people, particularly those who are at high risk of severe disease.
When it comes to vaccine rates, there is significant variation between and within states, largely because of because of the three Ps of healthcare disparity: politics, poverty, and prejudice. Sticking with measles, for example, New York was a clear winner with an MMR vaccination rate of 98%. Great job, you coastal liberal elites. Rhode Island came in second with just over 97%. Let’s all raise a coffee milk toast to all those anti-virus Ocean Staters.
On the other end of the data are states like Alaska (78%), Wisconsin (82.6%), and Georgia (83%). Overall, only 13 of the 49 (what’s your deal, Montana?) states included in the data met the CDC goal of 95% of eligible kindergartners having received both doses of the MMR vaccine. So is most states, and almost certainly even in parts of the others, there are communities that are fully primed for a major outbreak of this horrible disease.
Because of limitations in how this data was collected, the numbers could be even worse in reality. For example, it didn’t catch home schooled kids. This data doesn’t tell us why the numbers have continued to slip, but I doubt anyone would deny the complex and multifactorial nature of the problem. When it comes to reversing the trend, the CDC recommends rigorous enforcement of school vaccine requirements, school-based vaccine clinics, school nurse follow-up with undervaccinated students, and reminder/recall systems.
A Costly New Sickle Cell Cure
It’s hard to imagine a more heart wrenching malady than sickle cell disease, a group of inherited genetic disorders that alter the shape of red blood cells and can cause a wide variety of health problems. This can include anemia, because the abnormal red blood cells have shorter life spans, but more infamously can result in severe pain throughout the body, strokes, an increased risk of severe bacterial infections, and a lifespan often shortened by decades. In addition to the physical manifestations, there are also significant psychological and social difficulties faced by patients with these conditions.
Because it mostly affects black people in the United States, there is a history of extreme disparity in the recognition, research, and response to sickle cell disease. I wrote and then erased several attempts to encapsulate this issue, but they all felt inadequate. I know the problems. I’ve seen the repercussions time and time again. Hell, as a white man who grew up in the South, and then practiced medicine down there for the first decade of my career, I know that there were times when I contributed to it.
I’ve learned so much in recent years by truly listening to people’s lived experiences, accepting that implicit bias saturates medicine, and, most importantly, recognizing my part in it. Patients with sickle cell disease have dealt with the worst of this bias in medicine. This NEJM “Perspective” from 2020, written by actual experts in the care of these patients, does a much better job of explaining it than I ever could:
Medicine is a mirror for the racial injustice in our society; it is a field riddled with racial disparities in everything from research funding to patient care to life expectancy.1-3 There may be no population of patients whose health care and outcomes are more affected by racism than those with sickle cell disease (SCD). Patients with SCD are too often marginalized and dismissed while seeking medical care when their bodies hurt and they cannot breathe. As medical leaders around the United States issue statements denouncing racial injustice and calling for us to “dismantle racism at every level,”4 we must ensure that these pledges translate into durable improvements for patients with SCD.
Today, I can happily report that there are some significant improvements for patients with sickle cell disease right around the corner:
This year, Jackson and other people with sickle cell may have the option of finally living without the damage it causes. Two drug companies are seeking approval from the Food and Drug Administration for gene therapies that may provide what amounts to a cure. But the decision to take the medication — should it become available — is not so simple, it turns out.
This potential but very promising cure has, in clinical trials, halted the process that leads to the many varied complications of sickle cell disease. The red blood cells produced in the bone marrow do not become misshapen. In addition to prevention of the severe pain caused by the condition, these treatments could save billions of dollars in medical costs if all patients who might benefit gain access to them. Sadly, but not unexpectedly, many of them won’t.
First off, the expense will be a huge problem as the modified virus used to deliver the gene therapy will run upwards of a million dollars per treatment. Insurance might cover that, because the average lifetime cost of treating sickle cell disease is almost twice that. But there are other factors that would add to the cost in dollars or even lives:
Treatment starts with intense chemotherapy in a hospital to wipe the bone marrow clean, leaving space for genetically modified red blood cells that result from the treatment. Patients then spend about a month in the hospital waiting for the modified cells to grow. After they are discharged, the patients are immunocompromised for about six months while their immune systems recover.
Insurers are likely to pay for the part of the treatment that involves using a disabled virus to deliver the therapy. But whether they will pay for most of the chemotherapy, hospitalization and other costs is uncertain. Patients worry about bills from hospitals and doctors. Even if it is mostly covered, co-payments can be an issue.
In addition to the overall cost of these new therapies potentially preventing patients from accessing them, many won’t be able to for medical reasons. Bone marrow transplant is already an existing and potentially curative intervention for sickle cell disease, but it has been limited because few patients have a matched donor available. It is also only indicated for patients with severe disease, in particular recurrent strokes, meaning that many don’t qualify despite having significant and frequent disruptions in their quality of life, multiple hospitalizations, severe pain, and shorter lives. And when they do qualify, bone marrow transplant has significant potential risk and about 5% die because of complications.
The process that allows these new gene therapies to work, the ablation of a patient’s bone marrow in order to start with a clean slate, is the same as with bone marrow transplant. Similarly they will be at risk of life threatening infections for months. Though the issue of finding a matched donor would no longer be a concern, I imagine that the criteria for deciding who qualifies for gene therapy would be the same. Finally, many older patients will be too medically fragile to even consider taking the risk of ablative chemotherapy.
Oh, and this:
And, independent of the cost, how easy will it be for patients and family members who assist them to take off a month or more for the treatment, often traveling to distant cities with medical centers that can administer the treatment?
And finally…I can’t even with this crap
Acupuncture for sepsis. Maybe so, according to a systematic review and meta-analysis that was published last May in Acupuncture in Medicine:
The available evidence showed that combination of acupuncture and routine therapy may have benefit for sepsis compared with use of routine therapy only. Due to the low degree of certainty regarding its effects, further research is required.
I suspect that the routine therapy was doing most of the heavy lifting in those cases, but perhaps I’m just biased. I should keep an open mind. Although, there has been a long and sordid history of people thinking things work for sepsis, sometimes for years, that end up being useless or even harmful. Xigris, I’m looking in your direction. And you aren’t off the hook either, vitamin C. But maybe the little needles are the ticket. Maybe they just need to be electrified.
See you next time!

   Mumps
Mark Crislip
Link
I write this post with a great deal of trepidation. The last time I perused the Medical Voices website I found nine questions that needed answering. So I answered them. One of the consequences of that blog entry was the promise that Medical Voices was poised to “tear my arguments to shreds.” Tear to shreds! Such a painful metaphor.
They specified that the shred tearing would be accomplished during a live debate, rather than a written response. While Dr. Gorski gave excellent reasons why such a debate is counterproductive, I am disinclined for more practical reasons. I am a slow thinker and a lousy debater and have never, ever, won a debate at home. If I cannot win pitted against my wife, what chance would I have against the combined might of the doctors and scientists at Medical Voices? My fragile psyche could not withstand the onslaught.
Still, there is much iron pyrite to be mined at Medical Voices and it may provide me for at least a years worth of entries. Please forgive me if I seem nervous or distracted. I have a Sword of Damocles hanging over my head and it may fall at any time. My writings may, without warning, be torn to pieces by the razor sharp logical sword of Medical Voices. Or maybe not. It is my understanding that Medical Voices will only answer with a debate, so maybe I am safe from total ego destruction.
This month, as I perused Medical Voices, I found it difficult to choose an article. So much opportunity and I have limited time to write. I finally decided on Why the New Mumps Outbreak Puts You At Risk by Robert J. Rowen, MD.
Mumps is a timely topic as, along with measles, it has returned thanks to the work of Dr. Wakefield. His fabrication of data to falsely suggest MMR causes autism has lead to a decrease in MMR use. In some areas of England 15% of the children were not vaccinated, levels that allow the virus to perpetuate in the community. The second ‘M’ in the MMR stands for mumps. While the measles outbreak has been getting all the press, England has been plagued with mumps as well, with over 3000 reported cases. Dr. Wakefield can be credited with over 5000 (mumps plus measles) sick children. I wonder how he can look at himself in the mirror.
Last year an 11-year-old child visited England. He was not vaccinated for religious reasons and, in addition to wonderful memories of a trip overseas, he brought home mumps. There have been over 1500 cases in New York and New Jersey as a result. Most of the disease has circulated in the unvaccinated religious community, but there have been cases in adjacent communities as well. Most of the cases of mumps in the non-religious have been in individuals that have received the MMR, although the cases in the community have been isolated while the disease is persisting in the unvaccinated religious community.
This is being touted as a failure of the MMR and an indictment of vaccination in general. What you should have instead is the real disease, get real immunity, and never worry about mumps again — or so argues Dr. Rowen.
Does real infection give better immunity? Maybe. What happened in olden times is kids would get mumps and develop antibodies to the infection. Then, since mumps was constantly circulating, they would be intermittently re-exposed to the virus and the immune system would get a nudge and produce more antibody. Constant exposure kept the antibody levels high. Natural infection may, with some infections, lead to higher antibody levels and a more sustained response, at a cost of the morbidity and mortality. Everything in medicine is a trade off.
Contrast with today: your only exposure to mumps is from the vaccine. Since you are not constantly re-exposed, your immune system has no reason to make antibody and antibody levels drift down over time. This is happening with chickenpox. Shingles is increasing in incidence in the elderly since people are no longer getting naturally boosted from re-exposure to chickenpox. As their antibodies wane over time, the chance of shingles goes up. Hence the need for the zoster vaccine booster in the elderly.
The recommendation to help abort the mumps outbreak is another dose of the MMR vaccine and the brisk response many kids have suggests an amnestic response: they have memory cells that recognize the mumps and respond to the vaccine antigens.
I think of the vaccine as a four-foot wall to keep out zombies. Maybe the odd zombie will jump the wall, but unlikely. Zombies are not typically coordinated enough. Getting the disease instead of the vaccine is building an eight-foot wall. It keeps out the zombies as well, but during the construction a few will fall off into the mouths of the waiting zombie hordes. Mumps is not without complications (orchitis and encephalitis being the most feared).
So with that as back ground, what does Robert J. Rowen have to say about mumps?
Did you have the mumps when you were a child? If so, it’s one of the best ways to avoid the mumps now that you’re older. If you didn’t have the mumps, you could be at serious risk for contracting the childhood disease — even if you’ve had the vaccine. As you may know, I’ve decried vaccines for decades. Why? They’re toxic (they inject poisonous additives into you), they deny children their needed usual infections to develop a robust immune system, and now there’s a third reason. Vaccines may not last a lifetime. And if they don’t, you could contract the disease as an adult. Think it won’t happen? Think again.
The “toxin gambit” has been covered at length on this blog. However, the immune system does not need ‘usual’ infections to build a robust immune system. As I have mentioned in the past, the immune system is not like a bicep that gets bigger and stronger as you use it. There are over 1300 common pathogens that can infect us and uncountable non-pathogens we can be exposed to. We get enough infections in life — the vaccine preventable illnesses are a drop in the infectious bucket and can be avoided with no detriment to immune function.
I have to admit, as an infectious disease specialist who only gets paid to take care of infections, I do like I doc who seems to be in favor of children getting mumps, measles, influenza, tetanus, pneumococcus, Haemophilus, hepatitis B, rubella, hepatitis A, polio, diphtheria, pertussis and meningococcus.
No one has ever suggested that the mumps vaccine is perfect or that the efficacy lasts forever.
The effectiveness of the mumps component of the MMR vaccine is lower than that of the measles and rubella components. Estimates of the effectiveness of the mumps vaccine have varied in previous studies, ranging from 73% to 91% after 1 dose and from 79% to 95% after 2 doses.
It is well known that antibody levels slowly decline over time but that patients will have a brisk increase in their antibodies if they get a booster dose. Natural infection may give a longer lived antibody response but not without the complications from the diseases.
Is this ignorance of the data or willful misrepresentation of the data? I hope the former, but I suspect the latter.
Last week, at least 1,521 people in New York and New Jersey developed mumps. About 85% of the victims had the usual two doses of the MMR vaccine. What have they gotten for it? So far, 55 cases of swollen and painful testicles, five cases of pancreatitis, two cases of meningitis, one case of temporary deafness, one case of Bell’s palsy, and one case of inflamed ovaries.
That is what you get from the natural mumps? Ouch. That is the trade off. Vaccines prevent disease with almost no morbidity or mortality but immunity may fade with time and, if herd immunity is not maintained, disease can spread.
Mumps is a relatively benign disease in kids. It is far more problematic in adults. One fear is damaged testicles leading to sterility, which is probably an overblown risk (and something most men over 65 don’t worry about too much). The other complications mentioned above are also well known.
According to the CDC, “The median age of patients is 15 years (range 3 months–90 years) and is similar in all areas with ongoing transmission except New Jersey, where the median age is 17 years. Sound like kids to me.
What is the risk? “Orchitis is the most common complication of mumps in post-pubertal men, affecting about 20%-30% of cases: 10%-30% are bilateral. Orchitis usually occurs 1-2 weeks after parotitis. Of affected testicles, 30%-50 % show a degree of testicular atrophy.”
And he fails to mention encephalitis. That is the horrible complication of mumps. It’s rare, but awful to have a child brain damaged by a preventable illness. In Finland:
The incidence of encephalitis was 8.3/100,000 child-years (range 19.8 in 1974 to 2.5 in 1985 and 1986). The organisms most commonly associated with encephalitis in children were mumps, measles, and varicella viruses, and Mycoplasma pneumoniae. After the start of the nationwide measles, parotitis, and rubella (MPR) vaccination programme in 1982 in Finland, encephalitides associated with these viruses seem to have totally vanished.
Totally vanished. No brain damaged kids from mumps or measles. If the low vaccination rates become the norm, maybe we will see mumps encephalitis again. I bet some anti-vaxers will say the brain damage was not from the infection but that it was from shaking the child.
Of course, the pundits’ reaction is to recommend a third vaccine. This will raise the risk of immune reactions. And it will fill you with toxic substances.
Half a CC of vaccine will fill you with toxins. Yet another person I do not want to be my bartender. I would order a pint and get drop of ale and be told the glass was full to the rim.
But why would you want a third vaccine? Vaccines may not give life-long immunity, as does the wild virus. Furthermore, lifelong immunity might be fostered by repeated exposure to the wild virus circulating every few years and giving your immune system a memory boost. With the wild virus largely removed, large swaths of the population might lose immunity over time and when re-exposed, develop disease or at least become spreading carriers.
I would get a third dose of vaccine to avoid mumps and all its complications. He evidently is advocating for the return to the 1800’s when everyone got mumps and a few died or had permanent severe neurological complications compared to a well vaccinated population where no one gets mumps or its complications. Odd advice. Of course he fails to mention that when vaccine rates were high, mumps was almost non-existent. I have seen one case in 25 years of practice, and that was last year. The solution to mumps is not to let it circulate freely in human populations, the solution is to go all smallpox on its butt and eradicate it with vaccinations.
Please note it is not the vaccinated who are the “spreading carriers” in the current outbreak, it is the unvaccinated population.
If you or a loved one does get mumps, measles, or even chicken pox, I recommend an immediate ozone treatment, ultraviolet blood irradiation therapy, or a high-dose vitamin C IV. It sure worked for the few cases of mumps I saw in Alaska.
Huh? I have never heard to the first two interventions.
What is blood irradiation therapy? Take 6 oz of blood, irradiate it with ultraviolet light and reinject it into the patient. Infections will go away in hours to minutes. In the pre-antibiotic era it was 50% effective in comatose patients (those about to die) and 98 to 100% effective in less severe infections. It is equally effective for viruses, bacteria and even Tb.
Ozone therapy is the slow infusion hydrogen peroxide with similar benefits and no side effects in thousands of patients treated with the modality in the 1940’s.
I am not making this up; it is not an attempt at over-the-top humor. It is what Robert J. Rowen says on You Tube.
He also says that the therapy works in part by killing the bacteria or virus in the blood and then reinjecting it into the body where the immune system will have a much more brisk response to the dead bacteria. He calls it an autovaccine. Really. This from the man who has “decried vaccines for decades.” I guess it depends on what the meaning of vaccine is.
I’ve said before, please know where your closest oxidative physician is. If you are exposed to a childhood disease and become symptomatic, oxidation or high dose IV vitamin C could bring a quick resolution without complications. I am against vaccination. I would much rather treat an acute infection than the awful complications of vaccines. This includes the flu vaccine.
Treat self-limited diseases with rare complications and you will always have good results. All the complications mentioned in the essay are from mumps and not the vaccine, yet he concludes that it is the vaccines that have the side effects and should be avoided and you should embrace natural mumps, or influenza, and risk all the complications. Another Bizarro world essay from Medical Voices.
Man. Am I ever going to be torn to shreds with this one. Maybe next time I will write on a safer topic.

The 2014 Ohio Mumps Outbreak
Clay Jones on April 25, 2014
Link
As I write this post, a large outbreak of mumps is ongoing in Columbus, Ohio. The city, which on average sees a single case each year, has seen over 250 since February. To put things in further perspective, only about 440 cases are normally diagnosed in the entire United States annually. The outbreak began on the campus of Ohio State University, where about 150 cases have been identified, but no information about the index case has been reported thus far.
Although the current outbreak will likely smolder for months, the total number of cases thus far is considerably fewer than the worst of the past decade. A 2009-2010 outbreak in New York and New Jersey ended up affecting about 3,000 people. In 2006, about 6,500 college students throughout the Midwest were infected. It is unlikely we will see these kinds of numbers in Ohio, but even our worst in recent years pale in comparison to those that have occurred in England over the past decade, where there was a peak of about 56,000 documented cases in 2005.
The diagnosis of only a few hundred cases per year is a clear victory of the mumps vaccination program, which started in 1967. Prior to the widespread adoption of the vaccine, 186,000 cases were seen in the United States annually. That works out to a decrease in cases of over 99%. This reduction didn’t occur because of improved sanitation, cleaner water, or even sunspots. It occurred because of the hard work and dedication of vaccine researchers, medical professionals and the widespread public acceptance of a safe and effective vaccine.
Mumps doesn’t get the kind of press that measles outbreaks do. There are a number of reasons why this is true and reasonable. I will get into more detail, but essentially mumps, although it can result in significant morbidity, just isn’t as sexy and it isn’t a good candidate for anti-anti-vaccine poster child. Measles wins in that regard, and let’s hope it stays that way. I am terrified at the thought of HiB meningitis returning. But that doesn’t mean that mumps outbreaks can’t serve as fodder for educating the public on vaccines. First though, a primer on mumps.
What is mumps?
Mumps, like measles, is a viral infection for which humans are the only natural host. The single-stranded RNA mumps virus is, also like measles, a member of the Paramyxovirus family of viruses, which is quite an interesting group. This family of viruses also includes respiratory syncitial virus (RSV), which is the major cause of respiratory infection in young children and the most common illness leading to hospitalization in kids under 2 years of age. Croup, another classic pediatric illness, is also caused by a Paramyxovirus, as is canine distemper virus and a morbillivirus that infects dolphins.
Historically, young school-age children were the most likely to be diagnosed, but that changed after vaccination efforts took hold. Over time, an evolution in the epidemiology occurred. After the mumps vaccine was in widespread use, initially the bulk of cases were diagnosed in unimmunized children and adolescents, with 1 out of 10 cases being seen in adults who were born prior to the vaccine becoming available or mandatory for school entry. This led to the current recommendations of a dose of MMR (measles-mumps-rubella) at 12 to 15 months and again at 4 to 6 years of age, as well as documentation of vaccination for college students, although that is only required in 25 states.
As mentioned above, there have been several outbreaks in recent years. Although there have been instances where pockets of children who were not vaccinated have become ill, the majority of cases these days occur in the partially- and even fully-immunized. The most important factor in these outbreaks has been close proximity. Schools, camps and military posts have all been the site of case clusters.
Patients, while still predominantly young, now skew a bit older, in part because of being crammed together in dorms, for instance, but also because of shortcomings in the available vaccine. While the measles component of the MMR is upwards of 99% effective after two doses, the mumps counterpart is only about 80 to 90% effective. So mumps outbreaks, although rendered infrequent and less severe by our vaccine strategy, will likely continue to occur.
Anyone who is susceptible, whether immunized or not and regardless of age, can become ill when exposed to the virus. The mumps virus is very infectious and easily moves from one susceptible person to another, particularly if they are living in close quarters. The virus is spread suspended in respiratory droplets but can also be transferred by direct contact with an infected person or with a virus-carrying fomite. Once infected, the virus usually builds up for a couple of weeks before causing symptoms, but it can be shed in secretions for a few days before the first sign of illness and for several days after.
What does mumps do?
In many people infected with mumps, there are no apparent symptoms. As many as 15 to 20% will be completely asymptomatic in fact. And we think that roughly half of those infected will only have nonspecific respiratory complaints that are indistinguishable from the common cold. Although likely not to the same degree as those with more classic mumps, these lucky individuals still are capable of spreading the infection.
Classic mumps typically also involves some initial nonspecific symptoms, including mild fever, loss of energy and appetite and generalized body aches. What happens next in about 95% of patients is what makes mumps so recognizable to the public. Within a couple of days of the onset of symptoms, both parotid glands (in most cases although not always at the same time) become inflamed, swollen and very tender. This often causes the angle of the jaw to be completely hidden by the swollen tissue and it can last up to 10 days. The one case of mumps I’ve seen, which I diagnosed during a small outbreak in Louisiana in 2010, fit this description.
Although the classic presentation is uncomfortable for patients, it isn’t deadly and there are no long-term problems that result. Unfortunately, mumps is known to cause more serious complications in other areas of the body. Orchitis, inflammation of the testicles, is the most common of these when the patient is a postpubertal male, occurring in about a third of patients. This can result in testicular atrophy and impaired fertility. Sterility is rare but can occur when both testes are involved. A similar phenomenon, oophoritis or inflammation of the ovaries, can occur in postpubertal women although it is much less common.
The most common complication of mumps after involvement of the parotid glands, however, is meningitis. Luckily, it is often mild, perhaps only causing headache, but it can be more significant in 4-6% of cases. The prognosis is excellent with full neurologic recovery expected. Mumps can also cause encephalitis, which is widespread inflammation of the brain itself rather than just the outer covering as with meningitis. Before the vaccine, mumps encephalitis was the most common viral cause of the condition, occurring in about 1 out of every 6,000 cases. Mumps encephalitis causes fever and changes in mental status (by definition), and can result in seizures, weakness and even transient paralysis. Like viral meningitis, recovery tends to be complete.
Prior to the mumps vaccine, many children suffered hearing loss because of the infection. It typically only involved one ear, and the degree of hearing loss was variable. But cases of permanent bilateral deafness were known to happen.
There are more associated complications, such as Guillain-Barre syndrome and facial palsy. There have also been reports of arthritis, pancreatitis and even fatal inflammation of the heart, but these are considered to be rare. One very good bit of news is that mumps, as opposed to rubella (also included in the MMR vaccine) is not associated with birth defects when a pregnant woman is infected. Congenital rubella is an awful syndrome, much worse than mumps and even measles, and has become extremely rare because of the vaccine.
What do we do about mumps?
There is no specific treatment for mumps. The general approach is to reduce symptoms with medicines for fever, if the patient is uncomfortable, pain and inflammation. Often this can be accomplished with the same medicine, ibuprofen being a good choice. Some patients find the use of warm and/or cold packs helpful in dealing with a tender and swollen parotid gland. Ice, and elevation of the swollen scrotum, along with ibuprofen, can ease symptoms of patients with orchitis.
Hospitalization is rarely necessary, but may be warranted in cases of meningitis, encephalitis, or pancreatitis. The case I admitted back in 2010 was initially misdiagnosed in the emergency department as having a bacterial infection of the parotid gland, something which would be extremely rare in a child. But then again, so is mumps. And we weren’t aware of the small cluster of cases at the time.
The most important aspect of managing mumps is preventing spread to others. Isolation is often recommended for up to 5 days after onset of symptoms. Vaccination of susceptible individuals exposed to a patient with mumps is also recommended, although to date there are no studies supporting its efficacy in preventing symptoms from that exposure. The goal of this CDC recommendation is primarily to prevent infection from a new exposure during a current outbreak or from one in the future.
What the CDC Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) considers to be an adequate immunization status changed after the 2006 outbreak. Instead of one dose of MMR for children in kindergarten through 12th grade being considered adequate, they now require two. This is also true for high-risk adults, which includes those who work in healthcare facilities, travelers to mumps-endemic regions and college students. During an outbreak, they recommend giving a 2nd dose early to children aged 1 to 4 years and all adults. There is some evidence from the 2009 outbreak to support that offering a third dose might be helpful in decreasing spread of the infection, although this has yet to be replicated.
So why all the mumps?
The vaccine for mumps is a component of the MMR (technically also the MMRV, which includes varicella), the same MMR that has been the focus of controversy manufactured by a vocal minority of anti-vaccine celebrities, politicians and pseudoskeptical researchers over the past several years. The anti-vaccine movement, particularly in the UK, is clearly linked to an increase in vaccine-preventable illnesses and many experts are worried that we haven’t seen the worst yet. This has been covered extensively on Science-Based Medicine in the past.
The mumps component of the MMR, just like the measles vaccine, contains a weakened but live virus that has been processed using animal cells. Since 1978, the Jeryl Lynn vaccine strains have been used to make all mumps vaccine in the United States. This combination of two strains was cultured from the throat of Jeryl Lynn Hilleman, daughter of mumps vaccine developer Maurice Hilleman, in 1963. Hilleman developed eight of the current vaccines in use and is credited as saving more lives than any other scientist in the 20th century, although Norman Borlaug fans may not agree.
Where the similarity between the mumps and measles vaccines ends is when we look at effectiveness. We know that the mumps vaccine works pretty well. There is simply no other explanation for the dramatic decreases in incidence after it came on the scene. But continued sporadic and sometimes significant outbreaks speak to the fact that we certainly wish it worked better. The measles vaccine, after two doses, results in roughly 99% of people being protected from disease if exposed. With mumps, even with two doses, that drops to somewhere around 85%, with a range of 60-90%. That difference is especially meaningful considering that even if there was 100% uptake of the vaccine, herd immunity for mumps kicks in when about 92% of the population is immune.
When studies have compared the percentage of individuals becoming infected after exposure in unvaccinated and vaccinated populations during actual outbreaks, the effectiveness of the vaccine hasn’t matched the results of clinical trials. Not that the benefit isn’t significant though. With two doses of MMR, only 2 to 4% were infected while a little more than a third of those having received zero doses became ill. It’s a good vaccine, but 4% of thousands can add up. And because most people are vaccinated, at least in the United States, so are most people infected with mumps.
Some outbreaks, the one is 2006 that involved the United States, Canada and the UK being the prime example, involved a serotype that differed from the one used in the MMR vaccine. Differences were found in immune response in vitro, although vaccine-induced antibodies obtained even from serum 11 years after vaccination still appeared to work against the outbreak strain. But researchers remain uncertain about differences of effectiveness in natural infections. Half the amount of neutralizing antibodies may be enough in vitro but not in the real world. The question of waning immunity has been raised as well. So far the evidence is mixed, and there does not appear to be much talk of adding a third dose during adolescence or early adulthood.
Conclusion
At one point, there was a goal of eradicating mumps in the United States by 2010. Sadly, this didn’t happen and probably can’t be accomplished given the less-than-ideal effectiveness of the vaccine currently available and the ease of bringing mumps back into the country after visiting areas with higher prevalence. Recent mumps outbreaks, unlike those involving measles infections, are not a result of vaccine refusal, although that certainly may change if the number of vaccinated people were to continue to decrease.
Mumps isn’t the worst of the vaccine-preventable illnesses by a wide margin. But it can cause significant morbidity, including deafness and impaired fertility, and the symptoms of classic mumps can be extremely uncomfortable even if they won’t kill you. The MMR vaccine is extremely safe and is pretty good at decreasing your risk of becoming infected if exposed. It’s even better at protecting you from measles and rubella. So there is just no excuse unless you have a true medical contraindication. And even if you become infected after vaccination, your illness may be less severe than it might have been otherwise.

England’s Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Year: Mumps and the “Wakefield Cohort”
It may not be the most worrisome virus out there these days, but England has just had its worst year of mumps infections in a decade thanks in large part to their “Wakefield cohort”.
Clay Jones on March 27, 2020
Link

Anti-vaccine propaganda, and the pseudoscience that sustains it, has been around as long as there have been vaccines. Rather than spreading fears of being turned into cows, or at least developing bovine diseases, modern day deniers are morel likely to invoke the findings of research performed by scientists and medical doctors with apparently legitimate credentials. This modern day anti-vaccine movement arguably entered a new and more effective phase with the publication of Andrew Wakefield’s infamous, fraudulent, and now retracted 1998 paper in The Lancet. Though thoroughly disproved by numerous studies since it’s publication, it played a huge role in establishing a link between the MMR vaccine and autism in the minds of a generation of parents.
This specter of a link between the MMR vaccine and autism has resulted in countless parents losing confidence in the safety of that vaccine, as well as the vaccine program in general. There was an immediate and significant spike in vaccine hesitancy and refusal, which caused major outbreaks of vaccine preventable illnesses across the world. The damage is ongoing, as Wakefield continues to find new victims.
Since the MMR scare began in England, there have been numerous outbreaks of measles across Europe and the rest of the world. The United States, as readers know all too well, has not gone unscathed. In England, the population of underimmunized children who were born in the years after Wakefield’s publication and the subsequent sensationalized reaction from the press, a so-called “Wakefield cohort”, are now entering college. Not surprisingly, cases of the mumps, the second “M” in the MMR vaccine, are beginning to spike again now that this cohort is clumped together in large classrooms and dorms.
According to Public Health England, there were over 5,000 mumps cases in 2019. This was up from just over 1,000 cases in 2018, and is the highest total in a decade. To give a little perspective to these numbers, which are bad enough, England documented about 50,000 total cases of mumps in 2004 and 2005.
The current spike doesn’t seem to be letting up just yet. In the first month of 2020, over 500 cases were identified. Most of the recent cases have occurred in individuals who were not immunized, which shouldn’t come as a surprise. That being said, the MMR vaccine is not as effective in conferring protection against mumps as it is against measles. Even with two doses, as recommended by the CDC, you only get up to about 85% chance of immunity. This is below what is needed for herd immunity, so even a best case scenario of 100% uptake would still allow small outbreaks to happen from time to time.
An outbreak of over 5,000 cases isn’t small and is clearly the result of insufficient vaccination rates. The NHS has initiated a campaign to catch kids up on their MMR vaccine, which is even more badly needed because of a surge in measles cases leading to the loss of their WHO “measles-free” status after only three years of receiving it. Obviously healthcare professionals in England are currently dealing with a much bigger issue in the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic, leaving me to worry that this problem isn’t going to be solved any time soon, and that there may be more outbreaks of mumps (and measles) as people shelter in place.
If you want more detail on what mumps is, how you catch it, and what it can do, check out my 2014 post on the subject. In a nutshell, mumps isn’t as serious or potentially life threatening as measles, but that doesn’t mean it’s a walk in the park. Besides the classic presentation of swollen and very tender parotid glands, mumps can cause inflammation of the brain, testes, and ovaries, as well as seizures and transient paralysis. Long term problems, such as permanent neurologic injury or sterility, are rare, but they do happen.
I truly hope that this post finds you all happy and healthy in such uncertain times. As a pediatrician, and because children tend to have milder COVID-19 presentations, I have thus far been spared. My day to day life as a hospitalist has changed a great deal, and the contingency plans that my hospital, and my colleagues, have had to develop are quite distressing. But it is best to be prepared for the worse case scenarios. If only certain governments had done the same. Well, good luck everyone!

MMR is Safe and Effective
A new systematic review shows convincingly that the MMR vaccine is safe and effective.
Steven Novella on May 6, 2020
Link

It is important to point out, and for everyone to remember, that the anti-vaccine movement is not just misguided, they are objectively wrong. It is especially important while they are gearing up to “prereject” any possible COVID-19 vaccine. One thing for which there is strong expert agreement regarding the pandemic is that we won’t really get it under control until we have an effective vaccine. But the effectiveness of that vaccine will depend largely on public acceptance, which makes antivaxxers a danger to the public health, and as we are seeing, the global economy.
A recently updated Cochrane systematic review of the safety and effectiveness of the MMR vaccine is a good time, therefore, to emphasize that antivaxxers have been wrong about the MMR vaccine for over two decades. They claim it doesn’t work, and that it isn’t safe. They tried to link it to autism (and when that failed they migrated over to the preservative thimerosal, and when that failed they just blamed the vaccine schedule and vaccines in general). They are persistently and demonstrably wrong, which of course never slowed down an ideologically motivated activist, and certainly not a conspiracy theorist.
This new review shows that the evidence for the safety and effectiveness of the MMR vaccine is overwhelming. The authors report:
We included 138 studies (23,480,668 participants). Fifty‐one studies (10,248,159 children) assessed vaccine effectiveness and 87 studies (13,232,509 children) assessed the association between vaccines and a variety of harms.
That is a lot of data – over 23 million participants. These include studies from around the world, by many independent researchers and organizations. That is a lot of replication.
Regarding effectiveness, we have to consider each component of this trivalent vaccine separately. Sometimes the research looked at the MMRV vaccine – mumps, measles, rubella, and varicella, so there is data on all four components. Regarding measles they report:
Vaccine effectiveness in preventing measles was 95% after one dose…and 96% after two doses. The effectiveness in preventing cases among household contacts or preventing transmission to others the children were in contact with after one dose was 81%…after two doses 85%…and after three doses was 96%.
(I removed the technical statistical details for readability, but you can get that from the original report.) So after all three doses of MMR, children were 96% protected from measles, and this also prevented 96% of spreading of the virus. This is important, and a main reason for the third dose. It also highlights the fact that these are two different things, preventing infection and preventing spread. There is a lot of discussion about antibodies in those with COVID-19, and it is important to remember that we still don’t know how effective those antibodies will be in preventing further spread vs illness.
The numbers for preventing illness were similar for the other components – mumps 86%, rubella 89%, and varicella 95%. Protection is long term, lasting years and perhaps for life, but the authors point out that we do need more data on the very long-term effects of the vaccine.
What about safety? There is evidence for an association between getting the vaccine and risk of febrile seizures, but this is small. Overall there is a 2-4% risk of healthy children getting a seizure with a fever before the age of 5. With the vaccine there is an extra case every 1,150-1,700 vaccinations, which is relatively small. They also report:
The analyses provide evidence supporting an association between MMR vaccination and idiopathic thrombocytopaenic purpura (ITP). However, the risk of ITP after vaccination is smaller than after natural infection with these viruses. Natural infection of ITP occur in 5 cases per 100,000 (1 case per 20,000) per year. The attributable risk is estimated about 1 case of ITP per 40,000 administered MMR doses.
This is also an important general point – yes there is risk with the vaccine, but the risk with getting infected is even higher. In the case of ITP getting infected with one of these diseases is twice as likely to be associated with ITP than the vaccine. This is a good demonstration of why you cannot only look at risk when it comes to any medical intervention. That is a classic mistake of anti-vaccine rhetoric. You must look at risk vs benefit.
Finally, the reviewers report that after more than 13 million children who received the MMR were followed, there was no association between the vaccine and autism, cognitive delay, encephalitis or encephalopathy. Does this prove a zero risk? No. No amount of data ever will. But it demonstrates convincingly that the risk, if not actually zero, is indistinguishable from zero. It is so small that it is in the background, less than a million to one, and not worth worrying about. Again, the risk from the diseases that the vaccine prevents must be greater by many orders of magnitude.
Bottom line – the MMR vaccine is safe and effective. The data clearly show this, and yet scientists continue to study and monitor this vaccine and gather more data. This is reassuring, but the antivaccine movement has proven immune to facts and reality. If someone insists on being so at odds with established medical facts, the best response is to marginalize them. This is no more true during a pandemic, but is more acute, and hopefully more obvious.

The Revenge of Chicken Pox
Another outbreak, this time chickenpox, can be blamed on antivaxxers.
Steven Novella on November 21, 2018
Link

Vaccines work. That is a very solid scientific conclusion based upon decades of evidence involving hundreds of millions of people. But no scientific conclusion is so rock solid that there aren’t those who will deny it. The human capacity for self-deception appears to be limitless.
But for those who are not already too far down the rabbit hole, who may just be poorly informed or misinformed, occasional reminders of what should be obvious are helpful. The thing about vaccines – if you refuse to use them based upon misinformation about their efficacy, or baseless fears about their safety, there will be a highly predictable result. Vaccines prevent communicable diseases, and where there are pockets of people refusing vaccines, those diseases will come back with a vengeance.
Just the latest episode is occurring in a private school in North Carolina, at the Asheville Waldorf School, which has a high rate of vaccine exemption (110 out of 152 students). The most recent reports puts the number of cases at 34.
The chicken pox vaccine became available in the US in 1995. According to the CDC:
Chickenpox used to be very common in the United States. In the early 1990s, an average of 4 million people got varicella, 10,500 to 13,000 were hospitalized (range, 8,000 to 18,000), and 100 to 150 died each year. In the 1990s, the highest rate of varicella was reported in preschool-aged children.
And:
Varicella incidence, based on national passive surveillance data published in 2012, declined 79% during 2000-2010 in 31 states that met CDC’s criteria for adequate and consistent reporting. From this same data source, incidence declined 72% during 2006-2010, after a routine second dose of varicella vaccine was recommended. Varicella incidence from 2 active surveillance sites declined 98% during 1995-2010.
This is similar to what has happened after the introduction of every major vaccination program – the incidence of the targeted disease plummeted. Antivaxxers argue, implausibly, that this is just a coincidence. The incidence was dropping anyway. Sometimes they improperly use death rates rather than incidence rates, the former reflecting the overall quality of health care and not just the spread of the disease.
But this claim is simply absurd. The correlation between the introduction of vaccines and the precipitous decline in disease incidence is overwhelming. Chickenpox is just the latest example.
Further – when you take the vaccine away, the disease comes back. We are increasingly seeing infectious disease outbreaks in areas with high vaccine refusal. Unvaccinated children tend to cluster in schools that are permissive about vaccine avoidance. They then create an environment in which an outbreak can occur. This, then, threatens the broader community, and frustrates efforts at elimination.
Even though the data is absolutely clear, antivaxxers are so dedicated to their narrative that facts don’t matter. That narrative, however, has to be criticized, exposed, and marginalized, because it is an active danger to the health of society.
I know this message is like a broken record on SBM, but that is part of what we do – serve as a persistent reminder that facts matter, science matters, and you ignore reality at your own peril – and in the case of vaccines, at society’s peril.
Have a Happy Thanksgiving.

Pox parties taken to the next (illegal) level
David Gorski on November 6, 2011
Link
Normally, we don’t post on weekends on this particular blog, mainly because most of our readership visits during the week and we don’t have enough bloggers to cover the weekend reliably anyway. However, occasionally something happens that’s so bizarre, so worrisom that we can’t wait until Monday. I don’t even care if I’m late to the party after Tara, Mike the Mad Biologist, The Biology Files, Todd, and probably several others whom I’ve missed.
Regular readers of this blog and anyone who’s ever followed the anti-vaccine movement more than superficially have probably heard of pox parties. These are, yes, parties where parents who don’t want to vaccinate their children against chickenpox, hoping for “natural immunity,” expose their children who have never had chickenpox to children with active chickenpox in order to intentionally infect them with the disease. (Thanks, Mom and Dad, for a couple of weeks worth of misery and intense itching and a small chance of serious complications!) Although there might have been a weak rationale for such activities back before there was a vaccine for chickenpox, today pox parties are about as dumb a concept as I can think of and only make sense in the context of equally idiotic anti-vaccine pseudoscience, and apparently, as is the case with many idiotic things, has co-opted Facebook and other discussion forums as a means of getting like minded (if you can call what is behind this a “mind”) together for purposes of inflicting misery on their children. One such page even has a Quack Miranda-style warning:
It is explicitly expressed that, regardless of the beliefs of the group moderator or its members, the group is not responsible for the outcome of the connections made. This group is not intended to give medical advice, speak as a medical authority, or cause children to contract any illness. Parents who do so on this board, do so at their own risk and without the advise or recommendation of the leadership of this group.
Which is, of course, a lie so obvious that one wonders why the moderators even bothered.
Some proudly display pictures of pox on children’s limbs. Others are even so proud of their “efforts,” that they proudly post pictures of them on their blogs, with captions such as “The little people enjoying each other, playing, and getting exposed” and “Although it sounds awful, we certainly hope the exposing worked!” I can only shake my head and respond that “it” doesn’t just “sound” awful. It is awful. True, major complications are fairly uncommon but they can be quite serious, with all of this being done in the name of being “natural” and avoiding those evil vaccines. It turns out that some parents, apparently having difficulty finding children with active chickenpox in their area (thanks to the aforementioned evil vaccine, no doubt), are mailing the virus to each other:
Doctors and medical experts are concerned about a new trend taking place on Facebook. Parents are trading live viruses through the mail in order to infect their children.
The Facebook group is called “Find a Pox Party in Your Area.” According to the group’s page, it is geared toward “parents who want their children to obtain natural immunity for the chicken pox.”
On the page, parents post where they live and ask if anyone with a child who has the chicken pox would be willing to send saliva, infected lollipops or clothing through the mail.
Parents also use the page to set up play dates with children who currently have chicken pox.
Medical experts say the most troubling part of this is parents are taking pathogens from complete strangers and deliberately infecting their children.
One concern is that they are sending the virus through the mail.
Here’s video of the local Arizona news report:
Again, I can’t begin to describe how reckless this is. It’s also highly illegal—a federal offense. I know of what I speak, because I personally have had to ship viruses and DNA plasmids through the mail. The reason was when I changed jobs about four years ago and was in the process of moving my laboratory to a new institution. I had a lot of adenoviral constructs. Varicella virus falls under the same sorts of rules as adenovirus. There are very specific rules for shipping. Tara explains quite nicely some of the requirements, among which is that there are very specific labeling requirements for the package to indicate what pathogens are inside. In fact, I found out the hard way just how rigorous and complex the labeling requirements were when a couple of the packages were returned because, as much as we tried to follow the letter of the regulations, we had somehow missed something in the labeling and paperwork. At that point I even briefly flirted with the idea of loading the samples up in my car and taking them myself when I hit the road to my new location. I quickly abandoned that notion, realizing that that, too, would be illegal and, worse, potentially dangerous. What if I got in a car crash along the way? So instead, we checked, double checked, and triple checked our packaging and paperwork and sent it again. This time, it went through, as we hadn’t missed any of the requirements.
As Mike the Mad Biologist points out, this is little different from bioterrorism, other than in intent. For one thing, the parents doing this seem utterly oblivious to the potential danger to the postal workers or workers at FedEx, UPS, or other shipping company that they use to send these biohazards. One also wonders if the parents use anything approaching proper technique to insert their “gifts” into the packages so that they don’t get it on their fingers and thus contaminate the outside of the package. In any case, should the package be damaged or should the baggy fail, so much for containment, and anyone who comes into contact with the package is at risk. That’s why there are so many federal regulations about shipping biohazardous substances across state lines. Indeed, when it was pointed out that shipping biohazards like bodily fluids from an individual infected with varicella across state lines is a federal offense, this was the reaction:
A Facebook post reads, “I got a Pox Package in mail just moments ago. I have two lollipops and a wet rag and spit.” Another woman warns, “This is a federal offense to intentionally mail a contagion.”
Another woman answers, “Tuck it inside a zip lock baggy and then put the baggy in the envelope 🙂 Don’t put anything identifying it as pox.”
The level of irresponsibility and lack of concern for fellow human beings is staggering. As Todd points out, it’s not just varicella that might be in there? How does anyone know that there aren’t other pathogens in there? They are utterly self-absorbed, selfish, and lack concern for anyone but themselves and their own family. Indeed, look at the interview with the first mother in the video; she openly discusses sending pox through the mail and doesn’t seem to think it’s a big deal, all the while rambling on about how it’s the parents’ “choice.” The second mother, when confronted by a reporter, out and out lies about what was on her Facebook page, denying that she ever sent pox through the mail. It’s a mindset that was perfectly described as a Me! Mine! Mommy mindset that boils down to, basically, the right to be selfish.
But it’s worse than that. Near the end of the report from the local CBS affiliate above, there is a post from a parent looking for measles, which is much more dangerous than chickenpox. Her reason? This:
Dad is threatening to take it to court and getting exposed is the only way not to get the vaccine without possibly losing custody.
If you want an example of how far the irrational fear of vaccines will drive some people, you have no further to look than this story. At the risk of being too “strident” or “nasty” or “uncivil,” I can say unequivocally that what they are doing is, in my opinion, child abuse and that I hope that the feds come down on them like a ton of bricks for violating federal law and endangering everyone who comes into contact with their little “pox packages.”

   Varicella Vaccination Program Success
Steven Novella
Link
One of the basic human “needs” is the desire for simplicity. We have limited cognitive resources, and when we feel overwhelmed by complexity one adaptive strategy is to simplify things in our mind. This can be useful as long as we know we are oversimplifying. Problems arise when we mistake our schematic version for reality.
In this same vein we also like our narratives to be morally simple, so there is a tendency to replace the complex shades of gray with black and white. This is perhaps related to cognitive dissonance theory. We have a hard time reconciling how someone can be both good and bad, or how a good person can do bad things. So there is also a tendency to see people as all good or all bad. We can transcend these tendencies with maturity and wisdom, but that takes work.
A good example of the desire for simple moral clarity is the anti-vaccine movement. Their world is comprised of white hats and black hats (guess which one they perceive themselves as wearing), as evidenced by the blog posts and comments over at Age of Autism. There is a certain demand for purity of thought and message that seems to be getting worse over time in a self-reinforcing subculture. Many now see their struggle in apocalyptic terms.
The desire for simplicity even extends to factual claims. They oppose vaccination, and so they tend to make every argument against vaccines possible – even arguing, against all the evidence, that vaccines do not work. If vaccines were effective but carried significant risks, that would cause a genuine dilemma (cognitive dissonance). But if vaccines are both ineffective and risky, there is no dilemma, the cognitive dissonance is resolved, and the brain is given a nice dose of dopamine as a reward.
This means that defenders of science-based medicine have to counter anti-vaccine propaganda stating that vaccines do not work. For example, the data on measles is overwhelmingly clear, but this has not stopped vaccine deniers from distorting the data to argue that measles just happened to decline all on its own. It’s a massive exercise in not seeing the forest for the trees. Deniers look for anomalies in the data (usually artifacts of data collection) and then use that to call the big picture into question. Or they confuse death rates with incidence rates (death rates can decline just by improvements in medical care – this does not mean that the spread of the disease was decreasing). Meanwhile the big picture is dramatically clear – vaccine introduction lines up nicely with plummeting disease incidence.
So forgive us if we take the time to point out when further evidence comes to light that vaccines are effective public health measures. A recent study published in Pediatrics reviews the evidence for the effect of the varicella (chicken pox) vaccine on varicella-related deaths. They found:
During the 12 years of the mostly 1-dose US varicella vaccination program, the annual average mortality rate for varicella listed as the underlying cause declined 88%, from 0.41 per million population in 1990–1994 to 0.05 per million population in 2005–2007. The decline occurred in all age groups, and there was an extremely high reduction among children and adolescents younger than 20 years (97%) and among subjects younger than 50 years overall (96%). In the last 6 years analyzed (2002–2007), a total of 3 deaths per age range were reported among children aged 1 to 4 and 5 to 9 years, compared with an annual average of 13 and 16 deaths, respectively, during the prevaccine years.
That’s an impressive decline, if the absolute numbers are low. But when you are talking about childhood deaths, any reduction is welcome. Although it was not covered in this study, other studies also have looked at varicella incidence and hospitalizations, also finding a dramatic decrease. For example:
The vaccination program reduced disease incidence by 57% to 90%, hospitalizations by 75% to 88%, deaths by >74%, and direct inpatient and outpatient medical expenditures by 74%.
All of this data is also with the single doses vaccine, which was found not to produce adequate antibody levels in some children. The current recommendation is for a second follow up dose to boost immunity levels. It is probable that the two-dose vaccine will produce even more impressive results.
And so as not to oversimplify the picture – the varicella vaccine did come with a possible unintended consequence. Previous generations were often exposed to chicken pox in children throughout their life, resulting in a natural immunity booster. With the near elimination of chicken pox due to the vaccine, older adults have waning immunity and this has possibly led to an increase in herpes zoster. Once infected with varicella the virus is never completely eliminated from the body. It goes dormant in the dorsal root ganglia (packets of sensory nerve cells just outside the spinal cord) and can be reactivated later in life. It’s possible that decreasing antibody levels in older adults who are no longer getting exposed to cases in children are allowing more cases of zoster to occur.
The data on this is currently mixed. Models predict an increase, but actual surveillance has produced unclear results. The worst case scenario is that the older generation will experience an increase in herpes zoster, but this will be a temporary effect as the next generation will never have had chicken pox due to the vaccine. There is also available a varicella zoster vaccine to reduce the risk of zoster in the at risk generation.
Conclusion
There is a large and growing body of scientific data from which we can draw a few very reliable conclusions. Vaccines work. The general concept is sound, and specific vaccines have clearly been effective in significantly reducing (and in two cases eliminating) infectious disease. They are not risk free, but the incidence of adverse events is orders of magnitude lower than the benefits of the available vaccines.
We need to continue active surveillance of vaccine safety and effectiveness, as well as tight regulation of vaccine manufacturing. Vaccines are an important public health intervention, and we need to watch the vaccine program closely.
Despite this, vaccine opponents have continued to argue that vaccines are not safe or effective. Thankfully the data is so clear that the public is largely ignoring them.

Should I Get the New Shingles Vaccine?
There are two vaccines to prevent shingles and post-herpetic neuralgia in patients age 50 and up. If you are wondering whether to get vaccinated and which vaccine to choose, here are the facts to help you make an informed decision.
Harriet Hall on May 1, 2018
Link
A large number of vaccines are recommended for children; not so many for adults. Lately a new shingles vaccine has been added to the schedule for adults over the age of 50. The first shingles vaccine, Zostavax, was released in 2006. Now the FDA has approved another vaccine, Shingrix. You may be wondering if you really need to be vaccinated and if so, which vaccine to choose. Here are the facts, so you can make an informed decision.
Shingles and post-herpetic neuralgia
Shingles, or herpes zoster, is a late consequence of chickenpox. After chickenpox infection or vaccination with a live attenuated virus, the patient develops immunity, but an inactive form of the varicella virus (VZV) can persist in nerve cells in the sensory ganglia and can be reactivated later in life when the immunity to VZV wanes. The reactivated virus travels down the nerve and causes painful blisters in the dermatome, the section of skin served by that nerve. A serious long-term complication of shingles is post-herpetic neuralgia (which can sometimes even develop in the absence of a shingles rash!). It typically lasts 1-2 months but one-fifth of cases last a year or longer. It can be very painful and can have complications like aseptic meningitis. There is no cure; the pain is treated with painkillers, anticonvulsants, steroids, topical remedies, and antidepressants, often in combination.
Shingles is not transmitted from person to person, but exposure to a patient with shingles can cause chickenpox in someone who has never had chickenpox or the chickenpox vaccine.
What are my chances of getting shingles or post-herpetic neuralgia?
The incidence of shingles is 4 cases per 1,000 people per year; for those 60 and older, the incidence rises to 10 cases per 1,000 people per year. 1-4% of people with herpes zoster get hospitalized for complications. The fatality rate is 0.28 to 0.69 per million population, mostly in the elderly and the immunocompromised. It can recur: 1-5% of patients will go on to have a second or even a third episode.
Herpes zoster rates are increasing, and some have tried to blame routine vaccination of children, suggesting that adult immunity is more likely to wane when adults are not occasionally exposed to children with chickenpox. But the CDC has determined that rates started increasing before varicella vaccine was introduced, and they did not accelerate after routine varicella vaccination was started. And other countries that don’t routinely vaccinate against chicken pox have observed similar increases in herpes zoster rates.
According to the Clinical Evidence Handbook in American Family Physician:
The main risk factor for postherpetic neuralgia is increasing age. The condition is uncommon in persons younger than 50 years. However, among persons who have had acute herpes zoster, it develops in 20 percent of those 60 to 65 years of age and in greater than 30 percent of those older than 80 years.
Up to 2 percent of persons with acute herpes zoster may continue to have postherpetic pain for five years or more.
Oral antiviral agents (acyclovir, famciclovir, valacyclovir, and netivudine), taken during acute herpes zoster infection, may reduce the duration of postherpetic neuralgia compared with placebo.
Zostavax vs. Shingrix
The first zoster vaccine to be licensed, Zostavax, contains live attenuated VZV that cannot cause the full-blown disease but can create immunity. Rarely, it can cause a rash or a mild case of shingles. Live vaccines are contraindicated in immunocompromised patients because they can cause complications. The new vaccine, Shingrix, does not contain live virus, so it is not contraindicated for immunocompromised patients. It is a recombinant vaccine containing a surface VZV antigen obtained from genetically engineered Chinese hamster ovary cells, an antigen that triggers a targeted immune response to VZV. It also contains an adjuvant that enhances the immune response. It is more effective than Zostavax but requires two doses instead of one. The Medical Letter published this handy chart comparing the two vaccines and showing the efficacy for different age groups:
Adverse effects
Systemic adverse reactions to Zostavax were only slightly greater than with placebo. Shingrix appears to cause more adverse effects: 17% had severe local reactions that prevented normal daily activities for an average of 2 days. Other reported effects included myalgia (45%), fatigue (45%), headache (38%), shivering (27%), fever (21%), GI symptoms (17%), injection-site pain (78%), redness (38%), and swelling (26%).
Recommendations
The CDC recommends Shingrix for all immunocompetent adults age 50 or older, even if they have previously had shingles or Zostavax.
Conclusion: More effective but more adverse effects
The new vaccine is more effective but causes more adverse effects. Some will welcome the additional “insurance” against a painful and relatively common condition. Others will be put off by the reported adverse effects. I am one of those. I have never refused a vaccine before, but I looked at the odds for my personal situation. I have had shingles, so there is at least a 95% chance that I won’t get it again. I have had the Zostavax vaccine, so I’m protected to some extent. I don’t plan to get Shingrix;I’ll wait for them to develop another vaccine that is equally effective with fewer side effects.
Shingrix is different from most vaccines in that it only protects the person who is vaccinated. Most other vaccines protect others in the community through herd immunity, and I strongly recommend them because of their public health consequences. I have personally decided not to get the new shingles vaccine, but that shouldn’t influence the decisions of others. I am neither recommending nor “not” recommending it. I encourage everyone to do what I did: look at the facts and make a personal decision based on their own situation and preferences.

A Recent Case Report Highlights Why Skipping the Chickenpox Vaccine is a Bad Idea
Chickenpox is a nasty infection. And though it isn’t as deadly as some other vaccine-preventable illnesses, it can cause severe complications even in healthy kids, especially those too young to be vaccinated against it. Ignore anyone who shrugs it off as “no big deal”.
Clay Jones on September 21, 2018
Link
At some point in the early 1980s, a young and slightly less cynical me developed fever and malaise that was soon followed by a generalized rash consisting of small red bumps. These lesions quickly evolved into small blisters. I stayed home from school for a few days while several new “crops” of bumps and subsequent blisters would emerge and then ultimately crust over. I remember not feeling particularly ill after the initial prodrome ended, but the itch was intense.
Within a week I had stopped developing new lesions and was covered in the crusted remnants of the disease, which I am confident that the vast majority of readers will recognize as chickenpox, more formally known as varicella. Varicella is the classic and formerly ubiquitous childhood manifestation of primary infection with the varicella-zoster virus (VZV). My case was very typical of childhood infection in that it was relatively minor and resolved without any permanent sequelae. Even the scars that for years served as a reminder of particularly itchy areas are now long gone.
The majority of cases of varicella, then and now, were similar to mine. Because of this, and the fact that severe complications weren’t common, most people who are old enough to have had the disease remember it as an annoying childhood rite of passage. I certainly didn’t live in fear of chickenpox like my parents, and earlier generations, did of other vaccine preventable diseases.
But varicella wasn’t benign for many people, especially those with compromised immune systems, and it had significant economic costs. Yet there is no shortage of anti-vaccine activists claiming that the vaccine is harmful and that the disease is harmless, sometimes qualifying this claim with “in healthy children” despite the fact that most severe cases occurred in just that population. They believe that natural immunity is better than “synthetic”, whatever that means. And many hesitant parents who I would not lump into the anti-vaccine camp question the necessity of this vaccine as well.
But before I discuss a case report that provides an unfortunate example of why avoiding the varicella vaccine is a terrible idea…
A brief primer on varicella
As mentioned above, varicella is the typically childhood presentation of primary infection with the varicella-zoster virus (VZV). It is never cleared from the body, instead finding nooks and crannies in the central nervous system where it lies dormant. Reactivation of the virus, usually decades later, is commonly referred to as herpes zoster, zoster, or shingles. Although not the focus of this post, there is also a vaccine offered to individuals over 50 years of age which can significantly reduce the risk of shingles outbreaks.
Prior to the development and widespread implementation of a safe and extremely effective vaccine against the development of varicella, the highly contagious virus (> 90% of non-immune close contacts become ill) affected more than 95% of people in the United States before their 20th birthday, with roughly 4 million cases annually. Children, particularly those under the age of 10 years, were by far the most likely to become infected. Of these cases, around 11,000 required admission to a hospital, 80% of which involved healthy kids. Of the more severe presentations each year, about 100 people died.
Young infants, and the small number of unlucky adults, who developed primary varicella infection were, and are, the most likely to develop severe disease. To put this into perspective, adults made up 5% of cases each year prior to the vaccine but more than half of the deaths, most commonly as a result of severe inflammation of the lungs or pneumonia. Infants accounted for a large chunk of the remaining fatalities, with secondary bacterial infections and pneumonia being the more common causes of severe morbidity and mortality.
In addition to bacterial skin infections and pneumonitis/pneumonia, one of the most dreaded complications of varicella involves the central nervous system. Inflammation of the brain, known and encephalitis, historically accounted for about 20% of hospital admissions. In children, isolated inflammation of the cerebellum was common. Though seen more in adults, infants are at increased risk of diffuse inflammation of the brain, which can cause altered mental status, seizures, stroke, and death.
The varicella vaccine protects children
The varicella vaccine was first rolled out in 1995 and it has been a tremendous success. Initially only one dose was recommended for children 12 to 15 months of age, older kids who had not had the disease yet, and people with risk factors for severe infection. Within just a few years, the number of cases plummeted by over 70%. By 2005, the drop was 90%. There were also far fewer cases in the adult population, because herd immunity is a wonderful thing.
Despite these clear improvements, and despite more than 90% of children receiving the vaccine, the decline in cases plateaued. Because no vaccine is perfect, about 25% of vaccinated children were not developing immunity and there were outbreaks even among highly vaccinated populations. Disease tended to be milder than in the unvaccinated population, however. In 2006, the ACIP recommended a booster dose to be given at 4-6 years of age, which decreased the incidence of varicella by another 80% or so.
Currently only about 4 out of every 100,000 people will develop varicella in the United States. In addition to this, those who develop disease despite being vaccinated are very unlikely to have severe complications. Of course this will all go away if vaccination rates fall low enough.
Varicella-associated stroke in an 11-month-old child
A case report was published in the September issue of The Journal of Pediatrics that serves as a good example of why varicella should not be shrugged off as just a minor childhood illness. It also highlights the importance of the vaccination in protecting those that are too young to have received it.
In the report, the authors describe the case of an 11-month-old boy who presented to Seattle Children’s Hospital with the sudden onset of weakness involving the right side of his body. He was found on MRA to have a left middle cerebral artery stroke and signs of vasculopathy. It was then discovered that the patient, as well as his older siblings, had varicella 2-3 months prior that had seemingly resolved without incident.
Vasculopathy in the brain is a known complication of varicella, can develop weeks after the infection seemingly resolves, and is more common in children under the age of 1 year. Because of the possibility that VZV infection was to blame, and the fact that early treatment can improve outcomes, he was empirically started on an antiviral medication while spinal fluid studies were pending.
He was ultimately found to have VZV DNA in his spinal fluid and blood tests confirmed an immune response consistent with a recent infection. His weakness eventually improved, however follow-up imaging showed worsening of his vasculopathy with involvement of additional vessels. This may portend additional neurologic difficulties down the road.
Not discussed in the brief case report were any details regarding why this child’s older siblings had varicella. Did they catch it first and spread it to the baby, or were they all exposed at the same time? An 11-month-old is too young to be vaccinated, but his older siblings aren’t. It isn’t clear if they were not vaccinated because of choice or legitimate contraindication, the latter being very unlikely.
I’m curious where they were exposed to VZV. Was it a “pox party”? Do they attend a school full of the children of hesitant or anti-vaccine parents? Seattle is one of the “hot spots” of low vaccine rates that I wrote about a few weeks ago, after all.
Conclusion: Vaccinate your kids…please
I won’t lie and say that varicella infection is as scary as the measles or HiB meningitis, but it can cause suffering and even death. Thankfully we hardly see it anymore these days. I haven’t seen a case in 15 years. The varicella vaccine is safe and it is very effective when administered as recommended by the ACIP and the AAP. So unless there is a clear contraindication, there really is no legitimate excuse to skip it.

   Shingles Vaccine (Zostavax) Confirmed Safe
Harriet Hall
Link
Shingles (herpes zoster) is no fun. It usually begins with a couple of days of pain, then a painful rash breaks out and lasts a couple of weeks. The rash consists of blisters that eventually break open, crust over, and consolidate into an ugly plaque. It is localized to one side of the body and to a stripe of skin corresponding to the dermatomal distribution of a sensory nerve. Very rarely a shingles infection can lead to pneumonia, hearing problems, blindness, brain inflammation (encephalitis) or death. More commonly, patients develop postherpetic neuralgia (PHN) in the area where the rash was. The overall incidence of PHN is 20%; after the age of 60 this rises to 40%, and after age 70 it rises to 50%. It can be excruciatingly painful, resistant to treatment, and can last for years or even a lifetime.
Shingles is caused by the varicella zoster virus, the same virus that causes chickenpox. In fact, you can’t get shingles unless you’ve had chickenpox (or, rarely, chickenpox vaccine). Some of the virus hides in a dorsal root ganglion and remains dormant for years, then travels down the nerve to affect the associated area of skin. Shingles itself is not contagious, but it is possible to get chickenpox from contact with a shingles patient.
By various estimates somewhere between one out of five and one out of three Americans will get shingles in their lifetime; it’s more common after age 50 due to an age-related decline in cell-mediated immunity, and it’s more common in patients who are immunosuppressed. If you live to be 85, there is a 50% chance that you will have had shingles by then.
Since 2006, a shingles vaccine (Zostavax) has been available. It contains a live attenuated virus. It is recommended for everyone over the age of 60, even those who have already had shingles. There are a few contraindications like allergy to neomycin, immunosuppression, or contact with a pregnant woman who has not had chickenpox. But how safe is it? A new study is reassuring.
Pre-marketing tests showed that it was safe, but now a post-marketing study has expanded our knowledge. The VA did a randomized double-blind trial of Zostavax with over 38,000 subjects and followed them for 3.4 years. Serious adverse events occurred in 1.4% of patients who got the vaccine, but they also occurred in 1.4% of those who got a placebo! There was no indication that any of these reactions were actually caused by the vaccine. The incidence of minor inoculation-site effects (redness, swelling, pain and tenderness at the injection site) was higher in the vaccine (48%) than in the placebo group (16%), as would be expected.
How effective is it? Zostavax has been demonstrated to prevent 51% of shingles and 67% of postherpetic neuralgia. By one estimate, the number needed to treat (NNT) to prevent one case of shingles over a 3 year period is 58 and the NNT to prevent one case of PHN is 364. It is estimated that this vaccine could prevent 250,000 cases of shingles a year in US plus reduce the severity of the disease in another 250,000.
The public health implications of varicella vaccines are controversial. People living with children are less likely to get shingles — about 25% of cases are prevented. Apparently this is because adults are re-exposed to the virus and this boosts their immunity. As more children are vaccinated against chickenpox, this protective re-exposure effect will disappear; hence, more cases of shingles in the short term. In the long term, vaccinating children could drastically reduce the incidence of shingles in the population.
Only about 7% of eligible patients have received the vaccine. It costs around $200 and must be kept in a freezer. It’s covered under Medicare part D, but not part B.
For more information, see the CDC website.
Conclusion
Zostavax is safe and effective. Although not as effective as we could wish, it can significantly reduce the burden of a serious disease in the elderly population. It is recommended for everyone age 60 and over by the CDC and by many medical organizations like the American Academy of Family Physicians. Admittedly, the arguments for this vaccine are nowhere near as compelling as the arguments for polio, DPT and MMR vaccines for children. After learning the facts, not everyone will choose to take Zostavax. I chose to take it, and so did my husband.

Unintended Side Effects HPV and Shingles Vaccines—Reason for Concern
While vaccine debate rages in social media and on Capitol Hill, examination of massive data sets reveals unanticipated effects of the human papilloma virus (HPV) and varicella-zoster (Shingles) vaccines.
Kevin Folta on September 9, 2025
Link
Emerging trends in the peer-reviewed scientific literature show new evidence of unintended effects of two popular vaccines—the Human Papilloma Virus (HPV) and shingles vaccines. Surprising findings clearly indicate a relationship between these vaccines and various cancers, cardiovascular disease and dementia. This should raise concern for you and your family, and you should contact your physician as soon as possible—and make an appointment to get vaccinated.
While many in the upper echelons of public health rage on about claims of unintended negative side effects of vaccines, several recent reports refute popular online assertions of unanticipated risk. Quite to the opposite, several solid peer-reviewed reports reveal unexpected benefits of vaccination—results nobody anticipated yet are crystal clear as a vial of thimerosal.
A collection of recent scientific reports illustrates these effects. These unforeseen trends emerged from stepping back and taking a hard look at epidemiological data, unveiling reduced incidence of traditionally non-related pathologies in vaccinated populations. When large data sets from decades of tests and surveys are analyzed, vaccination for HPV appears to have protective effects against cancers beyond the human body’s nether regions, while the shingles vaccines protect against the onset of dementia, ophthalmic cancers, and also cardiovascular disease. The findings speak to an increasing role for viral infection as a cause of, or accelerant of, a broader set of debilitating human diseases than previously anticipated.
HPV Vaccine and Protection Beyond the Cervix
If there were a public health equivalent of a slam dunk or mic drop it would be the HPV vaccine. Those steeped in vaccine hesitancy or anti-vax denial errantly pooh-pooh the polio and measles vaccines, blaming their success on improved sanitation or antibiotic availability. However, the profound benefits of the relatively recently vintaged HPV vaccine in control of cervical cancer are impossible to ignore, except for those who choose to ignore them. But to add a layer of success on success, new analysis of global health trends suggests the HPV vaccine confers unexpected benefits against a range of seemingly unrelated cancers. While often vilified in anti-vaccination media as a culprit in human disorders, it appears that the opposite may be true; these new findings suggest unrealized protective roles for the HPV vaccine, and a wider contribution to public health.  
The human papillomavirus is a sexually transmitted DNA virus. It is responsible for triggering approximately 5% of malignancies, including cervical, anal, vulvar/vaginal, and penile cancers. Emerging trends suggest a role in head and neck cancers and potential contributions to colorectal and non-melanoma skin cancers. However, the introduction of the HPV vaccine has dramatically decreased the incidence of HPV-related infections and its associated cancers. The vaccine targets the risky subtypes HPV 16 and 18, the viruses accounting for inducing 70% of cervical cancer cases.
And it works. The CDC indicates a substantial decrease in HPV-related cancers in females 15-34 years old, noting fewer incidences in high-grade cervical cell abnormalities. These findings are reflected in a number of large, long-term, well designed population studies (e.g. here and here) where researchers confirmed sustained immunity and a decrease in cervical neoplasias over many years.
A new study
The suppression of other sexually associated cancers has been noted, with a reduced incidence of oropharyngeal, anal, penile and vulvar cancers in HPV vaccinated populations, as expected. However, the punchline of an August 2025 study by Seebauer et al. indicates that the benefits of the HPV vaccine may extend well beyond the sexually transmitted cancers.
The study examined health records from the Global Collaborative Network on the TriNetX platform, a database covering 160 million patients from 143 health care organizations around the world. The data allow comparisons of any given variable, such as receiving the HPV vaccine, against all other patient records, including demographic data, lab results, vital signs, genomic data, cancer incidence, family history of malignancies, and many other factors. These data allow researchers to construct retrospective cohort analyses, in other words, define a vaccinated population, and assess correlating incidence of any health problems. Such exercises would identify potential negative or positive effects associated with the vaccine.
Seebauer et al. explored the incidence of malignancy in those receiving, or not receiving, the HPV vaccine, at 8 and 20 year time points after vaccine administration. Over 80,000 individuals were represented in the cohort receiving the vaccine 20-years prior. Variables such as alcohol and tobacco use, family history of cancers, and socioeconomic status were also incorporated to account for potentially confounding factors. Upon synthesis, several important findings emerged.
Not terribly surprising
The data reflect what we already know, which is always a good starting point. The results confirm the demonstrated effectiveness against cervical cancer, as well as their role against oropharyngeal squamous cell cancers. Statistically meaningful associations were seen between the HPV vaccine and decreased incidence of head and neck cancers, bolstering emerging research around these malignancies.
Equally of interest is what the data failed to show. Analysis curiously did not show a robust effect against rectal and anal cancers, which researchers suggest is due to the long latency period of the infection or narrower protective effect of the vaccine against these cancers.
An unexpected surprise
But the big surprise was an apparent protective effect against some blood, lung and nervous system cancers. Those in the 20-year post-vaccination cohort showed lower incidence of leukemias, lung cancer, and cancers of the cranial nerves and spinal cord, as well as possible association with cancers of the eye. These findings support the hypothesis that protection against specific viruses has cross-protective effects against a series of seemingly unrelated cancers.
The authors note that it is a retrospective study and that the associations unveiled could be due to other confounding factors, such as misdiagnosis or errors in record keeping in the dataset, as well as factors not included in the database. Males were also not included in the early phases of HPV vaccination in many countries, which also may affect the results.
But even with those limitations the conclusion is clear—HPV vaccines show strong benefit in the prevention of cervical and anogenital cancers. But as important, the inferred protective effects against non-cervical malignancies indicate that the vaccine should be used more widely in gender-neutral vaccination campaigns.
Shingles Vaccines Confer Protection from Dementia Onset
Shingles is a painful, blistery rash caused by the herpes zoster virus, the same virus that causes chickenpox. The virus remains dormant in the central nervous system for years after the initial chickenpox flare up but may re-activate in older age as the immune system wanes, traveling along nerves to the skin to where the painful rash emerges.
But there are vaccination strategies to limit the incidence of shingles. The Zostavax vaccine was introduced in 2006, a live, attenuated virus that would induce immune response against the virus. A more recent recombinant version has also been developed. But does the shingles vaccine have any unintended side effects? It certainly appears to—it decreases the risk of dementia, as revealed by a brilliant experiment.
Vaxed vs unvaxed studies
In Wales, a shingles vaccination program began September 1, 2013, and anyone who was 79 on that date was eligible for the vaccine. Those 80 and over were not eligible due to a limited supply of the vaccine. Using public databases, researchers could track the vaccinated cohort (born the first week of September 1933) and compare them to the unvaccinated cohort (born the last week of August 1933). These two calendar-based groupings allowed diffusion of all other confounding variables, creating two populations that were essentially random, different only in that one was about a week older– and not vaccinated.
The group that received the vaccine exhibited a reduced incidence of shingles, as expected. Seven years later, the vaccinated group was 20% less likely to develop signs of dementia than the unvaccinated cohort. Similar results were observed in Australia, New Zealand and Canada, three other countries with the same record keeping practices around the introduction of the vaccine. These findings set the stage for larger clinical trials, as they certainly suggest that the shingles vaccination has a preventative effect against dementia.
Cardiovascular Protection from Herpes Zoster Vaccine
Another recently published report examined populations over 50 years old that received two doses of recombinant zoster vaccine (~102k) to those that did not receive the vaccine (~411k). The matched-cohort study then examined in the incidence of herpes zoster ophthalmicus (HZO; a herpes infection of the eye that occurs in 10% of shingles cases), heart attack and stroke.
The vaccinated group was 72% less likely to suffer HZO, with a 28% lower likelihood of heart attack and a decreased risk of stroke by 42%. The strengths of the study include a large, diverse population and favorable accounting of confounding variables. The study population will continue to be monitored to test for continuation of these trends over time.
Another recent study examined the effect of zoster vaccination in over 1.2 million South Koreans over 50. Examination of health records revealed that participants that received the vaccine had a 23% lower risk of a cardiovascular event, including stroke, heart attack or death from heart disease. The protective effect was strongest a few years after vaccination, consistent with the fact that live vaccine effectiveness wanes over time.
In call cases the mechanism of protection is unclear, but heart attacks and strokes are more frequent during an active herpes zoster infection, so avoiding the infection should reduce the risk. Neuroinflammation is a hallmark of zoster infections and may be a contributing factor to dementia. It also is important to remember that these are causal associations, the latter in a narrow demographic, so additional studies will need to be performed. However, it is clear that there is benefit from vaccinations against zoster, even without considering the protective effects against heart attacks, stroke and dementia.
Might This New Evidence Break Hesitancy?
These emerging trends in unintended vaccination benefits underscore their importance of in public health, now in mitigating tangential disorders. But more importantly, these findings present bona fide evidence that advocates may deploy in persuasive science communication campaigns. Antiquated references to infectious diseases like polio and diphtheria don’t move the needle, or the syringe it is attached to. The historic devastation of forgotten disease does not resonate against the glitz of targeted anti-vaccination rhetoric.
But from a communication standpoint vaccine hesitancy has always been fueled by emotional campaigns, and then opposed with evidence, logic and reason. Unfortunately, in the battle of the heart against the head, the heart always wins. This is especially true when children are involved, and an affluent population protected by herd immunity, unthreatened by infectious disease, can afford precautionary decisions.
But in an aging population the specter of cancers and dementia looms real, and just about every family will experience some version of these long term diseases or disorders. The mounting evidence of vaccine cross-protection finally may offer physicians and vaccine advocates an opportunity to wield relatable, emotional rhetoric that may cause some of the reachable hesitant to begin to reconsider their positions.
It is also a reminder that HPV and shingles vaccines should be a broader part of public health protection, more than the young women and elderly folks that are typically associated with these preventative measures. It also reminds us that viral infections are important to control, as their long term manifestations may be more deleterious than we previously understood.
    • 

Risk of Intussusception with Rotavirus Vaccines
Harriet Hall on April 15, 2014
Link
Rotavirus is the leading cause of severe diarrhea in infants and children worldwide, leading to more than half a million deaths each year in children under the age of 5. Before the introduction of the rotavirus vaccine, almost all children in the US were infected by the age of 5, and rotavirus infections were responsible for 400,000 doctor visits, 200,000 ER visits, 55,000-70,000 hospitalizations, and 20-60 deaths each year. The first rotavirus vaccine, RotaShield, was found to have an association with intussusception. Two newer vaccines, Rotateq and Rotarix, were thought not to carry that risk, but two new trials have shown that they do. Still, the risk is small and the benefits of the vaccines are great.
What is intussusception?
Intussusception is a “telescoping” of the intestine where one section slides inside another section. This can cut off the blood supply, block the intestine, and cause tears, infections, and death. Most cases are in young children. They have severe abdominal pain (intermittent at first), and pass blood in the stool, typically mixed with mucus and having the appearance of currant jelly. A barium enema can confirm the diagnosis and simultaneously treat it. Sometimes surgery is needed.
The baseline incidence of intussusception in children is on the order of 1-4 per 1,000. Most cases have no identified cause, but the most plausible candidate is hypertrophied lymphoid tissue resulting from viral illnesses, especially rotavirus infections.
Vaccine studies
The first rotavirus vaccine, Rotashield, was introduced in 1999. It was voluntarily withdrawn from the market within a year because post-marketing surveillance found 1-2 excess cases of intussusception per 10,000 recipients. Newer vaccines, Rotateq and Rotarix, were licensed only after testing (in over 60,000 infants each) failed to find any association with intussusception. Those trials were designed to have enough statistical power to detect a risk similar to that of RotaShield. Both new vaccines contain live, attenuated strains of virus and are given orally. Rotateq is a pentavalent (prepared from 5 strains) vaccine given in 3 doses at age 2, 4, and 6 months. Rotarix is monovalent (prepared from 1 strain) and is given in 2 doses at age 2 and 4 months. Either is recommended, but about 10 times more doses of the pentavalent vaccine have been administered.
After the new vaccines came into common use, studies in other countries pointed to a small increase in intussusception with the newer vaccines, although at a much lower rate than with Rotashield. The FDA responded by initiating a new study of both vaccines in the Post-Licensure Rapid Immunization Safety Monitoring (PRISM) program, a component of the Mini-Sentinel pilot program that was developed by the FDA to conduct active surveillance of the safety of medical products.
That study, by Yih et al., was published in the February 6, 2014 issue of The New England Journal of Medicine simultaneously with another study by Weintraub et al. that was based on data from the Vaccine Safety Datalink project, a collaborative effort between the CDC and nine large managed care organizations including Kaiser Permanente and Group Health Cooperative.
Results
The Yih study found a significant increase in the risk of intussusception after the first dose of Rotateq, with 1.5 excess cases per 100,000 vaccine recipients. They found no association with subsequent doses, but couldn’t rule that out.
For Rotarix, the findings were not significant, but a relatively small number of children got that vaccine (an order of magnitude lower), and the authors concluded that their risk estimates were imprecise and should be considered in the context of findings of increased risk in other studies.
The Weintraub study identified 6 cases of intussusception after Rotarix, compared to 0.72 cases expected from historical data. They found no association with Rotateq.
The two studies appear to have found different results, but they are based on only a handful of cases of intussusception. Small variations in case detection, confirmation of vaccine status, and chance alone could have affected the outcomes.
Their results should be considered along with other studies from the US and other countries. It is reasonable to conclude that intussusception can occur with either vaccine, but that the risk is low, on the order of 1-5 cases per 100,000 infants.
Vaccine benefits
As always, risks must be weighed against benefits, and the benefits of these vaccines are indisputable. An accompanying editorial in the NEJM estimated that each year in the US the vaccines have prevented 53,000 hospitalizations and 170,000 ER visits at the cost of 45 to 213 cases of intussusception. The ACIP estimates that 14 infant deaths are prevented each year in the US, and in Mexico deaths from diarrhea decreased by 40% after the vaccine program was implemented. Even the unvaccinated may benefit as they are exposed to fewer rotavirus infections in the community. The greatest benefits will be seen in Third World countries, but there is greater risk there too. If intussusception is promptly diagnosed and treated, it is relatively benign and has no lasting consequences; but adequate medical care may not be readily available in Third World countries. Another consideration: it’s possible that some infants may be protected from intussusceptions caused by the rotavirus itself.
Recommendations
A rotavirus vaccine (either one) is recommended by the CDC, the American Pediatric Association, and other professional groups as part of the routine immunization schedule in the US. Parents should be informed of the signs of intussusception and should monitor their infants especially in the first 7 days after vaccination; and since intussusception can recur, caution is advised in children who have a history of intussusception.
Science-based medicine in action
This is a success story. Pretty much everything about the rotavirus vaccines was done right. A serious potentially preventable health problem was identified, and the responsible strains of virus were pinpointed. An effective vaccine was developed and extensively tested. The first vaccine was voluntarily withdrawn by the manufacturer within a year because of a problem recognized during post-marketing surveillance. Government programs provided even more effective post-marketing surveillance for the newer vaccines. A possible side effect was recognized. Two (not one) new studies were funded by government agencies, not by Big Pharma. Even VAERS (the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System) was used appropriately, not to blame vaccines for random events following vaccination, but to compare the numbers of spontaneously reported cases at different time periods following vaccination and to give researchers a clue that the first dose of vaccine might be implicated, aiding them in designing appropriate studies. Vaccines work, and the scientific process generally works pretty well in spite of the flawed humans who carry it out.

Rotavirus Vaccine May Reduce Risk of Type 1 Diabetes in Kids
Rotavirus infections kill thousands of kids every year around the world, but far fewer than before the introduction of a safe and effective vaccine in 2006. Now it looks like the vaccine may also prevent type 1 diabetes.
Clay Jones on February 8, 2019
Link

As a medical student in 1999, when I first learned about rotavirus, it was the most common cause of severe gastroenteritis (vomiting and diarrhea) in the world. This included the United States where it resulted in hundreds of thousands of doctor visits each year, with 55 to 70 thousand hospitalizations and 20 to 60 deaths. During my 3rd and 4th year pediatric rotations, I saw several cases of severely dehydrated kids who required IV fluids, and came to know the fairly unique smell of rotavirus diarrhea intimately.
20 to 60 deaths a year was bad, but certainly paled in comparison to the death and mayhem caused by this virus in developing regions of the world. As many as half a million children were dying worldwide every year from dehydration and malnutrition caused by the infection, and 2 million were hospitalized. The vast majority of these severe presentations occurred in children under the age of 5 years, not because older children and adults were immune but because we develop immunologic protection from prior exposure so recurrences tend to be asymptomatic or mild. Certain immune deficiencies put patients of any age at risk for severe disease, however.
Back then, virtually every child in the world became infected with rotavirus at some point in the first few years of life. The virus is spread from person to person via the fecal-oral route rather easily because it doesn’t take much of it to make you sick. Though only requiring a relatively brief exposure to stool containing about 100 colony forming units per gram, stool from someone acutely ill might contain 106 to 109 times that amount. And shedding of the virus can continue well past the resolution of symptoms, even up to 3 weeks, meaning that adorable and well-appearing toddler you just met at the park might be the index case for your family.
The first rotavirus vaccine
In 1998, the first oral vaccine against rotavirus was licensed in the United States. RotaShield, which I must admit is a pretty cool name for a vaccine, was produced using a combination of human and rhesus monkey rotavirus strains because human rotavirus doesn’t grow well enough in cultures for mass production. It was very effective, reducing severe infection risk by close to 100%, and it sailed through phase 3 trials without evidence of significant adverse events. Unfortunately, the following year it was withdrawn by the manufacturer.
In a stellar example of one of the most important aspects of vaccine safety, post-licensure surveillance data raised the concern that the vaccine may be to blame for a small, but real, increase in the risk of a form of intestinal blockage known as intussusception. This is when a proximal segment of bowel, usually small intestine, is pulled into a distal segment, usually large intestine, like one of those handheld, collapsible telescopes or spyglasses. The increased risk was ultimately found to be about 20 times the typical rate during the week after a child received the vaccination, or about one extra case for every 10 to 12 thousand vaccinated babies.
Intussusception can be caused by a variety of intestinal infections, anatomical abnormalities, and even cancer. The link between the first vaccine and intussusception was, theoretically, that the live, but weakened, virus caused inflammation in the gut in susceptible children who were at increased risk of developing the condition with any intestinal infection. Overall, the vaccine was shown to actually reduce the risk of intussusception after that first week. Furthermore, the risk was likely strain specific because newer vaccines using different strains do not have the same issue.
Newer, safer vaccines
It wasn’t until 2006, just as I was completing my pediatric residency training and starting work as a newborn hospitalist, that we finally got another vaccine against rotavirus here in the United States. RotaTeq (less cool but what are you gonna do?) was co-invented by the amazing Paul Offit, a friend of the blog and my guest on episode 74 of The Prism Podcast. This is a guy who can legitimately claim to be responsible for saving hundreds of lives every day because of his work.
Right on its heels in 2008, a second live, attenuated, oral rotavirus vaccine, Rotarix, was licensed. While Offit’s baby is a reassortant vaccine produced with a bovine strain and 5 human strains, Rotarix contains just one human strain that provides partial cross-protection against most others. There are two additional rotavirus vaccines licensed for use in India and China, and a couple more in the pipeline.
The efficacy of the newer vaccines is on par with that of the original, reducing the risk of severe infection by 80-90% in many of the regions where they have been introduced. In the United States, there are about 50,000 fewer hospitalizations every year compared to when I was just starting out in the late 90’s. After 3 years seeing only newborns, I returned to general pediatric hospitalist work in 2009 and was amazed at the change. I can now say that I have not admitted a suspected rotavirus infection in many years.
In some resource-poor regions the benefit is still significant but has been less robust, with severe disease reduction closer to 50%. This is likely because of difficulty achieving high enough vaccination rates for herd immunity to begin to play a role. In regions with high uptake of the vaccine, we see much less rotavirus in adults and in children who cannot be vaccinated because of certain immune system disorders.
With the reduction in severe disease, visits to emergency departments, and hospitalizations, it was expected that mortality associated with rotavirus would also decrease. It did…a lot. Though still the most common cause of severe gastroenteritis worldwide, rotavirus associated deaths have decreased by close to 50%. That is hundreds of thousands of lives saved every single year. Hundreds of thousands of infants and toddlers who do not die. I am not a religious man, but that is a Goddamn miracle if ever there was one.
You are probably wondering about the risk of intussusception with the new vaccines. There appears to be a very slight increase in the first 2-3 weeks after dosing, so we don’t recommend the vaccine in children who have already had that type of obstruction. But the risk is significantly lower than it was with RotaShield, and it is considerably lower than the risk of severe rotavirus infection in children who are not vaccinated. Overall, the vaccine reduces the risk of intussusception in vaccinated kids because natural infection is a likely cause.
Wait, it gets better…probably
Late last month, a study out of Australia published in JAMA Pediatrics found a 14% reduction in the diagnosis of type 1 diabetes in rotavirus vaccinated children through age 4 years. They compared the rate of this diagnosis during the 8 years before and after introduction of the vaccine in May of 2007. Unfortunately, they did not see a decrease in older children.
This isn’t as out of left field as it might seem. There is a plausible expectation that reduction in the rates of rotavirus infection would also prevent some cases of type 1 diabetes in susceptible children. While we don’t understand the exact cause, we believe that a combination of genetic and environmental factors, most likely viral infections, result in the body’s immune system attacking the cells of the pancreas that produce insulin.
Rotavirus infection has been shown in murine data to injure the pancreas and to exacerbate diabetes, although it is not considered to be a common cause of pancreatitis in humans. There is also data showing molecular mimicry between certain rotavirus proteins and human T cells implicated in attacking pancreatic islet cells. The potential protective benefit would likely only be in children with a genetic risk factor and during a key period of immune system maturation when the complicated process of learning self from foreign invader is more prone to error.
Conclusion: More data is needed, but in the meantime please vaccinate your babies
This data is interesting but it should be considered preliminary. It warrants further investigation. But just imagine if it pans out. This is pretty exciting stuff! In the meantime, it’s not like we really need another compelling reason for babies to be vaccinated against rotavirus. It’s a safe, effective, and lifesaving vaccine regardless of whether or not it reduces the risk of diabetes. So what are you waiting for?

   Some Good, But Preliminary Real World Data on Those Baby RSV Shots
Link
Clay Jones on March 15, 2024
When I last wrote about Beyfortus, the new RSV antibody shot recommended for most infants and eve= n some toddlers, it was December and the manufacturer had dropped the ball.= Demand was =E2=80=9Chigher than expected=E2=80=9D, because apparently nobo= dy spoke to any pediatricians or parents in Boston, and I was having to dis= charge most of my newborn patients home unprotected* after having had a ste= ady supply for several weeks. Our experience of high demand was, not unexpe= ctedly, an outlier:
However, uptake varied across the country. Dr. Alexy Arauz Boudreau, ass= ociate chief for pediatrics at Massachusetts General Hospital, told ABC New= s between 80% and 90% of families in her patient population had their child= ren immunized against RSV.
Comparatively, Bartlett said the immunization was offered to parents of = newborns before hospital discharge and more than half of families declined,= which she called =E2=80=9Cdiscouraging.=E2=80=9D=E2=80=98
ABC News January 26, 2024
Dr. Bartlett is a professor of pediatric infectious disease at Comer Chi= ldren=E2=80=99s Hospital in Chicago.
I dug into the available data on Beyfortus uptake across the country and= found wide disparities, and also that an overall disappointingly low numbe= r of qualifying children received the proven safe and efficacious medicatio= n. What was to blame? In addition to the early supply problems, which didn= =E2=80=99t truly ease up until January, the degree of hesitancy and even ho= w the shot was promoted by state medical officials almost certainly differe= d significantly from region to region. Florida, we a= re all looking in your direction right now.
In fact, according to the CDC=E2=80=99s Immunization Info= rmation System data, which collects data on vaccines given from most st= ates, Florida appears to have put the fewest percentage of Beyfortus shots = into the arms of qualifying babies. This particular dataset is limited in t= hat it only includes children who were eligible (birth to 7 months if first= RSV season, 8 to 19 months with risk factors for severe disease in 2nd sea= son) prior to October 1st of last year, and who would not age out during th= e current season. So when it says that Beyfortus uptake through the end of = January was 0.7% in Florida, with only 1.6% of the higher risk babies less = than 8 months of age, it doesn=E2=80=99t include a lot of eligible children= who were born during the entirety of the RSV season. I doubt that things c= hanged dramatically in babies born later in the season, because Florida.
>
IIS data generally underestimates true immunization rates, largely becau= se of delays/problems with reporting. Perhaps their courier was eaten by an= alligator. Still, it is probably safe to assume that this says something f= undamentally true about Florida, Alabama, Texas, and other states with sing= le digit percentages of that initial cohort of eligible kids getting the sh= ot.
Alaska came in on top, reporting that 21.6% of that cohort of younger in= fants at the beginning of the season got the recommended dose of Beyfortus = through the end of January. No state did particularly well in this dataset,= however, though Massachusetts was not included. Maybe all of our courier w= ere eaten by=E2=80=A6a Boston Terrier? But I=E2=80=99m confident that our n= umbers were much better.
According to a different batch of CDC data compiled through the end of Februa= ry, it does indeed look like uptake of Beyfortus increased dramatically= once supplies stabilized. In October of last year, only about 13% of infan= ts less than 8 months of age got the shot. This increased to 43% in Februar= y. This data comes from the National Immunization Surveys, which involves rando= mly calling the cell phones of pregnant women and only included about 600 r= espondents per month. It is interesting, and likely reflects a true trend i= n some regions, but take it with a grain of salt because NIS data tends to = overestimate compared to the IIS.
The bottom line is that less than half of infants at the highest risk of= severe RSV disease will have received Beyfortus this season. Many of those= that didn=E2=80=99t were born to mothers who got the RSV vaccine during pr= egnancy, but many, and probably most in some states, weren=E2=80=99t so luc= ky. Hopefully next year will be better, and I think it will if only because= there will be a more stable supply. But there may be another reason.
As the end of the official RSV season is nearing, there is now some prel= iminary post-rollout data showing that Beyfortus may actually work even bet= ter than predicted. Just last week, the CDC released a report on the effectiveness of Beyfor= tus in preventing hospitalization with RSV.
For the report, CDC researchers looked at eligible infants who were less= than 8 months old on October 1st of last year, or born after that date, ha= d a known Beyfortus status (got it or not), and were admitted to a hospital= for an acute respiratory illness through February 29th. They excluded babi= es whose mothers had received the RSV vaccine or who had received the other= RSV antibody, which is called Synagis and is only used for a select popula= tion of premature infants, has been around for decades, isn=E2=80=99t great= for many reasons, and is going to be replaced by Beyfortus. They also had = to have had RSV testing performed.
So what did they find? Ultimately 699 infants met criteria, 407 of which= were positive for RSV and 292 of which weren=E2=80=99t. 1% of RSV positive= patients had received Beyfortus compared to 18% of the RSV negative patien= ts. Using multivariable logistic regression models (some kind of math, I th= ink?), they found the shot to be 90% effective at preventing hospitalizatio= n, which is 12.5 percent better than what was seen in prelicensure data. Th= ere are some limitations/caveats, however.
These aren=E2=80=99t big numbers. A very small percentage of these hospi= talized infants actually received Beyfortus. And most of the infants who di= d had risk factors for more severe disease. In fact, just under half of hig= h risk babies in the study got the shot compared to only 6% of those at low= risk. The results may not be fully generalizable to all infants. But if Be= yfortus works really well in kids who are more likely to require admission = to a hospital, it is going to work even better for lower risk kids, and the= re does not appear to be any concerning downsides. So the risk to benefit r= atio is still rock solid in support of giving it to all babies.
Prelicensure data went out to 150 days after dosing. In this batch of ba= bies, time since dosing ranged from 7 to 127 days with a mean of 45 days. T= he low numbers of RSV cases didn=E2=80=99t allow researchers to tease out e= ffectiveness over time, but it is likely that it does wane somewhat. Also t= his study only looked at hospitalization. It seems obvious that if the shot= reduces hospitalizations, especially if it does so in the highest risk bab= ies, then it would also effectively reduce the risk of outpatient and emerg= ency department visits. But more data is needed and certainly will be forth= coming.
Beyfortus has pediatric healthcare professionals and families excited ab= out the possibility of a major reduction in suffering from an extremely com= mon viral pathogen. We are hoping that the ultimate outcome will be similar= to what happened with rotavirus after a= safe and effective vaccine was introduced in 2006. Rotavirus used to make = 2.7 million infants and toddlers ill with vomiting and diarrhea each year i= n the United Stats, putting 50,000 to 70,000 kids in the hospital for sever= e dehydration and killing 20-50 of them along the way. The vaccine has redu= ced hospitalizations by 80% and I haven=E2=80=99t seen a severe case in 15 = years.
But no childhood immunization works that sits in a refridgerator.
*At the time, only handful of my patient= =E2=80=99s mothers had been able to get the RSV vaccine approved for pregna= nt women as a method of reducing serious RSV disease in young infants. The = benefit is believed to be similar, though my suspicion is that it will not = end up being as effective as Beyfortus. That issue also improved over the n= ext several weeks, though a small but significant percentage of mothers dec= lined the vaccine in favor of the postnatal dose of Beyfortus.

More Evidence Supports Infant RSV Shot Safety and Effectiveness
As RSV season rapidly approaches, some “real world” data out of France provides even more support for the RSV antibody shot for babies.
Clay Jones on September 13, 2024
Link

The beginning of respiratory virus season, a large part of which involves infections with respiratory syncitial virus (RSV), is right around the corner. The CDC is predicting that it will be about as bad for kids as it was last year, and perhaps even better. Last year wasn’t great, but it was definitely better than the train wreck that was 2022-2023. Those were rough times for pediatricians, particularly in hospitals in many regions around the country.
I wrote about my experience in the Boston area at the time here and here. Last year was still hard but much more manageable without the severe shortage of intensive care and hospital beds that had us managing critically ill babies in hallways at a community hospital with no PICU. As I discussed last summer here, pediatric healthcare providers and families with young children were excited about the prospect for better days ahead because of the roll out of a new medication that could prevent severe RSV in infants and high risk toddlers.
Nirsevimab (brand name Beyfortus) is an injection that contains antibodies against the F protein on the surface of the virus, rather than a vaccine that would encourage the body to make the antibody itself. That would work, and it does with the RSV vaccine recommended for pregnant people during RSV season and all people over 75 years, or 60 years if they have risk factors for severe disease or live in a nursing home. The F protein helps the RSV virus enter human cells, particularly in the lungs, which is why the shot was so promising as a prevention of severe disease.
Nirsevimab almost certainly reduced the severity of last year’s RSV season. Millions of doses were given out but there were huge issues with getting shots into arms. These ranged from expected logistical problems with a new drug that required staff training, space for refrigeration, and ironing out insurance coverage, but there was also the unexpected lack of supply when the manufacturers dropped the ball. Then, of course, there were difficulties with caregiver hesitancy and refusal, which varied from region to region in the usual ways. Florida, I’m talking about you.
Data from before the roll out looked really good, with an excellent safety profile and great efficacy at preventing RSV disease that required medical care. Preliminary data from after the roll out looked even better:
So what did they find? Ultimately 699 infants met criteria, 407 of which were positive for RSV and 292 of which weren’t. 1% of RSV positive patients had received Beyfortus compared to 18% of the RSV negative patients. Using multivariable logistic regression models (some kind of math, I think?), they found the shot to be 90% effective at preventing hospitalization, which is 12.5 percent better than what was seen in prelicensure data. There are some limitations/caveats, however.
These aren’t big numbers. A very small percentage of these hospitalized infants actually received Beyfortus. And most of the infants who did had risk factors for more severe disease. In fact, just under half of high risk babies in the study got the shot compared to only 6% of those at low risk. The results may not be fully generalizable to all infants. But if Beyfortus works really well in kids who are more likely to require admission to a hospital, it is going to work even better for lower risk kids, and there does not appear to be any concerning downsides. So the risk to benefit ratio is still rock solid in support of giving it to all babies.
That was back in December. Since then, there has been additional data that supports continued excitement about the prospects of dramatically improved RSV seasons, assuming of course that these babies get the shot. In July, the New England Journal of Medicine published a large post-licensure study that investigated the shots effectiveness at preventing hospitalization from RSV:
We conducted a prospective, multicenter, matched case–control study to analyze the effectiveness of nirsevimab therapy against hospitalization for RSV-associated bronchiolitis in infants younger than 12 months of age. Case patients were infants younger than 12 months of age who were hospitalized for RSV-associated bronchiolitis between October 15 and December 10, 2023. Control patients were infants with clinical visits to the same hospitals for conditions unrelated to RSV infection. Case patients were matched to control patients in a 2:1 ratio on the basis of age, date of hospital visit, and study center. We calculated the effectiveness of nirsevimab therapy against hospitalization for RSV-associated bronchiolitis (primary outcome) by means of a multivariate conditional logistic-regression model with adjustment for confounders. Several sensitivity analyses were performed.
The study found a reduction in the risk of hospitalization of 83%. There was also a 70% reduction in the risk of RSV disease severe enough to require admission to a critical care unit and 67% protection against the need for “ventilatory support”. These results, along with all the previous positive findings, strongly support recommendations for providing this medication to all infants.
Final final thoughts?
On a personal note, this will be my final regular contribution to Science-Based Medicine. I submitted my first post just under 12 years ago, after having been an avid reader since the debut in 2008, and a couple months after meeting David, Kimball, Steve, and Harriet at CSICon 2012 in Nashville. It was Kimball who invited me to send something in. We actually ended up working in the same hospital a year later after I moved from Baton Rouge to Boston.
12 years and over 250 posts later, I couldn’t be happier having been a part of this team. I got to meet and work with some amazing people. It gave me some recognition with journalists and even got me a brief and unsatisfying appearance on Inside Edition. I had the opportunity to speak at NECSS 3 times, and sit on several SBM panels. One of many memorable highlights for me was the time I led a panel discussion with David, Steve, and Paul Offit in 2019 right after having had a lovely green room chat with with Carl Zimmer and his wife about vaccine hesitancy.
I truly appreciate all of the experiences I’ve had related to SBM. I appreciate all the helpful, and sometimes not so helpful, feedback in the comment section. I definitely appreciate that David never told me enough already with the science-based satire posts. I obviously will never be able to quit my day job to work for The Onion.
I will probably contribute here from time to time in the future. Maybe this will just be a break for me to work on a book, perhaps a thorough take down of baby chiropractic or a collection of old Knudsen’s News posts. Here is the new Knudsen’s News site, by the way. Who knows what the future holds?
One last shameless plug. My wife, Emma Jones, is a hospice and palliative care doctor who recently published her first book. It’s about her experience with burnout as a healthcare professional and how she learned to manage it. Please consider sharing it with anyone who your feel might benefit.

   Pertussis Epidemic 2010
Steven Novella
Link
Bordetella pertussis is the bacterium that causes whooping cough – the main clinical feature of which is a severe lingering cough that can last for weeks or even months. Right now we are in the midst of an epidemic of pertussis cropping up in pockets throughout the US, most notable California. According to the CDC:
During January 1– June 30, 2010, a total of 1,337 cases were reported, a 418% increase from the 258 cases reported during the same period in 2009. All cases either met the Council of State and Territorial Epidemiologists definitions for confirmed or probable pertussis or had an acute cough illness and Bordetella pertussis–specific nucleic acid detected by polymerase chain reaction from nasopharyngeal specimens.
In addition, if the trends continue through the end of this year, which they are likely to do, this will be the highest incidence of pertussis in almost 50 years. These numbers are not in question, but there is some discussion about what, exactly, is causing it.
The tempting conclusion is that pertussis is making its way back into the population due largely to vaccine refusal and anti-vaccine propaganda. However, there is yet no data to support that conclusion. It may or may not be the case – we will know once a more thorough analysis is done of the individual cases of pertussis. And in any case, there are many factors at work.
First, pertussis has a natural tendency to cycle every 5 years or so, and this year is the peak of the cycle. This is certainly a significant part of the increase this year, regardless of other contributors.
In addition, the lack of vaccine-induced immunity is also playing a role, but not necessarily from vaccine refusal. Pertussis is a very contagious illness, partly because people are often contagious with it for days or weeks prior to knowing they have it, or that their cough is not just a common cold. Prior to vaccination pertussis was a significant cause of childhood death, causing about 8,000 deaths a year in the US alone. After the wide availability of vaccination against pertussis there has been on average about 10 deaths per year.
The current vaccine is an acellular pertussis vaccine (part of the DTaP injection, which included diphtheria and tetanus). The aP vaccine is a toxoid vaccine – it contains inactivated toxin proteins which are themselves harmless. It is therefore a very safe vaccine with few side effects. Prior to 1996 the whole-cell pertussis vaccine was used – this was similar but still contained entire bacteria (although inactivated) and had a higher incidence of side effects. The DTaP vaccine is actually less effective than the older DTP vaccine, but a little bit of efficacy was traded for increased safety.
The childhood vaccine schedule requires 5 injections between 2 months and 6 years of age. Young infants are therefore most susceptible to pertussis because they have not yet had time to get vaccinated and develop immunity. Immunity does last for years, but wanes in teenagers and older adults. Therefore periodic boosters (with a vaccine called Tdap) are recommended to maintain lifelong immunity. Incidentally, immunity from the vaccine is not much different than immunity from the illness itself:
A review of the published data on duration of immunity reveals estimates that infection-acquired immunity against pertussis disease wanes after 4-20 years and protective immunity after vaccination wanes after 4-12 years.
The factors, therefore, that are contributing to the fact that the current epidemic is likely to be the biggest in 50 years are – the natural cycle of pertussis, a lower degree of immunity from the current DTaP vaccine vs the older DTP vaccine, and waning immunity in older children and adults with low rates of booster shots to maintain immunity.
Two other factors are currently under investigation. One is the rate of undocumented aliens in California that may not have been vaccinated. The CDC reports:
Incidence among Hispanic infants (49.8 cases per 100,000) was higher than among other racial/ethnic populations. Five deaths were reported, all in previously healthy Hispanic infants aged <2 months at disease onset; none had received any pertussis-containing vaccines.
So early indications are that the Hispanic population is disproportionately getting pertussis. But the burning question is – are there pockets of low vaccination rates among vaccine-refusers, lacking herd immunity, that are also contributing to the epidemic? A recent New York Times article by Tara Parker-Pope argues that vaccine refusal is likely not a contributor because there is no association between county-wide vaccine rates and pertussis incidence. However, this argument is not valid. Counties are a mostly arbitrary political boundary, not a meaningful population or social boundary. There are small pockets of low immunization rates in communities that have been centers of vaccine-preventable diseases in the past, and it is still possible (even probable) that pertussis is having an easier time spreading through these populations as well.
Further – we are on the cusp of a new school year. Once children go back to school, the pertussis epidemic may get into full swing. There are schools that, because of their culture and policies, have very low vaccination rates. We will have to see what happens with pertussis in these schools once the classroom doors open.
Conclusion
What we can say at this point for certain is that 2010 is an epidemic year for pertussis, and this cycle will be the worst in half a century. We know that vaccination with DTaP is safe and effective, but requires booster shots as adults, and that not enough people are getting this booster shot. This epidemic is still nothing compared to the pre-vaccine era of pertussis, but it highlights the ongoing need for vaccination and herd immunity against contagious and deadly diseases like pertussis.
Whether vaccine refusal is playing a significant role has neither been confirmed or rejected by current information, but eventually this data will be available. And unlike the anti-vaccine crowd, we will base our conclusions on the evidence, not rhetorical expediency.

Whooping Cough Epidemic
Steven Novella on April 4, 2012
Link
The Washington State Department of Health has released a statement stating that they are in the midst of a whooping cough epidemic, which will likely reach its highest levels in decades. So far this year there have been 640 cases, compared to 94 cases over the same time period last year. This is a dramatic increase. Whooping cough is a vaccine preventable disease, and so the resurgence of this infection raises questions about the efficacy of the vaccine program – specifically, to what extent is this increase due to vaccine refusal vs waning efficacy of the vaccine itself?
Background
Whooping cough is caused by the Bordetella pertussis bacterium (a Gram-negative, aerobic coccobacillus, for those who are interested), which produce a toxin that paralyzes respiratory cells and causes inflammation. The result begins like an ordinary upper respiratory infection (a common cold) but then develops into a severe cough which can last for weeks. The name of the disease, whooping cough, comes from the sound made by the sudden inhalation after a sustained cough. The disease can be severe at any age, but is especially pernicious in infants, in whom it can cause apnea, or brief pauses in breathing. In infants less than 1 year of age half will need to be hospitalized and 1 in 100 will die.
The pertussis bacterium was first isolated in 1906 by Belgian scientists Jules Bordet and Octave Gengou. In 1939 researchers at the Michigan Department of Public Health demonstrated the efficacy of a vaccine against Bodetella pertussis. The vaccine reduced the incidence of whooping cough from 15.1 to 2.3% and reduced the severity of the illness in those who contracted it. In 1948 the whole cell pertussis vaccine was combined with vaccines for diphtheria and tetanus to make the DTP vaccine.
In the 1990s the DTP vaccine was replaced with the DTaP vaccine, which is still used. The whole cell pertussis component was replaced with a acellular vaccine. In the whole cell version the entire Bodetella pertussis bacterium is included in the vaccine in an inactivated state. The acellular vaccine contains only components of the bacterium. The change was made because the acellular vaccine has fewer side effects. However there was also unsubstantiated concerns about the risks of the whole cell pertussis vaccine that may have contributed to the decision to change. Both versions of the vaccine are effective, but some studies suggest that the acellular version provides less immunity than the prior whole cell vaccine. Today there is also the Tdap vaccine, which is intended as a booster vaccine for adolescents and adults.
Historically the introduction of the pertussis vaccine resulted in a 92% decrease in morbidity and 93% decrease in mortality from whooping cough.
The Return of Pertussis
Up until a few years ago pertussis was under good control in developed countries with a vaccine program. Pertussis has not known host outside of humans so it is even possible to achieve eradication. But in the last decade pertussis has been making a comeback. There is likely no single cause for this, but several can be identified.
There is evidence that the bacterium is evolving new strains that are less well covered by the DTaP vaccine. A recent study, for example, found that a new strain is emerging in Australia that is not well covered by the vaccine and is therefore spreading, because the existing strains are being selected against by the vaccine. The study also found that the older whole cell version of the vaccine produced wider coverage (better coverage for different strains) than the newer acellular vaccine. So it is possible that the return of pertussis is partly due to the narrowing of coverage that is allowing for the spread of newer strains.
To the extent that this is true it implies that we need to update the vaccine to cover the newer strains. This, however, may be only a temporary fix and still more strains may develop. Therefore we either need to chase new strains as they emerge, or we need to develop a pertussis vaccine that has broader antigen coverage, more similar to the older whole cell vaccine, but without the increased side effects.
Another contributing factor is the waning immunity provided by either infection or vaccination. Antibodies against pertussis do not last a life time, so adults who were either infected or vaccinated as children may have lost their immunity. They then provide a vector for the infection of young infants who are not yet old enough to be vaccinated. For this reason the CDC is recommending booster vaccines for teens and adults, especially health care workers and those exposed to young children.
Finally there are serious concerns about vaccine refusal as a contributor to the resurgence of whooping cough. Thanks to the anti-vaccine movement there is unsubstantiated fear about the safety of vaccines. In particular there are pockets of vaccine refusal resulting in a loss of herd immunity. Herd immunity results when enough of the population is immune so that an infectious disease cannot spread, so cases become isolated and do not cause an epidemic. Without herd immunity pertussis infections can spread through a population.
The evidence indicates that unvaccinated children are at higher risk of developing whooping cough than vaccinated children. Existing herd immunity is not sufficient to protect the unvaccinated, even in areas of high vaccine compliance. Further there is early evidence that whooping cough is spreading the most in counties that have a high vaccine refusal rate. The correlation between whooping cough and vaccine refusal needs to be studied in more detail, but certainly vaccine refusal is not helping and is contrary to the goal of increasing coverage to achieve herd immunity.
Conclusion
Historically controlled infections, like whooping cough, have the potential to make a comeback. There is a certain amount of complacence today toward diseases that are thought to be largely a thing of the past. However we are now experiencing a resurgence of some of these diseases, like whooping cough, and while the causes are complex and need to be teased apart, they are worsened by vaccine refusal which in turn is spawned by an anti-vaccine movement that is spreading misinformation and unwarranted fears.
With regard to the current whooping cough epidemic, the CDC has many specific recommendations for the public and health care workers. In short – vaccinate your children and get a booster.

The problem of waning pertussis immunity
David Gorski on September 17, 2012
Link
There’s been a lot of discussion, both in the scientific literature and online, about recent pertussis outbreaks, which are the worst outbreaks in the US in the last 50 years. How could this possibly be, it is asked, when vaccine uptake for the pertussis vaccine remains high? True, there are pockets of vaccine resistance, where uptake of the vaccine is low, but it’s becoming increasingly clear that, unlike the case of measles outbreaks, low uptake of the pertussis vaccine does not appear to be nearly enough to explain the frequency and magnitude of the outbreaks. Given that it’s been a while since any of us has discussed the recent pertussis outbreak here on SBM, I thought that it would be a good time for me to do so, particularly because there have been some new studies and new developments since April, including a paper hot off the presses last Thursday in the New England Journal of Medicine. As a result, those of you who read me at my not-so-super-secret other blogging location might find some of the material in this post familiar, but given the new NEJM paper, I thought that now would be a good time to synthesize and update what I’ve discussed before in different forums in a more comprehensive way, even at the risk of some repetition of previous material I’ve published elsewhere. Hopefully, it will also provide materials for skeptics and supporters of SBM to counter the antivaccine movement, which has pounced on the recent pertussis outbreaks as evidence that the “vaccine doesn’t work.”
Without a doubt (to me, at least), the biggest difference between science-based doctors and quacks is a very simple one. When a treatment or preventative measure isn’t working as well as it should, we science-based physicians ask why. We try to find out what is not working optimally and why. Then we try to figure out how to make things better. So it is with the acellular pertussis vaccine. This vaccine protects against whooping cough, which is caused by Bordetella pertussis, and is administered to children in the form of a combination vaccine, the DTaP (diphtheria/tetanus/acellular pertussis). Five doses are recommended for children, the first at age 2 months, and then at ages 4 months, 6 months, 15-18 months, and 4-6 years. There is also the newer formulation, the Tdap (tetanus, diphtheria, and acellular pertussis), which is recommended for people between the ages of 11 and 64. The Tdap is now usually administered first at age 11-12, with additional recommendations for a Tdap booster in adolescents and adults summarized here, here, and here. Unfortunately, although the vaccine works, recent outbreaks have suggested that we need to change our approach to pertussis vaccination. Let’s see why.
The resurgence of pertussis
It’s no secret that recent outbreaks have been notable for a large contingent of vaccinated children being affected, as has been pointed out in three recent studies. All three indicate that there appears to be a hole in the vaccination schedule that leaves children in the 9-12 year age range inadequately protected against pertussis. Two of these studies suggest that in that age group the attack rate during the recent outbreak in California the attack rate among vaccinated children approached that of unvaccinated children. Antivaccinationists love to cite these studies as smoking gun “proof” that the acellular pertussis vaccine “doesn’t work” and that “natural immunity is better,” but what they always leave out are the findings that the acellular pertussis vaccine in DTaP is quite effective in protecting younger children and in protecting teens who have received the recommended Tdap booster at age 11 or 12. The problem, it appears, is mostly in the range between the last DTaP dose, usually administered around age five or so, and the Tdap booster dose recommended for preadolescents.
First up, let’s look at a study study published last March examining the California pertussis outbreak by David J. Witt and colleagues at Kaiser Permanente. This study found a shorter-than-expected duration of immunity due to the the acellular pertussis vaccine. Basically, as I mentioned before, this study found that the vaccine was highly effective in children between 6 months and five years of age but that its effectiveness waned. The most disturbing part of the study was that it found that that vaccinated children between 10 and 12 were almost as likely to develop pertussis during the outbreak as unvaccinated children:
Among the 58 cases of pertussis in children aged 10-12, 55 (95%) had received five or more doses of pertussis vaccination. Eight of these 58 (14%) children had received their sixth booster-dose prior to onset of disease. In the 13-18 year age group and in the entire cohort of those 2-18 years of age, there was a highly significant increase in cases in unvaccinated children (p = 0.009 and 0.01 respectively). See table 1.
It should be noted that in all age groups, the attack rate in the unvaccinated and undervaccinated groups were higher than in the fully vaccinated group, but that this difference only reached statistical significance in the 13-18 year group, where the attack rate was nearly five times higher in the unvaccinated/undervaccinated group. Moreover, when taken as a whole, the attack rate was also statistically significantly higher in unvaccinated/undervaccinated children from ages 2 to 18. In other words, the vaccine works, but there is a period (age 10-12) during which there appears to be a hole in the coverage, such that waning immunity after the last dose results in decreased protection, protection that is reactivated by the booster dose at 12 years. Indeed, there was a very strong correlation between the interval between onset of pertussis and last acellular pertussis vaccine dose, with the interval peaking at 11 years. The authors conclude:
In the case of the recent California epidemic, it appears that the effectiveness of the current vaccine schedule, when paired with the imperfect vaccination rate, may be insufficient to prevent an epidemic. Earlier vaccine booster doses may be required to provide adequate herd immunity, absent an increase in vaccination rate, efficacy, or durability. Earlier booster doses could prevent immunity from waning, and address disease in the 8-12 age group.
In other words, this study doesn’t show that the vaccine doesn’t work. Rather, it suggests that immunity from the vaccine wanes sooner than expected, that this region of California doesn’t have a high enough vaccine uptake rate to prevent epidemics, and that the vaccination schedule should probably be changed to provide earlier boosters in order to protect older children and teenagers. Indeed, an accompanying editorial by Dr. Alfred DeMaria, Jr. agrees:
Continued widespread outbreaks of pertussis in the United States, with disruption of school and work, as well as with the significant threat to infants, begs the question of more effective use of Tdap on a population level. Experience with Tdap vaccine has diminished concerns about adverse events [12], but the duration of protection with Tdap is not yet known. Reasonable consideration should be given to the suggestion of earlier, more frequent booster doses, as well as the replacement of Td by Tdap as the routine adult “tetanus shot” [13, 14]. With US adolescent Tdap coverage of 69% [15], there is still more to do to achieve full implementation of current recommendations.
Indeed, the second study I mentioned, a study by Winter et al published in July in the Journal of Pediatrics more or less agrees. Basically, it found similar results, specifically a stepwise increase in pertussis among children aged 7-10 years who had completed the DTaP series but who had not yet received the Tdap booster recommended at age 11-12 years, along with a stepwise decrease in cases among adolescents from ages 11 to 14. The authors concluded that preadolescents are susceptible to waning immunity with the current schedule and that the adolescent Tdap dose is effective in protecting younger adolescents.
Again, the conclusion is not that the vaccine doesn’t work, but rather that, given the limited duration of immunity from the acellular pertussis vaccine, our current vaccination schedule is probably not aggressive enough, particularly in children aged 6 to 10, where another booster would likely be a good idea. Moreover, what antivaccinationists tend to completely ignore are observations that, although vaccinated children can still be susceptible to pertussis, they are less infectious, have milder symptoms and shorter illness duration, and are at reduced risk for severe outcomes, such as requiring hospitalization.
Finally, hot off the presses in the current issue of the NEJM is a third study, also out of Kaiser Permanente, that starkly quantifies the waning immunity due to acellular pertussis vaccination. It was a case-control study, in which the authors examined Kaiser Permanente Northern California members who received a pertussis PCR test between January 2006 and June 2011, a time period that includes the last pertussis outbreak in California in 2010. Cases included children who were positive for pertussis and negative for parapertussis by PCR during the study period who also received a fifth dose of DTaP between the ages of 47 and 84 months. These cases were compared to two control groups. The first group consisted of “children who were PCR-negative for both pertussis and parapertussis and who received a fifth dose of DTaP before receiving a negative test result (the PCR-negative controls),” and the second group consisted of “health-plan members who were matched to each PCR-positive child (the matched controls).” Basically, to boil it down to its essence, children diagnosed with pertussis and who had pertussis confirmed by PCR were compared to children who were negative for pertussis on PCR and then to the general population of health plan members. This was a highly vaccinated population (99%), which did not differ between cases and controls. Overall, the study population ended up consisting of 277 children between the ages of 4 and 12 years who were PCR-positive for pertussis, 3,318 PCR-negative controls, and 6,086 matched controls.
One of the big advantages of an health care organization like Kaiser Permanente is that it’s very large (3.2 million members in just Northern California alone) and its databases provide a complete electronic medical record that includes vaccinations and laboratory tests, as well as inpatient, emergency department, and outpatient diagnoses. All of this allows for analyses that would be difficult to carry out otherwise, also because it’s all one health system with standardized care guidelines, which reduces heterogeneity in delivery of care. This is thus about as good as it can get doing epidemiological studies. Also, Kaiser’s members exhibited incidences of pertussis among the various age ranges whose pattern mirrors the patterns observed in the previous two studies I discussed:
During the period from January 2010 through June 2011, when 95% of the cases of pertussis in the study population were diagnosed, the incidence of pertussis was 115 cases per 100,000 person-years among members younger than 1 year of age, decreasing to 29 cases per 100,000 person-years at 5 years of age, sharply increasing to 226 cases per 100,000 person-years at 10 and 11 years of age, sharply decreasing until 15 years of age, and remaining low in persons 15 years of age or older (Figure 1).
In other words, there’s a higher incidence among babies under one year old that decreases through age five but then increases again, peaking at age 10 and 11, before decreasing again. Again, this is consistent with waning immunity of the last DTaP dose at around age 5 or 6. It was a waning of immunity that the authors could quantify:
In the primary analysis comparing PCR-positive children with PCR-negative controls, with adjustment for calendar time, age, sex, race or ethnic group, and medical service area, the odds ratio for pertussis was 1.42 per year (95% CI, 1.21 to 1.66), indicating that each year after the fifth dose of DTaP was associated with a 42% increased odds of acquiring pertussis. A secondary analysis comparing PCR-positive cases with matched controls yielded similar results (Table 2).
What this means is:
In this study, the risk of pertussis increased by 42% each year after the fifth DTaP dose. If DTaP effectiveness is initially 95%, so that the risk of pertussis in vaccinated children is only 5% that of unvaccinated children, then the risk would increase after 5 years by a factor of 1.425 to 29% that of unvaccinated children. The corresponding decrease in DTaP effectiveness would be from 95% to 71%. The amount of protection remaining after 5 years depends heavily on the initial effectiveness. If the initial effectiveness of DTaP was 90%, it would decrease to 42% after 5 years. Regardless of the initial effectiveness, the protection from disease afforded by the fifth dose of DTaP among fully vaccinated children who had exclusively received DTaP vaccines waned substantially during the 5 years after vaccination.
So, basically, what these three studies indicate is that we have a problem with the pertussis vaccine. The question then becomes: What to do about it?
Putting it all together
With respect to vaccines, antivaccinationists frequently willfully invoke the fallacy of the perfect solution (also known as the Nirvana fallacy), which I like to liken to an old sketch Mike Myers back when he was on Saturday Night Live in which he played a Scotsman who would loudly say, “If it’s not Scottish it’s crap.” Basically, under this fallacy, antivaccinationists will argue, in essence, that if a vaccine doesn’t work perfectly 100% of the time, it’s crap. If it isn’t absolutely, positively, 100% safe, it’s crap. If it fails, even just once, to protect against the disease it’s designed to protect against, it’s crap. Never mind that nothing in medicine is 100% effective and safe and that the only certainty in medicine (and life) is that all of us will one day die.
None of this is to say that we shouldn’t strive to improve the acellular pertussis vaccine or improve the vaccine schedule, and that was the topic of a recent paper in the New England Journal of Medicine by Dr. James D. Cherry, a pediatrician at the David Geffen School of Medicine, University of California at Los Angeles, Los Angeles entitled Epidemic Pertussis in 2012 — The Resurgence of a Vaccine-Preventable Disease. He begins by noting that in the U.S. we are currently experiencing what may turn out to be the largest outbreak of pertussis in 50 years, asking the question: Why has this vaccine-preventable disease been on the upswing in recent years? Several answers are forthcoming, but here’s a graph of pertussis versus time:
Cherry first points out that whooping cough is a cyclical disease, with major epidemics every two to five years in the pre-vaccine era. Although vaccination was wildly successful in reducing the incidence from 157 per 100,000 in the 1940s to 1 per 100,000 in 1973, infection does not, contrary to the claims of antivaccinationists that “natural immunity” is permanent, produce lifelong immunity; neither does the vaccine. Cherry notes that this is in marked contrast to, for example, measles, for which immunity due to the vaccine lasts much longer. So now, even though there isn’t as high an incidence of whooping cough, the causative organism, Bordetella pertussis is still circulating in a manner similar to the way it did in the pre-vaccine era. Until recently, it just wasn’t causing epidemics the way that it did before.
Cherry tells us that there are actually two relevant issues to consider: The epidemiology of reported pertussis cases and the epidemiology of pertussis infection. He notes that existing studies suggest that 13 to 20% of prolonged coughs in adolescents and adults are likely due to B. pertussis infection, and studies examining antibody titers suggested an infection rate between 1% and 6%. In other words, there’s a lot of mildly symptomatic pertussis out there, which leads Cherry to ask:
So what are the causes of today’s high prevalence of pertussis? First, the timing of the initial resurgence of reported cases (see graph) suggests that the main reason for it was actually increased awareness. What with the media attention on vaccine safety in the 1970s and 1980s, the studies of DTaP vaccine in the 1980s, and the efficacy trials of the 1990s comparing DTP vaccines with DTaP vaccines, literally hundreds of articles about pertussis were published. Although this information largely escaped physicians who care for adults, some pediatricians, public health officials, and the public became more aware of pertussis, and reporting therefore improved.
Antivaccinationists will no doubt scoff at this suggestion the same way that they scoff at any suggestion that the increased prevalence of autism over the last 20 years could possibly be due to greater awareness and intensive screening programs, but as I’ve pointed out before, it’s a truism in medicine that whenever you look for a disease or condition more carefully you will always find more of it than you did before—sometimes a lot more, particularly if you use more sensitive tests or broaden the diagnostic criteria (the latter of which was done for autism in the early 1990s). As I discussed in the link above, examples abound in medicine in which screening campaigns and more sensitive diagnostic tests have resulted in an apparent increase in prevalence in diseases and conditions without any evidence of a “real” change in their prevalence, as asymptomatic and less symptomatic cases were picked up.
Cherry suggests that one factor behind the rise in pertussis lately is similar:
Moreover, during the past decade, polymerase-chain-reaction (PCR) assays have begun to be used for diagnosis, and a major contributor to the difference in the reported sizes of the 2005 and 2010 epidemics in California may well have been the more widespread use of PCR in 2010. Indeed, when serologic tests that require only a single serum sample and use methods with good specificity become more routinely available, we will see a substantial increase in the diagnosis of cases in adults.
One notes that the last study I cited used the PCR test exclusively to confirm a diagnosis of pertussis infection. Be that as it may, some of what’s going on here might just be overdiagnosis, in which mildly symptomatic cases or cases that aren’t that serious are picked up that once might have been dismissed as a persistent “crud.” Clearly, though, that’s not the only thing going on. Two other issues are likely also contributing. The first is what the three studies I just discussed document, namely waning immunity from the acellular pertussis vaccine. Cherry cites five studies showing that the old DTP (the whole cell pertussis vaccine combination with the tetanus and diphtheria vaccine) was more efficacious than the DTaP (the acellular pertussis vaccine combination), as well as two of the studies above.
Ironically, it is important to remember that the switch from the DTP combination vaccine (nowadays frequently abbreviated DTwP, to denote the whole cell pertussis vaccine) to the DTaP vaccine was largely driven by concerns about the safety of the DTP back in the 1980s stoked by a deceptive bit of muckraking in the form of a documentary written and produced by Lea Thompson entitled DPT: Vaccine Roulette, which first aired on a local NBC affiliate in Washington DC on April 19, 1982, and then ultimately was aired nationally on The Today Show. The documentary linked the whole cell pertussis component of the DTwP to encephalopathy through a series of horrific anecdotes of children who developed severe neurological issues after the DTP. Later, Harris Coulter and Barbara Loe Fisher (yes, that Barbara Loe Fisher, who also around the same time founded the antivaccine group the National Vaccine Information Center) wrote a book, DPT: A Shot in the Dark, further inflamed fears about the DPT vaccine being linked to encephalopathy that later studies failed to confirm, as Steve Novella described. So, in essence, a highly effective vaccine was traded in for a vaccine that’s also effective, but doesn’t provide immunity that is as long lasting, all because of fears of reactions that turned out not to be a risk of the original whole cell pertussis vaccine. To be fair, it’s clear that the DTwP caused more fevers and other side effects, but current evidence doesn’t support the link between the DTwP and really severe neurological complications, such as encephalopathy.
Finally, there’s this:
Finally, we should consider the potential contribution of genetic changes in circulating strains of B. pertussis.4 It is clear that genetic changes have occurred over time in three B. pertussis antigens — pertussis toxin, pertactin, and fimbriae. In fact, changes in fimbrial agglutinogens related to vaccine use were noted about 50 years ago. Studies in the Netherlands and Australia have suggested that genetic changes have led to vaccine failures, but many people question these findings. If genetic changes had increased the rates of vaccine failure, one would expect to see those effects first in Denmark, which has for the past 15 years used a vaccine with a single pertussis antigen (pertussis toxin toxoid). To date, however, there is no evidence of increased vaccine failure in Denmark.
These are the observations behind the claims by cranks like Mercola that vaccines are “causing dangerous mutations.” While it is possible that the B. pertussis bacteria is developing “resistance” to the vaccine through natural selection, the evidence that it is doing so strikes me as rather weak and preliminary. Even if it were, the answer would be to change the vaccine in order to include the evolved antigens. After all, do we decide that antibiotics as a class of drugs don’t work when bacteria evolve resistance or that chemotherapy as a class of drugs doesn’t work when tumors manage to do the same? That’s a rhetorical question, of course. Some segments of the alt-med world do, indeed, do just that, but reasonable scientists and physicians do not. They work to overcome that resistance.
Leaving aside that hypothetical problem that might be contributing to pertussis epidemics in the era of the acellular vaccine, what can be done to bring these epidemics under control? First, Cherry notes that the purpose of vaccination against B. pertussis is not to eliminate all disease. It’s to prevent serious disease (whooping cough) with its potentially horrific complications, up to and including death, particularly among young infants. One possible approach to deal with the issue of waning immunity of the DTaP vaccine would be to start it at a younger age with shorter intervals between doses. Another strategy might be to immunize pregnant women in order to reduce the risk that the mother will acquire pertussis around the time of delivery, with the added bonus that it would give the infant some protection for a month or two through maternal antibodies.
The point of course is that these recent epidemics, while they point to problems with the current vaccination schedule, do not by any means demonstrate that the vaccine doesn’t work or that it’s failed. Commenting on the current pertussis outbreak in Washington, the CDC put it in a recent MMWR:
The ongoing pertussis epidemic in Washington reflects the evolving epidemiology of pertussis in the United States. Although acellular pertussis vaccines provide excellent short-term protection, early waning of immunity might be contributing to increasing population-level susceptibility. Nevertheless, vaccination continues to be the single most effective strategy to reduce morbidity and mortality caused by pertussis. Vaccination of pregnant women and contacts of infants is recommended to protect infants too young to be vaccinated. In light of the increased incidence of pertussis in Washington and elsewhere, efforts should focus on full implementation of DTaP and Tdap recommendations to prevent infection and protect infants.
I also have one final point. While the evidence that pockets of unvaccinated children are the nidus for measles outbreaks is compelling, these latest pertussis outbreaks do not appear to be correlated with pockets of unvaccinated children. Certainly, none of the studies I’ve cited indicate that unvaccinated children are a major cause of these outbreaks, although common sense suggests that the existence of pockets of unvaccinated children can’t be helping and is unlikely even to be neutral. Unvaccinated children are, after all, at a 23-fold increased risk of catching whooping cough, which allows for the degradation of herd immunity at the very least as well as providing a reservoir for the offending bug, and the first two studies I discussed indicate that for most age ranges unvaccinated and undervaccinated children are at a significantly increased risk of catching pertussis than fully vaccinated children; the problem is primarily at one age range where waning immunity from the DTaP leaves a gap in immunity. However, in this case, as far as I’ve been able to tell, unvaccinated children do not appear to be the primary drivers of these most recent pertussis epidemics, as they are for measles outbreaks. We as science-based supporters of vaccination have to be careful not to overstate our case and blame antivaccinationists for these pertussis epidemics without adequate evidence. That only provides antivaccinationists ammunition to use against science-based vaccine policies.
It would be nice if antivaccinationists would do the same and not overstate their case. It would be even nicer if they wouldn’t use outright misinformation to argue their case. Of course, if they were to do so, then they wouldn’t be antivaccinationists anymore. The difference between science-based supporters of vaccination and antivaccinationists is simple. We face reality. Evidence and science matter to us. When vaccines do not function as well as we would like and try to fix it. Even with the problems with waning immunity due to acellular pertussis vaccine and even with these recent epidemics of pertussis, as Cherry reminds us, today’s incidence of pertussis is still about one twenty-third of what it was during a typical epidemic year in the 1930s. Don’t believe me? Then take a look at this presentation by Thomas Clark, MD, MPH about pertussis epidemiology and vaccination. This slide set includes a slide that puts the graph above from Cherry’s paper into proper context:
That rather puts the antivaccinationists’ attacks on the acellular pertussis vaccine into perspective, doesn’t it? Indeed, I can’t help but note that the graph above shows the total number of cases. Because the U.S. population has grown considerably over the last 90 years, if it were graphed by incidence, the effect of the vaccine would likely be even more striking. In any case, this graph illustrates quite clearly that the pertussis epidemics over the last few years are mere blips on the curve compared to what was observed in the past, before there was a vaccine available to combat pertussis. In other words, even with the recent epidemics in the US, this is not the bad old days, when up to 270,000 cases of pertussis could be diagnosed in a year, with as many as 10,000 deaths, mostly among infants. Still, although this is good, it is not nearly good enough. We can do better. Contrary to what antivaccinationists tell us, recent outbreaks of pertussis do not mean that vaccines don’t work. They do, however, mean that we probably need to develop a new vaccine that overcomes the shortcomings of the existing DTaP. In the meantime, it also suggests that we need to use the vaccine we have better, perhaps through earlier and more frequent doses, until we have a new vaccine.

The Pertussis Resurgence
A new analysis shows that the resurgence of pertussis is largely due historical patterns of vaccination. This and other data show the importance of full vaccine compliance in preventing returning epidemics of this deadly disease.
Steven Novella on April 4, 2018
Link


Pertussis is a highly infectious bacterial disease, also called whooping cough. It can often be serious, and even lead to death. In the 1940s a pertussis vaccine was first introduced, and this lead rapidly to a 100 fold decrease in pertussis cases in countries with an effective vaccine program.
However, since the 1970s pertussis has been making a slow comeback, even in countries with historically high vaccine uptake, like the US. Pertussis cases reached their nadir in 1976 with 1,010 cases in the US. A new study uses epidemiological data and computer models to test various theories about why pertussis is coming back. The short answer – it’s a consequence of how we designed our vaccine program. It is probably not due to any change in the vaccine itself.
The study also provides good evidence for the efficacy of the pertussis vaccine and community immunity. What they found is that when the pertussis vaccine was first introduced there was a mass vaccination program. Most people, essentially, were vaccinated over a short period of time. Most people, therefore, were either recently vaccinated or had survived a pertussis infection, which provided longer immunity. (Immunity from vaccines wanes after 4-12 years, after natural infection 4-20 years)
These factors created a “honeymoon” period in which there was excellent community immunity. This meant that even those who were not vaccinated were protected and unlikely to contract the disease. Infection rates plummeted, and it even looked like it might be possible to eradicate the disease.
As time went on, however, there were fewer and fewer adults who had long-term immunity from childhood infection. Further, immunity from the vaccine slowly decreases over time, so there were more and more adults with waning immunity.
The question for the current study is this – are these two factors alone enough to explain the slow rise in cases of pertussis over the last five decades? The authors conclude that the answer is yes. However, this does not necessarily mean that we should focus on adult vaccination. The authors also modeled interventions, and found that targeting children for vaccination would be the most effective approach to reducing pertussis cases. This is because children contribute most to the spread of the disease, while adults contribute very little, likely due to contact patterns.
Therefore the authors recommend that, in order to reverse the trend of rising pertussis cases, we make efforts to maximize compliance with the entire pertussis vaccine schedule among children. Community immunity in this population is most critical to minimizing spread of the disease.
They further conclude, contrary to what some prior research suggested, that:
Our results suggest that the train of events leading to the resurgence of pertussis was set in motion well before the shift to the DTaP vaccine.
So the reduced effectiveness of the DTaP vaccine is likely not the explanation for the resurgence. In the 1990s an acellular vaccine replaced the previous whole-cell vaccine, in order to reduce the incidence of side effects. It has been feared that the acellular vaccine is simply not as effective as the whole cell vaccine, and this still may be the case. However, it may not be the critical variable in the resurgence of pertussis. This makes sense in that the resurgence started in the 1970s, prior to the introduction of the acellular vaccine. However that does not mean that waning immunity from the acellular vaccine is not a factor.
They further conclude that eradication will not be possible without a thorough booster campaign, in order to address the issue of waning immunity from the vaccine.
The study does not mention vaccine-refusal, because that was not part of the hypothesis or analysis. It is, however, an implicit factor – if your goal is to maximize vaccine compliance, then vaccine refusal becomes a significant problem.
Also, the authors were looking at the long term trend in pertussis cases, not on pertussis outbreaks. A 2016 study looked at outbreaks and epidemics of both measles and pertussis and showed that voluntary vaccine refusal was a major contributing factor to these outbreaks. They found:
    • In at least 7 statewide pertussis epidemics and multiple more geographically restricted outbreaks a substantial proportion of pertussis cases in certain age groups were unvaccinated or undervaccinated
    • At least 7 pertussis outbreaks have been described in highly vaccinated populations, illustrative of waning vaccine-induced immunity
    • Reasons for nonvaccination are infrequently reported in pertussis outbreaks, however in 8 outbreaks, between 59%–93% of the cases were intentionally unvaccinated or undervaccinated
    • Individuals with vaccine exemptions have a greater risk for pertussis than those who are fully vaccinated
    • Undervaccinated individuals—those who have received fewer than the recommended number of age-appropriate doses of pertussis-containing vaccine—also have an elevated risk for pertussis compared with fully vaccinated individuals
    • Schools, communities, and states with higher exemption rates have higher rates of pertussis, including among the fully vaccinated population
    • States with allowances for personal belief exemptions or with easier exemption policies have higher incidence rates of pertussis
With pertussis, because of the waning immunity from vaccines and its highly contagious nature, we need to simultaneously do several things if we want to minimize the disease. The current study shows that the most important intervention is an aggressive vaccine campaign among school-age children. In addition, we need to have booster campaigns to maintain immunity in adults.
But also clearly we need to address the false claims and fearmongering of the anti-vaccine movement that creates pockets of vaccine refusal, contributing to outbreaks and hampering community immunity. Education is the way to deal with this in the long run. However, in the short term we simply need to have effective vaccine laws. It is clear from the evidence that allowing easy vaccine exemptions reduces vaccine uptake, reduces community immunity, and contributes to outbreaks and epidemics.

Pertussis Vaccine During Pregnancy Protects Vulnerable Newborns
Getting a dose of pertussis vaccine during every pregnancy is a strategy that has prevented severe disease in thousands of young infants over the past decade, and saved hundreds of sweet little baby lives. The evidence is clear, but not everyone who is eligible is receiving the recommended dose.
Clay Jones on March 3, 2023
Link

Pertussis, more commonly known as whooping cough, is a highly contagious bacterial infection of the upper and lower airway that is terrible in adults and especially nasty in young children. Infants in particular are at increased risk of severe disease. Roughly 20% of infants who develop pertussis will require hospitalization, and one out of every hundred hospitalized infants will die from either the respiratory complications or severe inflammation of the brain that can sometimes occur.
Though pertussis is not as common as it was prior to the development and widespread uptake of an effective whole-cell vaccine in the 1940s, when it was diagnosed around 200,000 each year in the United States, it is still around. Cases actually began to increase from a nadir of 1,000 reported in 1976 after increasing numbers of parents began to refuse the vaccine because of rumors, anecdotes, and anti-vaccine propaganda involving permanently injured children. Another factor in the resurgence of pertussis was the switch from the whole-cell vaccine to a less effective acellular vaccine for infants in 1991 out of an abundance of caution.
Multiple studies have since found that the whole-cell vaccine did not cause permanent brain injury in children. It was associated, however, with an increased risk of febrile seizures and, very rarely at less than 1 per 100,000 doses, an acute encephalopathy. Its appears that we are going to be stuck with the inferior vaccine for the foreseeable future.
Protective antibodies produced after completing the childhood acellular pertussis vaccine series wane over time, resulting in the need for a booster at age 11 or 12 and then every ten years after that. This means, unfortunately, that many, many people are out there right now with less than ideal immunity to pertussis, and tetanus as well since it is typically boosted along with pertussis. This is bad for healthy adults, worse for any immune compromised adults or adults with health conditions that put them at higher risk of severe disease, but really bad for babies.
The primary vaccine series begins at 2 months of age, leaving the very young at risk of disease in general, and more severe disease to boot. Most deaths and hospitalizations have naturally occurred in infants during the first 3 months of life. If a mother has circulating antibodies during pregnancy, these can be passed to the baby and provide some protection until they begin receiving their vaccinations. But again, naturally, this can’t occur if a mother has no pertussis antibodies to share.
In an effort to reduce the incidence of pertussis in this population, the American Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) began recommending “cocooning” in 2006. This is when unvaccinated family members, caregivers, and mothers who have just delivered receive a pertussis vaccine so that there is a protective barrier of immunity surrounding the baby. But this recommendation didn’t go far enough.
In 2011, ACIP recommended that all unvaccinated pregnant people receive their first dose of pertussis vaccine during pregnancy in order to allow for protective maternal antibodies to cross over to the baby prior to delivery. The evidence at that time was abundantly clear that the vaccine was safe for both mothers and the developing fetus. In 2013, this recommendations was again improved by encouraging a dose of Tdap with each pregnancy even in a previously vaccinated mother.
First, some good news.
A study published in JAMA Pediatrics this month looked at cases of pertussis diagnosed in infants in the United States between 2000 and 2019 to determine how effective, if at all, recommendations to immunize pregnant people were in reducing the incidence. During this time period, more than 57,000 cases were reported in infants, with a third being diagnosed in babies less than 2 months of age. During the pre-recommendation period, the average yearly incidence of pertussis was 165 per 100,000 (205/100,000 in 2012!) of these younger infants compared to 19.7 per 100,000 in the comparison group of infants between 6 and 12 months.
In the post-recommendation period, the incidence of pertussis in the younger infant group decreased substantially to an average of about 80 per 100,000. The incidence of pertussis in the comparison group did not change in the post-recommendation period, which isn’t surprising. The point of maternal vaccination is to reduce risk during the period before the primary childhood vaccination series begins at 2 months.
Now, a bit of not so good news.
When the recommendation to vaccinate all pregnant people came out, the uptake increased steadily. In 2014, about 25% got the vaccine. By 2016, that number had increased to roughly 50%. But in 2019, it had only increased another 5%, still leaving millions of newborns unprotected. This strategy obviously works better as more pregnant people get the vaccine, so we still have a lot of work to do.

   A Shot in the Dark Revisited
Steven Novella
Link
Most shots in the dark miss. Scientists learn this early in their career – most of the guesses we make as to how things work will turn out to be wrong. In fact, a proper understanding of science requires thorough knowledge of all the ways in which humans deceive themselves into believing things that are not true. In fact, most shots in well-lit conditions (informed by prior knowledge) miss. Ignoring prior knowledge results in chances that are all but hopeless.
Therefore the title of the 1985 book DPT: A Shot in the Dark by Harris Coulter and Barbara Loe Fisher, is perhaps unintentionally ironic. The book sparked the first modern popular concern about the risk of neurological damage from vaccines, in this case the pertussis vaccine that is part of the DTP vaccine.Fisher, of the National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC) still promotes the book and its content, even though the science has progressed in the last 25 years.
At the time the whole cell pertussis vaccine was part of the diptheria, tetanus, pertussis vaccine (DTwP). This combination has been largely replaced with the DTaP vaccine, which contains an acellular pertussis component. This change was partly due to safety issues, rare cases of neurological disease (seizures and encephalopathy) following DTwP being given. DTaP has a lower incidence of fever, seizures, and other side effects.
In the 1980s reports were surfacing of seizure and encephalopathy following DTwP. A 1991 review of these reports concluded that there was a possible association, but there was insufficient data to establish causation. It was also unclear if these reactions were causing any long term consequences. The safety of DTwP was therefore further studied, and as the evidence was examined it did not appear to support an actual link between DTwP and neurological injury. A 1990 review found:
There clearly is an increased risk of a convulsion after diphtheria-tetanus-pertussis immunization but no evidence that this produces brain injury or is a forerunner of epilepsy. Studies have also not linked immunization with either sudden infant death syndrome or infantile spasms.
In 1993 the Institute of Medicine conducted their own review of the evidence and concluded.
The committee concluded that the evidence is insufficient to indicate either the presence or absence of a causal relationship between DTP vaccine and permanent neurological damage.
But a later (1994) extensive population-based case control study found:
This study did not find any statistically significant increased risk of onset of serious acute neurological illness in the 7 days after DTP vaccine exposure for young children.
The DTwP has largely been replaced by the DTaP vaccine, and so there is little research into DTwP safety in the last decade. However, there is still some data from countries other than the US, that continued to use the DTwP after it was abandoned in the US. A 2008 Polish study, for example, compared reported side effects following DTwP and DTaP and found:
Comparisons done in children less then 2-years-old show in general about twice as high incidence of adverse effects following the whole-cell than the acellular vaccine. The biggest rate of proportions (RR = 4,75) was observed for high pitch cry. There was no significant difference in incidence of the most severe reactions, including encephalopathy and nonfebrile seizures, and there was no significant difference in allergic reactions.
So while there were more minor reactions to DTwP, there was no increase in seizures or encephalopathy compared to DTaP, which supports the conclusion that DTwP does not increase the risk of these neurological events. However, a Canadian study found a decrease in hospital admissions for febrile seizures following the transition to DTaP, suggesting that DTwP did increase the risk of febrile seizures. It should be noted, however, that febrile seizures do not generally increase the risk of developing epilepsy or permanent neurological damage.
Researchers are not done with the whole cell pertussis vaccine question. It is the nature of research to continually ask questions, to take shots at the truth (in whatever lighting conditions are available). A 2010 paper argues:
We argue that these reactions may have occurred in metabolically vulnerable children, specifically those with defects in fatty acid oxidation. In these children the combination of anorexia and fever that could be caused by the vaccine may have resulted in hypoglycemic episodes and possibly death. We believe that this association was not detected because these conditions were not recognized at the time and because these conditions are uncommon. Nevertheless, at a population level, enough events could have occurred to cause concern amongst parents.
This is a typical follow up question after negative findings – perhaps the effect (whether good or bad) exists only in a subpopulation and therefore was statistically missed by studies of the general population. This is a common question that can be applied to any negative study, and therefore is a fairly generic alternate hypothesis, which most of the time turns out to be false.
Conclusion
The DTwP story is a fairly typical one in the world of medicine. Anecdotal reports indicated a possible adverse reaction to the whole-cell pertussis vaccine. Researchers therefore looked at the question in various ways and eventually concluded that no significant signal or pattern could be detected. In short, there does appear to be an increased incidence of adverse events, such as irritability and maybe even febrile seizures, but no evidence of long term neurological harm. Never-the-less, a newer safer version of the vaccine, the acellular pertussis vaccine, became available and was adopted because it was probably safer. Even still researchers continue to drill down into the question of pertussis vaccine safety.
It is not possible to ever prove zero risk from any medical intervention. The data will always be limited. But we can demonstrate that the risk must be below certain upper limits, and that benefits outweigh risks – that net outcomes are improved with the intervention.
What we also see in this story is that anti-vaccine activists, like Fisher, froze their opinions about DTwP back in the early stages of anecdotal reports. The book, Shot in the Dark, was written prior to the informative research as to the safety of DTwP. The same appears to be true for those who continue to promote the myth that vaccines (MMR or thimerosal specifically) are associated with autism. The science has spoken even more clearly on this question – there is no detectable link between vaccines or mercury toxicity and autism. But the myth persists.

   Smallpox and Pseudomedicine
Kimball Atwood
Link
A good case of smallpox may rid the system of more scrofulous, tubercular, syphilitic and other poisons than could otherwise be eliminated in a lifetime. Therefore, smallpox is certainly to be preferred to vaccination. The one means elimination of chronic disease, the other the making of it.
Naturopaths do not believe in artificial immunization . . 
—Harry Riley Spitler, Basic Naturopathy: a textbook (American Naturopathic Association, Inc., 1948). Quoted here.
Here’s what a good case of smallpox will do for you:
If you’re lucky enough to beat the reaper (20-60%; 80% or higher in infants) or blindness (up to 30%), those blisters will leave you scarred for life. Oh, and the next time a good smallpox epidemic comes around, your children born since the last one will catch it and contribute their fair share to the death rate. But not you because you’ll be immune, so you’ll have the “preferred” experience of watching your children die well before you do.
Variolation and Vaccination
Except that none of this will happen, because the disease has been eradicated from the world—thanks, of course, to vaccination, which Napoleon reasonably called “the greatest gift to mankind.”
Smallpox was “the most terrible of the ministers of death.” It began at least several thousand years ago and rapidly spread wherever its human carriers traveled, eventually to the entire populated world. In endemic regions, it wiped out 1/4 to 1/3 of children in epidemics that occurred every few years. In epidemics among people who had not previously seen it, such as the natives of the Western Hemisphere during the early years of European explorations, it wiped out as many as 90% of everyone. It brought down armies and empires. Monarchs dropped like flies; it spared no socioeconomic class. Gods were invented in its name. There was never an effective treatment for it once it had begun.
Prior to the advent of vaccination, there was a heroic method that proved useful in reducing the severity of the disease. This was inoculation (‘variolation’): crude matter from a pustule of someone with the disease was etched into the skin of an uninfected person. This resulted in somewhat more indolent clinical cases, with death rates of ‘only’ around 2%, but the disease remained terrible and those so infected could still transmit it to others by means other than inoculation.
Vaccination, as many readers already know, was introduced near the end of the 18th century in England by the physician Edward Jenner. Jenner neither discovered it—it seems to have been discovered by milkmaids (and their close associates) who had noticed that after experiencing a cowpox blister, they never caught smallpox—nor was he the first to use it purposefully or even to write about it. He was the first, however, to conduct and report a series of convincing experiments demonstrating that people previously infected with cowpox could not subsequently be infected with smallpox (by variolation). He also showed that cowpox could be transferred from person to person by inoculation of matter from the cowpox blister, thus offering the first method for widespread use. Jenner is thus given credit not only for having introduced vaccination for smallpox, but for having introduced the concept of vaccination in general, although he would not live to see another example.
The Antivax Movement is Born
Opposition to smallpox vaccination (the name comes from the Latin for “cow”) began almost immediately after Jenner’s reports and remained substantial for more than 100 years. Some opposition was explicitly religious; some was based on disbelief in the method or, later, in the Germ Theory; some objectors claimed that vaccination caused terrible diseases, including smallpox itself; some voiced a political objection to state mandated vaccination programs. An early cartoon suggested that if Jenner had his way, people would start to look like cows:
Two antivax organizations in 19th century Britain were the National Anti-Vaccination League and the Society for the Abolition of Compulsory Vaccination. They sought to discredit Jenner’s reports and to argue, in keeping with the popular “hygiene” and “sanitation” movements of the day, that “cleanliness is more likely to prevent smallpox than [is] introducing filthy matter into the body.”
The Holy Trinity of American Quackery
These were, in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, homeopathy, chiropractic/osteopathy, and naturopathy. Hahnemann himself had approved of his contemporary Jenner’s assertion, believing that it confirmed “like cures like” (ably refuted by Oliver Wendell Holmes, Sr.). Constantine Hering, however, the “Father of American Homeopathy,” was the first homeopath to declare his opposition to vaccination. He called it “always a poisoning” and asserted, “we learn from year to year a more certain and better way of curing small-pox homeopathically.” He nevertheless admitted in 1883, near the time of his death, that this ‘better way’ had not achieved the certainty of prevention by vaccination.
In 1918, Benedict Lust, the “Father of American Naturopathy,” wrote this:
Like the alchemist of old who circulated the false belief that he could transmute the baser metals into gold, in like manner the vivisector claims that he can coin the agony of animals into cures for human disease. He insists on cursing animals that he may bless mankind with such curses.
To understand how revolting these products are, let us just refer to the vaccine matter which is supposed to be an efficient preventive of smallpox. Who would be fool enough to swallow the putrid pus and corruption scraped from the foulest sores of smallpox that has been implanted in the body of a calf? Even if any one would be fool enough to drink so atrocious a substance, its danger might be neutralized by the digestive juices of the intestinal tract. But it is a far greater danger to the organism when inoculated into the blood and tissues direct, where no digestive substances can possibly neutralize its poison.
The natural system for curing disease is based on a return to nature in regulating the diet, breathing, exercising, bathing, and the employment of various forces to eliminate the poisonous products in the system, and so raise the vitality of the patient to a proper standard of health.
Official medicine has in all ages simply attacked the symptoms of the disease without paying any attention to the causes thereof, but natural healing is concerned far more with removing the causes of disease…
In those words we find several of the recurring themes in quackery that were evident in the 19th century and remain so today. We know that naturopaths continued to espouse this view of vaccination at least until 1968, when the quotation at the top of this essay was among the materials they submitted to the Department of HEW in an unsuccessful attempt to be covered by Medicare. They’ve since learned to be somewhat more subtle about the issue, possibly because of the 1968 failure, but their distaste for vaccinations in general persists, as explained here.
An Aside: the “Cause of Disease,” Naturopathy-style
I’m sure you’ve been wondering, so here it is, right from the pen of Harry Riley Spitler, the author of the quotation that began this piece (courtesy of the 1968 HEW report):
The primary cause of disease is reaction to unnatural environment . . . When the body is weighted down by toxins in excess of the amount with which the vital force is able to cope, then enervation… supervenes and there is a lag in the body’s power to expel the “ashes” of metabolism… Enervation leads to the secondary cause of so-called disease — toxemia. Toxemia is the state of auto-intoxication resulting from the accumulation ot poisons in the body – poisons taken in from without in the form of incorrect food, impure water, vitiated air, etc., and which are not thrown off by the body because of its enervated state, and in addition thereto the poisons formed within the body itself by the processes of metabolism. . . The presence of these poisons within the blood stream and tissues causes the vital force to make efforts to eradicate toxemia, and these efforts are what is called “diseased crises.” . . . Disease, therefore, is not a hostile entity to be attacked, but is rather a manifestation of vital force in its efforts to continue to live and to remove anti-vital conditions caused by man’s deliberate, or ignorant, breaking of the laws of health and life … Disease, then, is the result of stagnation and accumulation of filth in the blood stream and in the tissues.
And the cure? Back to Lust:
The Program of Naturopathic Cure
1. ELIMINATION OF EVIL HABITS, or the weeds of life, such as over-eating, alcoholic drinks, drugs, the use of tea, coffee and cocoa that contain poisons, meat-eating, improper hours of living, waste of vital forces, lowered vitality, sexual and social aberrations, worry, etc.
2. CORRECTIVE HABITS. Correct breathing, correct exercise, right mental attitude. Moderation in the pursuit of health and wealth.
3. NEW PRINCIPLES OF LIVING. Proper fasting, selection of food, hydropathy, light and air baths, mud baths, osteopathy, chiropractic, and other forms of mechano-therapy, mineral salts obtained in organic form, electropathy, heliopathy, steam or Turkish baths, sitz baths, etc.
And, of course, enemas.
Natural healing is the most desirable factor in the regeneration of the race.
Wow. It’s all kind of fascistic, no? But I’m digressing.
More on the Holy Trinity
You probably noticed Lust’s approval of chiropractic, another field with a rich tradition of antivax fervor. Some chiropractors have learned to be a bit more subtle; others have not (and not all contemporary chiropractors are opposed to vaccinations). If you’ve perused the 1968 HEW report, you also know that the American naturopathic schools of the mid-20th century were mostly spawned by chiropractors, and that for some time there was little distinction between naturopaths and “mixer” chiropractors. Many “NDs” of that time also had “DC” after their names.
You may also know that contemporary naturopaths love homeopathy. Lust didn’t include it in his NEW PRINCIPLES OF LIVING, probably because of his emphasis on “drugless healing.” Nevertheless, he praised Hahnemann for having shown “the physicians of his day…that just as good results could be brought about by means so gentle that even a delicate child could be treated, without the slightest particle of danger.” It seems to have been left to the next generation of American naturopaths to fully embrace homeopathy, and this was done most conspicuously by a man who himself embodied the Holy Trinity of Quackery: John Bastyr, N.D., D.C. (1912-1995), the “Father of Modern Naturopathic Medicine.”
Bastyr was also described as a
…third-generation homeopath from Dr. Adolph von Lippe. His teacher was Dr. C. P. Bryant (who had been, in 1939, president of the International Hahnemannian Association). C. P. Bryant had been taught by Walter Bushrod James who had been one of Lippe’s closest students. He received doctorate degrees in naturopathy and chiropractic from Northwest Drugless Institute and Seattle Chiropractic College, respectively. He became licensed to practice naturopathic medicine in 1936. He is also credited with being the Father of Modern Naturopathic Medicine. Because of Bastyr’s influence naturopaths have been at the forefront of the rebirth of homeopathy in this country. He made sure that homeopathy shared equal emphasis with nutrition, hydrotherapy and botanical medicine in naturopathic education. Dr. Bastyr considered manipulation the most important therapy in his practice.
So there you have it: the mystical unity of three seemingly incompatible True Causes (Psora, Subluxations, Toxemia), and of three seemingly incompatible True Cures (similia similibus curentur, spinal manipulation, enemas). No wonder that John Bastyr the chiropractor is credited with having been the Saviour of naturopathy and homeopathy in the United States.
Another Aside: Early Vaccinations really were Dangerous
It’s ironic to consider that many of the early objections to smallpox vaccinations were somewhat justified, far more so than are contemporary objections to contemporary vaccinations. Material gathered from cowpox blisters, transferred from human to human, was invariably contaminated. Diseases plausibly attributed to such “arm to arm” vaccinations, in the era before the Germ Theory elucidated such risks in advance, included syphilis, hepatitis, and even smallpox itself, due to contamination from variolations occurring within the same hospitals or clinics. The advent of exclusively animal sources of cowpox didn’t occur until the mid-19th century, and “arm to arm” vaccinations weren’t outlawed in Britain until 1898. Preparations of pure virus—vaccinia—were introduced only in the mid-20th century.
The political objection to mandatory vaccinations also had more clout in the early days, when the concept of “herd immunity” had yet to be introduced.
“All this has happened before, and all this will happen again.”
This is from a meeting of the Connecticut Homeopathic Medical Examining Board, March 12, 2003:
TREATMENT OF SMALLPOX
The Board reviewed the following procedures for the prevention and treatment of smallpox as submitted by Dr. Mullen:
PREVENTION
Malandrinum
It is recommended to administer it at a potency of 30 CH twice a day for up to 5 days as a preventive. This remedy is also very useful to combat the ill effects of Allopathic small pox vaccination, as well as to control the disease that happens when a person gets unwillingly infested by the vaccine received from another.
Sarracenia
It is recommended to administer this remedy at potencies of up to 9 CH. I believe a good dosage schedule would be once a week for 2 or 3 weeks. It is recommended to administer this remedy at a potency of 6 CH every 8 days. Also useful in recent and distant ill effects of Allopathic vaccination.
Vaccininum
An indication for the use of vaccininum would be a patient’s fear of contracting smallpox.
Variolinum
Both Drs. Allen and Vosin enthusiastically endorse this remedy for the prevention of small pox. I would advice to administer it at potencies of 30 CH or 200 CH weekly for 3 or 4 weeks.
TREATMENT
Malandrinum
It is recommended to administer it at a potency of 30 CH. This remedy is particularly useful in patients whose symptoms are more evident in the lower half of the body. I would recommend daily administration for 5 consecutive days and then re-evaluate the patient.
Mercurius 200 CH every other day alternating with Thuja 200 CH.
I would recommend to use this combination up to 10 consecutive days and then re-evaluate the patient.
Sarracenia
It is recommended to administer this remedy at a potency of 9 CH. I would recommend to use it for 5 consecutive days and then re-evaluate the patient. This remedy can stop the disease in its earliest stages, including the development of pustules. The patient may be very sensitive to light, weak in the shoulder area and have shooting pains in zigzag from the lumbar region to the middle of the scapula.
Variolinum
It is recommended to administer it at any potency. I would recommend using it for up to 5 consecutive days, depending on the potency, and then re-evaluate. Variolinum is useful in patients with mild and uncomplicated small pox. Also when pustules are surrounded by a red halo and are often very itchy. Every other day for up to 10 consecutive days and then reevaluate the patient.
Thuja 200 CH
Every other day for up to 10 consecutive days and then re-evaluate the patient.
Wow. What exquisite, quaint, balderdash. Here’s a fun exercise that readers might enjoy: see what contradictions you can find between what you’ve just read and other efforts of the Connecticut Department of Public Health. Hint: start here. Then look at some of the practice acts, such as those for homeopathy, naturopathy, and chiropractic. Does one hand know what the other is doing?

Wrong About Polio: A Review of Suzanne Humphries, MD and Roman Bystrianyk’s “Dissolving Illusions” Part 1 (the short version)
Suzanne Humphries and Roman Bystrianyk’s book Dissolving Illusions make numerous egregious errors or deceptive statements about polio. Here is part 1 in a series about the truth and true impacts of polio.
Joel A. Harrison on November 9, 2018
Link

[Editor’s note: This is Joel A. Harrison, PhD, MPH second guest post. Dr. Harrison’s papers involve much longer in-depth analyses than usual blog posts, so we are posting both a “short version” and later the “long version”. Note that a downloadable PDF version of complete paper, including a detailed reference list, can be accessed here.]
From early childhood, though enjoying Sherlock Holmes, H.G. Wells, Jules Verne, and other works of fiction, I especially liked reading history and science, subscribing to the old adage that “truth is stranger than fiction.” Then I read a book that had a profound effect on me, William H. McNeil’s 1976 Plagues and Peoples. McNeil made a compelling case that much of human history has been determined not by great statesmen, nor military leaders, nor technology; but by the lowly microbe. In the 40 years since then I have read dozens of books and hundreds of articles on each of various infectious diseases from plague to smallpox to influenza to polio, numerous histories of each, their current status around the world, and, of course, their epidemiology. And along the way did graduate work in epidemiology, biostatistics, and read numerous textbooks and articles and audited courses on microbiology and immunology.
I am writing this article not only because polio seems to be one of the antivaccinationists’ favorite topics, which they often use to demonstrate to their uninformed readers the evils of vaccines and national vaccination programs (e.g., Adams. 2018; Child Health Safety, 2018; Olmsted, 2011, Olmsted, 2016; VacTruth, 2018; whale to, 2018); but also because polio has a special significance for me. As a child I remember my mother not allowing me to go to the local municipal swimming pool nor to the movies during polio season. In my elementary school was a little girl with a steel brace on one leg. During my life I have known several paraplegics. One, in particular, the older sister of one of my oldest dearest friends, met a man in the late 1980s who had been in an iron lung for almost 40 years, and several people who suffered from post-polio syndrome. And through my readings I discovered that my hometown, San Diego, had a major epidemic of polio in 1951 and being in the first cohort to receive the new Salk vaccine, I more than likely received a dose from a lot manufactured by Cutter Industries which because of poor production and quality control caused 204 cases of paralytic polio and 10 deaths (to be discussed in a later paper). So, fortunately, I dodged at least two bullets.
Unfortunate incidents and avoidable errors do occur; but these rare events should not be the basis on which to decide the merit of things like public health programs, as some, including Suzanne Humphries and Roman Bystrianyk in their book Dissolving Illusions, have attempted. Even more egregious is the attempt to take a monumentally significant public health issue like polio and, using “alternative facts”, minimize its significance, going so far as to claim that polio was an “insignificant” disease. This paper will show their total lack of credibility.
Incidence, mortality, disability, suffering: Comparing apples to oranges
From Humphries:
Prevalence of polio, 1912–1969
Since the early 1900s, we have been indoctrinated to believe that polio was a highly prevalent and contagious disease. Graph 12.1 depicts the incidence of various diseases in the United States between 1912 and 1970. Poliomyelitis is the line (with square points) at the bottom and reveals that the incidence was very low when compared to that of other infectious diseases. Polio has also been portrayed as a vicious crippler in the early and mid-1900s when it was habitually diagnosed by doctors who used a very loose definition of the disease. This graph denotes rates of clinical disease, most of which resolved and left no residual paralysis at all.
Given what a low-incidence disease it was, how did polio come to be perceived as such an infamous monster? This is a question worthy of consideration, especially in light of the fact that the rate was far less than other common diseases, some of which declined in incidence to nearly zero with no vaccine at all. Those who still embody a fear of polio may argue that it was a monster because it crippled people, especially children. But it was later revealed, after a vaccine was lauded for the eradication of polio, that much of the crippling was related to factors other than poliovirus, and those factors could not possibly have been affected by any vaccine (pp. 212-213).
Graph 12.1 referenced in the quote above is copied below as Figure 1. Note, that as the graph appears in her book, it is difficult to discern by color which of the lines represent which disease, so I have included a red arrow to indicate the line representing poliomyelitis. The data Humphries used to produce this graph is in Table 1 below Figure 1.Table 1: Rates Per 100,000 Population for Specified Reportable Diseases: 1912 to 1970. Historical Statistics of the United States: Colonial Times to 1970, Part 1. Bureau of the Census (1970), p. 77.
Year	Disease incidence per 100,000 population
	Syphillis	Malaria	Typhoid	Diptheria	Pertussis	Measles	Poliomyleitis	Smallpox
1970	43.8	1.5	0.2	0.2	2.1	23.2	<0.5	
1969	48.1	1.5	0.2	0.1	1.6	12.8	<0.5	
1968	49.9	1.2	0.2	0.1	2 .4	11.l	<0.5	
1967	53.2	1.0	0.2	0.1	4 .9	31.7	<0.5	
1966	57.1	0.3	0.2	0.1	3.9	104.2	0.1	
1965	59.7	0.1	0.2	0.1	3.5	135.1	<0.5	
1964	62 .9	<0.5	0.3	0.2	6.8	239.4	0.1	
1963	69.8	0.1	0.3	0.2	9.1	204.2	0.2	
1962	68.1	0.1	0.3	0.2	9.6	259.0	0.5	
1961	69.7	<0.5	0.4	0.3	6.3	231.6	0.7	
1960	68.0	<0.5	0.5	0.5	8.3	245.4	1.8	
1959	69.3	<0.5	0.5	0.5	22.7	230.1	4.8	
1958	68.5	<0.5	0.6	0.5	18.6	440.5	8.3	
1957	78.8	0.1	0.7	0.7	16.6	285.9	3.2	
1956	77.1	0.1	1.0	0.9	19.0	865.9	9.1	
1955	76.0	0.3	1.0	1.2	38.2	337.9	17.6	
1954	87.5	0.4	1.3	1.3	37.8	423.5	23.9	
1953	100.8	0.8	1.4	1.5	23.5	283.7	22.5	
1952	110.8	4.5	1.5	1.9	28.9	438.5	87.2	
1951	131.8	3.7	1.4	2.6	44.8	345.6	18.5	
1950	154.2	1.4	1.6	3.8	80.1	210.1	22.1	
1949	197.3	2 .8	2.7	5.4	46.7	420.6	28.3	<0.5
1948	234.7	6 .6	2.5	6 .5	51.1	421.0	19.0	<0.5
1947	264.6	10.5	2.8	8.5	109.1	155.0	7.5	0.1
1946	271.7	34.7	2.8	11.7	78.4	496 .8	18.3	0.2
1945	282.3	47 .4	3.7	14.1	101.0	110.2	10.3	0.3
1944	867 .9	43.4	4.0	10.6	82.7	474.3	14.3	0.3
1943	447 .0	40.6	4.1	11.0	142 .9	472.0	9.3	0.6
1942	363.4	44.9	4.6	12.1	142.9	408.8	8.1	0.6
1941	368.2	51.1	6.5	13.5	166.9	671.7	6.8	1.0
1940	359.7	59 .2	7.4	11.8	139.6	220.7	7 .4	2.1
1939	367 .1	63.2	10.0	18.4	140.0	308.2	5.6	7.5
1938	372.0	64.9	11.5	23.5	175.1	633.8	1.3	11.5
1937	264.8	84.2	12.4	22 .2	166.6	249.6	7 .4	9.1
1936	212.6	104.6	12.4	23.4	115.0	284.0	3.5	6.1
1935	205.6	108.1	14.4	30.8	141.9	584.6	8.5	6.8
1934	186.7	105.4	17.6	34.1	209.9	632.6	5.9	4.8
1933	193.4	100.0	18.6	40.2	142.6	319.2	4.0	5.2
1932	208.2	55.0	21.4	48.0	172.5	323.2	3.1	9.0
1931	197 .4	56.7	21.4	57.1	139.l	382.8	12.8	24.4
1930	185.4	80.0	22.1	54.1	135.6	340.8	7.5	39.7
1929	169.2	134.7	19.1	70.1	162.l	300.6	2.4	34.7
1928	174.2	138.2	22.6	75.9	134.3	466.3	4.3	32.7
1927	171.9	118.2	29.2	89.8	152.4	387.6	8.8	31.6
1926	196 .1	98.9	35.5	80.7	172.2	587.1	2.3	28.7
1925	181.2	86.8	40.0	82.1	131.2	194.3	5.3	84.2
1924	174 .2	98.4	31.0	105.6	145.0	463.7	4.6	49.6
1923	156 .2	124.2	31.0	131.4	146.7	680.0	3.1	27 .6
1922	157 .7	142.9	33.0	156 .9	97.7	241.8	2.0	30.8
1921	172.3	174 .7	43.5	190.7		274.6	5.8	94.7
1920	145.3	173.0	33.8	139.0		480.5	2.2	95.9
1919	113 .2		42.9	144.7		203.2	2.8	68.8
1918			50.0	101.5		474.9	2.8	83.1
1917			63.0	183.0		611.6	4.9	52.7
1916			82.3	129.2		621.8	41.1	23.4
1915			74.0	132.7		254.1	8.1	50.2
1914			82.4	152.5		295.8	2.4	66.4
1913			84.2	142.1		368.5	4.0	55.7
1912			81.8	139.0		310.0	5.5	30.8
Note that between years 1944 through 1955 (BOLDED), this table shows much more clearly than Figure 1 that the incidence of poliomyelitis was increasing. However, it is not the incidence of a disease that is most relevant, otherwise all the diseases included in Humphries graph pale compared to the common cold and even food poisoning, which an estimated 1 in 6 Americans (48 million people) get every year, resulting in 128,000 hospitalizations, and 3,000 deaths (CDC. Burden of Foodborne Illnesses). What is important are:
     1.  Degree of suffering
     2.  Disability
     3.  Mortality
     4.  Mode of transmission
     5.  Factors affecting the above (e.g., public health measures)
This abbreviated post (see full pdf version for details) will show that despite changing definitions of paralytic poliomyelitis and errors in misdiagnosis, the majority of cases were correctly diagnosed and, actually, the total number of cases of those infected with and affected by the polio virus was more than likely underestimated. Typhoid fever, caused by a bacterium, was basically eliminated by clean water, and other public health measures. Malaria, a mosquito-borne protozoon, was ended in the US by mainly economic changes together with public health measures. Syphilis is still a problem because it depends on human behavior. Diphtheria began its decline, perhaps based on mutating to a less virulent form, with, first, an anti-toxin and then a toxoid vaccine contributing to its further decline. Deaths from measles, a virus, were significantly reduced, reaching an asymptote of an average of 450 per year during the 1950s; but with a substantial amount of suffering, 45,000 hospitalizations, and up to 250 permanently disabled children. Given that the number of cases were underreported, the possibility exists that deaths were also underreported. Smallpox deaths were reduced to under 1% in the United States, except imported cases, by a variant of the virus, although variola minor still entailed quite a bit of suffering, and, as long as variola major reigned in much of the world, the risk to Americans neither vaccinated nor exposed to variola minor still existed. Whooping cough (pertussis), caused by a bacteria, was reduced and almost eliminated in the United States by vaccines. In addition, while Humphries figure uses incidence, I think most people would care more about the degree of suffering, deaths, and disabilities. And ALL of the above, except syphilis began declining, some as early as the late 19th century. Though deaths from pertussis, measles, and diphtheria continued from the end of World War II into the early 1950s, they were lower than earlier and continued their decline, while polio was on the ascendance, including both deaths and disability.
Poliomyelitis: Epidemics, Incidence, Morbidity (paralysis), and Mortality
According to the CDC Pink Book chapter on poliomyelitis:
Fewer than 1% of all polio infections in children result in flaccid paralysis. Patients do not experience sensory losses or changes in cognition. Many persons with paralytic poliomyelitis recover completely and, in most, muscle function returns to some degree. Person-to-person spread of poliovirus via the fecal-oral route is the most important route of transmission, although the oral-oral route is possible.
While the other diseases in Humphries graph were on the decline, polio was on the rise. (Trevelyan, 2005, pp. 35-36).
Humphries argues in her chapter that even the classification of these cases is suspect, lacking laboratory confirmation, and changing criteria for defining paralysis. The fact that some cases were misdiagnosed is not questioned, something one finds in all aspects of medicine; but, as I will show, the vast majority of cases reported as polio were polio!
Polio mortality
First, let’s look at deaths, something even Humphries can’t claim were misdiagnosed. The following table is from the CDC Pink Book Appendix E; it allows one to compare death rates from several of the diseases used in Humphries’ comparison graph. The table also includes paralytic cases separately starting in 1951. Appendix E only listed total cases for 1951-1953, so I added in parentheses the number of reported paralytic cases (Post-Polio Health International.Table 2: Reported cases and deaths from vaccine preventable diseases, United States, 1950-1982
	Measles	Diphtheria	Pertussis	Polio (paralytic)
†Total reported cases From 1951, MMWR separated paralytic and nonparalytic cases. Before 1951, MMWR included both as Total Cases.
Year	Cases	Deaths	Cases	Deaths	Cases	Deaths	Cases	Deaths
1950	319,124	468	5,796	410	120,718	1,118	33,300†	1,904
1951	530,118	683	3,983	302	68,687	951	28,386†
(10,037)	1,551
1952	683,077	618	2,960	217	45,030	402	57,879†
(21,269)	3,145
1953	449,146	462	2,355	156	37,129	270	35,592†
(15,648)	1,450
1954	682,720	518	2,041	145	60,886	373	18,308	1,368
1955	555,156	345	1,984	150	62,786	467	13,850	1043
1956	611,936	530	1,568	103	31,732	266	7,911	566
1957	486,799	389	1,211	81	28,295	183	2,499	221
1958	763,094	552	918	74	32,148	177	3,697	255
1959	406,162	385	934	72	40,005	269	6,289	454
1960	441,703	380	918	69	14,809	118	2,525	230
1960	423,919	434	617	68	11,468	76	988	90
1962	481,530	408	444	41	17,749	83	762	60
1963	385,156	364	314	45	17,135	115	396	41
1964	458,083	421	293	42	13,005	93	106	17
1965	261,904	276	164	18	6,799	55	61	16
1966	204,136	261	209	20	7,717	49	106	9
1967	62,705	81	219	32	9,718	37	40	16
1968	22,231	24	260	30	4,810	36	53	24
1969	25,826	41	241	25	3,285	13	18	13
1970	47,351	89	435	30	4,249	12	31	7
1971	75,290	90	215	13	3036	18	17	18
1972	32,275	24	152	10	3,287	6	29	2
1973	26,690	23	228	10	1,759	5	7	10
1974	22,094	20	272	5	2,402	14	7	3
1975	24,374	20	307	5	1,738	8	13	9
1976	41,126	12	128	7	1,010	7	10	16
1977	57,345	15	84	5	2,177	10	19	16
1978	26,871	11	76	4	2,063	6	8	13
1979	13,597	6	59	1	1,623	6	22	1
1980	13,506	11	3	1	1,730	11	9	2
1981	3,124	2	5	0	1,248	6	10	0
1982	1714	2	2	1	1,895	4	12	0
The number of deaths from polio was substantially higher from 1950-1956 than any of the other disease. Perhaps, as from 1953, Humphries doesn’t consider 3,145 deaths from polio, mainly children, of any importance? Note that number 2 in number of deaths from 1950 on was measles, with a high of 683 in 1951, just a minor blip on the screen according to Humphries (p.174).
Polio morbidity/paralysis
Though “fewer than 1% of all polio infections in children result in flaccid paralysis and most did eventually regain some or complete mobility”, given the large number infected during epidemics, this was a substantial number. In addition, as polio doesn’t affect the sensory nerves, many suffered intense pain and months to years to recover (e.g., Sass, 1996; Seavey, 1998; Silver, 2007).
Humphries writes:
The practice among doctors before 1954 was to diagnose all patients who experienced even short-term paralysis (24 hours) with “polio.” In 1955, the year the Salk vaccine was released, the diagnostic criteria became much more stringent. If there was no residual paralysis 60 days after onset, the disease was not considered to be paralytic polio. This change made a huge difference in the documented prevalence of paralytic polio because most people who experience paralysis recover prior to 60 days (Humphries, p. 219).
Humphries basis the above on Dr. Greenberg (see below); however, even with Greenberg’s adjustments there remained a substantial number of paralytic cases, e.g., 1951 (7,000), 1952 (14,000) (Ratner, 1960, p. 5). Note the black portion of each bar.
Dr. Greenberg’s chart showing what the incidence, total cases of paralytic polio would have been in former years if the diagnostic criteria of 1959 had been used (from Ratner, 1960, p. 5).
Humphries goes on to write:
As a case in point on how much paralytic disease thought to be polio was not at all associated with polioviruses, consider the well-documented Michigan epidemic of 1958. This epidemic occurred four years into the Salk vaccine campaign. An in-depth analysis of the diagnosed cases revealed that more than half of them were not poliovirus associated at all…In a large number of paralytic as well as nonparalytic patients poliovirus was not the cause (Humphries, p. 219).
Let’s look at the actual data from the Michigan study; but first, according to Brown (1960):
An additional correlation of clinical and laboratory information was made possible by the fact that 550 of the patients in the Detroit area were examined for muscles weakness 60 days after onset of disease. The results are presented in table 7 [Table 5 below] in terms of the degree of paralysis two months after infections, and they are arranged according to the clinical diagnosis at the time of admission to hospital and according to the results of laboratory tests carried out on specimens from these patients. It is obvious that most of the 308 patients considered to be nonparalytic on admission were also classified in that category two months later. Virus was isolated from only one-half of those among whom ECHO and Coxsackie viruses were equally responsible with poliovirus for the infections. Among the 242 patients originally diagnosed as paralytic, 187, or 77% were confirmed by laboratory tests to have poliomyelitis. The vast majority of these (84%) were found to have residual paralysis 60 days after onset of the illness, and it is of interest that 83% of these paralytic patients were unvaccinated and only four, or 2.5%, had received three doses of vaccine.
Table 3: Correlation of Laboratory Findings of Poliomyelitis with Muscle Examination Performed 60 Days from Onset of Illness (from Table 7 in Brown, 1960)
Original Diagnosis	Laboratory Diagnosis	Results of Muscle Examination, No.
Type	No.	Type	No.	NP*	P1a	P2b	P3c
Nonparalytic	308	Polio	66	56	4	1	3
		ECHO	53	52	1	. . .	. . .
		Coxsackie	41	40	. . .	1	. . .
		Negative	148	143	5	. . .	. . .
Paralytic	242	Polio	187	29	49	67	42
		ECHO	2	. . .	2	. . .	. . .
		Negative	53	20	11	15	7
* NP = non paralytica P1 = minor involvementb P2 = significant paralysisc P3 = severe paralysis or death
Just to be clear, the changed definition of paralytic cases explained by Greenberg did eliminate a substantial number of cases of paralysis; but a significant number of paralytic cases remained and in the following years, based on the revised definition, following the introduction of the vaccine, these numbers continued to decline until there were none, so, whatever some claim, the evidence for the effectiveness of the vaccine is substantial and undeniable and the Brown paper, based on lab confirmation and 60 day confirmed paralytic cases, found the majority were caused by polio.
And finally, Bruno makes a compelling case that the total number of people infected with the virus, even some with mild paralysis, was actually underestimated. (Bruno, 2000).
Humphries continues her callous dismissal of the cases of paralytic poliomyelitis;
Wild poliovirus was never the big killer or paralyzer the public was led to believe it was through the many frightening images shown repeatedly in the 1950s. Dr. Lennette, a well-respected virologist and pioneer of diagnostic virology with the California Department of Health, said in reflection on September 1987:
Actually, economically the disease wasn’t very important. Secondly, not many cases were seen in this country. There weren’t too many people paralyzed from polio in any one neighborhood, so it never made much of an impact (Humphries, p. 224).
For a little perspective, according to the National Cancer Institute:
Among children ages 0 to 14 years, it is estimated that 10,270 will be diagnosed with cancer and 1,190 will die of the disease in 2017 (National Cancer Institute, 2017).
For cerebral palsy, according to the Texas Adoption Resource Exchange:
About 8,000 babies and infants are diagnosed with the condition each year. In addition, some 1,200 – 1,500 preschool age children are recognized each year to have cerebral palsy (Texas Adoption Resource Exchange, 2018).
And approximately 4,531 new cases of muscular dystrophy are reported in the U.S. per year. Given the large number of neighborhoods in the US, the likelihood of one, let alone more of any of the above in a neighborhood is small. Yet, many Americans were and are aware of them and support efforts, both research and care.
So, Americans, even if not in their neighborhoods, were reminded of just how serious a condition paralytic poliomyelitis was as with other “low incidence” childhood diseases and disabilities. Keep in mind that from the 1916 epidemic on many neighborhoods had witnessed first-hand paralytic poliomyelitis.
So if polio, with 7,000 documented cases of paralysis or more, should be dismissed as unimportant, I wonder which one of the above and many other disabilities and diseases affecting mainly children, given their “low incidence,” does Humphries also think we should ignore?
Why did the American people view polio with such fear?

According to Oshinsky:
The disease reached its peak at the height of the cold war, when a national crisis often took the form of a crusade. And this particular crisis, an epidemic targeting defenseless children, grew to increasingly dramatic proportions in an increasingly suburban, family-oriented society preaching ever-higher standards of protection for the young. How ironic, how unfair, that polio seemed to target the world’s most advanced nation, where new wonder drugs like penicillin were readily available and consumers—mainly housewives—worked overtime to eliminate odors and germs.
No disease drew as much attention, or struck the same terror, as polio. And for good reason. Polio hit without warning. There was no way of telling who would get it and who would be spared. It killed some of its victims and marked others for life, leaving behind vivid reminders for all to see: wheelchairs, crutches, leg braces, breathing devices, deformed limbs (Oshinsky, 2005, pp. 4-5).
The March of Dimes
According to Humphries: “The March of Dimes campaigns . . . were . . . designed to impact human fear and emotion (Humphries, p.224).”
According to Oshinsky: “This dread did not begin with the National Foundation. A growing pattern of epidemics—the worst occurring in 1916—had already drawn . . . notice in the press (Oshinsky, 2005, p. 5).”
This was a time before the U.S. Government became actively involved in funding a broad range of medical programs. And few people had medical insurance.
According to Rose:
During its first 20 years, the Foundation assisted over 335,000 individuals with polio in a patients aid program that covered medical, hospital, and rehabilitation expenses. . . Covered expenses included payment for physician services, inpatient and outpatient hospital costs, the transport of polio patients (local transport to hospitals and the Military Air Transport Services, or MATS, organized through the US Air Force, home care (including nursing care), orthopedic devices, and home medical equipment. Rehabilitation expenses often involved long-term home care and carried over from year to year beyond the addition of new cases. . . The Foundation claimed that it was “the only voluntary health agency in the US which conducts a nationwide program of financial assistance to patients in meeting the costs of care of a single disease.”
It is important to recall the direct aid to communities besides personal aid that might have been beyond the scope of personal appreciation by individual recipients. From the outset the NFIP [the National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis, more commonly known as the March of Dimes] had organized systematic epidemic relief in concert with public health authorities involving the dispatch of physicians, nurses, and epidemiologists to affected areas, with medical equipment and supplies, to cope with local polio epidemics. It had supported the helping professions intrinsically involved with after care: nursing, physical therapy, and occupational therapy (Rose, 2016, pp. 156-158).
Only about 16% of the funds collected by the March of Dimes went to research and vaccine development, thus, approximately 84% went to care, education, and equipment (Van Riper, 1955, p. 141).
A low incidence relative to many other disease, yes; but incidence is not the important factor – suffering, disability, and death are. Even after Greenberg’s adjustments for determining paralysis, after Brown’s laboratory analyses distinguishing polio case from others, what remained were a significant number of deaths and even more so, the ever present specter of an ever increasing number of disabled children. Without the National Foundation, how would they have been cared for?
Estimates of probability of children permanently paralyzed
Humphries writes:
The CDC defines polio’s statistical paralytic rate and estimates that it is less than 1 in 100 for some sort of permanent paralytic syndrome. . .Prior to vaccination, Dr. Maurice Brodie reported that only 1 in 170 children with no antibody to polio became ill during epidemics. By these two drastically different risk estimations, you can see that statistics are not set in stone, nor are they necessarily a reliable indicator of risk (Humphries, pp. 239-240; see also: Brodie,1936).”
Unfortunately, Humphries fails to understand that at the time Brodie conducted his study it was not known that polio consisted of three identifiable serotypes, so, the antibodies used in Brodies analysis probably recognized only one of the serotypes. In other words, many of the children who tested negative may well have had antibodies to one or both of the other serotypes. In addition, Humphries fails to understand that almost all studies of any specific medical area will find a range of statistics. In the case of polio, for instance, it would depend on time, place, sampling scheme, sample size for any lab estimates, and, of course, which of the serotypes exist or have existed. However, whether one needed to vaccinate 100 or even 200 to prevent one case of paralysis (the number needed to treat), given the significant number of paralytic cases depends on whether one considers so many paralyzed individuals acceptable or not, especially given the documented safety of the vaccines.
Far more people were harmed by polio than originally suspected
Post-polio syndrome
According to Wikipedia:
Post-polio syndrome is a condition that affects approximately 25–50% of people who have previously contracted poliomyelitis—a viral infection of the nervous system—after the initial infection. Typically the symptoms appear 15–30 years after recovery from the original paralytic attack, at an age of 35 to 60. Symptoms include acute or increased muscular weakness, pain in the muscles, and fatigue. The same symptoms may also occur years after a nonparalytic polio (NPP) infection [my emphasis].
Poliovirus attacks specific neurons resulting in the death of a substantial fraction of the motor neurons controlling skeletal muscles. In an effort to compensate for the loss of these neurons, surviving motor neurons sprout new nerve terminals to the orphaned muscle fibers. The result is some recovery of movement and the development of enlarged motor units.
With age, most people experience a decrease in the number of spinal motor neurons. Because polio survivors have already lost a considerable number of motor neurons, further age-related loss of neurons may contribute substantially to new muscle weakness. (Wikipedia. Post-polio syndrome; see also: Halstead, 1998; Halstead, 2011; Horowitz, 1985; March of Dimes, 2001; McComas, 1997).
Studies have found clear evidence of polio virus in sufferers of post-polio syndrome (e.g., Leparc-Goffart, 1996).
Not only those who suffered paralysis, going through often long painful therapies, who appeared to have regained somewhat normal mobility, eventually only to develop post-polio syndrome; but a number of those, who following an acute episode of polio, even those asymptomatic, also developed post-polio syndrome. As discussed by Bruno:
Recent studies make clear that [non-paralytic polio] survivors do have late onset symptoms. Therefore, “postpolio syndrome” should not be used as the generic descriptor for late onset problems in polio survivors, because its diagnostic criteria exclude those without a history of paralysis, electromyographic evidence of denervation, and new muscle weakness. (Bruno, 2000; see also: Falconer, 2000, Nee, 1995).
Bruno further writes:
In the 1940s Johns Hopkins University pathologist David Bodian found that 96 percent of motor neurons were infected by the poliovirus if you had any paralysis at all! Bodian found that for each neuron the polio virus invades, commandeers, and destroys, its action is halted in another neuron. How is it that the poliovirus is stopped at least half the time? Most likely because the immune system is able to play catch-up and produce enough antibodies to attack the poliovirus before it conquers the entire nervous system.
But if on average 50 percent of all motor neurons are destroyed in anyone who had paralytic polio, why aren’t half of polio survivor’s muscles paralyzed? Bodian discovered that at least 60 % of spinal cord motor neurons associated with an individual muscle must be killed before the muscle shows any weakness at all. This means that muscles that were at one time paralyzed or muscles that have been weak, may have been operating on as few as 40 percent of their original motor neurons. . . What’s more, Bodian found that muscles thought to be completely unaffected by polio—muscles that had never been weak, let alone paralyzed—only have 60% of their motor neurons (Bruno, 2002, p. 29).
What’s more, Bruno makes a case that, besides post-polio syndrome, chronic fatigue syndrome may have the same pathophysiology (Bruno, 1997; Bruno, 1998).
So, the 1/100 to 1/200 ratio that describes the immediate aftermath of acute polio infection significantly underestimates the “true” extent of polio’s damage. Many cases of slight muscle weakness were missed and later those suffering from post-polio syndrome, both originally asymptomatic and symptomatic, and, perhaps, even chronic fatigue syndrome, were the result of the polio virus.
Humphries writes:
After the vaccine, there was a concerted effort to distinguish cases with poliovirus from cases without it. This was not a concern prior to 1958 when many diseases common today hid behind the name poliomyelitis. Transverse myelitis, viral or aseptic meningitis, Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS), chronic fatigue syndrome, spinal meningitis, post-polio syndrome, acute flaccid paralysis (AFP), enteroviral encephalopathy, traumatic neuritis, Reye’s syndrome, etc., all could have been diagnosed as polio prior to 1958 (Humphries, p. 224).
As discussed above, after Greenberg’s adjustments for determining paralysis, and using the same criteria together with laboratory differential diagnostics in Brown’s study, a significant number of cases of paralytic poliomyelitis remained. And neither post-polio syndrome nor chronic fatigue syndrome were known entities until decades later, so how could they be diagnosed as polio prior to 1958? And Humphries appears unaware that not only did the polio virus cause immediate cases of disability; but has been found to have resulted in “mild” effects on many during their lifetime and later disabilities, even those who did not initially appear to have been affected. Humphries seems unaware of just how much damage to neurons poliovirus did.
Summary and conclusion
I think it obvious that Humphries presentation is defective in numerous ways and displays a callousness towards suffering:
     1.  Humphries begins by comparing incidence rates for a number of diseases, essentially comparing apples to oranges;
     2.  When Humphries does discuss disease incidence and deaths, she ignores the tremendous toll polio has in terms of suffering and disability, something she does as well with measles;
     3.  Humphries ignores that all the diseases she compared with polio were either already eliminated or on a sharp decline at the same time polio was on the ascendance;
     4.  Whether 1/100 or 1/200 cases actually became paralyzed, when one counts up the actual number of cases of paralyses, it makes little difference;
     5.  Humphries dismisses that even after Greenberg’s adjustments, 7,000 or more cases of paralysis remained;
     6.  Humphries misuses the Michigan data, which actually found “among the 242 patients originally diagnosed as paralytic, 187, or 77% were confirmed by laboratory tests to have poliomyelitis. The vast majority of these (84%) were found to have residual paralysis 60 days after onset of the illness”, thus, 65% had paralysis 60 days later;
     7.  And, though, as exemplified by Greenberg and the Michigan study, changing definitions and mistakes in differential diagnosis, Humphries ignores the fact that the actual number of people reported to be affected by the polio virus is a significant underestimate, and that many suffered mild decrements in ability during their lifetimes, and later post-polio syndrome and, possibly, chronic fatigue syndrome;
     8.  Humphries ignores the cultural changes in the US – having survived the Great Depression and been victorious in World War II, with many previous diseases eliminated or on the decline, with the miracle of antibiotics, parents found an ascending, unpredictable disease that so visibly affected children to be extremely frightening;
     9.  Humphries opinion of the March of Dimes discounts the major role the March of Dimes played in helping polio victims (help that is doubtful would have come from elsewhere) and, by implication, Humphries probably would dismiss various organizations soliciting funds for numerous other “low incidence” diseases and conditions; and
     10.  Humphries ignores post-polio syndrome and, possibly, chronic fatigue syndrome, where studies have found the former and, perhaps, the latter actually a result of damage caused by the polio virus, not misdiagnosed as polio.
Though I think this paper alone makes a compelling case that Humphries lacks credibility, I like to be thorough, so I will be working on subsequent papers. As now planned:
    • Part 2 will focus in more depth on definitions/criteria for paralysis, lab confirmation, when and what types, and differential diagnoses and the role the vaccine played in the decline and disappearance of polio;
    • Part 3 will focus on the Cutter Incident, vaccine-associated polio, the role of tonsillectomies and provocation from other medical injections, and claims by Humphries that DDT and arsenic played a significant role, SV40 vaccine contamination, and discuss the Central Dogma that polio resulted from improved sanitation, together with other variables that partially explain the ascendance of polio; and
    • Part 4 will focus on treatments, including the iron lung, surgeries, immobilizations, various physical therapies, and nutritional approaches.
Basically, I intend to demonstrate that either Humphries is completely wrong (intentionally or not) about every point she so feebly tries to make or she grossly exaggerates, grossly overgeneralizes, and emphasizes ancient history. Based on her approach she would basically negate most of modern medical science. Stay tuned!
Acknowledgements
For valuable feedback and suggestions, thanks to: Sandi Berman; David W. Rose, MA; Dorit Rubinstein Reiss, PhD; Steven A. Rubin, PhD.

Wrong About Polio: A Review of Suzanne Humphries, MD and Roman Bystrianyk’s “Dissolving Illusions” Part 1 (the long version)
This is a longer version of my post on Friday, November 9th, 2018. It is a lengthy discussion of why Suzanne Humphries, MD and Roman Bystrianyk’s book Dissolving Illusions misrepresents the dangers of polio, one in a series of posts that should comprehensively show the problems with their claims. It covers far more than just polio, but is worthwhile for those interested in the details.
Joel A. Harrison on November 10, 2018
Link

[Editor’s note: This is the full version of the post from yesterday, with a much more comprehensive examination of infectious diseases that Humphries illogically compares with polio. Note that a downloadable PDF version of complete paper, including a detailed reference list, can be accessed here.]

[Note that I refer often to Wikipedia articles. I do this because they are easily available, accurate based on my other readings, and include extensive reference lists that I have checked out. However, as the reader will find, I also include numerous other references.]
Introduction
From early childhood, though enjoying Sherlock Holmes, H.G. Wells, Jules Verne, and other works of fiction, I especially liked reading history and science, subscribing to the old adage that “truth is stranger than fiction.” Then I read a book that had a profound effect on me, William H. McNeil’s 1976 Plagues and Peoples. McNeil made a compelling case that much of human history has been determined not by great statesmen, nor military leaders, nor technology; but by the lowly microbe. In the subsequent 40 years, I have read dozens of books and hundreds of articles on each of the various infectious diseases from plague to smallpox to influenza to polio, numerous histories of each, their current status around the world, and, of course, their epidemiology. Along the way I did graduate work in epidemiology, and biostatistics, read numerous textbooks and articles, and audited courses on microbiology and immunology.
Though a long proponent of vaccines, only over the past five years have I focused on mainly writing articles supporting them (Harrison, 2017, Harrison, 2018). I was driven to do so in response to what seems to be an ever-increasing noise and misinformation on vaccine safety and efficacy from anti-vaccinationist groups and web blogs. Since beginning of my writings on vaccines I have contemplated writing on polio. This is not only because polio seems to be one of the antivaccinationist favorite topics, which they often use to demonstrate to their uninformed readers the evils of vaccines and national vaccination programs (e.g., Adams. 2018; Child Health Safety, 2018; Olmsted, 2011, Olmsted, 2016; VacTruth, 2018; whale to, 2018); but also because polio has a special significance for me. As a child I remember my mother not allowing me to go to the local municipal swimming pool nor to the movies during polio season. In my elementary school was a little girl with a steel brace on one leg. During my life I have known several paraplegics, one, in particular, the older sister of one of my oldest andd dearest friends, met a man in the late 1980s who had been in an iron lung for almost 40 years, and several people who suffered from post-polio syndrome. And through my readings I discovered that my hometown, San Diego, had a major epidemic of polio in 1951 and being in the first cohort to receive the new Salk vaccine, I more than likely received a dose from a lot manufactured by Cutter Industries which because of poor production and quality control caused 204 cases of paralytic polio and 10 deaths (to be discussed in a later paper). So, fortunately, I dodged at least two bullets.
I am focusing on Humphries and Bystrianyk’s book for two reasons:
     1.  Their chapter on polio, “Chapter 12. The ‘Disappearance’ of Polio”, pp. 210-261, as far as I can tell, covers each and every claim/assertion made by antivaccinationists together with a large reference list;
     2.  Suzanne Humphries is a medical doctor. Most antivaccinationist articles that I have come across are written by people with little to no background in medicine or any of the other subjects relevant to vaccines, e.g., microbiology, immunology, epidemiology, etc. As a medical doctor one would expect that Humphries has had the basics of the aforementioned subjects and her expertise as an MD, perhaps, has had a greater impact than her antivaccine peers.
In this paper quotes from Humphries and Bystrianyk’s book will be referenced as “(Humphries, p. __).” Note that Humphries uses extensive quotes in her book, so I will do the same.
Unfortunate incidents and avoidable errors do occur, but these rare events should not be the basis on which to decide the merit of things like public health programs, as some, including Suzanne Humphries and Roman Bystrianyk in their book Dissolving Illusions, have attempted. Even more egregious is the attempt to take a monumentally significant public health issue like polio and, using “alternative facts”, minimize its significance. In Humphries’ and Bystrianyk’s book, the subject of this article, they even go so far as to claim that polio was an “insignificant” disease.
Incidence, mortality, disability, suffering: Comparing apples to oranges
From Humphries:
Prevalence of polio, 1912–1969
Since the early 1900s, we have been indoctrinated to believe that polio was a highly prevalent and contagious disease. Graph 12.1 depicts the incidence of various diseases in the United States between 1912 and 1970. Poliomyelitis is the line (with square points) at the bottom and reveals that the incidence was very low when compared to that of other infectious diseases. Polio has also been portrayed as a vicious crippler in the early and mid-1900s when it was habitually diagnosed by doctors who used a very loose definition of the disease. This graph denotes rates of clinical disease, most of which resolved and left no residual paralysis at all.
Given what a low-incidence disease it was, how did polio come to be perceived as such an infamous monster? This is a question worthy of consideration, especially in light of the fact that the rate was far less than other common diseases, some of which declined in incidence to nearly zero with no vaccine at all. Those who still embody a fear of polio may argue that it was a monster because it crippled people, especially children. But it was later revealed, after a vaccine was lauded for the eradication of polio, that much of the crippling was related to factors other than poliovirus, and those factors could not possibly have been affected by any vaccine (pp. 212-213).
Graph 12.1 referenced in the quote above is copied below as Figure 1. Note, that as the graph appears in her book, it is difficult to discern by color which of the lines represent which disease, so I have included a red arrow to indicate the line representing poliomyelitis. The data Humphries used to produce this graph is in Table 1 below Figure 1.
Figure 1: United States disease incidence from 1912 to 1970 (Graph 12.1 in Humphries, 2013, p. 215)Table 1: Rates Per 100,000 Population for Specified Reportable Diseases: 1912 to 1970. Historical Statistics of the United States: Colonial Times to 1970, Part 1. Bureau of the Census (1970), p. 77.
Year	Disease incidence per 100,000 population
	Syphillis	Malaria	Typhoid	Diptheria	Pertussis	Measles	Poliomyleitis	Smallpox
1970	43.8	1.5	0.2	0.2	2.1	23.2	<0.5	
1969	48.1	1.5	0.2	0.1	1.6	12.8	<0.5	
1968	49.9	1.2	0.2	0.1	2 .4	11.l	<0.5	
1967	53.2	1.0	0.2	0.1	4 .9	31.7	<0.5	
1966	57.1	0.3	0.2	0.1	3.9	104.2	0.1	
1965	59.7	0.1	0.2	0.1	3.5	135.1	<0.5	
1964	62 .9	<0.5	0.3	0.2	6.8	239.4	0.1	
1963	69.8	0.1	0.3	0.2	9.1	204.2	0.2	
1962	68.1	0.1	0.3	0.2	9.6	259.0	0.5	
1961	69.7	<0.5	0.4	0.3	6.3	231.6	0.7	
1960	68.0	<0.5	0.5	0.5	8.3	245.4	1.8	
1959	69.3	<0.5	0.5	0.5	22.7	230.1	4.8	
1958	68.5	<0.5	0.6	0.5	18.6	440.5	8.3	
1957	78.8	0.1	0.7	0.7	16.6	285.9	3.2	
1956	77.1	0.1	1.0	0.9	19.0	865.9	9.1	
1955	76.0	0.3	1.0	1.2	38.2	337.9	17.6	
1954	87.5	0.4	1.3	1.3	37.8	423.5	23.9	
1953	100.8	0.8	1.4	1.5	23.5	283.7	22.5	
1952	110.8	4.5	1.5	1.9	28.9	438.5	87.2	
1951	131.8	3.7	1.4	2.6	44.8	345.6	18.5	
1950	154.2	1.4	1.6	3.8	80.1	210.1	22.1	
1949	197.3	2 .8	2.7	5.4	46.7	420.6	28.3	<0.5
1948	234.7	6 .6	2.5	6 .5	51.1	421.0	19.0	<0.5
1947	264.6	10.5	2.8	8.5	109.1	155.0	7.5	0.1
1946	271.7	34.7	2.8	11.7	78.4	496 .8	18.3	0.2
1945	282.3	47 .4	3.7	14.1	101.0	110.2	10.3	0.3
1944	867 .9	43.4	4.0	10.6	82.7	474.3	14.3	0.3
1943	447 .0	40.6	4.1	11.0	142 .9	472.0	9.3	0.6
1942	363.4	44.9	4.6	12.1	142.9	408.8	8.1	0.6
1941	368.2	51.1	6.5	13.5	166.9	671.7	6.8	1.0
1940	359.7	59 .2	7.4	11.8	139.6	220.7	7 .4	2.1
1939	367 .1	63.2	10.0	18.4	140.0	308.2	5.6	7.5
1938	372.0	64.9	11.5	23.5	175.1	633.8	1.3	11.5
1937	264.8	84.2	12.4	22 .2	166.6	249.6	7 .4	9.1
1936	212.6	104.6	12.4	23.4	115.0	284.0	3.5	6.1
1935	205.6	108.1	14.4	30.8	141.9	584.6	8.5	6.8
1934	186.7	105.4	17.6	34.1	209.9	632.6	5.9	4.8
1933	193.4	100.0	18.6	40.2	142.6	319.2	4.0	5.2
1932	208.2	55.0	21.4	48.0	172.5	323.2	3.1	9.0
1931	197 .4	56.7	21.4	57.1	139.l	382.8	12.8	24.4
1930	185.4	80.0	22.1	54.1	135.6	340.8	7.5	39.7
1929	169.2	134.7	19.1	70.1	162.l	300.6	2.4	34.7
1928	174.2	138.2	22.6	75.9	134.3	466.3	4.3	32.7
1927	171.9	118.2	29.2	89.8	152.4	387.6	8.8	31.6
1926	196 .1	98.9	35.5	80.7	172.2	587.1	2.3	28.7
1925	181.2	86.8	40.0	82.1	131.2	194.3	5.3	84.2
1924	174 .2	98.4	31.0	105.6	145.0	463.7	4.6	49.6
1923	156 .2	124.2	31.0	131.4	146.7	680.0	3.1	27 .6
1922	157 .7	142.9	33.0	156 .9	97.7	241.8	2.0	30.8
1921	172.3	174 .7	43.5	190.7		274.6	5.8	94.7
1920	145.3	173.0	33.8	139.0		480.5	2.2	95.9
1919	113 .2		42.9	144.7		203.2	2.8	68.8
1918			50.0	101.5		474.9	2.8	83.1
1917			63.0	183.0		611.6	4.9	52.7
1916			82.3	129.2		621.8	41.1	23.4
1915			74.0	132.7		254.1	8.1	50.2
1914			82.4	152.5		295.8	2.4	66.4
1913			84.2	142.1		368.5	4.0	55.7
1912			81.8	139.0		310.0	5.5	30.8
Note that between years 1944 through 1955 (BOLDED) poliomyelitis incidence can be more clearly seen as increasing than appears in Figure 1 (dashed line indicated by arrow). However, it is not the incidence of a disease that is most relevant, otherwise all the diseases included in Humphries graph pale compared to the common cold and even food poisoning, which an estimated 1 in 6 Americans (48 million people) get every year, resulting in 128,000 hospitalizations, and 3,000 deaths (CDC. Burden of Foodborne Illnesses). What is important are:
     1.  Degree of suffering
     2.  Disability
     3.  Mortality
     4.  Mode of transmission
     5.  Factors affecting the above (e.g., public health measures)
The main focus of this paper is Humphries claim that polio was an “insignificant” disease. However, given that her book covers each of the diseases compared in Figure 1, the following will give a description of each based on the five points listed above, allowing the reader to gain a better picture of each disease, why Humphries is comparing apples to oranges, and, especially how, by focusing on incidence and death, Humphries mostly ignores suffering and disabilities. Besides polio, measles is a prime example of this. Though I believe the following description of each of the diseases is well worth a look, feel free to skip to the Poliomyelitis section below.
Measles
According to Wikipedia:
Measles is a highly contagious infectious disease caused by the measles virus. Symptoms usually develop 10–12 days after exposure to an infected person and last 7–10 days. Initial symptoms typically include fever, often greater than 40 °C (104.0 °F), cough, runny nose, and inflamed eyes. Small white spots known as Koplik’s spots may form inside the mouth two or three days after the start of symptoms. A red, flat rash which usually starts on the face and then spreads to the rest of the body typically begins three to five days after the start of symptoms. Complications occur in about 30% of cases and may include diarrhea, blindness, inflammation of the brain, and pneumonia, among others.
Measles is an airborne disease which spreads easily through the coughs and sneezes of infected people. It may also be spread through contact with saliva or nasal secretions.
People are infectious to others from four days before to four days after the start of the rash.
In May 2015, the journal Science, published a report in which researchers found that the measles infection can leave a population at increased risk for mortality from other diseases for two to three years. (Wikipedia. Measles; see also: CDC. Pink Book. Measles; Cliff, 1993; Mina, 2015; Perry, 2004; Strebel, 2018)
The CDC Pink Book’s Chapter on Measles gives the following statistics:
Before 1963, approximately 500,000 cases and 500 deaths were reported annually, with epidemic cycles every 2–3 years. However, the actual number of cases was estimated at 3–4 million annually. More than 50% of persons had measles by age 6, and more than 90% had measles by age 15. The highest incidence was among 5–9-year-olds, who generally accounted for more than 50% of reported cases. In the years following licensure of vaccine in 1963, the incidence of measles decreased by more than 95%, and 2–3-year epidemic cycles no longer occurred…Some form of residual neurologic damage occurs in as many as 25% of cases [including loss of hearing, seizure disorders, and mental retardation…(CDC. Pink Book. Measles). [thus, up to 250 cases with permanent disabilities]
And from the CDC website on measles:
About one child out of every 1,000 who get measles will develop encephalitis (swelling of the brain) that can lead to convulsions and can leave the child deaf or with intellectual disability (CDC. Measles).
And according to Orenstein:
By the late 1950s, even before the introduction of measles vaccine, measles-related deaths and case fatality rates in the United States had decreased markedly, presumably as a result of improvement in health care and nutrition. From 1956 to 1960, an average of 450 measles-related deaths were reported each year (∼1 death/1000 reported cases), compared with an average of 5,300 measles-related deaths during 1912–1916 (26 deaths/1000 reported cases). Nevertheless, in the late 1950s, serious complications due to measles remained frequent and costly. As a result of measles virus infections, an average of 150,000 patients had respiratory complications and 4,000 patients had encephalitis each year; the latter was associated with a high risk of neurological sequelae and death. These complications and others resulted in an estimated 48,000 persons with measles being hospitalized every year (Orenstein, 2004; see also: Roush, 2007).
Langmuir writes:
Note the stability of the morbidity and the steady downward trend in the mortality. Also, there is the somewhat ominous suggestion of a cessation of this downward trend since 1955 similar to the leveling off of the infant death rates during the past six years. (Langmuir, 1962).[Note that if one looks at Figure 2 below the deaths fluctuate from 1953-1960 within a range, so one should not rely on a single year’s stats]
Figure 2: United States Measles Reported Cases and Deaths per 100,000 Population, 1912-1959 (from Langmuir, 1962, Figure 1).
Humphries writes:
In the case of measles, the death rate had declined by almost 100 percent. You would never know it today, but the dreaded measles was no longer a major issue in the Western world by the time vaccines were deployed (p.174)
And:
…deaths from asthma were 56 times greater, accidents 935 times greater, motor vehicle accidents 323 times greater, other accidents 612 times greater, and heart disease 9,560 times greater (p. 308).
Talk about comparing apples to oranges. Almost all measles deaths are in children, the overwhelming majority with heart disease in middle aged and older adults. And motor vehicle accidents? I’m surprised Humphries didn’t just list the high death rate in those over 65, or murder victims. Maybe in a new edition of her book? As will be clear from my discussion below, the causes, and approaches to prevention, of Humphries hodgepodge of incidence and deaths differ significantly, that is, they are NOT comparable.
Humphries downplays not only deaths; but acute suffering and long-term disabilities. In the case of measles, she discounts an average of 450 deaths per year in the U.S. (even if these were eliminated, the following remains), the 7-10 days suffering, possible diarrhea, otitis media, and seizures, given > 50% of cases were in 5-9 year-olds, their missing up to two weeks of school, the estimated 48,000 hospitalizations, and permanent disabilities. In addition, given that nowadays approximately 60% of families are dual income households, one of the parents would more than likely have to stay home to take care of the child for up to two weeks (Pew Research Center, 2015). As only about 14% have access to paid family leave, for many, a child ill with measles can also represent a substantial financial burden (DeSilver, 2017). Humphries seems unaware of how measles weakens our immune systems, increasing the mortality risk for 2-3 years afterwards (Mina, 2015). Finally, given that the estimated number of cases per year in the U.S. was 3-4 million annually, the actual number of deaths and persons with measles-associated disabilities may have been substantially higher due to under-reporting or misdiagnosis (CDC. Pink Book. Measles). For instance, if a child developed secondary bacteria pneumonia, the death record may only list pneumonia.
Smallpox
According to Wikipedia:
The initial symptoms of the disease include fever and vomiting. This is then followed by formation of sores in the mouth and a skin rash. Transmission occurs through inhalation of airborne variola virus, usually droplets expressed from the oral, nasal, or pharyngeal mucosa of an infected person. It is transmitted from one person to another primarily through prolonged face-to-face contact with an infected person, usually within a distance of 6 feet (1.8 m), but can also be spread through direct contact with infected bodily fluids or contaminated objects (fomites) such as bedding or clothing. Rarely, smallpox has been spread by virus carried in the air in enclosed settings such as buildings, buses, and trains…Smallpox is not notably infectious in the prodromal period and viral shedding is usually delayed until the appearance of the rash, which is often accompanied by lesions in the mouth and pharynx. The virus can be transmitted throughout the course of the illness, but is most frequent during the first week of the rash, when most of the skin lesions are intact. Infectivity wanes in 7 to 10 days when scabs form over the lesions, but the infected person is contagious until the last smallpox scab falls off.
Smallpox is highly contagious, but generally spreads more slowly and less widely than some other viral diseases, perhaps because transmission requires close contact and occurs after the onset of the rash. The overall rate of infection is also affected by the short duration of the infectious stage. In temperate areas, the number of smallpox infections were highest during the winter and spring (Wikipedia. Smallpox; see also: CDC. Smallpox; Dixon, 1962; Fenner, 1988; Kennedy, 2018).
Variola Major vs Variola Minor (Alastrim)
According to Fenner: “Two clinico-epidemiological varieties of smallpox were recognized: variola major (case-fatality rates, 5-40%) and variola minor (case-fatality rates, 0.1-2%) (Fenner, 1988, p. 96; see also: Chapin, 1913; Chapin, 1932).” Note that the American version of variola minor is also called alastrim. Besides variola major’s exponentially higher mortality, blindness and/or severe disfigurement from pockmarks often occurred.
Other complications:
Complications of smallpox [variola major] include bacterial infections of the skin and other organs, pneumonia, generalized sepsis, destructive arthritis in young children and arthropathies, corneal ulceration resulting in blindness, keratitis, osteomyelitis, and encephalitis. The latter, present in approximately 1 in 500 cases (Kennedy, 2018, p.1003).
According to Fenner:
Patients with variola major usually excreted more virus and were thus more infectious than patients with variola minor, and variola major was more likely to overcome the effects of slight residual immunity due to vaccination. On the other hand, the severity of systemic symptoms from the prodromal stage onwards was so great in variola major that most patients were confined to bed and thus their contacts were greatly limited. Patients with variola minor usually had such a mild systemic illness that they were often ambulant throughout the course of the disease, and therefore made many more close contacts (Fenner, 1988, p. 317).
Fenner continues with:
Variola major prevailed throughout the USA until the summer of 1897 but by then had disappeared from the country except for about 100 cases, with 30 deaths, which occurred in 16 different states.
The substrain of variola minor that was later called “alastrim” (see Chapter 2) remained the dominant form of smallpox in the USA thereafter.
Although some cases of variola major were reported every year from 1900 until 1927, there were only 2 major outbreaks during this period. The first, in 1902-1903, affected particularly Boston, New York, Philadelphia, New Jersey and Ohio; variola minor was then prevalent in the Mid-West. The last large epidemic of variola major in the USA occurred in 1924-1925, when some 7400 cases were reported, over one-third of them in 4 cities: Cleveland and Toledo (Ohio), Detroit (Michigan) and Pittsburgh (Pennsylvania).
Vaccination played an important role in both the progressive fall in the incidence of smallpox and in the replacement of variola major by variola minor.
In the year 1927, for the first time, no case of variola major was reported in the USA, and apart from an outbreak in 1929 no further cases were notified until 1946. In that year a soldier returning from Japan introduced smallpox into Seattle, Washington, which resulted in an outbreak of 51 cases, with 16 deaths (Palmquist, 1947). In 1947 a man with undiagnosed haemorrhagic smallpox died in a Manhattan, New York, hospital. Twelve other persons were infected.
The last outbreak of smallpox in the USA occurred in Texas in 1949 (8 cases with 1 death), probably after importation from Mexico. (Fenner, 1988, pp. 328-33)
Thus, mortality in the United States did decrease exponentially in the 20th century as variola minor came to dominate the landscape. However, as long as variola major remained in the world, only those actually exposed to variola minor or vaccinated were at least partially protected from the dangers of variola major, as shown in Table 2 below. Also seen in Table 2, is that though mortality is exponentially lower with variola minor, it was not insignificant:
Table 2: United States of America: numbers of reported cases and deaths from variola major and variola minor, 1900-1950 (from Table 8.8 in Fenner, 1988, p. 330).
	Variola major	Variola minor
Year	Number of cases	Number of deaths	Case-fatality rate (%)	Number of cases	Number of deaths	Case-fatality rate (%)
1900	3,328	603	18.1	17,736	291	1.6
1901	5,332	980	18.4	57,042	396	0.7
1902	10,334	1,841	17.8	62,612	669	1.1
1903	6,113	752	12.3	46,624	828	1.8
1904	5,539	866	15.6	26,158	416	1.6
1905	1,798	272	15.1	17,619	134	0.8
1906	669	44	6.6	14,554	46	0.3
1907	359	23	6.4	18,618	73	0.4
1908	391	27	6.9	33,607	81	0.2
1909	193	36	18.7	23,367	119	0.5
1910	1,216	252	20.1	30,038	177	0.6
1911	359	76	21.2	22,685	98	0.4
1912	1,164	204	17.5	22,402	101	0.5
1913	354	98	27.7	38,046	161	0.4
1914	195	66	33.8	40,279	150	0.4
1915	578	177	20.2	37,803	130	0.3
1916	300	78	26.0	19,440	169	0.9
1917	973	174	17.9	46,535	146	0.3
1918	311	63	20.3	80,023	351	0.4
1919	1,121	172	15.3	61,755	155	0.3
1920	1,214	157	12.9	109,458	291	0.3
1921	3,152	320	10.2	105,335	438	0.4
1922	2,650	643	24.3	30,655	258	0.8
1923	301	65	21.6	30,589	100	0.3
1924	4,782	633	13.2	51,731	263	0.5
1925	2,633	536	20.4	36,748	188	0.5
1926	1,560	238	15.1	31,134	152	0.5
1927	0	–	–	37,977	151	0.4
1928	0	–	–	39,396	141	0.4
1929	59	11	18.6	42,282	145	0.3
1930	0	–	–	48,329	170	0.4
1931	0	–	–	30,151	104	0.3
1932	0	–	–	11,194	52	0.5
1933	0	–	–	6,491	35	0.5
1934	0	–	–	5,371	21	0.4
1935	0	–	–	7,952	23	0.3
1936	0	–	–	7,834	33	0.4
1937	0	–	–	11,673	30	0.3
1938	0	–	–	14,939	46	0.3
1939	0	–	–	9,877	39	0.4
1940	0	–	–	2,795	15	0.5
1941	0	–	–	1,396	12	0.9
1942	0	–	–	865	3	0.3
1943	0	–	–	765	6	0.8
Smallpox (variety not determined)
	Number of cases	Number of deaths	Case-fatality rate (%)
1944	398	9	2.3
1945	346	12	3.5
1946	357	24	6.7
1947	176	?	?
1948	57	?	?
1949	49a	1	2.0
1950	0	–	–
a The last probable occurrence of endemic smallpox
Though mortality was exponentially lower with variola minor, the suffering from variola minor could be substantial as shown in Table 3 below:
Table 3: Frequency of symptoms (percentages of cases) in the pre-eruptive stage in variola major and variola minor (from Table 1.3 in Fenner, 1988, p. 6). As shown in the table below, those infected with variola minor often experienced quite a bit of suffering lasting several weeks:
	Variola major	Variola minor
Symptom	6,942 cases
(Rao, 1972)	12,847 cases
Marsden (1936)	859 cases
(Noble et al., 1970)
Fever	100.0	. .	98.2
Headache	90.0	75.0	79.4
Malaise	. .	. .	66.7
Chills	6.0	34.0	62.4
Anorexia	. .	. .	60.6
Backache	90.0	38.8	44.2
Pharyngitis	15.0	20.6	38.2
Nausea	. .	11.0	37.0
Vomiting	50.0	34.2	30.3
Diarrhea	10.0	. .	3.6
Delirium	15.0	. .	. .
Abdominal colic	13.0	. .	. .
Convulsions	7.0	. .	. .
And, as long as variola major remained in the world, anyone anywhere was at risk from the following:
All the gravely ill patients were also tortured by mucosal symptoms. The tongue was more or less swollen and misshapen and hindered breathing through the mouth. The voice was hoarse and faltering. Swallowing was so painful that the patients refused all nourishment and, in spite of agonizing thirst, often also refused all fluids. We saw patients with deep invasion of the respiratory passages… Wails and groans filled the rooms. The patients were conscious to their last breath (Fenner, 1988, p. 27).
Typhoid and paratyphoid fever
According to Wikipedia:
Typhoid fever, also known simply as typhoid, is a bacterial infection due to Salmonella typhi that causes symptoms. Symptoms may vary from mild to severe and usually begin six to thirty days after exposure. Often there is a gradual onset of a high fever over several days. Weakness, abdominal pain, constipation, and headaches also commonly occur. Diarrhea is uncommon and vomiting is not usually severe. Some people develop a skin rash with rose colored spots. In severe cases there may be confusion. Without treatment, symptoms may last weeks or months. Other people may carry the bacterium without being affected; however, they are still able to spread the disease to others. Typhoid fever is a type of enteric fever along with paratyphoid fever. Typhoid is spread by eating or drinking food or water contaminated with the feces of an infected person. Risk factors include poor sanitation and poor hygiene (Wikipedia. Typhoid fever; see also: CDC. Typhoid Fever; Levine, 2018).
Prior to the antibiotic era, due to a 10% to 20% case-fatality rate, typhoid was a much feared disease. Beginning with chloramphenicol in 1948, the case-fatality rate plummeted to below 1% (Levine, 2018).
As early as 1873, William Budd “clearly described the contagious nature of the disease and incriminated transmission via fecally contaminated water sources (Levine, 2018, p. 114; see also Budd, 1873). Besides a vaccine that conferred some protection and newer versions still given to those traveling to areas where typhoid fever is still endemic, typhoid fever was nearly eliminated by public health approaches, mainly treatment of water; but also safer handling of foods (e.g., Curschmann, 1901; Vaughhan, 1894; Whipple, 1908). As Levine writes:
Whereas chronic carriers constitute the reservoir of S. Typhi, the maintenance of a high incidence of typhoid fever requires conditions that permit amplified transmission of S. Typhi to susceptible persons. Usually this involves fecal contamination of water sources consumed by large numbers of persons. In the later 19th and early 20th centuries, it was demonstrated in Europe and the United States that treatment of municipal water supplied caused the incidence of typhoid fever to plummet, despite the continued existence in the population of large numbers of carriers. Over one to two decades this led to the near-elimination of typhoid fever from many area (Levine, 2018, p. 1142).
Figure 3: Incidence of Typhoid Fever, by Year – United States, 1920-1960 (from CDC. Incidence of Typhoid Fever). Besides Table 1 from the Bureau of the Census above for disease incidence from 1912 to 1970, the graph below shows the rapid decline in incidence of Typhoid Fever from 1920-1960.
Thus, typhoid fever, a mainly waterborne disease, was brought under control by public health measures with vaccinations protecting those traveling abroad and antibiotics those few unfortunate enough to become infected. Note that currently in the United States typhoid fever isn’t even included in the list of foodborne illnesses (CDC, 2016).
Whooping cough (pertussis)
According to Wikipedia:
Whooping cough (also known as pertussis or 100-day cough) is a highly contagious bacterial disease [with] weeks of severe coughing fits. Following a fit of coughing, a high-pitched whoop sound or gasp may occur as the person breathes in. The coughing may last for 10 or more weeks, hence the phrase ‘100-day cough’. The time between infection and the onset of symptoms is usually seven to ten days. Disease may occur in those who have been vaccinated, but symptoms are typically milder [my emphasis].
It is an airborne disease which spreads easily through the coughs and sneezes of an infected person. People are infectious to others from the start of symptoms until about three weeks into the coughing fits. Those treated with antibiotics are no longer infectious after five days.
The classic symptoms of pertussis are a paroxysmal cough, inspiratory whoop, and fainting, or vomiting after coughing. The cough from pertussis has been documented to cause subconjunctival hemorrhages, rib fractures, urinary incontinence, hernias, and vertebral artery dissection. Violent coughing can cause the pleura to rupture, leading to a pneumothorax [lung collapse].
Common complications include pneumonia, bronchitis, encephalopathy, earache, and seizures.
Before vaccines, an average of 178,171 cases was reported in the U.S., with peaks reported every two to five years; more than 93% of reported cases occurred in children under 10 years of age. The actual incidence was likely much higher. After vaccinations were introduced in the 1940s, pertussis incidence fell dramatically to approximately 1,000 by 1976. (Wikipedia. Whooping cough; see also: CDC. Pertussis; CDC. Pink Book. Pertussis; Edwards, 2018)
Also:
In the earliest decades of the 20th century, infection with Bordetella pertussis was essentially universal by school entry. A high cumulative incidence and roughly 1 death per 10 cases…Pertussis was made notifiable in the United States in 1922. For 2 decades, reported cases were never under 100 000 and in 1934 peaked at over 265 000 (Clark, 2014).
The estimated annual average number of cases of pertussis from 1934-1943 was 200,752 and 4,034 deaths (Roush, 1986. reprinted 2007; see also: CDC. Pertussis Cases by Year, 1922-2014). Deaths from Pertussis from 1950 to 1956 declined from 1,118 to 266 (CDC. Pink Book. Appendix E).
Diphtheria
According to Wikipedia:
Diphtheria is an infection caused by the bacterium Corynebacterium diphtheria. Signs and symptoms may vary from mild to severe…Diphtheria is usually spread between people by direct contact or through the air. It may also be spread by contaminated objects. Some people carry the bacteria without having symptoms, but can still spread the disease to others. The symptoms are due to a toxin produced by the bacteria. The symptoms of diphtheria usually begin two to seven days after infection. Symptoms of diphtheria include fever of 38 °C (100.4 °F) or above, chills, fatigue, bluish skin coloration (cyanosis), sore throat, hoarseness, cough, headache, difficulty swallowing, painful swallowing, difficulty breathing, rapid breathing, foul-smelling and bloodstained nasal discharge, and lymphadenopathy. Within two to three days, diphtheria may destroy healthy tissues in the respiratory system. The dead tissue forms a thick, gray coating that can build up in the throat or nose. This thick gray coating is called a “pseudomembrane.” It can cover tissues in the nose, tonsils, voice box, and throat, making it very hard to breathe and swallow. Symptoms can also include cardiac arrhythmias, myocarditis, and cranial and peripheral nerve palsies [various types of paralysis, often accompanied by weakness and the loss of feeling and uncontrolled body movements such as shaking]
Human-to-human transmission of diphtheria typically occurs through the air when an infected individual coughs or sneezes. Breathing in particles released from the infected individual leads to infection. Contact with any lesions on the skin can also lead to transmission of diphtheria, but this is uncommon. Indirect infections can occur, as well. If an infected individual touches a surface or object, the bacteria can be left behind and remain viable.
Diphtheria is fatal in between 5% and 10% of cases. In children under five years and adults over 40 years, the fatality rate may be as much as 20% (Wikipedia. Diphtheria; see also: CDC. Diphtheria; CDC. Pink Book. Diphtheria; Tejpratap, 2018).
According to the CDC Pink Book:
During the 1920s in the United States, 100,000–200,000 cases of diphtheria (140–150 cases per 100,000 population) and 13,000–15,000 deaths were reported each year. In 1921, a total of 206,000 cases and 15,520 deaths were reported. The number of cases gradually declined to about 19,000 in 1945 (15 per 100,000 population). A more rapid decrease began with the widespread use of diphtheria toxoid in the late 1940s (CDC. Pink Book. Diphtheria).
According to Roush the estimated annual average prevaccine from 1936-1945 was 21,053 cases and 1,822 deaths with a rapid decline following the introduction of the vaccine (Roush, 2007).
As Grob writes:
Whooping cough, measles, scarlet fever, and diphtheria—all of which had taken a heavy toll among children in the nineteenth century—began to fall as a cause of mortality even the prevalence rates often remained high. By 1940 these diseases no longer posed a serious threat to life. Survival rates among children were correspondingly enhanced. Mortality rates in the 1-to-4 year group fell from 19.8 per 1,000 to 2.9 in 1940.
The decline in mortality from infectious diseases associated with childhood admit no simple explanation. The case of diphtheria is something of an exception, largely because effective interventions became available in the 1890s.
By 1894 an antitoxin with therapeutic qualities had been developed, and two decades later an effective means of immunizing children became available with the introduction of the toxin-antitoxin. Yet the precise role played by both in reducing mortality from diphtheria is ambiguous…There is some evidence that the emergence of a dominant strain of mitis [Editor’s note: a variant of the bacterium that caused a relatively mild form of the disease] reduced the virulence of the disease. Antitoxin serum may therefore have merely assisted a natural decline of the disease already under way. During the 1920s …immunization campaigns probably led to the eventual disappearance of the disease by World War II (Grob, 2002, pp. 205-6).
Rosen writes:
By 1900, diphtheria could be diagnosed by precise bacteriological methods, the sick person could be treated with diphtheria antitoxin, and well carriers could be detected, thus making possible really effective control. The next important step was to be made in the direct prevention of the disease. This was achieved by active mass immunization…In 1920 active immunization of school children began…by [1940], the disease had been virtually eliminated as a cause of death, with the mortality rate at 1.1 per 100,000. This was in striking contrast to a rate of 785 per 100,000 in 1894.
That the drop in diphtheria morbidity and mortality is not wholly due to preventive immunization appears to be indicated by the fact that this decline set in actually in the nineteenth century before diphtheria antitoxin began to be used generally, and continue progressively even before preventive immunization became widespread. The death rate among children up to 10 years of age in New York City was 785 per 100,000 in 1894, declining to less than 300 in 1900; and in 1920, when active immunization of school children began, it fell below 100…Certainly, the downward course of diphtheria morbidity and mortality has at least been accelerated by preventive immunization (Rosen, 1993, pp. 312-314).
From Rosen, as with smallpox, diphtheria may well have mutated to a more benign form, though still lethal for many, and antitoxin and finally a vaccine ended its reign.
Syphilis and sequaelae
According to Wikipedia:
Syphilis is a sexually transmitted infection caused by the bacterium Treponema pallidum subspecies pallidum. The signs and symptoms of syphilis vary depending in which of the four stages it presents (primary, secondary, latent, and tertiary). The primary stage classically presents with a single chancre (a firm, painless, non-itchy skin ulceration) but there may be multiple sores. In secondary syphilis a diffuse rash occurs, which frequently involves the palms of the hands and soles of the feet. There may also be sores in the mouth or vagina. In latent syphilis, which can last for years, there are few or no symptoms. In tertiary syphilis there are gummas (soft non-cancerous growths), neurological, or heart symptoms.
Syphilis is transmitted primarily by sexual contact or during pregnancy from a mother to her fetus; the spirochete is able to pass through intact mucous membranes or compromised skin. It is thus transmissible by kissing near a lesion, as well as oral, vaginal, and anal sex. Approximately 30% to 60% of those exposed to primary or secondary syphilis will get the disease.
Condom use reduces the likelihood of transmission during sex, but does not completely eliminate the risk. Congenital syphilis in the newborn can be prevented by screening mothers during early pregnancy and treating those who are infected.
Syphilis can be effectively treated with antibiotics (Wikipedia. Syphilis; see also: CDC. Syphilis).
Syphilis differs from the other diseases in Humphries comparison. It is the only one that depends on “intentional”, avoidable behaviors.
Jabbour writes:
Around the turn of the twentieth century, syphilis was a public health disaster in the United States of America. Because of the lack of official reporting of cases to public authorities, estimates of its incidence are difficult to obtain; however, the figure has been estimated conservatively at ten percent to fifteen percent of the general population from about 1900 to 1920, although its occurrence was presumed to be higher among men than women. Furthermore, since it is transmitted primarily through sexual contact, syphilis was a huge stigma that all individuals wanted to avoid. When people did contract the disease, they were therefore inclined to hide it from the public so as to avoid being permanently branded by their communities. Because of the disgrace associated with syphilis, the topic was generally avoided by the public and the media, such that a veil of secrecy came to conceal it.
Syphilis represented a unique public health challenge because it carried with it a huge stigma and because it was transmitted by sexual contact [my emphasis] (Jabbour, 2000).
With the advent of penicillin in 1943, syphilis became curable. “A rarity in the interplay of antibiotics and bacteria, penicillin has remained effective in the treatment of T. pallidum since its introduction, and it continues to be an efficacious first line therapy (Willeford, 2016).”
The American Sexual Health Association was founded in 1913 to fight prostitution and the venereal disease epidemic through public education on sexually transmitted disease and working to break down the social stigma attached to venereal diseases. During both World Wars they were instrumental in breaking up prostitution rings targeting military personnel (Wikipedia. American Sexual Health Association). In 1960 it changed its name to American Social Health Association and continues to this day. Various groups developed programs, including textbooks, “to shape and tame ‘the native capacities’ of impoverished children into socially acceptable, monogamous heterosexuals” (Egan, 2009).
An example of an excellent early medical book is Vedder’s 1918, Syphilis and Public Health. The book includes statistics, methods of transmission, and “Methods that May Be Taken by the Individual to Prevent Genital Infection [and] Public Health Measures”. An excellent book on the history of syphilis in the U.S. since 1880 is: Allan M. Brandt (1987). No Magic Bullet: A Social History of Venereal Disease in the United States Since 1880 (Enlarged Edition). Oxford University Press.
Malaria
Mikael Häggström Wikipedia. Malaria
According to Wikipedia:
Malaria is a mosquito-borne infectious disease affecting humans and other animals caused by parasitic protozoans (a group of single-celled microorganisms) belonging to the Plasmodium group. Malaria causes symptoms that typically include fever, tiredness, vomiting, and headaches. In severe cases it can cause yellow skin, seizures, coma, or death. Symptoms usually begin ten to fifteen days after being bitten.
The risk of disease can be reduced by preventing mosquito bites through the use of mosquito nets and insect repellents, or with mosquito control measures such as spraying insecticides and draining standing water. Several medications are available to prevent malaria in travellers to areas where the disease is common.
The classic symptom of malaria is paroxysm—a cyclical occurrence of sudden coldness followed by shivering and then fever and sweating, occurring every two days (tertian fever) in P. vivax and P. ovale infections, and every three days (quartan fever) for P. malariae. P. falciparum infection can cause recurrent fever every 36–48 hours, or a less pronounced and almost continuous fever.
Malaria has several serious complications. Among these is the development of respiratory distress, which occurs in up to 25% of adults and 40% of children with severe P. falciparum malaria. Although rare in young children with severe malaria, acute respiratory distress syndrome occurs in 5–25% of adults and up to 29% of pregnant women.
Malaria in pregnant women is an important cause of stillbirths, infant mortality, abortion and low birth weight, particularly in P. falciparum infection, but also with P. vivax.
Although P. falciparum traditionally accounts for the majority of deaths, recent evidence suggests that P. vivax malaria is associated with potentially life-threatening conditions about as often as with a diagnosis of P. falciparum infection.
Symptoms of malaria can recur after varying symptom-free periods.
Methods used to prevent malaria include medications, mosquito elimination and the prevention of bites. There is no vaccine for malaria. The presence of malaria in an area requires a combination of high human population density, high Anopheles mosquito population density and high rates of transmission from humans to mosquitoes and from mosquitoes to humans. If any of these is lowered sufficiently, the parasite will eventually disappear from that area, as happened in North America, Europe and parts of the Middle East. However, unless the parasite is eliminated from the whole world, it could become re-established if conditions revert to a combination that favors the parasite’s reproduction (Wikipedia. Malaria; see also: CDC. Malaria).
Though many articles and papers emphasize the public health contribution to the decline of malaria in the United States (e.g., Andrews, 1950; Andrews, 1963; Wikipedia. National Malaria Eradication Plan; CDC. Elimination of Malaria in the United States (1947-1951); Sledge, 2013), Gerard Grob, Professor of the History of Medicine at Rutgers University, paints a slightly different historical picture, emphasizing economic policies:
The disappearance of malaria did not follow the introduction of any public health measures or novel medical therapies. Indeed, the fact that the disease established such a firm foothold in the United States at all was surprising; malaria, after all, was a tropical disease. Settlement patterns near waterways, disruption of drainage patterns, and agricultural practices, however, combined to create optimum conditions for the spread of the disease by providing mosquitoes with ideal breeding sites. In the South the Anopheles quadrimaculatis was the primary vector. This mosquito breeds in still water, prefers an alkaline pH, and has an affinity to live in buildings rather than the wild.
At the beginning of the Great Depression of the 1930s, the areas with high malarial morbidity and mortality rates included parts of South Carolina, Georgia, Florida and Alabama, the Mississippi Delta region, and the portion of the Red River Valley near the junction of Oklahoma, Arkansas, Louisiana, and Texas. In many of these places human environmental modifications proved crucial. The experience of the Mississippi region is instructive. This area was devoted to cotton cultivation and provided an ideal environment for mosquito breeding because of the multiplicity of ponds of still water than followed the receding of river floods in the spring season. Agricultural laborers tended to live close to the fields, and provided a reservoir of infected and susceptible persons…Generally speaking, malaria had long since disappeared in most urban sites.
Although drainage projects and the use of insecticides became more common after 1900, neither played decisive roles in the disappearance of the disease. Faust, a leading authority…indicated that improving economic conditions may have played an important role.
More recently Margaret Humphreys has emphasized the critical role of population movements. During the 1930s people moved from urban area with high unemployment rates and returned to abandoned hacks in the countryside; many of these were located adjacent to stagnant water. The migration of infected persons further assisted the spread of the disease. By the end of the decade, however, the situation was reversed; outmigration from the southern countryside was characteristic. New Deal agricultural legislation encouraged large-scale farming and mechanization, which in turn depopulated rural areas and hastened the growth of towns and cities outside the infective zone. As the number of infected persons declined, the ability of mosquitoes to spread malaria diminished correspondingly. The malaria parasite, in other words, depended on frontier conditions of poverty and proximity to water. As rural southern poverty diminished, the parasite disappeared (Grob, 2002, pp. 185-6; see also: Barreca, 2007; Faust, 1945; Humphreys, 1996).
As can be seen from the Table 1 above, by 1946 the incidence of malaria in the United States had plummeted. Also note the continuous decline in mortality for malaria from the figure below:Figure 4: Morbidity and mortality rates for malaria in all States reporting cases and deaths, 1920 to 1940 (Chart 3 in Andrews, 1963).
And, for example: “Today deaths resulting from malaria naturally acquired in the United States are probably considerably less than 10 per annum, as contrasted with nearly 5000 annually during the period 1933-1935 (Faust, 1951).
Malaria, a mosquito-borne disease, showed an exponential decline in both morbidity and mortality for the first half of the 20th Century, and was basically eliminated in the United States by the end of World War II through economic policies and public health measures.
Poliomyelitis
According to the CDC Pink Book Chapter on Poliomyelitis:
Poliovirus is a member of the enterovirus subgroup…Enteroviruses are transient inhabitants of the gastrointestinal tract.
There are three poliovirus serotypes (P1, P2, and P3). There is minimal heterotypic immunity between the three serotypes.
The virus enters through the mouth, and primary multiplication of the virus occurs at the site of implantation in the pharynx and gastrointestinal tract. The virus is usually present in the throat and in the stool before the onset of illness. One week after onset there is less virus in the throat, but virus continues to be excreted in the stool for several weeks. The virus invades local lymphoid tissue, enters the bloodstream, and then may infect cells of the central nervous system. Replication of poliovirus in motor neurons of the anterior horn and brain stem results in cell destruction and causes the typical manifestations of poliomyelitis.
Clinical FeaturesThe incubation period for nonparalytic poliomyelitis is 3-6 days. For the onset of paralysis in paralytic poliomyelitis, the incubation period usually is 7 to 21 days.
The response to poliovirus infection is highly variable and has been categorized on the basis of the severity of clinical presentation.
Up to 72% of all polio infections in children are asymptomatic. Infected persons without symptoms shed virus in the stool and are able to transmit the virus to others.
Approximately 24% of polio infections in children consist of a minor, nonspecific illness without clinical or laboratory evidence of central nervous system invasion. This clinical presentation is known as abortive poliomyelitis, and is characterized by complete recovery in less than a week. This is characterized by a low grade fever and sore throat.
Nonparalytic aseptic meningitis (symptoms of stiffness of the neck, back, and/or legs), usually following several days after a prodrome similar to that of minor illness, occurs in 1%–5% of polio infections in children. Increased or abnormal sensations can also occur. Typically these symptoms will last from 2 to 10 days, followed by complete recovery.
Outcomes of poliovirus infection:
Fewer than 1% of all polio infections in children result in flaccid paralysis. Paralytic symptoms generally begin 1 to 18 days after prodromal symptoms and progress for 2 to 3 days. Generally, no further paralysis occurs after the temperature returns to normal. The prodrome may be biphasic, especially in children, with initial minor symptoms separated by a 1- to 7-day period from more major symptoms. Additional prodromal signs and symptoms can include a loss of superficial reflexes, initially increased deep tendon reflexes and severe muscle aches and spasms in the limbs or back. The illness progresses to flaccid paralysis with diminished deep tendon reflexes, reaches a plateau without change for days to weeks, and is usually asymmetrical. Strength then begins to return. Patients do not experience sensory losses or changes in cognition.
Many persons with paralytic poliomyelitis recover completely and, in most, muscle function returns to some degree. Weakness or paralysis still present 12 months after onset is usually permanent.
Paralytic polio is classified into three types, depending on the level of involvement. Spinal polio is most common, and during 1969–1979, accounted for 79% of paralytic cases. It is characterized by asymmetric paralysis that most often involves the legs. Bulbar polio leads to weakness of muscles innervated by cranial nerves and accounted for 2% of cases during this period. Bulbospinal polio, a combination of bulbar and spinal paralysis, accounted for 19% of cases.
The death-to-case ratio for paralytic polio is generally 2%–5% among children and up to 15%–30% for adults (depending on age). It increases to 25%–75% with bulbar involvement.Transmission 
Person-to-person spread of poliovirus via the fecal-oral route is the most important route of transmission, although the oral-oral route is possible.Temporal PatternPoliovirus infection typically peaks in the summer months in temperate climates. There is no seasonal pattern in tropical climates.CommunicabilityPoliovirus is highly infectious, with seroconversion rates among susceptible household contacts of children nearly 100%, and greater than 90% among susceptible household contacts of adults. Persons infected with poliovirus are most infectious from 7 to 10 days before and after the onset of symptoms, but poliovirus may be present in the stool from 3 to 6 weeks (CDC. Pink Book. Poliomyelitis; see also: CDC. What Is Polio?; Sutter, 2018; Wikipedia. Poliomyelitis).
While the other diseases discussed above were on the decline, polio was on the rise. Trevelyan (2005):
A disease originally considered mildly contagious is now regarded as very contagious—almost as much as measles …From an endemic disease it has tended to become epidemic and is now a common and periodic scourge and incidentally an item of great public interest. Poliomyelitis is one of the important emergent viral diseases of the twentieth century. From an apparently rare clinical condition—occurring only sporadically or in small outbreaks prior to the late nineteenth century— poliomyelitis had, by the 1940s and 1950s, emerged as an epidemic disease of global proportions.
While faecal contamination (of fingers, eating utensils, milk or foodstuffs) is considered to be the more common means of transmission, [droplet spread from the pharynx, a corridor of spread used by other childhood diseases like chicken-pox, diphtheria, measles, and rubella] is a critical second strand in the person-to-person propagation of the disease. Indeed, among older populations, and where high standards of sanitation are maintained, droplet spread may be the predominant route of poliovirus transmission. Finally, we note that, in contrast to some other diseases that involve faecal-oral transmission (notably, cholera), contaminated water supplies are not a prerequisite for major epidemics of poliomyelitis.
Infection with poliovirus is overwhelmingly subclinical, with the estimated ratio of inapparent to severe (paralytic) infections ranging up to 850:1. There were thirty-nine polio epidemics in the U.S. between 1910- 1971 (Trevelyan, 2005, pp. 35-36; see also: Smallman-Raynor, 2006).
[Note that the Trevelyan article and especially the Smallman-Raynor book cover in detail the history and geography of polio epidemics in the United States]
Swimming pools, chlorine, and polio
As I mentioned in the introduction, during polio season my mother didn’t allow me to go to the municipal swimming pool. Turns out, mother knows best, at least, sometimes. Chlorine does kill the polio virus, though not immediately. However, the chlorine must come in contact with the virus and if one child infected with the virus is leaking fecal matter in a swimming pool, only virus particles at the surface of the fecal matter can be reached by the chlorine, so other children can easily swallow the microscopic polio-infested bits of fecal matter. One study of polio virus particles, not fecal matter, concluded: “Complete inactivation of enteric viruses (beyond the limit of detection) was not achieved by the usual conditions for bacterial disinfection of water supplies …The results suggest that inactivation of enteric viruses in water at pH 7, 25 C, requires a minimum free residual chlorine concentration of 0.3 ppm for contact periods of at least 30 minutes” (Kelly, 1958). And actual studies from water samples from swimming pools found that chlorine had been effective at killing bacteria; but not viruses (Keswick, 1981; see also: Bates, 1977; Payment, 1985; Sinclair, 2009).
In other words, what worked for typhoid, a bacteria, didn’t work for polio, a virus.
Polio epidemics, incidence, morbidity (paralysis), and mortality
Humphries graph above, Figure 1, and Table 1 from the Bureau of the Census also above give the incidence of poliomyelitis from 1912-1969/70. However, to repeat what I wrote above:
It is not the incidence of a disease that is most relevant, otherwise all the diseases included in Humphries graph pale compared to the common cold and even food poisoning, which an estimated 1 in 6 Americans (48 million people) get every year, resulting in 128.000 hospitalizations, and 3,000 deaths (CDC. Burden of Foodborne Illnesses). What is important are:
     1.  Degree of suffering
     2.  Disability
     3.  Mortality
     4.  Mode of transmission
     5.  Factors affecting the above (e.g., public health measures)
Prior to 1951, reported polio cases were not separately characterized as paralytic versus non-paralytic. Humphries argues in her chapter that even the classification of these cases is suspect, lacking laboratory confirmation, and changing criteria for defining paralysis. In Part 2, I will discuss in more detail criteria for classifying cases, both clinical and laboratory, and differential diagnoses. For this paper, my focus is on Humphries claim: “Given what a low-incidence disease it was, how did polio come to be perceived as such an infamous monster? This is a question worthy of consideration, especially in light of the fact that the rate was far less than other common diseases (Humphries, p. 213).” Keep in mind that whatever Humphries claims, at the time both doctors and the public believed the data and, as Parts 2 and 3 will show, they were right. As I will discuss in this paper and in Part 2, the fact that some cases were misdiagnosed is not questioned, something one finds in all aspects of medicine; but the vast majority of cases reported as polio were polio!
Polio mortality
First, let’s look at deaths, something even Humphries can’t claim were misdiagnosed.Figure 5: gives the death rates for polio per 100,000 population from 1910-1975 (from Isabella B, 2015).Table 4. The following table from the CDC Pink Book Appendix E allows one to compare death rates from several of the diseases used in Humphries comparison graph. The table also includes paralytic cases separately starting in 1951. Appendix E only listed total cases for 1951-1953, so I added in parentheses the number of reported paralytic cases (Post-Polio Health International).Reported cases and deaths from vaccine preventable diseases, united states, 1950-1982
	Measles	Diphtheria	Pertussis	Polio (paralytic)
†Total reported cases From 1951, MMWR separated paralytic and nonparalytic cases. Before 1951, MMWR included both as Total Cases.
Year	Cases	Deaths	Cases	Deaths	Cases	Deaths	Cases	Deaths
1950	319,124	468	5,796	410	120,718	1,118	33,300†	1,904
1951	530,118	683	3,983	302	68,687	951	28,386†
(10,037)	1,551
1952	683,077	618	2,960	217	45,030	402	57,879†
(21,269)	3,145
1953	449,146	462	2,355	156	37,129	270	35,592†
(15,648)	1,450
1954	682,720	518	2,041	145	60,886	373	18,308	1,368
1955	555,156	345	1,984	150	62,786	467	13,850	1043
1956	611,936	530	1,568	103	31,732	266	7,911	566
1957	486,799	389	1,211	81	28,295	183	2,499	221
1958	763,094	552	918	74	32,148	177	3,697	255
1959	406,162	385	934	72	40,005	269	6,289	454
1960	441,703	380	918	69	14,809	118	2,525	230
1960	423,919	434	617	68	11,468	76	988	90
1962	481,530	408	444	41	17,749	83	762	60
1963	385,156	364	314	45	17,135	115	396	41
1964	458,083	421	293	42	13,005	93	106	17
1965	261,904	276	164	18	6,799	55	61	16
1966	204,136	261	209	20	7,717	49	106	9
1967	62,705	81	219	32	9,718	37	40	16
1968	22,231	24	260	30	4,810	36	53	24
1969	25,826	41	241	25	3,285	13	18	13
1970	47,351	89	435	30	4,249	12	31	7
1971	75,290	90	215	13	3036	18	17	18
1972	32,275	24	152	10	3,287	6	29	2
1973	26,690	23	228	10	1,759	5	7	10
1974	22,094	20	272	5	2,402	14	7	3
1975	24,374	20	307	5	1,738	8	13	9
1976	41,126	12	128	7	1,010	7	10	16
1977	57,345	15	84	5	2,177	10	19	16
1978	26,871	11	76	4	2,063	6	8	13
1979	13,597	6	59	1	1,623	6	22	1
1980	13,506	11	3	1	1,730	11	9	2
1981	3,124	2	5	0	1,248	6	10	0
1982	1714	2	2	1	1,895	4	12	0
As can be seen from the table, the number of deaths from polio was substantially higher from 1950-1956 than any of the other disease. Perhaps, as from 1953, Humphries doesn’t consider 3,145 deaths from polio, mainly children, of any importance? Note that I will discuss in Part 2 how these cases were confirmed to be polio. Note also from the table above that number 2 in number of deaths from 1950 on was measles, with a high of 683 in 1951, just a minor blip on the screen according to Humphries, to repeat what she wrote: “In the case of measles, the death rate had declined by almost 100 percent. You would never know it today, but the dreaded measles was no longer a major issue in the Western world by the time vaccines were deployed (p.174).”
Polio morbidity/paralysis
Though as discussed above, “fewer than 1% of all polio infections in children result in flaccid paralysis and most did eventually regain some or complete mobility;” however, given the large number infected during epidemics, there were still a substantial number of victims paralyzed. In addition, as polio doesn’t affect the sensory nerves, many suffered intense pain and months to years to recover (e.g., Sass, 1996; Seavey, 1998; Silver, 2007).
Humphries writes:
The practice among doctors before 1954 was to diagnose all patients who experienced even short-term paralysis (24 hours) with “polio.” In 1955, the year the Salk vaccine was released, the diagnostic criteria became much more stringent. If there was no residual paralysis 60 days after onset, the disease was not considered to be paralytic polio. This change made a huge difference in the documented prevalence of paralytic polio because most people who experience paralysis recover prior to 60 days. Dr. Greenberg said:
The change in 1955 meant that we were reporting a new disease, namely, paralytic poliomyelitis with a longer-lasting paralysis. Furthermore diagnostic procedures have continued to be refined. Coxsackie virus and aseptic meningitis have been distinguished from paralytic poliomyelitis. Prior to 1954 large numbers of these cases were mislabeled as paralytic poliomyelitis. Thus, simply by changes in diagnostic criteria, the number of paralytic cases was predetermined to decrease in 1955-1957, whether or not any vaccine was used (Humphries, p. 219).
Note that from Figure 6 below, even with Greenberg’s adjustments, there remained a substantial number of paralytic cases, e.g., 1951 (7,000), 1952 (14,000). Note the black portion of each bar.
Figure 6: Dr. Greenberg’s chart showing what the incidence, total cases of paralytic polio would have been in former years if the diagnostic criteria of 1959 had been used (from Ratner, 1960, p. 5).
Humphries goes on to write:
As a case in point on how much paralytic disease thought to be polio was not at all associated with polioviruses, consider the well-documented Michigan epidemic of 1958. This epidemic occurred four years into the Salk vaccine campaign. An in-depth analysis of the diagnosed cases revealed that more than half of them were not poliovirus associated at all [AND then quotes from the paper] In a large number of paralytic as well as nonparalytic patients poliovirus was not the cause (Humphries, p. 219).
Let’s look at the actual data from the Michigan study; but first, according to Brown (1960):
An additional correlation of clinical and laboratory information was made possible by the fact that 550 of the patients in the Detroit area were examined for muscles weakness 60 days after onset of disease. The results are presented in table 7 [Table 5 below] in terms of the degree of paralysis two months after infections, and they are arranged according to the clinical diagnosis at the time of admission to hospital and according to the results of laboratory tests carried out on specimens from these patients. It is obvious that most of the 308 patients considered to be nonparalytic on admission were also classified in that category two months later. Virus was isolated from only one-half of those among whom ECHO and Coxsackie viruses were equally responsible with poliovirus for the infections. Among the 242 patients originally diagnosed as paralytic, 187, or 77% were confirmed by laboratory tests to have poliomyelitis. The vast majority of these (84%) were found to have residual paralysis 60 days after onset of the illness, and it is of interest that 83% of these paralytic patients were unvaccinated and only four, or 2.5%, had received three doses of vaccine.
Table 5: Correlation of Laboratory Findings of Poliomyelitis with Muscle Examination Performed 60 Days from Onset of Illness (from Table 7 in Brown, 1960).
Original diagnosis	Laboratory diagnosis	Results of muscle examination, No.
Type	No.	Type	No.	NP*	P1a	P2b	P3c
Nonparalytic	308	Polio	66	56	4	1	3
		ECHO	53	52	1	. . .	. . .
		Coxsackie	41	40	. . .	1	. . .
		Negative	148	143	5	. . .	. . .
Paralytic	242	Polio	187	29	49	67	42
		ECHO	2	. . .	2	. . .	…
		Negative	53	20	11	15	7
* NP = non paralytic b P2 = significant paralysis
a P1 = minor involvement c P3 = sever paralysis or death
In Part 2, I will discuss in more depth changing definitions of paralysis, labs, and differential diagnoses; but as should be clear from the above:
     1.  Even with Greenberg’s adjustments, there was a significant number of cases of paralysis.
     2.  While Humphries, based on the introduction to Brown’s paper, stated, “An in-depth analysis of the diagnosed cases revealed that more than half of them were not poliovirus associated at all,” the introduction doesn’t separate the paralytic cases from the non-paralytic ones, while for the paralytic cases, the paper actually states that 77% were laboratory confirmed to be poliomyelitis and 84% of these had residual paralysis 60 days later. So, rather than “more than half of them were not poliovirus associated,” 77% were and 65% had paralysis 60 days later, based on criteria used by Greenberg. Didn’t Humphries read the entire paper? In addition, as Brown states: “Antibody determinations were possible on 185 of the 292 patients from whom poliovirus had been isolated,” so, for the cases that were not lab confirmed, this does not mean that they were not caused by poliomyelitis (Brown, 1960, p. 109).
So, Humphries displays a callous disregard for the significant number of cases with long-term paralysis and, based on her use of the Brown paper, her credibility is highly questionable!
Humphries probably missed that Greenberg, in discussing the incidence of paralytic polio up to 1957 also stated:
The present increase, I believe, is caused by a long-term, increasing trend in the incidence of the condition or disease we now call paralytic poliomyelitis. Without doubt, the increasing trend has been reduced to some extent by the Salk vaccine…If there were no other vaccine, complete vaccination of all susceptible persons in the population with Salk vaccine would be justifiable (Ratner, 1960, p. 89).
Humphries probably missed that Greenberg later chaired the Committee for the Study of Poliomyelitis Vaccines finding:
The development of vaccines against poliomyelitis has been a major achievement of modern preventive medicine. It might seem remarkable that United States policies in regard to poliomyelitis vaccination are being reexamined in view of the extraordinary success of the present program. Recently, serious questions have been raised about the present policy that advocates the use of the live attenuated oral poliovirus vaccine (OPV) to the virtual exclusion of the killed, or inactivated poliomyelitis vaccine (IPV). This policy has been in effect since 1962 when the decision was made to change from the use of IPV even though paralytic disease had decreased dramatically in the eight years since its introduction [my emphasis].
In considering the available data with particular reference to the experience in countries where only IPV has been used, the committee concluded that when properly used, either vaccine is highly effective both in preventing disease and in reducing circulation of wild virus in the community.
Both IPV and OPV are remarkably safe vaccines, although as indicated, rare cases of vaccine-associated paralytic disease occur in OPV recipients and their contacts.
The committee urges the United States to set the following goal:
To achieve more than 90 percent immunization status—as other countries have already done—as soon as possible. When this goal is achieved, contact cases will virtually disappear. Within five years aim for no less than 80 percent immunization status; in 10 years, for no less than 90 percent immunization status (Greenberg, 1977, pp. 1-11; see also: Nightingale, 1977).
So, with further data, based on the criteria for paralysis that Greenberg used to adjust the earlier data, where he concluded the vaccine reduced the incidence of cases, with additional data, his original conclusion not only was right, but proved even more valid. How did Humphries miss this?
Just to be clear, the changed definition of paralytic cases explained by Greenberg did eliminate a substantial number of cases of paralysis, as many as 30,000 during the first half of the 1950s; but a significant number of paralytic cases remained and in the following years, based on the revised definition, following the introduction of the vaccine, these numbers continued to decline until there were none, so, whatever some claim, the evidence for the effectiveness of the vaccine is substantial and undeniable.
And finally, Bruno makes a compelling case that the total number of people infected with the virus, even some with mild paralysis, was actually underestimated. And as discussed below under the subheading, Post-polio syndrome, the polio virus did result in severe neuron damage in many of these cases. Bruno writes:
Patients Did Not Present for Diagnosis. Failure to present for diagnosis may have resulted from symptoms being very mild or not being seen as indicative of poliovirus infection and from patients, especially those who were poor, not having access to or being financially unable to travel for medical care.
Paralytic Polio Was Underdiagnosed. Studies document the underdiagnosis of paralytic polio. Shaw and Levin reported that “mild degrees of muscle weakness may be easily overlooked” if manual muscle testing were employed without a functional assessment of strength.
Polio Cases Were Not Reported. Although diagnosis may have been more accurate and reporting to public health authorities more likely at city hospitals, the number and severity of polio cases during the epidemics may have prevented overwhelmed physicians from reporting the occurrence of polio, especially NPP, to local public health authorities…Furthermore, the Centers for Disease Control did not separately tabulate cases of nonparalytic and paralytic polio until 1951 and did not require the reporting of polio cases until the late 1950s (Bruno, 2000).
And Humphries continues her callous dismissal of the cases of paralytic poliomyelitis:
Wild poliovirus was never the big killer or paralyzer the public was led to believe it was through the many frightening images shown repeatedly in the 1950s. Dr. Lennette, a well-respected virologist and pioneer of diagnostic virology with the California Department of Health, said in reflection on September 1987:
Actually, economically the disease wasn’t very important. Secondly, not many cases were seen in this country. There weren’t too many people paralyzed from polio in any one neighborhood, so it never made much of an impact (See also Graph 12.1.) (Humphries, p. 224).
For a little perspective, according to the National Cancer Institute, “Among children ages 0 to 14 years, it is estimated that 10,270 will be diagnosed with cancer and 1,190 will die of the disease in 2017 (National Cancer Institute, 2017). For Cerebral Palsy, according to the Texas Adoption Resource Exchange: “About 8,000 babies and infants are diagnosed with the condition each year. In addition, some 1,200-1,500 preschool age children are recognized each year to have cerebral palsy (Texas Adoption Resource Exchange, 2018). And as discussed below, approximately 4,531 new cases of Muscular Dystrophy are reported in the U.S. per year. According to the National League of Cities: “The most recent data from the U.S. Census Bureau (2007) counted 39,044 general purpose local governments, which includes 19,492 municipal governments, 16,519 township governments and 3.033 county governments (National League of Cities, 2018). Obviously, depending on one’s definition of neighborhoods, the number would be larger than the number of local governments. So, the likelihood of one, let alone more of any of the above in a neighborhood is small. Yet, many Americans were and are aware of them and support efforts, both research and care.
Humphries omits the paragraph preceding her quote from Hughes:
Yes, there were more people who went into the field because Roosevelt was dramatizing his incapacities—not intentionally—but he was dramatizing in the sense that, whenever he got up to get to the podium to speak, it was quite an effort on his part. He was really handicapped. And this gave people some awareness of what the disease was all about [my emphasis] (Hughes, 1982, p. 22).
So, Americans, even if not in their neighborhoods, were reminded of just how serious a condition paralytic poliomyelitis was as with other “low incidence” childhood diseases and disabilities. Keep in mind that from the 1916 epidemic on many neighborhoods had witnessed first-hand paralytic poliomyelitis. In Part 2 I will address whether FDR actually had polio or Guillain-Barré; but at the time people believed it and through the March of Dimes, the suffering many children were experiencing.
So, polio, with 7,000 documented cases of paralysis (see above) or more, should be dismissed as unimportant, I wonder which one of the above and many other disabilities and diseases affecting mainly children, given their “low incidence,” does Humphries also think we should ignore?
To summarize
Figure 1 from Humphries compares apples to oranges. Typhoid fever, caused by a bacterium, was basically eliminated by clean water and other public health measures. Malaria, a mosquito-borne protozoan, was ended in the US by mainly economic changes together with public health measures. Syphilis is still a problem because it depends on human behavior. Diphtheria began its decline, perhaps based on mutating to a more benign form, with, first, an anti-toxin and then a toxoid vaccine contributing to its further decline. Deaths from measles, a virus, were significantly reduced, reaching an asymptote of an average of 450 per year during the 1950s; but with a substantial amount of suffering, 45,000 hospitalizations, and up to 250 permanently disabled children. Smallpox deaths were reduced to under 1% in the United States, except imported cases, by a variant of the virus, although variola minor still entailed quite a bit of suffering, and, as long as variola major reigned in much of the world, the risk to Americans neither vaccinated nor exposed to variola minor still existed. Whooping cough (pertussis), caused by a bacterium, was reduced and almost eliminated in the United States by vaccines. In addition, while Humphries figure uses incidence, I think most people would care more about the degree of suffering, deaths, and disabilities. And ALL of the above, except syphilis began declining, some as early as the late 19th century. Though deaths from pertussis, measles, and diphtheria continued from the end of World War II into the early 1950s, they were lower than earlier and continued their decline, while polio was on the ascendance, including both deaths and disability. Despite changing definitions of paralytic poliomyelitis and errors in misdiagnosis, the majority of cases were correctly diagnosed and, actually, the total number of cases of those infected with polio virus was more than likely underestimated.
Why did the American people view polio with such fear
According to Oshinsky:
The disease reached its peak at the height of the cold war, when a national crisis often took the form of a crusade. And this particular crisis, an epidemic targeting defenseless children, grew to increasingly dramatic proportions in an increasingly suburban, family-oriented society preaching ever-higher standards of protection for the young. How ironic, how unfair, that polio seemed to target the world’s most advanced nation, where new wonder drugs like penicillin were readily available and consumers—mainly housewives—worked overtime to eliminate odors and germs.
No disease drew as much attention, or struck the same terror, as polio. And for good reason. Polio hit without warning. There was no way of telling who would get it and who would be spared. It killed some of its victims and marked others for life, leaving behind vivid reminders for all to see: wheelchairs, crutches, leg braces, breathing devices, deformed limbs (Oshinsky, 2005, pp. 4-5).
And Williams writes:
Polio outbreaks were smaller than the epidemics of classic scourges such as cholera and plague; but they came into their own while these time-honored killers were being seen off…The contrast between extinct threats and the new curse coming into its ascendancy appeared particularly stark from the 1930s onwards. Tried and tested public health measures were powerless to prevent polio. And this in turn made the sudden and unpredictable strike of polio, deep into the heart of homes that were now safely barricaded against other infections, all the more terrifying.
There was also the thorny problem of what polio might leave behind. Polio was not like other diseases such as diphtheria and whooping cough, with an all-or-none outcome for the battle for a child’s life. If the victims of those diseases survived, then everything was soon back to normal, and the episode could be safely written off as horrific, but history. By contrast, polio only rarely made a clean kill. Parents, family, friends and schools could move on after the death of a child, but it takes a special kind of residence to cope with the emotional, physical and financial cataclysms of helping a child in a wheelchair or an iron lung to live a full and rewarding life. During the 1930s and 1940s, many parents were torn apart by those stresses, and many more prayed desperately that they would never be put to the test.
The great American epidemic of 1916 concentrated its wrath on the East Coast…Its impact far outlived the seven month attack. Anything that could bring New York City to its knees was bound to leave lasting scars on the American psyche, and the sheer magnitude of the assault was shocking, with 9,000 cases and 2,500 dead between July and December in the Metropolis alone (Williams, 2013, p.116).
One can actually find similar sentiments regarding polio much earlier as expressed by Ruhräh in 1917:
A disease may be feared on account of its causing death, but a disease which permits the patient to live in an enfeebled conditions is even more dreaded and its occurrence in a community makes a much deeper impression (Ruhräh, 1917, p. 97).
The March of Dimes
According to Humphries:
The March of Dimes campaigns …were …designed to impact human fear and emotion (Humphries, p.224).
Many doctors of the 1940s were aware that the pitchmen of the National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis (NFIP) and March of Dimes were responsible for the expanded terror that swept the nation (Humphries, p. 244).
According to Oshinsky:
Polio’s special status was due, in large part, to the efforts of a remarkable group, the National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis [the formal name for the March of Dimes], which employed the latest techniques in advertising, fund raising, and motivational research to turn a horrific but relatively uncommon disease into the most feared affliction of its time.
[However] This dread did not begin with the National Foundation. A growing pattern of epidemics—the worst occurring in 1916—had already drawn …notice in the press (Oshinsky, 2005, p. 5).
As explained above by Oshinsky and Williams, the fear of polio was already there, and, despite Humphries emphasis on incidence, the cases of death and, especially, the all-too-visible paralysis were on the increase.
The March of Dimes wasn’t the first private organization to seek funding for a disease. In 1904, the National Association for the Study and Prevention of Tuberculosis was founded; but an even earlier version, the Pennsylvania Society for the Prevention of Tuberculosis was founded in 1892. In 1907, the Association began their Christmas Seal campaign to raise money (Wikipedia. American Lung Association). “Christmas seals are labels placed on mail during the Christmas season to raise funds and awareness for charitable programs (Wikipedia. Christmas seal). Another, the American Sexual Health Association, was established in 1914.
This was a time before the U.S. Government became actively involved in funding a broad range of medical programs, though as early as the 1790s, the Marine Hospital Service provided care for sick and disabled men in the U.S. Navy and in the late 1870s, Congress allocated funds to investigate the causes of epidemics like cholera and yellow fever (Wikipedia. National Institutes of Health). And few people had medical insurance.
According to Rose:
During its first 20 years, the Foundation assisted over 335,000 individuals with polio in a patients aid program that covered medical, hospital, and rehabilitation expenses…Covered expenses included payment for physician services, inpatient and outpatient hospital costs, the transport of polio patients (local transport to hospitals and the Military Air Transport Services, or MATS, organized through the US Air Force), home care (including nursing care), orthopedic devices, and home medical equipment. Rehabilitation expenses often involved long-term home care and carried over from year to year beyond the addition of new cases…The Foundation claimed that it was “the only voluntary health agency in the US which conducts a nationwide program of financial assistance to patients in meeting the costs of care of a single disease.”
It is important to recall the direct aid to communities besides personal aid that might have been beyond the scope of personal appreciation by individual recipients. From the outset the NFIP had organized systematic epidemic relief in concert with public health authorities involving the dispatch of physicians, nurses, and epidemiologists to affected areas, with medical equipment and supplies, to cope with local polio epidemics. It had supported the helping professions intrinsically involved with after care: nursing, physical therapy, and occupational therapy (Rose, 2016, pp. 156-158).
And according to Van Riper:
[It] launched a vast training program for physical therapists … [AND] in 1946 came the establishment of equipment depots, strategically located throughout the country, from which apparatus, such as iron lungs, rocking beds, and hot pack machines, could be promptly shipped into epidemic areas (Van Riper, 1955, p. 141).
Table 6 (from Van Riper, 1955, p. 141):
Funds Provided by the National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis, 1938-1955
Project	Amount
Research		$22,600,000	
	Virology and epidemiology		$18,300,000
	Prevention and treatment of after-effects		$4,300,000
Education		$22,700,000	
	Professional education		$19,600,000
	Public education		$3,100,000
Prevention	Including gamma globulin and vaccine	$22,500,000	
Clinical studies and medical care	Including support of respirator centers	$9,500,000	
Patient care		$203,600,000	
As can clearly be seen in Table 6, only about 16% went to research and vaccine development, thus, approximately 84% to care, education, and equipment.
One example of the importance of the National Foundation is the major epidemic that swept through Hickory, North Carolina in 1944.
As Oshinsky describes it:
Surrounding hospitals were overwhelmed. “Like a tidal wave the plague swept through the Catawba River Valley,” Life magazine reported, “Youngsters with painful, useless limbs, some unable to swallow or scarcely able to breath, they came from mining villages up in the hills, mill towns in the valley, from outlying farms and urban centers.”
The foundation agreed to equip and staff a makeshift polio hospital, to be built by local residents…The plan was risky. It called for the people of Hickory to accept polio victims from across the state, bringing even more “germs” into a community already devoted by the disease. Epidemics produce few heroes. Indeed, as the local newspaper admitted: “Had grownups been stricken and not [our] children, everybody from the mayor to the street sweeper likely would have fled town.”
A call went out for volunteers. Hundreds showed up, “hiding the fear,” said one, “that had [us] quaking in our boots.” Merchant donated building materials made scarce by wartime rationing…Families loaned their electric washing machines and vegetables. Farmers trucked in meat and vegetables.
Orthopedic nurses arrived…and physical therapists …Most had been trained through grants provided by the National Foundation…Iron lungs, hydrotherapy tanks, and medical supplies were flown in from regional equipment depots set up by the Foundation.
Before closing its doors, the makeshift hospital had treat 454 patients…All told, the foundation spent about $400,000 during the epidemic and a far greater sum on the aftercare of the survivors (Olshinsky, 1905, pp. 69-71).
Just to repeat what Humphries wrote: “Given what a low-incidence disease it was, how did polio come to be perceived as such an infamous monster? This is a question worthy of consideration, especially in light of the fact that the rate was far less than other common diseases (Humphries, p. 213).”
A low incidence relative to many other disease, yes; but incidence is not the important factor, suffering, disability, and death are. For Humphries, after Greenberg’s adjustments for determining paralysis, after Brown’s laboratory analyses distinguishing polio case from others, what remained were a significant number of deaths and even more so, the ever-present specter of an ever increasing number of disabled children. Without the National Foundation, how would they have been cared for?
As a child, some of my favorite movies were with Dean Martin and Jerry Lewis. Starting in 1966, Jerry Lewis hosted a Labor Day Muscular Dystrophy Association Telethon that I remember well. The Muscular Dystrophy Association was founded in 1950 with hopes of gaining the American public’s interest. As the Wikipedia article shows, the amounts raised were substantial with several years exceeding $60 million dollars (Wikipedia. The Jerry Lewis MDF Labor Day Telethon).
According to Wikipedia:
Muscular dystrophy (MD) is a group of muscle diseases that results in increasing weakening and breakdown of skeletal muscles over time. The disorders differ in which muscles are primarily affected, the degree of weakness, how fast they worsen, and when symptoms begin. Many people will eventually become unable to walk. Some types are also associated with problems in other organs.
Prognosis depends on the individual form of MD. In some cases, a person with a muscle disease will get progressively weaker to the extent that it shortens lifespan due to heart and breathing complications. However, some of the muscle diseases do not affect life expectancy at all, and ongoing research is attempting to find cures and treatments to slow muscle weakness (Wikipedia. Muscular dystrophy).
A systematic review found the birth prevalence for Duchenne muscular dystrophy ranging from 15.9 to 19.5 per 100,000 live births (Ryder, 2017). During the first half of the 1950s, the United States had an average of 4 million births (Infoplease, 2018), thus, an average of 708 new cases of Duschenne’s muscular dystrophy per year, Currently, the total number of cases of the main types of muscular dystrophy in the United States is 51,300 with Duchenne’s comprising 8,000 of them (encyclopedia com, 2018). So, the total is approximately 6.4 times Duchenne’s, thus, extrapolating to the 1950s would give us approximately 4,531 cases per year. Lower than paralytic polio cases; but a substantial number.
Since Humphries obviously doesn’t approve of the March of Dimes, I wonder how she feels about the Jerry Lewis Telethon and other Associations raising money for a variety of medical conditions? Perhaps, she doesn’t think the public should be contributing to them, given their “low” incidence?
Estimates of probability of children permanently paralyzed
Humphries writes:
The CDC defines polio’s statistical paralytic rate and estimates that it is less than 1 in 100 for some sort of permanent paralytic syndrome…Prior to vaccination, Dr. Maurice Brodie reported that only 1 in 170 children with no antibody to polio became ill during epidemics. By these two drastically different risk estimations, you can see that statistics are not set in stone, nor are they necessarily a reliable indicator of risk (Humphries, pp. 239-240; see also: Brodie, 1936).”
Unfortunately, Humphries fails to understand that at the time Brodie conducted his study it was not known that polio consisted of three identifiable serotypes, so, the antibodies used in Brodies analysis probably recognized only one of the serotypes. In other words, many of the children who tested negative may well have had antibodies to one or both of the other serotypes. In addition, Humphries fails to understand that almost ALL studies of any specific medical area will find a range of statistics. In the case of polio, for instance, it would depend on time, place, sampling scheme, sample size for any lab estimates, and, of course, which of the serotypes exist or have existed. However, whether one needed to vaccinate 100 or even 200 to prevent one case of paralysis (Number Needed to Treat (Wikipedia. Number needed to treat), given the significant number of paralytic cases depends on whether one considers so many paralyzed individuals acceptable or not, especially given the documented safety of the vaccines (e.g., see Greenberg above; Note this will be discussed in more detail in Part 2).
Far more people harmed by polio than originally suspected
To repeat from the CDC Pink Book:
Up to 72% of all polio infections in children are asymptomatic. Infected persons without symptoms shed virus in the stool and are able to transmit the virus to others.
Approximately 24% of polio infections in children consist of a minor, nonspecific illness without clinical or laboratory evidence of central nervous system invasion. This clinical presentation is known as abortive poliomyelitis, and is characterized by complete recovery in less than a week. This is characterized by a low grade fever and sore throat.
Nonparalytic aseptic meningitis (symptoms of stiffness of the neck, back, and/or legs), usually following several days after a prodrome similar to that of minor illness, occurs in 1%–5% of polio infections in children. Increased or abnormal sensations can also occur. Typically these symptoms will last from 2 to 10 days, followed by complete recovery.
Post-polio syndrome
According to Wikipedia:
Post-polio syndrome ( PPS, or post-poliomyelitis syndrome or post-polio sequelae) is a condition that affects approximately 25–50% of people who have previously contracted poliomyelitis—a viral infection of the nervous system—after the initial infection. Typically the symptoms appear 15–30 years after recovery from the original paralytic attack, at an age of 35 to 60. Symptoms include acute or increased muscular weakness, pain in the muscles, and fatigue. The same symptoms may also occur years after a nonparalytic polio (NPP) infection [my emphasis].
The most widely accepted theory of the mechanism behind the disorder is “neural fatigue”. A motor unit is a nerve cell (or neuron) and the muscle fibers it activates. Poliovirus attacks specific neurons in the brainstem and the anterior horn cells of the spinal cord, generally resulting in the death of a substantial fraction of the motor neurons controlling skeletal muscles. In an effort to compensate for the loss of these neurons, surviving motor neurons sprout new nerve terminals to the orphaned muscle fibers. The result is some recovery of movement and the development of enlarged motor units.
With age, most people experience a decrease in the number of spinal motor neurons. Because polio survivors have already lost a considerable number of motor neurons, further age-related loss of neurons may contribute substantially to new muscle weakness. (Wikipedia. Post-polio syndrome; see also: Halstead, 1998; Halstead, 2011; Horowitz, 1985; March of Dimes, 2001; McComas, 1997).
Studies have found clear evidence of polio virus in sufferers of post-polio syndrome (e.g., Leparc-Goffart, 1996).
Not only those who suffered paralysis, going through often long painful therapies, who appeared to have regained somewhat normal mobility, eventually only to develop post-polio syndrome; but a number of those, who following an acute episode of polio, even those asymptomatic, also developed post-polio syndrome. As discussed by Bruno:
Many clinicians, even some who treat polio survivors, believe that individuals who had nonparalytic polio (NPP) cannot develop postpolio sequelae (PPS), which include fatigue, muscle weakness, joint and muscle pain, cold intolerance, and difficulty sleeping, swallowing, and breathing and which occur more than 30 yr after acute poliovirus infection. The common wisdom is that NPP is synonymous with “abortive polio,” in which the poliovirus caused a flu-like illness but did not enter the central nervous system (CNS) and, therefore, neither damaged nor killed neurons. Autopsies, of course, were not performed on humans diagnosed with NPP to determine if there was damage to the CNS. However, there is significant circumstantial evidence that NPP was associated with CNS damage. For example, it was reported in 1953 that 39% of those diagnosed with NPP had measurable weakness on manual muscle testing in at least one muscle group. A 1954 study documented that 89% of polio survivors who were acutely “persuasively nonparalytic” had “very definite muscle weakness” as much as 3 yr after the diagnosis of NPP.
Recent studies make clear that NPP survivors do have late onset symptoms. A population-based study of 828 polio survivors found that new muscle weakness and fatigue were reported, respectively, in 38% and 34% of those who had been paralyzed and in 14% and 21% of those who had had NPP
Therefore, “postpolio syndrome” should not be used as the generic descriptor for late onset problems in polio survivors, because its diagnostic criteria exclude those without a history of paralysis, electromyographic evidence of denervation, and new muscle weakness. (Bruno, 2000; see also: Falconer, 2000, Nee, 1995).
Table 7 (Table 2 in Bruno, 2000) gives the limitations in paralytic and non paralytic polio survivors compared with all Americans (%).
	Paralytic polio	Nonparalytic polio	All Americans
Limited in life activities	42	29	19
Limited in ability or unable to perform major activities	32	18	13
Limited in ability or unable to work	27	16	11
Bruno, quoting David Bodian, writes:
The average number of spinal cord neurons that are destroyed by the polio virus is almost 50%. However, nonparalytic polio may be associated with severe neuron damage in the spinal cord. What is more, some with non paralytic poliomyelitis do not have damage in the spinal cord but have characteristic damage in the brain, which is more extensive than in some who did have paralysis. All available evidence shows conclusively that every case of polio exhibits damage in the brain. The polio virus is capable of producing an encephalitis, with or without symptoms (Bruno, 2002, p. 20).
Bruno writes:
The poliovirus is remarkable in its ability to invade neurons. In the 1940s Johns Hopkins University pathologist David Bodian found that 96 percent of motor neurons were infected by the poliovirus if you had any paralysis at all! Given the ability of poliovirus to enter and damage such a large percentage of neurons, why doesn’t everyone infected with poliovirus become totally and permanently paralyzed? Bodian found that for each neuron the polio virus invades, commandeers, and destroys, its action is halted in another neuron that is then able to rebuild its severely damaged protein-manufacturing and protein-packaging factories and start functioning again. How is it that the poliovirus is stopped at least half the time? Most likely because the immune system is able to play catch-up and produce enough antibodies to attack the poliovirus before it conquers the entire nervous system.
But if on average 50 percent of all motor neurons are destroyed in anyone who had paralytic polio, why aren’t half of polio survivor’s muscles paralyzed? Bodian discovered that at least 60 % of spinal cord motor neurons associated with an individual muscle must be killed before the muscle shows any weakness at all. This means that muscles that were at one time paralyzed or muscles that have been weak, may have been operating on as few as 40 percent of their original motor neurons…What’s more, Bodian found that muscles thought to be completely unaffected by polio—muscles that had never been weak, let along paralyzed—only have 60% of their motor neurons (Bruno, 2002, p. 29).
What’s more, Bruno makes a case that, besides post-polio syndrome, that chronic fatigue syndrome may have the same pathophysiology (Bruno, 1997; Bruno, 1998).
So, the 1/100 to 1/200 ratio that describes the immediate aftermath of acute polio infection significantly underestimates the “true” extent of polio’s damage. Many cases of slight muscle weakness were missed and later those suffering from post-polio syndrome, both originally asymptomatic and symptomatic, and, perhaps, even chronic fatigue syndrome, were the result of the polio virus.
Humphries writes:
After the vaccine, there was a concerted effort to distinguish cases with poliovirus from cases without it. This was not a concern prior to 1958 when many diseases common today hid behind the name poliomyelitis. Transverse myelitis, viral or aseptic meningitis, Guillain-Barré syndrome (GBS), chronic fatigue syndrome, spinal meningitis, post-polio syndrome, acute flaccid paralysis (AFP), enteroviral encephalopathy, traumatic neuritis, Reye’s syndrome, etc., all could have been diagnosed as polio prior to 1958 (Humphries, p. 224).
As discussed above under subtitle: Polio morbidity/paralysis, after Greenberg’s adjustments for determining paralysis, and using the same criteria together with laboratory differential diagnostics in Brown’s study, a significant number of cases of paralytic poliomyelitis remained. And neither post-polio syndrome nor chronic fatigue syndrome were known entities until decades later, so how could they be diagnosed as polio prior to 1958? As I will discuss further in Part 2, as I mentioned above, though misdiagnoses exist in most, if not all aspects of medicine, a significant number of cases of paralysis were determined to have been caused by the polio virus. And, as discussed above, Humphries appears unaware that not only did the polio virus cause immediate cases of disability; but has been found to have resulted in “mild” effects on many during their lifetime and later disabilities, even those who did not initially appear to have been affected. Humphries seems unaware of just how much damage to neurons polio virus did.
Summary and conclusion
I think it obvious that Humphries presentation is defective in numerous ways and displays a callousness towards suffering:
     1.  Humphries begins by comparing incidence rates for a number of diseases, essentially comparing apples to oranges;
     2.  When Humphries does discuss disease incidence and deaths, she ignores the tremendous toll polio has in terms of suffering and disability, something she does as well with measles;
     3.  Humphries ignores that all the diseases she compared with polio were either basically already eliminated or on a sharp decline at the same time polio was on the rise;
     4.  Humphries doesn’t seem to understand the basics of estimates, that is, there is often a range; but whether 1/100 or 1/200 cases actually became paralyzed, still, when one counts up the actual number of cases of paralyses, makes little difference. And Humphries fails to understand that a 1936 estimate would have been made prior to establishing that polio was three distinct serotypes;
     5.  Humphries dismisses that even after Greenberg’s adjustments, that 7,000 or more cases of paralysis remained;
     6.  Humphries misuses the Michigan data, which actually found “among the 242 patients originally diagnosed as paralytic, 187, or 77% were confirmed by laboratory tests to have poliomyelitis. The vast majority of these (84%) were found to have residual paralysis 60 days after onset of the illness.” Thus, 65% had paralysis 60 days later, based on criteria used by Greenberg;
     7.  And, though, as exemplified by Greenberg and the Michigan study, changing definitions and mistakes in differential diagnosis, Humphries ignores the fact that the actual number of people reported to have been affected by the polio virus is a significant underestimate, and that many suffered mild decrements in ability during their lifetimes, and later post-polio syndrome and, possibly, chronic fatigue syndrome.
     8.  Humphries ignores the cultural changes in the US, having survived the Great Depression and been victorious in World War II, with many previous diseases eliminated or on the decline, with the miracle of antibiotics, starting families, confronted with an ascending disease, one that visibly affected children, unpredictable and, yes, frightening.
     9.  Humphries opinion of the March of Dimes discounts both that people already experienced fear regarding polio and the major role the March of Dimes played in helping polio victims, help that is doubtful would have come from elsewhere. Her hostility to vaccines blinds her to the fact that the vast majority of March of Dimes funds went to patient care, training of nurses and physical therapists, and medical supplies. And, by implication, Humphries probably would dismiss various organizations soliciting funds for numerous other “low incidence” diseases and conditions; and
     10.  Humphries ignores post-polio syndrome and, possibly, chronic fatigue syndrome, where studies have found the former and, perhaps, the latter actually a result of damage caused by the polio virus, not misdiagnosed as polio.
Though I think this paper alone makes a compelling case that Humphries lacks credibility, I like to be thorough, so I will be working on subsequent papers. As now planned: Part 2 will focus in more depth on definitions/criteria for paralysis, lab confirmation, when and what types, and differential diagnoses and the role the vaccine played in the disappearance of polio; Part 3 will focus on the Cutter Incident, vaccine-associated polio, the role of tonsillectomies and provocation from other medical injections, and claims by Humphries that DDT and arsenic played a significant role, SV40 vaccine contamination, and discuss the Central Dogma that polio resulted from improved sanitation, together with other variables that partially explain the ascendance of polio; and Part 4 will focus on treatments, including the iron lung, surgeries, immobilizations, various physical therapies, and nutritional approaches. Basically, I intend to demonstrate that Humphries is completely wrong (intentionally or not) about every point she so feebly tries to make or that she grossly exaggerates, grossly overgeneralizes, and emphasizes ancient history. Based on her approach she would basically negate most of modern medical science. Stay tuned!
Acknowledgements
For valuable feedback and suggestions, thanks to: Sandi Berman; David W. Rose, MA; Dorit Rubinstein Reiss, PhD; Steven A. Rubin, PhD.

Polio Outbreak in Papua New Guinea
A recent case of polio on Papua New Guinea shows that we cannot rest until the eradication of polio is complete. Close is not good enough.
Steven Novella on June 27, 2018
Link

In April a six-year-old boy in Papua New Guinea was diagnosed with the polio virus. Recently two more children in the same county were also found the harbor the virus, making it an official outbreak of poliovirus, according to the World Health Organization (WHO). While this is just three cases, this is an unfortunate and serious development.
We are in the midst of an epic story about polio and its possible eradication. I hope we are at the end of this story, but we won’t know until it happens. Poliomyelitis (polio) is caused by a virus (poliovirus), an enterovirus and member of the family of Picornaviridae. It is spread from human-to-human contact, mainly through the oral-fecal route, but can also be spread through common contact with water or food.
The virus enters and multiplies through the intestine, which is why it is classified as an enterovirus, but can spread to the nervous system. There it can infect the anterior horn cells of the spinal cord – the neurons that control muscles – and therefore can cause paralysis.
There is no cure for polio once infected. The only treatment is prevention, which is accomplished through sanitation and vaccination. There is the potential to eradicate polio from the world, because it has no non-human reservoir. This means the virus only infects humans. Many other viruses, like Ebola, can infect animals. That means that even if there is no human on the planet with the virus (called “elimination”), it can survive in the wild in animals, and then from there cause an outbreak in humans.
So far only two diseases have been completely eradicated – smallpox and rinderpest. Other infectious diseases that have the potential to be eradicated include: poliomyelitis, yaws, dracunculiasis, malaria, measles, mumps, rubella, lymphatic filariasis and cysticercosis.
Of these we are only close to eradicating polio.
In 1988 about 350,000 people per year were paralyzed due to poliomyelitis. That was the year the Polio Global Eradication Initiative began. This is a public-private partnership involving the WHO, the UN, the CDC, Rotary International, and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. The initiative mainly involved improving sanitation and medical care in endemic areas, and distributing polio vaccine, which is cheap, safe, and effective.
As a result of his eradication effort there were only 15 cases of polio in 2017 – the effort reduced cases of polio from 350,000 to 15. This, of course, stands as a major piece of evidence that vaccines are effective, despite the absurd denials of the anti-vaccine community.
Polio is now endemic in only three countries, Pakistan, Afghanistan, and Nigeria. Stamping out these last reservoirs of virus, however, has proven more difficult than anticipated. We have essentially been stuck here for the last 15 years – we are right at the finish line, but cannot take the last three steps to cross it.
This is why any cases of polio outside of these three countries are devastating. Hopefully, the cases represent a self-contained outbreak. The county in which the cases were found is fairly isolated, which is good. Also, to clarify, and outbreak does not mean that the virus is now endemic (self-sustaining) in Papua New Guinea – but efforts need to be made to contain the outbreak so that it does not become endemic.
I cannot help (being the nerd that I am) to liken the situation to Isildur and Elrond at Mount Doom. Isildur held the one ring in his hand, standing over the flow of lava, and all he had to do was let it drop and the evil of Sauron would have been eradicated. But “Evil was allowed to endure” and almost took over the world. It is an iconic tale, because we can relate emotionally to being so close to ultimate victory, only to lose everything.
In the case of polio, the reason we have been unable to let the ring fall into the lava is because of anti-vaccine sentiment. Yes – there are challenges in the three remaining endemic countries in terms of medical infrastructure and sanitation, but so were there in many other countries where the virus was eliminated. The critical difference was fearmongering about vaccines.
Some Muslim religious leaders in Nigeria have been preaching that the polio vaccine is a Western conspiracy, and will spread AIDS and infertility. This kind of fear is deadly, because eradication depends upon vaccinating every child. There has been progress against these conspiracy theories in Nigeria, but not enough to achieve elimination.
In Pakistan and Afghanistan conspiracy-fueled fear of the vaccine is also a problem (mostly spread by the Taliban). The Taliban also spread rumors that the vaccine contains ingredients like pork, which are forbidden in their religion, or that the people giving the vaccine are actually spies.
Unfortunately this latter rumor was increased when the CIA actually used a fake vaccine program to help track down Osama bin Laden. While successful, that move was highly criticized for adversely affecting the polio eradication effort.
So here we stand, at the precipice of Mount Doom, holding the ring of polio over the lava. It seems that every year the WHO proclaims that we can eradicate polio by the end of the year. I don’t doubt that this is true, but yet another year goes by and that last little bit of polio endures. Meanwhile, we occasionally see outbreaks in other countries like Papua New Guinea, exported from the remaining endemic countries.
Recently there was a report of a case of polio in Venezuela. Fortunately that turned out to be a false alarm, but the risk is real.
The polio eradication effort also shows how, now more than ever, we are truly living in a global world. We are all in the same boat – we can only eradicate diseases like polio if it is eradicated everywhere. We have a vested interest in the political and social stability of countries like Nigeria and Pakistan. Poverty in developing countries affects everyone.
I applaud the polio eradication effort, and they deserve tremendous support to help get them over the finish line. This support includes opposing the anti-vaccine movement, their conspiracy theories, and their pseudoscience. The failure to eradicate polio so far is partly on them. The movement largely consists of privileged Westerners who have the luxury of denying vaccines because they live in countries with great sanitation, where many vaccine-preventable diseases have already been eliminated.
But their pseudoscience and conspiracy theories affect all of us.

The Return of Polio
Once again we lose the chance to eradicate polio, but the goal still remains relatively close.
Steven Novella on August 3, 2022
Link

The first case of polio since 2013 was reported in the US in Rockland County, NY. So far there are no other reported cases. Hopefully this is just an isolated case, but it highlights the fact that polio still exists in the world.
Poliomyelitis is an infection caused by the polio virus, which infect the anterior horn cells of the spinal cord. This causes severe paralysis. Prior to vaccination the disease paralyzed hundreds of thousands of children worldwide every year. After vaccines were introduced in the 1950s and 60s, cases plummeted, reduced by over 99%.
The CDC states that the US has been polio free since 1979. This is considered “elimination” – the disease is no longer endemic in the US. Since then there have been only a few isolated reported cases imported from outside the US, the last in 2013, and now another case.
In 2002 the WHO predicted they would be able to eradicate polio from the world by 2005. It is possible to eradicate polio because there is no non-human reservoir. This was accomplished through a robust vaccination campaign. However, as close as they came, their efforts were thwarted by conspiracy theories being spread in Nigeria, one of the last three countries with infections. An anti-vaccine campaign there allowed polio to spread.
It took 15 years to get back to that same point, being on the brink of eradication. By 2020 wild-type polio was eliminated from Africa, and existed only Pakistan and Afghanistan. Although there was an increase since 2016 in these last two countries, once again the WHO could see the finish line, and were making a final push to get enough people vaccinated to complete eradication. Then the COVID pandemic hit.
COVID caused a significant setback in the WHO’s efforts to eradicate polio. Poor countries, especially in Africa, had to suspend their vaccine programs. The WHO also had to divert resources to the pandemic, and the US was threatening to reduce WHO funding, including specifically for their vaccination program. Now, two years later, polio cases have been reported in eight African countries, and continue in Pakistan and Afghanistan.
As of 2022, cases of polio are increasing in Africa and remain in Pakistan and Afghanistan. We may have missed yet another chance to eradicate polio, and will have to spend years trying to get back to the brink of eradication.
Of note, there are essentially two sources of polio – there is the wildtype polio virus that is spreading through populations, and vaccine-derived polio. The latter occurs when people are vaccinated with the live attenuated vaccine (which is not used in the US, where the inactivated virus vaccine is used). Live weakened virus can spread through feces, and unvaccinated children can catch the vaccine-derived virus. So still the best way to prevent vaccine-derived cases is through vaccination (to eliminate vulnerable hosts).
The NY case is a vaccine-derived virus, and the man who contracted it was unvaccinated. The strain of the virus has been linked to a strain in Israel, but this strain has also been found in the UK, so it’s not clear where the subject contracted the virus from.
One way to track viral infections is to look for viral DNA in wastewater. In fact, polio virus has been found in the wastewater in New York, and also in London. There have been no further cases reported, but this means there are likely people shedding the virus through waste. This is highly concerning, and is something that needs to be further monitored.
And this is the problem – polio is highly contagious. The only proven way to prevent infection is with vaccination. The dramatic reduction in polio cases over the last 70 years has been entirely through polio vaccine programs, and the only way to eradicate polio is by making those programs as thorough as possible.
The recent case in NY also highlights the fact that we still need to vaccinate children against polio, even in countries where polio has been eliminated. Otherwise we risk new outbreaks in those countries, and eradication becomes an endless losing game of whack-a-mole. Essentially we need to vaccinate the world against polio until it is completely eradicated.
The recent rapid increase in polio and spread to previously polio-free countries shows how quickly the virus can bounce back. It also highlights the absurdity of the anti-vaccine movement, who have pushed back against the polio vaccine asking why Americans need to be vaccinated against polio when it is not spreading in the US. This is why.
The recent return of polio also highlights the importance of the WHO, who is heading the polio eradication effort. Even if there is legitimate criticism of the WHO, that does not mean it doesn’t provide some essential services. Reducing or cutting funding for the WHO would be a disaster, and would surrender any hope of eradicating polio.
Now is the time to increase our efforts to have a thorough polio vaccine program and finally eradicate this serious infection. We are still relatively close to this goal (historically speaking). All politics needs to be set aside and this needs to be a world-wide priority. We can only accomplish this together, because even a single holdout can mean failure. 

Polio’s Resurgence
Surely we can keep iron lungs relegated to museums, can’t we?
Scott Gavura on August 4, 2022
Link


Note: Today’s topic may look familiar. Sorry about that. Here is my take on a topic Steve covered yesterday.
The first American polio case since 2013 was reported last month in New York. The young adult had developed paralysis after contacting a strain of polio that was vaccine-derived. How this infection occurred, and how widely polio may be circulating is now under investigation, as paralysis is an uncommon consequence of the infection, which often has no symptoms. Evidence of polio’s spread was also detected in England in London’s wastewater, where there has been (to date) no active case detection.
Wasn’t polio eliminated in most countries decades ago? How did we get (back) here?

Throughout most of human history, poliomyelitis (polio) has been a cause of paralysis and death, with cases going back likely thousands of years. A viral infection of one of three different polioviruses, polio mainly affects children and is most often transmitted through sewage-containing drinking water. Most infections have no symptoms, so the disease can spread widely undetected. In some circumstances, the virus infects the brain and spinal cord, causing paralysis and sometimes death.
It was not long ago that polio was a feared disease, with surges leading to cities closing down gathering places like pools and theatres. The infection, which mainly affects children, can start with flu-like symptoms but every parent feared the potential for it to worsen – in some cases, leading to the inability to eat and even breathe. Treatments for polio were (and remain) supportive only. The iron lung (see above) used changes in air pressure to inflate and deflate the lungs. While many children could eventually leave an iron lung, not all could, and some spent their entire life in iron lungs. Even without the iron lung, children could face a life of partial or complete paralysis.
Dr. Jonas Salk developed the first vaccine, inactivated and injectable, in 1955 and countries began widespread vaccination campaigns. From almost 60,000 infection in 1952, infections in the USA plunged to under 5,500 by 1957. The oral (live) vaccine was developed by Dr. Albert Sabin in 1961 which became the preferred vaccination method. By the 1960s, polio was paralyzing fewer that ten Americans per year. The iron lung, which was a literal lifesaver a decade earlier, became obsolete.
Vaccine-derived polio
Vaccination has virtually eliminated polio from the earth. The oral polio vaccine (OPV) became the preferred vaccination method after it was introduced. It contains poliovirus strains that have been weakened, in that they cannot cause severe illness, like paralysis. Because it is ingested orally, the antibodies it produces protects one from exposure to wild poliovirus in the event of future exposure. The inactivated polio vaccine (IPV) provides good protection against polio but this form of vaccination still allows the transmission of wild poliovirus, although the vaccinated individual will not themselves become ill. In the US and other countries, children receive the IPV at 2, 4 and 6 months of age, and again at ages 4-6 years.
The OPV is easier to administer and less expensive than the IPV and protects individuals and the community against infection (in the event the weakened virus is excreted and ingested by others, it can give immunity), which has been important in vaccination campaigns that seek to eradicate the disease. However, if vaccine uptake is low, the weakened but still viable virus can mutate, allowing it once again to cause paralysis. In the case of the New York resident that was identified with polio last month, the form of the virus was from the live vaccine which has not been used in in the US since 2000. Therefore, it is believed the virus originated in a country where the live vaccine is still used. This type of infection is exceptionally rare. In 10 years where 10 billion doses of OPV have been administered, fewer than 800 cases of vaccine-derived paralytic polio have been reported. Now there is a new OPV developed that will not lead to mutations that could cause polio, which could help play an important role in countries where the OPV is still used. Importantly, eradication of polio is within reach. With two of the three viral strains gone, only one strain remains, wild poliovirus 1. Polio circulation continues only in Pakistan and Afghanistan.
Pandemic effects on vaccination
The pandemic has had a significant effect worldwide on access to, and delivery of preventative health measures like routine childhood vaccines. With access to health care (especially primary care) restricted, and schools moving virtual, vaccination campaigns have been interrupted. This likely contributed to a recurrence of polio in Malawi, where a 3 year old child was paralyzed earlier this year, triggering a campaign to vaccinate nine million children in four countries.
Moreover, attitudes to vaccines may have changed because of COVID-19 vaccines. Pre-COVID, I would have expected the emergence of a safe and effective vaccine against a worldwide pandemic to reinforce how important vaccination actually is. But in some, the opposite has occurred, with hardened attitudes against public health measures, and especially vaccination – of any kind.
David Gorski noted recently how “new school” antivaxxers are increasingly indistinguishable from “old school” antivaxxers. If the endgame of the anti-vaccine movement is the elimination of all vaccine mandates, then even the high uptake and widespread protection we have against diseases like polio may be at risk. What a tragedy it will be if we ever see children in iron lungs again.

Holding the Polio Vaccine Hostage
Steven Novella on July 18, 2012
Link
Since the development of the vaccine, perhaps the most effective public health measure we have yet devised, only one human disease has been completely eradicated from the world – smallpox. The last case was reported in Somalia in 1977. Eradication was the result of a deliberate and intense campaign, requiring almost complete vaccination of the population, especially in certain population dense areas. Countries such as India and Nigeria were among the last to achieve eradication. Some of the lessons learned were that very high compliance rates were needed and that even small communities could harbor the virus and prevent eradication.
Several decades later, at the beginning of the 21st century, we are on the verge of eradicating a second major human infectious disease, polio. Like smallpox, polio is a virus that has no major non-human host, so eradication is possible. The polio virus enters the anterior horn cells of the spinal cord, the lower motor neuron – cells that connect the brain to muscles. When those cells die muscles lose their connection causing weakness and atrophy. Vaccine campaigns have successfully eliminated polio from most countries, but the wild type of the virus remains endemic in Nigeria, India, Pakistan, and Afghanistan.
We have the potential, with one final push (which is being spearheaded by the World Health Organization – WHO) to eradicate wild type polio from the world, but these efforts are being hampered by politics and ideology.
In 2002 the WHO had hoped to eradicate polio from Nigeria by the end of that year, and the rest of the world by 2005. Now seven years later that goal has still not been reached. The problem is not lack of funding, will, or scientific knowledge, but rumor and ignorance. Certain Muslim clerics began preaching to their people not to take the polio vaccine. The reasons varied, but were all based in fear of the West. For example, a BBC article from 2002 reported:
I am sceptical and apprehensive about the polio campaign given the desperation and the rush of the sponsors, who are all from the West,” a young scholar, Muhammad bin Uthman, told the French news agency AFP.
Clerics spread fears that the AIDS virus was being spread (some even claimed deliberately) in the vaccine. Others cited the Pfizer drug scandal from 1996 when an untested drug (an antibiotic called Trovan) was used to treat bacterial meningitis and resulted in a reported 11 deaths and others injured. The WHO was eventually able to get past many of these rumors, but the opportunity for eradication was lost and now the WHO is playing catch up.
Once again, however, politics and ideology are getting in the way of world-wide eradication of polio, this time in Pakistan and Afghanistan. Several factors are at work to frustrate eradication plans. Pakistan recently abolished its health ministry, so the WHO has to work directly with local leaders who may be less receptive to foreigners. The Taliban has long opposed vaccines. Time World reports:
In 2007, a doctor who spoke out against anti-vaccine propaganda was killed in Bajaur agency. The same year, he notes, Taliban fighters kidnapped a public health worker and held him captive until he promised to stop vaccinating children. Last August, Taliban gunmen captured and killed ten aid workers in Afghanistan, claiming they were spies. Such incidents keep health workers out of high-need conflict zones, often the very areas that are in need of care.
This distrust was greatly exacerbated in 2011 when the CIA used a vaccine clinic and its health staff to gather DNA from Osama bin Laden’s children and help locate Osama. This action confirmed the worst fears and rumors of the Taliban – that health workers are really spies working for the US government.
The Taliban has also announced recently that they will not allow the polio vaccine campaign in North Waziristan until the US stops its drone campaign. Estimates range from 280,000 to 350,000 affected children, who will not receive the oral polio vaccine because of the Taliban ban. They are essentially holding the public health, and world health, hostage as a political maneuver.
The CIA using health workers as spies has been universally condemned as reckless. Health workers in general and the vaccine program specifically must be kept apolitical and civilian. The Taliban is also committing a crime against humanity by using an essential health campaign as a political bargaining chip.
We have the ability to eradicate polio from the world and spare countless children from a crippling illness. Since 1988 polio cases have been reduce 99.8% by the WHOs eradication campaign, but endemic polio remains in the four countries named. The polio virus is highly contagious, and because of the potential of world travel if the world wide polio vaccine program is not kept up the virus can rapidly re-establish itself. We have the ability to eradicate this disease, to confine the polio virus to secured laboratories. We have the knowledge and resources – only ignorance and politics now stands in the way. Perhaps we need severe world wide pressure on the four remaining countries to stop their resistance and cooperate with the vaccine campaign. This is an issue of world health that should not be held hostage to any one group’s immediate desires or ideology.

Polio Eliminated From Africa
Wild-type polio has been eliminated from Africa. Now only Pakistan and Afghanistan remain.
Steven Novella on August 26, 2020
Link

It seems like a good time for a bit of good news – after two decades of concerted effort, wild-type polio has been eliminated entirely from Africa. There are now only two countries in the world with endemic wild polio, Pakistan and Afghanistan. Once again, we are on the brink of worldwide polio eradication. The world needs to come together for one final push to eradicate this disease forever.
I say “once again” because we were here 20 years ago, but missed our chance. In 2002 the World Health Organization predicted they could eliminate polio from the last African country, Nigeria, by the end of the year. Then, by 2005, they hoped to eradicate polio from the last countries on Earth, India, Pakistan, and Afghanistan. Those hopes were dashed, however, by anti-vaccine rumors spreading in Nigeria.
Specifically some Muslim clerics were concerned that the vaccine program was entirely introduced by Westerners whom they did not trust. They spread fears that the vaccine either contained the AIDS virus as a campaign of deliberate infection, or sterilizing agents so that Muslim women could not have children. This led to decreased vaccine compliance, and polio cases in Nigeria skyrocketed from single-digits to over a thousand, eventually spreading to other African nations. It has taken almost two decades to crawl back to where we were in 2002, and now the WHO’s efforts have succeeded in achieving zero cases of wild-type polio in Africa.
Polio is caused by a virus that infects motor neurons in the spinal cord. When these nervous cells die, this breaks the connection between the brain and the muscles those cells connected to. Further, these motor neurons keep muscle cells alive and healthy, so once the neuron dies, then the muscle cells they were previously connected to atrophy and eventually die also. The result is muscle wasting and weakness.
There are three strains of wild-type poliovirus. Two of these strains have already been eradicated from the world, but one remains. There is also vaccine-derived polio (see this discussion of the two types of vaccines). In rare cases the live virus vaccine can spontaneously mutate back to a more infectious type, and cause an actual polio infection. This vaccine-derived virus can then spread to those who are not protected by vaccination.
This happens when the live attenuated virus from the vaccine is excreted by the person vaccinated and gets into the local water supply. There it can spread to others in the community. This is actually mostly a good thing, because it can produce immunity in those who are exposed. The vaccine also protects against this vaccine-derived virus, and so the spread is limited in a vaccinated population. If, however, there are large numbers of unvaccinated people, the vaccine-derived virus can last for longer in the environment. This gives the virus more time to mutate, and on very rare occasions can mutate back to a form that can produce paralysis. If a community is fully vaccinated, however, this won’t happen.
To put this into perspective, the WHO estimates that the polio vaccine program in Africa over the last 20 years prevented millions of cases of wild-type polio, but caused hundreds of cases of vaccine-derived polio – about 10,000 cases prevented for every one case produced. Further, newer versions of the vaccine, which do not include the wild-type-2 strain of the virus which has been eradicated, produce much fewer cases of vaccine-derived paralysis.
The bottom line is that a thorough vaccine campaign prevents both wild-type polio and, ironically, vaccine-derived polio (by reducing the duration of spread in the environment and therefore opportunity to mutate).
It should also be emphasized that it is possible to fully eradicate polio. The virus has no non-human host, no reservoir in which it can survive and re-infect people. So if we reduce human cases to zero – the virus is gone. Just as with smallpox, it can be completely eradicated. But this is an all-or-nothing game. Close is not good enough. Polio is a highly contagious virus. If even a single case remains and spreads, we could be seeing hundreds of thousands of cases worldwide within a decade. This means that all countries need to keep up their polio vaccine program until worldwide eradication is achieved.
How close are we? So far in 2020 there have been 37 reported cases (of the wild-type infection) in Afghanistan and 65 cases in Pakistan (and zero in the rest of the world). Those numbers are low, but they can increase rapidly if vaccine efforts are not maintained. There is an aggressive vaccine program in these remaining countries but, as the WHO reports:
Unfortunately, children are still missing out on vaccination for various reasons including lack of infrastructure, remote locations, population movement, conflict and insecurity and resistance to vaccination.
In Afghanistan resistance is coming mainly from the Taliban, but not because they fear the vaccine, they fear Western spies and drone strikes. They have essentially banned door-to-door vaccine efforts in the territories they control. They do allow vaccine clinics, but these are too sparse to reach everyone who needs to be vaccinated. We need to get to 95% coverage to stop spread of the virus. This is a purely political problem, and may be the final stumbling block that prevents worldwide eradication.
There is a lot going on in the world, especially with a pandemic, but the fate of polio should not be overlooked. Eradication is permanent, and failure to eradicate means the entire world is still at risk for renewed polio outbreaks. This issue should be getting far more attention than it’s getting. The entire world has a stake in this, and the attention of the world should be fixed on Pakistan and Afghanistan until we cross the finish line. At this point, any resources spent to achieve this goal are worth it.

Eradication Isn’t Extinction. Too Bad.
So close to the eradication of polio. But never quite there.
Mark Crislip on October 17, 2023
Link

We are in the middle of yet another planetary extinction. I am old enough that I think I have seen the slow changes of a planet on the outs. The world is not the same as I remember.
The ocean is higher. I remember as a kid I could just reach the low tide line with a three wood. Now, low tide is where high tide used to be, and high tide has rendered some beaches unwalkable.
The beaches are barren. The birds, except for an occasional unkillable gull, are mostly gone. The rocks, especially since the blob and the heat dome of 2021, are mostly barren. The smell is different as well; the rot of seaweed is gone, the air oddly fresh.
The forests are quieter. The buzz of bugs are gone and, with less to eat, it is rare to see a bird flit through the trees. And it has been years since my windshield obscured by bug squish.
Yep. Eradication of any number of species is proceeding apace and if you are old enough you will notice. Unbearably sad and it is only going to get worse. But then, I have zero optimism about the future.
But not all eradication is bad. I don’t think I would cry over much if disease-bearing mosquitoes were to vanish, although I have no doubt it would a bad idea.
There are two eradications that have been deliberate: rinderpest and smallpox, both thanks to vaccines.

Rinderpest is the measles of animals and is likely the source of human disease, rinderpest having jumped into humans maybe around the 11th century. It has been a blasphemous rumor that god has a sick sense of humor, so, turn about being fair-play, I would not be surprised if, in the future, measles jumped back into cows from unvaccinated humans.
Smallpox was eradicated last century but still exists in two labs (one in Russia. Yippy.) and, given that the genome is published, the virus could be reconstructed. It would be easier to do than a woolly mammoth. So smallpox, or rinderpest, could come back. And never underestimate human stupidity:
Federal scientists last week discovered a half-dozen forgotten vials of smallpox virus while cleaning out a storage area on the campus of the National Institutes of Health (NIH) in Bethesda, Maryland.
Smallpox, due to the variola virus, was eradicated with the vaccine, which is the vaccinia virus. The vaccinia virus is an odd one. Where did it come from? Unknown.
The precise origin of vaccinia virus is unknown due to the lack of record-keeping, as the virus was repeatedly cultivated and passaged in research laboratories for many decades. The most common notion is that vaccinia virus, cowpox virus, and variola virus (the causative agent of smallpox) were all derived from a common ancestral virus. There is also speculation that vaccinia virus was originally isolated from horses, and analysis of DNA from an early (1902) sample of smallpox vaccine showed that it was 99.7% similar to horsepox virus.
But vaccinia disease continues to circulate in Brazil:
In recent decades, several strains of the orthopoxvirus vaccinia virus (VACV) have been isolated throughout Brazil, including many genetically distinct isolates within the same outbreak.
And with the vaccinia vaccine no longer being used, other pox viruses are making a resurgence, like monkey pox. Remembering that smallpox likely jumped into humans from rats:
Our results show two primary VARV clades, which likely diverged from an ancestral African rodent-borne variola-like virus either ≈16,000 or ≈68,000 years before present (YBP), depending on which historical records (East Asian or African) are used to calibrate the molecular clock.
And no reason a pox virus could not jump again. Murphy was, after all, an optimist.
So who knows. A lab leak, stupidity, reconstruction, another zoonotic jump? Smallpox may be eradicated but it isn’t extinct. Unfortunately.
Which brings us to the next virus to hopefully be eradicated, but not rendered extinct: polio. As a recent article in Science noted, Global polio eradication effort struggles with the end game. As an aside, I never did understand why Ralph Lauren decided to use polio as the name for his line of clothes, even if he does make really nice, albeit too expensive for me, clothes. And even allowing artistic interpretation, the logo looks nothing like an iron lung, more like a guy on a horse. More mysteries.
Polio is a tricky virus. Three strains (1,2 and 3), and two vaccines. The killed vaccine prevents disease but does not prevent transmission. The live attenuated virus prevents disease and transmission but has the unfortunate rare complication of reverting to wild type to cause disease.
There is more vaccine strain disease, mostly in Africa, than wild-type disease, mostly in Afghanistan and Pakistan and, earlier in the century, Nigeria, where the vaccination programs have had difficulties that were the same as it ever was. As an aside (squirrel), go see the remastered Stop Making Sense while you can. Tremendous.
Some of the issues for why eradication programs for polio had trouble in Nigeria and Pakistan were the usual suspects: poverty, poor infrastructure, corrupt governments. But there are some other causes as well. Let’s see if anything sounds familiar.
In Nigeria and Pakistan, it was believed that the polio vaccine was a plot to sterilize Muslim girls and to spread HIV. I feel silly mentioning that neither is true, and before we feel oh so superior, remember, as Art Linkletter noted, anti-vaccine folks say the darndest things.
Here’s Where That COVID-19 Vaccine Infertility Myth Came From—And Why It Is Not True
or
There is no evidence that any COVID-19 vaccine contains HIV
In Nigeria it was the combination of governors
the governor of Kano, is quoted as saying: “Since September 11, the Muslim world is beginning to be suspicious of any move from the Western world…Our people have become really concerned about polio vaccine
and
Kano state governor, Ibrahim Shekarau, reaffirmed that their decision was influenced by unsatisfactory test results by the federal government’s teams.
A well-regarded doctor
Datti Ahmed, a Kano-based physician who heads a prominent Muslim group, the Supreme Council for Sharia in Nigeria (SCSN), is quoted as saying that polio vaccines were “corrupted and tainted by evildoers from America and their Western allies.” Ahmed went on to say: “We believe that modern-day Hitlers have deliberately adulterated the oral polio vaccines with anti-fertility drugs and…viruses which are known to cause HIV and AIDS”
And some Imams who thought vaccination was going against Gods will. God evidently wants children to be paralyzed by polio.
Nah. Those reasons for refusing the polio vaccine do not sound familiar to me in the least.
In Pakistan they were a bit more aggressively anti-vaccine:
Vaccination efforts have been seriously stalled by the murder of at least 35 health workers who had been attempting to vaccinate children since 2012. Militants are suspicious of vaccinations, which radical clerics claim are part of a Western plot to sterilize Muslims.
I would be hesitant to vaccinate children if it meant my murder, but at least this doesn’t happen in the home of the free, land of the AR -15. Yet.
By the way, it isn’t just Muslim clerics who have these beliefs. In Kenya
It all started in 2014 when the Catholic bishops complained that tetanus vaccine administered to women of reproductive age during a campaign was laced with contraceptives in the form of Human Chorionic Gonadotrophin (HCG) …However, the Catholic bishops were not fully satisfied with the process (of demonstrating the vaccines were not contaminated) and hence called on all their faithful to boycott the August 2015 polio campaign.
One study noted that the boycott, fortunately, did little.
Compared to the November 2014 campaign, the proportion of children who were not vaccinated due to parent’s refusal significantly increased from 6% to 12% in August 2015.
But oddly concluded
The call for boycott did not affect the campaign significantly.
I guess a few paralyzed children is only significant to the child and their family,
Safe to say Catholic Bishops are often not a reliable source of health information. At least we don’t see that kind of nonsense from US pastors.
Pakistan was the likely source for subsequent cases in nearby Afghanistan. I always remember that the first word in my sub-specialty is infectious: spreading or capable of spreading rapidly to others.
Despite relatively superficial differences, humans are mostly the same everywhere. It is why the planet is doomed.
Is there good news? Yes.
Nigeria is getting polio under control and the Taliban has decided polio vaccination is not so bad after all:
Taliban launches annual polio vaccination drive in Afghanistan.Health ministry says the four-day campaign will cover more than nine million children in 31 of the country’s 34 provinces.
So maybe we will get the number of eradicated viruses to three. 350,00 cases of paralysis a year that will never happen. Add it to the innumerable species we have wiped off the planet.
A good thing (the eradication of polio, not the innumerable species), even if it means I will have to wear Calvin Kline instead.

   Where’s the outrage?
John Snyder
Link
I thank everyone for my warm welcome to the SBM community. Although vaccine myth is of particular interest to me, I promise that my posts wont all be vaccine related. There is, unfortunately, much to discuss. In fact I had a difficult time deciding which vaccine-related issue to write about for my inaugural post. In the end I came up with more of an opinion piece, but it’s an issue worth airing. Things in anti-vaccine land may be reaching a dangerous turning point.
In the very recent past, Haemophilus influenzae type b (Hib) was what could truly be called a scourge to humanity. As recently as 1987, this particularly nasty bacterium caused invasive disease in a startling 1 of every 200 children in the U.S. under 5 years of age. Approximately two-thirds of these children developed meningitis, with a mortality rate of about 5%. Up to 30% of the survivors suffered permanent brain damage. Those children lucky enough to avoid meningitis developed pneumonia, septic arthritis, osteomyelitis, cellulitis, epiglottitis, or generalized sepsis. Fortunately I have never seen or treated a child with invasive disease due to Hib. That’s because I began my pediatric training in 1991 when vaccination against these horrendous diseases was just beginning. What was once a common and devastating menace to children, the dreaded nightmare of every pediatrician, was quickly brought to it’s knees. By 2006, the incidence of invasive Hib disease had been cut by 99%. Within a short period of time, the very nature of pediatric medicine seemed changed forever. That’s why I was so saddened to read the Hib surveillance data from Minnesota released by the CDC in January. In 2008 five children in that state (ranging from 5 months to 3 years of age) developed invasive disease due to Hib. That is the largest recorded number since 1992, just after the vaccine was licensed. Three of those children had meningitis, one had epiglottitis, and another had pneumonia. One child, a 7 month old with meningitis, died. Of those five children, 3 had received none of the recommended doses of Hib vaccine due to parental refusal. The other 2 were too young to have completed the series, and one of these had an immunodeficiency that likely made the vaccine ineffective. At first these five cases from Minnesota seemed like an isolated fluke. Then came the news, just released by the Pennsylvania Department of Health, of seven more cases of invasive Haemophilus influenzae disease since October. All were children under 5, and all were unvaccinated or incompletely vaccinated. Three of these seven children have been confirmed to have died. And now news of a 3 year old in Maine who is recovering from Hib meningitis. There hasn’t been a confirmed case of Hib meningitis in Maine since 1989.
The most obvious and infuriating factor contributing to these small but concerning outbreaks is the increasingly prevalent phenomenon of parents refusing vaccinations for their children, or altering the vaccine schedule out of misguided concerns; either about the dangers of “too many too soon“, or the cumulative exposure to vaccine constituants. This delay in vaccination, à la Dr. Sears, has created an increasing population of children with gaps in their vaccination coverage, and who are therefore vulnerable to vaccine-preventable disease. I may write more on Dr. Sears in a future post. For now, suffice it to say that more parents can probably quote Dr. Sears’ irresponsible and scientifically unfounded vaccine schedule than can name 3 reliable sources of vaccine information. My fear is that these terrifying outbreaks of Hib disease may be the canaries in the coal mine, signifying more trouble to come.
In addition to the increase in parental vaccine refusal, a second factor may also have played a role in this upswing of Hib disease. And this second factor has a particular irony to it. Since December of 2007, there has been a nationwide shortage of Hib vaccine. Merck, one of only two vaccine manufacturers producing Hib vaccine in the U.S. (Sanofi is the other), was forced to close it’s Hib manufacturing facility due to bacterial contamination detected at the plant on a routine FDA inspection. No actual contamination of vaccine ever occurred. However, the company recalled 12 lots of vaccine and was forced to close and retool it’s facility. While the anti-vaccine crowd has predictably spun this as an example of the dangers of our vaccine supply, it is actually a perfect example of how stringent and effective the vaccine safety system really is. The Hib vaccine shortage that resulted from this plant closure led the CDC to issue interim vaccination recommendations. It recommended that doctors continue to administer the primary series of Hib vaccines (at 2, 4, and 6 months of age), but to delay the booster dose, typically given between 12 and 15 months of age, until further notice. While Sanofi (the sole remaining producer of Hib vaccine) has purportedly had enough vaccine to meet this goal, pediatricians (this one included) have often found their supplies running low, and themselves unable to complete the primary series at the appropriate intervals. This shortage, coupled with faltering parental confidence in the safety of vaccines, has created a dangerous situation. And sometimes a strange one. On one recent day I had a mother call frantically to make sure her child would get the Hib vaccine on time, while on the next day a parent called to ask about spacing out her child’s vaccine schedule to make it safer for his immune system. Which brings me to the title of this post.
Parental vaccine refusal endangers lives. Here we have a situation in which an unavoidable shortage of a vital vaccine, has combined with an irrational parental mistrust of expert scientific opinion to create a critical mass of vulnerable children. The result, so far, is four dead children. But in the absence of any shortage, vaccine myth and the poor parental decision making it breeds has already had a profound impact, with the potential for more to come. In the never-ending wake of Wakefield, measles outbreaks have occurred in pockets of under-immunized children in areas of New York, San Diego, and Milwaukee. Particularly in communities where parents know how to do their own “research” about vaccines. Many more children have suffered unnecessarily in the U.K. and elsewhere as a result of the spreading wave of panic over fictionalized vaccine dangers. In fact, as bad as this wave of vaccine parananoia is in the U.S., it’s far worse in Europe and the U.K. where vaccine mythology is rampant, and the threat of vaccine preventable epidemics is very real. This widening circle of vaccine fear across the Atlantic is a major threat to children in this country. Imported cases of vaccine-preventable disease can now find increasing populations of under-immunized children in which to take root.
To see children fall ill and die from completely preventable diseases because of irrational fear and a belief in myth should truly make us angry. Those of us who have the knowledge and experience to speak out publicly should do so. We should seek every opportunity at our disposal to speak with a clear and unintimidated voice to say that we’ve had enough. Enough of the armchair pseudoscience. Enough of the misinformed journalists. Enough of the celebrity grandstanding. That parents in this day and age would arrange a chicken pox or a measles party so that their children could actually get these diseases rather than have them safely vaccinated makes me want to scream. The hours I spend trying to correct the massive amounts of misinformation foisted on parents who believe a seemingly endless array of conjured myth is mind-numbing. We should be calling out the phoney mavericks, charlatans, and know-nothings for who they are. Robert Kennedy, Jr., David Kirby, and J.B. Handley believe they are fighting the noblist of fights. What they are doing, of course, is endangering lives. But more broadly, their rhetoric endangers the already fragile relationship society has with an evidence-based approach to understanding the world. It is our responsibility to make it known that the controversy is over. No, that there never was a controversy in the first place. That science and reason will not allow another child to die or suffer needlessly. Really, where is the outrage?

Salk’s swansong: renaissance of the injected polio vaccine
Ed Parker on October 28, 2014
Link

Picture a lab scientist. White coat, pensive expression, microscope in hand. Glasses, perhaps. The person you have in mind (providing you are willing to humour a stereotype or two) may have a striking resemblance to Jonas Salk, the archetypal laboratory researcher, born in New York City on Wednesday 28th October 1914 — one hundred years ago today.
The name will be familiar to many. As creator of the inactivated polio vaccine (or IPV), Salk is cemented firmly into the annals of medical history. When his vaccine hit the shelves in 1955, the annual epidemics of poliomyelitis represented a fierce insult to postwar American civility: one particularly devastating bout in 1952 caused over 20,000 cases of paralysis and more than 3,000 deaths, mostly among children. The arrival of IPV was greeted with nationwide celebrations, and Salk was praised as a worker of miracles.

IPV has been in demand ever since, and its use in several countries has been sufficient to get rid of polio. Until recently, however, Salk’s injected vaccine has largely played second fiddle in eradication efforts. When the Global Polio Eradication Initiative was launched in 1988, it favoured an alternative formulation, Albert Sabin’s oral polio vaccine (OPV), as its weapon of choice.
But the spotlight may be shifting. With the eradication programme preparing for what is hoped to be a final onslaught, IPV is poised to take centre stage once more. Indeed, the World Health Organization recently recommended that all countries introduce at least one dose of Salk’s vaccine into routine immunisation by the end of 2015.
Why is IPV so important to polio eradication plans? What does the injected vaccine offer that the oral one does not? The centenary of Salk’s birth offers a fitting occasion to consider these issues.
A tale of two vaccines
Although renowned for its paralytic symptoms, polio infections actually start off in the gut. After the ingestion of infectious material (usually in the form of contaminated food or water), the virus replicates in the cells lining our intestines. In the majority of cases, it ends here, passing without symptoms or perhaps a few days of flu-like illness. But in every few hundred infections, the virus passes through the bloodstream and into the central nervous system. This is where it can do real damage: destroying nerve cells and causing muscle paralysis in the process.
In some cases, this paralysis is mild and temporary. In others, it is more severe, leaving victims permanently disabled. In an unlucky few, it is fatal.
The two formulations of polio vaccine take rather different approaches to preventing this. Salk tackled the problem by inactivating polioviruses with formaldehyde. When treated in this way, the viruses are no longer able to cause an infection, but crucially are still able to induce an immune response to polio when delivered by injection.
IPV is good at inducing protective antibodies against polio in the bloodstream. If a vaccinated individual later encounters a polio infection, the viruses will be neutralised by these antibodies before they have a chance to infect the central nervous system. No nerve damage. No paralysis.
But there are some important caveats. The vaccine is expensive, and its delivery by injection requires a skilled hand. What’s more, although vaccinated individuals are protected against polio’s symptoms, the virus is still able to replicate in the gut, enabling the chain of viral transmission to continue. This silent transmission is a concern when eradication is on the agenda: polio can lurk, undetected, passing from vaccinated individual to vaccinated individual without causing any symptomatic cases (a scenario that was recently seen in Israel).
To some extent, Sabin’s oral vaccine makes up for these shortcomings. OPV consists of live but substantially-weakened polioviruses. These viruses are able to mimic the infection caused by bona fide polio, but with a significantly-reduced risk of causing any neurological harm. Like IPV, the oral vaccine induces antibodies against polio in the blood, but unlike IPV, the live vaccine also produces a local immune response in the gut. Crucially, this local response will prevent future poliovirus encounters from establishing an infection. It can block the transmission chain.
The ability to induce immunity in the gut isn’t the only thing OPV has going for it. The vaccine is cheap and easy to administer, requiring just a few drops into the back of the mouth to take effect. When you are attempting to vaccinate every child under five across an entire country in a matter of days, as routinely carried out in regions still affected by polio, these are obvious bonuses.
The achievements made during the reign of OPV should not be underestimated. When the eradication initiative was launched, polio was a global disease responsible for roughly 1,000 cases of paralysis each day. Today, there are just three countries in which transmission of polio has never been halted – Nigeria, Pakistan, and Afghanistan – and the disease causes just a few hundred cases each year. Despite the huge challenges faced by the eradication initiative, from vaccine boycotts to a recent surge in violence targeting polio healthcare workers, we are 99% of the way towards one of the great achievements in medical history.

It is in the final 1% of the eradication campaign that IPV becomes so important. For all of OPV’s qualities, it is still a live virus, and in occasional (very rare) circumstances, the weakened vaccine virus can regain its virulent qualities via mutation. Such cases of vaccine-associated paralysis are estimated to occur once in every 2.4 million doses of OPV. Every so often, these infections can even spread from person to person, resulting in circulating strains of vaccine-derived polio.
As we draw ever closer to eradication, these rare cases of vaccine-related disease become increasingly troublesome. As of 21st October, circulating vaccine viruses have added an extra 39 cases of polio to the 247 caused by wild viruses in 2014. Even though the risks of vaccination may be small, if you want to get rid of polio entirely, eventually you have to make the switch away from OPV.
The eradication endgame: counting down to zero
The current eradication plan looks something like this. By the end of 2015, every country will include at least one dose of IPV as part of each child’s routine schedule of jabs. In most of the world (especially in places where polio is still a problem), these injections will be supplemented by plenty of doses of oral vaccine – essential for inducing the transmission-blocking gut immunity required to halt the spread of polio.
If all goes to plan, this will bring an end to all cases caused by wild polioviruses. Good news, of course, but we’re not there yet. The rare cases of vaccine-related disease will still be an issue, especially the ones that can spread from person to person. So next we have to stop using OPV altogether.
When we are confident that enough children are receiving IPV, and that immunity levels are sufficient to prevent the spread of any lingering viruses, it will be necessary to stop using the very vaccine that has helped us get rid of 99% of the world’s polio. Oral vaccination will be brought to a halt, and IPV left to stand guard.
Both the oral and injected polio vaccines are indispensable to these eradication plans, so it is somewhat ironic that Salk and Sabin sustained such an infamous rivalry in the race to develop a polio vaccine – Sabin notoriously once suggested that Salk’s work could be achieved in a kitchen sink. The two vaccines may also make a better team than previously thought: in a pair of recent studies (one published in The Lancet and the other in the journal Science), researchers found that giving IPV to children who had previously received several doses of oral vaccine substantially boosted their transmission-blocking gut immunity. More than half a century after the first doses of IPV were given, we are still unearthing the vaccine’s hidden talents, and polio has never seemed more vulnerable.
Conclusion
One hundred years ago, a vaccine for polio did not exist, and little could be done to halt the annual epidemics of paralysis. It is hard, now, to fully appreciate the culture of fear that surrounded this disease. At the peak of each polio outbreak, entire hospital wards would be lined with iron lungs – coffin-like structures devoted to keeping their infected inhabitants breathing if paralysis spread to their lungs. Not every individual would leave their iron lung. Of those that did, many emerged with life-long disability.
Jonas Salk provided the first effective tool for preventing this dreaded disease, and polio has since been eradicated across much of the globe. The recent decision to include IPV in the routine immunisation of all infants is a fitting way to mark Salk’s centenary. It may well be a decision that helps consign polio to the history books.

Separating Fact from Fiction in the Newborn Nursery: Hepatitis B Vaccine for Newborns
Clay Jones on July 17, 2015
Link


For those of you new to Science-Based Medicine, I am a pediatric hospitalist and spend the majority of my time caring for newborns. It’s an extremely rewarding experience on most days. The babies are usually healthy, the parents are usually happy and appreciative, and I get to give a lot of good news. I also get to dispel a lot of myths and misconceptions regarding the care of infants, which as you can probably imagine, I take great pleasure in.
Parents ask a lot of questions, which I appreciate and encourage, but they also make a lot of claims about the care of children based on their prior experience, advice from well-meaning friends and family, or their evaluation of the online “literature.” Some of these claims I will challenge, nicely of course, when they are demonstrably wrong or increase the risk for a bad outcome. (“We read that babies should sleep inverted like a bat in order to increase blood flow to the brain.”) Some of these claims I acknowledge as an acceptable approach, even if I don’t agree with them myself, if there is low risk or a lack of available quality evidence to guide me. (“We burped our last baby every five minutes during feeds to prevent colic.”) Sometimes I even learn a thing or two from parents.
The safe, universally-recommended hepatitis B vaccine
A topic that frequently leads to both questions and claims from concerned parents during rounds in the newborn nursery is the vaccination against the hepatitis B virus (HBV), something that has been recommended universally for infants by the Advisory Council on Immunization Practices (ACIP) since 1991. Their strategy was, and still is, to wipe this awful disease out in the United States. Over the years, the recommendation for timing of the first dose has changed from “at birth before hospital discharge or at age 1-2 months” to simply “newborns before hospital discharge” in 2002, with qualifiers of medical stability and weight greater than 2,000 grams added in 2005. Babies that weight less than 2 kg at birth still will get the vaccine at discharge home or at 1 month of age if still in the hospital. This last change was recommended because of concerns over efficacy rather than safety. It’s an extremely safe vaccine.
In addition to questions about the vaccine, the most common being about any associated risks and the necessity for a newborn dose, I also get a fair amount of refusals despite attempts to educate and reassure. Most of the time these aren’t anti-vaccine parents, they just don’t understand why it can’t wait until they take the baby in to see their primary care pediatrician. They may assert that their child doesn’t need it at such a young age, that it’s not necessary considering the infant’s low risk of exposure. Many are medically savvy enough to question the need for the vaccine given negative testing in the mother. Thankfully, most of these families do go on to allow their babies to receive all the recommended vaccines on the ACIP schedule.
Only once in my career of roughly 12 years have I had a mother with active HBV refuse the immunization for their newborn. That is an entirely different issue which I will get into shortly. Questions about the need for giving the baby of a mother who has tested negative for hepatitis B infection a vaccination to protect them from a disease commonly thought of as an adult affliction, and related to “adult” behaviors, are understandable. But before I explain why we have this recommendation in place, a primer on the disease we are trying to avoid is in order.
What is hepatitis B?
Hepatitis B is an infection of the liver caused by the hepatitis B virus (HBV). According to the CDC, there were 3,050 cases of acute infection reported in the United States in 2013, which comes out to roughly 1 case per 100,000 people. In children under the age of 15 years, the incidence is now only .02 per 100,000. The numbers of reported acute infections in kids has plummeted since the vaccine was first recommended for all infants in 1991, and is down from nearly 14 per 100,000 in the 1980s. Overall there has been an almost 90% reduction in the diagnosis of new cases.
It’s important to point out that these numbers likely significantly underestimate the actual number of new infections with HBV. Because the acute infection frequently doesn’t cause any symptoms, many cases go unreported. After taking this into account, the CDC estimates that there were actually close to 20,000 new cases in 2013. Most acute HBV cases will fully resolve without any need for intervention, however a certain percentage will go on to develop chronic infection, with younger patients being at higher risk. It is estimated that between 700,000 and 1.4 million people currently have chronic hepatitis B in the United States.
From a global perspective, HBV causes significantly more illness and death than in the United States. The World Health Organization, which also recommends universal immunization of newborns against HBV, puts worldwide cases of chronic disease at around 240 million people. And three quarters of a million people die each year from acute (130,000) or chronic (650,000) infection.
Acute hepatitis B infection
The presentation of acute infection with HBV is extremely variable, ranging from a complete absence of symptoms to severe and sudden onset of liver failure that is life-threatening and requires aggressive treatment. This is a rare complication that occurs in less than 1% of cases, however. In general, when signs and symptoms of illness do occur, they tend to be similar in presentation in all age groups with loss of appetite, nausea, an inflamed and tender liver, and jaundice being typical. Fatigue can be severe in some patients, and persist long after the other complaints have resolved, which usually takes one to three months. Some patients will also develop more significant systemic symptoms consisting of muscle and joint pain, hive-like rashes, and tender swollen lymph nodes.
Most patients over the age of five years who are acutely infected with HBV will clear the virus and go on to benefit from lifelong immunity. But almost 90% of infants and 25%-50% of children between the ages of one and five years will not be so lucky. In contrast, 95% of older children and adults will fight off the virus during the initial exposure. The ability to fight off the virus clearly improves with age. The younger the patient, the more likely they will develop chronic infection and be at risk for devastating future complications.
Chronic hepatitis B infection
Patients with chronic HBV infection are often asymptomatic for decades. Children typically develop as expected and without any disability, but can present with kidney disease long before any liver problems. But it is the slow and steady injury to the liver, although sometimes it can be sudden and severe, that can occur which causes the greatest risk for eventual morbidity and mortality.
How chronic HBV infection naturally plays out in kids is complicated, and like acute infection it presents in different ways. The complicating factor is something called immune tolerance, a unique result when infection occurs in younger patients, particularly newborns who acquire the infection from their mother around the time of birth. Immune tolerance is the state where, although there is evidence of viral replication in the patient, there is little to no laboratory evidence of liver inflammation. This phase can last for months to decades and can go undetected. Even when identified, treatment is generally not recommended because of poor efficacy and concern for inducing antiviral resistance.
Seroconversion and clearance of infection
At any point during the immune tolerant phase, it is possible for the patient to develop antibodies against a key component of the virus (“seroconversion”) and rarely, to even clear the infection. This is very unlikely to occur when a child is infected in early infancy, with a conversion rate of about 5% per year. Kids who acquire the infection a bit later and from a source other than their mother have better chances, even as high as 70%-80% over the first 20 years. Again, development of these antibodies doesn’t mean that a patient will clear the virus and be cured, only that they have a chance. And unfortunately, conversion and even clearance of the virus doesn’t necessarily prevent all long term complications.
Immune active infection
The next potential component of chronic HBV infection is the so-called immune active phase. For reasons we don’t fully understand, at any time a patient can develop increased replication of the virus and increased inflammation of the liver. This is where significant and prolonged liver injury can occur but it is also the time when the patient has the best chance to develop antibodies against critical components of the virus.
The longer that a patient is in the immune active phase, the higher the risk of cirrhosis of the liver and ultimately the development of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). That’s right, the hepatitis B vaccine was the first vaccine to successfully prevent cancer, not the vaccine against human papillomavirus. This stage is typically treated with antiviral medications in order to limit injury to the liver and help increase the likelihood of seroconversion, although the success rates aren’t great in children.
Inactive carriers, aka Hepatitis Mary
After seroconversion occurs, these patients are considered inactive carriers. They have no liver inflammation and low or undetectable viral replication. They have developed important antibodies against the virus, and have a chance to clear the infection, but they are still at risk. As many as 20% will revert back to the immune active phase at least once, and 20-30% will enter a reactivation phase where their viral load will increase and liver inflammation can return despite the improved immune response. The reactivation phase can result in rapid deterioration of liver function and is also frequently treated with antiviral medications, but these patients will rarely go on to ever clear the virus so will always be at risk for long term complications.
What are the long term complications of chronic hepatitis B virus infection?
Cirrhosis of the liver and hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) are the primary long term complications of chronic infection with HBV acquired during childhood. These don’t tend to occur until much later in life but injury in the form of fibrosis, essentially scarring of the liver, is common within just a few years of infection. Unchecked fibrosis is what can lead to cirrhosis, and ultimately loss of liver function, years to decades down the road.
Liver cancer in the form of hepatocellular carcinoma, unlike fibrosis and cirrhosis, remains a potential bad outcome even in patients who have converted to less inflammatory phases of HBV infection, and even in patients who do eventually clear the virus. Adults who were infected as infants can have a rate of HCC diagnosis as high as 5% per year. In general, the more time that a patient spends with active inflammation of the liver, and the longer it takes for antibody conversion (if it happens at all), the higher the risk of HCC.
According to the CDC, one out of every four children who develop chronic infection with HBV will die as a result. Of the patients who are exposed outside of childhood and are unlucky enough to develop a chronic infection, 15% will ultimately die earlier than they should have because of it. There are a few thousand people every year that die from this vaccine-preventable illness, despite improvements in drug therapies and even liver transplantation.
How is the hepatitis B virus spread?
Historically in the United States, and currently in countries where HBV infections are endemic, the virus has most commonly been spread from an infected mother to their baby during the birth process. Babies are frequently exposed to a significant amount of blood and body fluids at delivery, so this should make sense. As it stands in the United States now, because of the success of the vaccine the virus is no longer endemic and infections are much less common. So the most common route of spread here is through sex with an infected partner or by being stuck with a contaminated needle.
But the virus can be transmitted from one person to the other through a variety of routes that don’t involve shooting up, healthcare workplace accidents, or risky sexual activity. Viral particles can be found in other infected body fluids, such as saliva contaminated by bleeding gums or biting the inside of the cheek. Children can spread it to each other during close contact in a household or if one toddler bites another. Transmission can also occur when sharing a toothbrush or borrowing a razor. These are all unlikely, but the risk is real and cases happen every year in young children and low-risk adults.
The people who spread the virus to others are often asymptomatic and don’t even know that they are infected. Furthermore, HBV can survive on surfaces for more than seven days and still retain the ability to cause infection. Think about that as your infant crawls around the floor of the gym at their daycare center putting everything within reach straight into their mouth.
Why newborns?
So now we’ve come full circle. As I stated at the beginning of the post, many parents are hesitant to consent to a vaccine that they believe isn’t really necessary in such a young child. They may question the risk of exposure to HBV because all they know about it comes from sources like Dr. Bob Sears:
Let’s take a look at the two different schedules. One of the main differences that the CDC schedule dictates is they suggest the hepatitis B vaccine be given the day a baby’s born, one month later, and then six months later. Now, if you look at hepatitis B, it’s a sexually transmitted disease. The only way a baby can catch it is through blood or body-fluid exposure, and that’s extremely unlikely to happen for any baby or young child in the United States.
So what I did on my schedule is, I took a more logical look at hepatitis B, and I realized that babies have no risk of catching this disease, so let’s not do the hep B vaccine while a baby’s young and small and more vulnerable. Let’s do a hepatitis B vaccine when a child’s more of a preschool age, where he or she is going to be entering school and be running around with a lot of other kids, and there could be some blood or body-fluid exposures in those kinds of situations. To me, that’s just a more logical time frame to do the hepatitis B vaccine. And some parents would even take it a step further and decide to delay their children’s hep B vaccine until their children are teenagers and the real risks of hepatitis B, such as sexual activity or [intravenous] drug abuse, come into play.
His rationale amounts to waiting until they are completely past the stage where children have the highest risk of developing chronic infection and ultimately dying of liver disease or cancer. And babies are exposed to blood and body fluid, as are toddlers who haven’t started preschool, when they have siblings or are in daycare. We do test mothers for HBV activity during pregnancy but no test is perfect and information transfer from the OB or lab to the newborn service can be lost or accidentally altered.
There are 25,000 infants born to mothers that carry the virus every year in the United States that we know of. If something goes wrong and a mother is falsely labeled as negative or unknown status, that baby can have up to a 90% chance of acute infection depending on what phase she is in (immune active with high viral load has the highest risk). If infected, most will develop chronic infection and of those chronically infected 25% will die because of it.
Sears is spreading dangerous misinformation but he’s not the worst of the fearmongering anti-vaccine crowd. Our friends Mercola and the NVIC unsurprisingly take it much further. Perhaps I’ll cover their nonsense in a future post.
In addition to serving as a safety net and protecting those most vulnerable to the devastating potential outcomes of this infection, we also recommend the newborn dose because it increases the likelihood that the child will go on to get the full series of 3-4 shots and be fully protected. And protected kids can’t spread the infection to the unprotected. And despite claims from the usual suspects of antivaccine rhetoric, the safety and efficacy of this vaccine is firmly established.
Conclusion: Vaccination can be scary, but it is necessary; it is necesscary
We expect a lot from parents in the newborn nursery. They are asked to allow their little bundle of joy to go through a long list of interventions that take the baby away from their sight and can cause discomfort: antibiotic eye ointment, vitamin K injections, heel sticks for metabolic screening, hearing testing, jaundice levels, screening for heart defects, and finally, the hepatitis B vaccine. And that’s in a perfectly healthy baby. Considering this, and the lack of good public understanding of hepatitis B and the need for immunizing the very young, I’m not surprised that many refuse.
But these concerns, as understandable as they are, are unfounded. The vaccine is extremely safe, and the benefit far outweighs any small degree of risk. Protection from hepatitis B infection, which thanks to the success of the vaccine is now uncommon in the U.S., is still very important considering the potentially life-threatening complications. Complications which are significantly more likely to occur in patients infected when they are infants.

   H. influenzae—it ain’t the flu, but it’s still pretty cool
Peter Lipson
Link
I’ve been thinking about an interesting organism lately, an organism that illustrates some basic principles in science-based medicine.
The organism is called Haemophilus influenzae (H flu), a gram-negative bacterium discovered in the late 19th century. H flu has a great story, both in historic and modern times.
The brilliant microbiologist Richard Pfeiffer isolated H flu from influenza patients in the late 1800′s (hence its name) and for many years, it was believed to be the cause of the epidemic illness, and when the flu pandemic of 1918 hit, researchers worked tirelessly to develop anti-sera against H flu.
But some things weren’t adding up. As thousands died of the flu, doctors were isolating H flu from victims, but also other virulent bacteria such as Streptococcus pneumoniae. Influenza was decimating military camps, and was seriously degrading our ability to fight in WW I, so military bases were a focus of research. Doctors looked for H flu in patients, but could not find it consistently. For example in Camp Dodge, Iowa, an autopsy series showed H flu in only 9.6% of victims.
Some researchers were focusing on something else. It was found that when sputum of flu victims was sent through filters too small for bacteria to pass through, it was still infectious. These “filterable agents” were known as “viruses”. But even into the 1920′s and 1930′s, it was not clear if H flu played a significant role in influenza, or if a virus was to blame. Interestingly, at a time when women couldn’t yet vote, women physicians and scientists were at the forefront of this medical battle.
As the evidence mounted, the decades-old belief about the role of H flu in influenza (which was held with some skepticism) was abandoned, but the world wasn’t done with H flu.
H flu doesn’t cause “the flu”, but it does cause some pretty nasty human diseases, especially in children. It was a common cause of ear infections, pneumonia, meningitis, and epiglottitis. The last is especially frightening. A toddler may begin with a sore throat, and rapidly progress to difficulty swallowing and breathing. If not treated quickly, the child asphyxiates. Taken together, H flu in children had a fatality rate of about 5-6%.
Since a vaccine against H flu subtype b (Hib) became routine in 1990, the incidence of H flu disease in children has decreased by about 99%, from around 40-100 cases per 100,000 to about 1 case per 100,000.
This is one of the great vaccine success stories. From personal experience, I can tell you that few things are as grave as standing in front of a parent clutching a child who is struggling for breath, drooling, and speaking only enough to say, “Mommy, help!”
The infectious disease promotion folks, such as “Dr.” Jay Gordon may want to read a little history, a little microbiology, and a little epidemiology before telling others to endanger their children.
References
Barry, John M. The Great Influenza: The Epic Story of the Deadliest Plague in History. Published by Penguin, 2005. ISBN 0143036491, 9780143036494
Wollstein, M.D., Martha. Pfeiffer’s bacillus and influenza, a serologic study. Laboratories of the Rockefeller Institute for Medical Research. 15 July 1919.
Coca, Arthur F., Kelley, Margaret F. A Serological study of the bacillus of Pfeiffer. New York Hospital and the Department of Bacteriology in Cornell University Medical College, New York City. December 13, 1920.

   Vaccines are a pain: What to do about it
Scott Gavura 
Link
As much as I support vaccines, I see the short term consequences. Vaccines can be painful. Kids don’t like them, and parents don’t like seeing their children suffer. That this transient pain is the most common consequence of gaining protection from fatal illnesses seems like a fair trade-off to me. But that’s not the case for every parent.
Today’s post isn’t going to focus on the extremes of the anti-vaccination movement. Rather, it’s going to look at ways to make vaccines less painful and more acceptable to children. The pain of vaccines can lead to anxiety, fear, and even nonadherence with vaccination schedules. Fear of needles and injections is not uncommon, it’s estimated that 10% of the population avoids vaccinations for this reason.
The vaccine schedules are intense. Where I live, the public vaccination schedule specifies seventeen injections of six different products over six visits in the first 18 months of life, plus influenza vaccinations and one-offs like H1N1. That’s a lot of visits, and a lot of tears if a child doesn’t handle them well.
In light of what’s known about the prevalence of needle fears, their potential effect on vaccination adherence (that could persist through adult life), and the possible impact on public health because of unvaccinated individuals, it makes sense to do whatever we can to minimize the pain and discomfort of vaccines, increasing their acceptance to children and their parents. But what works? I’ve personally found Smarties (the real ones) and Dora the Explorer stickers are effective distractions and bribes. But I’m not about to call my n=2 trial good science. Nicely, there’s much more evidence to guide our recommendations.
A systematic review and practice guideline has just been published on vaccine pain: Reducing the pain of childhood vaccination: an evidence-based clinical practice guideline. The lead author, Anna Taddio, is a pharmacist and professor at the University of Toronto, and coauthors include large team of academics and health professionals.The guideline is lengthy and detailed, so I’m going to summarize the highlights. There are also some practical handouts for health professionals and parents developed by the authors: links are at the bottom.
Distilling the Evidence
The systematic review looked at both pain and distress (collectively, “pain”) related to vaccine administration. An interdisciplinary team of physician, pharmacists, academics, stakeholders (including parents) were convened, who identified 32 focused clinical questions (later reduced, because of the evidence base). The review didn’t consider post-injection pain and discomfort, which is common yet transient. As pain management is typically based on a “3-P” approach (pharmacologic, physical, and psychological), three systematic reviews and three meta-analyses, one for each domain, were conducted for each clinical question. Evidence was restricted to RCTs. Recommendations were graded based on level of evidence and grade of recommendation according to a standardized format:
Overall, 71 studies involving 8050 children were reviewed. All recommendation were externally reviewed according to a validated process, by vaccination, public health, and medical associations. The study was publicly funded, and disclosed conflicts of interest were minor.
The Findings
Fourteen clinical questions were answered. The guideline has more detail and specific clinical considerations.
1. Does breastfeeding during vaccination reduce pain at the time of injection?
Yes. Breastfeeding has been shown to provide analgesic effects, possibly through the combination of holding, skin-to-skin contact, the sweetness of the milk, and the process of sucking. To reduce pain, breastfeeding mothers should be encouraged to breastfeed during the vaccination procedure. (Grade I-A)
2. Does administration of a sweet-tasting solution reduce pain at the time of injection?
Yes. Sweet oral solutions provide analgesic effects in infants, reducing signs of pain. Up to 12 months of age, infants who cannot be breastfed during vaccination may be administered a sweet-tasting solution during vaccination (Grade I-A). A simple formula is one packet/cube of sugar in two teaspoons (10 mL) of water. Place in the infant’s mouth with an oral syringe 1-2 minutes before injection. The process is well tolerated, and side effects, like coughing and gagging, are infrequent. Because of conflicting data, there is insufficient evidence to support this strategy in children older than 12 months.
3. Are there pain-related differences between different brands of the same vaccine?
There is only evidence for the MMR vaccine, where differences have been observed between brands. (Grade I-A) Differences may be due to formulation, adjuvants, and pH. Given this is a Canadian-based systematic review, it’s not clear what differences might exist in other countries. Greater knowledge that differences do exist may guide vaccine selection by health authorities. But little choice usually exists at the point of care.
4. Do different body positions results in different pain levels?
The very limited evidence that exists suggests that children are should not be in a supine (lying down) position. (Grade I-E) Sitting upright, or being held, seems preferable. This may be due to anxiety, which could impact perceived pain. Excessive restraint can increase distress, so holding and support without force is probably preferable.
5. Should slow injection, with aspiration be avoided?
Yes. Intramuscular injections should be given with a rapid injection technique without aspiration (drawing back on the plunger). (Grade I-B). As injection sites do not have large blood vessels, there’s no rationale for aspiration. Slow injection and aspiration may add to the pain due to longer contact time and possible needle wiggle in tissue.
6. When multiple vaccines are to be given in one visit, which first? The most painful, or the least?
This is a common situation. Where differences exist, give the most painful vaccine last. (Grade I-B). Based on limited information, MMR II and Prevnar appear to be more painful than other vaccines. (This may be specific to Canada. Anyone that administers vaccines routinely will probably know which are more painful.) Giving the more painful vaccine last seems to decrease the overall pain from both injections, based on the results of a single RCT.
7. Does rubbing the skin near the injection site, before and during the procedure, reduce the perception of pain?
Probably, in those 4 years of age and older. Rubbing and stroking the skin may reduce pain. (Grade B-II-1) The mechanism of the analgesia may be the “white noise” created at the site of injection. It’s not clear if this effect is present in young children. The optimal method of rubbing (frequency, intensity, pattern) isn’t known. Rubbing the injection site after injection is thought to increase vaccine reactions and isn’t recommended.
8. Does parental distraction or coaching result in less pain?
There’s insufficient evidence to say. (Grade I-B) Different interventions have been systematically studied, but don’t provide persuasive evidence that it’s effective. This could be due to a number of reasons, including inadequate training or preparation. Given distraction and coaching are cheap and can engage the parent in a formal role, they are reasonable interventions to make. Parent-led distraction is not as effective as clinician- or child-led distraction, however. See the references for a parental tip sheet.
9. Do topical anaestheics reduce injection pain?
Yes. (Grade I-A). Several topical anaesthetics (EMLA, Ametop, Maxilene) are available, and in some countries, without a prescription. They must be applied 20-40 minutes before the procedure. There is no evidence they interfere with vaccine immunogenicity.
10. Does clinician-led distraction result in less pain?
Probably, and is recommended in all age groups. (Grade B-I) See below for a training sheet for health professionals. The same health professional that is administering the vaccine can also administer the distraction, so the intervention does not consume more resources. See the tip sheet in the references for suggested distractions that may be used by clinicians.
11. Do child-led distractions result in less pain?
Yes, in children three years of age or older. (Grade B-I). Child-led distraction effectively reduces pain, however there’s not enough information to determine what’s most effective. See the tip sheets in the references for suggested distractions.
12. Do breathing strategies (deep breathing, blowing) reduce the pain of injection?
Probably. Slow, deep breathing helps relax children and seems to reduce pain. (Grade B-I). Deep breathing and slow blowing may be effective. Using distractions like bubbles, pinwheels or party blowers can serve dual purposes.
13. Do combined interventions (e.g., cognitive AND behavioural techniques) work?
They seem to, based on limited evidence (grade B-I) Combine different interventions in children 3 years of age and older.
14. What about telling the child, “It won’t hurt”?
Not recommended. This has been evaluated, and has not been shown to be effective. (grade D-I)
15. What about cooling sprays or ice packs?
There is insufficient evidence for or against cooling. While vapocoolant sprays are marketed to reduce pain, there’s no persuasive evidence these products are effective in children. Ice packs also may be ineffective. This could be because children perceive coldness as pain.
16. Do simultaneous injections cause less pain than sequential vaccine administration?
Insufficient evidence. Given the the difficulty blinding such an intervention, I’d expect this would be difficult to determine. Given the resource requirements to administer, there seems to be little rationale to consider this approach.
17. Is intramuscular injection less painful than subcutaneous, if the choice is available?
Insufficient evidence. RCTs have provided conflicting evidence. Manufacturer’s prescribing evidence should be followed.
18. What about acetaminophen or ibuprofen before the injection?
Insufficient evidence. There are no RCTs that have evaluated the common practice of giving analgesics in advance of an injection. There is evidence that analgesics do reduce the post-injection side effects of pain. As there’s some data suggestive that this may reduce the immune response to the vaccine itself, the practice is now questioned by some.
Conclusion
Not all arguments against vaccines are are amenable to the simple provision of education or evidence about their efficacy and safety. In some cases, simple interventions may be able shift perceptions of the benefits and consequences.
Compared to what we’d expect for other types of health interventions, the quality of the evidence for some of these recommendations is weak. Yet that shouldn’t stop us from considering them if they’re plausible and easy to implement: There’s little downside risk. By taking steps to reduce vaccine pain we can improve vaccine acceptance, completion of the vaccination schedule, and overall improvements in public health outcomes.

Another Child Suffers From the Effects of Anti-Vaccine Propaganda…and Tetanus
As an Australian child suffers from tetanus, a horrific and virtually 100% preventable illness, a prominent local anti-vaccine propagandist goes on the attack.
Clay Jones on March 24, 2017
Link
Last week, news of an Australian 7-year-old diagnosed with a vaccine preventable illness made the rounds. The child had not received a recommended series of vaccines that would have reduced her risk after exposure by about 100%, but this is a common occurrence in New South Wales where childhood immunization rates are below 50% in some areas. Mullumbimby, the birthplace of “rapper” Iggy Azalea and a recent host to a talk by New Age meme generator David Wolfe, in particular is a home to many unprotected children.
The vaccine-preventable disease in this case is tetanus. You’ve undoubtedly heard of tetanus before, likely when getting one of the recommended booster shots every ten years, but never known anyone who has had it. Many people are at least familiar with the term lockjaw, known as trismus in medical jargon, but there are a variety of signs and symptoms, some of which can result in severe pain and difficulty breathing even to the point of death. Although details of her presentation are few and untrustworthy, this little girl has very likely suffered significant physical discomfort and emotional distress. Her parents, regardless of whether or not they are to blame for their child’s condition, certainly have as well.
Tetanus is extremely rare in the United States and other developed regions including Australia, thanks to the widespread availability of a safe and effective vaccine. The developing world isn’t so lucky, experiencing about a million cases annually with a few hundred thousand deaths. And anytime there is a natural disaster we see a spike of cases related to dirty wounds and a lack of adequate medical care.
When modern medical care is available, mortality is low except for the most severe cases. The very young (specifically when a neonate acquires tetanus after their umbilical cord is handled in a non-sterile manner) and those over 65 years of age tend to have the worst outcomes. Unfortunately, those in developing regions who are diagnosed with tetanus have a more grim prognosis. Overall, the mortality rate can be as high as 50% without treatment.
It appears that the child in question is now stable and will recover, although it will takes weeks. She is lucky to be alive, thanks to the availability of modern medical treatment. Meryl Dorey, ringleader of the notorious anti-vaccine organization known as the Australian Vaccine-skeptics Network, which is headquartered in New South Wales, has responded to the situation here and here. I’ll address her propaganda, but first a bit more on tetanus because it’s interesting and I really want to paint a picture of what this poor child likely experienced.
What is tetanus?
Tetanus occurs when the spores of a specific bacterium commonly found in soil and mammalian feces inoculate unhealthy human tissue, most often via a penetrating injury through the skin. When the conditions are right, such as in the setting of an infection, a foreign body, or tissue that is poorly perfused or dead, the Clostridium tetani spores “wake up” and begin to produce tetanus toxin (tetanospasmin). Tetanus is also known to occur in the setting of home births, septic abortions, necrotic bowel, non-sterile ritual circumcision, and when injecting with dirty needles to name a few other causes.
Rarely there will only be local effects, but in the vast majority of patients the toxin will eventually gain access to peripheral nerves and travel along their course in a retrograde fashion until reaching the brainstem and spinal cord. The toxin will then bind irreversibly to inhibitory neurons and begin to interrupt neurotransmission of GABA and glycine. This results in complete disinhibition of neurons responsible for keeping the motor cortex and the autonomic nervous system in check.
What are the signs and symptoms of tetanus?
The end result of exposure to tetanus toxin, a neurotoxin considered by some to be the runner up to Botulinum toxin when it comes to deadliness, in most cases is painful muscular spasms in the setting of a general increased muscle tone. As if that weren’t enough, disinhibition of the autonomic nervous system can cause varying degrees of hell to break lose, with an overproduction of catecholamines and subsequent profuse sweating, increased heart rate and blood pressure, fever, and agitation. It’s the fight of the “fight or flight” reflex in overdrive. It can even result in life threatening cardiac arrhythmias.
As demonstrated in the video linked to above, patients with generalized tetanus have diffuse tonic contraction of their muscles. This is interrupted by terribly painful spasms that can be triggered by a variety of stimuli, even just a noise or a light breeze, and can be powerful enough to cause fractures of the spine and long bones. Patients with tetanus are generally kept in dark and quiet rooms with a goal of reducing external stimuli as much as possible.
Trismus occurs when the muscles of the jaw go into spasm and can limit the ability to open the mouth, making it difficult to speak, eat, or breathe. Another classic symptom, known as risus sardonicus, is when spasm of facial and forehead muscles produce a sustained smile with raised eyebrows. Intense spasm of chest and/or throat muscles can cause an inability to breath that can be extremely distressing, and is the primary cause of death in tetanus. Other causes of death are pneumonia, blood clots in the lungs, and heart attacks.
How is tetanus treated?
If you are lucky enough to develop tetanus in a developed country, you’ll probably live. It won’t be a fun few weeks, but there are a variety of interventions that can ameliorate the symptoms and speed recovery a bit. First off, any wounds need to be cleaned and cleared of dead tissue that may be harboring spores and toxin-producing bacteria.
Antibiotics aimed at killing the tetanus causing bacteria, as well as any suspected co-infecting organisms, is standard as well. It isn’t entirely clear just how much of a role antimicrobial use plays in recovery, but limited data is supportive. More important is the use of human tetanus immune globulin (HTIG).
I previously described the attachment of tetanus toxin to inhibitory neurons as irreversible. This means that the neuron will not recover function. Therefore a focus on binding up and neutralizing toxin that has yet to find a neuronal home is key, and this is just what HTIG does. This is known as passive immunization and has been clearly shown to improve survival. Recovery from tetanus occurs as neurons regenerate, a process which can take weeks to months.
Other aspects of management focus on symptom control. This can involve the use of sedatives and paralyzing agents in order to reduce the severity of muscular spasms. Magnesium sulfate has been shown to reduce autonomic dysfunction in randomized trials. Other drugs are often used, such as beta blockers and morphine, but they have less of an evidence base to support them.
Patients with severe presentations generally require placement of a surgical airway, such as a tracheostomy, and mechanical ventilation. They may be immobilized and on a ventilator for weeks, which puts them at risk of hospital acquired infections, ulcers, and numerous other complications. Nutritional management is extremely important as well, with most patients admitted to an ICU requiring feeds via a surgically placed gastrostomy tube, or even IV nutrition, in order to meet metabolic needs. Physical therapy is also important in speeding recovery.
Patients diagnosed with tetanus are obviously not immune and require active immunization as well in order to protect them in the future. Both the vaccine as well as HTIG are often given in the ED as tetanus prophylaxis when people seek care for wounds. This depends on whether or not the patient has been fully vaccinated (at least three prior doses), the timing of the most recent dose, and the nature of the wound. For example, if you are fully vaccinated but it has been more than five years since the last dose, you would receive the vaccine if you shoved a dirty nail into your foot. If you weren’t fully vaccinated, the same wound would call for HTIG in addition to the vaccine.
About that vaccine
Developed in the 1920s, tetanus vaccine, known as tetanus toxoid, consists of formaldehyde-treated toxin. This renders it incapable of causing disease but able to coax the body into mounting an immune response. The vaccine does not result in permanent immunity and must be boosted every ten years, although some people begin to have a significant decrease in antibody levels after five years.
Tetanus vaccine was first truly put into action during World War II, resulting in a significant decrease in cases compared to the previous world war. In the late 1940s, the vaccine was introduced in the U.S. (1950s in Australia) as a routine childhood immunization and national reporting was initiated. Prior to the vaccine, the number of cases had been steadily falling with better recognition of high risk injuries and improved wound management, but it has plummeted since in developed regions. In the United States, we have gone from 500-600 cases per year as the vaccine was being rolled out to less than 30 today.
The tetanus vaccine is extremely effective, with virtually 100% of people who have received the full series achieving more than adequate levels of protective antibodies. For this reason, almost all reported cases of tetanus occur in individuals who did not receive the full series or who have gone longer than ten years since their last dose, typically after failing to seek medical care for a high-risk wound. Very rarely do people with evidence of immunity become ill, and there is a clear inverse relationship between antibody levels and severity of disease.
The anti-vaccine community responds
Earlier in the post I mentioned and linked to two blog posts from Australian vaccine denier Meryl Dorey. In her posts, she questions the safety and efficacy of the vaccine, implies negligence on the part of the medical community caring for the child, and asks what the big deal is since loads of kids in Australia are killed by cars every year. There is truly too much pure nonsense to discuss in one post but I’ll pick out a few highlights.In Respecting our Families, Dorey laments the unfair treatment that the child’s parents have received from the public. This may be a fair concern. Medical professionals caring for the child cannot share private details regarding the reasons that she is not vaccinated and the family has not spoken to the press. We don’t know if this family is rabidly anti-vaccine or simply hesitant to allow their child to receive one or more vaccines. There may also be a true medical contraindication to the tetanus vaccine.
Dorey claims to have spoken with someone who knows the family, and proceeds to give numerous specific details regarding the events leading up to her diagnosis. I don’t know if these details are accurate, but they include an explanation for why the family has “rejected vaccines”:
I was told that this little girl had two members of her family who reacted badly to vaccines – one of whom nearly died from a tetanus shot. Another close relative had a serious reaction to a different vaccine which led to long-term physical problems.
If true, I can certainly understand why a caregiver would be hesitant to give consent for their child to be vaccinated although this would not be considered a true contraindication. The reality however, is that while there certainly are extremely rare severe reactions to vaccines, it is exceedingly more likely that vaccination was not to blame for any long-term problems or near death experiences. But without actual medical information we can’t be sure.
Dorey explains that the child suffered a crush injury to her toe and received what sounds like appropriate medical care. She then relates how three weeks after the injury, a time span that does make sense in the context of tetanus, she began to have what may have been trismus, convulsions (which were likely muscular spasms), and difficulty standing. The following day her condition worsened and she was referred to a hospital where tetanus was diagnosed and treatment initiated.
Dorey claims that several times during the period between her injury and ultimate diagnosis with tetanus, the child’s family asked medical professionals if she might have tetanus. Each time they were reassured. Maybe this is true, although it is more likely that their recollection has been altered by time, stress, new information, and the need to recall the memory over and over again while reducing cognitive dissonance.
Based on Dorey’s description of the events, there doesn’t appear to have been a reason to suspect tetanus during the three weeks prior to becoming symptomatic, nor a significant delay in obtaining appropriate medical care. Yet she implies that a delay in care occurred that prolonged the child’s suffering. If anything, she describes parents that waited until the afternoon to seek medical care for an extremely ill and uncomfortable child that had been up all night having painful muscle spasms and an inability to open her mouth.
She then butchers an attempt to discuss the medical facts about tetanus:
A hydrogen peroxide solution is often applied to deep puncture wounds, forcing oxygen into the site and if necessary, there have been recommendations to apply pressure to the wound, forcing blood to the surface since blood is highly oxygenated.
Hydrogen peroxide use is frequently discussed on anti-vaccine websites. In reality, it would likely increase the risk of tetanus because it injures tissue and is not recommended by medical experts. I would be hesitant to trust any medical information following such inaccurate statements. Like this for example:
Tetanus is very rare in Australia – mainly due to the fact that very few of us now live on the same land occupied by large animals such as cattle and horses who carry tetanus spores in their faeces. We are also much more likely to clean wounds thoroughly and properly when they occur, not allowing them to fester.
Tetanus is extremely rare in Australia because of the tetanus vaccine. Proper wound management is also important, but the implication that the vaccine isn’t the primary reason reveals her bias. She goes on to imply that the vaccine doesn’t really work very well anyway and is dangerous, and she links to a whale.to article.
In Both Doctors and the Media Misinform the Public About Tetanus, Dorey implies that the science behind vaccine safety and efficacy is mere “guesswork.” She also attempts to weasel out of her implication that the medical community failed to appropriately treat the child’s initial wound and to diagnose her tetanus in a timely fashion. This is immediately followed with the overt claim that that is exactly what they did.
It gets worse from there, including this gem:
Now, I will ask you all the question I have asked medicos for nearly two decades without any answer at all – if natural infection cannot convey immunity, how can vaccination do what the disease cannot?
No answer at all huh? Remember when I mentioned how deadly this toxin is? Only Botulinum toxin is more potent. The amount of toxin produced leading to most cases of tetanus is minuscule, yet it can kill the patient. This tiny amount isn’t enough to trigger an immune response, which is why the vaccine is necessary.
Conclusion: Tetanus sucks, get vaccinated
Tetanus is an awful disease and causes great suffering in those unlucky enough to acquire it, and it can be fatal. There is an extremely safe and virtually 100% effective means of preventing it that sadly some parents are denying their children. I can’t say with certainly what the motivation behind this child’s caregivers’ decision to refuse vaccines was, but it was almost certainly influenced by misinformation from people like Meryl Dorey.
Trivia: Tetanus is the only vaccine-preventable illness for which herd immunity does not apply as it is not spread from person to person. It lives in the soil and does not require a human reservoir to survive. Please make sure that you are up to date and seek appropriate medical attention for high-risk wounds.
Here is a description of another case of childhood tetanus recently published by the AAP.

What happened to the Lyme vaccine?
You can vaccinate your dog against Lyme disease, but there’s no vaccine for humans. Why?
Scott Gavura on October 4, 2018
Link


There’s significant and understandable concern about Lyme disease today. The spirochete Borellia burgdorferi was only discovered in 1982, and the disease only became reportable in the United States in 1991. Today, Lyme is the most common vector-borne disease in the United States (and Europe) with 25,000 cases being reported annually. Understandably, efforts have been growing to find ways to prevent Lyme disease, focusing on personal protection primarily, with environmental protection as a secondary measure. Some may recall that there was a vaccine on the market almost two decades ago, but it’s no longer marketed today. The story of the Lyme vaccine’s rise and fall is fascinating, and raises questions about whether there will ever be another Lyme vaccine marketed again.
What is Lyme disease?
Lyme disease is a bacterial infection spread by ticks. Its name comes from Lyme, Connecticut, where a cluster of cases called “Lyme Arthritis” were reported in 1977. While it’s highly prevalent in New England, Lyme disease has been reported in every state, and its reach continues to grow. Several species of Borrelia have been found to cause Lyme disease, but B. burgdorferi is the primary cause in North America. Lyme disease is carried by various Ixodes ticks, which vary based on geography. Ticks contract B. burgdorferi from a blood meal of infected host – usually a mouse, but it can be any rodent, and also birds. Infected ticks reside on shrubs or grass (peaking in June of each year), and will attach to mammals when they detect warmth and carbon dioxide. It’s preferably the white-tailed deer, but increasingly, a human. They can attach to any part of the body, but it’s locations like the back, armpits and scalp where they may not be noticed for a few days – which is when infection can occur. This image from the CDC gives a good illustration of the circle of (a tick’s) life:
Ticks must be attached for 36-48 hours before a transmission of B. burgdorferi occurs. Infections can be divided into three phases:
    • Early localized infection appears as a rash (often in the form of a series of concentric rings, or “bull’s eye rash”) and what feels like a viral illness (fatigue, headache, aches, and sometimes fever). It can occur in about 80% of those infected, usually within a month of infection.
    • Early disseminated infection occurs weeks to months after the initial infection. It can include neurologic (e.g., meningitis), and cardiac complications. This may be the first sign of infection in some.
    • Late disease occurs months to years after the initial infection. Arthritis is the most common sign, but there may be neurologic signs as well.
Lyme is diagnosed based on signs and symptoms, plus a history of possible exposure to ticks. Laboratory testing may also be used. While there are multiple reports of a condition termed “chronic Lyme” there is no persuasive evidence that “chronic Lyme” exists as a disease related to Lyme disease or its treatment. (More on “chronic Lyme” in the SBM archives.)
Treatment of Lyme disease depends on when it was detected and how it has manifested. Treatment is usually weeks of antibiotics and other therapies when more serious complications are present. When treated early, Lyme responds well to antibiotics, and a full recovery can normally be expected.
The origins of a vaccine
Given the growing incidence of Lyme disease over time, and the challenge in preventing bites, there was interest in developing a vaccine soon after Lyme was discovered. By the early 1980s, it was identified that most patients with Lyme disease had antibodies to a protein associated with B. burgdorferi, called the Outer Surface Protein (OspA). Antibodies against OspA were subsequently shown in animal models to protect against infection with Borellia burgdorferi. Two vaccines were eventually developed: LYMErix – by SmikeKline Beecham and ImuLyme by Pasteur Mérieux Connaught (ImuLyme was never submitted to the FDA for approval). How both vaccines worked was similar: They introduced antibodies in the body that would be ingested by the tick during a blood meal. The antibodies would then neutralize any B. burgdorferi spirochetes present in the tick, preventing any possible infection. LYMErix was a series of three vaccines at 0, 1, and 12 months. A 10,000-subject clinical trial established that LYMErix was generally well tolerated, with an calculated efficacy against symptomatic disease of approximately 76%, after all 3 doses were given.
Based on the efficacy data, LYMErix was approved in 1998. The Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) recommended the vaccine for people that engaged in activities that resulted in frequent/prolonged exposure to tick-infested areas, where rates of Lyme disease was known to be high. It was not recommended to those with no to minimal exposure to tick-infested areas. Over the first few years, about 1.5 million doses were given.
While the vaccine did work, it was not without limitations. The biggest concern was efficacy: Over 20% of those vaccinated could still contract Lyme disease. And to achieve the 76% efficacy, one had to receive three vaccines given over a full year. Importantly, the vaccine was not tested in young children (the trial enrolled ages 15 to 70), one of the populations at risk of Lyme. And the vaccine did not provide protection against all strains of the disease – especially European forms of Lyme. There was also uncertainty about how long the effects would persist, and if boosters might be required annually.
Media-driven safety fears and the end of LYMErix
During its review the FDA noted the possibility that the vaccine could have a relationship with autoimmune arthritis. Given Lyme arthritis was influenced by immune factors, there was the hypothesis that the vaccine itself could conceivably cause arthritis in some individuals. While this hypothesis was just that – a hypothesis – there was some research in the area that never actually showed the vaccine could cause arthritis. Nor was there any clinical trial or post-marketing data to suggest it was occurring. This eventually moved from the scientific literature to the mass media with headlines like “Concerns Grow Over Reactions to Lyme Shots” in The New York Times around 2000. Growing coverage was also accompanied by the emergence of anti-Lyme-vaccine groups (e.g., Lyme Disease Network) who touted “vaccine victims”. Because the vaccine was not on the routine recommended vaccine schedule, the protections offered to manufacturers under the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (NVICP) did not apply. NVICP offers compensation to individuals injured by vaccines, and protects manufacturers from frivolous lawsuits. Because NVICP did not apply, class action lawsuits were launched against the manufacturer.
The FDA examined the safety of the vaccine in 2001. A panel concluded that there was no evidence of arthritis and vaccine based on available evidence, but encourage enrollment in a safety study of the product. Importantly no difference was found in the incidence of arthritis when comparing those that received the vaccine to those that did not. The vaccine adverse event reporting system (VAERS) was also examined for safety signals. In a paper eventually published in 2002, an analysis did not detect any specific safety signals that were not otherwise detected in the clinical trials. No arthritis.
By 2002, there seemed to be little appeal for a Lyme vaccine. Perhaps accelerated by the class-action lawsuits and the anti-vaccine lobby, the demand for the vaccine continue to drop. The manufacturer voluntarily discontinued sales of the product that year – it had been on the market for just 38 months. There was no evidence it caused arthritis, but dwindling sales (and the growing liability of lawsuits) led to its demise.
Is a vaccine possible again?
There are no vaccines available to prevent Lyme disease today in humans, and it seems unlikely (but not impossible) that one will appear anytime soon. There’s a lot of hurdles to overcome – not just regulatory hurdles, but public acceptance as well. Any pharmaceutical company will likely assess the risk of producing a new vaccine carefully, given its history and the persistent but unfounded belief that the vaccine was harmful. But given the growing incidence and regional spread of Lyme disease in North America, and a greater understanding of the harms it can cause, there is arguably a greater need for a vaccine today than ever before. And given we can vaccinate dogs against Lyme, perhaps we should be cautiously optimistic that the continued search for a vaccine may lead to its reappearance someday.

Cunnilingus, Michael Douglas’s Cancer, and the HPV Vaccine
Harriet Hall on August 6, 2013
Link

Conservative Christians are calling for banning oral and anal sex between consenting adults, claiming that the practices allow for the spread of disease. Radio host Brian Fischer says that a rise in head, neck and throat cancers “among millennials” is a direct result of the influence of “Bill Clinton and Monica Lewinsky.” He compares oral sex and homosexual sex to drug trafficking, pedophilia and bestiality. He hasn’t decided how offenders should be punished but he suggests either issuing summonses like parking tickets or putting them into programs akin to drug rehab. He says Liz Cheney (the daughter of former Vice President Cheney) is “not a patriot” because she may support gay marriage.
Those of us who want the government to stay the hell out of our bedrooms will gladly ignore such rants, but the health risks of sexual practices are real. Michael Douglas recently shocked the world by announcing that cunnilingus could have caused his throat cancer. He was right, it could have.
HPV causes several kinds of cancer
Most head and neck cancers are caused by tobacco and alcohol, but researchers believe that up to 80% of oropharyngeal cancers are due to HPV (human papilloma virus) infection. The cause can be confirmed by testing biopsy samples for HPV DNA. The incidence of throat cancer caused by HPV is rising rapidly (a 225% increase from 1988 to 2004) and has been attributed to an increase in oral sex. It is estimated that by 2020 HPV will cause more oropharyngeal cancers than cervical cancers in the US.
Approximately 15 types of HPV cause virtually all cases of cervical cancer; types 16 and 18 account for 70% of cases. Type 16 causes 85% of anal cancers. Types 16 and 18 cause close to half of vaginal, vulvar, and penile cancers. More than half of cancers diagnosed in the oropharynx are linked to Type 16. In addition, people infected with HPV may be three times as likely to develop esophageal cancer. DNA tests for HPV are accurate, but there are as yet no FDA-approved tests for detecting HPV virus in men.
HPV vaccines
One of the Holy Grails of medical research is a vaccine to prevent cancer. Now we have 2 of them, Gardasil and Cervarix. Both vaccines are highly protective against HPV types 16 and 18, and Gardasil also protects against type 6 and 11. They have not specifically been approved for prevention of oropharyngeal cancer, but we can expect that they will accomplish that as well.
Only half of US girls age 13-17 have received a dose of the HPV vaccine, and only a third have received the full recommended series of three. Other countries have higher vaccination rates; the rate in Rwanda is 80%. Despite the poor uptake in the US, HPV infections in teens have fallen by half since the vaccines became available, suggesting that some degree of herd immunity is occurring. By one estimate, if the vaccination rate in the US equaled Rwanda’s, 50,000 lifetime cases of cervical cancer could be prevented.
The vaccines are most effective if given before sexual activity starts. A series of three injections two months apart is recommended at age 11-12 for both girls and boys. The cost in the US is a total of $450, not always covered by insurance; but the manufacturers have cut their prices to the world’s poorest countries to below $5 a dose. In poor countries, Pap tests are impractical, treatment of cancer is not readily available, and cervical cancer kills an estimated 275,000 women a year.
Two factors are responsible for the low vaccination rate in the U.S.: doctors are not pushing the vaccine and malicious rumors are frightening parents.
Irresponsible fear-mongering
Myth: The HPV vaccine has killed at least 21 girls (Mercola says 122).Reality: Deaths have occurred after the vaccine; deaths have occurred in girls who were not vaccinated; not one single death has ever been attributed to the vaccine.
Myth: The vaccine has caused 9749 adverse reactions.Reality: No serious adverse reactions have been attributed to the vaccine.
Myth: It has caused 10 miscarriages.Reality: It has not been linked to miscarriages. Sure, 10 individuals may have had miscarriages after getting the vaccine, but the baseline rate of miscarriage is higher than that in women who have not been vaccinated.
Note: these 3 claims were based on reports to VAERS (the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System). VAERS only lists things that happened after vaccination; it doesn’t mean they were caused by vaccination. Relying on VAERS data is a post hoc ergo propter hoc error in reasoning. 57,000,000 doses of the vaccine have been administered, yet no deaths or serious adverse reactions have been linked to the vaccine.
Myth: It hasn’t been properly tested.Reality: It was tested in thousands of girls before marketing, and the after-market experience with 57,000,000 doses constitutes a further test.
Myth: It hasn’t been shown to reduce the rate of cervical cancer.Reality: It takes a couple of decades for those cancers to appear. Meanwhile, it has reduced the rate of the infections that cause those cancers, so it would be amazing if it had no impact.
Myth: It only covers a few strains of the virus.Reality: Yes, but those are the ones that matter.
Myth: It will lead to promiscuity.Reality: More than one study has shown that it doesn’t.
Myth: Mike Adams, the “Health Ranger,” says the FDA knew as early as 2003 that the HPV virus was not linked to cervical cancer.Reality: What is he smoking? The entire scientific community accepts the strong evidence of a link.
Conclusion: A vaccine to prevent cancer!
We have a vaccine for cancer! A very safe vaccine that reduces the rate of HPV infections and therefore will reduce the rate of cervical cancer and several other types of cancer. If Michael Douglas had had the option of being vaccinated as a teen, it’s possible that it could have prevented his throat cancer. I don’t see any valid reason to refuse the vaccine other than perhaps its cost. My daughters were both vaccinated, and if I had a teenage son, I would make sure he got the vaccine too. And before anyone has a chance to suggest it, let me say that I do not receive any pay from Big Pharma nor do I own any stock in the companies that make the vaccines.

HPV Vaccine for Boys
Harriet Hall on November 22, 2011
Link
A recent announcement is likely to generate a lot of controversy. The Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices of the CDC has recommended that boys and young men be vaccinated against human papillomavirus (HPV). Previously the guidelines said boys “could” be given the HPV vaccine. Now they have recommended that boys age 11 to 12 “should” be vaccinated, as well as boys age 13 to 21 who have not already had the full series of 3 shots. The vaccine can also be given to boys as young as 9 and to young men age 22 to 26.
The vaccine was originally promoted as a way to prevent cervical cancer. Boys don’t have a cervix, so why should they be subjected to a “girl’s” vaccine? There are some good science-based reasons:
    • Boys can transmit the virus to female sex partners later in life, leading to cervical cancer in women.
    • More importantly, boys themselves can also be directly harmed by the virus. It can cause genital warts, cancer of the head and neck (tongue, tonsils and throat), anal and penile cancer, respiratory papillomatosis, and giant condyloma of Buschke and Lowenstein. In rare cases, immunocompromised patients can develop epidermodysplasia verruciformis.
    • There are other unconfirmed concerns: HPV has been associated with cardiovascular disease in one study.
Some of these conditions are not common, and the most common one, genital warts, may sound trivial. But “a picture is worth a thousand words,” so here is a link to a picture of a giant condyloma of Buschke and Lowenstein as an example of what HPV can do to the unvaccinated. The picture is not pleasant. If you are squeamish, you may not want to look at it. If you can’t even stand to look at it, imagine how devastating it would be to have it appear on your own body, and how nice it would be to be vaccinated against it.
The patient is a 45 year old man who had a 1-year history of discomfort when sitting. The picture shows a cauliflower-like verrucous mass around the anus, measuring 15cm in diameter. It required surgery. These lesions are rare, destructive tumors that mostly affect men under the age of 50. They are benign, but they destroy adjacent tissue, and malignant transformation can occur. They are caused by one of the types of HPV infection that can be prevented by the HPV vaccine, HPV type 6, which was confirmed by DNA analysis in this case.
Before anyone accuses me of relying on “anecdotal” evidence, that’s not what this is: this is an illustration of a rare but serious complication of HPV infection. If it appears alarmist, maybe that’s just what science needs to get its message across, to counteract all those emotionally laden stories of patients who were allegedly hurt (“Schoolgirl, 14, Dies After Being Given Cervical Cancer Jab”) and the lies that are continually published (“HPV Vaccine Kills At Least 21 Girls So Far”). Maybe science should fight back with headlines like “Failure to Get HPV Vaccine Causes Giant Flesh-Eating Wart!”
Gardasil is a quadrivalent vaccine that protects against HPV types 16 and 18, which are responsible for about 70 percent of cases of cervical cancer, and against types 6 and 11, which are responsible for 90 percent of genital warts. It also produces some degree of cross-immunity with other HPV strains. Overall prevalence of HPV in women in the US is 26.8%, although the prevalence of the types targeted by the vaccines is only 3.4%.  Most studies of HPV in men have reported a prevalence of least 20%, and some have reported much higher, up to 72.9%.  Prevalence data are misleading, because they do not reflect lifetime incidence or cancer risk: many infections resolve spontaneously, and it is the persistence of certain serotypes that leads to precancerous and cancerous lesions. By one estimate, between 75 percent and 80 percent of females and males in the United States will be infected at some point in their lives.  There is an alarmingly high incidence of new HPV infections in the teenage/young adult population, the group targeted for vaccines. Vaccines are most effective when given before initiation of sexual activity. These concerns have led to recommendations for legislation to facilitate vaccination.
The vaccine is very safe. Most reported side effects are mild, mainly local reactions with an occasional fainting episode. Deaths and serious adverse events after HPV vaccination have been reported to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System, but none of these have been causally linked to the vaccine. The vaccine clearly works. Questions have been raised about its effectiveness, but epidemiologist Tara Smith has shown that those questions are misguided.   While it is too early to document its impact on cancers or mortality, there is clear evidence that the vaccine reduces the incidence of precursors for several types of cancer. A recent study in the NEJM confirmed its effectiveness in preventing anal intraepithelial neoplasia, a precursor of anal cancer, in men who have sex with men. The rate of anal cancer is increasing in both men and women, and it is hoped that the vaccine will reverse that trend. The rate of HPV-related head and neck cancer is increasing in young men, and can also be expected to decrease with vaccination.
I won’t get into ideology, cost-effectiveness, or the pros and cons of mandatory vaccination, but the science is clear: for both sexes, the benefits of this vaccine outweigh the risks. In The New York Times Dr. William Schaffner was quoted as saying
This is cancer, for Pete’s sake… A vaccine against cancer was the dream of our youth.
I made sure my daughters got the vaccine. If I had sons, I would vaccinate them too.

   HPV vaccination misinformation and bias in Medscape.
David Gorski
Link
Like many physicians, I often peruse Medscape. It’s generally been a convenient and quick way to catch up on what’s going on in my field not directly related to my research, for which I tend to rely on pre-configured RSS feeds for PubMed searches to highlight any articles related to my areas of interest. Since these searches routinely flag hundreds of articles a week whose titles and abstracts I end up perusing, sometimes only cursorily to identify the articles I might want to read, it is impractical for me to rely on this approach for areas that are even only a bit out of my field. That’s where, at least so I thought, services like Medscape came in handy. I could look over stories and quickly find out about research and medical of interest to me, only occasionally needing to look up the actual journal articles. Like a fair number of physicians, I rely on it fairly regularly. I should also point out that Medscape sometimes even tries to go against the tide of woo, as it did when it published an article by authored by two of my co-bloggers, along with two others. The article, authored by Kimball C. Atwood IV, MD; Elizabeth Woeckner, AB, MA; Robert S. Baratz, MD, DDS, PhD; and Wallace I. Sampson, MD, entitled Why the NIH Trial to Assess Chelation Therapy (TACT) Should Be Abandoned, was a tour de force deconstruction of why TACT is bad science and unethical to boot.
So how to explain an article published in Medscape last week and authored by Alison Gandey entitled HPV Vaccine Adverse Events Worrisome Says Key Investigator?
The article could have been a fair assessment of whether the risks of Gardasil are higher than reported. “Could have” is the operative phrase. Unfortunately, in among the real scientists quoted (and quoted rather selectively, I might add), Gandey parroted back a whole lot of antivaccination nonsense and a misunderstanding. I expect far better from Medscape. Unfortunately, this time I did not get it. For example, there was this howler from Gandey’s report:
Members of the antivaccine movement point to a number of potential perils, including the presence of aluminum in injections. Like many vaccines, Gardasil contains aluminum salts. Each 0.5-mL dose contains approximately 225 μg of aluminum, 9.56 mg of sodium chloride, 0.78 mg of L-histidine, 50 μcg of polysorbate 80, 35 μg of sodium borate, and water.
Oh, no! Toxins! We’re poisoning the children! Won’t you help?!
I suppose I should be grateful that Gandey refrained from repeating the formaldehyde, antifreeze, or the ever-dreaded “fetal parts” gambit. On the other hand, although you may not know it, let me assure you that anti-vaccine advocates know the significance of mentioning borate (it’s a “roach killer,” don’t you know?) or polysorbate 80, (it’s been linked to infertility in mice–supposedly). Remember my old “toxins” post, and you’ll see how ridiculous these gambits are. For example, the rat study of the effects of polysorbate 80 injected rats with amounts of the chemical that, by body weight, were incredibly high; nowhere near that amount is found in vaccines on a per weight basis. Similarly, I can’t figure out why L-histidine was included in this list. Histidine is an amino acid that’s found in virtually every protein in the body. It’s also an essential amino acid in growing children. That Gandey would even mention it along with aluminum and other ingredients in the context of antivaccinationists’ complaints about a “number of perils” shows a serious lack of understanding of nutrition and pharmacology. As for aluminum, as I’ve said many times before, now that mercury in vaccines is being increasingly exonerated as a cause or “trigger” for autism by multiple high quality studies and lots of science, aluminum is fast becoming the new mercury among antivaccinationists. This goes in stark contrast to science and clinical experience, where aluminum salts used as adjuvants have an 80 year track record of safety in vaccines. Nor is there any compelling evidence, as claimed by antivaccinationists, that it causes or contributes to Alzheimer’s disease.
Next, Gandey quotes Christiane Northrup, MD. Yes, that Christiane Northrup, Oprah Winfrey’s favorite OB/GYN and a regular guest on her show, the doctor who has discussed with Oprah how women should use qi gong to direct their qi into their vaginas in order to achieve more powerful orgasms. Indeed, my co-blogger Harriet Hall, MD has deconstructed Dr. Northrup’s ideas, which, much like Andrew Weil‘s, are a mix of the sensible and science-based thrown together haphazardly with a whole lot of woo to the point where it’s often hard to tell which is which. For instance, Dr. Nortrhup is an advocate of so-called “bioidentical hormones,” a highly dubious “rejuvenator” advocated by Suzanne Somers that lacks any plausible basis in scientific medicine, as Dr. Hall discussed a while back right here on this very blog in the context of hormone replacement therapy.
Sadly, Dr. Northrup more than lived down to my expectations based on seeing her on Oprah. She exceeded in pseudoscience beyond even the dim view I generally have of her. Indeed, she did even worse than I would have expected, as she regurgitated a standard trope of germ theory denialists. Yes, germ theory denialists. I kid you not:
Dr. Northrup recommended that the money going toward vaccines and related programs be allocated to general health and wellness initiatives and proper nutrition. This harkens back to the age-old debate between Louis Pasteur and Antoine Beauchamp, Dr. Northrup suggests.
For most of his career, Pasteur subscribed to germ theory, while Beauchamp backed the more unpopular theory of biological terrain. The question: Is it the germs themselves that make people sick or a weakened state of immunity that allows germs to take root? “Pasteur was widely supported, but on his death bed conceded that Beauchamp was right,” Dr. Northrup said during an interview. She suggests that this is what experts should be concentrating on now.
Here’s the problem. None of what Dr. Northrup claimed in the quote above is true, other than that there was a debate between Pasteur and Beauchamps in the late 1800s over the role of “seed versus soil” in infectious disease. That debate was settled long ago–and not in Beauchamps’ favor. Indeed, that Pasteur “recanted’ germ theory on his deathbed or admitted that “Beauchamps was right” after all represents nothing more than a myth promulgated by germ theory denialists (shaking my head in disbelief, I still can’t fathom how it is that such people still exist in this day and age, but they do). Northrup simply parroted the same sort of misinformation beloved of “alternative” medicine advocates and especially germ thoery denialists, such as Bill Maher, and Gandey serves up this quote without even bothering to check whether what Dr. Northrup said was, in fact, true.
Worse, Gandey fails to give any sort of context for the reports of 9,700 adverse reactions reported to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS). What people don’t understand about VAERS is that it’s not a good epidemiological for establishing strong evidence of causation, and it’s dubious even for correlation. Indeed, such was never its intent when it was designed. VAERS was originally intended as a “canary in the coalmine,” so to speak, in that anyone can report problems that occur in close temporal proximity to vaccines. It’s an early warning system, not a rigorously administered database. “Adverse events” reported don’t even have to be something that looks suspicious as having been caused by vaccines. Indeed, I still remember the infamous story of how Dr. Jim Laidler once reported to VAERS a most unusual complication from vaccination:
The chief problem with the VAERS data is that reports can be entered by anyone and are not routinely verified. To demonstrate this, a few years ago I entered a report that an influenza vaccine had turned me into The Hulk. The report was accepted and entered into the database.
Because the reported adverse event was so… unusual, a representative of VAERS contacted me. After a discussion of the VAERS database and its limitations, they asked for my permission to delete the record, which I granted. If I had not agreed, the record would be there still, showing that any claim can become part of the database, no matter how outrageous or improbable.
In other words, just because a health problem or event is reported to VAERS does not mean that it was related to any vaccine. Moreover, whenever a reporter writes about VAERS, he or she should be aware that VAERS is very susceptible to corruption by publicity, well-meaning advocacy groups, or even litigation in a way that no other vaccine database is. As Dr. Laidler put it:
Since at least 1998 (and possibly earlier), a number of autism advocacy groups have, with all the best intentions, encouraged people to report their autistic children–or autistic children of relatives and friends–to VAERS as injuries from thimerosal-containing vaccines. This has irrevocably tainted the VAERS database with duplicate and spurious reports.
It’s even worse than that, though. As was shown in a study by Michael J. Goodman and James Nordin published in the journal Pediatrics in 2006, vaccine litigation has hopelessly corrupted the VAERS database. In the study, the authors, did something incredibly simple that no one had done before. They took data from the VAERS database from 1990 through 2003 and imported it into SAS data files for analysis. Then they searched the database using key words to look for reports associated with litigation, particularly with regards to autism. They also searched for records containing “thimerosal,” “mercury,” or “autism” in their fields, especially when coupled with terms like “lawyer,” “legal,” “attorney,” or “litigate,” while excluding records containing “legal” coupled with the term “guardian” that did not relate to litigation. They also excluded cases related to well characterized allergic reactions to thimerosal. Finally, they compared records from nonlitigation cases to those from litigation cases regarding symptomatology reported.
Not surprisingly, beginning in 2001, they noted a dramatic increase in the number of non-Lyme disease VAERS reports related to litigation, from only 7 in 2000 to 213 in 2002 and 108 in 2003. (They attributed the decline in 2003 reports to processing delays in creating public use files.) Next, they examined reports related to symptom sets. For autism, they observed a dramatic increase in the percentage of litigation-related reports from 0% of the reports related to litigation in 1999 to over one-third (35%) in 2002. For records mentioning thimerosal that weren’t related to allergic reactions, the rise was even more dramatic, from 0% of these reports related to litigation in 2000 to 87% in 2002.
Given that study from a couple of years ago, I have to wonder whether anti-vaccine advocacy groups, religious groups opposed to Gardasil on the grounds that it will “encourage promiscuity,” or potential litigants might be doing something similar with VAERS reports related to Gardasil. There’s no way of knowing yet because Gardasil is too new and there hasn’t been sufficient time to look at such trends and correlations in VAERS. In any case, the ease with which the VAERS database can be influenced by simple publicity (of which there has been a lot recently over Gardasil), advocacy, or litigation-driven reports is what makes it virtually useless for longitudinal studies or studies of correlation. It’s also why VAERS is so beloved of antivaccine pseudoscientists like Mark and David Geier, who love to go data mining in it for spurious correlations between vaccines and autism. The CDC’s Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD) is a much better resource for doing epidemiological studies about whether vaccines cause or contribute to specific adverse events or complications, not the least of which because reports are entered only by health care professionals and rigorous documentation is required.
Now, let’s take a closer look at those reported adverse events, shall we? The reason, of course, is that it’s not just Medscape that reports these VAERS numbers without context. CNN has the same thing recently, too, but I expect more of Medscape. Unfortunately, this time, I didn’t get it, and indeed Medscape appears this time to have done even worse a job than CNN. For example, when Medscape reports that 6% of the adverse events reported to VAERS were considered “serious,” as it turns out, this is less than half the 15% of reactions reported as “serious” for other vaccines. Moreover, although there is a perfunctory mention from a spokesperson from Merck that it’s impossible to tell whether these events were related to vaccines or not, the overall impression left by the article is that there’s a strong reason to be concerned. This impression is reinforced by the relatively free rein given to Gardasil critics, even to the point of reporting nonsense spouted by Dr. Northrup, and the relatively little said by those supporting the safety of vaccines, complete with a heart-tugging anecdote of a suspected Gardasil-related complication. It’s also bolstered by the lack of anything resembling a serious discussion of why VAERS reports are very poor evidence for adverse events causation by a vaccine.
Left out for the most part was information to put these reports in context. For example, here’s what the American Cancer Society says about the possible link between Gardasil and Guillain-Barré syndrome or death:
There have been 15 reports of sudden death after vaccination. The CDC says after careful review of the 10 reports that had adequate information for analysis, CDC could not establish the causal relationship between vaccination and death.
In addition, there had been 31 reports of Guillain-Barré Syndrome (GBS) after Gardasil vaccination in the U.S, ten of which had been confirmed as GBS. Of those 10, 5 reported vaccination with Menactra, a vaccine against meningitis, at the same time. Of the remaining 21 reports, 7 did not meet the case definition for GBS, one had symptoms of GBS prior to vaccination, 4 were unconfirmed reports, and 9 were pending additional follow-up. The CDC says the number of GBS cases reported are within the range that could be expected to occur by chance alone after a vaccination. CDC and FDA physicians and scientists continue to review all reports of serious side effects reported to VAERS to identify potential new vaccine safety concerns that may need further study. The American Cancer Society continues to monitor those reviews to ensure the safety of those who receive the vaccine, which has the potential to prevent the majority of the cases and deaths of cervical cancer.
It struck me as odd that none of this was discussed in the Medscape article. Where Gandey went wrong as well was in emphasizing doubts about the vaccine’s effectiveness above all else, whether valid concerns or not. For instance, she reported this quote:
At the 2006 American Society of Clinical Oncology annual meeting, delegates were enthusiastic. One presenter showed a series of cervical cancer photos and told observers that “these types of pictures will soon disappear in clinical oncology.”
Unfortunately, that utopian prediction is unlikely. “Cervical cancer is not a vaccine-preventable disease,” Dr. Lippman said during an interview. And in her recent editorial, she points out that surrogate end points — not cervical cancer — were used to measure the efficacy in the clinical trials.
“No one would want to wait to see cervical cancer develop in participants,” she writes. “But the general failure to mention that the precancerous lesions chosen for study are not only potentially removable, most (those that are CIN 2) would probably have resolved on their own without any intervention, is arguable.”
By this rationale, the MMR vaccine does not prevent subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE), a rare but late complication of measles, and the influenza vaccine does not prevent flu-associated pneumonia. I realize that some advocates of the HPV vaccine sometimes have a distressing tendency to oversell its benefits or label everyone, not just religious fundamentalists who see Gardasil as the tool of the devil that will take away a penalty for premarital sex, questioning whether the HPV vaccine is ready for widespread use yet as ““anti-woman,” but it’s a mistake to go too far the other way and undersell the vaccine’s potential benefits as well. There’s also a difference between saying that a vaccine against HPV can prevent cervical cancer, which is what is claimed based on the data, and saying it’s a “cervical cancer vaccine,” which strikes me as a bit of a straw man characterization of what advocates of HPV vaccination actually do say about it.
In conclusion, let me just point out that, as one of the main resident vaccine advocates here on Science-Based Medicine, even I am not yet convinced entirely that state-recommended and state-funded mass vaccination programs with Gardasil or any other HPV vaccine are, at this stage, warranted by science and policy considerations. The reason is not so much that I am concerned that the vaccine is not safe or that it is not effective. Indeed, the evidence suggests that it is. Rather my concern emerges in the context of the entire vaccination program taken as a whole. One problem is the expense of Gardasil. Compared to other vaccines that protect against acute deadly diseases, it’s not cheap, and without the funds to pay for mass vaccination a lot of parents won’t be able to afford it if their health insurance won’t cover it. Worse, the poor and uninsured, who would be most likely to benefit from it, would be the most likely not to be able to afford it. Second, my concern lies in whether the evidence is such that the vaccine’s benefits outweigh its expense and risks by a margin comparable to that of other vaccines in the routine childhood vaccination schedule, which is what I consider a necessary burden of proof to be met before the vaccine is added as a routine part of the overall vaccination schedule. Personally, I’m of the belief that HPV vaccination is safe and probably a good idea, but I haven’t yet been convinced that a mass vaccination program is yet justified. I’m close, but I”m not quite there yet, and I don’t claim that some skepticism isn’t warranted. The problem is that skepticism demands accurate information about potential risks and benefits, and this Medscape article provided neither.
That being said, Medscape is supposed to be operating at a higher plane, scientifically speaking, than mainstream news outlets. It failed miserably in its responsibility by publishing this misinformation-laden and biased article that even went so far as to allow the parroting of germ theory denialism by someone as unqualified as Dr. Northrup. The debate over whether the HPV vaccine should become a regular part of the routine health care of girls in this country is an important one, and articles such as this Medscape article serve far more to confuse,rather than enlighten.
I guess I now know that I should be a lot more skeptical of anything published on Medscape. I spotted this because I know a bit about the issues involved. I’m not so sure I could spot a similar level of misinformation in articles regarding topics about which I am not as conversant. I like to think I can, but that’s probably a falsely reassuring self-delusion.

   The HPV Vaccine (Gardasil) Safety Revisited 
Joseph Albietz 
Link
Gardasil (qHPV) was licensed in 2006 as a vaccine against four types of Human Papillomavirus (HPV) and marketed as, “The first vaccine targeted to prevent cancer.” From its inception it has been one of the more controversial vaccines. Some religious groups feared that the reduced threat of a sexually transmitted disease would lead to increased sexual promiscuity. Other groups were concerned about its safety. Some have questioned whether its high financial cost would make it a cost-effective intervention, while others have questioned the marketing tactics of its manufacturer Merck.
Most of these concerns bear consideration (though I have no time for those who advocate using the threat of disease and death to force conformation to their religious beliefs), and were in large part addressed by David Gorski in a SBM article last year. If you’ve not read his post, I strongly suggest you do so. Now that a large post-licensure study on qHPV has been published, it seems a good time to revisit the issue of greatest concern to me as a pediatrician and to most parents, namely qHPV’s safety and efficacy profile.
THE PROBLEM OF HPV INFECTION
Infection with HPV is a common problem, infecting 79% of the population over their lifetime, and holding the dubious honor of being the most common sexually transmitted disease. In addition to genital warts, HPV infection has been clearly shown to be responsible for a large percentage of cancers in areas that contract HPV, including the vulva, vagina, and penis (40%), anus (90%), and oropharynx (12%), but the most common site of HPV-caused cancer is the cervix. Cervical cancer is diagnosed in 7.9/100,000 women per year, amounting to approximately 11,000 cases in 2008 and 3900 deaths in the US. Worldwide, the WHO estimates 500,000 cases of cervical cancer and 260,000 related deaths.
We have largely failed in preventing HPV infection. Infections are not always obvious and are thus hard for sexual partners to identify and avoid. Barrier devices like condoms don’t cover all the potential infected areas (see the list above) and are thus helpful but of limited utility. Education and abstinence are clearly inadequate to fully address the problem.
In spite of our limited ability to prevent HPV infection, gynecologists have made significant progress in reducing the number of women who suffer from cervical cancer, in large part through regular screening with Pap-smears. The ability to identify and treat pre-cancerous lesions on the cervix or to identify cervical cancer early in its course has lead to a marked reduction in deaths from cervical cancer in the US. It has been so effective that one of the highest risk factors for developing cervical cancer is now a failure to obtain routine Pap-smears.
Yet in spite of the success of Pap-smear screening, we were still faced with 11,000 cases of cervical cancer and 3900 deaths last year. Through sustained effort and eternal vigilance on the part of patients and physicians we can reduce the impact of HPV induced malignancy, but the population at risk remains unchanged. And let’s be honest, humans suck at eternal vigilance. If we could prevent the infection, we could prevent its complications and reduce the impact of the inevitable lapse in our eternal vigilance. Vaccines allow us to do exactly that.
THE HPV VACCINE’S EFFICACY
qHPV is a vaccine against the two most common causes of genital warts (types 6 and 11) and the two leading causes of cervical cancer (types 16 and 18). Its antigen is a virus-like particle with no genetic material, so it is not a live-virus vaccine and cannot cause infection. It has an excellent response rate, inducing an adequate antibody response to all four types of HPV in 99.5% of women after the third dose that has been shown to persist for at least five years.
Regarding efficacy, most cervical cancer occurs decades after the infection, so it will be quite some time before we can demonstrate the effect qHPV should have on the incidence of cervical cancer. However, lesions identified on Pap smear and known to precede cervical cancer occur far earlier, and have served as a surrogate in pre and post-licensure studies. In trials to date, qHPV is 94-100% effective at preventing pre-cancerous changes from these four HPV types.
THE HPV VACCINE’S SAFETY
qHPV is effective, but what of its safety? When it was submitted for licensure, over 20,000 women between the ages of 16 and 26 (the peak ages during which most women are infected) were enrolled in phase 3 trials. Potential adverse events were solicited from all participants were nearly identical between the test and control groups. The only reactions that stood out when compared to the control group were fever (13% vs 11.2%), nausea (6.7% vs 6.5%) and injection site reactions (2.2% vs 0.9%). No serious reactions were seen. Based upon this information, qHPV was considered to be safe and approved by the FDA.
Since its release, however, there have been reports of serious adverse reactions following qHPV injection. Many articles voicing concerns about its safety cite the VAERS database. These reports have generated headlines in the mainstream media, not to mention being perpetual fodder for crank sites like NaturalNews and Whale.to., and have been a if not the major source of the concern expressed by parents.
As a part of routine post-licensure follow-up and to address these very concerns, “Postlicensure Safety Surveillance for HPV Vaccine” was funded by the FDA and CDC and published last month in JAMA. This article is the largest attempt to evaluate the adverse events seen since qHPV was released. In it, the authors compared the adverse events reported to VAERS to the expected background rate of reported events in the unvaccinated general population of women aged 9-26, re-evaluating the previously reported adverse events known from licensure as well as the reports of more serious events that have gained public attention. The results are reassuring.
Over the first 2.5 years since its release, 23 million doses of qHPV were administered, and VAERS received 12,424 reports of adverse events. Of these, only 772 (6.2%) were classified as serious or life-threatening. These are summarized in the table below, taken from the article:
Of all of these events, only two are above what one should expect from their respective baseline rates and not previously identified by the original licensure studies. The first is Venous Thromboembolic Events (VTEs). These are blood clots within the blood vessels that can be quite serious; these occurred in 0.2/100,000 doses. The second was syncope, or loss of consciousness, which occurred in 8.2/100,000 doses. This does not establish that qHPV causes these events; remember that this study and the VAERS in general are not designed to establish causation. Nevertheless, further studies are certainly warranted to confirm or refute qHPV’s role in these rare events, and physicians should bear the correlation in mind when considering the administration of qHPV.
Notice, however, that the rates of major events of concern, namely Guillain-Barre syndrome, autoimmune disorders, transverse myelitis, and death, were all exceedingly rare, and not above what one would expect to occur in the normal unvaccinated population. In spite of the clear limitations inherent in the use of the VAERS database, this study should strongly reinforce the confidence of physicians and parents regarding the safety of HPV vaccination.
Gardasil (qHPV) is a new vaccine. Recommendations regarding its use are likely to continue to change as we learn to optimize its use. Just last week, an FDA advisory panel recommended that qHPV be approved for use in males age 9-26, and Merck is likely to seek approval to broaden the approved ages of administration. Whether these developments should alter the current practice is a point of open debate. And of course, as with any new medical intervention qHPV warrants close surveillance for any unexpected adverse effects. Though uncertainties remain regarding this vaccine’s use in the sphere of public health, for a parent who desires to reduce the risk of HPV infection and HPV induced malignancies for their child, we can confidently say that qHPV is a safe and effective option.

No, the HPV vaccine does not cause promiscuity
Scott Gavura on December 18, 2014
Link

Today’s post isn’t about the flu vaccine, but that vaccine played a part in bringing you today’s topic. It seems that this year’s vaccine is a mediocre match for the circulating strains of influenza, and I was one of the unlucky ones in whom it didn’t appear to provide much protection. After spending several days effectively bedridden, I still feel like I’m emerging from a cognitive fog. So today’s post will be short. In the midst of my own infection, the results of a new study were announced that examined the effects of HPV vaccination on indicators of sexual behaviour in adolescent girls. I admit to being a bit dumbfounded by the topic when I heard it, and I initially thought I had heard the research question incorrectly. After all, the answer seemed (to me) so clearly self-evident, I questioned if this was an ineffective use of research dollars. This question seemed as pertinent as continuing to study the relationship between vaccines and autism: there is little reason to think there would be any causal relationship. But surveys of parents show this is a real concern for some. And now we have an answer grounded in real-world evidence.
The HPV vaccine is an effective means of preventing cancer. Let’s pause to reflect on the sentence I just wrote. We can prevent cancer, before it starts, with a vaccine. The human papillomavirus (HPV) is the most prevalent sexually-transmitted infection in North America, and almost all cervical cancer is caused by HPV. HPV causes a substantial number of cancer cases every year (26,000 per year in the US). As an anti-cancer strategy, vaccination is a pretty sensible one. HPV is not the only sexually-transmitted infection that can be prevented by vaccine. Hepatitis A and B are also sexually transmitted, and can be prevented with vaccines. However, immunization rates for HPV have lagged those of HBV and HAV, and anecdotally I haven’t seen a parental backlash against the hepatitis vaccines like I’ve seen against Gardasil and Cervarix, the two brands of HPV vaccine. Here are some uptake statistics for the Province of Ontario, where you can see the difference between hepatitis B and HPV:
I’m not going to spend time in this post reviewing the efficacy of the vaccine – that’s been blogged about before, and the CDC has excellent resources. And the safety of the vaccine has also been well established, in girls as well as boys. Despite what you may read on Natural News, Mercola or see in your Facebook feed, the HPV vaccine is effective and it lacks serious side effects. It is well tolerated and it works. Gardasil provides protection against four strains of the virus and Cervarix protects against the two strains that cause the most cases of cervical cancer.
The first vaccine, Gardasil was launched in 2006 and since that time has come to be offered by many public health agencies worldwide. In Ontario, where I happen to live, the program to vaccinate all girls started with the 2007 grade 8 cohort. The vaccine is offered in schools. Regrettably, the appropriateness of the vaccine was initially an issue with the publicly-funded Ontario Catholic School system but it’s now my understanding that the vaccine is being made routinely available to all grade 8 girls in Ontario. There are still substantial opt-out numbers, as you can see.
So why are HPV vaccination rates lagging? There’s been considerable study into the factors that influence vaccination decisions, and which can potentially be modified. You might expect that decisions are based on knowledge about the vaccine, but there doesn’t seem to be a relationship between the two. That is, some with low vaccination knowledge accept the vaccine, and some with a sophisticated knowledge base do not accept it. Studies of behaviours suggest that this factual knowledge about the vaccine may not make any material difference in decision-making. Instead, decision-making could be more related to beliefs, some of which may not be easily modified by facts.
And what are those beliefs? Some parents believe that HPV vaccination will increase sexual promiscuity, possibly by encouraging more sexual risk-taking owing to protection from the vaccine. And given the HPV vaccine provides no protection against viruses like HIV, there is the risk of more illness, in addition to the potential for more pregnancies. While there is no persuasive evidence that sexual education or other health interventions have this effect, the fear among parents persists, and has been reported as a contributor to HPV vaccine refusal.
This brings us to the study published last week:”Effect of human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination on clinical indicators of sexual behaviour among adolescent girls: the Ontario Grade 8 HPV Vaccine Cohort Study.” The full-text article is available from the Canadian Medical Association Journal. This study used administrative databases to look at two groups of grade 8 girls: pre-vaccine (2005-7) and post-vaccine (2007-9). The vaccine receipt status on each girl was obtained, and then indicators of sexual behaviour (pregnancy, non-HPV sexually-transmitted diseases) were tracked through grade 12.
This was a large study. The initial cohort was over 260,000 girls and they were followed for an average of 4.5 years. While only 51% received all three doses of the vaccine, less than 1% in the earlier cohort received the three doses. The results were reassuring. Across 10,000 pregnancies and over 6,000 sexually-transmitted illnesses, there was no statistically-significant increase in indicators of sexual behaviour related to receipt of the HPV vaccine. This was the case both for those that received the vaccine, and even those in the cohort eligible for the vaccine. (I won’t bother showing the graphs, as they’re essentially superimposable.)
Conclusion
Some parents fear that vaccinating girls against HPV will increase promiscuity. New research studying actual behaviours shows this worry to be unfounded. The HPV vaccine is safe, effective, and has the potential to dramatically reduce the prevalence of cervical cancer in the population. There are no substantive downsides to HPV vaccination. Despite this, vaccination rates remain suboptimal. This study may play a small part in addressing parental concerns and hopefully increasing the acceptance of this vaccine.
Reference
Smith L.M., E. C. Strumpf & L. E. Levesque (2014). Effect of human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccination on clinical indicators of sexual behaviour among adolescent girls: the Ontario Grade 8 HPV Vaccine Cohort Study, Canadian Medical Association Journal DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1503/cmaj.140900

HPV Vaccine Compliance
Steven Novella on May 13, 2015
Link

There are few home-runs in medicine. Most of our choices have some sort of trade-off – drugs have side effects, interventions have risks, and many treatments have marginal benefits. Sometimes, however, medical science hits one out of the park and develops a treatment that is safe, effective, cost effective, and convenient. Any dispassionate view of the evidence can only lead to one conclusion, leading to the absence of any legitimate scientific or medical debate.
I think the human papilloma virus (HPV) vaccine falls into this category. We have learned that many oral and genital cancers are caused by a sexually transmitted virus, HPV. Getting vaccinated against several strains of this virus prior to becoming sexually active effectively protects against infection by the virus, and dramatically reduces the risk of these cancers. Think about it – we can prevent cancer with a vaccine. This is a no-brainer.
A recent study shows:
HPV DNA was detected in 90.6% of cervical, 91.1% of anal, 75.0% of vaginal, 70.1% of oropharyngeal, 68.8% of vulvar, 63.3% of penile, 32.0% of oral cavity, and 20.9% of laryngeal cancers, as well as in 98.8% of cervical cancer in situ (CCIS). A vaccine targeting HPV 16/18 potentially prevents the majority of invasive cervical (66.2%), anal (79.4%), oropharyngeal (60.2%), and vaginal (55.1%) cancers, as well as many penile (47.9%), vulvar (48.6%) cancers: 24 858 cases annually. The 9-valent vaccine also targeting HPV 31/33/45/52/58 may prevent an additional 4.2% to 18.3% of cancers: 3944 cases annually.
The new 9-valent vaccine covers more strains. The study suggests that there are over 28,000 cases of cancer each year in the US that could be prevented by this vaccine.
Yet, a 2010 survey found that only 11% of 13-17 year olds had received the complete series of three injections, while 25% had received at least one dose. Further, for those who do get vaccinated almost half are starting later than they should or taking longer than they should to complete the series. These figures are improving, however. The latest figures from the CDC for year 2013 show a sharp increase, with 37.6% of girls completing the series, and 13.9% of boys.
The HPV vaccine is also not just for girls. Boys benefit as well, and this benefit is increasing as oral-genital behavior seems to be increasing in the younger population, leading to greater HPV rates associated with oral cancers. Male HPV vaccinations are cost effective, although it is still more cost effective to increase the compliance rate among young females.
A number of studies have looked at barriers to HPV vaccine uptake. A systematic review found:
Twenty-one barriers to vaccination were identified. Cost was the most frequently reported barrier, followed by feelings that vaccination was unnecessary, and concerns regarding vaccine safety and side effects. Facilitators included perceived benefit of vaccination, health care provider recommendations, and social norms. Few studies specifically sought to isolate the views of adolescents, though not being sexually active was the most commonly reported barrier among this group.
This is a situation in which education is likely to be an effective measure. Preventive measures in medicine are most effective when they cover the target population, which in this case is all pre-teens. The HPV vaccine is most effective when the series is completed prior to becoming sexually active. Not being sexually active is therefore not a reason to avoid the vaccine.
Pediatricians also need to be educated. Lack of recommendation by their doctor was given as the reason for not vaccinating in 13% of girls and 22% of boys.
The safety of these vaccines has been widely studied and monitored. The HPV vaccines are extremely safe, with only minor side effects. Of course, anti-vaccine propaganda will cite the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) data which shows reports of 1,671 serious adverse events following HPV vaccines by 2013 (after 67 million doses). The problem with citing this data, however, is that it is not controlled. This is a voluntary reporting system with no filters. It is, in essence, a massive exercise in correlation, without any way to assess causation.
Fortunately the data has also been looked at in a more scientific way, comparing the rates of adverse outcomes in those who receive the HPV vaccine vs those who did not. Such comparisons show that there are no serious adverse events that are more likely in the HPV vaccinated than unvaccinated population.
Antivaxxers are doing their best to spread fear and misinformation. It is easy to scare parents about side effects, so they have an advantage in their misinformation campaign. Most notorious are reports of deaths following HPV doses. With 67 million doses given, there are going to be random associations with other outcomes, including death. There have been 97 reports of deaths following HPV vaccine as of March of 2014. The CDC investigated every case. In 47 of the cases they had sufficient information to make a determination, and in every one they found that the death was completely unrelated to the vaccine.
Conclusion
The HPV vaccines are safe, effective, and cost effective. There is sufficient evidence to confidently conclude that they are an effective public health campaign, with the potential of preventing thousands of cases of a very serious disease – cancer. There are some practical barriers to full implementation, but they can be and are being overcome, mostly through education.
The only real barrier to full implementation is ideology – distrust of science, medicine, government, or corporations, irrational worship of the concept of “natural”, belief in magical medical nonsense, or the misguided belief that preventive measures promotes immoral behavior.

HPV Vaccine Safety and Acceptance
Steven Novella on January 13, 2016
Link

The public fight over the human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine is still raging. The debate partly reflects the underlying logic of health prevention measures, which is essentially a statistical game of risk vs benefit. Unfortunately thrown into the mix are ideological opponents to vaccines who are distorting the facts at every turn.
Notice that I said this was a “public” fight, because it is not a serious scientific dispute. There is sufficient evidence to confidently conclude that the HPV vaccines currently available are safe and effective. All medical interventions will contain some risk, it is never zero, but vaccines in general, and the HPV vaccine specifically, have minimal risks and clearly prevent disease.
In addition there is a social angle to the HPV vaccine in that it is given to children to prevent a sexually transmitted disease.
The science of the HPV vaccine
In a recent editorial for Nature Magazine, Dr. Heidi Larson points out that:
Every year brings 528,000 new cases of cervical cancer and 266,000 deaths, linked to human papillomavirus (HPV). We have a highly effective HPV vaccine, but suspicion stands in the way of its adoption in many countries.
This is a home run for medical science. We have identified a virus that causes cancer. We can vaccinate against the virus and literally prevent the cancer and death that results.
The efficacy of the vaccines has been clearly demonstrated. A 2012 systematic review concluded:
Taken together, the excellent clinical trial results strongly support the potential of the vaccines as high value public health interventions and justify their widespread implementation to prevent anogenital HPV infections and their associated neoplasia.
As with most viruses, there are many different strains of the HPV. As vaccine development continues, newer vaccines target more of those strains, with resultant greater efficacy. A 2014 review looks at all the currently available HPV vaccines and reviews their efficacy:
As of December 2014, there were 3 approved vaccines for human papillomavirus (HPV): bivalent Cervarix (GlaxoSmithKline, New York, NY), quadrivalent Gardasil (Merck and Co, Kenilworth, NJ), and 9-valent Gardasil-9 (Merck and Co). The average cost per dose is $120, with a recommended 3-dose course.
The more strains covered, the greater the efficacy, but even the quadrivalent vaccine, which is the most common given, has high efficacy because it covers the most common strains.
The full impact of the vaccine will take decades to unfold, because the idea is to prevent cancers that develop years or decades after infection. Since there is clear evidence that the virus is linked to increased risk of various cancers, evidence of decreased infection allows us to confidently project decreases in those cancers.
The evidence also supports the safety of the available HPV vaccines. A 2015 systematic review found:
The recombinant human papillomavirus types 6, 11, 16 and 18 vaccine was safe and well tolerated. The main adverse effects related to vaccination were pain, erythema, edema and fever. The low frequency of severe adverse effects encourages the administration of the vaccine in the population at risk.
As with most vaccines, side effects were minor, and serious side effect were rare. Of course, when you give millions of vaccines rare events are going to happen. Again we are back to risks vs benefit – low risk with high benefit clearly supports the use of a medical intervention.
In addition to overall safety, several specific concerns have been raised with the HPV vaccine. Such occurrences are unavoidable, and are actually a healthy part of the ongoing surveillance that should accompany any widespread use of a medical intervention.
Anyone developing symptoms following a vaccine is likely to suspect the vaccine as a cause, even when the temporal association is purely coincidental, or perhaps a nocebo effect. Researchers follow up on any such reports with solid evidence.
The most recent concerns about the vaccine were of increased risk of complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) and postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (POTS) in young girls following the vaccine. Anecdotal reports are useful only to raise possible concerns for more serious scientific investigation, they are not sufficiently reliable as a basis for any conclusions. They do, however, increase public fear and concern.
Individual studies looking systematically at the data have concluded that there is no increased risk of CRPS following the HPV vaccine. I could not find any published studies looking at POTS.
However, in 2015 the European Medicines Agency was asked by Denmark to look at the safety of the HPV vaccine with respect to these two conditions. They performed a systematic review of the evidence and concluded:
…the evidence does not support a causal link between the vaccines (Cervarix, Gardasil/Silgard and Gardasil-9) and development of CRPS or POTS. Therefore, there is no reason to change the way the vaccines are used or amend the current product information.
Distorting reality to support an agenda
I have noticed a common strategy among ideologues who oppose a safe and effective new technology or who deny an accepted science – they use lies and distortion to generate public resistance to the thing they oppose, and then cite the resistance they helped to generate as evidence that there must be a real problem.
With regard to the HPV vaccines, opponents have used fearmongering tactics to scare parents into thinking the vaccines are not safe. In addition, social conservatives oppose the vaccine as they think it might promote promiscuity. At the very least there are parents who feel that their child is not sexually active and therefore does not require a vaccine to prevent a sexually transmitted disease.
It should come as no surprise that the latter view is hopelessly naïve. A recent study in Tanzania, for example, showed that 11.6% of young girls who reported no previous sexual activity tested positive for HPV.
In the US data show that sexual activity incidence is 12.5% among females and 13.1% among males at age 14. As a public health measure it makes sense to initiate the HPV vaccine before most children become sexually active. When you think it’s likely your child is sexually active, it is too late for prevention that needs to happen before they are sexually active.
This is where the pediatrician comes in. Pediatricians need to strongly advocate for the HPV vaccine, to be knowledgeable enough to reassure parents of the safety and efficacy of the vaccine, of the need for the vaccine at a young age, and to counter the common myths and lies about the vaccine that the parents may have heard.
This is where a recent survey published in Pediatrics comes in. They found:
Response rates were 82% for pediatricians (364 of 442) and 56% for FP [family physicians] (218 of 387). For 11-12 year-old girls, 60% of pediatricians and 59% of FP strongly recommend HPV vaccine; for boys, 52% and 41% ostrongly recommen. [sic] More than one-half reported ≥25% of parents deferred HPV vaccination. At the 11-12 year well visit, 84% of pediatricians and 75% of FP frequently/always discuss HPV vaccination. Compared with physicians who frequently/always discuss, those who occasionally/rarely discuss(18%) were more likely to be FP (adjusted odds ratio [aOR]: 2.0 [95% confidence interval (CI): 1.1–3.5), be male (aOR: 1.8 [95% CI: 1.1–3.1]), disagree that parents will accept HPV vaccine if discussed with other vaccines (aOR: 2.3 [95% CI: 1.3–4.2]), report that 25% to 49% (aOR: 2.8 [95% CI: 1.1–6.8]) or ≥50% (aOR: 7.8 [95% CI: 3.4–17.6]) of parents defer, and express concern about waning immunity (aOR: 3.4 [95% CI: 1.8–6.4]).
So about 60% of pediatricians and family practitioners taking care of children strongly recommend the HPV vaccine. Of those who do so occasionally or rarely they do not cite concerns about safety or efficacy (except possibly giving it too early and waning immunity), but rather their fear that parents will be resistant.
Also keep in mind, these pediatricians are not recommending against the vaccine, they are just not being very proactive in recommending it because of fear of pushback.
Anti-vaxxers have seized upon this study as a propaganda opportunity. For example, the site Vaccine Impact has this headline:
Many U.S. Pediatricians and Family Doctors Not Recommending Gardasil HPV Vaccine
While another crank site proclaims:
Attention Parents: Brand New Study Outlines Why Many Doctors Don’t Recommend HPV Shots
The implication is that doctors know there are issues with the vaccine and so are not recommending it, as if they are recommending against it. In fact the study shows that most doctors strongly and consistently recommend the HPV vaccine, while most of the remaining do sometimes, just not consistently. The study did not reveal a significant number of doctors who recommend against it.
Getting back to the recent concerns about CRPS and POTS, in response to early reports of these possible side effects Japan decided to stop promoting the vaccine. They will still provide it if requested but will not actively recommend it. They have not yet updated their policy following the recent European report.
They are alone in this policy, while the rest of the world calmly follows the science and good medical practice.
Meanwhile, anti-vaccine sites are reporting that Japan has “banned” the HPV vaccine, which is not true.
Conclusion: Opportunities missed because of unfounded fears
Scientific evaluations of medical interventions are always a work in progress. Risks and benefits, especially of widespread public health interventions, need to be constantly carefully monitored, and any new apparent red flags need to be investigated.
This monitoring will create a predictable background noise of possible concerns, even for the safest of interventions. It is important for the medical community to properly communicate this reality to patients and put all information into its proper context, effectively communicating the bottom line of risk vs benefit for any recommended intervention.
Governments and regulatory agencies also have this responsibility – to keep evidence in perspective while following up any potential problems. Somewhere in the world a government or agency will fall down on this responsibility over certain issues, which is not evidence of a cover-up or a serious problem.
As with all science-based issues, it is best to rely on the overwhelming consensus of expert opinion, not cherry-picked outliers.
At the present time we have robust evidence for the safety and efficacy of the HPV vaccines, and good reason to recommend them for all pre-teen and teen boys and girls. There is actually an opportunity here to prevent cancer and death. It is a tragedy when that opportunity is missed because of ideology, pseudoscience, and fearmongering.

The claim that Gardasil causes premature ovarian failure: Ideology, not science
It’s amazing how, to antivaccine activists, it just so happens that a vaccine that targets a sexually transmitted virus must also destroy a girl’s ovaries. It must be a coincidence, right?
David Gorski on March 7, 2016
Link

When you’ve been blogging for over 11 years on your own blog and 8 years on a blog like Science-Based Medicine, particularly when what you blog about is skepticism and science-based medicine, with a special emphasis on rationally and scientifically discussing quackery, inevitably you see the same misinformation and lies pop up again and again. Indeed, those of us in the biz not infrequently refer to such stories as “zombie lies,” because no matter how often you think they’ve been killed they always come back. Personally, I like to refer to them as Jason, Michael Myers, or Freddy Krueger lies (or just slasher or monster lies), for basically the same reason. You kill them with facts, evidence, science, and reason, but sooner or later they always come back. Always. That’s why trying to refute them is like playing Whac-A-Mole. This time around, a group called the American College of Pediatricians (ACP) is claiming that Gardasil is causing infertility in girls, a claim that showed up last week on that repository of quackery, NaturalNews.com. Oddly enough, despite the article’s hysterical tone, it wasn’t written by NN’s big macher himself, Mike Adams.
The reason that slasher lies keep coming back is because they never really go away completely. They only look that way because they recede for a while until someone new discovers them or their originators decide the coast is clear and they can repeat them again. There’s one particular slasher lie that keeps coming up about the HPV vaccine, usually Gardasil (mainly because that’s the brand of HPV vaccine most commonly used in the US) but not restricted to Gardasil. Sometimes Cervarix falls prey to the same lies, mainly overseas where it is the predominant version of HPV vaccine used. Given that I was in Boston at the annual meeting of the Society of Surgical Oncology over the weekend and was also busy hanging out with Kimball Atwood and Clay Jones one night, surgical colleagues another night, and the Boston Skeptics on Saturday, it seemed to me to be a good time to revisit this topic, particularly given that it hasn’t been covered on SBM before. If this post looks familiar, it’s because it has appeared before, but it was in a different form. Consider this a beefed up version of the prior post, because even when I recycle material I can’t just recycle it unchanged. I have to tinker, add, and, of course, customize for the blog. It’s what I do.
The slasher lie returns
The slasher lie I’m referring to is, of course, the claim that the HPV vaccine causes infertility and sterility in adolescent girls and young women. Actually, it’s not entirely true that this is an antivaccine claim unique to the HPV vaccine. After all, it wasn’t so long ago that I discussed a pernicious lie being spread by Catholic bishops in Kenya claiming that the tetanus vaccine had been spiked with beta-hCG as a means of birth control. Another time, the same culprits claimed that the polio vaccine was being spiked with estrogen in order to sterilize Kenyan girls. Both claims were, of course, ridiculous, but the idea is there: Someone is using vaccines for “population control,” and they’re doing it by rendering young girls sterile. Actually, this is a very common conspiracy theory among the antivaccine faithful, that “someone” (usually involving Bill Gates) is using vaccines to depopulate the world.
So what makes the conspiracy theories about Gardasil different? Simple. Antivaccinationists have a special hatred for Gardasil. I realize that it sometimes annoys some of our readers when one of us waxes political or ideological, but in this case it really can’t be avoided. The hatred and fear of Gardasil and Cervarix very much appear to derive from the fact that HPV vaccines are used to prevent a sexually-transmitted virus, the rationale for that fear being that the use of such a vaccine will somehow “encourage promiscuity.” It’s even been called the “promiscuity vaccine.” Never mind that the evidence is quite clear that this claim is simply not true. Never mind that anyone who remembers her own adolescence clearly would know that fear of catching HPV and then developing cervical cancer 20 or 30 years down the road is not a major concern among teens as their raging hormones drive their behavior. None of this matters to the people making these claims, however, who seem to think that cervical cancer is a just punishment for “promiscuity” and naturally seem to latch onto conspiracy theories in which HPV vaccines would naturally cause infertility because the “promiscuous” shouldn’t be mothers.
Perhaps the link with sex and the fact that it is designed to combat a sexually-transmitted virus are what make the most pernicious slasher lie about Gardasil, that it causes primary ovarian insufficiency, more commonly known as premature ovarian failure (POF), so hard to kill for good. Basically, POF is early menopause and usually defined as loss of normal ovarian function before the age of 40. It can and does occur in young women and even teenagers, for whom it is a particularly devastating problem. (Just imagine going through, in essence, menopause at age 15 and you’ll get an idea of how profoundly horrific POF can be.) The linking of a vaccine viewed as promoting promiscuity to a punishment of losing fertility is simply too natural and irresistible to cranks, regardless of how wrong it is. Not surprisingly, this is exactly what we see in the aforementioned NaturalNews.com article, which is based on a press release by the American College of Pediatrics entitled “New Concerns about the Human Papillomavirus Vaccine.” You can tell you’re in for a heaping helping of BS from the very first paragraph:
The American College of Pediatricians (The College) is committed to the health and well-being of children, including prevention of disease by vaccines. It has recently come to the attention of the College that one of the recommended vaccines could possibly be associated with the very rare but serious condition of premature ovarian failure (POF), also known as premature menopause. There have been two case report series (3 cases each) published since 2013 in which post-menarcheal adolescent girls developed laboratory documented POF within weeks to several years of receiving Gardasil, a four-strain human papillomavirus vaccine (HPV4).1,2 Adverse events that occur after vaccines are frequently not caused by the vaccine and there has not been a noticeable rise in POF cases in the last 9 years since HPV4 vaccine has been widely used.
It’s rather amusing that the authors note that there hasn’t been an increase in POF incidence since the introduction of Gardasil, but nonetheless strain mightily to blame POF on the vaccine. Given the number of girls vaccinated over the last decade, if Gardasil were linked to POF we’d expect to have found evidence in the various vaccine safety surveillance systems in place to find adverse reactions to vaccines. That no such link has been found is suggestive, albeit admittedly not conclusive, that there probably isn’t a link.
Gardasil and premature ovarian failure: Slaying the slasher lie
To analyze what the ACP has said thus far, let’s take a look at the two references cited. Reference 2 can be dispensed with fairly easily. The first case discussed in the reference, for instance, was one of the first dubious testimonials claiming to link POF with Gardasil that I’ve ever encountered. It’s no more convincing in the article cited than it was in the BMJ Case Reports article from which it originated. Basically, the argument (as is the case the case with nearly all of these stories) is that because no other cause for this patient’s POF could be determined upon investigation, it must have been the Gardasil.
Of course, the vast majority of cases of POF are idiopathic; i.e., no clear cause is ever found. (Of the remainder, the cause is usually rare chromosomal abnormalities, autoimmune diseases, and other rare disorders.) It’s frustrating, but true. It’s also true that POF is more common than most realize; as many as 1 in 100 girls and women suffer from it.
You can see this problem in the second case, which is that of a woman who was diagnosed with POF at age 18. She received her series of three doses of HPV vaccine at 12 years and 9 months; near her 13th birthday; and at age 13 years and 5 months. That’s right. The author of this paper, Deirdre Therese Little, blamed POF occuring nearly five years after the patient’s last dose of Gardasil on the vaccine. To explain this long delay between vaccine and discovery of POF, she noted that the young woman had been on oral contraceptives since age 12 for irregular menstrual periods, which were stopped briefly at age 14 with a three month period of amenorrhea, and then restarted. She also had several health problems, including cerebral palsy, asthma, epilepsy. Overall, Little was clearly reaching very far to blame this case of POF on Gardasil. I hope she didn’t hurt her back or shoulder.
The third case is the only one that showed a reasonable temporal correlation, with the patient’s first late period occurring after the third dose of the HPV vaccine, but even that correlation is pretty thin gruel, as it is correlation without convincing evidence of causation. As is the case for vaccines and autism, is it not surprising that there are girls and young women who suffer POF in close temporal relation to their having received a dose of Gardasil. In fact, what surprises me more than the ability of antivaccine activists to find cases of girls whose onset of POF can be related to their having received a Gardasil booster, however tenuous and forced the correlation might be, is just how few cases they can find: Around six in the entire developed world, if you believe the statement, and of these at least half do not even have a correlation between vaccination and symptom onset convincing enough even to suspect that this correlation might equal causation. Add to this just how hard these activists are looking for such cases, and, even given how uncommon POF is before the age of 18, it’s actually rather amazing that Little and her fellow anti-Gardasil activists haven’t flooded the case report literature with such cases. Instead, we have about a half dozen.
Ultimately, Little even had to admit at the end of the article that case reports “do not and cannot establish causation,” but she certainly tried her best to spin every cherry picked preclinical study she can find to implicate Gardasil in these girls’ POF. She even goes so far as to cite dubious studies claimed to show that polysorbate 80 in vaccines can cause infertility in rats as well as the bogus claim that detection of HPV DNA in the vaccine is a great danger, which is a bit of misinformation promoted by pathologist Sin Hang Lee. It also turns out that Dr. Little is on the board of advisors for an Australian Catholic anti-abortion group called Family Life International, whose official patron laments the growth of promiscuity and the “redefining” of marriage (big surprise, the group is against gay marriage as well). On the website is a diatribe against Gardasil, which, FLI gravely notes, is “often associated with promiscuity,” along with a link to a YouTube video of the antivaccine propaganda film The Greater Good. It also turns out that Little’s co-author, Harvey Rodrick Grenville Ward, is cut from the same cloth, described as a “pro-life obstetrician/gynecologist.” He also apparently helps an antiabortion activist named Stephanie Gray give talks at local churches in Canada in which she shows graphic abortion videos to convince the audience that abortion is “wrong 100% of the time.”
Also not surprisingly, Reference 1 is an article by Lucija Tomljenovic and Yehuda Shoenfeld that claims that the HPV vaccine can trigger an autoimmune syndrome, part of whose manifestation is premature ovarian failure. These two are antivaccinationists we’ve met before. Shoenfeld is best known for having made up a syndrome that he calls ASIA (“Autoimmune/Inflammatory Syndrome Induced by Adjuvants”) for which no compelling evidence exists. He’s also known for having provided pseudoscientific reports to bolster antivaccine claims that vaccines cause autoimmune disease and being the scientific advisor for The Greater Good. Speaking of The Greater Good, Tomljenovic is known for working closely with Christopher Shaw, an antivaccine scientist who appeared in the film to proclaim that we’re all living in a “toxic” soup and that vaccines are part of that soup. Basically, they both publish lots of articles claiming that the aluminum adjuvants in vaccines (particularly Gardasil) are causing horrific health problems; they’ve even blamed Gardasil incorrectly for a death, as was reported by The Toronto Star in one of the worst mainstream news articles I’ve ever seen on Gardasil. Yes, working with other antivaccine scientists, Shaw and Tomljenovic have tried to show that Gardasil kills. It doesn’t.
The first case presented is a 14 year old girl who suffered amenorrhea after her series of HPV vaccine doses. The second is a case of a girl who was vaccinated with HPV at age 13, which was before she had her first period at age 15, when she had only two periods separated by one month. (Yes, they blame Gardasil doses given before this girl’s onset of menses for POF that happened two years after the doses.) The third case is a 21 year old woman who developed irregular menses after her third dose of HPV vaccine and ultimately became amenorrheic at age 23. Based on this thin gruel, Lucija Tomljenovic and Yehuda Shoenfeld conclude, “In this case, as in our three cases, no other possible causes of POF were identified other than the HPV vaccine.”
In other words, even though in the vast majority of cases of POF no specific cause for ovarian failure can be identified, to Tomljenovic and Shoenfeld that must mean it was the Gardasil that done it! They claim it’s because the vaccine can cause an autoimmune syndrome like ASIA, even though they present no clinical evidence that any of these patients had an autoimmune syndrome. It’s the classic tendency of antivaccine activists to confuse correlation with causation.
Of course, this isn’t the first time Tomljenovic and Shoenfeld have worked together. In fact, I’ve even encountered them quite recently, when they tried (and failed miserably) to show that Gardasil causes behavioral problems in mice.
Gardasil: When the slasher lie is down, don’t take your eyes off of it
As you can see, the evidence presented by the ACP as warranting concern about the ability of Gardasil to cause POF both comes from highly biased sources and rests on some pretty tenuous “correlations.” None of this stops the ACP from claiming:
Nevertheless there are legitimate concerns that should be addressed: (1) long-term ovarian function was not assessed in either the original rat safety studies3,4 or in the human vaccine trials, (2) most primary care physicians are probably unaware of a possible association between HPV4 and POF and may not consider reporting POF cases or prolonged amenorrhea (missing menstrual periods) to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS), (3) potential mechanisms of action have been postulated based on autoimmune associations with the aluminum adjuvant used and previously documented ovarian toxicity in rats from another component, polysorbate 80,2 and (4) since licensure of Gardasil® in 2006, there have been about 213 VAERS reports (per the publicly available CDC WONDER VAERS database) involving amenorrhea, POF or premature menopause, 88% of which have been associated with Gardasil®.5 The two-strain HPV2, CervarixTM, was licensed late in 2009 and accounts for 4.7% of VAERS amenorrhea reports since 2006, and 8.5% of those reports from February 2010 through May 2015. This compares to the pre-HPV vaccine period from 1990 to 2006 during which no cases of POF or premature menopause and 32 cases of amenorrhea were reported to VAERS.
Of course, as has been described before many times, the VAERS database is not a useful tool for assessing incidence or changes in incidence of adverse reactions due to vaccines. The reason is simple. Anyone can submit reports of adverse events to VAERS. Anyone. The reports undergo minimal or no vetting by medical professionals. Heck, there is even a famous description of how a man successfully submitted a report that a vaccine turned him into The Incredible Hulk. What that means is that any belief about a vaccine’s adverse effects can lead to more reports being filed. Worse, we’ve known for at least a decade that vaccine litigation itself distorts the database. Indeed, it’s very likely that the publicity of a “link” between Gardasil and amenorrhea or POF is the very reason why the vast majority of reports to VAERS of amenorrhea or POF are associated with Gardasil and why such reports took off after Gardasil and Cervarix were licensed. Basically, none of the above claims is compelling evidence that Gardasil or Cervarix is associated with POF.
Nor is this:
Few other vaccines besides Gardasil® that are administered in adolescence contain polysorbate 80. Pre-licensure safety trials for Gardasil® used placebo that contained polysorbate 80 as well as aluminum adjuvant. Therefore, if such ingredients could cause ovarian dysfunction, an increase in amenorrhea probably would not have been detected in the placebo controlled trials. Furthermore, a large number of girls in the original trials were taking hormonal contraceptives which can mask ovarian dysfunction including amenorrhea and ovarian failure. Thus a causal relationship between human papillomavirus vaccines (if not Gardasil® specifically) and ovarian dysfunction cannot be ruled out at this time.
I can’t help but note that the rat studies mentioned early in the statement used massive doses of polysorbate 80, far beyond what is in any vaccine; so their relevance to, well, anything is highly questionable. Basically, at best ACP has a few case reports, some of which aren’t even particularly convincing as single case examples of correlation, much less as evidence of causation, plus some cherry picked animal research. There are also appeals to ignorance. For instance, Scott S. Field, MD, the author of this statement, notes a very large study that found no evidence of a link between Gardasil and demyelinating or autoimmune diseases but dismissed it not having looked specifically at POF. So basically, based on some tenuous correlations, some reports in VAERS, and irrelevant science, Field recommends trying to scare primary care doctors to scare parents about Gardasil.
The American College of Pediatrics: Not the American Academy of Pediatrics!
The large number of bad arguments in its statement led me to ask: Who is the ACP, after all? On the surface, it sure sounds like a professional organization for pediatricians, such as the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP). Wrong. The ACP does little resembling what a professional society does; certainly it doesn’t offer continuing medical education credit. Certainly it is not the “leading association of pediatricians” in the nation, as its advocates claim. In fact, here’s the origin of the ACP:
In February 2003, the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) issued a policy statement declaring its support for homosexual parenting. The statement urges the states to extend the status of legal parent to same-sex partners, as well as marriage-equivalent status to homosexual and lesbian couples.
However, a new group–the American College of Pediatrics, a Tennessee-based alternative organization headed by Dr. Joseph Zanga–has just responded by requesting that its fellow organization reverse its stand.
Zanga’s group was formed by 100 dissenting members of the AAP. His organization disagrees with the AAP’s point of view on gay parenting, as well as numerous other social issues.
That’s right, the ACP is a small splinter group of conservative pediatricians who broke away from the AAP over its support for parenting by homosexual couples 13 years ago:
“We are essentially a Judeo-Christian, traditional-values organization,” he noted, “open to membership for pediatric medical professionals of all religions who hold to our core beliefs.” Those beliefs, he said, are that “life begins at conception, and that the traditional family unit, headed by an opposite-sex couple, poses far fewer risk factors in the adoption and raising of children.”
The chief purpose of his organization, Zanga commented, is to see to it that children and adolescents receive optimal healthcare, with children’s needs coming first, taking precedence over the political aims of socio-political activists.
And here’s how the ACP describes its values:
The American College of Pediatricians:
A. Recognizes that there are absolutes and scientific truths that transcend relative social considerations of the day.
B. Recognizes that good medical science cannot exist in a moral vacuum and pledges to promote such science.
C. Recognizes the fundamental mother-father family unit, within the context of marriage, to be the optimal setting for the development and nurturing of children and pledges to promote this unit.
D. Recognizes the unique value of every human life from the time of conception to natural death and pledges to promote research and clinical practice that provides for the healthiest outcome of the child from conception to adulthood.
E. Recognizes the essential role parents play in encouraging and correcting the child and pledges to protect and promote this role.
F. Recognizes the physical and emotional benefits of sexual abstinence until marriage and pledges to promote this behavior as the ideal for adolescence.
You get the idea. The ACP is anti-gay marriage, anti-abortion, and promotes the pseudoscience that claims that abstinence-only education is an effective means of reducing the incidence of teen pregnancy. Basically, it’s a phony medical group peddling anti-gay propaganda and pseudoscience to schools.
Unsurprisingly, the ACP now appears to have latched on to anti-Gardasil antivaccine pseudoscience as well. Quelle surprise.
HPV vaccines are effective and safe
Unfortunately, the ACP’s tactic has been more effective than I would like. The original article on the crank website Truthkings trumpeted the ACP statement as “Pediatricians Association Admits HPV Vaccine Causes Ovarian Failure“, making it sound as though a real, legitimate academic pediatrics association had concluded that there is something to worry about. It rapidly went viral with sites like The Healthy Home Economist and Collective Evolution. Because the ACP’s name sounds very official and academic, not surprisingly, the theme that pediatricians were “admitting” that Gardasil can cause premature ovarian failure was very attractive, and many were the articles in the “alternative medicine” and antivaccine blogosphere and on crank websites portraying this as the admission of a coverup. Fortunately, the ACP’s statement was so bad that even at last one who would be inclined to agree with the group on an ideological basis mercilessly eviscerated the ACP’s misinformation.
The bottom line is, as Steve Novella has summarized, the HPV vaccine is effective and quite safe. As a recent review described it:
A number of examinations of the VAERS data for HPV vaccination have shown a low rate of adverse reactions, and no link for any causal relationship between HPV vaccination and reports [43, 44]. There are a variety of conditions that can occur in the absence of HPV or other vaccinations, in young adolescent females, which can be mistaken for HPV vaccination side-effects, and therefore to draw conclusions from adverse event data to HPV vaccination is to mistake (time) correlation for causality [45]. In 2009 Slade and colleagues [44] investigated the 32 deaths attributed to Gardasil® that had been reported on VAERS. Of the 32 deaths there was not enough information to identify or verify the death for 12 reports. The causes of the remaining 20 deaths were: 2 due to diabetic ketoacidosis, 3 due to pulmonary embolism, 6 were cardiac-related (4 arrhythmias, 2 myocarditis), 2 were idiopathic seizure disorders, 4 were unexplained, 1 was due to juvenile amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, 1 case of Neisseria meningitidis serogroup B caused meningoencephalitis and the final death was related to prescription drug abuse. The authors concluded that statistically (proportional reporting ratio of 1.2 for 8- to 29-year olds) these results were not significantly (p=0.92) different from what you would expect from a similar sized unvaccinated population.
In marked contrast, let’s see what a real pediatrics association (the American Academy of Pediatrics) says about Gardasil:
Clinical trials have revealed the vaccine to be highly immunogenic, safe, and well tolerated in males and females 9 through 26 years of age. Antibody responses are at least twice as high in individuals of both genders 9 through 15 years of age as in those 16 through 26 years of age. HPV4 was licensed for use in females in 2006; antibodies have been shown to persist for at least 9 years. HPV4 was licensed for use in males in 2009; the duration of vaccine-induced antibodies is still under investigation but is known to be at least 5 years.
Science, man. It works. It produces wonderful things like vaccines that can prevent cancer.
While discussing (and dismissing on scientific grounds) the claimed link between Gardasil and POF in a recent editorial, “Human papillomavirus vaccination and primary ovarian insufficiency: an association based on ideology rather than evidence“, David Hawkes and Jim Buttery noted a problem that applies to claims of adverse events after all vaccines:
Little and Ward complained that adverse events following immunization were not recorded beyond 7 months after vaccination. However, they provide no rationale or biological mechanism for including a longer interval between HPV vaccination and onset of POI [premature ovarian insufficiency], other than suggesting adolescent girls may not associate a decline or loss of fertility with vaccination if it occurs slowly over time. As the time between HPV vaccination and the first symptoms of POI increases it becomes more difficult to draw a conclusion of causation, particularly in the absence of a biological mechanism. Little and Ward provide no maximum time period between vaccination and the onset of symptoms beyond which they would consider an association unlikely, and with some claiming a causational relationship even with a 15-year interval between vaccination and symptoms [7], a defined temporal criterion is essential.
Which illustrates a more general problem:
Without a plausible biological mechanism we are reliant upon epidemiological studies to refute claims such as these. To conduct such studies, an agreed case definition of POI is required, with initial identification of cases occurring without knowledge of vaccination status or timing. So in essence the claim of an extremely rare reaction to HPV vaccination that results in a poorly defined, uncommon condition is virtually impossible to refute rapidly, and may take years of international collaborative study.
This is exactly the problem with many claims of adverse events after vaccination. Antivaccine advocates won’t be pinned down, and trying to get them to admit a time frame after which they would agree that an association with vaccination is unlikely is like trying to nail jello to a wall. The same, not coincidentally, is true with their claim that vaccines cause autism. Even if a child’s first symptoms of autism develop many weeks or months later, it still must be the vaccines that did it!
Unfortunately, this particular slasher lie that Gardasil renders girls infertile by causing premature ovarian failure is certainly not dead. As always, there will be a sequel, and as usual it won’t be as good as the original movie, which was bad enough to begin with. The bottom line is that Gardasil is effective and very safe, and much of the opposition to it, especially claims that it damages female fertility, is rooted in ideology, not science.

   Mercola, Gardasil, and Toyota? 
Joseph Albietz
Link
Joseph Mercola, D.O. should be well known to readers of SBM for reflexively opposing science-based medicine while providing an endless stream of misinformation on his blog, advocating detoxification, homeopathy, the tapping of meridians chiropractic and more at his clinic, and peddling a treasure trove of vitamin supplements, foods, and Mercola-endorsed devices (on sale at his site for your convenience, no conflict of interest there!).
Nothing seems to personify the evil of modern medicine to Dr Mercola more than the concept of vaccination, and Gardasil, the vaccine against human papillomavirus (HPV), has been drawing a good deal of his ire of late. Case in point is this train-wreck of a post comparing the recent Toyota recall to Gardasil entitled “Time for the Truth About Gardasil.” The post is ill-named.
It begins:
Cervical cancer accounts for less than 1 percent of all cancer deaths — so it was somewhat surprising when the U.S. Food and Drug Administration fast-tracked approval of Gardasil, a Merck vaccine targeting the human papilloma virus that causes the disease.
Cervical cancer tallied 11,982 new cases of cervical cancer and 3,976 deaths in 2006, not to mention the non-cervical cancers for which it is also responsible. Worldwide it has an even greater impact as the second leading cause of cancer in women. Unless Dr Mercola is trying to tell us that he considers the prevention of several thousand deaths per year in the US alone a waste of effort, the fact that cervical cancer isn’t one of the leading causes of cancer death in the US is irrelevant to the FDA’s approval of Gardasil.
I’m certain the actual point Dr Mercola is trying to make is that in his opinion, Gardasil was inadequately tested prior to release, and that he does not accept the data supporting its efficacy or safety. The fact is that it was tested on over 20,000 women in stage 3 trials where both its safety and efficacy profiles were excellent while identifying a few rare but legitimate side effects, and that post-licensure studies after over 23 million doses have supported the original licensure data (I covered this topic at some length here, as has Dr David Gorski here). If Dr Mercola insists on having such exceedingly high standards for the safety and efficacy of a vaccine, surely he holds the myriad concoctions and other products he endorses and sells on his site to the same standard. Surely. Right.
He then continues:
As of the end of January 2010, 49 unexplained deaths following Gardasil injections have been reported to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System.
Mercola implies that the 49 “unexplained” deaths are in fact due to Gardasil (there were 48, not 49 on my check on April 2nd, 2010). There are two major problems with this statement. First and foremost, an unexplained death is, by definition, unexplained.
Second, of the deaths associated with Gardasil reported to CDC’s VAERS, the majority of them are explained. At the time of the post-licensure review published in JAMA in August of 2009, there had been 32 deaths reported following Gardasil injection occurring between 2 to 405 days after the last injection. This is the breakdown of those 32 reported deaths after investigation:
Eight of the reports were second-hand reports that could not be verified. Four were manufacturer reports with no identifying information for confirmation or medical review… Causes of death (of the remaining 20) included 4 unexplained deaths, 2 cases of diabetic ketoacidosis (1 complicated by pulmonary embolism), 1 case related to prescription drug abuse, 1 case of juvenile amyotropic lateral sclerosis, 1 case of meningoencephalitis (Neisseria meningitidis serogroup B), 1 case of influenza B viral sepsis, 3 cases of pulmonary embolism (1 associated with hyperviscosity due to diabetic ketoacidosis), 6 cardiac-related deaths (4 arrhythmias and 2 cases of myocarditis), and 2 cases due to idiopathic seizure disorder.
Keep in mind that over 23 million doses of Gardasil had been administered in the US at this point. It would be remarkable if none of those millions of women had died within a year or so of receiving the vaccine. A rate of death similar to that of the control population with a random smattering of causes should be expected, and is exactly what is found. As always, correlation does not necessarily mean causation, and Dr Mercola is deprived of his greatest source of rhetoric against Gardasil.
Not that it will stop him from jumping another shark:
By contrast, 52 deaths are attributed to unintended acceleration in Toyotas, which triggered a $2 billion recall.
Holy false analogy, Batman! He’s comparing apples to… I don’t know, mops or something. Where to begin? Let’s just accept the number of 52 deaths for now. These deaths are not simply associated with unintended acceleration in Toyotas, they are attributed to them.
These are two very different things! If Dr Mercola wants to compare 52 deaths attributed to defective Toyotas, he needs to compare it to zero deaths attributed to Gardasil, not 49. On the other hand, if he wants his analogy to use the 49 deaths associated with Gardasil, he needs to figure out how many people have died from any cause within a year or so of riding in a Toyota. Methinks the number will be slightly higher than 52.
Not to mention that he completely ignores the starkly different risk/benefit ratios of using Gardasil and driving a Toyota. No one risks developing cancer or dying from not driving a Toyota.
He concludes:
There has been no recall for Gardasil, however. In fact, it is required for sixth-grade girls in D.C., Maryland, Virginia, and many other states. Merck denies any of the deaths are related to its vaccine — and of course, it is difficult for the grieving parents to prove they were.
No, Merck doesn’t deny the deaths are related to the vaccine, the data does. There has been no recall of Gardasil because no recall is warranted, and in the meantime the vaccine is protecting millions from contracting HPV and the cancers it can cause.
My heart goes out to the grieving families to whom Dr Mercola refers; their loss is tragic regardless of its cause. But their grief is being needlessly compounded, and the memory of those lost insulted, as Dr Mercola insists on misrepresenting the conditions of their deaths and callously exploits their loss to spread misinformation and fear of vaccination.

Death by Gardasil? Not so fast there…
There is a type of “vaccine injury” story promoted by the antivaccine movement that is particularly pernicious, a narrative I call “death by Gardasil.” The stories, which use tenuous connections between vaccination against HPV to prevent cervical cancer and the unexpected death of a teen or young adult, are always tragic, and you can’t help but feel incredible empathy for the parents. However, none of these stories constitute compelling evidence that Gardasil kills young people. Basically, antivaxers exploit the grief of these parents and their understandable desire to find a cause for their child’s demise to demonize HPV vaccinations as dangerous and deadly.
David Gorski on February 5, 2018
Link

I’ve been writing about antivaccine pseudoscience for a long time now, both here and elsewhere. Indeed, I was thinking about this the other day and realized that I made my first big splash countering antivaccine misinformation around 13 years ago, and that I had spent about five years before that sparring with antivaxers on Usenet. In that time, I’ve seen all manner of pseudoscience, misinformation, and outright lies about vaccines, including claims that vaccines cause autism and neurodevelopmental disorders, autoimmune disease, diabetes, sudden infant death syndrome, and more. I’ve even seen claims that “shaken baby syndrome” (now known as abusive head trauma) is actually a misdiagnosis for vaccine injury, with antivaxers going so far as to defend child killers by claiming that it was vaccines that killed the baby, not the child abuser. As a result, there is little that antivaxers say that surprises me much anymore.
Unfortunately, included in this lack of surprise is a common claim made about vaccines against the human papillomavirus (HPV), in particular against Gardasil, which are designed to prevent cervical cancer by preventing the most common types of HPV that cause cervical cancer. (Why I don’t see nearly as much fear mongering about the other major HPV vaccine, Cervarix, I don’t know.) For some reason, the antivaccine movement harbors an unusually high degree of hostility for and fear of Gardasil, even though it is intended to prevent a potentially deadly cancer. It’s crazy even by antivaxer standards.
Strike that. The reason is not that mysterious. HPV, several types of which cause cervical cancer, is primarily a sexually transmitted disease. In order to maximize protection, HPV vaccination is recommended for preteen girls—and, more recently, boys—to ensure that they are protected before they become sexually active, although many who receive it are teens. Basically, yes, it’s primarily about sex, which is why one of the most persistent bits of antivaccine fear mongering about Gardasil is that it causes premature ovarian failure and infertility. It doesn’t.
One of the more extreme claims about Gardasil and Cervarix that makes the rounds from time to time is that the vaccine is killing prepubscent girls. I’ve discussed a number of these cases over the years, both here and elsewhere. Suffice to say, when these cases are critically evaluated, the evidence for a link between Gardasil and the deaths attributed to the vaccine is almost always incredibly thin and unconvincing. One example is Annabelle Morin, whose mother Linda Morin blames Gardasil for her daughter’s death, even though it almost certainly did not cause her death. Another example is Jasmine Renata, whose death at a young age was cynically exploited by antivaxers. It even attracted our old antivaccine “friend,” scientist Christopher Shaw, to the proceedings, where he tried to convince New Zealand health authorities that HPV vaccination can cause sudden death and that it caused Renata’s death.
The cases exploited by antivaxers are tragic, and the stories told heart-breaking. No person with an ounce of compassion can read any of them without feeling his heart break for the pain the child who became ill and died suffered and the grief of her family. One can even understand how the parents might come to blame Gardasil, even on the most tenuous of correlation. Discussing such stories requires care and tact, because inevitably any skeptical look at the narrative being promoted by the antivaccine movement will be portrayed as an attack on the dead child and the grieving family.
Unfortunately, they’re at it again; so once more I feel obligated to look into the stories being exploited to spread fear, uncertainty, and doubt about vaccines. This time, there are two tragic cases of teens who died whose deaths antivaxers are blaming on Gardasil. Their names are Jessica Ericzon and Colton Berrett. Both are horrible cases, particularly that of Colton Berrett. Neither, however, are evidence that Gardasil kills, no matter how much antivaxers try to spin them otherwise.
Jasmin Soriat: Death by Gardasil?
Last fall, the UK Association of HPV Vaccine Injured Daughters (AHVID) and SaneVax released a multipart YouTube documentary entitled Sacrificial Virgins. Here’s part I:
Before I discuss the death in the film attributed to Gardasil, I can’t resist commenting on the title of the propaganda video: Sacrificial Virgins. Of course, the imagery in the title is not about a loss of innocence, but a sacrifice of innocence, an image that resonates deeply in human myth, history, religion, and literature. The next question becomes: Sacrifice to what? In general, the implication of human sacrifice, particularly virgin sacrifice, is of ancient, pagan religion, and that’s clearly the imagery the video makers went for here. The implication is that vaccination for HPV is based not on science, but rather on some form of irrational, religious belief system that demands a virgin sacrifice. No one ever accused antivaxers of being subtle.
In the film, Christian Fiala, who, not surprisingly, is an HIV/AIDS denialist and a Board member of the HIV/AIDS denialist group Rethinking AIDS, claims to have identified a 19-year-old woman whose death was caused by HPV vaccination, one of the “virgin sacrifices.” Co-producer of the film, Joan Shenton, also an HIV/AIDS denialist and someone who apparently discovered antivaccine pseudoscience later in life, interviews the pathologist who did the autopsy on the young woman, Prof. Dr. Johan Missliwetz. In the interview, he pointed out that his first autopsy left him unable to find a cause of death, leading him to suspect a genetic heart defect, which is, of course, one of the most common causes of unexplained deaths in young adults. Previous interviews by him don’t really show him saying vaccinations caused the woman’s death. However, in this interview, he claims that his other thought about the cause of death, besides the genetic heart defect, was HPV vaccination, even though it was three weeks after the woman’s second dose of HPV vaccine.
When I first encountered that YouTube video, I could not find out who this unfortunate young woman was. Subsequently, I’ve learned that her name was Jasmin Soriat. Her death was described in—surprise! surprise!—The Daily Mail:
A teenage girl died in her sleep weeks after being given the controversial human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccine, a new documentary has claimed.
Jasmin Soriat, 19, a student from Vienna, suffered neurological symptoms after having a second dose of the injection and suffered respiratory failure three weeks later.
A pathologist who examined her body has said the vaccine could have been the cause of her death.
Jasmin’s story is one of ‘hundreds of documented deaths following the HPV vaccine’ according to claims in a new three-part documentary, titled Sacrificial Virgins.
And:
Government forensic pathologist Dr Johan Missliwetz was ordered by a court to do a second autopsy on Miss Soriat as the first could not establish the cause of death.
He concluded that the vaccine could have been the cause of her demise.The doctor, who has now taken early retirement, said: ‘I couldn’t find a reasonable cause of death but had two suspicions. One is a genetic disorder of the heart and the other one, it had to do with vaccination.’
If you examine stories like that of Jasmine Soriat, you’ll find that there are many commonalities. First and foremost, the temporal association between HPV vaccination and death is tenuous at best. In this case, Soriat had the first shot in the series and didn’t have any problems until weeks after her second shot. (The story I will conclude this post with demonstrates an even less convincing association.) If you want to see how tenuous the association between Gardasil and Jasmine Soriat’s death is, take a look at a more contemporaneous account of her death in 2007:
Less that one month after her last Gardasil injection, Jasmin’s friend discovered her body. She had evidently died in her sleep, succumbing to respiratory paralysis.
Jasmin was fit, happy and fun-loving. She had never experienced any serious illnesses, had no lung disease, and had never smoked. She also had no previous problems after any of her normal vaccinations.
Searching for answers, her parents meticulously reconstructed her final hours of life. According to their investigations, “She was at a concert, a Spanish band. Before midnight, she was at a fast food restaurant. She then drove with her flatmate home, via taxi to Dobling. At approximately two o’clock in the morning, she drank som [sic] tea.”
The next morning, her girlfriend came by to check up on her, but Jasmin, according to her friend, “must have died a few hours earlier in her sleep.”
As I’ve discussed before, there was no evidence linking Gardasil to Ms. Soriat’s death, other than a very tenuous temporal link. Far more likely is a genetic disorder of the conduction system of the heart, which can manifest itself as sudden cardiac death and show no anatomic abnormality on autopsy.
Common themes in “death by Gardasil” stories
After you’ve examined a few of them, you’ll rapidly find two main themes among the stories of “death by Gardasil” circulated in the antivaccine underground that make them unconvincing evidence for vaccine injury. First, the temporal link between Gardasil and death is almost always extremely tenuous, often with the patient having received at least one or two shots in the series with no ill effects and the ill effects only arising weeks or months after the shot on which parents place the blame for their child’s illness.
As a typical example, let’s take a look at the case of Christina Tarsell:
Between her junior and senior years, Chris had a summer job working at the college art museum while living with classmates in a house in Tivoli, NY. So after a short visit home to Maryland, Chris returned to Bard and her job on June 13, 2008. During the visit home, on June 3rd, Chris had gotten her third shot of Gardasil.
A few days later, Chris complained of feeling dizzy, tired and she developed a rash on her neck. She had a post-vaccine cough and sinus congestion that wouldn’t go away. We were never told of any side effects to Gardasil so we did not know these signs were significant. Chris was found dead in her bed 18 days after her third shot. What could have happened? Chris was always a healthy, wholesome girl, a non-smoker, an athlete. She didn’t take drugs or medication.
As of this writing, the cause is “undetermined”. Further investigation suggests that Chris, like other girls who died following Gardasil, may have had an autoimmune related response triggered by the vaccine. The CDC wants you to dismiss them as “coincidences,” while our beautiful, innocent daughters die needlessly.
This story has both of the elements that I discuss. The temporal relationship between vaccination and death is questionable, and she had had two shots before the third shot blamed for her death. She developed an unknown illness and died suddenly. Her parents did further “investigation” and concluded that it must have been the Gardasil.
Some stories don’t even tell the interval between vaccination and death. For instance, there’s the case of Megan Hild, who died at age 20 after a mysterious illness. The most detailed account I could find (which was not very detailed at all) only said that when “she started having severe bouts of fatigue, after her first two Gardasil shots, we thought it was due to her schedule” and that “she began to have a multitude of health problems, including terrible headaches and severe stomach pains.” Ultimately, she was found dead at age 21.
Don’t get me wrong. I’m in no way downplaying the tragedy the families of these girls and young women have endured or the grief and anguish they have experienced over the deaths of their daughters. After all, no parent expects to outlive her daughter, and sudden, unexplained deaths of people under 21 are an anomaly. We humans are also pattern-forming creatures; it’s hard-wired into our brains that, when something happens, particularly something that provokes such a strong emotional response in us like the death of a child, there must be a reason. If there is no good explanation available, the very human response to tragedy is to look desperately for one and to latch onto it when we think we’ve found one. For instance, Ms. Hild’s mother summed up exactly the sort of thinking that leads parents suffering the death of a child to come to erroneous conclusions about what caused that death:
On her death certificate it will read, Cause of death unknown. She’s my daughter and I loved her!!!! I will never see her graduate college. I will never see her wear a wedding dress and hold her babies in her arms.
The one thing in common that four out of the five girls that I have featured is that the actual cause of death is unknown. How can that be? How can these healthy, active young women for no apparent reason just die? That does not make any logical sense to me. There has to be a reason because things like this just do not happen, period.
Unfortunately, things like this most definitely can and do happen. We humans are simply unable to accept that, which leads to parents in mourning blaming vaccines for the deaths of their children.

The sad case of Colton Berrett: Transverse myelitis due to Gardasil, followed by suicide
This brings us to one of the more unusual and painful “death by Gardasil” stories. It’s also the most recent one circulating in the antivaccine underground, the death having occurred one month ago today. Truth be told, I stayed away from this story as long as I could, but I kept seeing more and more posts on antivaccine websites, blogs, and Facebook pages that I finally couldn’t ignore it any more. I’m referring to the tragic case of a young man named Colton Berrett, who has been portrayed as “another teen sacrificed by the HPV vaccine.” Basically, Berrett was an 17-year-old who had contracted transverse myelitis at age 13. His mother blamed his transverse myelitis on his having received the HPV vaccine. As you will see, as is usual with tragic cases like that of Colton Berrett, the story does not even provide a strong suggestion that Gardasil caused this unfortunate young man’s health problems and ultimate death.
None of this stopped Melissa Curtin of Stop Mandatory Vaccination from outrage at the death as having definitely been due to Gardasil:
Deep tidal waves of sadness and devastation shook a community of parents, caregivers, family and friends of vaccine injured and deceased children to its core — after learning about the death of Colton Berrett on January 5th, 2018, in Utah. Heartbreaking, heart-shattering, devastating, horrific, crushing – and most importantly, unnecessary. Another tragic death of a child damaged by and caused from vaccines, and in this case, it was the Gardasil/Human Papilloma Virus Vaccine (HPV) that took his life. Colton is one of thousands of severely vaccine injured children who ultimately lost his life and succumbed to the toxic travesty of vaccine injury and damage. He courageously battled for his survival. May he rest in peace and his story be shared widely. May his family be surrounded by love, community, and find peace in their hearts through this difficult time.
Colton was a vibrant, healthy, lively, intelligent, happy, positive, athletic, thrill-seeking boy with unbridled potential and a bright future. Only his future and life was robbed not just from him, but also from his loving family, his mother, father, and two siblings, from everyone that met him, and the larger community and world that will never have the opportunity to meet this adventurous, courageous, young man.
I have no reason to doubt that Colton was as described. I have no doubt that his family is grieving and suffering. I have no doubt that, before his death, Colton suffered. I can’t even imagine what it would be like to be an active 13-year-old struck down and paralyzed by a neurological condition like this and then, four years later, realizing that there was basically no hope of recovering any more than Colton had recovered, becoming depressed enough to take one’s own life. That being said, however, I have many doubts about the claims being made about how Gardasil caused Colton’s illness and demise, for reasons that I will explain.
It doesn’t help that it was Polly Tommey and the VAXXED crew who first publicized his story in the antivaccine underground last year:
Whenever I see anyone who had anything to do with the antivaccine propaganda “documentary” VAXXED, which was produced by Del Bigtree and directed by Andrew Wakefield, I see many red flags. After all, since the release of the movie in 2016, the VAXXED crew has been cruising the country, collecting stories like that of Colton that they can use in a follow-up movie, harassing scientists, and trying to influence legislators to pass laws favorable to their antivaccine agenda. In other words, not only are the VAXXED crew not objective, its members are the farthest from objective that you can imagine. They are die-hard ideologues who believe, against all evidence otherwise, that vaccines cause serious harm. Anything posted by VAXXED is to be viewed with extreme skepticism.
The video and his mother’s account above agree here:
A medical physical was required for Colton to attend a scout camp. This was prior to his 8th grade school year. His pediatrician and long-time family doctor recommended the HPV Vaccine to his mother, Kathleen. His doctor claimed the HPV Vaccine could help prevent cancer, and even if Colton was not promiscuous, he could give the virus to his future wife. Like many parents, Kathleen trusted her doctor. She confidently shared, “The doctor is the one who went to school, and of course you’re going to do what he recommends.”
So Colton got the Gardasil series. Because this was four years ago, he got the three shot series, where the doses are administered at 0, 1-2, and 6 months. (This was the old schedule. The CDC now recommends a two dose schedule for children under 15, with doses at 0 and 6-12 months.)
Colton’s first two doses of Gardasil produced no reported problems, and I’m quite sure that, had there been any problems with the first two doses, the VAXXED account would have definitely mentioned them. In the video above, his mother doesn’t mention any issue until the third dose, nor does any account that I’ve been able to find. Consequently, for six months and two doses, Colton was fine. Then this happened:
Colton was administered the third round of the Gardasil/ HPV Vaccine on February 1, 2014, about a month and a half just shy of his 14th birthday. About two weeks after, he experienced a painful neck ache following the vaccine and was given Tylenol to alleviate the pain. Adventurous by nature, the next day, Colton and his dad went motor-cross riding to use Colton’s new bike. That day when he arrived home, he became pale, started to feel nauseous, and was not well that evening – he headed to bed. Kathleen continued to check on him throughout the night and Colton expressed he could not use his right arm. Intuitively, Kathleen worried if he had spinal meningitis and if her son was going paralyzed. A mother’s or any concerned parent’s nightmare.
Colton’s dad brought Colton to urgent care at Primary Children’s Hospital in Salt Lake City the next morning, on Monday, February 17, 2014. Colton was almost completely paralyzed and that was the beginning of his 88 day hospital stay. Doctors and staff discovered through speaking with Colton’s parents that he was healthy, active, and not sick, until he received the HPV Vaccine two weeks earlier and experienced the neck ache. It was agreed that Colton suffered a severe adverse reaction and vaccine injury to the Gardasil vaccine. The doctors reported his vaccine injury to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS).
So, basically, Colton had no problems at all until two weeks after the third dose of Gardasil. What I find odd is the account that the doctors were so quick to say that they were going to report Colton’s case to VAERS, particularly after the third dose. That part of the story strikes me as rather odd. Be that as it may, this is what happened next:
Colton was originally diagnosed with Acute Longitudinal Transverse Myelitis; C1 through T-12 were affected (Cervical-1, through Thoracic-12). The inflammation in his spinal cord caused the paralysis which started in his neck and full right arm. His left arm was starting to lose function and become paralyzed. Colton was also having difficulty breathing, so intubation and a ventilator were needed. Paralysis continued spreading throughout his body and it was not too long before Colton lost his speech ability. Able only to communicate using the “thumbs up or thumbs down” method, that was soon halted due to loss of movement in his thumbs. Colton’s new reality included daily therapy to avoid infection and pneumonia, irregular temperature regulation, hot/cold packs for the spikes and drops in temperature, being uncomfortable with a cervical collar, and all this with a 15 pound ventilator/breathing machine. His family referred to this as his “ball and chain.”
Acute longitudinal transverse myelitis (ALTM) is a condition that involves inflammation of the spinal cord, in Colton’s case, C1-T12, which is a huge stretch of spinal cord. Here is a schematic of the spinal cord below that shows what a large portion of the spinal cord that was involved:

There are a number of suspected causes of ALTM. The National Institute of Neurologic Disorders and Stroke notes that the cause of ALTM is unknown in most cases, but that the discovery of circulating antibodies to the proteins aquaporin-4 and anti-myelin oligodendrocyte point to a definite cause in some individuals with transverse myelitis. Aquaporin-4 is a key protein that carries water through the cell membrane of neural cells. The myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein sits on the outer layer of myelin. Basically, the NINDS notes that the following conditions predispose to ATLM:
    • Immune system disorders
    • Viral infections.
    • Bacterial infections such as syphilis, tuberculosis, actinomyces and Lyme disease, as well as bacterial skin infections, middle-ear infections, campylobacter jejuni gastroenteritis, and mycoplasma bacterial pneumonia.
    • Fungal infections in the spinal cord, including Aspergillus, Blastomyces, Coccidioides, and Cryptococcus.
    • Parasites, including Toxoplasmosis, Cysticercosis, Shistosomiasis, and Angtiostrongyloides.
    • Other inflammatory disorders that can affect the spinal cord, such as sarcoidosis, systemic lupus erythematosus, Sjogren’s syndrome, mixed connective tissue disease, scleroderma, and Bechet’s syndrome.
    • Vascular disorders such as arteriovenous malformation, dural arterial-venous fistula, intra spinal cavernous malformations, or disk embolism.
Transverse myelitis can also be the first symptom of an autoimmune disease, such as multiple sclerosis or neuromyelitis optica.
The disease is treated by a number of modalities, depending on what is thought to be the etiology. These modalities can include steroids, plasma exchange, intravenous immunoglobulin, antiviral medications, and other medications to treat symptoms. Most people with transverse myelitis have at least a partial recovery, with most recovery occurring within three months after symptoms arise, although in some patients recovery might take two years. However, if there is no improvement within three to six months, complete recovery is very unlikely, and rapid onset of symptoms (as happened with Colton) generally results in poorer recovery.
According to the account, Colton had to be intubated, and you can see that he still had a tracheostomy tube and was using a portable ventilator, the noted “ball and chain.” He was quadriplegic for a month and a half, and he was unable to communicate for a time other than with his eyebrows and facial expressions. As of the time this video was recorded, his right arm remained paralyzed, and he had only a little use of his left arm. He had, however, regained his core strength and the use of his legs, after prolonged physical therapy. Overall, one can’t help but feel empathy for what this young man went through. At least, I couldn’t while viewing the video.
But did Gardasil cause Colton’s ALTM? It’s highly unlikely. For one thing, evidence does not support a link. A recent study of 64 million doses of vaccines found no association between transverse myelitis and prior immunization, including with HPV vaccines. Yes, I know that antivaxers will cite this paper claiming to find an association between vaccination and transverse myelitis, but it’s nowhere near as good a paper, methodologically speaking, and it’s published by Yehuda Shoenfeld, who has promoted an unproven concept that vaccines cause an autoimmune syndrome that is not accepted by medicine and is known for writing pseudoscientific reports to support antivaccine lawsuits. He’s also been the scientific advisor for at least one antivaccine propaganda movie.
Another explanation for why comes courtesy of someone who knows a lot more about the disease than I do and occurs in the comments after this Facebook post:
This FB post was made in response to a blog post by James Lyon Weiler, Who and What Killed Colton Berrett?, where he charges:
The vaccine changed the life of his family forever – and now, Colton is gone – forever.
I’m a scientist focused on root causes. It is no mystery to me what – and who – killed Colton Berrett.
Selfishness killed Colton Berrett.
Profit killed Colton Berrett.
Vaccine Risk Denialism killed Colton Berrett.
Direct-to-Consumer Marketing killed Colton Berrett.
The FCC killed Colton Berrett.
Pharma Ads in Newspapers killed Colton Berrett.
The Media killed Colton Berrett.
Political donations to campaigns from Vaccine Makers killed Colton Berrett.
Dorit Rubinstein Reiss killed Colton Berrett.
Paul Offit killed Colton Berrett.
Peter Hotez killed Colton Berrett.
Lee Harrison killed Colton Berrett.
Julie Gerberding killed Colton Berrett.
Thomas Frieden killed Colton Berrett.
State Senator Richard Pan killed Colton Berrett.
Coleen Boyle killed Colton Berrett.
Frank Destefano killed Colton Berrett.
Scientific Fraud killed Colton Berrett.
Medical Malfeasance killed Colton Berrett.
ACIP killed Colton Berrett.
CDC killed Colton Berrett.
Merck killed Colton Berrett.
Congress killed Colton Berrett.
The National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act (NCVIA) of 1986 killed Colton Berrett.
FASCISM killed Colton Berrett.
Because of course it did. At the risk of going too far, I can’t resist saying that I’m surprised Weiler didn’t list me as one of Colton Berrett’s “killers.”
In the comments, it’s pointed out that the family’s contemporaneous accounts of Colton’s illness make no mention of vaccines:
We see this sort of thing so often, and it’s so depressing. Basically, it appears that the idea that Gardasil caused Colton’s problems, like the idea that vaccines cause a child’s autism, came later, as the parents looked for explanations and encountered the cranks. In fairness, it’s unclear who wrote the post above, and the parents might not have told others of their suspicions yet, but certainly it seems odd that there is no mention here.
Later in the thread, a scientist further explains why it’s incredibly unlikely that Gardasil caused Colton’s transverse myelitis:
Parts are worth citing in detail:
Based on the statement by Colton’s mother in a Vaxxed video, Colton first developed symptoms two weeks after the vaccination. Transverse myelitis is marked by an extremely fast, fulminant course. It is very surprising for it to arise two weeks after the alleged inciting event. We know a lot about TM from EAE, an experimental/research procedure in which autoimmune encephalitis/myelitis is induced by coupling a myelin protein, such as MOG, with a strong adjuvant – usually Complete Freund’s Adjuvant, sometimes even with the addition of pertussis toxin. Complete Freund’s Adjuvant is an extremely strong adjuvant, so strong that in fact it is often replaced with squalene or AlOH because it is so unpleasant to the animal itself (it’s never used in humans). It makes no logical sense for the HPV vaccine, which does not penetrate the blood/brain barrier, even in the presence of the AlOH adjuvant (like MOG, it’s too big – in EAE, pertussis toxin is used to allow penetration). It makes no sense for the original inflammatory insult and the onset of TM to take so long. And, finally, demyelinating events in HPV are incredibly rare
And:
Having had an encounter with TM before, I am personally deeply sorry for Colton and his family. At the same time, I can’t find much data that in any sense supports the claim that his illness was caused by the HPV vaccine. Personally, I’m also a little dubious as to the ethics of Vaxxed using this young man, who has clearly been through an extremely traumatic and life-changing experience that has deprived him of his very identity as, basically, a prop, with the parents’ agreement. There are repeated assertions that Colton wanted to make the statements that he did, but this is an ethically complex situation. Colton is in a profound sense dependent on his parents, so he might be susceptible to manipulation and coercion to say the message his mother and/or the Vaxxed activitsts [sic] want him to say. Whether this was indeed the case or not, the ethics of burdening a young man in his complex situation with the burden of activism and a very complex message that he himself might not have the qualifications to comprehensively understand (despite his subjective situation, being a bird does not make one an ornithologist and being an alleged vaccine victim does not make one fit to judge often complex scientific evidence proving vaccines are safe). Life is short, fragile and infinitely precious.
Indeed it is.
The tragic end to Colton Berrett’s story
As I stated above and consistent with so many other stories promoted by the antivaccine movement to blame a child’s death on Gardasil, Colton Berrett’s story did not end well. Sadly, exactly a month ago on January 5, Colton died:
If you watch this next video, at around the 1:14 mark, a statement from Colton’s mother is read that reveals that Colton took his own life:
The story of Colton Berrett is one of the most tragic stories that I have ever encountered, and, remember, I have blogged about several of the children with incurable cancer treated by cancer quack Stanislaw Burzynski. A highly active and happy child, he was unfortunate enough to develop a horrific disease that robbed him of much of his ability to do what he loved the most and rendered him completely dependent upon others for many of his basic activities. He faced a lifetime ahead of him in which he was unlikely ever to get significantly better or recover much more function than he had already recovered. What makes the tragedy so much worse is how the antivacine vultures responsible for VAXXED have swarmed around the family since discovering his case, encouraging his mother to buy into the false notion that Gardasil injured her son to the point where he was so damaged that he took his own life and blaming Gardasil for his suffering and death. Their behavior, their exploitation of Colton and his family, is beyond despicable.
There’s even one case I know of, that of a 12-year-old girl named Meredith Prohaska, who died after receiving Gardasil. It turned out that the coroner had ruled that Gardasil had not resulted in her death. Why? Because she found what did: an overdose of the antihistamine diphenhydramine (Benadryl). Unsurprisingly, the publications promoting her story never corrected their articles, and Meredith’s story is still featured as a “death by Gardasil” story on the anti-Gardasil website My Gardasil Story and was described without mention of the true cause of death on the quack website Natural Mentor. So, basically, if the cause of death is not determined, to antivaxers it must have been the HPV vaccine. If it is, as in Meredith Prohaska’s case, determined not to have been related to HPV vaccination, then antivaxers never correct their previous stories. Either that, or the coroner’s findings are dismissed as part of the conspiracy to cover up the dangers of Gardasil.
There is abundant evidence that HPV vaccines are safe and effective, despite the myths about them promoted by the antivaccine movement. Unfortunately, a combination of that very human need to have an explanation for the death of a child and opportunistic exploitation of that need by leaders of the antivaccine movement lead to cases like that of Colton Berrett, Annabelle Morin, Jasmine Soriat, and Christina Tarsell being promoted as “evidence” that Gardasil kills even though they are nothing of the sort. Sadly, the empathy that we all feel for parents who have lost children tends to lead people to take the version of the story presented by the parents and antivaccine movement at face value and accept their conclusion that Gardasil killed their children.

In 2014, Dr. Kelly Brogan and Sayer Ji Told People Natural HPV Infections Were “Beneficial, Not Deadly.” What’s Happened Since?
Pseudoscience requires apathy about its victims, and that’s the most grotesque part about it.
Jonathan Howard on July 24, 2026
Link

“HPV Vaccine Maker’s Study Proves Natural HPV Infection Beneficial, Not Deadly.”
Way back in 2014, my old pal “holistic” psychiatrist Dr. Kelly Brogan wrote an article with Sayer Ji, the founder of the pseudoscience site GreenMedInfo, that helped me realize the depravity of anti-vaxxers, who didn’t just lie about vaccines, but actively encouraged infections with dangerous viruses.
Their article was titled HPV Vaccine Maker’s Study Proves Natural HPV Infection Beneficial, Not Deadly. Its core argument was that HPV infections were beneficial because they protected against HPV infections. The sheer stupidity of this argument made a big impact on me at the time and prepared me well for future events. The We Want Them Infected movement did not begin in 2020.
Their article began by saying:

Behind every vaccine is an assumption. That HPV causes cervical cancer, that cervical cancer causes death, and that a vaccine can effectively interfere with this linear relationship is the assumption to be examined in this article.
That’s gobbledygook, and it can be done with anything. Behind every car is an assumption. That wheels go around, that steering wheels will change their direction, and that brakes will stop them.
However, our plucky duo claimed to have discovered something that had eluded every expert in virology, oncology, infectious diseases, and vaccinology. With nothing but an internet connection, they alone had discovered the real truth.
They discussed a study titled Risk of Newly Detected Infections and Cervical Abnormalities in Women Seropositive for Naturally Acquired Human Papillomavirus Type 16/18 Antibodies: Analysis of the Control Arm of PATRICIA. It found:
Naturally acquired antibodies to HPV-16, and to a lesser extent HPV-18, are associated with some reduced risk of subsequent infection and cervical abnormalities associated with the same HPV type.
That a virus leads to “some reduced risk of subsequent infection” is obviously not a reason to embrace that virus, especially when there is an effective vaccine against it. Indeed, the original PATRICIA study, a phase III randomized, double-blind, controlled trial of the HPV vaccine concluded:
PATRICIA end-of-study results show excellent vaccine efficacy against cervical intraepithelial neoplasia 3+ and adenocarcinoma in situ irrespective of HPV DNA in the lesion. Population-based vaccination that incorporates the HPV-16/18 vaccine and high coverage of early adolescents might have the potential to substantially reduce the incidence of cervical cancer.
Dr. Brogan and Mr. Ji didn’t care about this at all, however. Rather than inform their readers of this important finding, they instead made some big assumptions of their own and wrote:
If, in fact, the HPV vaccines do not work as widely advertised, and natural HPV infectious exposures actually protect against the progression of HPV linked cervical changes to cancer, then taken together, both these findings challenge the most fundamental assumptions within vaccine science (aka vaccinology), and render highly dubious the oft repeated rhetoric that natural HPV infection is juggernaut –like deadly force the best defense against which are universal immunization campaigns…
Given the possibility that HPV infection itself confers protection against HPV reinfection and its more serious health implications (e.g. CIN1+), and that the HPV vaccine may not offer the same level of protection that our inborn adaptive immune responses to natural HPV infection does, we should pause to question the dominant HPV memes circulating out there – via the CDC, the pediatricians, the mainstream media – that proffer HPV is a ‘vaccine-preventable’ disease that we are morally and socially obligated to engage ‘preventively’ through vaccinating every susceptible adolescent on the planet. This fear-borne meme driving the herd to vaccinate against HPV—and everything else —is at least as infectious as the very virus they falsely promise their bivalent and quadrivalent vaccines will defeat.
Dr. Brogan and Mr. Ji concluded with a plea for science:
Perhaps it’s time for us to truly see how safe and effective they are by engaging in basic scientific methodology. We might find that everything we thought was true, is far from it.
Dr. David Gorski wrote a rebuttal at the time titled I Do Not Think That Study Shows What You Think It Shows. He had them figured out years ago. He wrote:
HPV is a vaccine-preventable disease. It makes sense in many populations to vaccinate against it. HPV vaccination itself is pretty crappy at preventing reinfection—according to the results of the very study that Ji and Brogan themselves try to use to claim that we shouldn’t vaccinated against HPV. Truly, in the antivaccine world of Brogan and Ji, up is down, left is right, right is wrong, and we have always been at war with Eastasia—and apparently a study looking at the correlation between antibody levels and reinfection tells us that vaccinating against a first infection is inferior to “natural infection.” Of course, if our immunity to a primary infection were so great, we wouldn’t need a vaccine in the first place. Either Ji and Brogan are incredibly ignorant, or they’re intentionally obfuscating. Take your pick. Neither possibility reflects well on them.
“Young Women Now Have ‘Close To Zero’ Risk Of Cervical Cancer Death After HPV Jab”
Enough time has passed that we can judge the predictions of Dr. Brogan and Mr. Ji. Were HPV infections beneficial after all? Well, here is a smattering of recent articles on the topic:
    • Young Women Now Have ‘Close To Zero’ Risk Of Cervical Cancer Death After HPV Jab
    • Australia On-Track To Be The First Country To Achieve Cervical Cancer Elimination
    • New Research Highlights Strong Benefits Of HPV Vaccines Beyond Cervical Cancer
    • Cervical Cancer Deaths Have Plummeted Thanks To HPV Vaccine
    • New Evidence Review Affirms Strong Safety and Effectiveness of HPV Vaccines
    • HPV Vaccine Safe And Reduces Risk Of Cervical Cancer, Anti-Misinformation Review Finds
    • HPV Vaccines Protect Against Cervical Cancer After 18 Years
According to that last article:
Most cases of cervical cancer are caused by human papillomaviruses (HPV). When HPV vaccines were introduced twenty years ago, experts dared to dream of a world without cervical cancer.
There are 660,000 cases of the disease every year, and around 350,000 deaths. The HPV vaccine was added to national vaccine schedules once it had been thoroughly tested and approved by independent regulators – and it is widely supported by cancer patient advocates.
However, it was clear that the full impact of the vaccine would not be visible for decades. That is because the vaccine is given in early adolescence to protect against a virus that causes cancers later in life.
Now, data from multiple countries is mounting. All the evidence points in the same direction: HPV vaccines are safely protecting against cervical cancer. As a result, the prospect of eliminating the disease is coming into focus.
A major new study from Sweden, published in the BMJ, shows that HPV vaccines provide long-term protection against invasive cervical cancer. Researchers used data from 926,362 girls vaccinated between January 2006 and December 2023.
By following this group for eighteen years and tracking those who developed cancer, they were able to conclude two things: Not only did the vaccine reduce cervical cancer by 79% compared to those who had not been vaccinated, but it also offered sustained protection for years after vaccination.
The proof that the vaccine prevents HPV infection and protects against cancer backs up several studies from other countries. For example, this Danish paper showed far fewer girls tested positive for HPV after vaccination, while this large Dutch study also showed strong protection against cancer. Data from Scotland and a new study from the US pointed in the same direction.
That’s a big deal. Moving forward, no one should suffer or die from an HPV-related cancer because they missed a simple vaccine, and it’s tragic that so many already have.
“I will be critical of the FDA officials who missed this important signal.”
Circling back to my writing from last fall, when disgraced ex-FDA leader Dr. Vinay Prasad faked that the COVID vaccine killed at least 10 children, I wrote that I was open to his evidence. That was true. I also acknowledged that if indeed he had it, which he didn’t, that would have implicated his predecessors. I wrote:
I will be critical of the FDA officials who missed this important signal.
That was also true. I cared deeply about this issue because I’d written many articles advocating for the pediatric COVID vaccine. Though I am under no illusion they changed many parents’ minds, I nonetheless would have been miserable had I given advice that could have hurt a child, however remote the odds.
Dr. Brogan and Mr. Ji share no such compunctions, however, and their callous indifference reveals three core features of pseudoscience.
First, although Dr. Brogan and Mr. Ji claimed to have been motivated by “basic scientific methodology”, this was a performance, a slick marketing gimmick to trick their marks. The data about the HPV vaccine was already clear in 2014, and it’s even clearer today. Yet, the research I posted above won’t matter to them at all. Not one bit.
Second, people like Dr. Brogan and Mr. Ji will never admit error, nor will they survey the scientific literature in 2026 and make the affirmative case they were right in 2014. They’ll act like they never promoted HPV infections, though that’s exactly what they did. They told people an oncogenic virus was beneficial, when there was a safe and effective vaccine against it, and they shouldn’t be allowed to forget it.
Third and most damningly, they won’t care about the consequences of their words. The people hurt by their anti-vaccine disinformation don’t matter to them at all. They’ve moved on to other things. Today, Dr. Brogan is busy extolling the glories of Dr. Brogan and pushing her monetized content. Mr. Ji meanwhile is a sycophant for our government and current medical establishment, trying to make MAHA global.
I would feel deep and profound shame if I had said a cancer-causing virus was beneficial. I would apologize, vanish from public commentary forever, and spend the rest of my days losing sleep, wondering exactly who I had hurt. Pseudoscience, however, requires apathy about its victims, and that’s the most grotesque part about it.

Preventing Malaria: A Glimmer of Hope?
A recent clinical trial tested a new approach to malaria prevention involving monoclonal antibodies.
Harriet Hall on September 14, 2021
Link

Malaria is a parasitic disease transmitted through mosquito bites. There are 200-400 million new cases each year, with 400,000 annual deaths, plus great morbidity and economic burdens. It has been especially devastating for children in sub-Saharan Africa. Mosquito-control measures, insect repellents, and mosquito nets have been only partially effective. Global infection rates decreased by 50-75% from 2000 to 2015, but the number of cases has continued to rise in many areas despite these interventions. Several drugs are available to prevent and treat malaria, from chloroquine to artemisin, for which the Chinese researcher Tu Youyou was awarded a Nobel Prize in 2015. Unfortunately, drug resistance has diminished their effectiveness. Several vaccines are available or are under development, but they are far from as effective as we might wish.
A phase 1 trial for a new approach
Rather than treating malaria, it would be far better to prevent it in the first place. An article recently published in The New England Journal of Medicine by Gaudinski et al. reported a phase 1 clinical trial of a drug intended to do just that. It was small two-part open-label trial of CIS43LS, a long-acting monoclonal antibody for malaria prevention. In Part A, the drug was given to 25 healthy adults who had not previously had malaria or received a vaccine for malaria; 4 of the 25 received a second dose, and the trial assessed the safety and pharmacokinetics of the drug at one of three escalating dose levels given intravenously or subcutaneously. Seven participants from Part A went on to participate in Part B, in which 11 additional participants were enrolled. 8 people enrolled in Part A and 7 in Part B were left untreated to serve as controls. Finally, a group of participants underwent controlled human malarial infection (after giving informed consent, they were bitten on the forearm by infected Anopheles stephensi mosquitoes); and those who developed parasitemia were treated with atovaquone and proguanil. The protocol was approved by an Institutional Review Board (IRB).
Safety: No safety concerns were identified. All reported adverse events were mild and resolved completely.
Efficacy: A total of 15 subjects were bitten by infected mosquitoes. None of the nine who had received CIS43LS developed parasitemia, while five out of the six untreated controls did, which was consistent with historical data.
Their conclusion: “…malaria can be prevented from 4 to 36 weeks after a single administration of a monoclonal antibody against the major protein covering the surface of the infecting sporozoite.”
Was this statement justified?
Not really. I have several reservations. It was only a small Phase 1 preliminary trial. It was open-label (patients knew when they got the antibody injection). It has not been replicated. They were not able to evaluate subcutaneous injection because of Covid-19-related interruptions in sample collection. The half-life of the monoclonal antibody is only 56 days, so the applicability would be limited to short-term travelers and others for whom a single infusion would eliminate non-compliance and would obviate the need for daily chemoprophylaxis. They studied healthy adults; what is really needed is a way to prevent malaria in children and in the general population. The authors called for further studies, which clearly are needed – at the bare minimum, a good Phase 3 controlled trial will be essential before it could be marketed.
Conclusion: An interesting new approach
        ◦ These results are intriguing, but monoclonal antibodies will not be acceptable for prevention of malaria until we know more. This is more of a “proof-of concept” experiment. As research continues, I hope more practical antibody treatments will result. We can’t celebrate just yet, but we should stay tuned. That said, it offers a glimmer of hope for malaria sufferers.

A Malaria Vaccine for Children: A Historic Achievement that will Save Countless Lives
WHO has officially recommended the first ever vaccine against a parasite, in this case malaria, and it will save thousands of kids’ lives every year.
Clay Jones on October 15, 2021
Link

I’ve spent the past two weeks preparing a Grand Rounds presentation on “Chiropractic and the Pediatric Patient” for my hospital and pediatricians in the community. I gave the talk on Wednesday and I believe it went well. For fun, I had time at the end for a bit of lagniappe so I showed videos of applied kinesiology surrogate testing, KST tandem adjustments, and the “Ring Dinger“.
So, a short post today. But it’s a post about a huge achievement in pediatric medicine that will save thousands of lives every year around the world. There is now have a safe, effective, and WHO-endorsed malaria vaccine for broad use in children living in regions where malaria is prevalent.
I really can’t stress enough how important this is. Malaria, a mosquito-borne disease caused by infection with a member of the unicellular Plasmodium parasite group, is one of the deadliest infectious diseases that humans have had to face. Over time, with mosquito control efforts involving insecticides, improved water drainage, and physical barriers, the surface area of the Earth where malaria is a concern has decreased dramatically. Still, 40% of the world’s population is at risk, particularly those living in poor tropical and sub-tropical regions, with sub-Saharan Africa taking the brunt of morbidity and mortality associated with the disease. There are still about 1,500-2,000 cases diagnosed in the United States every year in travelers.
The number of people that develop malaria every year is staggering. In 2019, there were 229 million clinical cases and 409,000 deaths. Most of these deaths occurred in children living in sub-Saharan Africa and these totals are almost certainly a significant undercount of the true prevalence and mortality.
More than 200,000 of those deaths involved children under the age of 5 years. Young children are often infected repeatedly during this period, with each infection potentially being fatal. Those who survive might develop partial immunity to malaria, which is why severe disease is less likely in adults. As with COVID-19 in children, death is not the only outcome of concern. Repeated bouts of malaria can leave a child malnourished, weak, and vulnerable to other infections. Obviously, the goal of any vaccine would be to provide some degree of protection without the risk of death from severe anemia, organ failure, or stroke.
The RTS,S/AS01 vaccine, now named Mosquirix, is the first vaccine against a parasitic organism and targets the member of the Plasmodium group that is most associated with severe and life-threatening illness. It works by limiting the ability of P. falciparum to gain access to the liver, where it typically would mature and multiply before moving on to invade it’s victim’s red blood cells. The vaccine results in immunity against the circumsporozoite protein that is found on the surface of the malaria parasite when in the form that initially enters the body via the bite of an infected mosquito.
Here is the official statement from WHO:
WHO recommends that in the context of comprehensive malaria control the RTS,S/AS01 malaria vaccine be used for the prevention of P. falciparum malaria in children living in regions with moderate to high transmission as defined by WHO. RTS,S/AS01 malaria vaccine should be provided in a schedule of 4 doses in children from 5 months of age for the reduction of malaria disease and burden.
They feel that the vaccine is feasible to delivery and will improve equity of malaria prevention strategies, being able to reach children who may not have access to things like insecticide-coated bednets or modernized drainage systems to reduce standing water and mosquito populations. The vaccine looks to be safe as well, with no major concerns seen during studies involving 2.3 million doses in 3 African countries. The safety profile isn’t spotless, however. There was an issue of a small increased risk of meningitis, though not at all the involved sites. Researchers felt that it was likely a fluke. Pilot studies are still underway, so this potential problem remains a focus. The vaccine is also highly cost-effective in regions with lots of malaria.
        ◦ When it comes to the effectiveness of the vaccine, it is good but certainly could be better. Still, a moderately effective vaccine that prevents 40% of total cases and a third of severe cases in the most vulnerable population is amazing. WHO predicts that RTS,S/AS01 vaccine, which has been in development since the 1980s, will prevent 5 million cases and 23,000 deaths every year. It’s a first step, however, with other vaccines in the works that look even more promising. The ultimate goal of WHO is a vaccine that is 75% effective.

A New Malaria Vaccine
A second anti-malarial vaccine in just two years could be a game-changer for this deadly disease.
Steven Novella on September 14, 2022
Link

In the 14 years of SBM we only have written two articles about malaria, both in 2021. At first this may be surprising as malaria is a serious worldwide illness, with an estimated 241 million cases per year and 627,000 deaths (although likely an underestimate). However, there hasn’t been much in the way of innovation to write about, until recently. Last year Harriet wrote about a monoclonal antibody for malaria, and Clay Jones wrote about the first malaria vaccine.
Already there is an update, with the recent announcement of another anti-malaria vaccine claiming greater efficacy. I don’t think this is a coincidence. I think we are seeing the results of advancing biotechnology. Monoclonal antibodies, for example, are finally coming into their own, with multiplying applications in almost every field of medicine. Vaccine technology has also been steadily advancing, which the world witnessed with the rapid roll-out of many anti-COVID vaccines within a year of its emergence.
The RTS,S/AS01 vaccine (now named Mosquirix and manufactured by GlaxoSmithKline):
…had a vaccine efficacy of 68% over a period of 6 months following administration of the initial three doses, but this efficacy waned over time. At 6 months after a fourth dose, administered 18 months following the third dose, vaccine efficacy was 44% (95% CI 40–48).
As Clay pointed out, this is still not at the WHO’s goal of 75% efficacy, but it is still good. Even at 44% efficacy this will prevent many deaths. Also, we need to keep in mind that (as with COVID) death is not the only bad outcome from serious infections. Malaria mostly affect sub-Saharan African children, who often have multiple infections by age 5. Those who survive can still suffer malnutrition, poor development, and increased susceptibility to other infections. It is a massive disease and societal burden. Even with modest efficacy, an effective vaccine has a huge ROI in terms of outcomes and healthcare dollars.
The new vaccine, R21/Matrix-M, is being developed at Oxford and manufactured by the Serum Institute of India, which is the largest vaccine manufacturer in the world. There has actually already been a preliminary phase I trial of this vaccine using a three-dose schedule in a cohort of children aged 5–17 months in Nanoro, Burkina Faso. The results showed an efficacy of 75% at 12 months, reaching the WHO goal. The new study in the same cohort uses a booster shot at 12 months following the initial three-dose regimen, and finds:
Vaccine efficacy was maintained in the high-dose adjuvant group, at 80% following the booster vaccine over 12 months, and 75% over 24 months after the primary three-dose regimen. Furthermore, vaccine efficacy against multiple episodes of clinical malaria was similar (78%) over 2 years of follow-up. R21/Matrix-M has a favourable safety profile and also induces high levels of malaria-specific anti-NANP antibodies that correlate with the observed protection against clinical malaria.
This is a significant improvement over the Mosquirix vaccine, and meets the WHO goal. The caveat is that this was only a phase II trial involving 409 children. The researchers are already beginning a phase III trial with 4,800 children. If this shows similar results that would likely be enough to get regulatory approval.
The other advantage to this vaccine, especially given the target population, is that it is cheap to produce, at only a few dollars per dose. The Serum Institute of India claims they can produce 100 million doses a year, which is a lot but not nearly enough. A full booster course is four doses, so that is enough for 25 million children, yet there are over 240 million cases a year. Hopefully production can be ramped up significantly.
The good news is that it seems we are on the cusp of significantly reducing cases of malaria. Malaria is likely the deadliest disease in all history, and remains a significant killer. The CDC in the US was founded essentially to fight malaria in the southeast, which was accomplished mainly through getting rid of mosquito breeding grounds. In Africa the mainstay of fighting malaria is through pesticides to reduce mosquito populations, mosquito netting, and drugs to treat infection once it occurs. But we have been lacking the single most effective tool in our infectious disease toolkit – a vaccine. That is now changing.
But why has it taken so long to develop an anti-malaria vaccine? Some infectious organisms are challenging to target with a vaccine, because they have a complex lifecycle or are able to evade immunity. Malaria is caused by a parasite, several Plasmodium species, that reproduce in the gut of mosquitos then migrate to the salivary glands and are injected during feeding on humans. The parasites then reproduce in the liver and in the final stage move onto red blood cells, where they cause serious illness.
The vaccines both work by targeting the initial phase of human infection, preventing them from infecting liver cells. They combine malarial proteins with the Hepatitis B virus, so essentially they work like a typical anti-viral vaccine, but the malarial proteins allow the resulting antibodies to target the Plasmodium parasite. The Oxford vaccine incorporates more malarial proteins, which they believe is the reason it has higher efficacy than the GSK vaccine. It was a clever approach that ultimately bore fruit.
Vaccine technology remains arguably the most effective medical intervention developed by humans. We are also seeing the results of advancing vaccine technology, and biotechnology in general. In a generation malaria, one of the greatest scourges of humanity, may become a thing of the past due to vaccine technology. 

Cameroon Begins First Malaria Vaccine Program
Steven Novella on January 24, 2024
Link

Despite massive efforts to reduce the disease burden of malaria, it remains a significant cause of disease and death in parts of the world, most notably Sub-Saharan Africa. Now we have a new tool in the fight against malaria – two safe and effective vaccines. Cameroon is just beginning a program to give the vaccine for free to children in four doses from 5 month to two years, and other countries are soon to follow.
Malaria is a mosquito-born disease caused by five Plasmodium species of parasite, with P. falciparum being the most severe. People become infected by being bitten by a mosquito carrying the parasite. Infection causes fever and flu-like symptoms, and sometimes anemia and jaundice. Severe infection with P. falciparum can also cause seizures, delirium, kidney failure, coma and death. Eighty percent of people who die of malaria, 600,000 per year, are children under five.
Malaria mitigation has three components. The first is chemoprophylaxis – drug treatment to both prevent infection and treat infection. The three most common drugs used are atovaquone-proguanil, doxycycline, and mefloquine, which target the parasite at different states of its lifecycle. They are given based upon how high the risk of malaria is in specific regions.
The second approach is to reduce mosquito populations, especially in locations where people live. That was the primary approach taken by the CDC in the Southern US which essentially eliminated malaria there. In Africa the main measures are spraying to kill mosquito larvae and release of larvae eating predators. Spraying for adult mosquitoes is human-occupied areas is also used.
The third measure is personal protection. Mosquitoes that spread malaria mostly feed at night, so sleeping under nets is critical. Nets impregnated with insecticide are more effective. Using personal mosquito spray, wearing clothes to cover as much skin as possible, and spraying the location where you sleep are also effective.
Using these three approaches the incidence of malaria and malaria deaths have been significantly reduced, but this reduction has plateaued in recent years and may be ticking up a bit. The role of global warming in increasing the range and seasonal duration of malaria is still unclear, but is a question of concern and ongoing research.
Into this mix now comes two anti-malarial vaccines – RTS, S and R21, both now preapproved by the WHO. RTS (which stands for central Repeat units, T-cell epitopes, and Surface antigen) was first created in 1987, and took over 30 years of research and development by the British pharmaceutical company, GSK. R21 is produced by Oxford.
These are the first anti-parasite vaccines to be successfully developed. Anti-parasite vaccine are difficult because of their complex lifecycle, which offer many opportunities to escape the host’s immune system, and because the immune response is so complex. This is also why it took so long to get efficacious vaccines for malaria.
According to the WHO:
“Both prevent around 75% of malaria episodes when given seasonally in areas of highly seasonal transmission where seasonal malaria chemoprevention is provided.” 
There are a couple of qualifiers in that statement, but it essentially means it is 75% effective when used optimally in areas of highest risk. That number depends on the population you study and the outcome measures used. A US-led study, by contrast, found:
“Results of Phase 3 testing show that among children aged 5–17 months who received 4 doses of RTS,S/AS01, vaccine efficacy against malaria was 36% over 4 years of follow-up.”
But that translates to one third fewer deaths from malaria in the vaccinated population. While overall that efficacy is modest, it is still highly significant, when talking about deaths in young children. It needs to be emphasized that the vaccines should become part of the existing malaria mitigation program – you still need the other three measures. But in combination, the WHO estimates this can prevent 90% of malarial deaths.
There are some logistical impediments to getting at-risk children fully vaccinated – funding, availability of enough doses to go around, and difficulty for some parents to get their children to a clinic where they can receive the vaccine. There are efforts to address all these factors. But there is also an additional factor – vaccine hesitancy. Some parents worry if the vaccine is safe.
Evidence so far from the pilot programs to test the vaccine rollout have found that it has an “acceptable safety profile”, is cost effective, and reduces the malarial burden on the population. In a phase III clinical trial overall adverse events were the same in the RTS group as the placebo group. However, there were more meningitis cases reported in the RTS group for children but not infants. This was a small number and not always temporally connected to vaccine dosing. Even taken at face value, assuming all such cases were caused by the vaccine, the benefits far outweigh this small risk.
RTS and R21 are great additions to the anti-malaria campaign in high risks parts of the world, specifically Sub-Saharan Africa. Like all vaccines, they are not risk-free, but the evidence (from phase III trials and now pilot use programs) show the benefits far outweigh the risks. Uptake has to overcome some vaccine hesitancy, but the early data shows that parent education is highly effective. That’s not always the case, but it is here, so we should take advantage of that.

Vaccine Post Updates: the Good, the Bad, and the Crooked?
Updates on two previous vaccine related posts plus one of the most ridiculous anti-vaccine theories of all time.
Clay Jones on December 15, 2017
Link

I don’t want to point fingers, but a very recent post covered something that I was planning to write about today. Let’s just call the mysterious author S. Gavura. Wait, that’s too obvious. Let’s call him Scott G. Thankfully I’ve got a couple of vaccine related updates to previous posts of mine, plus one of the most amazing anti-vaccine conspiracy theories I’ve ever encountered, as a backup.
New newborn hepatitis B vaccination recommendation
Two years ago I discussed the hepatitis B vaccine and recommendations for administering it in the newborn period. This safe and extremely effective vaccine has reduced the incidence of hepatitis B in the United States by nearly 90% since it was introduced in 1982. In large part because of universal vaccination recommendations in newborns, the number of new cases in the United States is now a fraction of those seen worldwide. But thanks to misinformation from people like Mercola and Bob Sears, many parents are still hesitant and some refuse the vaccine.
Since 1991, the vaccine has been universally recommended for newborns but there was wiggle room that implied it was also okay to wait a month or two. This was fixed in 2002 when the wording specified that all infants should receive their first dose prior to leaving the nursery. But the vaccine works best as a prevention of perinatally acquired infection when given in the first 24 hours.
There are still about 1,000 newborns per year that become infected with hepatitis B, the majority of which go on to develop chronic disease. And of those that develop chronic disease, 25% will die because of it from cirrhosis, liver failure, and even liver cancer. The hepatitis B vaccine prevented cancer long before the HPV vaccine.
In 2016, the ACIP recommended that most newborns receive the vaccine in the first 24 hours of life, with infants born to mothers with unknown status being immunized in the first 12 hours. In August of this year, the AAP officially endorsed this approach. The new policy statement was published in the September Pediatrics.
Mumps cases continue to rise, new recommendations may help
I wrote about large outbreaks of mumps back in 2014, and again earlier this year on The Scientific Parent website. Since then, there have been many additional outbreaks, such as the one at Syracuse University, and thousands of cases. To put it in perspective, prior to the past several years when outbreaks began occurring at alarming rates, the average yearly incidence was around 400 cases.
As I explain in detail in my previous posts, most of these outbreaks involve many vaccinated individuals. This is because, unlike the measles and rubella vaccine that accompany it in the MMR shot, the mumps vaccine is only 80-90% effective when given as historically recommended. That’s good, but when thousands of vaccinated people are being exposed it should be easy to see why some get sick.
Infection with mumps can be mild or even asymptomatic. But when it isn’t, the illness almost always causes swelling of the parotid gland(s) that can be very painful. It is also associated with meningitis, encephalitis, inflammation of the testicles that can result in sterility, and hearing loss. It isn’t as dangerous as measles by a long shot, but it still stinks.
Most children are immunized against mumps at twice, at age 12-15 months and 4-6 years of age. In both of my previous posts, I mentioned how there was growing evidence in support of offering an additional dose to individuals at risk during outbreaks. In October, ACIP unanimously approved a recommendation to do just that. They stopped short, however, at universally recommending a third dose for all people entering college, which is where most of the recent outbreaks have occurred.
The mumps vaccine, whether given in the classic MMR or the more recently available MMRV (added chicken pox vaccine), is safe. Unfortunately immunity appears to wane over time and most outbreaks involve older kids and adults. It may not be officially recommended yet, but I plan to having my own children vaccinated a third time as they enter college rather than wait until an outbreak.
Are you crooked?
I recently found out about the incredible theory of Forrest Maready involving vaccines, aluminum, and crooked faces. Maready noticed that younger generations are more likely to have crooked smiles and eyes. On his website he provides numerous cherry picked photographs to illustrate his point.
We didn’t always have crooked faces. If you look back at old photographs from the Victorian and Civil War era, you will be hard pressed to find images of people with crooked faces. They all seem to be symmetrical. Even when you find older pictures of people smiling, which seem to be rare, you will never see anyone with a crooked smile (besides Edgar Allan Poe). They will always have even smiles, with both sides pulling up the same amount. Now, crooked faces are everywhere you look. There are many celebrities with famously crooked faces, and for some reason, most of them all seem to have facial palsy on the left side of their face. Why is this?
I love how he gives Poe a pass. It perhaps goes without saying that Maready’s observation is nonsense. It is confirmation bias piled upon layer after layer of confirmation bias. He even goes on to claim that babies have crooked faces at alarming rates compared to earlier generations as well.
I see babies and young children of all ages as a pediatrician and this is something that we actually specifically look for. And excessively worried parents point out things they have noticed about their own children to me all the time. I have not noticed an increase in parental concern regarding crooked faces or in the diagnosis of facial palsy or strabismus. Crooked smiles and unusual eye deviations are not at all common concerns.
Maready postulates that the aluminum in vaccines is ultimately the cause of these crooked faces, as well as all manner of autoimmune disorders, autism, and even death. I’ll walk you through his reasoning, but he goes into lengthy and painful detail in this video. At one point he talks about “the Gardasil girls” and I almost couldn’t keep going.
According to his theory, first aluminum is engulfed by immune cells which then lie dormant in various tissues of the body. Then a triggering event occurs. This can be extreme exercise, pregnancy, lack of sleep, or infection. In response, aluminum-laden white blood cells emerge and carry the toxic aluminum to the brain and peripheral nerves where it causes damage. So vaccines lead to crooked faces in children that are a red flag for future neurodevelopmental problems.
There is, of course, no credible link between vaccination and the development of facial palsies or abnormal eye deviation. There is no link between facial palsy or eye deviation and autism or any autoimmune condition. The aluminum in vaccines is safe and plays an important role in improving efficacy of the shots. There is more aluminum in a child’s diet than in the entirety of the vaccine series. Maready’s theory is just rambling nonsense, fascinating as it may be.

   On the Orwellian language and bad science of the anti-vaccine movement: “SmartVax” versus “MaxVax”?
David Gorski
Link
If there’s one thing that’s true of the human race, it’s that when it comes to persuasion language is has power. Words have power. Just ask the advertising industry or politicians, who rely on their skills manipulating language to persuade for their very livelihood and authority. In the specific bailiwick of this blog, Science-Based Medicine, many of us have spent considerable verbiage describing how advocates of unscientific modalities rebranded as “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) and/or “integrative medicine” (IM) are incredibly skilled at the manipulation of language and renaming of terms in order to make them sound more persuasive, particularly to make it sound as though their modalities are scientifically supported or that it’s just another “alternative” to SBM. In fact, Kimball Atwood has made a special study of the language of CAM, even going so far to do an amusing feature that he used to call the Weekly Waluation of the Weasel Words of Woo. Indeed, the very name “integrative medicine” is a masterful term that makes it sound as though they’re just “integrating” the best of scientific medicine and “traditional” or “alternative” medicine when in fact what is happening all too often is the “integration” of quackery with medicine or, as I sometimes like to call it, “integrating” fake medicine with real medicine. Unfortunately, my definition of “integrative medicine” doesn’t appear to be winning, although I was gratified that I got several Tweets during our panel at TAM9 quoting my line about integrating quackery with medicine.
The anti-vaccine movement has been pretty good, albeit not as masterful as, say, Andrew Weil, when it comes to manipulating language to its own end. Who can forget three years ago, when the meme started spreading throughout the anti-vaccine movement that it’s “not anti-vaccine but rather ‘pro-safe vaccine’” and started demanding that the government and pharmaceutical companies “green our vaccines.” The reason is obvious; even anti-vaccine activists know that it’s a public relations loser to be explicitly anti-vaccine, which is Jenny McCarthy and the anti-vaccine groups that participated in her “Green Our Vaccines” rally did their best to downplay and hide their radical anti-vaccine base. They failed. (The signs about vaccines as “weapons of mass destruction” rather undercut the “pro-safe vaccine” message. I’ve dealt with this fallacy before in depth, explaining why it is appropriate to call them “anti-vaccine,” even as they strenuously deny that they are. More recently, the preferred narrative has been “too many, too soon,” which leads me to another term coined by the group SafeMinds and promoted on—where else?—Age of Autism.
Now, the SafeMinds/AoA approach is being dubbed “SmartVax.”
The Orwellian language of the anti-vaccine movement
I have to hand it to the anti-vaccine movement in general and SafeMinds in particular. I really do. Whatever the deficiencies in their knowledge of science, anti-vaccine advocates sure can spin the Orwellian language, where up is down, left is right, and vaccines are alway, always, always the cause of autism, or at least more harmful than good. The first stroke of propaganda genius about this site is the term “SmartVax” itself. Yes, it’s painfully obvious. After all, who wants to be in favor of the implied opposite of “SmartVax,” such as “DumbVax” or “StupidVax”? Of course, I fervently hope that some day a vaccine against dumb and stupid will one day be invented, but most likely I hope in vain. If there is one thing that isn’t vaccine-preventable, it’s stupidity. Yet that’s not the propaganda genius, at least not in and of itself. What elevates the dreck on the SmartVax website into the realm of brilliant P.R. is how the anti-vaccine activists contrast “SmartVax” with what they call “MaxVax.” Let’s take a look, shall we? It begins with a bit of revisionist history in a section entitled Overview of the SmartVax Philosophy:
In the early 1900′s, scientists coined the terms “allergy” and “anaphylaxis” to describe vaccine-injuries; at present, the mechanism by which vaccines cause injury is still not scientifically understood. Historically, the vaccine-injury risk has caused vaccine manufacturers and public health officials to be conservative when recommending new vaccines or administration of vaccines at earlier ages. However, vaccines proved effective against some deadly diseases and by the 1970′s a “maximize vaccination” philosophy arose that viewed vaccines as always having more benefits than risks.
Not exactly. The assertion that scientists coined the terms “allergy” and “anaphylaxis” to describe vaccine injuries is a distortion, with one minor grain of truth. Let’s start with the term anaphylaxis, the coining of which had nothing to do with childhood vaccines. Rather, it derived from the studies of Charles Richet and Paul Portier over 100 years ago of the toxin produced by a jellyfish, the Portuguese Man of War. During an oceanographic expedition, Richet and Portier managed to isolate the toxin and thought that they might be able to use the toxin in order to obtain protection, or, as they called it, “prophylaxis” in order to protect swimmers who came into contact with the jellyfish. When they returned to France, they didn’t have access to the jellyfish anymore; so they turned their attention to the toxin produced by the sea anemone Anemona sulcata, the “sea nettle”, which could be harvested in large quantities from the Mediterranean Sea. They injected venom from the sea nettle at various doses into dogs. The dogs that survived were allowed to recover and then reinjected. To their surprise, subsequent small doses of the toxin produced a dramatic illness that resulted in difficulty in breathing followed by rapid decline and death. Richet and Portier called this reaction “anaphylaxis,” meaning “against protection.” They concluded correctly that the immune system becomes sensitized to the toxin and that re-exposure to the same substance could result in a severe reaction, a discovery for which Richet won the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 1913. Vaccine injury is not exactly the same thing as what the SmartVax website is referring to.
SafeMinds is also distorting the history of the term “allergy,” which actually was not coined to describe vaccine “injuries.” Rather, the term “allergy” was first coined in 1906 by Clemens von Pirquet. A year earlier, von Pirquet studied the describe adverse reactions of children who were given repeated shots of horse serum to fight infection. Here’s a hint: Injecting horse serum to fight infection is not the same thing as being vaccinated. Indeed, Emil Adolf Behring won the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 1901 for the development of the diptheria antitoxin, having observed that injecting extracts of diptheria cultures containing diptheria toxin into an experimental animal induced the animal to produce something in its serum that could protect another animal against infection with diptheria. Ultimately, this led to a treatment for humans in which horse serum antitoxin was used in order to treat and prevent the disease, but unfortunately proteins in the horse serum could at times result in allergic reactions upon repeated doses. The following year, the term allergy was proposed to explain this unexpected “changed reactivity” in response to exposure to the horse serum. Later, in 1907 Pirquet characterized the same effect due to repeated doses of the smallpox vaccine–after he had coined the term for his previous observations.
After that little paragraph of revisionist history follows more revisionist history that consists largely of confusing correlation with causation (the “autism epidemic” that isn’t), claiming that the anti-vaccine groups that arose during the 1980s advocated a “smarter” vaccine schedule, and pointing out the 1986 law that created the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program without mentioning that anti-vaccine grande dame Barbara Loe Fisher was a driving force behind the passage of that law. Anti-vaccine groups only turned on the law when they didn’t like how the Vaccine Court had the temerity to try to use actual science to determine what does and doesn’t constitute a true vaccine injury. It didn’t matter that the Vaccine Court bent over backwards to give parents the benefit of the doubt, that it came up with a list of “table injuries” that are presumed to be due to vaccines even when the evidence is somewhat questionable, and that it paid most legal fees fo its petitioners, whether they won or lost. When the Vaccine Court didn’t accept the pseudoscientific view that vaccine injuries cause autism, the anti-vaccine movement turned on it and now generally rant that the requirement that vaccine injury claims go through this special court has allowed vaccine manufacturers to avoid any accountability. Never mind that the FDA and FTC regulate them and that the regulations covering pharmaceutical products (like vaccines) require considerably testing and oversight.
The revisionist history here didn’t exactly make me confident in anything else on this website, but let’s move on. Here is where we get to the meat of the matter; this is what SafeMinds describes as the difference between what it calls the “SmartVax” and the “MaxVax” philosophies:
SmartVax and Max-Vax are both “pro-vaccine” philosophies, in that both philosophies consider vaccines an important component in an overall children’s health program, but SmartVax differs from Max-Vax in important aspects of safety, research, and policy. The SmartVax philosophy is all about being smart with vaccinations: don’t over-use them, don’t bypass good science, understand the risks, and ensure that the risks are not hidden from the public.
Uh, no. Not even close.
Does SafeMinds really think we’re stupid enough to believe that its philosophy is in any way “pro-vaccine”? Think about it this way? Have you ever seen SafeMinds advocate the routine use of any vaccine or defend any vaccine? I certainly haven’t, and I’ve scoured its website looking for such a statement. What I see instead are unending claims that vaccines are unsafe or haven’t been adequately tested based on misinterpretation and cherry picking of studies, fear mongering, and rejection of studies failing to find a link between vaccines and autism almost before they are published. Just type the word “SafeMinds” into the search box in the upper left hand corner of this page, and you’ll see copious evidence of the anti-vaccine activism of SafeMinds, including, most recently, its purchasing public service announcement time in AMC Theaters for its anti-vaccine message, which, not surprisingly, has led to complaints of “censorship” and conspiracy theories about big pharma, pediatricians, and the government trying to shut SafeMinds down. That’s hardly about “not bypassing good science,” which is exactly what SafeMinds does every time it trashes studies that fail to find a link between vaccines and autism.
Basically, SafeMinds contrasts its “SmartVax” (i.e., its anti-vaccine policy in disguise) with “MaxVax” (what it labels the current vaccine schedule) by two “pillars”:
     1.  Evidence-Based Scientific Research (go where the evidence leads)
     2.  Appropriate Checks-and-Balances on Vaccine Policy
Pillar one is based on a delusion coupled with a massive straw man:
The first rule of SmartVax is the pursuit of evidence-based scientific research on vaccine-injuries to an unbiased conclusion, without being afraid of what the evidence might show, to develop the knowledge for a safer and more effective vaccine program in the long-term. This is in stark contrast with the Max-Vax tenet that such research should be avoided because the results might undermine public confidence in the current vaccine program.
The delusion is, of course, that SafeMinds or any other anti-vaccine group does or advocates anything resembling unbiased, evidence-based research. Quite the opposite, as we’ve documented time and time again over the last three years right here on this very blog, for example here. The straw man is that scientists claim that research should be avoided because the results might undermine public confidence. A more accurate and honest representation of the Orwellian-named “MaxVax” position would be that a link between vaccines and autism is highly implausible and that, although it is impossible ever to prove a negative completely (i.e., that there is absolutely no link between vaccines and autism), enough studies have been done to estimate the chances of such a link existing to be very, very, very low. After all, even Generation Rescue’s attempts at finding a link between vaccines and autism have failed utterly. In actuality, it is SafeMinds and its ilk that require more and more such research for the very purpose of undermining public confidence in the current vaccine program; that’s the raison d’être of anti-vaccine groups. And, of course, the “MaxVax” moniker itself is a not-so-subtle attempt to paint the public health establishment with the brush of unreasoning extremism and dogma.
Here’s pillar two:
The SmartVax view holds that appropriate checks-and-balances on vaccine policy will produce the most beneficial vaccine program long-term for children’s health. Government-owned research data on vaccine-injuries should be made open to the public and easily accessible to all researchers. Long-term double-blind placebo studies tracking both acute and chronic health conditions (e.g. asthma, allergies, ADHD, and autism) should be required prior to any vaccine approval. Philosophical exemption, by which a parent can opt to delay or exempt certain vaccines for the child without discrimination such as loss of federal benefits or access to public schools, should be a fundamental right in the USA (as it is in Canada and other countries).
Clearly, the message hasn’t gotten through to SafeMinds, although perhaps I shouldn’t be surprised about that, given how research ethics appears not to concern anti-vaccine groups very much when it comes to their own, which is in marked contrast to their attacks on pharma and “conventional” science. Performing randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled studies of currently used vaccines is completely unethical because it leaves the control group unprotected against vaccine-preventable disease. In fact, the only time such a trial could be ethical is if there is no currently existing vaccine for the disease; i.e., the vaccine is a new vaccine for a condition for which there currently isn’t a vaccine. If the vaccine is for a condition for which a vaccine currently exists, then the appropriate design of a clinical trial is to test the new vaccine against the old vaccine; doing otherwise would leave the control group unprotected against a vaccine-preventable disease. In addition, even doing epidemiological studies looking at health outcomes in vaccinated versus unvaccinated children is highly problematic, both on practical, scientific, and ethical grounds. On the other hand, in a perverse way, I’m glad that SafeMinds has put itself on the record as supporting an unethical clinical trial design motivated by its anti-vaccine views. It makes it so easy for me to go after its position.
The rest of its position is the same sort of superficially plausible-sounding nonsense that we’re accustomed to hearing from SafeMinds and its ilk. The real reason it wants access to data on vaccine injuries is so that it can “reanalyze” it and come to different conclusions, the way Mark and David Geier tried to do several years ago, and, of course, its call for “philosophical exemption” is nothing more than warmed-over “health freedom” rhetoric. Overall, then, there appears to be nothing new in the “philosophy” behind SmartVax. It’s nothing more than what we’ve been hearing from the anti-vaccine movement for a long time. It is, however, wrapped up in an appealing-sounding package. Unfortunately, the material is rotten to the core, just as pillar two of the SmartVax philosophy is unethical to its very core.
Where’s the beef?
Now that I’ve dealt with the revisionist history and Orwellian language of the “philosophy” section of the SmartVax website, let’s look at the “beef,” so to speak. What, exactly, is it that SafeMinds says about its “SmartVax” philosophy and what science does it use? The answer to the first question is, in essence, to claim that SafeMinds advocates “rigorous science” to justify its warmed over “too many too soon” complain coupled with an even more warmed over Bob Sears-style “alternative vaccine schedule” that would leave children unprotected against diseases like measles and pertussis for far too long. Perhaps the best example of the scientifically bankrupt and deceptive “SmartVax” reasoning can be found in a section entitled Weigh the Risks of Vaccination. One thing that is very apparent upon trying to wade through this site is that it superficially looks very “science-y.” However, the more I waded in, the more frustrated I became. In many cases, I couldn’t figure out how SafeMinds calculated its numbers and, worse, in many cases references weren’t easily locatable because they weren’t cited properly. For example, SafeMinds takes huge leaps based on a study of asthma rates in children in Manitoba based on vaccination timing but doesn’t actually cite the study on the page where it makes the claim or on the page where it explains the claim. This is a perfect lead-in to an example of the intellectual bankruptcy that is the SmartVax website.
Let’s take a look at the sorts of methodologies that SafeMinds recommends for estimating the “risks” of vaccination. Before I do this, however, let me just reiterate that it is a strawman argument that is being attacked when it is claimed that the “MaxVax” philosophy denies the possibility of vaccine injury. Scientists most definitely do not; in fact, it is scientists and physicians who study vaccine injury and estimate the frequency with which it happens, as well as potential predisposing factors. Think of it this way. Who did the studies that SafeMinds cherry picks? Not The difference is that scientists and science-based physicians base their estimates on science and epidemiology, not anecdotes, and most especially not on cherry-picked studies. Perhaps the most egregious example occurs when SafeMinds attributes a risk of 1 in 13 of “vaccine-induced asthma.”is administered according to schedule compared to a delay of three months, which leads it to produce this meaningless table. I also note that the Manitoba study was not a study of whether vaccination itself was associated with the later development of asthma but rather a study of whether the timing of vaccination with DPT was associated with asthma. There is a difference; yet SafeMinds uses the data from that study to make an estimate that 7.9% of the population is at a risk of “vaccine-induced” asthma from the DTP and Hib vaccines, even though the actual experimental group still got the vaccines, just three months later. One also notes that whole cell pertussis, as in the DTP vaccine, is no longer used in most countries. In any case, the authors themselves stated in the discussion:
On the other hand, McKeever et al did not find an association between asthma onset and the age at first injection of diptheria, polio, pertussis, and tetanus vaccine in their database of study of 29,000 children. To our knowledge we are the first to report that delay in adminstration of the first dose of DPT immunization is significantly associated with reduced risk of developing asthma in childhood.
One wonders why SafeMinds didn’t acknowledge this. It also fails to acknowledge that in the CDC study it also cites as evidence that the Hib and hepatitis B vaccines were associated with a weakly increased risk of asthma the relative risks were very low and the authors themselves did an analysis to determine whether a confounding factor might account for the elevated relative risk and concluded:
To evaluate the magnitude of possible medical care utilization bias, we performed a subanalysis restricted to children whom we knew were using two of the VSD HMOs (GHC and NCK) for their health care because they had made at least two medical care visits during their first year of life. In this subanalysis the relative risks for almost all of the vaccines of interest decreased, including those for Hib and hepatitis B. In another subanalysis in which we tried to reduce possi- ble health care utilization bias by restricting the analysis to children who had received at least two OPV, two DTP and one MMR, the relative risk of asthma associated with hepatitis B vaccine was less than that found in the main analysis. We conclude from these findings that the results of our main analysis are probably biased upward and tend to overestimate the relative risks associated with vaccination.
In conclusion medical care utilization bias did seem to influence the results for Hib and hepatitis B vac- cines, for which we found weak associations with asthma. Despite a similar bias that would favor finding an increased risk, we found that DTP, OPV and MMR vaccines did not increase a child’s risk of developing asthma.
In other words, the CDC Vaccine Safety Datalink team found no increased risk of asthma associated with vaccines for most vaccines, and for the two where they did the risk appeared to be very small and likely attributable to confounding factors. Yet SafeMinds mentions none of this, nor does it mention a recent meta-analysis that asks the question, “Is Childhood Vaccination Associated With Asthma?” The answer, in case you’re wondering, is a resounding no. Several other studies also support this conclusion, for example with respect to vaccination against pertussis and a recent German study that demonstrate no differences in allergic diseases between vaccinated and unvaccinated children. I will be honest here; the question of whether any vaccines are associated with an increased risk of asthma is not an entirely settled question yet, but one thing we can say. The vast majority of studies do not support such a link, and the Manitoba study is an outlier that needs to be confirmed, particularly given that it disagrees with a previous study. Moreover, the Manitoba study looked at a vaccine that is no longer used because its problems were recognized—by scientists!—and a safer version of the vaccine developed. Yet SafeMinds deceptively handwaves and in essence extrapolates a risk from a single outlier study to a more general risk and exaggerates a possible risk found in an old CDC study.
Such deceptive or incompetent (take your pick) biased cherry picking does not give me confidence in the rest of the “scientific” analyses of vaccine risks presented on the SmartVax website. Perhaps if I have time for a future post doing so, I’ll delve into the even more science-y tables presented as overall risks of vaccination versus the diseases protected against, but this post is already reaching a long length, and I’m getting tired. Also, I don’t want to finish without mentioning one last aspect of the SmartVax website.
Promoting anti-vaccine advocacy
Perhaps the most telling part of the SmartVax website is the About Us section. It’s all very confused, starting out focusing on mercury in vaccines as a cause of autism, even though it’s clear from numerous epidemiological studies that it almost certainly is not. It also parrots a number of anti-vaccine tropes:
Vaccines contain a number of components that have been linked to vaccine-injury, including aluminum adjuvants, mercury, antigens, and endotoxins. Research indicates that combining multiple vaccines into a combination vaccine can increase adverse reactions from vaccines, and also that adminstration of vaccines at an earlier age can increase risk of vaccine-injury. Research has not been performed on most vaccines in vaccinated vs unvaccinated children to determine whether there are links to the autism, ADHD, and allergy epidemics; research on asthma indicates that there is a link to vaccines. The entire USA vaccination schedule, which has approximately tripled since the 1986 law which protects manufacturers from vaccine lawsuits, needs to be studied and analyzed with an unbiased approach to find scientific answers. Similarly, there is a dearth of research on “Environmental X Factors” that contribute to these epidemics.
Yes, indeed. It’s the “toxin gambit,” coupled with “too many too soon” and the myth of an “autism epidemic” all rolled into one. SafeMinds then goes on to say:
Beyond the personal impact to individuals and families, the epidemic of vaccine-injuries has enormous implications to the public. A future America will be competitively disadvantaged due to medical costs, lost wages, reallocation of personnel into care-giving roles, and a smaller pool of qualified military recruits. Such a bleak future can be avoided, but it will require the American public to take action. Synergistic research from diverse scientific fields such as toxicology, endocrinology, and immunology could lead to a fundamentally new scientific understanding of how vaccines work and how vaccine injuries occur. This could provide the knowledge of how to design a new vaccination program that is both safer and more effective. But recent history indicates that Max-Vax proponents in the government and public health industry will suppress such science, unless there is a “SmartVax” consumer advocacy movement to protect these researchers from discrimination and encourage elected officials to insist that the CDC and FDA take action to recognize and reduce vaccine-injuries.
At its essence, the SmartVax philosophy is all about being smart with vaccinations: don’t over-use them, pursue the science, understand the risks, and ensure that the risks are not hidden from the public. A SmartVax approach will lead to improved children’s health by minimizing vaccine-injuries and protecting against infectious diseases. With SmartVax, the future vaccine program will be both safer and more-effective.
Except that, as I have just shown, SmartVax isn’t so smart about pursuing the science. The purported link between vaccines and asthma is but one example. In every case I’ve taken a look at, SafeMinds has cherry picked data, choosing only the research that suggests the highest risk and discounting all the other research that finds no risks. In the rest, SafeMinds distorts history, uses logical fallacies, and in general does its best to hide its anti-vaccine agenda. Amusingly, that is not enough. Looking through the comments of the announcement of the SmartVax site on AoA, I find it apparent that anti-vaccine advocates are not happy, nor are they necessarily fooled. Here are some examples:
Ray Gallup:
I’m anti-vaccine as well because I have seen first hand the effects of vaccines especially the MMR and in your case the DPT. Vijendra Singh noted that in his studies but of course the pro-vaccine lobby ignored his studies and focused their attacks on Andy Wakefield. The moderates in the community are basically kissing up to the pro-vaccine lobby. The moderates are timid and don’t support families and kids, unfortunately by their timid behavior.
None of us can change this behavior because these people are afraid of their own shadows. So families and kids will continue to suffer because of this cowardly behavior….on the part of parents/organizations.
Shameful. We can expect it from vaccine companies….but can we expect it from parents and autism/vaccine organizations????
Apparently so!!!
Next, here’s someone by the pseudonym veritas:
I agree with Elizabeth. Only no vax guarantees the total safety. All pediatric infectious diseases are trivial at our time, as can be treated or managed with antibiotics or proper care. I would not risk my child life with any vaccine now. They become more and more toxic and we have no idea what is in them. Experience of EU, where only a small fraction of parents vaccinate, is the best evidence that mass vaccinations are not needed and harmful. More children now die from vaccines than from infectious diseases; although tens of thousands vaccinated or not get sick from infectious diseases, they very rarely die in developed coutnries. The reverse is true with vaccines. You can recover from infectious diseases, but it is very difficult to recover to recover from vaccine-induced injuries, such as diabetes, asthma, chronic encephalopathy, autism, etc.
Actually, let’s look at the experience of the EU, where measles has returned with a vengeance, all thanks to a large pool of unvaccinated children. As for verities’ comment about all pediatric infectious diseases being “trivial” at our time, I would remind this ignorant person that, yes, even in 2011 children die of pertussis in the United States. Children still get hepatitis B and later develop cirrhosis or liver cancer at a young age. In 2011. This doesn’t even take into account the morbidity and suffering that many vaccine-preventable childhood diseases can cause.
Truly, veritas has chosen poorly for his pseudonym, given the misinformation he or she is peddling.
To conclude this post, here’s Kathy Blanco, whom I quote in her entirety:
Here we go again, the spineless approach to this worldwide epidemic, yeah, let’s be politically correct now? Not. Although I appreciate the EFFORT, to appear non aluminum foiled hatted, I know without a shadow of doubt, that it is and can trigger autism in our children. I believe NO vaccine has value or efficacy and so do top experts who have any job left. Perhaps when they read the site they may as in BIG may come to that conclusion. However, I have come to the further conclusion, that as not only a recipient of a damaging vaccine in my children (which sways opinion/vested interest, no lying), but, that the science does not support they are safe in any way, shape or fashion. That means the crowd that ashews no mercury, etc, are in fact, half right and half wrong. And I am afraid the mixed message of compliance, we can work with you attitude, is like saying, a murderer can get off or out of jail after good behavior. These people KNEW it was causing damage, and there is the bigger item for interests, and to be frank…the average parent gets the narly vision of a double breasted suit wearing liar in a vaccine regulatory chair/aka dollar signs, rather than explaining by statistic how this or that would cause or MAY cause something in their child. I think people sense the lying on pharma adds, and see the double standard business as usual stance on vaccines. Since we have started this “workable” parent routine, more vaccines have been added to the schedule. Do you know what they really don’t want to happen? Take a guess, it’s called the pocketbook. It’s called a general boycott, furthering exemptions or keeping them. That’s what they listen to. Not our sad puppy eyes, signs of damaged children at a march. Not even lawyers get them going. They know they are protected from damage claims even by the highest levels of our government, and they will continue their carnage until we finally get it, or they have completed their mission of the “soft kill”. The reality is…we are the consumers, and not consuming their garbage will stop their lying son of a gun asses. Sorry, thats this mommies humble wordly view of it. I tried to many years ago, to illuminate what child would become autistic if given a vaccine, just like this website, however, I had the balls to say it, no vaccine is safe, and don’t experiment on YOUR child. I know this won’t go pass the moderator, but it makes me feel better just typing it. What I was doing however, was suggesting to an unknowledgable average citizen, is that vaccines represent an immune challenge for which our children, in general can not handle, even on it’s premise, is the fact it is never tested in immune damaged children. And how can one “determine” such…it is more than autoimmunity in the mother, a a whole HOST of factors, generally felt by all in our community at large (toxic poisoning of our bodies by industry), that is WIDELY felt. No one goes unscathed. So therefore, no vaccine is safe. None. Deleyed reactions, of course, it’s called oncogenicicity (cancer forming), or to put it more mildly, chronic immune activation, and more mildly, WITCHES BREW.
In the end, SafeMinds is fooling no one. Its protestations otherwise that it is not “anti-vaccine” do not fool those of us who know better. Its torturing of the science, liberal use of revisionist history and bad arguments, and its favoring of Orwellian language, all coupled with never, ever conceding that any vaccine is safe and effective and never, ever accepting the evidence consistent with vaccines having no etiological role in autism pathogenesis, speak much louder than any “SmartVax” website. Even more amusingly, SafeMinds’ attempts to paint itself as a “pro-safe vaccine” organization appear to be backfiring spectacularly among the real anti-vaccine underground. Perhaps SafeMinds would do better to let the mask drop and let its anti-vaccine freak flag fly. However, if it ever did so it would lose any tiny bit of credibility that it can snooker the press into giving it. Consequently, SafeMinds’ attempts at twisting science and language will likely continue, as it walks the tightrope between disillusioning its anti-vaccine base and making it undeniably clear to everyone what a crank organization it is.
In a way, I almost feel sorry for SafeMinds. Well, not really.

Self-Amplifying RNA Vaccines
Self-Amplifying RNA vaccines are coming. Here’s a primer to get you ready.
Steven Novella on September 6, 2023
Link

One of the most amazing aspects of the COVID pandemic was the speed with which the world was able to create and deploy effective vaccines. This was partly due to regulatory streamlining and funding (such as Operation Warp Speed in the US), but mainly because the necessary technology was available. It took only a few days once the virus was isolated to sequence the genome of SARS-CoV-2. Scientists were also able to track the development and spread of genetic variants throughout the world through continuous surveillance. This was only possible because of recent developments in molecular biology.
The world was also introduced to the concept of mRNA vaccines. Vaccines work by introducing either an inactivated infectious agents or a piece (antigen) of that agent (virus or bacteria, for example), usually along with some immune-stimulating adjuvants, to provoke an immune response. The body creates antibodies against the infecting organism and remembers, allowing for a more vigorous and rapid immune response if the recipient is ever exposed to the living infectious agent. It’s like getting infected without suffering the symptoms or risks of an actual infection. Vaccines can also be used to target cancer cells.
Scientists explored for a while making vaccines using DNA, the coding molecule that carries genetic information. The idea was to introduce DNA that codes for a viral or bacterial protein, the host’s cells would then incorporate that DNA into the nucleus and start making the protein. This approach, however, turned out to be too complicated and essentially did not work. So they next turned to RNA vaccines, specifically messenger RNA (or mRNA). RNA molecules can also encode for proteins, but they don’t have to enter the nucleus and do not run the risk of being incorporated into host DNA. They stay outside the nucleus where the proteins are made. Once proteins are transcribed from the mRNA, the molecule is broken down and recycled.
The mRNA approached worked extremely well. The Moderna and Pfizer COVID vaccines, for example, are both mRNA based. There are several advantages to the mRNA platform. Perhaps the most important is that mRNA vaccine can be made relatively quickly compared to other methods. Traditional vaccine require complex cell cultures and safety measure to prevent contamination, while mRNA technology is relatively clean and simple. We already have the technology to program and mass-produce mRNA molecules, so the production of a new vaccine involves mainly knowing the genetic sequence of the protein or proteins you wish to be antigens for the vaccine. This allows for rapid vaccine development and precise targeting.
The introduction of a new technology, however, especially one involving genetics lead to some popular anxiety about the safety of these vaccines. Scientifically the evidence is solid, but it was easy to scare people about a genetic vaccine. It is likely that we are about to see another advance in genetically based vaccines – the development of self-amplifying RNA vaccines (saRNA). This is an extension of the mRNA technology that may also lead to more rapid development of vaccines and more effective vaccines.
The saRNA vaccines include an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRP) complex accompanying the RNA that codes for the viral antigen. These amplifying gene sequences will replicate with RNA many times, so that even a small dose of saRNA can lead to many copies of RNA producing the desired antigen. There are also possible trans-amplifying RNA approaches that have the RdRP genes separate from the antigen-coding RNA.
What are the potential advantages to this approach? Vaccines based on saRNA technology could use a lower dose and require fewer subsequent boosters. This will reduce inconvenience and expense, and improve vaccine compliance. Preliminary research on candidate vaccines show that the saRNA vaccines (also called self-replicating or repRNA) can produce antigens for weeks or even months after a single injection.
This study also demonstrated the use of nanoparticles to deliver the saRNA package. These are then like psuedoviruses – an outer capsule containing the genetic package. The advantage here is that one nanoparticle capsule can contain multiple saRNA packages. Therefore with one injection an saRNA vaccine can produce immunity to multiple antigens. This itself is not new but the platform allows for it more easily.
It is also possible, although research is ongoing, that saRNA vaccines will produce better immunity. One reason is that the sustained release of antigen over time better replicates a natural infection than a single bolus of non-replicating vaccine. This may cause a greater immune response, allowing for later stages of immunity to kick in and produce greater and longer lasting immunity. There are a lot of technical details to work out, but the saRNA platforms currently under development appear to work and do not seem to present any unique safety concerns.
In the next 5-10 years we can likely expect saRNA based vaccines to be going through clinical trials and start getting approval. It’s also likely that the next pandemic that hits will be targeted, at least in part, by these vaccines. It is also likely that there will be another round of fear-mongering about the new technology. It probably best for scientists to get ahead of this, to introduce and explain the technology to the public, so that at least it will be somewhat familiar before the next COVID. Let’s also get all the conspiracy theories and misinformation out of the way, and at least produce the data and the analysis to respond to this misinformation before we are in the middle of a pandemic emergency.
This is probably wishful thinking, but there is no reason not to try.

Sleep and Vaccination Response
A meta-analysis finds a non-significant trend in decreased antibody response with poor sleep. What is the significance?
Steven Novella on March 15, 2023
Link
Optimizing the antibody response to vaccines is essential for their efficacy, both individually and as a public health measure. Great care is taken in the formulation of vaccines to maximize this response. That is the essence of vaccine research – which proteins to target, with how much of a stimulus, and with which adjuvants (vaccine additives that increase immune response). Research also focuses on the number and timing of vaccines, and what antibody titers are necessary in order to maintain adequate protection from infection, reduce severity of infection, and/or reduce the probability of spreading the disease.
There hasn’t been as much focus, generally, on the person receiving the vaccine, other than demographic factors. We cannot alter a person’s demographics (sex, age, race), but are their factors we can change that influence the response to vaccine? A recent study looks at a potentially modifiable factor and Covid vaccine response – sleep.
The study, published in Current Biology, is a meta-analysis of studies looking at the correlation of sleep around the time of vaccination and antibody response. Data on sleep is mostly self-report, with subjects divided into <6 hours of sleep vs sufficient sleep from two days prior to two days after receiving a vaccine for Covid. The idea is sound, as sleep deprivation can have negative physiological effect, including impaired immune function. Insomnia can both impair immune response, making individuals more susceptible to infection, and impair immune regulation, leading to chronic inflammation.
However, overall the data from this study was negative:
“The association between self-reported short sleep (<6 h/night) and reduced vaccine response did not reach our pre-defined statistical significant criteria.”
There was a trend toward decreased immune response, but it did not reach statistical significance. So, like many researchers, they did a subgroup analysis and found that the effect did reach statistical significance in men but not women. In their summary they conclude:
Large-scale well-controlled studies are urgently needed to define (1) the window of time around inoculation when optimizing sleep duration is most beneficial, (2) the causes of the sex disparity in the impact of sleep on the response, and (3) the amount of sleep needed to protect the response.
I would add that such studies are needed to confirm that this effect is even real. Again, a causal association here is plausible but that does not mean it is real or clinically significant. When results like this are statistically marginal, especially if you have to breakout subgroups to reach significance at all, that decreases the chance that the effect is real or that there is a significant effect size. This is where replication is essential. If these results are a statistical fluke then looking at a fresh group of data is likely to regress to the mean or show different results. If it is real, then it should reliably replicate.
This study is a meta-analysis not new epidemiological research so they may not have been setup to do this, but ideally it is best for such studies to do internal replications. In other words, once you find a subset of the data that does reach statistical significance, then check the findings against fresh data as part of the same study, before publishing. This is a good way to minimize the flood of false positives that find their way into the published research. In my opinion, this should be standard practice and high-end journals should make it a near requirement for publication.
This study was also presented as positive, and that is how the media is reporting it, without the proper caveats. In fact, I think this study should be presented as negative – the data did not reach pre-determined statistical significance, and the subgroup analysis gets buried in the results and discussion as indicating a possible direction for future research – but not as the main result.
In this particular case the negative effect from reporting a potential false positive is likely minimal. It’s already a good idea to get a good night’s sleep, and making a special effort to do so around the time of vaccination is a reasonable thing to do even based solely on biological plausibility. There is no real downside to getting good sleep. There could be a downside, however, if the results are overhyped and, for example, some people or their doctors delay vaccination until they improve their sleep.
Future research should focus on several questions. Is the correlation between sleep and vaccine response real, and is there a sex difference? If so, then what parameters optimize the response? Also, if the correlation is real, what is the cause? Is it the lack of sleep itself, or are other factors both impairing sleep and immune response? Is the impairment of immune response clinically significant – does it actually increase the risk of contracting Covid? And, what is the net effect of any clinical intervention, such as treating the insomnia, especially if this treatment delays vaccination. Clinical questions can get complicated once you go beyond a simple correlation.
In the meantime, good sleep hygiene, or even medically treating insomnia, is a good idea if you are fighting off an infection, have been exposed or will be in a high risk environment, or are getting vaccinated. Ideally, chronically poor sleep needs to be treated like the serious medical problem that it is.

Science Based Satire: Falling Vaccine Coverage Over The Years Is A Problem That Likely Increased Due To The Failed Covid-19 Policies That Jonathan Howard Championed.
If RFK Jr. is to blame for measles outbreaks and deaths, then I would be responsible for saying he would be a net positive for public health in the US.  Thank goodness that’s not the case.
Jonathan Howard on April 11, 2025
Link
A measles outbreak now, 2 months after his nomination, can hardly be his fault, though, could it? Falling vaccine coverage over the years is a problem that likely increased due to the failed COVID-19 policies that you championed.
Dr. Frederik Schaltz-Buchholzer, March 2025
In January, I wrote an article for Sensible Medicine titled The Nomination of Robert F. Kennedy Jr. as Secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services: a New Beginning? I said:
RFK Jr. will be a net positive for public health in the US. The mainstream media – who were the most important enablers of the destructive COVID-19 policies – are falling over themselves and screaming wolf, oblivious to the fact that current US public health is a complete failure.
Just a few months into RFK Jr.’s tenure, I have been proven right. This week brought sad news that a second unvaccinated child died of measles in Texas.  Predictably, many so-called “vaccine advocates” are rushing to blame RFK Jr. for this tragedy. That’s inane. A measles outbreak now, 2 months after his nomination, can hardly be his fault, though, could it?
RFK Jr. started his tenure in February 2025, which erased his 20-year history of anti-vaccine disinformation. The fact that he was promoting the movie Vaxxed III – Authorized to Kill just last fall was rendered irrelevant. The moment he put his hand on the Bible to be sworn into office, he was born again. He emerged fresh, new, clean, and blameless. Nothing RFK Jr. said or will ever say can ever be blamed for low-vaccination rates.
Indeed, not only were his past sins washed away, his future ones were also forgiven. For example, in March 2025 he said:
There are adverse events from the vaccine. It does cause deaths every year. It causes — it causes all the illnesses that measles itself causes, encephalitis and blindness, et cetera. And so people ought to be able to make that choice for themselves.
However, this sort of rhetoric, coming from the HHS secretary is of no consequence either. Here are some other recent headlines, for which RFK Jr. deserves no condemnation or blame.
    • RFK Jr.: It Would Be Better If ‘Everybody Got Measles
    • Texas Children Poisoned After RFK Jr Touts Vitamin A As Measles Treatment
    • Dozens Of Free Measles Vaccine Clinics Close In Texas As Federal Funding Is Cut
    • NIH To Terminate Or Limit Grants Related To Vaccine Hesitancy And Uptake
    • CDC Will Research Widely Debunked Link Between Vaccines And Autism
    • The CDC Buried a Measles Forecast That Stressed the Need for Vaccinations
    • RFK Jr. Suggests Some Vaccines Are Risky Or Ineffective, Downplays Measles Threat
I hope you’ll watch this video too. As RFK Jr. points out, the measles vaccines “wanes very quickly”, it’s only sick kids dying anyways, and measles isn’t really what is killing them after all. He has even uttered a couple of pro-vaccine sentiments, though everyone knows he doesn’t really believe it. This is all net positive for public health in the US, exactly as I said it would be. You should be grateful I helped unleash RFK Jr. on the USA.
Non-satire comment: RFK Jr. is lying.
I rarely made predictions during the pandemic, but I’ll make one now. When measles and polio return these doctors will blame everyone but themselves and @RobertKennedyJr. Just watch. Bookmark this.
Dr. Jonathan Howard, December 2024
So who is at fault for the measles outbreaks this year? Why are parents refusing to vaccinate their children? Why are vaccine clinics closing in Texas? Why are parents poisoning their children with quack measles cures? Why did the NIH end grants to limit vaccine hesitancy? Why did the CDC bury a measles forecast that stressed the need for vaccinations?
There is simple answer to these questions. Falling vaccine coverage over the years is a problem that likely increased due to the failed COVID policies that Dr. Jonathan Howard championed.
I’ll give Dr. Howard credit for one thing. He was smart enough to try to get ahead of the problem. He could see where this was all headed, and in December 2024 he unbelievably tried to blame RFK Jr. and doctors like me who supported him. He said:
I rarely made predictions during the pandemic, but I’ll make one now. When measles and polio return these doctors will blame everyone but themselves and @RobertKennedyJr. Just watch. Bookmark this.
How pathetic.
Dr. Howard obviously doesn’t want to take responsibly for the failed COVID policies he championed here at Science Based Medicine. In his article Is an Abnormal Lab Value After Vaccination More Concerning Than Death From COVID?, he argued that death was worse than an elevated troponin in a child who felt fine. That’s an absurd policy to have championed! In his article “We’ll Have Herd Immunity by April”: Reflections on a Failed Prediction he argued that we didn’t have herd immunity to COVID in April 2021. What a ridiculous policy that was! In his article Incorrect Numbers, he argued that doctors should present accurate data to their readers. That’s a horrible policy. In his article The CDC Should Do Better, he said the CDC should do a better job of reporting COVID data. What an embarrassing policy to have championed.
In every article he championed one failed COVID policy or another, and this was very influential in the Mennonite community in Texas, where he has a huge following. It’s no wonder that after reading his article Children, Underlying Conditions, and COVID-19 parents declined the MMR for their child. It’s the only logical conclusion, and that article was widely read in West Texas at the time.
If you have any doubt about the power of Dr. Howard’s articles to lower vaccine rates, consider that the most recent child to die was 8-year-old Daisy Hildebrand, who should have received her first MMR dose before the pandemic. Indeed, Dr. Howard’s failed COVID policies can travel back in time. That’s how powerful he is.
You see, if sweet, innocent RFK Jr. is to blame for measles outbreaks and deaths, then I would be to blame for fluffing him. Luckily, that’s not the case. Unlike Dr. Howard, I can sleep at night. I vouched for RFK Jr.
.

Science-Based Satire: My Patients are Refusing the MMR Because the CDC Added the COVID Vaccine to the Routine Vaccine Schedule
If only they had let more unvaccinated children suffer and die from COVID, we wouldn’t be in this position today.
Jonathan Howard on January 12, 2025
Link
“When it comes to measles, there will be outbreaks— with or without Kennedy. That is inevitable. The uptake of MMR will diminish bc trust was poisoned by COVID. The CDC made a huge error adding COVID to the routine childhood immunization schedule, and public health failures have bred vaccine hesitancy. For this reason I suspect measles is inevitable.” – Dr. Vinay Prasad
I have been a pediatrician for 40 years, and throughout my career parents would vaccinate their children without hesitation. Now, for the first time many of them are refusing vaccines, and they all give the same reason- the CDC added the COVID vaccine to the routine vaccination schedule. This huge error has bred vaccine hesitancy, and the return of measles is inevitable. Just yesterday, I spoke to six parents from starkly different economic, education, and cultural backgrounds, who all said essentially the same thing:
My friends and I were obviously going to vaccinate our children against measles, polio, and pertussis. It never occurred to us to question vaccines until February 2023. Then, a bomb dropped. The CDC added the COVID vaccine to the routine vaccination schedule. None of us will ever forget the moment we heard the news. It was all parents at the playground could talk about for months on end. We were shocked and distraught that the CDC would do something like this. Their foolish decision made us question all vaccines, and one by one, we all decided not to give our children any vaccines at all.
Vaccine hesitancy has nothing to do with trust in pediatricians and institutions. As everyone knows, parents make entirely rational decisions about vaccines based on the data and evidence alone. Of course, we had all studied the primary medical literature regarding the the pediatric COVID vaccine. We were deeply familiar with the randomized double-blind placebo-controlled trials, and could rattle the results off the top of our heads. They sound impressive at first glance.
“Among participants without evidence of previous SARS-CoV-2 infection, no Covid-19 cases with an onset of 7 or more days after dose 2 were noted among BNT162b2 recipients, and 16 cases occurred among placebo recipients. The observed vaccine efficacy was 100% (95% CI, 75.3 to 100).”
However, all parents know that detecting statistical significance for outcomes we care about, hospitalization and death, requires an RCT with a large N, and these trials were not adequately powered to demonstrate efficacy against these hard outcomes.
Parents are also keenly aware that many observational trials support the pediatric COVID vaccine. We all read articles such as COVID-19 Vaccine Is Strongly Effective For Children And Adolescents During Delta And Omicron. However, we knew these studies were “plagued by confounding“, rendering them useless.
So we all asked ourselves, if the CDC can’t produce the highest quality RCT data for the COVID vaccine, why in the world would I vaccinate my kids against measles, polio, and pertussis?
The answer was obvious.
One thing is certain, people like RFK Jr. played no role in our decision not to vaccinate our children. The mistrust and misinformation he’s spread about vaccines for decades didn’t influence any of us one bit. He’s totally blameless, even in Samoa. In fact, the best way to curb vaccine hesitancy is to approve RFK Jr, and redirect his energies to generating more data. Similarly, doctors who told us “not to trust public health” have zero responsibility for the fact that we parents no longer trust our pediatricians or the CDC when they say things like, “Vaccines are very safe“.
I know this may be hard for you to hear. You likely supported the pediatric COVID vaccine and now you have to accept responsibility for creating something called the anti-vaccine movement. Please, don’t blame me for this hard truth. I am just reporting what my patients tell me every day, and there’s nothing unique about my experience. Pediatricians from around the country will all tell you the exact same thing. In fact, thanks to the CDC, vaccination rates are even plummeting overseas. That’s how impactful this one decision by the CDC has been. When measles returns to the U.S., don’t blame RFK Jr. or the doctors who amplified and legitimized him. Blame the CDC for adding the COVID vaccine to the routine vaccination schedule.
If only they had let more unvaccinated children suffer and die from COVID, we wouldn’t be in this position today.

Science-Based Satire: Children of Anti-Vaccine Parents More Likely to Refuse Cootie Shot
Are the children of anti-vaccine parents refusing their cootie shots? Are we at risk of seeing outbreaks in our schools? They do say that the organic, non-GMO apples don’t fall far from the tree. No, this is satire. Everyone knows that the cootie virus can only be found in government research laboratories.
Clay Jones on August 23, 2019
Link

Atlanta, GA-New research out of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has uncovered yet another assault on public health related to the anti-vaccine movement, this time revealing that children of parents opposed to routine childhood immunizations are significantly more likely to refuse the cootie shot.
“Childhood cooties has been largely kept under control since the discovery of a safe and effective immunization by a 3rd grade Chicago boy in the early 1950’s,” CDC cooties researcher Hammond St. Michelle explained. “Unfortunately in the case of anti-vaccine beliefs, it appears that the organic non-GMO apples don’t fall far from the tree.”
Experts like Dr. St. Michelle have good reason to be concerned. Like most vaccine preventable illnesses, vaccinating enough vulnerable children can result in the development of a herd immunity that helps limit the spread of a disease and protect those who are too young to be vaccinated or who have a legitimate contraindication. As cootie shot acceptance decreases, we may begin to see outbreaks similar to those observed with measles and mumps over the past few years.
Prior to the development of the cootie shot, virtually all children aged 4 to 10 years would be diagnosed with the condition at least once. Once a diagnosis was made, typically by another child familiar with the signs and symptoms after physical contact with an infected individual had occurred, social quarantine was put in place until the disease had run its course. According to St. Michelle, the effects could last anywhere from one recess period to a few years of school depending on the severity. “We are also very concerned about the effects of cooties in susceptible adults, which may be considerably worse than in young children. Just look at what’s happened to Shia Labeouf.”
Why are these children refusing such a safe and effective means of protection? According to the CDC investigation, a variety of reasons are being given on playgrounds all over the country. A common theme that has emerged is the denial of decades of available evidence that should have put any fears to rest. This denial often appears to have been learned from the behaviors modeled by parents who oppose other routine immunizations.
Some children refuse to acknowledge the effectiveness of the cootie shot altogether, and give improved cafeteria sanitation the credit. Others don’t think that they need the shot because they go to an all-boys or all-girls school, and believe that exposure will be unlikely. But modern diagnostic techniques have revealed the belief in gender specific strains of cooties to be false. Perhaps the most common concerns given involve potential side effects from the cootie shot. One study subject simply responded “Circle, circle, dot, dot. Doctors and scientists lie a lot.”

Science Based Satire: The CDC’s Unyielding, Unscientific Push to Vaccinate Children Against COVID Caused a Measles Outbreak in Europe
I warned you this would happen.
Jonathan Howard on January 26, 2024
Link

“Very soon, we will likely see real outbreaks of measles and other virus thought controlled by vaccination.”
I warned you that vaccinating children against COVID would damage confidence in routine vaccinations. In my article Entirely Predictable: More Parents Don’t Want Routine Vaccination for Their Kids, I wrote that:
For many of us who have witnessed the CDC’s repeated blunders with kids COVID19 vaccines, this result is entirely predictable…I worried that the unyielding push (non-satire note: only 11% of kids are up-to-date on COVID vaccines), to vaccinate kids with a COVID19 vaccine that has never shown reduction in severe disease or hospitalization in a randomized trial at any age (non-satire note: this is false), and certainly not against prevailing variants, was a huge mistake, and would lead the public to doubt all vaccines, rather than an embrace of all… Very soon, we will likely see real outbreaks of measles and other virus thought controlled by vaccination.
Similarly, in my article The CDC Is Breaking Trust in Childhood Vaccination, I explained that:
With its unscientific push to vaccinate all infants and toddlers against COVID, the agency will harm vaccine uptake for more significant diseases…The general trust deficit is more troubling than skepticism toward this particular vaccine, because it could conceivably drive down uptake of other childhood vaccines that we know are more important to children’s health, such as those against measles, mumps, rubella, diphtheria, polio, and Haemophilus influenza type b (Hib).
In my article Not the Way to Pull Vaccines Back from a “Dangerous Tipping Point I alone pointed out the “proverbial elephant in the room, COVID boosters” and said:
Trying to convince all people that all vaccines are the same is probably the way to make people reasonably skeptical of some vaccine be unreasonably skeptical of them all.
Don’t say I didn’t warn you.
“There was an ‘alarming’ nearly 45-fold increase in measles cases in Europe last year.”
Sadly, you ignored my pleas.
Now look at the news. The UK initially refused to vaccinate children against COVID and is not offering them boosters presently. It even encourages parents send sick children to school. Despite these wise, compassionate policies, they too are paying the price for the CDC’s unyielding, unscientific push to vaccinate children. According to a recent article titled UK Disease Agency Declares National Incident as Measles Cases Soar:
Latest figures from the UKHSA show that the uptake of the MMR vaccine is at its lowest level in more than a decade, with 84.5 percent of children having had two doses by the time they were five years old in 2022-23. And the number of measles cases has jumped, too. In 2023, there were 1,603 suspected cases of measles in England and Wales, an increase from 735 in 2022 and 360 the year before.
That’s not all. Another recent headline read, Whooping Cough Vaccination Urged As Cases Rise Rapidly In Wales.
It gets worse still. Sadly, CDC’s damage is not confined to the UK. According to an article titled Alarming 45-fold rise in Measles in Europe – WHO:
There was an “alarming” nearly 45-fold increase in measles cases in Europe last year, the World Health Organization (WHO) says. Health chiefs are warning that cases are still rising and “urgent measures” are needed to prevent further spread. Some 42,200 people were infected in 2023, compared to 941 during the whole of 2022. The WHO believes this is a result of fewer children being vaccinated against the disease during the Covid pandemic…
Speaking about the situation in Europe, Dr Hans Kluge, regional director at the WHO, said: “We have seen, in the region, not only a 30-fold increase in measles cases, but also nearly 21,000 hospitalisations and five measles-related deaths. This is concerning. Vaccination is the only way to protect children from this potentially dangerous disease.”
I don’t want to say “I told you so,” because even I underestimated the power of the CDC’s repeated blunders with kids COVID vaccines. Their maleficence has crossed the Atlantic, poisoning confidence in vaccines across an entire continent. One typical father in Kazakhstan, the most heavily hit country during this measles outbreak, said in a recent interview:
I was perfectly willing to give my child the measles vaccine, but decided against it thanks to the CDC’s unyielding, unscientific push to vaccinate children against COVID.
Another mother in Russia said:
If only the CDC had run a randomized double-blind placebo-controlled trial that was adequately powered to demonstrate a reduction in severe disease or hospitalization for COVID, I’d now be vaccinating my kid against measles.”
To repeat, I did warn you that the unyielding push to vaccinate kids with a COVID vaccine that has never shown reduction in severe disease or hospitalization in a randomized trial at any age and certainly not against prevailing variants, was a huge mistake. Anyone who knows anything about the anti-vaccine movement, knows anti-vaxxers change their minds when shown robust data from randomized-controlled trials showing that vaccines are safe and effective.
“For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life.”
In contrast to the CDC, one group of people who have zero responsibility for the increase in vaccine-hesitancy are doctors who said to parents:
When it comes to infectious disease, normality means a world where they are routinely exposed to, and overcome, viral illness. For children, getting sick and recovering is part of a natural and healthy life…Parents must consider that exposures are how we best protect our children against the variants of the future. In fact, it is reckless to let children age into a more serious encounter with a disease best dealt with while younger… Immunity is built through illness.
Nope, highly-credentialed doctors at prestigious universities who deluged with parents with this message throughout the pandemic have nothing to do with declining vaccine rates. Similarly, doctors who treated abnormal lab values after vaccination as a fate worse than death and wrote articles titled Public Health Should Lose Your Trust are totally blameless. Anyone who suggests otherwise knows nothing about the anti-vaccine mindset.
“Bivalent COVID Vaccine Very Effective Against Severe Illness In Children, Study Concludes.“
It’s ridiculous, but vaccine zealots argued that providing parents with accurate information about pediatric COVID and the pediatric COVID vaccine would boost confidence in all vaccines. These are the kind of people who wrote about the anti-vaccine movement before the pandemic and now point out that COVID killed more American children than all other vaccine-preventable diseases combined the past 4 years. They insist on sharing research that I don’t want to be true. Some recent examples include; Risk of Death 3 Times Higher In Brazilian Kids With COVID-19 Than With Other Respiratory Viruses, Study Finds and Bivalent COVID Vaccine Very Effective Against Severe Illness In Children, Study Concludes.
These idiots owe me an apology. However, I’m not the one suffering from the CDC’s unyielding, unscientific push to vaccinate children against COVID. Children across Europe, sick with the measles, are paying the real price.
